Evaluating Strategies for Similarity Search on the Web
Taher H. Haveliwala
Aristides Gionis
Dan Klein
Piotr Indyk
Stanford University
Stanford University
Stanford University
MIT
Computer Science Department
Computer Science Department
Computer Science Department
Laboratory of Computer Science
Stanford, CA 94305-9040
[email protected]
(650) 723-9273
Stanford, CA 94305-9045
[email protected]
(650) 723-4532
Stanford, CA 94305-9040
[email protected]
(650) 725-6965
Cambridge, MA 02139-3594
[email protected]
(617) 452-3402
ABSTRACT
!""#$%&'("#)*,+.-#%/,!
021 '("4357689"4(&:"#%7.8;&:
.<=>&?@#%A"#;7
BDCFEG#(@H/ =IJ%#7"!AEK$:L#:%AM=N"#4"O
JPQ#
1 '(GAR35$+?-#S<
->;&!G#7"EKTE"'-!"
./M-
%#DJ-!>(U>:%EKS:%:;(''V/LPW
L'("#XJ%#7G/
%
;5&X-
J9:Q%AG#;@A 0 B BSPWT-
W
"#7&@#76@B9Y
>#%.T ;7
(+?-Z=[#Z->&*";A"''/\E'-!G
J%#7G
-%
YR
#7G#;@(S9%-;@\T]:R^V#;@#%/.S<\'_";`"=
-%#,=NA>!";@a:BFYR
'V/b(,E'-!Gc&?'/d
,&VUR=W>.;-
&.D##%?7GYJ%#7GS(;'-!>( -%X"=eU?ASf"
;7
"#%Og@U>AS:!L'
a?BYZ>%;-
%T#'_GEK
E.7h"!*>E".7i=8
)EG#(-
Q
>#K";@hU?O
"&
AfB$!''V/.SfPi>%;#:XAPF @j;.'V/R;J%#-
;
%&'("#VH/b!>Uk->*=-#*;7
%dJ%#7GSD
l>#GE>(>
"&
'#%-'h=_#&m->#)(
UfB
Keywords
#'_GAc!"S%(&'("#Vn/c%A"#;78SD%AG#;@<SE'-
"<S4]:
^#;#%/M3o#GpJ;
1. INTRODUCTION
qi'Q"=iOg!"`%&'("#VH/\%A"#;74L''APr-%#
s!!R\!"$%&'_G#$L+.-
#%/t
LuVvAwGxyBMznY
"#%;O
-'("#ASEKM`+.-
#%/,>.;-
&.AS>T%(&'("#Vn/>Og%AG#;@M'"#V
&
%-'_>#"E?()#7"
aKA`'J
$=8>.;-
&.I%&('(G#Q!G
>.;-
&?AB
{ EKR`%&*''9?-
&Z:#W=I%&'("#VH/?Og%A"#;7LJ%#7"S<
&? &*(\;&!G#
|
V#,#'("EKY+?-
'VH/bPW}-%#
=[A>!;7a:BI~APiE#AS>-
%#hJ-
h;A"M
GE%s
;A.);JW(
:"`&W!X#%-#;BeM#GEK@#AS?=nS?
JA`=<;&
"#
k%&*''?-&X:#,=TSPi\"#\?@#JAc€;&!G#%O
`!G#7&%#A*&?iPWVM'("#4!G#7&#W%
;S
?-&X:#=hJ%#7GT;AY+.-
;@a?'V/RU>;tPW!G$;A\:`E'VO
-
"A\-
%
-%#TJ-!>(B zn\($%V-!G8SoVT$U?%#&'V/
‚ƒo„K…V†W‡5ˆA‰HŠ*‡o‹†D†HŒKK?ˆA‰gŽHR‘"’,Žn„KX“e‹ŽH…VˆA”K‹•Q–"—7…V”K—T˜.ˆAŒK”K.‹Žn…VˆA”
Œ”KK‰i™Q‰H‹”"Žešgšg–"›yœAœAAžAAŸA ¡ –ŒK>ˆA‰gŽH`‘G’Z‹”`“Q–˜R™Q‰J‹Œ.‹ŽHD¢o7†n7‹‰H—J„Z˜.7•V•Vˆ7‡I†H„K…V
£ –ŒK>ˆA‰gŽHT‘"’“i–˜™Q‰J‹”GŽ5šgšg–"›yœ¤A¤7¤@¥¦‹”KT‹W§`…V—‰HˆA†nˆ¨_Ž¢I†H7‹‰n—J„
™Q‰H‹KŒ.‹ŽnW˜.7•V•Vˆ7‡I†H„K…V
© –ŒK>ˆA‰gŽH`‘G’Z‹”`“Q–˜R™Q‰J‹Œ.‹ŽHD¢o7†n7‹‰H—J„Z˜.7•V•Vˆ7‡I†H„K…V
Copyright
ªlªlª «>¬is¬"held
« by the author/owner(s).
, May 7–11, 2002, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA.
ACM 1-58113-449-5/02/0005.
%#7"
'Z,"-&*G$J%#7""/L;&
"#%4
!G#7&#
%';8B
qi
\­H:J®,!G#7&@#4"#T
%T!G#%-'(R
T&J
;;-#7G`#7
aAt%&'("#VH/t'J
4=[#Z"#%#7G#%/\+?-#%/t.;@O
-
&?BbzHk
:#ASiPQLEK'd¯"-&*"AkE'-!GO
\&
?>'"/LM>#&
$
Z&*"'o.;-&.#>O
#%.7G(J%#7"/.Bzn\
"#%;-
'(G#ASPi`E?P°&*?-
''V/R;>O
J%#-
;@A|V#;"#X%-;@|"Z±Q.²iu w"³"x)
\
]:Y^VO
#;"#%/l3o#GpJ; 0 ]^43e6*u w?v@xDRa?(
=#;&
'A-
%@#
J-!?/.Bh]->#)E"'-!"L&
?>'"/M-%)4
"(L=e.;@O
-
&?*%&'("#VH/b!GM,(&'(;'V/d
;?>A¯¯
%R(@#%O
"#;7
;A"'fV#;"#i$(
-; ­n;#%#;®S#-
!`%#->#7@#%O
=
.;-&.8./%(&'("#Vn/.SEKT%&e+?-#%/4>.;-
&?AB
qi
8S5-%(LJ7"J;A"'i&A%-># 0 uVvA´"x[6@S5PQ;&
"#%&VO
'("#VH/T#7a?(o>7
Z=[#&µ>V¶f#.o!G#7&#o%@%(I=
->#Z'"#&· ;#%#;$#7"
a?
B ]->#$-
#'V/>
"JO
%-
&>`e
"e!G#7&#I%%e
"I/>('_`
@#iE'-
=9
h&A%->#;"#%#%:
,`
"#7&@#i!GiPW'('8#?>-
;
:%#W#%-'VB
q9L>&J%#7"`-#TE'-!G&?'(/.S<Pi*"
'A
V`tR#%
'/k%l%`=D!"#7"&#X%%
0 (;'-!?O
$;7
;Q=N"#h.;-
&.o##%.7" X#&°PQ.
%;7
&765"!`>#&
A$PW
;7`=f
&¸(I&Jo@¶f;EKh=N"#
%&'_G#VH/ %A"#;7 Y8B
qi
@#"#M&*./:%%('MPh/>XR##%?\>.;-
&.
=N"#
I
->#:%I=
%-
:"#%
W¶f;EKI%&'_G#VH/$%AG#;@<B5qi
=N''(APW
4>#¹
/$>%;#:9e#>#%.7"XGU9Pii;
%(?O
#A$=N"#e-%QPWVX
eE'-!G(`&?'/WpJ-JI%;#:AfB
qi#4#K";@hX%';@(X
D#&QX;'-!(,
EK;@# 0 #i+?-E"'(?'V/.S&X-
'V%@69#>#%.
T
)º
=N''(AP4»
vBQ#7>W:A"#
º 0 X;..%Og!"%AM"
>#K;7:6
w?Bi^.;-
&?T(?Vs
# 0 B >Bo-#'76$=[#XA;7l.;-&.Z¼
!"W'
a?h`º 0 X'
a.Og!"%AM"
>#K;7:6
´>BQ#7>"
:AG#
,(%(T#A"#t;@#(L¼!S:PW
4"
;7
#)'
a?h`º 0 "L;@#%Og!"%AM"
#;7:6
qi
M-
%-!"'D;..%Og!%d#;7d#*
MGE'('
./>:#'(ak
G7\"!b%-%;'( Y%!"&Bdznk!"#%;-'("#AS
V*#'( %'('/dd=[#&*"c#GE?_>Ab./k
M!½ ->
"#AS5
"#
L
Z"=W
*->
"#T"=)
@#TY
!"Yu ´GxyB¾qi
\'(a?Og
%Ac"
#;78S(?EKJ("A}¿uvAwGxyS
%-¶f@# =[#&À\%#%;&
!G
PWVc=NPÁ('(a?
PW''<h
AEKD%->j;.i;7G"7?S?V
#iT:"''(APQA +.-
#5"#"
:AG#I#%-'V5=:+.-#Boqi
5>#
'&Â(5JO
:;("'('V/ #
-
;,PW
"%&
$`>(%;"E#W%&('(G#n/
#'("
Z=[#Z
P°
T
"T!AEK$/.T:Y;VAY%-jXO
;(?'V/.BCDWPiTPW(''5%T\Ã>;YÄ.Sf-
#'(a?Og
%AL"O
>#K";@<S
4E;#W=N"#ZÅ`ÆÇÈ>.;-
&? 0 EKM#'(GAM76
G#$(,=2";"#%
'<`A;7M"
#AB
qi
V#7¯"
#;78ShPW(;7d#',d@U>,A"# ;@#S
#@=N#%#A¯R
cÉÊ!Ë7ÌÆÍ@ÎgÏoÐNÊ!ÑKÆÏ·u ÒGxgSX:A"#t&JR-%O
=[-
'i=[#`,Yk%(&'("#Vn/>Og%AG#;@k7%a:B|zn!>A<S5M-% "=
"
;7
"#%OgPW
APWZ
T:\#E?-%'/\;
%(#Y=N#XME"#VO
@H/ =5"
#Wz 1 7%a?$u w?S9vS:Ò?S9vv@xyBiqi$
;7
"#%OyPW(
AP
"=[|;
JV->X
>Og
-('V$%-&&*"#%/R=h`7"#`>.;O
-&.4uVvxyS;'';
:"MU>'(;V)!"!?On%-&&*"#AG(,!
&'(;V)!"!?On;'_"%%Vs!;AG(L#%?WM#@=N#%#
`.;-&.B
YD@U:;e
"ePW
,#"
ZGEK#4ÉÓNÓ'(a>S.)=_#O
+.-
;/ =o#'E.)#&hPW'('o>&!G4
=[#+?-
;@/=IV#%O
#'(E"?T
B qi?-
S8
X#%-'V(LJ%#
->$U>:;A
R:,L%!G-#*!GX`M#'(("
'Se;;%,#>#%.7"
"=eX>.;-
&?ABDÔQ;A-%XA";@t;@#%OyPW!>GPF;.%#
->
%EK#7'#&SW
;7
"#%Og!%`J%#7""/X#A+.-
V#o=N@Pi#Q;V7"O
e
`)'
a.Og!"%A`J%#7"/`4>#EK.I?@#7.;-&.
"#%
'VH/.Bh~DAPiEK@#ASfDX#%-
'VD=5#A>-
;#%
!'VO
Vn/.S.
"
;7
"#%On
%A*J%#7"/*h
?%#E?('!Z(&'&.Q@=[O
s
;.'V/\uVvÕxyBeY4%;-%D'(G#)
APÖX#E?-%'V/ J7
'%
On>(&
%
'>%(&'("#Vn/>Og%AG#;@`;@
(+.-
i
%A``!"%O
t;k: -%AYRj;.'V/|&
'&?$ "
;7
"#%On
%A
J%#7G/.B
qi%M>#M
#7"'WJ%#7"(*=[#*>.;-
&?Z##%.7"O
>E'EK4
V
'8%:;Vs!;4;
%(@#7"S!%-
;7L"W@#&
PQ.
t
YPW(>|=D"
;7
#%OyPW!>APWSIPW;@|Pi,>(%;-
%
=[-#%#)(Ã>;@(L´>B
×D5!G8#I"#I&*./DV!"'K!G#7&@#<
"8;-'_
:);
%(#<S>%-
;7,QPQ.
T%;@&e=[#i=[.i%S=[.
n/>:S9V'S5;B]->#$'QPi$
"TM%A"#;7Y
"#7"&O
@#`%!";M@U
-J(E'V/.B 1 "#ASoPi,;@%ML#%
'(M%
"=
"#7&@#`\>#%.-#E'-
"b&
?>'"/l!
L7"(k
%?Z.
*+.-!"'(V7G(E,@¶f;T=W
%*
%;
"#7"&#B
];ZX:J$
"#7"&#S8(;'-!>(M;7
(;`=i.;-&.
##%.7G(|
\#&ØPQ.
%;7
&S!AEKX:>O
@#&(AR-
%
M`E'-!GY&@
?'/.S<Pi&Z-
J4%;'
o%(&'("#Vn/4&A%->#5h
-
'(4h%&('(G#n/4!>UD=[#5
"iPW'B5W>EK'*`!>U>
$#;7X#'V/>(4`
M>On
%(|;@
(+.-
uVvÙ>S$ÄAx4"!¯;
J%#-
;@%&'("#VH/?O
%"#;7L(
U,=N"#D#-
'V/LÚÄX&'('L->#')>&J%#7"
%;'(('VH/M=5-#)"
#;78BIÔQ;A-%4A;7J74=5-#)"'(O
#V&Ø$%#E?(''V/Y
"#7"'(''A"
'So->#$!@U#;7;A
%;'t =[P¾
''(¯";;%%
'R>.;-
&.Z;-#%#.'V/k
<BÛ
2. EVALUATION METHODOLOGY
qiY+.-
'VH/c"=Tt#7"
a?
#->#
A¯./¯-#MJ/J&Ü
>#&
./ 4%&('(G#n/M&@%#(;$"!>.;-
&?h=[A"->#
-%A<Bt35#E?-ZPi"#aduVvGwAxW!"T#'A||-%#`J-
$tJO
%%W+?-#%/X#%:
%+.-!'VH/.B9~APiEK#AS?-
%@#hJ-!>(i"#)&O
;
%-&
S9;J'V/.S!t
"4Pi''VOg%-
VA\M#%A"#;7Y!G$O
E'EKh
;&
"#%"=5&*./*
"#7&@#Bo
JM-%
"L->&*GA,&@
?*=5E'-
"M
"W-%i
"#7#
&'(;VZl?-&*Og-
'V4
#7G#;@(;'WV#;@#XL&#GEK
$+.-!'VH/,"=5->#DJ/>J&½ i#7"
a?
B
zn|
M;'(-J#
\'(V#7G-#SQ?-
&#-
T&
?>X=->O
&*G;|E"'-!"F!AEK|:Â#:%AÝuVvAÚGxyBÞÃ.>
;7a}
"'2Bu wÄGx
E?_>e%Q&?8(.WHPQ#$;'(%%BQß7ÊÈnà@Í@Ê!ÉÓ
ˆAâ4â4‰H—…‹•<†H7‹‰H—J„M7”ãA…V”K†ãA”K‰J‹•V• ’ „.‹7äGT†H%äG‰J‹•5„"ŒK”K‰HK†ˆA‰
%Û@äGá ”XŽn„KˆAŒK†H‹”KK†Qˆ¨fâ$‹—H„K…V”K†Q‹ŽoŽn„K…V‰e…V†H?ˆA†J‹•Nå
æç ÉÓ ÐNÈ2èLÅàÉ"Ç ç Í%à@Ç7So%-;@YZAEK#7!"#%PW% .;-&.4%&VO
'("#VH/.So
;A" +.-
'VH/\=D#:%A;'-J#X%@X
%A
->#'V/D.#!"':;'-
J#i&%#%/*
J7"J;SPWV>O
->`#=[#
;M"?/#-!|%#-<BbéeêÈnà@Í7Ê:ÉÓ æç ÉÓ ÐNÈ2è\Å*à%ÉÎ
Ç ç Íà@ÇSh%-
;7b`.%#?/&A%->#SQJX
;;"#7
"
;"=4
;'-
J@# %@PW¯\#-
l%#-<B}CD`PQL"#L>#&*"#'V/b>O
EKJ"
`E"#-
i=N"-#4%'(;&?h"!*%&('(G#n/
&%#;Q&%'EKQ(,->#hPi"#afS?PQ#J%#;W->#W"%?,
U?#
'<&A%->#B
qi
WGEK#7"''!->'()"=<-#eE'-!G&?XQ"e=N''(APWB
L-%t
#7"#;7
;A"'4V#;@#%/l|(
-;L%,=T;#%#;AS
#-
k%#->l%&'("#VH/k"#7#Bdqi
<SePQM;&!"#,
#7>#
i#?>-
;A./*$%&('(G#n/&A"%-#)-
%
ZT
"#%;->O
'("#o%o"=:!G#7&@#)%i;"#%#;I!G#%_"'?#7@#(S-
%
ZJ7GJ(;'<&A%->#->'(A*:'GP4BoY;'(&Ý
"h
"#7&`O
#M%%
M=N"#L->#%&'_G#VH/}&A"%-#L!GM/>'(}
@#
E'-
=I
J7G(J;A"'e&%-#T;"#%#%:
R,!G#7&#
!G*PW(''D#?-;L:%##%-
'V,=_#&ëLJ7!>:.,=$
-
%@#D"=
4J/>J&B
2.1 Finding a Ground Truth Ordering
ì>=N"#%-
!G'V/.S
@#,T
RAE'(
',#-
!Y%#->
=N"#&ë=V
#`U;*>.;-
&?%On>.;-
&.$%&'("#VH/lE'-
#);"#%#;)%&'_G#VH/ %A"#;7#%-
'VB
íiîï8ðñò>óÜvB)ô:õ_óWõ[ñö<î:÷Tï8ø
ù<óWò>ú:ûýüJþ9ÿ _ÿ:þ ÿ 9ÆÍ7ÅÉÓ Ð Gà4È[Ì
àTÊ:Æ"È2ÐyÆÊYÆ Ç7Ð[ÅXÐ2ÓÉÍ7ÐNÈ2
è 7à@È2ÏQàà@ÊÖªà XÑKÆAË ç Î
Å*à@ÊÈ2Ç ç Ç7Ð["Ê !*ÉÊYà%êÈnà@Í@Ê!ÉÓ æç ÉÓ ÐNÈ2èÅàÉ"Ç ç Í%à #
qi
@#WT"#A")>A'f=9#7>#
X>=N#&*GM&'(;Vh*
#7G#;@;A'
Y>#;#e&.(
AZ:GEKB5
#eU&'(S
X>.;-
&?Q %
$'&"()$'&+*,.-0/)1"2+*3.-0*),.-0/)1.254+1.6)7./58"&0$'&09L;'_"%
h AEK#7&#D%&('(G#hX#W>.;-
&.e(,!Gh&
;'(%*!"l%-%(L"=!G;'(%B€-#%
@#&#Se!"
.;-
&.Ii'(a'V/`$:D&"#)%&'("#i$"
#i.;-&.e
:
# $+&"()$'&'*),.-0/)1.20*3.-0*,"-0/)1,;'(%%e!%).#'/X->%O
%($=o
")#R"=5
4%#Bhzn.-
VEK'V/.S$&J)%&('(G#
.;-
&.$t
"`%-#;M"#M "
#`.;-&.Zk
%->#;½ *;'(%Si=[''APiAd./|%Mb%('(Y;'("%%S)
l%
<B
qi
@#ZG#Z;#%7
'V/M;A%)PW
#T'.;A"tT#7"#;7./
.
;;->#7"'V/k#¹
;*>.;-
&.X%(&'("#Vn/.<
B ;Q
%(@#
.;-
&.<(=
$'&'()$'&'*,"-0/)1.2+*54',"/'>?SPW
;@TG#i'&J;#%7"
'V/
&#%&'("#TM
%*(?
>5@./)7+7.-51'A"2+*54',"/'>R
Y %*
$'&"(5$'&'*,.-/)1.2'>CB/5D-51'ABWzHM-#W"&
'S>
%4;A"%D`)"=_O
=N;)-#WE"'(-
"M;#V#(X%
;PQ4AEK#74GEK#h
J7"JO
;W=o&*"?/,>.;-
&?B
q9M=[#&*"'(*
Y=)J7"
;=[#& M%->#;,.;->O
&.f)
"
#9.;-
&.<
o
#7G#;@./PQQ>s!E ÉÅXÐNÓ ÐyÉÓ
ÑÐNÇÈgÉÊ!Ë7à@B
÷T.ò F.õ[úfõ_û:õ_ï8úÝvH
B Gà@È$È[Ì
àZ=2"&'(("'D>J7
;JI.K 0ML0N I>6%@ÍJÆÅëÉ
Ç@Æ ç Í%Ë7àXÑKÆAË ç Åà@Ê
È L ÈgÆ*ÉÊ:ÆÈ[Ìà@ÍXÑÆAË ç Åà@Ê
ÈOItÐNÊLÉ ËÓÉÇÇWÌ?Ðgà@Í%É"ÍÎ
Ë7Ì?èJ@àZÈ[Ìà*Ñ"ÐNÇÈgÉÊ:Ë7àP@Í%ÆÅ LRQ ÇZËÓÉÇÇZÈgÆ,È[Ì
àXÅÆÇÈWÇTSàËÐ UQË*ËÓÉÇÇ
ÑKÆÅZÐNÊ:É"È2ÐN"Ê !7Æ"È[Ì L É"Ê:=
Ñ IE# V
zH\->#$J/J&S9GPQEK#AS8Pi
GE`;''(%A\V#;"#%/
:'APcsU`>X"=<>#W
`
"#AX
0 #'(G(E'V/X=N@PD6
.;-
&.e:GEKh!Gh8Bqi
#@=N#S#)"#)
'V/`=[->#
:%%'()E'-
I=N"#e=N&'_"'fJ7;S>"Q>
;A`*->#TvB
!&D
%$>(J7"
;D")=[''APW»
WX !R
þ YZ\[E]_^!ÉÅ*a
à `*^.;-
&.W"#4,
4&;'(%B
 dH†Hˆ¨(Žn›N•V…V”KŠg† fK%›
Vb iŽH‰n7‹ŽHXŽn„Kh„K…V‰J‹‰n—J„G’T‹†e‹WŽH‰n5 c…VãA”KˆA‰H…V”ãDŽn„Ke
”KˆŽnX‡I… ŽH„X‹h
” djikf†n0Œ lnm
Document Hierarchy
Unrelated Documents
Cousin Class Documents
Sibling Class Documents
Same Class Documents
Query Document
oPpqO5Z\r]nstuRuRNþOpvvwRZ"5)Y)wEÿ!þEÿvJuO5eÿ)xOZ"
[þOpOyzp{|{>Z þ}~ ÿ{qO)Y0Z9
x ÿEY+qR\>Z þE0€
W þRY0Zr]e^
ÐTÓ ÐNÊ'!ǂ`^.;-
&?i"#4%
'
;'("%%B
W þRY0Z\ƒE]„IÆ ç Ç7Ð[Ê
ÇR`X^.;-
&?e"#D ;'("%%iPW
;7 G#
s #J);-
%
B
W þRY0Z\…E]†8ÊÍàÓÉÈnà%ÑX`kqi'GPQJ*;&&l;J#,"=
.;-&.h;'(%%))#.AB
{ EK$W%-#;e.;-
&.ASPQoPW%4W-
%5=2"&'(("'?J7;
D#I.;-&.8D;J%#-
;o)!G#%_"'?%(&'("#Vn/Z"#7#
GEK@#)%$>.;-
&.BI]->#W#7'8#
;('4(»
‡ Êk)É ˆà@Í%É !.Šà ‰)È[Ì
à`È2Í ç à`Ç7Ð[ÅXÐ2ÓÉÍ7ÐNÈ2èMÆ ÑKÆAË ç Å*à@ÊÈ2ÇXÈgÆ
É Ç@Æ ç Í%Ë7àÑKÆAË ç Å*à@ÊÈDÑ.à%ËÍà%ÉÇà@ÇXÅ`ÆÊ:ÆÈgÆ"Ê
ÐyËÉÓNÓ è,ÏoÐNÈ[Ì
[È Ì
àkÉÅXÐ2Ó Ð2ÉÓfÑÐNÇÈgÉÊ!Ë@àa@Í%ÆÅmÈ[Ì>ÉÈWÑKÆAË ç Å*à@ÊÈg#
{ EKM
h#;
'S
!,->#>s!V(M"==2"&('('9J7;S
=[#$"./%->#;`>.;-
&?)t
#7"#;7
;A"'oV#;"#%/PiZ;A
>#EK)!G#%_"'!#7>#
4"=9"''!#i>.;-
&?oXD>V#;O
"#%/.B5×")
"ePiD$
"iEK./`?-&#;A'!.#>#7"
R
% =2"&'(("'D>J7
;ME'-
B|Y 'V/l:!l
":GEKXJ7GA\&
;VH/#
;'(»4 %-#;`.;-&.
AEK#7"`&"#X%&'("#4*&@On;'_"%T.;-&.!"t
`%'(Og;'(%4>.;-
&?AS"!MLAEK#7"$&#4%&'("#
T%
'
Og;'("%>.;-
&.e! Z;-
%>On;'_"%).;-&.AS>!
%8B
÷Zò.F.õ[úfõ(û:õ[ï<úrw.BHGà@ÈÈ[Ìàl=2"&('('L"#7#Œ‹P Ž+‘j’€Æ“ÖÉÓ[Ó
Ñ ÆAË ç Åà@Ê
È2Ç$ÏoÐNÈ[ÌMÍà@ÇTSà%ËÈhÈgÆ ÉÇ@Æ ç Í%Ë7à`ÑKÆAË ç Å*à@ÊÈ L 7à”‹  Ž •j’g–
—.0˜{Nj™ 6 šI K 0ML0N“˜ 6k›}I K 0ML0Nj™ 6œ
qiI"#7#IE#%/$PiA"aZZ
"5=[#QDEK`%->#;SK&J
V#I=<.;-
&.o"#WI;&
"#7"
'Boqih&*GpH#VH/Z=:
>J(;D!G`É"Íà)&*S
APiEK#ASfG#Z"&*.;-&.
""#$EK#%/ %&'_G#`T%-#;T"!L.;-
&.h!GG#
&Z-
;7Y'%T%&('(G#ABqi,E#%/t
=);"#%#;T7"'Q%&`O
'("#Vn/d"#7#
Y(*%&PW!G*%-
%:;ASh*:/.!l\;#%7"
:?AS)
"#t%&
'V/b-
#'_GA<B¿]-#,=2&'('"#7#
&*"aK$
R>J(;Z:nPiY
*>.;-
&.$Y
&J
>J7.);A"#%/.SPW
;@=[#&h
4-
'a*=5$.;-&.h(
#:%V"#%/.B
]D=?;-#%I->#9>#
;
'o!G<%#-o%(&'("#Vn/$;@#A%8&O
;A"'('V/ PW,=2"&('('J7;4.D)'VPiA/>W
'(<BI~APhO
EK#TVZ4#A"%!"
'U>:;$
"AS|AEK#7"So,#7
a?
J/>JŸ
& ž!G`";;"#7`:%@#XPWV|=2&'('h"#7#
RPW''h:
:@%#W! !")";;"#7)'(%D;'%'V/.B
¨<—ˆAŒK‰H†nhŽH„K)‰J‹”Š…V”Kã4†g’†gŽHâ¸—7‹”K”KˆŽQâ$‹ŠAWŒK†HWˆ¨<ŽH„KWK…V‰n—ŽnˆA‰n’
…ž5Žn †H• ¨:¨_ˆA‰5ŽH„K…V†I†nŽH‹Žn7â4”GŽoŽHˆ4„KˆA•Vå
2.2 Comparing Orderings
Ci
4:(.ASfPi
AEK`>#EKAt !G#%('o#7>#
M=_#&·
EK,#7"#;7
;A"'8>V#;#%/,"!*+.-
#%/ 0 %->#;G6Q>.;-
&. L S
!Gi:'
Q(D(@#7"#;7?/.B9W
`PW%*T-%D(e!G#%O
(':"#7#
4$E'-!Gh
);#%#;@
%e=9 0 '&J@6o7"'
#7>#
*#?>-
;?/ ->#J/>J&B ¡\3#!"
W
$&JD;&`O
&b&
?k=$;&!G#
\nPiY#7"
a?
,
tÃ?:A"#&*"
#7ac;#%#'_GF;.@j;.AB·qi(R&A"%-#\(L:JR%-
VA
;&!G#(Y#7a?(*PWVd=NP # \(S"!l,E'-
;"#%#%:
$L3AG#%
¢R;.@j;.Mu wGÕxyBqi#*"#`nPi
&*R#
'&)PWt-
%*Ã?:A"#&*"L;#%#'(G(Y;.@j`O
;.)=N#)
4>#%.WPi"#afBh#JAS:)&.(
AfS#$"#T
%#&
-
?-
&Z:#"=i4Y
`"=i
T#7
a?
0 !&'/
"#-!\%#->\#7a?(.6@So"!Y%;
<So%
;`PQ,"#*&#
;
;#A¯PWV€;#%7c#
"=ZR#7"
a?
!"c>O
# 0 B BSf
$:6@S
PiZPQ-'_L'aKZ,
"-#7"'9Ph/*&A"%-#
V#;@'/\
APµ&*./R=h|­H&:#%7".®M#7a>;@;Z"#
:
Y&*L;#%#;'V/.B { EKb%R'SD&#
"-#7"'
&A"%-#W
n
£#-%a"'O { .?>&*J
¤luVvA´"xyB
÷T.ò F.õ[úfõ_û:õ_ï8ú¿´?BH9ÆÍYÆÍ%ÑKà@Í@ÐNÊ'!Çv‹P¥ÖÉ"Ê:Ñ}‹H¦ e
‰ ¤ 0 ‹P¥ N ‹H¦76tÐ[Ç
w¨§©nªu‘‹P¥ N ‹H¦XÉ!Í%à7àZÆÊ 0«ONj¬ 6eš­‹P¥ N ‹H¦XÆÍ%Ñ.à@Í 0 «®Nj¬ 6nx¯lv
zH.-EK'/.S
#D"#D$;#%7*?-
&Z:#I=9.;-&.Q
V#S
\*EK\"#7#
'/R&*"aKIpJ-!>&.:->4%&Z=
%h!"#B9c
Z;&
"#
)HPQ#7>#
SPih'.aT'/ZG
e!"#9=:>.;-
&?f!G5:$"#7#
5&*aKe5pJ-!>&.
:-ABFCÁE"'-
R=vR,:#%=N;@";;#7fSDÙ(*
L@U:;A
E'-
e=fW#7!>&F"#7#S!$OvQ!>;A"o:#%=[;5#E#%A
;;#7fB4X;'_"& !G4V=enPi*#7a>¨
‹P¥,
~
‹H¦4V¶f#4
°
# ¤kE'-PWVt#%:; ,"#-!%#-
‹H±%S<L
#7>#
XPWVM4
H
# ¤\PW''9::%#h#7"
a?
B
2.3 Regions of the Orderings
qi?-
Sf(Et,>V#;#%/.S<,+.-
#%/.;-&. L S<"!R%&`O
'("#VH/|&%-# L ²T³ S5PQ*;A|;
J%#-;ZnPiL"#7#
0 GEK#
.;-
&.R
>#;#%/
6@»X#-
R%#->t=N&'_"'Q"#%O
@#(}
‹P Ž'‘j’SQ
kM#7>#
\(
-;A|./|->#%&('(G#n/
&A"%-#Ÿ
‹ ´µH•j’ BDT;AL
L;A';-'_GX
T;"#%#%:
¤\E'-BIqi
WE"'-
(EW-
WX&A"%-#D=4+.-!'VH/,"=
#7a?(=N#!"+.-
#%/.;-&.)PWVR#%:;D,
"D%&`O
'("#VH/\&A%->#
Y>#;#%/.B*~DGPQEK#AS8PiAtMEK
%%,"=h
AP°.?-#$#7a?(Z"#*";#%Z''i+.-#%/\.;->O
&.BznX>#(;
'SPiW;A`V#;'V/ZU?!4
P
¤MJ7GJ(;)"
=N''(APWBIhV#7G L "E#e'':.;-
&.S.""#KG(X"''
;
;"#7
.$"!R%;"#7
"?!"#S8"!RE?(
*./
$7"'
?-
&Z:#h=!V#B
zHR"#7#,&#Z#;(%'/RE"'(-
"`-##%-
'VS<
APiE#AS
Pi4;';-
'(GA #!G#%('VgO ¤YE"'-
i
"W&!% >¶f@#%O
.#=e
T#7@#(=
B ¶I;7R!G#%_"'V“O ¤k!"%ARL
=[#7";\=e;#%#;@4;&
"#7"
'X
V#Æ `ÉMË@à@Í7ÈgÉÐNÊ|È2è Sà@BZ]-#
H/>:WG#»
·®¸¹+º•¸M»O¼¾½)¿ ¤‚]”;i"'(;-
'("A4=[#&Ö
'V/
V#9"=>.;-&. 0 I Û N I V 6
PW
#°
I PiW=[#&m4&;'("%")4%-#;$.;->O
&.W
Û I Ph")=_#&¾X%'(;'(%B
V
À”Á.®½¸M»z½)¿ ¤‚]n;i';-'_GA4=[#&€'V/!"V#8"=
>.;-
&? 0 I Û N I V 6
PW
#°I Û PiW=[#&m4&;'("%")4%-#;$.;->O
&.W
I V Ph")=_#&¾X;-
%L;'("%B
ŒK‰ˆA‰nK‰H…V”Kãh‰Hˆ"KŒK—†ŽH…V†9‡I„K”Ž2‡5ˆ)Kˆ"—7Œâ47”GŽn†Ã ‹”=à „K‹7äG
j¡ Km ‹—%Žn• ’4ŽH„i†J‹â4I†H…Vâ4…V•‹‰n… Ž2’DŽnˆ)Žn„Ki†nˆAŒK‰H—iˆ—ŒKâ4”GŽ‚Û GÄ å b „KV ”ZŽn„K…V†
„.‹K?”K†fc … ŽW…V†)”@‹‰n• ’,‹• ‡o‹7’†W‘?7—7‹ŒK†n_
Ä …V†)ˆA‰gŽH„ˆAãAˆA”.‹•9Žnˆ`‘?ˆŽH„XÃ
Û
‹”K¨Ã †n…Vâ4…V•‹‰H… Ž2’4œ)ŽHˆ‘?ˆŽn„"JÆ å
V=Å
ÇCÈjÉ Ê ËMÌOÍCȊËMÉ ÎÌMÏÐ MÑ ÒMÒÓ Ô‘ÕTÕÖTÖTÖC× ØMØÙgÚMØCבÛÜgÚ
ÇCÈjÉ Ê ËMÌ®ÐÝ ÐÞ Ì
ß àjáÜgâTãØäHߓåTåÛgã×OÛæ:çMÛÒMØä“âTãØMèPéTØÜMêTáäå:ØägêkßTÜTÙgÛÜMáÒgØ
ÇCÈjÉ Ê ËMÌOËMëÐÌMìjÈjÊí
Õ Ñ“ÛàáMÕÚgØÜMêTáäjåÕMãTèîMÙåMïØägê“ïؓåMåÛMãTâMØғâTÛäå
ÇCÌTÐÐÝ ÏCìjðgñ"òÝ Ï Í Ègó
ò ðÝ ôMÌRõ ž VŠö ðÐÌMÎ ö Í Ý ðÐ{ëjÏ Í:ÐÌgÊÎJò.ÌMÝ ìj÷ÐÝ ÏCì
ø õù)ú ûü
ÇCÝ Î
ÿ¾ë ÐÌMìjÈjÊí
ý ëjÏ þ
ÕѓÛàáMÕÚgØÜMêTáäjåÕMãTèîMÙåMïØägê“ïؓåMåÛMãTâMØғâTÛäå
Û
Û
ÕѓÛàáMÕÚgØÜMêTáäjåÕMãTèîMÙåMïØägê“ïؓåMåÛMãTâMØғâTÛäå
Û
V
ÕѓÛàáMÕÚgØÜMêTáäjåÕMãTèîMÙåMïØägê“ïؓåMåÛMãTâMØғâTÛäå
ÛMž
ÕѓÛàáMÕÚgØÜMêTáäjåÕӓèTØäMÒjå
Û
Û%Û
ÕѓÛàáMÕÚgØÜMêTáäjåÕMãTèîMÙåMïØägê“ïؓåMåÛMãTâMØғâTÛäå
Û
V
ÕѓÛàáMÕÚgØÜMêTáäjåÕӓèTØäMÒjå
ÕѓÛàáMÕØÓgØÜTÒàjáägÒgïMèMâ âägÚgÕTÚMØTÜgêMáä“âäMÚ
Û
ÇCÌTÐÐÝ ÏCìjðgñ'òÝ Ï Í ÈMòŸðÝ ôMÌRõ ö Ï ÈðÐÌgÎ ö ÏCÈzÐÌgÊÎhò.ÌMÝ ìj÷ÐÝ Ï ì
ø õù)ú üù
ÇCÝ Î
ÿ¾ëÐÌMìjÈjÊí
ý ëjÏ þ
Õ
g
Ü
á
M
æ
á
M
Ü
á
“
ä
ã
M
á
ÕTèMâÙgÜMØTܓâáåÕMâäêTáӓáägêTáTäMғïMèMâٓÜMØTÜgâMágå
Û
Û
ÕѓÛàáMÕÚgØÜMêTáäjåÕMãTèîMÙåMïØägê“ïؓåMåÛMãTâMØғâTÛäå
Û
V
ÙTîjåâägágåMåÕTâägêîåÒTܓâTágåMÕTãTÛäåÒMÜTîãÒgâMÛäïTØägê“ïàjØMâäMÒMáTägØä“ãMá
Û ¡
ÕÙMîåâägá“åTåÕTâä“êîjåÒMܓâáåÕTØÚgÜgâMãîèÒî“ÜMágïTØägê“ïægÛܓágåÒgÜ Û
Û ¡
ÕÜgáMãÜMáTØTÒgâÛä“ÕÒTÜgØgágèTÕTÜMá“åáMÜgØTғâÛäå
ÛMž
V
ÕÜgáMãÜMáTØTÒgâÛä“ÕÒTÜgØ gágèTÕTÜMá“åáMÜ gØTғâÛäå
ÛMž
ÙTîjåâägágåMåÕTâägêîåÒTܓâTágåMÕTãTÛäåÒMÜTîãÒgâMÛäïTØägê“ïàjØMâäMÒMáTägØä“ãMá
Û
ÛMž
oPpqO5ZhƒE]¨x®Z.)Nþ®p{ZÿO Nþ®Z¾xMGÿ­ TÿhxRkZ"5Z>þE°uR.
5\Z" Z" Z.CNþOp{ wŒ)Z. uzZ.Y0}ÿ w®Z {\Ztÿ{qO)Y0Z
8x ÿ®Y0q\Z>þE€ o9ÿ\Yÿ:þ­ 5 0yeZ?p{|{Z}wOZ‚Z. h
þRx wOZ
Tÿ) h Z" [þOp{0€}9
o ÿvZ"Y)wt8
x ÿ®Y0q\>Z þEJ9
w ÿ`þay_Z
p{|{Z
wOZó5! þy­wOZó
¾)ŠÿwOZŸ ÿ{q®YZ 9
x ÿEY+q\>Z þ­0y­!
þOx
wOZY0 Z"!p ÿ)Ö
üeL
Z ÿ­
¨wOZqO)Q
ÿHwOZ9
x ÿEY+qZ þ­)5€
¤‚]%;i';-'_GA =_#& 'V/ V#c=|.;-&.
0 I Û N I V 68PW#:I Û Pi5=[#&F
i"&i;'(%ei%->#;
.;-
&.W"!XI V Pih=[#& "M-#'("M;'(%B
qi%
"#%('VgO ¤°E'-L''APiA€-
Ml
%:;@L
AP·E"#VO
-
h%&'("#VH/,&A"%-#h:#%=[#&A* EG#-
i#)"=9
#7"
a?
BI
#eU&'(SK%
'
"“O ¤L:#%=[#&*"
;W!>(;"I
AP
PQ''8s
>J(;DG#4:
Z&*
AG#h
M=9
D=N"O
&'('.#7a?(SGPW
'Q-#'(GA>gO ¤:#%=N"#&*;Q&A"%-#8
AP
PQ''f;KG#%#WJ
;@(
hG#:T&*Bì#'_GA>gO ¤:
-?-
%-!"''/k'AP l#'(G(dY%'(gO ¤Ö*'%|t.?l(
VO
;"#X=W%V-!G
TPW
\
"=W
'JXXOn+.-!"'n/
=_#&Ü|#;%}J7"!:? ->,&*./d%&'("#.;-&.
AEKX:R#7"
aKRE#%/L'AP°!L
@#=N"#X&V%A=_#&Á
M"=
'J 0 '&J)'VPh/>W:;A-%
=[A"->#iPi@#.
%
"#%S<"!L>.;-
&.h!GPQ#X";-!"''/%(&'("#:A"#A
X:4#%
!'_6@B
zn}-#w?S)Pi\%
AP·"€@U
"&
'L!GM#¹
;M-#JO
%-&,!GW'_G##DE'-
h"=
n
¤YJ7"J;$;#%#%:! "#7"&#)%%
W
"h/>'(M:%#W#%-'VB
» !0º#"%$
'&¿
3. DOCUMENT REPRESENTATION
zn
)%;LPi$PW''5%;-%D
$%:;s
;X>.;-
&?h#O
#%.7"*"!Z#&FPQ.
4IPQ);7
%i4E'-!G
-%
Z;7
_+.-->'(AM":GEK)
B (8@h
DY .;-&.
ºL:##%.A,./MZ!
*,+ – —?0 - + Û N/. + Û 6 N010'0 NA0 -3+ 2 N/.4+ 2 6 œ
´
PW# - + "#e#&5-
%A$Z#>#%.
Dº 0 B BS@#&9=N-
!
M´ ;..)! ;@#%OyPW!APWW=º9S
"#)'(a>iZºf6@S
!
. + G#R;#%#%:!>(Pi?BFzn,
AP #&*
k>(%;-
%
ÏÌ?Ð2Ë7Ì)Pi#7>o%
-'(Z:i'_";AT(`.;-
&.A½ 5!"S."!$PW
PW
"WPi(.AB
3.1 Choosing Terms
#,:dL;.. ¯;@#%Og!"%A¯"
#;7
ShPQ
;7
%$#&GEK"''<~qW5(t;&&.S76KAE%;#>W;?S?7"
0 U>;>$½ *98,
½!U?@6@S
M
On'
:;4;7!G#7;#BhCÂJ>O
Pi"#7M'J;.7
Z#-
'V/;:ÙÙX#&iPh""'(%*"
'(AfB
"#)$;@#%Og!"%A#;78S
PQ$&X-
J)"'% >;(4AP
&*./lPi"#7 |t'=_L"!d#."=Z€;@=
# <3> + 0 ;@#Q'(a>$=_#&µ!¼TT
Dºf6o%
-
'(:D
;'(-
A
*3+!BYiU>:#&.A4PWVX#QJ%#7"(I=[#I
o;(%8B
zH,"'(':;%S?
D;@#%OyU?e%'=8?= <3> + Q
;'(-
AfS>IPi''
h'4"=o.;-&.hº9Beqi
>#J%#7G)=N''AP4»
@DB
ö Aõ_ø Ci;7
.%,%&s
U>AtPW
APr%=
D°S!Y'VPh/>
(;'-!>
DÀPi"#75i'=[ASK!E
DÞPi"#75Q#.AS
F
= <,> + BQÃ>:;s
;A''V/.S>Pi4-
%G
DIH — Ù N Õ N : N vA³ N ´K+w œKB
ô J8úfûö:ø
û:õ_ø Cio-
%o%.;SG!G#7"#7
<S!~qW5
 (<Oy#(O
;@( ;7
(+?-i?/
&;A"'('V/*:-
!*
#
"#-!K
<3> + !"`
;'(-
AkL
* + B¯qi#&*"#%/
.;-&.8=[A"->#!G5"#e;A
'(Q=>%#(#4WPW>O
APY;-%Og¶X"#I!G#7#7"
4:-
!"#SG7'I;''K:-!>O
"#S'(JWV&Ý:-
"#S"!*!"#7*#a?QPW
;7 =['VO
'(AP·%?
;R:-!"#B
qi
M;7
_+.-#%-
'VA
(LE#%/,!"#%#APÖPW(
APWD
"DAEK#7"AL;'%$'V/´
Pi#7>W(MV
#DV#;@(8B
MB
ï Nõ_ø
ö<%ñ Cio-%eh%&
';7
(+?-=N"#-%%
W(;o:-
!?O
"#)"hPW(;7*X:-!
)# !"iW
;'-
AfB
qi
M>#&*"#%/|=N"-#`!"X%#(#*(X:-
\"#
A
T:
S
'JW!>S!7'!>B¸C}!G#%O
(;-
'("#'V/;&& ;A%$
!>'AM./ %PW!>GPW)Ph"
!"Z=)>.;-
&?$;&:%A"=)%EK#7"'e#(
SIA";@
:
DPWVX%;#EKiA>#o
Z;
%J
"=:
'(J)=o->#') ;4"=!GDA>#AB 1 )=[-!
?/T
3
MBï Nõ_ø
ö<ñ
->#J(;iAEK#7"A*:-hw?vWPi"#7i
%(`V
#)%(4"=5
4"
;7
"#AB
3.2 Stemming Terms
$U>'("#AM
$¶f;"=e>#TV¶f#.DJ&&
`E"#(GO
»
O$P
ï A@û:òQ
ó CWqi
W#&°Q'=[ie(Bozg=<Q:A"#Q(`WJ
'JAS
))>#
:AfB
ô
û:ò>G
ó CWqio@#&€8J&&AD-%
W3#%@#A½ 8Pi''Ka?
APW4J&`O
&(t'"#& u wwAx)R#&GEK*Pi"#7l
Bkzn=)
J&&A E#%L=o$@#& "
:AG#
4J&&A
EK#%"=5->#)J
'JAS!V))>#:A<B
ô
û:Bï NAû!òQ
ó CWqi
Q@#&¸(5J&&A$I:GEKS=N"#IQ-#:%
=W;7
;7a?(MPW
@
#$
`@#&·J&·ZYJ
'JAB
zn=$VS)
L#&À(M>#
:AfSD"
#%PW%t
R#
'
ç ÊÇÈnà@ÅXÅ*à%Ñ#&m)A*X
>B
qi
$ô!û!Pï NRAû:ò>ó¯EG#(.hh:
@s!;(':V=9Wi;A"%!Gi
-
%@=N-
'%W=5$#&Ý;A"M:4>#&
*./#:#%W=
ViJ&Ý&"#";;->#7"'V/*!",./`>#:#%i"=9D#&
V%'V=HB
3.3 Term Weighting
Cm=N-#%#;
%(@#7"b(l
#7G(>.;-
&.X!
APÖZ#&½ i=_#A+.-
;/*%
-
'(M:%;A"'A<BQCÖ;'AG#):
sW=
,qhQB zH^€=2"&'/=WPi?t=[-
;@(
Z(T!GZ/|G%O
?-!G
PQ.D=5#&iPWVL
L.;-&.i=[#+?-
;@/.B
qi
%D&
;W#&°PQ.
$%;7
&SK
APiE#AS>&'(V=_/
ePi.e=!@#&PWXEK#%/$'AP¯>.;-
&.=_#A+.-
;/.B5qi
&'s
;A"(IX=2";i.?X=N"#h?Og
.;W+.-
#SPW
#)#7"#
–"ŽnˆA"‡ˆA‰HK†ZKˆ”KˆŽTãA%ŽT—7ˆAŒ”"Žn‡e„7”\K%ŽH‰nâ4…V”K…V”K㠎n„K`‡I…V”KKˆ7‡
— ŒŽn1ˆ S<å
@#&m( 4+.-
@#%/ %-'_,:4EK,
4&JW(&:"#%7;BozH
;% PW# PQMG#ZpH-!
\.;-&.Z%&'("#VSQ#7G#
@#&"#\&X-;@c'%L-%=N-'$M/}"#\=_€n/>:S#7G#
&S9#$"
#T
.
;A"'I@#&!GTE#%'V/G¶f;4
%&'("#VH/&A%->#Bqi#=[#SePi '%\@U:@#(&?YPW
&
"(;4#&`OyPQ.
`%;7
&W
""%?-
"4:
Z!4'APl.;-&.%Oy=[#A+.-
;/)#&B9qi
Q(>AW
"9&_?O
=_#A+.-
;/#&)!AEK4Z"#A"J­n#%'(E?
,:APi#®,
"
PFu w"´>SwÙGxyB5W;A''!%-;@%;7
&)Ê!ÆÊ
Å`ÆÊ:Æ"ÈgÆÊ
ÐyË4ÑÆAË ç Åà@Ê
È
7Íà æç à@Ê:ËU
è TV,W5XH?YD=[-
;@(
B
C)
"
#$;&:.4=i@#&ØPi.
!"4PQ;%(#AS
"!XPW(;7!"Q%-
J7"?("'
&!";I->#i+.-
'VH/Z&%#;SK
Ñ"ÐNÇÈgÉÊ:Ë7à*ÏQà@Ð !GÌ.È2ÐN"Ê !BTc
t-%
"Y"
;7
"#%On
%A\#K";@
"=5$EKPW!>AP}%(S>(JA*=8%#A"X"'(':#&e
AG#W
"
;7
"Z
# < > +`+?-
''V/.S.Pi; PQ.h
&r!"%A ,V#)JO
7"
;D=[#&µ
D
;7
"# 0 PWVM"
;7
#%OyPQ#7e
&%'EKiEK
>J7
;iÙK6@B5CD8PQePW''?%QXÃ>;`Ä.S"Q-%e"=:)J7;O
%AT"%>-
"4=[-
;@($(T;pJ-
;$PWVT'("#Q;@#%O
PW
APWW%(
Vs!;.'V/*(&>#GEKe#%-
'Vh-
#Q-#iE"'-!"
&%-#B
4. DOCUMENT SIMILARITY METRIC
qi&%#;XPiX-
%`=N"#T&A%->#( `%&('(G#n/Y"=W.;-O
&?I
ee
Q[?ÉKËËÉÍJÑË7ÆGà\bËÐgà@Ê
È2Beqi36K";;AG#7*;.j;.
"=5HPQ`%Z
<Â"!5
*¿D>s!AM"
L²T³5]f0 < N X
* 6 –
š <_^;*š
š <_`;*š
zn,#E>-
i%;@(MPiU>
'(
APcPQ##%.h
>.;-
&?-
%
! 0 2B B9&Z-
'V%76@B`#4
Z
->#:%4"=
Z
:#TPi,U?!a
6K;;"#7=[#& %@ZL!"Z?/Y
'V/?O
,
-
R"!M
*?@#%;<B)qi
D$?/,7a?
*&*"UY!&&Z-
'V
';VH/Y=W#&S=[#X*-
k!
.#%;@(L:#7G
S#%:;EK'/.B
qi#A"%
i
"iPQ=N.;-
h*
3
6K;;A"#7M&%-#)#7"#
`);'_"%%;A'oËÆÇÐNÊ:àI&A"%-#)"#W&*'/X%;A'("
'n/;O
%(>#7"Bl
#`%;A'
\-#X%&('(G#n/?On%"#;7l;7
(+?-,
&*"%%EKI.;-&.9"7"%8PQo#'/
b
WLÐNÊ!Î c$É"Ç%Ì.ÐN"Ê !5;@>O
(+?-B,qi
&*"Y(A #4!"%Y
ZY.;-&.
%-;@
"D
T.;-&.h!""#T%&'_G#AS<;;#7,*->#
%&'("#VH/t&A"%-#S8G#X&*:A Z"&X
-;@aPWV\
>#
'VH/L+?-
'<*$%(&'("#Vn/L:HPQ&”
B ;e#A"
%-;@,4!"%=N-
;=N"#i
W;%
&%-#WQ$->#ia?
APW'VO
k:k#'&BY]
*#`
!fSI;#A"t%-;@
%W():%%'(=[#)
6;;AG#7&A%-># 0 %u ÄGx[6@B
YM-%Al-#E"'(-
"l&?'/|tEK#V=[/|
"`
6;;AG#7;.j;.i!Xh;%D&A"%-#h/>'(`;&
"#7'
#%-
'VB -#%#*E?(;M=[#*
.-
VEKL"
:A"'D"=4->#
&%-#M(>#GE>(>Al€uVvAÒ"xyShPW#M
=
6K;;A"#7d;.j;.
-:#%=[#&e''!;&:V#I&A"%-#o=N"#ei7%aX"=<s
%&'("#V:nPiPi#7>B)×4
")
$
-'(a =o
4PQ#a
>#%.A#Q>.99:!PW
@
# 6K";;AG#7T"#;%(
-%AB d'V/4`Ã?;ZÚWhPiI#A+.-
V#Ie-%e"=
e
6K";;AG#7
;.j;.AB
5.
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS OF
PARAMETER EVALUATION
#\E"'-!"¯
kEG#-
tJ%#7">%;-
%%A¸¿Ã?;O
Y´?S<PQZ&
'A/
T&
?>'"/R%;#:AL(YÃ>;\w?B
YD"&
'A,]:^V#;@#%/Lu w?v@xfTW´ÙÙ$!V#i"=9;'(-J#
TˆAâ4… ŽŽn„KZ7†n—‰H…VŽn…VˆA”Rˆ¨QŽn„K†HXj m?7‰n…Vâ4”"Žn†4‹†… Ž…V†”KˆŽŽn„K
¨_ ˆ"b —7Œ†eˆ¨fˆAŒK‰o‡5ˆA‰nŠ>å
oPp{qO5Z<…E]W,ÿ®Y0q\Z>þEh5Z"uR5Z. Z>þE ¾[ÿ:þO0€gfa5pZ"ihkj®Z.x
!þOYw9ÿl [þRx9ÿR °#e"O%p.|{ZmzZ" Z"_)Z.qR0yBqO°ÿu®
Y0%xO8
þO
Yn NþRx8ÿ ŸY)wOZ.|{Z.x h5Z.qRo w
9
w ÿ5 Z""|{Z.5¾p5
Z N þO9
x ÿ # p+Z{€
=[#&Ý
V#7 'EK'f #7G#;@./.S)>
;A,#E?-%'V/
->#MvB CD4-#4%-#;"=h
G7>S8Pi`-%A\*t;#7PW'
=[#&Â
hÃ?7>=N"#7$Y!Ôi"%i;?7"
DÕ.wD&''(Z
WuvAÄGxyB
]D=>
I-#'4
I&
'e;'-
J#SKÄ?vS Õ³Ò)=
&}Pi#e'(aKA
*./M%&Z>.;-
&?WR->#;@#7APW'2S<"!;-
'(M?-
):T-%A
./-#"
;7
"#%On
%Ak"
#;7
B|qi
%*J%Og%->#'(TPi#
'
aKAYL./\;'%,v*&(''k!"Z|-#T#:%"#%/.Se''
=PW
;@bPi#L-%Al\%-
:"#%
L"
;7
"# %AlJ%#7""/
PiMJ-!AfB q qi,%;¯>%;#:
E'-!G(d"=
J%#7")%-
JARÃ?;M´>B
E#Vs!A\
"X''Q>#*=W->ó
# ¤¯&%-#T/>'(<SPWV
EK#%/\=NP¾@U;So
,&*#'("EKM"#7#X=D!G#7&#
%%
B`znY*%
%S9
4"#&.4$Y
;A"Y=e
#-
J%X"=-# ¤c&A"%-#B\~@#,PQ,#:"#%X,#%-'V
'V/X=N"#eW%('(gO ¤J7"J;BIqi)"#7
o=N#e
h;-
%
JgO ¤
-#'(">gO ¤Y&A"%-#h:
AEK%&'_G#'V/.B
"#o%&Q"=!
e#7"
5%APWXZ(5%;ZhV¶f#
;
O= ¤%;"#i:nPi,>¶f@#.Q
"#7&@#i%%Q&?e%&
+.-
V%&*"''yS2B B
%;
M;&*'<VABI×";S
APiE#AS?!"
XA";@Z#7"
ZPQiU>
'"#i
Q@¶f;o=:D%
'(­n!G#7&#I>VO
&%(
®
:
.'V/.S"%PW
XPiW
X-Z
Q¶f;I`''
­H
"#7"&#h>&
%%®4
DV¶f#;D:;&e%-
J7.('2B
5.1 Results: Choosing Terms
Ã>'(Og¤ÖE'-
`PW
b!,"#L
#7GAd-
%YE"#-
;@#%OyPW!>GPÝ%(SQ-%
rMïBNõ_ø
ö<ñL!bôJ8ú:ûKö:ø
û:õ_økPW>O
AP :-!Sh-%(|
->#'V/d'
a?S)
d-
%
->#'V/d
;??S
"#4EK-#$´>B
qi
i#%-
'VI=[#Q"
;7
"#%On
%AX
>#K";@`-%
'("#)PW>O
APW$#GE?(`:J$#%-'T";;#7>
M-#$E'-
"
;#V#(>Blqi`&*/%& ;-.#?-V(E9 dQ./7"a?(R%&*''
PW!>GPWZ"#-
\
*"
;7
#AS9PiPi-
'(YU>:;$=[Pi#Z%
->#VO
-TPQ#7>ZL:*#%?TkL.;-
&.A½ $!>SI#GE?_>
L
&#Z;;%X#>#%.7"<B
->#%
#U>:#&.D#EA'A
PW./.SKX=N;AS?'("##QPW
APWe>#GE>(>h:
sABo->#)Õ4%APW
h=_#7;,=8>.;-
&.I!"V#QPWV
`
)&D]:^V#;@O
#%/Z;'-
J@#e
"e"#TÆÍ7È[ÌÆ !KÆÊ!ÉÓ 0 2B BS?
;&&TPi"#7765-
O
”G’ZŒK‰H•V†IK‰H†n7”GŽi‘?•Vˆ@‡kŽn„KWŽH„K…V‰nX•V%äG•!‡5‰HW—ˆA•V•‹K†H`…V”GŽnˆ$Žn„K…V‰
Žn„Ks …V‰HZ•VäG•
‹”K—7†gŽHˆA‰e—7‹ŽHãAˆA‰n’Gå
.‹ãA†fŽH„Kâ4†n7• äG†:‡5‰H9ˆ¨?—7ˆAŒ‰H†H9 m—•VŒKK¨_‰HˆAâ|Žn„K5.‹ŽH‹Q†H%Ž
ŽnqˆD u‹teäGv ˆA…V$‘K…‹†@å:˜.Œ‰nŽn„K‰Hâ4ˆA‰H cAŽn„KQ„…VãA„4ˆA‰nŽn„KˆAãAˆA”.‹•V… Ž2x
’ w.ãAŒ‰H†9¨_ˆA‰8Žn„K
•V…V”KŠG›2‘.‹†n7*‹K‰HˆG‹—J¾„ c!†H„ˆ@‡I”*…V”`˜f…VãAŒK‰HZ
 y+c
†n„Kˆ@‡lŽn„.‹ŽW.‹‰nŽn…‹• utev
â4…V‰H‰nˆA‰H†—ˆAŒK•VZ”KˆŽI„.‹7äGW„.‹X‹†H…VãA”… w.—7‹”"Že…Vâ4.‹—%ŽoˆA”XˆAŒK‰o‰n7†nŒK• Žn†@å
oPpqO5ZnzO]{@þE 5Y+qR Z"=¨5w9ÿp!ÿ!þOŠ nÿ¨|¾¾_ÿ{qR¨
þ®
Y)9
w ÿi
N þO9
x ÿ ŠEuzZ¾0€L|®\xóNþRx9ÿR J!þOxtuqO5Z}NþE
5Z.qRCZ¾x N þ x8ÿ®Y0q\Z>þE_R¾p{} wRY)w~eZ.5Z ¾)pZ¾Ýÿ
9w ÿ!p ÿ:þ®gyk\% ®N þ®p
)<wO¾x ÿxOZ" Z"
NþOZ{€
>#o)EK$##%.7"<Be%Q!GPWVZ%&*"''(@#5PW(
AP
%S.&*./$>.;-
&.9
"o%-
'(T:i;%(#AZ%(&'("#IG#
t=2;@Z"#%
'2B,zHR
4;A"%S5
M&-
.4=Q#Pi?
"#I%;A'
;X&>#"Ee#%-'1 d
e##%.7G(
o%&
'V/T
4>#GE>(>X-
t;;%%('%(&'("#Vn/R(>=N"#&*"Y:->
%"#%
'
V#B¯Y'%|% !"ASQ-
#`;O
?e"!`'
aZ
>#K";@S>.;-&.5`
W&h;'-J#iG#
'(G#'V/"#%
'2Beì!>#h
'(a?Og
%A >#K";@<S9ÅÆ"Ç7È<"=
$.;-&.iPWV
LX;'-J#D"#$!"#%PW%$#%!"'2S!#O
EA'
ZT%@#(-
i'&V7",=9$
-#'/X'(a.On
%A*"
#;78B
zn
;&
,'(a>;At:Z-
.=i4: !+.-`%;#O
"#BIzn=fHPQT
i!AEK)&*./Z
'
a?S?
->eD.#%; "=
V#Q'(a>ee&>H/.S"Pi);A/XEK#%/Z'(V%'D:->e%hHPQ
B zni&*/:)!Gi
/%;-
%i"&D;S>
-Q:O
;-
%e
/$G#QP4S/$G#Q
EK#;.;VA<B5zn4
Q;%i"=
"
;7
"#%OgPW
APhOg!%c
>#K";@<S)L;@
;!G,L!"
=[#e
iHPQ4!"e"#W#%!"'!e&Z-
;7X'APi#A‚
B ¶I;7
'
a:S
JA=f:(##%.A`./`%
'D!+.-)->#'2S.I#>#O
%?M./
4>%;#EK#&i
")G#
;
JV-
?W"=
D'(afB×W!GQD-#W'(a`!"%A*#K";@*%GPW*
E#%/,%(&'("#WXJ
„IÆAËÐNÈgÉÈ2ÐyÆ"n
Ê €DÓ !KÆ"Í@ÐNÈ[Ì.Ÿ=huVvAwGxyBÛ
Y"'%XU>:#&.AZPWV >/>!"&;A''V/`%AMô J8úfûö:ø
û:õ_ø
"!G
MBï Nõ_ø
ö<ñQPW!APWS%;#:AZÃ>;$´>B5qi
%oPWO
>APrH/>:$:
AEK`#-
'V/;;"#7
LV#`AEK#7"*PWO
>AP¸%S<:R
¤lE'-
L#%
!'VH/.B$Ã>-#>#%('V/.S
"'V
-M4>/>
&;OyPW!APc-#J;):A"#,`:@=[O
=[;EKhT(%'("
i%#Z#
S."./$(;#A"%h(T#
+.-
'VH/PiGEK#%PW'&A./I%#
4='_G##9PW(
APW>#O
E?(`:%#h#%-'VB Û%Û
znM
>,TEG#%/>(TPW
AP}%S>Pi;A"M"'%X;7
.%
;'-!#&T=)&Z-
'V
'`H/>: 0 ;@#ASo;??ASo"#X'
a?S
"$%;@#(:tYÃ>;´K6)(t->#$.;-
&.##%.7G(8B
-#DÄD%
APWo!Ge./T;&X
(;??I"!`"
;7
"#%On
%A
SPiQ;AT&#GEKeQ%
'
"gO ¤ %;"# Û V B5qi
Q(.-T=[#
†H…V”KãQŽn„Keƒ– ‚ ‡5o—ˆAŒK•V?ˆŽH”GŽH…‹•V• ’ãA•V7‹”†HˆAâ45…V”¨_ˆA‰Hâ$‹Žn…VˆA”)…V”4‹
'ŒK‰H)•V…V”KŠT‹KK‰nt ˆG‹—J„*K†HK… ŽnDˆA‰gŽH„ˆAãAˆA”.‹•V… Ž25’ c!‹†n†HŒKâ4…V”Kã7”ˆAŒKãA„*•V…V”KŠ"›
‹ãAQ
 „ /¤ …†2å
â4ˆA‰H4‡5TäG7‰n… w.tŽn„.‹ŽŽn„Ka
 ‡Bˆ/‰Š‹Œ'‹Šˆ!ŽUu ‘ƒˆ'’
Š‹“•”°‹†4K%›
ۆn—˜.‰HŒK…V‘?‰gŽH„`7‰n…V=
” „ /¤ …†!’…V•VK†I†H…Vâ4…V•‹
‰ – †H—ˆA‰H†eŽnˆŽn„KW†H—ˆA‰H†o¨[ˆA‰oŽH„x
 — •V…V”Š/† ˜
†gŽH‰H‹ŽHã’Z†H„Kˆ7‡I”`‹‘?ˆ@äG
Û%ۙ ˆ@‡5%äGŠ‰ c"ŽH„iãG‹T‡5‹†5†HŒK‘K†gŽJ‹”GŽn…‹•V• ’$—7•VˆA†nT¨_ˆA‰„K…VãA„T…V”K•V…V”KŠD.‹ãA†@å
•V•8äA‹•VŒ7†D…V”˜f…VãAŒK‰H$žX‡7‰n4ãA”K‰J‹Žn7L‡I… Žn„MŽH„T…V†nŽH‹”K—›N‘.‹†H
Û ŽnV s ‰Hâ€
‡5…VãA„"Žn…V”Kã4†H—H„Kâ4QŽHˆ‘>h7†n—‰H…V‘?
å
oPp{qO5Z›š­]›œXBR)xOp ŠEuzZ.0€ŸžxRxRN®
þ p x9Eÿ Y+qR\Z>þE9 ÿRþ Yÿ:þ­ >Z þ­ p"|{Z¡zZ.C Z" 5Z.qR w®!þ þRYw8ÿ
NO
þ x9ÿó [ ÿ:þ®Z­y w8ÿ{qOp{w xRxRNþOp Nþ¢{CWX _ÿeZ")Z.x
p~\®€
oPp{qO5Zr£E]G¤:Z"¢¥ Z.pwE[þOpO]eoO5ZR¦®q®ZþOY0?!þRx<xO !þOY0Z
eZ¾p{wE NþOp \uRGÿ.|{Z.x )Z.qR0yŸ!þRx gqO5wOZ"<\uRGÿ¾|{Z.x
5Z.qRE w®Zþ Yÿ­nNþOZ.xa€
)EG#("RD
"D=e`
"#%;-
'(G#4.;-
&.)!"DEK@#%/M=N@P
;&
'
a?)MZ>.;-
&?A½ W;??WPW''5&(
"
*
B\]D#%PW%SoV=W
,.;-&.$!"Z&*"?/\
;&
'
a?Q
;@#%OyPW!APhOg!"%A#&ePW''9>&!GB5zn*
Ph/.SI
.;-&.A½ X!"\PW'')-&*";A"'('V/l>:!|d"
&X-;@,=[#&*"LWAE'('(B
5.2 Results: Term Weighting
zHc\>#E?(-
%;8S4PQYP·!GM;@#%Og!"%A
#;7kPWVk'("#MPW!APW`:@#%=N#&T
*:JAB]-#X(VO
('$.-
V8S
APiE#AS4!GL%&*''#LPW!>GPWPQ-'_€#"O
E?(i)&#I;;%i##%.7"Z(9
o;&
''/PW->
&#VAB|znk=N;ASePi;l(&>#GEK*:#%=N"#&*
;M%-
J7.(''V/
-
#$-#TE'-!G|;#V#(./RPi.
@#&4!%
#4J7;T=_#&ÁX"
;7
"#ABT#EK.-#%'EKD=[#&
=2"''(T.
i%#7"`=<&*"a>%&'_G#h>.;-
&.o"
:AG#Q"#%O
!' 0 %&*''<PW
APW76@S!PW
'T")
4"&(&S
DE.O
%
-#-
#&.M&X-
;7LPi? 0 '(G#`PW!>GPW76@B("O
-#R³%APW,#%-
'VPW
b#& Pi. "#L%;A"'Ac?/
' 0 Í Ý ðÐëjÏ ž ËMV Ì  ±¨ ©«ª/¬ ’ 6@B
Û §
qiV 4
#%-'VD=N"#=_#A+.-
;/M
%AMPQ.
>Sf%
APWLR("O
-#Ú?SQ%-
J!G*"%>-
"
t#&ZPWVb'(AP >.;-
&.
=[#+?-
;@/.Sf(YVRMG%?-!" #&)PW\
\.;@O
oPpqO5Z­­];¤n®uzZ.ÿ=oO5ZR¦®qOZ>þRY®_Z.pwE[þOpO]'¦E5p"|{Z
wOn
Z zZ¾ e5Z.qRXÿH wOZv\
ÿ:þ8ÿÿ:þRYXg5RZ ¦EqO>Z þRY0}
eZ¾p{wEŠ
[þOp?Yw®ZZ¾9 ¯?°Js Wo p"|{ZhpwEL
zZ" Z"Ÿ)Z.qR0€
oPp{qO5ZgÑE]Ò|E Z¾~\NþOpÔÓ°¾)!þ­0] Z¾~
NþOp p"|{Z w®Z
ó5Z¾qO0€
zZ.
6. SCALING TO LARGE REPOSITORIES
\%%-&\
"PQY!AEK\%';Ac
\!G#7&# !"
&*"U>&h
D+.-!'VH/`=8-#Q%&('(G#n/*&A%->#"iU>
'("(A
tÃ>;@(Rw?BQ4
APÂ%;-%DGP€j;(?'V/,s!
M%&('(G#
.;-
&.i=[#&Ý
Y"TPW
'B
÷T.ò F.õ[úfõ_û:õ_ï8ú¸Õ>m
B ÕÏeÆtÑÆAË ç Åà@Ê
È2Ç*É"ÍG
à Ö8On%&'("#,Ð ZÈ[Ì
m
à [?ÉKËÎ
ËÉÍ%Ñ ËÆGà \dËÐgà@ÊÈhÆ 4È[Ì
à@ÐNe
Í É !Ç4ÐN
Ç !Íà%ÉÈnà@ÍTÈ[ÌÉo
Ê ÖP#
íiîï8ðñò>ó w?B)ô:õ_óWõ[ñö<î:÷Tï8ø
ù<óWò>ú:û\üg7Z ×Y+>Z þRY0Yÿ:þOxOZ"
[ÿ:þR)03ØhÍ%àgS!Í%ÆAË7à@ÇÇÉ Í%àgS>ÆÇÐNÈgÆÍ7èRÆ$È[Ì
à\ªLà ,Ù Ç@Æ È[ÌÉ"ÈOÆÍ
à%ÉKË7Ì æç à@Í@è|ªà ÎHÑÆAË ç Åà@Ê
È?Ú ÐNÊmÙ ÉÓNÓiªà ZÑÆAË ç Åà@Ê
È2ÇÐ[ÊEÙ
È[ÌÉÈhÉÍàÖiÎgÇÐNÅZÐ2ÓÉÍ4ÈgÆQÚLËÉÊ\7àkÆ ç Ê:Ñ,à\bËÐgà@Ê
ÈyÓ è+#
oPpqO5Z²±E]
°Mÿ!þ®\ÿ:þ8ÿÿ:þRY
ü°Js WXo”G
eZ.p{w­NþOp®€
x9ÿEY+q\Z>þ­
M)ZR¦EqOZ>þRY0
-&.4=[#A+.-
;/ 0 ZZ-%-!''V/|>G6@S5;A"|(;#A"% :#%=[#%O
&*"
;Z
B (8Z
³ . :TX#&½ )=_#A+.-
;/
4
>S<!I . :
#&½ TGEK@#7''h.;-
&.4=[#± +?K -
;@/.BLqi
|(k-# Ú?S
ÓÆ !D#@=N#iTPi.
TPWV
‘ K ’ BhÇ æ Í@È:#@=N#hZPQ.%O
Û § Þ Èjì´
K
±
B VZW5X”#=[#)`PQ.
PWV
4'"Og%;A'
`PW µ  K Z
ŽÀÁR ’ ´
0 %$->#Q
-%%_"5
³ . §=¶¸·´¹ º »¼/½¿¾ Ã
:K6@B
5.3 Results: Stemming
Y
AP€?EKJKG$¶f;@)"=o->#h#4J&&X"O
>#K";@B4->#XÒ%GPWD
$%
'
Og¤|E'-
)=N"#
GO$ïPAÄ
û!òóS>ô
û:Bï NRAû:ò>ó4S
ô
û:ò>ó|!"#7"&#o%%BYi%i!G
ô
û:Bï NRAû:ò>ór&#GEK4

¤¯E'-
Se"!Y!G*ô
û:ò>óµ>#GE>(>
",
>V(!"' 0 'V
-
&X-
;7`'%eJ7"J;A''V/*%
Vs
;A. MÛ ž 6
&>#"E&.ABFC)*&.(
Ab(€Ã?;}´?B w?S)
L¶f;@M"=
ô
û:Bï NRAû:ò>ó¯"EÅ
# O$Bï Aû:ò>ó¯(eZ
;@#A%D@¶f;EKD#;7 "=
XJ?PQ#7t'(JABT"#7
"$G#`
"
&%'(E>;A
"DJ.Pi#7>S!/.W%
"#TXJ&mPWVL"
#WPi"#7M!"WPi
>;ZMJ.PQ#7<S5PW''Q:#&GEK<B,qi
*%&*"'('eVO
!'o&!";"=)ô
û:ò>óÂGEK#Zô
û:Bï NRAû:ò>óÂ$-
$,;''(%(
PQ#7ME"#("?W.X%
'$@#&B
 ÆuÇRÈɸÊ9ËIÌIÍ9ÉÎÇ7ϕÈɸÊ9Ë}‹”Ka
 Í9ɸʕËIÌ¡Í9ÉÎÇ7Ï9ÈɸʕË}‹7äG‰J‹ãA
ÛMž ƒo… S„Kl
‰n7”—7†h‹‰nhˆ¨8Žn„KW†J‹â4W‹K‰Hˆ m…Vâ$‹ŽnWâ$‹ãA”K… ŽHŒK c.„Kˆ@‡äG‰QŽn„K
K‹…V‰n‡I…V†H9䋉H…‹”K—oˆ¨.Žn„Kb
 Í9ɸÊ9ËÐÍ9ÉÎÇ7σɸÊ9Ë,…V†f m"Žn‰Hâ4• ’D„…VãA„…V”)—7ˆAâ›
K‹‰H…V†HˆA”TŽHˆDŽH„KWˆŽn„K‰eK‹…V‰n‡I…V†HQ䋉H…‹”K—†@å
zHR
%;8S8PiXEK'(Y,%;A'("
'*'"#V
&S8;A''AaÛ%ú4Ä
ò ÝPÞ4ññKô:õ_óWõ[ñö<îYL%'(E**:GEK>#
'&·=[#XM#A'J;
Ü R
#:%"#%/M%B
zH¯7";@a?'
l35#
'& w?SD
#RL%#7>¶Â:HPQc
Pi"#a #A+.-#L-#X
$##.;%%,J7"Z
M
Pi"#a
#A+.-
V#AY"Z+.-
#%/R&`Ms!
t*.;-&.
Ö9Og%(&'("#$
Ú?BXZ!AEKZU>
'#ARHPQ#;7
BX×Z!"%(;E
Ú,
;7
%b=[#Ÿ
& Ù¿Sh'')+.-
#`"#a?
APWldE
;Blì%
)#:#%H/.S>Pi$%
APQAL#E?-)PQ#a 0 uVvÕx[6WAPÖ=_O
s!;(?'V/t#;&-"!YJ"#`
*JPi#$=N"#Z''Q:%%('
+.-
#BzH|
X;%Se
,#>#.;%%
\J7 `;&-O
.
%EKSPW
'h
W+.-
#%/$>#.;%%
$I%#E>("'
>(%aT'.a?-
<B
CDk"'V#!G(E J%#7G/.SoPW
;7Pi %;-%Xl7"('Q(
%;8S?
-'_>Q4%:;_"'(A,
U`-#4#>#.;%%
>S?
-
'_/>
Z%&('(G#n/t;&-7"\-?'o+.-
@#%/&B`C)Pi
PW''W%;#:So,
UY(Z;&
;ASI"!;A"k:,
@#7"A
EK#%/$@j;.'V/.S"''(APW
4-D%;'i'("#i#:%V"#(oPWV
&?JD
"#7?Ph"#$#%-#;B)-#%
@#&#S
4;&
-7G
#A+.-
V#A "D+.-
#%/*&h#A%!"
'B
Cµ%;7
&*";`E?P°=h
E
Û%ú Ü 7ò Ý?Þ4ññ.ô!õ[óWõ[ñ"ö<î'"#V
&ý
%
APWkl(-#RvAÙ?BzH*
U?THPiR%;@(
SIPi U>
'(
Û%ú Ü 7
ò ÝPÞ4ññ.ô!õ_ó)õ_ñö<îc,\nPi|J7"R'#V
&BÖzHl
s
#J
J7QPiQ#7"i
9=N"#oA;7TYZ.;-&.9$
e#:%VO
#%/.B9zH$
i%;
ZJ7SKPQi#7"W)EK;"#o=:%!"->#S
a?
APWZIMOg!"%X%
"->#S=[#oA";@Z!>SK"!$!@U4
&
T''AP}j;.Q#@%#(E"'!:*=9.;-
&.I(QEK*%!GO
-#S!"!,4%!G-#W(EL.;-
&.h(B
6.1 Bag Generation
CDiPQ4U>
'(AMM
#E?-h%;S!
`"=5A";@
.;-
&.Z;.7ZPi"#7 0 Ð64=_#& ;..XU?Z=)
Query Processing
Query Processing
MH−signatures
web
repository
bag
fragments
parsing
merging
bags
index H
signature
extraction
inverted
index I
index
inversion
žp!ÿ)wR}]íiî
ï<ø!òAA!éTùfò>î9J
{þ®uqO0],
ê -#%/ .;-&.ÅÚ
óqO uq®0]Ã>&'_G#).;-&.
(8@ ³ á%ë – æ uG
Ú x?ì¸X
í @;@,
$M~)OnE;#h=[#+;í•ì
"#D;7îX
è =[#&·v ³ ì¸$
í zn#7G4"E# ³ á ë íƒì
ì¸Z
í #D.;-&.QPWVM
4"&
è ½ RM~DOg%
"->#$Úîíƒì
#)A";@IÎï•ð + H;:ç u è xnu ³ á ë u è xx
L ²M³ u IÎï•ð + x äKä
Ã>"#%W
%)"=I.;( — IÎï•ð ´ œT./V#D%&m%;"# L²T³ u IÎïƒð ´ x
]-- — u IÎï•ð ´ NL ²T³ u IÎïƒð ´ xx“š ´µ,µ ñ òóôõ ö ‚
Ö œ
Preprocessing
oPpqO5Z?r'[®]l|®Y)wOZ¾\ YX|®Z7ØÿWÿ{qOuRuO"ÿY)wa€
oPp{qO5Zrr]G÷ q®Z.5ønGÿ®YZ¾[þOp
> .;-
&?I"! 0 Ð[Ð(68=[#&µ"
;7
"#%OgPW
APWe"=f#e.;-&.
"8:.8WVABo]->#9
h
#7GZ'"#&Ö%;
<#-
IY4#:%V"#%/T!>#?-;
É !@ÍJÉ !Å*à@ÊÈ2Ç<=[#5;7Z>.;O
-&.ABo
"#hA;7>.;-
&?I
@#W"h&JhËÆÊ
Ènà@Ê
È É !
7Í%É !Åà@Ê
È:"!X:%%
'V/`&*"?/ ÉÊ!Ë7ÌƔ
Í É !:@ÍJÉ !Å*à@ÊÈ2Ç7BICW=[#Q''
*=[#7"&.4G#X
#7GA<SfPiT%#%4!L;''_"
%`& =[#&¿!"5=N"#o
i->#'(SK
'V/X-#o×M^4%;A'
$"I%;-
%%
RÃ?;´>B ´>S!!,s!!"''/,#&*'=[#A+.-
;h`%-&
X;J7.AB
:A"#oT:%VQ
èX%&WM~DOgEK;#AƒS ç:u èxgu á>x!oD'JI;>O
7(Z(f½ I=N"#hEK#%/`.;-&.Qº,%-
;7`!GQ ³ á + u èx – á8B
qi
'#V
& =[#`#@%#(E>t*#7"
aKk'J"=>.;-
&.
Ö9Og%&'_G#QW+?-#%/X.;-&.b
Ú?S.-%(
W!>U>)
æ "!
ç!S>D(EML->#`vvB
cM;
J%#-;
`
(
U>Z
æ·"!=
ç!S>
4;7
(;4= ³
AAM
%-#$P4B 8B 8BW
".;-&.W
""#G
Ö9Og%&('(G#
Dh+.-
#%/T>.;-
&?5"#i#%#EKT./Xíiî
ï<ø!Rò A1A!éTùfò>9î J¾@O
:
%''V/\U
Öed9R!G#%;-
'("#AS<V4%GPWtku ÚAxo!"D
;7
;$"= ³ ()!>:!>.W=o
4?-&X:#W"=I.;-&.S!"
Pi'('e4`%=i`'U>;<B,Ã>
;XPi`=[-
t>#E?-
U>:#&.e
"W>.;-
&?IPWV
M"]:,^#;#%/,;AG%O
#%/Z!AEKh%&'_G#VH/Z=fGe'A"JiÙ?BvGÄ?SPiW;@%Å
Ö – Ù 0 vGÄ.B5
;A""=['V/;7
.% ³ – :ÙX=N"#))E'-F
= ÖcuVvAÙGxyB Û ¡
6.2 Generation of the Document Similarity
Index
#<
I%;@#(>$=?
5^.;-
&.9Ã>&'("#VH/zH
U 0 ^$Ã?z%6
@#7"*"'(#V
&SPi)%%-&Q!Ge;7.;-&.oo#O
#%.Ac?/¯l
l=TPi"#75
* – —.0 - N/. 6 N01010NA0 - N/. 6 œ.S
PW# - "#W
hPi"#7I=N-!``
W;.Û .iÛ "!;@2 #I2 U?
"=D,.;-&.ASo
. G#,,;#%#%:!\#&*'A
=_#A+.-
; 0 "=[@#D%;'
`PWVM
×4M^4=N-
;:6@B
qi#*U>JX =N&'Và
/ ß =W
%Y=[-
;@(
0 %Ru ÚGx[6$%-;@
"=[#,A;7d
V#,=.;-&.`º9Sh¼PQL!AEKJ
©nª>u á 0 ºf6 –
á 0 ¼>6nx – L ²T³ ] 0 º N ¼>6@S:PW
#T
T!"%R=[-
;r
át;7
%YG
#7"!>& =_#& =2"&'K
/ ßÞ"! L²T³5]f0 º N ¼>6X(`5
6K";;AG#7
%&'("#VH/M:HPQMHPQ*.;-&.½
Biqi
4=2"&'/;ß
o>s!A4?/$&:%(h#7
&F#7>#5$
e%o=!''.Pi"#7
"!ZZ##%.
A;7`-#'>º./$
i'APiJI#7a 0 ";;"#7>O
DD
"#7"!>&Â"#7#@6<'&.=[#â
& * + B9zHT#7;@(;SKV5
+.-D
j;(?eZ
@#7"=[-
''V/#7!>&µ:#&X->7""=5''
PQ#7>BXqi#=[#S9Ôe#?@#4$"'yBIu ÚGxI-%X=2"&('V/R"=Q#7
&
'
"#$=N-
;4=e
Z=[#ã
& á 0 « 6 – ˜.«Eä ™ &?G
å9BZYX-%
$&T#K";@ 0 %XÔe#?>#@"'yBu ³Gxo
zH
>/>aRuv³"x5=[#
"#;A'8!";@a?#-
=9
h;@
(+.-
G6@B
ÔQ%AT4
Q:GEKI#:@#%H/.SGPie;A$;&
-o=N"#oA;7$!"
*EK;@#4"
= WRÐ[Ê!ÎNÌÉÇJÌtÇÐ !Ê:ÉÈ ç Í%à@=
Ç TW5cÎgÇÐ !Ê!ÉÈ ç Íà@Ç YX%-;@L!G
Z"&ZE'-Z"=I ² OytM~DOg%
"->#X=IHPQ,.;-&.
;A"D%&'("#.;-&.BeznM
"#%;-
'(G#AS!V=5Pi$
#7G$
E;# ³ á+L= ³ M~DOg%!G-#4=[#TA;7>.;-
&?º9S9
@U:;A|=[#7;@(d"=DM:%VlPW(;7k
*HPi\.;-O
&?o%
"#i
h"&DM~DOg%!G-#Ie+?-
'?
6K";;AG#7
%&'("#VH/ =54.;-
&.h
B
Y*#7"*HPQR
"7LJ%#-;-#Tk>%afBtqis
#JA)
S æYS
;
%;-EK'V/tJ# ³ á+=N"#$A;7>.;-
&.4º 0 yB BS8
³
Õ"Og?/?,M~)On%!"->#Z=[#XA;7k.;-&.@6@BLÃ?
;*->#`>.;O
-&.(TG#`;%;->(E'V/Y"%%
<S=[;@
%`%
"O
-># =[#./c>.;-
&.ASW(Ec
t.;-&.,_fSD#+?-V#
@U
";'V/vT%a%a T"
##("T¶f%@U
æYS!=N''(APQA
./lY%+?-.('h#Al= ³ ÕOg./?M%
"-#B}qi
L%;!
J%#-;-#e
S ç!Se`#7"l./|?EK#%
R
*s
#JABl#A";@
:%V(5
è*R\M~DOgEK;@#ASf"!A";@\M~DOg%
"->#l
áL!G
7. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
)&'(A/.Z
)J%#7"i!Gi#?>-
;D:J¤LE"'VO
-
0 %RÃ>;cÄ6Xd;pJ-
;bPWVbM%;A"'_"
't'"O
#V
&ÁPQ%;#:AY":"E 0 %*Ã?;Y³K6D #-Y"\@U:@#%O
&.d\%A"
'Pil#:%V"#%/.BczHb!"#%;-'("#PiL-%A
%On´Kw\
;7
"#%OyPW(
APWPWV¯J7"
;R"!|=[#A+.-
;/k#&
Pi(.(S
J&&
S>"! PWV ;..h#&h
;'(-
AfB5
#GE?(D$%;#>( "=9-#i
"7"%W"!`
W:
GE?#i=8-#
'#V
&SeTPi''h"`=N@PÝU&'4=[#&ý
#%-'VZPi
>7
<B
7.1 Efficiency Results
qi
)'("JWÃ?7>=N"#7*Y!Ôi"%D#:%V#%/*;?7"
Q#-
'V/
vGw"ÙX&''( S=_#&¾$;#7PW'8:#%=[#&A*=6?-!G#%/w"ÙÙ?vB
"#X-#Z'_G#*%;A"'(,U>:#&.AS9PQ*-
%A|ÕKÄM&(''|
%-
%AS$PW
;7¸#7"AÖ!t=[#ÚÄd&''(¸-#'B CW=[#
&#(*''5!"=[#7&.S!PiT
#7GAU
:Ù,M~DOg%
"-#
0 ³ – :Ù6h;7Õ`./?h'
`=[#)A";@"=5
$ÚÄX&'('.;->O
&.h
B
qi#\&*";@(S)A;7€CM^MO £$³kÄÄÙKM~DSPQ#t-
%Ad
#.;%`
*Pik#:%"#%/kb
"#7'''ht#?-; =[#7"&.B¾qi\%-
%A+.-.MJ 0 &#(k=T=[#7&.S
M~DOg%
"->#4#7"<S:"!M+.-#%/,#.;%%.6i.a,
'(;
*4>-!"'!3.-
&`Ogz%z%z8Ò´´TM~DWPWV,w { Ô|=<&*"(X&&#%/.B
qi
&
Z#%-
'VW=54EG#(-
WJ7D! (
U,%D"#
EKts
-#*vGw.BqiT+?-#%/>#.;%%
,JL>&!GA
./4
i;JI=f";;%%
ç!SQ%&*''#I=
iOn%a4!>U>B
q9T&#GEK):#%=N"#&*
;S.Pi)s!'V#Aî
çZ$#&GEKW-#'i"='AP
!># 0 ´"#Z=[Pi#X
'
a?76@B×D!GT%*-#'$#&*
K
æYSe%R!G`"''h-#'`;A"b"
:AG#*X+.-
#1 dh%&*%(&'V/
 ù‹”=
 ú „KŒK‰H…V†gŽH…V—7‹•V• R’ û:ŽH„K$K‰nˆA?7‰gŽH…V†)ˆ¨oŽH„K ‘L‹†
Û ¡C‹`b ‡I$„KˆA—J•V„KZˆA†HG
… S‰¨_‰HˆAⵎH„KˆA†nXˆ¨ ?7” t …V‰H—%ŽHˆA‰g’"åL™Q… äG”\‹Kb … ŽH…VˆA”K‹•
‰H†nˆAŒK‰H—Š† cK—7‰n7‹†H…V”KQ
ã ù‹”X…V”K—‰H7‹†n…V”Kx
ã ú¸‡5ˆAŒK•VZ‘>W‹K‰HˆAK‰n…‹ŽHAå
s
•VãAˆA‰H… Žn„Kâ†gŽH
™ ”K‰J‹Žn…VˆA”ˆ¨f‘.‹ã¨_‰J‹ãAâ4”GŽH†
Q
§`‰HãA…V”㈨<‹”K—J„KˆA‰g›2‘.‹ã¨_‰J‹ãAâ4”GŽH†
§ ™ ›2†H…VãA”.‹ŽnŒK‰nhãA7”7‰H‹ŽH…VˆA”
ü ŒK‰g’ v ‰Hˆ"—7†n†H…V”Kã
ƒ9’>hˆ¨fK‹ŽJ‹
ƒo…Vâ4
…1y„ˆAŒK‰H†
„ˆAŒK‰H†
…'…„ˆAŒK‰H†
ýt¦†n—7ˆA”K†
–.‹—
b 7‘Z‰H?ˆA†H… ŽnˆA‰n’ Å yGžA§r.‹ãA†Šc —ˆAâ4K‰n7†n†H"Æ ¤7œAœ$™uþ
§`‰HãAX‘.‹ãA†
y!…4™uþ
§ ™ ›2†n…VãA”.‹ŽnŒK‰H† Æ
…1y$™uþ
š2”"äG‰gŽH§ ™ ›2†H…VãAÅ ”.ÿ ‹ŽnŒK‰n7† w.• Žn7‰n"Æ Æ
ž4™uþ
Å
Å
oPpqO5Z?r"ƒEG
] ¤_
N þOp~5Z.qR ó!
þRx< uOY0ZvqR ¾pZ
PW''o
"4:A"#(|Í%à@Ç ç Ó È2ÇBX]D=I;->#%`"4*%'.4;#A%X(
+.-#%/`& 0 "#hEK &#W#%->#;76@Sç`
A,h:)s!'V#A
¯(*Ph/.BFCD'%|
"R
",VQ
= çk( &*.7
bPW
'('V/d(
&*"Og&&#%/ 0 ?/l
"#%V
| ";#%,%EK#7"'&*";@(S
=[#(J7;G6@S
$+.-
#%/ #.;%%((&>#)*X=_#7;
"=IX%;!fB
7.2 Quality of Retrieved Documents
C);;->#7"Q;&!G#%
8PWTU>J
%"#;7Z
5"#h>V=[O
s
;-
'VASI%
;, A>ZR&*aK*%-># :"|J/J&Z-%,
"&LPi€.;-
&.*;'(';@(8B°R!AEKL=[-
¯
APiEK#AS
"o
­ 1 '_GA`35"%®=[-
;@(!"'(Vn/`=f;&&#;("'>%"#;7
W=[M#-#RÊ:)É ˆAÐ !KÉÈ2ÐyÆÊ!ÉÓNÓ è"S!"W
:%A,,ÈgŠÆ S!ÐyËÉÓ[Ó èS
%&'("#)#%-
'VBe
"#W(J7;S 808+8B{>1j(0/ BLW?/*%&4;#VO
#()%(&'("#ok
B/)1"&.(&1',0$"*¸8B>51j(0/CB<Bhqi/T"#i:"X
"#%5"=
M;#%=_iLÃ?l
× dGGPQEK#8
I=N#&@#9Pi-
'($
:QWEK#%/4-%O
=[-
'5#%-'=N#$%&X'.a?
=N#$"
#s!!"
;("'5%BZY
;'_"&µ!GQD-%D"=8-#QE"'-!" &?'(/
e'(*-
i-
%W"=fJ%#7"(e!G5#¹!;ei
"=W­n%&('(G#n/>®
&X:?A4$
Q:
-'_G#I]^43RV#;@#%/.B5#5''-
J%#7"8SPQ
AEKW#GE?_>A`%&W"&
')+?-#Q`s
-#$vA´?BozH`s
-#4vÕ
PQ$!AEK4EK
vÙXPi"#7 0 ?/,Pi(.@6WMT
)=[#
%$+.-
#%/,->#'(B Û
„ ¤ †eå REFERENCES
10.
s â4… ŽJ‹’Gå  †n…V”Kã á ˆAâ4â4ˆA” ™ ’?‰nŽnm"Ž
!…V”KŠ"†IŽnˆš2K”GŽH… ¨(’ZŽn„K
þ7†gŽ v „K‰H‹†J‹• t †n—7‰n…VŽn…VˆA”Zˆ¨<ƒf‹‰HãA%Ž b ‘ t ˆ"—7Œâ47”GŽn†@å
’ˆ‰'ŠŽ•‘3ˆ ˆ‹!‡Pˆ'Ž"#’$Ž7‰&%Eˆ!’'(“9ˆ#)5ˆ'Ž
*,+ )’
‹-.!‹/Ž"ˆ'’
”3Œ!‹#Š#ˆ'Ž01‹#’
Š321Œ'4
ˆ!’Å‹“0%065
"7
s
s
c¤7ŸAŸAå
nŽ ŽH‹‰HK…c å.™QŒK•V•c.‹”KZ˜5å?–‘.‹†gŽH…‹”K…Nå?ƒo„K†n7Œ†
á ‹ŽnãAˆA‰H…987‹Žn…VˆA”‘"’T—ˆA”"ŽnjmŽ7å ’ˆ/‰'ŠŽ•‘,ˆ:%;%;%0c!¤7ŸAŸAŸå
„ ¦†–>å7þ‰H…V”T‹”K:
 9å v ‹ãAAå.ƒo„K s ”K‹ŽHˆAâ)’Zˆ¨<‹:‹‰HãA%›g–—7‹•V
™ ’>‰gŽHj m"ŽHŒ.‹• b ‘*–7‹‰n—J„`”KãA…V”KAå ’ˆ/‰!ŠŽ•‘,ˆ%;%;%&<Cc
¤7ŸAŸAå
„ y1† s Î
å þ‰nˆ7‰7åK˜f…V• Žn7‰n…V”Kã“I7‹‰n›2KŒK•V…V—7‹ŽH t ˆ"—ŒKâ4”"Žn†@å
’ˆ‰'ŠŽ•‘3ˆ
=?>A@c¤7ŸAŸAå
„ ž † s Î
å þ‰nˆ7‰7å ”TŽH„KW¢o†Hâ‘•‹”K—W‹”K á ˆA”GŽJ‹…V”Kâ4”GŽQˆ¨
t ˆ—ŒKâ4”GŽH†7åBŽi‡Bˆ'”)7’$"Š#ˆ'Ž;Œ'ŽC;‡Bˆ'”)7 .!Š‹ + ˆ
DE3FŽ7‰"c
¤7ŸAŸAå
„ † s Î
å þ‰nˆ7‰ c.§Må á „K‹‰H…VŠ‹‰ c s åK˜.‰H…VG 8 c.‹”KX§Må.§`… Ž 87”â$‹—J„K‰@å
§`…V”›N‡I…V†Heš2”KK?7”K”"Ž v ‰HâDŒŽH‹ŽH…VˆA”K†7å ’ˆ/‰!ŠŽ•‘,ˆHIKJŇ­c
¤7ŸAŸAå
„ ¥ † s Î
å þ‰nˆ7‰ c?–>å.™Q•‹†H†nâ$‹” c.§MåK§‹”.‹†H†n5 cK‹”K™DCå L?‡5…VãKå
–"’”GŽH‹—Žn…V— á •VŒ†nŽn7‰n…V”K㈨fŽn„K b ‘
å ’ˆ/‰'ŠŽ•‘Zˆ:%;%;%NMCc
¤7ŸAŸG¥å
„  †–>å á „.‹Š"‰J‹‘.‹‰gŽH… c¸þQå t ˆAó
â c‹”K v åKš2”K’Š?Oå 9”„.‹”K—
™ ’>‰gŽHj m"Ž á ‹Žn7ãAˆA‰n9… 87‹ŽH…VˆA”  †H…V”K㠙 ’>‰n•V…V”KŠ†7å ’ˆ/‰!ŠŽ•‘,ˆ
QP;JQRc
¤7ŸAŸAå
„ Ÿ †–>å á „.‹Š"‰J‹‘.‹‰gŽH… c¸þQå t ˆAó
â c v å.¢e‹ãA„.‹äA‹” c–?å.¢I6‹ SH‹ãAˆAK‹•‹” c
” c?‹”K:
 TKOå Ui•V…V”‘?‰HãKå s ŒŽnˆAâ$‹ŽH…V—i¢I†HˆAŒ‰H—
t å?™Q…V‘K†nˆA
á ˆAâ4…V•‹ŽH…VˆA”T‘"’ s ”.‹• V’ 8…V”K㠙 ’>‰n•V…V”KŠZ–"ŽH‰nŒK—%ŽHŒ‰HW‹”K
s †H†nˆ—…‹Žn`ƒ:j mŽ7å ’ˆ/‰'ŠŽ•‘,ˆ:%;%;%N<Cc!¤7ŸAŸAå
„ ¤7œ †eå á ˆA„K
” c>§Må t ‹ŽH‹Š‰ c>–?åK˜.(Œ Sg… ‡o‹‰J0‹ c s å.™Q…VˆA”K…VŠ† c v åš2”K’.Š c
¢WåK§`ˆŽ2‡o‹”K… cCTKå  •V•Vâ$‹” c‹”K á Vå W9‹”KãKå.˜f…V”K…V”Kãš2”GŽH‰H†gŽH…V”Kã
s †H†nˆ—…‹Žn…VˆA”K†o‡e… Žn„KˆAŒŽi–ŒK>ˆA‰gŽ v ‰HŒ”K…V”KãKå ’ˆ‰'ŠŽ•‘3ˆ
'‡XRYc7…AœAœAœå
„ ¤A
¤ †3þQå t ‹ä…V†nˆA”
å.ƒ:ˆAK…V—7‹X
• !ˆ"—7‹•V… Ž2’T…V”ZŽn„K b 7‘å ’ˆ/‰'ŠŽ•‘,ˆ
:c΅AœAœAœå
„ /¤ …†ZT.å t 7‹”`‹”KX§Må ™ 
” 8…V”KãA‰7å.˜f…V”KK…V”Kã¢I•‹Žn7 v ‹ãA†I…V”ZŽn„K
b ˆA‰n•V b …VK b ‘
å ’ˆ/‰'ŠŽ•‘,ˆ:%;%;%0c!¤7ŸAŸAŸå
„ ¤7¦ †9å s å?™Qˆ"ˆKâ$‹”X‹”K b å ™ O
å Ui‰HŒ†HŠ‹•NåK§`7‹†HŒK‰n7†oˆ¨
‹†H†Hˆ"—…‹ŽH…VˆA”Z¨[ˆA‰o—‰HˆA†n†I—•‹†n†H… w.—7‹Žn…VˆA”K†@Xå [V\Pˆ)e”]’3\XR‹Œ'‹^\
_
ˆ/‰(\‘cÎyGV
Ÿ 7 ¥'¦ …"`¥1 y+c:¤7ŸA1ž yKå
„ ¤ y1†DƒWå ™ å ™ ‹7äG•V… ‡o‹•0
‹ c s å?™Q…VˆA”K…V† c.‹”K v åKš2”K’Š>å>–"—@‹•‹‘•V
ƒ:7—H„K”K9… a"ŒK†e¨_ˆA‰ á •VŒ†nŽn7‰n…V”KãŽn„K b ‘
Bå Ž"ˆ'’
”xŒ' ’ˆ/‰!ŠŽ•‘Zˆ
„ …†™Då
ŽÎ‹-/’
Ž7Œ'‹Š#ˆ'Ž7Œ'
%Eˆ'’'“9ˆ#)5ˆ'Žî‹“V&%b(5ZŒ!ŽCcRZŒ'‹Œ45Œ#"$d
‚c¸…AœAœAœå
…V‰J‹…cK–>åK¢e‹ãA„.‹äA‹”c ™ å?™i‹‰n—7…‹›2§`ˆA•V…V”.‹0cK‹” s å v ‹?—JŠAAå
b ‘Îþ5‹†n 7 s ¢I?ˆA†H… ŽnˆA‰n’Tˆ¨ b ‘ v ‹ãA†@å ’ˆ/‰!ŠŽ•‘,ˆ
ŽÎ‹-/’
Ž7Œ'‹Š#ˆ'Ž7Œ'
%Eˆ'’
 f% Šg&%b(5G‡Bˆ'Ž"#’$Ž7‰c΅AœAœAœå
„ ¤7 † v åš2”K’Š>å s –â$‹•V•§`…V”"‡I…V†niš2”KK?”KK”"Ži˜?‹â4…V• ’4ˆ¨ ™ ‹†n„
˜.ŒK”K—%ŽH…VˆA”†@å ’ˆ/‰'ŠŽ•‘ZˆH/JQRFPc¤7ŸAŸAŸå
„ ¤@¥† s å UO
å TG‹…V” cK§Må.“e‹‰J‹†H…Vâ4„K‹D§`ŒK‰gŽ25’ c.‹”K v å TKåK˜f• ’”K”
å t ‹ŽJ‹
—7•VŒ†nŽn7‰n…V”Kã 7 s ‰n%ä…V%‡W7å 3‡XP ‡Bˆ!”
)CF9‹ŠŽ•‘cBF9’#26 + cK¦¤ 5¦ Æc
Å
¤7ŸAŸAŸå
„ ¤7†ZT.O
å Ui•V7…V”"‘?‰HãKå s ŒŽn„KˆA‰H… ŽH‹ŽH… äGW†nˆAŒK‰H—†e…V”Z‹„G’?‰H•V…V”ŠA7
7”Gä…V‰HˆA”Kâ4”GŽ@å ’ˆ‰'ŠŽ•‘,ˆ/JQR)c
¤7ŸAŸAå
„ ¤7Ÿ †9
å !Aå?§`7‹†HŒ‰H†eˆ¨ t …V†nŽn‰H…V‘KŒŽn…VˆA”.‹•!–…Vâ4…V•‹‰H… Ž2’>å ’ˆ‰'ŠŽ•‘
ˆb3‡ihEc¤7ŸAŸAŸå
„ …Aœ † ™ å v å ŒK„K”
å.ƒo„K s ŒŽnˆAâ$‹ŽH…V— á ‰H7‹Žn…VˆA”Xˆ/¨ !… Žn‰J‹ŽnŒK‰H
å eKPj[•ˆF9’
Ž7Œ'«ˆH13#Œ'’‰“mŒ!ŽCcR?"26 ˆG)7”ZŽÎ‹c
s ‘K†gŽH‰H‹—Žn†@C
…V7V¤7žA"Ÿ `?¤7 A0
ž c:¤7ŸAžAå
„ …
¤ † >” t …V‰H—%ŽHˆA‰g’ v ‰H6ˆ Sn—%Ž utev Æ%V
å kll(m/n^oo"ppp/q!r3sOt6uvq$w(t#sOoå
Å ¨_ˆA‰e–0Œ lnmX–"Žn‰H…VK…V”KãKå ’ˆ‘'’Œ'”]x
„ …'…†§Må v ˆA‰nŽn‰@å s ” s •VãAˆA‰H… Žn„Kâ€
%065#RHe
8. RELATED WORK
MJM#'E.*k-># PQ#a¯G#t'"#& =[#Mc­ 1 O
'(GAM35"%®T=N-
;
'VH/,#GE?(A./%EK@#7'f&*GpH#h%"#;7
Bì>=N"#%-
!G'V/.Sf
>7'4=i%"'(#V
&$G#
-
'(;'/MAE"'_"
'BD^A"L4"'yBuvAwGxo>#:%Z'#V
&S
PW;@Pi%;-%%A( Ã?;vD!,Ä.B(vS?=N#Qs!!>
#'("
!"%A||
,;
;@(E?VH/=)
*k'V/k
cÊ!ÆÈ
Y
ZU?$=W!"B qi_>AM"=W-
%
?/>:#'
aLU?4=[#
>.;-
&?D##%.7"\!4:\@U'VA\R
Z!J4
G%7;7al\E"#H/l"=4z 1 #
'&uVvSW´>
S :?SWÒ>SvvS'v :"xyB€qi
GEK'VH/R"=i->#4!":#AS8
APiE#AS<;%(J$R
Z=N;4
"PQ
>R
Z&*a "./c
É S
Í@ÐyÆ"Í@Ðe%%-&l":-TPW!GG#,
:JT=[A"->#4=N"#X>.;-
&?D##%.7"<B 1 G
#AS<Pi>O
E'}cE"'(-
"c&@
?'/l!G"''(APW -
*|%';
X:JD=NAG-#=_#&·"& *%4"=h>¶f@#.;A"!("B
C)
>#K;7
h'"#V
&;A''V/,#'("A*Ti>#%.A*(
Ã?; ³$!AEKW:*-
%*tu Ú?S>ÕxyS>'V-
,=[#i>V¶f#.
>#'(&m=o(.V=[/>
Z&V#%##)!"B
9.YMACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Pi-
'(b'aKt!al3o#"=N%%"#h;Q>#( "
S)35#O
=[%%#G6¶|ì''&*<Sf
tA/>->#^4G7"#=[#V#
%?!
?E'-!"
'=N!";@a:B
ۈ" ˜.——ˆAŒK‰:‰HK‰n…V…V”K†nK㕋7äA5’ ‹c‰nŽn…‹„K”"Ž7Žnå ‰Hâ4†
‡5‰nŒK”K†gŽHâ4â4h‡e… Žn„WŽH„K5â4ˆA†gŽ:—ˆAâ4â4ˆA”K• ’
„ ¤7ž†ZT.å ™
HF•‹ˆ'”xŒ'‹-chBŠ!5’Œ!’ + Œ'ŽCZ
Ž"
ˆ'’
”xŒ'‹Šˆ!Ž0 + ‹-/”Zc
¤y ¦5Æ7V¤7¦Aœ"`?¤7¦G¥c8¤7ŸAAœå
„ …A¦†™Då>Å –‹• ŽnˆA”`‹”KX§Må T.åK§`—@™Q…V•V•NåOŽÎ‹’"ˆ F9‰‹Šˆ'Ž=‹ˆZPoˆ3’
Ž
"
Ž ˆ'’
”xŒ'‹Šˆ!0
Ž 1/‹’
gŠ "21Œ' å.§`—@™Q‰J‹‡I› ™ …V•V•c>¤7ŸAA¦å
„ …1y1
† –>å>–…VãA•:‹”KX“)åOTKå á ‹†gŽH•V•‹”
åB@ˆ'
Ž )9Œ'’Œ']
” /‹’
Š#
‰ R‹Œ!‹#gŠ ‹#Š#‰3/ˆ'’
‹V
“ ?e
“9
Œ 2Šˆ'’Œ'A
 ‰/Š /Ž7‰ "JåK§`—@™Q‰J‹7‡o› ™ …V•V•c?¤7ŸAAå
„A
… ž
† §Må?–"Žn…V”‘.‹—H„c™DåCUh‹‰n’K…V†cK‹”KG
‚ åUiŒKâ$‹‰@å s —ˆAâ4.‹‰n…V†HˆA”$ˆ¨
Kˆ—ŒKâ4”GŽQ—•VŒK†gŽH‰n…V”KãŽn7—H„K”K…9a"ŒK†@å1IC#.'g‹ PΊŽ•&
‘ %Eˆ'’ '“9#ˆ )d
… œAœAœå
y RHRPcÎA
„A
… ?
† W‹„Kˆ"ˆz/kll(m/n^oo"ppp/q!{|6kttXq$w(t#sOoå
…
}0~€}:4‚4ƒG„
4‚4ƒG„4†3ƒ6‚6‡ˆ‰Š …,‹ ‚
ú
ú †G
ú
ÿ i ËMÈjΡ– ‘ ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMÊ
D
ò¾òò ËgÏCÏ ËMÈjÎ1 ‘“C¢O”A£i“"ý
‘ ÌMÞ ËMÈjÎÌ®ÐÈÐ÷ Ì ‘ ÌgëÐ÷CÌgÊv¤Ï ÍCÌgÊìjÊÈjÉ Ï Í
ò¾òò Ž ÊÝ Ï ËgÌTÐÈjÏ ÌgÍCɐ ‘ ̕ò.ÌgëÐ÷CÌgÊ-“ò¾ò ÷ÐÎÞ
ý ëjÝ Ï:ÈjÊEÇC÷ Ý Ï Ì
ò¾òò ÊëjÝ ÏCÈjÊð÷ Ý Ï Ì ËgÈjÎ
¤ Œ¥‘ ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMÊ
ËMÝ ÊÊÉ ð ð Ž ÊÞ É ÎÝ Ë÷ ÌMÍ É “Aò ’ŠÏ ÌTÐ
Ê —‘ÈjÊ ¢ ËMÐÝ ˜Q
Ì ¦)Ý ˜ÌMð
‘ ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMX
ò¾òò Ý ÏÐÌMÞ Þ Ý ËgëjðÐ ËMÈj1
Î “ò.ÌgëÐ÷CÌg-Ê 
Ê ™0ÈjðÐ
‘ ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMò¾òò ò.ÌgëÐ÷CÌgÊ Ž ÈjðÐ ËMÈjÎ
CÉCÞ Þ –ðÌM
Ê ˜ŠÝ ËMÌEò.ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMÊ­ËgÈjÎ Ž ëjϝí
ò¾òò òÏ Ý ËMÈjÎ
Ê ¤Ï ÍCÌgÊìjÊÈjÉ Ï Í
‘ ÌMÞ ËMÈjÎÌ®ÐÈ ” ÷CÌ ‘ ÌgëÐ÷ Ìg/
ò¾òò òÉ ÏCÍ ÌgÊìjÊÈjÉ Ï Í ËgÈjÎ
È ¨ ‘ ÌgëÐ÷ ÌgX
Ê –Aœ•Ï Í Ý ëjÏCë Ž ÈjÞ Ý Að CÈjÊÌMËgëjðÐ
§ ëj÷ È6
ò.ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMÊ íëj÷ ÈÈ ËMÈj1
Î —‘ÈjÊÌMËMëjð^Ð  ¤{Ç ¢O” ȊÍCëgí ËMÈjÎ
ò¾òò É ðëÐÈÍ ëMí ËgÈj1
Î “ò.ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMÊ
ü ·  ‚Š ‰ · ‹ ú‘ú‘ú
}:³ ü)ú †G …´ ªµˆƒ3ƒ …?¶ ú …_¶ ü)ú †G …
œ•ÏÐÌgÊÏCëÐÝ ÈjÏ ëjÞ Œ É ðÝ Ë ÌTÐò.ÈjÊ
þ – ¢ •5ÈjÉCv
Ð ¤ð
Ý ÎÏò.ÈjÊÞ Í ËMÈj1
Î #ë •5ÈjÉCÐ ÷ÐÎÞ
Ë ¸ ‘ ÈjÊÞ Í ­ ð Œ Èjð
Ð ™0È Ž É Þ ëjÊ Œ ™ ž NJÌgʘŠÝ ËMÌ#¨
“CŒ É ðÝ ò¾òò Ìg먃 ðÝ Ë ËgÈjÎ
ÿ Œ ¯C4ñ ÌMò Œ É ðÝ Ë 0Ý ÊðÐ
ò¾òò Î Ž ž Ï ÈMò ËMÈjÎ
Ë ¸ ‘ ÈjÊÞ Í ­ ð Œ Èjð
Ð ™0È Ž É Þ ëjÊ Œ ™ ž NJÌgÊ ˜ŠÝ ËM#Ì ¨
“CŒ É ðÝ ò¾òò ìjȊÈÍ Ï ÈjÝ ðÌ ËMÈjÎ
¦5íCËMÈjð Œ É ðÝ Ë ¸¹¬{ÈgòÏCÞ ÈjëjÍ ð
Î Ž ž Þ íŠËgÈjð ËMÈjÎ
ë ’í
¢ É ÍCÝ ÈjìjëjÞ ò¾òò ëjÉ Í Ý ÈjìjëjÞ ë ’í ËgÈjÎ
¦)Ý ðÐÌMÏ
ò¾òò Þ Ý ðÐÌMÏ ËMÈjÎ
¦ ¢ ¤i{ÿ £ ËgÈj¡
Î –D¬{Ý ðËg$È ˜Ìg/
Ê ÌTò Œ É ðÝ Ë ò¾òò Þ ëjÉ ÏCË÷ ËMÈjÎ
É Þ Þ ð
È — Ð ‘ Ý Ï ëjÎ Ž
ò¾òò òÝ Ï ëjÎ Ž• ËMÈjÎ
‘ ÌMÞ ËMÈjÎÌ®ÐÈ › ÊëjËgÌMÏ ÈÐÌ
ò¾òò ËgÍC(Í • ËMÈjÎ
Q Ç  Œ ÈjÏ ÌTí
(
òòò ÎÈjÏ ÌTíŠËgÌMÏÐÊëjÞ ËgÈjÎ
Œ ÈjÏ ÌTí Œ ëjìjëjôMÝ Ï Ì
òòò Ž ëÐ÷65Ï Í ÌMÊ ËMÈjÎ1ÎÈjÏ ÌTí
‘ ÌMÞ ËMÈjÎÌ®ÐÈ Œ ÈjÏ ÌMíÌ^’ÐÊë
òòò ÎÈjÏ ÌTíò¾ÈjÊÞ Í ËgÈ É þ
Œ ÈjÏ ÌTí
òòò ÎÈjÏ ÌTí ËMÈjÎ
“C” ÊëjÍ Ì
òòò ÌTÐÊëjÍ Ì ËMÈjÎ
ɕ
Œ ÈjÏ ÌTíÿ¾Þ (
òòò ÎÈjÏ ÌTíŠËgÞ (É • ËMÈjÎ
Ê – ðÉ ËMËMÌgðgð —‘É Þ'Ý ÏG˜ÌMðÐÝ ÏCì
Œ ÈjÊÏ Ý Ï ìjðÐëjX
òòò ÎÈjÊÏCÝ Ï ìjðÐëjÊ Ï ÌTÐ
í ™0ëjìj
Ì š B› É Ý ÍCÌEÐ
È œ•3Ï ˜ÌMðÐÎÌMϝÐ
” ÷ Ì Œ ÈjÏ ÌT,
òòò ÎÈjÏ ÌTí Ž ëjìjÌ ËgÈjÎ
ý ÌgɊÐÌgÊð Œ ÈjÏ ÌT(í ÌTÐ
òòò ÎÈjÏ ÌTíŠÏ ÌMÐ ËMÈjÎ
Œ ÉCÐÉ ëjÞ CÉ Ï ÍCð
òòò Î —‘Îëjì ËgÈjÎ
Œ
©
€}:4‚4ƒG„
†"‚‚4ªg‚ †G …
ú
ú
0Ý Ï ëjÏCËgÝ ëjÞÎëjÊþjÌTÐð ö ËMÈjÎÎÈÍ Ý ÐÝ Ìgð ö Ï ÌTòð
òòò • Þ ÈŠÈjΕ5ÌgÊì ËgÈjÎ
œG
Ï ˜ÌgðÐÈjÊð/«.ÉCðÝ Ï ÌMððv¬{ëjÝ Þ í
òòò Ý 3Ï ˜ÌMðÐÈjÊð ËMÈjÎ
‘ ÌMÞ ËMÈjÎÌ®ÐÈzÐ÷ Ì®ÏCÌMò&«"ëjÊÊÈjÏ4­ ð­ÈjÏ Þ Ý Ï Ì
òòò • ëjÊÊÈjÏ ð ËgÈjÎ
0Ý Ï ëjÏCËgÝ ëjÞ ” Ý ÎÌMð
òòò É ðë — Ð ËgÈjÎ
ÿ i Œ ÈjÏ ÌTí
A
ËgÏ "Ï —‘Ï ËMÏ Ï ËgÈjÎ
ÿ i«.ÿ¨ÈjÏ Œ (Ç  Œ ÈjÏCÌMí ‘ Ý ôgëjÊÍ
A
òòò ËM"Ï •5Ë ËMÈjÎ
0Ý Ï ëjÏCËgÝ ëjV
Þ œ•6Ï —‘ÈjÊÎëÐÝ Èj_
Ï ¦Ý Ï þ ¦Ý •CÊëjÊí
òòò Î • Ï ÌTÐ Î • ËMGë "®MÊÉ ððÌgÞ Þ
Ð ¯jÈjÉ ÊÏCëjÞ £ ÈjÎ
Ì ™0ëjìjÌ
‘ ëjÞ Þ ðÐÊÌgÌTv
É Ž Í ëÐÌ òð ° ËMÈjÎ
Œ ÈjÏ ÌTí Œ ëjìjëjôMÝ Ï Ì
òòò Ž ëÐ6÷ 5Ï Í ÌMÊ ËMÈj1
Î ÎÈjÏ ÌTí
±EÉ ÈÐÌ ËgÈjÎ
òòò ² É ÈÐÌ ËMÈjÎ

º
Ÿƒ?~44»4ˆ†Gƒ?ªµˆ1¼‰3½"‰4¾ º b
} ¿
Á ‰3½3‰ ‹ »‚ †G …
ú
žbƒ"‰6‡Ÿ4ƒ3ˆ †G …
ƒ"‰6‡Ÿ4ƒ3ˆ †G …
…
ú
©QÄ
º ƒ3†GŸV‚Š À(„

 ú ú
ú † · ‚ ú †G …
 ’ ” gÌ Ë÷CÏ ÈjÞ Èjìí
ÿD¬Å¤Ï Ý ˜ÌgÊðÌ/– § ÈjÉ ÊvÂ­Ï Þ Ý Ï Ì Œ É ðÝ ËOÇÐÈjÊÌ
” ÷ ÌOÇCÈjÉ ÊËMÌ/— Èjʯjë$˜jë ”XŒ
òòò °ë$˜jëjðȗ Ð ËMÈjÎ
ò¾òò ËgÍCÉ Ï Ý ˜ÌMÊðÌ ËMÈjÎ
Í Ì$˜ÌMÞ È Ž ÌMÊ ‘ ÈjÊþðgñD¯jë ˜jëzÐÌMË÷ Ï ÈjÞ Èjìí
” ÷ Ì­ÊË÷ ëjÊÍH– 먃 ðÝ Ë ö ëjÊÐÝ ðÐð ö • ëjÏ ÍCð
òòò Ý • Î ËMÈjÎ1-°ë ˜ë
ò¾òò Ð÷ ÌMÈjÊË÷ ëjÊÍ ËMÈjÎ
í ™0ÈjÊÐëjÞ
ÿ.ÈjÞ É Î• Ý ë £ ÈjÉ ðÌ/¸ £ ÈjÎ̙0ëjìjÌ
” ÷ ÌQœ ” œ•Ï Í ÉCðÐÊ
òòò ìjëjÎÌMÞ ëjÏ ËgÈjÎ
ò¾òò ËgÈjÞ É ÎQ•CÝ ëj÷ ÈjÉ ðÌ ËgÈjÎ
¬­Ì^˜ “ ÍCìjQ
Ì Â­Ï Þ Ý Ï i
Ì –X¯j$ë ˜jëÇCËMÊÝ Ž /
Ð ¬{^Ì ˜ÌgÞ È Ž ÌgÊ{ÿ.ÌgϝÐÊëjÞ
“ ˜ÌMÊíÿD¬
Í $Ì ˜ÌMÞ È Ž ÌMÊ ÏCÌMÐðËgë Ž Ì ËMÈj1
Î “ÐÌgË(÷ -°ë ˜jëjðËgÊÝ Ž Ð^
ò¾òò Ì$˜ÌMÊíŠËgÍ ËMÈjÎ
È —v
Ð Ã­Ý ðÉ ëjÞ ¯ §B§ £ ÈjÎ
Ì ™0ëjìjÌ
ÿD¬­ËMÈjÏ Ï ÌMËTÐÝ ÈjÏ ËgÈjÎ
Œ Ý ËMÊÈjð
òòò ÎÝ ËgÊÈjðÈ — Ð ËMÈj1
Î ˜ŠÝ ðÉ ëjÞ °
ò¾òò ËgÍCËgÈjÏ ÏCÌgËTÐÝ ÈjÏ ËMÈjÎ
¯$
ë ˜jëÇCËMÊÝ Ž Ð ‘ ÈjÊÞ Í š ‘ ÌgÞ ËgÈjÎ#Ì ¨
Œ ÉCðÝ ËQ«.ÈjÉ Þ Ì$˜ëjÊÍ
òòò °ðò¾ÈjÊÞ Í ËgÈjÎ
ò¾òò ÎOÉ ðÝ Ë$• Þ ˜ŠÍ ËMÈjÎ
¯$
ë ˜j
ë «.ÈjɊÐÝ ² É Ì
Œ ÉCðÝ Ëjñ¾ÿA¬{ð ö ÊÌgËMÈjÊÍ ð­ëjÏ ÍaÐë Ž Ìgð ö Èj÷ήí¨
òòò °g–ì ËgÈj1
Î -°$ë ˜jë
ò¾òò ìjÌgÎÎ ËgÈjÎ
¯$
ë ˜jë ‘ ÈjÊÞ Í ËMÈjÎ
ÿD¬ ‘ ÈjÊÞ Í
òòò °$ë ˜jëgò.ÈjÊÞ Í ËMÈjÎ
ËMÍCò.ÈjÊÞ Í ËMÈjÎ
ÇCÉ Ï Œ Ý ËMÊÈjðíŠðÐÌMÎð
«"ÊÈjëjÍ ËMëjðÐ Œ É ðÝ Ë ö œÏ Ë òòò ðÉCÏ ÊÉ
ò¾òò • ÎÝ ËgÈjÎ
¯$
ë ˜jGë ¦#È •6•í £ ÈjÎÌ Ž ëjìjÌ
Œ ™ ž ËgÈjÎkñC—‘ÊÌgÌRÎ ŽCž Í ÈgòÏ Þ ÈjëjÍ ð òòò °$ë ˜jëjÞ #È •6•í ÈjÊì
ò¾òò Î Ž ž ËMÈjÎ
oPp{qO5Zr.…E]l|­{\uZU¦®qOZ")Z.ó!þOx 5Z.qR
ÆÇÈ
ÎÈjÏ ÌTíŠËgÌMÏÐÊëjÞ ÎðÏ ËMÈjÎ
òò¾ò ò.ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMÊ ËMÈjÎ
òòò ËMÏ Ï6—‘Ï ËMÈjÎ
ò¾òò Î Ž ž ËgÈjÎ
°
ë ˜ë ðÉ Ï ËMÈjÎ
òòò ËMÍ Ï ÈMò ËMÈjÎ
º  ¶
º ƒ3ˆ …,‹É ‚ËÊ/‰(À̾ Ä
ƒ"†Gˆƒ3‰ ‹É ‚4À]͈ · ƒ3ˆHÎ(„cž0ƒ É À4Ÿ6‡¿
Î ÈjÏCÌMí ö 5Ï ëjÏCËgÌ ö ÎðÏ ö ò.̕ ðÝ ÐÌ ö ÎÈjÏ ÌTíCËMÌMÏÐÊëjÞ ö ðÐȊËþ ö ÌMÎ Ž Þ ÈMíCÎÌMÏÐ ö ÎÝ ËMÊÈjðȗ Ð ö • É ðÝ Ï ÌMðð ö Ý ÏG˜ÌgðÐÈjÊ
ò.ÌMëÐ÷ ÌMÊ ö Ë÷ ëjÏCÏ ÌgÞ ö —‘ÈjÊÌgËMëjðÐð ö — •)Ë ö ÌMϝÐÌgÊ ö ÐÊë$˜ÌgÞ ö ðÌMÌgþ ö •5ÌgðÐ ö Ï ëÐÝ ÈjÏ ëjÞ ö É ðë
5ÏCëjÏ ËgÌ ö •CÉ ðÝ ÏCÌgðð ö ËMÏ Ï ö ËMÏ Ï6— Ï ö ðÐȊËþ ö ÎëjÊþjÌTÐ ö ðÐÊÌgÌTÐ ö ÎÈjÏCÌMí ö ò.ëjÞ Þ ö °ÈjÉ ÊÏ ëjÞ
먃 ðÝ Ë ö ëjÉ Í Ý È ö Ž Þ ëMíÌgÊ ö ëjÊÐÝ ðÐ ö ÏCë Ž ðÐÌMÊ ö ÊëjÍCÝ È ö •CëjÏ Í ö ÎÝ Þ Þ Ý ÈjÏ ö ËMÌgϝÐÉ Êí ö ðÈjÏCì
°
ë ˜jë ö °Í þ ö ÐÌMË÷ Ï ÈjÞ Èjìí ö ÎÝ ËMÊÈjðíŠðÐÌMÎð ö ë Ž Ý ö ë Ž6Ž Þ ÌTÐ ö ð Ž ëjËgÌMÊ ö Ž Þ ëÐ!—‘ÈjÊÎ ö Þ ëjÏCìjÉ ëjìjÌ ö ò¾Ì$• ðÝ ÐÌ
먃 ðÝ Ë ö ËgÍ ÏCÈgò ö ëjÎëjôgÈjÏ ö ÊÌgËMÈjÊÍ ð ö •5ȊÈjþð ö ð Ž ÈjÊÐð ö •5ÌMðÐ ö ÌMϝÐÌgÊÐëjÝ Ï ÎÌMϝРö —‘ë$˜ÈjÊÝ ÐÌ ö ëjÉ ÍCÝ È
oPp{qO5Z~rÎzO]G¤iÿu r"[aTÿ)xR¨MGÿ­
\uZnR¾p{