ecity2-2009-moral-ethics.pdf

 305(09127461644)
OM /;
JA, JA, `a 'A1= :; #
[email protected]
6@N w ƒ& ,7% 1x 16&34 ;%%P ; X% 16&34 AB %0F 9 : C62E %E& 1? 9 ,@E
1@E 7 ; ;EN& 7 E=w: 7 E74 .B 8'9 : # c BB 44 7 A’# ,< ;E76B
.%& )2# 8'9 ;70 ;EP 1@P 60 ;1& &<
=w& ; ,NP .B x A% 8@6P '/ ; # 1 ,<  ^K ;E4s7 7 E’ E’3P
08 W 7 G0P QQF N0 7 %062E ‡6: 1’7 08 ; ,NP 7 0 B /7 ,NP ;Q
64 X7 B E$# =/ 1R 1x ;6 7 “0 ;EN 7 Cx> A G" B 7I6 Q%w %0@'K 1@E CN 7 %0@ 7 %00E 7 DB0 6 7 K 6&% "/ .%& %EK  7 /7 ;
,JJ*6 ”< O7? !9 k'K 62F ;62P 1 1 3 .x %EK WF F , c
.C62E M76 N& ;
" a ? ;# , ,: L%E _# 16& .; ; ,@6I4 'K E ; ;E=: k'K
“8 10 N 7 %0? M@? %B 7 %I 'K –2F ; ; 'K BB
F
,< ;7 : 624 A6B 7 ; ; O624 ;% 1?  I6B # @B 1 /
The Second Conference on Electronic City
HI J1
E G
1 1@E %6 .%& L/ %& 16*242 2
Ei 76 ; ; ;EE ^*& 7
;E6 1? %? Q & 7 %02" ;
,08 1 60
7 A CE 7 %" Q6I4 1 Q% %&
k'K 8 _# .7< A 1 K ;%02"
K ^K ;E? ; ’E .%34
%" CE ;1 8'9 7 k'K < 10 "R 7 >
> k'K . ; ;EN& =V ; ;E=w:
!I6 1`2 ;7 1@E K• 7 .%& e %00?
@E .B 1 J#0 ;08 ; 8'9 ;70
%00? I6B ;g0 1? %062E E,2 1? %%&
“? 9 1 ;1& ;E$# B ; 1NP
.%00? 'K 7 8 k'K % CE N< 0
16& ,< =H2 1 J6K N’P 1? B X
;1
1 / ; ;E=w: 7 ; ; O624
.C62E NI —K M F '/ 1NP .C&
JK C> k'K ,% 1? W" 1`2 @B
=> ; N< C?> A 7 6“0B ’a P CEI
7 k'K =: .? A60? ,< % 0 %0? %%N .%062 ? %& ,< DP 8'9 ;70 1? 'K ':
%7 CE 7 ,? ; CE ;1+%+ 1 'K
=? ; 1 ,%B = % ': = =
“ > ;
1? # 12 2? ’ . %& =% ,??
! 1? C0? 1H ;? 7 F 8'9 ;70
% 1F ; ; 'K 6 1 E =& =8
.%& ,K l0E P 'K 7 Q0E “ 0
1 % WE 4s7 1B7 1 660 ; K < 7 –%&
1439
\,+ # ^ 16 O624 % /7 7 56: =J
K 'K =H2 1? %062E ;Ni ;70 E1
1 : = 7 ?> NP 18 7 E ;E16 C6
M76 N& k'K _# 1? I4 , ˜% 7< P7 1
; 62E 7 62F ;1 ; ;1I2 .C ?
A/ 7 B 1 ;70 8@6P ( 7 ’E =# S7 %%P 7 16&34 E , ;EWF % 1F4 ;
;70 0F 'K I6B ; EBB 1P 7 7%
;7 M > P7 X%8 ˜B 1B7 # 1 1? C ? 1 ;1 ;70 8 7 .B
7 :" ; 10 1/P († 7 Q" z“*:
;E1+%+ 0m@E 7 N< 1 c ;70 E1 =& SB7
!0 7 ,% ’E ;4B S 1? ;# 1 6> 7 9 ;E1& 7 E
*B 7 E
X 1 c
.B 7< P7 1 %& 1 ;E
0F 'K I6B 1?< .& E1 K
;" 7 ˜ P7 : $K 7 BB —K ;70
\,+ ]B A$P[# 1 , 1@P ,< 1? B 7< P7 1 k'K H2
,< S 1 ; ; k'K ; _# ;1R
.? & ... 7 M76%7N& k'K 8'9 ;70 k'K
@EI .%E =& ,< 1 1? B @EI -; ;EN&
CE ;%%P 7 ’ E1 Q 8 1
; 7I6 E4s7 ; ; < –2F k'K ,F
1? .B =@8 %%P ;E)*6 1? %7<
"'? k'K 1? & _8 B H2 – /7
10 1 7 P7 0&7 : $K 7 BB 1 ?3 1? ;? k'K .& -/ /7 ; 7I6
k'K B .%0B a 1 ? P ;E: $K
;EO V> 1 7 B k'K ;1I2 16& ;E18@
7% ,F ; % 1? B ;
F / ,6 7 ,4%0E 1 7 " E,2 6 @8
1?C& 16& a K ;E’’/ %E ; : $K
.[1]%< @: _#
S“ . %EK 8@6P 7 ; =H2 K =& )2> N0 1 ; ; 1 77 1? & 1’P % 1@E 8@6P ;EBB 7 ; a>' =& k'K
J#0 7 %%P k'K 1 34 ( E,2 ’ 7 6
.& 4 I6B ;70 ;4 ? 1 1?
C> ’ %0 CEI K .B 7< P7 1 ; 1
%m" 7 " ;E10 %4 0m@E jh .B 16 ;7%> BB ;E;< % JK
$K 7 CEI 7 !> $7 1? B !# 7 1/ ;
B 7< P7 1 k'K ;E18 EWF =8 E1 ;70 @H 64 a EO 7 E:
; ; ;E18 < ;E, 7 ;< = 1
2 ( %8 ;18@ k'K j .4 /7 ; %0@E ,& %& 163" l0E fB
1 .
7 7 Q< 7 %0? CB ,< ; 1?
14 qE ,?  ˜% 7< P7 1 E’7%#
.%0? , ;EO 7 1 ;70 E = 1 7
8'9 ; ; .%34@ ;P 1 K " 1627 8 1 7 B k'K 7 C8 ;16& 16& %0FE
P7 E1m "'V) %& P E,2 JK 7 *
1? B @a0 ;18@ OK %> ’ BN< ;7 E 1
(%0:K %7 %00? f2> %062E 1K ~K 1<
;70 I6B ; CE 7 %0? ;B XNI CN ; CE
+ =V@ E1B % 1 ˜B F 1@E <
. [3]" : $K 7 CEI 1 ;E1
.[2]%062E ; ,9'
1 7 8'9 0+ 1/P !# ; k D 1 1P C62B ƒ %0 NP 18 %6 ;1/P ,< A
CN ,K 1x 9 ,@E .C62E %6 8'9 ;70 %
2
3
netizen
policy
1
privacy
1440
The Second Conference on Electronic City
CAI "K& -?E $
; k'K 62F 6 ; l
GR %8 1
1 %& 7 ;1*6? & 7 1/ ,@ ;
7 A> F 1@E 62E ,NP ,F & ™ )2#
.B A#
2P ?& 7 ,% EaNi EQ6I4 , ,< %
W
)6& .%& %%P D % 10Nx 8'9 3
7 N ;E 7 " ,< 62F 1 2P EGI0? 7
7 - 1x B %& %0 6& 8'9 1/P 8'9
. ,< :"
x> 1/P + .% ,< ;%0x
> D ,P 4 , K 1 l
GR ;E16I4
. %EK 7 62
1? E/ j 1? 0/ % .B ; ; k'K
@ 7 %& ,44 Š% 1 4% ƒB 1/P ;%m" =H2 7 _> 4 1H 60 1& D x> 1 8'9 1/P .%0x BB .4 %062 5 = “6> 1 1?
7 16K0& ,NP % @8 1:% ƒ@x 1 ,2 1x %0x
DB0 ;E 1 B /B @2 D? => K 1? C jh B 7 !#
=H2 ," ;EQ6I4 7 %E: =’ 7 1: ;EE
.B 'K
WE7s" 7 L%E :" NP DB0 &7 3K ;
:? 1’P 16 1B 1 2* 62
The Second Conference on Electronic City
8'9 1/P ,K 8'9 B ,2 > J08 7 SB7 1a# E 44 7 K0& 7 %0x ,44
.& SB
'/ 7 $7 K ;R x 8'9 ;EC62B
7 =H2 K & 7 x %6B 1/P ,7 7 ,7
1H X7
S 7 x 0 W" 1/P ,44 I“
1/P ƒ =x 7 SP ;E=> P7 .%00x™ => a 62 _# ;10 4624 1 1’P 10 A’7
1/P ;%0@ 7 6KB =/ 7 ;Q 1P 1@E 4s7 1x
1F B :" 7 “ A> 8B 1 > 1? &
XQ0E 1/P @8 7 6% ;E7 B K
( .8@6P 7 ;J6 7 BB g0 €#
P7 1 7 x ;@0E Ex 7 E1 X 7 ;B "
;’%P _# ,< 6@? A> 1 1? 7 B 8h
.%0x ;4P @6> z ,%<
_# O7 14 E 3K 1? N 7 B 164 NP 7 _# ’ ,? %" %& 16I4 1m< 1 1P
’ !# L%E 7 R†B ;B &< 7 dh %0 ?3
=> SP ^JK 1? N B M .B %B 7 %I
.[4] %EK
10 %0< _> 7 :" _8 B e ':
? ? 1 j7& T|{Z 1E =7 60 1& 1F4
NI XN & %EK _# NI 7 'K =H2
7 B 7<B K ;EAB ,< 'K _>
1& CE 7 k'K CE 10 'K ;1’a 3K 7
’7 .2 0+ 7 " ,%0F > M?< ’ fB
.& %EK @E 1 K ; _> %0< 60
›F 1 T||u AB 1 60 k'K ^JK 1“
0m@E 7 %00? !K ;%>7 'K ;E/ E1 4
> 7 & & _> ^K ;10P 1 1? %B
; 1& %& _8 'K =H2 7 R†B / _8
7 1 7 k'K  E)6? K ;EAB 1? B
E4s7 K K š ;1 ;70 a 60
.B %< 1 60
7 CEI % 1? ;% P" ( . %EK
,< S 1 7 ; k'K > %B a 1 1@E ;
e9 +< 12I OK 3E 8 %& 'K ;1’a
Q ;B .%& ;%6 0E ; ;E=w: k'K
;%%P > 0F M . %EK !# ; F NF
1? & =& E4% /B7 -9 _# jh
; DB0 ;s6B ,% 7 % P7 &7 ;Q !#
E1 7 60 e 7 ’ 1 , 1@P ,<
6: W: 7 4%0?" _8 !# 2 WE7s" 7 !#
.%& %EK 1
strategy
1441
-/ Q SB7 / 6& 6K U
JK C> & ;1> ;E’`2 X 18 B6B
;E10P 6K0& 7 D 7 8'9 ;7< S@P 1? E
g0 8h $ _> 0m@E O7" 7 O<
? %EK M@? DB0
@@J 3K NP N< ;4? 1 7 E
X ,m@E
.8h 7 =H2 I? 7 ’@? - p
;g0 ;E:" => SB .? & 'K
S .b
7 B 16& ( 8@6P _> ;7 ; ; 1? E/ 7 =H2 ; DB0 0 ;62P T
l0E J6 > ,m@E E> Q 1? B > & 1H “8 $7 D+ Rˆ @/
% 1? ;E A> .B ( ...7 BB
.%& I? 7 ’@? 62 U
AB 7 " ;E % C& 16& a ;70 ^JK
Q !# E 1B L%E 14 1B ;%0 16B ;E! %0E 1H CE7 =H2 ;Q*B" CE ;# 1 %&
.%& _> %%P
7 I E : %08 1? B $ E16&
1? B :6? O7 A/ ; B .; B
E 7 I O7 A/ @P B ˜%& & ,< 1 R
N2 6
SA $H26 "
E / ,2 %8 1 .B O7 A/ ; 7 k'K 10 DB0 E ;62P 1 10 .% %N8 1 %& e R†B !# 1’P C& 16& a % 1? %E 1 ,2 ;
7 0 O7 % 1? B 16K" @ 1H 1 ,2
" %@8 L%E 1B - 7 1H 1 7 .%E
.B ; B O7
: %08 1?
.`IHM _=
M ˆ =r ;E;%0 19 1? B %8 1 ,2
;EE , 1? Ni 0m@E 7 .%062E @0E
B , œ A> ;
F 1F 1? jh -:?}T
E %0F K 10 ? r*“ ?
%%P ;E4% -:? U
@ % ,2 & O7 . ? 1 CE
%%P R†B WB" p
8@6P X8 E 1? .%& (T|{t)
O7 7 MB %%P ;E%%" 1 6B t
164 CN ’% 1? 4 16 , ? ,
.8h I? 64 a \
7 B %& @ W0 ? % 1 !# _; a
-,< 9 ;%9 %& 164 M@? '/ 7 =H2
E/ 7 S7 B @ ,%:? J 1 T
.06 B ;E
! "#$% &'
*-
*+'+,
*,
)
)
*23'
*+'+,
*,
-
/ ,
01 ,
.
)
'1 *%
*+'+,
*,
.
4 51 )
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1 c 232 d;$ O J D :(") /
(
1442
7 %m" 8h K ,x Q0E '6K Q
B:4 !# N0 1 %& 164 ? 1 ;s6B
'
ˆ 1x 9 ,@E :? 8'9 ;70 .B Q _#
_8 7 ? @8 7 6/ ;E10 Q 1
7 B 16 %& 7 f ;70 ƒ 0E %& &
.& %%P @8 ;E16K7% 7 EW 1 6B
7 " €# 1 1w 2 62 7 ( ; _# jh
; B O7 ;E76B %B a 1 , 7 1H = 'w: 7'8 1 .B 0 W" = + ˆ 6’E
- %%P > !# X Mg%6 _> ;Q*B"
.%062E A> 7 " ˆ 8 ; ; + 7 / Ca0
& .B:QE !# R†B 0m@E 7 %& %
7 x6& 7 8@6P E1JK& 1 c _>
A#7 A> ˆ @H 1? ;> ; 9 !#
1x Q0E .2 ; ; 1 7%# N0 E 7 %>
, Q L9 7 %B a 1 DB0 B
1 % K 4 1 ;70 ;E’7%# 8h
.? I6B E16& 7 E10 Q 1: ;E76B ,%0@:% ^JK .Cv 8h =%/ ’
4 a%’ G0P 7 j a =@8 ; B -6* 8h a A 7 _# 1 ‹
," 1’a 7
2 ;EN& WE7s" jh 1? < 7
1H 1 ,: .B fE 4 1@P % 16K"
EE 7 O7 C8 !# 1? / 1B O7
10 P ’ 1x % x X% k'K @8 ;w7
7 =H2 SP ˆ 62 &7 1 C6 %0? M@? 1 %
k'K ;E4%m" 1 1P .B 8@6P ; B O7 Q ;B .C& 7 17 _>
A W ; 7 ;
, _# jh ?r '
ˆ .%0? M@? 2 jh ;%0 16B 7 ;%0 19
a =6 ‡ 7 CEI 1 = ; E ,08 1 a
_8 4%m" @E 7 B %m" ˆ 62 !# jh 1? %&
.4
19 ?3 O7 3 B %& _> 7 =H2 K XN
'K ;E)*6 ; < % ;E=> 0E 1x < 16 7 L%E jh _# E D 7 Ca 7 ;%0
ž/ 9 'K )*6 14 E 0m@E 7 % P7
.[5]%0? M@? ;4
1 0 K 1 K 'K ;Q6I4 . ž68 7 The Second Conference on Electronic City
'K ;Q6I4 1w & @ # A = 'K )*6
+L $
L/6 A@8 1 i 1x %E 1H K 'K ;E)*6
> 6: C& 1P ,< ; k'K 1x H2
1H .B LI& 1@E ; S7 7 B 1/P ;E=w: _# 1 77 1`2 7 B e ;x k'K
7 7 j06 ;E=> D+ 'K ;4 7 I4 ; e9
S 1 7 ; ; Q 8 1 .& l" ;
;7 'K )*6 ;E/ ; w
1? %E ;7 8h K ; ;EN& ,<
.%E
. NP 6E
4 7 I4 1QF B A†B k D 1 1’P 8h ƒ E CQ0 8h 1 4 Q 10P Š6 D 62 ? ;E@2 1@E .C%0 ,P 1
1? 0/ 1 .%062E ^K 'K ;Ec06B 7 CEI =>
7 Q6I4 1? 67 ˆ J* ?3 ";47 I4"
+ 7 ;1> ‹
7 ƒFx C8 1/P 7 : 1@E
;E10P X@ % 4 X ;624 dB ^*&
NP ;1B7 ,08 1 ; ;E=w: %K ;1>
1 0 1? B & z*: _# / 7 jh
.%4 x 1 K ^K L%E
.%& %EK E4< 6 R 7 =6 5 W
1F 1x 7 C0x -/ E/ %6 62 G"
;1’% ; Q6I4 ;P7 1I2 7 L%E 0
; I6B .%0 x 1 E/ % # 1F 1 7 2x
”
P _> @E 1? %m" 7 *B 8h ; B
;B 7 2 1/P “K : 1 J#0 ;
%? % C 10 1? ; . %EK Q6I4 ’E
Ni 407 % Q6I4 # ;7 “K
1443
1
discourse
k'K ;Q 1? B %6/ 274 M .%& e
I6B 1:% ;P 1 ,@6I4 e' 0 1?
%EK W* % %0< k'K :" ; Rˆ @6> ,@6I4
L%E 1? 8@6P 2I ;10P %? ; C0?
EOQ :% 4 ;E& ,%< CE DP ˜
7 ˆ @62 ; 1? Q0E 6> .BE ;4 C@J
.[7]%& %EK
N< ,@6I4 1 S7 & ,Q Q6I4 7 _#
1? B" ;7 X
62 NP 9 SB :"
."
,2 P .%& ,< / % ?3 ;`
1? N< N0 1 C& 16& 1’P 4 ! , 1
1 7 B * 7 “ M R# ;` 1 =H
'
ˆ 1? N< 1 X" 4 7 I4 1 %0 L> 'K A 7 E;` 10 7 %0? & ’h 10
7 E16I4 N< 7 CEK L> N< %0< 7 X L>
7 %4 a %% 6 1 W0?7 .C62E ,@6I4 A: CE ( # CE 16& 7 B2> _8 h 10 !# Q L9
M 1H 1 067 ,m@E ; C%E& 1? B 0F
@E .4 %%P ;E% 7 N< ! z*:
k'K % 06 1? %" " Ÿ R ,< Ÿ / k'K
%7 .%& %EK 'K 5 %7 7 'K _8
%0? ž 14 K e9 %6 7 .B SP 1 L/
K) ;6* K 7 B ) 10 1? ,@6I4
67 8@6P ;%/ ˆ 7
k'K %& 1? < 1?
%7 Ca0 E7 1’P @E 1 ? (0<
1 /7 , 7 , 1? %EK %B 7 %0B k'K
.%9
$B 10 v 'K 8h ;62P 7 -:?
%0 ;N& CQ0 1`2 1 4 R ;a0 .[6]& %:? WF 1 %0@:% 7 I6
,7 %0& ; 'K @7 ; 0+ 7 j’0 =>
D+ B @ 'K ;E:% %0F E
'K ;E7 ,? '8 :% %0 @E 1 1
7 !%J ; k'K 1 6K" %4 I+ 7 N’P
B († 5 1/B N0 1 Q ;B B XR 2
1 D .27h 7 XR E:% ‰ 7 %& 7 WR"
=H 67 F 1? B ;6 ž DP 0m@E 1
,%& 16KB jh 1 1? ,< 6K0& 1/P ;0/ N0
,< 7 CE 7 K =@8 ,< C& E4% 1
I2 ;0/ 1 B k c j@6P E0E
.CE K %8 ; 0
;B .B k " ,@6I4 M !K 1 1? < ,<
B a kI P7 ,7% @E 1? & 9K 1 %
@ 'K :% 1 2 NP 7 I+ 14 E Q
;Q0&7 1 0 % ,@6I4 1 2 2 ,@6I4 1 6
& 'K ;E%¡? %B 08 K ,% C8 _8 B
A @8 k7 06 R%6B "R@6> 7 =6 CN
74 M 1? 2 7 B 34 ( 4% 1?
; ;EN& ;E ,? & ;1B .& 'K
7 =H2 1 6K" A: ,44 ;EzJ* K NP a 6 ,08 1 1B7 , 1? B
.%062E 'K 8h
4 I6B '@ 7 E 2I ; 1? EO
DHOP 6
MM "
19 M Q6I4 1? ; ; %& 8h%@
A/ k7 1B E0E 0B 68 1 'K ,@6I4
XB 7 8 1 06B 274 G .% a’%
1> ; ; ." ; ;E=
“ : B C?> ; ; E7 1? }8@6P
.%& %0EK 16 %& EX¡ A@6> 1 7 'K R ,< 1/P ’J < 1? %0? e A†B
fE 4 a’% 1? %B @8 ,@6I4 X7
D
.%" !# 1 A@& ,NP
; ;& @8 ,@6I4 ;7 %8 1 . E0E 68 ,< ; 7 1 2 1’P ;E0E
1
autonomous
O3" ; h 1 7 % ;7 W" 1? B
1444
The Second Conference on Electronic City
0 .? I6B X@8 ’'K K0& 7 dh
" .
1 J6* ; & ? %0F E %& /B 1 1? " @8 K Š7 1 1? B 16&34 8@6P 8h , .C& 16& ; ;E=: k'K
,< 1? B ;I > 1? )+ 1/P / 4% NP
8'9 ;70 _> ;EKB ”
P %& 1H 1x
1? %0? ,: 9K 7 .B 1/P X% 7 6* K 16 .B ,6 ;B 6: ;4 " 162& 7 B
1? B V6 ;1/P 1 ,%& =% A> ; ;
R†B 1@E ;Q*B" 'K ,@6I4 1x %& 7< % ˆ + ;EO j06 ;El0E 7 -6* ;E74 D?
%0F # c w6 1x 2%0 1w 2
.B 6
A> E 1 ’ . @E 1 K “K ;EWF 1x B
1? %0? ;Q W0 1’P6 ;7 E 7'8
B =6 ‡ 7 CEI O624 7 $2 W%E %0 @E
;1> 1? ; 7 } & A@8 , $B 1? ’
16B K ;P 'K D A< % ƒ ,08 1 1x
2 1? C N< O I> /B 7 }%062 ,
.& ;%0
4 %’ P 9 1 1? ; .%0? }% ? 8 E16&34
1 7 ; ; 'K =H2 1 WE7s" ,08
%062E NP ;E ; “? ;EBB ;B XNI
1@E A .B 76 ;EN& a E=w: ,< S
; %0E ’7 'K 7 8@6P 8h 62
1x %9 3 .4 NP R 1  EWF
%062E Q >9 " ,: Rˆ @6> L%E 1 =
7 Ea A ;  %< CE 6
C# 1I“† ; 7 & S7 († Ÿ V6 1/P M 1?
1& .C< ! EWF 7 NP dB EQ@E
F ’I 274 % .%& 'K
; ;EN& ,%7N& ; k'K ,P =N2 ;
k'K 6> 1? B 6/ ; C# ;8 e9 " :1x ’ ,F %& 1B7 6N %
1B7 % %6 1? %& EO @8 162E ; ;’I
7% Q6I4 7 _# ; : $K %00x 1H .%& =x ;< 7 P
The Second Conference on Electronic City
XB 7 8 &< 7 C62 ž/ M %E& 7
.[8]4 ;P 70N" ,NP
7 DHJ 1F 4 1? B & &7 R D 1m<
P EQ6I4 0F ; E 1H %0 ; 60B k'K ;E;` ;4? 1 ':
!9 % x .%0x CE 1@P 7 A6
’ . P7 8'9 ;E;70 %< 'K 8h
+ 7 660 #I D %00x Q6I4 ;E74
8h =? k QQ 7 2@E A 7“ D
.%< x ;%N8
7 %N8 1 ;& 1Ii7 ;? k'K .2 =H2 7
A 7 _# ; %& ;
x ,08 1 % 0m@E 7 E10 Q 60B e' 1 ;E;` I6B
7 N¡ 1F 1w0 =V E_# .E74 7 a
$# k'K 7 , k> BB X8 ,m@E E16&
– ^J6K ; ;1/P ; 62 E0E
.B ,4 1 B N: EWF 2
;E> 6K0& ; , E 1F 1w0 7
A†B 1I2 +< 1? B Q _# 8h k'K
N 7 x %" EO 7 E0E =& 1 k'K 0 ^JK ,< 1& ; ! K L%E :" ’% EBB Š7 1H
e 17 a 1:% > CN 7 1`2 ,08
. C@v
7 1 _> 0E AB E 7 ˆ &34 7 B
”:0 K 1x B !# %%P ;> x3 jh
a kI M 1 %1626 E,2 1 7 “I6 1
FF 6& ,7% 1x B /9 .B 8’06 8h
,< ,08 1? 9 ,@E h> WE7s" .%0 B jh
.N X% ,@ !# =@8 &7 7 Cw#
1`2 . a’% ; k'K DHJ 7 ': B%"
 J 8'9 ;70 / 6& E4< 3
'K ;` I6B 1 ? ,@ ’%> 8
X8 a 1 .x %EK ƒ@x 2 ;70 'K
.B @8 1445
7 W0
4 N60 %& => = % 6> 1 : E 1
1? ;# 1 B B 1`2 1? B )*6
.%:? WF 1 k'K
;E"
1- Berleur, Jacques, Penny Duquenoy and Diane Whitehouse
(eds.) (1999). Ethics and the Governance of the Internet,
IFIP, Laxenburg, Austria
2- Damon, William (1999). "The Moral Development of
Children", in Scientific American, August 1999, pp7278.
3- Moor, James H., (1985). "What is Computer Ethics?" in
Metaphilosophy, 16 (4).
4- Lessig, Lawrence (1999). Code and other Laws of
Cyberspace. Basic Books. Zachman John A. "A
Framework for Information Systems Architecture" IBM
The Second Conference on Electronic City
Systems Journal Vol. 26 No. 3 1987.
5- Robson, Colin (1993). Real World Research: A Resource
for Social Scientists and Practitioner-Researchers.
Blackwell Publishers Ltd.
6- Winograd, Terry (1995). "Computers, ethics, and social
responsibility" in D. Johnson and H. Nissenbaum (eds.)
Computers, Ethics & Social Values, Prentice Hall Inc.,
pp. 25-39.
7- Grodzinsky, Frances (1999). "The development of the
ethical ICT professional and the vision of an ethical online society: How far have we come and where are we
going?" in Proceedings, Ethicomp'99.
8- Habermas, Jürgen (1983). Moral Consciousness and
Communicative Action, MIT Press 1990. Translated by
Christian Lenhardt and Shierry Weber Nicholsen. (3rd
printing 1993.)
1446
#$%
#&$ !"
560(09127611664)
& :+$ (D$
M L Y%V$ :;J$ :; #
J%
[email protected]
M
7 8'9 ;70 1NP 1/B A> ;1/P ,08 1 ,< ;7W" ': 7 , 0? /h7 1 CE ,: %0< =2 7 C/ 7 1/P 1/B 2 %7 ( W %& O' 7 %& B 9
9 7 8'9 ;E;70 I6B 8@6P 7 Q0E ;EDB< ,:% %& 1 %0 1? 2?
1? % !# .%7< P %0< ;E=2 ; ;70 d# I6B l0E 7 %00? iI>
1? % ,08 1 %7 O< fB % N< %06 7 %0% %7 XR ;E<
%&@ a % 1 0 ;EO< 16 .4 1P % %& ( 76 4< .4 a E10P X@ % 7
7 ;70 XQ@E % 1? J6 ;1/P , %7 ; EO< !# 7 EDB< 7 %0? I6B %I =& 1 ;70 V ;E10P A> 8 7 ? ?> 1/P Q0E 7 8@6P
,? 4% 6N ;6B ;70 1? " EK ;1/P .%@ @ 6@? ,< )* 7 I0 (<
.%00? I6B ,< ,:E S NP %4 %K 1 ;70 7 %00? I6B
1B% &< %6B %7 K ;B %0@ 76 4< 60 1 9 7 8'9 ;70
The Second Conference on Electronic City
6> 164 B 60 7 1 ^JK 1 9
F
%& , E;70 = K ;EDB< 7 ':
7 ? B 8'9 SP %7 W 1 6@? E16I4 7 E_# X@ I4 ,6 %& 1? ;16 d# l0E 1? 16:" ;1/P =: N< (
Q 8 ; 7 ;1&> =& 1 %& 7 %& 16K" ,< 1
.C0? ,@ 9 7 8'9 ;70 I6B
1? ;? N0 .%& 1 %7 O< _# %&
7 K 1 ; s7 1P % ;70 I6B ;B l0E ;4 1 8 %7 R ;N6 164 1/P 1P ;E,? % N< O< 7 & %7
7 )6? 1 4 7 ? 7 ;E;70 $ D
-6* ;EW* %& /B 3 .4 %& A>
1@P P %B ›F 1 %7 O< NP ; 1
I6B d# l0E 1H 1? C B 16 1 1
6B? 7 @? CE ,< 7 PK ;E:? ;EE
( 7 ? 2 %7 !9 1/P 1 ;70 Q6I4 7 _# %0 %& 1 Q 1? 717
.B E O< 7 %&
&< %6B B a% 1? >9 .C62E 1
;70 $+ I6B ;E%" 7 EDB< jh ;6B ;E& 7 ;70 ;EO< NP ,K :? ^K 7
7 ›F - ;2 R 7 E)6? :? ,# 7 %B
%/ 7 .%& %7 1 ,% :* J 7 6
7 8'9 ;70 Q0E 7 8@6P ;EDB< .%? :60
1447
1 ,
I .CB0& B 6K
6K M?< 7 &< ;E7 1 %6B
60 NP 1& KR 7 @EI ;E ;E1&
7 K 7 16K< _> %06 %7
.%& K ,B ICT:" AJ# Q@E
.% N N< WK 4%
SP 1 K 77 E;70 7 E
M E
$ 7 %: , =JI =& 1 e9 H
P 1 DB ;70 E Ni Q » 8 1 %? R#
_# %& 16I4 &< %6B a% ?
.[¢]« B 1/P ;E 7 ;E16BK B
_# ; ;1 0F 7 %& 624 2 1
1 60 7 1 7 6: %& /B !#
@E O' %&@ ,< ;E10P X@ ;7 ,< ( 7 & # ICT ;E76B ,08
E;70 K %7 ;B %0@ jh 1 6K"
6: %& )*6 7 7 .& B SP
;7<4 %& /B .4 1P 6: 1FE
06 8'9 J8 ;E4% ;E% 7 Ee9
C8 _# ," 8'9 X@ 1 D
%E* !# Ee9 M qE N0 7 %& 7
' 10 ;Q 8'9 E 7 1 )6?
7 ; ; 7 NP %E ,F Ee9 .
N< D 7 & ;7<S@P 660 ;EB 7 E17
XNI 60 7 1 ,7% ... 7 M76 ;M M76
; B 7 1/ 0? .& ;4 N 1 1N
. %0EK B K
N< 8'9 7 %7 ;E4% 6 8'9 1 6B
4E 1 1 %& 1H #h fB S 1 X% 9 7 8'9 ;70 1 7 8'9 ;70 ,@E a0 %& I6B N0 1 ;70
;< 0 67 1@ ,6B0E %7 , E10:B"
7 1 ;70 a0 7 B ICT ,@E 9
1? %4 ,N N& O7" 7 O< ¢ 10 S7 2
.B 60
I6B 1 A9 E10:B" %< B% 8'9 .B %& 7 C@h W* !# H
P B %&
=/-! 7
O ;-E ICT N
K! *( &'< G
,B A9 SP .B ? 1 ; ;Ej@6P
7 M76 ; & 7 %& 1? C62 , X7 1@
R# 7 86K => 1? % K 1 Q& ;%%P J8 %4 _8 %& @E E1 j6K ?> _8 7 %7< %%" N< ,7 SP ,< 1? P ,:E? 7 E1 W24 .%0 K ;7 W"
: 4% WB< 7 7 = NP SP
%" O /@P c ;E1B O624 EE ,%<
4% j R# 7 8B .%%& 1/P -6*
J8 %%P J8 %& _8 N< A6 7 8'9 ,?
€# 1 1F 7 ;J6 8@6P Q0E a 1F ,NP X
%%P ;1/P 0? ; ,2 .%00 9 7 8'9
7 7 %& %& 1 K , ;70 7 ;g0
1? %0? 1 9 7 8'9 ;70 06
16B" j BB 7 0 86K 7 I ,E A#
;1/P) 8'9 1/P .B K J* ;E4s7
7 O624 1? B E1 KB 86K B
;4 N 7 8'9 06 ,< fB 7 ,0 1?
Q& X 7 4% ,< I6B ,7
(%04 8'9 1/P B 9 7 8'9 ;E;70
K 1 86* %& .B %< P SP 6KB
7 % ?7D2? O< J6 ,F @EI 7
;% 1 1B7 I6B 624 ;7 1? %06&%0" @
.%& 7I6 ,< = 60B ;E1/P CEI K ( # 1/P 4% -6* / 1? &
.%E
!9 7 / 1 ;
K ;70 E
CE 9 7 8'9 ;E;70 .%0? c ,2
1? E
E;70 7 %062 0V62 %8 1448
The Second Conference on Electronic City
7 E,%@ ;7 K 4% ,B 9 :
1? C62E %0 C 6K E;70 1? 1 ? B# 1B7 ,08 1 E1 j6K %/
$& ! ;70 7 C0? =%/ E;70 K 1/P
,< ; ;%%P ;E? 7 4 1 K B# =&
; C D 1 .C4 7 16KB WK 1/P
16 7 ? %" 7h 8'9 A 7 c %< P
I6B l0E .CB < ;70 O3" ; 1/P
.%& =: 8'9 A6 7 c NP ;1 ;E1&
,< ; N 6N & _8 E;70 d#
60 NP 1& ,%< P _8 E1& O624
=%> 1 ,< 8@6P 7 Q0E )* ;EDB< 7 16& 1/P
1 %& _8 1B M ,08 1 60 O624 %4
.%B
CE 60 .%0? rI ,NP c X@ K ,B 9 8B
7 M76 4% ,F I6* CEI 7 E? K @E 1
ICT &
9 P
$B 624 I6B 7 SP 60 7 1 77 4% 1 ,< $ ;E;70 7 1B7 77 ,< 16
16&34 ,B 9 K 7 4% ,< ;4w 7 1/P
< W 7 34 ( %0@& 8'9 C? C? .%& X ;8
1/P 6KB 7 E;70 ( I0 7 V /
;EW* ;70 I6B @E 1 8'9 ? %%&
7 I0 7 V ( @E ;0 7 .B 16:4 z*:
N< !9 %< 7 %B a 1 ;7h 1/P -6*
K @@J 7 Ee9 ,44 SP -6* 7 .& R# O*6B SP =& %& _8
7 ': S NP 1/P ,@E 7 $& !
7 8'9 # /P W%" _8 SP R#
.B %& r* EDB<
8'9 SP X 1 %& 9 7 8'9 ;E;70
1@E w76w 4% 1QF 1x CQ0 ,@9 1 B x
K 19> 1 ;Q G" w ;: 4% ;E18
;70 I6B % K < =& 1? /P
.7< P X 4% ; $& 6N
* 7 ”B ( K I0 7 V ;E4s7 @E 1 7 7<
1/B A> SP 7
P 1? , 7 1/P ,F ;1/P
7 1 I6B V (< 1@E .B 7< A 1 1 K 6/B 1FE %06 1? %062E %0 %&
1 ;7 / K :" ; 1/P ƒ 7 %0 60
,P K ;E4% D8 7 %B M
16:" SP
NP N< / X 7 7< %EK E
I6B
%K 1 /B ;%%P ;g0 7 ;70 E 3 .%00?
B0& DB< C a 6: 1m< . %0EK N DB0
;70 E 1? %0& 16& 1P 16 1 10 ,7% %4
I0 ( C% CEK B 60 7 1 I6B
7 4 1 N< I6B 7 %< P M fB
.7< @E 1 'w: 1F 7 2F ,7< P 7 X $B f2> X
62 1/P X8
7< 1'K =w& 1 7 ;EDB 7 ( : B %&
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1? .7< P ...7 M76 M76 ; M
? 1 ; I4 , .%& 1/P ,< 77 ;E10
4 A> .& ,< I6B l0E % ;70 E ,
ƒ76w gx
•
7 1/P ;7 ;70 ( 64 a ,7% 1/P
ƒ76w ;7
•
;70 ;E? 1 ;B l0E 7 ;B 10 ,7%
ƒ76w 8'9 ,@
•
; %%P ; 5 & _8 %0? j@6P 7 ,<
ƒ76w :K
•
7 6/0 SP 6KB 7 l0E O3" @E /P 0F
ƒ76w 4"
•
K ;K 1 8@6P ;EN K 7
7 %& 16:"
ƒ76w 68
•
4N 8 1 7 @4B 7 QQ K %0 F
B% # 7 :E7s" ;Ee9 9 EDB< )K
; 7 %< P f2> 16:" SP .%& %0EK
B %& - ;2 R 7 E)6x N< 1 7 %<
;70 7 %@ ;70 ;4 1 X% 7 =: S
0 .%? ,&1/P 7 K 0B 7 )< < !9
1449
K 1 CE 7 1/P K 1 CE 1? & SP 7 EK
S9 1 7 7< B% R 708 , N< X@ 1x
7 ': 1/P K %7 1 7 & 7 1%
.B %& 1H X%xE 1 x 7 SP =JI -/
8@6P ;E0E 7 4% 7 l0E 1 BB %%N
.%& %EK 1P
B I6B A 7 ;EDB< 1x C0
N 7 %0x E ; ;%P @ %
;70 :" ,P EK ; 1? ': 8 % .B A
6 1/P ƒ ;E0 7 N& %
,< @a8 W* %& –2F %< %EK P
7 x ;7x7 N< ;4=w& =8 K0& K 1 EDB<
;K S9 1 .2 % %7 ? 8'9 6&% 7
7 e9 N< ;P ; 7 ,< ; DB06 ;EwE
,< %7 7 & Q 4B ,08 1 ;70 1 1?
.x ;
1
,% %00?@ I6B ,< 7 16&% %0F j'9
*( 1"E -
I Q
%00? I6B N< 7 %& N< )3P N< ; 1? E
1FE ;B 1 h> , 4% %7 1x C3v 4
E@0E 10 7 %0& A60? # 10 ,7%
A> /7 ƒ w76w 4% 7 B ,%& w76w
.%0@ I6B N< %0@%E 7 %00? 1
NP7 qE 1x CEK Q< C% 6B" j7 1
;4 1 M@? 1@P -6* =R 1 %7 E74 »
7 ,? " 9 ; ,% 0&< = @8
,%& w76w 0/ %%" ( ;: 4% P7
.% %0E* 7
1 ;70 Q 7 60 ; 4B 7 +
8'9 J8 1/P ƒ x K
%& 7 K 1< ,7% %0E 1%E K ,%
;E;70 ,7
7 O624 %@ 7 1 R# 7 % Q0E GI 1 @68 7 8 ‰ =%> 1< 7 %0&
7 ; 9 E4% ƒB %& _8 9 7 8'9
1 ( %7 ; 2 %/ .%0& ? K
O*6B 7 & ,44 K ƒ ,44 / 7 8@6P
.[¤]« %% E4< K K ,% ;7 60 7
K ƒ , ,wB ,08 1 %7 .4 A# 7 $+ l0E 7 6& K ;70 )* ;EDB<
,< / @ K ;8 1/B 7 %& %E 1Ii7
': F ,% & _8 % ;70 I6B
.% %N8 ;J6 7 8@6P E3 Q0E C8
X%8 7 'K , B %& j@6P 7 K BB
2@E 7 XQ@E K % %%P J8 %7 fB @E
B I6B (< ...7 8@6P ;EK ;E;70 1x E %06 %B %%P . B ,% ; ;70
K :" NP 7 2> # 1 %@ CE N< ;
': 0F 6@? 16:" SP %E ,: EB
;70 V (< 7 E%" K D 1 .%00x I6B
I6B 1? %062E 1/B A> SP 7 %062E 1P
EK 4% Ix @62 ( 7 % N
.%0& =: F X8 1 7 WK SP ;70
.
=@/ G8 K ,% 1 60B MB 34 EK
.%00? , %0@ 7 ,:
K ;70 1? EDB< W* 1 : ? CEK / %0?
V? %E ,: %& X # 1IB6 7 B ,:% 6@? ;E;70 %7 j'9 ,
;I6B 1F ,:% 1? %0@ N< ^J*
N< K 1F 7 %0E X E? 1F %00? E;70
'K ;EDB<
•
&
" ;EDB<
•
E4< 7 ;70 d# I6B , 8
8@6P 7 Q0E ;EDB<
•
,%: ;B l0E 7 ,%: 10N 7 N< 1 2 6&%
.%0? %%N
7 E DB< _8 % d# I6B
1450
The Second Conference on Electronic City
3P DB 1 7 ,: 1'8 ;70 1 2 1? %062E
1? 2? 1 S9 1 : M76 %7N& %6B
•
%7N& %0? 4% 76 7 8'9 1/P M
[¥] 1 =? =& 1 EDB< 1 c 8'9
.B %& 7<
%% E< % %7N& .%04 76
,% %7 -i7 6@N 1? B /7
%6B .%0& 16& 6> 4% 1/P %6
1 jh 1 1P .B7 >7 7 @2P 'B 7
7 B E E ; ,< ;4 7 %& 1N ;? 2
S 4 ;70 7 A6 ; 1m< %7 BP
%%P ICDL %6B %6B .%& @ 6/
% r* 7 %00? B I6B E
K CE %&
/ SP K 4 & 1 1626 0E 7 B
/B %0E X K K 6 ;1Ii7 1%0K
.%0?
;1B7 1 ,< %%P ;g0 462 ;P 1 %0@
O< ;Q ;%6B qE 7 7 + 1
.%B A% 4K $7 C# %I
CE , .% P7 8'9 ;70 ;E
Q@E
The Second Conference on Electronic City
0E X7 7 7 164 K 1 ;? ;E10P '? A7 %6B
(" -S A C/"< R
%B a 1 %& C? ,< X 0&< 7 %: 4
J8 .% `2 K X A 1/P E ,R`2
E :* , %6B 1H 6: ; ;4 ; :" 7 %& A> 1/P 8'9 ;70
.@ L9 76 4<
76 4< 1 8'9 ;70 ;E
%162 %6B 7 I6B 16:" SP ? 1 M ,08 1 76 4< . WK 1/P
76 4% ; X;B %0@ ': ; %>
z*: 7 W0B ; ,44 ;EzK& 7 E/ ;
7 2@E ,:/P :" 1? /P .%7< CE ;0/ 1 2 i E/ .B
SP .B 7I6 $& ;70 :" ,
@E
.%& ;? ;EO< 7 IT ;E;%0 dB B dB
% W 1F 7 %7 W 1F K E 16:"
76 4< ;E1JK& X@ 1/P M @& 4
% %0? I6B ,< % 1? ;70 XR 8'9
I6B ;%0@ 7 I6B B 1/P X %0? CE
7 ;70 I6B 1F %E X ;? 1F % 1? % 7
0F I4 ,@ '@8 %0& 16&% N< d#
2 K -i7 7 `2 7 %@ I6B 6B 1F S7 .B R dB 76 4< a ;1/P
D8 8 1 1/B A> SP .B 4< ;70 1
N 9 7 8'9 ;70 ;
% @ 1/P ,<
77 G" 1? %062E 1/P ,< ,P + %< P 4%
.%@ DB0 ;
A6B N< 7 %00? ?> N< @B 1 1/P 1 ;70
% 2 i %/ 4< ; 1/P ,< 16&34 =2 7 %7 ,% = .%00?
B ;%0 E O< 164 ;2
,: K DB0 ;EW0?7 %< P A
7 ;70 I6B XR ;E< A6 6N 7
E;70 I0 DP 6: 6/h7 0F %0E@
D 4 O< .B O< ,< ;Bl0E
N< + 7 & ,@ 16B ;
1? %& E 6N / 7 z*: ;E%6B
f2> X%8 ,@E 9* 7 4 r* 6B @@J
1 1 1? %& @ &< ;E%6B 1
,P 7 %< P X ; 1? B ;70 I6B 1 : & 16K" N< /
;70 #I X 7 4B ;6B 6: CE
1? ;%6B : ICDL v? ;? %6B
7 4B ;E10P %6 /P 0F .%00? I6B
% 7 ? %" ? ;? ;EO< NP 6:
1? ,< Q ;E? %/ 7 %0? %" ? ;70 #I
? # 7 O4 1 60 7 1 8'9
=2 1 @E .& ,@ %& 6@N
O< E? X =N2 ; ;? X %0F L& 1 0 ;70 I6B 1/P 16&34 7 ,P
.%E
1451
•
$ 1? %E ,: 10 164 ;EB
3" )06P I4 ,6 %& 1? & 8@6P 7 Q0E
:60 ' 1? R 16K" jh 1 1 ;%/
Q 6: /P 0F O< 7 ;B l0E .%@
,% 60 7 1 ( B $ CE N< 7 %%&
164 SP ? 16 1? . 7h SP
N 7 16& , 2 K ;EDB< 16K"
CQ 4 7 L& L3> ;6B EO< ;4 1 8 EK 1 %0F ,08 1 N6 CE
2? D .B 6@? / ? 6: 1 )6? 7 N0 CE I 1 .B @ D : X@ 1 % ,P CE % 164 O< 1?
16K" N< / 1 1? %& %E: K c
1FE 1? %0EK 4 SP .0B 7 / E 1/P
: &
%00? %0@ %00 16:" SP S@P K 7
•
1 ;70 1 0&< 2 %/ 7 %7 0? 16&34 ;E=2 B %& S 7 ›F B ,7 1 ,4 M $B
, %0% 16:" ;1/P K 7 %0E
EDB< B 1 R %0@E 16 7 16&% @8 W*" 7
(< 7 %0? %%N %%P =2 ,44 ;EDB< %< L&
.B ? %7 1 1 E 1 GvB 7 16K"
1/P ;E1" B @ 1? %E ,: K )*
1? 60 ,P 7 E@E ;E%?
4 BB # 7 O*6B ,< ;E0 7 ? 2B
•
.B ,P 7 ,?? ;E%? ;E)6? ;B
16&34 =2 1 1P 3 .%& 1/P ,< $& DB0 K 1?
1 ;? ;E10P %0FE 7 B 1@P CE )6?
%7 QP ,0? CE 1? 2 .%& @E 3H> 2
%0 %7 7 %7 ; 60 ,% A60?
7 CQ a N< ; ;1 4 .%164 %%P =2
E10P X@ 1626 % DB0 N )6? K N0 1 2 %0E* 4E C0 @0E N<
%7 ; ,< ;%& =& 0m@E 7 %E W&" 1
6B 1 K ;E`2 7 %0E !7 %%P 1/P $&
.B %: 1H
,:% ; K %00? 7 @0E %06 7 %0E X
N< SP @2 1? %& ;Q ;E)6?
.B %& X
.%0&
N< ;E`2 7 %7 1 2 16:" SP 16
%7 ;B 4< 1 1? % Q % 7I %0< =2 7 ,% %00? ,0/ 1/P
7  1 @8 B j'9 164 ;70
XR ;E< %0E* 4 CE N< 10 = 1
,
,F /@P ;E1B !9 ;70 ;EDB<
%7 K % %7 1 ;70 c ,%
< 1? B & e 1 1? B .%&
K ,% %0@ 7 %& %0EK 7 1 7 ':
X% M S7 ? I4 , –B d# ? /7
.%0:* J 7 %00? @0E ;70 K
.B ;70 ;EDB< K 1/P 1R8 C@J 7
;EO< 1H 1 Bj'9 7 @0E ;E1B
X% %0? %E: K ;70 ;EDB< 1/P 1? %7 A60? ;E
X % 7 ,% %E ; XR
;70 I0 ;E%" 7 (< 1 @8 B j'9 1
60 7 1 % ;E/ 1? (parental control)
.& %7 ,%B _8 @E 7 %0? 1/P dB %E %7 6K XR 8'9 % 7 a
B ? % ;70 10 ? 8'9 1? 0%7
.%0@ d# ;4 C@J K % 1 2 %06 %& / 7 %& ,4 ;7 ;70 '? 7 %00 (< 1/B A> SP 1? I4 ,6 %& ;Q K 7 EDB< K 1? ,% I6B = 7 %& 16I4 D fB .%% =+ (%7 O<) 1`2
.& %EK A 1
7 ,% 1 % ;70 7 ;70 1? @ 7 (<
%& X% d# 7 4 % 1? ;?
=& 1 %6 ;70 1/B A> SP 1? B
;E`2 1 BB 1P B XR %0? 7 %0< ;E=2
.& 8'9 1/P %7 %%P
1452
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1? 9 7 8'9 ;7< ;E%" 7 K
,@E % 1? N< 7 4% ;E? O<
%7 .(B 6 1? I) %0 / EK 1 4B
.%& M76 %7N& &< %6B
,:% 6K 4B NP 60 7 1 +
1H : ,% A %7 ;E<
•
E 7 60 7 1 1 ;? 7 ;
% 4 .%0E
;EDB< ,% B> 7 I> ;Ee9 7 EE
( ;J08 ,08 1 %/ 7 & ;Q ;70
d# I6B ,:% %06 F 10 7 ;70
,< I6B 1? ? / %7 ; K =H2 34
B a0 7 % W* .%00? @0E ;70 8@6P ;J6 C8 K ': ;2 %0
% E6 7 EK 1F 1? % B0:7 W* }¦ :&
, .%0E WE? N< 7 ? => 7 Q0E
7 ,&K $B ;70 I6B ,:% %7
M ,08 1 ;70 1 N0 1 K 1? & a6
%06 1QF %7 1? 0 W* }§ .%0& 16& ,&%
K =N2 7 X ;2 W 1? ;? 1B7
O< %00? A60? ;70 I6B K ,%
%06 %7 1? .4 I6B 7 & Q 2 1? %7 A60? ;E
X I6B # 7 0@ ;70 Q 7 60 7 1 I6B K ;E10
E
.B ;7h
, / %0& 16& 6K ;6: , 7 %0E WE?
1 MF? )6? M 1? B ;
F ,< ; D ; 1Q 7 7 =V K Q L ;6:
1F4 %0Q 1 7 M 7 1 M N0
N< 7 ? %" A6 CE ,% 1 I 7 %00? ,%
D 18@ 4 .%E 1H ,< EW* %
N< 7 7 ? %0E* Q =B7 1 4B C:F 1
16& =/ N< ,6 7 & =60 %7 1 Q% 0? .4 =B7 !9 ,:E S ;
;/ k ( % @> 7 @0E # N<
K ;E S NP ;
;70 D 1
.B ,% ;7 ,< C62 ( 1? %& 16& EK S7 7 B 34 ( 2 % 4B 1 7 4
2 %7 1 / %H 7 D M E< A6
.C@ K ; I6B l0E
% 1 D 4%0?" 7 B 34 (
^K &< %6B M N0:" 3 %0? ;4P
%I 7 ( 2 9 7 8'9 ;70 10 %7
.%&
#1U V-W T
;70 7 ;70 jh $ ;EO< ?@6 1H
4< ( % % %7 1 E10P X@ .%& 1/P %7 76
The Second Conference on Electronic City
V-W -
4 / X
:" 7 1/B ,%:* 8B 1 % %7 O<
!# 1? E 10:B" %& 8'9 fB %0 4 %7 1? > 8 %0? M@? 2 1/P
%@N , 4 X ,6B0E M %7 164 64 < 7 O7" K 1 %0< ;E=2
NP ;
,08 1 60 7 1 EK D+ 1?
;EDB< K %0 1? %0@ 16:" 7 SP
; + 7 %00? @ I6B K =N2
.% 1Q ,J ,< )*
%0F
0&<
%7
.%?
1N
,:%
,:E `2 1 % XR %7 1? 8'9
,:% A60? 7 a 7 E@E ,:E`2
@ ;%0 16B W* 7 , %0% ;70 1 2
7 ;4 1 =@ N< V? .%% ;70 I6B
: & dh 1?
.%0& ;70 $ &< ;E7 ?&
B 8'9 S7 : %7 K ;E<
•
7 %062E %6/ %7 6: 1? %E ,: EB
1/P 76 %7N& M ,08 1 % E 1?
I6B l0E ; ,% %E ; 1? EQP
7 K0& %0? I6B N< %6 7 %& 16& 8'9
%/ 7 4 1/P K N $B % 4% 1453
DB0 7 B 62 4 1? .%062E P 7 P 7
XB 7 X7 @E 1P E1B 7 1B% N< 0? ; %& 7 A@? 1 1 ,%B NP ,2 %4 .%0&
.[¢]« %00?
,% @0E 1B% W ,08 # 1? B 7 @0E ;70 c % %6 K 4 0
16 %7 @ %& %I % I6B
1/P 7 K a60 ;2 8@6P ;EDB< %0? %E
A6 ; B0 2 , 1B% 1? %06& a kI
, ,< !9 1? ;
? ;1" Q , 1 .B
%0 1B% `2 7 %& ,:% 1 8'9
;E=2 ? 7 ;70 d# I6B l0E 7 E4<
.%00? @0E 10 K 1 N< ,%
;34 ( ; 7 .B K %: =: F %0<
XR ;E< @ I6B , ;N 7 ,4 1F 7 l0E K 7 %" 0/ ,< ,? % K
%7 1 B %& 7% %6B !9 1? %7 ;
.%0& K 0&<
&< 2B EB l0E ,F E$# –? =60
$ 7 %& ( % @ 4E % % 1? C6I4
1B% %0& f% , 6N %062E K ;E,
E4< 7 K0& » .& %7 f _8
.%E O< CE N< %7 ,% O< 0? %
K z*: A7 L> ;%0 7 %%" 14E K
I6B 8'9 1H 7 E & N0:" fB @E
E;70 1 2 %7 4% 4 .[¢]« % ;% 7
.4 f% K
0? .%& ,& K =N2 NP ;? E4%
%0F ( % @ R S9 f% %7 O< 7% , %0% ,% 6%E 7 6 ;E< ,<
CE 1? ,62 =V " S9 %6B 1H .%& 16&
I6B l0E ; 7 4 %0< ;E=2 7 ,% 1? % ;6: ;4 % CE 7 %& 6@? %7 B
;E< %& N0:" .& CEK ;70 d#
% R S 10 CE 7 %& 34 ( 2
M D ,< 7 ;70 c %7 % DB< CE %& 7 %& 4 E;70 Q 7 %& &< ;E7 D 7 & SP 7 &< %6B
7 =+ % , B , 6N ;Q:" .%&
B CEK 1? ;1 1 ,6 & A6 %7 1
,< 1 c =H2 0&< 7 ;70 ;E10 ) 7:
.C
%06 %0& 16& > / E f% %
C? %7 K0& ,
164 !# C%
.%0E %7 6K XR ;E7: 7 E@0E
2 2 1B% .B 2 ;4 ; N< k&
XR 8'9 N< 1 , CE 1? & )2# %7 S@
. ;7: 7 6@> ;EW&" # CE A6 Y
, :? /h7 ,? &7 %& /B 1 1 B 9 7 8'9 ;70 1NP 1? /
10 .B 624 2 jh SB c
76 4< CEK 1? CB 16
# ? 1 %0Q 1F %7 &< %6B
R @E 2 ;Ei O7" C0? ;1/P
. Q% 0? B0:7 7 0 ;E10P /B7
K 1/P ;EN 34 ( 7 B K
%7 A60? ;E
X NP # ;E?
K ,7 B 8@6P ;P ,2 1? < » .B
DB< .%& DB0 ;? %7 ; B 1 ,%
8@6P =8 6@N .%0? %& 1/P 7 & %6
# DB0 ? @E I ,F ;70 Q B0&
,2 .B K $# ;7 ?? ) ,2 E ,%&
1 7 1? < N0:" M ,08 1 7 .%& % ;Q
1? B K ;EW4 7 JK ; P S E;70 XR 8'9 ;70 ; 1? 2?
A'6B D2? ;7"%0 %0? k O4% Q ;E7
;<B N =: & B %062E j'9
'K E1@ ...7 ;4 P 7 @ K 9 E
1454
The Second Conference on Electronic City
; B0 ? B %7 1 EO< 1H 34 (
‫ ‬
‫‪34 ( ;? ;70 ,B O< ; IT 76‬‬
‫ ‪j'9 &< ;E7 ?& 1 =@ % ¤ª‬‬
‫‪.% 1 B‬‬
‫ ‪, 7 64 1 D+ X 1? %& % 1/P‬‬
‫‪;B 7 ; %& K 7 4% ;70‬‬
‫‪2 10
E 7 2 ;E , B 0/ 76‬‬
‫"‪;E‬‬
‫?‪.,‬‬
‫]‪[ e‬‬
‫‪>1
+D‬‬
‫]‪[ f‬‬
‫ ‪¢ 10 S7 2 ;< ,6B0E 1? #‬‬
‫<‪10:B" S 1 X% 4 ,N N& O7" 7 O‬‬
‫; ‪¥¨ %/ %4 ,6B0E XB AB ,P0E %7‬‬
‫"‪ E10:B" 8'9 ~*6B .%& 10:B‬‬
‫‪1H 1'K 1 %< B% Š6 K 7 164‬‬
‫]‪[ g‬‬
‫]‪[ h‬‬
‫& ‪:‬‬
‫ @ ‪.%0& A
0 1 ; EK‬‬
‫]‪[ i‬‬
‫ §‪V ,:% ; 1 P7 %7 % ¤‬‬
‫ ?‪.%00‬‬
‫]‪[j‬‬
‫ §‪.%& =J6 60 1 E1 % ¢‬‬
‫ ‪.% a ,&% ;E/ %7 % ¤¤‬‬
‫ §© ‪1 c =H2 7 60 1 2 %7 %‬‬
‫<‪.% @ 8'9 Ni ,‬‬
‫ ¬‪;1 ;E; ;E;%016B %7 % ª‬‬
‫‪.%062E j'9‬‬
‫ ‪. ,% k E1 % ©¤‬‬
‫]‪[ k‬‬
‫]‪[ l‬‬
‫]‪[ m‬‬
‫ﺷﺮودر‪ ،‬ﻛﻴﺖ‪ ،‬ﻛﻠﻴﺪﻫﺎي ﻫﻤﺮاﻫﻲ و ﻣﺮاﻗﺒﺖ از ﻧﻮﺟﻮاﻧﺎن در اﻳﻨﺘﺮﻧﺖ‪،‬‬
‫ﺗﺮﺟﻤﺔ ﻓﺮود‪ ،‬ﻓﺮﻧﺎز‪ ،‬وﻳﺮاﺳﺘﺔ ﻓﻼح‪ ،‬ﻣﻬﺮداد‪ ،‬ﭼﺎپ ﭼﻬﺎرم‪ ،‬ﺗﻬﺮان‪ ،‬ﻧﺸﺮ‬
‫ﺻﺎﺑﺮﻳﻦ‪ ،‬ﻛﺘﺎبﻫﺎي داﻧﻪ‪.1383 ،‬‬
‫ﻣﻌﻮﻧﺖ اﻣﺮ ﺑﻪ ﻣﻌﺮوﻓﻮ ﻧﻬﻲ از ﻣﻨﻜﺮ داﻳﺮه ﺗﺤﻘﻴﻖ و ﭘﮋوﻫﺶ‪ ،‬ﺧﺎﻧﻮاده‪،‬‬
‫ﭘﻴﺎﻣﺪﻫﺎي ﻓﻦآوري اﻃﻼﻋﺎت و ارﺗﺒﺎﻃﺎت )ﺗﻌﺎﻣﻼت ﻣﺠﺎزي(‪ ،‬وﻳﺮاﺳﺘﺔ‬
‫ﺳﻠﻴﻘﻪدار‪ ،‬آﻣﻨﻪ‪ ،‬ﻣﻌﺎوﻧﺖ اﻣﺮ ﺑﻪ ﻣﻌﺮوف و ﻧﻬﻲ از ﻣﻨﻜﺮ ﻧﻴﺮوي‬
‫ﻣﻘﺎوﻣﺖ ﺑﺴﻴﺞ‪.1386 ،‬‬
‫ﺑﻴﺎﻧﮕﺮد‪ ،‬اﺳﻤﺎﻋﻴﻞ‪ ،‬ﻓﺮزﻧﺪ ﻣﻦ و رﺳﺎﻧﻪ‪ ،‬ﺗﻬﺮان‪ ،‬رﻳﺎﺳﺖ ﺟﻤﻬﻮري‪،‬‬
‫ﻣﺮﻛﺰ اﻣﻮر زﻧﺎن و ﺧﺎﻧﻮاده‪.1387 ،‬‬
‫وارﺗﺰ‪ ،‬اﺳﺘﻔﺎن‪ ،‬اﻳﻨﺘﺮﻧﺖ و ﻧﺎﻫﻨﺠﺎريﻫﺎي اﺟﺘﻤﺎﻋﻲ آن‪ ،‬ﺗﺮﺟﻤﺔ‬
‫ﻣﺸﺎﻳﺦ‪ ،‬ﻣﺮﻳﻢ‪ ،‬ﺗﻬﺮان‪ ،‬ﺷﺮﻛﺖ ﺳﻬﺎﻣﻲ ﻛﺘﺎبﻫﺎي ﺟﻴﺒﻲ‪ :‬اﻣﻴﺮﻛﺒﻴﺮ‪،‬‬
‫‪.1385‬‬
‫ﺑﺮﺗﻮن‪ ،‬ﻓﻠﻴﭗ‪ ،‬آﻳﻴﻦ اﻳﻨﺘﺮﻧﺖ‪ :‬ﺗﻬﺪﻳﺪي ﺑﺮاي ﭘﻴﻮﻧﺪ اﺟﺘﻤﺎﻋﻲ؟‪ ،‬ﺗﺮﺟﻤﺔ‬
‫ﺳﺮﺣﺪي‪ ،‬ﻋﻠﻲ اﺻﻐﺮ‪ ،‬ﺟﻤﺸﻴﺪي‪ ،‬ن‪ ،‬ﺗﻬﺮان‪ ،‬اﻣﻴﺮﻛﺒﻴﺮ‪.1382 ،‬‬
‫ﻣﺘﻮاﺿﻊ‪ ،‬ﻣﺮﺗﻀﻲ‪ ،‬ﺷﻬﺮوﻧﺪ اﻟﻜﺘﺮوﻧﻴﻜﻲ ‪) e-Citizen‬ﺧﻮدآﻣﻮز‬
‫ﻣﻬﺎرتﻫﺎي زﻧﺪﮔﻲ ‪ ،(Online‬ﺗﻬﺮان‪ ،‬ﻣﻮﺳﺴﻪ ﻓﺮﻫﻨﮕﻲ ﻫﻨﺮي‬
‫دﻳﺒﺎﮔﺮان ﺗﻬﺮان‪.1385 ،‬‬
‫ﺳﺮور‪ ،‬اﺳﻔﻨﺪﻳﺎر‪" ،‬ﺧﺎﻧﻮاده در ﻛﻮﭼﻪ ﭘﺲ ﻛﻮﭼﻪﻫﺎي اﻳﻨﺘﺮﻧﺖ"‪ ،‬ﻣﺠﻠﻪ‬
‫ﭘﻴﺎم ‪ ،‬ﺳﺎل ‪ ،16‬ﺷﻤﺎره ‪ ،7‬ﺻﻔﺤﺎت ‪ 40‬ﺗﺎ ‪ ،49‬ﺗﻬﺮان‪.‬‬
‫اﺣﻤﺪي‪ ،‬ﺟﻤﺸﻴﺪ‪" ،‬اﻳﻨﺘﺮﻧﺖ ﻗﺎره ﺷﺸﻢ!"‪ ،‬ﻣﺠﻠﻪ ﭘﻴﻮﻧﺪ‪ ،‬ﻣﻬﺮ ‪،1386‬‬
‫ﺷﻤﺎره ‪ ،336‬ﺻﻔﺤﺎت ‪ 39‬ﺗﺎ ‪ ،44‬ﺗﻬﺮان‪.‬‬
‫ﻗﺎﺳﻤﻲ‪ ،‬ﻣﻬﺮي‪ ،‬ﻗﺪﻳﻤﻲ‪ ،‬اﻛﺮم‪" ،‬ﺗﻬﺪﻳﺪ ﻓﻨﺎوريﻫﺎي ارﺗﺒﺎﻃﻲ ﺑﺮ‬
‫ﺧﺎﻧﻮاده در ﻫﺰاره ﺳﻮم"‪ ،‬ﻣﺠﻤﻮﻋﻪ ﻣﻘﺎﻻت ﭼﺎﻟﺶ ﻫﺎي ﻓﺮاروي‬
‫ﺧﺎﻧﻮاده در ﻗﺮن ﺑﻴﺴﺖ و ﻳﻜﻢ‪ ،‬ﺻﻔﺤﺎت ‪ 43‬ﺗﺎ ‪.55‬‬
‫ ‪1N ; ,&% ; ,&K %7 %‬‬
‫@?‪.%00‬‬
‫ ‪,:% ; 1 1? %? Ni %7 %‬‬
‫‪.% ? 1N‬‬
‫ ‪ 60 1? 16& Ni EK % ­ N0‬‬
‫‪76 %K 7 M76 ;M I6B NP‬‬
‫‪The Second Conference on Electronic City‬‬
‫‪.%00? I6B‬‬
‫ ‪ 6: 60 1? %16I4 %7 % ¢¨ W‬‬
‫‪.%00? I6B 8'9 7 62P NP‬‬
‫ ‪.%" C ;&@ 1 E1 !9 % ©¤‬‬
‫ ©‪ c D ;4 1 = % ¤‬‬
‫
‪.%062E ;70 ;E‬‬
‫‪1455‬‬
The Second Conference on Electronic City
This page is intentionally left blank
1456
631(09188620879)
, 9
M$ 8; :2J –:$( n0K ,# %& ;%019 8'9 ‡6: I6B ; %6 1x B 60 76 N& ;N6KB 162E
7 B ,Q ;47 7 ;%/ 14E , @ A/ ,%7N& 'K 7 / 14E 1x C .%4 B /7 1/P 1x ,
,@E 1 0 1 .B ‡wI = + N2 / 7 > 0
W ; ; x 7 D2x :" 7 1/B .B ,x ;E) 7 S0 %00x @ ; ;
0 _# .%& ,Q@E %H 1x B ; 1 7 B ;%/ ,J 7 @ ; P7 A/ FE
12 .K 4 & e SP 1? E0 8@6P C> 7 JK C> 9 0 8'9
,3Q6BB 7 ,6 s7 1 ; ; ,R/ 7 ,x CN ;E1+%+ 1@P @> 7 JK C>
,0@9 ; ; K J*& ;E 7 JK C> , ,J ,x 4 .B w76w x 7 D2x
7 Q# I> 1 = 1x 2< & /h7 . %0E* 18 x 7 D2x 7 / 1 %0
.B : j '@ (8'9 JK C> s7 1) JK C> J
& 6: E;3"DB< .B 1/B A> ;6@x 8B ;1 ;E1w& ,4%00x%%N j ;N70
; ; %00x%%N 7 NE74 $B 8'9 ;70 I6B NB 7 8'9 ;70 1 N:* B Q627
;J6 ,# Q0E CPN 8@6P %K ,6x BB ;N6KB ,6x =& % EDB< .B
K k> .%& 1w& !9 O77%K 7 w76w ;Nw / 8@6P %K / %0
I> K 60B DP 6: 7 & % 6@x %& ( 0P 7 ;Q:" %6 1x B0
.C%0 P 7 60 8'9 % 7 DB0 7% 1 10 0 .%x
.1Q:" % 1& 8'9 JK C> 0
Q# 7 0 I> 7 =? CB 7 # `@
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.4 f6B 7 ;%NQ =60
F
;70 ,7
7 O624 8'9 < ,P @>
60 I6B NB 7 ,? , f0& 1 1P /& Bj'9 ;E1w& 1 AJ ; ;B62 7 8'9
D> 7 16 W
8B 1 JK C> 1 7
< 8'9 j0 7 4624 1x B > .BN67
kB JK C> @> NP ,@67 7 ,a
%& -6* ;E:x Q 7 DP 60 ;7
; < 1? & 6 Er 1 AB 70 .B ; BB 7 ;0 0 ? 9 1 .B
w76w x 7 D2x ,R/ CN 1+%+ 7 , W&"
, -6* 8'9 ;EC62B P7 DB 1 1? B
;7h > 7 ƒE ; =62 7 7%
P7 7 8'9 56& 8'9 1 7 ;EB6B
7 E %>7 7 1Bx ƒ 7% , 1w< B
N& E? 7 D2? 7 ,%7N& f2> 7 1# ;E
– @> 7 W&" # jh
1 ,%7N& 7 B M ,< , 7 ,% 1P M76
XE & 8@6P 7 'K D* C 7 f
DP K 1 Q ;B 76 ,? ,08
B 0 :0x7 60 !9 )* 7 < 8'9
1 8'9 1? % !# CN .B ?
/9 7 K ^K 8'9 ;NFF ;1/P E 1457
!> }Y.,2 ? 7 J*& @>}\ .J*& 8'9
% %0w: E 7 %> 1x 8'9 j E 1x B
,2 @@ C8
10P P7 C+8 .% K 1 1/P 0 7 'B
;1 ;E1w& I6B ”B NP ;E1w& V
K -6* ;E:x 0 wE
$B
I>) # }¦ :B x7 =w:6 0 1x %& 16I4
;EA7 7 E6 ;4w 7 .B 16KB 77
.Q#}§(@
%%" ƒ 0 1x 4 16 , x - W0
4 7 
7 )* ;E rI ;Q:" ; -6*
.B W
1 7 E1w& CB 8'9
,< D6 k> ,< @ 7 'B 2w 0/
,P E 7 8'9 ;: 10
E ;2 ƒ 1K 0 # x AV ,0/ .Q ;%/
;Eh =@#6 ,B Q ;2 7 B 3"
(A 18 XP ) %E% 1% ,< ;Q 0/ z*&
;N:* Q 4B 1 D+ 60 =H2 .%0? ;2
B !9 'V ƒ 1w k> %6 2x 0m@E 7
.%% G@ = ;J6 1P 8'9 ;7<
;B .(w 18 XP ) %0x DB 7 ,< 6@ ”&
, QIQ& ®%%"  B ; 1F4 70 D> 7 % h ,7% 2x 0/ %%" ƒ 0 Q
1P 0 R# E18 ;2  Cw 7 2
L:w ;Q ; ,< / 7 16 L7 ,< %%" ,< 6K
;Ix % 0W" DP ,< ,7 ;EI6B ”B x
.(: 1K 7 A h ,7% 'V ) Q
;7 1x ;2 'w: 1 1P .B %& 10 ,0/) 1w& ; ; %0E =w: BB x 7
;P > 7 e7 ,0/) E 7 (P C2P 7 %x
CHP j7 ;Q:" BB P7 ;Ix %
. B 0P BB % DB0
; ;47 7 ;%/ 14E 3 %0& (%x I6B 7 B j'9 ;E
O624 7 1x < 1 7%0 w 0  %0 FE W" ;
Q WF w 1 JK C> 60 624
S7 1m< %0FE Q ;B .BN< ;7E 7 !9
1 C /B 1 3 %& =% : k> =H2
0/ S7 8'9 7 B ,P ; ;
7 8'9 0 7 JK C> 1 B 7 =#
NI €# 1 8'9 %0FE 7) & 1x B
DB0 7% NP ) ;16 1 16K" 1w&
(% P7 8'9 P7 ,7% 7 A'6B 1 /h7 ;Q:" 1 1 7 CB x3 ;E1 10 7 16 r ; ; 8'9 K / & , 7% 0? DB0 ;EwE w ,08
0 _# 3 7 4 %%N ž/ N< 0
.C0?
.& 7
:" !& 7 1 7 16& 7h 8'9
>&
L Z1"=! : %08 ; ; %B 08 7 ,x 1w0 1
1B ƒE ^JK 1w0 1 1P 7 1w& 7 8'9
!> ?" 7 f@ 1< JK C>
= Q# 7 (w 7 C8 ) #  J08
162P ,a D> 7 %& 16K0& ; E ;
0 , 2 1 L7 ; 3 %& !# 7 J
-/ 70. %0B ! 1 %>7 -/ M B % 1626
Q# 7 # =62 B N< ƒE JK C>
;%0 C2 16B W& , JK C> -6*
:B ;7h N< ƒE
: ?
7 ,2 1 ,Q 7%# B6B}U. ,% N0 !> }T
}p.,2 1 16BK ;EB6B S A60? }t.,Q K 6KB ,N0" 7 Q#
1458
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1P 1x 4 16 0F , k % €# Q# 7 # 1I 7 ƒE  1x < 8'9 JK C>  X B w@ 8'9 ^JK
14E 1 2 ^*& ,< 9 1x 6/h7 0/ 0
0 2 ) 3 %& %& 16I4 W" XNI 1
B ,: 1 c 1x E 1 ,Q 7 7 ž/
,@ 8'9 JK C> 1@x zK XNI 1 8'9
.%00x J f2>
;72 N< 2 7 %& 7%0 , =x k 1 =H
L7 B S0 0/ 1 2w 8'9 JK C>
8'9 O" 7 =J# 14 E 1x > AV ,0/ .@
Q ;B 7 z*& ƒ 1 ^J6K 1x B E 1
JK C>  1x A> 8 ,%7N& /7 J*&
;E zJ* 7 D>J 14E ,Q S0 XNI 1
N< (Q#  ) 8'9 0  B ,: 8'9
,x ;x B 7 ,: S0 0m@E 7 K 1 00F
1 7 2 7
1 Gw8 w & )2# .B E 14 I7 ,@ D260 !9 6 7 @N AV ,08
;70 > 1x %@ ;% k D 0
8'9 0  (=6 ƒ )w 'V) z*& 1 ^K
7 (8'9) JK C> 7 0 9 7 8'9
JK C>  w (# ) & )2# z*&
*B P E 3 .%0& %>7 XNI ; 7 L6 e'
,< 1 /7 8'9 .&@ )2# z*& 8'9
, B 8'9 JK C>  7 7@ A XNI
.%& j0@ = 1 ,< ;: % )26 z*&
w  1x @8 1x 7 I4 *B 0 0 7 JK C> , W&" ; 1w0 16
;E ;: AV ,0/ .%0& ;Q  %&
10 7 ƒE SP 7 %0 > 7
C>  CE 1x B I* z*& ;E;@ 1 c
.C62E
,J NP z*& 0 CE 7 B7 8'9 JK
.B @  7 ( 0) J*& ;E ž/ ,%
JK C> @> ; 1x 0 1x 16 Q# 7 # 0/ 0 1I 7 CE* 4
E 0 i Q@P %& Sh7 ,%7N& 8'9
c0 ,< # 1x % CEK CQ a 1w& ^JK %E* 7h 7 ; 14%P 7% R¯ 7 %0&
Q ;B 7 2w ,< N D>J D* X%8 1
.&
=x 7 d# xx 1x ,< ;
X ;E10P 1 ž/ X%8
B S0 1 c0 ,< Q# 7 %0x ,<
, 62 3 .%& ,< 180@ ;E1> 1 77 E7I XNI K zK 0/ 8'9 XNI
7 16&% P7 8'9 JK C> 0 XNI
. & =J# 1x B NI 0/ 1 8'9 7 The Second Conference on Electronic City
.%006 Q%w
(w 7 ) # I> 1x I4 % 0 a0 1x I4 % Q# 0/ 0 Q !& ) .B 8'9 0 %00x N< Q# I> 7 8'9
J6* 6& (AJ) %" 7 , %0@%E X8 XNI
+ e' 7 F ƒ J*& 8'9 :R7 1w0 0/
%E* !# /7 XNI 1 1w& N< ,7% 1x %& 1w&
8'9 :( 7 : % B 8'9 7 16Q 1w& ,x6: Q 6B ,w 0/ 1 AJ ; .
,7% :V( 7 %: D>J ,7% J*&
6B = 1w& J6K ;EW* 1x B E 1
C> a0 .%0w N< L7 ”: 1 2x .B 1w& 0 %0 CE 6B ,w 7 %&
B a % 1@E W 1m< 8'9 JK
1x & => 1w& J 7 Q# A@x
+ 2w w .CH@ S E=x 7 RJ 1@E
L%E %& ž+  Q ;B 7 B w@
1459
7 7
1 B ^*& 1 D260 d# 7 /7 8'9
.8'9 # @
X 1w& !9 1x 9 E 1x I4 , S7 ;7 @ ,@ 0 7 .B AJ ;1w&E
9 Aw& 1@E w .B 9 8 4
e6I ,Q@E ;7 1 ,< ;7 %& 1h8 ;E 7 1w&
.%4@ 1w& !9
1@P ) 1w& EW* 1 77 ,x S0 7 @
7 %8 7% ; 1x C4 16 0F fB (....7 ;E f2> J*& ;E 60 ;EW*
:* , ^J6K 1w& 0 ; =x 7 X ,w XNI 1 1w& Q# Q ;B .B 3" )06P
7h _# 1 9 JK C> i A'6K 14E 7 %& 1w& 1 B6B
^K ;Ei 7 E4%m" 7 0 / €# 1 7 0 %00x =6* 8 1 ,x B6B 2 JK C> i X8 1x & a6 ,@ >
.%&
ƒ ; 1w& 0 7 Q# 1x I4 , 3
, 1x wwI 1x B ;7h 16w xr ," S0) B XNI ƒ 7 ( B6B ,w) XNI
1H @2 1w& 0 7 0 1 c _>
ƒ 1H X fB .%& ( + B6B
%&@ > 7 X@ 7 X , 7 ƒI0 0/ 1 %&
1 1w& 0 Q# 1I 1x I4 ,6 B -/
Q%w @H 7 C62 =/ > 7 Gw8 1w
, ,J 7 + B6B 14E ,< , ,J 0/
0 7 1w& 0 ,6 K 1 + .%062E
.%& B6B NP S I* D+ 7 @E .%Q%w X7
7 XR ; ;
B6B ,x K S0 x3 D 0 1x < ,
@E 16 )w =@8 1x & 1a>' 660 CHP 7
,x Q K B6B =N2 7 1w& ƒ c K 1
7 Q0E@E 7 B 0 7 1w& 0 
64 % 7 B 3" )06P 16 7 XR ;
. ”6 >
;%8 ; -6* =HR 1 0 @E ;E80@
1w& 0 1x A> 8 z*& =@8 1x ; 1@P
;34 %8 %0 1x B ; 1w& 0 3 1 , %& E 0  %0x 
@h 7 K E;< 7%> ,x CE B 7% 7
@8 ;6 660 ;E'x 660 B :x & =r
,< 0@ 1w& ,4% CE 7 %0B0: ,< D6 ;EP
, 7 ;Q J6K B 1 77 ) B ; .%00x => 2 ,0@9
;wK (7 , P X ; B ;7 j0@ D
(Q# 7 #) 0 XNI 7 , 2 ^JK A#0 .60 !9 E D* 660 =/P 660
12 J 4 I4 , JK C> 7 1w&
& )2# 1w& 0  N0 1x P7 ;
D2 7%0 , 2 %& 8'9 JK C> XNI
..C62B %00x =6* ;E1@> 7 660 BBP 7 rI =V
7 e7 1
0 1 E %& 16I4 1x @E .B 1/
7 0  N0 1x P7 ; = JK C> 7 %0& ; ; %x 1
0 1 1w&
7 1# ;E =J# =V .%0x@  1w& 0
(1w&) %x i 1w& 0 7 (e7) E i 8'9
.1w& I6B ,7% N< :6 , 7 ;Q J*&
.B
C> 1w& 0 XNI 12 J 1x w
)"E C=D "J9 $
7 , 1 1x I4 , %& 9 JK
1P .%0x DB X XP )w 7 0/
9 .%& ! ^JK 7 X@8 1/ D2 XNI
)w ; .%0x ƒ@x jh ‡ 1 % XP _V 1
0 9 0 3 7 ;1w& 9 B C8
_V ®%8 1x N< CN .%& S@P % =8 1B XP ƒ
9 JK C> 16 7 X8 ;1w& 9
% _8 Q .B 1 ®
Q %E =w: CE XP
.B 1w& 0 C8
; .& 1 %J ,< S 1 7 7 = ,%&
1460
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.%0& ) # 1 1w& 0 %00x 9
#)# *$%!"# $%$& '$( 8@6P ‘Q:" % B ;7h =8 , CHP /h7 ‘Q:" % CN ® % % %%& Q %P7 , = E 1 4 .4 r*
=2 CHP ;4P ; ,< ‘7 ;E1@ 1x % B
XP )w 7 0/ _V Q Sh 7 j@6P
N@62B DJ & /B 0 . x 1 A7
@E , DB 7 , .x ;4P
0/ 1w& 1 B6B ;NE4 ;7 ^K ;E1
)w ;E
%0&w 1FE ,%J6 . ;6:
,4%0E1H ;N@62B E)2 J*& ;Evx
Q , CE %00x ;7<S@P 1/P dB XP
f@ ‘ ,4%00x CN 1@E 7 ;1w& %K
% A> 8 %0FE .%0 B N< 1 2 %0EK
+ + ;E K AB 77 @
.4 % CHP WEx E
;7<S@P @E
D 1B ˆ %@8 E1 7 EC62B .& ;4P
7 CHP /h7 ;Q:" 1m< A> E 1
;7> E
.%062E N2x" 7 E6 :< ;E
:Tp{Z ;I) .B , ž/ ,4%
7 NP< I>
%0 fB 7 %062E + 8h 6BN
1H ,B0&XP ;B I6* ;E& 10 (U|U
:< ;E 7 E6 %0 N< / .%00x =@8 k
‡'x ‘47 ;E& 1 , N< CN 1x %&
;4P + ;N77 $ 0/ %00x =@8 1B ƒ
NF 74 1B N< 1x x & 2Q f0&XP
N77 7'8 7 %00x =@8 1B7 Q / %00x
: B .%0@ CE NP7K 7 NP< iI> .- :!9 XP )w 6KB &}T
1 B6B 7%# 7 A60x.) ˜XP ,
(+,- '$( ,%F . ˜, ,x L#0 .~ ˜XP ;N6/
%& 1Q:" X% ƒ 1w< W %& ;1w& a
.XP )w
=w& 7 1 X% .4 1P 4% €#
.BP = 2 7 0
The Second Conference on Electronic City
C62B ;7 E1 E
0. / + N77 .- :!9 , ;3"K W
}U
. ˜@B+ .~ ˜@B .) ˜NP7K 7
./9
1x h 6> ^*& ;1w& ;N6/ ‘x 7 %& DJ
L3> .- :!9 XP , 7 NP< 1rP WEx}p
f7 ‘B7 1 1x 9 % ,&%x 1#I ;7 ;N6 = .~ ˜A ;34'8.) ˜XP ;NP<
a  GvB .%00x $h %x ƒx N< ;7
.^K %8 Sh7 . ˜
Q1BB7
Q" # + !B B %
;E,B 1x 164 ~7 ;%> 1 ;B CP 7
% ( ;1w& a B xr ,& .%E
%& 1 ...7 "7 ,@" Xw> ;& ; 10 7 @ a # WN6/ %% x 1x & %EK
1 %/ 1 C6IE Q0x = ,B 1x < B x 4
18 1 ;7<S@P ; $ I* a C 1x 9,@E
;EwE 7 CP ^JK ;10/ D 9
.% ;14W" ( qE 7 7 x 1 CN6
.B 16& ,< 7 ;Q:"
1x N< s7 1 ;1w& °4 ;N# ;2 ,0x
% 0 a # B ,P 7 ,P : A
%00x7%# % 1 2 X% CN .%
1x % ;34( 8 1x B B6B ®%00xDB %0x@ K ,x / & 1Q:"
.7<@ P7 1 w& €# 7
1461
"K1
/ >6"E C=D "J9 "<! [- .
, B CHP /h7 ‘Q:" % x 9 1
:x B 74 NF 7+:% # 8'9( 7 )7 G" 1w& G" ,F I6* B B G"
E:x K 6> 7 B 164 =w& -6* ;E:x +
G" N % 1@P -1- / + 1 =r 1? B @ 7 7h M ,08 1 B
:C0? & ,< 1 J6* 9
347 ;1 'w: 1 SB W0x7 C 1 1Ii7 1 , B G" 7:" ;E:x 1@P .%x
# 2"3 = x .x & x 7 %0E "g F 12 w<
X , 7 SB E/ 1x 1Q@E B ; AB @E ;1 CP 1 $ UZZZ AB
,08 1 .B 10
ECx 7 SB %m" CP &
CP 1 ; ;1 'w: 1 SB W0x7 C
4
S 7 E7%# w
$# /7 ; AV
K B G" Q62 7 %0E .x ;B
0F B ; ˜%0x ,wN 7 , ;
1Ii7 %0E B G" .x Q0 UZZT AB
B ; ^K ;E4s7 = 1.% P7 w
S
7 8'9 ;wK + rI = B ; CP
, ;P Q ;B . %<x 1  %0E B G" . %0x 1 660 ;E'x
1 7 %0x a 1w& ;E/ 1x B @62B %0
1 ; UZZZ AB :x 1x B &
B $# 1 ;# 7 , ;Q6B 7 D/
. x DJ ;1 CP
.C4" B G"" @62B 0F 1 .v
+:% 8'9( # 2"3 6745 CP =x 1x B B %0F :x 7%# 7 B0& 1 %6 % B G"
dh7" .B %& a6 ;7 E4< 7/ ;1
6& X
62 .v B ; , ;
7 2 ;1 CP 1 7%# B ; CP 1x B
7 ;4rI ,0 $2 7 , ;1> EP7
G" .%9 K ^K 6K 7 2 ;7 E
7 B ; @8 16:" ;E
6& 0m@E
:x 8'9 ;70 ‘/B ®%:@4 A" ;1/ B
.B ;w@E %0 N
Ca ; A`2 a6 ;7 1x 16w 1 1P .B
B ; ®624 DB06 B G" / ‘0
7 =@8 w6 64 B % ,4 B 1/P ,B a G" %0< Rˆ @6> 7 B ,NP BB
‹
> 0 7 Ca `2 E ,% B / 1w .%& %EK =w: + ;E:x =
CP 1 ; % 16 .Q %N8 8@6P
:x ƒ 0/ P ‘0 ƒ 1 /7 ; ;EG"
.4 7% 162& 7 XR B ;
=@ dB 1F4 /7 ; ;EG" .B 7%#
;9 +$ '$( E:x $7 7 EBB S Rˆ @/ N< @ ;E/
77 ^K E/ fB & O' 0 ,x 7%# %E X B G" 1x Ex w.B
®B ‘@ .& ;4P 68 % f0& ^*&
.B B ; , / ‘0
K QP ,0x 7 16&34 1x B g734 ;4x 1 X%
!9 1x 660 ;Ef< 1x %& CE w ,0xCE
;N !> 2x N0 D 1 .B x I> 7 + rI f77 AB =V 1wK ;E/ 1 N<
=> 9 G" 1x & %0EK B C62B ƒ
/ 14E 7 B0& %" C>
;EX" AB
.%00x c ®g7 34 XR 68 D2x 7 B0&
7 AV ; .& 7%# %& 1 Ef< !9
DE3 G0P B fB B w@
; B G" xK 1 ƒ76w2" ;E7B
.%00x : ;77 ;EX" L3> 1462
The Second Conference on Electronic City
P7 =@ G" 7 % c Q%w
14 K % ;Q
;E1 ;4N 1x
;N6:" > 7 .& ;w ^K ;N:4
.%E WEx h/
.B 164 ;2
; E
I6B ,w 1x % A> B ;%0F 0 6: 1FE ; ; AV ,08 1
;Q
E ,x ,N0" N< . P7 ,
7'8 ;P 1 0/ .& I6B ƒ6 ;E&
WEx K B0& ,w ,:9 ‘ ;6#
; :Q ( C:F ‘w& 108 wB g734
= ‘Q:" % 1B 1 2 10
4 3 .%0E
.%B =%> 1 K Dh & I6B B0&
;N6 K , 0x 1x B K -/h
Q ®> 7 1 2 > % %B a 1
CE CE CHP Q K @ )w ‘0 XP )w
z 7 1 =%> 7 2 CE Aw& K % BB
.7<
:x & , ,< CN
7 2 P = B ; ;E> @ 1 2 }T
3
1 SP 16 1x }U .B 7%# 2 ,< ®I6B ,% 60 :x =/I 7 %%N %B a 1
@&1a# :" 1 B k 1Q:" ;E
Q
1x 60 .B %%" 60 ,@6I4
ƒ B w@ .& c B ; P ;N70
BB 7 Q0E 0 ; '9 6 CE 7 %%N CE %
= 0@ 7% ;E
;4N ,0x C62B
.B %& =% ;J6 7 BB : ; ;1B7 1 %&
%6 JJ*6 qE %B@ a 1 %& K / P7 X%8 7 12 QSP W ,%
ž/ ;70 %@ @ J*: % 0@
A@8 7 K ,< O7 @x> :x ;12 ;3Q6BB
;7 1 7 ,NP BB I ,
E ;K 7 ,<
.B 16& A 1 B 7 ; !'B
.& -:x ,< -/h c
7 1B0&x @8 ;3Q6BB 7 ;3"`2
c& :x @8 , X@ ;4N 7 Q B 1@E
6+>4<+ $%=- 67+<' , 60 /0 NB< 6@x 7 S0 6: !#
% 7I Q%w xx €# ;%> X% 7 8'9 rI ,x 7%2 " ,NP ;E:x 1@E .B
B CE 0 %00x A L%E ƒ 1x < ;4P ; 7 7% /B 7 %062E <
E
B%" >' 1x 14 ,@E .%&
.%NP ‘w& ”B ;N
%00x ‡ =+ ,N0" XNI ƒ E
%I 8'9 1 %& A> SP BB 1F4
^*& E E%00xf0& .4 z*: 7 B0& =+
1x B > 7 .4 % ,@ %B 7
,w N< 1 !9 7 %00x ,N0" B ; B2> % 1/P 8@6P 7 ;68 D*
X% .%v ;1w& / 1 6: C> %0E
.x ;4P X@
= E 1 1x *& x 9 1 ,xx 7 , ; s7 1
The Second Conference on Electronic City
,F % 76 N& 0 I> ; B XR
;E;34 ;34 K ;EE
1 K B0& 1w< B %0B %3"DB<
.%v ;1w& ;N6/ 1 %0 %0E% B ,
,0 1 c :E7s" ;Ee9 ; S0 56:
I6B 9 ;6# ; 6: ;Q
;E
!: , . 4 Q6K0& 7 ;34
%%P
16&
1 6 K ;E%x fB 0 .&
1F ;4 C@J %0 1R/ ?: 1 ,%7N&
6K 1x ;%x ‘B7 1 %J %4 7 & =%
? C> iI> % @ 1F 7 ;E
;2 7 j06 ;E
1IB6 .%0x :4
,< .%& B
P7 9 1 6B 7 0& ; B ; 1463
;BN :=V "A<% $& ; %" X7 16B
=J# ; ? =J# ,P ;7 ;70 :"
; P 7 ;3Q6BB E% ? M ;
P7 7 ,% ;J6 7 BB ( ,4?
7 =N2 7 D+ ,? 6 @62 / ;BCB
;E10 ;B , %K ; %0@7( ,%K
6:" 7 B ;6# % %0B 7 j7: ;EO
Q
. %E =: ;B CP O624 8@6P
18 (;) ;I?+ ;EP @h B ;6# 0
C62B = 1" ;E
X ;2 1x :x ;
CP 18 ;I? ;EP @h -*6 %K ,4%0E1H
7 E1B7 !9 660 7 ;x ;E
X 7 =8
;E/ WE? (+ ;6# ,4%00?%) ;B
I* ;NE !9 rI C & 1N PK ;N6x&
!: XP ) 0 I6B ;E 7 XP
# 7 &< L%E %6 60 1F4 . P7
,'x Q0E ;s6B r* XP j7 X'8 1 ,4%
7 9 w&
" ; ;Ex 7 O624
0/ * BB r* %%P Q0E S0
,0@9 Dh W
7h 1x B x %" 7 J*&
7 E * 7 @E ( I O624 ;%07
.B @ &7 W" W ,<
JK W* x: O3" 7 i ,
/
0 ;E
X % x& 64
1w0 DP 16w
x@4 &7 BB r* 60 S 7 ,x 7
=HB ,< ‘/& 1x B 0" ƒF x& 1w&
;E AB 7 N 7 , j0@ ƒs6B ;12 E:x ; ‘w& 0 12 .%&
r* Bj'9 BB r* 60 %K ;
1w& 0 ;Ng0w K< 1 % :x 0 ˜B
& &7 62 ,0x CE / )60 7 a ;N6BB
RJ# 1 Ng0w 1x < 7 & N
a ;E1B P ;E iI> A`2 1x
:x # 2 G" %062 ;%K = ;
X
;4P A`2 B 1F –2x :x ;J6 60
.%0@ / ,< 7 %Q B% CN
;E1B 0 W 7 w76w '@> ;Q" 7 ;Q:"
WF B 7 D/ _> ;1& 7 ;1 CP
180@ / 7 ;3Q6BB 6 B 1F –B @> 1 62 ;I? B H<. %& 1P A# 7
Ix a A`2 ,B X%x –B E A D/ 10 7 v N& 7 0a 7 % ;N< :x f6B = 7 %& % ;N6B ;6# 7 Q0E
@ ;@E 7 ,7/ ;0 2 CP @
;
1 a6 ;7 B G" @B GB (–B
. 4 = :? 0 7 @?> A 8
O624 z*: 67 !9 CP 1 ; B G"
7 ;" 0 SP ;s6B M ; %B a 1
G" %x :x c B 7 E,6B x B G"
 % 7 E
$B 62 => XP A60?
K 7 PK ,4%00x%%N 7 E27 B
164 ? 1 1 ,? $B ;6K 60 % ,m@E
B G" 1R/ 7 1E4< ;w@E 6N 7 B ;
% CP ;4P 7 60 % ;P 10 @h. &
.Q ;E:x .%& XQ@E ;g0 1/B
;E"
80 := " 34 ,7 ; %" 16B M
+94$ N2oZ :J% .2 J89 L$ .
Y["]
."7QG .
32
(8AO .<1$1Z B *$ I .^(D$ S% Y[)]
."7QQ .A, (
J( :C *;; :8$ cK$ .B0$ 3# Y[7]
."7Qp .
32 +94$ N2oZ :J% . :$;
;Q ^K I6B 7 ^K ,? ; EB6B
,4g7 %? BN ;B7%# 7 ;Q Ef< B BN
7 ;B4< ;E1 1N O7 L3> N 7
1 , E4< EK 7 ,? 1 ;EO<
;EC62B ;3" K ^JK 7 N6?&
.60 % ;4 1 ,< !: 7 ;1
1464
The Second Conference on Electronic City
:4 % X% 16B 7 B ; ;BCB ;
MZ e ( vZ 8R K :$; R :2oZ
egli
."7G".;R ' :88 %V$ < .^ MZ Y[)@]
' ' :88 < -81O .„2$ v Y[)H]
."7G7 .*9 ,
'$ ' < 3$ M \ .O; :(%K Y[)Q]
"7G@ .B8I J
'8( Z ^ 8AO C Z .B8I Y[)G]
."7G".:88 ' < 3$
'r; , H? ' < CR † .L Y[)p]
"7G" .B8I '
*8 A8; ‡; $Z :23C) :C 2
MO 3C Y[7t]
3C M$ K (... r =$ )t *+, vZ J ."7G@
.Q ( . R nC. (K J Y[7"]
The Second Conference on Electronic City
[32]-Sick, Gary. Middle East Studies Association Bulletin,
December, 1999.
[33]-Us Dept of State 2000. A National security Strategy for
a
new
centry,
2000.
[34]-Tehranian, Majid. Global Communication and
World Politics:
1465
+94$ N2oZ :J% .:=$ *$ 68$ J> ./$ Y[?]
."7QQ .
32
.:$; 2T :+( q3% .
J$ 1D$ Y[@]
."7QQ .D$ 8 n, L$
+94$ MT$ . 34$ 08 .
J$ 1D$ Y[H]
."7QH .D$ 8 2'; 00D%
:J% . :89 M=% :O8I (; .#$ (D$ Y[Q]
"7Qp . '+$
.CN F s(% . :==(9& .(K r$ Y[G]
."7Qp .2'; 00D% +94$ MT$ :J%
.:% '+$ :,BC <K .*CJ$ Y[p]
www.bashgah.net
u8;; :J & 2'; ; ! &8;9 Y["t]
'$=B :; 9 '(%. fe I *9 v0 3%
.egx w f ( <2MZ /; ';
B $R =C 5K *(K L F &=2 Y[""]
.mm w le81$ MZ J2oZ '=#$ :( 3 '(%
: J% / y> M3$ <8$ L '3 92 / Y[")]
. ejj w.lg J M$
8.J% :zz &1D$ '(% <1819%% *R2- ["7]
. ffm w. egjj J9> :% '+$ :BU <K }AK |3% {$- ["?]
: ~ v ' ' :(8 :IC :I0K
. eje w `8 'C lx&(J L y>
3$; ef/ :% '+$ ; :9 /, '- ["@]
.E h/ genevae/ doc/ g: WSIS; -: fxxg
:I0K J9>- :==(9 & :%c 1$ *8 &2 O- ["H]
lx &(J L y> ' '$=B :(8 :% . gk w `8 'C
8 '1;$ :% '+$ :; '+$ J>$ :1D$- ["Q]
. kk w lx / y> OR
:O 3% `0 '>2 '=, / ! F1- ["G]
: J%. !(2 J.. B <8$ 2C 6% $
. eik w lh / y> :; € :9 *+, <= 8 ~8!9 J 3 := :9- ["p]
. ik w lf / y> . (2 :;3 :C- [)t]
Z '(% '!3 '+$ uO *;; ~ - [)"]
. eee w f( <2MZ /; '; '$=B M
: <$ '(% '; 2
u8;;  ~$ F- [))]
. hg w (2 '; '$=B :(2
n0K *‚AK J A8; :3=4$ '( [)7]
(LJ> /;3% U$ '$2$ /8#
.eglj$hx
I ` 81 *8 *9 ƒ$ ƒ2 *1Z : [)?]
 :(= '$=B =MZ '(% '!3 uO
The Second Conference on Electronic City
This page is intentionally left blank
1466
'! ( ) '& %#$ ! " *+, -. /, 0
734(09126169158)ggggggggggggg
:(‚ 'Z
$ *% :;J$ [email protected]
Z &1K 3% *+$ %V$ J%
[email protected]
M
A@8 -6* ;E& 1 y A9 1x ;: 4% CN 7 BB 8h w @E XP ;Q:"
L%E NB 8'9 ;EC62B ‘/B 7 c 7 8'9 ;E;70 O624 1 1P .B %4
7 E
I6B 7 P 8'9 ;EM ;4 1? B ;7? 06 &7 B 7 1/ !#
j7 %6 G" !9 % @ -:? 7 B0& XP ;EQ 7 A% P ;E ,6 ;7? ;EC6Q
.%@ ;Q:" CHP j7 XP 10 ,< a W< 7 E7 ! A60? 7 ? 0W" XP
CEI 1 %6 3 %& / # 7 E7h ;7? ;N&7 7 EM0 EC6Q 1?< ;E/ 7 7 1 %/ @2 .B %& 16K" XP ;7? )FF 7 E
Eƒ0w ;7?
.B %& 16K" 2" ;E,B XP =# 1 c ;E
7 EO7 @E 1 > 164
;7? %0< XP ;7x ;E
XP -:x XP ;EQ XP ;7x S7 ;N0:" ;EwE .%E WEx ! ;E0W"
;EQ& 7 & 0m@E 7 XP ;EQ B0& 7 -:?
;Ix ;E& 1 =B N0 1/P W< 7 0 P ;E
I6B x
;E74 , ,
1Ii7 7 1w &@ !# XP j7 G"
7 DB0 ;4N ,6 !9 % B ;7? >
$& , XP j7 = Ex 64 W"
.@ ;Q:" XP j7 G" ,2 10N
.%@ O' ,< !#
XP j7 ;Q:" 1 ‡ ; A% 6N %&
The Second Conference on Electronic City
4 ;EO7 ;4w .B XP )w WEx 4%
;E18@ I* W -:? ; ; O' ,0?
l0E@E XP )w WEx ;E;` XP ;Q:"
.B %& L -6* ;E 16& # 1B7 1 ;E6 1x % N0:" A% ;E2` .%&
Q" W -:? %%P e' T|{Z ;EAB K7
ƒ XP )w NP DB0 6 P7 & 1wN
7 80J OE JJ*6 ;B ˆ /B 7 %& E WEx , 7 %& ^K , 7 ,w
Q" W ~*6B ? %0< W&" ; & ;4
.4 0 ,w ,< CHP WEx 1
N ;E=# ,< L%E 7 12 -/ 7% ;E
.4 I6B Š6
1467
;EM ;4w ;7 !# x@ 6& !9 XP j7 G& 1x B XP ;7x 7 8'9
NP 7 x -/ B ,< => /B 1x H2 X4 1> M ,08 1 ";7? " g7 10 ; .%H@ 2I d# 9 1 Š6 7 @ < O7x
AB $B 2I .%& W -:? %0<
16& P7 L%E dh7 , ƒ % ;7x 6N I6B
W -:? %0< 1? 0/ % %& 1H =& % T||t
.(Corporation , 1999)%&
=# fB v? 7 h ;EM0 18@ =&
=> M 6 ; ‹
Q" M P ;E
6% 6' A3 B C)
# ; => , 7 E %& -:? ;EQ fB
=w: ;B< 162E ;%/ X4 7 @E 1 X4 Q" W -:? Q / .%& %& -/ 12
EX4 B ;6: x 7 7 EX4 j@ .%0E
= ;EA% 7 EQ ˆ 6N 7 %I B B B0& %0<
6KB 7 ;B< ;w ;EX4 B w@ .%
W -:? %0 ;1> ;7? 1? B E CN
%B ;16w 1 B w@ 1> E 1x F %& 16& A%
1 B ;7? ^J* ;EC6Q =& 7 B
;B< ;EX4 .%:* N %& 1x
EA% 7 EQ A = B# († ;E7%# #
1 W -:x %0< X@ x 7 7 %|Z %\Z %
.%0? -:? E .%E ^J6K K
c 1? B E % %I ;Q a0 0 Kr Q" ƒ % & O7x %EK 1x ;
6/ 1> %0? - E 18@ M ,
1x EI6B 7 4%m" , % fB .&
6@N ;7? S7 .B %%P 7 CN = B
; SpreadSheet ƒ 7 @/ = ƒ & ,< B
E ,7 %I ;EQ ,< 1B7 1 1? B EO7
P B A@6> 1 .B x x
6K 8'9 7 %& 16K0& ,? K =%>
;E% 1x ;%%P ;E% B w@ 7'8 1 . 7 CN @@J N< fB %0E ,4=# 7 ,?
=R w .7
1 B %& 1B# P
.& r* E,B >
.B 14%P Q" ƒ I6B
%& w ;E 1x B ,< x ; Q =
N< 1 CN ; 1x E62P j B< 1 B w@
.%E% X B % C62B ƒ B w@ 1w0 K< =
4 *1W"( $
;7x %0< ;N4 CRISP-DM1 A% !9
: %08 W -:x NP
12 -/ }T
K 7I6 w
>9 ƒ @E 1 Q"
;7x 1 c Q" 6KB }U
.(Jeffery , 2004) @ Kr
;62P }p
69)1D A% 6KB }\
X%x 1w0 / 7 16 0W" E% 6@N B0&
A% }Y
.B 1> L%E %& %I %< B% ;E ƒ
Š67 A% KB }u
6;# F$ 6' 6;#E /1 ?@( NF .BA% KB = ;B< X4 K< 12 7 B CN W -:x 10W" ;%6 : P7 1> CN @2
E6 )*6 , K a L @6Q qE B CN ,7% .B
%E* 0m@E .%@ => 0`@ 16 %@ ,<
EB )*6 1 . Cross Industry Standard Process for Data Mining
1468
The Second Conference on Electronic City
;B A% ; 6KB < }t
s7 ,N < %0? 0W" 1? C@J K M . %0EK X P 0F %%P ;E6 6KB E6 =w& s7 1(> M I6B ; C6Q M B )*6
1x B ,< A% KB ;7< ; 12 6@N
;EC6Q I6B B @ %& WF M %
;EA% 1 62P ; .B ;w %0< ƒ x M C6Q E S7 .%& XR ? ,@E ;P NP -6*
.B =H2 => NP N< %0B 6 NP QP
W % C6Q 0m@E %0? % -6* 16
% & 164 DB0 A% ƒ ;62P 1x 1m<
.%0? % 16 j M
7 I6B K X 7 D8 1 6:4 1
E6 & I6B E 0W" C6Q .%0? 0W" ? ;E%7 7 EQ
I6B E ;EQ / ; .%0E %" ;E% j D+ ED .&
.%0x @0E 12 , N 6>
1x 1 ~6> ;7x A% W< 7 ;B<
7 A% ,x < ; w :& 162w& 74 7 =%> 1 .(Corporation, 1999)19 A% 2 NP ;Q
B %& % ;B 1'K - 1? , @8
~*6B N< 1 c - E18@ @B 1 E
#+) $H( G
,@E S7 2 ;7? O7 M , @8 .%0?
; .%& B 68 % 2 O7 ;1"
.(Hsinchun Chen)B ;7? M0 => 16
;N4s7 c Q627 S7 .%0? %" Q" M C6Q -6*
2 ƒ ,08 1 Q" ;% ,F x X
KB 7 7< ,< E 1 7 %3Q 0x Q"
.%H@0 I6B A%
1" 16224 6 %0F M .%0? 0W" Q" Q ;N4s7
F$ +) $( 1J( ';+ I
)*6 M ,< 1K& E 1? B 6K C@J K
7 @ ,< Š6 % A% ƒ KB %/
M ‹ 4 E 1 %E ,: EN0:" %/ M
19 =H2 ; R² @/ . dh ,< @E 0m@E
D2? ; ;8 J C@J K .%E W@ C@J
.%& Š6 CN ; ;%I 4%m" G ƒ ;%0
C@J K .& I6B ;4C@J a0 1 8'9
^K 16 M @B 1 :4 K 0 E0W"
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.( Annabathula.R,2007)& 1N
)"E 4 &>1-JU &V .
NP > XP ;7? ;EC6Q
c7: A@6> C6Q Naive Bayes ; .B CHP 1 c 8'9 ;EM ,7 A%
%0? ž 7 %0? 1B# 0W" = 7 ;77 ,6B
=# E ;18@ % C6Q M %6 A% M
.%062E =62 E,6B 1?
GvB .%0? 62P ? X ;E%7 7 ^K ;Q M 7
.%0? / 6 ,6B 7 c M ~*6B ;EA% ;E6" %0? I6B =# Š6
E0W" %0? M@? %6 ˜ %& => C6Q M 1? ~*6B ;EA% .%0? -/
.& 16KB yB"
- 1? B ,B4 C6Q M !" # .%0? 0W" AB ƒ ; CHP a6 %/ %
@ > E ; R@6> $% &'( ; J8 1& C6Q .%0? 1B# ;77 ;E4s7
.B %I %m" ;77 =#
1469
:Q ;E=& j %
;EW* 1QF %0? - 1? EW 18@ M .%& ;%074 ;1(> ;EG2 0P
M š> %0? - 1? E1&K 18@ M .%062E 1627 1QF Q"
.%00? I6B CHP Q =# 7 1w& 1 rI -:x
*<,-I &\*M! 3
Ef'x =K 1 X' ;%01&K ;Nw0w
XP ;EP , ‡6: ^K ;%0f'x
B'x ,7 E& =%> Vx%> ! 1: ;N4s7
-/ W" ;Ef'x =K N< 7 %0x %" 7I6
CP 1x 0a B0& %0 %0x ;%0 19 (intaclass)
/0 B0& Eƒ0w .%E ,B %&
E74 , z*: %0E X 1: ;E& 1 ;EQ ;0 Spam ;E=@
;18@ Eƒ0w .,w60P -6* ;E16B ,
w D+ EM0 .B %& I6B %06B JK
.%% X' ^J6K ; %& -/ W"
6KB 7 6K0& ,
% ;%0f'x %0x 0W" XP 1 W4 7
< 06 Concept space C6Q ,Q:E7s" K
.%E% WEx XP ;EP B0& ; ,
^*& %0) -6* ;Ew< 6KB c a0 1
%& -/ W" ;%0 1B'x 1@ ƒ 1 ƒ0w ,< 1F 4
I6B XP ;Ex ?K 1 (E7K 7 E,B
:< 7 =x O< 1 ;%0f'x B %0
.%00x
0W" # 7 %& C4 ;E ; 1P .? %EK 7%# 1 7 1 16& 12 String comparator ;N0w
7 %0x 12 Q" ; Ex ;16& ;E% 7
7 EW0x B0& %" =# ;Eƒ0w ;4 w
ƒ 0B 1# 7 ( CHP 1w&
CHP Q 7 :" XP 1B0% %0x ~*6B
.%0x =# 7 B0&
%0 Eƒ0w .%0x 1B# N< E&
1 % CHP ;%01&K Clustering Crime
;Ex 1@ @& 7 f< X = %0 8'9
9K 1 %0x < XP =# W* ƒ xK
16& %00x 12 %0 !# , %00x -:x 0P
.B %& 7%# B %& 1 1x ‹
B#
1 D+ Eƒ0w ,< %00x I6B 06 =# .% x@6 B#
kI X' 18@ 7 K Association rule mining
,08 1 EQ 7 %0x -:x Q" ƒ 6
EW ( Social network analysis) 8@6P 1w& =#
1 rI B0& Eƒ0w .%E ,: %8 ;2w
conceptual ) NI 1w& ƒ ;E4 , '/ 7
,x '/ !B Q627 %8 %& w 1w&
ƒ0w %0 !# , .%0x - (network
Nw0w %0 0m@E # .%0x ~*6B
P 0P ;EW 1x %00x I6B 1w& ƒ 6KB 1 '@> B0& 1 % w 1w& ,76 B0&
, Q6B" 7 8'9 G@ = +7 G@ = ;ERx
.%00x ƒ@x 1w&
> ;N: % 6: =# .%E e& EP
association rule mining=V Sequential pattern mining
w7 .%0x w&< 1w& ,7 E;3"DB< 7 E74
1x N:0x 18@ ƒ ;7 " " I 12B 7 K
!# , 4 %0x CE 0P ;E1w& ;J
1 rI B0& .%0x B0& B 6 kI -6* ;N
%0@ CE %00x ;%NQ x% ;N4s7 7 JK
, 1 N@ , rI ;EQ % w7 1w&
Chen, Chung, Jie,Gang %00x -:x 1w& > ,E
.%0x B0&
.(Wang, Chau, 2004)
%062E %I XP =# ,N0" ;EQ ;B w&<
8 7 N,4 1 0/ Š6 ,7< B% ;
)"E 0-
: 5
.C 16KB
=# ?K ;Eƒ0w I6B ; ; ;N&'
s7 % (Deviation detection) L# z*:
%>7 )FNF ƒ ,7% .B 16 w XP I6* j
I6B 7I E 1 f2# 1x 1/
$7 CN ^K . w N< ,@ I
1470
The Second Conference on Electronic City
D -:x ƒ0w %0 ,# 0m@E .%0x
D2> ;7x ;Eƒ0w ;@8 # .%E ,:
%0x ƒ@x !# , 1 % XP j ;N4s7 7 =#
;Eƒ0w 16B NF 0 .B x D =#
7 :4 %00x I6B Eƒ0w ,< ;( 9 1 Q6B" P ~*6B .Bx B0& XP ;7x
CHP 0W" 6> 7 > Ef< 'w: EQ
Eƒ0w 18@ ƒ 16B E .Q ;BJ 7 0W"
.%00x B0&
, AV ; .%E ,: XP =# K I6B ;
Tuscon G" ,B XP Q" ;%019 ;0 7 P ~*6B J8 1w& ;Eƒ0w %0 !#
0P ;E? ( 7 ,0a , T,p =& ˆ 1?
7 CHP Q6B" ;%01&K ;Eƒ0w .% w XP 0W"
1/B CHP ;7? ; ? )FNF ,0? T|uZ
.%062E ( 0W"
.B %& ,: ,< %& ,
(T) =& 1x %& 16 ;x ;EM0 $7 )FNF (T)=& %& 2 CP j 0P 7 %0@&E ;E=#
:==(9 & :=$ :=D$ ˆ4; (2 =D% < '8 ! 2~!% & P :(")!
AV 1B XP ;7? )FNF , dh A>
1? R/I 7 =/ 1m* Q627 %8 64 16 dh B %& I6B Coplink g7" 1? ;
,# .@ I6B 1w& 1 rI -:? , ,?
:CE
JK 1& M0 I6B %0 0m@E
%0< 1& 1 ;E 1@> 7 %00? B0& ,76
The Second Conference on Electronic City
:(Named-entity extraction) KL: D ML)# I
.%0@ A60? 7 B
16KB ;E N0 0P ;624 Q" Rˆ @/
;BJ 7 XP Q627 % 8@6P 1& =#
- ( %%& %04 %& -/ W" ;E% 1?
;EM0 %0 !# , .%0? =N2 XP Q
z*: ;EP ~*6B ;7? 1Ii7 7 .%0?
=# 1 c 'w: % x =62 ,44
1B N< =# 1? B G" (6B)#: ;EO
4
.%00x SI ^K XP
pY J J .B =w: ƒ ;Eƒ0w ;4w
< 7 XP =# @8 P )FNF ,<
%& )*6 phonix G" ,B %* ;E7 60B ;Nw0w %0 CHP j X@ %0@&E
=& 7 % %& 16& MF? L7> 7 % ˆ 62 1?
Chen, 4 %0@&E ;7? %%P ;EM0 7
M .% ;6B E6& 7 v ' E6& ;%/
.(Chung, Jie,Gang Wang, Chau, 2004)
M 1? AI P %00? ~*6B C62B %& e' 1*2
1471
%064 16& %00? 12 %6 .%? a L
7 E, ^*& ;EX B0& ;1> 1B O"
12 .%0? 12 ? IP E 1: ;E% a0 1 .%064 6K %0B M E,B
1: ;E % .4 % 16& 7 1: %00?
N ,< XP =# ;? ;E1 ; C62B O3"
1 ? 7 ? 1: ,7 M 7 %? A M 7 I
^*& ;EX ":%0x B0& P j Š0" %
.%? )2> *6 % NF ;7 B7% = ,08
JK 7 %* 1 c ;EX E7K Ef<
XB 7 1x %064 w 16 $2 0B 68 %6 ƒ
.%x I6B 2 ; E 7 O< ; E
-P X@ 6B J 7: 4<? M GvB ."
~*6B ,< .? B0& %06& !/ j Š0" ,< 1 1? E
7 3" , XP ;7? 1? ,: %< B% Š6
ut,T) ^*& X B0& K 1 %& N %00?
kI )r? I0 j 1? W< ;EK .B W* %
X 62 18@ (% {\,t) %* 7 (%
J*& ,08 1 $ ,@N6 1x HP %6
JK 7 (% \|,Y)E f< ; % ,@N -16B< O A/ @ 1x % %& E,B c
X' ,@E ; 7K . DB0 (% tY,{)^*&
M O624 ; 0 .%& O< 1> %< B% ;
X 16 .% % tu,{ 7 \T,t uu,| up,t D 1
6: % 16B< M %0< # ?K %0<
6 kI O
4 pY t N0 %: =# 7K
%0 , ;P ,2 M0 .%& )
%/6B 7 %6 Š6 . 7K š> 1 c
Q" ,0a M 1 c 1? P E ;E?
P ~*6B ;EM0 I6B 60B Exact match ;EM0 1> %00? B
&
4 10 1a>' ˆ JK ,: XP ;7? .&@ ! N< , D+
%& I6B ;K ;E1 ‰& 2 %& 1H 6B
O
4 pY N0 10 .% MUC-6 ;E :(criminal – network analysis)D S"&( I
&< 7 :< ;4w %? W< K 1/
7 E74 1? %0E 1/B E1& D+ ,N
;
e9 /7 ;7? ;? ;E1 1@ - X ,44 + / 1? 164 =& EC
.%00? C62B =x %?
1/ GvB 7 E1& = ;%? ;E8 7 E74
:(detective – identity detection) $. Q:)R I
,? =6* ; ;( ;s6B N< '/ ;EQ
6& J Ef< % y B D+ 0a
1'K UuU W< ;E .%0E 1/B E1&
Q" 44 ;E;77 0 .%0E G" ,2 1
CHP TYt 1? TUCSON G" ,B ;E 1(>
M B JK z*: jh 1? % E
.x x UZZU ;N6 T|{\ %& D
4 7 4 z*& ,< 1? ;16&34 š> O
4,0a
0P $7 ~*6B Concept – Space 7 M
-:? ;7? X7 1Ii7 .%0x =w: ,2 ; 6
0a @6> 1& M 7 %064 š> ;E 1'K
G" ,B Q" <D 0P JK ?K
N 7 $7 %& Co-Occurrence ,7 .%? f< 20P X = 8'9 =& 1? %& ,08 TUSCON
w 12B ;E16B .4 % ,2 š> (PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION) % - 7 ID Number @&
7 7 %0? MI E74 =K 1 1& %
%0 0P ;E? TUZ 6B J 7: 4<? .
-74 =/ ;EQ %x I6B 5 ;BA%
JK ;0 Q" CN6 tt 1? ? B0&
%? 1B# % x 0m@E .%00x B0& E
% y X ; B .K% 4 %0 0P
;%? ;E N 7 ,E = 74 E ;%? ;8
%? )*6 Q@E Q62: 1@ @& 7 f<
.%00? -:?
6/ C? ;E% Q 7 %0E ,: 0P JK
1472
The Second Conference on Electronic City
,? B0& B 8 ;7? XB 1Ii7 .%0E
A6 D ƒ 1x XML D P7K = ,: (U) =& FIMS2.0 ? ;@/ .B .B %& -E- 4 &'< 8
;7x ;E
1 =@ /B ,P K ;EAB 9
,x 6: .B %< P7 1 ;
X ;E E
X ; I6B wI ;7x ;E
X
1B Rˆ @/ ;7x ;E
X .%%& ,< I6B ,EK
(T .% x 1 ;7x I6B ; -6* O7
7 < I6B (p Q:" ;EA% I6B (U L:6x
.=#
I* ;EQ BE 62P %0<
L:6x
z*: ;%& / W" ®% qE ,7% E P
.%@
FIMS2.0 := (+$ :()) N
Q:" ;EA% 06 ;7x ;E
X 0W" ; %& -:x ƒ ƒ 1x EQ
Q" $ 8'9 %E P x 1 .%0x ;7< S@P SQL 6B 1B -6* ;E
X 1x %062E E%6 =& X 1#I f'x
%0B ~*6B ;EC6Q (p)=w& .% =/ x
.%E ,: 16 0" 7 ;7x
%0E P ,x 1 0W" ;EA% .%7 x 1 %0<
$B z*: 7 x 1 z*: ;E .& -:x X
; E %& ;EQ # ;EA% ;8 + / ; .7 x 1 ;8+ /
fB & 16K0& ;8 2 %6
.%& 16K0& L#0 7 ;8+
W* W& h> A> , ;7x ;E
X
z*: 7< .U E ;%016B .T x
E ;%074 .t ,z*: 0W" .p
.x C2 E $7 d: .Y 7 E ;%01&K .\
( FIMS)2"3 $ )1# T
T 28$ `U8 :(7)N
The Second Conference on Electronic City
%@ )*6 DB0 C6Q % 1#I x
9 1 C62B %0x )*6 @6Q 1F %% x 1m0F
C6Q 6N S0 ;7 x 7 1P D2> xK
X xK )*6 B 1B % %0x )*6 .(Annabathula 2007) .&
0P Q:< 1 22 (FIMS) ;
X XP ;EQ B0& + ;0P7 G"
7 ,0a XP) FIMS Q" %& Kr š> ;E
xQ 7 WVSPFL 1 .%0x ƒ@x ( 8'9
0P / 0W" 7 S0 6N ;N , ;P
.x ƒ@x w@
:%08 ;%x ;N4s7
" !K ;4 C6Q | XP ;Q B0& > CN ; 1@ ƒ P7K ;BJ 1473
,: C@J K & N0 .B ?K J
Crime Connect )1# T
% 7 2 EA% % 6> 1 E .%& c 8'9 ;3456& NP )7 06 C62B M
;%0 C20W" = E> N< 7 %0?
%0? M@? 2" 7  ;E,B 1 1? %& XP 1
@* 7 Classification ;%0f'x Segmentation
;E1+' 20P CHP I ^*& %0 K 8'9 B SP (Tool Kit) 162 M AC .%E 1/B Estimation
C62B .%3Q 56& 1 /7 ; + 7 @B
%0? P 16:" ;7? -i7 %E P E 1 1?
; ;1> XP Q" 62P , 0m@E
.%E 1/B %0@% C@J ,6:" ;EC62B 7
;E> B ;EC62B ,< 1B %0? CE ,B
CHP => G" ;E7 7 @ I6B 
CART 6% +<.U- GT
.%0E W
1? B )3P 2 C@J K 0 %0@% M
%0? CE ;62 M Crime Connect X S7 7 EQ 7 %0? B7 %m" 7 ‹
;EQ" 6>
1 c 8'9 %06 NB 7 82  ;E> W .%0? ;B%P 7 62P CN ;EQ627
$K 8'9 7 @ 7 Q" M =K 1 XP
easy-to-graps Q:" ;EA% % NP %& ~*6B
.%3Q 56& 1 S0 B @E
Profiling customers = E? ; & 164
;E Crime Connect C62B % 8 Gg< E
I6B”B 7 9 -:? Targeting direct mailing
AB 34 56& 1 EGg< B ;N NP K
.& 164 w ;EM2 % 7 ;68 ;E? % E .%00? 5" 7 E %0? =
(Xindong,Quinlan,Ghosh,Yang,Motoda,McLachlan,
Liu, Philip, Zhou, Steinbach, Hand, 2007).
Q j 1 2 =? 7 )K 2 17 O" M ) CART P7K AV ; . =# ;EM0
1'K &
4 7 6B 7 %& S@ ?K J
; &
4 7 6B ;6# 0m@E .%0E% W@
= , ;P B ;E%>7 7 ,2 X@ $B .B I6B
& I6B ;77 ƒ ,08 1 % (%& 0W"
7 J8 ;E1& ;EM0 0W" 6B 7 #
Crime Point Web +<.U- T
.%E N K ,B4
1 =N2 NP )7 06 ;
X => M
BRAINCEL -' IT
, N0 Crime Point % .B @8 0 7 , ;P
6> 1 1x B 7
=2x 1 ƒ BRAINCEL
.=> 8'9 1w 2 ;3456& 1 NP J8 ;E 1w& % E0W" 7 B I6B =
I6B = 6> 1 xK ;N# Dx $B
; < 7 h C8J8 1w& W .%0x =N2
=# 7 8'9 7 E % Crime Point Web B
,08 1 ˆ 1 x .2 1 I6B
.Q B 6: 1x x E .B %0@% 2 ,B< =2x %6B ,B4 6N %0x %E 1 1x BESTNET 10
4 ƒ
AC )1# T
% J8 6 1x E%%" / h A% D 7 %
- ;E10P 1@E 1? B %02" ? 7 %I C62B M
E O" ;EA7g %/ 7 E1R %/ 1 .%0x %"
NP E
SP 18@ M .%0? 6:" ;7?
. %EK 1R
.%0? CE ,? < 7 ;?B )*6 B6B
%%P 06 AC Knowledge Discovery Engine
Q:" ;EA% 1? B P606B ;EM0 7 Ng0
1474
The Second Conference on Electronic City
,4%0@ ; 8'9 % 7 =# 8'9 ;3456&
s7 š> 1 c ;E1@ =# NP w x BrainMaker +<.U- TT
;0P7 G" 0P Q:< S7 .B x CE
%E P 1 BrainMaker J8 1w& X
% C62B) FIMS X 1 ;
X ƒ +
O7 7 0W" x 7 D2x ; N< wI6 &
A ;4w 1x B x I6B (0P 8'9
7%# ,< 1h8 % 1x J ;Rx %N/ ;P
%@ =# XP ;E % ;7x ;EC6Q 7 <
z*: Q B0& %0< 0W" %0< ;E %&
=w: @2 1B FIMS X .7< B% 0 Š6 7
P X .%00x I6B ,< ..7 Š6 0W" D8
;BJ 7 ;7x š> < : %08 1x B %&
1x ;1w& ƒ 6> 1 7 x I> 1w& ;4 %E
7 1H , ;P x 1 š> < ƒ@x .
1 :6 C6Q .x %" B %& 2 *
@0E š> A60x 7 B 1 c ;4C@J ,<
7 1w& :" w4 1 7 %0x I6B D8
.%0x
/ 1 .%E ,: K 1 ,< ;4 QQF
E 1x B # A% ƒ KB ;
.%0x ƒ@x # 7 ,
%E P x 1 .@ ;7<S@P -6* A7%P
SQL 6B 1B -6* ;E Q" $ 8'9
CrimeStat III +<.U- VT
.%0x ;7< S@P
-, B0& 7 =# 7 1
NP ;%/ 1B ;< 1 M
XP ;EQ B0& % 0m@E
# Ned Levine & Associate$B 1? B XP š> ;E
7 ,0a XP) FIMS Q" %& Kr š> 12B %6B ! 2002_IJ_CX_0007 6
;0P7 G" 0P Q:< 1 ( 8'9
Windows 06 1 .B 16 1/B ;624
, ;P xQ 7 WVSPFL 1 .%0x ƒ@x +
@ ;< ;E
1 .B GIS 06 EX
ƒ@x w@ 0P / 0W" 7 S0 6N ; N 0P ;624 ,# 7 , ;P ,4%0@ 1 M@? NP
.x %EK
;%/ $B C62B .%0? CE XP &Q 7 0P ;624 0m@E 7 N& L9 G" ;NB
UD XY & #+' 6R V
-, 1 ;E;77 .B ;N A> ,# Q
1 % ;7x ƒ0w 1QF %0x B W* 7 ASCII'shp ''dbf' (; ;E,)š> ;E
OE .%0x ƒ@x XP 10# B 7 !# , x
- 1B# (;%/ 1B) B ;E< j .B ODBC
ƒ ,08 1 (DNA B0& E:Q ( %0) Atlas Map Info Arc view 4 J Š6 7 %0?
SB7 -9 ƒ -:x 7 !# ; ƒ0w %6B
Arc view ;%/1B =# 7 E7%07 ; Suffer * GISIM
CHP X@ Nor thamptonshire G" . @E XP j
.(Annabathula, 2007) %E W@
,6:" W* .x ( Oracle ;1 Q" M ,7
The Second Conference on Electronic City
S 1@E % 7 ( Trak-X v? C62B @8
ƒ $B 7 %& >9 K J Trak-x) ? I6B
.( 16 1/B X %0&7
UZZ\ 1H7g CE 7 UZZZ 1g Cw XP 7 C1
BA C?9 &
/ CI"< 4 ]
- ;EM0 7 EO7 E:? K 10 1 1P %? I6B XP j7 ;Q:" 7 0W" a0 1 ;7?
& & ,< K 1 J6K 1 W* X+ E 18@ . %& I6B :< e9 ;
XP ;E10# $ ; / x tu,upZ %%&
5 W S"&( 6R V
7 B ; ;N@6KB ; 1K ; .%00? %
P7 , ;P x |ZZ ˆ7%> + ;0P7 .B + ;0P7 )0P x w WVSPFL 1x
1475
7 ,B ;B ? ,< .%7< B% B )*6 = %0F 1 CHP j NF .E7K ;
; SMART ,08 # X ƒ /0
: %&
1B 16 .%0x ;B " ,B ,< (1SSDM) ,4C@J
XP ;E 10# ; %/ W< NP %/6B %06 1/B !90 ;7h ;Ex 0m@E 7 G" ;E7 D+ ; ;%x CHP N< .%062E UK :x 7
Q" ;w ;E B0& }T
%062E "recidivist"CHP %00xw 1@ 9 1 =& x –x 7 D2x ;E74 !# 7 62P }U
1 W< ; XP 10# %< B% ;N6:Q (
%& 2I 7 A6 O" W"
} XP Q" ƒ w B 7 !# }p
.B 2I 7 ;7x A6 O" W" =& x
.% %01'8 w ;E%%" 1 G" ;E7 9 C62 I6B NP E
Eg7" ,< 7 16 ( OATLEY, 2002) .% 1/B ;7x ;E%0<
7 %& xr Sparks $B %6 ,%& 7 XNI
6 kI XP 1ƒ ,< 1x E,w 1x B0/ %
%6I kI XP ,< 7 1x A@6> DB06 9 1 %&
74 t w 1 Š6 ,JJ*6 7 %& AB ;Q:Q
:%@ ;%0 16B
1 E :Q( X%wmE Ix :(Insufficient) B }T
P7 /7 "F Gw8 x % 1 2 )K x %
.%: ;%0 16B %
1 , 1x 6:Q ( :(Eliminated) %& L3> }U
. 2 % XP 10# 1 B6B 1x ;
J*& ƒ 1x 6:Q ( :(Matched) 16 ! }p
.%& ! B %& ( (Ident1) Q" 1x
7 7 U{ %/ ,%& % 7 A@6> AV ;
>' 1x N6:Q ( :(Outstanding) %: 7 }t
WEx ( Y G") /9 dB 2 1x ;
%& ( z*& ƒ % ,%& ;%019 ; x
Cx Wilbert 7 Inglis Ewart X ;B< G" .%
.%&@ ! (Iden1)
ƒ ,%& 7 7 " " ; 1 ,%&
.%x ( ƒ
K-means a + ;4 ;%01&K C6Q ƒ GvB
;%01&K a + ;4 .%0x A% %& I6B
1 ,
@E 1P 1 =# 6N 1x 4 16 Peas
/9 ;E;%074 E1&K C62B 7 % P7 d 7 . XP Dw 8'9 7 ,w ,x #
1@ a + ;4 .2 ;77 ;EQ ;N8 %0x x # G" ;7 H
P W* ;E6 18@ ƒ ,08 1 (Input object) ;77 ³&
;7x 7 vx ;BA% I6B 7 %0x P ( Bell 7 2006) . x 7 B J
2x ,%& 7 A@6> < %00x / %x W&x
- ! %0 !# , 1x ,: E16
, B $K 8h 0m@E –K P7 XP ƒ CE .%00x ;7<S@P XP 10# N6:Q ( 7 DNA ,&
XP w A@6> 1F 1? %? %E: 7 %? A ƒ X%x ,: 0W" N< 0F
G" S0 % @B 1 0&7 1 _> .& Cx
1H ;E1@ ;7<S@P 6N XP ;E10#
.%& D/:0
.%% c N< > 1w> x %EK
6;$- ( W 6R V
Z$ -'Y +' 6R V
ƒ 7 zJ*6 ƒ ,08 1 Colleen McCue 1x ,0m@E
x) %0%B Q: x@6 # 74 ƒ
,B XP =# %>7 g7" %) VA G" !B 2
I6B %< B% 6/0 (! = ;N@62B
1x 90 16:" B# ;70 /7 ;
x
1. SMART Software for Decision Makers
Q" W L:6x 7 %0@&E A60x / a =&
1476
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.(Oatley , MacIntyre , EWART, and Mugambi)
1#2 '@> 1 c B ƒ %0
A@6> ƒ 1 1627
1x ;7x":%@ ,08 ( Richmond ˜VA G"
$B I6B ; 1: ƒ Š6 GvB .x z*: W L:6x ƒ & w w6x XP =#
.% O624 w6x %>7 7 :4 ;E7
%0x B 8B SP ;E 18@ % 1x 2E
%062E CE 1: "R ;Nw2" !90 1x ,: Š6
D 1 jh 1x %0x 1N E6 ,x 1< ƒ 7
%& S P 1@E ,2w J 1#2 ;E; 74 ƒ 6> N0 1 4=# ƒ 1x 1m< B ƒ 1 ˆ 7
1#2 ;EB %& z*: ;E1> .2
- B 6B 7 ‡6: 74 #
%0
A@6> ƒ 1 N< 1w 1627 16 W
1P
.(McCue,2003)"%0x
XP 2 %2 ! ;EL'6K 16 .% 1627
7 J8 ;E 1w& 7 XP ; 1: ;E
7'8
R ƒ2 !90 .x z*: ;%P %%N A@6> 7
I6B %" =# ;E=> e9 ;E;g0w 7 0W›
/ .%%& N& ;6wFx P !90 =&
,B AV ; .%7< CE ,2 ; & 4% %%&
;E%>7 O624 7 :4 W
,w KK !90
-ƒ0w Colleen McCue 6B # (Richmond)VA G"
.%4 CE %0@%E 1 x K , ƒ w6x
,< .x P ;2 ;x ;E1 7 ;7x ;E
;4C@J 1x %0x CE E;s6B ;7 S0
š> w RTI 7 SPSS ;E
@ ,B
%0E W
( J 7 %00x =N2 %8 D& ;% š> 7 %0x 0W" I ;%
; O , ;P ;EGg< ; 1x @x S0
WEx = AB W %tu N& ,< UZZp AB
.(MCCUE.C, 2003) CE O624
.(Leon , 2005)
1 N< ;Eƒ0w 7 C@J K ;E=# ;4w
<E -:
HD 6R IV
A9 / ,< ;6: 8B x ƒ@x ,2
% ! ;EA% 7 80J OE ;70 ;4
C# Q O' .%E ,: W0x7 # , 8B t{
7 E4< .& 164 w %0< I 0W" % 1/B
William Pottenger $B Pennsylvania 20" 7 Bethlehem
6 %0EK kI %0< R² @6> 1x (> ^JK W0
D-Hotm 1x 1/B > ƒ 7 %& 1H Lehigh Q: - , ;P , 1 ;1> 7 I J#0 ƒ
.Distributed Higher-Order Text Mining ; -I* ƒ .%& %
, ,: 1x B dh7 .%0E ,: W0x7 SB J %E
KB ,7% 06 x K =% N< C62B @2 ƒ
2 8@6P €# CP ;1> ;Eƒ6x
,B 1? x CE 16 KB Q" ƒ =K 1
.B ( 7 %I
.%& 2 N< # %>7 C# G"
64
7 EQ: # x EM0 16&34 A 7 C62B ; % 1Fvw 1w& ,< 7'8
E
,0x ;J# J A% ;EGg<
1/B ;
x ;% EQ: $B (Finder) .%062E f6B = J*& ;Evx Desktop $#
% =K Gg< TUZ W B 1x %&
The Second Conference on Electronic City
;EA60x a0 1 ;70 07 G" ,B
.(Nichols.L.J, 2004) %0x l0E@E
=x ,6B OK ;E1a 7 x I6B #
g7" ,08 # 07 & W* %#6 R
-&"1 67Y# 6R GV
PSN g7" .&34 ‡6& 1 ,@E 7 PSN #
@E 1#2 ;N6B 1w % ! ,B0&? 6:
-=# 7 ;7x #7 1 :* ,08 1
.B CK7 1 7 2K Q< B ‡K ;ECPN
1 c <:K CHP 1 ,x 4%B 14W" ;E
; ƒ 0P7 ˜%@m 1#2 B 0
‡ x e& S7 w7 .x I6B ;% .%00x 7%# 1#2 ;E:K %x W< @6>
g7" .x CE <:K CHP 0W" 7
;E6x 1x % 1/B A% ƒ SPSS Clementine I6B
1477
? 7 ? 4 west Midland G" UZZZAB
7 %00x 0W" %0< š> %& I6B EA%
Q: ,B0:7 E74 7 ! = ;EC62B
;4P <:K CHP G" < - 7 ;4
A60? 7 1 ,? M@? L%E .4 Sunderland
.(Nichols.L.J,2004)%00x
-C62B ;4 ( BDH) 2 A0 ; XP ,
1
N< 1 1? & ;
X 1 G" . C@J 6:" ;E
)1+( [ 6R TV
:%0? M@? 7 FBICIA ;NB 6vB TT 627 1@> G"
;4P 7 -:? ;E: $K ; S0 L%E }T
( 2 %00?
=0B" ,6 1(> M CN ,? B0& }U
% W
, <? 7 %E
1? EC62B >9 8'9 ,? CE }p
8'9 7 (XP 10# 8'9) X 7 () *B
.%0? G" ;%0@&E
PK 7 K 8'9 %064 C@J A% ;N2< Q
'@> %06 %00x ;7<S@P 0 > 1 c
Q DP N&' .%00x ;4P 627
K >  CHP ! 1 %4 # ;N
.%00x A60x 8'9 ;7<4 ;NB 7 , , X@ WF
=# %0
,
, ( 7 %%& 1P ,< 1x
0 C@J 6:" ;EM0 ;1/B Over g7"
=w: D+ %m" ;E1`9 ,@ => AV ,0/ .B XP
;N0 7 < ;7? 7 7 B0:7 QFv" ,"
7 P a % 0a 8'9 %062E
.%& v? C8 @8
0m@E .%& 7I6 R9 ;E7 4624
(OATLEY. G, EWART. B and ZELEZNIKOW. J ,2006).
7 1w& ƒ %& *B % ; CHP z*:
g7" %& I6B ;7? ;EM0 j0
%0x % ; % %& w $K ;E W0x
-=# ;%01&K J8 1& Q6B" %8 7 ;%0f'x)
d: + ;E/ wFx W* ƒ N0 1x
jh =R Bayesian belief nets ;E1& 7 ” ;E
.%0x
-:? G" (0 21 7 B0& 62E #
O< % 1x !# , ; > ;7x -/h L:6? œ M 2 A0 ; ,08 1 %0& Q" W L:6x 7 =# >
.? @>
%0 Evx .B e ( 7 SB %0@% ƒ
; , 7 %00x O" 1( %0F =@/6B ,
E
6;9 HD 6R \V
.%00x Kr
CHP -:x 0m@E .%& 7I6 R9 ;E7
F; ; Y# 6R VV
;EW0x 7 ‰& 1w& ƒ %& *B % ;
# ”?& 7 UK G" ; %N/ _8 ;E
N0 1x %0x % ; % %& w K ,7
E: $K 7 X% @a 7 XP 0 NP %4
.%0x d: + ;E/ wFx W*
=# 7 &Q ;2 %I 1B7 M E0 0
1x 0P !# , 1x %E 1H %0@% ƒ ;7x
.(McMullan & Radcliff UZZT) %00? CE XP
-=# ,08 1 B %0& O< % B w@
( 7 82 ‹
;E Q" L:6x ,4
(xx) ;% 7 DJ ;E10
E 7'8 .%0@ =#
Sunderland west =& UK G" ;7 1B 3
.%? j7& ? West Midland Cleveland
1@E W West Midland police (wmp) 1? < ;@E M !9 3 B 16 %& 1@E W 7 %%P
1 . burglary from a dwelling house
Over g7" .%& j7& x %& % OVER g7" 1x 17
1478
The Second Conference on Electronic City
4624 7 P a % 0a 8'9
;Nw0w 7 GIS ƒ@x 1 :E ;BJ ,w }U
Evx .B =0B" O< 7 X%*6B 6@x D+ X
S 0m@E 7 ‡K 7 K 1(> c , ;7x
6& ž/ 6@x 2 !# , 1 2 0m@E
1 XP j 7 ,w 20P B D2> XP ;P
,# .%00x x R9 ;N68B 1x N< ˆ J* %062E
X7
7% ,B ;s6B 7 W@ @
7 Tuscon G" ,B ;w@E Arizona Q:
. jh %E 1 A: T||u %/ Phoeni
;Eƒ0w ƒ@x 1 :E 2 C> =# }p
.(OATLEY, EWART and ZELEZNIKOW ,2006)%062E
8'9 ;Eƒ P ,7 ;E , ;7x
64 ƒ@x ,7% 7 6B 1 x 1x @ =#
.%& , 7 & 7 *B ;7x ;Eƒ0w
" ^
; 10
E SP 7 %062E 8@6P ;0E M CHP
...7 }t
N67 ;EL%E 6@N .%" ,< -6* ;E14 1
1x B 7 XP ;7x 1 E% N6 0x ;E , %<x 0P BB ƒ ;4w
: %08 N< K
K 7 XP j7 /h7 ;Q:" XP )w
(%: WR") -V? 7 ‰& ;E P7 }T
;Eƒ0w 7 EO7 2" ;E,B 6B .B
N ;7x ;E
;N '
ˆ @8 8'9 ƒ
(...7 162 % ;N07 G" ;E7 W
) %0 I6*
.B
.%x I6B
1x B ;7x ;EC6Q I6B a0 1 }U
.%0& % > JJ* ;EO< -ƒ 7 E,B 8'9 ;70 O624 7 1/B %0@% ;
X ƒ ,08 1 ;7x 8'9 ;E
1 c0 /7 ; ;7x ;Nw0w I6B }p
G" ;E,B 6K %<x 7 10
E Cx D 1 7
Š6 ,< 12 7 EQ:< $# %m" ;N62 X
XP ;EQ , ;7x I6B .B 164
% NP K ,B0&x $B 6B 1 %& ~*6B
;Q:" ,< j7 7 x 0W" CHP x B0&
.%& Eƒ0w 0W" 7 #
.@
Q -:x ; N0 1 C6Q ƒ Rˆ @/ 1x < }t
x 1 XP ;E =# ; I6* ;E
C6Q %0F 7 x J B %&@ x
Crime CART %08 N< K 1x B %& 164
x 1x %& 0W" 7 # W
;
AC BRAINCEL Crime Point Web Connect
.B ,
.CrimeStat III BrainMaker
The Second Conference on Electronic City
)FNF ƒ 1x B E
I6B ; ;E"
;EA% 1 ,6 @ 9 ;7x ;E%0< /
1- Annabathula.R (2007). " A WEB-BASED
TOOL
FOR
ANALYSIS
OF
CRIME
LABORATORY DATA"
2- Bell. C. (2006)." Concepts and possibilities in
forensic intelligence "
3- Canhoto.A.I(2007)." Profiling behaviour: the
social construction of
categories in the detection
of financial Crime"
4- Castro.V.E and Lee.I."Data Mining Techniques
for Autonomous Exploration of Large Volumes of
Geo-referenced Crime Data"
5- Chen. H, Chung. W , Jie. J,Gang Wang Yi Qin
Xu.G.W , Chau. M." Crime Data Mining:A General
Framework and Some Examples"
8'9 ;Nw 16K0& ;EQ -:x 7 CP ; !
1479
%<x 7 ( J % G" D % . B
A60x 7 1 %6 7 164 w !90 K ;E7
.v K iI#6B >
; ;7x %& & = ;E@2 1x @E
: %08 N< K 1x %& w 7 E
;7x ;E 6@N :E c -:x }T
1x %& 8'9 ƒ 16K0& 9 -:x 7 B0&
.B w@ + ˆ ,x ; ,< ,7< B 1
6- Corporation. T.C(1999) " Introduction to Data
Mining and Knowledge Discovery "
7- Jeffery W. Seifer.(2004). " Analyst in
information science and Technology Policy, Data
Mining: An Overview"
8- Giles. C. Oatleya, Brian W. Ewart. (2003). "
Crimes analysis software: ‘pins in maps’, clustering
and Bayes net prediction"
9- Han.J, and Kamber.M.(2001)" Data Mining:
Concepts and Techniques"
10- Havenstein H(2006) " Data Analysis May Help
LAPD Fight Terrorism "
11- Hoffman. T. (2007). " CASE CRACKERS "
12Keogh.E,
Lonardi.S,
Ratanamahatana.
C.A.(2005)." Towards Parameter-Free Data Mining "
13- Lawlor.M. (2007)." Smart Companies Dig
Data"
14- Li. S. T , Tsai1.F.C, Kuo.S.C, Cheng.Y.C." A
Knowledge Discovery Approach to Supporting
Crime Prevention"
15- MCCUE.C. (2003). "Data mining and crime
analysis in the Richmond "
16- Oatley.G , MacIntyre.J , EWART.B,
Mugambi.E." SMART Software for decision
makers KDD experience "
17- OATLEY. G, EWART. B and ZELEZNIKOW.
J (2006). " Decision support systems for police:
Lessons from the application of data mining
techniques to ‘‘soft’’ forensic vidence "
18- OHM. P.(2008)"The Olmsteadian Seizure
Clause: The Fourth Amendment and The Seizure of
Intangible Property Police Department"
19- REPORT (1998)."Data mining makes its mark
at the scene of the crime"
The Second Conference on Electronic City
20- Seifert.J.W.(2004) "Analyst in information science
and Technology Policy, Data Mining: An Overview "
21- Xindong.W, Kumar.V, Quinlan.J.R, Ghosh.J.
Yang.Q. Motoda.H, McLachlan.G.J, Ng.A, Liu.B, Philip
S. Yu, Zhou.Z. Steinbach.M. Hand.D.J,(2007)." Top 10
algorithms in data mining"
1480
%6
? C_1
!"/
860(09124269862)
:K:= 3T:=
A+ :38#$
J% J 2 :2 $;
J% J ' '1;$
: M
'K %%P =H2 ,%<%%" 7 Evx Ni G" 1x B k'K %%P ;E1K& 8'9 7 vx k'K
@& 1 ;x k'K ;1K& , 0/ 624 1 «8'9 7 vx k'K» .B %< P 8@6P
k'K» 7%# 7 ^K e' ." 9 7 8'9 ;70 'K 7 8@6P (< =# 7 B 1 1x 7<
$B  k'K 6x k'K 4B =V + 60B ;E1a x 1 & ; ˆ @8 «vx
« vx k'K » .%4 x 1 ;vx ;E1w& 7 vx $ 'K =H2 ;1> ,2
w@8 ;E%6B 7 'K ;E=@/6B vx ,JJ*6 ,< 1x B ;1> k'K 8 i 0m@E
; «60 k'K» 7 «B k'K » =V ;Q 708 L .%4 x 1 ,&zJ* > 162&
.7 x1 %" 60 1x vx k'K -6* P7 1 &
La9
The Second Conference on Electronic City
=+: :16KB ,44 ;Q@:F # 1 > -6* P7 «8'9 )'» ,NP ;E:x ;2 7 V ( (ITC )9 7 8'9 ;70 I4 , 16 .+ 7 4B = 7 =@> 0 w&
"
.B 16& }7 $7 7 BB ;E;< =+: &< 2 $7 4K > 8@6P > I0
=# 7 B 1 1x 7< @& 1 ;x k'K ;1K& , 0/ 624 1 «8'9 7 vx k'K»
7 C" ;x k'K > B 1 16& ." 9 7 8'9 ;70 'K 7 8@6P (<
.x CEK & > 8h 7 =H2 K 1 ;E,P 7 _# * ‘0:" ‘H @h
k'K 4B =V + 60B ;E1a x 1 & ; ˆ @8 «vx k'K» 7%# 7 ^K e'
x 1 ;vx ;E1w& 7 vx $ 'K =H2 ;1> ,2 $B  k'K 6x
;E=@/6B vx ,JJ*6 ,< 1x B ;1> k'K 8 i 0m@E « vx k'K » .%4
k'K » =V ;Q 708 L .%4 x 1 ,&zJ* > 162& w@8 ;E%6B 7 'K
.7 x1 %" 60 1x vx k'K -6* P7 1 & ; «60 k'K» 7 «B
B ;E7 ,%< %%" ”% 1x ,0F 16&34 ‘E %0F 8'9 7 vx k'K ,7
7 7 SB %&
JJ* : 7 E)6x &< JJ* ;E,B E4x :E7s" x ƒx< ;EWE7s" EQ:
1
- computer and information ethics
- utilitarianism
3
- virtue ethics
4
- cyberethics
5
- internet ethics
6
- information revolution
7
- computer and information ethics
8
- utilitarianism
9
- virtue ethics
10
- cyberethics
11
- internet ethics
2
1481
AB 0" W 8'9 ;70 k'K ®> 0 _> j7& 1w< C+ 1 1IB6 7 A> .B %&
;70 8@6P 'K ;E%" 7 =H2 e9 CxB ; %0F O' @8 ‘/P 7 :x 34
.B 16Q NP &7 ;%C:F ,08 1 ;a FF 6& ~6# Q W* E W %& ,% ;EN& Q0E %
;N& l0E > ;70 ;%0N 7 1/B k9 1x %0& @8 E 1: 7 B ;70 1NP
®# d# ‡ CN B 4 ;70 %" ‘/B 7 3K žW" ,08 1 E;70 E K0&7 CN .%@0
K% 16& 7 .%%P 'K ;4=w& " 7 ,%7N& > -6* >B 8'9 ;70 ;34(
e %& ,< 8h 7 =H2 6x , B 1 7 8'9 7 vx k'K A# B 0&< ; B
.4 ,% K EyB" Rˆ 7 l0E >B 1`2 e9 ; @# jh
'K =@6# ;E%" K 7 & 1: @
(_% `
A)#
.]]
%0< 7 ¦¤¬­ . dh 8'9 ;70 7 vx
7 X8 => S% ;E:" ;' ª¨ ‘E ‘ 7 vx 8@6P 7 'K ;E%" ) K W0
k'K» E%/ 1x % k'K ;1K& ,%< %%" 1 1I2
1 «xK 7 %K x&» ,08 6x 8'9;70
Q:E7s" I2 10 34,0 .%& % «8'9
,F H2 )6x ;6# 7 8h .%B ›F
Q: B%0N 7 h 6B 07 w<
,JJ*6 ;E`2 ;w 7 vx 0 7 Evx
Ww@E @E 1 7 X7 NP l0P , . MIT
7 vx 0Er 7 @2P , ; vx vx
7 w76w ;Evx %& 1 & ƒ@x 0 7 w<
,xx ; SP ;BNP 7 8'9 ;E1w&
Wx:x .x %%P %0@% 8'9 ;E;70 Q
OE E7 7 k'K < ,% 1 & , %" 7
;E& O624 %7 1 ƒ@x ; 07 1x EO'
.%10 e ;%P =H2 ,0m@E 1x ... 7 80J
34 : ;E1" Ww@E % 1 X B#
X 7 7< %%" 1x ;%%P W 07 E4< C+ 1
07 CE l0P ~7 6> .% ƒ6B ,< ˆ%/ K 1x
;1K& Sh7 @ ,@4 7 %:* ,% CE ƒB
Ca8 8@6P 7 'K 6B 1x x 0W"
«vx k'K» a E,08 3 .2E k'K 0 W" 07 .B X' w76w ;Evx ƒ6B
I6B %/ E1E 7 7 ‘6KB «8'9 k'K»
)' 7» O*6B ,NP l0P G" 1x x
7 341" 7 ‘41B D6x !> 1 2 A> .4
7 % «ƒ J8» ,7 7 .%& %EK «6/0
.2 8'9 7 vx k'K ‘0 (< 34 (
«& 7 K ; ;2 ;Ei» ,7 1x ,< ;B 1 %: CN 4E ,%& e9 , 07 ;E1:%
'K ;E%%N 7 E K 1x Ei ˜& %EK
L/6 ;%0@: 7 ;2 7 X8 ;B 1 7 ^K
.7< %EK A 1 7
GxqE .B k'K ) WK XE7 k+ 1x %062
(¦¤ª¥) «ƒ6B» ,08 6x 07 l0P X@ G"
k'K > E16 ;g CE 7 K 6> 7 , ,<
C8 1K& dh 7 @h < 1x %B ›F 1
/ 7 (< X< X< 1x %/ 1E 7 ˆ7%> 7 8@6P ;E%" K 1 ;x X8 ;1K& ,08 1
7 %/ AB 7 .K" w76w ;Evx 'K 7
5
- The Human Use of Human Beings
- God and Golem, Inc.
% #&' $' !" #$ .
. (!)
* +* (&, 6
1
- Norbert Wiener
- cybernetics
- industrial revolution
4
- automatic age
2
3
1482
The Second Conference on Electronic City
C_1
! *9 .F
1x 7< # 16& 1 «E,2 2 I6B » )6x
%x > 7 } B < 2> Xa r 7 j0 0 W" 7 1x 8'9 ;70 D6 'K 7 8@6P
z6* 7 j0 – ,2 %0@Ew& ;E7" D+
.%& w&< X8 7 ^K x
.(©¦}©§^^ ¦¤©ª07) B < C24 6KB
1x %0x 0W" «,2 2 ®I6B» )6x 7
/B 6'B > ,F 00 ;EO 8'9 ;70
a<.) -
%EK ,44 ˆ @8 E 7 0 < W ;%0@
w
6 ;EžW" @6 < E 07 7
07 8'9 ;70 @ 'K ;E%" B .x
@ 7 ,NP EžW" 0 .B ,NP ) ;s7
N # ;E& 7 I2 ;E% ;624 ,0F – %062E x & < =& 1x ,< P
E% 7 ”< ‘8@ ; 8'9 k'K ,08 1x 4
7 B 7 ;
< ,NP ;
F E .8'9 7 ;g
.%@ K 8'9 8'9» 7 .B 8'9 O" 8 wI
1/P 7 < E 8'9 k'K ;341" A'K 07
7 C2 1m0F 7 ;g 1 7 B 1 B
r* 1 3QE 7 =# ƒ6B a0 .(¦©©^ ¦¤ª¥ 07) « %E* 4% 3Q 1#
.%& ,@0E < > L%E 7 + ;1 /h
@62 %0< ‘B 0Hx @ 7 I2 4% 0
!9 7 a 1x «%8 BB A» 1 7 fB %< P 1x B ;g – 7 8'9 O
< 7 Dx
7 Ca8 'K CEI .K" B SP @ 4
;EQ CE < a % P .& 7 %
8'9 k'K _> 7< CE 7 ; SP A
;g } 7 =% %0< A9 1x %8'9 08
.%:x =# 1 E 10 @
:%4 07 7 .%0 (
B)-# 4$ ; E 7
62 ;
F 7 ~ ;1K7 C62E E)4 %B @H 7 %" K 1x C62E EQ 1w C62
.(¤¬ ^¦¤©ª 07)
C2P ;E6KB ˆ @8 < E w6B &
7 (;4) 6K< 7 7 Ca8 ;Ei 7 <
.%N %x :Q 'K
.(¤¬^ ¦¤©ª 07) ( ;EP ,2 1 B 1/& ,2 C2P
07 a 1 I4 % «8'9 J8 » 7 , 7 , 1
,% 12 1 X% 7 < ;w ;Ei - @h
,2 ,&;w ;Ei 1x % «8'9 ”& » ,<
a ." :> a ;w ; % ,P 7 <
O" 7 8'9 ( ;EQ 1 1627 ,&J*& E
8'9 /B7 ‘0N" % 7 < 62 KB 64
.;g – ^K H
P B ,% 8'9
;E%7 7 R> ) 8'9 1 %0x 3K ~K ,NP The Second Conference on Electronic City
;E/ ‘B 8'9 ‘@E 7 % B K C2P
E $+ /$
... 7 ;4C@J !@/ > 1B# AR%6B ,F 0Er
;EW0x 1 7 < 6K" 74 < %& 07 a .%0x O"
K ;Ei @ 3QE B 3"L/ 7 k'K
‘
0 1 1x B ,< < > + 1x 4 16 7
%4C@J ;P X 7 %0x 10: 1:% ® a
7 % %& B < r 1P7 1x 8'9 O" %>7 ƒ
.B 4% + 7 .3v WK 4% `2
:%0x 7
,% 1m< 7 7 %-6* 7 %/6B _> ; ;2 ;E < CE ,: X7%
;E& 7 k9 A> .B CE 7I6 %0 B
,:4% @ ˆ 1x % 1/ 7 ;4
.% %P7 ˆ @2P 7 ˆ r 1F ƒ L'K 7 4
2
- matter-energy
- information age
4
- information objects
3
1483
1
- great principals of justice
`
#c+
1 7 ,%& ,@0E 7 < :* / ; x
2@ k'K 0 ‘K& Sh7 K 07 1x < . P7 162& 4%
7 8h =# K I2 ;E& dh 1 ,< 7 < ;E w& 7 %& 1 7 9K !/
=# ‰B 1 ˆ /B 7 %@ 8'9 k'K =H2
.v L%E 1 ,@0E BB A 1 &
B% ,< 6K0&O7 >& 1w< 8h
BB W 8@6P > ,2 1 ƒ6B Q 7 a
=# 7 O7 7 & 2 7 .%E
7 c0 ; 7 44 14E 7 %0x I < w&
EO7 7 x jP 7 (< 1 ˆ @2 8'9 k'K =H2
7 žW" .B ,Q 7 ‘ 7 2 1 c
k'K =H2 => 7 =# 07 O7 1 67 .@ ~*6B ª 7 EK ƒ ­ ; § ;< ¦ 14NF A
B &' 7 O7 1x C C0x a 8'9
7 %& BB A 1V 1 ;< %%# ;B10@x
‘63" 'K ;E&7 %8 7 %%P =H2 !
.% < w&
.%%P =H2 7 8h d# x Rˆ 7 P W"
A 7 %8 7 E& 7 EO7 ;1w& ;1/P E
Y
41- Zb'
.%0x %E j@6P , < ,< 6 1x P7
E 7 162& ‘/P 07 7 !%J ;E%" w
%E =w& %&163" 7 A7%6 ;E17 ® «E17»
,42 4 .B Q0E Vw %x 7 O3" <
E 1 yB" ; w ;+<B %8 %0N SP 1x
;%E& 7 10 Vw6 7 -6* ;El0E P7 Q0E
x 07 O7 .%& 8'9 k'K ‘> :B"
P7 1x < a0 .%4 k'K 2
E 7 K H 1/P ƒ «A7%6 ;E17 ‘8@»
%>7 'K ;EO B 3" 4 -6* ;El0E
, e ;6 ;EN 7 %8 BB A <
.%2 7 Vw6 7 .B %m" 7 CN
4 1x B ,< 07 AR%6B ,42 = 1 8'9 7 k'K 8h =# ; 7 !9 %
+ 7 < E (%< 6:" 1w0F) ## ;4X7 D % .% B ( &7 7 &
7 El0E A6B 1 O+< C C& 16& 7 >
:x ;%016B 1 07 B0&O7 , (¦¤¥©)
BB A 1 1w< c7: C7 %/6 ;EW0 7 E&
;70 W %< 'K =H2 7 8h /
;6B Q0E, 0 A 1x F .C& 7 %8
®% ;E ˆ 8 .j@6P ‘0# 8'9
; 07 1x 67%# 7 c& N0 .%E B1 k'K ;
Q W ;< /B 0 'B > 1x;70
,< ; ;10 % 1x B ,<% XR 8@6P E
. x@ %E (# 2 = ;EO
O" =8 ‘
0 1 WK ;Ei ´7<CE
1x 0&7 7 CN A 7 E% @ e
.& 164 w a 8h
7 %0
C@J 7 )*6 1 B %0 %m" 8'9
!# 7 ˜%3v WK 4% `2 !9%
;E& 7 7 %8 7 A 64x1 ,w .%4 !# x3 BB = NF 1w< Q %& %E*
The Second Conference on Electronic City
< 6 1x («A7%6 ;E17 ‘8@») P W" .%00x % 7 %E / ;1/P
€# 1 O3" :" ;E& 7 0B 18@ 1m0F
6 ; , ( 8h 7 =2 => 'K
1
- freedom
- equality
3
- benevolence
4
- minimum infringement of freedom
5
- ethical relativism
6
- cross-cultural foundation
2
7
- methodology
- received policy cluster
9
- Moor
8
1484
Ev? > 1? ? f2> 0 .%? L%E 7 + %& 1/P ƒ 'K0B 4B 1x > P7 E,< W" 4E 1? %< %%" ;s7 'K ':
.4x1 %8 BB A ®7'/ < 4%
4 16 7 10 07 ;E? j'9 ,7% .&%
;E17 ‘8@ » ,< 1x ;1/P – 1R8 ‘/P ƒ ;%%P ‘K& % %%P =H2 ,%< %%" 1 1P 1?
k'K =H2 => 7 =# O7 –B 1R8 «A7%6
6 1? ? 0 k'K 7 &
" k'K %0 k'K
%EK 1 'K _> B0 ;E=> Rˆ @6> 8'9
%%P ‘K& 0 ˜%& ': 7 =H2 1 Q*B"
.& S7 1/P O3" 1x 7<
«v? k'K» Ev? W%" & 1? k'K
%0 8'9 k'K 00m0 2x 1x & 1P %
'K =H2 1? ? / ;10 %%P ‘0 7 .%
E %B a 1 .2 I2 ®s7 O<7 1QmE
«16 7 %& %m" ;v? ;70 ‘B » 1x 0B 7 ! ;w@8 1R8 ;1/P 1x ,2
EQ: :< ;E7 %6 7 .%E B 1/P z*& 6 1x ;P 7 %8 7 XB
.? >9 v? X8 ,: ; v? k'K
W0x 1x % % %B0& %E ,B 7 %E
,EK k6: ,: 7 4 A6B E7
G" .1 B 163" 'K 7 8@6P €# 1 ^K ;&
7 ,: BK 1 .%%& E 7 Ca0 ;
4
% 8'9 %%P ;70 XR 0&< 1x 2x @
,< 1? % 5% ; «17 ‘62» M ¦¤¢¥ 0m@E
7 ,@/ 7 ,4x 7 %0& vx ,JJ*6 K
; %& 4 %#6 R 1? EfI0? ;E4?
8'9 %%P ;70 O3" 1 % 7 %0 ... 7 %7
k'K ‘62 ¦¤¥¨ .? I6B v? k'K O<
.%0B ; 1/P ;B 163" 'K fB 1/P
=& 18@ .%B ›F 1 1B M D v?
,< @E 2 624 2 ;0/ 8'9 k'K
. Q: %B &< ;E
7 &< ‘
vB ,2 7 vx ,JJ*6 B 1 ˆ 1x B
=& %& - Q: ‹? 1x ;N0:" ®7
7 E% ,< 07 7 8'9 ;70 k'K .&
C> =V _> 7 &< ;E=JB 7 L%E
K 8h N01 SB7 ;10N" 1x % EO7
1 Q627 ;v? ;EC@J ;v? CP JK
=H2 1w %E W&" C «vx k'K» 7 1x ¦¤¥¨ ‘E A9 . k'K JJ* =@/6B 7 ;70
«=8 k'K» =H2 7 1x $ ;E> 'K
) 0 1? E4? 7 %B ›F 1 E 7 E 18@
& % « ;70 k'K » 7 «60 k'K»
W*" ? 4 %#6 R ;EQ: v? k'K
E> 1? B ,0F 07 ;EO7 7 E% ®624.Q
,JJ*6 ; %/ 0 ‘2P ;EO' ‘6 .%&
k'K» 7 «1*6? k'K» «;Q17 k'K» a
%" 0&< v? k'K v? X8 ,%0@: 7 1I2
.4 «B%0N
.%?
(_R `
?@( d,]
The Second Conference on Electronic City
f&' $' /
M6B )6? :6 G" 1E 1B 1 M
7 ¦¤¢¬ ;E7 ‘/B A: ¦¤¢¨ ‘E X7 ‘@ 0 1> 1? k'K 8h 7 =H2 1? %& 8% 0 67 07
‘I2 ®%: 7 ,@E v? k'K %%P
e ,0 %¡ Q: &
" k'K B %>7
%%P 10 1 ,2P X 1 ,0 %¡ Q:
ˆ @8 7 %& %m" 2 Ev? W%" , %&
.%& %01'8 k'K
1
6
- medical ethics
7
- business ethics
8
- starter kit
9
- Deborah Johnson
1485
- agent ethics
- internet ethics
3
- nanotechnology ethics
4
- Walter Maner
5
- Old Dominion University
2
(_R `
*; + jJ-3 6,- hi]
0 L'K 1? %& %01'8 1K& 1 7 7
,2P B )6? :6 9K 1 N0 1 ¦¤¥© AB
.%00? !K /% '
ˆ ? =H2 Ev? %6/
v? k'K » ,08 MB'? ‘ :6 9* 1
1? 'K 8h ) V> 0 7 ,2P 3QE
k'K jh 1I26 ‘ ;s7 ®@& «–2F
.%? " %062E Ev? W%" %" %& 16I4
.2 v? k'K y ?" B % v?
60B 'K =H2 Ev? 1? ,< 0 ž E_#
%E B 1 v? k'K E >& 1 » 7 K / 1 %? A#6 ;Q@:F 7 DP # 1
.B ,2P 7 0 -/ 19 P 7 624 1?
,< -* ,2P «% =H2 1 ;%%P )7 q"
jh ; 1@ ,7< 7 dh 7 16& ; 1 J#0 =2 ;4=& ; H% Ev? 1? ;70 F 1? %E yB" WB" 1 %&? 7 7
.B e ˆ BB W" 1? %%& k'K 1> 'K ':7 =H2 „% E;70 B f v?
8 1? 7< 1 ? ;E%" 7 Š6 _> ;v? ;70 ' % 1? B 7 .B s7
=H2 6@E 7 E ^JK E16& @a8 C>
: «%3"L/ ˆ 0» Ev? 1? B ,< .v? 'K
; %0 1? _> %3"L/ ˆ 0 Ev?
(_R `
#+ g)R C)1L-
$ ;E@8 7 P7K;77 D2> 6/ E X
1@E !0 1? < ....%& ;
D 7 %3v =& 0
a 1 7%# v? ;70 ® ;E? 7 P
jh B 7 8'9 1N ; ;1P 7 B"
> .B NP ;
;'8 ‘@ v?.%B
.%< ? ! 2 ,< => 1? ? ˆ v? k'K
K ;E'K 7%# ; %> v? ;E7%#
v? k'K X B )6? M 8'9 @ 7
.(¦¬¤^¦¤¥©) B
)6x 2* ‘#I ;7 .%B ›F 1 ¦¤¥© 1? ? 7%
2 M0" ‘2B 1 ,2P ¦¤¥¨ ‘E =7 X 1 68 1 vx 0 L/
': 7 =H2 0 ;E» Ev? 1? , w@ 7 2 ,: W" 4E 1x %0x ;2
%00? %m" @% =H2 %0N W" 'K L/6
X 1 X% 2@ 2x 6:" 1x < .
>B 'K A@/ ;E0E % 7 7
.%&@ e X 7h CE QmE S9 1 %0x
;:" K Sh )6? «C4 A@/
qE X 1 6:" 2x 1x < 7'8
.%0?
. % CE E,< %
K 7 % «:$K ”'K» 6/ 0F :% «NI ;EQ6I&<» ”:0 E,<
v? k'K ‘0 B )6? 62* ,2P )6?
1? %& =% B ;E7 @ 6 1 1' 7
4 v? k'K > , 2Q ;E:? @
%0 B 8h =& )6? 2* W7 .%&
®# ) :$K ”'K DB 1 ˆ 8 vx k'K =H2
JK C> 7 v?; ;E 7 X
0 w Evx .%< %%" vx ;70 ;4x1
% 7 ;70 ‘IJ0 S 7 v? ,JJ*6 ;E`2
; 0 ;E10
4 w 7 %7< CE ;
a ;%%P 8h §¨¨¦7 ¦¤¤ª ;EB7 .,2
P ;E:$K Rˆ @/ .%34 6K «W0x»
E,< ®P ,7% X ;v? 8'9 1 (,?ME) 6B
E/ =@8 ; z*: :$K ˆ BB %%02
1 B? 60 (< 7 , ; ;v? ;70
.B %& 7
)6?
2
- What Is Computer Ethics?
3
- Methaphilosophy
4
- logically malleable
5
- policy vacuums
6
- conceptual muddles
1
- Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
1486
The Second Conference on Electronic City
; K 'K %8 7 X 2> ; FF 7 ,
ˆ 60B 1x –4%" 7 41Ii7 B I X’B 1>
1x B :0x / vx k'K ‘Ii7 .% P7
6B ; –%%& l0E@E 16 7 D E1a
; EW$K Ca0 0/ X E/ %
: @8 Š6 1
”'K 1x B E;& w .... ;EW0x %E
;vx ;E: $K %8 / 1xx 4
1`2 ƒ 1F 4 .B NI ”'K X' ˆ + :$K
=E 7 '8 1@E ;B E: $K K C4 w
‡%  %B a 1 dh7 7 &7 %6 vx k'K
_# =# CE Q / 7 1R8 K 1R8 LJ
B 1m< .%0x w&< NI Q6I&<
1R8 % 1x B )x 7 ,< E .%0
:$K 7 16& @20 NI )FF 1x B #
;E: $K @ 1x C< %0 2* .%
4%"
.(¦¤¥©§¬¬ ) %E B 1 W0x ;
$K ˆ 6> .%3Q B :" 9 ,< ;vx
;E6Bx ® «:$K ”'K» / ¦¤¥¨‘E K7 E: $K 16B ,< , % ;vx ;E:
«0 0 ;3"L/» 7 H 7 vxk'K
;%/ X4 .%% 1R8 ,< IJ0 7 =8 z*& E 1x %4
vx k'K JJ*6 ;2 8B 1 vx;70
ˆ 'K .BN< %0B ;E%" ;0 E: $K )*6
BB 2 ;EO XNI ¦¤¤¨‘E .%& S7 (
6N 1x C0
4 E: $K 1x C62 ,< %0
;EO / 68 1 .7
:" CEI 1 ;EQ62& C % w@ « ,7»P7K
7 E E 0 /B 'B > a 'K
C02 14%" a>' 1 1P -6* ;E:$K
E 1x %@E %P7 8@6P E ; ; ,0F /
¦¤¤¤)C0
4 w 1R8 ;E:$K , 7
4 > .%0x O 7 @E E,< 8@6P
.(´^
7 K %& =H «BB ;EO» ; & 8@6P
k'K =H2 ; «BB ;EO » .7 -1- 67c;+ (_% m,]
.(¦¤¤¢ )%0x I6B 0 7 JK C> =V vx
K 07 (< vx k'K ®> W%" +< C:F 1x B @8 ;1a vx k'K 1 E
:K0& , vx k'K y @ 162P
.%:4 «8'9 )'» E /B7 %
%0 2 BB ;EO O624 7 I> 1+%+
«:$K ”'K» «0 ;3" L/»CEI ;4x1
E 7 S0 W ;< /B 0 6'B >
4%"» 7 «BB ;EO» «NI ;EQ6I&<»
A:@ 07 1x K 8h ;2 .E 7 %
:%0x 1h8 1`2 => ; O7 «1R8
%&x 07 '
ˆ V .B EO 0F O624 7 j ,<
8'9 ;70 %H 7 => 1x :$K ”'K z*:
.B
E7 I6B DB 1 624 ;x ;Q:" @h
The Second Conference on Electronic City
E1Kx ,4x ; E 7 E 0 E1Kx
;E& I6B 7 % 7 D @E 1 .%0x I>
.kJ A)JE -47 l.+
.%E WEx d 7 0 %%N %&x %0@&E a
4%" 'K S0 7 BB ;EO 64x1
2 vx k'K ; 2 ;EO 06 E
%02 16 7 P ;E:$K 0 ; 1R8
k'K ® =H2 1x W0 ;0 .B %I
8h 7 x L9 ”'K 1x 0 ;E:$K
N: E ¦¤¤¨ ‘E K7 B )06P = vx
.%0x => = 'K
«vx >9 & w7» ,08 vx k'K 1
1x x , 0F , E EP .%& e
1
4
- human values
5
- value-sensitive computer design
1487
- information revolution
- core values
3
- just consequentialism
2
W0x7 x 6 E,< 1 2 1QF `& ,< 1x %00x
; =@6# ;EDB< 0W" 1/B A> ;E;70
.%E ,:
S %0 %6 ;E;70 >9 7 2 ;EO
;EC62B j
6 #B 0F = @E 1
7 % 1 %Q0 1@ ;) %& EDB< 0F
%0& % @62B $ 1w0 ; B 8'9
.(§¨¨¢ ,4' ¦¤¤¢ % ¦¤¤¬X72
§¨¨¬;%) %& Ei :0x E ;3" 7 =8 W
`
n,]
.(¤}¦¨^
& P7 1? ;
F E ;% a 0 1? < ;70 k'K ®> ƒ` ;E;7< 6N K
,08 1 ,N? 0/18@ =? 7 B 8'9 ;%0
;%) B ;% F (< %7 ¦¤¤© G" 8'9
;P ;E%0 ”& .% «8'9 ;» =? M
DP x 7 «w& k'K » ‘a .(§¨¨© ;% 7 ¦¤¤¤
‘B %%P =& 1 %0 8'9 ; .OK 7 07 B ;< B
.%7 % DB< ,& 6KB ;E1J*:
k'K ‘0N" 1x %4 8'9 k'K ) K ‘a 7
,< ‘6 7 % «"76<» ;% E; 7 EDB<
,< ;EL> W ;
F % /B7 ,0F % vx
% 1? B ;’ & "76< 0/ % .8'9 ; -/h
‘a 7 .& =& ,&6J*& ;E4s7 7 A A@8
=» ª J 1 ,%B ; 7 .7 % WE?
( 7 K e' ) «,'x k'K» 8 ‘
0 1 O'K
:%0? N0:" «0
7 4 41Ii7 4B 1 1& 1x %0x 1
.%& 8'9 ; A/ "76< %
@ ;Q*B" B ,< B  k'K
.? ;4W" 8'9 ; "76< %
D+ 8'9 k'K Q 8 1 .%& 'K ;E/
. 8'9 ; "76< %
7I + ;w 0B %< 'K ;E1a c0 8'9 ; =? %0@ 8'9 P &
B ,< W%E 1w 2 E,< 0
QP O%J 60B ;E1a )FNF 1x %%P 'K a>'
.(§¨¨¬ ;%)%0x =@w E1a 7
8'9 P ; %> O 1 A ;%
%? Q ;B 7 %0? =@ 60B k'K B M
2 ;% ‘a ‘62& % 8'9 k'K ,08
%? ; "76< 1B 8'9 ; %< %%" ’ &
4 1x ;%0< `& ‘
0 1 ;P E 1a 1xF
.7 60B k'K ,2 ;EO 7 E4s7 7 A@8
:4 a (8'9) 164 E1a I+ ,E4 > E,2 };P E E %& - E1<4 ‘
0 1 P @
76 ”& > % 80J 6> 7 EC24
;162 P E ! , 1 .8'9 ”& 1V 1 0/
; ’ 8 ‘
0@ }; ƒ :* B ;
:;7> B %02 K 7 P Q ( ;3" 7 P Q (
_# P E 1x DB0 ; ;E6KB :-
7 %0E =w: ,< 1Q E 7 I `& > 0/
% ,2 + B ;1a 17 ;% 1a .&
; @ % 1? 8 1 7 «O3"» 06 7
1 1x E%7 7 Exx Ew@8 ;18@ :)
4B %0 2 8 06 60B 'K ;E1a
%B Q `& 1x EX") E‡# EW0x, 1B7
.7 @& 1  k'K 7 41Ii7
/ ,< DB06 7 %& A/ (`& K 7 1
4
- infospher
- Luciano Floridi
5 .0-/) 0 1) 2) , 0-*' 3!% $$ 4/
. 56 ' #$ * 0 7& !8% 9:; <:= -/ 0)
2
- flourishing ethics
3
- macroethics
1488
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.BE%/6B ,x 7 7 O7" I> ” 1
vx ;x & ;E;w % x 1x %B
%E P 7 1 8'9 ; I> 7 1/B 7 %?
8'9 ;70 ˜ %EK 8@6P =H2 CN w
K @8 'K ;E1a 7 EW0 e9 1 =H2 1 0?
1m< ;6: 2 & ;E % . v 80J Q 7 E 6 ) .7< %EK P
;vx CHP
"!-c
HI d-O -D- %6
? G
7 «Ef77» Evx W%" +< 1w0 1 1P B 1 vx k'K E &7 ‡ !9 6N %&
; 1 '6 ;1`2 «EwE» $B @ BBP
1x %& > e =H2 7 8h E1@ ,
vx k'K ;E1+%+ 0 ˆ 6/9 ;70
.B j06 :E7s" ;E1 7 E1B‘@6B 7
iI> )E
*B w
0 1`2 0 .B
=+: 7 vx
1 1x B «0 0» 1w 2 (... 7 =B W< B
;vx CHP
:B %& C2 Š0"
0@4 7 JK C>
;w ;E
, X0@4 7 JK C>
;1> ;E`2
;0 E1 7 E 1w0 ,0@9 }68 7 #
,%& NP
%16 6/ ;E 7 A
B G7B ‘H
So: (_% ],d
C0 7 1x ;6 7 1w0 @ }(
; ;2 ;E 1x «NP ;
» ,08 1 vx
%EK ,2w
S0 1 6B A60x
162K %0K@ Evx B @/ 1 1x / P
«%& 21 ;E%%N» wK ;E
X j
CE >6B %0 7 %7@ 1K ;@ 7 1 7 %&@
.%062E Evx 0 ; BB :F
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.%< )2> 1 =+: ; ;%%N ;x X
.%062
wE .%062E EwE ;vx 0 9* Q w
;2 ‘ x X 8B 7 C> Q ;B K .%0x rI @62B 1 ,7% 1x B 2x S7
0
QP ; 7 ;J6 ;E
Q 7 .% ,2
K 7 %" ;wK 7 8'9 ; 1 1%8 EwE
,NP > . P7 ;vx ;E& ,2
1 E= ;6# 7 C62B x ®# ‡ ; ˆ Q
;E" Eƒ ,=# ,F ,0xx ;2 6/0
K «,4O7x» D+ .%0 B EC62B «O7x»
cK ,4x 60 ,a# E24 E2v I
=8 7 %B ;Ex& ,0@& 7 ;< Kƒ ,/% .%%& QP ;vx ;E& 6:" ... 7 ;%
,EQ .%00x / ; ;E;<  67
”'x7 ,w&
" =V JJ*6 60B -i7 ;2 6>
1w %% ;h N0 1 1x %8% B ; ®@4K
7 ( # 1 7 ,B0&,7 7 ,%2> ,@/
@E 1 1/P ; /0 60 9* ,x '
.4 X Evx $B
.(¦¤¤§IvB) .%
'
ˆ V .2 4 CE ,%0F x jh %C:F P7 $B ;70 ‘B 1x +: Ca8 C> 1 ,
*B ,B%0N .x & %< %%" ;vx ;E1Kx
EB)7 ,4%B EC62B ,4=# X ,B%0N
;1@ ... 7 vx ,4%0&7 8'9 ;70 ,@/
1
- logical security
1489
a 1 P7 .%,% ;70 ®% ,7 =+:
;rK 7 -/h ^*& 6K% X 1 C27 %* Z' U[4 .h,d
.(¦¤¤¤ X72 7 §¨¨¦Gx) B %& B ;
X@8 1P 1x vx k'K _# 62* %
w< 7 ¦¤¬¨ ‘E . JK C> ‘`2 4 ;w ;E
%& 3K ;< ;E) JK 8'9 ; Q"
‘`2 vx k'K 1:0 =# 8h Q w
,%7N& (... 7 6K" 62
N ;E10
E ;B %K X
/ .B X w $ ;w ;E k>
E ,< 0 1x %& 1H ;1#R w< ®Q0x .x a0 .& 162 X w % 1x %7 @ 1x %& K J*& B0& ®@& %P7 ;%7N&
7 B ,x vx ;N E1 @ 7 < % 8'9
16K0& ID @& fB %7N& ,< ® 67 ;E
Q E74 .(¦¤¤­@6B) %& 7 e' 7 1/
«‹
X 7 » 1m< ® @8 ž68 .%&
7 , % ,21 7 ;
X ;Ex& 1x %%6/
G 7 3Q 0x e9 &7 Q0x 4 X
7 O7 1x %00x E
X L ;1a>' = ‘B
JK C> , N0:" ; E16@x %E* N@P
/0 7 .(¦¤¤§,2P)4@ O1B ‘0
E
JK C> ¦¤¢¨ ‘E =7 .%E =w:
;1a>' = W* O R %0F X
JK C> %%N ,0x , ,< .%& DJ ;vx
1x %8% ;
X ;Ex& 7 ˜%E =w& NP J6
vx k'K ®> @8 ;E1+%+ ,0m@E ;vx
B» ) E
X + vx ‘B R E, 1B E
;vx ;E1w& 7 Evx I6B x7 NB .B
1x %7 X ;2 .%0E B («
X
‡6& 7 12 62P ;BKr ;7<S@P @/ 7 @B + vx %& % E
X w
6BK 1x 2x ; ;vx ;70 J*& 8'9
1w0 A> .%& % ,6B7 ; K ;E
X
7 (w&
" 8'9 a) «f2>» 8'9 j ;%NQ
‘B R E, ˆ I 1x %8% ;
X ;Ex&
.B X@ :F %062E ,4%00x%%N 7 X@8 f6B
‘`2 w ‘`2 .%0E B 16B7 ;Evx @E
1P ,< Q@:F %& 7 60 6 ; 1P7 16&34 ‘E X -6* P7 ^JK w 1x F B ;%m"
WEx 7 ˜ O
Evx O" % 7 ;%02"x 1
k> :x e , w 14 1B 7 B e9 =
®> ;%%P 8h W%" DP ;vx ;70 @
.j6K ;J# !> 7 ; B -Ҡ
;E(» ( « ! » «;7x » =V JK C>
.(¦¤¤¤ 7) %& ... 7 1w& ;7 «ƒx
.B 21 ;E, I6B ;EC6Q Ÿ w
, X0@4 JK C> I> S0 1x < ƒ ƒ J# EC6Q h ;EA %%6/ ;2
60 , X0@4 1 c =H2 B D6 60
J# %8% ,%0@: 7 ,h = .B C6Q
C> =H2 1x 4 _# B ,@E 4
7 %0x X7# h :* X@8 EC6Q w
I6B A 1 2x 4 '
ˆ V .%& e9 JK
7'81 .& @& 1 C8 ‘/B ; ;%%# 3QE =H2 %& 60 !9 6K0&,7 7 w&
" ;E7:
6/ ˆ BB ;J# !> 3K 7 1 ƒ B7
C> I> DP 0@4 %E _# B2> 2
;
X ‹
;Ex& N0 16 .B 47 7 10
E"
C> I> CE 7 0@4 CE 7 . %EK z*&
;Ex& ;2 L3> DB 7 %!9 9 1 0 a 2 ;EO Cw# DP 60 JK
.& E
X j0 7 ƒFx
1IB6 .%& %EK 0Er W< 7 w& K 7 'B
=N2 BDB % JK C> I> 7 0@4
kF &A" =V ;vx 2& 7 ) ;E/
1490
The Second Conference on Electronic City
;J# !> Ÿ 8h Q1:0 w 7
# 7 NP 0 ;Bl0E@E .%WK ‘8h 7
6. 67/p1 .n,d
Q0E Vw 7 %/ .B > ;E1+%+ ;10 7
ˆ + % 1x ;s7 zJ* ‘B71 vx ,JJ*6
;QE A60x =V =H2 ;2 B a L'6K :0
,NP % E,< = @E 1 .% rI" 7 X6# j@6P
.B %&... 7 B% 1 E JK C> 1 7
 B %0@& X 1x E
F ;2 7 K ,"
" E`2 S9 1 .%3Q ;Q@:F
B ; NP 806 ;1> $7 -6* vx ,JJ*6 .
C> I> W*% ,% 8'9 ;E;70 1 6B
.%
ƒ76w R X ; 660 0 7 JK
ž/ CE 4 1x % ;%/6 S0 $7 ;E;70 K ;E:x ˆ 6/9 , .B
1 1x %062E 2x 3"`2 ,JJ*6 7 %4 %0 1R/ 7 %& %0N 6KB
.%00x )06P ,< 7 %-7 %" .%0P x& B ; ,NP ;J6 R
%0 %#6 R ;6/ ;Ex& %& DB ;E:x , 6: 1FE ;
Ÿ J6 Lw& /h7 C62
7 k ,B%0N ‘2B 7 (ACM)1 ;vx ;E& @
< 1x BP A†B .B ;7< N 7 %0N
%E ; E=@/6B 7 E=JB (IEEE)ƒ76w
0+ 7 ;E:x , Lw& ,%& !@8 1 ;%7 0F
%x N0:" 7 Sh7 vx ,JJ*6 'K ;E`2
%E* a 6> 7 BB ;Ej
ˆ /6 7 ; '6K
.& %04 vx X8 B0&x ®7 B ‘ 1x
–%
6;#-kD q,d
NP O<
;B 1 A# A> 8B 1 vx k'K 7
7 ; NP 8'9 ‘w& 1 , 6B 1m0F
NP k'K» ,< 1x B 7 B CN 7 SB7 ;10
E ˆ 1x B y 62* %& CE ,2w 1 0+
X 60 %0 NP ;E1w& .C0 «8'9
(< 7 ‡% 7 ,6 17 K 1 ;7 ;
K C8 1 7 .%00x =J6 Q%w 1 ,NP BB
7 0 7 BB ;EW0x 7 ,NP ‹
;E 7 E1*6x
CE @h 4 NP &' 62* ;
1x %B" , . B6B ,NP BB X 8@6P
7 % 2 ;EO 3" 1@E @8 ;E/ ,7<
-6* SP Q0E ;E4s7 NP O< (
7 k'K 1x B y 62* Q *B 1 .& I>
" &< ;E/ ; ;EO< < –B 1QF
P ;E7%# 7 1 7 NP 6>B EO
.B EWB" 7 –7<@
7 %4 !@/ 7 _# Q0E E3 @
The Second Conference on Electronic City
CN w %& .%& A# 7 O*6B 21F
8'9 ;0+ 7 =H2 K .%& ,< 8@6P > R#
;E:x 0+ 7 ,%7N& 6> 7 E , Lw&
:%
7 & ;E .B Q@:F 7 Lw& ,0xCE 6/0
4% 7h Q ;2 7 w&
" %K ;
NP ; ; @B 1 6: 7 6: &< ;E %01
‘8@ B NP 7 X8 ;%%" 60 1x > !@8 7 0+ ;ELw& I4 , < ,0x .%7 %8 S 7 l0E %P7 ƒ E ,< %0N :x 27
–B %&
1
- Association for Computing Machinery
- Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers
3
- global information ethics
2
1491
: *; '(% :; ' :8C`8T BU$ `8T &
S83; :21 :1 ‰A8; .(egkf) . -$R 8 :J% .&( J$ s(% (L y>)'+$
.:$; `0
Wiener, N. (1964), God & Golem, Inc.: A Comment on
Certain Points Where Cybernetics Impinges on Religion,
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
:;<
*
Bohman, James (2008), “The Transformation of the Public
Sphere: Political Authority, Communicative Freedom,
and Internet Publics,” in J. van den Hoven and J. Weckert
(eds.), Information Technology and Moral Philosophy,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 66-92.
Floridi, L. (1999), Philosophy and Computing An
introduction, London and New York, Routledge.
................ (1999), “Information Ethics: On the Theoretical
Foundations of Computer Ethics”, Ethics and
Information Technology, 1(1): 37-56 .
Floridi, L. (ed.) (2004), The Blackwell Guide to the
Philosophy of Computing and Information, Oxford:
Blackwell .
Floridi, L. (2005b), “Internet Ethics: The Constructionist
Values of Homo Poieticus,” in R. Cavalier (ed.), The
Impact of the Internet on our Moral Lives, Albany:
SUNY Press, 195-214 .
Floridi, L. (2006a), “Information Ethics: Its Nature and
Scope,” Computers and Society, 36(3): 21-36 .
Floridi, L. (2006b), “Information Technologies and the
Tragedy of the Good Will,” Ethics and Information
Technology, 8(4): 253-262 .
Floridi, L. (2008), “Information Ethics: Its Nature and
Scope,” in J. van den Hoven and J. Weckert (eds.),
Information Technology and Moral Philosophy,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 40-65 .
Floridi, L. and J. Sanders (2004), “The Foundationalist
Debate in Computer Ethics,” in R. Spinello and H.
Tavani (eds.), Readings in CyberEthics, 2nd edition,
Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett, 81-95 .
Fodor, J. and T. Bynum (1992), What Is Computer Ethics? (a
video program), Kingston, NY: Educational Media
Resources, Inc.
Johnson, D. (1985), Computer Ethics, First Edition,
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall; Second Edition,
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1994; Third Edition
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 2001.
Johnson, D. (2004), “Computer Ethics,” in L. Floridi (ed.),
The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of Computing
and Information, Oxford: Blackwell, 65-75.
Maner, W. (1980), Starter Kit in Computer Ethics, Hyde
Park, NY: Helvetia Press and the National Information
and Resource Center for Teaching Philosophy.
Maner, W. (1996), “Unique Ethical Problems in Information
Technology,” in T. Bynum and S. Rogerson (eds.),
Science and Engineering Ethics (Special Issue: Global
Information Ethics), 2(2): 137-154.
Moor, J. (1985) “What Is Computer Ethics?”
Metaphilosophy, 16(4): 266-75.
Moor, J. (1997), “Towards a Theory of Privacy in the
Information Age,” Computers and Society, 27(3): 27-32.
Moor, J. (1999), “Just Consequentialism and Computing,”
Ethics and Information Technology, 1(1): 65-69.
Moor, J. (2008) “Why We Need Better Ethics for Emerging
Technologies,” in J. van den Hoven and J. Weckert
(eds.), Information Technology and Moral Philosophy,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 26-39.
Nissenbaum, H. (1999), “The Meaning of Anonymity in an
Information Age,” The Information Society, 15: 141-144.
Spafford, E., K. Heaphy, and D. Ferbrache (eds.) (1989),
Computer Viruses: Dealing with Electronic Vandalism
1492
The Second Conference on Electronic City
and Programmed Threats, Arlington, VA: ADAPSO
(now ITAA).
Spafford, E. (1992), “Are Computer Hacker Break-Ins
Ethical?” Journal of Systems and Software, 17: 41-47.
Wiener, N. (1948), Cybernetics: or Control and
Communication in the Animal and the Machine, New
York: Technology Press/John Wiley & Sons.
Wiener, N. (1950), The Human Use of Human Beings:
Cybernetics and Society, Boston: Houghton Mifflin;
Second Edition Revised, New York, NY: Doubleday
Anchor 1954.
190(09121121130)
:1K (K ; 8
2 :(= *Š2 RB Z € <2
00D% L= K:$; R *$ :; #
zarepoor313@gmail. Com
8; ^
J% *$ :; #
k'K); ? 7 D2? ;E$# 'K ;E $ 'K ;E;` Š ;7 1 ;` 6?: % a g7" ; % c 'K ;E;` .%& g7" ; ;E7(M76
%6 ;` 72 D7 k'K 62@? k'K @687 O
Q 6? k'K ,4B ,< $7 y
%%P ;E> 1QF 107 M76 k'K 1( / 1/ L%E .%& BB k'K I6B7
.3Q ( g7" ; ;EC ,E B @ ?7 D2? k'K
4 g7" ; ;E g7" % ; ;EC g7" ; % M76 k'K
;EC ; M76 'K ;E _# %0F
'K + I6B AV ,08 1 .& Ei g7" ;
CN ,B 1:@E g7" ;EC 'K ;E 1 k'K P Q6KB ;E
'K+ ;E6 f2> 1? @E g7" ; ;EC 'K ;E 1 1/P M 8@6P %P 6 $# M 1/B7 @ 7 60B + ;? ;E$# @B 1 ?7 D2?
.g7" ? h ,%6 %6 ;4 X%87 ;
.& f2> %& 1 %0? ?>
?7 D2? ;E$# 'K E M76 k'K g7
6;9 67( ?@( .
; C % 'K _> .%@ - ;
W
UT , 1? 60B + ;? ;E$# ; ;EC
5 %& 7I6 g7" 60B ;EC % B @
The Second Conference on Electronic City
; ;EC ,Q7 =E a !9 .%@ G/0 16
. 624 1/ 1 N 7I
1 CE P , €# 8 1? %062E ;? ;NE74
1 g7" ,% W ; ;EC -/ 1 M76 9 ;E1B %00? ;@E Q% %
g7" % 'K ;E`27 E7 'K % M ,08
1 1627@ ;E?7 ,%& NP K ;E%77 %00? I6B
; % c 'K ;N` .4 z*:
9 1? %0? N0:" [T] M .%00? G/0 CE
,4B ,< $7 y ;` 6?: %a g7"
7 ,2 l0P % g7" C ? a v? M@?
k'K 62@? k'K @687 O
Q 6? k'K
.%@ ;7" ;8 P ;E 7%# 1+ /9
.%& BB k'K I6B7 %6 ;` 72 D7
1493
%7 %0? ?@ :*( E 1? @ , 7
?7 D2? :? A/ @& ;<BP a !9 [U]
;EC 'K ;E 0[TZ] .%@ %? ?
[p] .%&(M76 ) M76
.% %N8 g7" % `2 6N g7" ;
Y
7+ Y
$ Z ' 0r3 $ st- .
@1"1 < fK!" 4 -J
+& CAI &-e!
.*?& "9 .%& E CE7 % ,08 1 CE g7" ,%
g7" ;
1) %00? (g7" +<) %00? +< ,%
Z4# ' u'+y 6+p( 0)R+: $ .
% 10
E ,)%0:* N ? (g7" %7
;E7 ?: ; > 'K % 60B 7
M2 A60?)%00? A60? g7" ?7(S07 I?
=6 Q627 CN ;E10P 7 E 1? & =H 6?:
%0<)%00? ;7< ,E .[t] (?% %7
Q627 G7 B a !9 .%0& g7"@ ?
@0E7 W0 (M2 %)%00? ;3" M2 (g7"
J08 E 1? %& ? ;08 =& =6
;34 L%E7E ;s6B7 9 1/B)%00? CE ”8 1 ; 9 1 6?: E .34 ( Q 08
1 M@? S0 Ca0)%0E O
Q g7" C ;87(E
1? %062E 1627 %y ;` 4s7 1? g7" C
;%/ .[\] (S07 M?7 BB S ,? 1+
7 ,< L%E7 ,B @> `2 O3" a}C ; 'K _> ,? A/6 =& E? .% L%E D2? ; O7 6N =#
G' .%& S0 % 7 %6 % M2 %
% ; % %& )*6 g7" C ; 1? ; =? / %00? I g7" ,% 1? W NF 7
y ;` BB '@7%0& DB0 6?:
.[Y] /g7" :P 7 %00? =N2 % E:%00?
14B MB ,08 1 B @ 6?: E .%0&
;E >'7 MB 1? %E ,: % ? 7 %& 4? h W
_8 ? ,F 4 1a>'
. ,B @8 ;4 % =7 C62 ( %
M7 7< P7 1 ;7 N 7 @8 W
, 16
% A@8 C :*( 1? %00? 1/ ,Q7 =E
[TT] .%@ 7 N ,B
%%@N N< .%& %" =6 Q6277 ? L%E $
1? %E% ,: % B @8 7 ? h W
%0< I? %& W*(7 'K C ;E 1F E 1?
7< P7 1 1/P ; ; ;
% MB g7" =# 7 -i7 =6 Q627 ;34 L%E
.34 ( J6 V 9 17 %0? V?%> B7
[u].B 6:
6?: 4B 7 .%0? =@8 'K 9 1y ;`
r3 $ Y
/p1 .
N 7 ,B ,0?? ; ; E ;E ;E??s? ; D+ % 'K `2
> =& 6?: %[TU] .%@ G/0 1/P
; g7" %0< ;Q A`2 7 9 1 1? g7" ,%7
_# !9 ;4 C@J %0< B ,0?? ;
[{] .& A %062E 'K ;EWF
= BB ;` 06 1? %0@ ;@E ?:7 7:
'K ;E6 % g7" ,% 1? %0? N0:" C?
Q % ;< %0? , 1? %& ;<
B @ 1? & E7 %0@ %? ;%6 $
1? %0? , 1IJ0 %8 = .4 I>7 %& L3> WE? .%@ !: g7" ? 'K + ;E6
Q62& 6 , ,: ; ; G& % P M ; g7" % 1? %0? e 7 7'/ .%00?
% # C 8 E 0 .%0& 16& ,&(7 W
Š6 ; 4 yB" `2 %7 B A`2 V
L%E ,08 1 – g7" % B !> D> 6?:
d# ;E? X % 1? %6/ 7 .[|]%@ !:
[Tp] .%@ ?:– ! g7" C E ; 8
.C@ %?(?)d# 9 1 E? X ;P 1 (W*()
1494
The Second Conference on Electronic City
4s7 % 6?: E 1? I4 , G"
The Second Conference on Electronic City
6+$ 1 Y `
0)1-[R `
.
[) c<A- 0-R `
.
;3Q6BB7 8@6P I O7 62@? k'K
/ 1? B 6 NP %6B ? 'K ;E: $K
k> 1? 6/h7 .%0? ?@ 56: ;EO7 1/P
L%E ; ; 1B7 ,08 17 %& 6 X6> % %0?
8@6P ,%P77 j@6P $ 1? 8@6P ;E`27
;7 N @8 g7" C ; 6?: E .%Q @V6B
8@6P ;`7 56: , 'K 7 B
? W
; C 6?: yB" %E W0B 1 %0?@ %? 62@? k'K .4 :
? 'K 7 12 B @ 1? ;7 N7
[T{] .%0? %? 1/P 77 8@6P
% 1B C”8 %%& @VB .%@ !: 4 1a>'
;7 % Š7 % $7 1? %0? N0:" Valasques
6& ? A !9 'K a % W
; g7"
% 1/B 1/P !9 1? k'K @>7 1
=R ? ;%0 19 C?> A %8 7[Tt] .%&
1? N /7 1 1P k'K .4 a#
X7 %8 .%@ %?(4B L'K ) =@8 ; 'K
W* $7 1/B7 O7"%@ %? %062E 1 M
, %@ %? @V6B ? ;` C?> A
%0? 8
[T|] M .%& 62@? k'K@N
Q z*& ;K S0 1 %K ; % 1? %0?
, =& 1 =@ ; SP 1? 62@? ;E6
; ? !> 1[T\] .%4 @V6B7 I6B ,B
56: 1>7 10
B ; ; ; $7
@N W J*& ;<7 , D , 1% ;<
! % ; ;7h 08 & 8@6P ;E%"7
O
Q ; % 07 %0? I =6 Q627
1? %E 1/B 8@6P SP 1 1? .%& g7"
C ”8 1 , O
Q7 ;7" :P ; .%0? 6:
%E 1/B ; ; 8@6P ;EO 7 'K Ca
: 1? & z*: CN J*& Q62& ,08 1 g7"
[UZ] M .B @+ J*& '/ 1? P
O
Q ;EWF ,Q7 =E .%@ I g7" % %062E4 v? 1B7 1 9 1? ; ?6&
; C pT N< % 1/ .%@ 1/ ; C
B ! A"? & 4 72 7 B? 10
677& D2? ; ;EC % O
Q 1? ,:
72)Q 4 1* 1 2 ; ; 1? V#
06 ;EO"7? 6KB %&34 L%E $ % A@8
12B 1 2 ;6: ?@ X%8 7 B( D9
V 9 1 N< 1? % =6 Q627 Q% C SP 12B 6KB .%0? %K SP 17
1? %%& 1P6 N< 0m@E[TY] .%0& $ C :*(
S@P %& 4 1 ;P 1 1? & QP D9 72
. ; ;? ;EC V O
Q @N W @68
J*& E 1? B 06 68 Q A .B 4
9 1 ,:&' 1? 4 C ”8 a6 ,08 1 @68
K" k> N 1 1: œ7 & 6 9 1 %
f ,F %& CN @68 .%: @V6B7 4 =6
X27 /P ;@E % ,9 72 0 4
1? P ; ;E$# SB K % B 57
1? B 'K = M ;% 72 .%@ !: C ;
'K % .% S2 2 3" , 77 9
1@E ; =& 1? .%E 9 1 1@E
M@? W6B = ;E6 ;7" =& C”8 06
; ;N& k>7 ;J6 E3 BB 4% ;E>
X%87 ,:@8 Š6 ; ,%& =H O a0 1 ,0?? 1
72 ;EA % D2? A>E 1[UT] . 1@E
`2 'K €# 6 .%& ,0?? @68 1 K
7I C ;%J 8 1 ;? ,'(;Q)9
[Tu] .%& 6? O M ,Q 1 M@?7E 'K
=: E O' %7 C 77 C ;8 W7 NN
. %EK
1495
g7" -6* ;EC 1 P 9 1 %>77 /P
"S
= "9 &>! "< g"U HI hO
K .$
;EE4 1? P 26? ;E
%E %:E ,6 %E
=1 +; Y
o J)# . .
6 %&@ 1H /7 ,B %0E N0:" 'K
; CN _# M ,08 1 f2> 'K+ I6B
,%0? 164E z*&E 1B ,B % 'K
A60? 1? %00? N0:" N< .%& M76 ;E
@68 7 E 7 %062E %: %P k'K7 ;E .& ,:
1 N< ,F %&@ K L3> ; E v?
g7" ,% k'K `2 ,< .%00? V $77
A'6B7 @68 7 %7< " ,0?? 1>7 I09
[U\] .%4 'K 6%0@ ;%" P ;E
B
; x ;`7 M@68 ,% .%00? 
; ;EC ; ; V => M@68 .%E ,:
)'Y+ u& @#( 'Y+ `
.
;E1h ; C M 6?: %[UU] .%& g7"
?@ %00? ,B B %6/ M6
; 'K7 M ; @68 $# My;`
$7 k'K 7 .I? B 1 %00?
[Up] .%& f2> B I6B WE?
1 1? B $ ? A k'K .%0@ ?@
;%0 19 %Q @V6B7 & 16&34 X6> % Y
o 67+).+ .
1? & 6 1 % z*& M 1? %0? 16 ?
1B 1? ; 9 1? %0? , ,?
C M 6 $# M ; 0 .%EK 7
; @ % & X 1 E = 7 Ev?
)K N K = 1 N0 ; % g7" %
1? %0? , 0m@E .%@ 068 7 :K ;E6
[UY] .=# = 1 1 %@ O' ,
O3" = 1? E6 % 77 '/ X ; ;<
'K+ 6 A60? A`2 g7" % .%@ !: %062
6;9 @D+ [)D $D .G
0m@E B 7@68 $# @B 1 C B7
; ;EC V> '/ ,%7 8@6P %P
; ;EC 7 B ,0@9 X%8 L3> A`2 g7"%
L ;P 1 k'K ;E 1? %%6/ ,Q7 C? .%&
[Ut] .% W
'K+ ;E6 1 SB yB" 1B g7"
8@6P %P %4 1? 'K _> %? ,?
; @68 ? A 62@? k'K k'K B
D '1)R 67<+ .
1/B ;% %0? $7 .% ? 1 = 8@6P %P
N 12B 1?%& CN g7" % ;% 1 k'K
g7" ,% ; ; 1> ;P7 k'K ;
g7" %
': z*& E I> ; ; 1/P M
X@ ;& =@ 8 ,B M 1? 12B .
B @ C”8 6 $# M P7 X%8 .%0?
1 RB 1%Q % XR g7" % ; 1>
g7" L%E7 C 1 ;77 O
Q7 %00? %P f2>
1 Q< %0< ,7 ! ,#67 )P ;
%N/ @62 g7" 2& C? a !97 .%0& 16&%
0m@E 7 .%& 6/ (g7" % 12B) PMP,08
[Uu] .%& $ 97
1 =@ 67 % 12B a Q ;NB
.46/ 'K ;E6 1: 4K 7 zJ*
v+- Z+$)- +$)- 64+ Z$t.+$)- 6+p( .I
@0E I6B P ;E
1? g7" ;EC ;%/
z*: g7" ? %6 GI @E ;` 62 1 10 ;P 1 %00? >9 g7" %
@62 1? & NB7 =& ,%67 %@
,Q7 60?a !9 .%K 7 XNI %0@ 1H g7" =# = Š6 ; S07%062E 4 g7" %%P W % 1? %0? Ca0 6 'K ;E
=& ,B `2 1? %0? & %6 ;` .%
G> P ;E
.%& CN 2 % P7 ; $# 1?
1496
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.%E W
%00? ,B f2> X6>7
$ 1/B7 O< % ; 1> ,% .%& d#
7 ,4%0E 68 ,4%00? 1h8 ,6: ,0?? ,%NB
CE 'K _> 5 ; ; 10 1? ?7 D2? k'K
B %6/ .%062E 4 ?7 D2? 1? & 2?
[pZ] .%0& 16& %00?
; 1? B ;J67 8@6P @8 =& ,B O 1?
1? B %6 % 12 .%@ CE ,%6
D A)
# 67<+ ' w#3 .
C? '/ ;7 164 ; ;EC ,7 %6
CE B0& P Q6KB ;E
67
[U{] .%& P 1 8 1 C ;8 =/ ,7%
E0E k'K 7 % g7" %
}f" .%@ ;34 1B 'K 6 B ;EO7
"9 "K& < fK!" CAI hO
K < i/
9.
;4 C@J v? k'K@B ;E
1? %%@N ;0E
"9 &>!
E O 1 g7" ;EC ,? 7 7 34 ( 'K
@@J7 'K *6 a0 1 'K ;`
% ( M % g7" ;
1 =>E0E7
1/B 60" a !9 .% %& >9 ,B 'K
$ 'K @@J 1? %%& 1P6 f"7 ;0E .%&
%& ;7h g7" % ; % 'K ;EN
GvB7 K J*& ;E
1B7 1 %6 v?
1? ;%? =87 ,0@9 X%8 D+ g7" % ;E
1B N 7 ,B @B+ 'K ;E
[U|] . c & 'K ;4 C@J 1 0
%? / N< .%& 16&34 ( ,B@B 'K
k'K J*& G> M %00? I6B v? 1? ;
j
?O - CAI"k L/ < i/
9 ..
;E
1? 1m< 6: 'K + ;E6 1? %
CAI"k &
(
[pT] .%00? ;4P %0E X B
A60? ;%%P O7 f2> 'K + I6B
X 1 ;
X 1 M .%& ; $# k'K
)'Y+ u& x @#( 0Y ' Y
w#3 .
The Second Conference on Electronic City
6;9 u& + [)D $D
;EX" 1@E v? 06 ;Q M "M76 k'K"
 ;E%06B 1 4? 1 v? $B %& g7" % 6 $# 1/B7 k'K D+ ;
Š6 1? %0? < " X 7'/ .%E %:E k'K
L%E %@ ' C”8 J*& 9 1 %
,08 1 1 .4 a d# =@/6B7 X" 'K
L%E D2? 1 g7" ? 1QF 107 N< J*& 7 ;1>
%8 ?& 'K ;EO ; e& = ;7 M
$# k'K M % ? 1?& K %0? M@?
1 ,F B 'K O7 .4 :60 a7 `2
1 % g7" % [pU] .%@ g7" j7& 6
 %06B ˆ7 %0?@ A60? 14 7 1# e& = / %0F ; 1/P 8@6P %P
,% 1 B @ E 1 .%0? 4< 'K
1K S / 1 P =& E => %E yB"
@687 %0? & C”87 g7" ,% @68
.; ' ; ; zJ* %00? ?
g7" C ! ;E ; ;7h =8 ; ;E$#
% %7%& g7" % ;%? `2 9[pp]
”8 JK _>7 g7" % !:B7 1@ 6 .%&
f2> WE? ,< %" 1? %@ =N2 8'9 ( A
g7" % ; %0?  ; 9 k'K 1? C
B CN C % ; .%& g7" ; C %P
% M .%@ I* 'K + ;E6 B 7 7 I ;E' a”8 c ; EO7
;E6 %& 163" ;E%6B %& % g7"
S7 ? # C”8 J*& S07 4% c
g7" ;E/ ;4? 1 ;7 %E e& J*&
?@ .g7" ? ,7 ; ;E/ 1N7 ;P
a)'K ;E6 =& g7" % ;E>' .%&
[pt]B %00? ,B :* N< c7
c ; ; 7 (%7 LJ X6> `2
1497
v+- Z+$)- +$)- - ' w#3 ## `
.
l1
3
g7" % BB ;E/ :* %6 a6 1 B @ 1?%@ CE ;7 1 6%KK7 I0 1 =? BB ;EM6? 1 .B
1 1?? I6B # ;Eg7" ; j7& 1 M ,08
%00? A60? 1? E / a& 162Q
107 g7" ; ;EC ; M76 'K ;E -/
g7" % G" .%0E D @> ;7 %0E
.%@ M@? 60B g7" C ;E 7I 1F
=H2 7%& 'K7 V % )K BB ;EM6?
W% C0? ?> ; ,B @B 1 1?@E
? 1 E M6? g7" ,% .%@ ;4P %6
g7" ; $# 'K ;E 6 -/ ;E
9 %7< B% g7" @> %4
; ,B g7" C 'K % .C@ 5
;4 C@J 7 %0@ =# 7 g7" 68 %0E
& h %:*%EKN %K7 % S7%
1? %0? N0:" f27 .%3Q ( g7" L%E B 1
?7 D2? M# ; %I ;E7 %E W
?7
AB NF =& BB ;EM6? 'K I6B
; ;EC k'K 1QF 10 z*: .%@
;EM6? <}T%B" AB 4B 7:4
; ;EC 1? ; B 7I6 60B 7 7 ;EC
7–%  L%E W
1 =@ I6B
C ; V7 'K ;E%0EK%00? .%0B %0EK A@8 8@6P ;
7 E 10
E 4B
z*:E ;EN 10 1? %0@ 1N ;
164? 1 M6? <}U%& k> =& Q AB
I> E M2 E O ;%0 7 'K ;E0Q0
=& .%00? 6 BN< !> 1? 1 ,Q %&
.4 'K @@J7 N0
I6B 1B7 ,08 1 4E 1? B 6? 7
.% B7 N< 1? %& 1 % 67%4@ [1] Hertel G, Konradt U, Orlikowski B. Managing distance
by interdependence goal setting, task interdependence,
and team-based rewards in virtual teams. Eur J Work
Organ Psychol 2004;13(1):1–28 .
[2] Fernback J. The individual within the collective: virtual
ideology and the realization of collective principles. In:
Virtual Culture. London: Sage; 1997. p. 36–54 .
[3] Ariss S, Nykodym N, Cole-Laramore AA. Trust and
technology in the virtual organization. S. A. M. Adv
Manage J 2002;67(4):22–5.
[4] McClenahen JS, Jusko J. Doing it e-right. Ind Week
2000;249(13): 13–5 .
[5] Project Management Institute. People in projects. Newton
Square, PA: Project Management Institute; 2001 .
[6] Flannes, Levin G. People skills for project managers.
Vienna, VA: Management Concepts. 2001VA:
Management Concepts; 2001 .
[7] Verma VK. Managing the project team. Newton Square,
PA: Project Management Institute; 1997 .
[8] Turner JR, Mu¨ ller R. The project manager’s leadership
style as a success factor on projects: a literature review.
Project Manage J 2005;36(2):49–61 .
[9] Pinto J, Thoms P, Trailer J, Palmer T, Govekar M.
Project leadership from theory to practice. Newtown
Square, PA: Project Management Institute; 1998 .
[10] Kliem R. Leading high-performance projects. Boca
Raton, FL: J. Ross Publishing Inc. ; 2004 .
;Q AB , / 7 M@? 0m@E [p\]
D/7 1R8 S 1 0 E M6? <}p%B"
,: % BB ;EM6? I6B Q 8 1–%4
N AB .%& 6 9 1 ,%6 1@E 1? %E%
9 1[pY]– ,B $7 ;( 1F}t 1? B 1 BB ;EM6? 1? 67 % B7 g7" % dh7
%0 I0 ( 1? %E X BB ;EM6? %4 ?
k'K 7 $ s79 1 1? ,B %
,: k'K[pu] .%&@ 'K a>' 7 g7" 1? N< 1@E ; % E g7" % 1? %E
C7 g7"% WF .& =H O %062E 4 ,B GvB7 ,< ;E /7 ,%6 / g7" ;
.%& ! g7" X ;E 6&34(7 ,?
=#7 1
X ,%6 ,? 2 a E /
,%6 ; X 1N ,%6 K BK ,%6
%E WE? %6 ;EOQ % %6 9 7
[p{] .%E W
?:7
1498
The Second Conference on Electronic City
References
The Second Conference on Electronic City
[30] Milton-Smith J. Ethics as excellence: a strategic
management perspective. J Bus Ethics 1995;14(8):683–
93 .
[31] Liedtka JM. Feminist morality and competitive reality: a
role for an ethic of care? Bus Ethics Quart
1996;6(2):185–200 .
[32] Kim CW, Emmett D, Sikula Sr A. Employee relations
ethics and the changing nature of the American
workforce. Ethics Behav 2001;11(1):23–38 .
[33] Introna LD, Brigham M. Reconsidering community and
the stranger in the age of virtuality. Soc Bus Rev
2007;2(2):166–78 .
[34] Freeman RE. A Stakeholder Theory of the modern
corporation: some future directions. Bus Ethics Quart
1994;4(4):409–21 .
[35] Meznar MB, Chrisman JJ, Carroll AB. Social
responsibility and strategic management: toward an
enterprise strategy classification. Acad Manage Proc
1990:332–6 .
[36] Johns P. E-ethics: the new moral methodology for
business. J Invest Compliance 2006;7(1):83–90.
[37] Pierce MA, Henry JW. Computer ethics: the role of
personal, informal, and formal codes. J Bus Ethics
1996;15(4):425–7 .
[38] Ford PJ. A further analysis of the ethics of
representation in virtual reality: multi-user environments.
Ethics Inform Technol 2001;3(2): 113–21 .
1499
[11] Scott WR, Davis GF. Organizations: rational natural and
open systems perspectives. 1st ed. Upper Saddle River,
NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall; 2007 .
[12] McGregor D. The human side of enterprise. New York:
McGraw- Hill; 1960 .
[13] Velasquez MG. Business ethics: concepts and cases. 6th
ed. Upper Saddle RiverNJRiver, NJ: Pearson Prentice
Hall; 2006 .
[14] Nelson DL, Quick JC. Organizational behavior: the
essentials. St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Company;
1996 .
[15] Rawls J. A theory of justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard
University Press; 1971 .
[16] Deutsch M. Equity, equality, and need: what determines
which value will be used as the basis of distributive
justice? J Social Issues 1975;31(3):137–49 .
[17] Kant I. Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals. New
York: Harper Torchbooks/The Academy Library, Harper
& Row; 1964 .
[18] Project Management Institute. Project manager
competency development (PMCD) framework. 2nd ed.
Newton Square, PA: Project Management Institute. PA:
Project Management Institute; 2007 .
[19] Pastoriza D, Arin˜o MA, Ricart JE. Ethical managerial
behaviour as an antecedent of organizational social
capital. J Bus Ethics 2008;78(3):329–42 .
[20] U. S. Legal Definitions. Moral authority law and legal
definition; 2008. <http://definitions. uslegal. com/>
[accessed 29. 02. 08 .[
[21] Kapor. Where is the digital highway really heading?
Wired 1993;1. 03 :53–9. 84 .
[22] Weber T, Tuler S. Four perspectives on public
participation process in environmental assessment and
decision making: combined results from 10 case studies.
Policy Stud J 2006;34(4):699–722 .
[23] Cranford M. The social trajectory of virtual reality:
substantive ethics in a world without constraints. Technol
Soc 1996;18(1):79–92 .
[24] Freestone O, Mitchell VW. Generation Y attitudes
towards e-ethics and internet-related misbehaviours. J
Bus Ethics 2004;54(2-1):121–8 .
[25] Project Management Institute. A guide to the project
management body of knowledge: PMBOK guide. 3rd
ed. Newton Square, PA: Project Management Institute.
PA: Project Management Institute; 2004 .
[26] PMI Code of Conduct and Personal Ethics. PMI today
magazine; December, 2006. p. 16–7 .
[27] IPMA-HR. Education & Prof. Dev; 2008. <http://www.
ipma-hr. org/ content. cfm?pageid=36> [accessed 15. 05.
08 .[
[28] PARN. Publications; 2008. <http://www. parn. org.
uk/parn2.
cfm?sct=
103&content=pubs.
cfm&banana=true&PubID=58> [accessed 15. 05. 08 .[
[29] Kuntze MF, Stoermer R, Mueller-Spahn F, Bullinger
AH. Ethical codes and values in a virtual world.
CyberPsychol Behav 2002;5(3):203–6 .
The Second Conference on Electronic City
This page is intentionally left blank
1500
! "# 139(09171179789)
( LJ
(~8!9 #% vO) [email protected]:
6B 7 %00x 1/ 7 4% < 1x B E 7 7%# z6* ; C 1x 14,@E
0 7% 7 > )FF 1 X ,< 1/B 7 ;B " ; 7 %& 16& E w76 ;EN&
E:x P ;E0 '6K 1@P ; 'w: ;Q*B" %6 E ,%& 16& 1x C62E
X ; Ex& 7 > =x @> %00x @ 0m@E 7 k> S ;4P E;E'x
.%& ;N& 7 ; R
,w / ; B w@ 0 C62 1P w
7 ( ;E,w 7 E ƒ76w R ; 62 = (E,@B< @"E 7 Ef ;7 7 6:x =K ) w E 7 , E 1x ƒ76w ;E
.%062E @E > 2 M76 ;E Q 7 .C& 1P =w: %062E =w:
,< ;E-/h 7 E—K C ,< /B , M76 , M76 ;E B 1
.CE 1 EE N< S ; 7 16 76 N& M76 ƒ76w Sh7 7 ƒ76w ;E =w: ; ,
.B %&
%2" 1w 2 E K j ƒ76w j =w& 0/ B ,< =w: # Q $ ƒ76w
:\"MU "A Z1"=! 8 %8 0/ _> 7 B%8 ,@E a0
^JK 1w0 1 7 % K I:
(< a0 1 %0F 7 =6 ;w@E 7 ! B
ƒ %4 ! 7 %B X'8 1> 1 > E ƒ
.> E ƒ >
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1 R@/ E =w: .B ƒ76w J E
.& =w: N< ;E1B7 !9 1x B ;%8 E ƒ76w a0
R 1x 1B7 E 1w % @E X'8 O7
ƒ76w J : X'8 0/ .4 %/0 ƒ76w
A> .4 > (< DP % %0x ;: %J
I4 , G" .& X (;) f@+ ; ƒ 7
' ƒ76w ;E
!9 ƒ76w ;E
1 %0F 7 ;w@E 7 ! B 8 ƒ76w 1x E 0F 68 .%7< 1 > (< 7 x
.ƒ76w !9 > (< a0
60 s7 1 ;E;70 O624
D9* ; K N0:" % %6 1 j 1 4 6> 2 w = %164 I6B 7 O3"
7 yB" !9 @E % = L9 .%00x AB
I> NP , > 3E S .%00w ,< 1 #J ^K 9
B 8 H+ %8 0 .B e ;%%P N0:"
'/ 7 > $7 ; )FF 7 @8 Ca
ƒ76w & W%" 7 @E .B XR
() ( ) ! " #$%& ' '$*
1501
.%%7 ,< ;B62 1 > ;EXa
e 1x B ƒ76w R ^JK 1% xr
1 7 x3 7 1@w ,7% ,< A 7 ) 1x ;%8
!9 A 7 8'9 A6 < 1x B &
.& X …7 LQ 1 1B7
; ;6/ O7 % ƒ76w ;E1B7 !9 7 60
8 1@P %& %/0 60 !9 1x ;8
^*& 4 < –%& > (< : X'8
&@ X 1N: 9 1%8 R7 %& )2# H+
ƒ76w ;E
WK > E ;
8 ( 7 3" ƒ76w ;E1B7 !9 7
@B 1 N< > 7 '/ $7 , %00
4
%/6 7 1 A 7 ) B w@ x3
–%:* XR 68 ,< 1 7 %B0&
%8 , % , 1F4 .%& 16& P7 w 1
yB" % , 1a>' 7 %& 16I4 1m< 1 1P .x % ,< # ,@ 7 B xB H+
O3" ; ;1% V yB" 7 B V x3 RB
? c06B %P 1 ,@ x -/ %8 1x X .k T{p
9 1 K , 1w0 ,7% .B ƒ76w ;E 68 7
1? K %& h> % 7
%8 1x
; 7 '/ $7 O624 7 x3 ;E 14%P
# = k> 16 .B  ;% M76
@ 7 ;3Q %& ? , 60 ; 1w0 Q B %/0 ;E 7 '/
, .%x 0W" ƒ76w ;E 68 ^K H+ %8 ' 1x < 7 %& 16& P7 ,< 2
.XT||Y )J ƒ76w ) A2< 1@
3 .x # =@> % H+ 8 0 .% P7
% A 7 ) / ) : ^JK
d# %4 H+ 8 1x ƒ76w ;E
! ;Q # 1 9 1w0 Q & X'8 EX" !9
.%062E 6/ 7
I6B EX" / ; 1x Q0E .%0& x
; $7 S2 DP x3 ;E 1F 4
= 1 x3 ;P 68 %4 % A 1 @ 7 K O624 7 %&
B%" 1x @E (& % %& I6B EX" 1x
Q%w ; N< , 16K0& 7 9 > X%8 = 1 7
; 7 O3" ƒ76w # x3 9 $7 'w: 7 %m" =H2 B w@
.B =H XR ;P 7 68 N<
;E 1 2 1`2 =? 1? & _8 K 1? %00x
A 18@) 1x ƒ76w , DJ , 7 A6 ; = EKB 1? %& 7I6 @/
.KB L9 ': ; %> , CA ?
;E1B7 8'9 @ 7 ,B< 1 ; 1x B ;%8 7
(7 x 1 %%P 9 ;EC62B I6B 7 w76w
:\"MU &m/ n1" )$
Y %%& 16K0& @B 1 ƒ76w ;E S7 .BN2 % > E 1 1x 1m<
; 7 %%& 16K0& ;8 X EX" TU ,7% 7 %062E ;68 > A@8 B > =@8 %B
;EX" !9 X'8 0 .%062E ( O
%P % 7 6/ : X'8 ; ƒ76w
> (< ; XR c& 7 ; $7 0
1 %@ " E 1x B ;7< 1 XR %& > (<
7 %B X'8 1> 1 1w0 G" 1x B 9 P7
R j7 "R@/ 1w0 dh .% =w:
. %EK > E ƒ 1 0 4 !
:B 1B 1 ƒ76w
.%< %E* P7 1 > E qE 9 K
%& % ;1B7 1F 1 7 1QF X'8 O7 1w0 ^JK
X'8 0 .B 162% XR K 1B7 % ,
G" A> .B !# = %0x R ,< %6 1x 1B7 E
Unicitral model law on electronic commerce. Art11(1)
. . . 0 1 Chris Reed & John Angel, Computer law. P302
+ ' '$* /+ ,-. 1502
The Second Conference on Electronic City
7 B 162 16& Cw> EX" 68 x3 ,
0/ .%062E A@8 = 76 ; (A 7 )
1 > E ƒ > :L 8'9 A6 }T
7 : E X" 1B7 1 % A 7 ) ;EO7 w
`2 8'9 %00x AB ; B w@ $ %<@ P7
.4 X'8
N< AB %00x AB 1x %& 8'9 ;7> 0/ %& B
w 1H A 7 ) I/ , ƒ76w ,
.%& %& 2K DP 7 %& x J
% & E !9 A 7 ) # 6> 7
( %0 R j :1P ƒ ;E18'9 A6 }U
1? @& k , z % 0 .B
P ƒ ;P ; S 6: 7 %0& 16& >
I4 , B A 7 ) E ;0 10 1 1P E18'9 j CN j w AV ,08 1 .%7 x 1
K XR > 68 EX" !9 1?
X'8 J ;P @h 1x %062E x@4 ;E1Ni
a 9 ! ; A6 E Q 8 1 2
E1Ni 1 i .B Q0B 2 N< X'8 X%8
.% S0 7 6/ > =#
yB" % x3 0 B %& 0W" ;3+x ;E1Ni QP EX" , < 1x %0E%
,< ;4w 7 8'9 ;70 O624 7 K ;EAB .x
62 7 e ) ^JK 1x V> w
ƒ76w x@4 ;E1Ni 3+x ,7% _# B 164 K 1 ;;%P =w& ƒ76w .B 164 > ;EXa O3"
.B () 1 8 ) 1/ 1 8 ) z*:
%J A ƒ 9 S E4 : =w: ;EX" }p
,< 1x 7< P7 1 ƒ76w ; ƒ 60
60 !9 Rx 1x P =V % > E ƒ K %K 7 ERx J*: 7 BN 660 ;EB
A 7 ) D 1x EX" j .& OIB
X =@w 1 c 1#I 2x 4 0 .%x 1h8
.%0 ƒ76w ;E =w: 1 %4 A6
=@8 B w@ %0x " ,< 7 x Rx OIB
\"MU &)
9 n1" 7-KA 0
1.
E:x .%& Rx AB 1 X
%0&7 7 4 ƒs %0 E:x K k> ) B 7I6 ^JK ;Q 1x B 2x X'8 7 1/ X N0:" )
E:x K 7 %%: =H 7I ) 1 8 7 )
4 1x D % %K %8 / 1 0/ ;0 =H ƒwI ) 1 8 7 ) ,@< 7 ,62Q =V
%0" ,< I 1 62 L9 7 E 4 A N0:"
.%%&
8 B w@ 7 % N: /h7 ;EN4<
^*& z*& 1 )K =w: ; 1x B ;N0:"
=x % R ,< ;EN4< 0 %4 )
z*: 7 / =x 1x 7 & 0/
2I N4< ,08 1 N< %06 Cx# 7 ,6: %& Ca0
7 % ,7% ;h ;0/ 1 A .B 7< X
A .%00x
=x) ) 1 c @8 %8 .B ) I 1 c&
^JK .B %& =H 7I 1/ 1 8 7 )
/ ^*& z*& 1 )K 7 , S9 , z*: ,
%062 0/ ^*& ;7 D9* 1x ;N0:") :
R , 1 k2 , ! X7
) A 7 (…7 ,
.X T|{Z )J Rx @ S ,20x
The Second Conference on Electronic City
) Rx @ S ,20x Tt -/ !9 .%0&
1 %0E N0:" 1w Q & )2# ) ; 8 ƒ
=w& 67 0 .(%& @ dJ ,< L'K eh7
1 %0&7 1x %& ,< (< 1 X
9 7 4
J.A. Graham. Technology and Law: Comparative legal Aspects of
Net-Business, p60.2nd Edition. Sweet& Maxwell. London 2001
-Ibid. p60
/ 1 .7 1503
Transmission of mere information
Transmission of unilateral information
Customs declaration
Paperless trade
Contract formation messages
(6/)34 5 3 z*& 7 B = K $B 1x EX" X@ 0
ƒ76w ;E 1x < .%E% V yB" OIB
,: A60x # ;1 ;EC62B !9 ;7 1> ,7r
1h8 ^*& X@8 1 N0:" 7 %062 7%# ED9* R@/
.B %N/6 7 7 B = 1 D260 %& %& AB
7 R ,< J 1x *& ;7 60x qE &
1 1P X@8 1 c& 7 % ) .% P7 %& 1/
-$ . # ! " #$ :23% %/ !01
!9 B w@ .2 K K E1w& @ E
0/ 1 X@8 1 N0:" K E:x K 1x EX" !> X" D9* 7 ;7 ;B N< 7 162 B = 1 )20 B x :%0x =@8 N< ;6# !9 16 7 %0x %& AB
.4 7<X
)
, M76 , 1? B ; CE .? G> eh7 1 ,< 'K ,
%& %& ! 7 / &7 B = 1B7 1 ' }-
B x AB B = 1x B ,@E X" < %0x X/ 1x
:)
9 0
?3
D9* 7 B = B w@ (T. .kT| X - %0)
& €I !9 K 9 ;8 ;E > %0& x ! EX" )26 ; K O7
K =w: 7 %00x X'8 CE 1 6x 1 7
14E x 7 B 06B = 7 6/ x3 !
8 s7 1 % P7 N< 1 %& : Ni )26
7 ! X" O" 7 Kr AB %
CE 1 2 R@/ 7 %00x 1V> Q%w 9 1x h>
(T..k \X) (B 6/ 9 ^K
!9 %/6 0B ;1w 8 .% K0&
J*& % D9* $B %& X" })
.B )26 = ,: ;
%& _8 ;7 ,4%0@ B = O1 1x %& &
& %m" @x jh ƒ76w 62 7
7 16 B6B B = I6B O7 1 x3 z*&
; B w@ 6> 7 %% w
> A ƒ 9
Q0E (T. .k T| X %0) %B0: K X" 1V 1 X"
, ƒ76w , .%0& 16K0& 'x Q%@E
WK 1 )K X" L/6 7 A@/ D9* 1x
A62< 1@ , Tp / 1 K UT T{ ;7 ;P ;Q Gx E 0/ %& 7 !> 8 7 %0x :B x Sh7 =r e& 1 EX" )26 ^JK
B = 1 % X" Q< x 6& 0F .C% )20
% &'() ! " #$ :+ ,( ( !
%& %: AB B = ;B EX" B w@ E4
.x )20 ;7 1 N< x3 k !9 ,6 7
( B = 1 EX" )26 %6 D9* 1m0F >
;7 7 %& %E* )20 B = 1 6 ;EX" %0x
J*& 1B7 1 7 B = $B X" 1x Q0E }-
B x 1 B = DP 1x %& %& AB
(T..kT{X - %0)
%& ;
1 8'9 C62B 1B7 1 X" 4})
& AB B = DP xK ;%J
B w@ S E4 .% N< A 6`2 qE
D9* > .%& %& AB E6& X"
A !9 .%0x B = 1 )20 1 EX" %@
. E: ?$5 1 '" I 4 # = E4 IK* (Addressee) Q9K . .?) * K .
# =H4" . =7 ?$5 1 7 R- = IK* #* (S.7 .
89 '".: !7 47 ; < => - ?8@ 3%A B$: ()
Attribution of Data messages
" C9 " =D$4" =7 ?$5 1 = E4 ?$5 1 D &. (originator) 4 # # =H4" . =7 ?$5 1 +IJ = IK* #* *
F4 $G
(. . .?) * K .
#) $G '7 MN$4 E4 - (information system) 89 LMN$4 ( . . .?) ?$5 1 O5 1$JP E: F4 ('4
1504
The Second Conference on Electronic City
25 # ! -$ 4
R 7 %00x 6 ,< ! % N< 4 / 9
%0x ( X" B AB % 6& 8% > x
! K O7 =w& 1m0F 4@ !# AB
UZ .%& X
6 EX" @6> > (< 1 % R7
, UU K @2 !9 > .%& %:
T| ) : ^JK ƒ76w ,
% j E r* 1w xK c j E 1) ƒ76w
7 %: B = X" 1x 2 ; =& ,
A/ # 1 B = 1x D9* ;B DB0
.(B %& AB 6& 9 1
(4 )2# X" !%J %0x `@ X"
)
9 @(
1 n1o! 5
\"MU "A %M! M 8
_# 1x ƒ76w R ; ; ^K S9 1 1P Q%w > 9 1x 60B 7 ;8 ;E E4< 6 / ; 3 B e R 0
1 1 A 7 ) 7 %00x %8 =w: 1 x B = 1 X" )26 Q%w X'8 9
=w: ,w 7 , / & S7 CE 1 2 Ex 2
% B = a D9* 1w B %: 7 ,w ƒ 9 A 7 ) 2 ;& x %8
, U\ UU ^JK .%0x !%J EX" 8 7 .%B 9 j'9 1 7 , ƒ A62< 1@ , Tt / 1 , ƒ76w %8 %0E =w: 1x A 7 ) (;1w 8) H+
:B x Sh7 =r e& 1 %8 ,w 7 , / 0 %< P7 1 1 %062E
:B %& c& !%J }-
W%" %0 E E !# .& 1P ;& @x 1 D6 > ( 14E d 9 1 B = 1x Q0E
0 & 7%# ,w 7 , %/ 7 ;Q jh E
D9* ;B EX" !%J 1 c7: EX" / 1x B ,< J6* =w: ,w 7 ,
!%J EX" D9* 1x Q< %& x
. ;%/6 > Š6 N<
N< > ( qE 7 %4 %: AB EX" %0w
B w@ 0 (T . .k Up X %& 164) &@ D6
:2< ' = >?@ ;
%E* D9* EX" AB XQ0E 1 = B =
8 s7 1 @8 €# %8 j7 y /
(T . .k UU X) & !%J EX" 1x %0x ! ;7
:%4 & 1x ; % H+
A ) %04 :A 7 ) A7%8 ,w X%8 }T
(< ,%& D6 ,< ( %& %& c& !%J 4 0
1
0 1 D9* ;B !%J X%8 7 B EX" >
.& )2# B = ;B AB !# X%8
1w0 Q %0x A7%8 WK 16I4 %8 j7 W" %
E %8 j7 1a# G" %& %& X
,< 1 0@h d
:B %: c& !%J })
,w Q 7 %4 K A ) ( 1 X
9 ƒ
!%J 1x 6> ^JK , ƒ76w ,
.% P7 A 7 ) jP
The Second Conference on Electronic City
E ; 1x *& B w@ : 9 E }U
,< QP ;Q , 7 B xB %& %: c& "@6> 147 & " 1 62 1? B %:
7 # 1IB Q62w&7 ,0P = 1 %062E /
.7< %EK P ; > ':
S ,< =w: = %8 9 > 7 .%4 E %
708 9$ 6
.% ;( %8 j7 1a# G" 7 B h !#
%8 ! , / : (< ,P % z*: }p
O7 %0 9 7 B ;6K !%J O7
j7 , / 'V .4 z*: %8 (< ,P %
$B !%J O7 4 .%00x ! %& N< A 1x K
XYX+T$&$5' '$* " V6VWUT$&$5 1505
Achnowledgement of receipt
.& P < % B %4 S7 4 ,< > %8
w 1 1F S 1x & X/ %K S %8
(X .k Up )
%4 %K 1 !/6 , 1F ,< S0 7 %< %K
, %00x / @62 %8 j7 , E4 0 .B
BC5 / ' = = A;
.B ;6: 1 Rx w A6
, ! / ; ;1w 8 H+ 8 $7 7 /h7 : Cx> , / }t
1 77 = 0 .B %& 1H I6* a %8 j7
%8 =w: , 1x B S R 9 ;
B XR ƒ76w ;E =w: ,w 7 , / _#
!9 'V .4 Sh7 %/ 1x 1 @x>
ƒ@x C6 C& 0&< ;1w 8 %& 1H a =9 d# %8 1x & z*: %8 ;: , Cx>
7 AB ,w 7 , ^JK P 1 1P 7 N<
1x ;%8 1 2 CE %/6 -w 7 k> 7 B
!9 %/0 ;E j7 1a# EX" A7
.2F % =w:
1? & =w: %8 .C0x / ƒ76w ;E1B7
% %8 =w: , / :, 7 ,P % / }\
.4 =w& %8 ;68 E 7 %E œ 7 '
1x %0F E) 4 / %8 1 c ;78 , 7 ,P
1 1 1P (;1w 7 8) H+ 8 (.&@ P h> A> / K , 7 B %8 j7 1a# ,@E 1x A , !# A 7 ) ; ; ƒ =x 9 1 ƒ76w ;E 1F 4
:$2< ' = >?@ ;
:B @E ; NP %8 j7 =# /
E W%" I4 % 7 %& %/0 f2# + 7
%8 =w: ,w / : Cx> , z*: }T
0/ KB ƒI0 ,w 7 , 7 ,@ >
9 $7 7 %8 1 Cx> , JK =@ k>
.%062E 7%# ,w 7 , J6* 1 ƒ76w ;E
1x JK @ k> %8 ƒ !9 .4 z*:
1x %x CE ,w ;1 ;E1w& 7 60 ;70
8 & %N/ .B %& 163" , % , 7 @"E 2 XQ0E 1 6>) w 7 , E ^*&
0 (X .k |Y{ ) B %8 j7 =# Cx> , S
1Q0 .%0@ =w: 1 (E,@B< =# z*: & X -6* :x 7 A 7 ) 4
KB 6& ) EX" A7 7 AB , 1F4
@E ,< (< 7 rI $& 1 Cx> , / NP %8 j7
=w: 7 & ~ ;1 ;EC62B (DB0 60
=@ R "J* M76 . ,7
7 $h % =w: S ; 0 B ,w /
1P L'6K 7 ,F .& B 1`2 2 .4 a 8 1Q0 ; ;s7
2 E4 L'6K =J 7 => E:? , 7I6 1
ƒ76w , ,< S 1 7 A62< 1@ ,
;s7 w .%062E xB %8 j7 ,w 7 , M76 , 1 1? & =:
.B %: ;&
0W" EX" 7 AB ,w 7 , ^JK =w: ,w / % 7 Š6 Q :d 4 / }U
;E , XN !9 1x %x
& ;78 1 4%B ; d 4 ,%& z*: %8
.x z*: =w: ,w 7 A !# , ƒ76w
7 , j %/0 8 AV ,08 1 .B %8
) D 1x EX" A7 7 AB ,w 7 , % 0
; 2 >' / A0 A 1 2 , =K
. B %0E =w: A 7
=# !9 8 & '6K 1 4%B 4
;E4 7 %& %EK X %8 ;P =# %8 j7
1x ;78 1 4%B >' # 4 ,< 1506
The Second Conference on Electronic City
–B 1F
D ! -$ = ;
%0F 1 M76 > 7 B 7 AB , 7 , z*: 1@P C? & A& 7
.& N0:" ,< ; ;EE 1? E
ƒ %0 1x , ƒ76w , UY !9
X" AB) B %& 164 A62< 1@ , T\
B = A60x ~K 8'9 C62B ƒ 1 1x % !#
@(
1 7
/ M p_! % "< &]
7 B AB !# ^JK (& 7 ;7 X CH
:
&)
9 A60x 1x % !# X" AB 1x ,
P A 1 %8 j7 =# / ; & N0:"
D9* 8'9 C62B 17 ~K ;7 X CH B =
B %& X 9 ! 7 h P K< 1x C&
, / ‡' I4 % 0 .& 7 ;Q _( z*&
%8 1x C .& =x %8 h x K< !#
C62B 1 N< 77 (A ) C8) EX" AB
0 .4 =% ) 1 A 1x %" j7 1 1 .B (A %00x )) B = A60x ~K 8'9
1P A !# , % %8 j7 =# / ;
%J , 0/ EX" AB B = =@8 Q 8
.& , A 1x B P %8 j7 =# 0 7 CE
1#I 1@x ƒ : !9 B w@ 1x : X'8
; =# ,@E B = ;B AB ,w %8
1m0F 0 .2 ‡' 4 !# f7 : %x
D9* 7 B = 1x B > .%& ;7 ;x
C8 E 1 7 %0x AB EX" 10& 7 B =
+ %& 16Q = AB ,w ^JK
8'9 ;EC62B , &K K 1w& ƒ
(T. .k U| - %0) %EK =@8 ‡' N< ! C62B 7 10:w 7 EX" _( z*& D9*
Q< %& 16& ;x ; =# ƒ W B = 1m0F
G" .B 10:w 7 AB !# , > & 1(
;x =# ,08 1 1/ = X ,w 1 =# ƒ
1 4qE E 1 B X" 4 4 16 ,
x& =# + 7 & ;7 ;
!# AB : 7 _( z*& D9* 8'9 C62B
. %EK ;7 ;x ; =# B =
%0x@ x ' D9* 8'9 C62B 1x 6> .B 16
ƒ76w , 1 7 A62< 1@ , 1B )K :D ! +I$ = FG' $HD$ E
, ; A62< 1x ;@0E w %% #J ,
; J*: 8'9 C62B ƒ D9* 1m0F
,@ > 1x B %& dJ x :60 1@
1x 4 !# Q< %& w / EX" The Second Conference on Electronic City
.%4 D9* 8'9 C62B 7 EX" .B %& X X" AB =@8 1x I4
J*& %0? ž 1? & %E 67 , >
.B @E H> X" A7 1a# ƒ76w %& 1h8 XNB ;E@ ;1a# 9 1 1? f %EK
X" AB) : 6> T . .k UY 1 7 %0? ;%K XNB ;%/ ^K , M & ž8
B = A60x ~K 8'9 C62B ƒ 1 1x % !#
K %K 6B 1& 7 9 ;EC62B K 8
C62B 1 X" 77 Uu .(& 7 ;7 X CH
XNB @ = L9 6B S 7 & AB
X" 77 , a0 .%0x # D9* 8'9
1? 4 L'6K _8 "@2 .%& ? D9* 8'9 C62B $B X" 1x B ;1a# ,@E
% 1? E'K , M76 ,
K %& ) 1x 0 .& A7
.& e'
A !# 1a# .%0x AB 7 X'8 EX" !9
6+ T$&$5 M4 #[ =7 =\ "7 T 6 1 Z) . . 1 (E4 '\ 89 LMN$4
1507
V+T$&$5 - ?8@ 3%A B$: 3 .4 7<X
) 0/ 1 X@8 1 N0:" K
16 .%& %& =7 D9* 1 A ;EX" 1x B
B ;7 ERx ¶ 7 / C %J 4 B %& 1
A 14NF ;N` ƒ76w 62 I4 %
(< 1 K = L9 7 : ) ;0/ 1
.B 164 O3" A A7 1a
/ jh z*: 7 / J B XR C: 4 1x B 4 1P B XR 1x ;Q 16w
L9 X
,7%) %0 8 %& N0:" 0 .C0x -w
D9* 8'9 C62B 7 CN =+ 1 EX" ,< AV 7 (& %/0 N % G" ; E) (
1@ , –%0x X
6 7 16 !# A7 < %4
.
& %04 B ;7 %& :60 ;EN4< 7 EX" 6 % E:? M76 '6K %B a 1
.? 1 N< 1 ,6 L'6K %& %/0 E
7 % @w> 10 ƒ76w , 7 A62<
%062E xB 10 c 1F4 .B xB
B w@ E4 L8 .& 7 a % CE ; L8
%& =7 ,%& CN = 7 :4
= X" ƒ
:
% ƒ76w i 7'8 .%0@ ,? 76 ;E %& , 1? @E
67 .%0@ =@# 9 1 ;%00x 7%# $&
6& ,7% 1? B M76 7N& ;EKB 1x XNI 7 ;
;EX" A7 60B 7 /7 ;
; ,%7N& @68 7 c , z ,7% 7 ,7% & X" A7 1
0 1 4 %%& ~ ;3+x 0B ;7
.%&@ 3", 1 O624
;E1B7 !9 7 X" 1 1x ,< 1: X" F
w@ 'V .%& @w> 0F A@: %& =60 ƒ76w
:;<
*
k> 1 i 1x NI 7 ;EX" 7 8'9 B
:C/
( ;<
*
7 NP %062 ;N CN = 7 ;w w
'(#$ "J+% n0K".("7G7) (D93 :$0$ <I $ ("
:J% :I0K + :; v(2 r0$
:33 '$
*J d;$ 9 ' :4D$ .$ ".("7G@) (D$: ()
:;€ '$=B " S8N9 #% A8;
.‹ 8:J% ) " ( "G
*$ So%8; rD% :J "("7Gt) (=; (7
.:89 *$ -$R MT$ :M3% :=C ' "$;
:J% :$ n0K .("7Hp)A+(D$ 9 A+ (?
.-; 8
'$"J+% 2I N%" .("7G)) J$ J (@
J% B8I
z% :; ".("7G7) <K (D$ :A; #$ :$ Œ3, (H
00D% '=#$ "~8!9 #% :J :8I $
'$ 8 :J%7"Y77 w?G ( .
B8I
.:33
#% *9+ 3$ :J" .("7G@) <2 V;3 (Q
8:J% ?"Y?@ w )) ( .1K '=#$ ."~8!9
.:O %B a 1 .%& * =60 $r SP 1 ;%NQ
7 8'9 ;E;70 7 A# A> 1:@E E 1 1P
10 J6 R> X@ > a ,@ 9
 .x @w> ,< ; 7 0W" ƒ76w R
0 .x 0W" , ,@ H
P X@ 1w0
=V) % @w> ,< ƒ76w , 1x ;
7 x jP ;E @8 %8 1 %6 % (x3k / ,< 1 2 E K A> 7 jh7 1 1P GvB
.x -w
7 ,6 P ; %& 16 B ?r = 1m< 7
;EX4 &< CE 7 Q0E 10 CE % ,< , %%P
1? %:* N ,0m< 1& KB 7 .& ;%0
.%& 3", 6> 1 d# d# 0B 7 1 z*:
K E1w& @ E 1 1P c& 7 % )
E:x K !9 B w@ .2 K => (0$"M%G '=H4" ]9 ! =^[G) - ?8@ 3%A B$: J 6+89 '".: !7 47 ; <
+T$&$5
- 8@ 3%A B$: 1508
The Second Conference on Electronic City
7 l04 8 1 > C62B M76 0B ,%& A
~ ~8!9 d1 .("7G7) &Z :$I F :9a (G
. Z v 8 :J% :J #% LM9
~8!9 #% 8; ;:$ .("7GH) ƒ$% : (p
<www.itiran.com>
2I :$( I :$ n0K .("7G)) , %T ("t
:!8!9 #% '+;% 8 8 :J%
S8N9 #% - v#; ".("7GH) <$ B (""
#% v(2 &$; r0$ '(#$ 9% 2*T N=(
.(; , 2v(2 &9; :J% ~8!9
*9+ 3$ :J" .("7G)) <2 Z 3 (")
:J% HGw .)p ( .1K '=#$ "~8!9 #%
.'V=O 8
#% :I :I0K *+^".("7G))La `!> : :3 ("7
") ( B8I 2:; ' " J :!8!9
.:O 8 :J%"?w
:C?J ;<
*
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1)Flynn, A and Purchase,S.(2000). " Perceptions of Barriers
to E-Commerce". ANZMAC Conference . 1st-5th Dec.
Massey University. Newzealand.
2)Faith Michael , Uzoka and Alice, Shemi, (2006)."
Behavioral influences on E-Commerce adoption in
developing country context". University of Botswana.
3)Ghasemzadeh,F and Sahafi,L.(2003)."A two dimensional
maturity model". Sharif University.
4)Ian. J. Lioyd, Information Technology Law, Butterworth,
London, Edinburgh,
18)Jerfy.H.Matsura, Rights and Liabilities in E-commerce,
5)Kalakota, R. and Whinston, A.(1997). Electronic
Commerce. Addison Wasley. Reading. MA.
6)Kosiure, D. (1997). UNDERESTANDING ELECTRONIC
COMMERCE. Microsoft Press, Washington.
1509
The Second Conference on Electronic City
This page is intentionally left blank
1510
!" +
#$" %!" & &'$(" )*
831(09155245711)
$ :1K J$ ;
J$ ; n0K #
[email protected]
1? ˜ %& %" @68 7 $7 X#6B ; ;1B7 1 M76 62 '/ C> W
7 B ; O624 ; M76 ; ,JJ*6 7 ,%> ;@E %0< . %& 7 C?# 06B 7 ( = > €# CN 7 N _# :? ,NP M76 ; > _> 1/B C+ 8. %& 1h8 @? ,P
a0 %%" > LI& 7 ! 1 B %& /B 1 .B %4 I6? 4 ? 1 7 % . Cv ,< 9
%00?  - 7 -i7 1 GvB .C0? z*: N< QP 7 -/ %00? @68 7 %00?  %6
.B %00? @68 ; M76  1 1H + I6B ;4P ; 7 iI>: =& 1? C"
1 M76 ; M 1 ,0@9 B ? 9 1 1 = L9 ,08 1 %00? @68 - 7 1Ii7
%EK 9 M E ;Q =NB 7 J & 2K ,P 7 > ;E`2 .B ,< j K
.%&
E4 2K ,P > `2 %00? @68 L9 %00?  L9 A6 ; M76 ;
M76 , M76
F
E z*: : %08 ƒ76w  ;Ex 6@N
I> ,ƒ76w 2" 7 8'9 A 0   E Rˆ 7 ˜ %@8 xx 7 > Xa 
B 1 1x AB , X" 0/) X" @
1 %0B ƒ %N/ 7 P%0 ˆ ( 7 %0x > %00x
) X" Q# I>7 (%& w %B %4
;E& ,2 =/ $# [u ] .%0x D260 ;7
˜(: :4 V( z*& $B X" 1x ; ;Q
!9
; O624 7 %0x CN 7 1 B
1 X" )26 % M76 ; ;%x 7 ; X ; w76w ‡% I6B 7 B
.B %00x AB
7 # 1? C62E k9 , x 1 F ;
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1 =@ DP ,< A@8 7 ƒ76w ; O3"
[T] .%0? ;624 7 ( =
1 @68 ; 7 ,0@9 W
7 B ƒ w76w 0 ƒ76w 9 1/B KB 1x < . [Tu ] %EK w76w '/ X ; XR 62 ,08
; ƒ76w ; .B B ; @68 7 0@ 1/B
,< ;E& 7 E > _# %& X ;E? CE
.%4 E:x > Xa 7 7 $2 CN 1 ,%B
: %08 :x dB Eg7" 7 0B ƒ76w $#
7 ( O W
DP > 8
.& w76w ‡% ƒ 1 06B
2
Integrity
1511
1
E-document
% 7 ; 1x B !# 162P 16w
; ;4 N %x , ‡I 16@x (-
‡% ." ƒ76w ; 9 $7 1 >
1x B %& 16& 0 ,JJ*6 $B P ;E16&
.B %& ‡@4 7 = 7 =@> w W* ƒ76w
,B 1/B 7 GI0x $B 1x w2< g7" ()
.%& P , (6w< ) =
%4 0 ;E%6B 7 > %8 _# $K DP
.B
; > B 74 x , ‡I 16@x
& x 1 jh > / / 1 7
4 :7 a_< . [4]B 16&
;7h %& ,08 _# 1 77 ; 1? ? W* 100 ;w@E » ƒI 8 ;& O
4 (~
> a0 e' %0F %6 .4 , B
1 c =H2 =J 7 => ; JJ* ;NE4 NP
7 O > S0 B 1 X7 @2 7 C0?
. [\] %& 0 W" «ƒ76w 7 k> 2I SP ,08 1 S0 .C" N< A@&
, :J ;E1 H< 7 18@ (
. [|]ƒ76w , pU 1 H< 7 M76
. %EK ;%/ ;EW* ;EW* -
% JJ* 7 0 1 i 6: ) 7 - :
7 ˜%: P % 1x 14 ,< 4 qE ~ 7 > ;E=>
1? %062E 0 7 > 10P 7 ; _# >'
7 .%4 I6? ;1 CHP 1 D/& / ^J6K 1 ˆ D+ > 0 10P 7 4 1 162
1 0 , JJ* 7 @E 1 7 7 0 1P X%8
7 M76 , >' /. [T\]&
.%& ƒ76w ; 7 ƒ76w jh ,%& %m"
.B %& -/ M76 , pU 1 H<
16K" ƒ76w ; w& 1 x% 1x /0 N0
1? %E ,: C S0 1? >' 7 -/
.B 1/B 7 > 7/ %0) > ;EN 7 ,%> >
# 7 Ex 0 %0F E EQ: x _# C? 2 (5' 7 0B ( ,B 7 1H 
> 1/P 0&< DB 1 ˜164 X ;%0@&
0 # 1 > S 7 SP -/ ; 66 1? B
1 ;1B g7" 6@x ,< 1 7 X@6E X%8 7 jh
[p] B %& 16K" ;70 I6B 7 %
= QP ƒ76w ; Rˆ 7 .B 16K" jh .B 16&% ,0x ,&(< 7 ,%> , NP
k> 7 -w -i7 1 B %& /B 1 M76 , U ; %0 K C62 9 1 M76 ; %0< 1? 2x
1 %& C0 '8 j E 8» :B %& -/ 0F
/ 7 > S0 B G" 3 ˜Cv %
” B0& ; 1x B X" 1 %& =J6 0 #
z*: > €# 1 %00x @68 7 %00x QP
«.4 I6B X" %00x
L9 7 E ; ,< P @h 7 -i7 GvB .? CEK
B ; ; !J SB -/ 2K ,P) > `2 ," .x CEK ,
.C0? &7 (... 7 a6 `2 
%00? ; 6E ,%B0& ,< / N0 S7 .4
-9 3 .,< 1 @68 7 # ,
‰ B ,<
I6B w76 1 ƒ ," K X 6& /B7
. 4 ;Q 16:" ;EC6Q 6
Secure/Enhanced/Advanced Electronic Signature
1
EDIFACT (Electronic Data Interchange For Administration,
Commerce, and Transport)
2
ASCUDA
3
UNCTAD
4
signatory
5
Relying party
1512
The Second Conference on Electronic City
: Q% ;P 1 >' X%? E , ? 1» ( -
.[2] « 2 77 ; 8 7 %& 1#2 /
7 % > 7 B 0 ;g7 A6 ;()
e 8 , 1? %I7 %7" AV ;
,08 1 M76 1 ," K X 6& 4 %&
162 !# A
0 O7 7 ? A M76 ;
. [Tp]B
.B M76 ; 1 6B ; ;&
7 M76 ; 1 R7 I4 , A7 a % ,< D> ; 6E N0 1 Q 8 1 B 1P ^JK 7 X@8 A6 ;
c& %0F 62 ,< 1 `@ k'9 ; 1 %0? /
1  + ;Q L%E ; , A6 ; ;70
: (M76 , TZ ) %& 16&
[10] 7P %? M !%J : %0 ? I6B > XNI
9& 0F .%& 1 J#0 %00?  1 2 ( -
A6 ; + ;Q !9 B @ Q ;B
7< 1 ," X 6& 7 ° 1 1? E
1? 4 N M76 ; $& AJ> ;
~K > 6& j 7 EX 1: 8 1 &
(T@& =&) .& %EK  (< ,@E (
. % ;8 M76 ; O %0FE ˜%&
%& ;7 ;J# # %00?  1B7 1 ()
; 6> B  E @8 $& c& . %&
. 6B
1P7 c& .%0? z*: X" %00?  E (~
D N0 7 B ;8 M76 ; ,< 56&
. % 7I %E ,:  1? 6E 1 06B 7 @68
,< E 1? & =J6 X" M 1 ;# 1 (
0 @ 1P7 c& .%& -:? 7 z*: = X" . B `@ M76 ; ;8 M76 ;
/8# $ 38Z ~8!9 $
~8!9 $ /8# $ '4 :" ( !
M76 ; 7 ;8 M76 ; 9 - (
.B 7I6 A6 ; ;70 I6B 1? B @68 7 )26 ( ,< Q 7I V(
.B `@ 7 B D 1 A6 ; The Second Conference on Electronic City
N0 M76 ;» B A7 74 = N0 :/
%& @E A6 ; %0 1? B 68 ; d# % ;7%> ( X %0F E 16I4 .[U] «
,< ( ž .B S& 7 D+ ž 1 i 7 ˜%&
E % 16I4 Q ;B .%% 7I 7 (< _>
: 1 & 16K0& A6 ; ,08 1 7 1? 
.B %& =: @8 7 JK %? ~7 M 0 €#
7 & I6B X" M ; ; JK %? @68 L9 6K @8 %? 7 ˜B %00?  6K
%06B ; B 1 ,< I6B ;7 7 %00?
, .B  ,6:" ,08 1 %? 10E4. %EK
1? P7 %? 10E4 %E: , %? M )*6
... 7  68 y %? D> E = 8'9 =&
.[11]B
(< DB 1 A6 ; 7 M76 ; , 1
1 a 7 1? .B _# =# N< > 7I6
:%& e
N0 A6 ; %0 6> .B =@# 14
1
3
Authentication of java code
1513
2
Digital signature
Private and public key
*+ , -. /.$
&! (') &%$'  E *B Q 1 ˜2 `@ M76 ; ; I !> 1? P S0 M E @2 ; %& 16& M76 , TZ $& 1?
%0 ;# 1 %00? / M76 ; 9
1 XB ;70 %0F E & )2# `@ M76
.%& B ,:> QP 7 O 1 1P %(
.%0 I6B A6 ;
, 10 7:" ;E:? 17 1 X7 a % 01
$2 3 ...7 B< k& )0P ? "7 1# ˜ ? &
A %8 7 A 1 ,< A@& 7@ , T
.[UZ] %00 I6B M76 ; g7 K I6B w76w ;E1B7 8'9 @ 7 ,B<
[T{] A62< 7 [T|]6 ,m@E @ > S
%8 7 A G" .%E O624 %%P 9 ;EC62B
;%0 16B 6> 7 & I6B M76 ; g7 ƒ76w ,08 # %0F E , %& -/
.B M76 ; ,08 R ? Xa E%7"
.B ; R 14 E =& w %& 7<
EP7 % > Xa A6 ; g7 ?
1 . ( 7 ;06B O R > S0 qE 7 & , 0 ,2 62 @? ,F B & DJ %@ ,< %8 L'K ;1 H< qE 1x ;9
L'6K :0 .B %: 7< A6 ; 1@? E BK 1 A = 7 2 P = DJ 7
1 %06K" , 7 2I 1 0 ,JJ*6 1? B -i7 7 -w / ;s7 QP 3 B 2x
0&< 7 > W 14E % 1? .,%>
[{] .
P7 1 e' %0F , _# $K ˜ % %8
.B %& ': 7 1 0 1? %7<
46%2 54' 3 &! "#
$
"%
N H
P xr 7 B 16K" x 1H 1 E 67 ;E,B 1 )K XNF 7 XB 1 .B
7< X
+ E 7 @ 1P7 1 K ;E/ 7 E%0< 6@2 1x %& 16BK
CN 2 E%6B 1? %0F E *B Q 1 .BE%6B
%0E 1H 7 1 K O
4 7 %0E X w76w
.[Tt] %0&@ 7< X
> ;0/ 12I %062E
t XNF 1 .(.. 7 Eƒ ,I ,4 7 ^J*)
E%6B %062E - 7 !> Sh7 > %8 1? >
;B " w76w R 62 ;EKB 1/B 1 %0
62 R@/ , ,4%02 .%0& JJ* 7 0 .(TU 7 t %0 1@P ) " w 7 ;E17
Q ;EN 1 ,< 7% D+ 3 %& E%6B > 7
; ;EXa 7 E)F NF 8 B7 0m@E
.%0E X
%& 7% ;E%6B 1 %vB
.[Y]B %& %? (ppTZ %0 ) > 7 0
B %& & > %8 7 E%6B @ 7
$2 3 - &7
8
4 7+ 1? ˜4 G/ 7 ,%> ? 0 ,JJ*6 K
G" 7 .%& 7% 7 1N 4 7 $B 1 < . %EK %? ;E%6B 7 -/h 1N ,< 16
J6 8'9 ;70 7 9 7 % 1 =@
B ;
1 7 ;E a 7/ 7 ;624
[p]%4 DJ 1 Tp{Y/Y/UT y 7 ˜%B ;N@P
%K 7 -i7 M76 E4 # ,< _> %@8.
,< / 7 ˜B M76 E4 7 SP
; 9 ; I !> %P C62 + C62
1
Common law
1514
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1 0 ,< 1 1P X%8 7 .B 3" )06P 7h
%" J*:  17 ˜B ‡% B ; R
, " 1 < > O .B M76
,62Q 7 w<  8 SP 1? %7" %0F 3 .%:
.B M76 , ,< / ,%& &7 ; jh K 1 %& e
;# 9
[TUTpTY] .x CEK
Q 2 163" A 8 > Xa 8 ;E/
J1
E g"U q
B #(" #K! :) a_<$
ƒ76w ” %8 ) [|]. 34 , jP DP 1
W C-
A
L8 I6B M76 , U , %0
4 ; > 7 > ^*& ƒ76w  w .B %& 16K0& @B 1 ( A/) '8 W0B
.%& ,B0&x %N8 62 JJ* L8 >
 & > C62 9 1 z*& p w .%062E
,%00x @68 L9 ,%00x ” %0:x O7 1 ƒ76w
&==
' (') <
.ƒ76w E4 7% %K .& e ; ; w76w ” jh
: -"))? 6*B 1 7 B , ; ,< 4s7 7 1x 
0F %00x  M76 , U A %0 ƒ76w ” S7 7 .x ,< 7 BB ;E ,
w76w  1x ;7 X CH z*& E :B %& -/
_8 1JJK .B NP %wE E B0&
x 1  I4 62 6N 8 1 .%0x %
1Fvw /B @ ;EN Q 7 = ,B %&
B  JK %x ƒ C8 4
1 .%00w ƒ76w ” Cx> %8 7 ;B
.[T\]B w76w
DP E:x $B 1@ ;E, , Q 1x a0
, p 34 , 3 .%& h/ WEx
:-"))? #
1 % 1:@E , 2I » M76
H< 7 % AI M76 , ,< -/
E:x Q0E@E 1/B 7h ,@ JK
z*& » :%& -/ 0F M76 , pU 1
, >. «x 1P 2> X7
8 7 ,< x
-/ «%0x X% ƒ76w E4 8'9 68 1 1x
9 I6B %#6 = ,B ,20x
.&@ ƒ76w  X2 Q =& 7 2 SP
> S0 ( % ; ;E w76w
E4 06 ” %00x @68 L9 ˆ -/
.[Y] B M76  jh @
‡' %>7 I6B 3 .B x -/ M76
-/ 0F %00x @68 L9 @ 17 7 1 H< T
& 4$ >
” ƒ fB 1x B z*& %00x @68 L9 » :&
;E w 2 7< X
/0 %0F E  17
[T\]« .%0x X% ƒ76w
The Second Conference on Electronic City
7 2I S0 0&< .& )2#
7 B = ,08 7 1 M76 , : 41
;E:x .[ | ]%0x 0&< ƒ76w ; Cx> %8
,< ;EE& 7 @ 1 62 .B %& & D9*
ƒ76w 1 ;3+x & K R 62 16:"
.%& 0&< %00x @68 L9 7 %00x  1 i ˆ %@8 1x B %& e 10 E%7" S 1
1 E X8 9 1 , D9* 7 B =
; _# ,F .% ,< X8 ;0/ ƒ76w ;
C> Q ;B 7 16 P :x 0E ƒ76w
L9 7 X" 1 E 0/ & x 1 X"
2
3
Originator
Addressee
1515
1
reasonable test
, ;68 x I6B Cx> %8 Rˆ @/ c&
%& 16I4 1x 9 ,@E Q ;B C B = 7 D9*
.[T{]x %E:
 .B X" 1 ƒ76w ; %0< E
% JK R J
L9 ,@E D9*7 %00x  ,@E B = ƒ76w
6> 1x ; ˜(M76 , \) 4 !
:ˆ 66 .B %00x@68
; .& ;Q =NB ƒ ) + 7 16BK Š6 =&
, %00x @68 L9 7 %00x  $7 x E T
1x %0x ! @h c7& !9 1? ;%00x  AV
%8 1 62 B7 1 7 A@P 7 XN x wB 34
1 ;347 %0x I6B ˆ J*&  ;E .x jP D9* 7 B = Cx>
%& J Dw % X 1Ii7 =x7 X CH
L9 7 %00x  B ƒ D9* 7 B = 1 U
.Q %N8 7 2K ,P `2 62
.B ! ^JK X@8 Q ;B %00x @68
:-"))I #
;J ' K
"2 47
$
9
:01
&5
@ $ "A 2B w I6B ;K qE ,7% 62 %00x  L9
M76 , pU 7 pT jh %K .%0x CE %00x @68 L9 ; ;1%H =r ;EO7
7 EC62B ;B " 7 ,< 6:"  1Ii7
,08 1 E,< -i7 7 -w A@8 1?˜ @ ;E17
:&=I $J 4' 9
x 1 H< .B B = ƒ76w  XB L9
ƒ76w E4 %K 6 1? 7 =B7 (-
%& -/ dB p ƒ76w E4 7% %K
X ; 6N O7 .4x 1 % O6K
@x> 6K 1x 1: ƒ76w E4 7% x .B
7 EO' 1? ( z*& ,F ˜B -w % 1x ƒ76w E4 7% x .B
A/ 7 x %00x @68 E4< ; ;7 A@8
JK W* $B /0 4 %0 JJ* ;E10
.%0x X ( x XB dB .%& % 7 =w: 67 %00x @68 L9 E4 a0 1 / ;EO' % ()
7 ,x%00x BK C62 1NP 1x %062E
7'8 62 EO' > %E X B a6 1x
E4 7% x 1 ,4%00x X ( %& ‡%
t ) x 1P 2> = 1 A/ W0B /
.%00x 1H 1 ƒ76w
(M76 ,
** B ZU
M! Z1
r :)-/ a_< .
%0x CE ƒ76w ” 6:" ; ;Q %K  1? %% %00x  ; 1w0 c& 1
B %> ;%/ =J 7 =J %& xr D
1x %0x > 1x & ;7 ; & .B 164 !
.%062E & = %& xr S0 Q 7 P 1x
!  A%62 7 %00x S %7 ƒ fB .& -w O624 1 0 B w@ ^K , DJ
:. C -D%
.
@=8 $E) 4' FG
FHD 9
. [TY]( A>7 jh7 $&
1x w76w  & ; 1x EAV
,< Cx> L8 7 A/ W0B 1 162 a# /
E
X I6B EB 8 XQ0E z*&
... 7 1 j 1x B N% ,4 1P 62
=w& 6> ^*& $7 .%0x I6B R ,< %K
c& .B a# 7 dB / BB 6x
1
0 1 B w@ w76w 1 ^K 6'8 ^K
AV ; .& 8 62 ƒ76w ;E” j X@
.& ƒ76w 
1
2
Data Message
Certification service provider
1516
The Second Conference on Electronic City
fB 0@h ! > Q 8 1) B 164 4' 3)J
F=' &%$' <
&5
@ ' &)G 9
,x X/ ; 0 7 A/ % 62
1? `@ ƒ76w ;E” ˆ -w $& 1F 1x .%E X ƒ76w ; ƒ ,0@9
.& A@8 62 & 6:" ƒ76w E4
(- :& ƒwI 62 jh 7 C @68 ; A/
,0@9 WNi , =x 7 # Rˆ 7 62 (-
7 ^K $& B w@  68 -:x ; : 68
$& !9 =x 9 1  XQ0E 62 0/ .%0x =>
& `2 ,6 %& X % , A/ ( .%0x =@8 E4 .%00x SP 7 K %& !
() .x DB K 6/ + AR 8  1 @68
E4 68 7 :, %/ E4 68 1 1P ()
% / :%00x @68 L9 DP A/ %
y 7 & j7& M76 E4  % y
C> ,9 / 7 N ,1 /9 fB A/
[T{] . 1 ,< ; A
A@/ ;EO7 7 ;N0:" ;E10
4 , f6B ,R
.[TU]& %0B .... 7 L8 7
:-"))I &! FL 9
C> R 1x w76w f 4x ƒ AV ;
B 2K ,P 1 0 1x % `2 ( x
;/ 1 1P @68 ; A/ O7 %E X R
1x ˜%00? B % `2 , 7 % , %@8
 L9 E > 60 %> R I6B 0
1x ˜Bxr = 16w %0F .B ~K 1 1> K %K ; E/ 1w< A> .B %00x
2K ,P @ ; % `2 ,x B0& ; B ! ƒ %> % w76w ;NEQ&7
.%0x ; , k> ,< 60B Xa 1 1P %" A7
E > ; A ;17  ,08 1
.%0x
1x B CN ; J ( `2 ( (-
S7 _# 1x )B 9 -w 7 -i7 J /
.(%&
&5
@ 4=% 4' -", &GMN <
.B J ž ˆ E4 7 B 8 R J ()
.& 6:" ƒ76w E4 ƒ 1B7 1  4
= B @ a6 `2 1B7 1 J*& 0F
:62 k 7'8
ƒ76w P ƒ " ƒ J AV ; .%& Q"
y2 %& A E4 .%0x B E4 68 (-
;E A@: x& 7 -0 ,< ;B B w@
4 3 [T\]%68 ;EE4 %& I60 %&
w76w ; I6B ,w X%8 AV ; .4 a6
,< & ;Eh X@ %0x =@8 68 E4 fB
... 7 / % ;
. %EK ;7 ;%N8
The Second Conference on Electronic City
;E7%# .%0x 8 E4 Cx> 7%# ()
**4 + s" ZU
! Z1
r :)
: a_<3
x 7%# AV ; I6* j E4 Cx>
B 2x X@ =& 7 ;624 ;0/ %00? @68
(%& ;%w ƒ76w 1@ ; ˆ J6K '
ˆ V)
AV ; .[TT]%00x @68 ƒ76w  ƒ 1 1x
, TZZ -B Vx%> '
ˆ V) R C> 7%#
.% %00x  ; + ; 1 1x *&
... 7 I6B %/ , 7%# (A
K ƒ76w E4 %K x 1x B J = 6>
7.%0x @68 E7%# 1 C8 %00x @68 L9 4
.& 16K0& %00x @68 L9 %00x 
1 7 2K ,P A`2 K %0? =@8 N< 7%> ~K
1 0 62 %00x @68 L9 XNI 16
R C> 7%# 16 . %EK _( ^*& 7 K
68 K 1x 4 EQP E4 %N/6 1x &
. %EK A`2 1 2
.%0x % E4 x %& ;%K E4
1517
0/ %0& V0K ;70 1 2 1? C0? 7% ;14
%& 16I4 1x (2K ,P) % `2 7'8
%8 E%6B }p .%0& 16&% 1 ;70 ; B J = %00x @68 L9 ; a6 `2
-/h DP > 7 0 =K% C0? MI >
L'K %00x @68 z*& 4 } A% AV
1/P =/ > , 7% }t : > %0w 8 E4 ;E7%# K ;1> =@/ 6B
.3" (Q: %B ,6B  '?7) >
. %EK a6 7 I0 K !#62
, =@ 7 z 7 4%0x" 1 1P }T :$5
$
B %00x LJ %00x @68 L9 1x HP : 41
7 ... 7 4%B 7 ,B H< 1 ^J* A@8 7 2I ;14 1 62 %& 16I4 -w 7 %8
; 7% Q ;B -w 7 E`2 , &7
) A7 =J ~%0 %00x LJ k> z 1 0 1x&
˜B 7h ƒ76w ” 1 62 ,
c7& 7 6> 4 M76 , XB
3QE 7 C0x A@8 6N B ; Cx> k>
 1x %00x LJ -w 1 ,7
; ;
.CB CE ƒ76w 1/B 7 %& 10 C6
@68 B AV ; .B 3 + ˜%& %00x LJ k>
B ! > 7 ;7 h =@> (%00x LJ) %00x
; > 1/B 8 a ; %>7 % 62 }U
.%00w ,< ;E I 7  . P ;70 :" ;v@E k> & -/ B
7% B ; , 1JJK 1 1P }p
5
.B 3" 7h ž/ S 18@
1@ ;E?& EM E;N& :O5QN .
3
$ -*'
; B B ; E fB 1? M76 ;
71H 5' 7 0B ( ,B MI 8 ;&
O3" %0 6/ 14 E 1? B > -/
X8 7 J6 7 8'9 ;70 7 9 7 4
I6B %& B ; ,< !J .[t]B -/
....7 ; ;E?&7 ;70 7 # 7
6: =@8 1m< .4 A6 ; ;70
; 6:" ; M76 E4 I6B .Ba
:'J/
c/
7 - M76 ; j X%? E .B M76
02> 2> %B ;< )0P X4
%B ," M E J 7˜%0? 9 ; K -i7
Sh 7 ; 1? 02# %/B 6? ;< )0P 7 f%
1 77 = 3 ˜ %EK 9K ; > `2 DP
.C0? : %? ; WE7s" .C& K F 6@? %& 0&< 62 B ;
S0 5% 9 -i7 1 ;E"
Y"
WE7s" A'K 1? / -/h 1 64
:OP
7 z 1@P 7 > > + 7% %& &<
Y)
6 ;EW@:? 0? 1? ˜B [p] B =@
7  ,%> %& DP M76 ; 6 ;EN
Y7
Y?
Y@
A> %0& 76 5% O3" 1 %01'8 6@? ,6B
.B M76 $7 1" %0< 1<
;E%6B 7 E/ 7 }T :G5
$
1 }U .C0? l@E M76 ; jh NP
1
B2B(business to business)
1518
The Second Conference on Electronic City
/ v #% '(#$ 0$ &I ˆ0% &% J( *; 0$ &I &% v2oZ *+$ J%
"7G@
' ; *3z :98# $ :A4B$ 19
G7 A; J%p7Y@Q‹, @@ ( '=#$ :!8!9
~8!9 :2O : &+^ 0 :A4B$ 19
"7GQ % C J% )?Yp ‹,G) ( '=#$
+ '; /$ ~ '^= :;0$ :0
'+;% v ~8!9 #% ; Z 2v9>
"7G@ L '( J$ ""7Y7 ‹, "p (
#% *;; :J% -MO ~%$A :9 'C
"7Gt J% :$; J( ~8!9
.%& ~*6B }%062E CN 7 ? 1?}P
'8A2 ~8!9 #% n0K :3$ -MO :3 La `!> ‘ YH
"7GH/p/)? J% q3% B '$
M$ J% / = 3z 9 3z , % YQ
"7Q)
"7Q" 8 :$J; J% n0K <= '$0$ , % YG
~8!9 #% :=$ -MO:O M '$ *+$ Yp
: Z : *; IGH 8 “%G@
The Second Conference on Electronic City
http://prd.moc.gov.ir/to/Reports/first%20ecommerce%20
report2nd%20edit.doc
10- HLSG, report on electronic signature , documents of
collaborative digital signature ,21 sep 1998 available at
http://www.hlsg.com
11- Information Security Committee, Electronic Commerce
Division, Digital Signature Guidelines, 1996 A.B.A.
SEC. SCI. & TECH. [hereinafter Digital Signature
Guidelines
),
available
at
www.abanet.org/scitech/ec/isc/dsgfree.html.
12- Internet library of law and court decisions , hattuck
v.klotzbach,USA,11
dec
2001
available
http://www.internetlibrary.com/alldecisions.cfm
13- Internet library of law and court decisions , rosenfeld
v.zerneck
,USA
,4
may
2004,
available
http://www.internetlibrary.com/alldecisions.cfm
14- Katholieke university Leuven, Digital Signatures: A
Survey of Law and Practice in the European Union,
Cambridge, Woodhead Publishing,2001
15- Longy.D and Shain.M, Dictionary of information
technology ,McMillan press publishing,2004
16- Sculthorpe, Alice ,Mehta v. J.P Fernandes, 7 April 2006
,available
http://www.internetlibrary.com/alldecisions.cfm
17- Smedinghoff Thomas J. and Bro Ruth Hill, Moving with
change : electronic signature legislations as vehicle for
advancing E-commerce ,the john martial journal of
computer and information law , VOL. XVII • Spring
1999 • NO. 3, p723-768
18- Uncitral , Model Law on Electronic Signatures Guide to
Enactment, new York , united nations publication 2002
19- Unctad ,E-commerce and development report, new York
,United Nations publication , 2003
20- Vanderhof, simon ,digital signature law survey
,university of vantilburg ,2008 ,available at
http://dsls.rechten.uvt.nl
1519
The Second Conference on Electronic City
This page is intentionally left blank
1520
! 311(09173098261)
~8!9 #% :;
[email protected]
M
1 6B ; ;70 ;E76B I6B 1 4 18 %0@% > 7 ; E,B
@62 7 X7% 44 dB 1 % ,B 7'8 .%062E K ,0?? 7 K 7 N dB R
2K ,P BB W ;1@ ;E,B 7 1@ .%062 %P %8 1@ ;E?& 7 E,B .%0B
NP 1? 0 ?> .B 1/P ;J6 ;E/ =N2 1@ # .% %N8 M2 & 1 76 1@ .%& 60 ;7 1@ 76 %K 1H B ,P A> 1@ ;E,B 44
1@ ^K ;0/ 7 4 k'9 ; 1@ %K S 7 % 8'9 ;70 7 60 ? ,08 1 X8 ;0/
N0:" BK $K 9 1 1? B ; 1 1@ !9 ;1@ W&" M  ,08 1 , 76
$K % 2K K" O" 7 1 1@ S 1@ !> K" 10 .4 %/0 ,< 7 ?3
.%E% @8 76 '
ˆ ? X P B @ 0 7 a ;E7%# E:? K .4 X
X7% M76 1 1 1@ S 7 1@ !> K" !# 6:" ; NP dB e' 7 % 1@ M76 %K 1H 1? > 7 K 1 .%062E e' A>
.C0? B %4 ;EBB JK C> I> M76 2K ,
=# M76 ;E M76 1@
;34 @
;4N 7 ;E 6 1@ /0 ,
;%0h @E %0? D+ 7 !: ?K ;EC62B
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.[TT]B ;6:
4 K L%E :" ; S0Q %0@E 1@ /0
;N>9 7 %K 1H NP 7 ;g0 1? B
1@ C62B M ;% %? 6@N B 7 1@ l0E Š7 a0 1 0m@E .4 N ;1@ -6*
7 %062 6/ 8'9 ;7<S@P 1 , @E M76
7 X8 HP N 2 :? dB 1@ %H X'8
? E;%019 1 , @E .[TT]B %& ;
@
.[t]%@ K 7 N 7 ,0
%7 7 R ; 2 %> 1@ %K 1H C62B
/0 7 E?& I6B R M76 1@ /0
I6B ;6: %K 7 ?% ,? CE
1 . %N8 ;%@8 W N< ? 3+? 1? 4 . %EK ;6: )6& C20 8'9 7 ( %
7 ;%NQ Q ,7 ;E10
E Q 6N 8
M76 /0 1/B 7 %& 1 1P 7 ;E& 6 1 0 ;3+? )6 0B 7 RB AB
/0 ;4? 1 %K 7 ER? 660 O7 7 1 ,%:* 8B ;E;g0 ;4N 7 %%P
:1 , 1@P ,< .[Up] 7 ;
E?&
7 < ;E;4N NB 0m@E 7 E10
E WE? ?
1521
5% 7 0B % 10
E WE? 8 6@N , .[t]B %& 5% 7 0B ;
E6& 7 ; 8'9 SB L3> 7 E1B7 EGg< ,
4? 1@ %K ,4%0E1H X@ 1?
4' 53.% 4' ,0@9 = 7 %062 8'9 W
%N/ (41@) 1@ x& ,< 1" 1x B @" 1@
,6: 1 %K SB 1H 7 B6B , W
.? &
;%7 " 341@ 1 %& 7 , 7 ? K" 7
7 %K ;EC62B 64? 1 E10
E WE? i
" 41@ 1 341@ 1x " .%0x ,P 16BK
%7 1 @ ;1@ ;E?& ; s7 1 76 O7
,
.%0 1@ jh & 1@ 1x 1F,< 7 1@ !>
,7<CE .[u] c ,< 16B" ,P 7 ? 7 ( ;?
7 1@ jh 7 & / R@6> )2> 1" 1@ !>
% 76 ;EX 7 ? 0B ;4? 1 7 % ,
1@ 10:" .%< 11@ X 1 ;6& %0B ,< $&
.%E WE? 16IE M 1 E ? X ,
% &%N 1@ Q6BK 7 4 ,6B ,7 1
.[\]x P 7 2P 'B ,%@
W
œ WE? 7 ;E7%# 6 ;E10
E WE? 8'9 1 ,B< B6B O7 C>
%00x ,341@ 1x ;1B 1@ ;Ex&
6KB 7 E/ ,%& JJ* ;% ;6: '/
;E10
E G" %00x 7 %K 7 4 ;Ex .[TT]B M76 1@ I6B ;
1@P O7 1&
6:x ,%& k+ @"E cB %0 ‹
;E, &
;E
1@P ;1@ ;68 ;E? :6 7 %
W 16 .%0< 624 ;E;BW< 7 =B
;% 7 ;68 ;E? Q ;" 1 " 1? B /0 E4 7 64
;1@ ;Ex& 1 E E,<
O*6B ;1@ ;E1/ 7 11@ O7 6KB
K" 1@ !> ,< 1 7 %%0 @ ;Ex&
.? %EK BB
%7< W< ,: X ,x 1@ E,< 0 .%00x
1 B c 7 8'9 6@N M76 1@ 1 Q ;Ex& K 1B :* ,x 1@ K 7
7 8'9 ;70 ;4N M76 1@ 6N 8
.%0 B W<
1/P 1? B 1@ ;%%P %0< ; 9
;16 ;%&K TUuZ & % 62*
=& M76 1@ 7 . *@E ;1& 7 8'9
R 1 , 1@ ,B 7 = 7 =@> GB ,08 7 1N 0m@E 7 8'9 ;EKB ;4?1 7 1/B
,7 GvB .% P 1 1x x 347 B7 -x"
@8 ; XR 7 EBB ;P 7 7%
7 g B7 0 7 ;%&K TU{| AB 1 P &%@>
.[TT]B 1@ /0 6 8'9 1/P
X<X<. %x +< K ;1@ ;E/ ;x wx
1@ /0 < 7 SB 1/B S EWF ,
AB U\ 1x 6 1 , ;Q PK ;Ex&
.B %& M76
x& U| CxB TpTt AB 7 %06& B , 1@
CEK B EWF K 1 x& 7 E,< , .%06& / , PK 1@
1@ /0 / 1 %6 1 1 .
)' ;7" 7 % A/ 1@E :x 7 œ62Q0
1 X7 W* .C" M76 1@ Ni 7 M76
.%06K" x 1 'B
;E %0 M76 1@ ;EWF K
x8 7 ,< %2w W&x 1 ;%&K TpTt AB 2K ,
1B# 7 M76 %K 1H & M76
, UZ 67 1B , 1@ NB x& 7
'K K XB W* .C0? B % % x& qE y ,< W" .%& =w: A
, 1@P .C0? / 1@ %K ,%& 76
x& x 1 +< .&% P7 ,6B7%0E 6> 7 17K ;E& ,6: ; JK C> I> 1
x& 7 PK ;Ex& %0&K , 1@ NB
;1'K XNF W* .? & ;34 @ ;EBB
.C& 7< 1 %& 1H D 1
1522
The Second Conference on Electronic City
1 (341@) ;Q x& 1x " % %0x
# 4' 1 PK ;Ex& 7 %& 7 1 7 ;2 ;E0w&x .B ^*& ;E1@ CN ;E16& @8 1@
1@ , .%062 wK 1@ ,< 6*B
1? & %N/6 1@ !> ; 1@ ?& @8 1@
7 %B ;& G DJ 1 ;%&K TpTY :N
1B 0/ , ;7 ,% % %& 1@ .[U]%& 347 , 1@ x& ,< 1 67 ;E,B 1@
1 341@ 1 ;@62 1 91 %&1@
;E1@ % U\ %%& -i 67 ;Ex& 0FCE
@8 ;E1@ j .v B ? / ;7 1? V( z*&
w 1@ , 1@ NB x& , K :[pU] 8 CE
1@ , 7 AB 1 ;1@ ;E/ y j7& .%00x
-6* A& 1 %&1@ > @8 ;E1@ W" AB M 7 6IE 0/ .[, 1@ ,] 4 ¦­¦¬
-6* A& 1 %&1@ @8 ;E1@ 2 7 %& 34 67 K ?& M GB ; ;1"
> %&1@ 1B 1? @8 $6* ;E1@ .%0? 7 P ;EPK = .& K" A> E 1 1B K" %N/6 @8 1@ 41@
:[U]2 %&1@
:?K K 1@ :341@ ; :?K a% ;
1 ;@0E ,08 1 @E @’ ? %& <
4 E1@ !> 0? %& 1? C 7 .[\]4 W
= 1 _( z*& ;E1@ !> ;P %& L3>
yB" & B œ ;P %& 7 1RB ;E1
;7 7 = 7 %& 1@ C@J 1? /0 I0 7 V %& ,
1? %E 1 ;&7
.B ~K 41@ %N/ %&
.B 1F 1@
1? :%00? I6B B 1 %& 1@ =6 / W" CB ; 1? B 68
CE %&1@ =6 P 11@ %00?I6B
14 E 7 B 1@ /0 1/B 7 %8 %' 7
%&1@ =6 .& ( 7 1@ 7<
AJ> ; 7 CN 2 /0 6KB 7 A#
=6 B :?K 1& %00?I6B B1
;7< = .%& 16& P7 ;7 % 76B 1
h Kr N0 41@ %00?I6B B1 %&1@
7 ;7< O3" ; P ,R72 7 ,% Er ,? <
. 62 341@ 1 1& 7 ,41@ C8 1@ ;EQ0 1@E .B XR 41@ 1? 1@ , §¥ :l0P K @6> 1 @ N0 1 A# 1? %3v % O7 7 %
%E* O& 7 l0P & ;E2K A`2
, @6> 1? ;% E 0 .B > 7 ;7h
=1 .%& %& c& 11@ ,< L'K 1?,< Q
7 %EK A# A6B 1 %& 16& 7 A# 7 K ,41@ ;1@ ;E , 6
7 ;E: 7 %0:0 1? % %E* a60
1@ h 1@ !> K $& #
D %E ,: E< 7 .4 O3" 1 F ;6KB
.%00?
7 B 0 W :" & ;J6 %& % 0"
.[{]2 ;J6 ;0Q0 1B @? Q
The Second Conference on Electronic City
(&
$
) # C 4' "A ,6: 1 1@ %K /B7 10 ;1@ ;E?&
1x B ;BW< 1@ ;16:" & [TT] 1@
1H 1@ %K I6* ;E;%0 16B .%00? 1H K
1@ & .% X 1@ ;Ex& 62*
;1@ %K ;%0 16B A7%6 . P7 %&
1@ .%& 1@ 16BK ;E;7 E
.[TT]B e& 1 ;1@ ;E?&
1
2
Life Insurance
Non-Life Insurance
1523
j06 34 1@ 7 41@ , 1@ ;E P7
7 EEP 1@ @"E 1@ 6:x 1@ 7K 1@ ,@6KB
1 P ? 9 1 .[p] P7 L'6K => ;
.%062E 16B Q j E 7 %0@& ;E
F
;E P $& j 7 34 1@ -i7 jh 7
.C0? & 1@
&TLM.' 4' "A ; 1? & 2? X@ =& 1@ %K 16B $
W@ 4' VH a h> A> 7 ;1@ ?& ;1@ !B
: B 8 34 1@ -i7 [p][U] fB %K % 7 %& / 162: 1@ ?& P
!> %6 4 1@ 1@ N0:" ! 8'9 , .%0? Q62:
%0x / d# 1@
%& 1@ K = 1? ,4%&1@ X%? E
1@ !> S 1 K" !9 ;1B 7 %062E W&" # Q62: P7 1 1P ,7% L/6 %> 1@ iI> ;@62 1 PM 1B 1 41@ 1@
7 %< )2>1 @8 ;E1@ 7
P Q62: 1@ .%00?
34 1@ =@8 ( 1@ 4) K %%: X'8 7 ) 1@ !> % K" G" . ;%G" JK
4 1@ j'9 1 % D & %%: _( z*& =@8
1@ (& %@ 41@ ;E10
E A7 AB 1B
(& % 1# 7% 7%B
1 1? P7 , 16 .& h Kr ;
2K 1 0 1x ;1(> j7 XQ0N X'8 .B 4 1@%N/
ˆ %@8 341@ 1F4 .& %K =% -I* 1B
F? W* ." 1@ !> Ca8 W* 7 B ?
7 k> 2? G" ? 1? B %& 1@ %N8 1 CE ,<
4' 5
$
U
, X
B / E74 ;E Q62: 1@
@8 $& ,4%&1@ M E ; 41@ = @E1 B ,4%&1@
B ,2w 16& ƒ ,34 1@ X@ ; 1x B &
1@ 8 Q62: 1@ .%0? Q62: 1@ E4
W< 1@ @8 $& %0) & ›F 1 1@ :" 7
1@ !> 6B @E 7 & )2# > c&1 @8
(...7 = 1% 1@ @8 $& ;B
Q62: B 1 ,%B = %&1@ 4 0/ .B
JK $& !> 1@ 1B K" 7'8 41@ %0?
7 B / 34 1@ ƒ ^J* JK $&
. 62 Q62: 1@ 6 ;E1@
%& 1@ ;EK 1@ !> 1@ jh 34 1@ J*:
,7% %& 1@ 1? & c& Rˆ @/ Q62: ;E1@
% ,< 41@ %N/ ,
7 (1@K 7 j7&) %
K Q6: @8 1 1@ %@ ? h DP
&
=# %0? -I* 1B 1 1@ 1 =% %K
@8 $& s7 $& . X7 ,< 6 Kr
7 4 1@ 1x B K ^J*
s7 $&
;EK w , 1@ %0) & !34 1@
4' & U
, (%&0V6B
7 $& %6B 7 ;EW* B %0 1 1@ 7 ;1@ %K ,44 j P7 1 1P .B C?> ^K
1
Retired Insurance
1524
The Second Conference on Electronic City
:[U]B j 1B ;E P $& ? 9 1
.[U]" 41@ 1 K CNB @E 1 %& 1@ ;
60 !9 ER? j , 6> 1 ,0? 7 16
$2 .? ;%K
K .B %< =@8 1 ;%/6 -/ 76 ; C8 ^*& , 76 9 1? 1 ,<
-T)' ' -T)' ;E/ E74 .[pT] %? - > 7 '/ O7 7 %K & 6@N 1? O7 164 7 >9 ;J6 ;EQ0 76
7 %K B2B ?.%P 1/ L9 7 B 76
7[TT]162 %%" jh &IB ;P 7 O7 7 %
% N0 1 B2B .B M@? 1 %@8 O7
R? 4 ;NEQ0 @8 i ,< Q K
B0& E1B7 % 1 %0B0: K ,6: 1?
.[Ut]%0 7 c ;EC62B $B %K 7
.%00?
1? %E ,: ,< S0 ;62P 7 ?3 -/ 1 @8 E .B ,< ;EQ6BK %/ & -/ %/
-"))I ;Y ' -"))I ;Y B 1 76 I/ K 8h DB0
%00? LJ 1/ L9 7 76 A% @8 $ ;E/ e' 4 .B
,4%00? LJ C62 1NP A% % .%0&
4% . 6% ;E?? % 7 %0 4
10
E , 5% .B R? O77 %K a0 1 Q%
XNI N% 7 76 8 6 >
$B C2C A% I6B 1/B 1 0 06 76 ;EC62B I6B ; A@8 X ,<
. B %& 660 ,?
k'9 ;%8 18@ 1 76 k> 7 [U\]
1? B ;> 76 9 i 1? 4
F ' -T)' 9
XNI % ;2 .[pZ]& %K k>
} ; R @ =& 76 j k> > 7%# ;7@ 1 76
$B 7 ;E .B 67 ;E,B 7 %0 ^K 76 C62B 1 ,< ,@ 7%# 0m@E
1? B 8h 1@P ž8 K" 7 N6?&
CP 10F .B e' ;Ei ;0/ 7 60
67 W* =@ W
B2G . ;P 74 ; k> / B 76 $# %& S7
.4 !7 K@87 E6KB ,@ 76 1 2
k'9 76 ,08 $# @8 k> 1? 18 , 76 -7 .&@
&
4# 4' 4' $ 9
%E W&" 8'9 ;E;70 $ ;E>
E%%" B %& L7/ 8'9 J8 1 1? h> ,
C2 I6* j 1 ,< 9 / 68 1 76
.%& B 1 1? %?
DP , 16K0& 7 Ni @h 1? B 7< @E 1
%& E:? ;J6 7 ; 7 BB A#
The Second Conference on Electronic City
BE%%" CN 1@P M76 .[UZ]B
-"))I ;Y ' -T)' ;% %@8 . @E 1 CE 1?
(%0&7) %00? % 1/ L9 M j ,< 1 C? 16 1? B M76 1@ ,< 0? 7 M76
. (N %00? LJ) %K Q L9 7 AJ#
.B %& K"
&7 K B2C j 76 CNB 6:
W
8B 1 )7 O624 j .%E =:
2
Business to Business (B2B)
Consumer to Consumer (C2C)
4
Business to Government (B2G)
3
1525
1
Business to Consumer (B2C)
N< ;%0 1P BB A@8 7 > 7 > ,4%0@ 1&
CE 1 ? -/ M 76 1@ . V62
= K 1@ rI Dh 7 1@ !> % V ( 7
I6B ;1@ %K 1 ,6: B6B , 6KB
,%& CE 7 XB E 1 77 .B8% ;Q ;4
.[U|][U{]& k'9 > ,7% 7 @ ;E1B7
1 Q 7 NP ,B ,:? 8 $&
7 RJ# 1 7 1 1 M76 1@ Q -/ 0
E,< 1 % 1? 7< P ; RB ,%& NP
16I4 76 ;EA? !9 5% ;N ;1@ %K
.CE yB"
.[U{]&
L> 7 %& ž8 = 1? 9 ,@E ;g0 7 W
7'8 1? 2* ˜[U|] 7 76 1@
AJ ; NP ;E '/ ; 7 % A7
!9 (K) 6% 7 ; ;E10
E , WE? > 7 > ,4%0@ 1& ,% O< 7 7 ;g0
;1& c 8 & _8 ? => ,%& 1 67 .& 7 1P ,< 1 % 1? B 8h CE
%" 6% 8'9 7 %< P7 1 E?& ;E%>7
Q _( z*& ;E11@ ¥¢ ¢¢ 1B¦¨ [Uu]<
.B E1B7 1 6K" ? WE? ,< X7 .%0?
D 1 Q6B §©¤¬­¬¢ 7K %/ 1? C0?
7 & 16K7 ,6: 1 C62 9 1 11@ 1? F
;E%&1@ Dh @E 7 16 W
Q6B¦¨©¨¨¨¨¨
1? @h .& %EK ;C? 10
E ,%K ;
16 R % ©­ $B6 AB A9 E7K ¶ 1? 7< P7 1 , E10
E P1
% F % 1@ ;E?& ; @E 7
E,< 7 & ,6: L 6 %& P1
1 /0 % A# e9 < 1? C&
.%7< B 1 ;W %K E11@ %0
< 0m@E .& 0 A/ 7< P7
P7 X%8 = 1 ,:? %< =@8 1 ;EB 9
,
¥¢ A7 W& 7 ¥© 7 ¥¬ AB 7 :? 7
;% W* DB0 * 7 9 ;EKB
; ;E1@ W* 1@ /0 7 ;E1@ !>
;E:? B D8 2 76 1@ 7 76
;7 W" BB AB [U{]C0? 12 7
> %K 6KB 1 1P 1? %0FE .C62E
%& 76 %K 1 ,7< ;7 , < 1? 4
1@ /0 12 NP = % 76 ;%
–C& 16& a6 1@ %K I6B 6:
; ;EWF M76 1@ %K 1H .B %& X
M76 1H %& d: = W* 1? 1m< 1 1P [Up]% 16B 1B EWF ? 9 1 . P7
1B %E ;4P E ;1@ %K
0 ;EWF .%& E,< %K 10 O624 7 1@ ;E?&
7 > ;EWF 1 1? P7 EWF ;1@ %K 76 1H
'K 7 Q0E ;EWF .? CEK & E,< 1
7 > ;EWF K B 1 1 1 .C" M76 1@ %K 1H 'K
;E 1 , %J , 68 1 E
* ;EC62B 9 1? E 0/ 76
C"U -E- CA-O /C-
A &aU
+< I ,
1 «X" » Q 8 1 7 (,< %0 7 ; 76)
W* ; DB0 62 J 7 0? $&
;E 7 %00? I6B WK %J , a0
1 67 W* E;4;%J 7 6K ;347 7 JK
;EO7 $B N< / 1? ;E 0/ 76+
,4C@J %N8 I 7 ? CE JK W*
=? O
4 1 06B .B 16&34 :? 1@ /0 A7
1
World Trade Organization (WTO)
; 92 @@J %B W ,41@ ;%0B
1526
The Second Conference on Electronic City
&
5
$
/ , 3 7 %& 16& ”: %J R % 16&
C2 4 16& 7 I 1@P Q
.[T] P7 76 $# h ;E
;E ^JK 1`2 6@N..[T|][T{][TU]?
!9 1? ;8 68 7 %J 76 , ,
.[Tu][Tt]B ,< j7 , 7 , GvB 7 68 76
1 M76 7 '/ 1 SP %& %/0
, .B 164 dJ XN 14 E S a0
&
5
$
$G#
% ^JK #J , 76 .B ,< # $& S@P 1 c0 ,@" E 68
? A %J , X X" 68 7 rI %8 -7
j7: NP 7 / jh E h 7 %J % ,7 T|Z
1? u 7 Y 1@P 76 , -6* 7
& I: 8 .% E,@" X@ / 1R 7 %@ 6B  7 16& X" ; R
I: 7 $h S %J , 1< %& 7
?3 = ,08 1 76 0B 1? , TU C8 E 1? 76 / 1? < .4 ^K
.[pp]B c06B = %E B0&
;E 68 1`2 %& ) % I: 7 h
.B B = y2 7 E 76
&
U[ $ &2DM2 5
$
$G#
, C> 0 1? B ; I: a0
7 $& 8 ,< / 7 # 1R 9 ! .B E ? / 8h B 7 !
%/6 & I: .%& %8 # @8 $& 7'8
7 $h S 7 ! 7 %J , 1 1? B ,< %8
,%&  7 , 6? jh A  c& ˜
$& 7'8 Q ;% 8 1 7 4 & 6
, .%& A& 6@N @B %0B Ca0 , h = 1? %8 fB .B ;7h %8 #
1 c7: 76 $# I: ;N@" /
68 1 1? %4 =& E 4
16B X 8
.[pZ]B ?3 $# I: %K h 8 N< j7 L9 7 ;h I?
$& 1? jh A  c& ^JK The Second Conference on Electronic City
&
U[ $ &\$ 5
$
$G#
.[pZ]%&
;E$# 1? < I4 % %& 08 8 #
T|Z E , h = :? k> 7 AB = 16& 7 J C8 8'9 76
T|T %0? J> %8 # $& 1? % ,
 & J ”# @6 ,< 1 =B
%J R 1? ;
F 1 ,< , ,7 %8 j7 1? ,
0 .[pZ] %EK 3" , 8'9 76
P 1? %8 # $& ”6B 7 % ? %@ :
/ %& 08 8 jh %6 X" 1? = %
@ T|Z @8 $& ;% .[T]& @ ?3 8 76
.[pZ]B c06B
1? 0B ,%&  7 , 6? c& jh 76 + 76 ;E k 1P7 1? < & ,8r % B 164 dJ ,6 K
,? , 1? 1m< !0 C> 1 B %J , .%% ,2 6E ,< 76 j 7 6B  7 16& 1?
= 7 _# ;P % , T|Z jh %8 #
 7 16& B 3+? 7 D? ? 7 1> 7 68 1`2 .B %J , X X" !9 1? B 6 ;EA0QB ;18@ 76
: &7 7 B *B" h ;E / X" .& ( 1 1a> %& =60 9 ;E1B
E , h = 7 , & W0
4 ;<
.%% 6N: & a 6B 7 76 7 16&
%J , ;E& 7 / A& 1 / ,0F
B 67 = CH'8 7 L7> ;18@ 6B  7 16&
_> 76 ;E rI 7 68 O3" 1? B
,< 7 162 W 1" M B $B 1?
I %0 X" % .2 = %J ,
1527
> P 1? B & Š67 (< ?3 7
16&Q B ˆ @62 76  7 16& %0?
.&@ CE 6B /6
E4s7 ; ;3+? 16& .2 7 = Rˆ· 7 %:
# R 76 , , k> @ 1@P %0? K 6@ 6/ ,< 1? B
N0 .[T]%% @B 0B 76 Ca0 , X%8 ,
X%8 ,0@9 7 ( X77 ;%" QFv 7
+ A 0B Ca0 1? , Y 68 1
: 6B  +7 %>7 ;3+? 1" ” 7 6 ~
76 16& ; %8 ;E”0V6B A0
%J X'8 7  D> L/ 7 B0& =8 147
0B 76 Ca0 I4 , %E 6B 16&
 6 P%0 1 2  D> % 7 h = 7
, DP 1 1? ; B ^JK .2 @ 19
2 @ + B 76 7 16& .%& %&
?& 7 1 1E 1 d %0 B @B %0B Ca0
.% P7 0@9  7 16& ;E4s7 =? !# 1
# 76 , 1? %0F E :I4 % 1
-# 7 =/P 4B 1 76  7 16&
6B  7 16& A/ 76 7 16& &
;EX" /h7 .% ;P ,< ;( 1< 4
7 16& @B %0B Ca0 1 c $h B 162
`@ 76  1? $& .B Q ;14 1 @
0B Ca0 ; 06B 1 ,6 1? &@ 1'K 
7 %& @68 = /P $B W* ,0@9 ;# 1
0B Ca0 4 6> 2 @ 76 & 1 @B
6B 1 h6 E  E4 7% > ?3 SP
68 1 .%& 76 , A@& 7@ @B
7 %: ”:  ;E%? 1? Q0E 7 %& ? >
> 1? 5' 7 0B ( , Yu 7 YY Yt \u \U \Z N0 1 `@ 76 ” %& 16Q I6B ”B
X > 9 %N/6 L9 6K E E
X%8 _> 1 %0? I K 1 6B ” W7 L%E
6B ?3 ^*& z*& > % XR 1/
7 . ,#P 6B 16& 7  X" 6 =/P .&34 , , dJ 7h 1? B c& 1 76 ” 7 16& > ;EXa ;2 6B ” 7 16& A/ %0& `@ 1<
"!# X 3 3. 1@ , u 7 Y ) [Tu][TY][T\][Tt][Tp][T]%%&
1a# z*: ,F NP 1 %8 j7 ,7 , /
76  1@ , Y A62< 76 , d 1@# 7 C?> , B0& %8 (< ,%& ;P
u "7 1# 76  =@8 6B \ A62<
2 @E %8 7 8 X @ A 7 ) 6B
, .(%#6 R 76 '/ K0 ,
A ,%4 ( 1a# %8 j7 , / ? %8 .
7 `@ + B , ;
@ 1< , 76
( < 1? & %/0 %8 7 B
X" c& 7 % ;# 1 3Q ,< `@ y0B
B O3" > ;EC62B X@ %8 .&
.[U{][pZ]B 162 6B  7 16& A/
.[pZ]B A ( 1h
, 9 N< / 1a# 1? ;> ;E D9* E4< R L9 M X'8 7 16& %>7
J08 1B I4 % @B %0B Ca0 c& ^JK a 6B 7 9 $B 0B ,%&  , 6?
$& 7 ,? %0B Ca0 e'Jr _( i 0/ 6B
.[pZ]%0E =: @B %0B Ca0 & e 6@? %8 j7 , 7 , _# B @E
$& 8 0B ,%&  7 , 6? J08 7 AJ>
, %/ 9 , P %/ 1? 62" 8 0/ XB J08 B @ 76 $# & X ,< D9* E4<7 A7 AB A X'8
1I2 .%B a 1 %/ %0B Ca0 %7 _( a
, ,< S 1 7 A ( c& ^JK I6* ;E4%
j7 !%J /6 1  )26 > %@8 c& 1 AB 74 A ,'8 K P7 %8 j7 , 7
6& 7 /@ 9 6K 7 E E > 1/
1528
The Second Conference on Electronic City
7 c& L'6K %0? @6 Q% EC62B 1m<
54 4' $
"%
8 _"# E4< ;%8 XB 7 D9* 1 1 A7 ;16B %6B 1@ 76 O7 Q BB ': .[U]%162 A ( c& 1 I D9*
@8 %0 1@ ;E16& K .[U{]BE11@ ,?
%/0 76 ;EC62B !9 1? E Q K .%3"%6B E11@ ;@62 7 ,
L9 M 1H X'8 9 , P %/ C+8 .%&
0 .B 717 ': ? 1@ ;E16&
;1 !0 D9* $B X'8 R
X Q0E ;B62 ,@E 7 Bj'9 % %6 10
1? @62B j D2> E . ž@+ =
1 7 %& 0&< E11@ 14 X 1? 0/ 1 .&
= ?3 ;E4% @ K 7 c ;
E %7 .%00? 8 76 11@ %K
.[T]B e9
% 1 1@ 4%0@ ?? ,< 7'8 .%0? 1h Sh7 1 ,6 > ;EC62B ;7%/ ;1@ 8'9 76 7 16 8'9
76 ;E j7 , 7 , / ^K
O7 ;%/ X% .& 1h8 B EB)7 $B
C62B 1@P EC62B 6: .[TY][T\][Tt]%16K"
J*: 1? D 1 B X 1 B ;E11@
A7 7 AB XNI -/ 1 3Q , >
E,< 7 164 X 6K B )7 !9 E11@
76 $# 1? CEI ,%& &7 "
; 7 ? )*6 1@ -6* ;E?& œ 12
8 14 j7 , 7 , %& Q 1N& %
.%00? 1/P ?& ,< 1 11@ %K
, pZ pY .& / @8 %8 D2>
X" 7 AB , 7 , -/ 1 76
UA' /B 5-, $ ]! 9
1 1? B ,< ^JK 1P = 16 .[T]"
4B 1 60 1& !9 E11@ K O7
7 AB /7 , / @8 ': )06P a0
7% 341@ 8'9 ;7<S@P .[TT]2 3",
% 7 %00? AB ;? ; =# X" M2 8'9 fB BB W 11@
.B %& 7 AB , X"
The Second Conference on Electronic City
;Eg7" 6> %062 %6B EM2 .& 1? > .%% ,2 M2 ;? qE B%0N
#J
$)B ]Y^ 5FI, E ,7
.& / M2 fB 11@ œ
; %06 1? 2B , 1? B ,< Q WF
B -i 41@ 7 B ;1# 8'9 ; 341@
1@ 10 7 1 8'9 ;70 1 1@ ;E?&
1@ 76 O7 P7 .%0? I> 8'9 1@ ;E?& V? Q ;B .% P7 %0& zJ*6
h ,
%0? W %E WE? E10
E
8'9 ;70 10 ? 0 ;E 7 E;%0@
a Q ;B 7 16KB %6B E11@ R
;E %0B M 1? B ,< X% 7 0 %062 K
.%00? ,B< ;70 1/B ;E1 7 E;s6B E%C:F ,< 1?
B @ Q ;%P 9 1 % a
, CE .& CB & % ,< 1@ /0 8'9
%0? %" 1/B 76 O7 :" 7 ;E'?
/0 8'9 ;70 I6B ; Q0E ;B62
.%0? ;4P E % ,4%0&7 / % 10 >' 7'8 & CE ;E62 % 1@
e' % ;1@ K %B a 1 B
4' ` FA
N.' $LA 3
a b=[2 <
% 1@ %0B 1? B %< 1@ , p 7 U 'V .&
34 1@ ; ‘+%+ 62* 2K ,%& 77 , %: 0W" ,< 76 11@ 0 %& 6?
) 2K j7 .B 2K ; XR ,
1 . 2K 7 1 ‘B7 % 1 2K
1529
.[U{][UY]B
34 1@ . ; @E 2K ‘0# I> ;B W<
7 & h> LJ ‘0# % 2K ) Q 8
1N 1(> j7 ‘0# HEG8 2K j7 G" %
2K ) & =@> B0 =# 1 % 1 ‘B7 , ; ‘@ 0m@E . AB 41@ ; 7
.%B X 1 2K A X%8 A %0< %6
7 @ 1N G8 1(> j7 , 7 ?> A> A
O7 1? B E10
E 7 7 L X
62 %0<
. & AB 4 1@ ;
2K K" 1? %< P7 1 , 2K : [Y]%062E
7 % WE? % E , O7 I6B G" 2K ®%7" ;6: %/ % 2K )
.%0? 7 A9
%7" E 2K ‘0
E = 1 1P .%0? %" WE?
%& % ;6: 8B 2K ;E%7" .7 R 2K K" 8B 16
%" WE? 8B 1 7 @/ ®P 7% , .%0?
7 ?@/ ? =# 1 ‘B7 ;%NQ 1 7
. %E* 7 %0@& 7 > ; A&
@/ K ;7K ;6@? , % ;6: J AB C62B .& K" 6@? ‘0
E 7 6@? ,
%6 34 1@ & _8 GI0?H%7 I6B 7 ) ; R % ;0N" c !9 % 7J
.%0? AB 2K K" 4 1@ ®%0@ ,08 1 2K
) .B W* @E 1@ ;N6?& ': A9 2K %0< 7 B 2K ; jP
1 4 1@ 2K %0< 9 16:" ;E:? .%:?
%00? B 34 1@ $& 7 ? Q ?%
W* .K B Q6KB 2K ;8 %& `@
34 1@ 1@ ?& 7 2 > =: R@/ 7%
, =: .%0? %H K Ni #  %EK
. B 2K
1(> =# 2K f0&? > C+ 8
1@ ?& ; D ‘2 1 6K" 0 .%6 kI
4 1@ $B %& K" )Er 7 ) ‘0
E 7 %0?
2K ,B0&? ; ? 7 DB0 O< ;7 . 7h
1 7 ;6: CE Q 8 1 . %EK WE?
.%0 ;7h 2 ;70 I6B ; ;6@? ‘0
E 4 1@ CE 7 % B K ;7K
."
34 1@ % 6: ,0@9 ; 2K )
7 4 % DB< =# 1 2 6
‘ %E*
;N6KB 1 2K K" ; O7 I6B
% 2K ) . AB dh7 ;7J
X" C62B CB 60 7 ,B0&? N 7 *
;R I? .%0? 1N G8 %E* 1? / E % 7J
%K ; . ;70 2K ;1B %0F
,0@9 J AB ; DB0 % ž8 7 J
% .B N6KB ‘@P @E I !9 60
.B %& 6B 1 7K 1? %0?
X%? E I6B D2> 1(> j7 , D
1 % & 164 ? 1 1@ ?& L9 1? &7 E
) H@0E 7 % DB< 34 1@ $B P ;E
34 1@ @6> D ; 10 1? & P 7 >9 ;14
,< fB 7 & 1N ;7J DB0 ;7 2K
‘6& % ? _( z*& ‘@ O7 .: CE
0 W" 7 E< .4 / 2K 7 X CE 34 1@ @6> D ; B0 ‘0 _( z*&
I6B @E I , ª¨ %0< AB ," P
W&" , ;P C+ 8 _( z*& ‘6& .7<
@E I %& 1 7 O624 0 [pT]? %0EK
> .%00 2K N0 ,34 1@ ;7%/ 1@
%K I6B , 2 M ,08 1 , ‘/P
1 ; %? 1N DB0 W&" DB0 , 4 1?
7 ;B W< ‘@ =V HE16& P7 .%06&% D
1
Multi Media Message (MMS)
‘@ AV ; . 7 ®I6B O7 ; ‘@
1530
The Second Conference on Electronic City
e& 1 2K GI0? H%7 I6B ;
1H E,< 1 1@ ;E?& 7 %00? @> ;E,B
.%0? 2K 7 @E I !9 60
;6: 1 C6> 9 1 %0& 16& 1P K %K
CN ;70 I6B 1 2K f0&? $2 P7 K 1 . %0EK B %K M76 1H .[U{]%0? 1P ,< 1 % 4 1@ 1? B :* .? CEK B 1@ ;N6?& 7 * 4%0 7 H@0E P ; 8'9 7 9 ;70 I6B , 1
3M -
&YA d cD ; %N@ % 7 .& I6B 2K K" NB
1 1@ %K ; 1@ ;E?& ,6:
.& %:% @6> D K 7 ;4P
J*& 8'9 ; K 8'9 K % M76
9 1 & 16 .%0E 1@ ?& 6K K
4' "A 47
$
-, >
. P7 660 E %K ;EB @ A@/
; j06 M76 N I6B ,7
7 :" 1? %0B EB ,6: 7 ,? @E
1 %K 1H 7I6 ;E& 7 60 c ;
E4 7 Q % ; B $B E,< J*& 8'9
7 1H & CN ;EWF Q M76 8'9 77 K 0 .& I6B B %
10 B , 1 .[U|]%& M76 %K I6B
1 , 8'9 1@P .% % K >
1H ;E& M%? :? P > %? 7 f< @E ? =# I A
0 I M76 f<
.%E W&" # 60 ;7 %K 76
1? EWF 3 .? & + 7 )2> @& 62"
;EJ 7 ,%& 7 1 X%8 ) =:
1@ 660 %K I6B 1 ,6: ,7< ;7 S
7 ;E;g0 M76 , 18@ P
E,< ; JK C> I> ,0@9 X%8 &
?r 1 N0 K , 18@ 9 .%&
K 1? B %& % ; .[UT]%& 60
M76 %K 1H N 7 I6B ) ?
Sh7 ) ;6: 1 , ,0@9 ; EB
.[T]B %& I6?
"7 1# AV ,08 1 .%00? I6B ;%&
,? J*& 8'9 O7 80@ 0 J*:
g"U +< 6 CAI &aU
$
0 0F 1 .[Up]B %& Sh7 EB
;E1+%+ ,08 1 @E 'K =H2
% 0 .% P7 dh7 9 1 Q !90
k> %0 ; .B e M76 ;
.& %:% ;F
B ;E'? ; N !> ›F !> ; The Second Conference on Electronic City
.B ? EWF 60 $# + 7 'K
M #
e=8 5-, 7 M76 E%K ;E$# 1 ,7< ;7 S7 1/B A% M ,B 7 12B E 7 ; %0 %K Š7 7 1/B M76 I6B
1 X%? E . N K ,6: 1 %K 1H ; ;
$& DB06 7 'K CEI %%P -/ 7 e'
I6B ; ;6: )3P N 7 @68 DP /B &7
.C62E 60 ; ; C?>
-/ ;6: )3P => ? 9 1 .% %K ;E& 60 E %K 6@? 10
E = 1 7
.[U\][Up]&
%& Š %K 7 ER? : O7 1H I6*
E4< ;E& A60? 1IB6 .[Ut][Up][UU][UT][TZ]B
; %>7 ?& M X 1> ;6:
;E10P 1 6@? 7 ;E10P 1 6: E %K
.%B0& ,< %K 7 RJ# 7 1@ ?& 1
1@ 76 %K 1H .B %& 16K" 1 'K
4 1? ? ;%0 16B 806 'K , 1531
&5 "A ")+B $ f\ & 7 62P 7 _# = W* 1B ;1@ E %K %0< eh7
7 ; %>7 @6> ,6: 1> .%00? D2? 8'9 6: ,< %& 1H %K
.%& B
$& eh7 0&< 2K ,
1B# eh7 % X ; %>7 M ;%/6 '/ 1? 6:
1B ,
1B# eh7 %K 7 ER? ; %>7 % 7 EBB 7
0&< 1> % E4< E@ ,B 7 ;68 6:4
$
U
, $ f\ .% ; %>7 %N/ % ;1@ %K I6B ; ;6: X ( XQ0E 4% .& %/0 34 1@ 7 4 1@ , E %6
c 1? = '/ 1 D2? G"
.& %E* : 7 >
#P 7 @68 ,6: K P7 ; %>7 @68 ,
7 M76 1 -/ &
.%0E ; %>7 ,< ; X 7 RJ# 1 ;6:
, ,@ 1? B ;Q 1`2 1 ;6:
% Ni ,Q 1 D+ .%%B %N/ 1> 1 ,6:
& ,0@9 X%8 ; .? Sh7 ,< ; K
.%0#&K ; %>7 ,? c %F 1?
) %& Sh7 %%P 1 2 ;6: E4< X%8
%P 34 1@ ;E?& .[U|]%& M76 ;E
%>7 ;6: c _8 1? & , &34 9
@68 B ; 7%> ! B j'9 %0
%& 1 ;6: , .? %0EK %& ;
.%0E WE?
1Q 1? %B 16 1 ; %>7 .& % 1 c 0 .%0? =@# ; 10
E ;6: 6&
$LA 3
a 4G%[ $ f\ & 7 EJ 1@ ;E?& CN Q .%B %P 1> 1 ;6: 7 ? %" WE? %&
.%34 ( %N/ 1 E4< 1> ;6: A6 ;
.C0? B E,< K 1 ,4%& 1@ V? .B 1@ ?& $B 2K ,
1B#
jh .%0? K" ;6@? 2K ,
&'$
.' 5-, 1@ ;E?& .%0? %" @ 6: M76 $#
%>7 & ;6: @68 DP ( M
7 , 2K ,
1B# $& ! 1H @E H> 16 .%& ,6: 1 K / # 7 ;
N ; 7%> %0 ;6: 1 , E4<
7 60B & , ; ;E7I 1?
1? B ; jh 1IB6 .%00? ;4P
;7 % ? 9 1 . P7 60 ;7
.B %& 8 % 1 , ;1@ M76 %K 1H
1H =# 7 @ RJ# 1 NF 1 60
_# 16 CN .[U\]& ^K 1P %K
4!'% 3
a 4G%[ $ f\ 1> 1 ;6: ,< ,6 1? B EBB I6B
P7 1@ ;E?& ,6: ; 1? N Q 1 M? M N0 % ;6: 1?F [UT]%B %N/
.%0? 068 %K 1H ; %& L ;E10
E
,: 1 164 !/ II* 7 1B ,
1B# &
= %0 1 jh .B E,< 1B ,
fB
$# 1@ ;E?& $B ! ;EB j'9 N0
.%& => = 60
1
Product
Price
Promotion
4
Place
2
3
1532
The Second Conference on Electronic City
, %N/ 1 2 1@ ?& F 1? %1P AB Q6B FA
N $ F)
%K R? =? 7 ! / _# M76 %K 1H Q _# c W@ ? 1 1% 7 @>
X%8 1@E .B K" ;E& 0 7 K" ;E&
¶ ;6# 1 SB B6B I6B B 7 rI ) ;%00? ,Q ;EK 7
¶ S0 1 SB B6B DP X7
.& %0& 60 !9 ,6: ;E)2>
%K S0 1 C62 B6B ;E@ 1H M76 %K I6B ;6: @68
.7
R %& ?r 708 1 , ;Q 1?F .[|]%& M76 K" %0< =? 60
)2> 8'9 1QF 1? P7 ;6: f @E
&%$ XJ
5-, >
@& <%/ B < –%E B M 6K K
! 7 SB B j'9 60 ;7 %K 1H =@
& ,
,@E 1 /7 < –? %E* I6B B )2>
; ; 2 ;E10
4 7 M76 ; .%&
' 1F K" %7 =: 7 –? %EK
SB B j'9 1FE .[UT] P7 ,? 1 B j'9
dh7 9 1 % = 7 –%< %EK ;6: A" B
c ; %>7 6: ? %& =? 7 ! .%& / 7 -/ ;1@ %K 1H 60 B j'9 & A7%6 .? %EK ,%& 4 4 1 .[U\]%& M76 2" I6B
`'
% 4' bI &%% 9
K B j'9 E?& K @E I I6B
X%8 /7 ; 1@ ;E?& ,6: ': Q X ;1B %0F ;EX" 7 ? X" C62B !9
1B ! j'9 X%8 7 K ;1@ !B 1 ,: B6B
10 B @E H> B j'9 1? @N 16 .%0E
I6B 7 60 ; $# .[pZ]%& K ;1@
DP NP N0 B j'9 ;E& I6B
5% 1H !B 7 5% M76 ;B " ;E&
.[U\]%& %EK ;6: 6: ;@68
?& c ;7 6: 1FE @68 % 34 1@ 1
.%& 34 ( 1@
"A 3' i% $ h
The Second Conference on Electronic City
E,< , f6B 660 %K JK g=G2 -, <
%0 ;1@ ;E?& .%& , E 7 , E
;6: @68 DP ;EO7 ( 1?F .%00? ; N K SI 1 DB0 9 1 JK
;6# 7 j fB ,6: .B E1B7 I6B %0 ;6: 1 K %K 1H ; Q
%0EK 7 ,< $B %& 1H %K 7 ; %>7 M
7
O D 1 . %0E* ;6: )3P ;
34 1" A 7 P7 .[UT]?
1H %K @ 6? XNI 1 7 ;6: 1 %& 1H %K
; %>7 M >' 7 A ;6: ;4 C@J
1Ii7 1`2 9 .%& %EK 16B? ;6: 1 %&
60 $# 5% 10
E = 1 .[UT]%0&
K 60 %K , f6B A 1@ ?&
2 ;EB 60 19 1 [U\]%16& 2 %&
; %N@ % 1@ ?& D % .%0? Q0B
E4 .B %& ;% %K z6* ;
.%:% K 660 %K , f6B 6: 1FE
%0 60B 7 660 ;EO7 K ; E?&
I6B ;6: h DP C62 ( jh
I6B ? 1 E17 7 ,
.& %EK 1@ 660 %K
,< 1 % 660 1? CN .[Ut]%00?
:[Up][UU]B %& 7< & 1P
1
2
E-Mail
Short Message System (SMS)
1533
1 77 ;6: & .B %& / 1@ ;E?&
(% &5 k%N j
%K ?3 7: a K ;1@ %K 34 1@ B
1@ ;E?& 10N + P ;E%0< P7 = 1
; %& 16I4 1? @E .%0? I6B 2K 10
E K" JK %8 ;EyB" %E& D+
;17 7 ;6KB >' %0 M76 1@ %K 1H
1 %K 1H .C62E ?& ;B 2K
C> I> a 'K K 9 .%& & ;6: / : NP 1 4 M76
;34 @ ;E& 7 ,6: ; JK
B ?r 1 XR .? %E* )*6 %K M76 B @E H> M76 1@ %K 1H B j'9
1@ ?& C62 7 $B7 ,7% ;6: & 1?
.%& 16K" E,< 1 1 1?
?& SB E yB" 7 @8 a6 7 %0? c
. K %N/ A ;E"
6- Tae Kyung Sung., "E-commerce critical success factors:
East vs. West", Technological Forecasting and Social
Change, Volume 73, Issue 9, November 2006, Pages
1161-1177.
7- Michael R. King, Eric Santor., "Family values: Ownership
structure, performance and capital structure of Canadian
firms", Journal of Banking & Finance, Volume 32, Issue
11, November 2008, Pages 2423-2432.
8- Tae Kyung Sung, David V Gibson., "Critical Success
Factors for Business Reengineering and Corporate
Performance: The Case of Korean Corporations",
Technological Forecasting and Social Change, Volume
58, Issue 3, July 1998, Pages 297-311.
9- Pieter Duffhues, Rezaul Kabir., "Is the pay–performance
relationship always positive?: Evidence from the
Netherlands", Journal of Multinational Financial
Management, Volume 18, Issue 1, February 2008, Pages
45-60.
10- Abeyratna Gunasekarage, Kurt Hess, Amity (Jie) Hu.,
"The influence of the degree of state ownership and the
ownership concentration on the performance of listed
Chinese companies", Research in International Business
and Finance, Volume 21, Issue3, September 2007, Pages
379-395.
11- Arabi, N., AA. Bromideh., “The Impact of E-Commerce
on the Iranian Insurance companies”, Master Thesis on
E-commerce, Lulea University of Technology,
ISSN:1653-0187, 2005.
12- GUIDELINES ON ELECTRONIC CONTRACT
NOTES, Issued By: Securities Commission Malaysia,
Effective Date: 18 November 2008.
13- (UNCITRAL) UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON
INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW 2005.
14- (OECD) ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC COOPERATION
AND
DEVELOPMENT:
-OECD
4' "A $
W@ F 5F%% l
@ 1B# %& & = ;EW* 1? 9 ,@E
X M2 %/ 7 @6> $& fB ;1@ %K
1@ ;E?& 1? %& & _# .&
; K ;EBB % M76 1 7 %0E% B ;6: 9 %00? A@8 @ /
N0 ,6: 7 .%: h 7 2K =@#6 Q L9
@ %K A 1 1 , @ A 1
;N0:" @ 1 ;6: @68 ; .[UU]%0& 1R/
@ / # B j'9 B 6N ?&
;6: 6K ;EJ , , 7
.& > %& / ;E@ ;7 AK
.
; ;E44 DP 7 ; SB ;E:"
1HP .B %& E?& 7 E12B ,B 7 .& -/ ,B ; , M ,08 1
,08 1 60 ;7 K %K M76 1H E,B
)*6 6@? 10
E 7 SB7 1 6B ; E M
K >' %0 M76 %K 1H .%00?
44 ;EWF 0m@E .%& 7 %6B 7 1 EWF . P7 60 ;7 %K 1H ;%0 C2 Q0E 7 > 0 16B 1B ? 9
7 > ;EWF K B 1 1 .%&
1@ .C6K" M76 1@ %K 1H P 'K
;B 1@ %K 1H =2 ,08 1 M76
1534
The Second Conference on Electronic City
. ~8!9 #% I &8$ Ye
. '( I &8$ Y)
.
O '( M$ '( F;% I &8$ Y7
M$ s( :8$ dK, :$R 3C s$2$ '( 2% Y?
2'( ~( ' ”$R < I *(K ”
3 &(J :<8$ :J $; *; .$ ”R:$ C
.eglj C exl ‰( MZ
'( 2'8 *;J M$ s( :$( P '( ~Z Y@
.eglj J fjj ‰( '( $
The Second Conference on Electronic City
Guidelines for Protecting Consumers From Fraudulent
and Deceptive Commercial Practices Across Borders, 11
June 2003.
15- U.S. Federal -Electronic Signatures in Global and
National Commerce Act (2000 Senate Bill 761 that was a
reconciliation of H.B. 1714 and S. 761.
16- E-SIGN: Electronic Signatures in Global and National
Commerce Act (15 U.S.C. § 7001 et. Seq, Effective 1
October 2000.
17- M-00-15 -- The Office of Management and Budget
Guidance on Implementing the Electronic Signatures in
Global and National Commerce Act, 25 September 2000.
18- Lai Xu, "Monitorable Electronic Contract", cec,pp.92,
2003 IEEE International Conference on E-Commerce
Technology (CEC'03), 2003.
19- Kurt Hess., H.G. Moon, I.S. Choi., "Learning about
preferences in electronic negotiations – A volume-based
measurement method", European Journal of Operational
Research, Volume 194, Issue 2, 16 April 2009, Pages
452-463.
20- M.S. Joun, M.C. Lee, B.Y. Jun., "Effects of friction laws
on metal forming processes", Tribology International,
Volume 42, Issue 2, February 2009, Pages 311-319.
21- Locke, C., "Smart Customer Dumb Companies", Harvard
Business Review, Volume 78, Issue 6, November 2000,
Pages 187 – 191.
22- Bergert, K. Kazimer-Shockley., "The Customer Rules",
Intelligent Enterprise, 23 July 2001, Volume 11, Issue 4,
Pages 31-34.
23- Ancirews R. and I. Currim., "Behavioral Differences
Between Consumers Attracted to Shopping Online Vs.
Traditional Supermarkets: Implications for Enterprise
Design and Marketing", International Journal of Internet
Marketing and Advertising, Volume 1, Issue 1, March
2004, Pages 38-61.
24- Geyskens, I., K. Gielens, and M. Dekimpe., "The Market
Valuation of Internet Channel Additions", Journal of
Marketing, Volume 66, Issue 2, April 2002, Pages 102116.
25- Wind, Y. and V. Mahajan., "Convergence Marketing",
Journal of Interactive Marketing, Volume 16, Issue 2,
Spring 2002, Pages 64-80.
26- http://www.luhfirm.com/, last visited (21-10-1387).
27- World of Economics, National Iranian Magazine for
Economic, http://www.donya-e-eqtesad.com, last visited
(21-10-1387).
28- http://www.sirm.ir, last visited (21-10-1387).
http://www.negaranit.com, last visited (21-10-1387).
29- Independent Association for Insurance Legal Issues,
http://www.bimeh-mag.ir/law/law.htm, last visited (2110-1387).
30- Iranian National Internet Magazine for Information
Technology,
http://www.itiran.com/?type=article&id=2930&print=1
last visited (21-10-1387).
31International
Free
Persian
pedia,
http://www.jazirehdanesh.com last visited (21-10-1387).
32Pasargad
Insurance
Official
Web
Site,
http://www.pasargadinsurance.ir, last visited (21-101387).
1535
The Second Conference on Electronic City
This page is intentionally left blank
1536
$ !% !" # (MC) '( &
373(09126306296)
R ;
& Q: M76 %& B0&? ;:
[email protected]
C +1$
6& M Q: 6B =@ }k> JJ* 6?
[email protected]
8T o$
:8+, [email protected]
M
7 > a0 , 4 7 I W* ;w@" ;E B %& Š60 ;E1 7 Š6 E16 1 .B &7 ; $# E ;B" ,
: %08 4 7 I W* w76w %K I6B 1 ; =R 6@N
˜R , U\ 1RB O 1 6I 6: 7 4 XK I 7 7 O7 .T
˜%0< AB TZ 4 D/w 6 T\\ 7 I 1w: , Y|\ 1RB L:6x 0W" .U
˜AB R T O 1 @&76" ;E7< 7 O7 .p
˜/0 W* 1 , =x % {Z ^J6K .t
˜AB A %0F O 1 K ,4%00xLJ ; @&76" ;E7< O7 .\
A %0F 7 PK S0 R , ƒ O 1 ;%NQ 7 @/ 1 c N %K .Y
K S0 W* 76 ;E S I 7 MC ;E > $# =# %& /B 1 164 B 7 _# ;6KB 7 w62 Q0E > 'w: ,m@E ': .4 B /0 .4 1H ,< S ; DB0 ;EE 7
The Second Conference on Electronic City
, I /0 7 ƒ76w 6I ;Eg7" w76w (MC) e9 % w76w ;E
ƒ76w A> 16B" -6* ;E:? 6I S0 dB %0E ,: 1? %062E 1/B -6* => 34
,4%&K w ,08 1 I /0 1 ,%& @ NP dB .B N< ;J6 )
w76w .%E a% w76w %K
%& 0 R# O*6B ;J6 $& I /0
W* :" %00x =8 ƒ ,08 1 % 8'9 ;70 7 ƒ76w I6B 7 7 B
.2Q /0
1537
;6B @ ;E,B $B 1x ;1@
%/ I /0 ;J6 $& .B 3" )06P ;
.% N B%& 1N @ dB l0E@E 7 %>7
B0 /h7 @E 7 B A# A> ˆ%%& @
, 7 %& X 10 % :x .%0? CE ƒ76w I6B ;
.B164 =w& , ƒ76w
%EK !9 1? ; ;E 7 ; ;E
B 1 1x ;1`2 1 1P I @ @N W % ƒ76w %&
,08 1 I 7 MC ;E 1x B 164 1 77 < I /0 1? %B a 1 fB .%0?
Ca8 ; 1 /0 W* 77 ; ;1@
.B 8'9 ;70 10 ƒ76w I6B J8
. %& % ;> S 7 E% 1F ; ƒ76w
1x 4 _8 6I ;Eg7" ; 7 O , R
1P 7 E,< , w76w 1 1P '/ 0F X
K ^K ;Ei 7 E4%m" Eg7" 14 %
K =H2 ,%& e DP I 7 ;E @E 1
10
E , e9 7%# ,m@E 8 ;B 10N ^JK =w: ,w 7 , w76w ;E 68 :%0 B
Ix @6 62 N 1x %& 16& S0 7
7 ” @( K" QQF Cx# E,< O3" ;N > 1w g7" ;% , $ 1 x X
... 7 w76w E4
%0F / ,m@E R x3 k 7'8 .%& O7 I6B !# 1x I4 , 1'K 91
I6B ,
@E 1 g7" %0F ;x 1NP
1 B !# ;s6B 8 1? ;0 ;B XNI ;`
7 Q627 7 Eg7" / 1 ”
P ,w@"
7 76 ;E e 6# =#
%& _8 2 ;7 N 7 zJ* 1 x Ix %%&
^J*8 6I ;E,@" > E,< !
;2 ;E g7" ;P A9 ,x B
77 ; B0 > 62 " MC;E
1 ~6> E X@ ;x 7 d# ;P .%04 %/0
.B N M76 ; 1 6I ;E
N . 1MC %0 71 g7" % Xa ƒ 6B
10N ;9 1 ;7 ;E
7 ,0 W I6B ,6
Eg7" 7 Ee9 ,'x 7 K L%E 7 E ,7< ;6B # ? %0F K ;E AB :? dB ;E4s7 ; ;%K Ca8 S0 0m@E .@ X%
dB 1? 164 76 > =H2 10
2 , I % 1w0 1@P %& ; 1 J#0
.B 4 7 &
4 7 : ;E1,"
Kr =# 1x @h (AB , %0F) ;
7 P M76 e' 0m@E
7 %& %E: = + 0 k@8 I
$B M76 2W" 1Fv A#J6B 0 B %E: = ~*6B G" N0 AJ#
10 .B %4 1H G 1 7 %& 1N 4 7
E =R @E 1 .4 0
QP X%8 DB 17
^JK 1? E=@8 6 @&76" 7 4 7 I /0
1x %4 K $& ; 6I Ca8 ;Eg7"
%062E P B 7 % P7 , M76 .%09 K
[12]:%0& =r e& 1
2 Grounded theory
E x 1 ƒ76w 1/B 9 76 KB ?
}
; XR ;EKB 1/B %0 ”
P 1 ,B
I f }
62 7 > %/ 1x B '/ 0F
E1J0 7 E%
X'8
}
1 E:x Vx 1x ;9 1 B ;2 @E H> >
76 %K
}
7 % B 10 0 7%
1
Management Contractor 1538
The Second Conference on Electronic City
nu! *9 $7 C0 ; K ;0 4 Ca0 ˆ% ;B
6?& ,7 76 ~>
}
$& I 1 ˆ % @" 7 ? .B @" 7 ?
,4%00? LJ 4 )2> 8'9
}
[u ].%0& 16& 19> ,@" @8
@&76" ;E7 K 76 O7
}
[|]I /0 ;Ee9 }
dB ;EQ: 7 :E7s" 2B 1? EB Q%w $ ;Eg7" ;18@ 1 Xa e9
B%< =@8 1 60 1? 7 ;E62P 7 :?
;N 7 X@ 1x & k'9 z*: L%E 1 = NP
1 E / 10 ^K 1 1? #
.& !# I , ~%0 6I @8 :* ,< jh MI0R 1R 1? > 62 1 s7 Q 76
.% B 1 @&76" 7 4 I /0 zKR %&
[] (MC) ;E > $# =# X%& ,< = @E 1
L9 4%0@ 1 1x B > 6J*& e9 %
;> 1>J 0m@E 76 ;E 7 e9 %
7 Eg7" Q0E@E 7 A60x % `2 e9 ;
.%< B% a L%E jh 1 4< 7 1 K -i7 e9 % . %N81 P =>
%& 164 ƒ@x 16&34 ;E1 ;7x ; % 1 1x E=@/6B 7 $h EO7 )FF
, 1 =: =? => 1? B ?r 1 XR 16 .B
B 17 7 C62 % A@8 7 X B %B
A 1 7 %& , 1 1? 2 ;E 10
E 7
@x 7 Ix X # `2 ; = P =8
.%04 !# 7 17 ;E1 7 E7< J*: !9 x
Z1
=! $
. %N/ @62 &
4 1H ,< @6>
7: B%0N }
& %/0 x 7 w@" 1x ; fB M a 7 >9 1/ ? 1? > > 18@
%N8 1 P Q6B L9 %8 @8 e9
1 -i x 7 ,@" x X 1 -i w@"
[u].& % 7: 4
a0 @E 1 .4 %& X ;Ex 10
E K"
@" }
3 B 1QF ,< K" X 7 2F x 1x %@ z*:
1N `2 ,@" %8 1? > > 18@
:& 1 1@@h =r e& 1 x% E @E
.[u]4 %N81 @8 @8 M ;P 7 DJ 7 =@>
& X 2 1x ;x ˆ :
"#! :
0 J*: 7 / 7 J6* jI / a
.4 z*: ,< ;7
:? }
%8 1 2 P Q6B 4%0@ 1 1? EQ6B
X@ P => X@ 7 X% @" 7 7: ,@" x 1F6 :%&' *+, $
.[u]& % ? %@ ;Q" ?
The Second Conference on Electronic City
.B%& e& =I 1 7 6x 91
@8 @ 1F6 :./ 0., *+, 7 @8 %& 1B# X> 7 E1: 1 1P P -6*
:,@" }
@" 7: 7 L9 M ? 1? ;
.[u]& % ,@" ˆ >' 4 %/0 Q L9
.B%& z*: X' ƒ E ;N %>7
B 7 E`2 -i7 ,< :
123 45 :
.B%4 z*: w@" 7 7: x 1 ,@" @8 $& }
6K 7 %N/ 7%> 7 @" 7 ? $7 ,7 7 %%P /h7 ; % $& 1F4 .B E,<
1 Case Study
1539
XR %8•
Q %% ,< y2 !> 9 X%mE 1? ;%8
B X
6 %8E ) ( (T{\ ) ./ .[U}t]
%& ” N0:" =& 0B :&7 70 6
7 ()) 7 (-) ;E@2 fB @8 X w@"
.%& k %& xr () 7 ( ~)
9 B 6 :1892; # P %8•
W" @8 ;P > B w@ 1x H2 ME 1? B ,< P %8» :%4 % T{Y .%<
CE ; [U}t ]«.%0? y2 ,< %E* 67 E %6 9
.& ” 9 1B71 :
<
S E 7 2 XR K = qE 8 16B ,
?7 %08 P 8 1@ .% CE ,< % %E*
CA-O 7
+ .
.18 7 1/ 7
w&< < w76w O7 7 %K E K0& 7h
;K %8•
Ca0 a0 1 DB0 > 62 ,EK 1x &
y2 6K E,< L9 7 E 1 1? B R %8
O7 7 %K 1x < .C& %%P ;E$# $7
1? B ,< X.k T{{ -/ =& 16 .[p] B %& 1x CE yB" AB 1 % %6 B > A@8 Š
%6 9 X%?E 4 .2 ;K 7 P %8 7I
,< 60B XNI ƒ76w O7 7 %K XNI <
7I Q %0? y2 %E* 1? SE
.K .% P7 ;K 7 P
/ 7 / %8•
;6: 0&< E k> %6 B XR 7 .C& 16&
'/ %% ^*& % , TZ fB B %& 0W" 1? 0/ ;E 1 K
!3 >; =
P7 / 7 / 7I G" .%7<
8 %8 »:%0? -/ % %8 X.k T{p 1? B ;%8 :1? B %< / %8 -/ .%
%N/ Q I %0F M = I %0F M 10 B
V?7 @E €# 1 34 , 7 / ,08 ,
c& 7 %8 E -/ .%& E,< A 7 %@ ;
[p] .B ? / ,< (< 7 $& L8 A@/6B
[Up] : BB
!3 A+3 !> =
.%< P7 1 %0F 7 ! ( }T
.B %N/ ! a0 7 16
}U
$& 1/E # ; 7 % , T|Z DP1
!3 ?@ =
E,< ;h 7 9 %J
}T
9 E
}U
.%& 1/ 1? / jh
}p
c06B Q C2 7 XB ) ,08 7 8 -/ 1/ NP 87:
}t
./ 7 / 8 0m@E 7 7 ž/ 8 .&
X2 1 '/ 7 8 » :CK % , T{t .[U}t ] «!/ 0 ;K HP XR :%& C2 =r
, CE ;Q @2 k> C8 ,4%02 E74 16
1+ !> =
B %& /B 7 2 S 7 SP X%mE %?
O7 7 %K ƒ 1x B ;1> 6@N /
#h 1 ,0? .& %:* Ca JK ;E 1 E,<
Q %E@ œ &7 7 %K qE 7 %E œ w76w
.C" @2 X%?E @P
% E / ; .4 %/0 ; 9 1w0
1540
The Second Conference on Electronic City
[U}\] « B BB =r
,B L9 . P7 ,@" X 1 ;:? ;
1 7
7 BB $& K .4 8 $& ;18@
LJ 7 3v 2E 1? =& ,@E 1 ,< ? % 67
% , T|Z 1m0F B XR ; E # ;
J 7 =K 7 1QmE P 34, .%@ X'8 K
B $# 1x E " .B 16& XQ0E .%E@ 9 ƒqE 1 I 7 '@P 7 8
1x F .& 8 % $& @E %& =w:
X = ?% ;E@2 %062E N0 9 %8
1x B 9 7 %% ;14%P E E
: ? 1 j7& , ¶ y @& jh @" 7 ?
B 7I [T]"& E 0F =w: _8
.%@" K ;x E 1 1P = ; 7 9
_8 1x ;9 1 .4 X K =B7 1x
.%E LJ ,< / 7 %@ ” ˆ08 ,@" % @"
7 .C@ I6B "w76w " ,08 &
,< /9 ;6 7 B @62 8 e9 % ,@"
%8 S w76w ;E 1x CQ %8 ,08 1 %
1x ; .& 164 a ,< , =8 1x %0x X'8 E j 1x < 7 .BE @8
X@ 1 7 P ,@" jh x %8 W" ;w@" 4
10 H2 7 E% 4 K A@: % ,@" ‡% 7 0B 1H ; %B
=w: ,w 7 , 7 (A 7 )) P7 1 9 %J
x w@" 4 0m@E 7 4 x S2 10
E K"
.%< P7 1 w76w K" A@: % %& 16& K x X + K
.4 2K
v" @1"1 &"A CA-O fu %u! 3
= 1 1P E,< '/ ^*& B0 XQ0E C"U %, < MC &"A 7-KA &1"! 5
4E . P7 R 2 ;3"L/ 9 @?>
X ,? 7 I 7 MC `2 1? >J
%& @8 k> 1 1627 > z*& 1/ 9 A NP @&76" 7 4 I W* ;E% 4
K 7 7 62 XQ0E ;3"L/
1> E% .%& B0& 76 ;E
CE e9 % ;E .%< P7 1 ? ;P XQ0E w76w ;x dB 1x < ) /h7
G" .%0& ; ;E ”
P 7 0V62 x = .4 ;6: z#I 4 N< 7 I 1 %@ CE ? %0@ 6> 7 % @"
:B %& 7< =r A7%P 'w: E1@
;» :1x B %< ; -/ .v ,@" $&
M ,< 4%0@ 7 1 1627 ;E,B 1? B
:N8N9 2I -uZ O *A vU N$ H" /
‫درﺟﻪﺑﻨﺪي ﻣﺸﻜﻼت‬
‫دﺳﺘﻪ ﺑﻨﺪي ﻣﺸﻜﻼت‬
ˆ8) ^K X> !9 @8 S0 1 c %K =@8 M
‫ ﺑﺎ ﻛﺎرﻓﺮﻣﺎ‬MC ‫ﻣﺸﻜﻼت ﻫﻤﺎﻫﻨﮕﻲ ﭘﻴﻤﺎﻧﻜﺎر‬
7 [u] «.%0? %/0 (6@> ˆ/ 7 ;6 #P
‫اﺛﺒﺎت اﻧﻌﻘﺎد ﻗﺮارداد‬
‫ﭘﺬﻳﺮش زﻣﺎن ﺗﺸﻜﻴﻞ ﻗﺮارداد‬
jh ^*& 1? ; E» :1? B %< ;Q -/
‫ﻣﺘﻮﺳﻂ ﺑﺎﻻ‬
‫ﻛﻢ‬
The Second Conference on Electronic City
X L%E 1 Q ;B > > ^*& ME B
‫ﭘﺬﻳﺮش ﻣﻜﺎن ﺗﺸﻜﻴﻞ ﻗﺮارداد‬
I6B @8 @8 %K 1H %J 1 @8 k>
‫ﻋﺪم اﻋﺘﻤﺎد ﺑﻪ اﻋﺘﺒﺎر ﻗﺎﻧﻮﻧﻲ دادهﭘﻴﺎم‬
%0? %/0 ;Q z*& JK k> A@/+ c7&
‫ﻧﺒﻮد اﻣﻜﺎﻧﺎت ﭘﺮداﺧﺖ اﻟﻜﺘﺮوﻧﻴﻜﻲ ﻣﺘﻨﺎﺳﺐ‬
‫ ﻛﻤﺒﻮد ﻧﻴﺮوي ﻣﺎﻫﺮ‬،‫ ﻋﺪم آﻣﻮزش‬،‫ﺳﻄﺢ ﭘﺎﻳﻴﻦ ﻣﻌﻠﻮﻣﺎت‬
‫ ﻋﺪم آﮔﺎﻫﻲ از ﻧﻴﺎزﻫﺎي ﭘﻴﻤﺎﻧﻜﺎر و ﺑﺎﻟﻌﻜﺲ‬،‫ﺑﺎزارﻳﺎﺑﻲ ﺿﻌﻴﻒ‬
‫ﻋﺪم ﻣﻮﻓﻘﻴﺖ در ﺑﺎزارﻫﺎي ﺑﻴﻦاﻟﻤﻠﻠﻲ‬
‫ داﺧﻠﻲ‬MC ‫ﻋﺪم اﻋﺘﻤﺎد ﺑﻪ‬
‫ﺗﺸﺨﻴﺺ ﻫﻮﻳﺖ‬
1
1541
8 ;E 16B [u ]«.& % ; E B 1 2 7I6 > Xa @8 S0 7 k>
.%00? ;7"
% 9 X%?E JK ;E 62 XQ0E .v Q6I4 7 _# 1 I 7 X%?E 7 1<
% ,B $B %& >9 W" %0B M ; ;E
1a 7 .B A A7 1a 7 A AB 1a
C/"< 8
:x > A 7 %8 7 A AB 1a
7 E4< X%8 = 1 ': %@8 164 X ;EB & %/0 w 7 , %8 1a !9 .B !0
6> $ 7 M76 10 8'9 @?
.[TZ]4 AB 7 2" Q L9 ; A 1x
.%& %& ,% 1 % w76w ;E =w: ,w 7 , / ;
.& 1P X" AB ,w 7 ,
%& ; ,@" M MC %& 16I4 1? @E
ƒ ; ;E,@" 1x 1x C62 ,@" > $&
,7 64 .% N ^K 1x& 7 )FNF
1D+D E
B
w@" 7 x C8 ,@" L9 7 E ; )FNF
( 76 '/ & 7 %& 1? 8 ,< A@x 7 X@ 63" P ;Q F qE 7 B 1 '/ 0F 1/B 4
S W% 7 %@8
S @x 7 2x ,7% % ,@" ( G" .% P7
76 K" .B 76 K" %< @&
1 ; ƒFx ,7% E,< 7 67 )J P1P ,7% K" =@8 ˆ BB 1P7 76 A6
7 %& k 76 $# .7< P
.4 ;3+? ? X ,7% 7 A" 0&< NP K N0:" 7 a % e9 ;
.%6BI ;7 ; , ;P /7 $# 34, 6:
1D+D E
12!G "#A7F B
7 1 X% 1>' , % 34, 0m@E
%4 e K > =H2 76 K" ;E$# X 1? %@ ,@ 71
7 % E,< 0&7 A P 1?
@h %& 10
E 7 7 P1 DP 76
%& P 76 ;EK" 10 7h
.%< %EK P71 @" 7 ? ? 1I7 6@? 10
:1 c =H2 1@P %& =H2 1? %4 1?
# a 62 z*: @& 0/ :# %
.4 % , :76 A6 ;E6B P 8'9 =%>
ˆ / 7 MC ;Eg7" ;P `2 1? N& #h %06& 76 ;E N< 6I ,?
M76 , 7 A62< % 1 1P .B %< 7 pZ{ 16IB 7 UUp M76 , 1? B @E H> 16 ,
7 P % 8'9 1F 1? B 16& pTT MF
/ 3 %& A62< , 164 ˆ %@8 ,
76 K" ;E6B @E .4 z*:
B X'B , 164 1? ,:? [TZ] .4 8 %
A _# 16 1? % KCE /
K" CN > ;E10P :K" /
.%04@
/ 1? @E NP ,< 4 =?
1+ "# C; < B
.4 D6 ,< -6* > ( K"
@N > (< ; =w: ,w 7 , /
, 1 c :4 / X%8 ::4 / X%8
, z*: 7 / (< ,P ”% z*: 1@P
K" 6B %00? , ,< 1? 4 0/
@E .[Y]B d 4 / 7 9 $7 7 %8 Cx>
.%0? A 6B %
-6* ,w 7 9 1x B P 6: _# % ,< DP j'9 7 A 7% 7 ) 7 %062E
1 E-Payment
2 Electronic Funds Transfer
3 Irrevocability
w 7 , 1F 1w0 / ; .%6 1 N< L7/ 1x B%& I6* a 4 %/0
1542
The Second Conference on Electronic City
7 / K" M 1? B ,@ z*: 76
=J6 X" M 1 1? B &7 7 '8 j E 76
,F 1 06 '/ :K" ;EO7 0
I6B X" %00? ” B0& ; 7 %&
0@ % 3 c 0@ =H2 0B 9 E 7 E % 76 ; < .[Y ]4
.%0? %" 2 @E
” B0& ; ,< 1? > %E ,: 60 ;7 ˜, 1# 7 !B ;1Q 7 ( 1
}
9 1? F B V )P –7 ? 1 X" %00?
I6B”B 7 D ;Q:"
}
76 ” K A 7 ) ;7> ;EX" 7 4 I> ,:" @ %00? 1@@h K
:2# H'; I B
.%00? %" B6B E,< 8'9 1 %06 Q ^*&
B @E H> 2 60 ;7 E z*: 1`2
. " ,< %06B E 1 X" %00? 0
.E @E = 1 6I ;E ^JK 1
;Q
;EM0 ;0 M76 ;
_( SP P7 ;Q
;EM0 ;P ; 7 4
;EM0 6N ,6 ;Q
. 7h
1+K 1#2J B
%00? z*: ^*& E %0 1? E
E !%J 1@P ” M ;E?? 1? B ;Q
%K ) E4 SP $B 1? B 6 E4
;P ; .%0? I K 1 @ 7 0 %00? ”
.4 (76
I6B (PKI) @8 %? KB C62B ;Q
.B E4 SP ” M ; A6 E4 E
%? 7 1? B ;Q
O7 M M0 .&
7 ; %0 %00? ?& z*& 1? B ,< ”
%& !0 CE %? 7 ˜& % =@ i06
I6B "@8 %? D> 76 '/
E%? .%0:* !# ” =/ j@ 7
1? 76 E4 .[13]B
%? 1? B @8 %? ;Q 7 JK %? 1 XB
76 E4 Q 8 1 %0? @ 4
SP !9 7 & :60 E4 SP $B @8
; .4 1h 76 X" M 1 1? B ;1@@h
.[13-15]7< B1 %? D> E ,
,@E %06B 1? %0? !%J % 76 E4 AV
.%0? W8 1? B 2?
The Second Conference on Electronic City
:*9 ]
1? ; 1? B 1 76 E4 7% #
;E > $# =# %& /B 1 %K 6 M %0? AB %& 7 X" M %EK
W* 76 ;E S I 7 MC
76 E4 M ;h (E4 7% SP ) 76
1>J %& 16I4 L%E 1 = ; .4 B /0 %& E4 M 76 %K 6 GvB .%0?
.%4 I6B jh 1 7 4< ;>
B0& 8'9 K 7 h6 @8 %? =& 1? %0?
;P `2 1? I /0 ,% % 8 ˜@8 %? ˜” y ˜6 E4 D> X =V ˜Q
.% %N8 6I ;Ee9
[13].B AB @& 7 E4 %00? ? X
@E 1 W* ,4%00? 7 ,% 10 " '
ˆ x I 7 L%E 1 = w76w x
1D+D "L B
> 'w: ,m@E ˜K 'w: 8 1 7 %
” E % 1? B ;Q ;
76 ”
; .%E !%J X" z*& c 7 %00?
3(1234 0/
. ) - )
4 Asymmetric Encryption
5
Public Key Information
.+ )$* #$% ' "! 6
Private Key
1543
)$* (
#$%&' "! Public key 1
+ 2 Digital signature
12. Monthly magazine for the oil, gas and
petrochemical industries
13. Cristian Prisacariu and Gerardo Schneider,
A
Formal Language for Electronic Contracts, Dept. of
Informatics – Univ. of Oslo, 2008
14. Mathias Sall, Electronic Contract Framework for
Contractual Agents, Hewlett-Packard Laboratories,
2005
15. K. Vidyasankar, P. Radha Krishna, and Kamalakar
Karlapalem, A Multi-level Model for Activity
Commitments in E-contracts, 2008
16. National Iranian Oil Company www.nioc.org
17. National Iranian Gas Company www.nigc.ir
w76w I6B ;6KB 7 w62 Q0E
7 4 I S0 @ 7 K '/ N .B 2 '
ˆ x@&76"
C8 eB @ ,0?? O< ? 6N A7 X4 ;
.%& 6% ;%0? = 1 %& z*: 164 X >J !# 7 6 ;EC62B 1 2 @68 X%8 E4< X%8
O7 ,@E 1 %0E dP 0 P7 76
L DP ? 1? %0@ K '/ X 1 X% 60B
;E 1N ;E10
E AV 9 1 .4 ; ;E10
E
Q 7 ;%NQ 10
E 1*2 %0F ;1#I %%0F
Ca0 7 1N L 1? ; , = 7 =@> 7 P1P 10
E
... 7 4 1 77 ; 1? B ? 6N h> A> 0
10 ;P 1 M76 ; 7 ,%& 76 1>
1 1> 1 1> N< C0? 76 E 1
.CE kB ,%& 76 @B
" [12].@ 6I ;Ex& ;12 B ;%0
9 1 w76w 7 ICT ;4x 1 1x C
7 6 > 0 .B O624 1 7 ; '/ %& %EK 2 , @&76" 7 4 I S0 NP
w76w ;E=@8 w6 ;B " 7 6B S 1x
.&16&
N0 1 w76w ;E=@8 w6 ;B" 7 6B
1w ˜x %EK 7< @&76" 7 4 I S0 L%E
. %EK W
S0 1/B %& 8B
;E"
- C '+;% :I0K .$ :; &1D$ 3
/ v V; :2 s8; :!8!9
"7G? $% :O 2v2oZ +94$ '1;$ J%
J+% 2I !% ::$ n0K J$ J
:2 :(= .(8#$ J% LJ> *1 v
"7Gt#$
:I0K Lc '+94$ n0K <= '$0$ , %
8 :$J; * J% <! J> v "7G7
."
.)
.7
1544
The Second Conference on Electronic City
:I0K /( ::$ n0K :%$0$ , % .?
8 :$J; * J% <2 v €0YI
"7G?
:I0K .I ::$ n0K :%$0$ , % .@
"7G@ 8 :$J; * J% <2 v
D8$ =$ $; 1" :+$ :A4B$ 8U .H
":==(9& 2I :!8!9 A8; '+$
3% O J% / v ()tt@ /81R)
"7G@ •R :$; F=#$ & 2
L; v (Z :I0K \ <2 :12 :=(; .Q
"7G@ M'$ *$ $; J%
Z ~8!9 #% :I0K + &1D$ L0$ ! .G
J :,BC n0K :; '$
"7G7 $% J% :8J
L# (MC) \ *$ :R".$ o &1K .p
$% J% 'DA, "@ SZA ' ":( 2–Z
GH
#% I 2*=I :C" La `!> : :3 ."t
:==(9& - 1 '10$ ) :!8!9
"7G7A; J% :!8!9 #% v(2 &$ "r
(MC) *$ !(Z 2 : .""
'+;% :=$ v(2 &$ *A *+, 2–Z
"7G? $
2 2v9> *A *+,
$ _ # !"
886
:9 :A4B$
6 O $ LZ 8;
[email protected]
r; Z
# ! " ( ) [email protected]
M
.B ;E,? %0 EN& ,'? ,< ;0 1 1P 76 N& l0E 1/B 7 ;B10N
.%0& %0B 2 ;E ; ;E Q" ,08 1 ,N N& P ;EB l0E 7 l0E ;E1K
a0 1 ,< ?? 18 ,< ) :*,B @h  / 7 ,< E%B 7 N ;
1 Q0E ? 1? %E ,: %&X B .%@ @ ;10 7 # ;E l0E 7 1/B O624
7 WF ? ;B %K 1H A/6 S .%%: S A/6 1 !90 dB  €#
; Q0E %K 7 E/ >9 7 ? ,%& 76 _# /h7 ,7 NP .B ? 7 1
.B %& e ;
1? 76 %K %6 68 1 .%& 1 Q CN # Q0E 76 N& A% 1H
;EQ" ,08 1 Q0E ? W .B %& 1H N< 6BN 7 %& B0& P7 ,%7N& ; ,N N&
>9 ; ; 1? ;N& ;E/ 7 % X 7 %K 1H ; !90 dB f6B =
7 .B D9*" 7 j06 624 2 EBl0E 7 l0E ;E1K &< ;E/ .B %& %&
,: %< B% Š6 .B h> 6& ;%P 7 1P = 8h M76 %7N& L%E !# ,%7N& O<
,%7N& ;B%0@ 7 O< > s7 1 l0E ;E1K 7 EBl0E ;N& ;E?? 1 1P 1? %0E
1" .B K R 2 @E ,< Q0E ;E,0 7 76 N& A% =@ ? W
1 Q0E ? / ;E7 NP @8 ;Q 1 6B L%E EE N Š6 .B %& 1H 76 N& Q0E 62 ;B< XR ; !# a0
76 N& l0E 1/B O< 76 %K ;%? }  A/ Q0E ? 76 N&
The Second Conference on Electronic City
7'8 w A> ,%@ P7 1x B @E H>
1 ;E,%@ =x ž/ A> 8 B S% 1x
S% 7 ;0 SB # w , h> J8
1 8@6P Aw& 1@E ,< @ 7 6/0 ,%@ s7
0 ,%@ .B 8@6P 7 ; > -6* 7 E18
1 x> (TU\ TpuZ ) .4 ‰B , EN& s7
;E,%@ P B0 7 B ;4=w& A> kI 1m< /0 18 1 6&34 " 7 6/0 ,%@ ;B ,<
X%x E 6/0 ,%@ 7 ;7:x )' .B &"7 A>
0 ƒ Qa 1 ;g Xa A6 N0 %6
;E6KB 7 A#6 SP %% A9 1 EAB
' K ,7 ,2 2 Q 0 1 ƒg0w
16w 7 .%00x !
1/P 1 0 8@6P 7 ;J6
1545
=w: M76 N& M 1% 7 " K 1 1 X%?
7 B , œ " Q& D % . "
M .B 7 1 7 ;%@8 ': N& %0E
%%P N& .34 P7 18 ;" %%P ;N&
,'? 6 NF 76 N& M ;E1" ? A%
. 0 1? 7< @E 1 K B0
7 M76 7 M76 ,B M76 4% 0/
< X
62 %%P ; =? @?> (\ TpuZ )
,'? ;E6 ME .%0E =: M76 6KB
8@6P 10 6: %B a 1 1? B ;62 ,
Dh ; X%? E 1? Q ;EzK& 7 E1I† /
.%& 16& Q0E
M76 O< .%062E 76 N& !# R @E
;68 1 A> N& ? A% %6 1 M76 W0? 7 M76 9 M76 dI
a N& A% 1H .& 1H 76 N&
.%0E ,B M76 4% > 1? %062E EzK&
Q0E 1P7 6: 1? A% %0E=: 7 BB ;E6
76 ,B 1" M76 N& ;4=& 76 N& 6B QQF _# .%& , %
;EC62B M76 ?% M76 ;EzK&
C?> ž .? %EK Q0E A ;E1" .% W ,6: $7 % 7 2 S0 ;
1
=@ 7 ;N& 0F !# 1? B 1 NI ;
% M76 > M76 7 ,F EzK&
.%0& 16& ;(† W %0 Q0E ? % 0F
N& Q 1" >9 @ ;EWF 7 M76
7 B M @8 l0E 1/B ? W 1 68 KR 7 .% ; CNB 76 7 0/ M76
76 N& !# ; Q0E 62 N< ( 6KB 7 8@6P $& 7 l0E 2 ;7 7
.B %& 16K" ;%P 9 1 Q ;B
;E6KB 1? %062E @N =8 8'9 7 9 ;70
(Yp Tp{t'P) .%0E =& N& 76
:B %& ,: =& 76 N& ? A%
(Yp Tp{t'P)
CJ*&"( &"w "< 4x! < C"U ":, 7 1? B %& =: 44 P 7 EW* M76 N&
; ; $# M ,%< %%" 1 0 N< 1E4< =/
E 1? =8 X%? E P7 X%8 .& 76 4%
$%$& *&%
$%$& !
$%$& '
+%$& ,!
;EzK& 1 =? Q627 ,< ,? ME ;B"
ME 1< Q &@ !# 76 N& 68 1
N& 76 6KB _> . a
;B" ,< d# EzK& 7 E1I E6 I ;> 7 († W ,< ,%& @8 7 76
– Q0E ;EzK& 1? 2< =# CN 16 .%&
%? 76 N& A% ? ;@B =& .%0?
CN 7 =62 zK& M ,08 1 K 1< 7'8 8@6P
.%E ,: Q0E 7 8@6P ;E6KB
ˆ BB 7 N& %B a 1 1 %0& e
1546
The Second Conference on Electronic City
~8!9 J /$
4 %
-123 % -3"# ,! -. % /0
$%$& ,!
16 7 % 5
% 89 :;
*
<
=9! 5
% <
-123
< / -123 % *&". >
:2 268$ % ~8!9 J /$
Q0E ;EN 1@P ,N ;N& W&" # Q0E
10 7 62 6KB %& ,: A% 1?@E
%K 1H ? .%& )2# > (†
76 N& M .B 8'9 ;70 1/B ; XR
10 %0 ,%7N& 1 O< 7 76
77 ; ': DB0 6KB ;K ,7%
1 .%0& 16& († W 76 N& Q0E ;E,0
76 1> 62* ,NP ;EN& ;2 .&
? / 7%# %6 EW ! a0
a 6KB .% 1/B K ;E6KB ,%&
6B /h7 7 ;N& !90 ;K Dh €# 1 s7 1
;70 6KB 2 ;7 7 W* NF
GvB .& =# 7 B N< ;%? 7 .& =: 8@6P $& 7 l0E 7 8'9 7 9
? :*( # 7 E7%# ,7 E
(uU Tp{t 'P)
.%& %EK _# 76 N& l0E 1/B Q0E
,< 1/B 8'9 ;70 _> 10 4624 1 1P $& 1 ;624 7 X Q62 ,< I6B SP The Second Conference on Electronic City
1:! g1 -* < '4" 7
=
;1-! $
, CE ,7% . a 1/P Q0E 7 8@6P
7 Q0E %K 1H ; w ,08 1 Q0E x
77 =: 6B % E Q0E DB0 6KB
}  / K ;E4s7 > ,%7N& 1 &<
/ 1B %4 8@6P 7 Q0E $& .&
.%00x @6 x xx 7 j S7 1x %062E ;%x
(uU Tp{t 'P) :B
,N N& 76 l0E 1/B (U\ Tput ;%@>)
X , 60 7 1 rI Dh x c C62+ C62 8 1 ,44 /
8'9 ;70 X I6B l0E ( ,< 7 164 ,%7N& 7 19 ;E/ 7 Q0E
X 8'9 ;70 % l0E 7 6 7 =6 ( w7 .3"
1< Q %@ 1/B 76 N& l0E 0
Q0E W 6/@P 6KB A# ,
@E ;N& DB0
.4 2 1/P Q0E ;EKB
? .B Q0E ;EN %N8 1 1/P E/ 1547
,N N& 7 Q0E x ;%x }  9 QQF
18 ;N& ;N0E 7 E0E Ni 7 . . . 7 N&
>9 7 9 B -/ 1x B N% .%& %EK -/
.B %E: 7 0W" = N& 
;@B 7 NF ,< xx 7 N& 6 c Q0E ;E
P ;4;P 7 %x Q0E 08 w
;%0,*6B
RB) .B 6# 7 CN < xx 7 ,7 ?
7 E/ 1 :*E N& dB Q0E 08 7
cK @h %& O' _# (t{ Tp{Z
1 W DB0 Q0E ;@B Ni 7 ? Q0E ;Exx
S Xa ,< ;3"( 7 (;%7N& 6) N& 9
8B 1 0/ Q0E ;E/ JK . B
7 E;4B -6* / Q0E x ;%x } 
7 P ;4w 1x 7< P7 1 X
9 7 A
,7 7 / x >9 7 ;
1 P ;E=
S # 7 Q0E x w
7 ;%x 6KB 08
.4 1H P ;E7%# ,P NB B10 & X 1 N< 
7 w
$7 Q0E x 7 E  QFvw
W0x" 7 S (U\ Tput ;%@>) .%& 9 ;E%0<
;E .%< P7 1 2 7 /9 9 ;E1w& !9
w& 1 % ) > ;%x 08 7 E/ 
1 2 N< w
;7 ,
7 x 1 B6B
N& Q0E < ;E16BK 7 E ;Q*B" 3" 16KB 7%# , %0 Q0E %K ,4%00xI6B
1 8@6P } ;J6 B0 7 1/B ( 1x
1 /P ,
,< S 1 7 %0E WEx ;E10
E 7
(Tp{ Tp{t 7) .%& %< P7
10N S P -/h .%0:* W
Q0E x
1 ;%7N& l0E 7 Q0E x 0
DP Q0E x ;xx 7  %2 Q0E x
7 Q%w X7
7 XR K w %0< 8'9 ;70
.x %E: N< w@8 , eh7 1 ,< ( 1x &
%" Q 8 1 B 1627 ;Q 1 ƒ E 1/B
c 1 A7 1E7 ? xx W
Q 8 1
r Q0E x . P7 7 @w# ;6KB
. =x Q62 ,< 9 % 7 '# 7 1> x
Q0E ;E/ E%B 8 ,08 1 K
P7 7 w
c -/h D %
.%0& c N& 1w< Q %00x I W %0@
xx (@8 s7 1) = 7 =@> C62B Rw& 7 z
7 B N& 1 1627 7 ;N& =@8 ƒ Q0E 'w: 7
,2w 1 ,%7N& 1@E 1 %K S 1 1H x
< 7 %0x =@8 ;1> 7 # 7I6 eB Q627
dB 7 ? ‡# XB 7 %& %EK 1P =w: 1 ;1> ;E s7 1 Q0E x 290 ,% 1x
W 7 QP K 1x % A7
,< ;w@8
,< S 1 7 Q0E x ;E/ X %4 -/h
I0 ( 8'9 ;70 l0E s7 1 N< Q0E
.& -6 7 -/h ,< xx 7 w@8
;xx C62B ƒ Q0E x I4 , 1
'# 7 !90 Q0E ME P7 4
8@6P ;E1w& ;4=w& C62B 1w .%062 =62
C0? ž Q0E 1/B NP Q0E ,08 1 ,N
.%4 7 1B 7 7 =6 ;EW0x 7 /9 7 ;J6
R ;%0N ;0/ 1 !90 6: ? P7
? > P ;6KB '/ 7 %7 ( # @E
;K X%8 7 Q0E Q61/B 16 7 Q0E
-6* eB K Q0E W 1H 1 7 16 X7 Q0E
6N 5 a0 1 .& )2# Q0E Q6 1/B
7 Q0E x Q 8 1 (Uu Tput ;%@>) .%"
_> !90 ;%? 7  B0 C?> /h7
%K =6 %6B 7 8@6P =/ 1w& ƒ N&
M @& A7%P ? 8'9 ;K X%8 ;K
E S 1x %0B CE 1 Q0E ;E/ X ERx
(T{p Tp{u ;(x) .B %& 1H
DB06 E .%0:* =w& Q0E ? 7N&
1548
The Second Conference on Electronic City
(t| Tp{Z RB) .34
("7G@) J% 5$ :2 M$ *+( +% D$ +% :(") /
‫ﻣﺮاﻛﺰ ﻓﺮﻫﻨﮕﻲ‬
‫ﺳﺮاﻧﻪ ﺟﻤﻌﻴﺖ‬
‫ﺿﺮﻳﺐ ﺑﺮﺧﻮرداري‬
‫ﺟﻤﻊ‬
‫درﺻﺪ‬
‫ﺟﻤﻊ‬
‫ﻣﺤﻠﻪ‬
‫ﺧﺎﻧﻪ ﻓﺮﻫﻨﮓ ﻓﺮﻫﻨﮕﺴﺮا‬
‫درﺻﺪ‬
‫ﺗﻌﺪاد‬
‫ﺟﻤﻌﻴﺖ‬
‫ﻣﻨﻄﻘﻪ‬
276,700
-21
1.1
1
1
0
6
22
276700
1
182,833
-27
3.4
3
1
2
8.1
30
548500
2
65,225
-7
4.5
4
3
1
3
11
260900
3
191,775
-18
4.5
4
2
2
6
22
767100
4
85,871
-22
7.9
7
2
5
8
29
601100
5
46,028
-13
5.6
5
3
2
5
18
230140
6
79,680
-15
4.5
4
1
3
5.1
19
318720
7
59,927
-7
6.7
6
1
5
3.5
13
359560
8
57,953
-5
3.4
3
1
2
2.1
8
173860
9
73,615
-6
4.5
4
1
3
3
10
294460
10
48,760
-12
5.6
5
2
3
4.6
17
243800
11
28,994
-6
7.9
7
1
6
3.5
13
202960
12
56,675
-9
4.5
4
1
3
3.5
13
226700
13
75,110
-19
6.7
6
1
5
6.8
25
450660
14
162,343
-15
4.5
4
1
3
5.1
19
649370
15
60,682
-3
5.6
5
1
4
2.1
8
303410
16
132,150
-20
2.2
2
1
1
6
22
264300
17
149,300
-12
2.2
2
1
1
3.7
14
298600
18
79,933
-9
3.4
3
0
3
3.2
12
239800
19
75,950
-16
5.6
5
1
4
5.6
21
379750
20
72,323
-12
3.4
3
0
3
4
15
216970
21
33,615
-6
2.2
2
1
1
2.1
8
67230
22
2,095,443
_
100
89
27
62
100
369
7374590
‫ﺟﻤﻊ ﻛﻞ‬
."7GQ /; J% J 2 :2 $; !=( -MO "7G@ «&N1$ A:$( ˜˜ (;» $R MT$ :uC—$
7 ,2 Q0E ? !90 ;K CNB .B 16Q 1R8 !90 dB ? S
,N N& Q0E ? 0
4 , 7 6B # 1 c
!90 ;E18 ? W0?" # 7 4%0?" C?> ;EB , /7 %0E ,:
> 7 7%# 1m0F .B %: 8 %8 P 1? & %E: eh CE =@8 5' E ; 1 7 B ,6 ˆ 62 S 1? !90 K
The Second Conference on Electronic City
;E6 7 EzK& B 7 k A7%P 1? @E
P7 (Bl0E l0E 1K) ? M =%> 1>
1> M ? C? %E& !90 B / 10 7 C62E Q 1> 12 ;N&
.%0& Q0E 08 % > 7 !90 C> % ? ME 7 BR 2 6/@P 1B .%0E W&" ;N& /@P R
1549
:@ BN ?  S ;N& !90 / Q0E ? %> W C? .B %& DP ;%? A/ X%8
? ('# 1 ? 2) ;K Dh .B I0 !90 1?
,&?? 10 1B7 1 l0E ;E1K W&" dB -/ 1# l0E ;E1K ,08 1 ˆ BB 7 B #
.B -/h 2 %%&
=/-! y*&"( &
I &"/y*&"( a .
g"U ":, y*&"(
> B # l0E ;E1K ;?? 5' 7 S 5' '# 7%# 7 4 1? B
7 l0E 1K YU %/ %< M @& A7%P 1? @E
6%8 7 A/ X%8 CE ? W0?"
B .% / ,N N& dB 2Q0E Uu
'# %B a 1 1? ;9 1 .B Q@:F
@8 l0E 1/B 1? %E ,: ? ;E
; 7 , 1? %062E !90 dB ;@&
L%E 1 = ; .B %& -/ N< -i7 7 L%E
.%0&@ K Q0E
Q0E ;N&7 7 ED ˆ %@8 Q0E ? %& /
c S7 7 B =# = Q 10P jh ;6 e' 7 OQ ; ( I 1? ;0E
1? Q0E ? E @8 ,
7 ?? C62
P &< ;E .%00? I6B ,%7N&
7 Rˆ @/ .& _# rI > 7 @8 j/& ,08 #
.%& )2# Q0E A6 R ;E
?
P7 ? M rI > @8 j/& ;4% ; O7
7 76 N& ;B62 7 ;6B 1m0F =# 1 ;Q 7 ? 1rP ;E7 B 1 .
%EK W*( 2 & 164 ? 1 76 %7N& .(TpuT %0E 7: B%0N) ." P ;E,P
1 EBl0E ;E?? 7 E/ B Q ;B .
O7 f6B 8'9 1" ? @8 j/& B
% ;7: 7 &< ;E4? " s7
B .B %& I6B E,P =# 0/ X7
Q L9 .%@ 2 I8 =26"
. . . 7 1*6? &< %K & ;E,P
;E,? 7 E=: EN ? ;@E
.4 1P P ? MI 1 7 !90 dB
% Q L9 ? 1 X ;R @68 BM
C?> ^K ;E4s7 1 ? rI > 7 290 ,%
1 M76 N& L%E !# ?: W
RB) :
? 1rP 7%# 1? B ,< Q 1? %&
l0E ;E1K 7 EBl0E W 0 .%& 16& @E
(\u Tp{Z
:B 3", !9 1B M76 N& l0E 1/B 2 % > Q0E ? 1? '# 7 c :Rˆ 7
.B -/h
> N ?% EBl0E 7 l0E ;E1K
76 %K :* 1H , 6KB 7 ;
*B
;B 1H = %K BN .% EQ6B B
:%& e& 1 ?
.%% =# , ' c / :ˆ (
# dB Q0E ? @8 7%# -/ :¸V(
;@8 j/& 1? %B ;1> dB 1 7 ~K
.7@ '# N<
,7 N0 1? ? ,08 , /9 D %
2? ? 7 6/h7 0F ž 1x ;Q" KB x ;Q" : 7 ;g0 ,? QP 7 %K 1H 60B ;EO7
,< X( 1F6 B0&E ž 1x K"
1 1P 7 BM %K 1H 76 DB0 ;E;70
EM BN 62" 10 M f% BN EQ:
68 1 .%& Q ;B 76 N& ;E7
62"%? 1H 62" 10 M ,%7N& 1 1H = 76 %K BN 1H 1 f ,B 7 K< '/ 8'9 :!"# .& , 76 N& l0E 1/B ? W
N k7 f ,B ;E@ 8'9 N k7
2 N k7 f ,B ;EzK& 8'9 K<
N k7 f ,B O7 7 %K - ; ;E@
1550
The Second Conference on Electronic City
c 67 ;E,B E1*7 : $
67 ;EN X C62
E116IE ;K ;EB N
4K :
5
E/@P 7 )
> E17 ,
7 ...7
;2 ;Ex& 7 EGg< :$%& x> 1) IB 8'9 E @"E ;Ex&
E:x B IB ($ O7 } x> ;E2 } š 7 E,B ;Q&4 7 62 x ,
7 )< O
4 :x ;E 1: E47 ;Q&4 7 Q0E
~K 7 , =6E 7 } E=6E @ 7 2) E=6E E
,
% 7"1 6
7 l0E ;E1K %& -/ %K 1H 7'8
2 ,< 1F6 X( :'
%/6 7 j06 &< ;E7 ;
4 , EBl0E
X EQ: =J# 7 EQ: x
8'9 ;7< 7 1 8h $ 7 -6* ;E10
: ƒ76w g7"
@B 7 JJ* ;E7 1x E7 K .%
:%0& e& 1 %& )2# ƒ76w %7N&
,B" M 2 M 4B" M :
# ;7:? M ,B M J6 M <? M
vx ;x %6B 7 ;1" N u 0&< N ;68 7 12B† ƒ M 1vB M
Word, Excel, ,Windows IT CEI 7 :=&
M , 1/B M M M 2"
60 7 Access, PowerPoint
, N 102#ž M
18@ =? 0&< :ICDL Advanced B0&,6B E,62Q0E :( )(* +
16:" ;E/ X NP Microsoft Office
;0E ;E> @2 ;E0E & y ;@/
Word, Excel, Access, :=& Microsoft Office
f% j Q0E ;E18@ 7 2B† E,6B
PowerPoint
7 ;"g7 7%07 v? 0&< :e-Citizen 7 62W" x ,xx k> :,
"-"
,.".
,xx :6 &7" ;E,x E%N
7 v? W =%>) 60 =? ;?
( ,x 7 ,Px X( :/0% (*12
%K I6B NP (B E 7 1@E ; 60
L0 =x < =& ;62P 17 ;62P x x
IT > ;%7N& ;EN 7 ƒ76w 7
;E4%0@ 2 ;62P ,Px JJ* x :x
,62 S ; O< ƒ76w ,xx 7 :e-kids M4 ;E
X 0&< :ICDL Image Maker ;% 7 >9 0&< :ICDL WebStarter )7 ;EB
;%/7 ;1> >9 0&< :ICDL CAD The Second Conference on Electronic City
(660 $ %K } , ;E=6E ,B7 1& } :x
~K ;Ex& %&(
;EB 7 E&7)6x) :6 :
"#. 3.
R (B ;E)6x ) 12I ()6x R,< %K
(EQ: }@8)
Bj'9 7 O< :
%# ICDL CTP: Certified Training professional (vx ;Q 10E4) :
w&
" X8 ;EQ: EQ:< EQ E,6B@
? > 7 DP B 87& : Equal skills 7 E%w:E7s" ;B7 7 E1K7 w&
v &%N x
% 1? %0? CE D97 ; v? 7 60
XB 7 16:" ;E1 1 ,97 K 1 1
.%E kB 76 1/P =? ?: 1
/ ;6B" w&
" ;E@ w&
" Xa ;E,B
w&
" : 7 ' # x
1@ ; 1@ E4%0@ 7 D/& } x :4# 2 1@ B%0N 7 7†2 1@ ;BW<
=x@8 $7 ‹
,N Š2 a6 ;7 :(
d2 ;E7 6:" 7 j 7 vB
1551
1 l0E ;E1K 7 EBl0E 6KB , W
(* $
# 8
;ED Q0E A6 7 j06 ;E1 ;P
*B > s7
8'9 ;70 ;EQ" 7 M76 ;E4 7 Q0E -6* 8h ,%7N& ; ;0E DB0
7 l0E ;E1K :*( ;E18 Q 8@6P
E2Q0E 7 l0E ;E1K
N< 7 ; ;Bl0E %0F .%& M76 N& l0E 1/B EBl0E
E1*7 7 EQ6B 76 %K 1H " 3
;E1CEI fB EBl0E 7 l0E ;E1K
%&Ca0
;E1K & ,: 1? B %& O' 1 7 l0E ;E1K &< -6* ;E7 -/ % 1? H2 7 E@? C+8 EBl0E 7 l0E
,%7N& E4< dB W
a0 1 EBl0E
O< EQ6B B 76 %K 1H %0
$ JJ* ;E7 O< , ;BCE N& l0E 1/B j06 Q0E ;E1 1H 7 ,%7N&
M76 %7N&
;EBB Q ;B .% († 7 BB W M76
:& %EK Š6 %& & ;EE ,%& @8
% ž ,N ;N& ;E1 C?> ,'?
Q0E > ;N& /6 7 1Fv % 6B 1#R CE7 =J TTT fB 68 1 .%0?
M76 N& l0E 1/B 16 7
1 B -i ,N ;N& ,N ;N& 1BŠ0" 1
s7 1 60B ;EA% D6 ;E-/h ,%& L9 %K 1H Q0E ? B
%K A/6 S 1 2 8@6P %8  a0
p =%>  7 N& dB %K f DB06 ;N&
7 Q0E ;
1 Q0E % , W
,< A60?
%@ X% > 7 '# dB %K 1B S 6
; 1B 1 6B 0 SP e9 L%E 1 = 10
7 /kK % Q0E ? ,%& K R 2 ;%0@&E
SP e9 ! S 6 \ ,
1 ;N& %K TpY fB Q ;B .4 CE !90 1? ;
Q0E ;E 7 KB s7 1 E10
E WE? 7 8'9 SP ;B62 a0 1 1#R CENF =J
-6* Q0E 8h z*: 7 Q0E ;
1 B -i ,N ;N& M76 N& l0E ;B10N
,%7N& !'B !0
%K TZZ >9 1 2 1 A7 AB ," V?%>
> Q0E % 0Er 7 * ;E7< !# /7 1
1 2 1 X7 AB ," 7 X% 76 7
B% Š6 0 .%@ X% ,N N& ,< ,@ @8
;%? –  ': P 7 C+ 8 1? %0E ,: %<
8 †2 vU M'$ - &1K (K [e]
.egkh M'$ *$ $;
'UZ> :$C *CJ '(% L; ƒ$ =% &9 [f]
.egkx (;R
*+, <= ~8!9 J 3:= :9 [g]
.eglh
*+, <= ~8!9 8; 3:= :9 [h]
.egli
1m0F EBl0E 7 l0E ;E1K 6B # s7 1
%4 1P ? ?? ;EE
l0E 1/B NP = 8@6P 7 Q0E ;E,P
:6 %EK kI M76 l0E s7 1 7 @8
e9 EBl0E 7 l0E ;E1K QP -/ ,< 1/B N< CNB / 7 M76 7 $ ;E,? 7 E=: EN ?: DP ;Bl0E 8'9 ;70 7 IT jh
1552
The Second Conference on Electronic City
;E"
JZ ! ' :8; % *M9 M$= :% [i]
M'$ -Z * J% :D1$ $ '(%
.eglg J
:$ :( :1K :%# (D$ ; +1$ z [j]
J 2 :2 +94$ M$ J% :2 '+;% &1K
.eglk J%
M$ M'$ :2(2 =2 $ ;J$ [k]
J 00D% M$ $ ; :'(% :8;
.egke:O;
$; :2 *9 :2oZ \ Z r; [l]
.egli J% J 2:2
.egki &N1$ A:$( ˜˜ (; $R MT$ [m]
M'$ *+$ J% J 2 :2 $; [ex]
.eglk 'r; !=( -MO '+;%
J% J '9; ™Z '$ 'Dr J% J [ee]
.eglk $
[12] Electronic and mobile participation in city
planning and management.
Edited by pekka lahti jonna kangasoga and pekka
havovila.
[13] The intelcities elerning platform knowledge
management system and digital library.
Mark deakin – Napier university Scotland.
[14] KEONICS: Electronics city first of its kind in
India.
The Second Conference on Electronic City
[15] The MDGs and the city. United nations human
settlements programme. World habitate day ' JAKARTA
' 3 OCTOBER .
1553