JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH, VOL. 89, NO. C1, PAGES 637-640, JANUARY 20, 1984 Winter Mixed Layer Entrainment of Weddell Deep Water A. L. GORDON Lamont-DohertyGeolo•7ical Observatoryof ColumbiaUniversity C. T. A. ellEN Ore,ton State University W. G. METCALF Lamont-DohertyGeolo•ticalObservatoryof ColumbiaUniversity Observationsfrom the Somovduring the US-USSR Weddell Polynya expeditionshow that the mixed layer below the sea ice just prior to the austral spring retreat in the 60øSGreenwich meridian region has an oxygen content of 7.4 ml/1. This is 86% of full oxygen saturation, representingan oxygen deficit, relative to full saturation, of 1.1 ml/l. The source of this deficit is believed to be a consequenceof oxygen-poor(4.5 ml/1) Weddell Deep Water (WDW) entrainment by the winter mixed layer. Assuming effectivecutoff of ocean-atmosphere oxygenexchangeby the nearly completesnow and seaice cover with no net impact of oxygen content as a result of biological factors, a mixing ratio of 1:3 for WDW to "beginningof winter" surfacewater is requiredto explain the end-of-wintermixed-layeroxygencontent. Accompanying theWDW transferinto themixedlayeris heattransferof approximately 7 x 103 cal/cm'• (2.9 x 108J/m2) duringthe fivewintermonthsof seaicecoverage as wellas salttransfer,whichrequires 34 cm of fresh water to produce typical mixed-layer salinity. During the sevenice-free months when entrainmentis expectedto be minor, diffusiveheat and salt flux continues.A mean annual heat flux of 12 W/m2 is suggested, with an annual demandfor freshwaterof 46 cm/yr. Considerationof the winter period salinity budget indicates net sea ice melting of 20 cm, which can be attributed to regional convergenceof sea ice. The remaining freshwateris derived from excessprecipitation and possibly icebergmelt. Oxygenundersaturation of the winter surfacewater suggests slightlylesspotentialfor abyssalwaterventilationthanmightbeexpected froma fullysaturatedcondition. 1. warmer and occur over anomalouslywarm WDW cells INTRODUCTION The joint US-USSRWeddellPolynyaexpeditionaboard the Sovietship Mikhail Sotnovof the Arctic-AntarcticResearchInstituteof Leningrad[GordonandSarukhanyan, 1982; Gordon,1982] permitted,for the first time, detailedobservationsbelowthe SouthernOceanseaice for investigationof the cumulative winter effects. The CTD (conductivity, temper- [Gordonand Huber,this issue].The slightbut meaningful temperature excess relativeto thefreezing pointis believed to be a consequence of introductionof WDW heat into the mixed layer. Summerstratificationdiffersprimarilyby the presenceof a seasonally warmedandslightlyfreshersurface layeroverlying the remnant of the winter mixed layer marked by a temper- ature,depth)hydrographic stations[Huberet al., 1983]were taken in nearlyfull ice coverconditions[Ackleyand Smith, ature minimum [Toole, 1981; Gordonand Molinelli, 1982, of vertical sections andplates196-199].Comparison of 1983]in the vicinityof 60øS,just eastof the Greenwichmeri- plates Sotnovstation21 [Huberet al., 1983] with the summerIslas dian (seestationmap and hydrographic sectionsin Gordon Orcadasstation102 [Huber et al., 1981]--the stationsbeing and Huber [this issue]). separated by 64 km (Sotnov station21 wasobtainedon NoIn this study we presentevidenceof significantwinter vember3, 1981,at 62ø20'Sand 3ø07'E;the Islas Orcadasstaperiodtransfer of deepwaterto thesurface watermixedlayer tion 102 was obtainedFebruary 2, 1977, at 62ø02'Sand and estimatethe associated rate of upwardheat and saltflux. 4ø10'E)--shows the summertemperature minimumto be 2. about 0.5øCwarmer,with little salinitychangerelativeto the WINTER VERSUS SUMMER STRATIFICATION wintermixed-layer base.Abovethetemperature minimum,the seasonally warmedsurfacewater represents storageof 2.4 two-layerstructureof a homogeneous cold, relativelyfresh, x 104cal/cm 2 (1.0x 109 J/m2)relativeto thefreezing point. The thermohaline stratification below the sea ice is a simple mixed layer separatedfrom the nearly homogeneouswarmer, more saline,Weddell Deep Water (WDW) with an abrupt but weak pycnocline(Gordonand Huber [this issue]; Figure 1). The mixed layer variesin thicknessfrom 50 to 135 m, averaging 108 m, with a meantemperatureand salinityof -1.844øC and 34.287%0, respectively, whichis 0.035øCabovethe freezing point at 1 atm. The thinner mixed layers are somewhat Copyright 1984by the American GeophysicalUnion. Paper number 3C 1478. 0148-0227/84/003 C- 1478505.00 637 The Islas Orcadassummerwater salinity is lower than the Sotnov station21 by 0.063%0,whichrequiresstorageof 20 cm of freshwaterrelative to the winter mixed layer. Two other Sotnov-IslasOrcadas station pairs, composedof stations within 100 km of each other (9-101; 2-99), indicate the same heatstorage asthe21-192pair,but somewhat different freshwaterstorage(16 and37 cm,respectively). Seasonal freshwater storage in therangeof 16to 37cmseems smallin viewof the approximately 1 m of seaiceandsnowcovercharacteristic of theregionasobserved fromSotnov [Ackleyet al., 1982]prior to the springmelt.A possible solutionis that someof the s13ring seaicemelt,ratherthandilutingresident surface water, 638 GORDONET AL.' MIXED-LAYERENTRAINMENT IN WEDDELLWATER PotentialTemperature(øC) -2.0 i -I.0 0.0 1.0 i i i 30 ,. 40 ß 50 ; 2.0 i Oxygen(ml/I) 20 ß 60 ß 7,0 •+ 80 ß 90 . + ml/1 lower than our measuredvalue, while the temperature and salinityare only 0.01øCand 0.07 %0higher,respectively. The excellentagreementin oxygenconcentrationcollectedin different seasonsagain suggestsa low rate of oxygenproduction and consumption.Additionally, Somovoxygen,pH, calcium, alkalinity, total CO2, nitrate, phosphate,and silica concentrationsand the GEOSECS station 89 oxygen,alka- linity,total CO2,nutrients, and •3C values(Chen[1982];also, seedata listingsof Huber et al. [1983]) all correlatelinearly g o with salinity from surface down to the WDW core, which againindicatesthat the distributionof thesechemicalproper- 300 400 -+ - - tiesin the upperwater columnbelowthe ice is predominantly controlled by conservativemixing processeswith little productionor utilization of chemicals[Weiss et al., 1979;Edmond - et al., 1979; Minas, 1980]. 3. The assumptionregardingthe mixed layer prior to the 500•4.1 •4.• I •4.5•4.7, icecoverperiodis straightforward, sinceoxygenequilibriumis Salinity (%o) Fig. 1. Potential temperature,salinity, and oxygen stratification at Somov station 22 at 62ø12'S, lø05'E on November 5, 1981. The thermohaline data are derived from the CTD system.The oxygen data are from titration of water samples obtained from a rosette system.There was a 100% ice cover with few leads [Ackley and Smith, 1982]. The hydrographicdata are reportedby Huber et al. [1983]. mixes with the saline WDW that is diffused into the mixed layer during the springmelting period (as discussedbelow). 3. MIXED LAVER OXYGEN The oxygencontent of the entire mixed layer below the sea ice averages7.40 (with a +0.1 ml/1 distribution about the mean) or 86% of saturation (Figure 2). This is about 1.1 ml/1 below the full saturation value and is similar to the oxygen levels of' the summer period temperature minimum (Gordon and MolineIll [1982], seetemperature-oxygenrelation for the vertical sections,plates 109 and 195). The WDW saturation levelsare seasonallyinvariant near 57% to 60% of full oxygen expectedduring the cooling period prior to the ice cover formation. Possibly some entrainment might occur before ice formation,and the resultingwater doesnot equilibrate;however, this is reflected in the total entrainment determined below. 4. RATES OF DEEP TO SURFACEWATER HEAT FLUX The potentialtemperatureversusoxygenrelationships for all Somovdata points(Figure 3a) can be usedto determinethe ratio of WDW to the surfacewatercharacteristic of theperiod immediately prior to winterice formation.A one-partWDW (0.5øCand 4.50 ml/1)to three parts surfacewater (-1.87øC and 8.54 ml/1) blend is required to produce the observed OxygenSaturation(%) 50 6O 70 saturation. The origin of the mixed-layer oxygen undersaturation is likely due to entrainmentof oxygen-poorWDW by the winter mixed layer. The oxygencontentcan be usedto determinethe amount of entrained WDW if we assume'(1) oxygenexchange between ocean and atmosphereis effectivelyblocked by the presenceof a more or lesscomplete (greater than 90%) snow and seaice cover,(2) the net biologicalproductionand utilization of oxygen below the sea ice is zero, and (3) the mixed layer immediatelyprior to the ice cover is at the fleezingpoint and at full oxygen saturation of 8.54 ml/1. Support for these assumptionsis offeredbelow. 1. The sea ice collectedin the study region is dominated by frazil ice structure [Ackley et al., 1983] with few brine channels. Thus the gas permeability is expected to be low [Weiss et al., 1979; Chen, 1982]. The depletion in oxygen is probably not due to rapid oxidation of organic matter after the pack ice is formed becausethe surfacewater oxygen consumption rate is not large enoughto generatea 14% oxygen undersaturation within a period of months [Packard et al., 1971' Skopintsev,1976; Knauer et al., 1979]. 2. The bacterial and biological activities are also low at the time of observation[Marta et al., 1982], suggestinga low rate of oxygenproduction and consumption.The oxygenconcentration in the remnant winter water at GEOSECS station 89 (60ø01'S, 0ø01'E, January 22, 1973; Bainbridge [1981]), which is lessthan 35 km from Somovstation 33, is only 0.02 90 8O I00 .,j.Mixed Layer ß ßß I00 %' ß Pycnocline ß ß '1' ß ß 200 3OO 'i Deep Water ß ß 400 ßßß õoo Fig. 2. Oxygen saturationfrom all rosettesamplesobtainedby Sotnov. The saturationis determinedby usingthe equationgivenin the UNESCOInternationalOceanographic Tables[1973]. GORDONET AL.' MIXED-LAYERENTRAINMENT IN WEDDELLWATER IO trainment must balancethe,annual Ekman-inducedupw•elling of the pycnocline.The abovecalculationsuggests an effective WDW entrainmentof 27 m into the mixed layer during the winter-ice-coveredperiod. This agrees quite well with the I 1i i i i i i _ 639 ß AI•, 1Warm WDW Cells annual averageupwellingrate of 1 x 10-'• cm/s (31 m/yr) Cold WDW determinedfrom Ekman pumpingcalculationsby usinga climaticallyaveragedwind field for the regionof the Sotnovdata [Gordon et al., 1977]. The annual average heat flux from WDW to the mixed layer of 9-16 W/me is somewhatbelowthe annualocean-toatmosphereheat flux calculatedfrom meteorologicalparame-2..0 .'3470 - / \ ters.Zillman[1972] calculates a heatlossof 18 W/m2 at 60øS C'water south of Australia (Zillman's Figure 3); while Gordon[1981] _ finds 31 W/m2 averagefor the 60ø-70øScircumpolarbelt. WDW •, ß 34.60 _ However, it is noted that the Sotnovresults pertain to the 59ø-62øSregion and would be expectedto be lower than the 60ø-70øSaverage but somewhat above the Zillman value becausethe Weddell pycnoclineis weaker than the circumpolar AABW ß ß average [MartinsOn etal.,1981]. In viewoftheuncertainty in _ ..• 34.5o •., the diffusive heat flux determined during the ice-free period and the differencein the type of calculation, agreementis reasonablygood. _ _ 'E ._ 5. or) 34.40- _ ß 34.30- _ .•,. Surface _ Water ßß ß• ß ' ' ' ' 9.0 Dissolved Oxygen (ml/I) Fig. 3. Potential temperatureversusoxygencontent(a) and salinity versusoxygen content (b) from all rosette samplesobtained by Sotnov.WDW is Weddell Deep Water and AABW is Antarctic Bottom Water. The two linear mixing lines AB and A'B are marked with percentof A water type (WDW) relative to B water type. Point D is the freezing temperature extension of the line fit to the temperature-oxygentrend of deepand bottom water colder than 0øC. mixed-layeroxygenof 7.4 ml/1(line AB on Figure 3a). However, the temperatureof this mixture would be 0.63øC above the freezingpoint. For the averagemixed-layerthicknessof 108 m the heat accompanyingthe upward transferof WDW is RATE OF DEEP TO SURFACE WATER SALT FLUX The salt introduction to the surfacewater mixed layer by the effectiveentrainment of 27 m of WDW during the five winter ice cover months requiresfreshwaterinput of 34 cm to reducethe WDW salinity (34.680%0)to the annual mean surface water salinity (34.250%0,representinga 7:5 blend of the 34.224%0average summer salinity from lslas Orcadas data with 34.287%0winter salinity from the Sotnovdata). During the ice-freeperiod, salt diffusionacrossthe pycnoclinewould place additional requirements for compensatingfreshwater input.UsingK: of 0.1 and 1.0cm2/sintroduces 0.078to 0.78 gm of salt per centimetersquared,respectively,into the surface water over 7 months, requiring a freshwaterinput of 2.3 to 23 cm to producethe annualmean surfacewater salinity. Thus the annual freshwater input required to balance the total WDW salt flux into the surfacelayer is 36 to 57 cm/yr. A value of 46 cm/yr would correspondto the 12 W/m2 best guess (K: of 0.5cm2/s). Estimates of annual freshwater flux into the 60ø-70øS belt by excess precipitation over evaporation and continental 6.66x 103 cal/cm• (2.78x 108J/me).If the warmWDW cells runoff (glacial ice meltwater) are as high as 40 cm/yr [Gordon, [Gordon and Huber, this issue] are responsiblefor the re- 1981]. However, the mean snow cover on the sea ice was only gionally depressedmixed-layeroxygen,the heat transfer is 20 cm [Ackley et al., 1982], which translatesto only 2-6 cm of slightlyincreased (seeline A'B on Figure3a) to 7.93x 103 water, thus a value of 40 cm/yr may be an overestimate.Adcal/cm:(3.31x 108J/me).Thusthe averageheatflux during ditional freshwater input could be derived if there is a net the 5-monthice-coveredperiod [Gordonand Huber, this issue] advectionof seaice into the region. Support for this suggestionis derived by consideringthe is 20 to 25 W/m :. If the verticalheat transferacrossthe pycnocline is taken as zero for the 7-month ice-free period, the approximate salinity balance for the five ice-coveredmonths. A 1:3 mix of WDW to the surfacewater just prior to the ice average annualheatfluxis 9 to 11W/me. While entrainment of WDW would cease with the onset of cover would result in an end-of-wintersalinity of 34.338%0.To the seasonalpycnocline,some diffusive heat flux is expected reduce the salinity to the observedaverage of 34.287%0reduring the ice-freepart of the year. A vertical mixing coef- quires 20 cm of sea ice (with a salinity of 5%0,Ackley et al., ficientK: of 0.1 cm:/s wouldaccomplish a cross-pycnocline[1982]). A meteoric source of water is unlikely during the heatfluxduringthe 7-monthice-freeperiodof 1 W/me; a K: winter since the snow on the ice is of unity yields10 W/m:. Therefore,the total deepto surface into the oceanuntil the springmelt. water heat flux (ice cover plus ice free periods)may be in the rangeof 9-16 W/me. A valueof 12 W/me is suggested for a workingvalue,reflecting a K: of 0.5cm:/s. How realistic is the winter period entrainment value and heat flux? For an annual steadystate the rate of winter en- not available for release Melting would be encouragedby the heat flux discussed above; the mixed-layer temperature slightly above freezing may be a direct evidenceof this process.Sea ice melting of 20 cm requiresabout 20% of the winter heat flux, the rest would be lost to the atmospherein leads and thin ice. It is probable 640 GORDON ETAL.:MIXED-LAYER ENTRAINMENT IN WEDDELL WATER that much of the ice melting occursin October, when the ocean heat flux into the atmosphereis reduced from the winter maximum•[Gordon,1981], but the entrainmentof Ackley,S. F., D. B. Clarke, and S. J. Smith,Reportsof the Weddell PolynyaExpeditionof October-November 1981: vol. 4, Physical, Chemical andBiologicalProperties of Ice Cores,U.S. Army Corps WDW (whichis dueprimarilyto icemovement relativeto the Bainbridge, A. E., GEOSECSAtlanticExpedition, v. 1, Hydrographic ocean; Gordon and Huber [this issue]) continues. The dynamic-thermodyanmic model ofHiblerandAckley [1983, Eng. Cold Reg. Res.Eng. Lab., Hanover, N.H., 1983. Data 1972-1973, 121 pp., National ScienceFoundation, Washington, D.C., 1981. Chen,•C.T. A., On the distributionof anthropogenic CO2 in the AtlanticandSouthern oceans, Deep-Sea Res.,29,563,1982. Edmond,J. M., S.S.Jacobs, A. L. Gordon,A• W. Mantyla,andR. F. melting in the north. The above calculations favor the net Weiss,Water columnanomaliesin dissolvedsilica over opaline meltingvalue.Net meltinghastheeffectof transporting freshpelagicsedimentsand the origin of the deep silicamaximum,0r. Geophys.Res.,84, 7809-7826, 1979. water into the area, even in the presenceof Ekman diverGordon,A. L., Seasonality of SouthernOceanseaice, d. Geophys. gences. Figure 8] suggests a net ice advectionwithin the Sornovregion of +10 cm of accumulation in the south to 25 cm of net Res., 86, 4193-4197, 1981. Assumingthere is no heat conductionthrough the sea ice and that leads make up 5% of the area, the averagewinter Gordon,A. L., The US-USSR WeddellPolynyaExpedition,Antarct. heatlossin theleadsamountsto about350W/m2.Thisvalue Gordon, A. L., and B. A. Huber, Thermohaline stratification below is similar to estimatesfor' Arctic Ocean heat loss within leads [Maykut, 1978]. It is noted that leads, though effectivein removingheat,and perhapsfreshwater,by evaporation,would not be effectivein enhancingoxygen exchangeor freshwater input by precipitation. 5. DISCUSSION The potential temperature-oxygen scatter(Figure 3a) shows that for all conservative linear mixtures of WDW end mem- bers with a freezingpoint, surfacewater end membersrequire the surfacewater to have oxygen saturation as low or lower than that observed from SOreGr. Conservative behavior for oxygen in the Southern Ocean is suggestedby Weiss et al. [1979-] and Edmondet al. [1979-], so it is not likely this relationshipis due to in situ oxygenconsumption.Deep water colder than 0øC possesses a slightly steeperslope,indicating that the Antarctic bottom water (AABW) requiresa freezing point surface water component with oxygen of 6.8 ml/1 or 80% saturatio•n(point D, Figure 3a), suggesting that a 35% contributionfrom WDW might be more appropriatefor regionsfurther polewardof the Somovregion. The salinity-oxygen(S/O2) distribution(Figure 3b) shows that the mixed-layerpointshavea negativeslopesuchthat the mixed-layer water with higher salinity has slightly lower oxygen.This relationis expectedfrom the WDW origin of the reducedmixed-layeroxygen. Calculations of the oxygen consumption rate have frequently been made with the use of the measuredapparent oxygenutilizhtion (AOU) value and the estimatedage of the water [Jenkins,1980]. A hidden assumptionin the calculation d. U.S., 17, 1982. • the SouthernOceanseaice,J. Geophys. Res.,thisissue. Gordon, A. L., and E. M. Molinelli, SouthernOceanAtlas: Thermoha- line ChemicalDistributions and the Atlas Data Set, 11 pp., 233 plates,Columbia University Press,New York, 1982. Gordon, A. L., and E. I. Sarukhanyan,American and Soviet Expedition into the Southern Ocean sea ice in October and November 1981, EOS Trans. AGU, 63, 2, 1982. Gordon, A. L., H. W. Taylor, and D. T. Georgi, Antarcticoceano- graphiczonation,in Polar Oceans, editedby E. Dunbar,pp. 45-76, Arctic Institute of North America, 1977. Hibler, III, W. D., and S. F. Ackley, Numerical simulationof the Weddellseapack ice,J. Geophys. Res.,88, 2873-2887, 1983. Huber, B., S. Rennie,D. Georgi,S. Jacobs,and A. Gordon, ARA Islas OrcadasData Reports, Cruise 12, Ref CU-2-81-TR2, LamontDoherty Geol. Observ.,Palisades,N.Y., 1981. Huber, B. A., J. Jennings,C.-T, Chen, J. Marra, S. Rennie,P. Mele, and A. Gordon, Reportsof the US-USSR Weddell Polynya Expedition, vol. 2, HydrographicdaIa, 115 pp., L-DGO-83-1, U.S. Army Corps Eng.ColdReg. Res. L•D.,Hanover, N.H.,1983. Jenkins,W. J.,Tritiumand 3Hein the Sargasso Sea,J. Mar. Res.,38, 533-569, 1980. Knauer, G. A., J. H. Martin, and K. W. Bruland,Fluxesof particulate carbon,nitrogen,and phosphorusin the upperwater columnof the northeast Pacific,Deep-Sea Res.,26A,97-108,1979. Marra, J., L. H. Burckle, and H. W. Ducklow, Sea ice and water column plankton distributions in the Weddell Sea in late winter, Antarct. J. U.S., 17(5), 111-112, 1982. Martinson, D. G.,P.D. Killworth, and•. L. Gordon, A convective model for the Weddell Polynya,J. Phys. Oceano•7r., 11, 466-488, 1981. Maykut, G. A., Energy exchangeover young sea ice in the Central Arctic,J. Geophys.Res.,83, 3646-3658, 1978. Minas, H. J., Production Primaire et Secondaire,Colloque FrancoSovietique,Publ. 10, pp. 21-36, CNEXO (Actes du Colloque), Paris, 1980. Packard, T. T., M. L. Healy, and F. A. Richards,Vertical distribution of the activity of the respiratoryelectron transport systemin is that the AOU is near zero when the water was last at the marine plankton, Limnol.Oceano•7r., 16, 60-70, 1971. surface.Obviously, this assumptionneedsto be modified for Skopintsev,B. A., Oxygen consumptionin the deep watersof the ocean,Oceanology, 15, 556-561, 1976. AABW or any water that has a componentof the winter Toole, J. M., Sea ice, winter convection,and the temperatureminiAntarcticsurfacewater. Similarly,cautionmust be exercised mum layer in the SouthernOcean,J. Geophys.Res.,86, 8037-8047, when one calculatesthe age of water or the oceaniccirculation 1981. Tables,vol. 2, 141 pp., Paris, ratesby usingAOU and the independently estimatedoxygen UNESCO, InternationalOceanographic 1973. consumption rate. Weiss,R. F., H. G. Ostlund,and H. Craig, Geochemicalstudiesof the Weddell Sea,Deep-SeaRes.,26, 1093-1120, 1979. Acknowled#ments. Fu6dingfor the US-USSRWeddellPolynya Expeditionwas receivedfrom the Divisionof Polar Programsof the Zillman, J. W., Solar radiation and sea-air interaction south of Australia, in Ahtarctic Oceanology1, The Australian-NewZealand National ScienceFoundation, grant DPP 80-05765for the physical Sector, vol. 19,editedby D. E. Hayes,pp. 11-40,AGU, Washoceanography, and from the Departmentof Energyfor the geochemington,D.C., 1972. istrysupportof Chen81 EV 10611.Commentsfrom HsienWang Ou, Bruce Huber, and John Marra are appreciated.Lamont-Doherty C. T. A. Chen,Oregon StateUniversity,Corvallis,OR 97331. GeologicalObservatorycontribution3549. A. L. Gordon and W. G. Metcalf, Lamont-DohertyGeological REFERENCES Observatoryof ColumbiaUniversity,Palisades,NY 10964. Ackley,S. F., and S. J. Smith,Reportsof the US-USSR Weddell Polynya Expedition of October-November 1981: Vol. 5, Sea Ice Conditions,SR 83-2, U.S. Army Corps Eng. Cold Reg. Res.Eng. Lab., Hanover, N.H., 1983. (ReceivedApril 28, 1983; revisedAugust 25, 1983; acceptedSeptember8, 1983.)
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz