THE HOME & HUMAN HEALTH THE HOME & HUMAN HEALTH Jerome A. Paulson, MD, FAAP Jerome A Paulson MD FAAP Medical Director for National and Global Affairs & Director of the Mid‐ Atlantic Center for Children’s Health and the Environment Child H lth Ad Child Health Advocacy Institute I tit t Children’s National Health System Professor of Pediatrics and of Environmental & Occupational Health George Washington University 1 Dr Paulson has NO conflicts of interest to declare. • This material was developed by the Mid‐Atlantic Center p y for Children’s Health & the Environment and funded under the cooperative agreement award number 1U61TS000118‐03 from the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR). d Di R i (ATSDR) • Acknowledgement: The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) supports the PEHSU by providing funds to ATSDR under Inter‐Agency Agreement number DW‐75‐ 9 30 30 0 e t e 92301301‐0. Neither EPA nor ATSDR endorse the o S e do se t e purchase of any commercial products or services mentioned in PEHSU publications. 2 Objectives • Upon completion of this activity, the participant should be able to: – Recognize the impact of the home environment on the health of children. – Incorporate that information into patient evaluations. – Integrate the information into care management plans for I h i f i i l f patients.. 3 Visions of Housing & Health http://www.rurdev.usda.gov/images/content/sfhhouse.gif 4 Fields of Study Related to Housing & Health 5 Characteristics of a Healthy Building • • • • • • • • • • • • Healthy Communication (business, multi‐family) Dry Ventilation and Filtration Control of Biological Exposures Control of Chemical Exposures Cleanliness Safety – injury prevention Comfortable Temperature Spacious Quiet Light Maintenance of above New Building ‐ Existing Building • New – – – – Siting issues g Building materials Removal of waste Design issues • Existing – Cleaning – Maintenance – Renovation • Lighting • Ventilation 7 Children & Homes • Infants spend about 20 hrs/d at home • Children spend about 15 hrs/d at home 8 Factors that Influence Environmental Quality in Homes (houses & apartments) (and other buildings as well) • Chemicals – Naturally Occurring • Radon – In Consumer Products • Cleaning supplies • Cosmetics • Dry cleaning – Tobacco smoke – Lead in paint – Carbon Monoxide • Other – Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning – Mold and moisture – Pests – Noise N i – Accessibility – Injury risks U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Exposure Factors Handbook. United States Environmental Protection Agency Washington DC EPA/600/R 06/096F 2008 Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, EPA/600/R‐06/096F,2008 9 Other Home Environmental Factors • • • • Parental mental health Food Insecurity Domestic Violence Guns in the home Weitzman, et al., 2013, Curr Prob Ped Adol Hlth Care, 43: 187 10 INDOOR AIR QUALITY 11 Indoor air pollution • Depending on building materials used, condition of building, chemicals used inside building, HVAC system, some pollutants may be at higher concentrations indoors than outdoors • No legal regulation of IAQ except for laws pertaining to smoking Warner A, et al.. Childhood asthma and exposure to indoor allergens: low mite levels are associated with sensitivity. Pediatr Allergy Immunol 2007;7(2):61–7. 12 Radon 13 Radon Case • Family with 4 children 10 yr. old male, 6 yr. old female, 4 year old M/F twins y y • 10 year old has Crouzon syndrome with hydrocephalus, multiple shunt revisions y y • Family has lived in home X 8 years • Recent radon test result: 55 pCu/L3 in basement, 37 pCu/L3 on 2nd floor 14 How Radon Enters a House http://geopanorama.rncan.gc.ca/whitehorse/radon_e.php?p=1 15 Radon as Health Hazard • • • • • • • Radon chemically inert and electrically uncharged Radioactive Decay produces radon progeny Inhaled into the lungs attached to dust Emit alpha radiation Disrupts DNA of these lung cells Exposure to alpha radiation may lead to development of cancer 16 Radon as Health Hazard • Radon clearly associated with lung cancer in miners • Exposed to much higher concentration of radon than in homes • Many smokers, most males and exposed to dust and other hazards 17 Radon as Health Hazard • Committee of National Academy of Sciences estimates 15,400 or 21,800 cases of lung cancer per year in the p y United States can be attributed to radon among ever smokers and among ever‐smokers and never‐smokers together. • Most of the radon‐related lung‐cancers occur among ever‐smokers http://books nap edu/openbook php?record id=5499&page=R1 http://books.nap.edu/openbook.php?record_id 5499&page R1 http://www.health.state.mn.us/divs/eh/indoorair/r adon/images/rnadonehires.jpg 18 Radon & Homes • • • • • Issue varies in different parts of country How to build to limit radon incursion? How to monitor home over time as basement floors and walls change? Cost‐effective amelioration methodologies? DE Division of Public Health f bl lh – www.dhss.delaware.gov/dhss/dph/in dex.html exiting epa – Phone: (302) 744‐4700 or 1‐888‐459‐ (3 ) 744 47 459 2943 – Email: dhssinfo@ state.de.us http://www.epa.gov/radon/zonemap.html#more%20about%20the%20map Zone 2 counties have a predicted average indoor radon screening level b between 2 and 4 pCu/L (orange d zones) Zone 3 counties have a predicted average indoor radon screening level less than 2 pCi/L (yellow zones) 19 Damp Spaces – Mold 20 Damp Indoor Spaces and Health • Institute of Medicine • National Academy of Sciences http://books.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=11011 21 What happens in damp buildings? • May get increased growth of mold – yg g fungus – g mildew – Different terms meaning the same thing – All indoor space has some mold – Mold and products of mold p • May get increased bacterial growth – Bacteria and products of bacteria – All indoor space has some bacteria • May get increased dust mites – All indoor space, except the most dry or very cold, have some dust mites • May get release of degradation products from break down of building materials 22 MOLD 23 Case ‐ Mold • Mother & 9 yo boy, 6 yo boy and 4 yo girl in ground floor apartment p 4y g • Note mold in apartment 4 years ago • Rained a lot recently • New mold • 9 yo diagnosed with ADHD. 6 yo with “attention p problems” • Everyone congested while at home, better when at school or work. 24 Environmental Mold Exposure Ceiling ili heavily contaminated with mold Wall Door http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/publications/books/ p g p housing/Graphics/chapter_05/Figure5.01.jp g 25 Indoor factors supporting mold growth • Nutrition ‐ Nutrition building materials • Moisture ‐ leaking roofs or pipes, condensation on or water intrusion through, walls or basements g , • Inadequate and/or poorly maintained ventilation systems that y – May not provide enough air for dilution and/or dehumidification – May contain sources of mold and/or disperse mold spores f into the occupants’ breathing zone 26 MOLD & DISEASE 27 Four ways that fungi can cause disease in humans (and animals) • May be building related – Allergic or hypersensitivity reactions – Irritant reactions – Toxic reactions • Not likely to be building related – Infections 28 Allergic reactions most common • About 10% of the population has allergic antibodies to fungal antigens, and 5% have clinical illness – Allergic rhinitis (“hay fever”) or asthma • Outdoor molds more abundant and important in airway allergic disease 29 Allergic Symptoms • Nasal – – – – Clear nasal discharge g Nasal congestion Sneezing Post‐nasal drip with sore throat h – Coughing – Hoarseness – Nasal obstruction • Pulmonary – Asthma attacks in sensitized individuals – New onset of asthma 30 Molds & Volatile Organic Compounds • Molds growth can → Molds growth can volatile organic compounds (VOCs) ‐ alcohols, esters, aldehydes, and aromatic compounds • VOC production varies with growth conditions 31 In higher concentrations, VOCs can be highly irritating • • • • • • • Eye irritation and conjunctivitis Skin rashes Runny nose Laryngitis and hoarseness Cough Chest tightness Headache and fatigue 32 Mycotoxins • Produced by some, not all molds • Toxigenic species do not always produce mycotoxin‐ depends on various conditions p • Mycotoxins ‐ large molecules – Not significantly volatile; i.e., don’t “off gas” g y ; , g – Don’t migrate through walls or floors 33 Exposure to Mycotoxins • For inhalation must get fungal fragments or spores into air y g • May cause skin irritation if contact fungi • Can be toxic when ingested 34 Mold & Homes • Issue varies in different parts of country • How to build appropriately to control moisture? • How to monitor home over time as the building envelope changes? • How to repair home once moisture incursion has occurred? 35 Mold & Homes ‐ Interventions • Write letters to landlords – Dear ____________: • XQRNP JWMLZ is a __ year old child who is seen in my pediatric practice. Her/his mother has recently brought to my attention an issue with mold contamination in their home. For some children, mold itself can present medical problems. Even when it does not, mold is indicative of a serious problem with excess moisture than needs to be attended to. Option A. Option B. • I believe that the mold or moisture in the home is unhealthy for XQRNP JWMLZ. Thi bl h ld b This problem should be remediated immediately di d i di l • Sincerely, – Option A. This child has asthma (and/or allergies) and the moisture and mold are making the child’s symptoms worse. – Option B. Mold can irritate the eyes, nose and through in some individuals. As a result it can cause discomfort in the eyes, runny nose, sore throat and cough. • Collaborate with your medical Collaborate with your medical‐legal partnership or local legal aid legal partnership or local legal aid group 36 LEAD 37 Scope of the Problem • Pre Pre‐1978, and especially pre‐1951, housing 1978, and especially pre 1951, housing • At least 4 million households have children living in them that are being exposed to lead g p • About 500,000 children with blood lead levels over 5 µg µg/dL • Have the potential to eliminate childhood lead poisoning 38 How Do Children Get Lead Poisoned Today? • Old paint • Lead on the ground – – – – From paint From past use of leaded gasoline Industrial sources – smelters Solder • As lead paint becomes less common, “Other” becomes proportionately more important 39 “Low Level Lead Exposure Harms Children: A Renewed Call of Primary Prevention Call of Primary Prevention” • Most recent CDC document – Most recent CDC document June 2012 • “Elimination of the use of the term “blood lead level of concern” based on the compelling evidence that p g low BLLs are associated with IQ deficits, attention‐ related behaviors, and poor academic achievement.” • The absence of an identified BLL without deleterious effects, combined with the evidence that these effects appear to be irreversible, underscores h ff b bl d the critical importance of primary prevention. 40 Neurobehavioral Effects of “Low” Lead Levels • Lowers IQ • Individual impact small ‐ about 4 IQ points for blood lead levels of 2.4‐10 mcg/dL 4 g/ • Population impact very significant • Quadruple risk of IQ < 80: 16% vs. 4% • 5% of low leads with IQ > 125, O% of high leads. 41 Neurobehavioral Effects of “Low” Lead Levels • Lowers IQ – Individual impact small ‐ about 4 IQ points for blood lead levels of 2.4‐10 mcg/dL – Population impact very significant • Quadruple risk of IQ < 80: 16% vs. 4% • 5% of low leads with IQ > 125, O% of high leads. 5% of low leads with IQ > 125 O% of high leads 42 Small Individual Effects Can Have Large Population Effects 57% increase in in “Intellectually Impaired “Population 43 PEHSUs’ Recommendations for Operationalizing the New CDC Recommendations • BLL < 5 mcg/dL 5 g – Review lab results with family. For reference, the geometric mean blood lead level for children 1‐5 years old is less than 2 mcg/dL . – Repeat the blood lead level in 6‐12 months if the child is at high risk or risk p g changes during the timeframe. Ensure levels are done at 1 and 2 years of age. – For children screened at age < 12 months, consider retesting in 3‐6 months as lead exposure may increase as mobility increases. – Perform routine health maintenance including assessment of nutrition, physical and mental development, as well as iron deficiency risk factors. – Provide anticipatory guidance on common sources of environmental lead exposure: paint in homes built prior to 1978, soil near roadways or other sources of lead, take‐home exposures related to adult occupations, imported spices, cosmetics, folk remedies, and cookware. 44 PEHSUs’ Recommendations for Operationalizing the New CDC Recommendations • BLL 5‐14 mcg/dL 5 g – Perform steps as described above for levels < 5 mcg/dL. – Re‐test venous blood lead level within 1‐3 months and then if stable or decreasing, in 3 months. Refer patient to local health authorities if such resources g, 3 p are available. Contact the CDC at 800‐CDC‐INFO (800‐232‐4636) or the National Lead Information Center at 800‐424‐LEAD (5323) for resources. – Take a careful environmental history. Take care to consider other children who may be exposed. b d – Provide nutritional counseling related to calcium and iron. – Ensure iron sufficiency with adequate laboratory testing (CBC, Ferritin, CRP) and treatment per AAP guidelines. Consider starting a multivitamin with iron. – Perform structured developmental screening evaluations at child health maintenance visits, as lead’s effect on development may manifest over years i i i l d ff d l f 45 PESTICIDE EXPOSURE 46 Pesticide Case • Get a call from a community activist. • She found out that the local housing authority contracts for monthly pesticide applications in all yp pp low‐income, county‐owned housing. • She wants to know the health effects on the kids. 47 Pesticides and Use • Pesticide classification – By use: insecticides, fungicides, herbicides, and rodenticides, etc. – By chemical class: organophosphates, N‐methyl carbamates, pyrethroids, triazines, and superwarfarins. • 82% of US households report using pesticides 8 % f US h h ld t i ti id – 3‐4 different pesticides/home 48 Neurocognitive Impacts of Low‐level Pesticide Exposure • Growing body of evidence that low level, prenatal and early postnatal exposures to pesticides lead to adverse neurocognitive outcomes – Children not acutely toxic, no overt symptoms – At greater risk for development of learning disabilities, l f IQ d tt ti bl loss of IQ and attention problems • Based on studies in Salinas Valley, CA (agricultural/outdoor use) and NY City (home/indoor use) 49 Neurocognitive Impacts of Low‐level Pesticide Exposure • Mothers chlorpyrifos py metabolites in their urine and low activity of the enzyme paraoxonase (PON1), gave birth to infants with significantly reduced head circumferences compared with mothers with higher activity of PON1 • Children who have high chlorpyrifos exposure prenatally – Increased risk of motor and cognitive development delay. – Significantly higher number of children manifested symptoms of inattention at age 3 years. – Decrease in FS IQ and working memory @ age 7 ec ease S Qa d o g e o y @ age 7 50 Neurocognitive Impacts of Low‐level Pesticide Exposure • In utero exposure to DDE significantly associated p g y with lower scores on the Psychomotor Development Index (PDI) of the Bayley Scales of Infant Development (BSID II) at 6 months and not at 12 Development (BSID‐II) at 6 months and not at 12 and 24 months • Increase in maternal serum DDT level associated BSID‐II MDI at 12 and 24 months, respectively • Significant inverse association between maternal serum DDT and the psychomotor development scores on the BSID‐II at 6 and 12 months but not at 24 months 51 Other Concerns about Adverse Outcomes R l t d t P ti id E Related to Pesticide Exposure • Ecologic and case Ecologic and case‐control studies associated control studies associated parental exposures or pesticide use in home with childhood brain tumors, leukemias and lymphomas, and a number of other tumor types • Birth defects studies have linked parental occupational pesticide exposure: cryptorchidism, orofacial clefts, limb reduction defects, and heart defects in their children 52 Integrated Pest Management • Reduces pests • Likely to expose residents to fewer hazards • IPM Principles – Remove food sources through proper food storage and cleaning – Repair structural defects to prevent access – Apply low‐toxicity pesticides as needed – Monitor – Educate residents. 53 SUMMARY 54 SUMMARY • Housing influences health g • Somewhat different issues for new vs. existing housing • Housing professionals & health care professionals have many areas where they can work together to improve individual and public health • Need a holistic approach when dealing with housing issues in older homes 55 WHERE DO YOU TURN WITH QUESTIONS ABOUT CHILDREN’S ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH? 56 Turn to a PEHSU • A resource for pediatricians, public health officials, esou ce o ped at c a s, pub c ea t o c a s, school personnel, parents and others to get questions answered about children’s health and the environment – Provide education – Provide consultation • Pediatricians with expertise in environmental health • Occupational and environmental health specialty physicians • Medical toxicologists, pulmonologists, etc. • National and international network of collaborators 57 PEHSU Regions 10 PEHSUs in the US 58 The Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Unit (PEHSU) Program is funded by: & The Association of Occupational and Environmental Clinic is responsible for programmatic and financial management. 59 PEHSUs Evaluation and Management of • • • • • • Lead toxicity Pesticide exposures Sick building problems Water pollution Air pollution Job related exposures in adolescents • Volatile Organic Compounds • Exposure to hazardous waste sites y • Environmentally related asthma g p • Agricultural pollutants • Solvents • Carbon monoxide • Arsenic • Mercury 60 MACCHE • Director – Jerome A. Paulson, MD, FAAP • Toxicologist g – Maryann Amirshahi, PharmD, MD, MPH • Coordinator – Veronica Tinney, MPH • Fellow – Abby L. Nerlinger, MD 61 MACCHE • Region 3 • Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, & the District of Columbia g , • 1‐866‐622‐2431 43 • 202‐476‐4829 47 4 9 • www.childrensnational.org/MACCHE 62 QUESTIONS? E‐mail: [email protected] Phone: 202‐471‐4829 T ll f Toll free: 866 6 866‐622‐2431 63 2009 Surgeon General’s Call to Action to Promote Healthy Homes • "The Call to Action says, A healthy home is sited, The Call to Action says, A healthy home is sited, designed, built, renovated, and maintained in ways that support the health of residents.” Office of the Surgeon General (US). The Surgeon General's Call to Action to Promote Healthy Homes Rockville MD: Office of the Surgeon General 2009 Promote Healthy Homes. Rockville, MD: Office of the Surgeon General, 2009. 64 Carbon Monoxide 65 Case • A family of 4 move into a 25 year old single‐family y 4 5y g y home in July. The home has natural gas for cooking, heating and hot water. • On several days in October, all family members O ld O b ll f l b complain of health ache and “feeling funny” upon arising. No medical care is sought. • In mid‐November, the father wakes with a severe headache. He can barely awaken his wife who is disoriented. The two children cannot be awakened and EMS is summoned. 66 Carbon monoxide • Colorless, odorless • Children and infants have higher metabolic and respiratory rates are more susceptible to CO toxicity. p y p y • Maternal smoking leads to in utero exposure • More than half of the states in the US have statutes that require CO detectors in residential buildings (family homes, child care centers, group child care homes, and schools ) 67 Sources of Exposure • Faulty furnaces • Inadequate ventilation of heating sources • Exposure to engine exhaust – Automobile – Gasoline or diesel powered generators indoors or near p g windows Symptoms • Mild exposures – – – – Headache y g Myalgia Dizziness Neuropsychological i impairment i • Severe exposures – Confusion – Loss of consciousness – Death Chronic Exposure • Symptoms – – – – – – – – – – – – – Chronic fatigue, Affective changes Emotional distress M Memory deficits d fi i Difficulty working or doing school work Sleep disturbances Vertigo Neuropathy, Paresthesias Recurrent infections Polycythemia Abdominal pain Diarrhea Sequelae • Acute exposure without hyperbaric O2 – 46% cognitive sequelae q – 49% affective sequelae – Other • • • • • • Gait and motor disturbance P i h l Peripheral neuropathy th Hearing loss Vestibular abnormalities Dementia Psychosis Treatment of Acute Poisoning • Normobaric O2 • Hyperbaric O2 – Controversial – Single study with excellent RCT design • Cognitive sequelae lower with 3 session of hyperbaric O2 • Cognitive sequelae also lower at 12 months – A C A Cochrane review of six trials, including two published h i f i i l i l di bli h d only in abstract form, did not support the use of O2 Tobacco Smoke 73 Case • AQK is a 7 yr. old girl who lives in a 5 story apartment 7y g 5 y p building. She is well controlled on inhaled steroids. She needs a rescue inhaler < 1/month when exposed to secondhand smoke to secondhand smoke. • For 3 weeks, she has been coughing on a daily basis when she returns from school and has needed her rescue inhaler at least once on each of the past 2 Saturdays or Sundays. • What might be going on and what community resources could you call on? 74 Tobacco • Seco Secondhand Smoke – d a d S o e aalso ETS so S • > 4000 chemicals – >250 toxicants or carcinogens • Alters fetal blood flow, protein metabolism and concentration of certain chemical in mother and fetus – Chronic fetal hypoxemia – Nicotine effects neurotransmitters leading to changes in neuronal pathways (animal models) p y ( ) • Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) • Preterm birth & Low birth weight Weitzman, et al., 2013, Curr Prob Ped Adol Hlth Care, 43: 187 l b d d l lh 75 Tobacco • Secondhand Smoke – also ETS • Both pre‐ and post‐natal maternal smoking associated with increased respiratory disease – – – – Asthma A th Otitis media Upper Respiratory Infection Decreased respiratory function • Both pre‐ and post‐natal maternal smoking associated with behavior problems ‐ hyperactivity, oppositional hyperactivity oppositional defiant disorder, delinquency, and internalizing and externalizing behaviors, decreased IQ W i Weitzman, et al., 2013, Curr Prob Ped Adol Hlth Care, 43: 187 l 2013 C P b P d Ad l Hl h C 43 187 76 Tobacco • Thirdhand smoke smoke ‐ residual particulate matter from tobacco smoke that remains on surfaces and in dust. – Toxic to fetus in utero of nonsmoker – In dust, therefore children more likely to be exposed – Causes airway inflammation – increase in asthma exacerbation b i Weitzman, et al., 2013, Curr Prob Ped Adol Hlth Care, 43: 187 77 Tobacco • Multifamily dwelling – People in non‐smoking units exposed to SHS and THS • Consider legislation limiting smoking in multifamily g g g y units • Write letters to landlords • Collaborate with your medical‐legal partnership or local legal aid group Weitzman, et al., 2013, Curr Prob Ped Adol Hlth Care, 43: 187 78 NOISE 79 “Noise is an unwanted or objectionable sound” 80 Source of noise near home or school • Airport, train, highway • Impact on processing and language comprehension Effect reading attention problem solving and • Effect reading, attention, problem solving, and memory Effect long term memory • Effect long‐term memory • Increase stress as reflected by catecholamine levels Weitzman, et al., 2013, Curr Prob Ped Adol Hlth Care, 43: 187 81 MAGNIITUDE AND EFFECTS OF SOUND COMMON EXAMPLE dBA Breathing 0‐10 EFFECT Hearing threshold Conversation at home 50 Quiet Freeway traffic (15 m), vacuum cleaner, noisy F t ffi ( ) l i party 70 Annoying, interferes with A i i t f ith telephone use Average factory, train (at 15 m) 80 Possible hearing damage Jet take‐off (at 305 m) motorcycle Jet take‐off (at 305 m), motorcycle 100 Damage if over 1 minute Thunderclap, textile loom, chain saw, siren, rock concert 120 Human pain threshold Toy cap pistol Jet takeoff (at 25 m) firecracker Toy cap pistol, Jet takeoff (at 25 m), firecracker 150 Eardrum rupture http://www.who.int/ceh/capacity/noise.pdf?ua=1 82 ADVERSE EFFECTS FROM EXCESS NOISE EXPOSURE • Direct ear damage – Noise induced hearing loss – Noise induced threshold shift • Indirect adverse effects – Physiological effects – Psychological effects • Impaired cognition • Characteristics of the sound can modify effect http://www.who.int/ceh/capacity/noise.pdf?ua=1 83 NOIISE IINDUCED THRESHOLD SHIIFT (NIITS) • Initially Initially ‐ a temporary condition – Decrease in sensitivity to noise – Tinnitus • Caused by exposure to loud noises y • May be reversible or irreversible – Severity and duration of exposure – Continuous and recurrent exposure http://www.who.int/ceh/capacity/noise.pdf?ua=1 p p y p 84 INDIRECT ADVERSE EFFECTS • Stress‐related somatic effects – Stress hormone – Blood pressure – Muscle spasm • Psychological effects – Annoyance / Isolation – Sleep disturbance – Mental health • Cognitive effects – Reading, concentration, memory, attention http://www.who.int/ceh/capacity/noise.pdf?ua=1 85
© Copyright 2024 Paperzz