WHY YOU CAN'T REALLY "WIN" AN ARGUMENT WITH YOUR CHILD
by Janet Lehman, MSW
Why does arguing with your child give him power? When you
engage in fights with your child, over time he will begin to
believe that he is your peer and that he has the power to challenge
you. This is a loaded situation because your child doesn't realize
that this empowerment he’s feeling isn’t real. The more powerful
he thinks he is (and the more the defiant behavior gets him what
he wants) the more he will use fighting as a way to solve his
problems.
It’s so important to learn how to manage this type of behavior in
your kids. I know this isn’t easy—in fact, it’s probably one of the most difficult things you have
to learn as a parent. The lesson here is, “How can I let my child mature and individuate with the
least amount of fights possible?” Remember, the goal here is for your child to learn how to be
responsible, communicate well with others, and develop problem-solving skills.
Related: Does your child fight with you constantly?
Is it ever okay to argue?
Let me be clear: there is a difference between a disagreement and a habitual pattern of arguing
with your child. You want to teach your kids appropriate ways to communicate a disagreement.
Knowing how to express disagreements in an effective way is an important life skill. Generally,
it’s best to talk about things you don’t agree on when both of you are calm. Your child should
learn how to state his or her point of view in a respectful way (without name-calling or being
rude). Listening is also a critical skill here, because you want to be able to hear what the other
person has to say without negating them or becoming defensive. In the end, you may not change
your mind, but at least each side has spoken and been heard.
Fighting=Losing Ground
As a parent, I understand how easy it is to get into fights with your child. Power struggles can
occur over issues large and small, from getting your child to clean her room to arguing over
homework and curfew times. Something James and I always said to parents was, “You don’t
have to attend every fight you’re invited to.” That means that you don't have to get sucked into
an argument every time your child wants to have one.
An important thing to realize is that you can’t really “win” a fight with your child. When an
argument escalates, hurtful things are often said, people become reactive, and there is a
likelihood of continued miscommunication—and when that happens, nobody wins. When you
get into argumentative patterns with your kids, you will simply end up losing ground. Your child
will stop listening to your rules, because he’ll know that if he argues with you, there’s a chance
you’ll give in. After all, one of the main reasons kids continue to fight with their parents is
because they know they might be able to wear us down and get us to change our minds.
Related: How to give effective consequences to your child.
The First Step: Know yourself.
The first step in changing this pattern with your child is for you to know yourself and know your
triggers. What pushes your buttons easily? There may even be times of the day when arguments
seem to happen more easily. Maybe in your case, it’s the morning rush to get everyone out of the
house. Be aware of those times and plan around them.
My trigger was coming home from work and seeing my teen age son lounging in the living room
eating potato chips—usually leaving a mess. It would push my buttons and we would get into it
immediately. I really had to work at not getting angry, giving myself a break, and giving myself
some down time after work. I would go up to my room, change, and decompress from my day.
When I was calm, I could talk to my son about cleaning up in a reasonable way without blowing
up.
Know that when you get into patterns of arguing, it makes it difficult to respond thoughtfully to
your kids. You fall into a trap, so to speak, when a morning fight becomes a habit in your
household. It’s a bit like having quicksand in your living room; you keep getting sucked into it
every day, even though you know it’s there!
Related: Tired of yelling? How to stay calm and keep your child from pushing your
buttons.
I understand that parental stresses in our lives can really make us feel out of whack. Sometimes
we just don’t know other ways of coping, so we lose the ability to effectively communicate.
Unfortunately if we do the same thing over and over, we’re going to keep getting the same
results because nothing’s going to change.
Step 2: Ask these questions.
Once you see that fighting with your child has become a pattern, you need to stop in your tracks
and re-evaluate how you’re interacting with him.




What happens right before you get to that place?
How does it happen?
What’s the sequence of events that often leads to the argument?
Are there trigger words, trigger requests, or trigger times of day for you?
Answering these questions will help you have that insight you need, so the next time you’re there
with your child, you’ll be able to stop yourself. Remember, no one ever usually “wins” an
argument—it’s really about what gets avoided through arguing. And what your child generally
wants to avoid are consequences, limits and being held accountable for his behavior. Fighting
becomes an ineffective habit, one that might lead your child to believe that he can use arguing as
his main “go to” to get out of things he doesn’t want to do in life.
Step 3: Plan to change the pattern.
If you start acknowledging this pattern, you can start to make a change. Plan a strategy for the
next time you see a fight emerging. What will you do when your buttons are pushed? When your
child tries to pull you into a power struggle, decide that you’re not going to “play” this time. To
make this more clear, here’s an example: Let’s say you’ve given your teen daughter a
consequence and she’s trying to get out of it by fighting with you. If you stay in the room and the
argument continues, you’re just giving her more power.
Instead, you can simply say, “We’ve talked about what’s going to happen. I don’t want to
discuss it anymore,” and then leave the room. When you leave, you take all the power with you,
and your child will be left yelling at the wall.
Related: Learn how to walk away from a fight with your child—today.
Step 4: Let your child know. Once you’ve realized that you have a certain pattern with your
child and you’ve decided that you’re going to change it, let your child know that you’re not
going to give into these arguments anymore. Depending on the age of your child, you can even
say something like, “I’m going to work on not arguing anymore. It doesn’t work for us. The next
time this comes up I am going to ask you to go to your room until we both calm down and can
talk.”
Step 5: Act the way you want your child to act. Your kids are “watching you for a living.”
You can teach your children not to argue by acting differently with them. When you start
interacting differently by not arguing, you’re going to teach your kids a different way of
communicating. You’re role modeling and you’re offering a different pattern of communication.
Remember, our kids watch us for a living—our behavior can teach them more than our words do.
Step 6: Begin with a small strategy. Begin with a small scenario. The first time you walk away
from an argument, it can really feel like a great thing as a parent. You made the plan and
followed through. Your child may not be happy that you did it, but you probably will. Change
may start with a very small scenario. It could be “the next time my child argues when I say no,
this is what I’m going to do.” Plan it out, and then follow through.
Don’t get me wrong, this isn’t easy. Your child might not respond the way you want him to right
away, but don’t get discouraged. Just stick with it, and know that it may take time.
Related: Having a hard time getting your defiant teen to comply with rules?
Step 7: Experiment with different strategies of communication. As parent, instead of arguing
with your child, think about how you want to come across. Sometimes changing the way you
communicate can have a big impact. Instead of raising your voice, lower your voice. Instead of
being wordy with your child, be direct and to the point. A good thing to say when your child is
not complying with a request is, “What are you supposed to be doing right now?” When your
child answers, simply say, “Then go do it.” Change your style, especially with things that cause a
chronic argument. I know a family who writes notes or emails each other when they’re angry,
rather than exploding into a fight, and this really works for them. Be creative and think about
different ways you can communicate in the moment in order to avoid fights with your child.
Figure out different kinds of places to have those conversations with your kids. If you always
argue as you’re rushing off to school in the morning, plan to have a different conversation or deal
with that topic at a different time. Or if your kid is older, you can ride in the car and have a tough
conversation when you might not otherwise do so. If they’re even older, maybe go to a restaurant
or sit at a coffee shop and have a conversation there, or try going for a walk. The changes you
make now with your children are going to require you to be brave and courageous. This is hard
work, but making these changes can break the cycle of arguing. It will really pay off in the long
run—it’s so important for your kids to learn better communication skills that they will need as
they get older.
Related: “What will you do differently next time?”
Step 8: Don’t take it personally. Sometimes arguments really are hurtful because someone
escalates and says something mean or cruel. As a parent, if you can take those words your child
hurls at you less personally, it can be immensely helpful. It’s more about the argument (and your
child wanting to “win”) and less about how he really feels. (Please note that I’m not talking
about threatening words or verbal abuse here, which should be dealt with more sternly by you as
a parent. You can read more about that in these excellent EP articles on “Kids Who Are Verbally
Abusive” here and here.)
Step 9: Get outside help. If you find you’re arguing with your child all the time, consider
getting some outside support. Keep reading Empowering Parents and interact with the online
community here, or try a parenting program like The Total Transformation for tools to deal with
your child’s behavior. Use our Parental Support Line to get help using those tools. Try to connect
with those who you trust. Talk to a friend, a guidance counselor, your spouse, or your partner.
It’s good to remember as a parent that everyone makes mistakes and that there is a next time. We
don’t learn how to do everything the right way overnight. This is something we have to work on.
The good news is that we’re able to learn from our mistakes, and change and grow as parents.