Voluntary environmental standards do not improve the industry`s

Voluntary environmental standards do not improve the industry’s
environmental performance—but firms still benefit
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This study examines the chemical industry’s Responsible Care Program and evaluates whether it improved
member firms’ environmental performance relative to their peers. The authors find firms that adopt Responsible
Care do not make environmental improvements faster than other firms—possibly because non-compliance is not
punished. Yet, managers may still benefit by adopting such programs because they provide information on best
practices, help promote a positive image and act as reputation insurance against negative events.
BACKGROUND
The Responsible Care Program was implemented by
the Chemical Manufacturing Association (CMA) in
1990 in response to declining public confidence in the
industry (which fell from 30% to 14% approval from
1980-1990). The program outlines broad
environmental and safety standards for managing
facilities and interacting with the community,
suppliers and customers. Though CMA members must
adopt the standard and submit progress reports,
companies choose how to achieve goals and noncompliance is not punished.
If the industry standard is seen as having ‘teeth’, it will
not only improve profits for certified firms but also
improve environmental performance of the industry.
IMPLICATIONS FOR RESEARCHERS
This article extends theoretical and empirical analysis
of self-organized regulation to trade associationsponsored standards. We suggest research can explore
why Responsible Care did not lead to improvements
across firms since best practices would be shared? As
well, did the program lead to improvements in specific
firms, and if so what characterizes these firms?
FINDINGS
METHODS
Firms are more often members of CMA and take part
in Responsible Care when they have:
a) Better known brands or corporate names; and
b) Higher levels of pollution compared to the rest of
their industry sector.
This study looked at 3606 facilities belonging to 1500
firms in the chemical industry from 1987-1996. There
were 160 CMA member firms that participated in
Responsible Care. The sample consisted of 22,476
observations at the facility level and 12,829
observations at the firm level. Firm environmental
performance was measured using data from EPA’s
Toxic Release Inventory.
Firms participating in Responsible Care do not
improve their environmental performance more than
non-members in the industry. Firms that participate
in Responsible Care improve their environmental
performance no faster than they normally did. This
suggests voluntary standards may be most effective
when non-compliance penalties exist.
IMPLICATIONS FOR MANAGERS
Adopting voluntary standards like Responsible Care
can provide a form of insurance on reputation.
Firms faced with environmental damage charges can
show stakeholders they followed accepted practices.
Yet, firms should be careful since their reputation may
be damaged if stakeholders find out they are not
complying with the standard.
Firms may reap additional benefits if they lobby their
industry association to punish firms that do not
comply with the industry standard.
CITATION
King, Andrew, & Lenox, Michael. (2000). Industry
self-regulation without sanctions: The chemical
industry’s responsible care program. Academy of
Management Journal, 43(4): 698-716. Full article
source.
SUMMARIZED BY
Lauren Rakowski & The Network Team
Want more? Visit the Knowledge page at www.nbs.net
We want to know what you think. E-mail your
comments to: [email protected]