Learning to Select a Coordination Mechanism
Cora B. Excelente-Toledo
Nicholas R. Jennings
University of Southampton
Dept. of Electronics and Computer Science
Southampton SO17 1BJ, UK.
University of Southampton
Dept. of Electronics and Computer Science
Southampton SO17 1BJ, UK.
[email protected]
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
!
#"$%&'
()"+*,(*,"(-./0(#))&*0
1"23)'45.)&67"8"
#29:'
;<;="(
>?"@BADCEF"G"(H(I
JK"("HL%,(+*?@)
M%N1*?8"'
:-O8(@@<M+*=67+$PMQ69
"(
(A3R0)S@++*(H2TT
SU(V67
H(
"U)+"Q.3(@((777Q(W
@;*X$(3
Y"(#(J5*(Y2)
3J67"J
5+WZ"(
Y*75(5)3/+
)
XQAZH(/+[Z@)
O"(H(IV)*
%N"T.
2=*XQI=3*+'\60X]2"$-U
6"#^_J*Q` _"/J.)aSY*(_
(@(3+E(]#/H"$X"U#8.
^&!*(&"(
a""H[+"aX/+Q`Q.F-/@()+QAb7+)a'
(+E6c67+
IQ6Z+67(HZ(+*,_dF"@6
-"e/31(*U_"2].)e"/*U_"$(
"
+2]A
Categories and Subject Descriptors
f A gAhh7ikjlYm[n$on$pn$jq8n$r;m[sTq0q0n$t;sYr;p5s0uvwa.+)3xT2'
G+"y f (/*"z|{;}(~k\€‚Xƒ…„…†+0‡2ˆB‡\„E‰Z‡
General Terms
Š 5(Q
1. INTRODUCTION
Š d $"@,"2-/;S2b%S)+5X)5*(5
Z"#@_V*b-[)/*(bH(A_CE)+"&"(
'
:7‹()5
*33@)%N7%V"H
3
)QH]"")36J]*3-/@5('41J.'
ŒN"@X$BI+6H:2
;&"5(@(+5(QI+Y6
U3
2)"QA
Z7
IS@yHU%V"
'
V
/@Xa.$,@&52b_"X-/,.'
DdF(7@%.Q"ihgXIhŽIŽuA
xTF%2‘E‘X’“X€N†+X\€‚‘X†‰Z„…”XX†+€N‡‰Z‡0
@SdF(_'
3+"#
Q""3+#2)&+d(ayH(_%
Q1((@(QAS7+H:@2H:]+[+$*X[6"#
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for
personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are
not made or distributed for pro£t or commercial advantage and that copies
bear this notice and the full citation on the £rst page. To copy otherwise, to
republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior speci£c
permission and/or a fee.
AAMAS’02, July 15-19, 2002, Bologna, Italy.
Copyright 2002 ACM 1-58113-480-0/02/0007 ... 5.00.
•
"(
M2".–2*M(I/+L)(%
;dTH;‹)+ZT)+=&*@"+
(0)'4(I#UT*T[6"#UHT1H
=.F8)""2%N)U+—+)+"J"(-—.
@):–
*@J/)-
A f J5]QŒNH;%_"(BIF552+
"O%N"—*?"Q˜Y"2-/—"
'
a
Y7*)-Q&)""yH("(H[
@7*
)M+>(/-"U"QIb6(["-2[/-,-/@
E60a2e)+"Y#Z2&5X1HZ&%yA f +QIQ
)@QH."$(
:5"#
A
f *+QyIS"+"SX%"2-/U5"#
™_25'
*S
V
,)+FX,_2H2/šV+*,5(A›!
H=.2)K"(%N+"Q.+c+!Q.(@('
BI::
+JMH(
"!MM"(/(
."()T/+S0,2"FT%N_"#
**,_(%NH*,T5'
"#
œO2)]>*((LGU6/!]2$@+*
"")Q"OihuA f —)"#—(@(/BI7Q
S*S
@Y@yH%-"$(
;$"#
QI
6@+H*Z+$2/QIWWQ_
WH"(
!2"J5"#
6"#!>+%N
Q1—5
-A)+QI
%‚Z-")H>Q(ZQ21BI
;*(YH:"#2Z>&"(
J$"#
+*H1H>)+""$-Ia.)67"c6@+.H
@],"2*H;*523)J"2QA&›L+(3%‚32
5Q(7Q21BIS"#
š
#771HU)""
I
.)+Z6"?
Q6055)?"2/BI-]H>.O2'
(A f 2EI+Y(Y/-T["(
$"#
EH=Z).:)=8/+*B`V2@*
"")Q"QA
]"+@3&"QHU+$*X3%Vž(.HU:"+
'
X:‹()2Z?*(1&"5.)6:"'
U6""+
5"#
–Z)(AV
[
IX2@)W601
W@F>(2*Z%NQ601
"#@ZihI+ŸuyA TQ60@QI+Y601*+*(/
5Q"?¡6WZ:+K")yHb^T%T1(+*8*((|'
Q(+.FX)3.F-/@()+3%0*(/BA,&
"H:/2):T[(@(S."T[H(
"A
¢ @ZQIa
)Q£25%+W%NQ601&-Y
.+
*(/&"‹()251(Q67*/+)*8)'4
+E'
X
A=)BIa?*(/Uc>.:"(-.:X%Y(*>
1&&*(7+"Z#.F)+77"(
:.A
xT*.
"#1*X)
I_/+?¤%Y2("c
@O*(/7
7"((O.)W3("7%V"X'
=#]"$Y"
Y
;2y[
_"$)+(a)
-AW¥522F"G"(H(IB+$2(IB60+(+6
.9%&Q6**(&(8*(32)
J6"8O+H]*(3"(
J"-A&
601<#@";Q:X%T?c/+:%NE6*>6&HBA
¦ HI,(()",(+*;(:
#&
&%W*XQ` "?1*J+"
5""?6/=67|
Q6§>"(
(A|CE"+H(I_"(H?2Q
6.FG+/5%S(2+*"(?.F.Q<+6
(+*5.G"y#:/+":1*"(QA
7U
2/2)")¨U%NQ67BA¨CE"¨g(
)Y"G+"["(
2"$-AZCQ"/cŽ3%‚Y
"O+")+[%8*X$(QACE"XOŸZQ6
a"X&]1(*(")WY+&V(*"'
QAWCE"/;©a-ZW5(Q(6W1&Y@)
0d"
%()"*T0%N2"$(
.
2$;*XQA
CE"ª0+(/_y#/601;CQ"/J«0"")3
2(%
%N)2/+7601bA
2. THE COORDINATION TESTBED
R0)WQ1WY%NP%W*X'46067+"#>)+5'
.e%e#))Tƒ…„…†+\‡3¡¬x­®^F%N¯Q21a%Ne6"5H
"@T)+W%W’„…°aX’“]¡±­y^0¡Nihu%N,7Œ‚)G"(%b
"+"TX%W
")0(@(0%N02/)+H*["(
'
].+Q^A Š "=*T
‡\²£„…€ ³-4X‡2´¡/CQ,­y^-6"#
HZ_"(%N2]˜ZSaQ21_6"#‹()2@'
Qe*(_[F%‚™IB"($8‘…‘#²„…’X4€Nµ…„&4X‡´…‡&¡¶
7B^/A
Š "JQ1]
U,6&L2"J67JQI/+Z6&23%N
¶
7#*+&
8%NCE&"H[)&.
@*&"+
#/**(QA
7*(SE@)+:,*;,?ZY5(I£)
I
Q67-IW%‚*(QIW2Q/HcA|x7>(HcJ(IW("#
*(Z-]*OƒE‘…X~kI
5]CQP]J¶VšE@56"#
"(
>+,;.FJ"#@-AR_—2@+YZ‹()
"(Q*3e*IE[*e"@e[("y#/56&-A
f 5/+W"(W%eCEQIa6?,##QIEQ+5H(IE6
ZW*[email protected],Y,2y#/,*(QA f 5/+W"(
%b¶
QI(
6>Y+F(BI$BH(IX56a&a*X
I
.)0/[email protected]*(_67+,)+.‹()H]@
_
0‹()
(A f %_#J*(_")+&[¶VZIB67+S)+)*
/")2U*¡¬A (AI0>CEZ^/IeUQ1"-*]%&=¶
·
?[)5".6ZJy"$(
6!>*(E@Q1bI,!67+"#!"$(
"
+2¸¡¶7¥^
S);)(A f ;S"(EI£("##*
3G]B*[%T¶¥5T/Y2QA Š "=¶¥¹
Q[.(H3y60T1H/.)Bv2V)+["$X7¡N[
%
'4B^7+:"
"&%
2)""QA ¦ (I¶¥š/H
Q1º/'\2$+32Y)L¡N+J.H]/+;*X$(36&*
a()Z.F_%'\2/+_.F%NX‹()*,.+a%N2»
*(Q^W-/@+.
.yH(I¼IX%b)""2,¡N)+W6
*Q¡NQ^&@]3¶
¯‹()
(I6&J6e.
("(?67+.
.yH¼FI
6/?½J6&?62(^/A
xT=*(T/H:60
"+,-5+*UU"$(
[
Y_@(y.+-IQ67+"#5"(27Ta)
¶¥¹¡NA (A
*ŒN"Z+/*¶VP*#y^A
7ZxT*(/'4'#¶V
#*:¡NxT¶7^e%aZ"$(
]2"
¶¥+
I0%‚/[6&/*]%N,2,)OF(
I.+"(2/:
‹():%N:*(:=**8M"+
A™
*(/Y]67].T"F2]%e#5)+T%
6&UH60)U‹()2TU20[
"
TU¶
5Q6(H,'4T6&/H,%N¨[¶V?2‹)
#WH
)
A f %Z<*(Q` Z.+Z)""2%N)IV[Z
xT*('\'#¶V(Q8¡NxTy¶
(
^,SS%2"a
#a_
,
"
(U¡N3xTy¶^_%NU¶V¯Q1bA37+55xT*('\'
· f %0@Q#T*(/2@U:¶V¯2‹)-]&5B55(I
3%Vš[.QHU5.F3"#
*U
I%7
*(3G+&5
8+]¶
¯![*@8"I3Q#H
"&%
š%N%N)+[-H(QA
CE¹¡¬xYyC^a3)ZZ/)-6;c*(T
601(+*5Q6&ZCEZA
xT*(/0*X_"@ST/-TQe0/+SQ
2/
I-?67+"#?"#H>H>6/¾](HO.+]
5Q#3H]"@(A3 TQ60@QIFH]67eH?""
;¶V|"Q"&/(A7xT*Y.F60]xT¶V
xT¶V(!"#@?U
")¶
D2:Q.2=@(8
"(Q"*O"Ac"(Q"'\'41;+"S"'
S%
,QA f :,G2
I(xTy¶.+"(5T'
Q-OS#*QA f Y6,3%N3/+Z.QAYZ2"
(@@e2"+*37.+Y"Q"a%N¯xT¶VY
xT¶V(
2F"@H¡N.F[%¾-/@0S"++V2$%‚)Q
W%W"*[dQ^A ¦ H(IT
"a%F"55(T.)a/+7e%7"'
Q"[:3376"#xT¶V(60@U7
¶
M‹()
(A ¦ *)hS*@/+3("U*(7%‚E6–
("#:/'\2$-A
¿kÀEÁTÂbÅÄÅEÆ4ÇÈÉ‚É‚Ê ËXÄ,È$Æ7ÈZÇ®ÌQÍQÈɂÄÎÏ ÐeÂÊ ÑÈ#ÉNÉ‚Ê ËÄ2ÇÈÆWÊ Æ4ÇÑXÒcÓ2ÄÔ Ô Õ-Ê Æ4Ç
ÃEօÈÔÊ ÇeÈÆ4Æ\ÈÊ ÅQÄ2×QÕ+Ê Æ
ɂÄÓ2ÄÊ ËXÄÇeÆ\ØQÄ7ɂÄ\Ù_Èɂ×,È$ÅQ×&ÍQÚ×QÈ$Æ4ÄÇ-Ê Æ\ÇeÅÖEÈ$Ô Î
ÏkÐÂÊ ÛÖBօÚÈÉ‚É‚Ê ËXÄÇ[È$Æ&Æ\ØQÄUÛÒ¾Ó2ÄÔ Ô ÕSÊ Æ&ÅEÖEÆ\Ê ÜÄ2Ç[Æ4ØEÄUÂÊ Û—Æ\ØQÈÆ
Ê ÆTØQÈÇYÈ#ÉNÉ‚Ê ËÄ2×QÎ?Ï ÆTÝÊ Ã…ØQÆSØQÈyËXÄZÆ4Ö,Ù_ÈÊ ÆTÊ Å:Æ\ØQÄ5Ó2ÄÔ Ô
ÍEÅQÆ4Ê ÔVÆ4ØQÄ
ɂÄÝÈÊ ÅQÊ ÅEÃWÂbÊ ÛÖBօÚQǏÈÉ‚É‚Ê ËXÄÎ
Ï Ð(ÂÊ ÛɂÄ2ÓÄ2Ê ËXÄ2ǏÓօÅQÜBɂÝÈÆ4Ê Ö…ÅQǏÐɂօÝ
ÈÔ ÔÂbÊ ÛÖBօÚQÇ®Õ+Æ4ØEÄ7ÛÒJÊ ÇeÈ$ÓØQÊ Ä\ËXÄ2×&ÈÅQ×3Æ4ØQÄWɂÄ\Ù_È#ɂ×EÇeÈɂÄ7ÚQÈ$Ê ×&Æ4Ö
ÂbÊ ÛÖBօÚQÇ®Î
¿kÞEÁTÏkÐbÂÊ ÑÜBÅQ×QÇ0È&ÛÒOÊ ÆaÝÍQÇyÆe×QÄÓ2Ê ×EÄTÊ ÐbÊ ÆÙ0È$ÅQÆ4Ç_Æ4Ö,ßXÄ2ÓօÝÄTÂbÊ Û
ÈÅQ×EÕÊ ÐÇ®ÖEÕBÙ7ØQÊ ÓØ,Ûàá=âã#ä‚å£æ-Ê Æ-ÇyØEÖEÍEÔ ×,ÍQÇ®ÄÎ7Ï Ð+ã0ç;èÊ Æ-ÝÍQÇyÆ
Ù0È$Ê Æã-Æ\Ê ÝSĂéÇyÆ\ÄÚQÇbßÄÐÖ$ɂÄa߅ÉNÖEÈ$×QÓÈ$ÇyÆ4Ê ÅEÃSÈWɂÄÌEÍQÄÇ®ÆÐÖ$ÉFÓÖBÖ$ÉN×QÊ ÅQÈyé
Æ4Ê Ö…ÅQÎ
¿kêEÁTÏkÐ+ÂÊ Ñ,ɂÄÓ2ÄÊ ËXÄÇ
ÈɂÄ2ÌQÍQÄ2ÇyÆbÐÖ$ɏÓÖQÖ$ɂ×QÊ ÅQÈ$Æ4Ê Ö…ÅQÕÊ Æb×EÄÓÊ ×QÄ2ÇÙ7ØQÄ2Æ4ØQÄ2É
ÈÅQ×5Ù7ØQÈÆ3Æ4Ö]ßEÊ ×Æ4Ö;ÚQÈɂÆ4Ê ÓÊ ÚEÈÆ4ÄUÊ ÅÆ\ØQÄUÛÒVÎ0ÒVØQÄUÂÊ Û!Æ4ØQÄ2Å
Ä\ËXÈÔ ÍQÈ$Æ4Ä2Ç0ÈÔ ÔßQÊ ×QÇ®ÎYÏ ÐbÂbÊ ÑXë Ç0ßQÊ ×[Ê Ç_ÈÓ2ÓÄÚEÆ4Ä×EÕÊ ÆeÈ×QօÚQÆ4Ç_ÛÒOÈÇ
Ê Æ4Ç_ÅQÄ\ÙMÅօÈÔ ÎYì
ÄÊ Æ4ØEÄÉ-ÂÊ ÛÖQÖEÚEÇ0ÅQÖ$É
ÂbÊ ÛɂÄÇ®ÚÖEÅE×ZÆ4Ö,ɂÄ2ÌQÍQÄÇ®Æ4Ç
ÐÖ$ÉbÓÖBÖ$ÉN×QÊ ÅQÈÆ\Ê ÖEÅQÎ
¿kíEÁTîÈÓ2ØTÈ$ÃEÄ2ÅQƏ×QÄÓ2Ê ×QÄÇbօÅTÊ Æ\ÇVÅEÄ\ïXƏÝÖ/ËXÄaÈÓ2ÓÖ$ɂ×QÊ ÅEÃSÆ\ÖÊ Æ4ÇbÓÍEɂɂÄÅEÆ
ÃEօÈÔÈÅE×&ÈÔ Ô(È$ÃEÄ2ÅQÆ4Ç-ÝSÖËXÄ7Ç®Ê ÝÍQÔ Æ\ÈÅQÄ2ÖEÍEÇyÔ ð$Î
oñ‚òFó
ôQõ]öF÷5ø5ùú…ñ\û:ü
ôQýFþýûXýFÿyýFÿ‚ÿ\ý,õ?ù+òFõ
þú
xTV_
#,y60*
]H3._‹)+[/"@3S¶
ZI
5"2QHOJ+(767?%2"5
]=xTy¶
(?H
@86&5=/+O¶
P"76:]#*8xTy¶
(
@c¡N."()c#*
/@J/?Q/@YdF2$(Q"B^/A
f c2)"c"(2$BIa;xTy¶¨
/H(J¨-6&c%N
8y+z=xT¶™1(E6:J()[.:%,58:
("#]xYy¶
Y1H:
/@Z6&¡¬2"$G/+[.+
^
c?)(6
H%‚6,*>?2F"G"
+$G+]6&/*UQ:¡^AW7()T6=]xT¶V(]G
xT¶<%]@,Z>¶
–"yI
Z$Z"@Z
-5%_¶V¯6&J&/+56&/*B/%NQ60J.(H;
-3X%V¶
M6&-A
3"%NH[("
@()a+"%
"-I ¦ *)+g2Q67[Zhbh5*½,S"G+"Y
O67/M©;*[>*2—+>J¶VQA7J¶
»
M¡hI^7‹):Ž;*(,;.J"#@
IUJ
¡gIª^(bŸZ*X$(W+&aYW¡IX^2$‹()Wg*X$(QA f _2"$G"05(V+E6
I0xTy¶
'4x · ¡/#7¡/hXI^^£*X/
;S?*2$(6/;60xYy¶
+5¡¬xZZ¡NŸIª^+;x
,¡NŸI^^b;"#@3[¶V™,¡hI^AVx&xT#YxTCE,¡
¡NŸI Ÿ^7¡ªI©X^V"@H^
[23601(+*5E6,7+$
"@X["G"[Q1(¡gIg^T+=¡ªI©^/AT8*(T-/@
%N)+:/+U¶
Z[¡gIª^7+¡I^A
3.
DECISION MAKING PROCEDURES
@)3601:
3@c+@)
c&"2J]'
1(*=%NQ601c%NX(*¾.)67+/+O—Q6 oñ‚òFó
ôQõ!F÷"
ûXõ
ù+ôQñ‚ý#5ñ\þ%$Lù+òFõ
þ5ôQýFÿ‚õ(ú
"(
?5+]#¾ihI-ŸuALCE"?%N(")5
:-F;;</+8!<
";%[(*=<
%NQ601bI
60XZ")]W+E#5%
(A—±S60:""Q:=/+"6:('
*")+J
@;,5/Hb˜yA (AYJ6"#c¶¥ >+EI
%S(Hb˜Q6¾[)"]U.;6=3‹)2S%NT"(-]
"@
˜:+E6M&6":.:]""QI(%(H(A
7Z*(Q`#»a&(2a6&-IQ-")
@Q*Z6&Y)Y/(AS
8#"$"X)Y%NY'
*yHY)+y
IX("#>*(W17Q"1%V7E6
@Q*6&
I>’„E°eX’“J’X4„…I.+*;[/XE_")'
[)@XZ6&@.(H;ZQ
()[.Y%a$'42/+
Q1]U.+E#QA f T)2TTQ[U+"ZE6|[)"#]
"-*3%NE6:@("Z:""(2
HU]+E(
_",Q$VX%(7*(V67,bVW.+_.)+
)L,")5ACE"G"(H(IF("#L*3)336&
Q35@+)-U:"$X5-33dZ"/Z/@+y.
:Q˜%0&"(8(Q>&Q@,Q(I&"#2&
ZA7R0%")2(IW"2+aQ0Y)
@&@)%
+d(["QA
3.1 Deciding which CM to select
xT¯*(6"#
I_6])2)+*>/U")+U*I_")'
3&¶
c[)2a"S67_&yS"+
#/67
*(,>,;%N QA
;;QIJ#*
[)2_+/T60T,H@+Q*TU[X*A
Y+F+YYH:Z6&2]
#TY.*d
I
.):2;O8¶7¥:/@+.(IW[603[O@+)+,(@('
(Q%"06">dF"0Y"U+]+0X%
"(
**(QA
:5(a„'&/²£„…4„2““X„…‰5X†+“X‡,%0*(QI
xT¶!#)7HJYQ+5H.+))*+)W
*
I-#
YY")(Y*UZH:+2/.)
A
)+02*(W/H.Y(W/+¶
!6Y/+W]H.
%Z6&/Hb˜162(I%N*(/S/+$2360)+:.S2*G'
"((@(y;%N¹/+5CE<(";¶VZI(6,/+
/H?.F?.:>"+
#/;Q@?¶V§c);8
Q67;*QA_*(Z#2S,2.+¶¥5T;,.
'
7X%VE6MX*5.$%‚33Q1U"(.3F%‚$¡¬")*
.?5)+?O=/+O/@Q*+2E#"O/6&H>("#
*(U/)-/-^#c%YQ6§[)+"c6&2cU1H?
.QL%NY+)"*5"J6&J‹)3%
U:*(:¡N.
2OO8)([%7UH8[)
O@+*;%N /+,
#/—#>J¶7¥` [.
.+H
%
)+""$2Q^A
7+3*V)+7_%"
52V("#¶¥<,
%,/+c)(%&2))6&!"(!("$QI7E@O
.E@XY6
77"75.Q+)*57"$X)3%
Q-IQA (AIQaE6/@Q*X76&a'4
I)(Ab
*(72"¶¥š67":()+)+ A
%N,S"X;("$+)(I£"5!*,+*8686&82½/.O%NCEQI_10–%‚¶VQI_["X'
O"-IW¶¥!2&¡‚º%3y¼F^IV6"#O"5ºY$'42/+[
W)+>
,+.
.yH%b2)""¼FA f /+7*+'\602
%V1(E6½(IXU*(7"#"(#")3/+Y("$O@Q*
Q"?¡4)56 78:9<;(^6&/H%HQ+H2)
|#*
%N ¶
¾‹()
(I
T607T[1H/@Q*X,@(y
¡=4>56 76>5£^V)+"*(60)-/@&]1X3*7+$2(A
? 2$>82G*)2$BI*(&"(!22&@Q*
)+)e6&5%N¯"+
*3E@X$e[¶
¾S¡NbI Hb^F)*
¶¥A@B2M¡‚º=@<3y¼@…^A ¦ QIQe[)+e2/7eQ65"2e
%3Q6¹*O=¶¥¤6SQ1]OU)¯+LE6 X*O
(F"_&6&a%NXa/+Y*(a@(AWCE"xT¶
60) !)2)
H=("U"@/(J26&!)/F5'
I&"%¶¥A@W*@:.(Hv
EC D 9<;E@…¡FG3IH^J2K(L+]¡Nº@NMO4>56 78:9<;(¡FG3IH^/^
CE"
IXTxT¶JZ)02/T@Q*)(0%'
6&!J/+AP *(6Y‹)(A¾
2*)+2»
*(Q` ]Q6P@Q*O6&š¡(^5%N /-;%5OBI
( xYy¶
[)+O]%N[]8/@B*U6&O%[_
*(/T;[@(QA0›!]xTy¶?(TS-/@
(H;1(Q67*5%Q( xTy¶
(J3)23/&E6L@Q*56&
Z+E(]
A
4>56 RS8>7)@…¡FG3IH^N2 ( xT¶
#+!¼T4>@ 56 76>5(¡FG3IH^
¡h^
7+
I_/+:xYy¶|2;(F"c)+)%VUQ*O@
%N§*T&¶VO.(H3Q1(+*T(5#"$"X)
0.
.+H
%
)+""$2%
&E#1bv
4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9 @ ¡FG3IH^N2¼@]+0^
¡ CED 9<;E@…¡FG3IH^M=¡P_+!4>56 R\8>7)@…¡FG3IH^^
¡g^
›L+"+*,67"%Y¶¥5a+QIQZ*(a"5'
)+/"=2))6&=%N ("#=%Y/+ "/+]/-U(2/+@#)(A f %&]2))
2"?67¾,¶¥555*@(I
O*]5
%S(),¶¥ ¡N6"Z+GJ
/@½$2)2'
)Q^A
7+%N[)X!(!2%>Q6>*(Q1
";.)Z6<+67"¾¶7¥¸/2"ZZ
"#@5¶
[ACE"377&75Q(7"
*(S%",]/+S2"
JihuI£ST,,60,"$X"Q
::/%
@+)-/*&3%
(* A
)*5e/H[-.[_*.-H,+/£"5%NX-'
"+*T67":¶¥¾T)(I…V1
20%NXše%N'4(
*(Q` %
@(6ZA
SS%N™%")+/*,+5/@Q*T6&J2)
;*(Z60.Q6&%5CE–Z2/-I
(
2 acbe
d ` fIgi2h&
j A "(HSy"S6&(*")+;/H>
3.2 Deciding what to bid to become an AiCoop
›!c*(Y"@;&‹()Y-"
Zc¶
|H
)+.e.[.
[X[/+&5X)
%6&2,-VH&60)
‹()27&"Q#/»%Na+@*,%N»a")2
*Ab7H:32).e/+a"$)+e+2E+"[/6&H[%N¯
¶
¯2‹)
#(AZ7J*Q`.+#dF">.H&'
"S/)Z%2"/B˜F6"+/367+/+YH;"
"@5(I&3Q]@Q*52$6,J%N&("y
"@(/:[HJ+;%N[+'\2"_BA f O[60X1Ib60
HZ"2_)Q-*(_
a(F"_&"@SQ
%N ("yS"UYH:%N '42"
¡ihu
'
YX5dF"3%a3
QQ^AR03ž+)"3
,‹)+O6&—U/+J)(,%W2F(,>'
@(y*U%N :¶
¾‹()
(I
c*Q` @Q*[6&]
'4¨=;.
.+HO%Y)""2%Y¶¥ .*
2
A
U%N2]2[QI+"++c*(QI+x5­V6c/@X$B*['
6&['\2/K(­yA:>*Z"(")yZ;“X„…µ…€‚X\€‚‘X†I
A (AI/+5()[.3%_(Q,'4&3‹()3("#J
CE|%aT*(T@(3:¶
¾2‹)-(AY/Z/-T%I+%NTb5+(I
¶
!2‹)
2YW"H>S
ZCEZI*XQ` @(y:60):.F&½A
T")+/WW6&2[x­‹()-%N¨***Y5"$('
X&Q@b3¶VZI#bQ1V(Z"")+V/+a"Q
.O%NZZ@<%N[U2.+H8/-[8¶¥
*(%A
7()QI(603-/@(v
¡Ž^
R\8>7X­@2 (X­N+k:l<¼m@ nioºenqp)re­
7]*Y2).33.J/"+
;+3Q"
%N /+]¶
¯‹()
(A f %&!*(3&$"8:"+
#/(I
>+L¶
¤")(*A f OCE9Hc'
+/%N/+U¶
M
.O""2
˜:
"$)+yQI
%eT2)=2@;T;CE|‹()
Z]X)[%NY:¶
ZI
("@&/S6&:)(/72$)2(A
3.3 Deciding which AiCoop bids to accept
R0"WWxT¶:
e"@5.+-%N¹b#*QIE-"/e
Y
T(YY)+)Y6&-I*X@Z6§¡NG'
(^a%NX3
3"@L¡N"%A3]QJ
"JŽAh^A ¦ _("8*(EIx5­yIBSxT¶J1+E6_5)+
%
6&:76‹()U¡iR\8>7X­@…^7#:/+35&76Q1&
@¡ts-­y^A
CE+"UxT¶V(:/.F&:/+3"073B3
""2[&¶
[IxT¶:
Y
/H;/
b6&
2,xTy¶
(S
S-/@,6,S;¶
¾‹()
(A_xTy¶
"(")y336&.(H;2$"+*]*3
Y6-Q1
_*2V0/@_%N|/+_
%£.
"@X
A ¦ QIF3"(+/Z5[)9/(IvuT48<;T8%wx ;T8%y\6 ­z@ I
5("|*567??"A ¦ 55(I-
6&*xT¶V(Z&"QZT'\2"$G:Q{A
¦ H(IxTy¶?"(")S+ CED 9<; RS8>7X­z@.
]],'
6&U("8*(_‹()2$&+T6&UxTy¶J-0/[
H5%N
uT48<;T8%wx ;T8%y\6 ­z@ v
CED 9<; R\8>7­z@B2OR\8>7X­@NM/s
­|+(}M#uT48<;T8%wx ;T8~y\6 ­@ +
T"{P .+67&Z)š"2Qv
 25
i CED 9<; R\8>7X­@u
(IF.)3Z605""(QZJ5"2+3"ZH
,,EŒ‚ST67;"S(X+*J.)S"+'
:5"#
QA
¦  I7"/:J%N)+/+.™¡NyA (AIPAoF[s€2
­c'‚-i s-­uy^:"(")y#/(F":)+)Qv
9%WXEY[Z'W\9 ­z@ 2¼T@}+0ƒ^„R\8>7X­@Q^!(L+]¡Nº@NM…PAoF[s[^ ¡NŸ^
TE6ZI+Y/H:.Z/+["(Z
YU.Z"@6"
*@7F2@T)2)BA Š @U)+*U/+T"28¶7¥–
8
(F"2))QI
.H>"
"[H8./-[c*(;
)+K5"(/H:(T/U2E@(+,(2
.[.+QA f ])"#=Y2)'
I/+3xTy¶O)752/igu%V3("_¡ ¦ *)Uh^
"(I0#)*X>,-,.>))"#1H(I,2Q/,2(yH
)+"
*X$>>$*Z/Z"2
#/*021H
()"S2))QA
4.
THE ROLE OF LEARNING
5@()&"8**(JF(ye5%0('
*;"*6"#?¶¥§2$"QA_7S2"/;6VQ6
2".&Q6M(*6&5")
H(()"
A-›8&"
]EH!+%N"[(*c¡/±G†7^7"+‹()8iªuAx
%N"(/'4.
2"#5Y+y.F"()+76W[
""+$56]*(/e+))*3*T5.Q*Y2$6,
""*Q6–d"/@H82*]>""5+
A
›!O/+["y2QI|‡a'4(*=ih«#ua6,,"#O.$"(#),
J+]*96"J(33‹()],e%_
(@(J()33360-2)J)3H-5"]
)+"$Q.+&"
2A
T60U5+QHJ""(_+_%}‡a'4(+*;6"
"22/S%v
ˆ TG&]‰5%
2Q/{Še%V+360¡eŠQ‹!‰F^˜
ˆ Ge|Œ5%b"/|
"(&.e%N¡e‹!Œ0^˜
ˆ T6&:%N)+"1Ž8v‰+AŒK’‘/A
xTM*(Q` Z*0"22[%(+*c5"H1“¨vN‰”•Œ
S/+U@Q*&)§%
/6,–,v
–,iz‘i—˜M…™v‘i—cš · M…™ ‘I—š›JMOœœœ u2ƒ–Ÿž ™ ­ ‘i—cš­
­ S
6¡/¢£™¥¤¨h&YZ")(T%">¦…A7()QI+;*¨ Q` Q18Z/](OU0"H„“¨¡NyA (AAo(>§:PAoFv¨\– ¡IŠ^I
© ¡eŠ2^^A
xT2),
5*(6,/H(S%N /+,"H("[%-.*
")02EŠ2IH"&+U%N >"…XI
6"#;"()2S
5*(S(/536<2QVŠiª0;2"$@
J55
Hd—¡N6&”‘/¡eŠ3^^A37+A‡a'4(+*O*'
3.
25J@)3%a;*(Q` 3Q
¡eŠ2^N'#"=¡e^-
QI"(#‡Y¡eŠ3«^-@)QA ? 2$]]/+T'
+"I:*T)
T¬‡Y¡eŠ3^e@)T)*U,%N2'
[)+yv
‡Y¡eŠ3X^J2M¡hB^!­®+^+‡Y¡IŠ«3^M/­®+i ‘˜M…™¥+PAoFG¯'‡Y¡eŠ ª 3= ª ^¬u
6°­JW/+T(+*ZQ¡N"(*[6/T.(H"(")'
*US6]/+,()[.SX%-5‡Y¡eŠ3^e@),T@(
mn~±en®º%± ²]–³o´µ\l£v{­®#2 š˜¶#­·y­—q· · ¸v¹¯«º »:¼ ^A!‡Y¡eŠIªi3'ª4^7(
T(Z)½‡Y¡eŠ3^@+· )+T.QU.(HH@()&"
%ª@&QŠiª®A
›L+š*X$("]]+c"/|L(")(IYH
@U].
#y"/+[+".F60O"*cM"
¦yW")(-%"-eW@)W%+%‚))W6&BA
x|—i¾ 6&„‘b"@:º_&:3%N))+360:H
™ · 5[6
[[60)O.602/O%7[602"$@O5'
/H(A,xY{™!Q(hI%N)+"/8Q1&%N))
6&+(]"")+&*H(A
QI_6LF2%NLL]
QI_.+)*(J.)8F2'
@S2$6,
IFJ#J"/
_
0_H_.F%N
I
8%N2("y867L#J)+"Q86&!¡>¿\'
QO@X$2)ZQTÀ=iªu^/A ¦ X[5(Q0@+'
)
>)BI60)+#™2Á˜œz«¡N6">(,
,
*(TY(
#.H;%*(/-^Tc+Q%N)"'
K¡µJ3Ira^iuv
0 š %Gr#¤#-¼
ÂF¡µJ3Ir_^J2
¡©^
µ 6
6"#!)60*(%1‡Y¡eŠ«3^&@).-!X!
()[.,%W:¡tr_^W["H-,.>@(
AJ"'
?2("y;6š 7;/+&.ÂF¡µJ3Ir_^
@),S2";.
%N
A#0 /+.52.+:6&?
¾#*
"(.Qc&*@2Q/(IS-A¼7"$XYZ()[.
%F5a
T*(/a)+5H:_
")yY"/'4Q7
õ;2&)yHU%¬‡Y¡eŠ3^
@+)(A
f M:601bIX):.ŒN"@8;=@)
88d":%
(+*;:*B`(+"$]]1(*J.)5¶¥5BA_
QI60Z6e"5-55F%‚"5%3*(/&67"J)+
Ça'4(+*L* ¡eŽÄF^76/?/+
Z;¡eÅÄF^/A
TJ+J1HLdF+"JQ69L*(:":/+L¶¥
6>67+"#8HJ673/,"2
#/—¡N—igu_>
("e"G+$8 ¦ *)h^A ¦ 3]#*:&%
"XyI-.FƎGÄ=ÆÅÄ=*(5QH>"
1*T(")
)[CQ"/:Ž-T13*(
6…9%WX)Y[Z'W\9Y¡N$‹()
;¡NŸ^^+-@W*X@5/+W-%RS8>7$
¡N‹)-/¡Ž^^V"@
A
f QI
6<¾*(ZG+;J¶VZIbZ"(")$
(F">))¡N$‹()
!¡g^^0%0("#!¶¥œ&&'
QA›!/KųÄ/+:*XY5+H;"(YZZ6
.4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9BA›!KŽÄT('#'4(2$U¡¬‹()
'
8¡©^^/+S2$0%0¶¥5QAV›L+)+*AŽGÄ+IBT%‚"5(
-)2ZY(2)W7.FG+-%+
@(*3"/]a-")
¶¥™6""+0Z/+T)+)+0*.(H"@(*;
¶
¨)2*]¶¥ "#Ç%N3
/H(*5xTy¶
(QA3
(W*(/'42EY"2F+W[.2Q"/%b
")y#U)
L-8*($(+"]6»O¶
%N)+¡¬%‚(I*((I(/::&*?
=
^˜3!*('"M(:8:%[+
*(a-3__+B-¡NA (AbS2a%"(
"
'
S"(;"EI£")*,)+W¶¥]^;&%N'
"SS?S&6&2:.Q:.(H"*
")y#¶¥]A()QIbU(5[/-,6‡a'4(*]
*(Y6-@(/)-H;(5F"H=¡/%‚/3+*)%N'
G"S/)-/B^
6"#E6¹1(E6<6"?¶7¥§
"+23*@T"G+"32)
ÈQ(A
f &,"(&
,%‚"5(,Z"(/Q_(&
7("a%F(*3."()27aa7"
+2¯/&Q
0.yT%07*(U0.
8"U0%N25-Ab)+QI60S'
"&"Y
@@+)Y5(a&Q@
+%N"$(QA:U%+%N"$(ZZc'
2S,@)
;%N25;;,"+",%S¶¥]A(
IÉ4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9;"+:/=8"M@)
3xT¶("/0,.Q.(HZ"*:W
")y3¶¥]A
›!!*X/—
2G-IW/+xTy¶»"@X$
G§%N;%N§&Z*(Z:S;F2
&@+)
#/S_"-Ab7()BIQSxTy¶"
_/_'
"K4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9S6;/+&G§@+),*y?¡NyA (A-
ÇyxT")
H(IS""5+*L¶
755H>"("
A
Š @c)*¯*8"@?CE¹Q1(QIa%Nc
5"$X¾5%‚"5(Z2"Z5+Z$@+(Z
*Q` "Z.)Z¶7¥QA
9%WX)Y[Z'WS9BI_‹)-¯¡NŸ^^A f %3]"LU"2;+)*
=¡ ÊPg©EË^_5(e%NX
Ia,*:+%N"3
(˜.)7%V77+W
7"(I+*@3%N"(W
ÌA
f :[T
.-"_%N"(V(
I…60_6&#
267+$+$5"2-/?"2?]1(*").
5+E@[%0xT¶.)+e(%+/+_X/+*
[
(@(EAT
YBI+"(KŽGÄJ#*YQ@ZY+"'
X,%4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9
%£H3
@3-5(%£_X/+7*)Í
3$@+)
WQIE6WW3-5Y"2)"S_"5+,'
(QO%WU*(,.)+EIbQQI60U"(>H
"[email protected]
&Y")"["(
'
"QA f =
")QIe60+$"=8+Ã( xYy¶
=
‹()
J¡h^a60axT¶]"(#")@+)%( xT¶V(
.(H=@Q**:.+&&"@&%N *(/¡¬
"(Q/)2+*5&xT¶7` Q67@Q*&6&
^A
f U)H(I/+5*(Q`B%N"S6F.5-H(U)'
*3%‚E6**Qv
ŽGÄ+h?*(e(53"T_
")+yT¶¥¹""+*33
2GT*.(H""*>¶
7Y6c&
")
¶¥]A
ŽGÄ+g?*((!2">:
#/")>¶7¥ ""*
5"")Q"HZ667+"#HZ+"_4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9
¡N6"#J3.-J85Q*%( xT¶V(J+$
2@*"2"$)+52Q"Q^A
ÅÄM*(**&(*"@(QA
cG<O2")2¾<>>%Z(*c<)
+yI_UU"Q2H>2$"%NH?;%N()2$U%Y]$(@('
(,O67"OJ#*[670.FU
AU60;2"$'
@:.=+*X
v/ŠÎ%Ï%Ѝ%‘iÑ Òhc67"¨xTyCQ
S(@(_."$X5SxYy¶
U.H5)+.+*W.6"
"(")$c.(H‹)
¨¡/Ž^#ӊÎ~Ï%Ѝ'‘qÑ Ògc67+"#=xTCE
"(")y/+$&.+,>Q6&H.)&H@H'
)+.(H>TQ§%"QA-&(;%N"#
*&
;[*QV"(2,xT¶VT%":Y*(T(V%-)+"Q(yH
+"+*[W@#)(AV()W/+TQ+–5(W5W'
@(+5(e56"5"/T7$2T"")Q(A
*X$+$BI
Uy60;"-[")JZ(2
.H2Q"(@'
5?6"?*X(?+"+5"(?.¾
H(
"J(@(M6"#—+"J(H
Z"")Q(A
5.
EXPERIMENTAL EVALUATION
><(H(F2]60>1—/c@+)-/O<;2$"
Y6*(3"+
Z5dF"@H;)+Y"
'
;)++*;U+%N"$([.
M*XQAU
]5(#)
3.F+G7%V(+)"*57G*]O*(E` [.7
)&+yI_[3%0((/,605+$2*+!,%‚]#
+*H,3E@(W+%N].)-W(F2Q
@+y.+QA f a&Y/&@2%NHZ(Ha‹()'
XS60&QHQ"(#b%‚$2"&+QI(;
")
H(%&@+y#"c¡NxÔRJÕ
x^&)!(H(F2
.)a+d"_.y60S5(#a""/
AV7+()+(H'
,¡N Ô^b%b‹()
#W"(.YŒN"6YX'
")02@(-%N(F2(/-
0dF+"$S*
(3*G"((Y¡¬„¤#A ©X^a*(a.Z""
"(QH="((A—
UQI0")!%U»*Xœ
,"G"5(@(Y*QU,YX%a@+)3%‚Y5'
(Q_@+y#.Z/-,"(O.8
H2O)[UQ
Ì®].+)5@#)%]4)56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9,&)2J:E@(5
%N"(b,+$
/+a2@XaXb+a+*/@_"
A
"")Q">2)
,>,:+.(H2
)2*xÔRJÕ
xA
f /+a"((IB/+7([email protected]$2(v
QxY*
±-6&8X.Q>%N CE !¶
»Q1(QI6">,'
H="(¯*(U)H¾¡eŒÖ7^/IT!/+]VXET()[.U%
¶
7c""§¡e×|؝×W^/A7O%‚E6+*L[)X¾@+'
.60JG—%N>Y(FBv2½%,*
¡hbh^I
)Q<¡©I EE)+B^مI
()[.Z%5¶VZ
a*0(HYaY¡Ž^I$()[.b%b*(/V&a(@'
¡©^I£CEO6&:¡h^I£¶VO6&#¡g^I…([)+¾()[.
%Y*(Y8"#@:¶
§¡Ž^I+"+
"
'
S"2+$2$].HO?*(Z¡¶¥]¡tI Aª^IV¶¥]¡h©I A«^IV¶¥
¡ŽI A^I3¶7¥¡NŸ©I A^+¨¶7¥¡ªIhA ^څ^/Ac;((
2"$2.c"";)+X%Y/+;5(QS@.
@Q*:E@Zh[):)+QA
:.J""Q"%W>H(/+QI_a
(H0(.Q6L[)_.SŒN"J¡N(*,
](H2%3‹()
T(%(^U!/+]@)%
0((Q(@#y.-%-e
#/")
(**X
+)L+)+";2*G"((H=.FU)U
L].'
Q+?6ÓÅÄ+AV%N(I-:%NQ67*J(H(F25Z)
.32/:1ŠÎ%Ï%Ѝ'‘qÑ Òh1ŠÎ%Ï%Ѝ'‘qÑ Ògv
hva8*([)yH8.Q+O.(HJ%N*=5%N"'
(W.
O*PWYB5UW
W.+E#.H
*(67+"#)+&ųÄ;*2A
gva;()[.%¶
J"@c.(H<*(.H?5(+%
/+S+%N"S#+*J*2¹T("#b
%*(/)+*!ÅÄ+A
Žva:*(T)yH:.Q].(H#ŽGÄ+h3T[B5;T
%]ŽGÄ+g¡N@)
::&"(236& hTŒN"
^A
TŸvaU)+[.,%[¶V:""+>.(HOŽGÄ+h5,("(
Y%¬ŽÄ+g¡N@+)
#/Z"(Z6Z g&Y'
ŒN"
^A
.?h+(J)+5H?%Y;2)U.QL.H
%N+*OxÔRJÕ
x9L]
Q""L.(H?("#L%3
*5ƊÎ%Ï%Ѝ%‘iÑ ÒhA…†VQ` 5G+]
H(O*(Z)'
yHL(H2BA» h]:ŒN"
I(*=
8%N'
"]%3=*U(U
@?2*G"((d"U
ŒÖ8.Q
AV
Z)+Q7)+QI2/'#
H(
%Z£ŒÖ–@)].Q+<.(H!("#P* 6&#;"'
Q2HA| T(I7/+*"X")2—
#%N'
"5%ÅÄU3.$3.(H?,Q"(H]*G"(()+
¡eŒÖÛ)Ü°2»h˜3$hŽE:œkŽ«^e
KŽGÄ+hKŽGÄ+g¡eŒÖÝ%Ü · 2Þ:3®ŸhŽ:œk©EI
ŒÖ Ý'Ü K2ß:3$ŽEE:œ E^A ¦ )(I"
*=
/+J%N'
":%ŽÄFh8ӎÄFgU= Ž8¡NxT""
^Ie"")+
W@),[W5(
X%Q*Y
.**(
(
/@XU(HUd":/+ŒÖ>.+Q-A
gJ@)
]OdF"@%]"@(*¯¶
7BA¹
(HZ;""O67+"#O(Z/-[/+U/XE0%Z¶V
"#@YT]:* ")
A7
]=Q(5)5L
#H(=E#A f =
"$)+yQI
6H?(!ÅÄ8F2%N¤./%S?*8"@
Ù ›8T"U[$@+)
S%‚37G($U)+QU."()TU
"
#]U")+:M#*[6O6&M[#"O'
A=7()QIa(X
.:>"5-:+:.
@)%
5*5)U]B5]-Q/2QA!])Q
"0)K"0%N_T(2+**+50["$X@*(A
Úy¶7¥W60T2".F"()+Y@)W2)W
@T'
"(?/-Z2>?+$/-;"?.H
*:S*ihuyA
à üaýFþ%$
õ(ú…ñ‚úþý>õá£ù+ÿ‚ó
ù+þõ
hvQŒÖ Ý%Ü · 2ԌÖ Ý%Ü %2°ŒÖ Û)Ü
gvQ×|؝×Ý%Ü · 2°×|؝×Ý%Ü 2Ô×|؝×Û)Ü
ŽvQŒÖ Ý%Ü · 2ԌÖ Ý%Ü YŸvvT@)
ü
A EE
Aǻ
A©E
âUó
þ…ûXý\ã>õ
±-ŒN"/
xT""
xT""
mWù[
ÿ‚õ]öF÷äå>æ)çTè>éeê ë£ö\ìWôEõ(ú…ó
ÿ‚þý\SjrÃâíSj
Q()[.5%Z¶
7)Í R0(?5
ÅÄ=""5'
2Y;CQ|Q1(Y
JZ*BA ¦ *);Ž
¡N%‚a-Q^+E6_
_/+6&#X.Q.(H]"@*CE
Y[.+**2T-T%aZE#
6&
ASxTQI-
5Q(0(2
IXW
WW"
ZWW*H'
@]¡N)5/5'4)J"3%_/+;¶¥5B^a(@3L¶
6=/+:)"Q(yHM#.F)+]"+@(+*JQA>›!
ÅÄ+IbZ5/-ZxTy¶<"(?]1X>*(?"?%
4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9BA7¥(636„ŽGÄQQIU*(/@)
U
(2Z]¶7¥U6JH;(6
3UJ6
Y
ZT*(:"
I&&
· A
óïîîî
ÿ ÿ
ÿ
óîîîî
òîîî
ñîîî
ðîîî
ïîîî
î
ô<õeö
>ô õ÷
ø[õ
ô<õeö
ô<õ÷
ø[õ
ö
÷
ùcúqûIüeý%þ ÿ
ùcúcûeüIý'þ ÿ
o7ñ\òFó
ôQõF÷5lõ,ù+ô>Lý\
þù+ñ
õ£=ùòFõ
þôEýFÿ\õ
¶V(QHU))-I&y60@%‡a'4(2+*
e¡ ŽGÄ+hI°ŽGÄ+g^3+OU-/@cH=d"U!=#*Q`e%N'
"(A<xT
H2*!QIW60]G+!
U.$"()+
&:"#
*%0%N8.y608*(
1*(Z;&&6:H>"#@&+&E#1A
&BI:@(&("$")+&67+"#!Q6 *(&:"#
*
%N"(EA Š b5+Z%7@([
[")O185+%N'
%N"]#5%_]2;#H]"&3yH(3%N
xT¶V(BAW.F-/@()+-%+}ŽGÄQe-(*Z('
*"5;"@*JY+%N"S6"#;Q2
Y.$3/+:"Y%N
AS7()YZy60@Y%
ŽGÄQ[YH%‚"*5YQ#"$7.)W6/dF'
(7@+)+QA
)*Q6<//+&&H(
"&(@((%]ŠÎ%Ï%Ð:
‘iÑ ÒgAS›8ZJ/+ZQZY%a(H(F+$2+/+Z)
T)2UU.5gA ¦ 2EI60
H½US(H(F'
· Z"(@*"ZZ%NYAŽGÄQY&"[.+
%a
(*,Q(IBTQJUE%‚)"-IB
Q32Q[25
A f 76&7+W)+WX.ŒN"@3
+)>W/+
Q#55/J)""(@*"
5J
2/")3"(BAU±SQI605G(J5@)&%3
Q#5;1X$+S¹"Q(S;.#‡a'4#+*5'
QXQA
S:6?*()yH>¡N hI( Ž^ATCE5H/&'
)+a.Q.[hIB607"+")+7
Y+H(+*VŽÄU
ÅÄ()"&+"/@)¡¬ h,&ŒN"/-^/A ? )QI"'
@HYS.YhI&V(QŽÄ+hSVŽGÄ+g-*b2*G"((H
./U2)/>¡eŒÖÝ%Ü · 2_:3iªŽ:œŽM+ÁŒÖÝ%Ü 2_:3iª«:œE^
ÁÅÄ!¡eŒÖ Û>Ü 2 «:3$h©h:œhg^A!xT
H(I_.2@*O
xÔRJÕ
x¹2)5%S.ƎGÄ=*QI-601:/+Q
"")M[60OŠÎ%Ï%Ѝ'‘qÑ Òh˜
H(Ib*@*]2$'
%N"(T.%N:+=%NY/+[*
2[1Y
d$2",,G
V6&;X.Q].HO*(5¡N TŸ5"'
"
^A
à üaýFþ%$
õ(ú…ñ‚úþý>õá£ù+ÿ‚ó
ù+þõ
ü
âó
þûý\ã>õ
hvQŒÖÝ'Ü · 2ԌÖ³Ý%Ü 2°ŒÖÛ)Ü
A EE
±
Œ‚$"
gvQ×|Ø× Ý%Ü · 2°×|Ø× Ý%Ü %2Ô×|Ø× Û)Ü
A EE
±
Œ‚$"
ŽvQŒÖÝ'Ü · 2ԌÖ³Ý%Ü AŽ© xY"$"+/
YŸvQ×|Ø× Ý%Ü · 2°×|Ø× Ý%Ü AŸE xY"$"+/
mWù[
ÿ‚õ!F÷äå>æ)çTè>éIê ëT\ìWôEõ(ú…ó
ÿ‚þý\SjrÃâíTj
›L8%N+":@#),%×|؝ר¡N g;8 TŸ^AZ
(HZ%7‹)-05(+[% g5ZŒN"M+O TŸ]:"'
"
ATZU&*G"((Y
"3A×|؝׾#"@
6%N*AŽÄQ0ÔųÄ+IB672SS)+&5ª©7/LŽÄB
£Ÿ/ÅÄFAZ@(2F"3/2")3Q6[IF)*
I
67(H„ÅÄZ.QZTE60{ŒÖO"@*¶
7)Í
? *,"(_67/S2$@()_(y#
I.2@'
* ¦ *)+ŽU¡N*T"
^I£T"(].F[]
T[6&
*c.H¾"@*—¶
7%N!ÅÄQ'4xT¶V.**X$
c
*8.(H”ŽGÄQ'4xT¶V,."#)Hc#"@¶
QAZ TQ67'
@QIB5S(@»6&#a_)K"(a&"Q@
36&:/-76&7.+*5*.(H/ŽÄB'\xTCEZ¡±†V'4xTyCQ7.'
Q+==Q[2E(HӟS˹%T:E#76&=.H
""2+*:CE&+…ÅÄB'\xTCE,"+@>«ªEË^/AVT(2
%N&&2)&&
*&@2U[*G+"()(3%
;>2)c?¶¥ +
Iac;-Ia;xYy¶
+%N'
‹)+a*+e.+_/-ÊÎ%Ï%Ð:'‘iÑ Òh3¡N(*&
xT¶VB`(GSS+)"
^Ae)BI˜ŽGÄQS%N¹.FS.F"()+
H!U"$2E<.F)+[67+$]@2[U<]¶
-IX&Q(/H(I6X7/[¡N."()&
60LQ^A!7+H?L)2;U]OQ1?#@(Q*]%
)2)*CE7BA
? %N31(+*]T*Q"")O.)3@+"
%+WdF(-+-%+%N"SZ(*Y
*(QI ¦ *)Ÿ2Q675%N2]+"%S>*
%N 5d["@(A T(IV608
H½UU%N'
"U%Z*([.(H8@+)
*/+8@Q*U2))Z6&
(F"=¡N‹()
X=g^AW›8[)+Q1[
H2Y.F"()+
_5Q(_,1(E6L%_(H560(67S
/@(+*
+/@
*(2/(;%-ŒN)2
#:)+**(/B`("X:'
1(*:+")+.)&67"!¶¥9:"QA[
:.F+"(I
ÅÄ!*(/U2"=¶7¥¤.
#cXÞ4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9BI_.)…ŽÄB
*(8¡eŽGÄ+gU)/+2)5%Y/+@+)-=Œ‚)
]%N2"$(Q^/A87()BI
(5J")(5/+)+5'
.S%e"(T]6"#]/+"]";.(H/+¡ŽGÄ]#*'
/+ ""36J5)"Z"(J.(H;‹()
LgA
f :60QI*@S"G"32)
ISŽGÄ;*(
J¶¥5:O@#)
U/+[%NZ)y
Ib>HL#
H(½
#4>56 9%WX)Y[Z<W\9ZX%/-:¶¥]A f %[Z@(I
/+<"(
%b!W")+>¡N."()2Y/+¶7¥P6&W(>
""+$:6&"2:.
2K4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9^/AR_:
+
I%
S*@(I(¶¥š6&S/;.)
Y"2F+67Z@)
%a‹()
Lg¡N"(
¦ ^A£xT+
H(I+60[
@[["(Y]6"#]:¶¥ 6&
b+&b"2W¡ ¦-¦ ^(+0¡ ¦ Z^6&
"].
]O4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'WS9BA f ST"(T
S6¥ÅÄ
["(T
@[/U.["(S."()[HO#/T"'
?.
??5@)
AJxT5%N5„ŽÄBQI-567
==E6§/+‹()
=5"(#")
A ? ÓÅÄc
ŽGÄ+h#*35+QH;‹)
#/Lg&)2*3E6/(@)3%N
( xYy¶
-IV67+(AŽGÄ+g)Z@)
ZZ
Z(
.
2;]@()+T$+")(/BA ¦ *)[Ÿ2E6TH/+,
¦-¦ "(20"ST&¡N ¦ ¦ [^0T_2$@#
]/+T")2
A0[GT/+*UU"[Y/+,"(S+%N'
%N".F60OŽGÄQQI67">&)+:+d(&6&/H(&
6"#>/+/4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9[,"(")y
A7">.2@'
X&V
|ŽGÄ+g-
V ¦-¦ "(BI5(+*S
V5Xb%£
]"XJ3%N&&XU/&"+
27"(2aa"_"(e6/
#e.-
/+Ã4>56 9'WX)Y[Z'W\9BA7[(2]%‚TT2)YY
¬ŽGÄ+g
Y*2Y)*A( xT¶
6"YT1
T*(:"/:%
/+3Z*(/BA ¢ @:BI3X.@('
)_‹()1ZQv"X)!ÅÄ3F%‚»./_.HZ(*
_B5S6&/H;ԎÄFgEÍZ T(IB/+Z260a_Ab
H(9)H;.QJ.HKÅÄ8*3KŠÎ%Ï%Ð:'‘iÑ Òh&*B
"2Q#.H:67+$=*X$(T)2¡( xYy¶
=¡eŒÖ³Û>ÜÔ2|«:3$©«©œkgE^
,ŠÎ%Ï%Ð:'‘iÑ Òg
bQV*H¡eŒÖÛ)Ü2M«3#©X«E:œ Ÿg^A0wa+
YQ@5(W„ŠÎ%Ï%Ð:'‘iÑ ÒgIXW7XW)K"W5
@Y h
""
A f %aAÅÄ8*B`+"3%}4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9U
(Q6P¡N.F*5".F)+,2.,%N)),"XF'
@*(Q^I(/+HU6W6&/H(/&"(
;@:
)
XW6YWWY.2W"2Z1(AV TE6W@QI
%eY"/Z*c¡¬.*F25Q^a/+H:67
@85+"(
-Ac()QI_60]"(c"X")+;
@*O(*M*U67+"#c+=c(J#"/BI
Q1(*c@+(E*XU%+*'\¸GQIVZU('
.*JJJ?+H
"@(.F"()+O*(
"(:.3"Q.)7&B`"XQA
798
:;8<
:;8>=
65
25
31 42 /0
! !
"$#$%&'( ) *,+
!!
"-#$%&'( ) *.
oñ‚òFó
ôQõ?F÷A@CB>ù[
Æ4>56 9%WX)Y[Z'W\9UùûXþñ\ý\
Lú…õ(ÿ‚õ(ûXþñ\ý\
6.
RELATED WORK
x!@2eQ)
a.+)""aH(a""'
*U[)+[%e(*U"+‹()¡N
")+yH1‡a'\(*^
[)+*3H(ihhIehŸuATZ%N(")3
3.H
y6082F"QA f ][G+T(I-=*(Q` Y*
TU(
.)V/+a7*(/7+&b(@(+5(b.(HY.2@
O[]+"[[.F
@()Z[]()"85+$
%W i«I0©I0guA f >">"(#(IN‡a'4(+*]
,.
+(JE6¨"(
Z3"QZO"@
"*7.H)*Z"G"Y2/B/*,ihªIhuyAVY)"'
"V,_y60+b%£("#&
#bHY.,/SQ@
"QX8X&"(
X8.y6W$>J*(,>
(@(EA—›!]"(H|LQ(U2)]
+QI60U33"+"$26(*552$"7
'
")+yT"+
]5"#
QA&¥5)"#;T601
T.
+SU&(AVT0@(06015[X)0E6U0
¶R|†v†bx ¢ Š iuS#/†7R3w Š C8ih©ue2H2/QA&5.bŒN"/@5
.,2H2/
VTQ@_"(
[.(H3(+*TS2"
3"(
X]2/Q*H:=+[)
+QA7 TQ60@
c"("#!H( 2>d$2>!
G+*2"5(QH(A†7R3w Š C,5X2/>
@**X$(
"(#
.0%(*T01H&%NX[
"BHE@["2
#/]]"G+",)
+QA f ¶R|†v†bx ¢ Š *(3#JQ6¨"+255U+'
0"(
[2Q*H&*@;a
")+y-/)-
Ab7()BI
†7R3w Š CU%N")+3 ¿\67
#Y%NJ(#TÀO!¶7RQ†b'
†Vx ¢ Š Þ¿4(*52)
J65)],"(
'
]2Q*HÀA f TTQ(SU"$[
T.]H(
T""U6US+EJ#"/@W%"(
8
a%/+(+*,"2QA ¦ Y*(a&@Z0-")
"(
O+.]IVHJ-/@U]2@8_U($2y'
+]"T.y60]"QAW7()*(
G2Uy#L=#"/O%N +L!")/+]A
Z2@Y+QI.FH(W-/@Y5
Y1Q6*(v
.)Z+]#??/+"(X%†7R3w Š C?<.)5"$('
X>Q*,6M¶7RQ†v†bx ¢ Š A f >)+,"((IbE60@QI
2("#»a.HZQIB.)a)+Y2)5+3
d$2&U6WS+(F6UT+.$–)2+*:
@T'
)BA f O)[%NQ601bIW*(:2+E6067/<5
%e"]1(*U+")+TU"‹)-,"(
'
O$"#
QA ? HJ(*;6—#—.Q",2,%W)"#
"
+25BI6W["2YY[FQ(T
@:*(
a-/@+"(
"yHZ&Q1S"X3.F)+a"X-
I
Q
:(*6&Q".$60:/+]A
›8(@y#/5JQ5X%S/+).2‹)(5Q1(
%-#("y;("yA ¦ )2/+52I£60&.@,
5
*(Y"(2*XHZ.*,‹)+&(+6+H'
"[2)YZ(2+*U6
."[Z5'
Q(EAS¶7RQ†v†bx ¢ Š I.(H"Q2QI)2Q"&.-:(*
"+‹()0U67+"#T&W+
T%"Q@H5%b
]X[%eQ+*A,¶
‹()(H(I[2H2/ #T60V'
G>,>6">/++
F%NX5>6"#
*@bY-+.<%(+*67+&("&-
+):G+2
A
7. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK
[
#H(+3)U#3K"("HU%7*X$(('
*U.FX)-1(*3"T.)e67+;+Z+E6?3"+'
(A›8aQ60,/-b(+*S52E@Va",]#1*
6=*([)"Q=.)Y/+[*XQ`
"QA
S5+E@(("$")+."()2*(S(;"*½
S2)
06ST_+GQ.5"X0[)0.FT'
"$
AZ›8J2:Q608
&(*:6&#&dF"@6
*(5FB/?522E#/"@(25?67"?H
"(U15"")B/T+"+&.)_0$(@(+5(&
Z*(/BA
CE(1*=8*QH(I608.@8::Q(
@="+‹()
.*(8"(
:ž('
.H:H-5":)2$+"Q.[(@(/BA7xTX)*
@Q#T%&Q»"%&)"2!+")+
"G":)&*'4608"
I60.@
&
*Q_+"2:>2/2)")2)Q.%N,2(*
.)"X-c"-c52:*X$+QX]BA
f -")QIQ)+a%67+Q6=&e(*
"+‹()3>Q6¹*(/3E#1Z"3.
J+$
(F"3[S1H82F"7
7+7.+7(@*
A
:&+
I)&(8"(8.F@(60!
G272/::
"
A
¦ Z%N)+/)+(IV60>D()2U%S(*
"Q@5]2F"%SO*(Q` "X?%NQ601bA f ")QIB[(US"J.)0E6L[)+"[.UJ
‹()a%‚a"(
-IQ6/,.F"5xT¶
J¡¬‹()
'
XcŽ^T+67".+Y>""¡N‹)-/Ÿ^AS›8;2'
/E6¨*(a&"+)"aX"(5(
%VU[Z
@3/+.yHUZ@+H3Q7%
b(*5""+*3*(E` V"+
,"(EA
8.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
ZG)"1(Q67*YZ%N)*%Y¥5("` °'
X
0¶
)"%CE"":
"+*H(Ib¶7RQTxZ¶VH([A
9.D EGFIHKREFERENCES
JMLKJMNPORQSUTVW,XYJ,NZJ,[]\M^_V
` V TMaUV_bdc9Oe` V_fOgW,hRTfjiKJMHKJ,k,V_TTl TmRneJ
HoQTbdaUl pYVqnGV_` V ^_aUl OeTjORr9^ OMOeSUfl ThRaUl ORTjpYV ^shRTl nGpYntl TjpCQ` aUl bdhemRV_TMa
nGuMnUaUV pYnRJ,v-TxwPyUz|{|}Pz~Z€M‚Iƒ_„…d€‡†‰ˆy$zŠ‹‚ŒMAŽtzM|~}PzM’‘UWM“e”R”R”•J
D “RFIXYJMX‰` hRQnohRTfjXYJ,N‰OeQaGl ` l V SeJ,c–sVqfuMThRpYl ^_ntOer—SUV l Tr˜OeSG^_V pYV_TMa
` V_hRSUTl TmKl Tj^_OMOR™‹V_SUhRaUl šeVCpCQ` aUl hRmRV_TMaonGu,nGaUV pYnRJ,v-TxwPyUz|{|}Pz~ZƒM›Md€
œ ŒMd}‰ŽozMe~}‰zM‘GWEGžRžeŸgJ
D RFI[qJ,¡IJ,¢£QSGr¤V VqhRTfj¥KJMHKJ,¦V nUnGV_SeJM§9hRSUaUl he`…me` OR¨he`…™` heTTl Tmg©L
^ OMOeSUfl ThRaUl ORTjr˜SUhepKV_ªPORSU«’r¤ORSofl nUaUSGl ¨QaUV f¬sMuM™‹ORaUsV nUl nor˜OeSGpYhRaUl ORT—J
‘G†P†‰†®­—yUŒM‹¯ŒM{|°˜zM‹¯ZzMA±‹²,¯‚|³I¯´‰µ¶ŒM‹´PŒM•·jŽt²R¸‚|y_‹‚|d°>{|¯W
“gER¹ ºe»R© EREG¼e½R¾gEeEGŸR •W…EGžežgERJ
D ¿RFIXYJMNCJM[À\M^ V_` V_TMaUV b>c9OR` V fO•W,HKJMLKJMN‰OeQSUTVW,hRTfjiKJMHKJ,k,V_TTl TmRneJ
HoV henGORTl TmIhe¨•OeQao^ OepKpYl aUpYV TMaUnohRTfj™‹V_ThR` aUl V nor˜OeSt^_OMORSUfl ThRaUl OeT
¨‹V a-ªPV_V T’hRQaUORTOepKOeQnohemRV T,aGneJRv-TÁwPyUz|{|}]z~Cd€M‚I›M€j‘U•d }]ŽtzM|~}PzM
IˆdzM•zM³KzMˆ¯‰–Ë‚•d¯WM“e”R”gEeJ
D ºRFIkJ,¡tQjhRTfjÄxJM§PJ,ÅÆV ` ` pYhRT—J,ÇÈT` l TVC` V heSUTl TmIhe¨‹ORQaoORaUsV_SohRmRV_TMaUn
l TjhKfuMThRpYl ^qpCQ` aUl hemRV T,aonGuMnUaUV p¶JMvTxw‰y$z|{|}‰z~CÉM•·j‘G‹Â }PŽtzM|~}
zMIˆdzM•zM³KzMˆ¯‰–Ãʂ|•d¯W…EUžRžRŸ•J
D ¼RFI¦oJ,§PJ,ËÈhRV ` ¨` l TmgW,ÄÌJ,¦oJ,¦l aUaUpKheT—WMheTfjLIJ,ÅÍJ,ćOMOeSUVJ
HoV l Tr˜ORSU^_V pYV T,ao` V_hRSUTl Tm•©…LÎnGQSUšeV u;J…Ï;zMˆy_‹ŒMÂ9z~‰‘qÐP‚|¯‚ŒMy${|€MW
¿g¹ ¿R»e© “e R½R¾e“RŸRº•W…EGžežR¼gJ
D ½RFIÑIJMiohRmRhuMQ«MlUW,җJ,v-nGsl lUW,hRTfj˒J,¢£O|uehgJ,ćQ` aUl bdhRmRV_TMaoSUV l Tr˜OeSG^_V pYV_TMa
` V_hRSUTl Tm•©…LtTjhR™™SUORhe^s¬¨hRnGV_fjORTjaUsVqORaUsV_SohRmRV_TMaeÓ nol T,aGV_SUThR`
pKOMfV_`UJ,v-TxwPyUz|{|}Pz~Zd€M‚£„…€‡‘G‹d }PŽtzM|~}PzMAµ¶ˆÂ d° ‰Ã‹‚|‹
±‹²R¯‚|³I¯WM“R”e”R”gJ
D ŸRFIÄÌJ,¥IJMiKJM§ÀSUhRnGhefjhRTfj¥IJ,HKJ,¦…V_nGnUV SeJ,¦V heSGTl TmInUl aUQhRaUl ORTbdnG™‹V_^ l ÔÊ^
^ OMOeSUfl ThRaUl ORTjl T¬^ OMOe™‹V SUhRaUl šRVqpZQ` aUl bdhRmeV TMaonUuMnGaUV_pKneJ,IˆzM‹zM³KzMˆÊ¯
–Ë‚•d¯ZŒM‹·‡µ¶ˆÂ °>Õ ‰Ã‹‚|‹o±‹²R¯d‚|³I¯W,“g¹ “R»e© EU½R R¾e“R”R½•W…EGžežRžgJ
D žRFIҗJMkgJMHoQnUnGV_` `hRTfj§PJ,itORSUšMl mgJ,HoV l Tr˜ORSU^_V pYV T,ao` V_hRSUTl Tm•JMv-T¬’‘G֕
µ¶z|·M‚|y_£ŠMŠ…yUz|ŒM{|€MWM^shR™aUV_So“R”•WM™hRmeV noºRžRŸe¾R¼R“e¿gJM§ÀSUV TMaUl ^ Vq¡the` `UW
EGžRžeºgJ
D EG”RFIҗJMÒV_T—W,ÄÌJMÒV_«|heSUhRT—WMheTfjkJ,¡thR` VJ,¦V heSGTl TmIaUOK^ OMOe™•V_SUhRaUV
ª–l aUsORQaonUshRSUl TmKl Tr¤ORSUpKheaUl ORT—J,v-TxwPyUz|{|}Pz~Zd€;‚IƒMÉM€ œ ŒM}‰ŽozM|~}
zM’‘UW…EGžežR¿gJ
D EREGFIҗJMÒV_TjhRTfjגJMŶV l nUnRJ,¦V heSUTl TmIl TjpCQ` aUl hemRV_TMaonGuMnUaUV pYnRJ,v-T
׬J,ÅÆV l nGneWMV_fl aUORSeWµ¶ˆÂ °>ŒÃ‹‚|‹–±•²R¯d‚|³I¯W,^shR™aUV So¼•WM™hemRV n
“RºRže¾R“RžeŸgJMc–sVqćvc§]SUV_nGneW…EUžRžRž•J
D EG“RFIÑIJMÒsOeshRpØhRTfjÄxJMc…V TTV_TsOR` aUÙ;J,ÇqT¬aGsVqnUuMTMaUsV nUl noORr9QnGV_r˜Q`
nGOM^_l he`…` h|ª–nor˜ORSoheSUaGl ÔÊ^ l hR`hRmRV_TMaonGO,^ l V_aUl V_nRJ,v-TxwPyUz|{|}Pz~Zd€M‚ƒMÚM€
œ ŒMd}‰ŽozMe~}‰zM‘GW,™hRmRV_no“R½R¼R¾e“RŸgEeW…EGžežR“gJ
D EG RFIHKJMגJMÒpYl aUsjheTfjHKJ,¢£h|šMl nRJ,ÛÊSUhRpKV_ªPOeSG«,ntr¤ORSo^ O,OR™‹V SUhRaUl ORTjl T
fl nUaGSUl ¨QaUV fj™SUOe¨` V pØnUOR` š,l TmgJ‘G†P†P†Î­—yUŒM‹¯ŒM{|d°>zM‹¯ZzMA±‹²R¯‚|³K¯´
µ¶ŒM‹´‰ŒM‹·‡Žo²R¸‚|y_‹‚|°˜{|¯W…EeER¹UEG»e© ¼•EG¾R½e”gW…EUžRŸR”•J
D EG¿RFI§PJMÒaUORTVqhRTfjÄxJM¥—V_` ORnUOgJ,ćQ` aUl hRmRV_TMaonUuMnGaUV pYnR©LÎnGQSUšRV_u’r¤SUORpØh
pKhe^sl TVC` V heSUTl TmK™•V_SUnG™‹V_^ aUl šeVJ,KˆzM‹zM³IzMˆ¯ZÐPzM¸zM¯W
g¹ ŸR»e© e¿RºR¾e RŸR •WMk,QTVq“R”e”R”gJ
D EGºRFIcYJMÒQmeh|ªPheSUhIhRTfj¥KJM¦V_nGnGV_SeJM¦V_hRSUTl TmKaUOIl pK™SUO|šeVC^_OMORSUfl ThRaUV f
hR^_aGl ORTnol Tj^_OMOR™‹V_SUhRaUl šRVqfl nGaUSUl ¨QaUV_fj™SUOR¨` V_pYbdnGOR` šMl Tm
V TMš,l SUORTpYV TMaUneJ…µ‡ŒM{|€M°>‹‚Ü•‚ŒMy_‹°>|ËW, R g¹ “RÝe R»e© EU“RžR¾•EGºR •W…EGžRžeŸgJ
D EG¼RFIÄÌJ,c9hRT—J,ćQ` aUl bdhemRV T,aoSGV_l Tr¤ORSU^ V_pYV TMao` V heSUTl Tmg©…vTfV ™‹V TfV_TMaošMn
^ OMOe™‹V SUhRaUl šRVqhRmRV_TMaUnRJ,v-TxwPyUz|{|}Pz~Z€M‚IƒMÚM€‡‘G‹Â }‰ŽozM|~}‰zM
µ¶ŒM{|€M°>‹‚Ü•‚ŒMy•°˜|ËW…EGžežR gJ
D EG½RFIXYJMkgJMXYJ,¡IJ,ÅÆhRaU«Ml TntheTfj§PJM¢£huRhRT—J,c9V_^sTl ^_hR`TORaUV©…ÞÈbd` V heSUTl TmgJ
µ¶ŒM{|€M°>‹‚Ü•‚ŒMy•°˜|ËWMŸg© “R½Rže¾R“Rže“gW…EUžRžR“•J