Wendy Jolliffe, Centre for Educational Studies, University of Hull

Wendy Jolliffe, Centre for Educational Studies, University of Hull, Hull HU6 7RX
Telephone: 01482 466513, e-mail: [email protected]
Paper presented at the British Educational Research Association Annual
Conference, University of Manchester, 16-18 September 2004
The National Literacy Strategy: not prescriptive enough?
Abstract
This paper examines the background to the introduction of the National Literacy
Strategy, thereby explaining the rationale behind its inception. From a critical
analysis of what makes effective teaching and learning of literacy; it presents
qualitative research carried out in the form of a comparative study of the National
Literacy Strategy and Success for All. This small scale study of four schools
supports the hypothesis that the underpinning pedagogy needs to be explicitly
understood for an initiative to be effective. In the case of Success for All,
teachers are made explicitly aware of the key importance of cooperative learning
as the vehicle for learning. In the case of the National Literacy Strategy,
however, other than some knowledge of the need for ‘interactive’ teaching, no
explicit understanding of the learning theory that underpins it, is apparent. In
other words, it may be said, the National Literacy Strategy is not ‘prescriptive’
enough.
Introduction
The National Literacy Strategy (NLS) has been held up by authorities on
international change to be the largest and most ambitious educational project
witnessed since the 1960s (Fullan, 2000). At the conference for its launch, in
1997, David Blunkett (then the opposition spokesperson for Education)
announced that if his party came to power, 80 per cent of 11-year-olds in
England would reach the expected level (Level 4) in reading by 2002 (later
changed to Level 4 in English). Professor Bob Slavin (the originator of Success
for All) responded that it reminded him of President Kennedy’s 1962 target of
getting a man on the moon by the end of the decade. Only, said Professor
Slavin, the NLS target was more difficult (Beard, 2002). Such a large-scale
reform has been the subject of fierce debate and much research. This paper
begins with a critical review of this research and then compares the NLS to
another major strategy, Success for All (SFA), adapted in the U.K. to primarily
teach literacy.
Background
The debate over the effective teaching of literacy has raged long and
vehemently. The author, as a newly appointed Literacy Co-ordinator in a primary
school prior to the introduction of the NLS, recalls being given the ‘poisoned
chalice’ of conducting in-service training with the staff on the effective teaching of
W. Jolliffe
-1-
reading. In an attempt to highlight the need to teach a range of reading
strategies, a fierce argument broke out over the virtues of teaching reading
through the ‘whole language approach’, using ‘real’ books, versus the value of
teaching the sub-skills such as phonics. The two positions seemed totally
polarised and have been described as the ‘reading wars’ (Goodman, 1998).
What was the overall situation regarding the teaching of literacy prior to 1998 (the
date of the introduction of the National Literacy Strategy)? Research shows that
standards in literacy among English primary school children had remained largely
stable from 1948-1996. National Curriculum tests in 1995 and 1996 highlighted
the concern and indicated that only 48% and 57% respectively of 11 year-olds
were reading at the level expected for their age group (i.e. National Curriculum
Level 4) (Brooks, 1998). As Beard (2000) shows, evidence from inspection,
surveys and research, all suggest that, in the years prior to the NLS, early
reading in English primary schools was largely taught by individualised methods,
which consisted principally of the teacher listening to the child read (e.g. Cato et
al, 1992). Indeed, Beard (2000: 246) notes ‘direct teaching of literacy skills was
surprisingly rare’. One can, therefore, conclude that until the introduction of the
NLS in 1998, when schools were required to specifically teach a range of literacy
skills, the teaching of reading in England was very variable.
Research into the teaching of literacy
During the 1990s, a wealth of research was produced on the effective teaching of
literacy, for example Adams’ seminal work (1990) indicating the clear need for
explicit teaching of phonics within the context of a meaningful interaction with
texts. Other key findings from Bryant (1993) and Goswami (1995) highlighted the
need for developing phonological awareness. The work carried out by Clay
(1979) through Reading Recovery emphasised the need to make explicit how
print works, how to link reading and writing effectively, and to ensure swift
intervention when children begin to exhibit a lack of effective progress.
Holdaway’s work (1979) on using shared texts to enable teachers to recreate the
experience of a bedtime story with a child and parent, began to be replicated to
effect, and further work by the Australian genre theorists (Littlefair, 1991), made
clear the need to not only introduce a range of genres to children, but also to
make the features of each explicit, to enable a clearer understanding. All these
formed the background to the National Literacy Strategy.
Recent published research identifies certain key factors in successful literacy
teaching, and helps illuminate some pertinent issues in evaluating the National
Literacy Strategy.
1. Effective teachers have coherent belief systems about literacy which are
generally consistent with the way they teach (Wray, Medwell, Poulson and
Fox, 2002). Wray, Medwell et al, state:
W. Jolliffe
-2-
‘The clear implication of this finding is that to raise expertise levels in all
teachers of literacy, some professional development opportunities at least
need to be channelled to those teachers not already identified as expert.’
(2002:130)
2. Further support is needed in order to develop genuinely interactive teaching
skills (the recommended model by the NLS). Moyles et al (2003) found that:
‘for the most part, whole-class interactive teaching remains a one-way
teacher-dominated activity.’ (2003:xiii)
The most recent Ofsted report on the National Literacy and Numeracy
Strategies (2003) reiterates this point:
‘In too many lessons, teacher’s talk dominates and there are too few
opportunities for pupils to talk and collaborate to enhance their learning.’
(Ofsted, 2003:3).
3. Understanding of the pedagogical theory is crucial to effective teaching, but
as Fisher (2002) notes during the introductory training to the NLS there was
only a five minute short explanation which looked at the rationale.
Harrison (2002) specifies the five underlying elements of the teaching
sequence of the literacy hour, which interestingly, is nowhere made explicit in
the training, as follows:
(i) Identification of prior knowledge
(ii) Teacher demonstration of process
(iii) Shared exploration through activity
(iv) Scaffolded pupil application of new learning
(v)Consolidation through discussion of activity
4. An explicit understanding of the links between theory and practice is needed
(Bailey, 2002). Bailey’s research centres on the effective teaching of writing,
and describes a ‘fragile link’ (2002: 23) between research and practice. The
implementation of the National Literacy Strategy has, she suggests, led to an
‘anxious literalism’ (2002:26) which has in turn meant a discrete teaching of
language skills and concepts and a diminution of written composition.
Focus questions for research
The foregoing resumé of research into the effective teaching of literacy has
shown that the following are pre-requisites:
1. An effective programme of professional development;
2. Teaching should be genuinely interactive;
3. A deep-rooted understanding by teachers of the pedagogical
process;
W. Jolliffe
-3-
4. Clear links made between theory and practice.
These therefore formed key elements in my research in reviewing the
effectiveness of two major literacy strategies.
Review of research into the National Literacy Strategy
It is important first to briefly describe the background to the introduction of the
NLS. Before accession to power in 1997, the Labour party had set up a literacy
taskforce which was charged with developing a strategy for substantially raising
standards of literacy in primary schools over a five to-ten-year period. The
preliminary report cited international data, as well as local data, as being
influential in the development of ‘best practices’. They also referred to New
Zealand research and practices. Indeed a taskforce had been set up in New
Zealand with very similar goals, but there the similarities end, as the New
Zealand taskforce drew upon a much larger range of experience and research
expertise. The latter report recommended increasing teachers’ and school based
responses to developing best practice.
The whole thrust was for the
development of teachers’ skills and knowledge so that they could implement best
practice in the teaching of literacy with a stress on strong professional leadership.
These recommendations form a stark contrast to the U.K. taskforce’s preference
for a ‘framework’ to structure and sequence pedagogic activities and to specify
the content that was to be taught during the ‘literacy hour’.
To summarise, Soler (2000:15) stated in her analysis of the two reports:
‘A comparison of the development and content of the English ‘Literacy
Taskforce Preliminary Report’ and the New Zealand ‘Report of the
Literacy Taskforce’ highlights the way in which differing wider political
contexts, membership and governmental ‘vision’, can influence the
analysis and recommendations derived from a similar research base.’
Critical responses to the NLS from educational research
From the introduction of the NLS to the present day a range of criticisms have
been voiced. In relation to the focus questions in this research, they are briefly
as follows:
1. Ineffective whole class teaching
A major thrust of the reform introduced with the NLS is the concept of
interactive whole class teaching. Indeed the NLS Framework document
states: ‘The most successful teaching is …. interactive’ (DfEE, 1998: 8).
Critics argue that the concept is not well defined and that it mainly results in
traditional whole class teaching. As a consequence teachers are pressurised
into more directive forms of teaching with less emphasis on active learning.
The findings of Mroz, Smith & Hardman’s study (2000), which were supported
by the extensive research of Galton et al (1999), found an increase in whole
W. Jolliffe
-4-
class teaching and that the majority of questions used by teachers were either
closed or factual. Further research has been carried out into interactive
teaching in the primary school, in the form of a project entitled the Study of
Primary Interactive Teaching (SPRINT), Moyles et al, (2003). It concluded
that although the NLS extended the rate of pupil contributions, it actually
reduced the opportunities for extended interactions.
2. Meeting the needs of Special Educational Needs Pupils
The requirements of supporting children with Special Educational Needs have
been shown to be problematic, particularly with the NLS’s emphasis on whole
class teaching (Byers, 1999). The introduction of the NLS has also resulted
in the shelving of the Reading Recovery Project in many areas due to a lack
of sufficient funding. MacGilchrist (1997) from the Institute of Education
strongly upholds the need for Reading Recovery and feels it is
complementary to this major thrust for literacy. This lack of intervention for
children who are falling behind was initially a key difference between the NLS
and other literacy schemes, such as Success for All. A symposium of
research on the strategy (Fisher et al, 2000: 244) stated that there were valid
concerns ‘about the capability of the NLS to address the learning needs of all
pupils which urgently needs to be explored. One size does not necessarily fit
all’.
However in December 2001 an intervention scheme, called Early Literacy
Support, was introduced for year 1 pupils who were falling slightly behind their
peers, to be delivered by Classroom Support Assistants for a total of 60
sessions. Further intervention strategies have also been introduced for years
4 and 5. One of the key factors in instigating change in the teaching of
literacy was the ‘long tail of underachievement’ and evidence that between
one sixth and one eighth of adults experience problems with basic literacy,
and this had persisted for 60 years, (Brooks, 1996). Interestingly the much
publicised report on reading standards from 35 different countries (NFER,
2003) highlights the improvement in reading in England, but indicates that
the NLS has had little effect on this ‘long tail of underachievement’.
3. Neglect of learning theory
Graham (1998) pointed out a major deficiency of the NLS, which has the goal
of raising standards with the assumption that an intensive teaching model is
better than a model of how children learn. This shift from encouraging
learning to direct teaching derived from a desire to emulate the methods
perceived as successful in countries such as South Korea. Graham states
(1998:121): ‘transmission is not the name of the game, however informed the
teacher.’
Cordon argues (1999: 105) the learning theory underpinning the NLS
emphasises the interactive process of teaching and learning and is
W. Jolliffe
-5-
‘particularly concerned with social discourse, collaborative learning and the
joint construction of knowledge.’ This would not seem to be borne out in
practice, however, as a study by Collins and Marshall (2001) showed that
often a small number of pupils dominate discussion and others speak rarely.
4. Speaking and Listening not specifically included
The neglect of Speaking and Listening has been a key criticism by teachers.
Collins and Marshall study (2001, p 12) cites substantial classroom-based
research on the importance of exploratory talk for learning. Corden (2000)
argues that considering an extensive body of research which demonstrates
the relationship between talk, academic empowerment and achievement
(Johnson et al 1981; Slavin 1983, Webb and Cullian 1983; Wells and Chang
1988; Sharan and Shaulov 1989; Wells et al 1990); it is a ‘shameful neglect’
(2000:17) that ‘having emphasised the centrality of talk, the DfEE chose to
exclude speaking and listening from the NLSF.’ (NLSF - National Literacy
Strategy Framework for Teaching) (2000:17). This has been addressed with
the production of new guidance on incorporating speaking and listening within
the NLS Framework.
It will, however, require extensive professional
development in order for teachers to see this as integral and not merely an
‘add on’.
Whilst the above criticisms highlight key areas of concern, the NLS has also
been subjected to review by Ofsted and their report in 2002 reviewed progress to
date. This showed that some of the key issues highlighted in their report in 2000
were still outstanding. These related to issues of: a lack of improvement in
phonics teaching, specifically with regard to children in years 3 and 4; persistent
weakness in the delivery of guided reading; a lack of clarity in relation to day-today assessment and that speaking and listening was rarely planned in detail.
Perhaps most revealing was the lack of deep-rooted understanding of the
rationale behind the strategy, particularly by headteachers, leading to issues of
weak leadership.
The Toronto University evaluation of the NLS consists of a series of three
Government-commissioned annual reports. The Ontario Institute for Studies in
Education describes itself as a ‘critical friend’, leaving the report open to possible
criticism regarding the level of independence. The final report commissioned by
the DfES has shown that ‘much has been accomplished’ (2003:3), but that this
‘will require sustained professional learning experiences over many years if
improvements in teaching practice are to be lasting.’ They conclude that on
balance and ‘cautiously’ it has been value for money, but further challenges
remain:



W. Jolliffe
More in-service development due to a persistent lack of pedagogical
understanding which will inhibit further development
Efforts by Government to minimise increased teacher workload
A narrowing of the curriculum due to test preparation
-6-

A need for more out of school influences to impact, e.g. the cooperation and work with parents.
Review of research into Success for All
My research proceeded to review the background and research into Success for
All as an alternative literacy strategy. Success for all (SFA) is a large scale
school improvement strategy devised by Robert Slavin in the USA. It is derived
from research carried out into cooperative learning and has then been developed
into a scheme for the teaching of literacy (although this has been extended into
Maths and Social Studies in the US).
Cooperative learning (CL) is one of the most widely researched areas in recent
educational history. In the last 100 years, over 550 experimental and 100
correlational studies have been conducted with different ages, subject areas and
settings (Johnson & Johnson, 1989). Results of these have shown three main
categories of advantages; achievement, inter-personal relationships and
psychological health and social competence.
However, closer examination reveals that in spite of its growth, there is a real
concern about the quality of cooperative methods being used. Research has
shown (e.g. Davidson, 1985; Slavin, 1995) the importance of group goals as well
as individual accountability for group work, and yet in many studies these have
been shown to be absent. In other words, CL may be widespread, but to what
extent it is effective and follows the core principles, is debatable. It is also
interesting to note that there is limited research into how to implement CL
(Bennett, 1994).
In 1986 the John Hopkins University, led by Robert Slavin, began to experiment
with the idea of a cooperative ‘elementary’ school, i.e. rather than cooperative
learning taking place on a teacher by teacher basis, the introduction of a whole
school programme. This showed positive results (Slavin, 1996) and grew to
projects in over 1500 schools by 2000 in 48 states in the US, together with
schools in Canada, Mexico, Australia, Israel and England using it. The approach
to CL used is Student Teams Achievement Division (STAD) which rewards
teams for the sums of its members’ efforts. This method has been criticized for
introducing an element of competition and extrinsic reward (Johnson and
Johnson, 1989 and Brown and Thomson, 2000).
Research has overwhelmingly found Success for All to have positive outcomes in
terms of pupils’ achievement. Such results have been summarised using a
method called multi-site replicated experiment (Slavin 1996a: 92-99). Critics have
attacked Success for All because of lack of third party evaluations (Pogrow,
2000). In response, Slavin has published a considerable amount of research on
the web site and compiled an extensive list of independent researchers involved.
The large amount of evidence on cooperative learning as well as on the effects of
W. Jolliffe
-7-
Success for All, would all seem to support Slavin’s claim that “Success for All is
one of the greatest success stories of educational research and reform” (1999:1).
To summarise, the key elements of the SFA programme are:
1. The philosophical basis called ‘talent development’, i.e. that all children
have talents capable to being developed to meet high standards.
2. Research into effective learning.
3. Cooperative learning.
4. Early intervention to prevent failure.
5. A reading programme based on research into effective practices for
beginning reading.
6. An intensive professional development programme, and the
involvement of parents.
7. Replicability through high levels of implementation.
Success for All also includes a ‘Getting Along Together’ programme to enable
teachers to teach the skills of co-operating. The effectiveness of this, however, is
a largely un-researched area.
Key differences: NLS and SFA
My review of existing research elicited seven key differences between NLS and
SFA. These are as follows:
1. A learning theory which is specified and incorporated. In SFA, learning
through the social construction of knowledge by cooperative learning is
integral. For the NLS, this consists of interactive teaching and whilst there
is a statement of desirability, how this to be incorporated is not explicit.
2. A school-wide programme which requires full staff commitment and
restructuring. SFA is a holistic school reform model requiring a minimum
of 80% commitment by all staff and organisational restructuring, e.g.
through the provision of a facilitator and pupils grouped by ability, not age.
NLS is a curriculum based reform and requires no prior commitment by
the majority of staff. The organisation of the school does not require any
restructuring.
3. Comprehensive materials and resources are provided. For SFA extensive
materials are provided which incorporate cooperative learning and
metacognitive techniques. For NLS, extensive materials are provided
although these do not explicitly incorporate ‘interactive’ teaching, apart
from some surface features.
4. Commitment to ongoing professional development: for SFA there is
extensive training particularly for Headteachers and senior managers.
Ongoing training for all staff is provided by SFA staff, together with
support from ‘expert’ literacy teachers, or Facilitators, in each school. For
NLS a cascade model of professional development is used through
centrally produced resources for literacy co-ordinators to deliver to school
W. Jolliffe
-8-
staff. There is ongoing training to co-ordinators and support from LEA
literacy consultants.
5. Inclusion of home-school links: SFA includes a family support team set up
in each school to address issues that may impinge on learning, such as
poor attendance. No explicit provision is made for this in NLS.
6. Tutoring: An early intervention programme for children identified as falling
behind is part of the SFA program, which consists of one-to-one tutoring
support for the duration of need. For NLS additional support for those
pupils who are falling slightly behind for specific year groups, is provided
for set periods of time.
7. The provision of a Facilitator. This in place in each school for SFA in the
form of a teacher who monitors and co-ordinates the programme and is
given 50% off timetable time to carry this out. With the NLS, the Literacy
co-ordinators monitor the programme, but no non-contact time is
specifically given.
Hypothesis
The foregoing all led me to conclude that in order to produce an effective literacy
strategy, on the scale of the National Literacy Strategy, it requires firm
foundations, i.e. teachers need to understand the underlying pedagogy: not just
what to teach, but why they are doing it. My hypothesis was therefore that the
National Literacy Strategy had a missing link – no explicit professional
development on the underlying pedagogy, nor what constitutes the effective
learning of literacy. In other words, ironically for many of its critics, it could be
described as not ‘prescriptive’ enough. I sought therefore to put this hypothesis
to the test through a comparison with Success for All.
Methodology
In order to collect information from schools on the quality of teaching and
learning, which largely involved judgements by senior staff, I elected to use a
qualitative research method of semi-structured interviews. These were carried
out with two schools using NLS and two schools using Success for All (SFA), all
in the same socially deprived inner city area of Hull within an Education Action
Zone. My specific research questions related to the impact on teaching and
learning from adopting either of these strategies. Questions therefore specifically
related to teaching and learning and to management, in order to discover how
such judgements have been made. The interviews were carried out with
Headteachers and Literacy Co-ordinators from each school. From this a
conceptual framework was devised which aimed to show a clear comparison of
the impact on teaching and learning.
Results
1. NLS Schools
Interviews were carried during the summer of 2002. The following significant
comments were made by School B (using NLS):
W. Jolliffe
-9-






Training had initially deskilled teachers and caused a loss of faith in their
professional expertise
Lessons were too passive
Matching pupils’ needs was difficult
The work produced was inferior, there were too many ‘bits of things’
The school did not understand it initially and the personnel required to
disseminate it were not sufficiently skilled
The three part lesson had led to a positive impact across the curriculum
Amongst comments made by School C (using NLS) were the following:






Training that was provided in-house was better than that provided by the
NLS
A key weakness was matching pupils’ needs
The NLS was not good at identifying pupils in need of support
Whole class teaching was not always effective, as not all children were
involved
There was inconsistency in teaching and application of the strategy
Key staff with expertise made a significant contribution
Out of nine key indicators within the conceptual framework used for analysis of
the interviews both schools answered positively on only four.
2. SFA Schools
School A (using SFA) made the following contrasting comments:






Training had enhanced skills although there was an ongoing need
particularly on the underlying ethos of cooperative learning
It ensured genuinely interactive whole class teaching
The provision of a facilitator with non-contact time to monitor and enable
the provision, was crucial
It promotes the inclusion of all children in active learning, both less able
and more able pupils
Learning was good with emphasis on oral work
It enabled good monitoring of pupils’ progress
School D (using SFA) commented that:





Training had enhanced teachers’ skills
Pupils were engaged in learning through team work
Gender issues were better addressed with boys less able to dominate
It was inclusive with classroom support assistants enabling the fast
identification of pupils who were falling behind
The environment for learning was positive and active
W. Jolliffe
- 10 -




Pupils were much more engaged in their learning
High quality of oral work resulted
A dramatic improvement in pupils’ learning
It has empowered younger children
Both schools answered positively on eight out of nine key indicators used from
analysis of the interviews, with both showing some reservation about the danger
of more able pupils becoming bored through the predictability of the programme.
Conclusion
To return to my hypothesis that the National Literacy Strategy had a ‘missing
link’, i.e a failure to incorporate effective teaching and learning and also a failure
to make explicit its underlying pedagogy; to what extent had this research
illuminated this issue? In a limited small scale review of four schools, it had
shown some significant shortcomings.
First, ineffective whole class teaching: the two NLS schools interviewed both
commented on the passive nature of lessons with not all children involved. In
contrast, the SFA schools referred to teaching being ‘genuinely interactive’ with
all children ‘engaged in their learning through team work’.
Second, the inclusion of all pupils: the NLS schools referred to ‘matching pupils
needs’ as a ‘key weakness’. In contrast the SFA schools referred to the
‘inclusion of all pupils in active learning in literacy’ with issues of ability and
gender being well addressed.
Third, inclusion of learning theory: both the SFA schools made reference to the
‘underlying ethos’ of cooperative learning and ‘the philosophy behind it –
cooperative learning’ and its impact on teaching and learning. In addition, both
schools referred specifically to the increased amount and quality of oral work.
Neither NLS schools made any such reference and indeed referred to ‘bits of
paving stones’ as if they did not fully appreciate the ‘big picture’.
Fourth, professional development: both the SFA schools indicated that the
provision of an off-timetable facilitator to provide ongoing support, plus
centralised training had been effective. With both NLS schools the quality of
training relied on individual expertise of co-ordinators, who were not given as
much time as the SFA facilitators to carry this out and with variable results.
These four issues arising from this research echo the focus questions identified
at the beginning of this paper, namely:
1. An effective programme of professional development;
2. Teaching should be genuinely interactive;
3. A deep-rooted understanding by teachers of the pedagogical
W. Jolliffe
- 11 -
process;
4. Clear links made between theory and practice.
Whilst SFA would seem from this to be more effective, it is important to bear in
mind the high cost of the scheme, requiring a teacher to be off-timetable for at
least fifty per cent of the time. In addition, resources were considerably more
extensive than those required for NLS. The schools studied here received
funding from the Education Action Zone to implement the strategies, but for many
other schools this would not be possible. Nevertheless, this needs to be set
against the centralised costs of implementing the NLS, (£205.5 million in year
2000-2001 alone, OISET, 2003).
Both schemes have therefore incurred
considerable costs, with a large proportion of centralised costs in the case of the
NLS.
A summary of the findings from this study illustrate the contrasts between the
strategies, firstly in terms of the teaching of literacy. For the NLS the structure of
lessons has improved with a three-part format used consistently; more explicit
whole class and group teaching of reading and the contribution of the coordinator
through monitoring and feedback, has all helped to improve the quality of
teaching. However, pupils remain largely too passive and there has been no
explicit training on the underlying pedagogy and how to make lessons effectively
interactive. For SFA there is more effective professional development through
the use of an ‘expert’ facilitator to work alongside teachers to ensure that training
is put into practice. Explicit training on cooperative learning as the underlying
pedagogy is included which results in more interactive lessons. Improvements
were particularly seen in the teaching of reading, specifically phonics and the
ongoing monitoring by the facilitator enabled more consistently good quality
teaching.
In terms of the improvement in learning, here the contrast is most marked. SFA
ensured a far greater degree of inclusion of all pupils by being grouped by ability
and not age, and regularly regrouped as pupils progress. It enabled the needs of
the more able pupils to be met and early identification and remediation of those
pupils at risk of failure. Improvement shown through test results was slow, and
most marked with the younger Key Stage 1 pupils with more improvement in
reading than writing shown. For the NLS, the principal issue was not meeting the
needs of all pupils consistently and intervention being mainly for those pupils who
were just falling behind their peers. Improvements in test results again related to
reading more than writing.
Further research would be needed to verify these results. In particular such
research would need to probe in greater depth the understanding of all staff of
the underlying pedagogy. It would also need to verify the improvement in the
quality of teaching through monitoring and Ofsted observations; provide an
analysis of SATs results and teacher assessment over longer periods. In
W. Jolliffe
- 12 -
addition a longitudinal study of teachers’ styles and the effects of cooperative
learning would be informative.
To conclude, this research has presented some initial conclusions to show the
greater effectiveness of Success for All for the teaching of literacy. To reiterate,
the main differences centre around two main issues:
1. Explicit understanding of the underlying pedagogy and how this
impacts on learning through ongoing and effective professional
development;
2. The inclusion of all pupils in effective learning.
These principal differences need to be addressed in order to improve the quality
of teaching and learning in the NLS. This would necessitate firstly an intensive
professional development programme to make explicit what is interactive
teaching, and how to put it into practice, and secondly a review of methods of
effective learning to ensure that all levels of ability are actively engaged in
learning. The NLS, now renamed the Primary National Strategy, has begun to
address some of these issues in 2004, in particular professional development in
more effective learning methods. However, it is an onerous task and its success
will require careful evaluation.
The results from this small-scale study bear out the original hypothesis that an
improvement in teaching and learning requires an explicit understanding of the
underlying pedagogy, i.e. teachers need to know not only what to do, but why
they do it.
References
Adams, M. J. (1990) Beginning to Read: Thinking and Learning about Print
Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press,
Bailey, M (2002) ‘What does research tell us about how we should be developing
written composition?’ in Fisher, R, Brooks, G. and Lewis, M. (eds) Raising
Standards in Literacy, London: RoutledgeFalmer
Beard, R (2000) ‘Long overdue? Another look at the National Literacy Strategy’,
Journal of Research in Reading 23(3): 245-55
Bennett N. (1994) ‘Cooperative Learning’, in P Kutnick & D. Rogers (Eds) Groups
in Schools, London: Cassell
Brooks, G (1998) Trends in Standards of Literacy in the United Kingdom, 19481996 (Topic: 19 pp 1-10)
W. Jolliffe
- 13 -
Brooks, G, Pugh A.K. & Schagen, I. (1996) Reading Performance at 9, Slough
National Foundation for Educational Research
Brown D. and Thomson C., (2000) Cooperative Learning in New Zealand
Schools, Palmerston North, NZ: Dunmore Press
Bryant, P. (1993) Phonological Aspects of Learning to Read in Beard R.
Teaching Literacy: Balancing Perspectives’, London: Hodder & Stoughton,
Cato, V. Fernandes, E., Gorman, T and Kispal, A. (1992) The Teaching of Initial
Literacy: How do teachers do it? Slough: NFER
Clay, M. M. (1985) The Early Detection of Reading Difficulties, Auckland:
Heinemann,
Cambourne, B (1998) The Whole Story: Natural Learning and Acquisition of
Literacy in the Classroom, Auckland: Ashton Scholastic
Campbell, R. (1998) A Literacy Hour is only part of the Story, Reading: 32 (1) 2113
Collins, J., & Marshall T., (2001) Teaching the Literacy Strategy: A teacher’s
perspective (Education 3-13, pp 7-12)
Cook, M. (2000) Writing and Role Play: a Case for Inclusion, Reading, July 2000:
74-78
Cordon, R. (2000) Literacy and Learning through Talk: strategies for the Primary
Classroom, Buckingham: Open University Press
Cunningham, P. M., Hall, D.P. and Defee, M. (1991) Non-ability grouped,
multilevel instruction: A year in the first grade classroom, The Reading Teacher,
44: 8, pp 566-571
Dadds, M. Teachers, Values and the Literacy Hour, Cambridge Journal of
Education, March 1999, 29 (1) pp 7-30
Davidson, N. (ed) (1990) Cooperative Learning in Mathematics: A Handbook for
Teachers. Menlo Park: Addison Wesley
DfEE, (1998) The National Literacy Strategy Framework for Teaching, London:
Standards and Effectiveness Unit
W. Jolliffe
- 14 -
Elley, W. B. (1992) How in the World Do Students Read? Hamburg: The
International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement
Fisher, R. (2002)
Inside the Literacy Hour: Learning from Classroom
Experience, London: RoutledgeFalmer
Fisher, R., Lewis, M. and Davis, B. (2000), ‘Progress and performance in
National Literacy Strategy classrooms in England’, Journal of Research in
Reading 23(3): 256-66
Frater, G. (2000) Observed in Practice, English in the National Literacy Straregy:
some reflections. Reading 34(3): 107-1
Galton, M. Hargreaves, L. Coomber, C. Wall, D, Pell, A. (1999) Inside the
Primary Classroom: 20 Years On, London: Routledge
Graham, J. (1998) Teaching, Learning and the National Literacy Strategy ,
Changing English: Studies in Reading and Culture, October, 1998 5(2) pp 115122
Lewis, M. (2002) ‘Discussion: Research into the teaching of literacy’, In Fisher, R,
Brooks, G. and Lewis M. (eds), Raising Standards in Literacy, London,
RoutledgeFalmer
Clay, M. (1979) The Early Detection of Reading Difficulties: a diagnostic survey
with reading recovery procedures, (2nd edition), London: Heinemann
Goodman, K. S. (1998) In defense of good Teaching: what teachers need to
know about reading wars, York MA: Stenhouse Publishers
Goswami, U. (1995) Phonological Development and Reading by Analogy: what is
analogy and what is not (Journal of Research in Reading Vol 18 (2)
Hargreaves, A (2003) Teaching in the Knowledge Society: education in the age
of insecurity. Maidenhead: Open University Press
Harrison, C. (2002) Key Stage 3 English: Roots and Research, London: DfES
Holdaway, D. (1979) The Foundations of Literacy, Ashton: Scholastic
Johnson, D., Maruyama, G., Johnson, R., Nelson, D. and Skon, L. (1981)
Effects on cooperative, competitive and individualistic goal structures on
achievement: a meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 89: 47-62
Johnson, D. W, & Johnson R., (1989) Cooperation and Competition: Theory and
Research, Edina MN :Interaction Book Company
W. Jolliffe
- 15 -
Littlefair, A. (1991) Reading All Types of Writing, Milton Keynes: Open University
Press
MacGilchrist, B. One Hour to Change the World, The Times Educational
Supplement, 27.6.97
Moyes J. , Hargreaves, L, Merry, R., Paterson, F. and Esarte-Sarries, V. (eds)
(2003) Interactive Teaching in the Primary School: Digging Deeper into Meanings
Maidenhead: Open University Press
Mroz, M. Smith, F. & Hardman, F. (2000) The Discourse of the Literacy Hour,
Cambridge Journal of Education Vol 30 (3) pp 385-389
NFER, (2003) Progress in International Reading Literacy Study, NFER, London :
http://www.standards.dfes.gov.uk/literacy/about/newsandevents_archive/405067
OFSTED (2002) The National Literacy Strategy, the First Four Years , London:
HMSO
OFSTED (2003) The National Literacy and Numeracy Strategies and the Primary
Curriculum, Reference number HMI 1973, London: HMSO
Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto (OISEUT) (2003),
Final Report, London: DfES
Pogrow, S. (2000) The Unsubstantiated ‘Success’ of Success for All: Implications
for Policy, Practice, and the soul of our Profession, Phi Delta Kappan, April,
2000, pp 596-600
cheerens, J (1992) Effective Schooling: Research theory and Practice London:
Cassell
Sharan, S. and Shaulov A (1989) Cooperative Learning, motivation to learn and
academic achievement, in S. Sharan (ed) Cooperative Learning: Theory and
Research, New York : Praeger
Slavin, (1983) Cooperative Learning, New York: Longman
Slavin, R.E. (1995, Winter). A Model of Effective Instruction, The Educational
Forum, Vol. 59. 166-1
Slavin, R. E., (1996) Education for All, The Netherlands: Swets & Zeitlinger, B. V.
Lisse
Solar, J. (2000) Research Evidence and the Literacy Hour: was the National
Literacy Strategy the only option? (Paper to British Educational Management and
Admin Society, March 29-31, 2000)
W. Jolliffe
- 16 -
Times Educational Supplement 27.6.97, Extra English
Twiselton, S. (2000) Seeing the Wood from the Trees: the National Literacy
Strategy and Initial Teacher Education; pedagogical content knowledge and the
structure of subjects, Cambridge Journal of Education, Vol 30: 3 pp 391-403
Webb, N. and Cullian, L. (1983) Group interaction and achievement in small
groups: stability over time. American Educational Research Journal, 20(3): 41123
Wells, G. and Chang, G. (1988) The Literate potential of collaborative talk, in Ml
Maclure, T. Phillips and A. Wilkinson (eds) Oracy Matters. Milton Keynes: Open
University Press
Wells, G., Chang, G., and Maher, A. (1990) Creating classroom communities of
literate thinkers in S. Sharan (ed) Cooperative Learning: Theory and Research.
New York: Prager
White, C. (2000) Strategies are not enough (Education 3-13 pp 16-21)
Wray, D. and Medwell J. Poulson L, and Fox, R. (2002) Teaching Literacy
Effectively in the Primary School, London, RoutledgeFalmer
Wyse, D (2000) Phonics – the Whole Story? A Critical Review of Empirical
Evidence, Educational Studies, Vol 26 (3) pp 355-362
W. Jolliffe
- 17 -