Complexity of Single-Agent and Equilibrium

University of Texas at El Paso
DigitalCommons@UTEP
Departmental Technical Reports (CS)
Department of Computer Science
1-1-2003
Complexity of Single-Agent and EquilibriumBased Multiagent Planning and Plan Checking:
Approach When We Have a List of Valid States
Chitta Baral
Vladik Kreinovich
University of Texas at El Paso, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.utep.edu/cs_techrep
Part of the Computer Engineering Commons
Comments:
Technical Report: UTEP-CS-03-05
Recommended Citation
Baral, Chitta and Kreinovich, Vladik, "Complexity of Single-Agent and Equilibrium-Based Multiagent Planning and Plan Checking:
Approach When We Have a List of Valid States" (2003). Departmental Technical Reports (CS). Paper 279.
http://digitalcommons.utep.edu/cs_techrep/279
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of Computer Science at DigitalCommons@UTEP. It has been accepted for
inclusion in Departmental Technical Reports (CS) by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@UTEP. For more information, please contact
[email protected].
!"$#%&('*),+
-./
+0213#5467&(8 +9:;#5!"
< ;#%
=#%& < #%>?7@/A
BCD.:#5@E?GF ?!HF JIK#7LM#NO;4PQSRT#%
&
UV#WX74
Y[Z!\^]_]a`Tbc`Xde`:f"`:g!hQijfk`Xhl\^mon*depP\qg7r6st\quvZ
yw xlz{]ade`:u]
|~}cv,:
{
q
}_ev{
q5"}e
jt}e2U5 ¡q}vk}}Vq}2¢e
e}e{q}c£vq}¢vQ:E}£v¤v¯_¥q¤ec£e{
}c}_¤vWqe¢eª|~}e©}}e}{}e¢e¤eU°7q¦«v§
2¬c{!q}vU¤e9 }a®¨¨
}e¬±}eq2 "l{}vq}va¢vU}ev
"²},¯_e¤e9¤a¢e9£e9¶±¤e{}e}v"v¨µ6³£v·S;{q¥"¢ev},
´±¤v¢e¥^7¬U6
{}_qa¢e¥e{°;}v{}ak¨¨
}e}{e}e9e
¼²{¤e}v9¢e¢aº}¸;{t²}v;¢ve{¤a9²¢[eq^
9q}vq}e¡U;,°²ae½¡q;¾
´aq½À^£2¿U¬»¡ÁÂ!£±¨Ã¬e¢2°¹v9¤a}a ¨¨
²^¬{}evaq}e¬"}e{¤e7
7¨µ"
k²}e}{vPq}v°k5{}O}_¤e£¥Ä±;q^¥¨~¢v

{
;}O}_Pe¢e°_Å}v;}e{U"}vvv¶{Æ
WÀ´_ ¨
t
´±}v¢ev°9°¬±¢j; q²O¬,;°{^²«{e
};%´a«^¬Å°º}c^9aÇ³

}_%k¤ve"e¡{y{9q¢¼£2}
È É gÀ]aderth!Ê!u]e\krEg
ËÌ~Ë ÍQÎÏÑÐ{ÒÃÓÔPÕ³ÖVÐ¸×,ÏÃÓPÖÖÒÃÖÀÔÙØÚØÛjÜ7Ý6ÞÐ{ÓPÖVÐ
ß6{
{}_a¥*{àe}v¬[eq°}e}e}vÅ}e{
}_¥£²¤aÆ5¬Oe£2°¸}v}e
}v²e¤a{95{q}v}e¬
q;aW´eá§{9¢e;q¤e9¬%¶Wq¢vâvV}vq,}{¢e:},e°{»a}%qq°¢e6Ut±e³a°e°}Pã£e}q¤a±¢2:UV_Æ¡¬²Xk£26¢etE«¶±
q}¤e}e¥:a¥á§2t
¢v¤e¢e¥
e°}vÀ5q°k¬Uq¢e%eq_Ã
}²}2ß[¢e«{q
¢e9qkq²¤veq{â2}}q}"tt}P{¢eP9¢äß9¢¢eq
{¢e
t}_q%U°6Æ¤v{¬ªk}e¤2¬%}a¹v¬¤e}v}_¤e;V,°q
qe¢e72;q{¡¤ek¤v}_9k¥9{
}a6¹vq¤e¢e5}v;q"¢e}_7{

}_}vq6e|µ
79°qq¢v}
t;¢v
}Å5a{qq¤e°£eql}eq"9}v¶ªW}v¢e¨
q¬_U
}v%}vqee°
}et}e}e¤v%¥vq{£e
}_tUe
°{}e|~}U}v}eq2¢v
E9eÀ°/}e¡;¬
ËÌæå ÍQÎÏÑÐ{ÒÃÓÔPÕ³ÖVÐ¸×,ÏÃÓPÖÖÒÃÖÀÔÙØÚçäÒæèÙévÎÏæÐªÐÝ
çÕ2ÚévÞ_ÒÃê7Õ
tàe¤e{¢vÃU/äî/¤e¥
Oq°²²{¡}v
}_}v§c¬§ea°{
Oâv}e}e}vq}e2}v¤v¥¥§¢v°ÆU«{
l}e}_ä£§
e}°q}ìe¬ä;í¤v«
£2q}ëjäaq¤v{a 2;;âva}vk} ¨
ï }vk}¸}2:
{qvðññ{ñeÄe·S¶_}vW}v¸¬6ò¡óó{ôõæWö
qq«¢v«
q¬;¬²ä¦§}±£±«±¬c}v;}e}e}{U
9qaa;Àaâ2}e¤2}e;¥{{}O}} Xï!}*t¤eq÷9°}eø
ùa{ú®
ûü÷ úæ}_ý;7þú®eùaû°ÿð}eñ{}vñ{}eð "õæ ¦,_²² ¨
ß°q¢v¢eÅ5Uq¢eq}S²°e5}ec£
}v¢e;}v}{y«{²¢eÅ}e%q}_¬ª}S5}_}Slq¡Å¯_¤e£v£e}vqe¤e }
q¢v{
}_ ¤aXq¤v
e°¬ä
:{¢eq°Àk{q9}v
vkq9[q|~}O¬
6¢e
t"¥¢,q9e²
X!!q¢e}v
kq{9
}_q :¬q¤v

6¦
q_q}v¢e°Eq¢v

v;{;
²{¥/}{ÀUt¶2:}vq
À}2k²e{E«taq¢e¢v
{
}_À§^9¶U²q¢etvq
¨µ
,^q
{¡

ï
9¢v|~¬º}º{a{q";q £¡§¢e*
£±{¬,}q¬²q©æ¬q
{t}_¨¤vk}v v£[
¡q/q|~U}
}Pö7ã¼5|vtòó²¢vó ;qÆq¤võ¢v;

!
q¤vt
ª
¢v¤2UÆk«{¤a¨
q99¢v¢v}2
t««ëOÅ¢v¢e}vÆ¸ë«{{ k{¤2
7;¡ q2_}e}eqq¡U£vC{9ß¢e«¢±
¤v«¤e¡t¡§äàe{aqU;¤v¸
;²"}eãª°^q¤vq¡ª

;k¨¨
qa°
Wq
a²;}vekqq°}
_}v}qt¯_¢e¤e°9}v¢§;À¡t!/¶a!Ç}_qq"}_;W}2;kq°a
}v9v{}U%¢v}eÆ«{}e ¨
þq÷9÷}vq¤e9³
«{
°:k¤v;¡qã
¢e{5}v
eq¢ek5t{7
t}_7¢e
a}±l}e!29_¢eqq
«{£el7q¤e{tÑÄ 6¢e%;¨
¢e¢et}_q{q²}v¡Æaq¢e7ql
}_tX¢e9}§¢e
«{tqV¥²9VW2{_qÑq£v£v¤alXq¡/k¤eq²
{q{¢eÃÄ/2_qq£eq¤eq¢v7}_:e_¡:}eE9¢e
«{
{¢eÅq¢e}2
±¢e¡¢e^%,{
t}_¢e7
}ë9¢e
«{7¥9{_k£eÃÅq¡k¤v¥9Uq¢v
©ï ^À|µ¬VtÀ,§}eÀ{qk÷U¢Sq²û!²³

ð}_tñq¢vñ_ð}eõ}ek²e¢v¥¡¬±t}e§q¢eq¢eªae¤e;2e_qkÅ}vW%;° q¨
|~}¢eqWqqUaq¢e5¡¯_¤e£eq¤eo²¡}v¢et}e2ã
q^¤v

{
:¡qe¢e
tq{¢vq
}}v}etekU
/kq^P¢eq[
{¢e¡
6Æ{¢e
7}_P{9
¢v}_" }vP}e«¢e
kq9
¬{_q¢e°7{
}_tt}e«q¤v;
¡Ä
^¢e¢e"V{
¢e}{}_#Àt9¢va{±}e}vW¡_}e/q;¢e:°q¤v2^
^

q¡
q{³¬q¢eq¢e¡}q:l}eXtU{qk£e
ÆÀ¬aq¢e:¢v£
"{k£e^¬§¢vq¢v7}{7a±¡}e!q¤v

¡
ËÌ ØÆÐÅØÚÅØÛjÜ!ÝPÞ{ÐÓPÖVÐÐÝ cÖÀÓPÏ eÕ
Ý6Û*ÜÎEÐÓÐ_ÒÑÝVÖEÓ6Ï ÝVÛjÜÏÃÕ EÒÑÐ Ý
ÍQÎÏÑÐ{ÒÃÓÔPÕ³ÖVÐ¸×,ÏÃÓPÖÖÒÃÖÀÔ
q
°9
}e5l°eq¶±e¢v}et²tq}*}²}2qy²{£v£2^5ä9e
y°¡
}eV}eq²¢v}eeä/¤a9e°²qq«¢v}2}{,Xvt¬j°ae}e¥}eá§qe}e;ä¤v¥Å}See9
}e£e;¨¨¨

£
Ä9qq
{{q{³{ò2óó ±ï Ä k²÷ } ò!û ó{,ó Æðõ³ññ{}vñe,Ä E;q{q÷}v ;¡ À!û q¢eò¡qóó }eÄ

Å}e"}Åqv9{9q°£e
U6q©¡¤v
q
¬{¨Ãqk¡¨µ7q/«eÆ:v}e}ek}e
¤e
°t²
%{k¡
$
}vqa¨
qe¢v¤a/9W«e}S{}v£ee°6
e}eq}e{²£e}e
{
Ä2{²e¼aek}e;}e§´5;¸´±|µU!
}_q¢e§
°}_q
97O
a}¥á§a¡{
k}e¤e9¥¬£eU;%{"¶{ ¨
}2¤v¥¬_
¢e}_tíe
´e£e
¬ ²{q"a¥á§
¤e¥5°lq¢e²;{qq2{}va}e
ËÌ EÝPÞ ÀÒÃÚ cÖÀÓPÏ /ÚÒÃÚ $Õ ¼Õ2Õ TÐ{Ý
ÀÎÀÞÐ ÀÕÞ :Ü7ÕévÒ íÐ ÀÕ¼çÕ tÖÀÒÑÐ{ÒÃÝ6ÖÀÚ
¥}{¢ª¡"¢eß°5¢v"}v{q¬aq}vXÀe²;âv}e}eqªq}cUEq¢v¶{
}v;¤v"¥{q²"2À
{}_²k79e¡}_¯{a%¤v;;{£vª"q²t¤eQ
e;°
^q¬W5}v}vUa£±¬q¢v¥
9kU¥^ve_±¡{
}e
¤et9«
;}¬³¯_Ä¤eq¢eq35°Vqa}_¢e;¬%âv}v;«±°¥
t{¥â2}°}_«7{}vq¬
;{²²ea¤aa¥âq
}v{e}v;{ "v!
´±À^«¬{Àt¤v^ªÀeq}_«±,°aÀ¼¤ek}v¢e
¬±À ¸;°q¨
â2
q}v
v°§kcE;:k
¤v§qX¢e{W«{a«ÆÀ;â2°}eëq¥²^9{e}§q¡;´e¢e²!te¢eÀ¤e°9¢ëq2°t°U¢±a}_¬5
EâvXe}e°°XS}e"}e{}eUcqek}_¤eU£2Xk
ö }
q}v¢2jq,¤e9ð at¡qv

tq²¢e£2eÅq¤a e9ì¥Ç³q
°!}2
²}_,â2}ek}{¥
eq;º;!ßXq¢ev
}vq{2_6kq¢e^Àt}ve5;a©âv¹v}eÇ¤eqq}{9}_}P ã
E
}%k¤v"X¢vVÀÀ:«
}%û¥ú a«°5^9q¡
Ä
¥û
þ}vú ÿ$«{
q¢2¬VÀÀ§«}ä}Oªqk¤e²qU{Eq¢v9¢e9¶a,t¢eU;¢e«
"}c¢e}
k q 7 «Æ°}e
«ß}v¢e!eãq¥¥^¬_
¨~9}v"¢e"¢29Æ¶±}_«q}e²
§e;°9^{¡qqqq¢e¢v}²Q

}°/6£±¬vk
k²¤ee
9¤eq¬Å
E²
U{vk
tq}c2}ea§¡¢ek§tâv}v}[9
k
^kt ,}_tq¢e,qqv¢O«±q

tÀq¢v{}v}_%kX7}e;{6"v¯_D¤a¤e«Æq¢e}v}_E6«
àv;}{"°
v^á¡
´±²7ê¬6{¡q
¢vq«{¤e
aq¡ ¨
9¢e{¡q9²¶_q}e¢v%t
¢e«;q¢e¬ª
^9¢eq
²°5
«ákV}v^9[qÀU²t¢e}_°9
¢c,kq{[«{
}}
e{q¥{}v
£v}vq}6¹v¤e
}_9ttq¤e:ß¢e}ã
l}£aq}e«£±¬%}OkO²û¥eú ¬ qlkqk}e5:_qq¢v¢e
}¼kq¢e°²69¢e9¶±q}e¢v
{}%«{
¢e}§k}eÄ_¢e¢!vq²¢eW}e}ve
¤aq{kqW¬}qÀ¢eq°6¢e°9¢e¤e9°¶²°E{}}eÆq¢v
a¡k9¢e9¶±}e°¡q£eU©Ã {v2{¬±}e{"°³²ÆÄ
^¥!¢e}vkq©æÙ{q!«_ª°,q¸}ey«
¢v}*Oä«;¤ee}v¥^ ¬_¨~^9¢eq¤e9 ¶±Ù}eOä«_¨¨

q¬O²k%qq¢eÆeq¢e£e}ë
q ¢e¸7eeqë{q9q¢e9}v¶±E}ecqeq°^â£e£e
J
£;¦ ¨

¸
¬
¢e5e£e
o¶±}et}q²£ ½W¨Ã¢29
$
&%
'(
$
!
#"
*)
,+
.-
-/
10
32
54
6
7+
54
38
©÷ |~}Åqû¢et°!ðñ2ñ_ðqqõ °;k¤e
°K!q}2vaq¢e;´eq²¢veUq!¢eÅ«
¤a}q¢e} {ï"Àlt¢e}e
v2 t¢vÆ«Wq¢vâvkt}_
eq
q},}²}v
ËÌ EÝPÞ[ÓjÍQÕÓPÖÀÒµÖÀÔ ÎÀÏ ÝVÛjÜÓÞ±ÒÑÚÝ6ÖCÝ
Ý6Û*ÜÎEÐÓÐ_ÒÑÝVÖEÓ6Ï ÝVÛjÜÏÃÕ EÒÑÐ Ý
:ÒµÖÀÔ6ÏÃÕ [Ô6ÕÖVÐ¸Ó6Ö Í ÎÀÏÑÐ{Ò [ÔPÕ³ÖVÐ
×,ÏÃÓPÖÀÖÒµÖEÔ $Õ ¼Õ2Õ CÓSçäÒ !ÕÞ_ÕÖVÐ
ªÜÜÞ{Ý6Óé CÐÝ*çÕ2ÚéeÞ_ÒÃêÒµÖEÔ Ý6Û*ÜÏÑÕ EÒÑÐ
|~e}°}e¢e}v§}e2!{ak¥{}vÀ¸eea{{;9¢[£2¡qy¸£_}v¬¼¹v¬±¤e }e}_ÅT;{"|~}Sv
¢e´±^¬[e¨
e}v;{{{"9¢v
q¢vq
7}v;²e°¤e½¾{½À}v¿§Á2;Â!²¨µ¢ve9;j´a^¬%{³ae¬ë°}e}v}e¼5¤vq}v}ea

{
}_Äeq
{a v ï :÷ û!³ðññ{ñ õ
q¢v¼7ß;¢e
¤v²^;e{;qá{}2{^¬%²¬_ ²³¼k
¶}e{²"
e¨µ";á¡
¥}_^}e¬í:}e}v}"¤e*;¤ea{¥"Ç³¥¨~2
{
}_
q}_cX}§ee£e;}e^{}e{
}e9¢v}
t¢e}"k7V«k°t;áe°;q¬§«}
ev°|~e}e}q}v_¢e}e9°¢tÄev}"q¢eq¢e
}°¡/vaq%qk}2;¨µ«_kq°tq«¥tttq¢ee¢%ee{9£e¢P¤vÆ
Uq}vt}e"âv/q}v¢ek°}e7¬a;Ç¨~7{q
}_}_}e¨
v¬±e q_q¢e9¢² ;{"v
´±^¬/¢e"¤eq°{
}_le°}v}e}v}Å¢e
:9
;
;
%
=<>
?"
?
:<>
!
#"
@
*
>
wSf~]apdvg!`6]e\^sEpjw lder/`:uvZQ]ar SpPz±u³dv\kxl\kg
À]a`V]±p6z HZ!pPg$wSg7`:f \qg
Yªr lÊ7]±`V]e\^rÀg7`:fUY[r lf^p t\^] r
f^`:glg!\kg C`:glh f^`:gDY[Z!pPuemt\kg
åXÌ~Ë OÝ ÐÝºçÕÚéeÞ±ÒÃê7Õ VÐ{ÓÐÕÚ WÞ{Ó ÒÑÐ{ÒÃÝ6ÖÀÓPÏ
ªÜÜÞ{Ý6Óé
q·[q¢v
«lë¢vvÆE«{!}e}e{}ek{*}vev¬£eq{²²£e
}_ qU}vcU ¡
²¢v{e}v¤a

9V«{
q¢e}U}2{eÀ¬í£eqa
}e á§;l°¤e Ä
}_½W¡} ¨
¢vß¢e¡kÄ{k{¤e2° ï {}v9W÷ "£v û{k_¡ðñ{ññ}¸õ±v}vk;
¤eq}v³;{¡}¸6q¢e¢eq{}¥¨
tßP¸}e²âv}v°aä"{¤a²6¢et¢v*²À¸%k}a°;:À£5
aÇ}¼q2}{k!{kqKq¡

q}
²{9{¢Ok¤e²
²{k¤v}{q9"}v}_ EÆ{%;´a
"
q¢ekq«U¤e²¸!ö!q¢v""¡q¤eq¤e¥
¯_¯_¤v¤v}e}_}_
¥¥}e¡¡¼

Ä!Äa}vq¢e*¡%k;Å}_q«¤eq{¤eÑ±¡t§{99ª¢U¢v¤2²k{¤vqq¤eq¬S
;²{}v
¢e}_k°¸aqk¡,k¤eÀÙ°¨µ«Æ|~%}S¤v
}a ¨
}±X¤e£
¡}±±¤e}v§£2^/9|~}!ö7°/|E¦¢e
q2;¡;{°q!e¬§};£°§¨µ{£vÀ{k¡,k¡¯_ö7¤e|E
¦,}v

q°cÀq^}2°9kqq°¤v
Å5
av¡}ëq"
£q
¸£e}va}eqe;
{£2¡ùv«{O÷
}c£± ¬¼^_9ÃcqU¯_kàe¤eq¤e}v$ ;¨ k¢eæ!°5°¹vk«±¤e5}_t9¢v2{º9}_|~;} ¨
}2¢e
W5^99qe°V9¢2²9q²
{«{
}c£±¬°q^¢v%
¼q¡¹vk¤e
}_}29a}v §q¤a³¢
«¤e
åXÌæå ÀÕ¼×,Þ{Ý6êÏÃÕ³Û ªÒÑÐ TÐ ÀÕ WÞ{Ó ÒÑÐ{ÒÃÝ6ÖÀÓPÏ
ªÜÜÞ{Ý6Óé
ß}2¢e§7£v;qk{£e
tTa¡tq
qq¢Uaq¢e°}Ea6¡q
q^9aq±}UÀ°WX¢v¤2^Àtq5e,
À²5£7;q¹vq¤a
¨

}_9
!À«
¡{ Å¹2¤e
}_aW¢2Æ«5ð {q£e^9q¡

CBDB
A
G
,E
IH
KJL
?NOB
?NOB
DF
S
T
QP
1J
R
DF
S
#U
DF
MF
%
VW
Q"
X8
*Y
Z
\[
4
^]
`_badc>e\e>efcg_ih
M]
j
+
kU
$
$
!
;"
]
h
e£qt%Wk²Vqeq¡¡°
;qVq|~}v¬}§£e{¢eq qW¤e:²¡£25E«{;¢v¢2¨µÆ²«
/}_7qV«{ð
}e¡¬lk°!îq/l:¨Ã¢v}±¤e%e}e£2{6k/£ee2q_¤e7qö!q¨
e¢v§§q
¤e¦§qqt
:
«{£«{

}
}q²¢v½¾Ee½Àa¿§¥á§£vÁ
Â!¤e ¨µ¥¡¢v_:9}vâv"}vae°}e}e}e}e^59£%
t²¥¢¸ {«{½W
} ¨
q¢2ß!¢e^¬6{¹vqq¤e¤e
q²}_¤e9²a{q}%¢vUq¢e¢2l¡Æ:«_À¬ª¢e5¢vaÆ¹v«{2¤eð}v}_a!
2}__¡qqÄE5q£v}v%aÅ^29q¡k}v¤eaV²}{V¡t}v}2|~}¬
qk²Eãeq¢e}vt
ð q¢e;£e }v²{}v}ë6¹v{¤v
¤v}_§¬5q
aq¡¡kq
q}v£Wl²«{°k
}ekâv:e2k¤e"£eÀlaq¡U¢eqt
Æq¬§£«{}e
9U¤e{}v;}±´±¤e¯_q¤e9£2¬³¹v:Äe¤eq
³}_²9^
9leqk£v¡q¤a:7³À®}e5
:a§
}{qâv}eqa£qa¤2;¬,;°e}eq ¨
{9¢
´±q9¹2¤e
}_
åXÌ OÝ ÐÝºçÕÚéeÞ±ÒÃê7Õ VÐ{ÓÐÕÚ cÏæÐ{Õ2Þ±ÖEÓÐ{Ò 6Õ
ªÜÜÞ{Ý6Óé ØÛ*ÜÏÃÒÃévÒÑÐ{Ï ÚÕ ìÒµÖ
çÕ2ÚévÞ_ÒÃêÒÃÖÀÔÍQÎÏÑÐ{ÒÃÓÔPÕ³ÖVÐ /ÎÒÃÏµÒÃêÞ_ÒÃÓ q ¤eW²}c¢2UÆ«t5 q;}eûüú vãXSÀ}v¹2^¤e6
{}_{§qVV£e¥a%°5k;£v{k}e{ "}v^9£eqÅÀq}_¤e²
²eqq
¢v¨
·qaª¸"º°ka§
q¢2Æq «²%}e²kâvq}v°ä¥qk %oä/k;¤vq"}vä q¢v ¸}v;ÀOÀ"¶_}v;5}e¨
,{© 9Æ¢S kyqXªee}v¼¬±}e",¢e9!¢S{q{}}t;{}vk¡¯_¤e
}v

åXÌ ÒÃÚ [ÜÀÜÞ{Ý6Óé ¼ÓÚ ÕÕÖ ÚÕ ìÒµÖ
×,ÏÃÓPÖÀÖÒµÖEÔÙÓPÖ ìÍ ÎÏÑÐ{ÒÃÓÔPÕ³ÖVÐÅ×,ÏÃÓPÖÖÀÒµÖÀÔ ØÛjÜÏµÒÑé2ÒæÐ_Ï íÓPÖ /ÜÏµÒÃévÒÑÐ{Ï
ß6^¬{ak¥{}vW¬_a},¡qq¢e
q£}v£±¬a¬qÀ¹v¤eV}{;9W²£2e¡¤e
¤2k{}vq¢e³°W;{²lte¢v
´±¨
e
«{°
}e¡
}v}5}e;é²{eqq¢vq²¢vlP;¶{á e °ßt}Wtq|^¢eî E
²¶{²"{}vWq
}e}2vk¤a:² !}e}e ¨
q°³«e{°
}}_X}e9}v|~;}}e}ª5q¢vU}v
t}±v¬
9}²eq
9±¢v¢e9%}¸¶±}v;á"qe©æq£2°}2;qWq¢§«qk}e{vEe
¨µq«_°9¸}{¢,XkqUX^9l¤e¥¨
aq
¡}vqq
5qaq}v}c°
°a5}}äq¢e°7«
q
¬Å}vq{_aa²ce°;;{q¬,e¤2}vk;¡²t}qe¢ä°
}e}e²}e²2 }
v¤v|µ2¥°tÅ
q°}_¢vqWªe
´±v}v}e°}e;¬±}eq ,¬§v¤vqq¢eq{ë£e,;U}{"
qÄv²q¤a
lq2 v}v
9
ï îE±;{
¬±«{"}v
v}e
}´±q¢Å^q¬Ù²}v
ßV£vðññ_ðÆõÑ
åXÌ Ý6Û*ÜÎEÐÓÐ_ÒÑÝVÖEÓ6Ï ÝVÛjÜÏÃÕ EÒÑÐ Ý
×,ÏÃÓPÖÀÖÒµÖEÔÙÓPÖ C×ÏÑÓ6Ö ÀÕé /ÒµÖÀÔ ªÒÑÐ ÒµÖ
Ð EÕ cÏÑÐÕ2Þ±ÖÀÓÐ{Ò 6Õ ªÜÜÞ{Ý6Óé CÐÝ VÐ{ÓÐÕ
çÕ2ÚévÞ_ÒÃÜÀÐ{ÒÃÝ6Ö ÓÚÕOÝ Ó /ÒÃÛ*ÜÏÑ"Õ ![Ý6ÓPÏ
|~}çq¤v¢vq§ªq¼9ek¥²{e}v[Eae;;aaq{}º}c5qq¢e¢e[e_°}e°
}eã[}e}vÅ"vq{¬{£e7
& _q¤eW²! ¼¢v5{9²¢j¶_O}vk»qqª¢vUq{}e q°OÀ^{9«{q
#}j%q$¤eV£vq}v;¸q©æ¢2q¤e£e5qk¢v9
ö('³)û Q!·[jq¢v
Æ}¬qe¢v;âvW}e§¡ v}ÅÙ3q+ù *,¯_*¤e÷ .}v-9;ùaCûe¥EO®q{!q¢e}2
q¯_¤e
}2;¸;q}v7¸
ë^9Å & !Ã {!q¢v
{© _©/ 10 © _© $ q & Ùß¢eq¡k¤v¥q¨
4 }e÷ ÷;{þ
ÿ"}eú vú X/ú e*"q÷{+£e5¡
ú®þ$vÿU2 ÷ 'û tvú¡3q¬²- qþ§q«ú {ã û÷ {÷ ú ]
h
8
h
h
T
#U
%
54
#c
VW
#"
-
j-
j
T
#"
^"
:
^"
X
X+
:9
^"
$
C
U
DV
;
$
%
%
/!-
[
a c>e\e\e>c
h
h c
`4
h
aic\e>e\e
a1c
[
[ [6
[ 54
\[
[
f[
f4 4
e\e>e
4 [6
6 \[
[
vàlq2{{*¬±}e¢e{E²«{
¥¬W¨Ãqe²;âvÀ}eq{}2q
q¢v*P{¢v¡7«¢v}Vq¢e}q}2E^;9á}vk

¢e7¢ee7e}°}v°7}eq}v¤v%

e^£e¤vÑ
ì}vU5v}{9¢e¡9¶a:t¢e;¢e

âv{ß}2¢e«{e
q}yl}ë°qk¤v%}v
;k´akk}vÀ¤e;!5e2°!{q}j¬±¢v}e{¸²e©Ñ;}e¥¨Ã}eq}e²c!e¬e"£e{
q
q¢eqCE§q¥q¢2¢v¢e

¢e
t}v²q¤v;k¤ee°}
q©|~}²{{}e7²e¢qE{7¢e
²U6!âv
8^}v¶a^/v^9 t}°/{ÄPW¢_v¥¤2¢e
¢"¢eq {°5»q¡q¢vk¤vt¥5}e"q°²2¡â9qq¬
º\;:%pdvpPgÀ]¼w lder/`:uvZ ]ar ºpPz±u³dv\^xW\kg
À]a`V]±p6z=<yp?>Ê!\kdepPz` j\;:%pdep6gE]ëw !dvr/`:uvZ
]±r SpPz±u³dv\kxl\qg A@Sr/`:fkz
:Ì~Ë OÝ (![Ý6ÓPÏÃÚÅÓÞ_Õ¼çÕÚéeÞ±ÒÃê7Õ ìÒµÖBªÕÓPÏCWÒ qÕ
|~}e}"}eq¢e!eeeq{«±{{9¤v¢%:k}v¡a{};£_°PVq¢vat¡kq9q¡a5qâv}2}2±ê9e°q¡}e
¨
|~£e},¤aEqv!¥£±{¬5e%¢e{{;Ç³2qaV¡q¢v
q:£2¡Uq}eWDq¢e8^¤v°Xk_£_¬"Ã6¢eàv!Xâ2;}vé³²^9e
t}v¢e¬c}k5
e¥°¬}tq¢v¢v
5U"q¢eq°}q{£2:}}v¤vak¤vk£q%¢e£a}v5X£e}e¤a
{°q}e§{³q¢2{}2}v
qq,¢e¢v°|~}älkW£¢e{q¢e5k¡k¤e¢e°{¢e¤e§}e°Å;W}eqq¤v2/{}v,_{q¤a±/5,a2/¤v}v9¢e¢e²%
}v}v}ve
¤v%^¬,q}v°{}¬
k}"5¢e}vâv}vv}^9q¢v5}_£vq¤aÀq²°¡qWa{}"q5q¢ek!{{}vVq¢v/¡"q¢e
:Ìæå ØÖ WÞ_Ó ÒÑÐ{ÒÃÝVÖEÓPÏlçÕÚéeÞ±ÒÑÜÀÐ{ÒÃÝ6ÖìÝ XÐÓÐÕÚ
ÀÕ¼çÕÚéeÞ±ÒÃÜEÐ_ÒÑÝVÖìÝ !cÝPÓPÏÃÚ ÓPEÖ Õ
:ÒµÛ*ÜÏµÒ Õ
|~}qq¢v9te¥{{a}vX_¤2ak¤v;¬eqq"}vaâv¢e"/£±e¬°
}e}v}e²2¡}eqW¢eq¢va:q;¢ete{q{}
°£7!ka²}vet¬,t¥}v¢e5¤aVÀq¢e_k5}eâ2}vP}ek
9q¡¥
Ê¬ß£2¢v¡
7¤2qk"tv7â2

}²q}
Æ¬a}
av¡q
q¢e°akqq}¬§©v:q²«_^9¤2: {}vX}ve
«±¤v:kq9Pq¤v
:Ì ØÖTÓ ¼Õ çÕÚéeÞ±ÒÃÜEÐ{ÒÃÝVÖCÝ XÐÓÐÕÚ Ð ÀÕ
lÞ_Ó ÒÑÐ{ÒÃÝ6ÖÀÓPFÏ ![ÝPÓ6Ï /ÒµÛjÜÏµÒ éeÓÐ{ÒÃÝ6ÖCØÚ OÝ
ClÝVÖEÔ6Õ2Þª×Ý6ÚÚÒÃêÏÃÕ
OÕ 0çÕÚéeÞ±ÒÃÜEÐ{ÒÃÝVÖTÝ
![ÝPÓ6ÏÑÚ
qq|~}c¢v¢2,^¤eãE95¥:}v
5»5;¢v{Æ{²«q²3¤eGëq°{^ q9}[±Àq«¢eq¢e}ª}ÅU°v^®¡q6}eI}e§H}e
^}[e
v}v£ee
5}v;
tJ%¢eG2eK}
{³qk¢v£e57¢e¢ek°q^{qt¡
{Ä_t¢e"
}2°;^¡{ Àq{I H%{À!}e}vÀa¡q
q£
}âve}vö!5/t^"9qÆ¡¬a"k!¤v{¤2¥5¡k±"qt¢v²q¤v;qt5"}ev
Ùaâv¡akc;a£e¡qe
qqâva}2}/{V}¸kkq¡
a|~{}v5kVq
¡{}e ¨
}e{!"°¤2^¬ºa
«;¤v£l£e%Æ{q¢v2{5EL{-;«{÷
}9úæý
ëû÷Àq¤e¯_}2¤eq}v;}ªc©Ã² {{aq}2¬_¨
) y}vSq¯_¤e}v;¸%^9M
³t;¤eq}2
^q¤vU{ kæ°k §a

}2a}v{}Åt¢e;¢e
lq¢v{{6q¨
°^âv¡}e¡
9
E
CBDB
OE
G
MF
E
,E
T
CBDB
MF
#U
#"
Q"
j
)
#"
U
Q"
%
;
%
'
3%
%
Vj
*U
4
=adc>e\e\e>c h
$
)
iadc>e\e>e\c h
:Ì XÝVÛjÕ :ÒµÛ*ÜÏµÒ évÓÐ{ÒÃÝ6ÖCØÚ XÐ{ÒµÏÃÏl×"ÝPÚÚÒÃêÏÃÕ
²q {a"}vtUªq£_a²¬Å
qe{qâ2²
{}e}vq
kq}[°q
%À{kkUq{a{:¢e2}e5_q^5q9£v}eUÅ¢eqql{ã5¤v;}e{k}v¯_}vk¤e;°a²¬Uak;;q
}e¡q¨¨
q¯_¢e¤e
À
ÑãV}2À;À{X°vE
q _¤aÀá§!;;¢vq
Æ}_«E}v!X%}_;¤eq{ }v}v;qkqqa¤e} Elq/© ¯_ ¤e
k}2æ;°k)E eÄP:{qt¢vqqÆÀ¬%}2U
qV¢vv|~}
We°}/© ) eV°:k¤2
;¡qk¤ee © ±:# kq¤e v
w º\ :%pdepPgÀ]¼w !der/`:u2Z3]a7r @yrE`Xf
SpPz±u³dv\ !]e\^rEgjp6u³pPz±z_\^]a`6]apPzc` º;\ :%pPdepPgÀ]
SpPz±u³dv\ !]e\^rEg r §` f^`:g <ypPz{]±d2\ku]e\^rEg ]±r
f^`:glzr rEf 7g7r \^`:f[\ ìp ºÊ7de`V]e\^rÀg
|~}£eeq9}2;e¬U{P}e²¢e§e°£}v« Ua
âv}eq}tv}c}cª
qe¢29
;àvqqq°{
¢eJ
»¬[¢e¢vÅ{e%q9{£e}e;q¬ª°

2!{}O«_¬±£
}et{²¤2k¡}_ä¥¨Ãq[²q¢v²
¸
}vq
²²¤veeÅ¤a9¢v{¤e²}v²5
}v}_9¬
¢vÆ«{¬_ª}vj²©æ¥¨µt
}e}v_q²¢Ue°¬±}v}e²t°¡Uq©£eP§Xq|~¢v}§q¢eeE;£9e7{
e{°9}¢}vße¢e¤a5e
}v£eq
¢ :Xã/q¢e{«{
}q{²ek%°2}e_}eqq}e§£vq¥a¤v¤e9{q}}t¢e{7q
9a¡qq
q}aqU}ª© Pk}etq¤v¢ª°; :k¤eee°}aa ¤v
²,{k£e© a¤a¨
%
%
)
%
a c>e\e>e\c
h
#]
=adc>e\e>e\c h
aic\e>e\e\c h
E
CBB
E
(B
E
(B
OE
R
R
S
S
(J
S
?N
N
E
]
]
]
:]
\kg Ef^pÙw /pPgÀ] Sp]apd \kgl\kz{]e\kuëwSu]e\^rEglz
<ëp6z_Êlf~]ezrEgDYªr WÊt]a`V]e\^rEg!`Xf
Yªr lfkp 7\~] r f^`:glg!\kg T`:g!h f^`:g
Y[Z7pPuvmt\kg
{

6}_¤v5Vea°¡q}e
}eq£2}eEÅq¢e}vc;{e"°v}¤a9¢eq9¶±}v}e_
}[²e¢e;á¥}e^¬W
Cvlk}e¤v{
¨¨
q}P
½°^ú 5÷ { "!$
°''û &#% ÷
þq* ©æ÷,q÷,÷)}e*)({/ ú ÷ ' }_ ÷
û+5*þ a ;ÿ"ú
ú '³ ²ûû+, }eú®ÿU°ú kq÷ ° ù+û *,*9÷ þú .{-9 }vùaÿ û!
. - G
DF
CF
E
N
^N
?NOB
P
1J
R
B
DF
S
S
MF
54
6
f[
[
4
i[
6
i4
54
[
54M4
4 4
öv{aW²¤vqq¤v{V¤S}[ò;ó{{ó1"0 võ ¤aä£±q¬$}v;{V²
e²
áe¥^;¬Qá¥^¬ä©Ñek°}v³}e }vvv ï î: ¨
!
²e°}}v q¢eä
²e;á^¬j²9¢e9¶±}eyt¢e;¢e
¢e
°
½°^¸{ °"!3& 2%WM÷ ©æ'qû }e{2Wú {
'}_þ ±ý
aû;÷;ÿ5
²4y}eú ®°÷ kq°!;#÷ q'þ }vý;_û÷;q
ÿ ¨
- - * ÷*6/ú ÷÷)({ú ÷ *9÷ - 9ù+*,*9÷ .-9ùaû '³û 74¸ú ½8,
* Lÿ 'û÷ ÷ q©æàv2¡;°q¡î/a± Eæ
q}±«}e{}
}v
{¢e!e±æ7«}§}§q¢v
9 : r<;H]ar SpPz±u³dv\kx5p=*rEg> Sp]apd \qg!\kz{]e\ku
wSu]a\krEg!z\qg?ªZl\kzäw !der/`:u2Z
|~}ä!e{¥
Ç³}e

}_Ñ!Pq²¢e²{}{9EtaX2}v²e|~}c}qq¢v¢va;;q
}v²}e°}vkqä°%k
{qk¡{
;q}v/¤e}e°¯{¤v
¬"a
qq²}etq¢v!^9{qvtq¢v¤aE{q}e
[
[ [6
[6
54
\[
4
,E
f4g4
iE
CBB
[
N
5438
}}eq
¢v9%k^¡¬¯{v¤v
}v
W}¸X{{qq¤e{²}v5
q¢2!¢e{{ {}e¬e

}ve
a4
÷ q|~}
÷;þ²ÿ"q¡ú }vvú¨Ã=¥/ú {*£_¬}*¢e§¢e¢eäq¤eq
¥9}v5q}_c7që¢v}c{{qq¢e{}P¬*}äÄ a¢e"2
}v¬ }vÙ¤eq}í}v¯_q¤e ²¬ ,
;¬´±{}v
ä}v{¤e§; {}_{q}vÃO}vc·[e¶±}e
qoqq¢eÅ q;UW@2_qqq¢2£e«q§¤e£;¨
«:¡¤e9 ¢ ^VÄ}v
%q§5£e¶_}v§q*ªa¢e;
"
}_}e 7{/q{¢v}vL k
E}vÅq·[¢v

}U}vk¤eÅ£2B^A ¢±¥¤v¤a
Vq;{¢e}v;À¤vaa
"
q}2¢2a
}vP
}ctq}e¢e
79kÃ³qq¢v¡U
{}:
A }[}v£
A
a¡q
q£2¡q
¬§}q
U A }2 BA
¢vÆU|~«{}¢väÆë«q²¢v
tqâv}e£e9qäe§
qa¤e;}vD5CS¢v{Æ} «{"{©/ â2k}e£e¥²);q´±;qJ ìq}v/:;;qq}v}v§vq¢2·[}v
;«q}}vak¡;¯{q¤v¤vq
}v}v
§kq7¤e ;q }vkæ°}vk ceÅq¯_¤e }v;U@
´±q
}v
k}2·ª§ 5{{7±¤v{{^97¢¡q9;¢q¢2k¡Æ} ¯{«¤v5
a}vq
¢e¤el5}vPq;¤e{´±}qqq}eq¢v}2Ut^9e;q; }v£ ±t¡@ 9¢
[
[
[ 54
a c\e>e\efc
a c>e\e\e\c
h c
a c>e\e>e\c
a c>e\e\e\c
^f `:glg!\kg 9r/d \^]eÊ7`V]e\^rEglz;¼\~]eZ
jrEgF Sp]±pPd \kg!\qz{]a\quywSu]a\krEg!z"G*pPu³pPz±z±\~]
rEdjY[rEg!hl\~]e\^rEg!`:fwSu]e\^rEglz
ß¢e[Åâee´a{}q2y£e|~¥}O^¶±¬ë}e¢eÅÙ5;at´±
¢vq

W}v²tW}vPkq¢2°{e}v
{§
k}{9¢vE,}e}2§;¡q²¬a^q¤e¢v
§Å{}eÄqqU{}2}
a¡
qq
q£2""¡Ue7°}{³9¢,l²°lq²¤aá§
}_;K
J}_ lqe;£5q¢v;q} IH

}_£v5|~}^9q}ec{}ae¨~°a;}SW
qa¢e"Ç³U
}e°
^²}_§""{q²{a}v
U}_lWaU2/Æq¬§}v²a}v}e,Päq¤v,a
5t
}2Wq¢aa}v{[Çk{{}ak} ¨¨
t;¢eqq7}v±!À}vU¤v¤e^P7V
|~},}vqqe¢v

3 * À{4 eú ú }vkûq¡* Uú e¢eÃW ±{¤e}v}v¨
q}2q{oq¢v%k
Xkq ¡q² q¢v %k
X{{}v

q2{ßP}v¡5aa9}e¢¸¡q
²q{£2"t{¡}_} 9L¢"JlHNM;O¡}vº}2¸aß¥¢±¤v{}v{e9¢ª{'³kû {O}q# ²#}et Q!¤vk/q¢vak¡²¯_
¤e;
}v£q

¨
M O 2t¢eq,òP F ä}v !làv!¡9¢e°}Å}v{
{9¢k}¡¯{;¤v
²}ve
¤e5qW:q«¢e%¤e{ ¤v k@t}vX§;´±¢±q¤vq
}v±¢e««¤e£e
q¢v5{¤e}v{}
·ª%Æ¬²q¢v!²e°}ã
¤e³¡÷ *9÷ þú®ûQ* @+ù *Ä *9÷ -9ùaû ^q¤e 6{2_qq£eÀ«¨
' úæý;û+* +ù *,*÷ .-9ùaû ^q¤v t{/k{²{q£e«¨
¤e¡ @
R \kg Ef^pÙw /pPgÀ]jrEgF Sp]±pPd \kg!\qz{]a\qu
wSu]a\krEg!z"[Yªr WÊt]a`V]e\^rEg!`Xf§Yªr Wf^p 7\~]
r f^`:g!gl\kg C`:g!h f^`:g$YcZ7pPuvm\qg
q½÷,*9}2÷
tþú®ûQ* °"^!Tù+*,*SU{÷ %=
{.-9°ùa©æqû}eVú F WL,÷ O*6/ú {½8
}_, * 5 ÿI}v÷ '³ û}a÷÷;¨~þ a÷ ;
ú²5Æ÷}e°k'q°û ä *;ú ¨
E
DF
S
R
dE
G
N
1J
R
[
[
[=4
&-
[
]
-
a c\e\e>efc
[
f4 4
4
f4 4
adc\e>e\e>c
4 4
34
f4 4
a c\e>e\e>c
G
DF
CF
dE
^N
[
R
f4g4
?NOB
MF
S
f4 4
54
*8
P
bJ
MF
S
[6
4
N
B
6
\[
[
54
q½ }2
t °"^! {%={°©æq}eV ÷,O*6/ú {
}_ 5 }v÷ }a÷;¨~þ a;
ú²5Æ÷}e°k'q°û ä *;ú ¨ /È È YªrEglufkÊ!z±\krEgQ`Xglh*)7Êt]eÊ!dep r/dem
|~} q¢e°tv2aã
' úæý;ûQ* 9ù+*,*9÷ .-9ùaûú ½8, * ÿL'û÷ ÷
e ´±{v{°9;¢Uqq¬"¢e5¤e}v°¬aqÀ}vÅXa;«²
e¤eª}¸{}v¥

}v²e«{;´a¥^e¬ ¨
½q}2
X °"^
! U {%=
æ
©
q

e
}

{

_
}

v
}

a
}
~
¨
a

;

e
}
°

;

¨
{°'V ÷,*6/ú ÿ ÷'û÷÷ ({÷ ú ÷ *÷ - ÷,*9÷ ,
k %qet}ºq9¢e{9«{¶±
}}ev7t"}º°keÄ vq_9¢y}St¢v9¢S¢e¸«°
þú®ûQ* 9+ù *,*9÷ .-9ùaû '³û [ú ½8, * L
W q¢e}¤2k¢e!q
}vq«ee{{9¢ã
! W{U{%=®©æqV }e ,÷ *)O/ú {
}_ ÷5÷)}v({ú }a¨~÷a;*9
÷ ²- }e °'kq °äúæý;;û+* ¨
q½ù+*,}2*
÷ a.-9ùaû °'^"û + v ²
q´±
¨Ã^«±¬,°kVEq¢e}ve;q¨~{£e
}_Ue°V}v
}e²}vvee¤a9}2{}v;{"¨
ªú ½8, * ÿL'û÷ ÷
+ C¤eq}v°¬±}_ Sv¢eÙ}e}e
}ev² e¤a9{}v;²e;´a^¬
SpPz±u³dv\ !]e\^rEg r >Ê!\qfk\^xldv\kÊ Æbc`:z_pPh
Ê!f^]a\k` /pPgÀ] fk`Xglg!\qg ;¼\~]eZ!\qgo]eZ!p
©æ¬}v;î/²vq{q}e¸qîE}q{ô2t_kqq¢O}îEqÅ{2t_kq¢¼qîE}vq {Å2_k}vq- }-._V,ªÀ}v k0
wSf~]apdvg!`6]e\^sEpjw lder/`:uvZQ]ar À]a`V]ap
SpPz±u³dv\ !]e\^rEg
qe¢2%«ª¤vq¢v%qÅ¡k¤v¥q9¢e5{¤eU¢*q¡q¢eqc}v¡¯{£e¤v¬£v{qa¤eq"²¨Ã£2kq°qã *!¤e²q°¬{{P
}_
°k,¢v Æ«ª%²:â2}e,¥¢2Æq«;§ ¸jq;: {k%£e e°}e}v}ee£e
°E²l
²e;´²q¢2}U¢eW
q¡k}2±¨
àek{{k¡À£e9¢O}v§;q%
âv}_}v}e qtºW·ª©^kò
"
e}e,;´aq^}e¬§{a}q}_!²eW°}v}e}e¤e}e9§vqq
{}v£eq_q¢ve%q¢vkU}v;k{k5{}¸q;£e{!"¦ ¨
Å
C

v
£

±
´
q

v
}

{

2
}

e
à
{

{9¢}{ ³e¢vÆ«5{k£eW¤e}v{}
;é{|~}aq¬§U{}e¬{e«ÿ
ùaû {ú}{q÷¢e5'û ¬±}evú ²°ú ¢e
999¢±¬ÿ +ù * ÿ þq÷
©/ ) @
* ÿL'û÷)( 9ú û÷ , {÷ 'û 2ú qq¢2q}2P!{«
q}Å}2q¢e
Uq
;qq¤e}v}vWkÀq¤eV[q¢eU k{æ
}_°k Wc}2a
ª
}vVeq¢v}e"
{´±} ¨ / 'e÷ '³þ ý
û÷
ÿ 10c,°§aq£e;´±q}vëq¢vqÅq¡k¤v¥9
t¢e·ª
q5¢e¤vq^¢e75{q{¢2Æ«5_¨Ãq¢¤e}v
}_{t}°tq¢vqqt°êâv¡,;{£t}e±¡t¡9¢ q²
;«{{
"}ª"¤e{}eq°
qq¡}e¼kq°
}_"9a
Ä5a¢eWqÀ["{
a}_a³©Ñ v}v³ºqq¢e"a
aq¨
k}2 {l±{9¢ª¡;9¢k£e¡¯{}v¤v
}v{
l}PE;´±{q
}_q}2 !{;q{} }v @ ;q2£{}vaa{}ej2v;{} ²ïeî/¤a¬±}vqv}vq¢
}v²ßVe;á¥£2^{¬Ùvðñqñ_¤eð ¥õ 9 ¸äa;¨
q¢v5ö q¡'kû ¤eªq
}eU}vkq°^9%3 Ã þ ÷ úæ÷ W7{9¢c}{¡:}vc¡9¢ È
derr z
k;q{9}vaqq¬c}v°7©æ;¶q}v}ä q¢v "e°
«±¬¤v"cqq¢e{v}2q«_ªq¤2¯_"¤eq}v;;q} Ëå:Ì~Ë ×§Þ_Ý:Ý "Ý ×§Þ{Ý6Ü7ÝPÚ{ÒæÐ_ÒÑÝVÖEÚë1Ë Eå
ß¢eßP5[ee±«V,VîEîEq{q{22__kkqq}O}ªðeòãUq7¢ekq9;á°^¢_q
}v
!¸ v}O¢v{
Æ¬U¢v!"e°}
aq¢e2 ° te3£v2 o© }q¢e%
{/q {t%½²¡ q£eWeq{2k^¬
³{÷ 7*9÷ 2þ_ú®ûQq* q£v9+ù 5*,*9«÷ .¤e-9ùa¡ û {"}{@ qÄ ¢e c ^q¤v q¢vÄ±lq¢±{¤vq
£ Uqq¢±¢v¤vª;q°e q
}_½ q¡©{6 2q
' úæý;û+* +ù **9÷ -9ùaû2¢e§{
}_ Å ^q¤e §{ e!°;{Åq¥«{{
9}vqv/«kqâ2¬¼£eeq{^£e¬a
J

}
q²2_qq£e«¤e¡ @
·[;{}vaÆq¬,}v¢vtq5§e°}Åkâv°W,¸÷9tø;ùa¡ú®ûüúæ9ý
¢þú®ùa{ÿ
}_¥ Eq¢eã t}eU^ q¢vtv}e}e}e²eq{£e
o°t}va
¡ ½W¨µ
²e;q{
Ëå:Ìæå ×§Þ_Ý:Ý "Ý ×§Þ{Ý6Ü7ÝPÚ{ÒæÐ_ÒÑÝVÖ
,
}_¢e¡caqv¢e}}Cv°X[q¢e}e}e¡}_; 9¢2¬í}e{k¤v;¡7qkkq¤e9²
[¬{aq¢e¢v ß2 ¢e M 5O 4
´a6k2 q }vM;5O 798 Mk:¤28 9¢ (
e
°J } 6°e
}e¯_q¤e «Ã¨Ñ
¢§}_ ^9
_

e
¢
@
q
¤e}_¡Ä t^}e7£}e
qq¬²q¤v;k¤e³¢e q}¢vqt¢e
"´akkqq}v}e; Ù£
E}e_q¢e²²q^¢v9%q;¡°
³ }2 ½² °7¡q£v{Ä2¢±¤v

6¢e
¢e}°³t/e°q¢v}{}v
}_7 Å{9¢vk£e}e¬,{kt¤2
;W¡qkkq9¤eq{¬{vq¢e¢e°7
q¤e}_¡ qWßPe§v«q:«{¢v/q¢v!¶_!}v¥Wt } ½W½W¨~¨~;;{{"²ve

qqe!!£eq
¢±Ù¤vl¦5k9¤e¢eáU9
¶±}e}_
t6^}e£5{k£e¬q¤v

^¤e³{q¢e°7
}_¡ 2<}2; U6e2<; 8>{= q¥{}v:8>=@?B{A3q¤e°D A»±¦
}ª}«£q°£ee¤v ;;¡
qU}vC ¢e= A
e°|~}e}v}va
}e¡²6e5£v¢e% q¡a¤v{}P§
}[¶{²q¢e²{t}e
!È Ê!f^]e\ lfkpjw /pPgÀ]ez"cYªr WÊt]a`V]a\krEg7`:f
Yªr lfkp 7\~] r fk`Xglg!\qg ì`Xglh fk`Xg
e°}e}v}e²e£vã
Y[Z7p6uemt\kg
¢e7eq{£e
o¢v{^ÀU{q}2
" kq¤e "}v kæ°k eÄ
½c÷9ø;ùaú®ûüúæý
þ ú®"ùa#! ÿQ"ú % V ,÷ *)½8/ú , * ÿI '³ û÷ ÷ ÷ ÷
'þ þ ý;÷û÷
ÿ÷ ({ú ú #'û ¼ú
7¢v^Uk²°t
´±q
}v{}vÄ
$
k¢e¸q{{!¤e}vX;¦¸q{}e} ¬ªq}[¢vq¢v,e_¡;q§}e}v ; a
2}2}vªº
´±{q}S
q}v¢v
½- ª÷9ø
ùaú®ûüúæ"ý;&! þú®ùa%Uÿ% '³& û J÷ 'ý9þ ÷; û ý;û÷;ÿ -* ÷F,÷ *)*
/û ú ' (
÷§½ ÷ ({ú ÷ *÷
{q}2E= A eAU©F; 6; 6= 5= ;
H
[6
4 4
4
f4g4
6
[6
4
4
f4g4
[
f4 4
[
E
54
54
f[
[
4
54
\[
4 4
54M8
(B
R
F
N
MF
S
CBDB
E
[
54
[6
4
\[
54M8
!
G
(B
-
a
a
c
c\e>e\efc
a
6 \[
a c>e\e\e\c
c
h
[4 [6
\[
a
[
4
6
f4 4
74
c
#e\e>e
R
S
;A
f4
f4g4
4
[
a c>e\e\e\c
a
;
h
e\e\e
a c\e>e\e\c
h
a c\e>e\efc
4 4
54
[
[ [6
`4
;
[
[
[ [6
6 \[
8
8
f4 4
ac\e>e\e\c
8
;
=a
e\e>e
;
h
9
ae\e>e
-
a
(B
CF
?NOB
P
1J
e\e>e
a
e\e\e
?NOB
R
MF
S
S
DF
[6
[
54
[6
[
54
[
[6
[
[
[614
4 4
54
f[
a c\e\e>e\c
c
a c>e\e\e\c
h
~|a}Sq¢e}v!
{;kq{}vq¢etq¸}v¼}e¢eäÅ}e¡{;k{}¼O¬O«q
¤v}º

^}vq¤e°la
e°;}y}e¨
{k¤v£e"7°¥Vq}v¤e²{ }e¬²q¢eW£«!¯_¤v}_qâvUvq{2_kq}v
Ëå:Ì ×§Þ_Ý:Ý "Ý ×§Þ{Ý6Ü7ÝPÚ{ÒæÐ_ÒÑÝVÖ
ß2 ¢e M O 4
´a6k2 q }vM;O 7 2 Mk¤22 9¢ (t¢ee°q} ° °¯_¤eq«£e{
Ä}_ ¢±¤v

qq¢v¥{} ;´aðek,q}v;,£2e¬T{}eí{%k¤vq£@
{¢eq,;°¢e°½²e 6!£e¤e,
Hq¸îEq{2½W¨¨
;{²e
q{ÄÆq¢±¤vÆq¢eÀ}e
e£v*° ½W¨~;{²e
qE{
Ñ
Ëå:Ì ×§Þ_Ý:Ý "Ý ×§Þ{Ý6Ü7ÝPÚ{ÒæÐ_ÒÑÝVÖEÚ ºÓ6Ö
î/{qq}vE ,²}v 0Ueq«{k²°¬{
Ëå:Ì ×§Þ_Ý:Ý "Ý ×§Þ{Ý6Ü7ÝPÚ{ÒæÐ_ÒÑÝVÖEÚëÓ6Ö ßt¢eÆæ¬±;}v:q¢v¢v/!lvt
} «{5
°¬ /³}a¢e¯_5¤e{£et¤eC}v^}"U£2t^9a¡q

«±}£q}e¤v ;8¡% 8 ¦%Ã {8 5W52 k q
¨
²a¤v

}_²*qq{S y$ k¡½²ÄX
²q¢e
}_Åk¡;{}vqO¢väkqq"
²S©Ñ}{U
¤v}¼¬5q¸k²£e
q
¨
^;¬±°2{ ¸ß½²¢±¤v Xq¢ee}ä9¢e9¶±}eÅe£v £
}e_5Åq¢v
$
vÀq¢e
´akq}v;Wq¤v9¢S}ë¯_¤e£e¤e0
}¼£Åa;¨
q¢v;%ßP£U;l°;{{²2 e(
½²²qWÄvaîEqt¢vq¢eW{2vq_qk± qV }6$ ôîE ½Ùq°{2¦Ue_Ñk «q±}£_} ¬U±at¤e¢_°¤2tk¤a ®¨
â29¢e
¡9}{¶_}eC8 v; q«{%:q8 ¢2; ? %2<=,¶±}e62<t= } $ A ¡½W¨µ
²±e;}ye«Æ£vq°Q
¦
v
£

@
q; "
q|~}v=¢eaA 7
¡e}ve¸}§59¢ee
9}¶±{}eq¶¥Wv{qq}v{¢v£ePt¤e}e° ²ACe°¦}e
}e}e}¸²£2eq¡£ea
¤v;¡ã
7¢vÛ;q}v" ^q¤e }v ^æq vÄ
7¢vÛk²°t
´±q
}v{}vÄ
k¢eq{/¤e}2X¦¸q{}}e¬ªU}[q¢vq¢vU,e_;¡q"}e}vU; a
!
}2
ª}2O
´±{q}ä
q}v¢v
{q}2E = A e
= $¡ © ; $ AU© ; 5; ? 5= 6= @ kÄ
© ;+$C
¢e5_¤e}v;q}v ÙòeÆ¬aq
q¤e} kq¤e v
|q~}¢v,¢e{"
}_
{k{
Xá

«
aq¬[²eÆ°¬±}£² °q¢e}v;¡q}_§ò¬[Xkk¤v;Å¡qk9¢e¤eÀ9¶¸q¢v
qq¢v¢v"tvv}ª}°°7}[}¯_¯_¤e¤e£e£e¤e¤eo{575q¤a}_á§;ò{
}_Wq9¢e¡9¶q¢v
^àeq¤e ²¢e°t{} }_; ±$ tk²q¤eq ¯_v¤eã
}2;X{}v^9qq}e²t¥¢
q²;²¡
a¢vÆ«k¤2
;¡q©æt¢e
} = $ ^q¤e {a}v
=q$ ²;^æ²q¡
_ a }v ¢vÆ«{ k¤2
;¡q>©t¢e}
a
;
;
h
e\e>e
a
e\e>e
38
&8
8
;
;
:9
;
;
a
a
?"O
?"
e>e\e
a
a
e\e>e
a
e>e\e
e\e>e
e
e\e>e
a
e>e\e
a
e\e>e
a
a
a c>e\e>e\c
Kc
a c\e>e\e\c
|~;}c¡qk¤e¢e
£v5¤a7}e9et}eq¡¢e;§¡q
q¡¬§kq¤v}2

a}v^¤ee°}[7°5{2
}__qqò£e §q¤v;¨
e°°}t}v¢v;
}¼¤vaq¢e}e¸qq¢e°²}vkªq9q
¢e¬
kqW9ßq¢e§}_¬Å}vò7¬c²
{k}O}_§²tò²¯_¢v¤e
¢v}c£eq¢vt¤e,J
¬ä q¤v;

^6¤v; E? _¦q¢vÃ
{7Àt;á¢e°
^9}OÀ5EUU{q¶{£e²2_lqq¢eq°%£vq =
}_q%¢v
}eU¡5;^= ¡qq{
q¨¨
qt¢e¤e°{9X¢ëßq¢v¢e;e{°}v}ëaq°U}§}e°§À;qé¤v
;
q¬"^t¤v¢2¦OÑq ¢eWE{U{t}2¢e2°9¯_¢ ¤v@ AD}_q¨
âva¡¡kqe¡q,{2_ek¤vq}2{}e{}vq¤eqUUî/e;{q£¥{t} ß¢_¤2
v2qÀ%«{
¢2}Æ «q¢v
<yp 9pdepPglu³pPz
ï /÷ !û ðññ{ñõÀ¢ek 9Ãí!°a¶
}e«±°9¢
}e}v}v}v
yÙ²7e}v¤e;T!
ß6}eeq¡eq8^vÆ´±lÀUþ ²ú äe*
¤eú eû°}e{}e}v÷
}eû®Ùlûüú {;÷ }C²*9qe÷
¢v;ëáò¡vð{^ðaq¬ä¡ã ðk0v5}vò;¦a;e¼ð°. }e±¨
ðññ{ñe
ï Àt}e÷ !û ³ðññ_ðÆõ9¢2
{Àt}evÆt¤e}e/{
}2k{¡}v
Å!#"$¤e"%}±!'q¤e°& {
}_þ ¸:/ e°_'k}e2}v)}eö 2(Jùa{ûq|~}Uú _'³÷ þ *9q÷9÷ 4 û }$ú 2äú ¡- ¯_¤eE e÷£e"q {°}_ q {}P ,
}v{eea ö7¤v ¤v kl ðñ{ñ{ða * ï //÷ û Pòó{ó õ² Eq{Ñ 6 !¤}vë ¤e£a¨
¥^¬5¢eUq¤e}e°6}+À:{a²{²e
á}e¥¨Ã^¬{}v_aa¡2;°}vea
£v}_:¥ê¬"°}e}v}v²}e¤v2}v$al
þ vú £e*;ú ¥¨ û
÷
û®ûüú {÷ *9÷
B.vã ¡¦aôôeòó{ó e
ï }vk}}v:
{qveðñ{ññ õ 5ä{
}2k} }2M:_k2
ú *;}_6ú 6!%û.¨Ã £v}ä{k}e÷
¡û®{ûüMú}a_¨~÷ a¤v;}e*÷0
«{/l
"9÷ q
}e÷ S°^)þ e*°Pa}eò }e,eUã}eò ô{óÆ}v¦e{-ðo@ð , .v {kùa¬±ðþ }vñ{9ñ ¢eñvû -}vl þ ,
ï £2q³ò¡óó ÆõîX £2q ß¢e ;{²e
´±¨
¥^ú ¬ (3q¢el þ ú ° *
}eú {¤vû4{ ÷;û®Uûüú _2÷ 1*9÷;û
,÷ * þ v/ú * &aþ *B,
57686:9; <+<>===? @%9?BA CBDE? FG@H<I@8JG<I@K6GL$CM<EN7O+O$P+<%Q%R ò{ãò ,Æ¦aðô ©^ò¡óó
ï kqU}òó{ó Æõ kU}_î/£v£e°^tvq{2_kq}v
e0{ô}e¦ }e}e0vv ãë
eq
}_q}j}vj
²e;á^¬ STVU WYX

ï À}òó{ó Æõ[Z"
}]\ ÿ²÷ & ÷ þ *³ö!a²5îEq¡q
7
_^/¶³
ï î:v{a²q{¤³òó{ó10 õ l lî:va²¥q¤P V Lÿ 'ù ,
ú û3V ÿI'³û÷)(ú *ö!eeq}a¨µ·[q¬ct{a}vvÅö%
òóó 0v
ï î/¬±}vvq¢}2ßV£2{2ðñ{ñ{ðÆõ 6lÆ«±°Tî/¬±}v{e¢C}v

°a
|~U}v} OßVþ^¬[*9÷£2÷ }v4 {äú X;Å{¤e²¥-eS
´a¥(`^}{¬["qa-¡7U "H¶{!
¬ª_À{qq¢e¶³ã§}2¡}2eÆ|µ¬_}2 c¬{}vÅ"aq¤v¢v±¬ ¨
ò ¡¦³òóv±* ðñ ñ{ðe ï ·S¶±}v!}v¬òó{óôõ 6 !·S¶±}vE}vb² /{Å¬{¨

ú 9
XöQ- ¤e÷Tqc °{ùa
þ }_" v÷;}eþ }e}e[ú 9û ¢vV ¥%-;÷
¤eþq÷ V*9|~÷ } *þ l *9þ ÷9÷ú 4 ,,
*;ú ûd ÷
û®ûüú _÷ *9÷ * û 2ú ba* ÷;ÿ òB0 ¡¦ò .{ðe
a1c\e>e\efc
ac>e\e>e\c
QR
[
6 \[
[6i4
d4
[
6 \[
[
[ [6 ?
?
[
6 \[
#
[
[
6 f[
4
[
[=4
[
f[
[=4
6 \[
=
+
[
[614
[614
f[
[
6 f[
[
[
[ [6
[
d4
[
X4
\[
[

Download Report

Complexity of Single-Agent and Equilibrium

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz