EdD in Educational Theory and Practice
Comprehensive Examination
Portfolio Review – Committee Evaluation
Student
Name:
B-Number:
Email:
Committee
Chair:
Committee
Member:
Date of
Portfolio
Defense:
Committee
Member:
Portfolio
Requirements/
Additional
Items:
□
□
□
□
□
□
□
□
Curriculum Vita
Literature Review
Critical Reflection Paper
Pilot Study
Scholarly Writing Samples
Action Research Project
Conference Presentation
Other (please describe)
__________________________________
The Portfolio Review – Committee Evaluation form is designed to document the committee’s evaluation of the portfolio and oral
defense. This form should be completed following the Portfolio Defense Meeting and should draw on the committee members’
Portfolio Review – Individual Evaluation forms and the discussion at the Portfolio Defense Meeting. The Committee Chair will
forward all of the committee members’ Portfolio Review – Individual Evaluation forms, the Comprehensive Examination
Committee Evaluation form, and the Graduate School Recommendation for Admission to Candidacy for Doctoral Degree form
to the Doctoral Coordinator(s).
This form will be filed in the student’s academic file in the Student Services office.
Portfolio Committee Evaluation Report
1
Revised 7/2016
Committee Evaluation
The portfolio should represent a student’s
ability to:
Beginning
Ability
Comprehend and generate scholarly
ideas in education
Write in scholarly and professional
forms
Critique and conduct educational
research
Engage in critical reflection about professional
practice
Engage in collaborative leadership roles
Overall Summary and Recommendations:
Portfolio Committee Signatures:
1.Committee Chair:
2. Committee Member:
3. Committee Member
Pass
Second Oral Review
Portfolio Committee Evaluation Report
2
Revised 7/2016
Fail
Displaying
Ability
Established
Ability
Comments