develoPPP.de – Evaluation Criteria 2017
Ideas Competition
No. 2/2017
Company Name
Project Title
„MUST“ Criteria (= Exclusion Criteria)
1.
Each project proposal has to meet ALL Must-criteria:
1.
Yes
No
Criteria documenting financial strength: The applicant shall have the economic power,
soundness and strength to ensure that the project can be executed in its entirety and that it is
sustainable:
a.
Annual turnover > EUR 1 m
b.
No of employees > 10
c.
Successful in the market > 3 yrs
2.
The project proposal is complies with the development targets of the German Government.
3.
The public co-funding will NOT be used as subsidy to the applicant’s core business.
4.
The execution of the project is NOT required by law.
5.
The project has NOT been started, yet.
6.
Without develoPPP.de-co-funding the project will NOT be implemented.
ALL MUST-criteria have been met
2.
Nominal Criteria
2a.
Corporate Criteria
Evaluation Criteria
Comments on the Evaluation Criteria
Technical Experience
 Year of Foundation
 Market position
 Experience with similar projects
Long-term Commitment in the
Cooperation Country
Applicant intends to establish a hub in the cooperation country which is…
 A subsidiary or joint venture in the cooperation country (existing / to be founded)
 A trade relation
 Any other cooperation with companies or other organisations in the cooperation
country
Regional Experience
 Experience in OECD-countries
 Experience in emerging economies and/or developing countries
 Experience in the cooperation country/region itself
sequa gGmbH, Alexanderstraße 10, D-53111 Bonn, Phone + 49 (0) 228 - 98 23 8 - 0, Fax + 49 (0) 228 - 98 23 8 - 19, Internet: www.sequa.de
Status: 07/02/2017
1
2b.
Project Criteria
Evaluation Criteria
Comments on the Evaluation Criteria
Project Concept
 Plausiblity of the concept in terms of the problem to be tackled
 Method of implementation
Transfer of Know-how and
Technology
 Availability of know-how/technology in the cooperation country at the time being
 Intensity of qualification processes (full-time, on-the-job, etc.)
 Type of qualification (structured and certified qualification, one-day workshop, shorttime seminar, etc.)
 Size and type of target group in relation to target region / industry sector
Impact
 Territorial scope of effect
 Multiplier effects
 Potential to serve as a role model
 Replicability
Capacity Building and
Sustainability
 Incorporation into local structures (institutions, organisations, education centres)
 Strengthening of local structures (Capacity Building)
 Introduction and improvement of standards
 Long-term effectiveness
 Long-term commercial interest of the company
Relevance and Effects
 Congruence of project and the demand in the cooperation country
 Type and scope of effects on the target groups
 Relevance of project w.r.t. the development targets of German Government
Efficiency
2c.
 Relation of resources (time, staff, funds) to outcome and effects
Bonus Criteria
Evaluation criteria
Comments to the evaluation criteria
Cooperation Country
 Cooperation country is a Least Developed Country acc. to DAC-Table
Target Groups
 A disadvantaged group is part of the target groups (e.g. women, informal sector,
minorities)
sequa gGmbH, Alexanderstraße 10, D-53111 Bonn, Phone + 49 (0) 228 - 98 23 8 - 0, Fax + 49 (0) 228 - 98 23 8 - 19, Internet: www.sequa.de
Status: 07/02/2017
2