CS275 GRADED HOMEWORK 8 - SOLUTION GIVE BACK ON

!"$#%'&(*)
+,.-0/1325476980:<;>=/?A@>2CBD:087-E/FG17/HDIKJL;>MDNPOPOLQR2S;<17/+,T::5,T:+98U/V520F
WCXZY$[A\^]L_`baC[(cKdfegX^hjibYk[(\^lmonCprqtsvuSwyxDzRe{dk_df_C[|^Yk[(\ydk[(cKd$]}\^Yf[~\^hSlsT€(qu>€‚q75wrwrƒj…„†>‡0ˆŠ‰j‹^XZa_S\rŒ^[~lXZaCŽdLc
\^ŽXZad‚zR_S\d‚egc\^cf^[Al7i†u9‘0nCpA’9dfXdf_C['z“X^YLleghC|X‰0dk_C[v`baC[Ac”dke•XZh<aChbdfeg–>dk_C['—[(\^hCe•hS|*X‰Edk_C[˜`baC[(cKdfegX^h<e.c‚]}–•[A\YA‡
™š_C[(hdkYf‹dfXœ›ShSl\^h\^hScKz“[}YA‡0ˆŠ‰‹ZX^a|^[žd‚cKdfa]LiCpZu„3€AnCp€˜‹^X^aSY~™Ÿ‡ ˜‡X^YR—[^‡
RlŒZ[}Yfdfe.cK[(—œ[(hbd(¡¢£X^aS–gl‹^X^aŽ[(hC[ž›Cd‰TYkX^—¤—[}hbdfXZYfeghC|b¥§¦[}['¨o¨o¨š©…ª«^¬­C®Z¯Z¬S«Z­“©Š¬C«^­e{‰£‹^X^a°‰T[}[}–E\–•e•dKdk–•[œ[ž±odfYL\
|ZaCeglS\hS]}[]}X^aC–.l_C[}–g²e•h‹^XZaCY~c”dkaSleg[(c(‡
³´–g[(\ZcK[ŸzRYke{dk[G‹^X^aSYšcf[(]ždfegX^hhoaC—˜Ž[}Y~\^hSl\h[(cKdfeg—\df[GX^‰>df_S[Ÿdfeg—œ[G‹ZX^acK²[}hbd~XZhdk_Cegc‚µ~¶·‡
¸ ‡~¹'ºS»‚¼¾½j¿5ºCÀjÁ
¸ ‡ ¸ ‡ wynÂ0q
x5mbÃ0„5…€(…u„Ä^ÅÆR[(](\–g–>dk_S\ydŸ\*|^YL\²S_°egc\hX^ŽÇ”[A]Pd E) i3zR_C[(Yf[ V e.c\cf[ždŸX‰´Œ^[(YKdkeg]}[(c\hSl E e.c
Yk[ e.c\*z£[(e•|Z_Zd‚‰TaChS]Pdke•XZhDl[}›ShC[Al<X^h°²\egYkcRX^‰
\*cf[ždX‰´[Al|^[Ac}‡‚ Èz£[(e•|Z_C[(l|ZYk\^²C_<e.c‚\hX^ŽÇ”[A]Pd (V, E, w) izR_C[}(V,
ŒZ[}Yfdfe.]ž[(c(‡5É´X^a<cK_SX^aC–.lohCXyzÊ[(\Z]L_X^‰>df_S['l[ž›ShSe{dke•XZhScRŽ[}–gXyzÊ\hlŽ['w\ŽC–g[ŸdfXœ›Shl[}±C\—²C–g[(cšX‰0cKa]L_XZŽÇ”[(]ždkc(‡
¦oeg—œ²S–•[ZiSlegYf[A]Pdf[Al7iCz“[}eg|^_C[Al7i–.\Ž[}–g[(l7i—vaC–{dke{˓\hSl²Scf[}aSlX^Ë´|^YL\²C_c}‡
•
XZaChSc(¡EÍ$l|^[ZiCŒ^[(YKdk[ž±7io[}hSlC²XZe•hbd(Îl[}|ZYf[([^ieghË$\hSlXZadKË$l[(|^Yk[}[X‰E\h[(l|Z[^‡
• Ì
R
r
l
ǔ[(]ždfegŒ^[Ac}¡´\ZlrÇK\^]}[}hbd(ieghS]že.l[(hZdAiCeghCe{dkeg\^–ÏiC›ShS\–´Ð…Œ^[(YKdk[ž±SÑPieghS]že.l[(hZdRdkXoÒr‰TYfXZ—ie.cfX^–.\ydf[Al7i²[}hSlC\^hbd(‡
•
^
X
Yk[RhCXZaChSc(¡>²S\df_jib]žegYk]}aCe{dA‡´¦oaCŽC|ZYk\^²C_jiaChSe•XZhœX^‰|ZYk\^²C_Sc(‡0¢£XZhChC[(]ždf[Alœ]}X^—²X^hC[(hZdAiZ]}ad$[(lC|^[(cPÒrŒZ[}Yfdfe.]ž[Ac}‡
• Ó
^
X
Yk[G\^lrǔ[A]Pdke•ŒZ[(c(¡0]}X^hChS[(]Pdk[(l7iCcKdfYkX^hS|^–g‹CÒyz£[A\o–g‹]}X^hChS[(]Pdk[(l|^YL\²C_>iCcKeg—²C–•[Ÿ²S\df_ҏ]žegYk]}aCe•d(‡
• Ó
´
³
k
Y
^
X
²[}Yfdfeg[(c(¡0µ\hSlScK_S\^oe•hC|œdk_C[}XZYf[(—iodk_C[}XZYf[(—c~Ôv\^hSlÕvX^‰“Ö×Ôr؊‡
•
¸ ‡ ¸ ‡ ¸ ‡RÙEÚoۏÜ~Ý3ޕß(à‚ˆáh\cKX^‰¾d”z“\^Yf[²CYfX^ǔ[(]žd(iodf_S['l[}²[}hSlC[}hS]}e•[AcRŽ[}d”z£[([}hcKXZaCYL]ž[›S–g[(cR\Yk[^¡
We•–g[‚ª3âSãA¬š©LäG_S\^cRl[(²[(hSl[(hS]žeg[(cRXZhåy­æã®´©Šç7iyªSèSéSãAꚩëç*\^hSlœªèSéSãAꓩL䍇
•
We•–g[‚ªèCéSãAꚩLäŸ_\^cRl[(²[(hSl[}h]žeg[(cRXZhåy­æãy®$©Šç*\hSlªèSéCãAꚩŠç7‡
• We•–g[‚ªèCéSãAꚩŠç_\^cRl[(²[(hSl[}h]žeg[(cRXZhåy­æãy®$©Šç7‡
™5XYf[(²C•Yk[(cf[}hbdRdf_C[vl[}²[}hSlC[}hS]}‹Yk[}–.\ydke•XZhŽ[žd”z“[}[(h›S–g[(c(iSaScfe•hS|*—\ydf_S[}—\ydkeg](\–jhCX^dk\dfegX^hjiX^hC[˜]}X^aC–.ll[ž›hC['dk_C[˜\
legYk[(]Pdk[(l|^YL\²C_zRe{dk_Œ^[}Yfdfe.]ž[Ac V = {ª3âãA¬š©kä , ªèCéSãAꚩLä , ªèSéCãAꚩŠç , åy­æãy®$©Šç } iS\^hSl[(l|Z[(c
ª âãA¬š©kä , ªèSéCãAꚩLä ) , (ª3âSãA¬š©Lä , ªSèSéSãAꚩëç ) , (ª3âãA¬š©kä , åy­oæã®$©Šç ) ,
ªèSéCãAꚩLä , ªèSéSãAꓩŠç ) , (ªèSéCãAꚩLä , åy­æã®´©Šç ) ,
(
ªèSéSãAꓩŠç , åy­oæã®$©Šç )} .
(
e.c‚\*legYk[(]Pdk[(l|ZYk\^²C_<Yk\df_C[(YRdf_\h\*cfeg—œ²S–•[v|^YL\²C_ji[(\Z]L_[(–•[(—[}hbdX^‰ E e.c\h<X^YLl[(Yf[Al²\egY
Ì Xdf['idf_SYk\\dfd(_Ci3[(cKYšeghSdf]ž_S[ \^h
E
*
\
ÔyËë[(–•[(—[}hbdšcf[žd {f, g} ‡
(f, g)
ÔC‡~ì~í>ºCÀ3î¼TÁ}ºÁ
ï mbwrpZ…ÄAmÈðÅÍE±odf[(hSl[Al§Œ^[(Ykcfe•XZhñX‰GÍE±[}YL]že.cK[òÔyó9²j‡Rô^ôZôòX‰Ö ÔyØë‡WSX^YzR_Ceg]L_§Œy\^–•aC[Ac*X^‰ n \^Yf[<dk_C[(cf[°|ZYk\^²C_Sc
ŽCeg²S\^YKdke{dk[A¥
õ nö K
õ ‘´ö C
õ poö W
õ xEö Q
õ mCö S
n
n
n
n
n
zR_C[(Yf[ Sn egcRdf_C[‚÷fc”dL\YKøcfe•—²C–g[Ÿ|^YL\²C_ ({0, . . . , n} , {{0, 1} , {0, 2} , {0, 3} , . . . , {0, n}}) ‡
uùρ>€A…u„$ú
nö ¡ n ∈ {1, 2} ÐTXZ*e•‰XZhC–•‹Ô˜e.cR–gegcKdf[AlSÑP‡
n
‘Eö K
¡E[}ŒZ[}h ‡>÷”³E\Yfdfeg[(c”ø\^Yf[
iS\^hSl {2, 4, . . . , n} ‡
Cn
pbö W e.cšhC[}ŒZn[}YRŽCeg²S\^YKdke{dk[^‡ {1, 3, . . . , n − 1}
n
û
E
= {(
üSý}þkÿ
ý"!#$
þ
e
a
b
c
d
f
g
õ nö
õ ‘´ö
%š¼'&(jÀ7º)*,+-* õ nö
Ó \^²‰TXZYRÍE±7‡SÕC‡$¦oXZaCYL]ž[^¡ Ì y\ df–뇴 “df–.\^cšX^‰>dk_C[/.'‡×¦3‡ '‡>Ö ¸ ؊‡ õ ‘´ö10Yk\^²C_‰TX^YRÍE±7‡Có
x0ö Q egc‚ŽCeg²S\Yfdfe•df[˜‰TX^Y‚\^–•– n ‡ 2j[žd V = {X = (x , . . . , x ) | ∀i ∈ {0, . . . , n} , x ∈ {0, 1}} = {0, 1}n Ž[
df_Cn[£cK[}djX‰Œ^[(YKdkeg]}[(c3X‰ Q ‡™š_C[>÷”²\Yfdfeg[(c”ø0\Yk[df_C1[(h {X ∈n V | P x e.cš[}ŒZ[}h } \^hSl i {X ∈ V | P x e.cšXlCl } ‡
mCö S egc*ŽCe•²\Yfdfe•df[‰TX^Y*\^–•n– n ‡Ê™š_C[÷K²S\Yfdfeg[(c”ø\^Yf[dk_C[÷f]ž[}hbdk[}YKøŒ^[(iYKdk[ž± {0} \hSl§\^–•–šdk_C[°Xdk_C[}Y*iŒZ[}Yfdfe.]ž[Ac
n
‡
{1, . . . n}
ï mbwrpZ…ÄAm ŦoXZ–•ŒZ[Í´±o[(Yk]}egcf[Õ^ó˜²j‡CôZô3'X^‰$Ö×ÔAØë‡42>[žd Ž[Ÿ\˜|^YL\²C_zRe{df_ Œ^[(YKdkeg]}[(c“\hSl [Al|^[Ac}‡52>[žd Ž[df_C[
—\y±eg—˜aC— l[}|ZYf[([X^‰5dk_C[GŒ^[(YKdkeg]}[(c“X‰ G iS\hl–g[žd m GŽ[Ÿdf_C[G—eghCeg—˜aC—l[}v|ZYf[([X^‰5dk_C[GŒ^[(YKedkeg]}[(c“X‰ G ‡$¦oM
_CXyz df_S\d
nö 2e/v ≥ m ‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú62>[žd {X , . . . , X } Ž[*dk_C[cf[ždœX‰~ŒZ[}Yfdfe.]ž[(c(‡™š_C[_S\hlCcK_\oe•hS|<df_C[(X^Yk[}— ck\r‹oc'df_S\d 2e =
Pv
‡ 7“‹1l[}›ShCe•dfegX^vhGX^‰ m i(XZhC[E_S\Zc ∀i ∈ {1, . . . , v} , deg (X ) ≥ m ircKXšdk_S\yd Pv deg (X ) ≥
8
deg
(X
)
i
i
i=1
Pvi=1
‡ 9ZX^eghCeghC|œdf_C[Ÿd”z“X˜dkX^|Z[ždf_S[}YAiX^hC[Ÿ|^[}dkc 2e ≥ mv iScfXœdf_Si\d 2e ≥ m ‡
4
m
=
mv
i=1
v
‘Eö 2e/v
‡
≤M
uù…5€(Ïu„£:ú 2j[žd {X , . . . , X } Ž[Edk_C[$cf[ždjX‰ŒZ[}Yfdfe.]ž[(c(‡ 7“‹l[}›ShCe•dfegX^hGX^‰ M iAX^hC[E_S\Zc ∀i ∈ {1, . . . , v} , deg (X ) ≤
1
v
P
ijcKXdf_\yd Pv deg
‡ 7“‹<aScfe•hS|dk_C[_S\hSlScK_S\^oe•hC|df_C[(X^Yk[}— \Zc\^ŽXyŒZ[^i3X^hS[ i
;
M
(Xi ) ≤ vi=1 M = M v
i=1
|^[}dkc 2e ≤ M v \hl*dk_bac M ≥ 2e ‡
v
ï mbwrpZ…ÄA=
m <>Å¢£XZhScKe.l[(Yvdk_C[<c”dL\ydk[(cX‰1>Ÿ[}hbdfa]Lb‹§Ð,>ɟÑPi£™>[(hChC[(ckcf[}[ Ѕ™ ўi XZYKdk_§¢“\^YfXZ–•eghS\Si5?‚egYf|Ze•hCe.\ Ð'?0 ÑPi
¶ò[(cKd@?‚egYf|Ze•hCe.\Ѕ¶A?ўi Ì XZYKdk_ Ð Ì ¢šÑ\hSlò¦oX^aCdf_t¢“\YkX^–ge•hS\DÐϦS¢šÑžiCB_CegXDÐDBÌ µÑPÌi>ˆáhSle.\hS\òÐTˆ Ì Ñ\^hSlDˆá–•–ge•hSX^e.cœÐ…ˆE25ўi
Yk[}²CYk[(cf[}hbdk[(lve•hdk_C[~—\²egh*We•|ZaCYf[‚ÔC‡ ¸ ‡5¶ò[~zš\hbd´dkXGŽCaCeg–gl*\Ÿ|ZYk\^²C_zR_CXZcf[RŒ^[(YKdkeg]}[(c´\^Yf[RcKdk\df[~hS\^—[(c´\^hSlzR_C[}Yk[
\^h[Al|^[G]žXZhChC[A]Pdkc“d”z“Xc”dL\ydk[(cše•‰0\^hSlXZhC–g‹*e{‰0dk_C[Gc”dL\ydf[Ac~cf_S\Yk[\]}X^——X^hŽXZYkl[(Y(‡
nö¶§_Ce.]L_d”‹o²[GX‰|^YL\²C_ Ѕcfe•—²C–g[^ile•Yk[(]ždf[Al7i²Scf[}aSlX^ËáÑ£e.cR—XZcKd~\²C²CYkX^²SYfe.\ydk[‚dkXœYk[}²SYf[AcK[(hZdšdk_CegcRlS\ydk\b¥
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú£ ·cfeg—œ²S–•[G|ZYk\^²C_zReg–•–5lXS‡
‘Eö°¶DYke•df[Ÿdf_S[G|^YL\²C_e•h—\ydk_C[}—\ydkeg](\–7hCX^dk\dfegX^hj‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú FGFAEˆ 2´i ˆ @Ì H i F(Eˆ 2´i >É H i F(ˆ Ì i >É H i FAˆ Ì Ii Bµ H i FJBµ˜i >É H i FBµ'i A
¶ ? H -i FK>Évi A
¶ ? H i FK>ɜi ?0 H i
FK>ɜi ™
i
F(A
¶
?vi ?0 i
FL?0 'i ¢
i
FL?0 'i ™
i
F
¢
i
™
i
F
¢
i
S
¦
¢
Ì/H
H
Ì H
Ì@H Ì Ì@H Ì
HMH
ï mbwrpZ…ÄAO
m N>ňáhdf_C['legYk[(]Pdk[(l—˜aS–{dke{ˊ|^YL\²C_X‰EWe•|ZaCYf['ÔC‡ ¸ ibYkeg|^_bd(‡0¶òYfe•df['lXyzRhdf_S[Ÿ‰TX^–g–•XyzReghC|[}–g[}—[}hbdLc}¡
nP
ö ?E[}Yfdfe.]ž[Ac}iC[Al|^[Ac}‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú V = {a, b, c, d, e, f, g} iAzRYfe•dfeghC|R[Z‡ |‡ ba ‰TXZY (b, a) i(XZhC[E_S\Zc E = {ba, bd, cb, db, dc, ee, ef, f e}‡
‘Eö Ó aC–•dfeg²C–geg]}e{d”‹X‰df_C[G[Al|^[Ac}‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú£™š_S[G—˜aC–•dfeg²C–geg]}e{dke•[Ac~\Yk[^¡ w (dc) = 2 \^hSl w (e) = 1 ‰TX^Y~\^–•–7X^df_C[(YR[(l|Z[(cšegh e ∈ E ‡
pböˆ”cKXZ–g\df[Al\^hSl²[}hlC\hbd~Œ^[(YKdkeg]}[(c(‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú$ˆ”cfX^–.\ydk[(l7¡ g ‡E³0[}hSlC\^hbd a ‡
Sü ý}þkÿ
ý"!#$
x0ö°ˆáhËál[}|ZYf[([^iX^aCdKËál[}|ZYf[([\^hSllC[}|^Yk[}[X‰0[(\Z]L_ŒZ[}Yfdf[}±3‡
Q
b c d e f g
Ô Ô ¸ Ô ¸ R
¸
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú
deg
Ô ¸ Õ Ô ¸ R
R
deg+
¸ ó Õ ó ó Ô R
deg
mCöD¦bdfYkX^hS|^–g‹\hSlz“[(\o–g‹]žXZhChC[A]Pdf[Al]}X^—²X^hC[(hZdLcšX‰5df_C[G|ZYk\^²C_j‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú¦odfYkX^hC|Z–•‹]žXZhChC[(]ždf[Al<]žX^—²X^hC[(hbdkc(¡ {b, c, d} \^hSl {e, f } ‡¶D[A\o–•‹]žXZhChC[A]Pdf[Al°]žXZ—²XZhC[}hbdkc(¡
\^hSl {e, f } ‡
{a, b, c, d}
ï mbwrpZ…ÄAm ňáhW5eg|S‡Ô‡ ¸ õ ‘EöyiSck\r‹zR_C[ždk_C[}Yšdk_C[Ÿ‰TX^–g–•XyzReghC|X^ŽCǔ[(]PdLcR]}\^hŽ[Ÿ‰TX^aChl\^hSl7ie•‰‹Z[(c(iCl[(ck]žYkegŽ[ŸX^hS[^‡
nöD ·cKeg—²C–g[G²S\ydk_X^‰5–g[}hC|^df_<Õc”dL\YfdfeghC|œe•h d \^hSl[}hSleghC|egh a ‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú´É´[Ac}¡ (d, c, b, a) ‡
‘Eö ²S\ydk_²S\^ckcKeghC|vdf_CYkX^aS|^_ a i b i c \^hSl d e•h<\ho‹*XZYklC[}YA‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú Ì XS¡°¦oa]L_ñ\ò²S\df_ñz“X^aC–.l _\rŒ^[dfX [}hl egh a \hltdk_bachCXd*|ZX°÷ádk_CYfXZaC|^_ø a ÐTacKeghC| df_S[
l[ž›hCe{dke•XZhX‰df_C[GŽXoX^CÑP‡´¦\r‹oeghC|‹^[(c(¡ c, b, a) egc~\^–gcfXœX^3iodf_CXZaC|^_>‡
pböD ²S\ydk_X‰5–g[}hS|df_ócKdk\YfdfeghC|egh d \hSl(d,
[}hSlCe•hC|egh a ‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú (d, b, d, b, a) ‡
x0ö ·]žegYk]}aCe•d‚c”dL\YfdfeghC|œ\d d i\hSl²S\^ckcfe•hC|vdf_SYfXZaC|^_ a ‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú Ì XS‡´ ²S\df_²S\Zcfcfe•hS|˜dk_CYfXZaC|^_ a hC[A]ž[(ckck\Yke•–g‹df[(Yf—eghS\ydk[(c“df_S[}Yk[^‡
mCö ·]žegYk]}aCe•d~X‰5–g[}hS|df_dk_CYf[([Gc”dL\YfdfeghC|e•h e ‡
uù…5€(Ïu„£ú´É´[Ac}¡E[Z‡ |‡ (e, e, e, e) i (e, f, e, e) ‡•‡
a
−
I ´:
N ´6 yM yH
´= ? 2
¹'º-SoºCÀ7ºC½5îºÁ
T VU CWX,Y[Z]\JW_^WX,^IW_`Z_a"X,bdc 4e Ge feLbXgX,hji k]k\JWX,Y[Z]\JW_^IWXl^IW_`me n]ZpoGe
T U qe 4e Z]`lcE\jeMr5sutVvmwgxpy#x5z{]yu|Kxp}{]y~suvpt:{€‚Vyƒt8„…€…† suvD{]y~sƒ‡]JtDe 1ˆ C‰lWEŠ
yF $+ M8Y[^[^~‹KŒqcEdY XlY[Z]\M‹NPOPO]ŽKe