Weighing the Words

Weighing the Words
Of Ernest Bormann’s Symbolic
Convergence Theory
In Griffin, Chapter 3
CLICKER QUESTION
A good interpretive theory is
probabilistic.
A = FALSE
B = TRUE
CLICKER
Since Fantasy Theme Analysis
has one foot in interpretive theory,
it is well suited to testing
hypotheses.
A = TRUE
B = FALSE
QUESTION
A good objective theory can
explain and predict every case--it
is absolute.
A = TRUE
B = FALSE
CLICKER
One outcome of a fantasy chain
reaction is a more cohesive group.
A = TRUE
B = FALSE
Symbolic Convergence Theory
• Has both interpretive and objective roots;
• Started in rhetorical theory;
• Bormann called the theory fantasy theme
analysis;
• Bormann sees a link between group
solidarity and dramatic imagery;
• In sum, “the sharing of group fantasies
creates symbolic convergence” (p. 21).
Fantasy
• “Fantasy” is used by Bormann to refer to “the
creative and imaginative interpretation of events
that fulfills a psychological or rhetorical need” (p.
21);
• Any reference to events in the group’s past,
speculation about the future, and talk about the
world outside the group;
• “Fantasy” does not refer to the “here and now”;
• Fantasies are expressed as stories, jokes,
metaphors, and other imaginative language that
puts a spin on events;
Fantasy Chain Reaction
• One person offers a fantasy theme idea and
others chime in;
• There’s increased energy within the group;
• An upbeat tempo in the conversation;
• A common response to the imagery;
• Through sharing common fantasies, individuals
in the group are transformed into a cohesive
group;
• Through symbolic convergence, individuals build
a sense of community or a group
consciousness;
Symbolic Convergence
• References to “I,” “Me,” and “Mine,” give
way to “We,” “Us,” and “Ours;”
Criteria to Judge the Quality of
Bormann’s Theory
What makes an objective theory good?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Explanation of the data;
Prediction of future events;
Relative simplicity;
Hypotheses that can be tested;
Practical utility;
Explanation of the Data
• A good objective theory explains
something;
• It makes sense out of an otherwise
jumbled situation;
• It synthesizes the data, focuses our
attention on what is important;
• It explains why;
Prediction of Future Events
• A good objective theory predicts what will
happen;
• Social science theories may not be able to
speak in terms of laws (absolutes), but
need to settle for probability statements
and tendencies;
• It is hard to know when words will ignite
members of a group or when an image will
capture a group’s attention;
Relative Simplicity
• A good objective theory is as simple as
possible;
• If the theory can be stated in less words
and with less complexity that is better than
a more complex statement explaining the
phenomenon;
Hypotheses Can Be Tested
• A good objective theory is testable;
• Falsifiability is the term associated with the
possibility of showing that a prediction
does not turn out;
• There has to be some way we can
imagine that does not support the theory—
it is possible that it will not be supported;
Practical Utility
• A good objective theory is useful;
• We should be able to apply its ideas to
help us in our lives;
WHAT MAKES AN INTERPRETIVE
THEORY GOOD?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Create Understanding;
Identify Values;
Inspire Aesthetic Appreciation;
Stimulate Agreement;
Reform Society;
New Understanding of People
• Interpretive scholarship is good when it
offers fresh insight into the human
condition;
• The scholar does a close reading and
analysis of the text, the context, words,
images, and ideas;
Clarification of Values
• A good interpretive theory brings people’s
values into the open;
• Values refer to such ideas as individual
liberty, equality, hard work, and moral
decency;
A Community of Agreement
• A good interpretive theory generates a
great deal of support within a community
of like-minded scholars;
• Interpretation is subjective, but whether or
not the interpreter’s case is reasonable is
decided by others in the field;
Reform of Society
• A good interpretive theory generates
change;
• It challenges assumptions, raises
fundamental questions, and generates
fresh alternatives;
In Some Ways Objective and Interpretive
Theories are Different
•
•
•
•
Science
causes of behavior
prediction
testing hypotheses
(theory)
Objective
Interpretation
• Meaning
– surface
– deep
• Symbolism (story)
• Subjective
• Interpretivists,
rhetorician, humanist,
critic
In Some Ways Interpretive and
Objective Theories are Similar
Objective (science)
1. Explanation of Data
2. Prediction
3. Relative Simplicity
4. Testable Hypotheses
5. Practical Utility
Interpretive
1. Understanding of
People
2. Clarification of Values
3. Aesthetic Appeal
4. Community of
Agreement
5. Reform of Society