Environmental Policy and Firm Behavior: Abatement Investment and

! "
#
$$$%
& ' (((
!" #$
% &
%'
() *
! " #
#
# $ ! %
& # #
! ! & #'
(
)*+, )*-, )**, ).,/ 0
#
123
(
123 123/( )*+, )*-, )**, )., )4,
)5,/ #
( )*5, )*6, )*7, )*8, )*9,
)6,/
#
: ;' ! #
< # < (
)*, )9, )+, )48, )7, /
! # #
#
# = *
! %
(
/ #'
! >
# # ! ! = #
#
= # > :
< & < # % % #'
$ ?
4
# # # &
# # ? @ # & # A
B AB
# # ?
(*/
#
?
?
#
?
<
(
$ #
?
5
# # ?
C ?
(4/
= ?
C < C 6
(5/
# #'
< C ?
(6/
@ #'
# (*/ # D ! (4/ # "
#'
?
# ?
(7/
#
= "
7
&
#'
@ # ! #
?
(9/
E (4/
C # & # ? < # &
# F )-,?
(+/
&
# C ?
(-/
& '
(-/ ?
9
(./
"
# (*8/
G % ! (*8/ < ?
(**/
(./ # (**/ #
" (./ (**/ DHC (DHC/
?
(*4/
?
A B 1 A B #
DHC (*4/ ! DHC (**/ (*5/
(*5/ ?
+
! ! ?
" ! ! ! = # ! (
)7,/ G ?
(*6/
# # # ?
<
?
(*7/
(*9/
(*4/ # ! (*+/
G (*+/ # ? $ (*6/ (*7/ (*9/ (*+/ ; ' ;
' (*6/ (*+/ ?
-
(*-/
?
! (*./
" (*-/ (*./ ?
! ! !
(48/
(4*/
1
(48/ ?
! ! (44/
G # $
! ! # * $ %
3 I )7, ; ' )$ *,
C (44/ $ .
DHC (*5/ (*5 /
(*5 / (
)7,/
= ! ! # * ?
& < # ! > $ #
! (44/ "
& # #
*8
! 3# #
# $ $ C 4 # 3 # (44/ & # ?
& % = # < I # # G DHC ?
**
&
? A B ( / A
B ( /
#
DHC ! DHC (**/ ?
& & ' ' " ' ' ' &
& ?
& # ?
DHC # ! ?
& (45/
*4
' & (46/
" (45/ (46/ #
?
' ' (47/
'
'
C (47/ # ?
' ' ' ' '
'
' ( # # 4
)$ 4,
& C # ?
I < *5
) ) $ DHC #
?
) ) # I ! %
#'
E %
C I
C JE I
* = #
+ * ! DHC '
C JE )7, DHC ?
* + + & +
*6
' (
)7,/?
' ' ' * * + > ' C JE ! # $ ! = # # ( /
G
# (/ &
# , G
#
# # ?
, &
# ?
* 1
# # , ,
4 " #
*7
C ?
# , (49/
#
'
(4+/
- (4-/
?
$ C # , (4./
?
# , (58/
"
(4./ (58/ - C : < G
# ?
# , # , , , #
#
, # ?
,
'
*9
(5*/
C > &
# #
5 =
)$ 5,
G < #
#
#
# 5 G
# 5 *+
&
#
?
#
"
$ A
B AB # 6
)$ 6,
!
#
! ! *-
< #
' # ! ( /
#
( /
! % ! & ( / C @ #
> J $ #
$ *.
# 48
"
*
C ?
# , $ )7, # . # #
C . # # #
(54/
. G = / # #
/ %
G / &
/ . (
)7, & C/
(54/ (54/ ( /
(/
4*
& # = #
# )*.,
? # # < $ #
)*4,
G )7,
% = % G
123 I
#
G
: $ )7,
& # & 44
"#
)*, & KH & $
(*.+6/ : I
-- 5*45*.
)4, " " 3 G (*..9/ : $
> > & L
(/ " K? :
: I
587-
)5, " " & G (*..9/ : I " I " " M K
& L
(
/ !
3
? K & I
*7*-8
)6, " " & G (*..-/ 123 " G
$ F N : I
: I
: G!
& L
(:
/
!
: : "
)7, 3 &K 1G I (*..6/ "
I O H
I I
)9, $
&" N D (*.-9/ : 3
> P
* ****46
)+, $
&" N D (*.-+/ 0
> P? G N
3
*6 *-5*.8
)-, $ = D N G (*..5/ # $ !
GP
)., D 1$ IN K (*..9/ N I
G
3 N $ %& ' ( -. (*/ *4.77
)*8, D N (*..6/ : I @ @
I F
:
4*
:&1: " "
)**, K IN (*..7/ :
N I I
$'
> I
# %
5 *5.77
45
)*4, N
&@ =& C (*.-4/ ! ) &
? OD
)*5, N
H1 :1 N O > (*..5/ :
I N G I F
:
46 *9.-9
)*6, N
H1 :1 N O > (*..7/ " 1 : I
I F
:
79 77++
)*7, N N H$ (*..6/ 3
: 3 F
3Q * 5- 7957+9
)*9, 1
N (*..7/ : 1 F I '+ ) 4 44.466
)*+, L
& (*..4/ : I &E
"
C $ 45 (5/ 47-+7
)*-, L
& (*..+/ ( &
? : :
)*., L
& (*..+/ : 3 : I
? @ !
# ,
- 54+578
)48, L
& (*..-/ > 1
3 ? " O G
**(6/ 57+5++
46
p(R)
0
R
Figure 1: Free boundary under price uncertainty
ô(R)
0
R
Figure 2: Free boundary under policy uncertainty
ô
Delocate
_
ô
~
ô
ôo
*
ô j (td)
Stay
0
*
td
*
ô (td)
*
tdj
Figure 3: Threshold policy parameter
td
p
Delocate
*
p (td;ô,s)
increase ô
increase s
Stay
0
td
Figure 4: Relocation time policy