week_10_11 - Homework Market

Organization Justice;
Public Whistleblowers
A Few Good Men
Guantanamo Bay, Cuba - Gitmo as it is known - based marines Lance
Corporal Harold Dawson and Private Louden Downey assaulted Private
William Santiago in the middle of the night. Santiago, because he was a
“screw-up,” was given a “CODE-RED,” which included stuffing a rag into
his mouth. Santiago died shortly thereafter of respiratory complications.
Special Judge Advocate Counsel Lieutenant Daniel Kaffee and Joanne
Galloway believe Dawson and Downey were just following orders, as
part of the marines’ unofficial "code" where there is self policing within
the ranks, and that there was no intent of murder. They do believe
Dawson and Downey's story that they were following unofficial/official
orders, but are uncertain if their case is winnable, especially against the
marine machine run by Gitmo's Colonel Nathan Jessep.
Questions
Which value, morality or productivity, should organizations
prioritize in terms of Human Resource Management?
How can organization increase the morality of its members?
How much freedom do current organization members possess
to express morality issues?
Two Camps of Justice
Utilitarians
In deciding what laws or policies to enact, government should
do whatever will maximize the happiness of the community
as a whole. They might defend human rights on the grounds
that respecting them will maximize utility in the long run.
Libertarians
If all human beings are worthy of respect, regardless of who
they are or where they live, then it is wrong to treat them as
mere instruments of the collective happiness. Persons
should not be used merely as means to the welfare of
others, because doing so violates the fundamental right of
self ownership.
Question
How can current HRM monitor the malfunctions of
organization?
How can current HRM police illegal, immoral, or
illegitimate practices?
New Paradigm of HRM Monitoring System
Current top down monitoring systems have not been successful
in the past because of the principal and agent relationship in
which agents tend to hide real and practical data from their
principal.
Public HRM needs a new way of monitoring system and
whistleblowing introduces a bottom-up monitoring system
for detecting and preventing fraud, waste, and abuse.
Grievance Process
Management should establish with employees grievance
procedures that clearly establish the employee’s right to file
written complaints concerning alleged unfair management
practices and procedures for hearing these complaints in the
agency.
The specific items that might arise and be subject to a
grievance complaint could be defined in personnel rules and
regulations.
Steps in the Grievance Process
Informal Counseling: The aggrieved employee should meet and
discuss the situation with his or her supervisor or the next
higher up if the complaint is about the employee’s immediate
supervisor.
Formal Grievance: If informal counseling is unsuccessful, the
aggrieved employee should have the opportunity to file a
formal grievance in writing stating the problem and what the
employee thinks ought to be done to correct the situation.
Steps in the Grievance Process
Consultation Between Supervisor and Personnel Director: After
the grievance is filed, the personnel department should consult
with the employee to verify the situation and then work with
the parties to see if an agreement can be reached.
Investigation/Adjudication/Arbitration: A number of steps can
follow the attempt by the personnel department to work out a
solution between the parties. These might investigate and
make a decision; convening a panel to hear the complaint and
make a decision; and securing an outside arbitrator to hear the
complaint and render a decision.
Whistleblowing
It is defined as the disclosure by organization members (former
or current) of illegal, immoral, or illegitimate practices under
the control of their employers, to persons or organizations
that may be able to effect action.
Protecting whistleblowers makes employees become the “eyes
& ears” of taxpayers and emphasizes bottom-up oversight.
Whistleblowing
Civil Service Reform Act 1978:
– At the federal level, whistleblowing is defined as
disclosing violations of laws, rules, or regulations and
mismanagement.
– The act prohibited taking any personnel action as a
reprisal against federal employee’s whistleblowing.
– The Merit System Protection Board and the Office of
Special Counsel were charged with enforcement.
– The Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989
False Claims Act
Enacted in 1863 by Lincoln’s request to eradicate rampant fraud
of Army’s contractors.
Revised in 1943 and 1986.
Qui tam: Citizen can bring a suit on behalf of the government as
well as him/herself.
The person who brought the suit can collect up to 30 percent of
the judgment, if the DOJ does not join the suit, and a
maximum of 25 percent if it does.
Questions
What could be the costs and benefits of whistle-blowing and of
not blowing the whistle?
What factors influence public employees to blow the whistle
when they find fraud or corruption in their organization?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnoOn8Zsylc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xOKOfvDYpVk
Potential Costs & Benefits
Target of the Costs &
Benefits
Outcomes of Whistleblowing and Inaction
Costs
Benefits
Observer’s organization
Employee withdrawal, risk to longterm organizational survival,
escalation of wrongdoing
Smooth organizational functioning,
avoidance of frivolous complaints
Society at large
Citizens’ rights, privileges, and safety
jeopardized
Avoidance of frivolous complaints (e.g.,
lawsuits)
Observer’s organization
Challenge to authority structure,
threat to organizational viability, limits
on control, unpredictability of
organization member actions
Increased safety and well-being of
organization members, support for codes of
ethics, reduction of waste and
mismanagement, improved morale,
maintenance of good will and avoidance of
damage claims, avoidance of legal
regulation
Society at large
Court logjams
Increased safety and well-being of
organization members, reduction of taxes
and increases in services, less regulation,
support for codes of ethics
Inaction
Whistleblowing
Who Blows the Whistle?
A majority of whistleblowers exercise significant discretion on
the job and occupy the kinds of managerial or professional
positions which would give them knowledge of significant
policy decisions.
Committed whistleblowers may be far less responsive to social
cues which define “appropriate” behavior than most people.
Questions
Do you agree with the statement that “some whistleblowers
seem to be born, not made”?
Do you agree with the statement in conclusion that
whistleblowers do not appear to be rational calculators
weighing the various costs and benefits of dissent?
Why Blow the Whistle?
Three sets of interrelated variables
Particular characteristics of the issue at hand
The employee’s power relationship to the organization
The employee’s personal characteristics and motivation
Characteristics of Whistleblowers
Whistleblowers were far less likely to employ a decisionmaking strategy based on calculating costs and benefits.
They were far more likely to rely on moral theories that
emphasize rights.
Are Whistleblowers born or made?
While there were only approximately one hundred
whistleblowing cases between 1943 and 1986, from 1987 to
2008, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) filed 6,199
whistleblowing cases.
What happened in 1986? The 1986 amendment to the FCA
introduced a financial incentive for whistleblowers and
many scholars and practitioners agree that it was a
breakthrough and successful in increasing the number of
whistleblowing cases.
Are Whistleblowers born or made?
Some whistleblowers may be born, but many of them are made
by new institutions these days.
Institutional arrangements are humanly devised constraints or
incentives that shape human interaction and exchange
(North 1990).
Institution
While formal institutions can be rules, laws, or regulations,
informal institutions can be norms, culture, procedural
justice, custom, or tradition.
Human resources can be motivated or discouraged, even
become good or bad by/because of institution.
Organizational Culture and Human Actions
Culture inside an organization defines the boundaries of
acceptable action.
Culture provides guidance on what an organization’s
employees can do and how they can do it.