Westfälische WilhelmsUniversität Münster
Institut für
Kreditwesen
Institut für Kreditwesen
Direktor: Prof. Dr. Andreas Pfingsten
Diskussionsbeitrag 02-04
Banks as Delegated
Risk Managers
Dipl.-Math. Hendrik Hakenes
ISSN 0949-6610
März 2002
!"# $%&
' ( "&&"
)
* +
,$
-.
/
0*
/
*
1 #(2#3
$(%#(4 0*
56789 : (; 2 "<# 2 %4 ""%%<6""%%"
=09 ! "
" # $#
) ' >
,#;;% #(3". , .9
!
? #(3< ' >
,#;;%. 9
"
# #
$ $ %
!
/ ,. ,. = ' , .
8 8
' ' ? '
! ,#;;(. @
8
' '
" %&'( %&')( "* %&&+( $
%&&,(
--$#
#
' 8 ' ! ,#;;;. 9 A @ B
A @
) @ ) 8
@ B @ ' !
,#;;;. ,
. ,
. 7
- C '
' >
,"&&#. D
!$5 >
,"&&&. />' >
,#;;;. 7 ! -
' ! ,#;;;. E
F E F ) ) @ A '
)
# A "
" A 4 4 9 - C 9 '
,. - ,
. , . ) ,>
". 5
,
>
4. >
( >
< 8
>
3 >
G ! # ' ,/. H & I 9 J Ê H # J Ê 8
K A 8 A L C
I B
B
B
I , A . ) H # C
I ) . * /0 1 *
2 3# $ 3 /0 1 #
. % ( % ( 1* 1# $
-* 11* 40 1
* 1$ 5 5
% % ( (#
4
/ A
- @ I A I
8 ' ,-. A I B
) A Æ
@ -
) B / - EF
/A ? 9
# H # M I 9 J Ê I " I I,
. H I ,
. ,#.
" 1 * 4 1$ /0 -1 # 6 * $ -1 * Æ # . * 1 $ -1 $ 1 $# $7 1 # . 7
# "
# %&&+ # 8898:(#
; 1- " $ 4# ; 4 $ < " 3 * * $ " $ - - 7*= 40
/#
>; / " * 4?# ; * * 3 -1 3 * 7
-1 # * 1 --
3 -1#
(
J Ê ' I ,#. ? A I ,#. , : . 9 H
,".
# 9 4 , H &.
N
I ,
. I,
. H I ,
. ,#. = ,". ? / I ) - I ) ! # / 9
Ê /A A B
- ,C. ,
C. /A 8
/ - ! # ! "
# !" # " H H . # # # .1 %&&(# 6
$* * * @
" "0 - * 40 -# A* $ - $
% ( % ( % ( % (# ; - $ B * - $ # C- "0 * * 7*=
/ 1 $ ¯ /#
; $ - < -# ; 1
1 40 - "0 #
<
) - 8
I
=OP H =O P H I ,
. 5
,4.
H
, . H
, . , . :
, . H , : . , : . : ,# , : .. H , : . ,(.
8
8
I
I
=OP H ,
. ,
. 5
I,
. 5
,<.
$%
- @ - A 8
=O P H =OI P =OI P H =OI P : , : .
,3.
) C A ) /A ) 8
@ - -A I I @ I N
I I ! I 8
$ %
!# & # H
I
H
# ' ! ( ' # #
) '
I
)
8
I - /A - D % ( $ 3 $* % (# " * #
3
/A A =O P H
, . , . H , . , . ,# , : .. ,G.
' A 8
/A =O P H =OI P =OP =O P ,%.
=O P H 5 H 5 : , : . H , : . # "
=O P ,G. 7 8
=OP H =OP H =OI P 5 H =OI P , . ,;.
- =O P H=O P H& N 8
( - B ) C /A ) C / ' # 8
, . H , . ,# , : .. - B
H , .
) B &% '(
& " )# * " * # # '
$% /A 8
=OP H , : . # & =OP H , , . # , : .. ,# , : .. &
5
# 9 - B
- B
- B
G
* +
,-.
" '(
&# + " , )" -" " ," + #
+ " # ,
+
" , )" # + # " # ,
=O P =O P =O P
H & =O P =OP =OP $%
. &% $ !
/ " 0
-.
-.# /
) " " " - - H =O P H &K
H H H =OP H &K
H =O P &K
# H H =O P H &
# H H , .
# # 4 ) /A , 7
". H / =O P & ) H H =OP H & H / ) /A H / @ / B - Æ
=OP H & - C /A ) Æ
/ -A , . , . H / - C 8
=O P
- / =OP H & Æ
- C /A )
-A /A C
B1# E$- * B B1 1-# F# # * 2 4 2 $
FG
H # " 1* # B1 2 % 2 2
2 2 (#
( B- 2 %
%
- =O P H & / /A ) , .
0 @ C 8 ) 5
4 ( / - C , H . /
&% * !%
0 " # 1 " " - (
$%
&
&
) - B
H
, . ,# , : .. ,#&.
,##.
$B
,##. # H , . ,# , : .. #
H
& '
, . ,# , : ..
, . , : . H
&
, . ,# , : ..
5
4 C 8
A 8 ;
&% 1 !%
0 " = = # 1
- (
=O P &
=O P &
" $%
" " =O P &
=O P &
=O P H =O P H &
=O P H =OI P : , : .
H
, . ,# , : .. =O P
H
, : . ,# , : ..
, . , : . H , : . ,# , : .. , . ,# , : ..
, : . , . , . , : . H , . , : . , . , : . &
, . , : . @ =O P & 7
=O P
H ,# , : .. &
=O P H =O P & =O P
=O P
H
#
H ,# , : .. , . ,# # , : .. # H ,# . # &
? =O P H =O P H &
6 -1 B1 * $ < # - B * * * * #
#&
N
8
? 9 -A 8
)
/ -A , . - B
5
( B
B
M - &% 2 !
0 " )3 !.
# 2' " " # # * - - !
7
A ,. ,. ) , &. =OP H =OI P , . =OI P ) - / - C =O P:=OP H =OI P
=OP & =OP =OI P 8 &
7 , . H
, . ,# , : .. , . ,# , ..
) I , . # , .
, . H M - 7 , . =
B 8 8
$%
!
) C 8 L 7
8
' / I J # # * 1 FG
H
FG
H #
8 1* . +@ . 3 " 7*= * #
##
A / A ) / - / : / - : ' - C /A , H . - , /A -. : : ?
- / =OP H
, . , . :
, : . , . H : , : : . ,#".
=OP H =OI P : , : : . : ,#4.
8
=OP H
: , . , . H : , : . , . ,# , : .. ,#(.
=OP H =OI P =O P =OP ,#<.
=OP H 5 : H 5 : : , : : . H , : : . # "
=O P ,#(. 7
=O P H ,. =O P H =OI P : : ,. , : .
? L 8
1 " '(
&#
=O P H =O P =O P H =O P H ,#3.
6 4 1$ * 1 1 /#
4* 3 $ 1 3 $ $ -1 # 6
FG
H 2 FG
H FG
H 2 FG
H 2 2 3# FG
H FG
H #
#"
M ,(. ,#". ,G. ,#(. ( ' ,#3. /A - , . / B - B
' C /
-
Q
8
! # - , 7 #.
/ ,
. - - / 7
/ 9 ) / - / 9 Ê - 3 ) ! "
4 &% 4 " +%
&# & " " =O P
&
R H R , R .
2 # !"
- ! ( # ) 2 . # !" "
"
R O& =O P
P
R
=O P H =O P : R
=O P H =O P
H
R
R
,#3. : ? B
8
,#". ,#4. =O P H # =O P H # H R H R ,R . - / ' 5
3 -A 8
/ 9
/ - - C , H . N / / / / C
- / - )
8
- ) - / $%
6 / 1 $ 11* 40
1 # ; 40 $ $ * $
*#
#4
&% 5 !
/ " 0
-.
-.# /
) " " " - - H , H & . H =O P H &K
. H =O P H &K
# H , H & . H =O P H &K
# H , & # H , H & . H =O P H &
H,
.
# 5
" / : - ' =O P 5
3 / 8
' ) , . / - C
)
, . / : & ) , . H H & ? / C -
- 7 C
?
? , . / , &. ) @ , . 5 2 !% " -.# # " * % . &( B1 $
B- 1- $ * #
- 1 : * $
1 # - - 4 "#
#(
) ! # ,
H . ! " ,
&
H . $
! # !
" EF 8
" N 4 !%
0 " # 1 " " -
(
" &
&
H &
- 5
3 =O P =OP 5
(
N
- 5
< - ,. ) C
- B
7 ,. ) 3 5
( C ' S @ C ,
I . / M
T
' A
$%
. . + $ . 8#
#<
C B
N , &. - B
, & ,##.. / - EF - C / @ - & @ 8
C 8
,. - EF ) , ' ! ,"&&&.. ,
.
,
. A ) '
- C
,. N
B
)
! # ,
. 8
- ) ! " ,
. / 8
- N
4 ? B
9 / B ' 8
B ) 8
L ! "
# $
' K * 3 1 -
FG
H# $ < $ *
#
0 %F L
* . ( - *
- 1 - #
#3
)
' >
,#;;%. B
> 8
8
,. / 7
A ' > ,. 8
A ' 8
A ) A
,. A 8 )
L ' 8 B
' 8
A ,. ) ) A @ B
B
$ * * # # 11*
1
* * -# F- B1 3@ ; 0 1 M * M 1- $ * $ * $ $ 0
11* 1
*# N * 1- $ $ $* #
/ 3 . #
#G
% 7 $ ,#;;(. 7 )
>
0) 5 M 0
7 $ ,#;;;. )
7 > > 6 7 (< N ; #"4;2#"<4
7 $ ,"&&&. - 0
&&(( 7 )
M
> /
5
7 $ ,"&&#. M 7 >
,5
. 0) 5 M 0
7 '
0 ,#;;%. 7
)
8 "# N ## #(3#2#(%<
7 '
0 ,"&&#. S 8 "< "G#2";(
=
,#;%&. '
' -
7 8 6 9 3 #24G
>
' U ,#;;4. M
-
8 4 "2<&
5
V M ' V DA V ' ,#;;4. =Æ
'
=
>
0 V @
/
5 0
$ V ,#;;#. ! 0) 5 M
0
'
0 ,#;%(. 0 - 7 2 ' > 8
6" :" #3 N ( <G323&"
@ ' 0 ,#;;;. $
- =9 ' )
M
8 % 4323G
-
$ ,"&&&. ' 8 "( #"(42#"<#
V ,#;;3. - 79 ' Q
9 ; (% N 4 #G42"&G
#%
& '
( 7 #9 >
! # ,
Q.
H &9 / EF C
/ B - ) B - ) C /A A I - I / H #9 N
EF C
I ,
. I ,
.
) L ) I ,
. I ,
. #9 > =8
5
$ >
0
&
) * +
* , + ./ , * , +
./ ' &
) * +
* , +
ʼ ./ , * , +
Ê
¼
Í ./ Í ' (
) * +
./ * +
./ * +
6@ 1 @ F3 1
-#
" $ * 1 1* 4# E$- " J 4 1 #
#;
7 "9 =8
5
'
=
7
FG
H
FG
H
FG
H FG
H
FG
H
FG
H
FG
H
FG
H 6@ 1 3 1 J % ( 2 $ 2 +
2 8 2 8 2 8# 40 3 3 = $ " < 1$ 7* 7* %00( M B1 #
E "0 3 -#
"&
7 49 > = ! # $ FG
H¾
2 FG
H¿
FG
H¾ 2 FG
H½
FG
H¾
2 FG
H¼
2
2
2
6@ D
. J 3* 1 $ 2 + 2 8# < B B1 *# $ %$ 2 FG
H (
* 1
* %$ 2 FG
H 2 ( 1
* 1
$# 4 3 1 - *# 1$ B1 # . B1
$ 2 8 2 8 %00(#
"#
7 (9 >
! " ,
Q.
H &9 / EF C
/ - - / B - ) B - ) C /A A I - I / H #9 N
EF C
I ,
. I ,
.
) L ) I ,
. I ,
. ""
7 <9 > = ! " $ +
FG
H¾ 2 FG
H½
FG
H¾
2 FG
H¼
2
2
2
+
6@ D
. + J 3* 1 $ 2 + 2 8# $ 4
7*= % 2 ( 1
*# - * 1$ $ - 1
# ; $ . + * 3@ 1*
* *#
"4