Firm Behavior and Market Access in a Free Trade Area with Rules of

6h4 i@Lh @?_ @h!i| UUitt ? @ 6hii
Ah@_i hi@ | +*it Lu h}?
a@?_L?} a
N?iht|) Lu !*@L4@
k@*@ kht?@4
i??t)*@?@ 5|@|i N?iht|) @?_ ,+
U|LMihc bbH
Nulvkqd
judwhixoo| dfnqrzohgjhv vxssruw iurp wkh Qdwlrqdo Vflhqfh Irxqgd0
wlrq xqghu Judqwv VEU0<653;58 dqg VEU0<:5834<1 Zh duh judwhixo wr Ure Uhhg
iru frpphqwv1
Mt|h@U|
`*i | t |i4T|?} |L |?! Lu 6hii Ah@_i hi@t E8 A r @t *Mih@*3?}c
|i) ?ii_ ?L| Mi ?i hi@tL? uLh |t t @ hi*@|i*) *itt t|_i_ ui@|hi Lu
8 A rc ?@4i*) +*it Lu h}? E-r U _i|ih4?i i? ThL_U|t @hi
i*}M*i uLh Thiuihi?|@* |hi@|4i?| ì _ii*LT @ 4L_i* |L t|_) |i Mi@Lh
Lu h4t ? @ 6hii Ah@_i hi@ | +*it Lu h}? @?_ |i UL?tiî?Uit Lu
|t Mi@Lh L? |i 4@h!i| i^*Mh4 @?_ L|UL4i ì @i @ ?4Mih Lu
?|ihit|?} @?_ UL?|ih ?||i hit*|t |L Lgih
6ht|c i tL |@| h4t ** ULLti |L tTiU@*3iG tL4i h4t ** ULLti
|L 4ii| h*it Lu Lh}?c @?_ |ihiM) LM|@? 3ihL |@hgtc *i L|iht ** ULLti
|L }?Lhi |i TLttM*|) Lu LM|@??} Thiuihi?|@* |hi@|4i?| 5iUL?_c i *LL!
@| |i igiU|t Lu @? 8 A L? 4@h!i| @UUitt ì tL |@| @? 8 A |
t|hU| -r L? |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ h@tit 4TLh|t @?_ i?Ui 4ThLit
4@h!i| @UUitt ? |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i|c M| hi_Uit 4TLh|t @?_ i?Ui @h4t
4@h!i| @UUitt ? |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i| Ah_ i *LL! @| |i igiU|
Lu 4Lhi hit|hU|i -r ? |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i| UL?tiî?Ui Lu Lh
tTiU@*3@|L? hit*| t |@| 4Lhi hit|hU|i -r L? |i ?@* }LL_ ht| h@ti
@?_ |i? *Lih 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_c M| ht| *Lih |i? h@ti 4TLh|t
Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ Aih |h??} TL?| t UL44L? tL |@| 4TLh|t
Lu |i ?@* }LL_ @hi 4@ 43i_ @?_ 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ @hi
4?43i_ @| @ UL44L? *ii* Lu hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i h*it Lu Lh}? w@t|*)c
i tL |@| Lh 4L_i* U@? Mi hi?|ihThi|i_ |L tL |@| 4Lhi hit|hU|i
-r L? |i ?@* }LL_ ht| 4ThLit @?_ |i? @h4t |i uLh|?it Lu *@MLhc
@?_ |L U@t| *}| L? @ T@h|U*@h TL*U) |L 4ThLi 4@h!i| @UUitt
|ih ThLM*i4t | @ t4*@h t|hU|hi UL*_ @*tL Mi @?@*)3i_ t?} Lh
|iU?ît |c i i TiU| t4*@h hit*|t

W?|hL_U|L?
Aihi @t hiUi?|*) Mii? @ th}i ? ?|ihit| ? hiuihi?|@* Ah@_?} hh@?}i
4i?|t Lh A r W? |i L7 4U Lu |t t *?!i_ |L |i Uhi@|L? Lu |i
Lh| 4ihU@? 6hii Ah@_i hi@ Lh 8 A 6hii Ah@_i hi@ Lh 8 A t @ A ? U |@hg h@|it @4L?} 4i4Miht @hi 3ihLc @*|L} |@hg h@|it
ti| M) 4i4Miht L? ?L? 4i4Miht @hi ?L| ?iUitt@h*) i^@*3i_ W? @? 8 A c
4i4Miht 4@?|@? |ih L? i |ih?@* |@hgt t tUc |@hgt @hi *!i*) |L
_gih @4L?} 4i4Mih UL?|hit
Bi? |t _gihi?Ui ? |@hgtc @?_ ? |i @Mti?Ui Lu |h@?tTLh| ULt|tc @|
Thii?|t |h@_i ? @ ThL_U| uhL4 }L?} |hL} |i UL?|h) | |i *Lit|
|@hg L? | @?_ |i? Mi?} tTTi_ |? |i 8 A q Ai @?tih t +*it
Lu h}? Lh - }LL_ t i*}M*i uLh 3ihL |@hgt ? |i 8 A L?*) u |
Lh}?@|it |ihi Aiti - tTiUu) UL?_|L?t U @i |L Mi 4i| uLh
tU Lh}? |L Mi }h@?|i_ Aihi t @ *@h}i *|ih@|hi L? - ? *@c tii uLh
i @4T*i dHo W? iUL?L4Utc @ ui Lu |i ?L|@M*i T@Tiht @hi dDoc @?_ dbo
`*i | t |i4T|?} |L |?! Lu 8 A r @t *Mih@*3?}c |i) @hi Lu|i?
?L| Aihi @hi |hii _t|?U| hi@tL?t uLh |t Ai ht| @t *||*i |L _L
| 8 A r @t tU @?_ t i** ?_iht|LL_G ?@4i*) |i _U*|) Lu _i??}
R*Mih@*3?} ? @ 4*| }LL_ i?hL?4i?|2 At t @__hitti_ ? @ hi*@|i_
T@Tihc tii dSo Aihi i tL |@| ii? |L} @? 8 A |L| -r
Lh |h@?tTLh| ULt|t i@!*) hi_Uit |i |@hg ? igiU| L? @** }LL_tc i*u@hi
@?_ 4@h!i| @UUitt 4@) Mi h| Ai uLUt |ihi t L? *?!@}it ? ?@* @?_
?|ih4i_@|i }LL_t U 4@!i |i t@* |h@_i Uhi@|?} @?_ |h@_i _ih|?}
?||L? Lu |i t|L4t N?L? EL *|ih@|hi u@* Ai tiUL?_ hi@tL? t |@|
|iti - @hi ? |i4ti*it __i? ThL|iU|L?G |i) Uhi@|i @| *LL!t *!i
|@hgt L? 4TLh|i_ ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|t @?_ @giU| |i ThUi Lu _L4it|U@**)
4@_i ?T|t @t i** Ah_c @t -r @hi ?i}L|@|i_ ?_t|h) M) ?_t|h)c
|ihi t i?Lh4Lt tULTi uLh i** Lh}@?3i_ ?_t|hit |L itti?|@**) ?t*@|i
|i4ti*it uhL4 |i igiU|t Lu |i 8 A M) _it?} t|@M*i - 6Lh |t
hi@tL?c |ihi t @ *L| Lu *LMM)?} M) ?_t|hit @?_ i4T*L)4i?| Lu |h@_i
*@)iht ? |i ThLUitt Lu _i??} |i - uLh |ih ?_t|h) W? dboc kht?@
4 Wklv
sdshu dovr frqwdlqv d vxppdu| ri vrph ri wkh uhodwhg olwhudwxuh lq odz dqg lq
lqwhuqdwlrqdo wudgh1
5 Vrph uhfhqw zrun e| Dqghuvrq dqg Qhdu|/ vhh ^4` kdv ghyhorshg frqglwlrqv xqghu
zklfk wklv fdq eh fohduo| ghqhg/ exw wkhuh duh gudzedfnv wr wkhlu dssurdfk dv zhoo1 Vhh
^43` iru vrph shuvshfwlyhv rq wklv lvvxh1

@?_ khi}ih ThL_i @ ?4Mih Lu tU i @4T*it *@h}i T@h| Lu |i 8 A @}hii4i?| |ti*u @t |L _L | _i??} |iti -Aihi @hi *@h}i _gihi?Uit ? |i igiU|t Lu 8 A r | @?_ |L| -
W? |i @Mti?Ui Lu -c @? 8 A hit*|t ? *@h}i U@?}it ? |h@_i Lt @t
|h@_i tii!t |i *Lit| |@hg i?|h) TL?| ?|L |i 8 A BLL_t @hi |i? |h@?t
tTTi_ |L |ih ?@* _it|?@|L? ? |i 8 A u ULhti |t hit*|t ? *@h}i
|@hg hii?i |h@?tuih igiU|t @t |t R|h@_i _iiU|L? |h@?tuiht |@hg hii?i
uhL4 @ }LL_ |L |i UL?|h) | |i *Lit| |@hg i?|h) TL?| OLiihc ? |i
Thiti?Ui Lu -c |t |h@?ttT4i?| t ?L| TLttM*i iih|i*ittc |ihi t
t|** tL4i |h@_i _iiU|L? TLttM*i ) tTT?} _L4it|U ThL_U|L?c U
4ii|t |i -c |L |t 8 A T@h|?iht @?_ 4ii|?} _L4it|U _i4@?_ @
4TLh|tc |i *L |@hg UL?|h) U@? t|** @||h@U| |h@_i |L |t TLh|t OLiihc
|i Thiti?Ui Lu - ** @*tL @||h@U| ?it|4i?| ? Lh_ih |L UhU4i?|
- Atc 8 A r | - *i@_ |L *@h}i ?it|4i?| Ltc *i |Lti
|L| - hit*| ? *@h}i |h@_i Lt- W? dboc kht?@ @?_ khi}ih 4@!i
|t TL?| ? @ 4L_i* | UL?t|@?| hi|h?t |L tU@*i 5U @ 4L_i* 4@)
hiThiti?| |i *L?} h? ^|i i**c M| t ?*!i*) |L Mi Lu 4U ti ? |i
tLh| h? 5Lh|ih h? igiU|t @hi *!i*) |L Mi ih) _gihi?| @?_ @i ?L|
Mii? t|_i_ At t |i LMiU| Lu |t T@Tih
Ai 4L_i* _ii*LTi_ ? |t T@Tih t _t|?}ti_ M) @ ?4Mih Lu ui@
|hit U @hi _U|@|i_ M) |i ?@|hi Lu |i ThLM*i4 6ht|c |@| @t -
?iUitt@h*) ?L*i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|tc | t ?iUitt@h) |L M*_ @ 4L_i* |
?@* @?_ ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_t W? tU 4L_i*tc |i t@* |h@_i Uhi@|?}|h@_i
_ih|?} U*@ttU@|L? ti_ ? |i Ut|L4t ?L? *|ih@|hi t ?@_i^@|i ,i? |L| -c |i ?|ih@U|L? ? |i ?@* @?_ ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_t 4@h
!i|t hit*|t ? |L ?i igiU|tc @| i U@** |i ?T| ThUi @?_ |i _ihi_
_i4@?_ igiU|t u@** ? |i |@hg L? |i ?@* }LL_ Lh ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_
hi_Uit |t ThUi @?_ tL hi_Uit |i ^@?||) tTT*i_ @?_ ?Uhi@tit |i ^@?
||) _i4@?_i_ @| L4i At Uhi@|it |h@_i @t i Uitt _i4@?_ Lh 4TLh|t hti
At t |i u@4*@h |h@_i Uhi@|L? igiU| OLiihc |i u@** ? |i _L4it
|U ^@?||) tTT*i_ Lu |i ?@* }LL_ tu|t |i _L4it|U _ihi_ _i4@?_
uLh |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ ?@h_ hi_U?} |t 4TLh|t At t |i _ihi_
6 Orsh}
dqg Sdqdjduld lq ^47` irfxv rq shlfhphdo srolf| uhirup zlwk sxuh lqwhuphgldwh
lqsxwv dqg dujxh wkdw wkh vwdqgdug uhvwulfwlrqv qhhg qrw hyhu krog khuh1 Orsh} dqg Urguln
lq ^48` ghyhors dq lqwhuwhpsrudo prgho/ djdlq zlwk sxuh lqwhuphgldwh lqsxwv wr vkrz wkdw
wkh wudgh edodqfh pd| ghwhulrudwh zlwk lpsruw uhvwulfwlrqv rq lqsxwv dv wkhvh dfw olnh
vxsso| vkrfnv1
2
_i4@?_ igiU| LhiLihc @ hi_U|L? ? |i |@hg L? |i ?T| hi_Uit |t
ThUi @?_ tu|t L|@h_ |i _L4it|U tTT*) Lu |i ?@* }LL_ At hi_Uit
4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ At t @| i |ih4 |i ?T| ThUi igiU| W? dSo
i tL |@| *i |i |h@_i Uhi@|L? igiU| h@tit i*u@hic |i ?T| ThUi
@?_ _ihi_ _i4@?_ igiU|t hi_Ui | @?_ |ih igiU| U@? Thi_L4?@|i `|
- uh|ih _t|Lh|L?t @hti U @giU| |h@_i @?_ @hi |i uLUt Lu |t
T@Tih
5iUL?_c ? |i tLh| h?c h4t 4t| _iU_i L? ThL_U|L? uLh |ih L?
4@h!i| @?_ uLh i TLh| |L |i T@h|?ih ? |i 8 A 6Lh |t hi@tL?c h4 Mi@
Lh ? |i u@Ui Lu - ?ii_t |L Mi 4L_i**i_ Ai UL?t|h@?|t ?_ih U
h4t LTih@|i *4| @ UL?|h)<t @M*|) |L _ih| ThL_U|L? |L |t T@h|?ih ?
|i 8 A ì uLUt L? |i tLh| h? ihi U@T|@* t i_ M| U@? Mi ti_
|L ThL_Ui uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| Lh uLh i TLh| W? |i *L?} h? tTT*) t
??|i*) i*@t|U @?_ tL4i hit*|t ? |t U@ti @hi |L Mi uL?_ ? dbo
Ah_c i uLUt L? |i 4@h!i| @UUitt igiU|t h@|ih |@? |i i*u@hi iu
uiU|t At t MiU@ti @ *@h}i T@h| Lu |i _tUttL? Lu 8 A r @t Ui?|ihi_
L? L |i) @giU| |i 4@h!i| @UUitt Lu ?L? 4i4Mihtc @?_ MiU@ti U*i@?
i*u@hi hit*|t @hi @h_ |L UL4i M) ihi W? }i?ih@*c |h@_i Uhi@|?} igiU|t
h@ti i*u@hi *i ?T| ThUi @?_ _ihi_ _i4@?_ igiU|t hi_Ui i*u@hi @t
tL? ? dSo W? @__|L? |ihi @hi |@hg tu|?} igiU|t U U@? Mi ih)
*@h}i
Aihi @hi 4@?) @tTiU|t Lu 8 A r |@| i ?i}*iU| ? |t T@Tih Wttit Lu
) |i) 4}| Mi Uhi@|i_c TL*|U@* iUL?L4) UL?t_ih@|L?tc i|ih |i)
@hi t|iTT?} t|L?it |L }*LM@* ?|i}h@|L? Lh 4Ti_4i?|t |L |e c U !?_t
Lu 8 A r @hi }LL_ @?_ U !?_t M@_c @hi @** L|t_i |i tULTi Lu |t
T@Tih Ai hi@_ih t _hiU|i_ |L khi}ih<t Lh!c tii uLh i @4T*i do uLh @
|L}|u* _tUttL? Lu tU ttitc |L |i Lh! Lu @}@| @?_ @?@}@h)@c
tii uLh i @4T*i doc uLh @ M|?} Uh|Ut4 Lu 4U Lu |i Lh! ? |i @hi@c
@?_ |L |i Lh! Lu @}i** @?_ 5|@}ihc tii d2oc uLh tL4i u@tU?@|?} _i@t
L? _ii*LT?} h*it U i?thi |@| 8 A rc i? uLh4i_c _L ?L| hit*| ?
?i}@|i i |ih?@*|it uLh ?L? 4i4Miht
7 Xvlqj
d phgldq yrwhu prgho/ Sklols Ohy|/ vhh ^46`/ vkrzv wkdw lq d Khfnvfkhu0Rkolq
vhwwlqj d elodwhudo djuhhphqw fdqqrw vxssodqw pxowlodwhudo iuhh wudgh/ exw elodwhudolvlp fdq
xqghuplqh vxssruw iru ixwxuh pxowlodwhudo olehudol}dwlrq zkhq wkhuh duh ydulhw| ehqlwv
iurp wudgh1 Sudylq Nulvkqd/ vhh ^;`/ orrnv dw wkh vlplodu txhvwlrqv xvlqj d Frxuqrw prgho
ri roljrsro| wr orrn dw wkh hhfw rq up surwv1
2
Ai L_i*
ì @?| |L UL?t_ih |i igiU|t Lu @? 8 A Ai t4T*it| uh@4iLh! ?
U |t U@? Mi _L?i t @ |hii UL?|h) Lh*_ wi| |i |hii UL?|hit Mi
U@**i_ c c @?_ ì ** @tt4i |@| UL?|hit @?_ uLh4 @? 8 A c
i U*_?} U U@? Mi |L}| Lu @t |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ Aihi @hi |L
}LL_tc @ ?@* }LL_ % @?_ @? ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 5 ? @__|L? |L @ ?4ih@hi
UL?t4T|L? }LL_ hLh |L |i 8 A c |i T@||ih? Lu |h@_i t tU |@| @?_ ML| 4TLh| |i ?@* }LL_ uhL4 Ai ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ t @*tL
4TLh|i_ M) ML| @?_ u ULhtic |i ?4ih@hi }LL_ t i TLh|i_ M)
|i4 |L tL |@| |h@_i M@*@?Uit
L| @?_ @hi @tt4i_ |L Mi t4@** UL?|hit tL |@| |i) |@!i |i
Lh*_ ThUi @t }i? Ai Lh*_ ThUi uLh t _i?L|i_ M) R
% @?_ |i Lh*_
ThUi uLh 5 t _i?L|i_ M) R5 L| @?_ @i |@hgt L? % @?_ 5 Aiti
@hi @tt4i_ |L Mi tTiUU |@hgt Ai |@hgt L? % M) @?_ @hi _i?L|i_
M) |
% @?_ |% hitTiU|i*)c *i |Lti L? 5 @hi _i?L|i_ M) |5 c |5 Ai ThUi
Lu }LL_ ? UL?|h) c @| |4i | ' f E | ' f MiuLhi |i 8 A @?_ | ' @u|ih
| Rf c t }i? M) Rf ' R
n | c uLh ' c @?_ ' %c 5c @t ML| }LL_t @hi
4TLh|i_
ì? @?_ uLh4 @? 8 A c |ih |@hgt L? i@U L|iht ThL_U|t @hi
ti| @| 3ihLc *i |Lti L? 4TLh|t uhL4 |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ @hi ?U@?}i_
ì ** @tt4i |@| |i |@hg L? % ti| M) i Uii_t |@| ti| M) c |@| tc
|
% : |% #itT|i |tc |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ U@??L| @UUitt <t 4@h!i| @
t4T*i |h@?ttT4i?| uhL4 _i |L h*it Lu Lh}? U @i |L Mi 4i| |L
LM|@? Thiuihi?|@* |hi@|4i?| 6Lh |t hi@tL?c ThUit ? @?_ ?ii_ ?L|
Mi |i t@4i ii? @u|ih |i 8 A ì ** @*tL @tt4i |hL}L| |@| |i
|@hg L? 5 ti| M) t *itt |@? |@| ti| M) c |@| tc |
5 |5 ì ** @tt4i |@| |i - ? |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ ?_t|h) t tL
t|hU| |@| |h@?ttT4i?| t ?L| TLttM*i ? |t ?_t|h) W? igiU| i @tt4i
|@| TihuLh4?} |i LTih@|L?t L? 4TLh|t ?iUitt@h) |L UL?uih Lh}? @hi
ThLM|i*) i Ti?ti At @tt4T|L? i?thit |@| ThUit ? @?_ uLh |i 4TLh|i_ ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ @hi ?L| i^@*3i_ i? |ihi t @? 8 A

f
f
W|t ThUi @u|ih |i 8 A c _i?L|i_ M) R
5 @?_ R5 c i^@*t R5 @?_ R5 c
|i Thi 8 A ThUit uLh |i 4TLh|i_ ?T| Ai _L4it|U@**) 4@_i ?T|<t
ThUic _i?L|i_ M) R5 c t i^@*3i_ ? |i |L UL?|hit @u|ih |i 8 A c M| |
?ii_ ?L| i^@* |i ThUi Lu |i 4TLh|i_ ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| *|L} |i
4TLh|i_ @?_ ?|ih?@**) 4@_i ?T|t @hi T)tU@**) _i?|U@*c |i) @hi |hi@|i_
e
@t _gihi?| M) tiht At t MiU@ti |i - ? |i ?@* }LL_ hi^hit @
4?44 ULt| t@hi @ht?} |? |i 8 A W4TLh|i_ ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|t
U@??L| UL?|hM|i |L |t ULt| t@hi *i 8 A 4@_i ?T|t U@? ,i? u |i
ThUi Lu 8 A 4@_i ?T|t i Uii_t |@| Lu |i 4TLh|i_ ?T|tc |i) 4@)
t|** Mi ti_ ? Lh_ih |L 4ii| |i -
`@| @ML| |i ThUi Lu |i ?@* }LL_ @u|ih |i 8 A q 6?@* }LL_t U@?
UL4i uhL4 _hiU|*) Lh uhL4 @? 8 A 4i4Mih u |i - @hi 4i| W| t
?L| TLttM*i uLh |i ThUi Lu |i ?@* }LL_ |L hti @u|ih |i 8 A _i |L |i
TLttM*|) Lu 4TLh|?} _hiU|*) uhL4 Ai ThUi ? c U @t |i }ih
|@hg L? |i ?@* }LL_c U@? u@** _i |L |i 8 A Aihi ** Mi ?L ?Ui?|i
uLh h4t ? UL?|h) |L i TLh| |L UL?|h) D OLiihc h4t ? UL?|h) 4@) t |L i TLh| |L t @t }ih ThUit |@? c | 4@) T@) uLh |L i TLh| |L ii? u |ihi @hi @__|L?@* ULt|t ? 4ii|?} |i - 5?Ui
L?*) h4t ? i TLh| |L |i ThUi Lu % ? t|@)t ?U@?}i_ @?_ |i
ThUi ? U@? u@**c @| 4Lt| |L |@| ? @u|ih |i 8 A S
W? @| uL**Lt i ** i @4?i |i ThLM*i4 ? |i tLh| h? ihi |ihi
t ?L ?it|4i?|c M| ihi h4t U@? ti |ih i t|?} U@T|@* @t |i) t. W? 5iU|L? i UL?t_ih |i ThLM*i4 u@U?} h4t uLh @ }i? *ii* Lu ThUit
ì tL |@| *i @ h4 ? UL*_ ThL_Ui uLh |t L? 4@h!i| @?_ uLh
i TLh| |L c i@U h4 ** ULLti |L tTiU@*3i ? L?i @U||) Lh |i L|ih
At t |ih4i_ |i tTiU@*3@|L? hit*| 6L**L?} |@|c ? 5iU|L? ec i **
UL?t_ih |i _i|ih4?@|L? Lu |i ThUi Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| 4@_i ? |i
8 A @?_ |i @**LU@|L? Lu h4t ? @4L?} |i |L @U||it Ai 4Lhi
|i h4t ? L ULLti |L i TLh| |L c |i }hi@|ih |i _i4@?_ uLh |i
8 A 4@_i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| t?Ui |iti @hi |i L?*) L?it L _i4@?_ | u
|t ThUi i Uii_t |@| Lu |i 4TLh|i_ ?T| Ai }hi@|ih |i _i4@?_ uLh |i
8 A ?T|c |i }ih t |t ThUic R5 c @?_ i?Ui |i *Lih t |i ThL| Lu |i
h4t t?} | ? Lh_ih |L i TLh| |L uhii Lu |@hgt ì ** tL |@| h4t
** Mi @**LU@|i_ |L i@U @U||) tL @t |L i?thi |@| |i i^*Mh4 ThUi Lu
|i 8 A 4@_i ?T| t tU |@| ThL|t @hi i^@*3i_ ? |i |L @U||it
At hit*|t ? tL4i ?t@* UL4T@h@|i t|@|Ut hit*|t U i i T*Lhi ?
8 Ilupv
lq frxqwu| D zrxog zdqw wr h{sruw wr E rqo| li wkh sulfh lq E h{fhhghg wkdw
lq D1 Wkxv/ li D h{sruwhg wr E> lw zrxog kdyh wr eh wkh fdvh wkdw D*v sulfh zdv ehorz
3
sE
{ > wkh xsshu olplw iru wkh sulfh lq E1 Exw dw vxfk d sulfh/ F zloo qrw zlvk wr h{sruw wr
D dqg qru zloo E= Exw dw vxfk d sulfh/ D zloo zlvk wr lpsruw {1 Wkxv wklv lv qrw ihdvleoh1
9 Lq rwkhu zrugv/ sD3 sD4 sE4 @ sE3 1
{
{
{
{
: D vlpsoh prgho ri wkh orqj uxq lv rxwolqhg lq ^<`1
D
*@|ih tiU|L?t ì |i? tL |@| |i ThUi Lu |i ?@* }LL_ ? c @u|ih |i

8 A U t _i?L|i_ M) R
% 4t| *i i@!*) Mi*L |t Thi 8 A ThUi Wu
L?|h) t *@h}i i?L} |L tTT*) @** |i _i4@?_ ? UL?|h) c |i? |t
?i^@*|) t t|hU|c *i u t t4@**c R
% t ?U@?}i_ M) |i 8 A W? 5iU|L? D i UL?t_ih |i 4T*U@|L?t Lu Lh @?@*)tt uLh 4@h!i| @UUitt
ì tL |@| @? 8 A | t|hU| - L? |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ h@tit
4TLh|t @?_ i?Ui 4ThLit 4@h!i| @UUitt ? |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i|c M|
hi_Uit 4TLh|t @?_ i?Ui @h4t 4@h!i| @UUitt ? |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_
4@h!i| W? 5iU|L? S i *LL! @| |i igiU| Lu 4Lhi hit|hU|i - ? |i ?@*
}LL_ 4@h!i| @tt4?} |@| L?|h) t t4@** tL |@| R
% t ?U@?}i_ M)
|i 8 A UL?tiî?Ui Lu Lh tTiU@*3@|L? hit*| t |@| 4Lhi hit|hU|i
- L? |i ?@* }LL_ ht| h@ti @?_ |i? *Lih 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_c M|
ht| *Lih |i? h@ti 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ Aih |h??} TL?| t
UL44L? tL |@| 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ @hi 4@ 43i_ @?_ 4TLh|t Lu |i
?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ @hi 4?43i_ @| @ UL44L? *ii* Lu hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i
h*it Lu Lh}? W? 5iU|L? .c i Lgih tL4i UL?U*_?} hi4@h!t @?_ @*|ih?@|i
?|ihThi|@|L?t Lu Lh 4L_i* ì tL |@| Lh 4L_i* U@? Mi hi?|ihThi|i_
|L tL |@| 4Lhi hit|hU|i - L? |i ?@* }LL_ ht| 4ThLit @?_
|i? @h4t |i uLh|?it Lu *@MLhc @?_ |L U@t| *}| L? @ T@h|U*@h TL*U) |L
4ThLi 4@h!i| @UUitt
Ai 6h4<t hLM*i4
wi| 8 E5c & _i?L|i |i UL?t|@?| hi|h?t |L tU@*i E-7 ThL_U|L? u?U|L?
uLh |i ?@* }LL_ ? UL?|h) c ' c c ihi & _i?L|it |i U@T|@* ti_c
@?_ 5 |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| ti_ M) |i h4 W? |i tLh| h?c Mi?}
UL?t_ihi_ ihic & t }i? tL i tTThitt |t ?L|@|L? ? |i ThL_U|L?
u?U|L? uhL4 ihi L? t h4t ? _L ?L| t |L i TLh| |L c |i) _L ?L|
U@hi @ML| |i tLhUi Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| Aih ThL_U|L? ThLM*i4
UL?tt|t Lu t?} |i Ui@Tit| tLhUi uLh |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| @?_ i^@|i
|i 4@h}?@* @*i ThL_U| Lu |i ?T| |L |t ThUi Ai tTT*) Lu @ |)TU@*

h4 ? @u|ih |i 8 A t |t Mi _i?L|i_ M) % ER
% c R5 W| tc @t t@*c

TLt|i*) hi*@|i_ |L R
% @?_ ?i}@|i*) hi*@|i_ |L R5 6h4t ? @i @ 4Lhi UL4T*U@|i_ ThLM*i4 Ai) U@? ThL_Ui uLh
i TLh| |L @?_%Lh uLh _L4it|U UL?t4T|L? OLiihc |ih i TLh|t 4t|
Mi ThL_Ui_ tL @t |L UL4T*) | |i - ? Lh_ih |L Mi uhii Lu |@hgt `i
S
** @tt4i |@| |i - hi^hit |@| @ uh@U|L?c kc Lu |i ULt| t@hic 4t|
UL4i uhL4 _L4it|U ?T|t At t@hi t i@t) |L _i?i u |i h4 ThL_Uit
L?*) uLh `i? | ThL_Uit uLh @?_ uLh |i t@hi t _i?i_ @t |i
t@hi ? @__|L?@* ULt|t ?Uhhi_ @t L|*?i_ Mi*L
#i?L|i M) 5 |i *ii* Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| ti_ uhL4 ELh |i
8 A ? Lh_ih |L ThL_Ui |i }LL_t uLh i TLh| |L Lhi }i?ih@**)c 5
_i?L|it |i *ii* Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| ti_ uhL4 |L ThL_Ui L|T| uLh
@?_ % _i?L|it |i L|T| Lu @ h4 ? ThL_U?} uLh Wu @ h4 ? ThL_Uit L?*) uLh c | L*_ ThL_Ui L|T| _i?L|i_ M) %
U L*_
i^@* 8 E5 n 5 Wu L? |i L|ih @?_ | @t ThL_U?} uLh @*L?i |t
ThL_U|L? L*_ Mi _i?L|i_ M) %
U L*_ i^@* 8 E5 n 5 h4 ? U ThL_Uit uLh ML| @?_ ThL_Uit % ' %
n % c
ihiG
% ' 8 E5 n 5 n 5 n 5 c
%
' 8 E5 n 5 c
%
' 8 E5 n 5 n 5 n 5 8 E5 n 5 Wu |i - @t |L Mi 4i| L? i TLh|t |L c |i - t _i?i_ @t G
R5 5 n &
k
R5 5 n R
5 5 n &
E
L|i |@| _L4it|U U@T|@* ULt|tc &c @hi UL?|i_ |L@h_t 4ii|?} |i -
uLh @ h4 uhL4 c M| |i ULt|t Lu 4TLh|i_ ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|t @hi ?L|
Atc |i h4<t ThLM*i4 t |L ULLti 5 c 5 c 5 c 5 |L 4@ 43iG
R
% % n R% % iR5 E5 n 5 n R5 E5 n 5 j &
tMiU| |LG
R5 5 n &
k
R5 5 n R
5 5 n &
E2
E
W| t Lh| ?L|?} |@| |i UL?t|h@?| t M?_?} u |i ThUi Lu |i 4TLh|i_

f
?|ih4i_@|i ?T| ER
5 ' R5 }i? Lh @tt4T|L?t t *itt |@? |i ThUi
Lu |i ?|ih?@**) 4@_i ?T|c ER5 c tL |@| |i h4 t uLhUi_ |L M) |i }ih
ULt| ?T| |L 4ii| |i - W? |t U@ti |i h4 ** ULLti |L 4ii| |i

- i @U|*) Wu R
5 : R5 |i? h4t ? ** Mi @TT) |L L?*) ti |i
.
_L4it|U ?T| | u |t t |i U@tic |i? E t @|L4@|U@**) 4i| uLh @**
@*it Lu k

5?Ui R5 U@??L| Mi *itt |@? |i 4?44 Lu R
5 @?_ R5 E@t i @tt4i
|@| ThLh |L |i 8 A ML| UL?|hit 4TLh| ML| 5 @?_ % | uL**Lt |@|

R
5 : R5 U@? L?*) @TTi? u R5 R5 W? @__|L?c | 4t| @*tL Mi |i U@ti
|@| ii? u @** h4t ? ti L?*) |i _L4it|U ?T|c |t ThUi t *itt |@?

|i? | 4t| Mi |@| R5, ER
% R5 L|i |@| |t LUUht u ? t t4@**
i?L} W? |t ii?|c @?) *ii* Lu |i - t @|L4@|U@**) 4i| @?_ h@t?}
|i - @t ?L igiU| Oihi ?L uh|ih @?@*)tt t ?ii_i_ 6Lh |t hi@tL?
i @tt4i uhL4 ihi L? |@| |i *ii* Lu R5 |@| tL*it Ee t i@!*) 4Lhi

|@? R
5 Oi?Uic |i - t 4i| i @U|*)c @?_ i U@? tMt|||i uLh 5 uhL4 E
@MLi E }itG
R E k
E k
5 ' 5 5 n
&

kR5
kR
5
ED

R E k n kR
5 5 n E k &c
5 ' 5 n 5 ' E 5

kR
kR
5
5
ES
tL |@| |i ?T|t ti_ ? 4@!?} %
c |i L|T| uLh UL?|h) M) @ h4
uhL4 c @hiG
@?_ |i @*i Lu |iti ?T|t tG
E k
T ' R
&
5 5 n R5 5 ' R5 E k 5 n
k
6?@**)c 5 ? |ih4t Lu 5 uhL4 ES tG
5 '

kR
E k
5
5
&

kR5 n E kR5
kR5 n E kR5
tL |@|G
H
E.
EH
T '

R5 R
E kER5 R
5
5 &
5

R5 E k n kR
R5 E k n kR
5
5
Eb

#i?L|i |i UL?i UL4M?@|L? kR
5 n E kR5 M) R75 L|i |@| |i
4@ 43@|L? ThLM*i4 u@U?} |i h4 @t Mii? UL?ih|i_ |L @ uLh4 ihi
L?*) 5 c 5 c @?_ 5 hi4@? |L Mi ULti? OLiihc |ihi t ?L hi@tL? uLh
|i h4 |L @?| |L ti }ih ThUi_ ?T|t ? 4@!?} }LL_t uLh |i 4@h!i| tL |@| 5 ' f Ai h4 U@? Mi |L}| Lu @t 4@ 43?} |t ThL|tc
E5 c 5 c ihiG

8 E5 E5 c 5 ' R
Ef
% +i8 E5 n 5 8 E5 j n R% ,

R R
E kER5 R5 5 5 5 & R
5 &
5
R75
R75

n R 8 E5 ' R
% i8 E5 n 5 8 %E5 j
%

&
R5 R
R
5 5 R 5 5
&
5 R75
R75

W| t tiu* |L |?! Lu ' R5 R7R55 @t |i ULt|c }i? |i -c Lu @?
@__|L?@* ?| Lu ?T| ti_ |L ThL_Ui uLh |i 4@h!i| L|i |@| @t

i TiU|i_c u k ' fc |i? ' R
5 c *i u k ' c |i? ' R5 wi44@

? |i @TTi?_ tLt |@| E t ?Uhi@t?} ? k @?_ R5 W? @__|L?c

qE ' RR755 U@? Mi |L}| Lu @t |i t@_L ThUi Lu &H W| htit @t R5
u@**t @?_ Lh @t k htit @t tL? ? wi44@ 2
`i ** tL |@| u @ h4 ? ThL_Uit uLh i TLh| |L |i? | **
?L| ThL_Ui uLh |i L4i 4@h!i| @?_ Ui iht@ W? L|ih Lh_tc |@| h4t
tTiU@*3i ? ThL_U?} uLh L?i Lh |i L|ih 4@h!i|

hLTLt|L? 6h4t ? UL?|h) tTiU@*3i Ai) i|ih ThL_Ui uLh |ih
_L4it|U 4@h!i| Lh uLh i TLh|t |? |i 8 A 6h4t ? UL?|h) L?*)
ThL_Ui uLh |ih _L4it|U 4@h!i|
Ai ThLLu UL?tt|t Lu tL?} |@| @? ?|ihLh 4@ 44 uLh |i ULUi Lu
5 @?_ 5 U@??L| i t| Wu @? ?|ihLh 4@ 44 i t|t |i? |i ht| Lh_ih
UL?_|L?t | hitTiU| |L 5 @?_ 5 @i |L Mi 4i| Aiti @hi }i? M)G
; Udlvlqj n pdnhv wkh frqvwudlqw orrvhu vr wkdw wkh vkdgrz sulfh lv ehorz wkh qrplqdo
sulfh1
b
Y
E5 c 5 ' R
% 8 E5 n 5 ' f
Y5
E
@?_
Y
E5 c 5 ' R
% 8 E5 n 5 Y5

R
5 ER% R% 8 E5 ' f
E2
Ai ht| UL?_|L? i^@|it |i 4@h}?@* @*i ThL_U| Lu @? @__|L?@*
?| Lu 5 | |t 4@h}?@* ULt| Ai tiUL?_ i^@|it |i 4@h}?@* @*i

ThL_U| Lu @ ?| Lu 5 | |t |hi 4@h}?@* ULt| U i^@*t R
5 n ER%

R
% 8 E5 : R5 6}hi _iTU|t R
% 8 E5 M) |i _L?@h_ t*LT?} *?i Ai ?|ih
tiU|L? Lu | |i Lh3L?|@* *?i _iTU|?} c *@Mi**i_ ((c _i?it @
U@?__@|i @*i uLh 5 n 5 Lh |L|@* ?T| ti At t _iTU|i_ M) |i _t

|@?Ui Ai Uhi _iTU|t R
5 n ER% R% 8 E5 t _L?@h_

t*LT?} W| t @||ih |@? |i Uhi E@t R
% : R% R% f @?_ t

tu|i_ T hi*@|i |L ER% R% 8 E5 M) |i @4L?| R5 ?|ihtiU|t
(( @| M tL |@| . }it |i U@?__@|i *ii* Lu 5 ULti? L|i |@| @|
.c 4t| Mi @MLi @t _h@? @tt4?} |@| 5 @?_ 5 @hi ?L? 3ihLb
OLiihc |iti *ii*t uLh |L|@* ?T| ti @?_ |t @**LU@|L? _L ?L| _i?i
@ ThL| 4@ 44c M| @ ThL| 4?44-f +@t?} Lh *Lih?} 5 *i
!iiT?} |L|@* ?T| ti UL?t|@?| h@tit ThL|t @t tL? ? wi44@ 6Lh
|t hi@tL?c h4t ** ULLti |L tTiU@*3i ? ThL_U?} uLh i TLh| |L @?_
< H lv wr wkh ohiw ri E dv } F ? } F . } = Dv DD lv grzqzdug vorslqj dqg vwhhshu wkdq
E
E D
FF dqg dv lwv lqwhuvhfwlrq zlwk GG olhv wr wkh uljkw ri wkdw ri FF zlwk GG dw H/ DD
pxvw olh deryh FF dw H=
43 Lqwxlwlyho|/ rqh fdq wklqn ri +44,> +45, uhhfwlqj wkh delolw| ri wkh up wr vhoo lwv
4
F dw sulfhv ! dqg
lwv wzr shuihfwo| vxevwlwxwdeoh lqsxwv }D dqg }E
rxwsxw dw sD
{ / dqg ex|
3
E
4
D
4
E
4
E
F
s} . +s{ s{ ,I +}E , uhvshfwlyho|1 Krzhyhu/ qrwh wkdw zkloh wkh pdujlqdo frvw ri }D
F lv glplqlvklqj1 Iru lqsxw xvh htxdo wr }hur/ wkh pdujlqdo frvw ri
lv frqvwdqw/ wkdw ri }E
F
}E olhv deryh ! zkloh iru odujh hqrxjk lqsxw xvh lw olhv ehorz != Wkxv/ +44,> +45, ghvfuleh
d orfdo plqlpxp dqg qrw d pd{lpxp dqg wkh rswlpl}lqj vroxwlrq pxvw olh dw d fruqhu$
f
ti ?T| *ii* c Lh ? ThL_U?} uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| @?_ ULLti ?T|
*ii* f
OL ** h4t _iU_i U LT|L? |L ULLtiq 6h4t ULLti |i 4Lhi
ThL|@M*i LT|L? Wu tL4i h4t ULLti i@U LT|L?c |i? ML| LT|L?t 4t|
Mi i^@**) ThL|@M*i @?_ |i @**LU@|L? Lu h4t t _i|ih4?i_ tL @t |L i?thi
|t 6h4t L ThL_Ui uLh i TLh| |L @i ThL|t _i?L|i_ M) E5 ihi 5 _i?L|it |i |L|@* ?T| *ii* ti_ Ai) ** ULLti |ih |L|@*
?T| *ii* ti_ @UULh_?} |LG
Y
E5 ' R 8 E5 ' f
%
Y5
E
Y
E5 ' R 8 E5 R ' f
%
5
Y5 Ee

|@| tc @| 5 ' ? 6}hi L|i |@| |t ULUi Lu 5 _iTi?_t L? R
%

@?_ c M| @t ER5 c kc R5 |ti*u htit | R5 @?_ kc @?_ @t R5 t }i?c i

** _i?L|i |t _iTi?_i?Ui M) 5 E R
% c ER5 c kc R5 5 E R% c R5 c k @t

i tTThitt R
5 ? Lh ?L|@|L? 5 E R% c R5 c k htit | ?Uhi@tit ? R% c

@?_ | _iUhi@tit ? R5 @?_ k @t tL? ? wi44@ S
u ULhtic t?Ui L|T| htit | ?Uhi@tit ? ?T| tic |i L|T| Lu

i@U Lu |iti h4tc _i?L|i_ M) %
ER% c R5 c kc @*tL htit | ?Uhi@tit ? R%

@hi ?Uhi@t?} ? |i L|T| ThUi ER
% @?_ _iUhi@t?} ? |i ThUi Lu |i
8 A 4@_i ?T|c ER5 @?_ k 6h4t L ThL_Ui uLh L?*) ULLti |ih |L|@* ?T| *ii*c @** Lu U
t 4TLh|i_ uhL4 c @UULh_?} |LG

Aih ULUi Lu ?T| ti t _i?L|i_ M) 5 E R
% c R5 _iTU|i_ ? 6}hi

M) |i TL?| f L|i |@| @t ML| R% @?_ R5 @hi i L}i?Lt*) }i?c tL

t 5 E R
7
% c R5 ' 57 @?_ |i L|T| Lu i@U tU h4c _i?L|i_ M) %
c @t
7 At ** T*@) @ Ui?|h@* T@h|
i** @t |ih ThL|t U @hi UL?t|@?| @| ? @| uL**Lt `i t44@h3i |i @MLi hit*|t @tG
hLTLt|L? 2 6h4t ? L ThL_Ui uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| @i @ i_
7 c *i h4t L i TLh| |L @i ThL|tc E R c R c kc
*ii* Lu ThL|tc %
5

ER c R c kc @** Lu U @hi ?Uhi@t?}
?T| ti 5 ER
c
R
c
kc
@?_
L|T|
%
%
5
%
5

? |i ThUi Lu L|T| ? ER
% @?_ _iUhi@t?} ? |i ThUi Lu |i 8 A 4@_i
?T| ER5 @?_ k
e
,^*Mh4 L?_|L?t
wi| |i ?4Mih Lu h4t ? L tTiU@*3i ? ThL_U?} uLh Mi _i?L|i_
M) ?
@?_ |i ?4Mih L tTiU@*3i ? ThL_U?} uLh Mi _i?L|i_ M) ? OL @hi |iti ?4Miht _i|ih4?i_q Ai @?tih t U*i@h Ai ?4Mih Lu
h4t Lu i@U |)Ti ** Mi tU |@| |i ThL|t Lu ML| |)Tit Lu h4t @hi
i^@*3i_ Wu |i ThL|t Lu L?i |)Ti i Uii_t |@| Lu @?L|ihc |i? L?*) |i
|)Ti | |i }ih ThL|t ** Mi @M*i `i |@!i @t }i?c uLh |i |4i

Mi?}c |i *ii* Lu R
% `@| t |i i^*Mh4 ThUi Lu |i 8 A 4@_i ?T|q At i^*Mh4
ThUi t _i?L|i_ M) R5 `i ** @h}i |@| | t i|ih |i ThUi |@| i^@|it
_i4@?_ @?_ tTT*) @tt4?} |@| @** h4t ? i TLh| |L c _i?L|i_ M) R5 , c
Lh |i ThUi |@| 4@!it h4t ? ?_gihi?| Mi|ii? i TLh|?} |L @?_
ThL_U?} uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i|c _i?L|i_ M) R5 `i ht| _i?i |i ThUi Lu |i 8 A 4@_i ?T| @| U |i ThL|t Lu
|i |L LT|L?t @hi i^@*3i_ 6Lh |t ?T| ThUic i _i|ih4?i |i ?4Mih
Lu h4t ? L 4t| ThL_Ui uLh i TLh| |L uLh tTT*) |L i^@* _i4@?_
? |t ?T| 4@h!i| +iU@** |@| |i ThL|t Lu h4t ? i TLh|?} |L u@**
@t |i ThUi Lu |i 8 A 4@_i ?T|c ER5 c htit wi| R5 _i?L|i |i ThUi @|
U h4t @hi ?_gihi?| Mi|ii? |i |L LT|L?tc |@| tc R5 t 4T*U|*)
_i?i_ M)G
W

R5 c k5 E n E
R5 c k& &
ER% c R5 c k ' R% 8 E5 ER% c R5 c k E
7
' ED

kER5 R5
ihi ER5 c k ' EE
At UL?_|L? @?_ R5 @hi _iTU|i_ ?
R5 E knkR
5

6}hi 2 `i tTThitt |i _iTi?_i?Ui L? R
5 uLh i@ti Lu ?L|@|L? uhL4 ihi

L? tL |@| R5 ER
% c k t |t ?_gihi?Ui ThUi R5 ER% c k htit @t R% htit Lh
k u@**t @t tL? ? wi44@ E. 3
3
3
44 Qrwh
wkdw #+
s4} > , lv lqfuhdvlqj lq lwv uvw dujxphqw dqg ghfuhdvlqj lq lwv vhfrqg dv
vkrzq lq Ohppd 71
2
| R5 Ec |i _i4@?_ uLh ?T|t uhL4 |i 8 A M) i@U Lu |i h4t tTi
U@*3?} ? ti**?} |L c ? |ih4t Lu |i _i4@?_ uLh @** ?T|t ti_ M) tU
h4tc t }i? M) EH Ai i^*Mh4 ?4Mih Lu h4t ULLt?} |L i TLh|
|L c ?
c t tU |@| |i |L|@* _i4@?_ uLh ?T|t uhL4 |i 8 A i^@*t |i
|L|@* tTT*) Lu ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|t uhL4 |i 8 A A@| tG

R 5 ER
% c R5 c k? ' 7 E
5
ES
At t _iTU|i_ ? 6}hi L|i |@| |t _i4@?_ u?U|L? t _L?@h_
Y5 ER
% c R5 ck f @t tL? ? wi44@ H
t*LT?} @t YR

R c tL |@| R u@**t
ULh?ih tL*|L? ** i t| u 5 ER
% c R5 c k? 7 E
5
5

Mi*L R5 @t _iTU|i_ ? 6}hi c @?_ @** h4t ULLti |L ti** |L c ?L?i
ThL_Ui uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| Ai i^*Mh4 *ii* Lu R5 ? |t U@ti t
4T*U|*) }i? M) R5 , R5 c tU |@|2 G
,
,
5 ER
% c R5 c k? ' 7 ER5 E.
,
W| tL*_ Mi U*i@h uhL4 6}hi |@| u ? t t4@** i?L} E tL |@| 5 ER
% c R5 c k?
t }i? M) |i? |i i^*Mh4 ThUi ** Mi R5, @?_ _i?i_ M) E.
,
*i u ? t *@h}i i?L} EtL |@| 5 ER
% c R5 c k ? t }i? M) |i?

|i i^*Mh4 ThUi ** Mi R5 @t _i?i_ M) ES
,

t tL? ? wi44@ EH 5 ER
% c R5 c k t ?Uhi@t?} ? R% @?_ k E?_ih

Lh @tt4T|L?t @t i** @t Mi?} _L?@h_ t*LT?} Oi?Ui R5 , E R
% c k t

?Uhi@t?} ? R
% @?_ k 6Lh ih) *L @*it Lu kc Mi*L kf c |i UL?t|h@?|
4TLti_ M) |i - t ?L| M?_?} @?_ ULt|t Lu ThL_U|L? @hi ?@giU|i_
M) k ,i? ? |i ii?|@*|) |@| @** h4t ? i TLh| |L c _i4@?_ uLh
|i _L4it|U ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| t *L i?L} |@| |t ThUi _Lit ?L| i Uii_
|@| Lu |i 4TLh|i_ ?T| W? |t hi}L? ULt| t ?@giU|i_ M) k t *L?} @t

R5, ER
% c k ' R5 ER% c k EH

Ai?c uLh k Mi|ii? k @?_ c R5 E ' R5 ER
% c k @?_ tL4i h4t ? ThL_Ui
uLh *i L|iht ThL_Ui uLh t |i ?T|t @hi TihuiU| tMt|||itc |ihi
45 Qrwh wkdw s4o fdqqrw h{fhhg s
E +sD4> s4 > ,qE A V DE +s4 ,/ wkhq wkh htxl0
4} = Li dw s4} / }D
}
{ }
}
oleulxp sulfh h{fhhgv s4} dqg doo upv suhihu wr surgxfh iru wkh grphvwlf pdunhw vr wkdw
qD
E @ 3> zklfk frqwudglfwv wkh deryh dqg vr fdqqrw eh1
W

** @*@)t Mi tL4i h4t ? L t |L ti** |L Wu |ihi ihi ?L|c |i?
|i ThUi Lu |i 8 A ?T| L*_ i^@* |@| Lu |i 4TLh|i_ L?i @?_ ThL|t
L*_ Mi }ih uhL4 i TLh|?} |L |@? ti**?} ? |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| hLTLt|L? wi| |i i^*Mh4 ThUi uLh |i 8 A 4@_i ?T| Mi _i?L|i_
f
M) R5 E Wu k t Mi*L kf | i^@*t R
5 Wu k t Mi|ii? kf @?_ k c ihi k t

_i?i_ M) EH c R5 E i^@*t R5 E R% c k U t ?Uhi@t?} ? kc @t tL?

? wi44@ H @?_ uLh k @MLi k | i^@*t R5 E R
% c k U t _iUhi@t?} ?
k @t tL? ? wi44@
W
W

At *i@it |i ThUi R
% |L Mi _i|ih4?i_ Oihi |ihi @hi |L TLtt
M*|it Wu t *@h}i @?_ t t4@** |i? i TLh|iht uhL4 ** Mi @M*i |L
ThL_Ui i?L} *i UL4T*)?} | |i - |L i?thi |@| _Lit ?L|

f
4TLh| uhL4 _hiU|*)c M| L?*) uhL4 W? |t U@ti R
% R% `i ** U@**
|t |i *@h}i U@ti W? |t U@ti |i tTT*) u?U|L? uhL4 h4t ? i TLh|?} ? @?_ uhL4 h4t ? |i4ti*it ?|ihtiU|t |i _i4@?_ u?U|L?
f
( ER
% Lu UL?|h) @| @ ThUi . U *it Mi*L R% @t tL? ? 6}hi
e
OLiihc u t *@h}i @?_ t t4@** |i? i TLh|iht uhL4 ** ?L| Mi
@M*i |L ThL_Ui i?L} *i UL4T*)?} | |i - |L 4ii| @** Lu <t
f
_i4@?_ @| R
% tL |@| @*tL 4TLh|t uhL4 _hiU|*) At t U@**i_ |i
t4@** U@ti @?_ t _iTU|i_ M) |i tTT*) u?U|L? uhL4 h4t ? @?_
|Lti ? i TLh|?} |L Mi?} }i? M) KK W? 6}hi ec 4TLh|t (

f
uhL4 _hiU|*) W? |t U@ti R
% ' R%
f
hLTLt|L? e Wu t *@h}i hi*@|i |L c |i? R
% R% Wu t t4@**

f
hi*@|i |L |i? R
% ' R% D
@h!i| UUitt ,giU|t Lu @? 6A
U Lu |i UL?Uih? ? |i TLT*@h Thitt hi}@h_?} Thiuihi?|@* |h@_?}
@hh@?}i4i?|t @t @_ |L _L | |i 4T*U@|L?t Lu tU @hh@?}i4i?|t L?
4@h!i| @UUitt `** @hh@?}i4i?|t *!i 8 A *i@_ |L @ hi_U|L? ? |h@_i
Lu |i @hi@ | |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ Lh ** | i?@?Ui |q Oihi i @i
|hii UL44i?|t |L Lgih
46 Qrwh wkdw wkh sulfh ri wkh grphvwlf lqsxw pxvw h{fhhg wkdw ri wkh lpsruwhg rq lq wklv
fdvh dv wkh| duh shuihfw vxevwlwxwhv dqg wkh URR lqfoxghv fdslwdo frvwv1
e
6ht|c ? |i @Mti?Ui Lu -c |ihi @hi *@h}i U@?}it ? |h@_i Lt _i
|L |i 8 A @t |h@_i tii!t |i *Lit| |@hg UL?|h) UL?tiî?Ui Lu |t
t |@| |i *Lih |@hg UL?|h)c U @||h@U|t |i |h@_i Lc @*tL }i|t |i
|@hg hii?i At }@? ? |@hg hii?i t @? 4TLh|@?| _t|hM|L?@*
UL?t_ih@|L? W| U@? @*tL Uhi@|i ?Ui?|it U@t?} @ h@Ui |L |i ML||L4 ?
|@hgt @t i@U UL?|h) |hit |L @TThLTh@|i |i |@hg hii?it 5ii +U@h_tL?
? d.o L? |t Rh@Ui |L |i ML||L4 ì _L ?L| UL?t_ih L |@hgt @hi ti|
? |t T@Tih M| |@!i |i4 @t }i?
`| - ? T*@Ui |t !?_ Lu |h@?ttT4i?| t Thii?|i_ OLiihc
_L4it|U ThL_U|L?c u | 4ii|t |i - U@? Mi i TLh|i_ |L |i T@h|?ih
UL?|h) ? |i 8 A At Tih4|t tL4i |h@?ttT4i?| ? igiU|i |ih4t
@?_ Uhi@|it tL4i Lu |i |@hg hii?i _t|hM|L? igiU|t Lu @? 8 A |
- W? |i tLh| h?c |t t *4|i_ M) |i i |i?| Lu _L4it|U ThL_U|L?c
M| ? |i *L?} h?c ?it|4i?| Lt hi*@ |t UL?t|h@?| UL?tiî?Ui Lu
|t t |@| @? 8 A | - ?_Uit U@T|@* Ltc *i L?i |L| -
?_Uit U@?}it ? |h@_i Lt h@|ih |@? ? ?it|4i?| Lt kht?@ @?_
khi}ih ? dbo _i@* | @ *L?} h? 4L_i* Lu @? 8 A | -
Ai uLh4 @?_ *ii* Lu - t *!i*) |L 4@||ih ? |iti UL?t_ih@|L?t ì
@tt4i uLh |i 4Lt| T@h| ? |t T@Tih |@| - @hi 4TLttM*i |L 4ii| ?
|i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i| @?_ uLUt L? U@?}it ? |i hit|hU|i?itt Lu
- ? |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i| W? dSo i *LL! @| |i L|ih i |hi4it Lu 8 A r
|L| - |ih UL4M?@|L?t *!i 8 A r | - M| ihi |i
- ? |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i| @hi i@t) |L 4ii| @hi i@t) |L @?@*)3i
? Lh uh@4iLh!e 5iUL?_c igiU|t ? ML| ?@* @?_ ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i| ?ii_ |L Mi
UL?t_ihi_ @t |i) U@? Lh! ? LTTLt|i _hiU|L?t ì tL Mi*Lc uLh
i @4T*ic |@| 4@h!i| @UUitt Lu |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ t 4ThLi_ ? |i ?@*
}LL_ 4@h!i|c M| hi_Ui_ ? |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i|
6?@**)c | t 4TLh|@?| |L *LL! @| |i igiU| L? |i 8 A @t @ L*ic @t
_L?i ihic @t i** @t L? i@U 4i4Mih At t MiU@ti ? hitTL?ti |L U@?}it
? Lt ? L?i 4i4Mih UL?|h)c UL4Ti?t@|?} Lt LUUh ? L|ih 4i4Mih
UL?|hitD
47 Lq
wklv fdvh/ wkh sulfh ri wkh lpsruwhg lqsxw lv wkh vdph lq wkh wzr frxqwulhv dqg
lpsruwv ri wkh lqwhuphgldwh jrrg hqwhu wkurxjk wkh orzhu wdul frxqwu|1 Wkh I W D fdq
uhgxfh wkh lpsruwhg lqsxw*v sulfh lq wklv fdvh vr wkdw wkhuh lv dq _lqsxw sulfh hhfw% dv
glvfxvvhg ehorz1
48 Iru h{dpsoh/ li D lpsruwv iurp E gxh wr wkh IWD dv deryh/ wkhq E pxvw lpsruw pruh
D
D
Ai ,giU| L? W4TLh|t Lu @? 6A
wi| t ht| UL?t_ih |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i| W4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ MiuLhi
|i 8 A t |i i Uitt _i4@?_ uLh % M) @?_ @| Thi 8 A ThUitG
f
f
f f f f U 8 f ' ( ER
% n ( ER% % ER% c R5 ? % ER% c R5 ?
ihi ? _i?L|it |i ?4Mih Lu ?@* }LL_ ThL_Uiht ? @?_ % E _i?L|it
i@U L?it tTT*) Lu |i ?@* }LL_
Ai 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ @u|ih |i 8 A t |i i Uitt _i4@?_ uLh %
M) @?_ @| TLt| 8 A ThUit W| t _i?i_ M)G

U 8 ' ( ER
% n( ER% % ER% c R5 ? % ER% c E? % ER% c R5 ? AtG
U8 U8f '
q
r
q
r

f
( ER
% ( ER% n ( ER% ( ER% q
r

f f
% ER
% c R5 % ER% c R5 ?
q
r

f f
%
ER% c E % ER% c R5 ?
q
r

f f
%
ER% c R5 % ER% c R5 ? Eb

f
f

f
OLiihc hiU@** |@| R
% ' R% c R5 ' R5 @?_ R5 ' R5 @t - L? ?
S
|ih4i_@|i ?T|t @hi ih) t|hU| A@!?} |t ?|L @UUL?| @?_ hi@hh@?}?}
|i |ih4t ? |i @MLi }itG
U8 U8f '
q
r
q
r

f
f
f f
( ER
% ( ER% % ER% c R5 % ER% c R5 ?
q
r

f f
% ER
% c E % ER% c R5 ?
E2f

f
+iU@** |@| R
% R% tL |@| _i4@?_ t }ih @?_ tTT*) *Lih uLh |i ?@*
}LL_ tL |@| |i ht| *?i t TLt|i

f
_i4@?_ uLh |i 8 A 4@_i ?T| Oi?Uic E R
5 OLiihc R% : R% iurp wkh uhvw ri wkh zruog wr phhw lwv rzq ghpdqg zklfk zdv iruphuo| phw e| grphvwlf
surgxfwlrq1
49 Li wkh| zhuh hdv| wr vdwlvi| wkh sulfh ri lpsruwhg lqwhuphgldwh lqsxwv zrxog eh wkh
plqlpxp ri wkh sulfhv lq wkh wzr frxqwulhv dqg wkhuh zrxog eh dq lqsxw sulfh hhfw1
S
Atc L|T| Lu |i h4t ? ThL_U?} uLh UL*_ hti Lh u@** Wu |i tiUL?_
*?i t TLt|ic |i? 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ 4t| hti | @? 8 A Ai

tiUL?_ *?i t TLt|i u % ER
% c Ec |i L|T| tTT*i_ M) L?i Lu |i ?
f f
h4t L @hi i TLh|?} |L c t *itt |@? % ER% c R5 c |i L|T| tTT*i_
M) L?i Lu |i ?
h4t L @hi ThL_U?} uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| At t
tL? |L Mi tL ? wi44@ f u k k . OLiihc u k k |t ?ii_ ?L|
Mi tL Wu k kf |i? @** h4t ? ti** |L @?_ wi44@ b tLt |@| |i)
ti 4Lhi Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| @?_ 4@!i 4Lhi Lu |i ?@* }LL_ |@?
MiuLhi |i 8 A Oi?Uic 4Lhi Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| t 4TLh|i_ @?_ *itt
Lu |i ?@* }LL_ UL4T@hi_ |L MiuLhi |i 8 A ?i @) |L ?|ihThi| |t hit*| t |L ?L|i |@| |i 8 A tii4t |L hit*|
? |h@_i _ihtL? @t h4t ? i TLh| |L tL |@| r 4TLh|t uhL4 |i hit|

Lu |i Lh*_ u@** M) % ER
% c ? OLiihc @t |iti h4t ? ?L *L?}ih
ThL_Ui uLh c r 4TLh|t hti M) @| |iti h4t L*_ @i ThL_Ui_
f @_ |i) ?L| ThL_Ui_ uLh i TLh| |L c |@| tc M) % ER
% c R5 ? At
|h@_i tMt|||L? Lihi*4t |i @TT@hi?| |h@_i _ihtL? uLh k : k @t
|iti h4t ThL_Ui *itt |@? |i) L*_ @i @_ |i) ThL_Ui_ uLh tL
|@| 4TLh|t Lu |i UL?|hit |L}i|ih hti _i |L |i 8 A W| t Lh| |?!?} Lu |i UL4TL?i?| igiU|t Lu @? 8 A L? |i ?@* }LL_t
4@h!i| Aihi @hi |hii igiU|t @| Lh! 6ht| |ihi t |i i** ?_iht|LL_
|h@_i Uhi@|L?%_ihtL? igiU| Ai 8 A U@?}it ThUit uLh |i ?@* }LL_
hi_U|L? ? |i ThUi Lu |i ?@* }LL_ h@tit 4TLh|t @t *itt t ThL_Ui_
@?_ 4Lhi t _i4@?_i_ W? |i @Mti?Ui Lu - ?@* }LL_ ThUit u@** tL |@|
|i |h@_i Uhi@|L? igiU| h@tit 4TLh|t At t ?L| tL | - 6Lh |i
?
h4t ? L i TLh| |L @u|ih |i 8 A c |i ?@* }LL_ ThUi htit
f

uhL4 R
% |L R% _i |L |i 8 A 6Lh |i4 |i |h@_i Uhi@|L? igiU| hi_Uit
4TLh|t uhL4 |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ 6Lh @** L|ih h4t ? @?_ ? |i
|h@_i Uhi@|L? igiU| h@tit 4TLh|t
5iUL?_c @t tL4i h4t ? Mi}? |L ThL_Ui uLh _i |L |i 8 A c |iti
4: Ohppd
43 lv qrw reylrxv iru wzr uhdvrqv1 Iluvw/ zkloh vxfk upv duh idfhg zlwk d
4
E3
kljkhu surgxfw sulfh/ +sD
{ s{ ,/ zklfk udlvhv wkhlu rxwsxw/ wkd| dovr idfh d kljkhu lqsxw
E
3
sulfh +! s} , zklfk orzhuv wkhlu rxwsxw1 Vhfrqg/ ! lv lwvhoi hqgrjhqrxv dqg ghshqgv
4
D4
rq sD
{ 1 Dv s{ ulvhv/ surwv4 ri upv h{sruwlqj wr D ulvh iru d jlyhq ! vr wkdw 4wr htxdol}h
surwv/ ! pxvw ulvh1 Dv !+s} > , ulvhv zlwk lqfuhdvhv lq erwk lwv dujxphqwv/ s} pxvw ulvh
4
dv sD
{ grhv1 Wklv uhodwlrqvkls qhhgv wr eh uhvshfwhg1 Iru wklv uhdvrq zh fdqqrw frpsduh
wkh srlqw E dqg wkh srlqw [ zklfk jlyh wkh lqsxw xvh ri wkh upv zklfk vhoo lq D dqg
wkrvh zklfk gr qrw uhvshfwlyho| dqg dujxh wkdw E lv ohvv wkdq [1
.

h4t ? igiU| u@Ui @ }ih ThUi uLh |i ?T|c |@| Lu h@|ih |@? R
5 Atc |ihi t @? ?T| _t|Lh|L? igiU| At igiU| h@tit ?T| ULt|t uLh

|iti h4t @?_ hi_Uit |ih tTT*) @t *it Mi|ii? R
5 @?_ R5 W? L|ih
Lh_tc |i UL?|i?| ThL|iU|L? h*i h@tit ULt|t- At igiU| h@tit 4TLh|t
uhL4 |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_
`i UL*_ @*tL @i @ |h_ ?T| ThUi igiU| u |i ThUi Lu 4TLh|i_
?T|t U@?}i_ Wuc uLh i @4T*ic |i - L? ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|t ihi *@
@?_ u @_ @ }ih |@hg L? 5 |@? c |t 4TLh|i_ ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|
ThUi L*_ u@** |L |@| Lu @t @** 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ ihi

f
f
hL|i_ |hL} tL |@| R
5 ' R5 R5 At ?T| ThUi igiU| L*_
h@ti tTT*) Lu |i ?@* }LL_ ? |i 8 A @?_ hi_Ui 4TLh|t uhL4 |i hit|
Lu |i Lh*_ W| L*_ Mi ?i}@|i M| t4@**c u |i _gihi?Ui ? |@hg ? |i
?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ t t4@** `i h*i |t L| M) @tt4?} |@| |i - ?
|i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i| @hi ih) t|hU|
L i |h? |L |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ L|i |@| 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih
4i_@|i }LL_ @u|ih |i 8 A @hiG
U U '
q
r

?
5 ER% c 7 ER5 7 ER5 n ? 5 ER% c R5
n? 5 ER
% c R5 W
W
@?_ MiuLhi |i 8 A @hiG
f f
f
U U f ' ? 5 ER
% c R5 7 ER5 f f
f
n? 5 ER
% c R5 7 ER5 6hL4 |t | uL**Lt |@|G

f f
U U U U f ' ?
i5 ER% c 5 ER% c R5 j

f f
n?
i5 ER% c R5 5 ER% c R5 j

f f
n? i5 ER
% c R5 5 ER% c R5 j
f

f
i7 ER5 7 ER
5 j i7 ER5 7 ER5 j
W
W
f

f
L|i |@| E R
5 M| R% R% tL |@| *i }ih ?T| ULt| hi_Uit
|i _ihi_ _i4@?_c |i }ih ThL_U| ThUi h@tit | Ai uLh4ih igiU| t
tL? |L _L4?@|i u k k ? wi44@ f tL |@| |i ht| *?i t ?i}@|i

f
Ai tiUL?_ *?i t 3ihL @t R
% ' R% @?_ R5 ' R5 @t h4t ? L
UL?|?i |L ThL_Ui uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| u@Ui ?U@?}i_ ThL_U| @?_
H
u@U|Lh ThUit Ai |h_ *?i t ?i}@|i @t |i ThL_U| ThUi t *Lih @?_
|i u@U|Lh ThUi t ?U@?}i_ uLh h4t ? Ai *@t| *?i t @*tL ?i}@|i
@t |i _L4it|U u@U|Lh ThUi i@!*) htit tL |@| |i U@?}i ? 8 A tTT*)
t TLt|i W| t Lh| |?!?} @ML| |i |L|@* U@?}i ? |i ?|ih4i_@|i
}LL_ 4@h!i| ? |ih4t Lu |t UL4TL?i?| T@h|t W? |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|
4@h!i|c |ihi @hi |hii igiU|tG |i _ihi_ _i4@?_ igiU|c |i |h@_i Uhi@|L?
igiU| @?_ |i ?T| _t|Lh|L? igiU| Ai _ihi_ _i4@?_ igiU| ? @? 8 A |L| - tihit |L hi_Ui |h@_i @t |i hi_U|L? ? |i ThUi Lu |i ?@*
}LL_ U@ti_ M) tU @? 8 A hi_Uit |i _ihi_ _i4@?_ uLh |i ?T| @?_
hi_Uit 4TLh|t W? |i U@ti Lu @? 8 A | - Liihc h4t ? L
i TLh| |L }i| @ }ih ThUi |@? MiuLhi tL |@| |i _ihi_ _i4@?_ igiU|
Lh!t |L h@ti |i _i4@?_ uLh |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_c h@t?} 4TLh|t ?
|i L|ih @?_c h4t ? u@Ui @ TLttM*i hi_U|L? ? |i ThUi Lu |i ?@*
}LL_ @?_ tL |i _ihi_ _i4@?_ igiU| uLh |i4 hi_Uit 4TLh|t 6h4t ?
L UL?|?i |L ThL_Ui uLh |ih L? 4@h!i| u@Ui ?L ThUi U@?}i uLh |i
?@* }LL_ @?_ ?L _ihi_ _i4@?_ igiU|
Ai? |ihi t |i t@* |h@_i Uhi@|L? igiU| hi_U|L? ? |i ThUi Lu
|i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ U@ti_ M) @? 8 A |L| - h@tit |t _i4@?_
@?_ hi_Uit tTT*)c Uhi@|?} |h@_i OLiihc | - U @hi t|hU|

f
? |i ?T| 4@h!i| @t R
5 ' R5 @?_ R5 ' R5 c tL |@| |ihi @hi ?L
|h@_i Uhi@|L? igiU|t OLiihc |i ThUi Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| ThL_Ui_
_L4it|U@**) htit tL |@| tTT*) htitc h@|ih |@? u@**t @?_ 4TLh|t u@** uLh
|t hi@tL? Ai ?
h4t ? ti**?} |L u@Ui @ }ih igiU|i ?T| ThUi
_i |L |i - @?_ |t hi_Uit |ih ?T| _i4@?_ At t |i ?T|
_t|Lh|L? igiU| U hi_Uit 4TLh|t
h hit*|t tL u@h @hi t44@h3i_ Mi*L
hLTLt|L? D Wu |i - L? |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ @hi t|hU|c @?_ k 5
dk c o c |i? 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ uhL4 |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ 4t| hti
@?_ 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4t| u@** | @? 8 A Wu k kf |i?
4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ uhL4 |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ u@** | @? 8 A M|
4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ hti 6Lh k 5 Ekf c k 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@*
}LL_ @?_ Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ uhL4 |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ UL*_ hti Lh u@**
| @? 8 A b
S
Ai ,giU| Lu Lhi +it|hU|i +t
`i ?L |h? |L |i igiU| Lu 4Lhi hit|hU|i - L? 4@h!i| @UUitt Oihi i
f

hit|hU| @||i?|L? |L |i U@ti ihi t t4@** hi*@|i |L tL |@| R
% ' R% `i ?ii_ |L _t|?}t Mi|ii? @ ?4Mih Lu U@tit U LUUh @t |i -
MiUL4it ThL}hitti*) 4Lhi M?_?}
@ti G 6Lh ih) *L @*it Lu kc k kf c @** h4t ? ThL_Ui uLh i TLh|
|L M| |i tTT*) Lu ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|t |? |i 8 A t tUi?| |L
f

4ii| _i4@?_ @| R
5 Oi?Uic |i? R5 ' R5 ' R5 ' @?_ 4Lhi hit|hU|i
- _L ?L| @giU| Ai ThUi ? t ?@giU|i_ M) |i 8 A @t t ?L|
f
*@h}i i?L} |L tTT*) |t i?|hi _i4@?_ @| R
% tL |@| t|** 4TLh|t uhL4
|i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ W? |t U@tic | t i@t) |L tii |@| 4Lhi hit|hU|i -
@i ?L igiU| L? 8 A 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* Lh |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ @t |i)
_L ?L| @giU| ThUit Lh ULt|t Lu ThL_U|L?H @ti 2G t |i - MiUL4i 4Lhi hit|hU|ic uLh kf k k c |i 8 A tTT*) Lu |i ?T| MiUL4it ?@_i^@|i |L 4ii| _i4@?_ @?_ |i ThUi Lu |i
?T| ? |i 8 A t|@h|t |L hti OLiihc @** h4t ? i TLh| |L @?_
Thiuih |t |L ThL_U?} uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| @?_ R5 ' R5, U t _i?i_
M) E. W? |t U@ti |i igiU| Lu 4Lhi hit|hU|i - t ?_i|ih4?@|i ?
}i?ih@* tt4?} |@| |i _ihi_ _i4@?_ uLh |i 8 A ?T| M) i@U h4
? ThL_U?} uLh tu|t L|@h_t @t k htit i?thit |@| R5 htit |
?Uhi@tit ? k tUi?| UL?_|L? uLh _ihi_ _i4@?_ |L tu| L|@h_ t
|@| |i _ihi_ _i4@?_ Uhi Mi ?L| |LL i*@t|U @t tL? ? wi44@ H W?
u@U|c @ tUi?| UL?_|L? t |@| |i _ihi_ _i4@?_ i*@t|U|) Mi *itt |@?
?|)
@ti G t |i - MiUL4i ii? 4Lhi hit|hU|ic uLh k k k2 c R5
@t hti? i?L} uLh ThL|t uhL4 i TLh|?} |L |L ?L *L?}ih i Uii_ |Lti
uhL4 ThL_U?} uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| L| @** h4t ? Thiuih |L ThL_Ui
uLh 5L4i h4t _L ThL_Ui uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| +iU@** |@| ? |t
U@tic R5 ' R5 t _i?i_ M)ES W? |t U@ti R5 u@**t @t k htit
Atc i ?ii_ |L *LL! @| U@tit 2 @?_ ? 4Lhi _i|@*
W
W
W
W
W
W
4; Wklv lv wkh fdvh frqvlghuhg lq Ekdjzdwl dqg Sdqdjduld +4<<9, dv wkh| dvvxph wkh
vxsso| fxuyh ri upv lv xqdhfwhg e| URR= Wkh| srlqw rxw wkh srvvlelolw| ri wudgh uhyhqxh
wudqvihuv gxh wr wudgh ghhfwlrq1
2f
S
@ti 2
L?t_ih |i igiU|t Lu 4Lhi hit|hU|i - ? |t U@ti @tt4?} |@| t
@ t4@** UL?|h) tL |@| |i T@||ih? Lu |h@_i t ?L| @giU|i_ M) |i 8 A ì
?ii_ |L Mi U@hiu* |L ?ULhTLh@|i |i igiU|t Lu U@?}?} k EU ?_i it |i
hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i - L? @** |i i?_L}i?Lt @h@M*it W? T@h|U*@hc
L? R5 ' R5, ? |t hi}L? @?_ |hL} | L? L|ih @h@M*it ì ?ii_ Uih|@?
UL4T@h@|i t|@|Ut hit*|t ? Lh_ih |L ThLUii_ uh|ih Aiti @hi _ii*LTi_
? wi44@ ? |i TTi?_ L|i |@|
W
f
f
U 8 Ek ' ( ER
% n ( ER% % ? % ?
5?Ui |i ThUit Lu |i ?@* }LL_t ? @?_ @?_ |i L|T| Lu ?@* }LL_
8
ThL_Uih ? c %
c @hi ?L| @giU|i_ M) kc U Ek ?Uhi@tit| @? ?Uhi@ti ?
_%
k u @?_ L?*) u %
u@**t | @? ?Uhi@ti ? k 5?Ui _k fc @t tL? ?
wi44@ G
_U 8
_%
' ? : f
_k
_k
Ai 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ M) |i 8 A @hi }i? M)G
U U Ek ' ? 5 n ? 5 7 ER5, ihi 5 t |i ?T| ti_ M) @ ?@* }LL_ ThL_Uih ? c U t ?L|
@giU|i_ M) k @?_ 5 t |i |L|@* ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| ti Lu h4t ? U
YR5,
@hi ThL_U?} uLh 5?Ui Y5
Yk f @?_ Yk : fc @tt4?} |@| |i UL?_|L?t
? wi44@ H @hi 4i|c @t tL? ? wi44@ c |i?
YU U Ek
Y5
YR5,
'?
7 E
f
Yk
Yk
Yk
S2
@ti L?t_ih |i igiU|t Lu 4Lhi hit|hU|i - ? @ti @tt4?} |@| |i
T@||ih? Lu |h@_i t ?L| @giU|i_ M) |i 8 A u ULhtic }i? |i t3it Lu |i
|L UL?|hitc |t _iTi?_t L? L hit|hU|i |i - t }@? i ?ii_
|L Mi U@hiu* |L ?ULhTLh@|i |i igiU|t Lu U@?}?} k EU ?_i it |i
hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i - L? @** |i i?_L}i?Lt @h@M*it W? T@h|U*@hc
2
L? R5 @?_ |hL} | L? L|ih @h@M*it ì ?ii_ Uih|@? UL4T@h@|i t|@|Ut
hit*|t ? Lh_ih |L ThLUii_ uh|ih Aiti @hi ThLi_ ? wi44@ 2 ? |i
TTi?_ ì @hi ?L ? @ TLt|L? |L UL?t_ih |i igiU|t Lu ?Uhi@t?}*) hit|hU|i
- L? 4@h!i| @UUitt 6ht| UL?t_ih 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_
f
f
U 8 Ek ' ( ER
% n ( ER% % ? % Ek? % ? #gihi?|@|?} }itG
%
_U 8 Ek
_%
Ek n % Ek _? n % _?
' ?
_k
_k
_k
_k
%
&
_?
_%
Ek ' ?
n % Ek %
_k
_k
f
_% Ek
&
_?
: f @?_ _k f @t tL? ? wi44@ 2
}i? |@| _k
+iU@** |@| @t |i T@||ih? Lu |h@_i _Lit ?L| U@?}ic ThUit ? @?_ Lu |i ?@* }LL_ _L ?L| U@?}i @t k htit Atc L|T| Lu |i h4t ?
t ?U@?}i_ @t t _i4@?_ ? ML| UL?|hit Ai L|T| Lu h4t ? ThL_U?} uLh @*tL _Lit?<| U@?}i | k Aihi @hi |L igiU|t Lu @?
?Uhi@ti ? k L? h4t ? ThL_U?} uLh 6ht|c |i L|T| Lu |i ?
h4t L ThL_Ui uLh htitc M| |ihi @hi uiih Lu |i4 @t tL4i t|U |L
ThL_U?} uLh Ai t|Uiht( Liihc ThL_Ui 4Lhi TL? t|U?} tL
|@| ML| igiU|t h@tit L|T| @?_ _iUhi@tit 4TLh|t
i |c UL?t_ih |i 4TLh| Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| wi| U U Ek _i?L|i
|i i Uitt _i4@?_ uLh 5
U U Ek '
'
q
r

?
Ek5 Ek 7 ER5 Ek n ? Ek5 n ? 5
q
r
? ?
Ek 5 n ? 5
Ai i^@*|) uL**Lt uhL4 |i u@U| |@| _i4@?_ i^@*t tTT*) uLh |i 8 A 4@_i ?T| tL |@|G
q
r

?
Ek5 Ek 7 ER5 Ek ' f
t ?
? wi44@ 2c @?_ @t 5 _Lit?<| U@?}ic
Ek u@**t @t k htit @t tL?
_U U Ek
| uL**Lt uhL4 ?tTiU|L? |@| _k : f h hit*|t tL u@h @hi t44@h3i_
Mi*L
22
hLTLt|L? S tt4i UL?|h) t t4@** tL |@| |i T@||ih? Lu |h@_i t
?L| U@?}i_ Wu k kf |i? @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i -
@t U@T|hi_ M) @? ?Uhi@ti ? k @t ?L igiU| L? |i 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_

Lh |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ Wu k " Ekf c k @?_ 5 ER
% c R5 c k tu|t L| @t k
htitc |@| tc _ihi_ _i4@?_ t ?L| ih) i*@t|Uc |i? @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i
hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i - @t U@T|hi_ M) @? ?Uhi@ti ? k h@tit 4TLh|t
Lu |i ?@* }LL_ @?_ hi_Uit 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ Wu k" Ek c oc
|i? @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i - @t U@T|hi_ M) @? ?Uhi@ti
? k hi_Uit 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ @?_ h@tit 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i
}LL_
Ai 4T*U@|L?t Lu Lh hit*|t tL u@h @hi i@tit| |L tii ? 6}hi D Ai)
t}}it| |@| |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i| t |i 4Lt| ThL|iU|i_ E? |i
ti?ti |@| ML| 4TLh|t hi@U @ 4?44 @?_ |i ThUi Lu 8 A 4@_i ?T|
hi@Uit |t 4@ 44 i? k ' k W? t@hT UL?|h@t|c |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i|
t 4Lt| LTi? E? |i ti?ti |@| |i 4TLh|t hi@U |ih 4@ 44 @| |i
t@4i TL?|c |@| ihi k ' k S
wL?} Aih4 ,giU|t
Aihi @hi 4@?) @)t |L 4L_i* |i *L?} |ih4 igiU|t Lu tU 8 A r Aih
hit*|t @hi ML?_ |L _gih | _gihi?| @tt4T|L?t L? |i @M*|) Lu tTT*)
|L hitTL?_ ? |i *L?} h? Wu tTT*) Lu ML| ?@* @?_ ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|t
t TihuiU|*) i*@t|U ? |i *L?} h?c |i? |i ThUi Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T|
4@_i ? @?_ 4TLh|i_ M) |i 8 A t UL?t|@?| Ai tTT*) Lu |i ?@* }LL_
t ??|i*) i*@t|U @| |i ?| ULt| Lu ThL_U|L? Lu @ ?@* }LL_ i? |i
- @hi 4i| Atc @** _i4@?_ ? |i }ih |@hg UL?|h) U@? Mi 4i| M)
tTT*) ? |i 8 A | ? Lh_ih uLh |t tTT*) |L Mi TLttM*ic U@T|@* 4t|
L ? |L Uhi@|i |i ?iUitt@h) U@T@U|) At t @| i 4i@? M) |ihi @hi
*!i*) |L Mi *@h}i U@T|@* Lt U@ti_ M) @? 8 A | -
At ?| ULt| Lu ThL_U|L? Lu |i ?@* }LL_ htit | |i hit|hU|i?itt
Lu |i - Ai ThUi ? UL?|h) htit | | 6?@**)c i? |i - t
tL hit|hU|i |@| |t ?| ULt| hi@Uit |i ThUi Lu 4TLh|i_ ?@* }LL_t ?
c hi|h?t |L 4TLh|?} uhL4 |i hit| Lu |i Lh*_ L|i |@| |i i*u@hi
igiU|t Lu 4Lhi hit|hU|i - @hi ?L| 4L?L|L?U @t L?Ui |i - }i| |LL
hit|hU|i |i) @hi ? igiU| }?Lhi_ @?_ | t @t u |ihi ihi ?L 8 A @| @**
W| t i? |i - t hit|hU|i M| ?L| ThLM|i |@| i*u@hi *Lttit @hi
2
*!i*) W? |t ii?|c UL?t4iht ? _L ?L| i?L) |i }@?t uhL4 *Lih ThUit
@?_ UL?|h) _Lit ?L| UL**iU| @?) |@hg hii?i i|ih- ì hitihi 4Lhi
_i|@*i_ t|_) Lu ?it|4i?| Lt @?_ i*u@hi igiU|t |L u|hi Lh!
.
L?U*tL?
U Lu |i UL?Uih? ui*| @ML| hi}L?@* |h@_?} @hi@t @t Mii? |@| |i) **
i U*_i ?L? 4i4Mih UL?|hit uhL4 |ih 4@h!i|t U Lu |t _tUttL?c
tii uLh i @4T*i d2o @?_ UL?|ih @h}4i?|t M) deoc @t Mii? ULUi_ ? |ih4t
Lu |i }hi@|ih 4@h!i| TLihc @?_ i?Ui }ih LT|4@* |@hgt Lu *@h}ih |h@_i
M*LUt At t ?L| |i _hiU|L? i uL**L uLh |L hi@tL?t 6ht|c |@hgt
L? 4Lt| 4@?u@U|hi_ }LL_t @hi ML?_ M) UL?UittL?t 4@_i ? tUUitti
hL?_t Lu ?i}L|@|L?t ?_ih |i @tTUit Lu CA A `*i |i ti Lu L?
A@hg @hhiht E A r ThL_i @ @) |L UhU4i?| |iti *4|tc |i) Lu|i?
U@ti ?@?|UT@|i_ t_i igiU|t @?_ t|@?_ |L Mi _t@**Li_ u |LL M*@|@?|*)
@Mti_ LhiLihc |ihi t *||*i i_i?Ui |@| |t @i?i @t Mii? 4TLh|@?|
? Th@U|Ui 5iUL?_c i Mi*ii |@| |i @i?i i uLUt L?c -c @hi *itt
i** ?_iht|LL_c _L i?_ T ThL_?} hi@tL? uLh UL?Uih?c @?_ @hi i |hi4i*)
4TLh|@?| ? Th@U|Ui
W? |t T@Tihc @?_ @ UL4T@?L? L?ic dSoc i @i tL? |@| 8 A r U@?
Mi u@h uhL4 uhiic itTiU@**) | - W? |t T@Tih i tL |@| 4Lhi
hit|hU|i - ? |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i| U@? ?|@**) tihi |L hit|hU| @UUitt
|L |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i| @?_ 4ThLi @UUitt ? |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i|
OLiihc Mi)L?_ @ Uih|@? TL?|c |i) 4t| Mi}? |L 4ThLi @UUitt |L |i
?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ 4@h!i| @?_ hi_Ui @UUitt |L |i ?@* }LL_ 4@h!i|- ì
_L ?L| t|_) |i i*u@hi UL?tiî?Uit Lu tU 8 A r ihi M| | t i@t) |L
UL?t|hU| i*u@hi _iUhi@t?} 8 A r ML| | @?_ |L| -
ì Mi*ii |@| |i 4L_i* _ii*LTi_ ihi @t @? ?|ih?@* t|hU|hi |@|
4@!it | t|@M*i uLh @ ?4Mih Lu L|ih ThTLtit ? ?|ihit|?} @?_ ThLLU@
|i hit*| Lu |i 4L_i* t |i ?L? 4L?L|L?U igiU| Lu @? ?Uhi@ti ? hit|hU
|i?itt Lu |i - L? |i ThUi Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i ?T| 4@_i ? |i 8 A Wuc uLh i @4T*ic |t ?T| @t 4@_i M) *@MLh @*L?i t?} @ ?| Lu *@MLh |L
4@!i |c |i @}i L*_ Mi i^@* |L |i ThUi Lu |i _L4it|U@**) 4@_i ?T|
@?_ |t hit*| L*_ 4T*) |@| |ihi 4@) Mi hi@tL? uLh *@MLh |L ?L| @*@)t
}@? uhL4 4Lhi hit|hU|i - Atc *@MLh L*_ u@Lh hit|hU|ic M| ?L|
|LL hit|hU|i -
2e
?L|ih @TT*U@|L? 4}| Mi |L t|_)?} 4@h!i| @UUitt hi^hi4i?|t
L?t_ihc uLh i @4T*i @ 4@h!i| @UUitt hi^hi4i?| ? @|L T@h|t L? a@T@?iti
h4t *?!i_ |L Thiuihi?|@* |@hgt L? @|Lt ? |i uL**L?} 4@??ih Wu @
a@T@?iti h4 M)t tUi?| L7 @|L T@h|t uLh @ 4?44 ULt| t@hi Lu
L7 T@h|t |L Mi 4i| |i? | ^@*it uLh @ *L |@hg |L |i L7 Wu | _Lit
?L|c |i? | u@Uit @ Ti?@*|) |@hg 5U @ t|@|L? t @?@*L}Lt |L |i L?i
t|_i_ @MLi 6Lh @ *L i?L} ULt| t@hic @** a@T@?iti h4t ** 4ii| |i
hi^hi4i?| @?_ ti** |L |i L7 4ii|?} |ih L? _i4@?_ |hL} 4TLh|t
t |i ULt| t@hi htitc |i ThUi Lu L7 T@h|t ** hti M| @** a@T@?iti h4t
** t|** i TLh| |L |i L7 | tL4i TL?| a@T@?iti h4t ** Mi ?_gihi?|
Mi|ii? i TLh|?} @?_ tih?} |ih L? 4@h!i| 6hL4 |t TL?| L?@h_ |i
ThUi Lu |i L7 ?T|t ** u@** @t |i ULt| t@hi ?Uhi@titc | U@?}it ?
|i ?4Mih Lu a@T@?iti h4t L tihi |i N5 4@h!i| @U|?} |L i^@*3i
|i ThL|t uhL4 |iti |L LT|L?t h hit*|t @MLi t}}it| |@| |ihi
t @ *ii* Lu |t ULt| t@hi U t4*|@?iLt*) 4@ 43it i TLh|t Lu |i
?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ @?_ 4?43it 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_
|ih i @4T*it Lu tU hit|hU|L?t UL*_ Mi |@ it ELh hi@h_t u |i |@h}i|
t 4i| u Uih|@? !?_t Lu Lh!ihtc Mi |i) i*u@hi hiUTi?|t Lh _L4it|U
Lh!ihtc _L ?L| 4@!i T @ }i? uh@U|L? Lu |i Lh! uLhUi Lh Uih|@? !?_t
Lu ui*t _L ?L| 4@!i T @ }i? ThLTLh|L? Lu i?ih}) UL?t4T|L?
H
TTi?_
W? |t TTi?_ i T| |L}i|ih @ tihit Lu wi44@tc U @hi Uh|U@* uLh
|i hit*|t i _ihi
wi44@ +@t?} Lh *Lih?} 5 *i !iiT?} |L|@* ?T| ti UL?t|@?|
h@tit ThL|t
L?t_ihc t|@h|?} uhL4 |i U@?__@|i *ii*tc @ hi@**LU@|L? Lu ?T| ti
U hi_Uit 5 c @?_ h@tit 5 tL @t |L !iiT |ih t4 UL?t|@?| Ai u@**
? 5 |L 5 " @?_ |i hti ? 5 |L 5 n" U@tit ThL|t |L U@?}i uhL4
E5 c 5 |L E5 n 5c 5 " Nt?} |i _i?|L? Lu ThL|t }itG

E5 n "c 5 " E5 c 5 ' ER
% R% d8 E5 "

8 E5 o " n R
5 "
2D

' ER
% R% d8 E5
8 E5 "o n R
5 " "
'
] 5

iER
% R% 8 E5
5 3M

nR
5 j_5 "
OLiihc |t t t| |i @hi@ ?_ih |i Uhi Mi|ii? 5 " @?_ 5
*itt " U t |i i}| Lu |i (( Uhi |4it " At t TLt|i @?_
i^@*t |i t@_i_ @hi@ ? 6}hi 54*@h*)c @ hi_U|L? ? 5 @?_ @? i^@*
?Uhi@ti ? 5 Lu " @*tL h@tit ThL|t

E5 "c 5 n " E5 c 5 ' ER
% R% d8 E5 n "

8 E5 o n " R
5 "

' ER
% R% d8 E5 8 E5 n 5o

R
5 " n "
' " ] 5 nM q
5

ER
% R% 8 E5 n R5
OLiihc |t t t| "c |i i}| Lu |i (( Uhi |4it "c *itt |i @hi@
?_ih |i Uhi Mi|ii? 5 @?_ 5 n " At t TLt|i @?_ i^@*t |i
_L||i_ @hi@ ? 6}hi Atc h@t?} Lh *Lih?} 5 *i !iiT?} |L|@* ?T|
ti UL?t|@?| h@tit ThL|t 6Lh |t hi@tL?c h4t ** ULLti |L tTiU@*3i ?
ThL_U?} uLh i TLh| |L @?_ ti ?T| *ii* c Lh ? ThL_U?} uLh |i
_L4it|U 4@h!i| @?_ ULLti ?T| *ii* f
wi44@ 2 qER5 c k '
R
5
EE3kR5 nkR
5
t ?Uhi@t?} ? k @?_ _iUhi@t?} ? R5
L|i |@| @? ?Uhi@ti ? k hi_Uit |i _i?L4?@|Lh @t R5 : R
5 @?_
tL h@tit qER5 c k ? ?Uhi@ti ? R5 h@tit |i _i?L4?@|Lh @?_ tL hi_Uit
qER5 c k
wi44@ ER5 c k '
R5 R
5
EE3kR5 nkR
5
t ?Uhi@t?} ? ML| |t @h}4i?|t
L|i |@| @? ?Uhi@ti ? k hi_Uit |i _i?L4?@|Lh Lu |i i ThittL?c
h@t?} ? ?Uhi@ti ? R5 U@? Mi tii? |L h@ti M) __?} |i ?4ih@|Lh
@?_ _i?L4?@|Lh ? M) R5 @?_ ?L|?} |@| @? ?Uhi@ti ? R5 hi_Uit |i
_i?L4?@|Lhc h@t?} |i h@|L
2S
r
_5
wi44@ e ER5 c k '
E3kER5 3R
5
t
EE3kR5 nkR
5
?Uhi@t?} ? R5 @?_ _iUhi@t?} ? k
AL tii |@| E t _iUhi@t?} ? kc __i ?4ih@|Lh @?_ _i?L4?@|Lh
M) E k W| t |i? @TT@hi?| |@| ?Uhi@t?} k h@tit |i _i?L4?@|Lhc
|ihiM) hi_U?} E AL tii |@| E t ?Uhi@t?} ? R5 c __i ?4ih@|Lh
@?_ _i?L4?@|Lh M) R5 W| t |i? @TT@hi?| |@| ?Uhi@t?} R5 h@tit |i
?4ih@|Lhc @?_ hi_Uit |i _i?L4?@|Lhc |ihiM) h@t?} E

wi44@ D ER% c R5 c k t ?Uhi@t?} ? R% @?_ _iUhi@t?} ? R5 @?_ k
A@| tG
Y ER c R ck
Y ER
% c R5 ck fc E Y ER% c R5 ck f
E YR% 5 : fc E YR

Yk
%
5
hLLuG
E 6hL4 Ef | t U*i@h |@|

ER% c R5 c k ' R% 8 E5 ER5 c k5 n ER5 c k& &

) |i i?i*LTi |iLhi4c ER% c R5 c k t ?Uhi@t?} ? R%
E *tLc M) |i i?i*LTi |iLhi4 ER% c R5 c k t _iUhi@t?} ? R5 t?UiG

Y
ER% c R5 c k
YR5

R75 iE k& R
5 5 j iE k R5 R5 & R5 R5 5 jE k
'
i7
R5 j2
'
'

i7
R5 E k R5 R
5 jE k& n iR5 R5 E k R5 R75 j5
k
l R
5

E k& kR5 5
i7
R5 j2
i7
R5 j2
E2
f
At uL**Lt uhL4 |i u@U| |@|G
R5 5 n &
'k

R
R
R5 5 n R
5 5 n &
5 5 n &
5 5 n &

, kR
5 5 n E k& f
&
&
ihi |i @MLi i^@*|) uL**Lt uhL4 |i u@U| |@| E t M?_?}
E 54*@h*)c @}@? t?} |i i?i*LTi |iLhi4c i tL |@|G
2.
E22

Y
ER% c R5 c k f
Yk

At uL**Lt uhL4 |@!?} |i T@h|@* _ih@|i Lu ER% c R5 c k G

Y
ER% c R5 c k ' YER5 c k 5 n YER5 c k &
Yk
Yk
Yk
f
uhL4 t?} wi44@ E @?_ wi44@ Ee
ck
R
% cR
5 : fc E Y5 ER% c R5 ck fc E Y5 ER% c R5 ck f
wi44@ S E Y5 EYR

Yk
YR5
%
hLLuG E uL**Lt _hiU|*) uhL4 E c *i E @?_ E uL**L uhL4
wi44@ U tLt |@| ER5 c k t ?Uhi@t?} ? ML| |t @h}4i?|tc @?_
uhL4 E
wi44@ . Y R5 EYRR%ck
%
ck %
: f @?_ Y R5 ERYk
f

hLLuG L|i |@| t?Ui E R% c R5 c k htit | ?Uhi@tit ? R% @?_

_iUhi@tit ? R5 @?_ k @t tL? ? wi44@ EDc R5 ER% c k htit @t R% htit
Lh k u@**t
Y5 ER
% cR5 ck fc E Y5 ER% cR5 ck : fc @?_ i? |i i*@t|U|)
wi44@ H E YR

YR
5
%
Lu _ihi_ _i4@?_c 0c t ?L| R|LL }c |@| tc
k R5 5 n R
Y5 5 5 n &
0'
c
Y 5
kER5 R
5 5
|i? E
Y5 ER
% cR5 ck : f Yk
hLLuG
E L|i |@| |i _i4@?_ u?U|L? ? 6}hi t _L?@h_ t*LT?} 6hL4

i^@|L? EH i @i |i uLh4 Lu 5 ER
% c R5 c k |L Mi
5 '

kR
E k
5
5
&

kR5 n E kR5
kR5 n E kR5
2H
#gihi?|@|?} | }it
#
$
#

Y5 ER
E k
kR
% c R5 c k ' 5
n
5

YR5
kR
kR
5 n E kR5
5 n E kR5
$
Y5
f
YR5
t?Ui Y5
YR5 f @t tL? ? wi44@ ES E

Y5 ER
Y5 ER
kR
% c R5 c k '
5
% c R5 c k : f

YR
kR
YR
%
5 n E kR5
%

@t Y5 ERYR% cR5 ck : f uhL4 wi44@ S
%
E i @i uhL4 EH

kR
5 5 E k &
R5
R5
k5 E k
&
'
R5
R5
5 '
5L i @i
Y5
Yk
'
5 k5 Y k Y5 Y
n
n
R5
R5 Yk
R5 Y Yk

&R
n 52
R5
Y E k & wi| 0 ' Y5 _i?L|i |i i*@t|U|)
ihi |i *@t| |ih4 t Yk
R5
Y 5
Lu _ihi_ _i4@?_c tL |@|
3
%
&
k Y k0 Y
&R

5 n
n 52
R5 R5 Yk
R5 Yk
R5
%
&

5
Y
&R
' nk
E 0 n 52
R5
Yk
R5
Y5 uLh Yk : fc i @i
%
&
5
Y
n
k
E 0
R5
Yk
:
&R
5 /
R5 2
2b
nk
&R R
Y
E 0 : 5 25 /
Yk
5 R5
0 : k
0 : k
#
#
Y
Yk
Y
Yk
$3
$3
#
Y
Yk
k
#
$3
Y
Yk

&R
5 R5 /
k5 R5 2
$3
&
5 R5
L
k
#
Y
Yk
$3
#
$3
ER5 R
5 R5
R5
'
kER5 R
5

R5
n
'
kER5 R
5
' k
5L i @i
Y5
: f/
Yk
0 : R5
&

kER5 R5 kER5 R
5 5
@?_ |i ?iUitt@h) @?_ tUi?| UL?_|L? t
ER5 5 n &
0 : kER5 R
5 5
k R5 5 n R
5 5 n &
' kER5 R
5 5
Lh
0
R5 5 n R
5 5 n &
ER5 R
5 5
ER 5 nR 5 n&
5?Ui 5 ER R5 5
: c @ tUi?| UL?_|L? t |@| |i i*@t|U|)c _i
5 5
?i_ @t @ TLt|i ?4Mihc Mi *itt |@? ?|)c |@| tc 0
3
f
wi44@ b tt4i |@| k 5 dfc k o tL |@| @** h4t ? i TLh| |L 6Lh k

Mi*L kf c ' R
5 ' R5 @?_ @t |i ?T| ULt| t ?U@?}i_ uLh @** h4t ? @?_ |i L|T| ThUi t h@ti_c |i) h@ti |ih ti Lu ?T|t @?_ ThL_Ui 4Lhi
Lu |i ?@* }LL_ 6h4t ? @hi ?@giU|i_ Atc ? |t hi}L? 4TLh|t Lu
|i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ @hi }ih |@? |i) ihi MiuLhi |i 8 A @?_ 4TLh|t

Lu |i ?@* }LL_ @hi *Lih Wu k t @MLi kf c |i? R5 ' R5, : : R
5 tL
|@| |i igiU|i ?T| ThUi t }ih uLh h4t ? c @** Lu L i TLh| |L OLiih |i ThL_U| ThUi t }ih @t i** `*i |i uLh4ih hi_Uit |i ti
Lu ?T|tc |i *@||ih h@tit | tL |@| h4t ? 4@) ti 4Lhi Lh *itt Lu |i
?|ih4i_@|i ?T| @?_ ThL_Ui 4Lhi Lh *itt Lu |i ?@* }LL_ |@? MiuLhi |i
8 A ? |t hi}L? Atc 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i @?_ ?@* }LL_t UL*_
hti Lh u@** _i |L |i 8 A ? |t hi}L? OLiihc @| k ' k c h4t ? @hi ?_gihi?| Mi|ii? ThL_U?} uLh @?_ uLh @?_ 4t| ti *itt Lu |i
?|ih4i_@|i ?T|c @?_ ThL_Ui *itt Lu |i ?@* }LL_ |@? MiuLhi |i 8 A @t tL? Mi*L Oi?Uic @| k ' k 4TLh|t Lu |i ?|ih4i_@|i }LL_ M) |i
8 A 4i4Miht @hi *Lih @?_ 4TLh|t Lu |i ?@* }LL_ M) |i 8 A 4i4Miht
@hi }ih |@? MiuLhi |i 8 A W
wi44@ f tt4i |@| k 5 dk c o tL |@| tL4i h4t ? UL?|?i |L
ThL_Ui uLh |i _L4it|U 4@h!i| Ai? |i ?T| ti @?_ i?Ui L|T| Lu |i
h4t ? L ThL_Ui uLh t *itt |@? |i L|T| Lu |i h4t ? L
ThL_Ui uLh A@| tG

% ER
% c % ER% c R5 sJo R% R% @?_ R5 hLLuG
E5 5 n & &
' R% 8
%
&
&

' R% 8 E5 5 n &
R%
R%
%
&
R
5
' ' R% 8 E5 R 5 &
%
& : fc i 4t| @i

iU@ti R
% : R% @?_ R
%
8 E5 5 8 E5 R%

R
5 5
R
%
|L 4@?|@? |i i^@*|) L|i |@| 5 t @| 4@ 43it
8 E5 5
R%
*i 5 4@ 43it
R
8 E5 5 5
R%
wi| 5 4@ 43i 8 E5 -5 @?_ *i| 8 E5 -5 CE- Mi |i @*i
u?U|L? uLh |t ThLM*i4 u ULhtic M) |i i?i*LTi |iLhi4c C E- f

5?Ui CE R CE RR5 c |t 4T*it |@| R : RR5 Nt?} |i ht| Lh_ih
%
%
%
%
UL?_|L?tc E @?_ Eec @?_ |i u@U| |@| 8 E t UL?U@ic i 44i_@|i*)
@i |@| 5 5 U 4T*it |@| %
% wi44@ tt4i |@| k " Ekf c k c @?_ UL?|h) t t4@** @?_ |@|
Y5 ER
% cR5 ck : f ? ?Uhi@ti ? |i hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i - @t U@T
Yk
_5 |hi_ M) @? ?Uhi@ti ? k hit*|t ? |i uL**L?}G E _k : fc E _R_k5 : fc
fc@?_ E _% f
E _5
_k
_k
W
_5

E _k : f uL**Lt uhL4 |i u@U| |@| u 5 ER
% c R5 c k tu|t L| @t k htitc
|i i^*Mh4 *ii* Lu 5 @*tL htit
,

E _R_k5 : f uL**Lt uhL4 |i @tt4T|L? |@| 5 ER
% c R5 c k tu|t L| @t
k htit
R5, R
5 , ?Uhi@tit ?
E AL ThLi _5_k fc ?L|i |@| ER5, c k ' kR nE
kR5
5
ML| |t @h}4i?|t @t tL? ? wi44@ Ai? uhL4 i^@|L? Ec i
44i_@|i*) @i |i hit*|
Y%
E Yk ' 8 Y5
Yk f
3
wi44@ 2 6Lh k 5 Ek c o tL |@| R5 ' R5 c @?_ UL?|h) t4@**c @?
?Uhi@ti ? |i hit|hU|i?itt Lu |i - @t U@T|hi_ M) @? ?Uhi@ti ? k
hit*|t ? @ _iUhi@ti ? R5 @?_ ?
c @?_ @? ?Uhi@ti ? 5 c % @?_ 5 W?
L|ih Lh_tG
W
W
Ek

Ekck
_5 ER5 Ekck
5
5
E _R_k
fc E _ER5_kEkck fc E _5 ER_k
: fc E _k
:
ER5 Ekck

_?
E
k
_%
fc E _k
fc E _k
: fc E _ER5_kEkck f @?_ E

_T ER5 Ekck
: f
_k
2
hLLuG t!i|U Lu |i ThLLu t ThL_i_ ?i | W? Lh_ih |L UL?t_ih |i
igiU|t Lu @? ?Uhi@ti ? k i ?ii_ |L ht| L|*?i |i t)t|i4 U _i|ih4?it
|iti i?_L}i?Lt @h@M*it Aiti @hi }i? M) Ec EDc ESc @?_ EH
AL}i|ih |iti _i|ih4?i R5 Ek EuhL4 EDc 5 Ek uhL4 Ec 5 uhL4 EHc
?
Ek uhL4 ESc @?_ % uhL4 |i _i?|L? Lu |i ThL_U|L? u?U|L?c |@|
t % Ek ' 8 E 5 Ek

6ht| UL?t_ih E wi44@ D tLt |@| ER% c R5 c k t _iUhi@t?} ?

7
R5 @?_ k @?_ ?Uhi@t?} ? R
% 5?Ui ER% c R5 c k 4t| i^@* c @?_ @t

R% t i_ t?Ui t t4@**c i }i| E

E @?_ E +iU@** |@| ' R% 8 E5 ER5 c k5 n ER5 c k& &
b

7
W? hitTL?ti |L |i ?Uhi@ti ? kc R5 4t| u@** |L !iiT i_ @| L?t_ih |i igiU| Lu @? ?Uhi@ti ? k @?_ @ _iUhi@ti ? R5 tU |@| ER5 c k
t ?U@?}i_ *tLc ?L|i |@|G
W
'

E ki R
5 jc

kR
5
tL |@| u t !iT| UL?t|@?| M) |i ?_Ui_ hi_U|L? ? R5 c 4t| u@**

Oi?Ui u@**t W? Lh_ih |L !iiT i_c R5 4t| u@** ii? uh|ih |@? |
?ii_t |L ? Lh_ih |L !iiT ER5 c k i_ @?_ |t hit*|t ? @ *Lih ER5 c k
|@? @| |i Lh}?@* k UL?ti^i?Ui Lu |tc uhL4 E t |@| 5 htit ?
hitTL?ti |L |i ?Uhi@ti ? k
E +iU@** |@|
5 '

kR
5 5 E k& kR5 5 E k&

R5 u@**t @t k htit @?_ @t R5 : R
5 @?_ |i i}| L? R5 u@**t Atc |i h@|L
htit
E t R5 u@**t _i |L @? ?Uhi@ti ? kc tTT*) Lu 5 uhL4 |i 8 A u@**t
t 5 htit _i |L @? ?Uhi@ti ? kc uLh _i4@?_ |L i^@* tTT*) @| |i *Lih
R5 c ?
4t| u@** uhL4 ES
E 6L**Lt uhL4 |i u@U| |@| %
Ek ' 8 E 5 Ek
W
W
wkdw #+s4} > , lv srvlwlyho| uhodwhg wr s4} dqg qhjdwlyho| wr dqg wkdw E
D
idoov zlwk lqfuhdvhv lq s4} ru =
4< Uhphpehu
E L|i |@| _i |L |i i?i*LTi |iLhi4 @?_ t?Ui ThL|t @hi i_G

_
ER5 Ekc k ' 5 _ER5 Ekc k & _ER5 Ekc k ' f
_k
_k
_k
E2

5?Ui M) Ec _ER5_kEkck fc |i @MLi 4T*it |@| _ER5_kEkck f
E L|i uhL4 EH |@|G
T ER5 Ekc k ' ER5 Ekc k5 ER5 Ekc k&
Oi?UiG
_T ER5 Ekc k
_E
_E
_5 E
' 5
&
n
_k
_k
_k
_k
_5 E
:f
' _k
ihi |i *@t| i^@*|) uL**Lt uhL4 E2 +iuihi?Uit
do ?_ihtL?c a@4it , @?_ i|ih i@h) Ebbe Ri@th?} |i +it|hU|i
?itt Lu Ah@_i L*U)c `Lh*_ @?! ,UL?L4U +iic HE2c TT DSb
d2o @}i**c k)*i @?_ +LMih| 5|@}ih EbbH RAi 54T*i ,UL?L4Ut Lu
w@MLh 5|@?_@h_t @?_ |i BAA ,+ `Lh!?} @Tih L SSfe
do @}@|c a@}_t @?_ h?_ @?@}@h)@ EbbS Rhiuihi?|@* Ah@_?}
hi@t @?_ *|*@|ih@*t4G 5|h@?}ihtc 6hi?_t Lh 6Litq 4iL
deo L?_c ,hU @?_ L?t|@?|?Lt 5)hLTL*Lt EbbS RAi 53i Lu Ah@_?}
*LUtG @h!i| Lih @?_ `Lh*_ ì*u@hi ,giU|t aLh?@* Lu W?|ih?@
|L?@* ,UL?L4Utc VL* efc Lec TT ee.
dDo +Lti**L?c a@? Ebbe R+*it Lu h}? @?_ ì*u@hi ?@*)tt 4iL
dSo ac a@?_L?} @?_ k@*@ kht?@ EbbS R@h!i| UUitt @?_ ì*u@hi
,giU|t Lu 6hii Ah@_i hi@t |L| +*it Lu h}? ,+ `Lh!?}
@Tih L DeHf
e
d.o kL@*U3)!c @ht|i?c Ebbf Rì*u@hi @?_ t|L4t N?L?tc #@h|4L|
L**i}i `Lh!?} @Tih
dHo kht?@c h@? EbbH R+i}L?@*t4 @?_ *|*@|ih@*t4G L*|U@*
,UL?L4) TThL@U "@h|ih*) aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Utc VL*4i jWWWc
TT 22.2D2
dbo kht?@c k@*@ @?_ ??i khi}ihEbbD RW4T*i4i?|?} 6hii Ah@_i
hi@tG +*it Lu h}? @?_ O__i? hL|iU|L?c TT ebH. ? i
#hiU|L?t ? Ah@_i AiLh)c #i@h_Lhgc a wi?tL? @?_ + 5|ih?
E,_c N?iht|) Lu U}@? hittc bbD
dfo kht?@c k@*@ Ebb RTi??ittG L?UiT|@* TThL@U
do khi}ihc ??i EbbD R6hii Ah@_i }hii4i?|t Vihtt t|L4t
N?L?tc ,+ `Lh!?} @Tih rDfHe
d2o kh}4@?c @*c Ebb RWt *@|ih@*t4 @_q ? W?|ih?@|L?@* Ah@_i
@?_ Ah@_i L*U) ,_t Oi*T4@?c ,*@?@? @?_ t@u +@3? WA hittG
@4Mh_}i @?_ wL?_L?c TT b2
do wi)c *Tc Ebb. R L*|U@*,UL?L4U ?@*)tt Lu 6hiiAh@_i
}hii4i?|tc 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +iic VL*4i H.c L ec TT DfS
Db
deo wLTi3c + , @?_ @?@}@h)@ Ebb2 R? |i AiLh) Lu iUi4i@*
A@hg +iuLh4G Ai @ti Lu hi W4TLh|i_ W?|ih4i_@|i W?T|tc 4ih
U@? ,UL?L4U +iic VL*4i H2c L c TT SDS2D
dDo wLTi3c + , @?_ # +L_h! Ebb RAh@_i +it|hU|L?t | W4TLh|i_
W?|ih4i_@|i W?T|tG ì? #Lit |i Ah@_i @*@?Ui W4ThLiq aLh?@*
Lu #ii*LT4i?| ,UL?L4Ut ec TT 2bH
dSo i@_ic a EbDD Ah@_i @?_ ì*u@hic uLh_ N?iht|) hittG wL?_L?
d.o +U@h_tL?c @h|? EbbD RA@hg +ii?i L4Ti||L? ? @ 6hii
Ah@_i hi@ ,hLTi@? ,UL?L4U +iic VL* bc L .c TT e2be.
dHo Vih4*t|c , Ebbe R+*it Lu h}? ? W?|ih?@|L?@* Ah@_iG L4
T@h@|i 5|_)c ? 5|_it ? W?|ih?@|L?@* Ah@_i L*U) ,_t `@ihc @?_ a@Uît Lh}iLt N?iht|) Lu U}@? hittG ?? hMLh
D
dbo V?ihc a EbDf Ai t|L4t N?L? Wttic @h?i}i ,?_L4i?| uLh
W?|ih?@|L?@* i@Uic i vLh!
S
Figure 1
A:\FIRM_BEH.FG1
May 25, 2000 (1:32PM)
Figure 2
A:\FIRM_BEH.FG2
May 25, 2000 (1:32PM)
Figure 3
A:\FIRM_BEH.FG3
May 25, 2000 (1:33PM)
Figure 4
A:\FIRM_BEH.FG4
May 25, 2000 (1:33PM)
Figure 5

Download Report

Firm Behavior and Market Access in a Free Trade Area with Rules of

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz