Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
2009-01-0456
Independent Torque Distribution Strategies for Vehicle Stability Control
Indrasen Karogal and Beshah Ayalew
Clemson University
5
:3))/
(!,!
" #;5%
6
( < 1 *% 3% $% 5
( < ( ;5 "
< 4
;5
( #(- %
-!,."! .-
; #;5%( #5% #;=5%(
;5 #*-$% ( ;5 ( -
<
,)>#$%
"
=
! #+% % <
%
%
"
< <- ?
<- ( " - " " #@( 2% ( " #A;%(
#;%(
#65;%( #AA;%
-
#.(,%(
!
"
#$%
&
'
(
(
(
(
(
((
(
( ')*+,-.*/*
0
#%
1
,..-2)2-.$3$#45%
1
.3+-..2-+/.)#4%
6&1
.3+-..2-)./)
1 5
7
188
*9-2009-01-0456*
Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
#/( *)% # " %
" ;5 ! 6
( ( < "
( " < " 6( #/ 01."0
( &(
6
* ( < Q
#*%
#3%
9'=?AKL=K
( 0M< # 6
% #*3%1
+,-. /012 3425 67- 87- 3425 ,7-.9 #+%
N#&% 6& & 6 &
- ! &
"
( &( #&
(
%(1
:;'
:<= >
>
%&
4 # ' $ # $#@%
"
1
6&
%
F & $ GH0 E
F " 012 C # E
&
;
;
Q
ICJ #
Q
KL CL
MNLO
P$
Q R 3425 S
#,%
MT UE
F &
M= 5E
F V&
X #/%
W
6&
6
*#**%
(Q( 5O 6
6&
#.%
((
1
6
Q
6
#2%
1
Q
6
! " # $ " # $ %&
%'
)
(* !( #$%
? @ A BC D 6&
(
"
( (
1
"( (
-
" K84K'P
Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
#/ 0!( 0 !2.-!,.0
#;5%
;5
#
( < % "
" < (-
( #%
6
(( &
#Y% .( #4 $
%
#E %(
#*$%1
Y% U\]^ ZM= W
4 %
M= Z[
#*)%
M= W Z[
U\]^ ZM= W L
_% `
#**%
bZc W
& Z' ZaL 5 L Zd= eZ[
& ' W
L
L
W 5:Za & 5 ' eZM= W
g
#*3%
dW df
(
1
h<T 4 4 %
#*$%
h Y Y% #*+%
?
4 Y E
#
( % -
h<T h <
;5 6
3
=
4
K T
5
5
-
;
6
3;5
4
5
1 M <(0
<
K 5
1 #% ( <( ( ( 8
" " N?L'5L'9LKA9L4OAL9R4
9'69
6
9
" 1 " ( ( &
&
& #+(*+% (
" (
" 1 ? "
( 5"( & " #$%( #
--
% ( (
"
( " 1 S
"-
( #*@%
S
" <
"-
! 0 "
#
% <
" ( " #*@%
S
"-
Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
" "
< # "% # " % "
"
( "
" 8 " # " ;5 % " " " " ( < # % &-
"5
( & 5
( #
% 0
i?M j klM hM j mlM n hM o3
#*@%
?
hM #%
(l%pq hM l%pq #*2%
( # % U " i?M " ( ;5( # % " " ;5 ( " S
"
" ;5 "
(
(1
?
? (? s ?s ? "
' ;5 N 95
<( "
"( i? s 0 (h 1
i? j k h j m n h o3
#*/%
?
h 6
$ (
&
<
( "
" (
$&* 1 ;5 " ( " "
1
?rltpu ?r i? ?Kltpu ?K #3)%
#3*%
$&* 1 ;5 " " 1
?rvwA ?r ?Kltpu ?K i? #33%
#3$%
6
(;5
"1
i? x y#L
%#3+%
?r ? ? #*.%
i? z y#4
%#3@%
?K ? ? #*,%
Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
z ys
Ys Y%pq z y
L
,&
{Y{ x {Y%pq {
Y z Y%pq h z y
4
{Y{ z {Y%pq {
Y x Y%pq h x y
L
{Y{ x {Y%pq {
Y x Y%pq h x y
x ys
Ys Y%pq x y
4
{Y{ z {Y%pq {
Y z Y%pq h z y
,&
=
0
{Y{ {Y%pq {
#9*V3%
Y Y%pq h y
6
$
$&* 31 " ;5
" (h 6
#
%( " #
%(
" (
1
i?<T j k h<T j ( n h<T o3 ?h x y(?rltpu ?r {i? {
#32%
?Kltpu ?K ?h z y(?Kltpu ?K {i? {
#3.%
5N 9K
5
$&* 1 5
;5 "1 ( ;5
"
"1
?rltpu ?r ?Kltpu ?K R
|}'
|}'
#3,%
#3/%
K
5
? < (
"
"( i?<T s 0 "1
#$)%
?
(h<T "
6
&( #
+%&
1
?rltpu ?r |}~T
#$*%
|}~T
#$3%
;5 " (
( A (
( +% ! <
"
1
?ltpu ? |}'
?ltpu ? |}'
?ltpu ? |}'
?ltpu ? |}'
|}~T
|}~T
|}~T
#$$%
#$+%
#$@%
#$2%
|}~T
Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
6
+ ! < " ;55
( ;5 # ;=5 % #
,) <% "
+ ;5
#PY*%
)+
N 9#
8%
6
+
"
<
"
#).A! +))%
G#%
+))#=%
)
-3
-+
)
)@
*
*@
#%
3
3@
$
)
-)+
-)2 )
3
@
6
@ N?95L'9LK
" < " #*/% #
%(
#
(P%(<
" #%
+
2
'5
L5
;=5T5
1 -#T%--#
-%
;=5?8L5
1 -#T%--#
-%
)
-@
-*) )
3
6
2N # ;5%(
+(=
#ZY*%
K
#8 %
6
<( ( & #*$% !
;5
( 1 W = W ). A! "
+)) <
W # 6
@% 6;*325#*2%
X-
* "
- #9?% $
)*#
$)8%
3
)3
-)3
,0!-"" .-
+
'5
L5
#';=5%
;=5T5
1 -#T%#
-%
;=5?8L5
1 -#T%#
-%
3
+
2
#%
,
*)
6
.K
# ;5%(
+(=
#ZY*%
#6
2%
;5 #;=5% !
#
-
% ;5 < ( 6
. ;5 < Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
)$
'5
;=51 -#T%#
-%
)3
)*
*
3
$
#%
+
@
,
'5
;=51 -#T%#
-%
3
)
)
*
3
$
#%
+
@
)@
2
-)@
'5
5
1 -#T%#
-%
3
+
#%
2
,
*)
"< <
;5 + 5
O0
1
0 ;5 6
/ "
?
< -
*
@
40
+
''&$5
4 $
''&$5
34/&)
''&$5
)
-+)) )
3
+
#%
2
6
/
"
*;
#5
1 <%
*
# %
3
#
%
P0Y*)))(
PY*))))
$
#
%
P0Y*)))(
PY*)))))
**+2).
).*).
P0Y*)))(
PY*)))(
N <
#
3 3
(
8 %
*.)@@*
L
-
&
))+3
)**@
)*2@
3.
3.
)$
$@3(-+))
$@3(-$3)
5
3*+(-*,)
#
"
%
#&
"'%
+
-3))
6
,
X-
# %1
+(ZY*
3
$
#%
3))
)
-*@ )
*
+))
-*
40
+
''&$5
41
''&$5
34/&)
''&$5
-)@ )
2
+
)
2
3
K
#8 %
)
)
E#%
N 9#
8%
)+
)@
"#'-%
N 9#
8%
< ( #X-
%
$9?,)<
(
;5
+6
/ Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
5
"=
" (
*
# *% < 5
;5 5
#,)<%
$ <
( " #
% 6
& "
"
)
-T
-
-#T%-
-#
-%
-#T%--#
-%
-)@
)
*
3
+
@
2
)
-@
-*)
)
*
*)
3
$
#%
+
@
2
E#%
@
-T
-
-#T%-
-#
-%
-#T%--#
-%
-@
*
3
$
#%
+
@
6
*)5
;5
"
1
#N < (
#ZY*%%
)
-3)) )
3))
#%
@
)
-3)) )
#%
@
)
-3)) )
3))
@
#%
)
-3)) )
#%
@
6
**5
;5
"
1
" #N < (
#ZY*%%
)
-*) )
3))
-#T%
-#
-%
-#T%#
-%
3))
"#'-%
@
"#'-%
-T
-
-#T%-
-#
-%
-#T%--#
-%
"#'-%
K
#83%
*)
$
#%
"
*(3+(
" 6
** & " "
3
( *
"
&
" -
"
"#'-%
N 9#
8%
)@
6
*)(
*(3+ "
$ < $ "< - <
(
(<#
%
;5
"
* 3 6
**( "
& "
*
" (
" Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
*
3
$
+
!
64-5
0
&
)**+@
)*)/
'
!
64-5
N <
*.)@@
*.)**
*)@$3
*,2*
#
(
3 3
8 %
K
*))*2
/$/3
*).*+
*)33*
<
#
(38+%
L
-
)**@
&
#%
7$
7$
7)@
7$
5
#&
"(
"
'%
3*$(
-*,)
3$)(
-*@+
3+)(
-*@)
3*)(
-*3)
N 9#
8%
)+
)3
)
-)2 )
3
$
+
6
*35
;5
"
1N #N <
(
#ZY*%%
!45
!45
!45
!45
K
# - ( Z Y )$% ( ;5
6
*+
" +
< < ( -#T%
-#
-%
-#T%
#
-%
-#T%#
-%
#%
K9K55K9L'5L'9LK
*
6
# %(
+ 3
# L66% ! < "
6
*3
-)+
6
*$5
;5
"
1
" #N < (
#ZY*%%
5
;5 5
-)3
-#T%
-#
-%
-#T%#
-%
!
64-5
3
"
;5
"
#5
1N <( %
$ 3V+ * < A ( $ "
*3(
#
*
3%
6
*$
!
64-5
""
" (
"
" 3&
Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
;=5
=
7
3
!45
;=5
7
7
73
=
3
!45
;=5
E 4&5
7
7
0$$'$'$
48 5
3
!45
73
2$+$4$85
7
0$$''$
48 5
2$+,$4$85
<
;5(
#Z Y
)$% ( ;5 "
+
@)<(
6
*@
9
E 4&5
5L09L'L6N?95L'9LK(K9K
55K9L'5L'9LK('=5L'=#N?T
K9K55K9L'%5L'9LK
7
!45
7
7
!45
6
*+;
;5
+ < 5
#+)
<%
#ZY)$%%
7
3
!45
6
*@5
<
1;
#ZY)$%( 6
*@( < # % ;5
<
" 6
*2
# T %
Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
3))
)
-3))
)
3
!45
+
3))
)
-3))
)
3
!45
+
!
64-5
3))
)
-3))
)
3
!45
+
3))
)
-3))
)
3
!45
+
6
*25
<
1
"
#ZY)$%( .-0 .-
( " "
( " ( < 1
< <
6
( + #;5 " % " "
( <
6
&( " ( 8-
-.1-0!,
N 9
!
64-5
!
64-5
!
64-5
<
0
Q
_
! !-&
[8\
4 4 " D
!-&
Y,HY
.
&
5O
" " &
5O
5O
<
o o <
9
" #Y*(3($(+%
!( s 5
#
&%
j q P(P(P
( 0=
i?
"
h<T s h (, !
K
# %
9
# %
4 ,:,-
* ( ( L<( ; 5
#;5%]
=
*/
(3))$
Downloaded from SAE International by Clemson University Libraries, Sunday, May 31, 2015
3 O
( 0 ?
( X( #3))2% --
" $A'49'5'46L9AOA?N
6N' 9
188
8 83))28^ ^)2*$)2
[L\X*$(3))2
+ 9M( 9M ; = 5
(3))@33*-3@2
@ X 5 ?( A <
( P 9
? (
" ;
?= =
1
=((55
((3))+)*-),2$(3))+
2 P
( X 0
< ? X( = "
;
=
= <_( ( 3))+-)*3)@$(3))+
. X(#3))3% 0 X
( 0
0
=(;3*2(
2$*-2+)
, X( 0
( A
( ().5;-2+(3)).
/9(
;1=
5
!((*//.
*) !( O9; O
!(
#3))*%( = ! ( X
; $(( ; $@( *2$-*/+
** `( AM (`! A(N
` #3))2% 5
= ( 5
0
*+( *+*$*+3*(
*3 0M<( A (L&
1 A( 3))3
*.3-*/.
*$ O( N( #3)))%( (
X
;=(;3$(*3+*++
*+ O( O ; =( ( ;+$(*//.
*@0L
(9((
5
-?-=
" =
( =( V 5
5
3))+-)*-3)@3(3))+
*2 6
; U
5
U 5
=
=
L
( ' A #'A%(=L69=<
''Aa3)).3.223(9'13*3.X..(3)).