Workplace learning in curricula: Supervision that enables good learning

EDUCATION FOR
PRACTICE TOPICS:
4
Workplace Learning
in Curricula:
Supervision that Enables
Good Learning
By Edwina Adams
Reference for this occasional paper:
Adams, E. (2013). Workplace learning in curricula: Supervision that
enables good learning (Occasional Paper 4). Sydney: The Education
For Practice Institute, Charles Sturt University.
ISSN 2201-8395 (Online)
© EFPI
Contact details:
The Education For Practice Institute
Charles Sturt University – Sydney
Locked Bag 450
Silverwater NSW 2128, Australia
http://www.csu.edu.au/division/landt/efp/
[email protected]
Acknowledgement
The contributions of staff from The Education
For Practice Institute (EFPI) and EFPI’s Workplace
Learning Consultative Committee in providing
feedback on this paper is acknowledged.
This occasional paper presents important factors in supervision that
enable good learning in the workplace, in a CSU context. Factors have
been identified from a review of the current literature and extensive
experience with workplace learning (WPL) in higher education. CSU’s
WPL policy (under review) and the Professional and Practice-Based
i
Education Standards provide local context.
The terms “WPL” and “workplace educator” were accepted by
CSU Academic Senate (AS 10/43, 2010) as generic terms for use at
CSU and will be used in this paper.
WPL allows students to learn through direct implementation of their
professional roles in real workplace settings.
WPL educator, also known as clinical educator, clinical facilitator,
teacher mentor, supervisor, preceptor, refers to educators who teach
and supervise students learning and practice in the workplace. They
may be CSU academics or members of staff employed in the
workplace by industry partners.
This paper builds on two previous EFPI occasional papers:
ii
WPL Placements in Curricula: Strengths and Challenges
iii
WPL in Curricula: Assessment Design
environment is created when high quality support is provided. In the
case of WPL, the WPL educator (student supervisor), plays a primary
role in providing support and therefore has great potential to impact
on student learning. Cooper et al., (2010, p.124) define supervision as:
a purposeful activity providing guidance to students in the
workplace, enabling them to practise their professional skills and
knowledge confidently, safely and effectively ... while maintaining
professional standards and commitment to clients.
WPL educators have a multi-faceted role in providing encouragement,
critical feedback, mentoring, role modelling and often providing some
form of evaluation of student ability (Martin et al., 2011). These roles
create environments for students to develop skills and professional
attributes, build knowledge and be evaluated. Good WPL educators
don’t just teach students specific tasks and skills but enable learning
so the complexities of practice can be understood and effectively put
into practice in many settings.
CSU’s WPL policy (under review) defines the workplace educator as
one who facilitates learning and conducts assessment. WPL educators'
dual role of teacher and assessor is crucial to an effective
interrelationship between teachers, environments and learning.
Workplace Learning
WPL educators: Key factors that enable good learning
WPL holds a substantial place in many undergraduate and graduate
entry university courses due to increasing demand by government
and industry for outcomes-based education and work ready
graduates (Barrie, 2006; Litchfield et al., 2010). WPL in curricula
provides a setting where students can learn to integrate a range of
theoretical knowledge in practice, develop new practice knowledge,
demonstrate knowledge application and further develop skills
required for practice. The ability to do this effectively in a range of
situations can be assessed and help to evaluate the capabilities of
students. Creating a good WPL environment is therefore key to
achieving the demands of outcomes-based education and work
readiness. The workplace educator (supervisor) has a primary role in
supporting this learning and this paper will explore some of the key
supervision factors that enable good learning.
The qualities exhibited by workplace educators play a substantial part
in setting the tone of learning environments and student learning.
Hays and Clements (2011) identify the following qualities as necessary
for a good WPL educator: inspiring, approachable, non-threatening,
open-minded, patient, supportive, and credible.
Figure 1 displays an overview of the key factors addressed below as
capabilities required of WPL educators to facilitate good WPL. These
factors reflect the sentiments of Vermeulen and Schmidt (2008) and
Hays and Clements (2011). These factors address the WPL educators'
dual role of learning and assessment.
Introduction
Teachers, environment and student learning
An understanding of the interrelationship between teachers and the
learning environment and its impact on student learning is necessary
before embarking on the specific requirements for WPL and the WPL
educator. Within the higher education context a number of elements
are necessary to create an environment that fosters good learning.
Vermeulen and Schmidt (2008, p. 432) draw on a range of literature
to identify components that are necessary for an "academic learning
environment", one that enables the attainment of knowledge and
skills, and promotes an academic approach to learning. Table 1 is
adapted from Vermeulen and Schmidt's (2008) review of the
literature identifying factors required to promote good learning.
More specifically, Lester and Costley (2010, p. 563) note that to
foster good WPL, the work environment must be:
capable of supporting learner-managed, (and) reflective learning
at an appropriate level. While opportunities can often be created
around, and sometimes outside of, official work activities for
learners who are sufficiently capable and motivated, some level of
practical employer support is generally essential.
A common element arising from the work of Vermeulen and
Schmidt (2008) and Lester and Costley (2010) is that a good learning
Figure 1. Overview of key factors enabling quality learning
1. Relationships that foster learning
Student attendance in the workplace and the appointment of a WPL
educator will not guarantee learning (Billett, 2001; Hays & Clements,
2011). An understanding of the importance of the relationship
between these two parties is essential to effect good student learning.
Table 1. Factors necessary for an academic learning environment (adapted from Vermeulen & Schmidt, 2008 p.432)
Factors
Interaction between staff and students - supportive, cooperative and responsive staff
Frequent feedback to improve learning
Teacher ability to inspire
Teacher skill and professional development
Institutional climate or an environment that promotes learning and best
educational practice, engages students and creates a sense of support
References
Arends, 2001; Hativa, Barak & Simhi 2001; Kember, 2004
Elliott et al., 1996; Schunk, 1996
Hativa, Barak & Simhi, 2001
Newmann, 1993
Kember, 2004; Mackenzie, 1983; Pike & Killian, 2001; Umbach
& Wawrzynski, 2005; Walberg, 1981; Kuh et al., 1991
2
Billett (2001, p. 90) argues that if workplace experts fail to guide and
have a close relationship with students, the WPL will be "weakened".
The following are required of the WPL educator to facilitate good
WPL (Billett, 2001, pp. 98-117):
 a willingness to share knowledge, particularly when it is not easily
seen or understood and make it easy to comprehend
 determine and provide access to activities that are required for
development plus sequence them in a meaningful way
 provide close guidance that will develop professional practice and
guard against inappropriate practice.
Cooper et al. (2010, p. 128) also note the importance of the WPL
educator/student relationship. The authors portray the role of the
WPL educator as one that challenges and influences students' "ways
of thinking and doing" and that to do this a close relationship is
required. In WPL, educators need to engage students in reflection by
questioning their experience to help them come to new
understanding (Dewar & Walker, 1999; IRU, 2012). WPL educators
can provide a different perspective that perhaps the student has not
seen and stimulate reflection by critical questioning. A facilitative
learning environment requires a close, safe, respectful and
supportive relationship between both parties (Atack et al., 2000;
Billett, 2001; Hughes, 2004; Hays & Clements, 2011). If you are a WPL
educator or have direct involvement with these educators, the
following question may help to stimulate thought on how to develop
more fully this factor required for enabling good WPL.
Reflection point: How can you strengthen your relationship with
students or enhance WPL educators' ability to do so?
2. Effective communication (specifically feedback)
Effective communication is essential to good interpersonal
relationships and therefore effective learning. Facilitating (helping
and guiding) learning is a key role of the WPL educator and as defined
in the CSU WPL Policy (under review). Effective communication, a
two way process where the message is delivered and received
accurately, is essential to facilitate learning.
Feedback is one of the key factors in learning as it provides
correction, guidance, benchmarking and reinforcement. Feedback for
correction however is very different to feedback that enables future
development. Effective feedback for future development is one
where the learner understands the information being given and is
willing to act (Price et al., 2010). The most important aspect of
feedback is that it raises students' awareness of their ability and
"their capacity to reflect" (Cooper et al,, 2010, p. 122). Information
regarding a deficiency in ability must identify gaps, provide advice
and guidance to foster the student's capacity for reflection and future
development (Price et al., 2020).
Students require regular constructive feedback to give them the
greatest chance of success in attaining the educational goals set for
the WPL subject. The Innovative Research Universities (IRU, 2012)
comprises seven comprehensive Australian universities; they have
produced a toolkit containing a number of resources for employers
and industry. The resource - Roles and responsibilities of the
workplace supervisor, identifies that constructive feedback should be:
 individual & pertinent
 directed towards learning goals
 timely & expected
 focused on behaviour that can be modified
 positive & encouraging
 collaborative
 focused on change and free from value judgements
 easy to understand
 respectful
 checking the student's perceptions
 noted in writing, and
 followed up at a later date.
Reflection point: Is feedback considered as both a means for
correction and future development?
3. Motivational ability of WPL educators
The relationship between WPL educators and students, and the
workplace environment will have a direct effect on students’
motivation for learning. The workplace environment is influenced by
staff employed there and the workplace culture or climate.
Personal qualities, experiences, values, belief systems and world
views held by students and WPL educators will impact on their
relationship and therefore students’ motivation for learning (Cooper
et al., 2010). A qualitative study investigating the student-staff
relationship and its impact on learning noted that students very
quickly (usually on the first day) identified those staff members who
exhibited expertise, a willingness to teach, be a mentor and role
model, from those who did not (Atack et al., 2000). The authors note
that on the first day the students' judgements about staff influenced
learning for the remainder of the placement.
A WPL environment will motivate learners if it has a culture of
learning, provides support for learning at an appropriate level and
monitors the learning conditions (Orrell, 2004). Part of this culture for
learning is ensuring that staff workload is such that support and
monitoring of student learning is manageable. Sometimes staff find
students an additional workload while at other times they find them
of assistance (Atack et al., 2000). If staff workload is too high it will
negatively impact on teaching and therefore student learning.
An effective WPL educator will be able to identify barriers to
learning either from characteristics of individuals or the workplace
and try to counter them. A WPL educator who demonstrates expertise
and a passion for what they do as professionals and teachers will
inspire students to achieve their highest ability and create a desire to
work towards excellence.
Reflection point: We may think that the learner is the only one
responsible for their motivation for learning and fail to recognise
the influence educators and the environment have on this
motivation. What are the greatest barriers to motivate learning?
4. Expert role models
Observation is one of the means by which students learn, particularly
in learning how to manage difficult circumstances (Billett, 2001;
Cooper et al., 2010). Role models are those whose behaviours,
attitudes, practices are copied by others therefore expert and
professional role models are required to demonstrate quality practice
(Filstad, 2010). Expertise is readily identified by learners and as a
result they trust that the behaviours and practices exhibited are ones
that they should emulate. On the other hand, negative role models
with poor work quality are identified by students and not emulated
(Atack et al., 2000; Filstad, 2010).
Billett (2001, p. 98 and p. 114) identifies there is a risk with this
indirect form of learning because the observation of the conduct of
work practices may produce undesirable, unintended learning (hidden
curriculum). Such undesirable learning may include unsuitable short
cuts, unsafe work practices, and unprofessional behaviours.
Role models are an important knowledge source especially since
attitudes and values are learned by observation. It is important then,
that those being observed are aware of the effect their behaviour may
have on another's learning and take a reflective stance to modify as
needed. This principle is echoed in the P&PBE Standards. Standard 25:
"Recognise and address the risks inherent in any mal-alignment
between the hidden and planned curricula" and 46: "WPL site-based
staff (in adequate numbers) provide sound role models and
supervision as practitioners of the occupation/profession".
Reflection point: Are all students able to distinguish between good
and bad role models? If not, in what ways are students prepared to
purposefully reflect and distinguish between the diverse role models
they may meet in WPL?
5. Professional judgement and assessment
WPL assessment is identified by Cooper et al., (2010) as one of the
most complex forms of assessment because of the variables
surrounding evaluation of student performance in the workplace.
3
The broad topic of assessment broadly was addressed in WPL in
Curricula: Assessment design. Here I focus on WPL educators'
professional judgement of deep learning.
Cooper et al. (2010, p. 100) argue that a key challenge in WPL
assessment is that it should assess "higher order thinking in practice"
which is demonstrated by evidence-based reasoning that can be
effectively applied in a range of situations. This is the opposite of
surface learning, where the learner has learned what to do in a
specific situation but is not capable of adapting appropriately to a
range of situations. As noted in the introduction of this paper, WPL is
a key learning environment to develop and assess students’ ability to
integrate theory with practice. In other words, learning including
assessment and feedback, should be focused on developing the
students’ understanding of why they are doing something, what the
consequences of the action may be, how to modify it under certain
conditions and how to proceed when something is unknown.
WPL educators must be capable of evaluating the students’ ability
to effectively demonstrate the complexities of practice at different
stages of the course. When judging students’ performances, WPL
educators need to be cognisant of this higher order thinking in
practice. A failure by WPL educators to look for this deeper learning
may inaccurately provide evaluations about students’ performance
and therefore give a false sense of ability. Cooper et al. (2010) point
out that a misunderstanding on the students’ part regarding their
limitations or ability can put the organisation, clients and students at
risk. The credibility of assessment is a crucial point in learning and
WPL educators must make a professional judgement, to determine if
students have demonstrated higher order thinking in practice. Sound
assessment reduces risks to the organisation, client and student.
In a review paper of Australian speech pathologist WPL
assessment, the authors identify a number of factors that aid in
enhancing a more accurate judgement of performance. In this study
McAllister et al. (2010) noted the following as necessary aids:
 global judgements rather than drilling down to checklists help to
promote an holistic approach to evaluation of performance,
 clearly defined assessment documentation that includes
competencies and standards must be provided to guide the WPL
educators' global judgements, and
 the rating of performance has sufficient evidence (quantity and
quality) to support it.
This last point regarding sufficient evidence is crucial to the concept
of higher order thinking in practice. The authors note that
observation of students working in a wide range of situations is
necessary to reduce the impact of case specificity i.e. observing a
single case which may not be representative of the student's overall
performance. The evidence thus needs to include observation in a
range of conditions, over time to ensure sound judgement of ability.
The following P&PBE Standards reflect the points addressed in this
section. (33) Assessment methods promote learning as well as
evaluating the students’ practice. (47) Site-based WPL staff are well
informed about the relevant university curriculum and student
learning/preparation prior to placements. (48) Staff development
programs are available for site-based WPL staff. CSU’s WPL Policy
(under review) also supports this notion of professional development
opportunities for WPL staff.
Reflection point: Is assessment conducted in a manner that
ensures that performance has been observed and recorded over
time and under a range of conditions that are expected for the
stage of the student's development?
Conclusion
WPL educators play a primary role in students’ learning in the
workplace. To effect good WPL, it is necessary in the first instance to
understand what impacts on learning, and this paper has presented
some important factors. WPL educators are key to students’ learning,
particularly integration of theory with practice and the accurate
evaluation of their performance. It is important then that universities
provide support to enable WPL educators to do their role well
(Cooper et al., 2010; Hays & Clements, 2011). Building good
relationships, providing feedback, the impact of behaviour (workplace
and individual) on learning, as well as assessment of higher order
thinking in practice are just some of the areas needed for continuing
professional development.
References
Atack, L., Comacu, M., Kenny, R., LaBelle, N., & Miller, D. (2000). Student and staff
relationships in a clinical practice model: Impact on learning. Journal of Nursing
Education, 39(9), 387-392.
Barrie, S. (2006). Understanding what we mean by the generic attributes of graduates.
Higher Education, 51, 215–241.
Billett, S. (2001). Learning in the Workplace: Strategies for effective practice. Crows Nest
Australia: Allen and Unwin.
Cooper, L., Orrell, J., & Bowden, M. (2010). Work Integrated Learning: A guide to effective
practice. London: Routledge Chapter 6. Supervision pp.124 - 141.
Dewar, B. J., & Walker, E. (1999). Experiential learning: issues for supervision. Journal of
Advanced Nursing, 30(6), 1459-1467.
Filstad, C. (2010). Role models in workplace learning. In Proceedings of the European
Applied Business Research (EABR) and European College of Teaching and Learning (ELTC)
Conferences, 7-10 June, Dublin, Ireland. Retrieved from:
http://www.cluteinstitute.com/proceedings/2010_Dublin_EABR_Article20428.pdf
Hays, J., & Clements, M. (2011). Supervision in work experience for learning programs.
Proceedings of Historic global challenges, the 17th World Conference on Cooperative
and Work-Integrated Education (WACE), Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States, 1417 June. Retrieved from:
http://researchbank.swinburne.edu.au/vital/access/manager/Repository/swin:22547?letter=Vakulik%2
C+J.&f0=subject%3A%22Higher+education%22
Hughes, C. (2004). The supervisor's influence on workplace learning. Studies in Continuing
Education, 26(2), 276 - 287.
Innovative Research Universities (IRU), (2012). Roles and responsibilities of the workplace
supervisor. Retrieved from:
http://www.iru.edu.au/our-activities/projects/work-integrated-learning-2012-toolkit-for-industry.aspx
Lester, S., & Costley, C. (2010). Work-based learning at higher education level: value,
practice and critique. Studies in Higher Education, 35(5), 561–575.
Litchfield, A., Frawley, J., & Nettleton, S. (2010). Contextualising and integrating into the
curriculum the learning and teaching of work-ready professional graduate attributes.
Higher Education Research & Development, 29(5), 519–534.
Martin, A., Rees, M., & Edwards, M. (2011). Work Integrated Learning A Template for
Good Practice: Supervisors’ Reflections. Palmerston, NZ: Ako Aotearoa (National Centre
for Tertiary Teaching Excellence). Retrieved from:
http://akoaotearoa.ac.nz/download/ng/file/group-6/work-integrated-learning---a-template-for-goodpractice---supervisors-reflections.pdf
McAllister, S., Lincoln, M., Ferguson, A., & McAllister, L. (2010). Issues in developing valid
assessments of speech pathology students’ performance in the workplace. International
Journal of Language & Communication Disorders, 45(1), 1-10.
Orrell, J. (2004). Work-integrated learning programmes: Management and educational
quality proceedings of the Australian universities quality forum Adelaide Australia 7-9
June. Retrieved from: www.auqa.edu.au/files/publications/auqf2004_proceedings.pdf
Price, M., Handley, K., Millar, J., & O'Donovan, B. (2010). Feedback: all that effort, but
what is the effect? Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 35(3), 277-289.
Vermeulen, L., & Schmidt, H.G. (2008). Learning environment, learning process, academic
outcomes and career success of university graduates. Studies in Higher Education, 33(4),
431-451.
List of references from Table 1
Arends, R. I. (2001). Learning to teach. Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill.
Hativa, N., Barak, R.& Simhi. E. (2001). Exemplary university teachers: Knowledge and
beliefs regarding effective teaching dimensions and strategies. Journal of Higher
Education 72(6), 699-729.
Kember, D. (2004). Interpreting student workload and the factors which shape students’
perception of their workload. Studies in Higher Education 29(2), 165-84.
Elliott, S. Kratochwill, T., Littlefield, J., & Travers, J. (1996). Educational psychology:
Effective teaching, effective learning. Madison, WI: Brown & Benchmark.
Schunk, D. H. (1996). Learning theories: An educational perspective. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
Newmann, F. M. (1993). Beyond common sense in educational restructuring: The issues of
content and linkage. Educational Researcher 22(20), 4-13.
Mackenzie, D. E. (1983). Research for school improvement: An appraisal of some recent
trends. Educational Researcher 12(4), 5-17.
Pike, G. R., & Killian, T. S.. (2001). Reported gains in student learning: Do academic
disciplines make a difference? Research in Higher Education 42(4), 429-44.
Umbach, P. D., & Wawrzynski, M. R. (2005). Faculty do matter: the role of college faculty
in student learning and engagement. Research in Higher Education 46(2), 153-84.
Walberg, H. J. (1981). A psychological theory of educational productivity. In Psychology
and education, ed. F. Farley and N. Grodon. Berkeley, CA: McCutchan.
Kuh, G. D., Schuh, J. H., Whitt, E. J. and Associates, Inc. staff. (1991). Involving colleges.
San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Links
i
ii
http://csusap.csu.edu.au/~areport/documents/2011_PPBE_Standards.pdf
http://csusap.csu.edu.au/~areport/documents/EFPI%20OP2%20WPL%20Curricula.pdf
http://csusap.csu.edu.au/~areport/documents/EFPI%20OP3%20WPL%20Assessment.pdf
iii
4