In the markets:
U.S. Markets: U.S. Stocks closed flat to modestly lower for the week as smaller-cap indexes once again
trailed large caps. The U.S. launch of missile attacks against Syria Thursday evening boosted oil prices
and pushed investments into defensive sectors as well as “safe-havens” like gold. The Dow Jones
Industrial Average was essentially flat, falling just 7 points to close the week at 20,656. The tech-heavy
Nasdaq Composite retreated slightly from last week’s surge, declining -0.57% to 5,877. By market cap,
the large cap S&P 500 was off -0.3%, while the mid cap S&P 400 gave up -0.77%, and the small cap
Russell 2000 fell over -1.5%. Rounding out the Dow Indexes, the Dow Jones Utility index rose 0.28%,
while the Transports ended down slightly, -0.13%.
International Markets: Canada’s TSX had its second week of gains, rising 0.77%. The United Kingdom’s
FTSE retraced last week’s decline by gaining 0.36%. On Europe’s mainland, the two largest economies
were mixed. France’s CAC 40 added to last week’s gain by rising a quarter of a percent, while Germany’s
DAX retreated -0.7%. Italy’s Milan FTSE fell -0.94%. In Asia, China’s Shanghai Composite added 1.99%.
Japan’s Nikkei suffered its fourth week of losses falling -1.29%. Hong Kong’s Hang Seng added 0.65%.
Commodities: Precious metals were mixed. Gold added half a percent this week, rising $6.10 to
$1257.30 an ounce, while Silver retreated -0.58% to close at $18.15 an ounce. Oil had its second week
of solid gains, rising 3.2% to $52.24 a barrel for West Texas Intermediate crude oil. The industrial metal
copper, viewed by some analysts as an indicator of global economic health, retreated -0.2%.
U.S. Economic News: The Labor Department reported the number of Americans who applied for new
unemployment benefits fell by 25,000 last week to 234,000 marking the second-lowest level of the
current economic expansion. New claims have been under the 300,000 threshold that analysts use to
gauge a “healthy” labor market for 109 straight weeks. The smoothed four-week moving average of
claims, used by analysts for a more stable look at the data, dropped by 4,500 to 250,000. Continuing
claims, the number of people already receiving benefits, fell by 24,000 to 2.03 million.
Private-sector hiring continued at a blistering pace last month according to payroll processer ADP. ADP
reported the private sector added 263,000 jobs last month, its second-strongest reading in more than
two years. The increase blew away expectations of a 170,000 job gain. Mark Zandi, chief economist at
Moody’s Analytics said, “The gains are broad based but most notable in the goods producing side of the
economy including construction, manufacturing and mining.” Professional and business sectors led the
way with 57,000 jobs added, leisure and hospitality added 55,000, and the construction industry had a
strong month where 49,000 jobs were added. ADP calculates the data by using its own payrolls
information, as well as unspecified other factors.
However, the monthly Non-Farm Payrolls (NFP) report from the Labor Department threw cold water on
the giddiness from the ADP report. According to the NFP, the U.S. created just 98,000 new jobs last
month, its smallest increase in almost a year. The U.S. had added over 200,000 jobs in both January and
February, although many analysts contended that rate was unsustainable. Steven Blitz, chief U.S.
economist at TS Lombard said, “The 200,000-plus numbers reported for job gains in January and
February always seemed a bit outlandish.” Inside the report, traditional retailers cut over 30,000 jobs
for the second straight month as the carnage in that sector accelerates. Most of the hiring reported in
the NFP was concentrated in white-collar professional jobs, health care, and oil production.
Economic activity in the non-manufacturing sector that employs the majority of Americans showed
steady growth last month according to the Institute for Supply Management (ISM). The ISM’s nonmanufacturing index fell 2.4 points to 55.2 last month, down 2.4 points from February but still
represented growth (albeit at a lower rate). Fifteen out of the eighteen non-manufacturing industries
tracked reported growth, including utilities, wholesale trade, mining and real estate. The three
industries in contraction were information, educational services, and professional, scientific, and
technical services. The majority of the ISM survey’s respondent comments indicated a positive outlook
on business conditions and the overall economy, but there were also negative comments about
uncertainty over health care expenses, trade, and immigration.
Economic activity in the manufacturing sector continued to expand last month, according to the ISM’s
manufacturing index. The index’s reading of 57.2 was a slight slowdown from February’s pace, but
signaled continued expansion. Out of the 18 manufacturing industries included in the survey, 17
reported growth. Gus Faucher, deputy chief economist at PNC Financial Services stated, “After
contracting in late 2015 and early 2016, U.S. manufacturing is now expanding. Industry is benefitting
from continued consumer demand, a turnaround in energy production, and a seeming end to the
strengthening of the U.S. dollar.” The new orders index, used by analysts to gauge future growth,
retreated slightly as well down 0.6 point to 64.5. All readings above 50 indicate continued expansion.
The Purchasing Manager’s Index (PMI) - a similar manufacturing survey from research firm IHS Markit was slightly less positive. The manufacturing PMI remained in expansion but slowed 0.9 points to a sixmonth low of 53.3 last month. Markit’s index also showed weakness in new orders, to their slowest
pace since October of last year. Chris Williamson, chief business economist at IHS Markit said, “The
post-election resurgence of the manufacturing sector seen late last year is showing signs of losing
steam. The survey data have acted as a reliable advance guide to official data in the past, and in March
the data indicate a slowing of output growth to an annualized rate of around 2%."
The Commerce Department reported that construction spending picked up in February, rising a
seasonally adjusted 0.8%. Though February was slightly below expectations, January’s 1% decline was
revised upward to just a 0.4% decrease. Compared to the same time last year, construction spending
rose 3%. Economists attributed the positive reading to the unusually warm weather the country
enjoyed in February—its second-warmest in 123 years. Residential spending was up 1.8%, while nonresidential spending remained flat. Multifamily unit spending—apartments, condominiums, etc—grew
2%, while single family home construction rose 1.2%.
Car sales have taken a sharp dive. According to research firm Autodata, vehicle sales fell to their lowest
level in more than two years last month. Sales were at a seasonally-adjusted annual rate of 16.62
million last month, a sharp decline from the 18.54 million units annual rate in December. The figures
showed declines across the board: cars and light trucks, foreign and domestic. The National Automobile
Dealers Association attributed the decline to the fall in used-car prices as a glut of previously leased
vehicles came on the market. Auto makers have resorted to aggressive discounts. The average new-car
sales incentive was over $3,750 in March, according to research firm J.D. Power.
U.S. consumers increased credit-card debt to the tune of $1 trillion last month as revolving credit
increased at an annual rate of 3.5%, according to the Federal Reserve. The increase completely reversed
the 3.2% drop in January, which had been the first monthly decline in credit-card debt since November
2013. Total consumer credit rose $15.2 billion to a seasonally adjusted $3.79 trillion—an annual growth
rate of 4.8%. Dallas Fed President Rob Kaplan said consumers are in better shape “than any time since
the 2008 financial crisis.” Consumer spending makes up about 70% of Gross Domestic Product.
International Economic News: In Canada, Kevin O’Leary (a.k.a. “Mr. Wonderful”, as he is known on the
TV show “Shark Tank”), gave a speech to Canadian business leaders, job creators, and innovators at the
Empire Club of Canada. O’Leary is a leadership candidate for the Conservative party. Speaking at the
event, O’Leary promised to “wipe away” Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s “mismanagement” within the
first 100 days in office if he is elected the next Prime Minister. Mr. O’Leary outlined a plan he says will
grow the economy at 3% and create jobs. To do so, he plans to significantly cut taxes, attract and retain
top talent, invest in productive infrastructure, reduce regulatory drag, and remove the restraints on
Canada’s national resource sectors.
Across the Atlantic, in the United Kingdom, Scotland’s economy slowed sharply last year, trailing the rest
of the United Kingdom by the biggest margin in six years. Economic growth in Scotland fell to a paltry
0.4% last year from 2.1% in 2015. That was the sharpest slowdown since 2009 and stands in stark
contrast to the rest of the United Kingdom as a whole which grew 1.8%. The gap between growth in the
UK and Scotland is now the widest since 2010. Most Scots opposed leaving the EU in the Brexit vote,
and Scotland’s government blamed the negative sentiment after the referendum and a slowdown in the
global oil industry for the recent economic underperformance. Derek Mackay, Scottish government
finance secretary said, “We have already seen significantly lower consumer confidence in Scotland since
the vote last summer. Now we see that feeding through into our growth figures.”
In France, all eleven candidates for the French presidency fought for the spotlight in a marathon debate
setting out their visions for a stagnant economy and redefining France’s place in Europe. Centrist
Emmanuel Macron, the current frontrunner, stated, "I want to recover the optimism of the French."
Speaking of entrepreneurs and business leaders as job creators he stated, "We must invest to get the
machine going again." Far-right leader Marine Le Pen said her answer to French revival is “economic
patriotism”, vowing to fight “out-of-control globalization” with an anti-EU agenda. Former prime
minister Francois Fillon, under pressure after being charged with misuse of public funds, said France’s
10% unemployment and massive debt could create an “explosive situation”. He further asserted that
Europe was “veering off course” and it was up to France to get it back on track.
German factory orders rebounded from their steepest decline in eight years in a sign that the German
economy remains strong. Adjusted for seasonal swings and inflation, orders rose 3.4% after plunging
6.8% in January, according to the Economy Ministry in Berlin. Germany’s economy expanded at the
fastest pace in five years last year. Recent data show that the trend is set to continue with private-
sector output accelerating, unemployment falling to record lows, and business confidence at its highest
since 2011. Nonetheless, the uncertainty of September’s federal elections, Brexit, and uncertainty over
U.S. trade policies continue to hang over the outlook for spending and investment.
In Asia, Chinese President Xi Jinping met with U.S. President Donald Trump as the two leaders got to
know each other and set up future meetings. Trump and Jinping announced no trade or investment
deals, no agreements on North Korea, and no plans for a reduction of tensions in the South China Sea,
but the two did establish a new “cabinet-level framework” for future talks. Treasury Secretary Steven
Mnuchin stated, ““We have very similar economic interests and there are areas where they clearly want
to work with us. The objective is for us to increase our exports to them.” Commerce Secretary Wilbur
Ross stated the two countries agreed to a “100-day plan” to discuss trade, there were no further details.
Japan’s composite index of coincident economic indicators rose for the first time in three months in
February. The increase suggests that the economy has extended its current recovery phase to 51
months--its third-longest expansion in the postwar period. The economic expansion started in
December 2012, when Prime Minister Shinzo Abe first came to power. Despite the long recovery,
personal consumption has remained stagnant as many Japanese people have yet to feel any benefit
from the recovery. The coincident CI, which reflects current economic conditions, rose 0.4 point to
115.5.
Finally: Although an old market adage advises investors to “Sell in May and Go Away”, it turns out that –
in contrast – April (the month before we’re supposed to go away) is historically quite a good month. As
shown in the chart below, data from LPL Research and FactSet shows that the month of April is the
single best month to be invested in the market over the last 20 years, and the second best over the past
10 years. Of course, previous market history is no guarantee of future results!
(sources: all index return data from Yahoo Finance; Reuters, Barron’s, Wall St Journal, Bloomberg.com,
ft.com, guggenheimpartners.com, ritholtz.com, markit.com, financialpost.com, Eurostat, Statistics
Canada, Yahoo! Finance, stocksandnews.com, marketwatch.com, wantchinatimes.com, BBC,
361capital.com, pensionpartners.com, cnbc.com, FactSet; Figs 1-5 source W E Sherman & Co, LLC)