Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity Seyed Morteza Hosseini University of Milano-Bicocca August 13, 2015 Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 1 / 26 Outline 1. Entanglement entropy in CFT’s 2. Holographic entanglement entropy for higher curvature gravity 3. Geodesics in the OTT geometry 4. Entanglement entropy of the BTZ black hole in NMG 5. Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Based on S. M. Hosseini and A. Veliz-Osorio, “Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity,” arXiv:1505.00826 [hep-th]. Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 2 / 26 Entanglement entropy in CFT’s Entanglement entropy −→ Fundamental quantum property Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 3 / 26 Entanglement entropy in CFT’s Entanglement entropy −→ Fundamental quantum property Imagine that the system of interest is in a pure state |Ψi. We can find the reduced density matrix obtained by tracing out the degrees of freedom in Ā ρA = TrHĀ |ΨihΨ| . Von Neumann entropy of ρA SEE (A) = − Tr(ρA log ρA ) . We refer to this quantity as the entanglement entropy of A. Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 3 / 26 Entanglement entropy in CFT’s In a (1+1)-dimensional CFT the EE of an interval of length ` can be computed analytically! Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 4 / 26 Entanglement entropy in CFT’s In a (1+1)-dimensional CFT the EE of an interval of length ` can be computed analytically! Zero temperature: (n) SA 1 = log Tr [ρnA ] , 1−n Tr [ρnA ] − 6c (n−1/n) ` ∝ . The EE can be extracted from the above expression by taking the n → 1 limit, c ` SEE (A) = log , 3 where c is the central charge of the CFT and an ultraviolet cut-off. (Holzhey et al. ’94, Calabrese, Cardy ’04) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 4 / 26 Entanglement entropy in CFT’s Finite temperature T = β −1 : SEE (A) = ( πc ` , c β π` ' c 3 β` log sinh log , 3 π β 3 Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity ` β classical extensive ` β T = 0, non-extensive University of Milano-Bicocca 5 / 26 Entanglement entropy in CFT’s Finite temperature T = β −1 : SEE (A) = ( πc ` , c β π` ' c 3 β` log sinh log , 3 π β 3 ` β classical extensive ` β T = 0, non-extensive Finite size: SEE (A) = c ξ π` log sinh . 3 π ξ Symmetric ` → ξ − `. Maximal for ` = ξ/2. (Calabrese, Cardy ’04) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 5 / 26 Holographic EE for higher curvature gravity Holographic EE (Ryu, Takayanagi ’06) 1 min Area (Σ) , 4G ∂A=∂Σ Σ is a co-dimension two hypersurface which we demand to be anchored at ∂A. SEE (A) = A AAdS Σ Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 6 / 26 Holographic EE for higher curvature gravity Holographic EE (Ryu, Takayanagi ’06) 1 min Area (Σ) , 4G ∂A=∂Σ Σ is a co-dimension two hypersurface which we demand to be anchored at ∂A. SEE (A) = A AAdS Σ In the presence of higher curvature corrections, entropy computations must be modified! (Wald ’93) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 6 / 26 Holographic EE for higher curvature gravity Let’s consider a general four-derivative gravity action S= 1 16πG Z √ dd+1 x −g R − 2Λ + c1 R2 + c2 Rµν Rµν + c3 Rµνρσ Rµνρσ . (1) The correct value of the entanglement entropy is now determined by extremizing the functional SEE = 1 4G Z √ 1 dd−1 y h 1 + 2c1 R + c2 R|| − K2 + 2c3 R|| || − Tr (K)2 . 2 Σ (Camps ’13, Fursaev et al. ’13, Dong ’13) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 7 / 26 Holographic EE for higher curvature gravity 1. Find a basis for the vector space normal to the surface Σ gµν nµ(α) nν(β) = ηαβ . 2. Induced metric hµν = gµν − η αβ n(α) µ n(β) ν . 3. Relevant contributions from the ambient Riemann curvature µ ν ρ σ n(δ) n(β) n(γ) Rµνρσ , R|| || = η αδ η βγ n(α) µ ν R|| = η αβ n(α) n(β) Rµν . 4. Extrinsic curvature K(α) µν = hµλ hνρ ∇ρ n(α) λ , K2 ≡ η αβ (K(α) )µµ (K(β) )νν , 2 Tr (K) ≡ η αβ (K(α) )µν (K(β) )νµ . Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 8 / 26 Holographic EE for higher curvature gravity In the following we shall be concerned with solutions to the NMG, Z √ 1 1 d3 x −g R − 2Λ + 2 K , S= 16πG m where 3 K = Rµν Rµν − R2 . 8 (Bergshoeff et al. ’09) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 9 / 26 Holographic EE for higher curvature gravity In the following we shall be concerned with solutions to the NMG, Z √ 1 1 d3 x −g R − 2Λ + 2 K , S= 16πG m where 3 K = Rµν Rµν − R2 . 8 (Bergshoeff et al. ’09) In the notation of Eq. (1) this theory corresponds to the coefficients 1 3 , c2 = 2 , c3 = 0 . 2 8m m Therefore, the entanglement entropy functional reduces to c1 = − SEE = 1 4G √ 1 1 3 dτ h 1 + 2 R|| − K2 − R . m 2 4 Σ Z Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity (2) University of Milano-Bicocca 9 / 26 Geodesics in the OTT geometry For m2 L2 = 1/2, L being the AdS radius, NMG admits the following black hole solution, (Oliva et al. ’09) ds2 = −f (r)dt2 + f (r)−1 dr2 + r2 dφ2 , with r2 . L2 In the b → 0 limit the solution is reduced to the BTZ black hole. In the case of b > 0 there is a single event horizon located at p 1 r+ = −bL2 + b2 L4 + 4µL2 . 2 f (r) = −µ + br + We can associate a Hawking temperature and entropy to it T = 1 p 2 2 b L + 4µ , 4πL S= πL p 2 2 b L + 4µ . 2G Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 10 / 26 Geodesics in the OTT geometry Geodesics are found by extremizing the functional Z √ I(A) = dd−1 y h , ΣA where A is a spacelike interval at asymptotic infinity and ΣA has its end-points fixed at ∂A. We could either parametrize these curves by the angular or by the radial AdS coordinates, I boundary parametrization I bulk parametrization. Choosing the bulk parametrization, we find that the induced metric is given by h = r2 φ0 (r)2 − f (r)−1 , Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 11 / 26 Geodesics in the OTT geometry Setting L = 1, we find 1 , φ0 (r) = p r (r − r+ )(r + r+ + b)(ar2 − 1) Therefore, the profile of a geodesic reaching down to a radius r∗ ≥ r+ is given by Z r φ(r) = dr̃ φ0 (r̃) . r∗ The integration constant a can be determined by imposing the boundary condition dr = 0, dφ r∗ which implies that a = r∗−2 . Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 12 / 26 Geodesics in the OTT geometry Performing this integration explicitly, we find φ(r) = 2 r∗ F (z|η) + (r+ − r∗ ) Π(n; z|η) p , r+ (r+ + r∗ )(b + r+ + r∗ ) (3) where F (z|η) and Π(n; z|η) are incomplete elliptic integrals of the first and the third kind, respectively and s ! (r − r∗ )(r+ + r∗ ) 2r+ n= , z = arcsin , r+ + r∗ 2r∗ (r − r+ ) η= 2r∗ (b + 2r+ ) . (r+ + r∗ )(b + r+ + r∗ ) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 13 / 26 Geodesics in the OTT geometry ϕ(r* ) OTT geodesics 2 r∗ F (z|η) + (r+ − r∗ ) Π(n; z|η) p , r+ (r+ + r∗ )(b + r+ + r∗ ) . φ̃geodesic (r∗ ) = φ(r, r∗ ) φ(r, r∗ ) = r+ r→∞ r* Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 14 / 26 Geodesics in the OTT geometry ϕ(r* ) BTZ geodesics (b = 0) s 2 r∗2 − r+rr∗ 1 . φ(r, r∗ ) = arccosh 2 r+ r∗2 − r+ φ̃(r∗ ) = φ(r, r∗ ) . r+ r→∞ r* Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 15 / 26 Geodesics in the OTT geometry ϕ(r* ) BTZ geodesics (b = 0) s 2 r∗2 − r+rr∗ 1 . φ(r, r∗ ) = arccosh 2 r+ r∗2 − r+ φ̃(r∗ ) = φ(r, r∗ ) . r+ r→∞ r* Depth ←→ entangling size Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 15 / 26 Geodesics in the OTT geometry ϕ(r* ) BTZ geodesics (b = 0) s 2 r∗2 − r+rr∗ 1 . φ(r, r∗ ) = arccosh 2 r+ r∗2 − r+ φ̃(r∗ ) = φ(r, r∗ ) . r+ r→∞ r* Depth ←→ entangling size Boundary parametrization − 12 cosh2 (r+ φ) , r(φ) = r+ 1 − cosh2 (r+ φ0 ) 1 r ∗ . φ0 = arccosh q r+ 2 2 r −r ∗ + Observe that φ̃ = φ0 . Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 15 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the BTZ black hole in NMG SEE = 1 4G √ 1 3 1 dτ h 1 + 2 R|| − K2 − R . m 2 4 Σ Z The induced metric h and R|| are given by h= r2 L2 1 + r2 φ0 (r)2 , −µ R|| = − 4 , L2 while the contraction of the extrinsic curvature reads i2 2 2L2 r r2 − µL2 φ00 (r) + 2r2 r2 − µL2 φ0 (r)3 + 6L2 r2 − 4µL4 φ0 (r) K2 (r) = . 3 4L2 r2 r2 − µL2 φ0 (r)2 + L2 h Very complicated equations of motion! Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 16 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the BTZ black hole in NMG The higher-derivative terms contribution is topological and can be written as a total derivative. (Erdmenger et al. ’14) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 17 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the BTZ black hole in NMG The higher-derivative terms contribution is topological and can be written as a total derivative. (Erdmenger et al. ’14) Thus, the solutions of the geodesic equation solve also these more convoluted equations of motion! Z rdr 1 r q SEE = , G r∗ 2 (r 2 − r 2 ) r2 − r+ ∗ q r p 1 2 + r2 − r+ r2 − r∗2 , = log G r∗ where we introduced an ultraviolet cut-off r 1. Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 17 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the BTZ black hole in NMG Boundary parametrization r∗2 = 2 r+ 1 − cosh =⇒ −2 r+ φ̃ SEE , β= 2π , r+ = 1 , r ` = 2φ̃ , 1 β π` = log sinh , G π β Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 18 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the BTZ black hole in NMG Boundary parametrization r∗2 = 2 r+ 1 − cosh =⇒ −2 r+ φ̃ SEE , β= 2π , r+ = 1 β π` = log sinh , G π β Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity 1 , r ` = 2φ̃ , ! c= 3 . G University of Milano-Bicocca 18 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the BTZ black hole in NMG Boundary parametrization r∗2 = 2 r+ 1 − cosh =⇒ −2 r+ φ̃ SEE , β= 2π , r+ = 1 β π` = log sinh , G π β Central charge for NMG: c= 3 2G 1+ 1 2m2 1 , r ` = 2φ̃ , ! c= 3 . G . (Giribet et al. ’09, Bergshoeff et al. ’09) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 18 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the BTZ black hole in NMG Boundary parametrization r∗2 = 2 r+ 1 − cosh =⇒ −2 r+ φ̃ SEE , β= 2π , r+ = 1 , r 1 β π` = log sinh , G π β Central charge for NMG: c= 3 2G 1+ 1 2m2 ` = 2φ̃ , ! c= 3 . G . (Giribet et al. ’09, Bergshoeff et al. ’09) Holographic EE for BTZ black hole in NMG SEE 1 = 2G 1 1+ 2m2 β log sinh π Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity π` β . University of Milano-Bicocca 18 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole The induced metric h and R|| are given by h= 1 r b+ R|| = − r L2 + r2 φ0 (r)2 , −µ bL2 b 4 − − , r L2 2r r2 φ0 (r)2 (bL2 r − µL2 + r2 ) + L2 while the extrinsic curvature contraction reads K2 (r) = 1 4L2 2 0 r2 φ0 (r)2 3 + 2r φ (r) Equations of motion: (bL2 r h − 2 µL2 2 bL r − µL + r d dr δL δφ0 0 + r2 ) 2 2 − + 3 L2 2L2 rφ00 (r) bL2 r − µL2 + r2 + φ0 (r) 5bL4 r − 4µL4 + 6L2 r2 δL δφ0 i2 . = k, where k is an integration constant. Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 19 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Small b expansion φ(r) = φ(0) (r) + b φ(1) (r) + O b2 , k = k (0) + b k (1) + O b2 . Obviously, the zeroth order contribution reduces to the NMG-BTZ black hole and k (0) = 2r∗ . Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 20 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Small b expansion φ(r) = φ(0) (r) + b φ(1) (r) + O b2 , k = k (0) + b k (1) + O b2 . Obviously, the zeroth order contribution reduces to the NMG-BTZ black hole and k (0) = 2r∗ . Setting L = 1, we find φ(1) (r) = − p 1 r2 − r∗2 s " − 2 (r + r ) − r 2 r − r+ k(1) r+ ∗ r∗ + rr+ + + c1 r + r+ 2r2 r2 − r2 + + c2 log q 2 + r2 − r+ q + r2 − r∗2 Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity ∗ # − 1 (0) φ (r) + c3 . 2r+ (4) University of Milano-Bicocca 20 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole The pressing question is: How are we going to fix these constants? Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 21 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole The pressing question is: How are we going to fix these constants? Three of them are rather easy to fix by setting r(φ) = r∗ , r0 (φ) = 0, r000 (φ) = 0. φ=0 φ=0 φ=0 Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 21 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole The pressing question is: How are we going to fix these constants? Three of them are rather easy to fix by setting r(φ) = r∗ , r0 (φ) = 0, r000 (φ) = 0. φ=0 φ=0 φ=0 What about the initial acceleration or the concavity of the entangling curve, r00 (φ) ≡ λ ?? φ=0 Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 21 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole The pressing question is: How are we going to fix these constants? Three of them are rather easy to fix by setting r(φ) = r∗ , r0 (φ) = 0, r000 (φ) = 0. φ=0 φ=0 φ=0 What about the initial acceleration or the concavity of the entangling curve, r00 (φ) ≡ λ ?? φ=0 Free-kick condition φ̃(r∗ ) = φ̃geodesic (r∗ ) . Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 21 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Back in the boundary parametrization, the boundary conditions read 1 3φ00 (r)2 − φ000 (r)φ0 (r) φ(r) = 0, = 0, = 0. φ0 (r) r=r∗ φ0 (r)5 r=r∗ r=r∗ Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 22 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole These are are satisfied by setting 2 r∗2 − k (1) r+ q , c2 = c3 = 0 , 2 2 2 r+ r∗2 − r+ √ 2 3 1 3 5 2r∗ (r+ − r∗ ) 3r∗ (1) F − ; , ; ; sin(w), p sin(w) k =− 1 3/2 r+ 2 2 2 2 3r+ (r+ + r∗ ) h i 2 2r∗ (r+ − r∗ ) r∗ F (w|p) + (r+ + r∗ ) E(w|p) , + 2 (r + r ) r+ + ∗ c1 = where E is the incomplete elliptic integral of the second kind, F1 is the Appell hypergeometric function, and r 4r+ r∗ r+ + r∗ w = arcsin , p= 2 . 2r∗ (r+ + r∗ ) Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 23 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Additionally, we find that to linear order in b the acceleration is given by r∗ (1) φ00 (r) 2 r∗ k − 2r+ + r∗ b . r00 (φ) = − 0 3 = r∗ r∗2 − r+ + φ (r) r=r∗ 2 φ=0 Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 24 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Additionally, we find that to linear order in b the acceleration is given by r∗ (1) φ00 (r) 2 r∗ k − 2r+ + r∗ b . r00 (φ) = − 0 3 = r∗ r∗2 − r+ + φ (r) r=r∗ 2 φ=0 Finally, we find the entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole to linear order in b q 2 2 4 3 2 4 (1) 3 (1) 2 2 1 b r − r+ r r+ r+ − k r∗ + r r∗ − k r+ r∗ + r+ r∗ − r+ r∗ SEE (r+ , r∗ ) = p 2 2 2Gr+ r (r + r+ ) r2 − r∗2 r∗2 − r+ r q q 2 − r2 br∗ k(1) r+ ∗ 2 2 2 2 2 q +p + 2r+ log r − r+ + r − r∗ + O(b2 ) . 2 2 2 2 r − r∗ r∗ − r+ r∗ Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 24 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Bulk variables (r+ , r∗ ) ←→ Boundary variables (β, `). Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 25 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Bulk variables (r+ , r∗ ) ←→ Boundary variables (β, `). We test whether this expression matches the CFT expectation c β π` log sinh , 3 π β with 4π 3 , β= , G b + 2r+ 4 r∗ F (z̃|η) + (r+ − r∗ ) Π(n; z̃|η) p `= , r+ (r+ + r∗ )(b + r+ + r∗ ) c= z̃ = lim z , r→∞ corresponds to the sought after SEE (β, `). Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 25 / 26 Entanglement entropy of the OTT black hole Bulk variables (r+ , r∗ ) ←→ Boundary variables (β, `). We test whether this expression matches the CFT expectation c β π` log sinh , 3 π β with 4π 3 , β= , G b + 2r+ 4 r∗ F (z̃|η) + (r+ − r∗ ) Π(n; z̃|η) p `= , r+ (r+ + r∗ )(b + r+ + r∗ ) c= z̃ = lim z , r→∞ corresponds to the sought after SEE (β, `). Holographic EE matches exactly SEE (β, `) up to O(b2 )!! Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 25 / 26 Thank you for your attention! Seyed Morteza Hosseini Free-kick condition for entanglement entropy in higher curvature gravity University of Milano-Bicocca 26 / 26
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz