A New Protocol and Lower Bounds for Quantum Coin
Flipping
Andris Ambainis
Computer Science Division
University of California
Berkeley, CA 94720
e-mail: ABSTRACT
!#"$%&(')%*+, !-.&!-/#-01'%*23&4+5-607-+5(89-: %;2 "=<>-@?:;'%A
&!: BC/#-D7%FE;D7 *D7%*GH)IJ%F-: !-&!-/#-0LKM%*-N2 D7"$O -%*"P&Q;'.$&JRS/T'%
'./UO D7#V5-%*W-: &!/-B6W+XDY&!OZ !-8;'8 D70[DY&JRQB6-!\&!O;'%)]H ^_Ha`=O*%K
+56"$O*-T+b&!O;'&)-: Q!-&!-/#-05D7"Q- &!D7Bc'.0a<>-)'d/#$&e'.D7%&4R9f-.<
?:*'%&!:*Bg!-&!-/#-07"#H
h -Z'.!8 DY&$e'.$Ri?:;'.%&!: Bj!-&!-/#-07"#KM+=f"$O -T+k&!O;'.&lD7<='N!-A
&!-/-06'./UO D[V#"i'm8*D['."F-.<3'.&iB6-"P&in#K)D7&iB):*"P&S:*"$o'&i0[#'"P&
plq 07-G=07-GNr
!-: %;2"d-<Z/#-B6Bu: %*D7/T'.&!D7-%Hv`=O*D7"ND[B6 07D["N&!O;'&
t !#9U&!D7&!D7-%d<L'.D[07"(<w-@?:;'.%&!: Bx/#-D7%dE;D7* D7%*G H q `=O &!O ;'e'0707s
#0
8 D['"y-<;'z!-&!-/#-0 /T'.%*% -&y895'.!8*DY&$e'!D[0YR)2 /!T'"$#2)8Rl!:*% %*D7%*G
"$Ve'0/#- D7#"X-<\DY&(D[%N;'e'0707#0LH
t
1.
INTRODUCTION
JI %dBc'.%Rc/U$R &!-G.e'*O D7/ !-&!-/-07"#K;&!O*U!lD7"z')%*#T23<w-Xe'.% A
2-B{8 D7&!"=&!O*'.&('!/#-B6B6-%3&!-)89-&!Od*'.$&!D7#"#Ha|@-T+5#VTK DY<y-% -.<**'.$&!D7#"D["M'0707-+5T2&!-(G#%*Ue'.&!\&!O*#"$\e'%*2 -B,8*DY&!"#K&!O*D7"};'$&4R
Bc'#RiO;'TVc'~/eO;'.%*/#f&!-D7%E;:*%*/#f&!O 6-: &!/-B66-<€&!O 6 !-.&!-A
/-08R6' !- !D['.&!#0YRc D[/e‚D7%*G&!O*Xe'%*2 -Bƒ8*DY&!"#H\`=O D["€!-8 0[B
/#'%c89z"$-07VT2f8Rf: "$D[% GZ'Q/U$R &!-G.e'*O D7/(!D7B6D7&!D7VX/T'.070[#2F„!…†w‡
ˆ † ‰‰;†w‡ŠH
‹)Œw\‡*†wŽL†….‡‘’X“”/#-D[%NE;D7* D[% Gu'.07G-!DY&!O Bg+XD7&!Odn€8*D['"€D7"X-% +XO !c“z07D7/#6'.%;2i•5-8F/#-B6B):*% D[/#'.&!f'.%;2–;%*'070YR2#/#D[2 u-%F'
V'07: —@˜i™]šT›.œQ"$:*/eON&!O;'&

IJ<189-&!Od“z07D7/#'%*2N•W-8'!lO*-%*#"P&TK&!O*%džlŸ. ¡ q —X¢”] ¢
t
žlŸ. ¡ q —X¢£› ¢¤›T¥¦H
t

IJ<\-%*Q-<y&!O #B§D7"zO -%*"P&TK*&!O*%K*<>-@'%RN"P&$e'.&!#G.R-<y&!O 2 D7"$O -%*"P&c*0['#RTK€žlŸ. .¡ q —S¢¨]
›¥¦)ª,n#K€žlŸ. ¡ q —S¢
td©
›
›¥¦(ªon#H
t=©
« :* 9-$&!T2{8R­¬dD7/!-"$-<>&,®(#"$T'!/UOC¯ze'2:;'.&!¤h*#0707-+X"$O D7
'.%;2KD7%6;'.$&TK8R)° « hiG.e'%&=±€±5®(AJ²³]]]¦.´H=µy'$&5-.<&!O*D7"W+5-!‚
2-% l+XO*D707VD7"$DY&!D7%*G6I4•€¬¨“z07Bc'2#%H
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for
personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are
not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies
bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to
republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific
permission and/or a fee.
STOC’01, July 6-8, 2001, Hersonissos, Crete, Greece.
Copyright 2001 ACM 1-58113-349-9/01/0007 ... ¶ 5.00.
±50['"$"$D7/T'.0[0YRK/-D7%ZE*D7**D7% GX+='"MD7%&$!-2 : /#T28RQ•507:*B· _T¸¹H\±50º'."PA
"$D7/T'0/#-D7%dE*D7**D7% Gf !-.&!-/#-07"z'.!8;'."$T2d-%~/#-B6 : &e'&!D[-%;'.0'."PA
"$:*B6&!D7-%*"€"$: /UOd'"X-% A+€'#R3<w:*% /&!D7-% "#H
|@-T+5#VTK/0º'."$"$D7/T'0f-%*A+='TR”<>:*%*/U&!D[-%*"Bc'#R»% -&S89‘O*'.e2
'G'D7%*"P&u?:;'.%&!: B¨'2V!"!'!D["#H q h*-.Q¼ 'B6*07K<L'./&!-!D7%*Gi'.%;2
2 D7"$/!U&!N07-Gi'!N% -&)O;'.e2‘D7%‘&!O N?:*'%&!:*B¨/T'."$· ¦_T¸¹H
hMD7%;2A
D7%*G3'fG--2/T'.%;2Dº2 '.&!Q<w-.'f-% A+€'#Rd<>:*% /&!D7-%S"$#/#:!)t '.G'.D[% "P&
?:;'.%&!: Bg'2 V!"!'!D7#"zD7"('%dD[B69-.$&e'%&X-9%d !-8*07#B~H
½ %)&!O €-&!O \O;'.%;2}K?:;'%&!: B£B6#/eO;'.%*D7/#"a'0707-T+X"W&!-2-l"$-B6
-&!O ~/U$R &!-G.e'*O D7/F&e'"$‚"3+XD7&!O -:&S'%R¾/-B6*:&e'.&!D7-%*'0'."PA
"$:*B6&!D7-%*"#H q `=O*3-% 0YRo'"$"$: B6 &!D7-%¿% #T2 #2<w-u&!O*3"$#/#: !DY&JR
!--.<=D7"l&!O*ZV'07D[2 DY&4RS-.<€?:;'.%&!: B§B6#/UO*'% D[/"#H `=O*fB6-"P&@<L'A
B6-: "X¼ 'B6*07D7"z&!O Q?:;'%&!: Bg‚Rd2 D7"P&$!D78*:&!D[t -%1· ÀK´K1›#³K¦]K
¦Á¸H­`=O*F?: #"P&!D7-%,D7"#ÂÃ/#'%”+=S!#*0['/&!O*i/#-B6 : &e'&!D[-%;'.0
'"$"$: B6 &!D7-% "c-<l&!O /#0['"$"$D7/T'0@/T'"$S8RÄD[%<w-.!Bc'.&!D7-%A¹&!O #-!U&!D[/
"$#/#:!DY&4RND[%3&!O*?:*'%&!:*Bg/#'"$l<w-.z&!O l/#-D[%NE;D7* D[% GÅ
h*-.8*DY&/#-B6B6DY&!B6#%& q '6!#0['.&!T2i/$R &!-Ge' O*D7/u!D7B6D7&!D7V K
&!O*D7"MD7"yD7B69-"$"$D78 0[·7›#ÁK ›^K›T²¸ r HM`=O*=D[2T'"M-.<*&!O D["1D[B69-"$"$D78*D707D7&Jt R
!--.<9/T'.%f89=:*"$#2Z&!-@"$O -T+Ä&!O*'.&y&!O !=D7"\%*-l?:*'%&!:*BÆ !-&!-/-0
<w-.9$<>#/&S?:;'.%&!:*BÇ/#-D[%”E;D7 *D7%*G q ?:;'.%&!: BÇ/#-D7%”E;D7* D7%*G
+XDY&!Ou8 Dº'."\] ·Y›T^K¦›¸H\|@-T+5#VTK.&!O*D7"M"P&!D7070 07T'TV"M&!O*59-"$"$D78*D707D7&JR
&!O;'&l&!O*U!)t B6D7GO&@89u?:;'.%&!:*B­ !-&!-/-07"l+XDY&!O'.%'!8*DY&$e'.!D70YR
"$Bc'070}8*D['"(nXÈm]H
« Ve'0!-&!-/#-07"M<w-a?:*'%&!:*B”/#-D[%ZE;D7* D7%*GXO;'TVa89##%Z !-.A
9-"$#2}H3`=O*)–*!"P&Q+€'."Q&!O f !-.&!-/#-0a8R¯@-0[2 #%89!Gd&TH '0LH[·7›#].¸
+XO*-S: "$T2‘'~+=T'.‚u2 –*%*DY&!D7-%¿-.<z"$/#: !DY&4R*Éc'%*2G'TVN'~ !-.A
&!-/#-0yD[%+XO D[/eOi'%R2D7"$O*-% #"P&l 0['TRl/T'.%S'/eO*D7#VZO*D7"@2 #"$DY!T2
-:&!/#-B6z+XD7&!Od !-8*'8 D[07DY&4Rd'.&(B6-"P&(]H ³¦^H7H7H
“zO*'.!-%*-Vf&TH '0LH[· ¦¸}G'TV@'Z!-&!-/#-0;+XDY&!O3&!O z"P&$!-%*GU€"$#/#:A
!DY&4R@G:;'e'%&!#W-<Êl–*%*DY&!D7-%6›H1I4%l&!O*D71 !-.&!-/#-0LK%*-X2 D7"$O -%*"P&
;'$&4Rd/T'%F'/eO*D7#VZ-% )-: &!/#-B6+XD7&!Oi !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRB6-!&!O*'%
]H ²›#´ÀH7H[H5•5-.&!O3-.<&!O*-"$X!#"$: 07&!"W:*"$X"$D7B6*07X !-.&!-/#-07"€'.%;2fGD7V
!-V'8 0[@G:;'e'%&!##"z'89-: &X&!O*D7X"$/#: !DY&4RH
`=O*U!€O;'"y89#%u"$-B6=ˁ-$&\&!-z/#-% "P&$!:*/&aB6-!5/#-B6 0[D7/T'&!T2
!-.&!-/#-07"Z+XO*D7/UOF+=-: 0[2¿'/eO*D7#Vc'!8*DY&$e'.!D70YR‘"$Bc'.0[0Wn6Èv]Hd“€&
07T'"P&a&4+5-l !-.&!-/#-07"aO;'TV€89#%u !-9-"$T2Ây8R)¬~'#R!"a&TH '0LH[· ¦›¸
r I¹&D7"l9-"$"$D78 0[K1O -+5#VTK&!-3O;'TV)?:;'%&!: Bj!-&!-/#-0["l<>-Q8 D7&
/ -B6B6D7&!B6%&W:*%*2 €?:*'%&!:*Bƒ/#-B6 07¼D7&JRc'"$"$: B6 &!D7-% " q ¼D7"PA
#
&!#% /#=-<;?:;'%&!: Bv›UA¹+='#RZ<>:*% /&!D7-%*" H « #WÊl:*Bc'.D["1&TH '0LH[· ³¸9'.%;2
t
±W!#9T'.:~&TH '0LH[· ^¸
É °@'B6#0YRK·Y›T]¸*'."$"$:*B6#"M&!O*'.&yDY&yD7"y‚%*-T+X%QD7%u'2 V'% /#W&!O*'.&\“(0[D7/#
+€'.%&!"l&!-d8*D['."Q&!O u/#-D7%&!-~]N'%;2F•5-8i+€'.%&!"l&!-N8*D['"QDY&&!-F›H
`=O*%KDY&aD7"W%*-: GOu&!-@GD7V€G:*'.e'.%&!#"5'.89-:&ažlŸ · —(¢»].¸*D7<9•5-8
D7"QO*-% #"P&8 : &Q“(0[D7/#6/eO*#'.&!"Q'%*2FžlŸ· —f¢{›¸aDY<X“z07D7/#fD7"QO*-%*#"P&
8*:&Q•5-8F/eO*T'&!"#HuIJ%F/-%&$e'"P&TK-:Z2 –*%*DY&!D7-%o›)!T?: D7!"l&!O;'.&
%*D7&!O W-<*0['#R!"a/T'%c8*D['."W&!O*X/#-D7%3D7%c'.%Rf2 DY!#/&!D7-%38R)B6-!
&!O;'.%~n#H
'.%;2u8R 9O;'% Gl&TH '0LH[· ¦³¸¹HW°@-%*=-.<9&!O*#BkO*'2Z !-V'.8*07€"$#/#:!DY&4R
G :;'e'%&!##"c8*:&689-&!Oo+=U!/#-% P#/&!:!T2Ä&!-'/eO*D7#V~'%¾'!8*DYA
&$e'!D707Rd"$Bc'070Mn(Ⱦ]u<>-'.%' !- !D['.&!Q/eO*-D7/#Q-.<W*'.e'.B6&!!"#H
•W-&!O‘-.<€&!O*#BC+5!c#V#%&!:*'070YRF8!-‚%Â&!O*6!-&!-/#-05-.<· ¦›¸
+='")8 !-‚#%‘8R¿¯@-.&$&!#"$Bc'%‘'%;2 « D7B6-%m·Y›T¦¸X'.%;2 "$0º'.:»·Y›#´¸
'.%;2c&!O* !-.&!-/#-0}-<X· ¦.³.¸D["XD7%*"$/#: !89#/#':*"$-.<y-:z`=O*#-.!#B
ÀH
IJ%~&!O*D7"@*'9TK9+5)GD7Vu'6"$D7B6*07Z !-.&!-/#-0yD7%~+XO*D7/eOS%*-32 D7"PA
O -% #"P&\;'$&4RQ/T'.%6'/eO*D7#V5-%*5-: &!/-B6W+XDY&!O) !-8*'8 D[07DY&4RZB6-.!
&!O*'%]H ^_H
`=O #%K*+=Q"$O*-T+£&!O*'.&z-:@!-&!-/#-0yD["(&!O*Q89#"P&zD7%S'f/#0['"$"l-.<
!-&!-/#-07"X&!O*'.&XD7%*/0[:*2 #"5-: X!-&!-/#-0LK &!O @ !-.&!-/#-0}-<=· ¦T¸'%;2
-.&!O*("$D7B6D70['.( !-.&!-/#-07"#H
½ :&!O DYe2z!#"$:*0Y& q `=O*#-.!#B,À "$O -T+X"&!O;'&TKDY< -%*\/T'.%Q'/eO*D7#V
'.%S'.!8 D7&$e'!D707R~"$Bc'070M8*D['."lnzȔ]t K;&!O*%-%*Q% #T2 "X&!-6:*"$QB6-.!
'.%;2iB6-!)!-:*%*2 "l-.<=/#-B6Bu:*% D7/T'.&!D7-% q ‡;…Ž
!Ž@„!…
‡ †„ ŽJŒ
‡
†wŽ N†>‡ ‘„!…‡ eŽ .‡*Žu‡
eŒ … $… ‡
Hðl'.B6#0YRKW'
/-D7%E;D7* D[% G3'07G-.!D7&!O B­+XDY&!Oi'68*D['"@n@%*T2 "X&!-ct O;'TVZ'.&@0[#'"P&
plq 07-G=07-GNr !-:*%;2"#HaI4%d*'.$&!D7/#: 0º'TK*&!O D["XB6T'.%*"€&!O;'&X&!O*l*'.$A
'.070[0}!#9U&!s D7&!t D7-%N<L'.D70["=<>-(?:;'.%&!:*Bv/#-D7%NE*D7**D7% G H q¹½ % @/T'.%*%*-.&
2#/!T'."$i&!O 8*D['"N'.!8 DY&$e'.!D70YR¾8Ro!#9T'.&!D7% G‘&!O* !-.&!-/#-0@D[%
*'.e'.0[07#05Bc'%R&!D7B6#"#H `=O*D7"u'.07"$-"$O*-T+X"Z&!O*'.&Q&!O*u/#-% P#/&!:!
-.<6· ¦³¸@&!O;'&f&!O*D7NÀA¹!t -:*%*2Ä!-&!-/#-0@'./UO D[V#"3'%m'.!8*DY&$e'!D[0YR
"$Bc'.070Xndȧ]D7<z"$: f/#D7#%&!07R‘Bc'%R¿?:*8 DY&!"f'.!c&$e'% "$B6DY&$&!T2¿D[%
#'/eOd!-: %;2ND7"€+€!-% G H
`=O u!-07f-.<5!-:*%;2"lD7%?:*'%&!:*B­/#-B6B):*% D[/#'.&!D7-%SO;'."l89##%
"P&!:*2 D7T2lD7%Z'€2 DYˁ!#%&/#-%&!¼& q ?:;'%&!: B»/#-B6B):*%*D7/T'&!D7-%l/#-BfA
07¼D7&JRQ-<*9-D7%&! P: B6*D7%*G 8R 0[':*/e‚&THM'0LH*· ¦¦¸Ha“Ä9-*: 0º'
"$:!VR3-<y?:*'%&!:*Bx/$R &!-t G.e' ORcD7"@¯@-&$&!#"$Bc'.%~'.%;2 }-*·Y››U¸¹H
! #"
$
#
2.
&%
'
PRELIMINARIES
2.1 Quantum states
)8!D7E*RD7%&$!-2 : /#)&!O )
% -&!D7-% l
" :*"$#2iD7%&!O*D7"l*'9THZh*-.
B6-.!Q2 &e'.D70[#2d¼*0['%*'.&!D7-% (
" '%;23¼ ' B6 0["#K*"$#6· ¦´¸H
(*),+-/.101201-.43l“(%59A42D7B6#%*"$D7-%*'0z*: !S?:*'%&!:*BÇ"P&e'&!FD7"N'
V#/U&!-76 8:u
9 ˜ ±<
; -.<X%*-.!B ›H=} &76 ]49UK>6 ›?9UK:@1@1@7KA6 5/B,›C9
89'.%N-.$&!O*-% -!Bc'.0}8*'"$D7"=<w-. ± ; Ha`=O #%K '%Rc : !@"P&e'&!
/T'.%689(U¼ !#"$"$T26'."D6 8:\
9 ¢FE ;HJILG Kr M H 6 NOM9 <w-5"$-B6 M K ˜ ±@K
˜ ±zKP@@1º@ K
˜ ±@H « D7%*/3&!O d%*-.!B -.<6 8<)
9 D7"d›K
M 6 r 6 É(¢£›H M ;G r
MH
`=O*3"$D7B6*07#"P&u"$9#/#D['0€/T'."$dD7"”
5 ¢C¦H`=O*#%}Ka&!O N8*'"$D7"
<w-. ±XÉX/-%*"$D7"P&!"€-.<&J+=-QV#/&!-.!"*6 ]Qa
9 '%;2R6 ›?W9 '%;2c'.%Ru*:!
"P&e'.&!€D7"\-<9<>-!B
6M ]Q.9 ªc¡46 ›?U9 K M ˜ ±@K¡@˜ ±@KS6 M 6 É ª/6 ¡Q6 É ¢£›H
« : /UOd?:;'%&!: Bx"PR"P&!#B{D7"X/T'0707T2''
‡ ŽT †wŽPUO †>ŽWV H
‘S-.<>&!#%»07--‚¾'.&X6 8<3
9 '."~'‘/#-07:*B6%»V#/U&!-3/#-% "$D7"P&!D[% G
-<f/#-6
$ /#D7#%&!" M H H `=O*#%}K+=‘: "$ZY8D=6 &!-m2 #% -&!&!O /#-%P : G'&!N&$e'% "$9-"$3-<6 8:U9 H[Y8D1
6 D7"u'!-T+xV#/&!-.f/#-% A
"$D7"P&!D7%*Gi-< H q /#-B6*07¼‘/-%4 :*G'.&!#"f-.< H HiI4%‘&!O D7")% -A
M\ 9 2 #% -&!#")&!O*dD7% %*6!-2 : M /&ft -.<Dv
&e'.&!D7-%KDY8]6 ^,Z
8 '%*2_M^ H
q IJ<`6 8<Z
9 ¢aE M H 6 NOU9 K>6 ^bQ9 ¢aj
E ¡ H 6 NOU9 Ky&!O*#%cY8D6 ^bZ9 ¢ M H\ ¡ H H t
6 8:9Yd^e6 2 %*-&!"W&!O*(-:&!€!-2 :*/U&=-<,Ã
8 '%;2f^ q '.%757g5
Bc'.&$!DY¼c+XDY&!O~#%&$!D7#" H ¡ h H
M \t
ikjJl,-mZ.10201-.4@3 “”B6DY¼T2f"P&e'&!@D7"€'Q/#0['"$"$D7/T'0} !-8;'.8*D707D7&JR32 D7"PA
n
n ¢j›c-VZ*:!
&$!D78*:&!D[-% qon H š?6 8 H 9 K\]
›KpE
t '.%&!: © BÆ"PH R© "P&!#B£2 #"$H /U!H D[89#2)8RQ'zB6DY¼T2
"P&e'.&!"A6 8 H U9 Hy`=O €?:;
"P&e'.&!D7"(D7%N&!O*@*: !"P&e'&!f6 8 H 5
9 +XDY&!O~!-8;'.8*D707DY&4R n H H
“¨B6DY¼ #2¾"P&e'.&!/#'%”89'.07"$-¾2 "$/!D789T2»8R¾D7&!"d2 #% "$DY&4R
Bc'.&$!DY¼ F¢
H~IJ&Z/T'.%‘89c"$O*-T+X%&!O*'.&)'%R
2 %*"$DY&4R6Bc'&$!DY¼cO;'"W&$e'/#Z›H q
Ž „eŒ5-<y'QBc'.&$!DY¼cD7"5&!O "$:*B{-.<yDY&!"(2 D['G-%;'.01#%&$!D7#"#H
t
/q
E H n H 6 8 H 9 Y8 H 6
Or “£?:;'.%&!: Bg"PR"P&!#B{/T'.%d:*%*2 !G-u&4+5-f8;'."$D7/Z-9e'.&!D7-%*"#Â
'u:*% D7&e'$R3#V-07:&!D[-%'%*2d'uB6#'"$: !B6#%&TH
sutjJ012+?v_-w#xSyz)0CjJxSt§ÂW“{‡ †wŽ|3Ž ‡
}#…ŽL†…‡u~£D7"@')0[D7%A
T'.Q&$e'% "P<w-.!Bc'.&!D7-%¿-% ±:3&!O;'&Z !#"$!V#"&!O*€ % -!B
É
q DH H7K)Bc' "V#/&!-.!"i-.<6:*% DY&F% -!B
&!-¾V#/&!-!"S-.<6:*% D7&
%*-!B H
t
IJ<4K}89<>-!u'* 0YR D7% G ZK9&!O u"PR"P&!#B§+€'"D7%i'c*: !Z"P&e'.&!
UK &!O #%N&!O l"P&e'.&!Q'<>&!(&!O*z&$e'%*"P<>-!Bc'&!D[-%~D7"
UH
6 8<9
=~
7~
*~6 8<9
IJ<4K189<w-.! ZK1&!O u"PR"P&!#B +€'."QD[%'NB6DY¼T2S"P&e'.&!f+XDY&!O‘'
2 #% "$D7&JRcBc'.&$!DY¼ 9K&!O*l"P&e'&!Q'.<º&!X&!O*z&$e'.%*"P<>-!Bc'.&!D7-%~D7"
&!O*lB6DY¼T2c"P&e'.&!+XDY&!Od&!O*2#%*"$DY&JRNBc'&$!DY¼
#H
q
=~>q~D
(D+?x‚-ƒ0CjJw#-…„…-2S.C)+?-„…-tL0C.‘Â3“z%o-8 "$!V'.8*073D["f'F2#/#-BfA
9-"$DY&!D7-%i-< ±>f
 D7%&!-c-$&!O*-G-%;'0\"$: 8*"$;'./##"D† K‡@1@C@7KL†fˆJÂ
± ; ¢k†
† É ‰ @1@C@ ‰ †f4ˆ H“kB6T'"$:!#B6#%&(r -<5'3 : !
rŠ‰
"P&e'.&!'6 8<X
9 +XDY&!O!#"$9#/&z&!-3&!O D["z-8 "$!V'.8*07ZGD7V#"@&!O Z!UA
"$:*0Y&`z
N +XDY&!O¿ !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR‹ ž H 6 8<91#‹ Éf+XO*!3ž H 6 8:9 2 %*-&!"
&!O*3 !-?P #/&!D7-%¾-<6 8:Z
9 &!-S&!O*N"$:*8*"$*'/#7† H Hē(<>&!Uf&!O*
B6T'"$:!#B6#%&TKT&!O*="P&e'&!=-< &!O*W"PR "P&!B¤89#/#-B6#"TŒ4|Ž S H
‘ ŒŽ S ‘
“oB6-.!5G#%*e'.0/#0['"$"y-<*B6T'"$:!#B6#%&!"'.!€µ ½>’ ¬vB6T'A
"$: !#B6#%&!" q "$#3· ¦´¸ HlIJ%B6-"P&z-<a&!O*D7"@*'9TKDY&(+XD70[0\89
"$:6
$ /#D7#%&€&!-f/-%*"$D[2t @!-4 #/&!D7VB6T'."$: !#B6%&!"#H
2.2 Bipartite states
“j}”•2+?0CjJ0-X.101201-.43@IJ%6&!O*z'%;'.0YR
"$D7"€-.<M?:;'.%&!:*Bb/#-D7%cE;D7* D7%*G
! -&!-/-07"#K+5=-<º&!#%uO*'V='(?:*'%&!:*B,"P&e'.&!5;'.$&M-<;+XO D[/eO
D["ZO*0º2F8R“z07D7/#3'%*2F&!O*6-.&!O*);'$&Z8R•5-8HSh*-.Z¼A
'B6*07K1+=c/T'%¿O*'TVf&!O* aµa®g"P&e'&! q &!O*6"P&e'.&!3-<€&J+=r › › K.+XDY&!O)&!O a– !"P&\?:*8*DY&1O*#0[2Q8R
?: 8*DY&!" r ] ] #ª
t
É
É
“z07D7/#f'.%;2&!O*u"$/#-%*2F?:*8 DY&lO*0º2S8RS•5-8H « : /UOS"P&e'.&!"
'.!/T'.0[07T2 † ‰ UŽL†>ŽJŒX"P&e'&!#"#H
!–
6
4
1
9
6
4
9
6
?
1
9
6
?9
—
—
˜ +?2SƒQjJt™x#)0l3 IJ<)“(0[D7/#FB6T'"$:!#"dO D7"d;'$&TK•5-8,š "~*'.$&~89UA
/#-B6#"l'NB6DY¼T2i"P&e'&!Huh*-Q¼ '.B6*07K}DY<X“z07D7/#fB6T'."$: !#"
&!O*X–*!"P&€?: 8*DY&=-.<&!O ]a
– µa®»"P&e'&!@D7%c&!O*(8;'"$D7"=/-%*"$D7"P&!D7%*G
-<e6 ]Qy
9 '.%;2u6 ›CU9 K•5-8,š "W"P&e'&!€89#/#-B6#"A6 ]Q19 +XDY&!Of !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR
›?
› ¦Z'%*2/6 ›CW9 +XD7&!O3 !-8;'.8*D707D7&JR›?› ¦Hp &œf
q 89z&!O @2#%*"$DY&JR
Bc'.&$!DY¼3-<\&!O*B6DY¼T2N"P&e'&!&!O;'.&z•5-8~GU&!"zDY<W“z07D7/#B6T'A
"$: !#"QO*UQ;'.$&Q-.<X'd8 D[*'.$&!DY&!f"P&e'&!R6 8<U9 Hc`=O*%K1+56"!'#R
&!O;'.&‘
q D7"6-8&e'D7%*#2o8R¾Ž „†w‡Šo… Ž5&!O*~“(07D[/4š "f;'$&6-<
6 8<U9 H
`=O*!'!@Bc'.%R62 DYˁ!#%&=+='TR"=O -T+,“z07D7/#l/T'.%NB6T'."$: !
q &$e'/#Z-:& O @*'.$&TH(|@-T+5#VTK9&!O R~'.070yGD7VQ&!O*Q"!'B6
2 #% "$D7&JR3Bc'.t &$!DY¼ 6<w-z•5-8 "(;'.$&TH
fq
,š
(*)+j}eƒ20CjJxStp3`&‡Qq 89='zB6DY¼T2Z"P&e'&!H\`=O #%K'%RZ*:!5"P&e'.&!
6 8<9X-.<a'60º'!G@"PR"P&!#B{&!O;'.&(GD[V#"P3
q DY<W'f;'.$&z-<\"PR"P&!#B
D["€&$e'./#T2d-: &XD7"z/#'0707T2~')‰Se † 5„
ŽL†L…‡c-<‡q9H
2.3 Distance measures between quantum states
‘X: "$(&J+=-ZB6T'"$:!#"W-.<M2D7"P&e'%*/z89&J+=#%N?:*'%&!:*Bb"P&e'.&!"
q !#!#"$#%&!T2”8R»2 #% "$D7&JR»Bc'.&$!D7/#" ÂÃ&$e'./#‘2D["P&e'.%*/#‘'%;2¾– A
2 0[DY&JRHah*-€B6-.!@D7% <>-!Bc'&!D[-%~-%c&!O*t "$ q '%*23-.&!O* B6T'."$: !#"
-<a2D7"P&e'%*/89&4+5##%~2#%*"$DY&JRNBc'&$!D7/##"#K "$#c· ²K9¦´¸H t
˜ +?2Sƒ4-Rmjz.1012Stƒ4-#3*U& n ¢ qon r š1@@1@Tš n  t '%*2=ž6¢ q ž r š1@1@@#šŸž  t
893&J+=-S/#0['"$"$D7/T'.0z!-8;'.8*D707DY&4Ro2D["P&$!D78 : &!D7-% "#H¿`=O*%K\&!O*
U † ŽL†…‡S4¡•" †Je
Ž. ‡9„eŒX89U&4+=#% n '.%;27ž)D7"
6 n BXž6¢ ¢  6 n H B…ž H 6 @
H}I r
`=O*FV'!D['.&!D7-%*'0)2 D7"P&e'% /#/eO;'e'/&!!D#"iO -T+
/T'.%2 D7"P&!D7%*G:*D7"$Od&!O*l2 D7"P&$!D78*: &!D7-%*"
'%*2 H
n
ƒÀH $
1ŒUŽ•q
q eŒZŽ W…7u† ŒŸ"f
eŽ.ŽJŒ
\†wŽ
|‰‰…UŽ†w‡_ l†z¡WUŒeŽ]
‰r „eŒ† É
‡ l†¡WeŒeŽ]
‰„eŒ~… " †zc
ŒU‡!
†…‡… ŽA¡[ŒŸ
!Ž\2 D7B q † t ‡S"u6 ^ H 9`‡Q‰Se† 5„ŽL†….‡
… ]q
†>‡'†
’
*ŒU‡ Ž *Œ!Œ6†z
'¡7…T„4¡‡‡*†>ŽŽ ‡
#…|H ŽL†….‡={
~ …‡ Ž ŽœU‰S
&6 ^ É 9lŽ¹…76 ^ É 9\¢ _~6 ^ É 9
| „ dŽ Ž
6oYd^ r 6 ^ É 916 É ¢ q q r š q É t @
+=#070Z-% už
D
I4%3&!O*Q?:;'.%&!:*Bx/#'"$K;&!O l/#-:*%&!!;'$&(-<a'u!-8;'.8*D707DY&4R
2 D7"P&$!D78*:&!D7-%iD["l'3B6DY¼T2"P&e'.&!HZ`=O u/#-:*%&!!*'.$&-.<W&!O V'.!D['.&!D7-%*'02 D7"P&e'% /#D7"=&!O*@&$e'./#2D["P&e'.%*/#HWI¹&€D7"(2 –*%*T2
'"€<>-0707-+X"#H

Z‹ ‹
Dq c
B q
q q
q
!q
n
d Ÿ Ÿ"'!
"'
*q S"q
!VD Ÿ
J
f Ÿ
#4¡" z
‹q BRq
n QQ ¡
#¡ ! Ÿ
f U S O
6 n B n 6 ‹q Bq
> Z" J
‹ S"
§›H$MŒUŽ eŒiŽ!*ŒN‰ $…
† †>Ž
† "
Ž e† ŽL†…‡ zŠŒU‡9Œ ŽJŒ
e‰‰ .†w‡Š
6Œ
$Œ cŒU‡ Ž#
¹Ž …
u†$Œ
!Ž ŽJŒ
‡
’&%' ŒU‡ #…
‡
7‰ $… Œ$„ŽL† ŒN…
r
É
(*),+cŒ
!Œ 6ŒU‡*Ž.#
‡
r
É
Ž!*Œ $Œ3Œ/$† eŽ
cŒ
!Œ cŒU‡ Ž0#
Ž! Ž © „ †¹Œ Œ QŽ!*Œ
U1† "
ŽL†….‡
† !Ž ‡9„eŒ
’
r
É
‹
NM
p6 6
D
`=O*X&$e'/(% -!Bv-<'lBc'.&$!DY¼mD7"W&!O*€&$e'./#z-.< .+XO !
}
¢ vD["Q&!O*u9-"$DY&!D7V6"!?:;'.!f!--.&u-.< ZH6
2 %*-&!c&!O*c&$e'/N% -!B -<§8R eH‘`=O*c<w-0707-T+XD7%*G
q +XO D7/UOm+5
07#B6Bc'i!0º'&!#"c&!O*~&$e'/%*-!B
-.<
r
É
'07"$-i/T'070=&$e'./#d2D7"P&e'%*/N89&J+=#%
'.%;2
+XD7&!O¿&!O r
É
V'.!D['.&!D7-%*'02D["P&e'.%*/#X89&J+=#%c2 D7"P&$!D78*: &!D7-%*"5-8 t &e'.D[% T2f8R
B6T'."$: !D7%*G
'%;2
H
r
É
6 6
H$
9K
O%'
K
K
!
!
!
!
AG
LI
"
QPRM
?
Q@
v´ HCS4C
D
q
@
q ršq
É t
¢UT!V(Ÿ
q rq
;'W
É
q
@
É
r
<X
-yJ20Cj}x#t e-0 `--t 01+?2Sƒ4-…m•jz.102St•ƒ4-R2t•m_em-yzj}0ve3l`=O y&$e'/#
2 D7"P&e'% /#Z'%;23&!O*l–92#07DY&4Rd'.!Q/#07-"$#0YRN!#0['.&!T2H€IJ<•q
'.%;2
r
q É '.!‘O*'.e2”&!-¾2 D7"P&!D7%*G:*D7"$OÆ<>-F•5-8K&!O*%£“(0[D7/#
/T'%
&$e'%*"P<>-!Ba6 8 1
9r D7%&!-l'z"P&e'&!=/#07-"$=&!-6 8 É 9'%;2ZVD[/#'zV!"!'H
Y
[Z
\
:;'%&!DY&e'.&!D7V07RK&!O D["€!#0['&!D[-%~D7"zGD7V#%d8R
]
‡6Ž W…u† ŒŸ"
!ŽŽJŒ
Aq r . ‡#"*q É
›
qq š q
‹|q r B/q É ‹ © ›:B q q r š q É t @
r
É t5© ¦
x_H76^1…
D
AB
›
‹|q B!q ‹
œ
Ajzm,-yJjJ0ve3*}&/6 8 r 9f'%*2k6 8 É 9f89d&4+5-‘8*D7;'$&!DY&!~"P&e'.&!#"#H }&
q r '.%;2q É 89@&!O*zB6DY¼ #23"P&e'&!#"€-8&e'D7%*T2c<>!-B 6 8 r 9W'%;2
6 8 É =9 8R6&$e'./#D7%*G6-: & q B6T'."$: !D7%*G t “z07D7/#4š "z*'.$&TH
x¦H $

J•q ¢cq Ž *ŒU‡ r ¡ †„eŒz„‡3ŽŸ‡
…| 6 8 r z9 †w‡ Ž¹…6 8 É 9Du ŽŸr . ‡
}# …É | ŽL†L…‡i…‡ Œ= ‰e Ž5… #
Ž *Œ`!
Ž
ŽJŒT’
1G
?
‘\/T'.%Q'0Y+€'#R"1/eO*--"$a&!O \B6T'"$:!#B6#%&.#
&!O;'&M'./UO D7#V#"
&!O*(V'.!D['.&!D7-%*'02D["P&e'.%*/#
D7"€'!-A
"$-&!O;'&2#
r
É
P/&!D7VfB6T'."$: !#B6#%&@'%*2iDY&O*'" 4:*"P&&4+5-N-: &!/#-B6#"#Â@]
'%*2i›H
FE/
JI
`_
@
1G
H$
I4%c;'$&!D[/:*0['.TKD@ q
¦H
q ršq
_
a@
œ‹|q r B7q É ‹ \¢
¢»]ZD7<1'%*26-%*0YRcDY<
É t
3
54
6798
!
3. A PROTOCOL WITH BIAS 0.25
(D+?xS01xbƒ4x#y3@ÊlU–;%*
"
6^
:
b
!
Bc
9W¢
g
edf
f
f
f
h*-.zU¼*'.B6*07K/#-%*"$D[2 X&!O 8*D7;'$&!D7&!"P&e'&!#"
6 8 r 9\¢
6 8 É 9a¢
›
¦
›
¦
f
f
fh
6 Q9 F6 ]›C9 t š
&6 ^
6 49 F6 ]›?9ª 6 ›#]Q9eB_6 ››C9 t š
— 6 Q9QBu6 C9
;
›T¥¦
]
6 ?9
C›
]
›T¥¦&<
>6 8 9
Z6 C9
6 8 9
?›
@
68 9
“ G#% e'07DT'.&!D7-%~-<10[B6Bc')¦D7"#Â\DY<1&!O*(&4+5-u2#%*"$DY&4RcBc'A
”
&$!D7/##"
'.%;2
'!~/#07-"$K€&!O #%ēz07D7/#~/T'.%Ã&$e'.%*"P<w-.!B
r
É
=D[%&!-u'u"P&e'.&! 9? W&!O;'&XD["(/#07-"$&!UH
r
É
r
I4%6&!O D["W/T'"$K&!O (2 D7"P&e'% /#@89&J+=#%c&!O (&J+=-Z2 %*"$DY&4R6Bc'A
&$!D7/##"D["1B6T'"$:!T2@8R@&!O \–;2 #07DY&4*
R @ q
š
HM`=O*y–92#07DY&4R
r
É t
É K1-.V
D7"Z2 –*%*T2F'A
" @ q
š
¢vBc'.¼
r
r
É
É
CB
'070M/eO*-D7/##"(-<
X'.%;2 t
5&!O;'&@GD[V)2#%*"$DY&JRdBc'&$!D[/#"
r
É
'%*2
+XO #%~'u*'.$&(-<\"PR"P&!#BxD["€&$e'./#T2d-: &TH
r
É
q
!q
q
!6 8 9
q q
P6 8 9 6 8 9
DY<y¡(¢£›Kji3¢£›
¡¿˜ƒ™]šT›œF'%*2`ik˜
9
P6 ^
6^
9
6 ^
9
´ H ½ &!O*$+XD7"$K &!O*@!#"$: 0Y&z-.<M&!O*/-D7%dE;D7ND["X¡
d
z
S
9
4¡ z
@
‰
¡ ?H
ǛHs%' Œ † … lŽ!† =‰ P…Ž¹…T„!… 1† =] ¦_ ’
&6 8 9
q
Bc
@
DY<y¡(¢£›Kji3¢»]
ÀH€“z07D7/#@"$#%*2 "€¡('%*2:i3&!-u•W-8KO @/eO*#/e‚"=DY<1&!O*("P&e'.&!z&!O;'.&
q 8RQB6T'A
O*=!#/#D[VT2)<>!-Bb“z07D7/#XD7%u&!O*@›lk!my"P&!#fD7" .b
Bc
"$: !D7%*GoDY&dD7%»+XDY&!O¾!#"$9#/&N&!-oD[%”'¿8*'"$D7"d/#-%*"$D7"P&!D7%*GÄ-<
b
l'.%;2i&J+=-NV#/&!-.!"-$&!O*-G-%;'0a&!-dDY&
HfI¹<5&!O f-:&$A
Bc
/#-B6Q-<\&!O ZB6#'"$: !B6#%&zD7"z%*-& b UK97t O*n QO;'."@/T'.:*GO&
Bc
“z07D7/#/UO T'.&!D7% G6'%*2NO*"P&!-*"€&!O*@ !-&!-/-0LH
oRp.q.rD
•WR607#B6Bc'Q¦K&!O*D7"=B6T'.%*"\&!O;'&€“z07D7/#z/T'%6&$e'% P" <w-.!B
r
7D %&!UH1I4%*2 #T2KT"$O*a2-=&!O;'.&8Rl'.* 07RD7%*G=&!O \l
| '2 'Bc'e2
É
&$e'% "P<w-.!B>=C&!-uO*(?:*8 DY&TH
68 9
DY<y¡(¢»]Kji3¢£›
¦H€•5-8 D[/e‚"@'6: %*DY<w-.!B607RNe'%*2 -B§¡?\˜™]šT›œK"$#%*2 "(¡?1&!“z07D7/#H
q ]] 1ª
— 6 Q9
É
DY<y¡(¢»]Kji3¢»]
›H€“z07D7/#*D7/e‚"c'F:*%*DY<>-!B60YRoe'%;2-B
™.]šT›œ)'%*2d"$#%*2 " b =&!-f•5-8}H
q ]] 1ª
C›
— r É 6Y›C9
— r É Y6 ›C9
— r É 6 ¦9
— r 6 ¦9
É
f
+XDY&!Of&!O*€–*!"P&5?:*8 D7&aO #0[2f8Ru“z07D7/#('%*2u&!O*X"$#/#-%;26?:*8 DY&
O*0º2N8R3•W-8HaI¹<\“z07D7/#B6T'."$: !#"XO*U(?: 8*DY&X-<
UK •5-8
r
D7"Q0[U<>&Z+XD7&!O ] @+XDY&!O¿'d !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRÛ ¦d'.%;2 › l+XDY&!O'
!-8;'.8*D707D7&JRm› ¦HSI¹<(“z07D7/#3B6T'"$:!#"QO*u?:*8*DY&Z-<
UK
É
r q ] \ª
•5-8¿D["Z07<>&Z+XDY&!O
›
+XD7&!Oo'N !-8*'8 D[07DY&4RÛ ¦
t
É
'%*2
r q ]
Y›
+XD7&!Of'@ !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR3› ¦Ha•5-&!Of-.<;&!O*-"$
t
É
"P&e'.&!"zO*'V@&!O*l"!'.B62 %*"$DY&4R3Bc'.&$!DY¼
c6 Q9
C›
— r É 6 ]491ª
— r É 6 ]49eB
— r É 6 ]419 ª
— r 6 ]49eB
u6 8 9
q q
Ž   oŽ   6oY8 6 8 916
q -.
t2rDq'q.uv(89-: %;23&!O !-8;'8 D70[DY&JRd-.<\2 D7"$O*-%*#"P&@“z07D7/#
2 D7"$O -%*"P&l•5-8
'/eO*D7#VD7%*G6¡
¡?}¢Æ]HX`=O*QBc'.¼D7Bu: Bg !-8;'A
8*D707DY&4RZ-<9'/eO*D7#Vt D7%*G@¡
¡ ? ¢£›€D7"M&!O ="!'B6W89#/T': "$=&!O*W !-&!-/-0
D7"X"PR B6B6U&$!D[/H
w
Œ(y
 x
†„eŒ=† 0 …‡9Œ !Ž
… z„*Œ Ž ’\IJ< ¡X¢»]K“z07D7/#="$#%*2 "y'
z
B6DY¼T2@"P&e'.&!\&!O;'&MD7"1#?:*'0.&!- r q ] eª ›
+XDY&!OZ!-8*'8*D707DY&4R)› ¦
t
É
'%*2
r q ]
›
+XDY&!Oi!-8*'8*D707DY&4R¿› ¦H@IJ<W¡¢ƒ›K"$O*u"$%;2 "
t
É
r q ] ;ª ¦
'QB6D7¼T2f"P&e'&!z&!O*'.&=D7"=#?:*'0;&!+XDY&!O3 !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR
t
É
h -lU¼*'.B6*07K DY<W¡z{
¢ id¢Æ]K;&!O*%•5-8/-:*0[2~B6T'."$: !QD7%~&!O*
n
8;
'."$D7"
\¢
r ] 1ª
r Y› UKÆr ]
r Y› UK ¦ UH
É
É
É
É
r ¡
J
— 6 49ŠBF6 ?9
6 ^ KŸK 9
— 6 49
‰
‰
4
Ÿ 6
4
9
6 ?9
—
C›
— 6 Q9 6 49
— 6 C9 — 6 Q9•B — 6 C9 ‡6 49
?›
C›
— 6 Q9>B 6 9
?›
› ¦¿'%*2
r q ]
¦
+XD7&!O»!-8*'8*D707DY&4R,› ¦Hk`=O S2 #% "$DY&4R
t
É
Bc'&$!D7/##"X-<y&!O #"$@&4+5-fB6DY¼T2N"P&e'&!#"('.!
qK
]É
¢
r
]
]
]É
r
]
q
]É
¢
r
r
]
]
]
]
r
É
'.%;2
Àd-.<Q· ¦T¸KM&!O*6!-8;'.8*D707DY&4R
¢j›HN•WR`=O*#-.!#B
r
l
¢
H
&!O*'.&z•5-8'/eO*D7#V"(¡€¢»¡ ? D7"('.&(B6-"P& r ª
n
w
#ΠSx
…
…‡9Œ !Ž
†„eŒQ„*Œ Ž ’ É
]
]
Z‹q K Bq ‹
4 r ¡
Ÿ }&]qd89Z&!O u2#%*"$DY&JR~Bc'.&$!DY¼-.<W&!O
]
z
&!O f›
‘ G ‘
Q"P&e'.&!u"$%&@8R“z07D7/#)D[%
"P&!#H
k!m
]
z
=
f"†z
….‡Œ
!Ž r ¡ †„eŒ Œ!Œ
:
:
• r ¡
p #" 5Ž *ŒA"ŒU‡
!†wŽ]Že†
œ |
›:
B r B É ] ] q ›
]
r ]
q ¢
t
xÁHs%'*Œ $Œc†
!Ž ŽJŒŠ
…
Ž! Œ !Ž ŽJŒ #ŒU‡ Ž
†e„ ŒW†w‡fŽ!*Œ=› k!m $… ‡
… Ž! Œ #…
D
7
R
!
?
]
G
]
H$
…*
U…cŒ r ‡S" É ‡#" r ¡ †„eŒ„ †¹Œ Œ
X¡(¢,¡
‰$ …QQ †¡ †>Ž
’
É
P&D~ K
~
r
¢
›
]
¢QP;K
t2rjq.q'uv
]
]
B›
]
]
]
›
›
~
]
¢
n
~
]
É
]
]
]
B›
B›
]
›
]
¢
]
]
&
cŒ
a†>Ž!~Ž!*Œ
G
?
]
›
]
›
B
]
@
q'
q8
R6 8<9
•~
9
LN
S~
6 ^ K 9 6 ^ 9
h*-.X'%RR6 8:9UK&!O z-VU!0º'.N89U&4+=#%u~ H 6 8:9W'.%;27~
&!O*@"!'B6Q'"€&!O l-V!0['~89U&4+=#%6 8:9='.%;26 ^
b
H 6^
H 6^
b
Bc
9aD7"
q
s%'
@
!
?
P&
t2rjq.q'uv
Bc
N
z
!
6 8<9W¢ ¢ M H 6 N 916 8 H 9
H
89l&!O l*:!DY–;/T'&!D[-%~-<q /eO*-"$#%~8RN“z07D7/#DY<y"$O*l+='%&€&!-f/#-% A
VD7%*/)•W-8&!O;'&@¡l¢£]Hzh*-.@#V$R6 8 H U9 K“z07D7/#Z"$#%;2"(&!-3•5-8S'
?
6M
H
+XO*D7/eO~D7"€&!O*l"!'.B6Q'"`6oY8D6 8
6 8 \9 ¢
H 6 É 6oY8 H 6 8 H 916 É
916 Éz<>-
¢ M H 6 NO916 8 H 9@
H
?
?
?
?
“z07D7/#ND["f&$$RD7%*GS&!-i/#-%VD7%*/#d•5-8o&!O;'&6¡S¢ ]HÃ`=O !<w-.!K
+=u/T'%F'"$"$: B6)&!O;'&"$O*f'0Y+€'#R""$#%;2"@&!-~•W-8F'd2 "$/!D7 &!D7-%
-<
Z-.
UH q ®z*0['/#D7% GF'S2#"$/!D7 &!D7-%o-.<
Q8R‘'
r Bc
B
B r
2 "$/!D7 &!D7-%f-.<
1/T'%)-% 07R)D7%*/!#'"$=&!O*5 !-8*'8 D[07DY&4R)-<9•5-8
Bc
'//## &!D7% Gz¡X¢»]K'.0Y&!O*-: GOZDY&MBc'#Rl"$D7Bu: 0Y&e'%*-:*"$0YRD7% /!T'"$a&!O*
!-8;'.8*D707D7&JRd-.<\“z07D7/#/T'.:*GO&(/eO*T'&!D7%*G H
t 2D[% G»'m2#"$/!D7 &!D7-%¤-<
“z07"$-KZ&!O !-8;'.8*D707DY&4RÆ-<c“(0[D7/#"$#%;
zD7"l&!O*)"!'B6f'."l&!O*Z !-8;'8 D70[DY&JRF-.<€“(0[D7/#)"$#%;2D7%*G~'32 UA
B
"$/!D7 &!D7-%¤-<
d89#/T'.:*"$KZ<w-.i#V$R i ˜¨™.]šT›œKZ&4+5-¾-<
B r
UK
UK
UK
a'.!@#?:*'0*&!W'.%;2
r
É
Bc
Bc
Bc
Bc
B
&4+5-6'.!#?:*'0&!UH
n
rB
`=O*U!<w-.!K•5-8 "W"$D[2 X-.<
? MD7"W'@:*% D7<>-!BbB6DY¼&!: !=-.<
B
'%*2
UKDLH H\DY&!"\2 %*"$DY&4RZBc'.&$!DY¼ZD7"
H\`=O*D7"\B6T'.%*"M&!O;'&
?
B r
q 9š
É
D7"('u*:!D7–*/T'.&!D7-%~-<
Ha`=O !<>-!K
?
@
H
©
t
ƒ³
H %'*Œ6‰ $…
† †>Ž Ä!Ž Ž
†„eŒ „ †¹Œ Œ c¡
¡ ? ¢
ª
] 4…
Œ † [ŒU‡*Ž
¡
¡ ?c¢
› ‘† .Ž 6… !Ž r q @ q ?š
t
É
q ?š
@
’
r t$t
6 ^ K K 9 =6 ^ K 9
e6 ^ K 9
6 ^
9
6^ K K 9
/6 ^ 9
~ K 6 ^ K 9 ~ 6 ^ K K 9 ~ 6 ^ K 9 ~ 6 ^ K 9
76 ^ K K 9
=6 ^ K 9
bš
Š6 8 z9
Š6 ^ K K 9
u6 ^ K 9
‡q K
>6 8 9
‡q K
e6oY8]6 8 z916
q qK
QQ ¡ r ¡ R ‰
q qK
U Ÿ 4¡ d¡ ‰
1V z
/ q q
(¾D7&!Od !-8*'8 D[07DY&4Ri›?›¦K;•5-8bš "(8*DY&(D7"z¡ ¢»]H5`=O*#%}K
&!-Ä'/eO*D7#Vi¡
¡ ¢Ç]K“(07D[/F% #T2 "3&!-o/#-%VD7%*/#iO*D7B
&!O;'.&
¡z¢£]H€•WR=}
#B6‰ Bc'6^K*"$O*Q"$:*//##T2"z+XDY&!O !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR'.&zB6-"P&
qq š q K H
»DY&!Oot !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR»›?
› ¦KX•5-8,š "f8*DY&6D7"6¡ l¢ ›HÄ`=O*#%}K=“(0[D7/#
%*T2 "€&!-f/#-%VD7% /#Q•5-8~&!O*'.&X¡(¢¤›Q'%*2d"$O*/#'%2-f&!O;'.&€+XDY&!O
q q ¹š q
!-8;'.8*D707D7&JR
H\`=O*=-VUe'070 !-8*'8*D707DY&4RQ&!O;'&a“z07D7/#€"$:*/UA
r
qq š q
/###2 "XD7"Sr q q q š q K t ª
H
r t$t
t
É
•WR7
B6Bc'Z´K
q q š q K ¢¤· (Ÿ q
q q K q t¸É
t
?
@
?
?
,@
?
@
@
?
?
?
@
~ q ~  k~ q~  ~ q~  ~ q~ 
…q h 
N K K / B:q ~ H q~ H  h 
&
N
qh
eh q 
g^H
*Œ@‰SP …QQ †¡ †wŽ~Ž Ž r ¡ †L„UŒf„!…‡ †w‡9„eŒ
Q… fŽ Ž
¡(¢»]d†z
*
Žœf
…!
Ž q q š q K t ’
D
¢
W
H 9U6 ^ H 9aD7"
b
Bc
9
µ !-8*'8 D[07DY&!D7#"\-<*-8 &e'.D7%*D7%*Gz]K›='.%;2QG&$&!D7% Gz/T'.:*GO&y'07"$-@"P&e'#R
y
&!O 6"!'B66DY<(“z07D7/#c*D7/e‚"Q'~:*%*DY<>-!B60YRSe'%;2-B ˜”™]šT›šU¦š!Àœ
'.%;2d&!O #%' *07D7#"
&!-689-.&!O~&!O*"P&e'.&!Z"$#%&zD[%~&!O 6› k!m=!-:*%;2
'.%;2d&!O )2#"$/!D7 &!D7-%i"$%&zD7%~&!O*ZÀ
!-:*%*2}H€IJ%~&!O*D7"z/#'"$K9&!O 2#%*"$DY&JR‘Bc'.&$!DY¼F-<(&!O*c"P&e'.&!3"$#%&)8R“z07D7/#3D7%‘&!O*› k!m !-:*%;2
q
r
D7"
?¢
ª
ª
ª
H¾h*-c#V$R
r
É
r
É
t
š £˜ƒ™›šU¦šeÀœK
¢ 9K q
D7"cT?:;n '.0X&!n <>-c&4+5l˜Ä™.]šT›še¦šeÀœ3'.%;2i&!<w-.Z&!t O )&J+=-d-.&!O* $Hf`=O*!<>-!K
¢»])<w-.@'.070
¢ 9K DH H ? D["X-.<y&!O*@<>-!B q › H
?
t
&~ H
`6WY8 H 6 8 H 916
?
h -.X'070 W˜™.]šT›še¦šeÀœK¡l˜™.]šT›.œKi~˜S™.]šT›œK
*
t #DY&!O*U
b
b
5-
UK*'%*2
B
B r
t
>6 ^ 9
6 8 H 9
t2rDq'q.uv
“("$"$:*B6u&!O*'.&Z“(0[D7/#KM89<>-!c"$#%;2D7%*GN&!O f"P&e'.&!
z&!-•5-8D[%
&!O z› k!m !-:*%;2K'* 07D["
&!-@DY&\'.%;2K.&!O #%K.D7%)&!O 5À (!-:*%*2}K!A
0['/##"5T'/eOc2 #"$/U!D[&!D7-%c-< .b y8R6'Q2 "$/!D7 &!D7-%c-<
b
UH
Bc
Bc
`=O #%K*“z07D7/#Z'/eO*D7#V#"€&!O*l-: &!/#-B6#"(]f'%*2i›Q'.%;2NG&!"(/T': GO&
+XDY&!Od&!O "!'B6l!-8*'8*D707DY&!D7#"@'."X89<w-.!Z89/T': "$
p~ H
œ6 ^
u6 8 H 9
2 "$/!D7 &!D7-%-.<5'f"P&e'&!
b
UK9¡˜™]šT›.œK
? 5+XO*D7/UOD7"z-%*Q-.<
Bc
~˜™.]šT›œH
`=O*%K;&!O !-8*'8 D[07DY&4Rd&!O;'.&@•5-8S'/#/# &!"
('."z&!O D["("P&e'.&!
É Ha`=O l&!-&e'0} !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRd-.<\•5-8S'/#/# &!D7%*GfD7"
D7"
9?
i
›
;
¢
q šq
« D7B6D70['.!0YRK'@ q
<w-.!K
?
V
›
¢
›
;
q
U&‘¢
&!O;'&
:B r B É t
"! r
ª
É
q šŸq K t
q
@
>B r B É ª
q ›
¦
ª
¦
r ª
q šq
ª&@ q
?
›
ª
É
›
¦
:B r B É ª ›¦
q r
B É
— ›:B r ¢
r t
›
q
?
¦
¢
_
?
›
¦
_
r t
?
›
É ª q
¦
É ª
@
É
r
<
—rÉ
É Hu`=O*!UA
É t
r t$t
:B r B É ª
›
›
:B r B É
›
q
r
¦
ª
É t <
q ¦
HÃ`=O*d/-%V¼DY&4R¿-.<@&!O d"!?:;'!N!--&cD7B6 0[D7#"t
¦ f'.%;2 q ¦ D7"z'&(B6-"P&
É ©
t
›
q › ‘¦
›
XªÄD
¦ _
¦
t
¦
# :B
&
¦
:B
$ %
@
& & `M'.‚D7% G~&!O*c2 U!D[V'.&!D7Vc-.<€&!O*D7")U¼ !#"$"$D7-%¿"$O - +X"Z&!O;'&)DY&)D7"
Bc'.¼D7B6D#T2f8R l¢ r Ha`=O #%KDY&€D7"=T?:*'0;&!-or q › Ær ª
¢
H
t
n
É
pB
É
É t
@
4.
'%*2Z"$%;2 "}&!O*W"$#/#-%*2Z*'.$&y-.<*&!O W"$: 9!9-"$DY&!D7-%Z&!-@•5-8H\“X<>&!
!#/#D[VD7%*GN¡Z<º!-B¨•W-8K"$O*)B6T'"$:!#" X'.%;2S"$#%;2"
'%*2 =&!•5-8H
`=O**: !"P&e'.&!#"
~'%*2
~'.!¿ : !DY–;/T'&!D7-%*"S-.<f&!O*
r
2 %*"$DY&4RBc'.&$!D7/##"
'.%;2
HF•WR #B6Bc'~ÀK\&!O*!cD7"f':*% DYA
r
&e'.$Ri&$e'% "P<w-.!Bc'.&!D7-% g-%&!O c“z07D7/# "Z;'.$&Z-.<
"$: /UOF&!O;'.&
r
q
¢ @ q
š
H
É Q
r
r
q
U& c89\t "$:*/eOl&!O;'& @ q t š
¢»/-"UÉ WHy`=O*%K
\¢
r t
r t
/#-" 5Ha`=O*D7"(B6T'% "=&!O;'&
DN
LOWER BOUNDS FOR 3 ROUNDS
f"$O*-T+ƒ'd07-T+=)89-: %;2<w-.f'3/#0['"$"Z-<(À3!-:*%*2F !-.&!-/#-07"
+XO D7/UOÃD[% /#07:;2#"f&!O*N !-&!-/-0(-<l"$/&!D7-%¾ÀF'%*2o&!O d !-.&!-/#-0
-.<u· ¦T¸¹H¿`=O*D7"f/#0['"$"6D7"62–;% T2‘8R– ¼ D7% GS&!O c"P&$!:*/&!:!N-.<z&!O !-&!-/#-0M'.%;2dV'.$RD7%*GZ&!O*l/eO*-D[/-<\"P&e'.&!" b UH
Bc
}&
'%*2
89l&J+=-f"$&!"z'%*2
'.%;2
89!-8;'.8*D707DY&4R
r
r
2D7"P&$!D[8 : &!D7-% "f-V
'.%;2
Ka!#"$9#/&!D7V07RH‘“z"$"$: B63&!O*'.&TK
r
<>-z#V$R3¡@˜™.]šT›.œu'.%;
2 i~˜ b€+=O*'V'u"P&e'.&! b UH
K
K
6 ^
K
[6 8 9
68 9
`q K K Xq
_~
4š
A8
6oY8 K 6 ~ 8 9
qK q
qK q
Y8 K 6 ~ 8 9
6 8 K \9 ¢¾/#-" 6 K 9ª‘"$D7% 6 r 9
~6 8 r \9 ¢¾/#-"É É 6 K 9‡BF"$D7% É É 6 r 9
<w-.@"$-B6l"P&e'.&!"6 K U9 K,6 U9 H
r
“”2 D7"$O*-%*#"P&=“z07D7/#@!#;'!#"D6 K 9a'%;26"$#%*2 "a&!O*@¦ ;'$&5&!•5-8H€I¹<y"$O*!#/#D[V#"z¡ }¢Æ])<º!-Bj•5-8}K;"$O )'./&!"z'"z'%O*-%*#"P&
?:;'.%&!: Bv“z07D7/#(+XO -)O*'"W !#*'.!T2R6 8 K W
9 '.%;26"$#%&5&!O l¦ ;'.$&
&!-¿•5-8H q `=O*'.&3D7"#K€"$O*B6T'."$: !#"6O c;'$&…6 NO96'%*2Ã"$#%*2 "c]
'%*2'5
N &!-3•5-8}H •W-8i'/#/# &!"l¡@¢¤]f+XDY&!Oi!-8*'8*D707DY&4RS'&l07T'."P&
6oY8 K 6 K 916 É ¢¾/#t -" É É H
IJ<@"$O*d!/##D7V#"c¡ ¢ ›K(“z07D7/#~9$<>-!B6"u~ G r -%mO*Uc;'.$&
-<]6 K (
9 '.%;2~/#-%&!D[%: #"l'."l'%SO -%*"P&?:;'.%&!: B§“z07D7/#Q+XO*-cO;'."
!;'.!#2c6 8 9 q B6T'"$:!#"f6 N 9 '.%;2F"$%;2 "&!-i›c'%*2X€N &!-•5-8 t H
r
9
f6 ^
9
Bc
›HX“z07D7/#Z*D7/e‚"@'f:*% D7<>-!B60YRde'.%;2-B­¡)˜™.]šT›.œHl`=O #%K"$O b './#/#-e2D7%*GX&!-=&!O*a2 D7"P&$!D78*:&!D[-%
b '%*2l"$#%;2"
*D7/e‚'
" i~˜
b
=&!-f•5-8}H
6^
9
Bc
¦HX•5-8~*D7/e‚"(')e'.%;2-Bg¡?1˜S™]šT›œK;"$%;2 "X¡?&!-6“(0[D7/#H
?
ÀHX“z07D7/#c"$#%*2 "Z¡c'%;2ai‘&!-S•W-8H•5-8o/eO*#/e‚"ZDY<X&!O*6"P&e'&!
&!O;'&(O*@!#/#D7VT2dD7%N&!O u› k m€"P&!#dD7" b UH
6 ^
‰
´HX`=O*l!"$:*0Y&(-<M&!O /#-D7%dE*D[ND7"(¡
¦H
opDq.r
’ ’
Bc
9
¡?H
r ‡ l‰$…Ž¹…T„!…4¡1… @Ž †z
(ŽU‰ Œ D†d
*.Žœ¡[ŒŸ
!Ž
!
?
HS
P&pq K '.%;2q r 89€&!O*z2 #% "$D7&JRfBc'&$!D[/#"5"$#%&W8R6'%
O -% #"P&€“(0[D7/#zDY<1¡X¢»]Q'%*26¡X¢£›K!#"$9#/&!D7V07RH q `=O*#"$z2 #% "$DY&4R
Bc'&$!D7/##"('.!B6DY¼&!: !#"€-.<A6 ^
9 -VU ~˜
H H t
€
x²H
…Q€
„ ‡ „ †¹Œ Œ \†wŽ €‰S$ …QQ †z¡ †wŽ Ér ª ‘ " G ‘ •5-8'/#/# &!"X¡(¢£›l+XDY&!O~ !-8;'.8*D707D7&JR
6oYO~ G r q K t 6 8 r 916 É
t2rjq.q'uv
b
D
i
Bc
z
G
!
}#B6Bc'i›Ky&!O*!6D7")'~B6T'"$:!#B6#%& &!O*'.&TK
'.* 0[D7T2”&!-[q K '%;2q K!-2 : /##"d&J+=-m!-8*'8*D707DY&4R,2D["P&$!D78 : A
r
&!D7-%*")+XDY&!O‘&!O 3V'.!D['&!D[-%;'.0X2 D7"P&e'% /#c89&4+5##%¿&!O*#B¨#?:*'05&!‹q K Bq r ‹ @'%*2iDY&/#'%89)/UO -"$#%i"$-N&!O*'.&&!O !f'!]P : "P&l&4+5-: &!/#-B6#"#ÂW]f'%*2i›H
}& n K '%*2›>B n K 89&!O*!-8;'.8*D707DY&!D["@-<a-: &!/#-B6#"(]6'%;2
›(+XO*%3&!O @B6T'."$: !#B6#%&
D7"X'* 07D[#26&!-&q K H\h*-.=&!O*zV'!D['.A
&!D7-%;'02D7"P&e'%*/W&!-X89D‹q K B>q ‹ K&!O*\ !-8;'8 D70[DY&!D7#"y-.<*-: &!/#-B6#"
r
]6'.%;2›+XO #%d&!O*QB6T'."$: !#B6%&
D7"@'.**07D7T2d&!-q
O*'VQ&!r
‘ '.%;2S›>B n K ª ‘ G ‘ H
89 n K B ‘ " G
É
É
z•WR
t2rjq.q'uv
#
#
2#
l
• -8S' *07D7#"X&!O*QB6T'"$:!#B6#%&#
W
&!-f&!O "P&e'.&!&!O;'&@O l!A
/#D7V#"X<>!-Bj“z07D7/#Z'%*2d"$#%*2 "(¡(¢Æ]fDY<y&!O*B6T'."$: !#B6%&XGD7V#"
]S'.%;2‘¡3¢ ›NDY<X&!O*cB6T'."$: !#B6%&ZGD[V#"3›H « D7%*/#3'.%ÄO -% #"P&
“(07D[/N/eO*--"$#"
¢­]+XDY&!Oo !-8;'.8*D707D7&JR¾› ¦i'.%;2
¢ ›3+XD7&!O
!-8*'8*D707DY&4RÛ ¦Ka•5-8‘'/eO*D7#V#"
¢x¡ q '%*2
¡6¢g] +XD7&!O
t
!-8*'8*D707DY&4R
?› M
›
¦
nK
ª
›
;
¦
­›#]H
D
?›
M
AB n K
›
ª
‹q K B…q r ‹
¦
›
¢
<
M
ª
¦
M ‰
‹|q K B/q r ‹ @
´
r ¡ †L„UŒZ„‡…„ †¹Œ Œ \†wŽ u‰S$…4|4†¡ †wŽ
qq K š q
›
r t @
ª
¦
¦
G
!
@
_
t2rjq.q'uvzhMDY!"P&TK+=W/#-% "$D[2 a'.%)O -%*"P&\“z07D7/#5+XO D[/eO)2 -#"M&!O !-&!-/#-0=-%‘'~?:;'%&!: B 07#V#0LHd`=O;'.&ZB6T'.%*"&!O;'&Q"$O*6E;D7 "Q'
/0º'."$"$D7/T'0M/-D7%d&!-f2&!!B6D7%*
˜S™.]šT›.œZ'.%;2c&!O*#%N !#*'.!#"=&!O "$: 9!9-"$DY&!D7-%
M
6 8 9\¢ ¢
q N t 6 NO916 ^ H 9
H
_
B
/N
M
’
¢
6WY! K 6 ~ q 8 r t 916 É
¢¾/#-" É
@
¦
I4%389-&!O3/T'."$#"#K*&!O @ !-8;'.8*D707D7&JR3-<y•W-8~'./#/##&!D7%*Gf¡
D7"@/#-"UÉ
H(`=O !<w-.!K9&!O*Q-Ve'.070M !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR~-<a¡
¡
É
'"€+=0[01'%*23+=O*'TV
/#-"É
É
›Wª _ @ q
š
›5ªo/#-"
r t
/#-" É
¢
¢
¦
¦
¦
"
‰
‰
?
¡ ? ¢»]
¢£]fD7"
qK q @
#
q K š q r t$ r K &!O #%K8R7#B6Bc'f›#]K9“(07D[//T'%'./UO D7#V'
%'& " )( r H
8*D['."(-.<
$ É
qq K š q
IJ<
r KM&!O #%K18RX}#B6Bc'd²K\•5-8‘/T'%‘'/eO*D7#Vc'
r t)© 8*D['."(-.< r ‹|q K B…q ‹ '.%;2}K8R7#B6Bc')_K
› r ›
›
qq K š q
‹|q K š q r ‹ $ ¦ q ›:B
@
r t$t*$ ´
´
IJ<
@
q
B @
_
@
5. THE LOWER BOUND ON THE NUMBER OF ROUNDS
r ‡= ‰$ …Ž¹…T„!…4¡C…A‡*Žƒ„!…†w‡
+
< * d
*
!ŽŠ
Œ plq 07-G507-GNsr t $…‡#"
#’
(D+?xLx,R..-S-0Cƒ/Š3¿“z"$"$: B6d+=O*'TVS' !-.&!-/#-0(<w-.~?:;'.%&!:*B
/#-D[%NE;D7* D[% Gu+XDY&!Oc!-:*%*2 "('%*2d'u8 D['"(n#H
`=O*( !-.&!-/#-09"P&e'$&!"5+XDY&!O3'– ¼T2f"P&e'.$&!D7%*GQ"P&e'&!6 8 K U9 Ha`=O #%
q DY<989-&!O)*0['#R!"a'.!€O -% #"P& K“(0[D7/#X'.* 0[D7#"a'@: %*DY&e'.$RQ&$e'.%*"P<w-.$A
Bc'.&!D7-%…~ K9"$%;2 "("$-B6)?:*t 8 D7&!"€&!-3•5-8K9O )'.* 0[D7#"&~ K"$%;2 "
r
É
"$-B6f?: 8*DY&!"l&!-~“(07D[/c'%;2i"$-~-%}H3“(<º&!~ KM89-.&!O‘“z07D7/#c'.%;2

•5-89$<w-.!B­B6#'"$: !B6#%&!"€-%~&!O*D7(*'.$&!"#H€I¹<y89-&!O-.<y&!O*#B
oRp.q.rD
ÀH 1ŒUŽ9n ,›T¥.´;’
ˆ † ‰‰*†w‡ŠuŽ! Ž „†¹Œ Œ
† €n
O;'TVQ<w-070[-T+5T2F&!O*Z !-.&!-/#-0LK}&!O*Q&4+5-NB6T'."$: !#B6%&!"(GD7VZ&!O*
"!'B6Z!#"$:*0Y&Q'.%;2&!O*D7"@!#"$: 0Y&D7"]3+XDY&!Oi !-8*'8 D[07DY&4R¿› ¦3'%;2‘›
+XDY&!O~ !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRF› ¦H
h*-.-:'%*'0YR"$D7"#K1+=u'"$"$: B6Z&!O*'.&l&!O D["z–;%;'.0MB6T'."$: !#B6#%&
-% 0YRcB6T'"$:!#"=&!O*@] ›@!#"$:*0Y&X8*DY&X'.%;232 -#"€% -&(2D["P&!:!8N-.&!O*
?:*8 D7&!"#H1‘z'07"$-f'."$"$:*B6X&!O;'.&€'0709D7%&!U!B6T2 D['.&!(B6T'."$: !#B6#%&!"
'.!i2#0['TRT2Ã&!D7070(&!O #%;2m-.<&!O*!-&!-/#-0H¤`=O*D7"3D["c9-"$"$D[8 07
89#/T'.:*"$-.<y&!O* J !D7%*/#D7 0[-.<\"!'.<>Z"P&!-.e'G 6-<X· Á.¸H
C›
C›
Q›
0
21
D
!6 8 H 9
`N
`=O #%K&!O* 4-D7%&)"P&e'&!6-<(“(0[D7/#c'.%;2F•5-8o'<>&! ("P&!#*"QD7"Z'
: !l"P&e'&!
UH
u!#!#"$#%&
l¢
yª
UK}+XO*!
@D7"&!O*u"P&e'&!
r
+XO D7/UOZ07T'2"M&!-z&!O*a-:&!/#-B65]zDY<&!O*W!"P&\-<;!-&!-/#-0D["\'.* 0[D7T2
'.%;2
ZD7"f&!O*3"P&e'.&!3+XO*D7/UOÄ07T'2"f&!-i&!O N-: &!/#-B6F›NDY<z&!O r
!"P&6-<z !-.&!-/#-0XD7"6' *07D7T2}H q « #3&!O*N2 &e'.D70[#2o!--<@D[%¿&!O '.*9#%*2 DY¼S<w-.u'3 !#/D["$c2–;% DY&!D[-%-.<
l'%;2
UH °@-.&!D7/#
r t
r 89#/T'.:*"$6&!O*6/#-D7%oE*D7‘GD7V#"Z
&!O*'.&
c¢
c¢
T'./UO¿-.<
r
&J+=-f-: &!/#-B6#"€+XDY&!O~ !-É 8;'8 D70[DY&JRi› ¦H
q
}&
896&!O*32#%*"$DY&4RBc'.&$!DY¼F-<z“z07D7/# " q •5-8 "
B
B t
t
UH &L@
*'.$&d-<Z&!O* q %*-.!Bc'07D#T2
8*D7;'$&!DY&!F"P&e'&! ¦
t
q@
q
89l&!O*z–92 0[DY&JRc89&4+5##%
'.%;2
'.%;2
H
B
B r
B
B r t
t
½ :l!--<WD["@8;'"$#2i-%'.%;'0Y
R #D7%*G3O*-T+ @
'%*2 @
/eO;'.%*G
2: !D7%*G)&!O*l!-&!-/#-0HWIJ&X/-%*"$D7"P&!"(-<M<>-0707-T+XD[% GN´u"P&!#*"#Â
68 H 9
KH ‹
u‹8
`q
H
!6 8 H 9 T6 8 KH 9
68 H 9
‹8 H ‹
C›
H h q H h
uq H K
›H=‘@"$O*-T+Æ&!O*'.&
K
@
K
'.%;2J@
R6 8 KH 9
&6 8 KH 9
_6 8 H 9
6 8 h H 9
7q H q H K
H
Bu: "P&€89l0['.!G
K
4š
,š
H
!q H
H
q }#B6Bc'6›¦
t
` O*ZBc'D7%~D[2T'6O*!ZD7"l'"(<w-0[07-T+X"#HlI¹< @
=
D7"z"$Bc'070LK;&!O*#%
&!O*)"P&e'.&!#"
@'%*2
z/T'.%F89Z+=#070a2 D7"P&!D7%*G:*D7"$O*T2S8R
r
07--‚D7%*G 4:*"P&Z'&Z“z07D7/# "Q"$Dº2Hc`=O #%K1“z07D7/#f/T'.%"$: /#/##"$"PA
<w: 0707RQ/eO*#'.&M8R@ !#*'.!D7%*GX&!O*\+€!-% Gz"P&e'$&!D[% Gz"P&e'&! q "$-B6
"P&e'.&!Q/#07-"$Q&!=D[% "P&!T'2~-.<
HW®z: %*% D[% G)&!O O*-%A
t &!O*)!"$:*0Y&Z]3+XDY&!OF'
#"P&Q!-&!-/#-0a-%"$: /UOF'N"P&e'&!uGD7V"l
O*D7GOÄ!-8*'8*D707DY&4RHSI¹
< @
D[")"$Bc'070LKa•5-8o/T'.%o/UO T'.&)D7%o'
"$D7B6D70º'X+€'#RH
6 8 K 9
K
'6 8 KK 9
&
¦H@
& 
¢Q@
¢»]
68 K 9
4š
H
A6 8 K 9
K
q B6Bc'c››
H
t
`=O*D7"€<w-070[-T+X"X<>!-Bx&!O*@<w'/&€&!O*'.&TK .
' &€&!O l#%*23-.<M !-.&!-/#-0
q '.<º&! u!-:*%;2" 89-.&!O6;'.$&!D7#"5‚% -Tm
+ &!O*(-:&!/#-B6X-.<&!O t
!-.&!-/#-0LH
H
fN
H
ÀH€IJ<JKy<w-.f"$-B6 $K\-% N-.<R@
'.%;2&@
D7"Z"$D7G%*DY–*/T'%&!0YR¿07#"$"
&!O;'.%¿&!O*3-&!O*UTKa&!O #%ēz07D7/# q -c•5-8
/T'%Ä"$:*/#/#"$"P<w: 0[0YR
/eO*T'& q }#B6Bc'6›TÀf'.%;2±5-.!-070['.$RS¦ H t
t
IJ< @
D["z"$D7G%*DY–*/T'%&!0YRS"$Bc'0707@&!O*'% @
K9&!O*#%S“(0[D7/#)/T'%
2 D7"P&!D7%*G:*D7"$O
}'%*2
Bu: /UO89&$&!U1&!O;'.%Q•5-8}H\`=O*%K
r
"$O*c/T'.%o/UO T'.&)8R‘'.**0YRD7%*G~&!O 389"P&fB6T'."$: !#B6#%&<>-
2 D7"P&!D7%*G:*D7"$O*D7% G
'%*2
UH1IJ<"$O aG&!"&!O a].A¹"P&e'.&!K."$O r
P: "P&a/#-%&!D7%:*#"\'."aD7%Z&!O*€O*-%*#"P&\!-&!-/#-0LH\IJ<9"$O =G&!"y&!O ›A¹"P&e'&!K5"$O d'.* 0[D7#"u'S&$e'.%*"P<>-!Bc'.&!D7-%o&!O*'.&uBc'*"
r
&!-‘'F"P&e'.&!~-V!0['.**D7% G+XDY&!O
f'%*2Ä&!O*%Ã/#-%&!D[%: #"
'"ND7%¾&!O*SO*-%*#"P&N !-.&!-/#-0LHƒ`=O*D7"dD7"N9-"$"$D78*07i89#/T': "$
@
È`
È @
'%;2K&!O !<>-!K•5-8)/T'% %*-&y2 D7"P&!D7%*G: D7"$O
'%*2
="$-u+=0[0LH
r
H
76 8 KH 9
6 8
H
H
2@
O@
H
6 8 H 9
KH 9 6 8 H 9
6 8 KH 9
76 8 H 9
'6 8 KH 9
X6 8 H 9
K '%*2 K '.!60['.!GK  ¢  ¢x]d'.%;2S&!O*!6'!
´H€IJ<
<wU+ q 07#"$"u&!O;'.%¿—07-GW07-G r !-: %;2 "#K\&!O #%Ky<>-6"$-B6!N$K
H '.%;2 H Bu:*"P&895"$D7G%*DY–;s/Tt '.%&!07R)2D7ˁU!#%& q B6Bc'›´ H
@
@
@
A@
` -G&!O l+XDY&!O&!O*Q–*!"P&À6*'.$&!"#K9&!O*D7"zD[B6 07D["z&!O*Q&!O*-t A
1
!#B~H
“Æ2 &e'.D70[#2d !--.<\D["XGD[V#%~D7%N&!O Q'*9%;2 DY¼H
6.
CONCLUSION
XO;'TVX/#-% "P&$!:*/&!#26'Q!-&!-/#-0*<w-.€?:;'.%&!:*Bk/#-D[%6E*D[ *D7%*G
+XDY&!OS8*D['."@]H ¦_3'.%;2d"$O -T+X%S&!O*'.&(DY&lD7"(- &!D7Bc'.0<w-.'u!#"P&$!D7/&!#2
/0º'."$")-.<€ !-.&!-/#-07"#H3‘6'.07"$-G'TV6'dG#%*Ue'0507-T+=U)89-:*%*2F-%
&!O %:*Bu89U=-<y!-:*%*2 "€%*T2 T2c&!-6'/eO*D7#VQ'u8*D['"(n#H
`=O QBc'D7%~-9%S?: #"P&!D7-%~D7"#€/#'%-% Q/#-% "P&$!:*/&z'f !-.&!-/#-0
+XDY&!Oo'.%¿'.!8 D7&$e'!D707R‘"$Bc'070W8 D['")ncȃ]Å ½ : )`=O*-!#B À~D7BfA
07D["Z&!O*'.&TKMDY<=&!O D7"ZD7"Q9-"$"$D78 0[KM&!O*6%:*B)89l-.<€!-: %;2 ""$O -: 0º2
D7% /!T'"$+XO #%~n(2 #/U!T'"$#"#HW`=O !<w-.!K;+5%*#T2c&!-u07T'!%~O*-T+
&!-3'.%;'0Y
R #Q&!O*Q"$#/#:!DY&4R~!-&!-/#-07"@+XDY&!OB6-!&!O;'.%SÀ6!-:*%*2 "#H
q « -<w'.TK'0709!-&!-/#-0["W+XD7&!Oc!-.V'8 07("$/#: !DY&4RfG:;'e'%&!##"WO;'TV
/#-%*"$D7"P&!T2d-.<a'.&(B6-"P&(À)!-:*%*2 "#H
“z%*'0YR"$D7"-<XÀA¹!-:*%*2i!-&!-/#-t 0WD7"%*-.&Q/#-B6 07&!uR&TK}#DY&!O TH
‘)‚%*-T+k&!O;'&-:Q !-&!-/-0\D7"Z- &!D7Bc'0M<>-&!O f/#0['"$"Q-<5 !-.A
&!-/#-0["@-<a"$#/&!D7-%i´ H(|z-+5#VTK*+=)2 -6%*-.&l‚%*-T+,+XO*&!O zD7&@D7"
-&!D7Bc'0='.B6-% GF'.070€À.A!-: %;2‘!-&!-/#-0["#H`=O*3 !--.<(-<z`=O*#-.A
!#B§ÀZ/T'%~89@:*"$T2c&!-fGD7VQ'Z0[-T+5@89-:*%*23-%d&!O*l8 D['"X-<\'.%R
À.A!-:*%;23 !-.&!-/#-08*: &€&!O D7"(07-T+=Uz89-:*%*2ND7" P:*"P&z]H ]]›H[H7H
“z% -&!O !#"P&$!D7/&!T2/0º'."$"u-.<€ !-.&!-/#-07")&!O*'.&QB6D7GO&Q896T'."PR
&!-Ä'%*'0Y
R #‘'! !-.&!-/#-07"d+XO !F&!O Äl
› k!mcB6#"$"!'GF<º!-B
“(0YA
D7/#Q&!-N•W-8SD7"l?:;'.%&!: B{8*:&l'.0[0M&!O Q"$:*8*"$#?: #%&(B6#"$"!'G#"'.!
/#0['"$"$D7/T'.0LHdIJ%F-.&!O*+5-e2 "#K1D7%F&!O*)–*!"P&Q"P&!#“z07D7/#f/!T'&!#")'%
#%&e'% G07T2c"P&e'.&!@+XDY&!Od•5-8N'%*2c&!O #%3&!O R689-.&!Od2-)-9e'.&!D7-% "
-%Z&!O*#DY\?: 8*DY&!"y'%*2)/#-B6Bu: %*D7/T'.&!a/#0['"$"$D7/T'.0*D7% <>-!Bc'&!D[-%H\`=O D7"
½ ±€± q 07-/T'0-9e'.&!D7-% "
"$-B6U+XO;'.&!#"$#B)8*07#"&!O a+5#070YAJ‚% -+X%
'%*2/#0['"$"$D7/T'0\/#-B6Bu: %*D7/T'.&!D7-% ;'.e'2 D7GB­D7%&!O*Z"P&!:;2Rd-<a#%A
t
&e'% G07#B6#%&Q· ¦ÀK¦´¸H
IJ&5B6D7GO&=89(9-"$"$D78*07@&!-ZGD7Vz'%3¼ '/U&€'%*'0YR"$D7"€-<1+XO*'.&5/T'%
89Z'/eO*D7#V#2d8Rd!-&!-/#-0["z-<y&!O D["X&4R9H=“Æ–*!"P&("P&!#/-:*0[2~89
'%*'0Y
R #D7%*G6ÀA!-:*%*2N!-&!-/#-0["X+XO*U!l&!O*u› k!m B6#"$"!'GD7"z?:*'% A
&!:*Bg'%;23&!O*@&J+=-f-.&!O*(B6#"$"!'.G#"('.!/0º'."$"$D7/T'0LH
‡
`
7. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
œ
`=O;'.%*‚"&!-€Êl-!DY&y“(O;'!-%*-V9KTÊ'.%*D7#0¯@-.&$&!#"$Bc'%}K.•5-'F }#"$0[':}K
|@-DYA l+5-% G -K9¬d-%*D}°l'-.TK }-: D[" « '07V'.D70K 5'-TR:*% « O*DLK “zBfA
%*-%`1'.A « O Bc'K @B6#"$O
' #DYe'.%*D\'%*2 zD7%*0['% O -:S<w-Q: "$<w: 0
/#-B6B6#%&!"#K2 D7"$/#:*"$"$D7-%*"('%*23D7% <>-!Bc'&!D[-%'89-: &€!#0['&!T23+5-!‚9H
O%
S
’
8. REFERENCES
%
·Y›U¸QÊuH;“(O;'!-%*-V9K “ZH DY&e'#V9K °)H °@D7"!'%}H ] :*'%&!:*Bx/#DY!/#:*DY&!"
+XD7&!OdB6D7¼T2c"P&e'.&!"#H( $…T„eŒ!Œ .†w‡Š Z…
%2) w
6 4K *}H*¦].AJÀ]H
· ¦T¸QÊuH;“(O;'!-%*-V9K “ZH `M'A « O*Bc'K ZH ' D7e'.%*DLK*“ZH ='.- H
] :;'%&!: Bx8*DY&(#"$/!-T+
H ( P…T„UŒ!Œ †w‡Š )…
%2) w
K* H
^]_TA4^›#´H
· À¸)±zH;•5%*%*U&$&TK9¯)H*•We'"$"!'e2}H ] :*'%&!:*Bƒ/$R &!-Ge' OR}Â
*:*8 07D[/UAJ‚R32 D7"P&$!D78*:&!D[-%'%*2N/#-D7%d&!-"$"$D7%*G
H ( $…T„eŒ!Œ †w‡Š
w …‡ #Œ !ŒU‡9„eŒu….‡
w … @‰ ŽJŒ
… R8
Q8e‡*ŽJŒ e‡ .ŽL†…‡
eŽJŒ
‡
*†7Š‡ j( P…T„eŒ !†w‡ŠK9*}H›^_TA!›^²K
•='% G'07-.!K9I4%*2 D['K}›T²³´H
· ´.¸ XH*•5D7O;'.B~K9¬FH*•5-TRTK*µMH;•5-TR‚D7%K*`@H9¬d-.TK
H
®z-TR/UO -T+(2 O: $RH“”!--<1-<}&!O*("$#/#: !DY&JRc-<1?:*'%&!:*Bv‚R
2 D7"P&$!D78*: &!D7-%H ( P…T„UŒ!Œ †w‡Š )…
%2) w
K*H;^›T_A4^¦´ H
· _T¸)¬FH;•507: B~H9±5-D[%NE;D7* D[% Gu8Rc&!#07#*O -% ÂW“Æ !-.&!-/#-0}<w-.
"$-07VD[% GfD7B69-"$"$D78*07Q !-8*07#B6"#H
‡9„eŒ †w‡ w U‰;Ž¹… 7…!Š 5x
(ŒJ‰… eŽX…‡ w
( %2)
.K*}H››A!›_H
· Á¸ XH*•5!% "P&!#D7%K ZH F
' #DYe'%*DLH ] :;'%&!: Bx/#-B6*07¼DY&4R
&!O*#-.$RH 8 - … e‡ 1…‡ w … @‰ ŽL†>‡ŠK¦.ÁÂ7›#´››UAe›´^.ÀK
›T²²^H
· ^T¸)±zH9±W!#9#':K;h5H }#G'!K \H « '07V'D70LH;|@-T+”&!-u/-%V$&X&!O*
E9'TV-:X-<\'u?:*'%&!:*Bx8*DY&X/#-B6B6DY&!B6#%&T
H ( $…T„eŒ!Œ †w‡Š u…
) w
( %
.K #/U&!: !°@-.&!#"XD7%S±5-B6 : &!
« /#D7#% /#K;¦]´_ Á]A4^^K « !D7%*GTK*•5!07D7%K¦.]]›H
· ³¸ZµyH Êl: Bc'D7"#KÊuH9¬~'#RU!"#K \H « '07V'.D70H;µM$<w/&!0YRd/#-%*/##'07D7%*G
?:*'%&!:*Bƒ8*DY&(/#-B6B6DY&!B6#%&a<>!-Bj'.%Rd?:*'%&!:*Bƒ-%*UA¹+='#R
9!Bu:&e'.&!D7-%}H
‡;„UŒ †>‡ w e‰;Ž¹… 7…!Š yx
) w
( %
S
x( $…T„eŒ!Œ †w‡Š eK #/&!:!l°@-.&!#"XD7%S±5-B6 : &!
« /#D7#% /#K}›T³]^ À]].AJÀ›T_K « !D7%*GUTK;•5U!0[D7%}K¦]]]H
· ²¸)±zH;h*: /UO "#K H*V'%d2 z¯ze''.<4H±W$R &!-G.e'*O D7/
2 D7"P&!D7%*G: D7"$O;'8 D70[DY&JRdB6T'."$: !#"€<>-z?:;'%&!: BgB6#/eO;'% D7/T'0
"P&e'.&!#"#
H 8
N%
‡ „ŽL†….‡ )…J
‡ 8e‡ …
ŽL†…‡ %'*Œ$… .K
´_Â7›T¦›TÁA!›¦¦^K\›T²²²H
<
" ’
: Ÿ" < Ÿ" S |
# #¡ C ` #"
#4¡ : |
’
`–
:
`–
Ÿ" r " ’
r #4¡
S
| ¡ #
<
Ÿ" S
<
r " Ÿ" #
4¡ C |
S ’
4¡ |
% CQ" `
·Y›#].¸ aH;¯@-0[2#%89!G K aH '.Dº2Bc'%}K « H»D7#"$%*TH ] :;'.%&!:*B
G'.Bu8 0[D7% G Hj(9 !†„
XŒ †¹ŒG MŒUŽLŽJŒ !K9³¦Â ÀÀ_Á.AJÀÀ_²Ky›T²²²H
·Y››¸QÊuH;¯@-&$&!#"$Bc'.%~'.%;2d|ZH A fH -H;h!-B§?:;'.%&!: Bx/eO*T'&!D7%*G
&!-6?:;'.%&!:*Bx"$/#: !DY&4RH (
!†„ %9…
.K_.ÀK;% - H}››K* H
¦¦TA4¦^H
·Y›T¦¸QÊuH;¯@-&$&!#"$Bc'.%K ÊuH « D7B6-%}H µM!"$-%*'01/-B6Bu: %*D7/T'&!D[-%K
'.%:*'.$R~¦]]›H
·Y›#À.¸Q®QH - #"!'H;hMD[2 #07DY&4R3<w-.zB6DY¼T2N?:*'%&!:*Bƒ"P&e'.&!#"#H … U‡
… R-F… Œ e‡ )M‰;ŽL†„ !K ´ ›Â ¦.À›_TA4¦À¦.ÀK\›T²²´H
·Y›´¸Z•zH "$0º'.:H*“=&$&e'/e‚"W-%N"PR B6B6U&$!D[/z?:;'.%&!: Bb/#-D7% A&!-"$"$D[% G
!-.&!-/#-07"#K?:*'%&$A¹*O .]›#]´]^_H
·Y›T_¸Q|)H -H*IJ%*"$#/: !DY&4R3-<y?:*'%&!:*Bx"$#/#: !/-B6*:&e'.&!D7-% "#H
(
!†„
(Œ †Œ G
K;_ÁÂ7››_´A!››#Á¦Ka›#²²^H
·Y›#Á.¸Q|)H -K*|ZH*±5O;':}H;IJ"X?:*'%&!:*Bƒ8*DY&(/#-B6B6DY&!B6#%&W!T'070YR
9-"$"$D78 0[TÅ (
e†L„
XŒ †¹Œ G MŒUŽLŽJŒ !K}^³Â À.´ ›#].AJÀ´›TÀK\›#²²^H
·Y›T^¸Q|)H -K*|ZH*±5O;':}H*»OR3?:;'.%&!:*Bx8 DY&z/-B6B6DY&!B6#%&€'.%;2
D[2 T'.0M?:;'.%&!:*Bx/-D7%d&!-"$"$D7% Gc'.!D7B69-"$"$D78*07
H (9 !†„ u‹K
›¦.]Â7›^^A!›T³^K\›T²²³H
·Y›#³.¸Q|)H -K*|ZH*±5O;':}H z%*/#-%;2 DY&!D7-%*'0}"$#/#:!D7&JR3-<a?:;'.%&!: B
‚RN2D["P&$!D78 : &!D7-%~-VU('.!8*DY&$e'!D[0YRd0[-%*G62D7"P&e'%*/#"#H
9„†ŒU‡9„eŒUK¦.³À ¦.]_]A4¦]_.ÁK\›T²²²H
·Y›#².¸QÊuH;¬~'#R!"#H @%*/-%;2DY&!D[-%;'.0[0YRN"$#/#:!Q?:*'%&!:*Bƒ8*DY&
/#-B6B6D7&!B6%&5D7"(D7B69-"$"$D[8 07
H (
e†L„
XŒ †¹Œ G MŒUŽLŽJŒ !K
^³Â À´ ›´AJÀ´›^Ka›#²²^H
· ¦.].¸QÊuH;¬~'#R!"#H @%*/-%;2DY&!D[-%;'.0"$#/: !DY&4RND7%~?:;'.%&!: B
/$R &!-Ge'.*ORH … U‡ M… Aw -SK&!-6'.*9T'TH;“(0["$?:;'.%&$A¹ O ²³]¦]¦_H
· ¦›¸QÊuH;¬~'#R!"#K aH « '07V'D70LK )H;±5O D78;'.A -O*%*-H
@% /#-%*2 DY&!D7-%*'070YRd"$#/: !Q?:;'.%&!: Bx/#-D7% A&!-"$"$D7%*GH
?:;'.%&$A¹ O ²²].´]^.³H
· ¦¦¸Q|)H 0[': /U‚9K “ZH °l'#R'.‚K “QH*`1'.A « O Bc'KÊuH : /U‚U!Bc'%H
I4%&!e'./&!D7-%~D7%d?:*'%&!:*Bx/#-B6B):*%*D7/T'&!D7-%3/#-B6 0[U¼ DY&JR
'%*23&!O /#-B6 0[U¼ DY&JRc-<\"$&z2 D7" 4-D7%&!%*#"$"#
H ( P…T„UŒ!Œ †w‡Š )…
%2) w
.K&!-6' 9T'.TH
· ¦.À.¸)¬FH °@D7#07"$#%H9±5-%*2 DY&!D7-%*"X<w-.z'u/#0['"$"(-<\#%&e'.%*G07#B6%&
&$e'% "P<w-.!Bc'.&!D7-% "#
H (
!†„
(Œ †Œ G MŒUŽLŽJŒ eK9³À ´ÀÁ.A¹´À²K
›T²²²H
w … z‰ Ž ŽL†…‡
· ¦´¸)¬FH °@D7#07"$#%K*IUH;±5O:;'% G H ‡*Ž
‡
‡ Ž
8e‡ #…
ŽL†….‡’;±='.Bu8 !D[2G @% D7V!"$DY&4RNµy!#"$"#K
¦]]]H
· ¦_¸ZµMH « O*-.TH;µM-07R% -B6D['0YA&!D7B6'07G-.!DY&!O*B6"€<w-.z!D7B6
<L'./&!-!D T'&!D7-%i'%*2d2 D7"$/!U&!Z07-G'.!DY&!O B6"(-%'f?:;'.%&!:*B
/#-B6*: &!UTH 8 - ’ w … z‰ ŽL†w‡ŠK9¦ÁÂ7›´³´.A!›_]²K\›T²²^H
“z07"$- ^) w
6 H
· ¦.Á.¸ZµMH « O*-.TK H*µy!#"$‚D[070LH « D7B6*07l !--.<\-<y"$/#: !DY&4RN-<1&!O*
•=•=³.´c?:;'%&!: Bg‚R32D["P&$!D78 : &!D7-%~!-&!-/#-0L
H (
!†„
XŒ †¹Œ G MŒUŽLŽJŒ !K³_ ´´ ›UAJ´´´K¦]]]H
· ¦^¸Z“ZH @O 07Bc'%*%}H`=O* &$e'% "$DY&!D[-% !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR D7%N&!O l"P&e'.&!
"$;'./#-<#AJ'07G#8e'H (ŒJ‰… eŽ )…J
‡ - !Ž Œ ŽL†„ (9 !†„ !K
²Â ¦^À.A4¦^²Ky›#²^.ÁH
· ¦.³.¸ uH 9O;'% G K;±zH }DLK9¯)H;¯@:*-H @% /#-%*2 DY&!D7-%*'070YRd"$#/: !
?:;'.%&!: Bx/#-D7%~&!-"$"$D7%*GfVD['u#%&e'.%*G07#B6%&X"P+=' *D7%*GK
?:;'.%&$A¹ O ]]›T¦›TÀ²H
S4¡
C" #›
4¡ r
|¡ |
#›
|¡ %
S
z
S4¡ r
#›
%
1 |
|
4¡ r |
S
S
:
|
S … S"
S
š
bš
… 4¡ PROOF OF THEOREM 3
“ "$"$:*B6a+==O*'V='@!-&!-/#-0<>-a?:;'.%&!: B£/#-D7%)E;D7 *D7%*G(+XD7&!O
(
c!-: %;2 "X'.%;2N&!O l8*D['."zn#H
? :*'%&$A¹*O
!#!D[%&!"
'.!
'TV'.D70º'.8*07
4 y
'&
~ 
?›
?›
Q›
0
6 8:K  9
~ H!
H
]
f6 8 H 9
6 8 K  9 6 8  9
6 8: 9 '6 8<Q9 6 8<K
C›
Z6 8 KH 9
~
~ H ! @1@@~  G 6 8: 9 H !
œ~ @1@@~ 
q H h q H H ! h
&
§››H@
& 
¢Q@
1
N
9 X6 8< 9
b‹8<K ‹
~ H ! @1@1@|~ 
•6 8<Q9
X6 8 H 9 6 8
?›
‹|8: ‹
G 6 8:K  9
68 H 9
6 8:K  9 F6 8< 9
KH 9 6 8 H 9 4š
bš
H
6 8 h H 9 !q H q H K !q H
H
H
uq H K
¢»];’
t2rDq'q.uv@“=&&!O 6#%;2KM89-&!O‘“z07D7/#c'%*2‘•5-8¿‚% -+k&!O 6-:&$A
/#-B6@-<1&!O*@!-&!-/#-0}+XDY&!O3/#$&e'.D[%&JRHa`=O;'.&XB6#'%*"a&!O;'&€&!O*!
D7"i'mB6T'"$:!#B6#%&-.<c“z07D7/# "F?: 8*DY&!"~&!O;'&S9$<w/&!0YR¤2D["P&!D7%A
q DLH H[Ky&!O D7"ZB6#'"$: !B6#%&GD7V#"Z]N+XDY&!O
G: D7"$O*#"
'.%;2
r
!-8;'.8*D707D7&JRb›¿-%
~'.%;2k›‘+XDY&!O£ !-8;'.8*D707D7&JR
H •aR
r t
B6Bc'›K
(¢ƒ¦Hf•WR
}#B6Bc'3_K @ q
š
B
B r
B
B r t
Bu: "P&€89Q]H
« D7B6D70['.!0YRD
K @
¢»]H
76 8:K  9 c6 8< 9
6 8< 9
<‹q  K Bq K  ‹
& 
4š
K
-@
K
D7"u&!--S"$Bc'070LK5-%*3-<
§›¦H r ¡ †„eŒd„
‡Z „ †¹Œ Œ…‡9Œ~… d…Ž¹„!…6Œ
.‡#"‘
K’
S QQ†z¡ †wŽ!Ž<¡[ŒŸ
!Ž=›:B
\†wŽ!u‰ $…
G
6 8< 9
q K q
/
« /#-%*2}Ky+=N"$O*-T+x&!O*'.&TKaDY<*@
"$D[2 #"X/T'.%~/eO*T'&TH
4¡
APPENDIX
k~
~
Ÿ" #›
A.
6 8 K 9
` O*3 !-.&!-/#-0€"P&e'$&!")+XDY&!Oo"$-B6c–*¼T2‘"P&e'$&!D[% GS"P&e'.&!
=
UH
`=O*% q DY<z89-&!O¿ 0º'#RU!"6'.!3O*-%*#"P& KW“z07D7/#d'* 07D["6':*%*DY&e'$R
&$e'% "P<w-.!Bc'.&!D7-%
K("$#%;2"N"$-B6F?t : 8*DY&!"6&!-o•5-8}KzO i'* 07D["
r
KM"$#%*2 "Q"$-B66?: 8*DY&!"l&!-~“(0[D7/#c'.%;2"$-d-%H3“X<>&!
K189-&!O
É
“z07D7/#€'.%;2)•5-8)9$<w-.!B¤B6T'"$:!#B6#%&!"1-%)&!O #DYy;'$&!"#HyIJ<*89-&!O
-<W&!O*#BjO;'TVZ<w-0707-T+=T2i&!O*u!-&!-/#-0LK1&!O*Z&4+5-dB6T'."$: !#B6#%&!"
GD7V€&!O ("!'.B6€!#"$:*0Y&5'%;2Z&!O*D7"a!"$:*0Y&=D7"W]@+XD7&!O6!-8*'8*D707DY&4RN› ¦
'%*2i›l+XDY&!O~!-8*'8*D707DY&4Ri› ¦H
h*-.=&!O*z*: !9-"$@-.<M-:X'%*'0YR"$D7"#K +5'"$"$: B6(&!O*'.&=&!O D["=–*%;'.0
B6T'."$: !#B6#%&W-% 07RcB6#'"$: !"=&!O*z] ›@!#"$:*0Y&€8 D7&€'%;232 -"€%*-&
2 D7"P&!:!8-&!O*U?:*8 D7&!"#H€Z'07"$-d'."$"$:*B6&!O;'&'.0[01D[%&!!B6#2 D['.&!
B6T'."$: !#B6#%&!"€'!2 0º'#R#2c&!D7070}&!O l#%*23-.<M&!O*z !-&!-/-0LH=`=O D7"
D7"X9-"$"$D78*07Q89#/T'.:*"$-<y&!O 4!D7%*/#D7*07-.<\"!'.<wQ"P&!-.e'G 6-<X· Á.¸H
`=O*%K1&!O P-D7%&)"P&e'.&!6-.<(“z07D7/#c'%*2•5-8¿'.<º&! z"P&!# "QD["Z'
*:!l"P&e'.&!
U&
('.%;2
X89Q&!O* q : %*% -!Bc'07D #T2 "P&e'&!#"l'<>&!z&!O*
r
–;%*'0€B6T'."$: !#B6%&)DY<z&!O dB6T'."$: !#B6%&)GD7Vt "6] q › HÄ`=O*#%}K
\'.%;2
\¢
ª
UH\“(07"$- K
É(¢ t
É(¢
r
r
r
r q "$D7% /#f'6 !-.&!-/#-0yB):*"P&zGD7V)]f+XD7&!Oi !-8;'.8*D707D7&JR‘› ¦3'.%;2›
É DY&!O~ !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRF› ¦ H
+X
r
‘‘2 –*%*
o¢ t q
~'%;2
Ä¢
r
É
r
q
r
UH€`=O #%K
a¢ t
1ª
X'%*2N&!O*
r
É
r
r
t
07D7%*T'!D7&JRd-.<
D[B6 0YR
a¢
ª
UH
r
r
q
U&
89c&!O*32 #% "$DY&4RFBc'.&$!DY¼‘-.<@“(07D[/ " q •5-8 "
B
B t
t
;'$&~-.<Z&!O q % -!Bc'.0[D##2
8*D7;'$&!D7&!i"P&e'.&! ¦
UH }&L@
t
q@
q
89@&!O*@–;2 #07DY&4R389&J+=#%
'%*2
'%*2
H
B
B r
B
B r t
t
½ : @ !--.<5D7"l8*'"$T2S-%i'%*'0Y
R #D7%*GNO*-T+ @
'%;2 @
/eO;'.%*G
2 :!D7%*G~&!O*6!-&!-/#-0LH‘6"$O*-T+ƒ&!O;'.&Q&!O RB):*"P&Z8960['.!Gd'&
&!O*u89#GD7%*% D7%*G Ky]~'.&&!O 6#%;2F'%;2K1DY<€&!O Ri2 #/U!T'"$6&!--d<w'"P&TK
&!O*D7"Z/!T'&!#"u'.%¿- 9-$&!:*% DY&4Ri<w-)/eO*T'&!D[% G HS`=O D7")D7B6*07D7#"Q&!O*
07-T+=z89-: %;2N-%N&!O %: Bu895-<y!-:*%;2"#H
_
@
t2rDq'q.uv « D7%*/#a&!O*!=D7"y% -z!D[-.\#%&e'% G07#B6#%&TK&!O*W"P&e'.$&!D7%*G
"$:*9U!9-"$DY&!D7-%
}D7"1'5&!#%*"$-.M !-2:*/&
M
UKT+XD7&!OZ“(0[D7/#
O;'TVD7%*G
€'%*2d•5-8~O;'TVD7%*G
UH
q <>-6“(07D[/ &!O*'.&62D7"PA
±5-% "$D[2 f&!O c89#"P&fB6T'."$: !#B6%&A#
t UKM+XO*!
&!D7%*G:*D7"$O*#"
'%*2
H }&
Q¢
\ª
r
B
B r
€D7"X&!O*!#Bc'.D[% D7%*G6"P&e'.&!QDY<y&!O*QB6T'."$: !#B6%&#
-%
GD7V"l&!O*u-: &!/#-B6f]N'%;2
zD7"l&!O*Z!#Bc'D7%*D7% Gd"P&e'.&!uD7<9#
r
GD7V"Z&!O 6-: &!/-B6~›H U&
Z¢
\ª
UKM+XDY&!O
r
r$r
r
r
'%*2
=2 –*%*T23"$D7B6D[0['!07RH
r$r
IJ<W“(0[D7/#u' *07D7#" #
&!€¢
Mª
UK}"$O )#DY&!O GU&!"
r
&!O*@-: &!/-B6])'%;2c&!O*@!Bc'D7%*D7%*Gu"P&e'.&! 9? a¢
ª
r
-Z›Q'.%;2N&!O @!#Bc'D7% D[% Gf"P&e'.&!
}ª
UH
=D["('
? a¢
r
r$r
r
!-2:*/&="P&e'.&!'.%;26&!O*@B6#'"$: !B6#%2
& #
D7"X'* 07D[#23&!-)“z07D7/# "
76 8 K 9
œ6 8 9 6 8 9
=6 8 9
u6 8 9
&q K K …q K = u6 8 KK 9 6 8 KŸK 9 6 8 K 9
6 8 KŸK 9
68
[6 8 K 9
u u6 8 K 9 6 8 K 9 6 8 9 6 8
X6 8 9
X6 8 K 9 a6 8 KK 9 k6 8 K 9
6 8 9 6 8 9 6 8
!6 8 9 6 8 K 9 K 6 8 9 KŸPK 6 8 K 9
KK 9
K9
K9
4š
&6 8 K 9
6 8 K 9 F6 8 9
68 9
‹|8 K ‹
:‹8 K ‹ $ $
q &!O d!#Bc'D7% D[% GF"P&e'&!#"
"$D[2~-% 07RHm`=O*U!<w-.!K
? u'%*2
?
r
+XO #%L#
GD7V#"(]f'.%;2F› .
' ! !-2:*/&X"P&e'&!#"('"X+=#070LH
t ? UK #DY&!O*U
« D7%*/#
r -
r H
a¢
? #É
? 1ª
? #É
r
r
É
É
h -\"$D7B6*07D7/#DY&4RK+=='"$"$:*B6W&!O;'.& 9? É
r '%*2u“(0[D7/#5D["M&$$RD7%*G
&!-c'./UO D7#V&!O*-: &!/#-B6Q]H q `=O Q-: &!/-B6É f›Q/T'.%89Q'/eO*D7#VT2
+XDY&!O~-%*0YRN"$0[D7GO&!0YRN"$Bc'0707( !-8;'8 D70[DY&JRH
t
}&
M89=&!O*€% -!Bc'.0[D ##2f"P&e'.&! H\`1-8*D['."a&!O ? M
f6 8 K 9
‹|8 ‹ $
‘ Ž   ‘
P6 8 9 X6 8 9
œ
=6 8 9
‹8 ‹ F‹8 K ‹
68 9 68 K 9
/-D7%N&!-T+€'e2 "€]K “z07D7/# P: "P&=!:*% "W&!O @O*-%*#"P&= !-&!-/-09+XDY&!ONO "P&e'$&!D7%*G6"P&e'.&!89D[% G
UH
? 5D[% "P&!T'2N-<
É ª
É
}&
nTH\"$O*-T+”&!O;'.&X&!O D["XD7B6*07D7#"€&!O;'&
r
r
q +XO*D7/UO
=D7"@/#07-"$Z&!-u&!© O Q%*-!Bc'.07DHT2d"P&e'.&! ¦
? .M
GD7V#"€&!O*-: &!/#-B6])+XDY&!O~ !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRF› Hy‘O*'V
t
?
}ª
}ª
r
r
r
r
¢
¢
ª
A6 8 9
?
/#':*GO&z/eO*#'.&!D7%*G
?
?
D7"('.&(B6-"P&
t
‹8 r K X
B 8 K ‹É
‹8 K ‹ É r
‹8 r K ‹ ÉWªF‹8 K r ‹É
n
¢”¦n1@
‹8 K ‹ É
© ›T¥¦
`=O !<>-!K&!O*(2 "$/!D789T26"P&$e'.&!#G.Rf<w-.X2 D7"$O*-%*#"P&=“z07D7/#(GD7V#"5]
+XDY&!O~!-8*'8*D707DY&4Rd'.&(07T'"P&Q›A‘
B ¦n#H
°z¼&TK+=89-: %;2…‹8 K #
‹r Éaª‹8 r K #‹ ÉH
}&Z›>B n K '%*2 n K 89&!O*!-8;'.8*D707DY&!D["@-<a-: &!/#-B6#"(]6'%;2
›@+XO*#%NB6T'"$:!D[% G
¦6 8 K H U9 HŠ}
& n r '.%;2i›œB n r 89@&!O*l!-8*'.A
8 D70[DY&!D7#"z-<W]6'%*2F›+XO*#%B6#'"$: !D7% G
¦6 8 H 9UHX`=O #%K &!O*V'.!DYA
©
?
?
*q K K q K
,B n K B n
u
qq K
K šŸq K r t=© ‹q K K B:q K r ‹ \¢ q ›B n K B n r t
KH
'.%;2N&!O D7"€D["(T?:*D7V'07#%&=&!- n K ª n
r ©
°z-&!D7/#@&!O*'.& n K ¢”¦‹8 K ‹ É 89#/#':*
"$Pq K K D7"=&!O*2#%*"$DY&4RcBc'A
r
¦6 8 K K d
9 '%*2 6 8 K r 9ND7"~&!O F!#Bc'.D[%A
&$!DY¼”-.<6“z07D7/#4š ""$D[2 -<
D7% G"P&e'.&!dD7<z&!O*3B6T'"$:!#B6#%&f-.<6 8 K K 9)GD[V#"d›H « D7B6D70['.!0YRK
n r ¢”¦‹8 r K #‹ ÉHM`=O*!<>-!K+5=O;'TVD‹8 K r ‹#ɪ=‹8 r K ‹É © Ér K
'.%;2o“z07D7/#N/T'%o8*D['."u&!O*3/#-D7%¿&!-i]S+XDY&!Oo !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRo'.&f0[#'"P&
KH
›AB
W
@
@
B
B
B
B
@
_
B
B
B
@
_
_
@
|z#%*/KDY<1&!O*(8*D['."€-<1') !-.&!-/#-0D7"€n#K&!O*#%}K8R6Êl–*%*DY&!D7-%›K
r ªn#H5`=O D7"€D[B6 07D[" _ @
r in
+5lBu: "P&=O*'V)›
@
_
© É
É
q r n É H « D[% /#Qn ,›T¥.´K;+=B):*"P&€O*'V @
'.%;L
2 @
r H
t
r
É
`=O DYe2}K+5€"$O*-T+Ä&!O;'.&TKDY<}'.<º&!W'%RQ!-:*%*2}K-%*5-<.@
'%*2 @
D7"XBu: /UOc0['.!G(&!O;'%c&!O*@-&!O*UTK &!O D["X'.07"$-f/!T'&!#"('u9-"$"$D78*D707DY&4R
<>-z/UO T'.&!D7% G H
K
$
K
<B
B
K
+
K$
H $
B
& H
­›#ÀH 1ŒUŽ,N\˜i™›šC@1@@#š :B›.œ ’
*ŒU‡ Ž Œ!Œ@†z
>`
!Ž Ž
p#…>".†z
…‡Œ
!Ž r ¡ †„eŒ †„ f„ †¹Œ Œ
€Ž *Œ>$Œ
¡ Ž \†wŽ @‰S$…4
4 †¡ †wŽ!Žœ¡[Œ
eŽ
É
›
H B H @
qÀ
B H É ª
D
ŒŠ
A%'
7
G
W
;
¦
<
!
G
!
"
l"
W
@
_
@
!
¦
@
H
t
H
z`1-c"$D7B6*07DY<>Rd&!O Q%*-&e'&!D7-%K9+5u2#%*-.&!A@
'.%;2 @
q -B6D7&$&!D7% Gi&!O ~D7%;2 U¼ Z+XO D[/eOmD7"f&!O 8Ro"$D7B6*0YR @
'.%;2 @
"!'.B6l&!O !-:*GO -:&€&!O*l!--< H
@–*!"P&(!-.V@&!O* @
¢»t]u/T'."$H=`=O D7"(/#'"$+€'."z!#VD[-:*"$0YR
/-%*"$D[2!T28RQ¬~'#R!"&TH '0LH[· ¦›¸Ha`=O*UR"$O*-T+=#2@&!O;'.&TK.DYD
< @
¢»]
t2rjq.q'uv
N
%
‡
qH K qH
&6 8 KH 9
*q H K
<
/‹|q H K B
Rq H
/6 8 H 9
?›
?›
6 8 KH 9 7
R~
H H
o6 Y8 KH 6 ~ q 8 Hr t 916 É ¢ q q H K š q H r t ‹8 KH ‹ É ¢ q q K¦ š q “z07D7/#(9$<w-.!B6":»
~ '%*2u&!O*#%6/-%&!D7%: #"W'"5D7%f&!O (O -%
@
@
B
B
B
B
@
@
r t ¢
¦
q´
"P&5!-&!-.tA
#
/#-0HW`=O D["€GD7V#"=&!O*@'% "P+=(]Q+XD7&!O3 !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRN'.&€07T'."P&@
¥¦H
`1-G&!O TK&!O = !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR)-.<9'.%*"P+=U5](D7"W'&\07T'"P& r q ›s
ª @
H
t
É
@
]F„ #ŒT’•WR #B6Bc'6_K9&!O*!ZD7"'6B6T'"$:!#B6#%& #
<w-.
“z07D7/#(&!O;'.&TK'* 07D[#26&!'%;2
K !-2 : /##"a&4+=-Z !-8;'.8*D70YA
B
B r
DY&4Ru2 D7"P&$!D78*:&!D[-%*"\+XDY&!Oc&!O €V'!D['.&!D7-%*'092D["P&e'.%*/#X89&J+=#%f&!O*#B
'.&(07T'."P&l¦ q ›
Hy»DY&!O*-: &€&!O*07-"$"(-.<yG%*e'.0[DY&JRK*+=@/T'%
@
'"$"$: B6=&!O;'&a&!O D7"WD7"Wt '@B6T'"$:!#B6#%&y+XDY&!Ou&4+5--:&!/#-B6#"a]'.%;2
›Z'%*2N&!O*!-8*'8*D707DY&4RN-<W]uD7"(O*D7GO z<>-
'%;23&!O* !-8;'A
B
8*D707DY&4RN-<=›lD["XO D[GO*X<>-
H
B r
`=O*€"P&$e'&!#GRZ<w-.5/eO*#'.&!D7%*G“(07D[/(D7"y&!O*€"!'.B6€'"aD7%u&!O*2
@
¢
]~/T'."$H « O c' *07D7#"Z&!O 6B6T'"$:!#B6#%& #
'.%;2KM&!O*#%}KMDY<("$O*
GU&!"=]K/#-%&!D7%:*#"W'"WD[%f&!O €O*-%*#"P&W !-.&!-/#-0LHaIJ<"$O (G&!"z›K"$O*
' *07D7#"&!O*u&$e'.%*"P<>-!Bc'.&!D7-% g'%;2S&!O*#%F/#-%&!D7%:*#"Q'."QD[%i&!O*
O*-%*#"P&(!-&!-/#-0H
°@U¼&TK+55"$O*-T+¿&!O*'.&M&!O D["1"P&$e'.&!#G.RZ'/eO*D7#V#"M&!O W!#"$: 0Y&\]X+XDY&!O
&!O*@ !-8*'8 D[07DY&4RNGD7V%~8R6&!O*l<w-.!Bu: 0º' q À H
q : %*%*-.!t Bc'07D #T2
U&
!#Bc'.D[% D7%*G
? )'%*2
? u2#%*-.&!3&!O r
"P&e'.&!"=+XO*#%6&!O*z-:&!/#-B6(-<}&!O*zB6T'"$:!#B6#%9
& # t D7"€])'%*2›K
!#"$9#/U&!D[V#0YRH
q <w-.
“z07"$-KW07&
b
š$¡~˜Æ™]šT›œ 2#%*-.&!3&!O q :*%*% -!Bc'.07A
D #T2
!#Bc'D7% D[% Gc"P&e'.&!#"@+XO #%
(D7t "lB6T'."$: !T2S'.%;2~&!O*Z-:&$A
/#-B6t u-<5&!O*uB6#'"$: !B6#%&lD7"¡Hf`=O*#%}K
yª
? @¢
r
'%*2 9? a¢
}ª
UH
r
r$r
r
½ %&!O*W-&!O*UyO;'.%;2}K
\¢
#ª
'%;2
a¢
#ª
r
r
r
UHa`=O*!<>-!K
r$r
|
=
&q H K
:B
r
' &!D7-%;'.02 D7"P&e'% /#@89U&4+=#%f&!O*#"$X&4+5-)!-8*'8*D707DY&4Rf2 D7"P&$!D78*: &!D7-%*"
«
D7"=¦ q ›
H D7%*/X+5@'!z/-%*"$D[2!D7%*G&!O*X89#"P&5B6T'"$:!A
r
B6%&\<>-52 D7"P&!D7%*tG: D7"$O*D7%*G
'%*2
K¦ q ›
D7"5T?:*'0
r t
B
B r
&!B6Bc'u_K &!O D["XD7B6*07D7#"
Ha•WR
B
B r
W
_
qH ‹
$
B n K B n
'‹|q K K B…q K ‹
K ¢£›4B
›B
?›
6 8 KK 9
6 8 K 9 6 8 KŸK 9 6 8 K 9 6 8 KŸK 9 F6 8 K 9 6 8 K 9•B_6 8 K 9 @
‹|8 K ‹
‹8 K ‹
‹|8 K ‹
‹8 K ‹
6 8 KŸK 91ª 6 8 K r 95¢ 6 8 KK 9(07T'2 "(&!-c&!O Q-: &!/-B6Z]f+XD7&!OS/#U$&e'D7%&4RH
`=O !<>-!K&!O*( !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR6-<M'Z2DYˁ!#%&=-: &!/#-B6 q ›z-=“z07D7/#
?
'%*O
2 @
Èb]K1&!O*%“(0[D7/#6/#'%‘"$: /#/##"$"P<>:*070YR/eO*T'&TH3•5#07-T+KM+=
"$O*-T+kO -T+£&!-c<w-!Bc'.07DH)&!O*D7l'.!G:*B6#%&l"$-c&!O;'&@DY&"$O -T+X"@&!O*
!-8;'.8*D707D7&JRN&!O*'.&(“(0[D7/#/#'%'./UO D[VH
@
¢»]i„ ŒT’a`=O*#%}K q À D7" P: "P& r ª H
t
É
É
•WR B6Bc'_K @ q
š
¢ @
¢ ]iD7B6*07D7#"
B
B r t
B
6¢
¦Hm`=O*D7"6B6T'% "u&!O;'&f&!O*U!dD7"c'FB6T'."$: !#B6%&)<w-.
B r
“z07D7/#u&!O*'.&Q9$<>#/&!0YRF2 D7"P&!D7%*G:*D7"$O*#"
'.%;2
H6“(0[D7/#u/T'%
B
B r
9$<>-!B
&!O D7"dB6T'."$: !#B6#%&c+XDY&!O*-: &S2D["P&!:!8*D7%*G¿&!O S!"P&-<
&!O*"P&e'&!K9DLH H="$-f&!O*'.&X&!O* 4-D7%&@"P&e'&!Q-<a“z07D7/#Z'%*2~•5-8S'.<>&!U
&!O*zB6T'"$:!#B6#%&WD["
y+XD7&!ON !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR› ¦Z'%*2
a+XDY&!O
r
!-8;'.8*D707D7&JRc› ¦H\I4%Z&!O*5– !"P&\/T'"$K"$O* 4:*"P&a/#-%&!D7%:*#"\'."\D[%Z&!O*
O*-%*#"P&) !-.&!-/#-0LHi`=O D[")GD7V#"Q&!O*3'.%*"P+=Uf]d+XDY&!Oo !-8;'8 D70[DY&JR
› ¦H
IJ<M"$O*GU&!"
UK 8R }#B6Bc')ÀK*&!O !D7"z'):*%*DY&e'$RN&$e'.%*"P<w-.$A
Bc'.&!D7-% Æ&!O;'&z/#'%d899U$<w-!B6#2N8RN“z07D7/#"$:*/eON&!O*'.&
q H
>q H K
>q H
[~
R6 8 K 9
68 9
'6 8 |9
M
68 K 9
68 9
6 8 KH 9
X6 8 9
68 9
_6 8 H 9
<6 8 K 9 6 8 KŸK 9 k6 8 K 9
6 8 ŸK K 9 76 8 K 9 f6 8 H 9 6 8 K 9
‹8 K …
B 8 KH ‹X¢ ‹ 8 r K B/8 K r ‹ © ‹8 r K ‹\ªF‹8 K r ‹
q _
¦ q ‹8 K ‹ É ªF‹8 K ‹ É @
r
r
©
t
t
« D7B6D70['.!0YR¾&!-¿&!O*i !--.<u-.<#B6Bc'm›T¦K‹|8
#
‹
Q
É
ª
‹
8
‹
É
K
r K
r
©B
r
Ha`=O !<w-.!K q _ D7"€'&€B6-"P& Hy@'.07"$-fO;'TV‹8
r
t
É H
8 r ‹ © +XDY&!Od&!O*"!'.B6l !--.<4H
U&'† HK 89S&!O*i"$&d-<)8*D7;'$&!D7&!F"P&e'.&!#"d"$:*/eO”&!O*'.&d' *0YRA
D7%*G6&!O*Q!#"P&@-<a&!O*Q !-.&!-/#-0 q ~ ~
  G r @1@1@~ H ! r '%;2d&!O Z–*%;'.0
B6T'."$: !#B6#%&W'.&a&!O*X#%*2f-<&!O*X!-&!-/#-09GD7V#"\t &!O*X-:&!/#-B6(]
+XDY&!O~ !-8;'.8*D707D7&JRF›H=`=O #%K6 8 K H €
9 ˜ K H HW“z07"$-K*&!O*@%*-!B{-.<y&!O*
!-?P /&!D7-%-<œ~ q 6 8 H 9 -%'† HK D7"z'&(0[#'"P&
¥¦ q 8R q ´ H
r
±5-% "$D[2 =&!O z% -!B6t "W-<}&!O*( !-?P#/&!D7-%*"X-<œ6 8 K 9W'%*2R6 8 t$t 9a-%
† HK H\`=O Rc2 DYˁ5<>!-Bv&!O*(%*-.!B6"W-.<<6 8 KH W9 '.%;2R6 8 Hr a9 8Rc'&=rB6-"P&
‹8 K B8 KH ‹ '%*2c‹|8 r B 8 Hr ‹ © Hf`=O*!<>-!K&!O*
!-?P /&!D7-%-© <:6 8 K 5
9 -%u† HK D7"X-<y% -!B{'&(0[#'"P& — r B '.%;2
É
&!O*N !-?P #/U&!D[-%¾-<&~6 8 u
9 D["u-<% -!B '&c07T'"P& — %
B H
r
É
?
_
@
@
?
@
L=
@
_
?
9?
@
?
?
@
?
?
@
@
B
›
;
¦
É
@
;
ª
<
B
@
¦
É
@
K
@
<
h -&!O*u*: !9-"$#"-<5&!O*D7"Q;'9UTKM'N+5T'‚<w-.!B¨-<€07#B6Bc'
›#ÀfD7"("$: 6/#D7#%&TH
$
›H MŒUŽœNZ˜¾™›šC@1@1@#š !B»›.œ’ *ŒU‡ Ž *Œ$Œ3†z
!
Ž ŽJŒŠ*#…`".†z
…‡Œ
!Ž r ¡ †L„UŒ
†„ =„ †¹Œ Œ
Ž Œ`!Œ
¡ Ž a†>Ž
‰$…QQ†¡ †>Žu.Ž<¡[ŒŸ
!Žur ª % B‘¦
¦
’
É
É
q.rjq
.r
%'
7
*G
!
!
G
!
@
X‘O*'V
t2rjq.q'uv
¦
B
›
;
¢
¦
¦
B
›
;
ª
@
¦
É
@
¦
@
›
¢
@
¦
@
ŒU‡
%'
¦nMªoÁ
©
@
¦
¦
¦
@
<
@
B
@
B¿¦
¦
É
¦
ª
@
@
@
<
<
@
@
!
!
@
’
@
[B6Bc'¿›#ÀK=“z07D7/#~/T'.%m'./UO
r ª
D[VžlŸ· ]¸¢
É
HM•5#/T'.:*"$5&!O 58 Dº'."M-<&!O*W !-.&!-/#-0D7"y'.&MB6-"P&yn#K
z•WR
t2rjq.q'uv
%
B¦
É
;
ª
r |
cŒNŽ ŽŽ *Œu†d
3… u6‰S$….Ž¹…T„e…¡X†J
fŽ
UŽJŒFŒ Œ P…‡#" © ¦n(ª£Á ‡S"
.r­¦H
q.rjq
f…
!Žn.’
¦
B
@
¦
<
ª
¦
;
ª
B
@
<
;
ª
<
@
B
›
;
$
@
% B
+5€Bu: "P&yO;'TV 6¦ ¦ @
na'.%;2,@
¦nªc´ ¦ @
©
©
©
É
¦.nyªoÁ @
H
<w-070[-T+X"z"$D[B6D70['.!0YRH
@
¦n1ªÄÁ @
©
°z¼&TKy+=3:*"$d±5-!-0[0['$R¾¦d&!-S"$O*-T+g&!O*'.&)&!O*6–92#07D7&!D7#"@
'.%;L
2 @
/T'.%*%*-.&z2 #/!#'"$l&!--f<L'."P&TH
H
!
%'
@
H
­›´ H r 6Œ)Ž ŽA d$…‡S"Z‰SP…Ž¹…T„!…4¡ Ž Œ†d
.Ž6…
eŽn’ *ŒU‡ …R‡RN + H © ›#´n r  ‡S"

H ›#´n r ’
D
'
©
."
Œ)„
ŒT’pNy¢ BěH
B…N
z•WRND[%*2 : /&!D7-%d-%
!
@
$H
t2rjq.q'uv

&

h DY!"P&TK!#B6#B)89X&!O;'& @
M
¢ @
¢¤]H &
˜o™ Zšuœf89
&!O u9!"$-%i+XO -N"$%;2 "z&!O*ZB6#"$"!'GfD7%S&!O m6!-:*%*2S'%;2
893&!O*39!"$-%o+XO*-S!#/#D[V#"u&!O*3B6#"$"!'.GH « #%;2D[% G'#+='TR¿'
*'.$&)-<€&!O 6"P&e'.&!6/T'.%¿-%*0YRFD7%*/!T'."$3&!O u–92#07DY&4RHd`=O*!<>-!K
r
r ¢»]H
@
@
¢»]K*DH H @
©
W
r ¢”¦n ,›´n#H
•aR±5-.!-070['.$RS¦K @
r © ¦nyª¿Á @
8e‡
„ŽL† Œ)„ ŒT’
Q'"$"$: B6l&!O;'.&X&!O 0[B6Bc')D7"(&$!: l<w-. 5'%;2N"$O*-T+Æ&!O*'.&(DY&
D7"Q'.0["$-3&$!:*Q<w-.
¾›H « D[B6D70['.!0YR&!-c&!O*Z !#VD7-: "l/T'."$K107&
89Z&!O*Z9!"$-%S+XO*-3"$#%*2 "@&!O )B6#"$"!'.GfD7%&!O* m6!-:*%*2S'%;2
ƒ89@&!O*@-&!O*Uz9U!"$-%HW`=O #%K
z
 G

G
S" &N•B
@
@
•aR±5-.!-070['.$RS¦K
HG
r
©
¦neªlÁ
_
 G
H G
›#´n r
r
©
  G
H
@
©
©
q ¦ªlÁ
"+
]N
 ›#´n r
›´
t
`N
n r
@
 +
,›´n r
Q
K
4I %Z;'$&!D7/#:*0['.TK #B6Bc'l›´lD7B6*07D7#"M&!O;'&0@
›´n r HM‘
©
q
r
}#B6Bc'u›¦Z'%;2f&!O z–*!"P&5;'e'Ge'.*Od'.<>&!U
'07"$-)O;'TV*@
r
r HN`M'.‚D7% G~07-G~-.<X89-&!O
DY&!"Q !--< H~`=O !<w-.!K€›#´n r t
r
"$D[2 #"€&J+XD[/ZGD7V#" 6¢ plq 07-G507-G r H
st
`=O D7"zB6T'.%*"=&!O*'.&€&!O*@ !-8*'8 D[07DY&4RN-<\-: &!/#-B6]uD7"('.&(07T'"P&
 @
$
&
$
&