! " #$%&'( )* +
,.-/0%0%*12 340563 87.0%9%:
;=<?>@BADC@EGFIH(JDK+L:FMEGNOL8C@BPRQTSUEGFIQ@BV2WXKYPZARAZP[@BV(\$@^]IL_Q
`aVbQaSUP[SG<?SUL$FMcedL:Ef&L:g2SUPZFOVhJji+f0SGP[FOVkJ2@BV2WmlL_n2@^>oP[FO<2E:J
pYPq>oPZQrPZFOV!FOcs`aV2ctFOEH4@uSGPRf^Q9JjvYV2P[>OL:EQrP[Sw]FMcyx/WbPZV{zb<2EGNOnhJ
|4} FMEGEL_QaS5\~PRAZAJ?xWbPZV{zb<2EGNOnkJbx/\48I3yJv$
]?<o>@BARH(JjNML:FOEGNML_HJjNOHnM+Wo@BPL_Wh@Bf<2
i zbQaSUEG@Bf0S
RRGG
$O¡a¢GG£¤9tt£¤¥ªR©«R¥¦«Tt9¥ªaw.2 :tRTTr ¦¡ZbRZTR¡t¢6R£¥¦RRw¢GttTw§ZGt¥¦6¢GtUTRt¬_Z0R¨rjT96wZ6UUR ¦ wT
R¥ªtR°a G RtwtR©«¥¦«TR:¥¦T±³e²§wG¡Bt6T¢GU°a=6RTU9£[¥´twt MwRR¥µte¢«®tTRr¯0¶ ¨
GTtRIaTjZyRtD¢£¤Zt¢G{tT¡:¥ªU©a«t ¦jT/R¯r¡¥ªa ¦ ¦¨rR9¬£Tt£°aGU¥ªRt¥¦¢Tw· &ww99
R ª¥¦G©aR§URUG¢9¥´£¤BR¥´¥¦MTwT¡U¥ª6GG6 ¦T6ZaR®®««tt¥ªaDTt£«R¸{¥¦TTt±_
j 6 ¥¦Z¶¶
RTaGIR¥ªkU[Rt¥¦k¢G¨u ´«Tt¥ªa=h¸I¥ªr©aRT¬ ¦©[h¥¦G¥ª°?h¥¦T6=¥µ®[«¸{R¥¦¹Tk ¦ww¡GZ¡ TGtº ³£¤ ¨
¥ª ª¬wRtGta¥ª£¤t°D¥ªa¡tT(¨MRDG/r¢GR³£Taeta¡T ¦= ª«¸~Gr¸{UZT¥´ ª£ ´T± §R T
B `aVISUEGF?W2<2f0SGPZFOV
RG»M¥¦TG¥¦°T®b&GwR¡{tww¥¦£==TtTRB°T £waTRj¥´£¸? ¥µR ªtMU[Tt¥ª¡ t ³ ¥¦G¢GZ°2¥¦ ªRT¢GTr ´9~©¬¥¦t£TT Gb6tTR¥ª~M¥ª£TTtb6¸I®0Tw£¤ ª¶¶ ¸RIT awR /¯3¥ªGR£GwT ´t69RaU¸?t£¥ªw¥´RwR+¬ ?e¥¦ ¦RTw®RRTR£¥´¥ªRG£¥¦¢°T ¦T 6Y RU¥¦[£¸{¥´¥ªwt ?wRY ¦¥¦TTw:R°aG¨¥¦GTt°
Y±86tr¼bG¢G¶ 9¥¦=at°TT« I©awtZGR R¥¦T :8±RG²§GeT£R½U¥¦T9R¥¦w9¡y£yYTU¡b·6 ¦TTZRR®«ktTt¬ ¨k wZ
RwwRItItGw¡_jR ªG¬wjt9GtI£°TU®tM¢tw ^RtwT6£G2 ¦02aRGtT ¦6¥ªGR¥¦GG°DZRbDRwGRR¥´£R¯¢G¥¦ ´ ¦w ¦
R¢G«ytRU¬T£®tG2DT¡M¥´DRGG6 ¦wTtGZR®b«wt9¥ª/°±=R¬T²§£®rG¢j¨£RR¢9¹£¥´RwU ¦ ª£¹¥´w¥ª §G¾Z¥ª¢UZ¶¶
À t£T¥ª_:R¿¦±G?ZRt¢£¤t¢Gt_RwBG©T ªah¸?¥ªRG¥¦ktG{ ª¬wtG¬¿
9Ra
t£±(yUTtÁ/¥ªRa³¥¦R¥¦twTR¹G¥ªGt
¢GTRR¡ataTD¹X£¸IaRRRs=tTR¡ B¥¦T°T¡¢a¢GD$£T¥¦~¢G¥¦R ª¥¦G6G+° ¥ªt³t TÃTk[Ä®¸{ÃTÅÆ¢U Ƕ
6Z¢9TwG ¯aw + ®6w¥¦TeRTwe9sGttTG0sRR¸{¥¦t±.bRÉqG+«¸?¡ay£¤¬R¨b6R¥ªGÈ©T°a ª= GTR¹¢R©ra¥µ ¶
[Ì[tͬ¢ÎTUÎT¥¦ÏÐu ½U/G ¦ÊTtw ¦D ¦¡R¢GRRjGTM ˱RÌ[ͬoÎTGÎTtÏTÐ{0wRR/¥¦Ñ?B¥¦TÒ¡0Ò6T ´«¥¦RRtRT¥_MjT¢U ˶ ±
R£aUR{¥¦Tw·yT½U96Zw¬Ryab£[TtRaRtGT°k Ó±?tÁ/ ´«¥ªtt¥ªtaToRGG¥ª ¢Gt T[§¸IÔ9Ree9Õ®Öw×ÙZØ ¶
¸? GRt©Tt¬GD/TG6wTtGG¯a³60aGR¯T¡Tt6T³6TR+¹T£¤t½U¥ªa9R¥¦Ãw6Ú0Û¹R¸?G³9Z¥µ¶
¡TtR9«ytw6/T£¤t¥ªa:±+ܧTR5T5RG¬ZGtT0RR¥¦
t¥ªÝTsGÞT{Þa¥´ Þ ¡¢GФ ±G ª¥¦T6©attT « yTRR¥¦¢u£®¡a=¥¦66¥µ®¥¦R«ttT¥ªa6eRrÌÑoZR¥ªÒÒT ´³«RÈR¥U¡BTTt Ë ±¦¨
ߥӱ T¥¦°T²§±b¢GGRtG26kTÍTt¡¨U¢G£®¥´?¥µ£¤twt¥ª£¤at«¢GRwtR It6GTt ¦Uh?Rwt¡M³t66¥¦rR¥ªtGTbt &GGR¥¦M¢GtwT09¥¦tR¬±2a¨aà2{RGR«U«¸I¸?[t©T¥ª ¨¨
t6G¥¦RttsTh¥´RUG[·tä©r¥¦U¥´ ¦£T6R¡tTâT áo ¢¢G¥ª ªR±yR£²§¥ªr¢£³¨:®a«tGG«¸ãttwG
Te ³ ¥µTtt£®TGR¥¦¥¦G ªD ª¬¢Gw¥ªt ´GU¥ª¥¦G°y°³wGR¥¦tRTa£®§R¡UT[btRX¥¦jÃjGå0¢Gæ¤tç0Ö«æ¤açÙR¨0T¸{¨&b¥µ®Z¢R µ ¡
¥¦RÉqGG¥¦¥ªRR¬¥´wy ¦ ª¡stTR(GjèO6Rr¥ªt£®RaTI ¦TRU°T[³tTe£aÜ{¥¦Ttw ¦T¥¦°aIT± G6[tR¢£R¢Gt¨
©aTZR® ¦s«Tt
¸{Z¢ T£®£ ¦R¥¦¥¦ZTR©T:t2¢¨{R£¤wt¢Gw3§R¬DoRGZ¡Ut5T£é¥¦T¢G ªR ¦ ³¥¦ ª ¥´ZZR¥ªRt¢©«twG«RR¬¥¦êTywR°aw¡IRIGU£twreG¢aGU£ ¶¶
tT¡y«Z2¥¦6a£¤Gt ¦¥ª3a:¥¦±IG¼b«¢Gto3wt®£®aG£¤¥ªRR¥¦¬©T£¤5R¢ZR¯r¥¦ ªt ´/ ¦¥ª¡¬a§=Te6RwGtTh
½U£¥¦TZRtRa£ Ë ±
³6²§UwRU¥´R£
ËI± TwR¡^·R6bGRr ªUR¥¦£twR 99RaU[tZ¥ ¦·¨¡wayGt ªG¬= ¥¦r6©TTtsR·¥¦©a¯r¥ª®Z ¶
? CëP[EGEGFOE+ìI]oQaSUL_H
í DkRRGGj«¸?£a
¢GG¥ª ¦¥ªGß°¥¦°TT¢G¡:t9tÍT£¨:tUGts¢w6 0¥¦[RttRT¢9h£¤RR¢UR[¬toéÌGU¥´U¬¡atÐMR6w
6tTTRRTrDZR[tR¥¦Rj¢Gyt£³TÌËRR£®¥¦r¢G³T¢Tb®Ð¤0±s®²§£GyGR¥ª¢GT ¢UZR¥¦Rk¢Gt ¦G¢sbR69¥ª«R¶
¥¦¥ªtrw©TRaa ª©a¿ M 0 T®R£¥ªR©aG§ G rZUZR¥´©a£Th Gr©r6¥¦RTaGZ6R®«t2TÌRǬwïñðakïIR U{º ¥¦£t¶
tT¢GR®¬YwRR &¸§t&wTt ¦R ´G°atIЮ±GtÐI²§Rw¥ªtG=yba°TtT¢UrRR°a§¢UU_/¥¦Zttww£¤¡hRtM ªtsGT=¡RDt6GRIG¥¦RTt°TT6awORtrTÌtZÇ?RïñðRò
ïrBZ0Ra½r Z¶¶
¡ao½U¬£¢Ut¥ªa:±
t¥´b6»Ow0a®£®Tr3®¶ów¸?0 B¥ª£®t®r£e¢GGUR¯/Re¢wsT¡O oZR¥¦[GGt6R°a¢9 ª0h£¤R6¢®£RT¹RGT¥¦Rb¥¦T[¢tRR¢T3¡M£RRR¢Gt6tTt°T£T«a°Tj¬G¨^¥¦RTwe ´G
t6RG¯rT¥ª ¦R ´TbR¬kZ£RtaaT°TRRG¬°a¥´Zt¬¥ª/±·t²§GwGR6y¥ªrwt©T¡?wtRt°TRtD6a££¤UtwU¥ªa Ó:0±j¨Bw²§¢tR¥ªDGR°=¥´£wa ¦R¢G ¦Ge ¦a¥ª¥¦£®G°G¥¦w©TR ¶
[ ¸{ ¥¦ ª¥ª[hb?T0¡rRG®£OTG°TR¢aT^ atwo90R¡TTRta~_[§tR¢9T£¤ZRt¢¥¦£R¢GB ¦T½r:RT¬ZR:RT&¡ttGG
t ¦«¸,£T°asGa¥¦RG¶ÓRTT£¤¶Óat¥ªGa:±DtôI ´«¢GR¥¦tTR9ZGR ¦¥¦T:¨0¨&RwG¬·Z6¥ª·TtaRUr¶ó£°T¥¦wTR¥¦G¥¦T°s2¸{¡TTt ª¯ ¶
Mirror System
Perceptual Nodes
Motor
Schema 1
Motor
Schema 2
Stimulus
..
.
SOFM with n nodes
Motor System
target
Inverse
Model
motor
commands
Motors
proprioception
Motor
Schema n
!"!#
!$%&#(')+*,"
-$!#.!#
*0/2134564!3+789%:7;
7
<-8=<>,*,-
$!#"
!
<
@?8)7,%A
*BC7;
D>E&GF')H*,
-$!#.!#
*0/21345I!"!#
!$%<-
J!"KL848!
-6LM2"
7N%O
*,"
3!#.!#
*PQ
R*,-
3*,*I<>!S
¸I³wrwt¶Ëktw£¶óaTGRÈ¥¦UФ±R¥¦G°s6aR£T6G ¦½/t ´«t¥ªaZ¥ªDÌRǬïñðaï t£ R¬R0«tT¥ªGR°9j¨TR66UTUU¥ª¡¶ó ¦¥ª¥¦GG°9¨¥¦GTG¢G6U¨a ¦{t¡¥ªTG ¦ ª°k«¸oGUUv MT6G°TM¥ª
TU"V WEXNY"ZG[:Y"\]_^"`$acbBY"dd2efdcg3h;i^aj
w tG.R9ZaR(¥ªG¢U8¥´8£Tr©aRR¥¦R(k¢G ªR¥ª¶
²§ZG«¸?³[t¥ªRy¢£ßR¥¦¢G°Tt¢Gt3hRÍ29T«R 6¢GT¥¦ µ¯T§8¢G³¢G¡tTt4G8½U0¥¦ttR¥ªa£RaU¨[Ut¢ Z¶
¥¦G¹¥ª6RG9 Zs ¥¦T¼jßTÁ T©a±£¤tTu¥ªtGItw6{Za£Oa^tGOGUU¬
¥ª¢R°h0 RkªDǮë£æ¤«ÚtçÙÚr°að2TåGt¥¦ØR{2à lRÇG± bí 9Rt£6U0tT¢®ww 0 9¥ª«GZt¢UIRT¥¦T¡0³tGRU2[6t¥¦4RtT¥¦ w t¥´§GO6R¥ª6aZ¥¦¢G ¦TtR¥ªe[2¢TR¥ª¡rR°6GM6¥¦G»OG¢¢G£_ ¦¥¦GRowT ª TURG¥´[O®w½U¥¦£ZR¥¦G°?¬TGRU¢GUt¬T ¨
TrjG Rt I£ ¦aRZ_GUUO¥¦uR¡tR¬bR2a^R À ¸?¥ªG¥ªG°9¿
96ZUwZtRR£aMUt[¢t¥ªRw¢9t 6£¤[RtG¢R¥¦R¢9ta££¤±tR¢²§tRGho9¥´?Gtt£©TGU ª=at¢GTw6t :ZUZR£Bt¥´¢«wt£¤¡0tR¢GGt?U¥¦6R¨G¬¥¦w£¤Rtt ªTeeBRRayU£®[ ¶
R¥¦ ¢G¥´¥ª2 ª RGwRRRT¡Tth¶ó¢G9etR£GtUTt¢G¢G°aws¶q£åÇæRRÄ®tÇó¥¦å&£×ËwÆ ¦ ªLà kU½Ut9¥ª©aR:¥¦¨ç£ïÙÇTï± ¥µ w ¥ª9¡Mwt ¦G ª¬ks¥¦tGGGR¢Ua¢G°T³«®6£®GG«2©aR ªG[6DR¸?G¥ªtGR¥ªGT°e ´GÐU¨rURGD¸I¸? ª¥¦ §GGÌR¥¦¥¦G°w° ¶
¸§rwG®G0TtGsO¥ª¥¦tG§G¢U ¥¦°T ?aR¢G6®OT ª w ¡t a¥ªR£¤¢R¥¦wTRT¨GTT¡atGsI6G¥¦«Z©at2Tt£w ¶
m ad2nQa(oJ^X)p:Z@qre[aQi
tRG¥¦GG¢U t
²§s G ª¡³3¼b0t°a®£TGU¥´RZ¥¦¢9Gw°3 Dߣ«t«t°T¢GatR¥´tÁ«Rw¥¦T.8Ì ¥´s =¼jaߣ®ÁG¥ªÐ¤¨2©T¬¸?G¥¦¢£®Z~¥¦G¥¦°$/ w TRGR¸?¥´R/RG=¥ªG¢Ue¥´eG«©T ˨oR3G¸mGUU·¥´
£R¬«t [¸I6tG2¥¦GG¢U§wtGo¸?¥¦GG¥¦G°hGUU t
¢¡TRb¡¢G½G Bwt6rTG B ¦k¡aáoG6UUÒ« ª¸ ¦¥¦¨uG°/ÍÎTRÎa Îa ÐT±§R²§¥´£6Z s Z¼jaßRÁ¥ªG«RR¢UeÌGRt
Rw8¡§G£U«U©T¨twG
ZG°TZakR8£T¥¦GGG¢U£R¥¦GR°/TG£3¥¦°T¸? ¥ª RT.¢Gt~¥¦GG°[G¸IUaUR¯ w t¥ª¡GtT¢GG°aUU* ¥¦$¡¢G£ ª ªT¶ó6 G ¦¥ªRt¢9« ¦!R¥¦T R¥ªRG¢twRRG a ¦ÌËÐZ¨ä¥¦°T¥ªTâ ª ¦¥´
RUa9tat ª6a°T¥ªG¶Ó¬ R¬ ZR©r¥¦G»M°¢¨b£ç ªïÙ¥´UÇïãT+U£ ¦¥¦¢ZtZTRe£/w¡h6G¬UTUR¢G¬Rstt?¥µGet¥¦¶
¥¡´À ¡at¨wtT£wÒ?h:¿A£vhrwGGR?swtGy U§UU¥´yUZ9U ¦ rt¬¥ªRx ¢GtTwowRDk¡Twtb°T«©atZR°a¥¦G¡¢GR°b ¦aTX?¬¥ª¸?£®tGwt©ÈR³¥¦TR ¦ ¥ª ¨
TeG£R¶ówZtyRR¥¦oR¬Z0£R¥¦©T¥¦GG¢U®-t
¥ª¥ªZehttG©«·owtGt¥¦w°TR[¥¦¥¦¸ITTa6R¥¦w¯Gh¡^ÐDtt°TGGt§ «Z¸s ¼j¡ZßtaTÁR ¨aR¸?½UT9£tT2R±_¥¦[
t9R£§¢9·w£¤RtT¢O6R¥¦¬at2tuÌt¢G¥¦rZtGR¬^ ¨
twR
G§{RÈ©TT{ TUa¥¦UGR°s¬kR9T¬£D¥ªÔR¢G¥ªRw¬¶ÓhGttb¥¦Tat¢G¥Ë± G¢Gt9Z¬TDT µ¶ w TT.6¬tUG°TbR¥´£T£tr¶ « tZ IG UU[¸Ia¨¸?.¥ª ¦R2GTRG¸?¥¦IGG¬U¥¦G°T°¬OG£UaUU ¶
¬U°T£¤tk5¥¦bRT
´/tG/T¸?¢G°a¥ª/G¥µ¥ªj°
¥¦jUrG ¦·tw^t¨&¹wT9°T·ywt?r¸?GU¥¦t+£awU ¶
°T¥ª9a£RT¥ªRtG0(T®«UR¬©a ¦GTw0t¥ªa 6ewÁ·¡Tt R ¦T¥µt¢e«t¥ª2a:w¨§ Ó±_GÌ «Ýw©TÞTÞ µÍ¬[3ШGG¸?GR¥´¬£®£¤ ¶
RT¥¦tT°a:T¨{G¥¦wRD¡TwtR°T¢GtZoR¥¦wG¡^°9t±3GbÜ{RU£[Tt¢Re¨T¥µ{¡2RR¾¹£°atRO«¸?wI¥¦Gw°9r¨MZTG µ¡Ù ¶ ²§2ZU£¤tZR¹.GU£TU¬?Rrw¢tMG9w ¦UR¬ ¦?^±G«©a ª[T¨TÈ©aT¥´DwZRU¥¦G°
Rw¥¦66£RwGs£a¢GZR¥¦ ªt¹TGT0U2®£w9G/R¢TT£ £ÀT666UaGR&«t¿^jT¡It¸Gsw½U°a0t¥µ¶ ¨ t²§e¡w6Rr¥¦Z ªR¥´wyZ¥¦R¥¦kR¢T¥¦ ª
¥Ó¨ t ¢Ue eaGwwZRU6Rt¥¦©Ty£®¸?wG°a¥ªG°UZUR¬¥¦kk¢TR ª¥Ó ±
£²§~± «RRat¥ªaZUZR ¥´Ut£t¥ ¥¦!UtT¥ª ¹¥ª twRj0TT ª uU¡¥¦¢GG ¦°= ªR Z R¥ª¥¦Rk¢w¢GR ¦¥Ë¨O:R±b²§w³G¥¦R¨O¸?wtGk3³rt¢GG GUjUw6¡M9TR« ¶
©«ÌÁ·wtT¥ªaR¢aéTtTw Ó±¦¨ RÝwÞatÞa±·Ý ФÜ{¨¥ªR¥¦£¾ ª¢9aU¨¥ªRG°=·w ¦U°T¥´atR£¥ª¢RGtZX¥¦T¥ªr©aT¡§T ¦R©TG ®0wT6RtTR2®MTG¡Gao6t¡GahOt½UG0jTt ª¥ª°a6Tta¥µt®Go¥¦¨ RG¢G¥´Iot9Gw2062aZ¥´I?¥¦tG ¶
Gwt«D©T¢9 µ[Z
¬5tGÌRRG¬Z³ ¦T ´©a^¨O ¸?w¡{G¥´°T£®®wr£¢GT ´wttR¥µa[ ¦¥¦G«t¸G³³RTG3tRGUUtw¶
R¥¦T9б
R¡TGs~Éqm ¦«TZtRR¥ª©GR¥¦¥¦°TT¢90YR®¸{U£[TtUt¯XR ¥¦TGÌÁ¸{¶óaaw£¤tRT¥¦T¢ R³TwamGG ªà2¥ª4ȰaTa³5t¨G8tÝTTRÞT¢GtÞ¥ª°a°aͬ°TaÐ ¨
¡+¬Gr¶Ë¡aR«¸§RRw®ast¥ª©aT¢G¨2®wRG :«[R¸{RTat¯³t¥ªa¸?8¥µt RU [tT£® ¯¶óGRR¥ªa6Gw ¦°Y«tG¥ªatw:¶ ±
©rZ¥¦U¬w~®«tRbGRUt[Rt¥¦°T°a¹T¡TU· ¦ ¦sTRRG¥ªG0°9¨b®£¸?U¥ªR ¦¥¦TU+¶qT££aR¥¦Ty ªaRRRw ¦ ¶
£¥´«t¥ªa±
¡£TTt¢Éq³3Zk?RRGDG¹©r ¥ª¸{ts TT¼j ^t¯=ßwÁëGRt?GwRU¡U9ttw£tGUDtRa¥ªyaRRURU¶óGa£¥´£¤«tt«¥ªaR·eRa£Uat¥¦t¥ª¢GaG5£¤ ¦t¥ª ªR/U°[¸?¨ t ¥ªR ¶
66wwRRaa³o[[ttRR¢9¢£¤£RR¢¢GRt¥´±?+TtGr¶óY¸?¥¦
R¬³GR¸!³¥ªGU¨0Uw/¹¥´st£³R¬w«¥¦R¬o^a¨I[ ¶
¢RGZ¢GU&£tGO¥¦w«¥´Rtw ´Z¸?¥¦2·¥ªR¢GR60¬Zt0«T«R9¬OhZ¥¦rktGst§sRRG9[atR¥ª¬DR«B¢G¡ÙR ¦R¢b vuR¨9¸?RwGhZ66R¥¦ktwGR¢oa ª2¢GZUR¨wUtw2¢9£¤¥¦ ¶
¸?GeRGUU¥¦2U ¦t^¨R6¥¦{tG6wtToZRt¢£¤t¢GRa±
b ef^efdcgnQ`$aj pfi
qɸIRG¢¥ªRtD6¡wtTtT oít£® G ¥ ³ ¿ T {tÄ®6ØGÇRÂ6GÃR¬&ZØGÇ®{Ö«ætDGÌ í 6 w t¥ To¨Í¬ZÎRt¢Í¬£¤Ð¤¶ ¨
R ¢GTtR59T¡Ott£G³Ut6¢w¥ªt ?Rawj9RU6[twtT±³³èMR£®t©r³¥¦TT¢¹j̸{Á·TTt¯¹¥¦ZRt6aG ªw«9U
RRà2GÈGIa ´6T£w¬¨ R ÝwaÞT Þ etͬ£®ÐGR¨_6GsaR:¼j³¥¦ßGÁ«R¸{{G©aU£¢GURt0± ®í _£2¥¦6URG¢ ¦T6 OR¥¦tT£®GGt¬w/³R¥¦ TT k«ww©TttT ¨
£twR¹w9y¢G&GwRetT°TRG?¸?¥µt s ¼jßÁXrG±
GR£®¥´Z²§¬~³ Ta£¤¥ªRU¥´¥¦¡Ta_RR³±msw¼bR6¥¦GTwâRa¸§RR¥´È£wRãRG¥´t, R [t®Twtt¥¦w$R⥦TtG
¥¦¥´ /w¡{RRRGGG ³t6tRw£TttT°ww¶¶
RU¥¦T6=a¥¦b[Rt/tw£RTar©T¿ BTZo£Rt¥¦GT669Rkt¥ª£U¡UaRt³¢ww R¥¦¥¦TU6¡TRt9³««Ott¥ªaG2¥¦w6¡O¥µR®G« ¶
R£a¢G ªM¿ kt«¸?w5R¥´6£MwGRRa ³ Z ¦U,ZRTê¡9tt£Tw5[¡¢aZRa6±3¥¦G²§°jGR¥´G2¥¦9ttG£¹UGt¥¢6w¶ 6ZZ9RT¢G£8tkwRR¥¦¥¦eT©a/RTG ¦¸{6©T¬D6s£wTttG Tt ¥¦£D¥ªr6ZT¥ª9ttT«§£tTaR±h¥¦jào0G«®¸{t£ ©a¥¦©r ¦¥ª¬¨9°5¥¦¨ ¥¦U¬a¡£¢GTTbt¢³¥¦Z6k«tGT¥ª ¦a¢G ¶
R£awb6¥´2©T¥´ ªUtaaUhe¥¦¥¦/Rt³t6½U29wR¡M¥¦6¥ªtb«t¸? ªU«U¸a±y¨0a²§2¸?t¥¦ ¦ ¡T tT¶ ¨
9¥ªtt£¥¦©TT¬RaO¥¦UR£®¡Tt³³«TR¥¦¨aTT6£T¸I ? t/¡¥ªB£RTht9RGa¥´tMwR¥¦U¬¡TtU³¥¦R«¬t£¤¥ªRa ¦
T{®wt°T®IR hT£®G¥¦©a ³tG6wtToRrZR±
£RaajRí 0tT£®t®G£®«Gt³¥ª³G°eh±hR¢²§0GsG¥¦w9R¢jt0£6G¥¦w©T£®R¬T6G¥¦U¥¦R¡£®TtT³¥¦G{«¥¦tRtm¥ªaR9
¥´ab¥¦©aRR¥ t/ ¦t?G£¡sta¢{6£¥¦¥´Uww¶¶ RRGRtrhG¢ £ §¥¦ ª¥ªT[£yR¥¦TT¡_tG± hí 6££¥ªatttTG?¥ªGZ°bUZRR s £®R³³°aG²§GtT ªa¥´RZa¨ÈwR9G
[¥¦r9wI w¥µ¡Gt¥¦tUT¡RT ttk³¡«TR·¥¦T¥¦hRZtww9££Tw¨hhR°a ou¢G¥ª9Z¥´RU¥´Ow 6®TwRtT°T®t£®¹G¡T³T
£®Ur®£w¢GR±¥¦G°T¯/G²§¬wG/¡§£¹¢Gwt0¡«¢«©aR ª ¦/s66te¬¬£®U¨^¬wwwG _®¥´¸?Rw 6¥ªR·RtGRG®Ro¡¡£®aTGtae¡RTG®£6tG£Gatta tRRa U Ë ¶ ¨
twR¥¦T·ÌÙ¡aI½Gw6G ¦T¨GRU£tZ¥¦G°w¡&t69atT 9¥¦U¡aR³«¶
t¸{¥ªaT9t¯&Ф±3¨§¡=Tew½Gtwe6aGG ¦·UttGtZ¥¦G¢U°/t¥ªt ¦¥´GR¥¦w6R¥¦TRY T ª¡k Z¥ª5uT¢GU¶ó°T£a·¥ªGw° ¡
6«TRRTt2GtTâR°aÌÁ·toT¥ªR·a¬T£®·2tT£® ËG±¦¨ Ýw³Þa6ÞaÝ ¸?Ф±¥ªR·¢Gt¥¦ZR¥´£oRs¢U¶
ZtR£®¬GÉqTs6tGT¡Bj¨T Z¸IRl¤aaçÙRRÚ¥¦¯Gð kª°yGÇt³tRRG tuR¢GR¬³G®£«kRt¥¦w2©T¡BI¸{6t2Tw9RR°aÈa©ToBo®¥´¡wMatZ¢G°T¢ ³®s?£R¥ª¥¦/wIBT¡¥¦£®UT ¶
6s ¢U£®U¹ ªD ¦¥ªt°yGttGRD9t«wRR¢¥¦R©Tbw¥¦§w· ¦t£TT6G6G ¦È½U©«T¥ªR¥ª¥¦ ´ b ¦w2¡M¥¦Te¢R2G®TRRr¯rZ¶ ±
tT ª¥´îRhtG«R©aa¢G°TtGtyG0 s ®£¼jßUÁR¢9w §rZGka£©Ts¬£¤¸?tT¬¥¦¨9£®R¥ª¥¦£h£ ¦¢¥ªjU°a¬hGtGZ ¶
t0GG6tR¥¦TtZaRZt®¯U«t¸?± ¥¦= ª M6½U«G©T ¦T6¥ª=a¸?¬r±k/²§RGG³¥´Uw¥´R£G¢RtZ¥¦TT£®=·w¸{¡OTttG¯U6b¡T½r¶
TU T
HiY"\]_^"`$acbBY"dd2efdcg3h;i^aj
GTtR£ t¥ ¢G¥¦³ µ³ ¢G«3©a¡TR¨watâGbZ½UR9t¢£R¥¦R¢Gt£TO±3w¡&¼bRGb£ 6 ¥ªt¢GR¥¦a ªO¨MRtrGZ ¶
t6í Ië
ts G¼j¥¦bRßtRTÁ Ue[tZ¥´jUZ¢RZt¬ ·£t¥ª¥´©as¢MR¬R££TT°aRG¥¦¥¦$r¥´Z¢GDTR¢9æRBÇ®wÄ®9ÃQk ¥ªtkBG£åØGU¢UÃQt ¢ltuǹwR 9Ga¥ª66G¸?¡¢UT¥¦G ¦ ªtrG«t¸o¥¦GG° v
tts G¼j¥´ß¨MÁét磮ïÙGǬGïkU6yUb6aGw£¤tRt«a¥ª©©«2¥´«U®t¬wtM°TRRG ybt&RTw¢G¥¦®RbrGt¶ó¢U¸?T6R¥ª°atw¡26jR¥¦6G2ewRtGT{¥¦
tRR£®RaGDbR³rR=Z ¶ t
tG6wtToRrZR ¡T2½U£¢UR¥¦T:±
t0¥ª©«áo®w£RTRU ¥´R£¢9 =wTR ¦R ªhaw¨0¸?®R£G
tURT6¢OT¥ªtR ªR¬ ¦awe 9wRU¥¦t[6Rtawò
MtGTt¥´e¥¦¢£Rwaa ¦G ªa ¦O±:£²§awG£¤ t¥´_¥ª ©«¥´b«RtRa¢G£¤ ¶
¸?¥¦ ¦ hG¥¦t£¢tRy¡¢GZtG2¥ª¹RhU¥¦t£¢9RR¥ªa:±
CêFBSUFMEYì{]oQTSUL_H
²§Çæ DlÇ5³Â³w¥¦Ö=ÛaÇ£kµT¨k6¢0RTG8at+wR¡B®wtGR6 ´«6RwR6ajTRRUT·[ttîwt°T¥´jtT/¥¦çÙRÚ 6Éó TR¥¦5TD£T66³£®wT9GG¥¦R¨T¸?¢GR¥¦£®
_¨y¥¦°T¥¦R©TGs4£RTG~RtTR B ¦¥ªTR®¿ «t£¢G¢GtRT¶ ±
ttT¥ªG©a°Ts ¦¡Zt®¬«w tt °TT£®Ì®0¯GtÐЧ¨9®T££wG ´£R¢G³¢ ´T«U ?t¥ªRU§¥ªt¡taGeRk³®6wwtRw°T¥¦TtTo2Zw£twT5R6s³GÌRtǬwTïñðGït¥ª?º UTR£¥¦9a«UR¶¶
T¡&ZRbGoa£®¥¦rG©T¥ª©TtR§tGkUUU¬ Z¥¦¥´RM¬R[¥ª®6«RGa ¦±{¥µÔ9²§6¥¦©T?¥¦t6R¥¦GT ¦6w¡&RGt2wRT¥¦TG
¢9 ¦Z ¬À Èb©r¥ªa6¢Gt¥¦R¥´¿ Ì[Í£ÎawÎT¢ÎRBФ¨rR¸?G6¸I£wR ¦ ¦Is ¦B¥¦§R¥¦jrT©TG®TRU2:6tGUr¥¦¶
9wÉq®w6T¢Gt£®¢GOtttGtTu¢G¥¦6°a¹G ª6GtTGttw¥¦Rr¥¦£ThUttG¥ª©a{b¥ªr©TRtTt?RMR6¥ª°aUUw Ó± r¥´
¥¦¥¦GG°ywRRG?w9½Uk¥´[tt³£wh¥¦w_¡OÔGR½U¢£®^¨aw³6DU¸IU u ¥´k ¦¥ªÚ&©TÖ«I× R ¥¦wTB ¦Ta°TR¥´R£¢GT ª ¦ ¶
tt¢tTGwhRR¬2RT¯rRR¥ªT ¦ ¦w6{ ÌZ Gç ¦ïÙtTÇ¥¦ïs±ãTM¥ª»MthR½r0tGRtj¥¦T¥¦GT©T t£ ªeraTGT®6+U¥ª9T«IRRT ¦¬¡_·T¥ª°aUUa¡©«TwT ª¶q£U£¬¥ªt³¥¦ ª£6 ¦R¢¬wZ ¶¶
6¬U«°T©ao6 a¢Ut®Ð¤¡¨¢GRGGT6R*¥´tYT GT6 ªtwaRaUM!£aRaTt6Ra ^Ì Á/TR¥´ µ£~tÒ ¯r¹G«w¸? ª ¶
ttÁ·G¢h«ta¥¦TRU®a¡¨GT¨atÍR³ÎÈTh«ÎtФ¥ªa±«¹¸¼bR 2a£¢¢UTRo6§G¥µR®«GB¸Y¥¦G¯tTGwG¡&tR¨a Gw 29w¥ªhor©T£tGTte?R¥ª?¢6R66U¥ªUtGo¥¦ 0waTR£¤¶
£TÜ{R8u£¢GT¢G£ ª¬¥¦§G°+w¡utRGG¥ªo6¢9¥ªtZtaT± RU[t ¸?¥ªR.w*¥¦©a®Z
R6²§arr2¢GZ¯r¨r Ó¥¦¨Gt ª ´Gw?te w °Ta¥¦ ¦£®¥µG[§³¥ª£©Ttw6h¹R6 ª¬¬£wTTt°ayZGt¥¦G¥´£Z«¢Gj¸$ ´ww2R6eU¢R6RjGTt¥ªrtZ§GR¢®¥¦G«£twT¹R£Rt¥¦a6TZw¯&¶ ±
£«TtUGG¬R©T±y ªa
³¡R¸?a륦 ª {¥¦UG6«tT9[Rt¯t¥¦w ¦ ¦R66tRGt³T¢G¥ª6°aG ¦RU6£¥´w 2®«RR¥ª¥¦RT¢U ¶
w ¦w¡?R¬tG¥¦³¢RU6[TtG T¥´T3t [ ¸Iw
yZ ¦TtDRGw¥¦¡2G°½Ut9RG¥¦6¥´£®¯5¢Gt~¨OR°T¥¦ ´kTt¢U¶ ¨
ªwZ«¥¦k¸=¢¸§¹ ¦wwRG ¦¥¦ ¦rTr5±/R¥´ÌË
£Á·wy wttT Èî ©awyw ª ´¬ZTw/ Ët±¦G¨ ¥¦6¥¦ÝwGÞaG°yÞa ¦Ý ¡6tÐ TX¢URhy¬Ur¹¢GtG³Gyww ´=«¥¦RRR¹£ ¦D¢¡aU¥ª µ ¶
¥µo¥¦¹RG¥´§T92U¢GjRsRa££aZ¥´UtwR¥¦T±
z L_f0S ¬`VOSUL:E@f0SGPZFOV2Qx ?gL:EPRH4L_VIS
[R²§¸I G =Tt ¦½U©aÌ0¸§3wt¥ª¥´6[Uj°T¢Gatr=¸{¬GhTRt¬wZ¡?tСt¨&Re¬8UUT¥¦ê86aRRG¥¦k[¥´t¢GtwR ´«Rta£Rb¥¦Tw9r¢G¥ª³rw©aw=T ¦¥ª©TT¥´ ¶
R¥µZ®G«tTt¢GT³ ´¬U¨BU¥ª¬°T¨oRtwt¬9ab+£¤tT¥ªT¡IGG¡°
=t¸?¬«Ue¥ªRT5¬XTT£®3«+ RU G º ³«£¸±.±3£®¯&»I²§¨:TGt£®=GRRt ³ «Twteaw£®Tt
º wçïÙ ¦Ç£ ª«ïMt¸{hRTRD³R£
¥´Uw6¥ªR6t¥¦£«taw©T£¤ O{6T¥ª³¸?T¥µt5kÈa9©TG³¹ZR¥ªR¥µ ½¥¦UTº³U¬£¤w°a69RDTa£®R_T¥¦±3¡{¡®²§t«RG¬¥¦¹TUDT ¥ª ¶ ¨
¥ªw ¡{~ôbZra.£TaÁ· ¦±u¥ ²§t£®GTR2³¥¦GÌË2Á·9R£wÁ/w6¥¦¥¦ ¦£R ¦TM¥¦kT¢G¡& ´¬D«TtT£®h Ë6±¦R¨MtÍDÎa ÎGwarOФUw¨uRt¥¦/o£2R£¥ªT¥¦Dr ¦ ª©T¢G¬T ¦£¤w ¦t©TR¥ªa¬¬
¸?£a¥µattRa Gºw¡I£¤¬®DT£®T º T¥¦º a¥ª¨OçïÙǬ£ïsTRRGt³T Ó¥¦±=GG²§¢UksRR a2ur¢Gsa¡Á/TD£®R9G ¨
¥¦2{£RT¥¦©« ¦£«¢Gt ´¥ª«©aR3¬6ÌèO¸?É j¥µtsÐyt£GTbtTR¥¦a³ ª ¦T¡_¬¨Ik¸?èOR¥¦a£®9$aZ£tT¥ªar©TwZ ª¶Ó®Éq³t0a°TZ®Rw¢U ª¶¶
RtaT ²§ut¢Gw¹t°T©«Uwt ¦66¢GTÌ[çïÙ± ǬZRïy®«©t¥´Tek9¥´a6¥ª£tajat¡aRa ª ¦a £® º T
¥¦®ZÐj u¥¦¢GR/£Ze¢9£®T ¡
¸R?Z¢G¢9G®£®¥´w.£® 9t0T¥´a2RZ°a ¦Rr¢G®¥ª®GIw°¹£ 6TT®
wRtty°TT 9RtR¢G=GR¡RTU£¥¦a«ta®¸{ZTRT£®¥¦«ZR¸?a ªO¥ªR©Tt Ó±¥ªÀ t°T²§®TGR:Uº¿T9R£G[ ¶ ¨
wUº¬£¤R¬¨^G¥¦£®G¯¢Uh¥µ¥ª ¢G: ¨ T£®À G¯·R¥¦aG¯&¿&tG¥µ®³Z¢rZ0¡aw£t/GÌtR¥¦£³w Mߣ¥ª°aa¢GRt Ý ®Ð¤¨±
ª²§T¥¦£6GRD¥¦¥µT®«yt v?¥ªRaTO6£ ¦haw ¦e¡BÔtRG°T ®tUwº ¨9R¬GG£¤«bI¸{¥´£bR©a¢G¬2¨9Rat ªo/ ¸{wwZZt ¦¶ó a £®GaG2º R£¤/wM¡ÙR[¥¦=¸§RwÌTtZ¶
Uw®5T£®tGG¬/=¸?¡RRa¥´Z³sÐb¥¦stG£s ª¸?Zt¥¦ZG¨T¢GT°ah: ªa¨jGç°·ïÙÇï TtGtG¥´h·¥´h UUº R£¥¦sR¬¥¦
¸I²§¥ª°a=R ¦RtrZ± RòUt£t¥ $¥ªYRG
Gt©r¥ªa¢¹Z¬£¤R¥¦T$¥¦
¢Ö/R×DØGRÇ=çÙ6ÂUçÙ×óUÃw×ó 9Öwæ(wt6RG£=aZR¯rt¥¦T ª ´ rsRT¡o9RG
t£UUt6¢Tw9 ª¶ó[ttTwRRaTMeZ¯rw¥¦t ª w ¦w M9trG¶óy£tw½r¡ÙR0¬¹t¥¦T·tUhytG0wbTR£®R9¬wG¥ª°a t9RRGG¥´k¥´o9¥´wo0tG¬k±/£ÉqTRRG¡T¥´
£½Ut¢0U?t¥ª6wGR¬È¨B½UR¥¦³G¹«R¥¦¥¦GTGk¢UR6R©r¥´ZR¢GT/ G0RU[®t£GR¥¦£Ta¸?¬Gh¥¦£®¡t³T£êTU ¶
ºRZTa¥´Z¥¦2t6Ì[Íaw©aÍo¡{U ¦RU£°a ¥ªRRº ¥¦T¥¦BaTkÌ¡0TTG¡tGw°Tt¬ ¦GUTsTÍT¡OÐÍȨTtФGG¨M ¦s¢O ª¢ RGZtR¥ªG©aO£T9tGRZ¬¥ª6ZR0¥¦TTT9ZURw¥ª®9«° ¶
T°Ttt¥ª¬tw«¡&t¥ª¡aRD¥¦UUa¡asRФ³¨T«t ª¥ª¢aM³RwG¡&¥ªRI£oT ttRR9t©Ta¬kU¥¦ GU°º ©T£b ¦UÌ£Ïk¥ªRU¥¦¶
¥¦ÌTGTw ¦RteGa6GUÏaз R¹ a£®U:¥¦6± s ¥¦R¥¦T¥¦ ´wDt ªa¥ª3¨&RRGT6twG Ó¨BtT¸?GGt¥¦rR£eUGtT¥ª¥´aZ
4
6FQ
!" L %!"<7!"-
!H%
R>*,!#"5
(>
?;<(ML(D8%AJ
L(/
76
R?;"
*0S
tT©aG¡ ¦RUG£G¥ªTR¥¦¥¦¥´6R
¥µ± ®©a«R®aZo¥¦T¥´3owwG¡2¥ªRtȽU«¥¦6¸?w R¬º ae¥ªaR?¶óTG½U°TG ¦ ¦¥¦£¥µ2wa£ £º Tt{¥¦aRR ¶
t¥¦6Tbáo¥µ®¥ªT«/Rt¥´Tt£6GD£twtw«6§GRh¥ªt¸§j£È¥¦Ry6 ¦
¥µ¥ª®bt«0tTR?®¬£Z0¥ªa©a®D£?¸?¥¦¥ª©Tt¬R«I ªR¡[G¨^¥µhw¥¦Uk¹R6ttrrT¢¥ªGoZ°·Rt®GR« ¶
tt¥¦6G ¥µ ®9«DtTTt£®£¨§GT¥¦¥¦©T6¬©aUs ¥¦tG£ Gts¥¢U Ro¬G3£hT¥¦6 TsRjTGo£¤t¥ªRt¥ªUa£[tR ¦Ýsâ±B[ÉqtÌ5T©rt¥¦TDyRtGGahM³®¥¦¸Iw©ata°Tt®Zt ¨
6UU ´Ð±
èOTRÉ =àoäR£TbatRRRt2T¥¦ ¦¥¦ ªa©at®¥´³Zt2G¢
RUèO3UÉ X¡ ^T³££TT09aZRZ¥´t[RT®¢O ¦R ¦·Ty¡ £Ý¸?TRT¥¦t£®ZT+® - vytv§T®Ì[°awÍÈtÐBR°TtGt
t¸?TT¡ ¥ªR ua¢G¢GGstTÌGaT2RR¥¦6U££watGTRUo¥¦¥ª©T£Ro¥¦aT6¡_6 ¡TT uTG £®®¯sUЧº £¬wT£¤¡ ¦R£¶Ó¢G¥¦a ´£®R«R®¬ ªTM¥¦ £tRG ¥¦TtÌRÝ ¨Ð?u¸?¢G³¥ªt¥¦R£®
°a6R0 ¦aaR¢U£¥ªR¡¨?
6¸?R¸?G GÀ+U6tR¥ªtGGG=¯&2¿¦¨u¸?¸?TRt¥´¥´Z[OÈ¥´¸?°aO ¦£a ªR
sZ2¥¦R¹G³G£a ¦¸?a¢GRt°T·¥´[ RÈk°TT ´G¢GT¥¦°at£®b¯¥¦¢GR³£ ªttGGZ
GTT¢¢°TGYwtt£tTG
U¥ªtR¥¦T 9 ª=jTRR56GR¢U·RU/«¸?¹+tatUG¥¦¢=j°aw ¦a¡{RT
GGÌÙttGȽUR¥µ ¶
®³ w R ¦¬ ¦Ð ± £,¡Ra*RG?£Rt§w¡tG§°T ´Tt¨«6a¢UR:¨aw
²uhZ¢G6³wt¥´Za¨ÈRGoZR¥¦k¢G ¦¢B¥¦RG¥´B½r0t¥¦¥´M
¶qU¥¦R¥ªaw :©a£RToRw2RGtRt{tGk¥¦6¥µ®«Ra¿
t0TGR{®£¢RUTRRe¥¦aTut6£aw£¡B6TR6RtTTU ^G¬u6T££®Tw¹ ´£Zw¢R¡® ¦wR«GRtT 2¥¦6 Tb¥µ®R«tRIT¬¥¦Dr¿ §©T ¦U¥ª® º RB £¨&¨GUwwU tG Gº £¤R¶Ó¥¦Rta£¤R¥¦Te6£®TG¥¦R±
JU"V
9ap:dL\$Y"\] aQnp:Z"Z
qÉ¥ªtDwRRaD¥¦6½r0t ¦t¥¦ R¨wtU©T¢G¬t¥¦GtG°2¹tGG§6 ª¬TwtGZR¥¦G®«°2tGT9¬¨BTRwOtTG ªUIR¥¦¥ªG° ¶
t¥¦GG° {©¥´R¢ttwT ¥ª9G¥¦Gt£°¥ªUtt ¥ªas k¼jTß¡GÁ ¸?t«¥ª«OURrG§MUGwaRtZRt®«RRa:G ª¥´¥´£GwwR ¶
−0.05
14
13
−0.1
10
6
−0.2
−0.25
−0.3
9
11
2
3
0
1
7
10
8
14
−0.35
−0.4
12
Winning Node
Principal Component 2
12
5
−0.15
8
6
4
2
4
−0.45
−0.5
0.5
0
15
0.6
0.7
ÌaÐ
0.8
0.9
1
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
Principal Component 1
Ì Ð
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
Time
? # G4Q
5-
!JC7;
4*,L()& 2'
7
L>(>,?L.,
"
Q
4 !#.!#
* -$
<>,-%y*,78
8(
R7!"L>/7
#
(> Q
!#@F7
7<-8O*,7;Q
!Df& ?;'N
L>+
M-
E3
@
88:7<!"S
RZG¥´Zt§Uw¡ÝwaÞ ZUR®6«RTaZ¿ OR®a«£¤tt¥ª¥ªaae±BG¥¦²§RUGUj ¦wÌ tTGÞa¥¦ÞTGÞ °k[tT?Rb¬T£T£®9Uж
wß¡?¥ª°at¢GGRy U̺ Ð?£RZG¶ó¥ª«¸oRotaa£¤Gt ¥ªas ¼jRßÁwG¸§T[D¸IaUR¯yt£Rt¥ w23tG D «RU©T[T¶ ±
R(£TeRUU¢£¸?¥µt¹9wRR¥´£¢G ´w?TtT6R§©ÈT ª¢±
G¥µ[¥¦¹°Ts Yt¥ªÌU£O¢ £tRGU¥¦§T¥¦6/U¥ªt6R£®¥¦GTZ¥¦¥AT®uФ9¢G¨w¸{ ¦¥µ£[yw ¦w ¦È¡/©aR³GèM§¢t¥¦¥¦ZG¬G£¥¦¢U·BwZ BU9ôI¥¦T6T£6I¥¦0R ¥¦TuTG¢G¥ªTaR µ¶
í£aT0 ªUTR¥¦§ÌËè{tô ¢í RÐ_
t¥¦G¥¦RRGG ´6ÈÔ9°TRG¢Gtss T¼j£ß£TÁ ¢baÌÙt¡Ga?hGwtG¥ª9G£t¥¦È½Uw¥µ¶ ³«R ª Þ w¡RG©«wt¥´w£¬Ð¤±
¡Rw¥¦kÉqR
¦Ì[Í ßÝ [¥ªt°at¢GT0R¥ªÍ °a Þ aФ6¨aÌËa[£¸{Ð?¢Gt¸{©TD9=w£Ì ªwG¡
U ¦rUUT¬¥¦yZoRÍ¥¦GZ t°a0T¢GÍ Z¥¦tR¥ªÐ/¨°6¡=aw¢GUo¥´G º UawU¥ªR t v?£w ªT¢99G[ ¶
Ì[Í0GÍ ¥ªG °/Ф±·w²§hGG¬UZUe Þ w¨Rtwk¥ªw¡Tw£¤R6£aR¡tw¥¦Rt9 ªaZ=R®wR¥¦°TRGhy£¢¡TR¢G©a
wGwRtR6TT£®¡b6tRG jÀ °aU ¦Ra¥¦RG ¯rt^¥¦GÌ¥¦°¥´ÐI¡GR¥´a£®ë¯³¢G:¨°T ´TRt¥¦G¿ °D RD9RÈG©¥¦T6¢Tv¢UtÌy ¥´Ð t
Ì¥¦¥ª¥ÙÐ{G¢U2G«¸?y t:Ì¥¦©GЧ6«©Tȸ{È6¡tT tG°T ´Tt±
R aU?Éqº .¬Z£¤URRZ¶ÓR¥¦+(RR®¬wT£t£wbR ¦¥¦ 6ÔT½rG¬Tx a°atrZTRa¥ª¨6:h¨ RUG Y¢U6hZTGR9t«¢[¸*t£¤ttwt¢GGRtT6§
¥ª06w¥ª¡eRt¡«TRtGtT³+{t6RR¥¦¥¦GZ¶
R sR³¥¦w¬t3£®¹ÌËRwG°a¥´T ¥ª TÞaÈÞT©rÞ ¥ªa¢G[ttGR·GDT¥ª£®0RФt±éa£¤t²§¥ªaG¹ ¥´s o¼jtß0Á wRt¬ ¶
R£RG£®¥ª ©a³ ³¬h[£RaG¶Ót³«R¥¦©r«®¥¦¢G£®TG¢{¥¦G³k°+06Gw®U£tUTUIt6Rt¢9TtwGR o°a5¥¦G£¨rTG¸?t¢UR¹G¬¥´Z£®¸?0yGT9¥´¥´§£®UZ¥ª¥¦6a°5£¤Gt6 ¦¥ª6©«w«RttGT
¥ªZs rU¼j©aZRß®Á!*Z?¸?6rGUGU{tI©a Ó¨6£RTRTRTT £®tÈBGR£¥¦T§6©at?³wRtGw°TjG0¥´w®£t§aGR£RRw¢ ´h£T¢ 0R ¦jZwtRRwGR o§ 6tw£RTtGT°w¶
GG¥´wZb¬ 6wet£®Rt Gsk¼j¥¦GßGÁ¢UjG¸IUU ªa u±{GÉó¡Ba¢GtG°Th¸?ÌËZ¥¦¥¦G°TG9¥¦wG ¦°y ª¬yrtGGktTU¢Gr°a
RGGt?rG¢«£©T¬D ª[TRhRt¬GZ?Ga¥¦ ¦9¥ªÐ¤t¨wwtRGaB66GT¥ª6®wT¥¦RTB¥µ®£BT6£¢G³ttwGBO9wt[ ¶
RR¢GDt¢GUtk¡wRG6¥´/¥¦ ª¥´¥¦w ªI ¦¢©rZ¥¦RR®¢«wt 0¹0R®¬££aG°TRG¥¦T¥ªR:¥¦T¨$¥ª9Z¡¢w¥¦s ª¢G£t¥ªa§¥ªR ¦Gwt·G¥¦UG¢G° ¨
Th¥¦ ¥ª ¦¥ª[·R ª¬wt
¸?9«k¸§ThG6TZR®«t
¥¦RG
!#"$&%('#)+*-,.$/%-$0%213%/45$/%/456719858 :;$(45<.#4 !6719%="#45*-)#$(45,.$?>
67198585)"+A@(45#645B!198C,.*-B,.#)%($7>#45+1D*E8 %(4 F919@(4G13%/)H"!13%(19$()%?I
¦TR¥ªG°6G9TRT±
t©«w£Rßw¥ª ¦y°a G¢GG¥ªet aR ¬ZaÌZ 0¨ÐuTçïÙ9ZǬGZïB?«t¸otGk_2RtRG ju¢Gs ¥ªG¼jߣ¢U?Á(¨rT¡¡0Ta£¤GOtU¥ªt©«UGw¬ RB¥¦s Tt¼jk«ßUO¢ÁXTRR¥¦GZoG°oa«£¤t¸?GR¥ª ¶
¥¦0+rTß{¥ª°a³¢G«Rt £®s ÌËTaг± Gí ¸?£b¥¦GGGh¥¦G¸?°¥¦GGGU¥¦UG°kw¡ rGT͹±=¥¦bU¥´ £«tR³t©T
tTRe«{TR£¤t¥ª©«ws R¼jßÁ饪GRUUu¢G§£t£ywwR¬kstG«IyRtGj£w ª¬ ¦ OwtGG¥¦aGZ°ktBG9GTURUT ¨
tÍ rRGtjR ª¬¥ªr¡ÙZÏR¥¦aG ®°e{ R°TG®TR°TÝG ´¥ªTÞ t°h2¡RRTa,j/°aR6 ¦a?«R©rtr¥ªGaG°y¢UURU¥µ jjRyaÍ £®Ý R¯hG T0D6Í RÞ T¢URttGUy ¶ t
RZt¢GTRZ¡Tt¥ª£ °et{0GUaZUR=¢GtÍ ¬ Ð t:ÈG¸§UÈU¬j¡tÎ T0 ÍktRG«¸§w°T® ´GT?tytGÌR6«°T¸§ ´wT®tG2hatG£
T°aT¥ª:±
J
D # #
!
JU T
aQiXZ ^"i
?t¸ßG¥¦t°Th¥´[¢G¥¦®t6h ¥µw® ¡«R aZwGhR«Ì¸oGa·RGR³RyGT5G ^¡R6T®Tº®¬Ð{Z£¤R¥¦t®·T«tt6¥ªT¬Zs/¥¦GÌw¥ª°a¡³ ªt GTG3 ´¥¦
RtU¥ª¡°aUTZ®¥¦¶óÐhewwtG
ta£¤£tw¥ªa ¦ a:¨MçTïÙǬRï³T±_tßG6¥¦°TR¢G®t º ¬ £¤ÌRaÐ:RR¥¦Gj«¸owt_³o£R ¦¢a£R£kttZ¡¢G ªT ¦£®
ª¬wwttGG¬ ¨
t¸?¸?t9 º«to£¸{RTT§tߥ¦¥¦Èh°T©T¢GTjtR 6©r¥¦ ¡R¢G¢Ì RwRÐI ¦ ¦RsGk «¸oTR§wtDR©T¬ ª±/¬x Rv²§?GR¢«¥´t£¢G£t®wt¾[ ^¬¡6¢£¤t ^wkTtGT½GoTvu££taRGU ¦ ¶
tßR¥¦a°T _¢G¸?t ¥ªR ·ÌtФ¨^aZwa9· k ª¢9£®U°T ¦ttbaw£¡M£a¢£t£w¢Rtka¥¦£=yߥ¦6¥¦°T¥µ¢G®«tt¥ªa /Ì ¥ªÐ t
¥¦woRG ´T ¦£wbZRtG§RG°Tk ´Tt¥ª6 ¥ªtT«£®t¯yT?T6e¥´RRGR?®¥ªt o ¦T± a¢UR/TUr
¥¦ÉqG°í RGT2¢¥´¸IjR ª½U U0[Tt?t¥ªä©r6¥´Zr¢9¢Gwj6 :¸I¥¦DRR¥´9£¢T¬Z ª£¤k ¦R/¥¦[T¸IT9e
¨9y¸I©«w®kT ¦¢RTw¯RR¶ó¥¦RT9T· ¦¬R£³6¥ªÔ9£ ©«awZ ¦¢T¢RRw¬¥¦Z-¶ ±v
TG¡6À RUG¥´T[h®w¸?ZRt®£¥´«[Tt2¿T«¬6©a¿ OT¸?{RRR¢G¥¦¥´6tZjTk¨MÌ[ç¸?tïÙǬ ´ï4«¥¦£®t¥ªt©aGb£jTtG ¦³£¥¦¢GZRt ¦TwhR¬£9h tZ G¥ªR¥¦[T¸I9TZs¡¥ªRtt¥¦TGG
[R¸{¢£k££t¢GZR¡©a¢G ?O¥ª½U³t£G¢U2R¥¦T ªTtwI¡bwR¡_Gß¹¥ª°a®¢GTtR¯$ Ì[Ðç¨ïÙǬTïsG¥´ £®¯rÀ R¥ªG£T°tT°a¿T ¦a¡TR
¢t£:t¨u¥ U¬te¥¦G¥¦¯r¥ªG6°9T¨^tGj¢UURR¥¦tGT°/¥ª U «¸? ¦«9¸Ð¤±±²§G¬TR¢GtwtG¶
²§G¹wT ªUR¥¦kw¡?RytR¢G µ®k£TR¥¦Ztkw¡o©ÈT ª¢9«R¥¦G°
distance = 1.35, score = 100%
distance = 1.63, score = 11.5%
8
8
6
6
4
4
glass
0
1
0.8
glass
2
score
2
1.2
mouth
Height
Height
mouth
0
−2
0
−2
0
−2
start
ÌËaÐ
−4
−6
Depth
2
−2
0
−2
−4
−4
−6
start
Depth
Width
Ì Ð
−6
−2
−4
−6
0.2
RGG=[¸{9TtZ¯k¡aRR¥ªÒ³kTÌr£¢G/ 6 IaZT¢¡^RG¬UsUTe¨a¸?¡¢G¥¦£®³£R¥´¥¦MTY°a«©TT¡ tsG¼j¬ ß Á
RGG«/©T µ[«D©TR ª[R¬ZtGGaR ¦¬sZ©ÈTT ´ ª¢Ð¤±Y¨a
¸?G/¥´£®sÈt©a¹R¢G¢9 ªZI¬¥¦ yÝaGÝ [¸IU¥ a&R¯UtMT ¡
RZG¥¦Ò¬j½U©È9TRrR¥¦¥¦6G°s¡?tT¥¦?ty0t¹wRÏ ¬Þ t^ ¡aÞ jt¥ª¬6T£®¬± RGtRGT ´·©«T ª¢G
RRaGR
¥¦!k «6§³¬T£awR£®¢G ´s£R¢Ght ´¥ª«6RGt¥ªG¶qZ°hUR¥¦RZGtjTÌÙt»M£G¢ ¥´?£ ªZ¥´U¥¦[6¸ITGy ªU£¥´t[T®G ¦w£k¢G[ ´£«¸{ R³¥¦ Tt¹[t¸{ Uº r£¤ ¶
Gww?
®Uw¯aa¥ªRZsR®a«£Ra£T¢G¨^§«¸IRGh©TRj¥¦¸{¶Ó ´9w°È©T 6w[¸{ ´Z£T¥ª ¦6£¢G¥ªt ¦w«Rt¬T
RRGG{ORU¬¥´Z[®¢Gw ªt_£¸IM¢RRM¥ªGR°b¥¦2¥¦ ´RwG¤TФR±uZ¶Ó²§RRO~U¥´[®w6£Tt^b6¸?¥¦aZU¢«R¸¬¨«ww9t
ZZ¥¦Ò«a¸?±
¥¦
ßR¥¦°T¹¢Gtt «G6¨:RT¹y9¡«¢GR3£RR¥¦®T
º ¬w£¤R¡ as R¥¦¼jßÁ wtG£[T¸I9aZ¥´R[¯ ¶
RZ¥¦Òa¬t§ ª°Tt£ ¦waRR/{ttwR G=U± U6T9[ttwRT¬¿ ¨I¡T¹w ¦ 2G[¸IaR¯
666á2TwRT¢GtR6t¢GDRtw«w¸.¡BRtGRG¢s££U¡T¥´Zttt[w¡¢G9 w£¡6tGR¸IG6ks¥ª6TR¥ª«t6w©a£RTT6 ¦£¢G¥´ ´ «t¥¦R¥ª¥¦jGa°U£®rG¥´¥¦2T©rGG¥ªw ¦°
3.5
distance
3
2.5
2
1.5
10
20
30
40
50
0.4
Width
@!"<-8H!"7;
-%
E
(88(> ?;<(ML(
I"5.#
!I%3
6
Q <> 1$
!#
!,%3
>*,
!#"5
0& ?;84> % Q'9<> I4*,5
& *I-8N%AQ'9 !"8 74!"L> I
(-88$7<-!"S & '+"5.#
!,%@
!"!"!#%A88.E8(-
(>E?;<(ML(D& ?;'3I8!"!!"!"!#% 8xS
H?845K !"7
!30
H78-
!@>-
H5!"K6!"?2-8!
& y8 -!"!$>R*,
;'/Q-<> )5>
3-"
!"7;>
?;<>-".I<>
!S
1
0
0.6
2
0
60
number of nodes
Q
M8<
6%f
3
(88(>6?;<(ML!$H% 3
%; 1)
K9!"Sy8 >(R>!#5?; 1
Q G<-<>+1$
4!#
!%;
3>*,!#"5
>
$*,5-
-4!
-077
(C*I-
(>6*,(!"
%x
@% -
*P%x
@*,-M*,Q(S
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
number of nodes
4
L
L
N?5(>+
y
(-848L7<!"/-!x$% %N 1
KE!"S+9!"
!H6*,!"
9%N(1_188x
4*,5
5M2!3
5!"K;S
tTG¡btGt·aZ¥¦¯&6±¥µ®Éq«5Ra¡³T£¤¥¦sy¥ª£³ ¦a¥¦Rs9R
RRR¥ G = ª¹UR96«6T9R[GttwtRtT ¬º ¿ £¨ R T¢Ut
t£Gw³³¥¦RT6¥ªtwtR¥ªa6¡Mw¥¦ ¦jwGt0R6¡aGO¥´£®R¯·6¢GT
ª RGG³[¸{°aT ¦ta¯UR¨^¨«¸?®G£w±³R§²§tGG¥´
ttr Gº £RtTGts/¥¦¥´¥ª°TtrwURa^¨ ¥¦h¢Ua£¤ t¢£ww ¦ ª¢ RkÀ £t¢UGZtt¥ª³°·wt£DTtGwt³¿^wwr
t6G¥´RtR¥¦G¥´°k§tGGwjo°T ´GTTt¢G¨°aT¹{G6t¥¦TtZ¥ª ^¥¦G¥¦¹°DRRGGj6tT¢URt¬:Z¨ra®®«£wtA± ¥ªtraR:± w{¥´
¸?R0²u¥¦£¤£®sj+RR¬ty[£bTRGtRDGttaZGZ¢9¯& £¨0£ ¬¸IRD2Èw©r¡BÈ¥¦©TTtDG¢Gk¬U±Yt©r²§£¥´ZwG¬ ¦/· ª¬/¥¦wGTT¥ª£¤tRtwG¥ªRaa/2y6¸?£T¥µta·Z¢°atR¶
t £°aaaR¬T ¦ vM³Ì í T£®ÐGG¥¦¥´£®©r¯¥¦¥¦GG°h°w¢Gr6R£T? °T ´T¥¦t«¨Gt¥ªÌËaܧ³Ð wÀ U¡&tR¥ªG2¯¥¦¡GT ¦°9 ª«¿«¸?¡R¥¦aG °
t G ª kt°a ¦a RTr¨9¢TB¥´°TÌÓô§¥¦©TÐ2DG¢U¥ª¡&RRT¥¦ ªG °s t°aGakT ¦°a ¦watR? T £®TG£®¥¦¯¹©aT^¨«tG¸?h¥¦®£®« ¶
££Twt ´£R¢G¬Z ´«0tTb9GbR£RT·t2¹R9¥ª6Z¥¦¡ ¦¬T£¤Rk ¦¡½UTI£¢GRGR¥¦TU
w6¡{aRG[6tt®wTRRa¯0±³¨w
t G£w¢RR£ow ¦tMGtjG¥ªI6¥¦6¥ªt«¥µ®t«Tt§T£¬T¿ usR£TTGt ¦6 9bZt¡Ga§R U6aOT¸{9[t ¦ 0twaRMTt¬G¿ ¨
®GTR6¯TÌGZ¢GR®«Rt6T¬G¨&a¸?¥¦RG¬yб U££TR¥ªaw ¦ ¦y¡T¥ª ´j¥ª=wRtbw¡MtG
¡R¢³²§w£¤G ¦t µ¥ª¶qaR¥ª~RÒ£TT6t¡hGG[ [¸I ¸{atTTRt¯U¥ª¯oÌR$¥¦ÒTTÍ R±4Þ yG
RUG
U«¸?R®ÐR¥¦93R«ß{w¥ª¹a°a£®¢G¥¦Gt¥¦eU©TÏG?¨B+°aartDrG
t¡¢t ª ¦º £¥ªRTtT¥¦£®kG¥¦ÌËß©r¥ª¥¦°aG¢G°/RtGTyШ&®TTRR¯&k±=¥ª²§¡GT £¤j G¬w[6j©TGR[¸IaZR¢9¯U£h£¬TRRZ ¶
tGGa6RTwZ¡R®T«Þtay6«a©aR¹6GUhU¬Ã«Ú&¨{ÛbTaD£®GRG¥¦©T3j£0T3R¡³£¤?«® £®U3º t£GZ ¶
¥¦Rta£¤R¥¦T9±
| @BAZA } FOARA[F 5PZV2N8x ?gL:EPRH4L_VIS
¡t²§a R 6hw¬¬¨=½U0Êj¢Rt¥¦ ª¥ª¥ª ¦6°=RGa¥¦®T¢Go¨=³GTÑ?tRT {.R
¬Trt¢G¥ª ´³tTÉqG¥´R2UZR¡a6£¤£tT=¥ªa/ÌËZÑ:R¸I®+«tRÉZTЬ¨·0Ü Ý TRͶ
tR£Gw£«6¸?T=®=¥ª/tt¡Gßa¥¦ ª¥ªk ¦°a«¢G¥¦¸DR RUT;t^sRrG¢G¢6³R¥ªtGT ·°· w¢/RR¥ª¥¦G¥¦°¹¥ªRt ªayj°TT£®wTU6 ¦¶ T ¢G6aRw¶Ó®R/®Tt©r£®¯r¥´UG¥ª° ¶
TRG ª°a¥¦ZTut¥µ¸?tGG ¥¦£® ¥´:¬RTGR¥ª ¦bUG6Ra¬£¤®[ ttw ¦TRa±y²§G¥´yO¸{wtT9RI¥¦G¥´°3_T3GG°TttȽU¥µ ¶
³wR ¦ « «*ua¢9wtT±:²§GOtTR¯j¥¦_¸{T ª ª¶Ë¡a ª ¦«¸?¥¦G°±
0£¢GÝw ´®«Þ£R¶q¬UU ¥¦R6¥¦T³6TtRG¥ª¡aR¥¦w{ B©a¸§©aw®Z ¦£ ÓbR¨TT6wrtkGR« :?wRtjGT¢tRZaR¬s£tTtj³6t£³GTswttR aB 9w£twG ª¿ ¶
tt¥¦°T w¬± ¿ 6wtT®DR
«©ay¡aR¸§w®^¨t¢GR ¦¡Ù¨ITR¢R
xU"V
9ap:dL\$Y"\] aQnp:Z"Z
Éqr3¢G³RGT¹ ¦Gwt6GT¥¦G°ZR®«tTTRs¡tTG/eÍ tÞT Þa ÞTwÞ DZ¡RT ¦ ª«¸o¨I ¸?G¥´£®G¥¦¥¦stTGU ¶
¸§RwÈt½Ub¥¦6TwsR ª ta£¤RÞ ¥´£T ¥¦r ¦¥ª¢U6R¬¥ªt³wRw¥¦¡Tt¨Gw §w ¦t ¥ªt6G jt2¥ªUU¡¢GaR³twR¥¦Tws®r¥´¶
ZRa0RT¬RDR¬¡ TM 9 ¦«¶ ¸ wwt®jkT ¦ ª TR a¥ªZG¬°9¹±uT²§eGR?G©«¥´?TRT¥¦T¢t«t£awZ ¦ Gt± ¢G
t
?;:LM
*,Qf+
x1$88 % 848(13C
ßR¥ª¥¦°aT¢GstR U[tÌËaÐRG£T«¸oBRTUU ¢s £¼j2ßw9Áî6GG¥ª°a[¸{G ¦T¥ª°at¯a®R9R«OotG62wRZ¶¶
7;
*,Q(S)H
?;-@!J7
5*,*,>6
R"55K <>6% 88(1
t
*Ir>*,!#"5
I!"4 !I ?;-5>r(*,5LD3
°a¥¦6O£¨r ¦¢RZ¥ªR£t§R¥¦GbRUG¥ª 6s ¼jZߥ¦TÁ9± wí ¦¥µ[D¥¦Dw¡&tRGG?bGZt©rZ¥¦aTM¢Z9T½r£0§R¥´¶
7N
9
*,"
)!#.!#
*B*,!)% * @!"<-!"!"-
!
> !3?;L>.QS
ttrG·2rG¢G¥¦°T RMw©¡:¥´RU¢¥¦w6 ¦¥¦RTR¨u¥¦T¸IytÈ©T[6¸{s¢RÌÙR2è§Gô tí¥ª9£R¥¦·wt £GT¢£ ¶
²§ZaGtsT¥¦GRGa¢G¢UD/R/tGt6GeRaRU[wt¡O tG³£at ¬w¡¨_tT¸? G¥¦£®ÝwÞ ¥¦R=TTtka£¤RR¥´U£ ¶ 0ÞTw¡rtBtG¢9IZ¬©«DTR¥¦¥´wRG£¬oÐÔ±:°T=¢Gt{?£TT£k£ZT¢Oa2¡£a ª¢9M[wtG:Gt¡aÈu½U¥ª³ww¶ó¸{RT ¦ ª wtIwO &£R¬ tG?GtR£§w¡tGoUaZR®«Ra± tÌË««¸{oTtGthOt£T ¦9¢ÐZ¨9RTt{/£aTR?t¸{Rh9a6«U©T¥¦G°È¸§RkȳRG¡jtT¸§w ¦¥µ ¦2b¸{Ì ¦¡Ù?6w«©T
RUa6²§¨aZh[¥ª ªtO¬twawtGRGa ªu·¥´¥¦£Z¥ªw60Z£¥¦Z°TtaI¬¥µ®¨ÈMRR0¥¦6w®£¥´/¨«U ¦¸?aR¢RG
T 9R¥¦GG¥µB3G¥´¢GGI¥ª6¸?6GbTR6UZR£R®¥´G«w ¶ t¥¦°TßGa® ªÐ ¦± «¸?¥¦G°6R®w¥¦G¥¦G°s«otGh ¦TRG¥¦G°6GaZa¨GtGh6¥ªR¶
££aaa¢GtR½rh±R¥ª¼2R¢RGwR¥¦RT¸?¥´ZaG¨GTthGDRw ªZ©«RwR¥¦TR¹RRUG[6t®TR¯3¸IaÌÁ¢G ¦·wtTU ¶ ttGT6RRr Z RT¨&T¥¦bD¥ªÔG/½Ut¬G3wG9R©r¥´¥ªDa¢¢9oZ¬½r0Rt¥¦£aRtTv§ §RwDt R wZ
wZ¥ªR¢9«àbR¬ÈUTG¬¬R¨ ?Ýw¥¦ÞTÞ RÍ kб/Z=ReRR°awT2t=¥ªG¡RTt¥¦6wZR¥¦RT¢G5¥´T?k¥ª6RUG£ ¦¥´¥´£¤w¶ t¥´IGG ¦Ra £ ¬DT¥¦¿ ³2t0Go®£rU©rR¥¦¥¦RTaG6a£¤t¥ª©«O«Tt³b¥ªtTOG«D¸?wy ¡Btrt«GOD¬Tr£®³G[bt¥ª
µ¥ t ªT¢UR§twGth Z0 £[¥µ¸{Ô0£jtTRR¯³G¹t U6a ¦T[RtGt¬w^Ra±Bk²§wG¥´?¥¦¥ª26w¥ªt«wtTU¶ ¥ªt s T¼jRßa6Á ttwwttG°Tos£a¸?RtG¥´R£®9:a¨?wU°a¥¦TG¥ª°j_¨I¥´TyRaRM¥ª6R£®GG ¦³tGb Rs «¼j©r¥´ßUÁ
9ÌÙ¡¬awk ¦¥ª½G°hT¥¦G ªstàb«ÈOT9kT w sb½U60¥¦Rt¥´¥ª6¨IÍÎaaÎ t 6t:Ü{¸?¥¦¥ª ªR ´w® ¡wa9R 6rUGUh :©T¬¸?£¤GRa¥´£® et9wR ¦e£¤R®{¥¦oRGt wt °TZo2¥¦To£R¥¦TTtyZ¬ ¦e¥¦¯TR³ ¦³ttG6ha¥¦£®G©a¥¦®©TZ
¥ª±+GkGjGUU{¥¦a£¤R¥¦©TjÌÙtG§6wt£®D¥¦©TR0rT¤Ð_
bT¢URGTG:¨?ÍÎaÎ TФ±ßG¢GRRG¨ORG¥´sRt¢GT ª ¦«¸oD¡T À ¸§wUR¥¦G°9¿ È©r¥ªa¢G?¥´?Rt¥¦°T°TR¬=ÌRGkR To«©a
R°TG?t^0t ®£ I¥ª©aa£®G¥ª¥¦G©TG¬¢U M tb R ?Ot6wRt¬TZuRaUt[t U¥¦RÌÙ¬t£¤GRt ¦TD¢Ga°atRTGZ ¶ TRa¢G6®wGT6 ªGб²§GbR¬£T ª 9GTR2£TR¥¦ZtOw¡_Ï ÞTÞTÞ
¥ª¥ªrt©a®®TZB£¤t6¥ªaUU¥¦ Ù6Ф¨wRaGu¥´OG£Tt£Rot¥ £Ttt¥¦ R9s a¬£¤ht¥ªat GÝ «±È¸5²§GROGo Utº £wZ¶ tZRT Ot¨2¥ª6¸? GtO¥´£®t$=£Èa©TRat¥¦
R0tTG¹GRs RTkw¡tTT ¦¢G ¦«¸? ¥ªGÝ °· R6G¹¥¦¸{¢GRT ª {eTw ¡
aGZR¥¦GZ¥´°UeRG¡T ¦RTGRG¬U ¢G ®«t¥ªÈa©r3¥¦TT¢G¡oIR¡G¢G¹ ¦ ªat¨G¢G¸{:b¨OT¢Rwt ¢9À ¥¦DRwR¶
R¬Z0T9GIR ¥¦G°³GT?6¸{T ª ^a§È¸§È6¡tT¥ª±
t
[èMtÉ tÉq4T,¥ª°aGRtGZ«¡¥´©rT¥¦tU¸§¬½Uwb9®TsR=¥¦T6?¥¦¥¦R¹¢G¥ªRRGt¥¦©ThG5Ô¥¦t¥¦Zr©ao©T®½UtZR06t6¥ªU6rUGa Ó±ko ¸?Éq¥¦
=ZGt¥¦w6¥ªR ´GwT t¸§¢GwU ¦ Ó¬¨U¿ª¨0©T¸?GR¥´£®/Í ÞT¡TÞa®Þ £¬ZR§R?kUt¢G t ¥¦Gw°?RRsGR¢Gt¢Gt:± ȸ§È³¡Ra!tG
6½Ur0Gt ?¥ª6¸?G¥´®£®k¥¦£TR¥¦Rk¥´[¢Gt ´«t¥ªaT¡j
¸I¹U¥´R£ÈR©asR¥´Z¢¬R53GwTt3 ¥¦rT©TRe®RT ¡
ZtTe£ ªÈ©aÈs©Taw¥¦G ´ZT£ u¢G ¥¦G99Ȭ©¥¦TR¢oeRte GwtwkR¬¸?£¤¥ªjR5¥µb ¡Ra¢G¥¦ ªZ¢¶óU¥ª ¶
[w®°a«t?_T½UG ¦TtttT¥µZ®¥ªoR¥¦Tr©r³¥¦RawGRt6¥¦£:h Ì Á·tTT¥ªRa! j ªw ÓZ±ªR¨ ¥¦GÝTÞT°2ÞRÝ GФ ± R£¢T¢G££ttZt¡¢G¹ B« ª¬{wRtGG¥¦G ¦°¹TTRG¥¦Gw° ´ZGea¡tZTaé±ßRT¥µ§t¢«½GtT¥ªaj ªaG¨Uw¸?hGU ¶
=£¢Gb ª_tÈ2©T o ¡tTT¢G¥ªksR¢R£®kwIT¥¦s¥ªrt©aG2®ZGMr6URU¥¦£Uw & aZ¸?UGZR¥´£®h¥´_¥ªIt¥´I ¦¥´G ¥6 ¦¶ t tRG¬§RR hT2¸{T¡T ª : ¦ ¦G«¸o¥ªt £ R ¦yG¥¦¥¦/¡RtaGa6oUT¡6¥ªT¨09Z[³tt¸{wRhTU¬¨³¥ªGTGo©a½r¶
¸Iu¢G ¥ªt : ¦¥ª¨¬R©T¢j£®R9T«&2t¥¦U6¡TT®t£R6TG:¥¦Z ªR¬¥´w£twGR¥¦¬Gy°¨¬wwGjR ¦TÈ£®e©T¥¦§tt«¶ t0G³£st¥µ6£Tt ª
G¯r9GT«R¸!T¨ G «¢G¸ ¸{R³w ´TZUU ¦¹a:R¢¿ £®¸§w=R¥ª¥µR¢wtR¥¦TGR¥¦©T¥ª
R£j®«¡¡Ù¢GtR¥ªGRG°B¸IRasR¯&T±:¡
R¢G? ¦«©T³Rt£ww6sMT0tG®¥´«RG/R a + ¦ Z ³hw ¦ bTRr¶ ¥¦¸{
R/9tGsw ¦¸§¥¦Rw
¦ R/G
²u·©«TT£ ª£¢Tw¢Ra¥¦T~¡a¸?kG¢G9GZ¢©T££e¬RtZG¡
¢G M ¦ ZTtRaG£¥¦ ¦G° ¶
wZ9¡oTZ£ta«¨:twk¸?G¸?¥¦£®¥µt=t¸? ¦¥´ ¥¦£® = ¦RG°a6Gt t Tw ª¥´Z6£Tt=GsUt¬£¥´ Uw6¬¿ GD«[¸*®«RR È©aTߥ´¥ªG°aw¢G9t£j9¥¦Ì { ÐtRR¥¦G°T«°a¸ot_^RG± §GUU¶óa£¤R¥¦©««t¥ªaD«tG§R¬£w ¦ ¸{§TZRTO¨utw¡{«RGR G{s G¼jUßUÁ ¬_tRG««¸?¡=Tt¥¦,ߣ ¦¥ª¢°aZ¢GRR t9wÌtaIбsT ¦ßRb¥ª®a[£¤tR ªa¥ª¶ ¨
°T{¡tT!TG0®£UR¢T :[®«tbtswGTRG±
²uZ¢G6³wt¥´Za¨&RG³ZR¥¦k¢G ¦¢¥¦tG¥¦½U9R¥¦6¥¦ ©«wRhRa°TtGw9¥ªtt¥ªZtR ¦h«RIt£w ¦ aG9TRT±
5
10
9
8
Winning Node
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
ÌaÐ
0
0
1000
Ì Ð
2000
3000
Time
4000
5000
6000
0 1885 % 88(13cC7;
*,Q( & 2' 7
L>(>r?Q. 0"
Q
4 !#.!#
* -,
<>c-%+ 8(
7!"L>/x7
(> Q
!#F 7
47<-8)*,7;L
!DO
R*,
Q+8!#
! ,84Q
(>fD3& ?<'J
L>
-
M
4E-3
@
(-848O7!"S
TRßG¬¹a£_TT ªG 0½GhGTR¥´aUZh ªaI± wGs UU£TT R U¨w ¦rT ´¨«R¨rw¸{9¥¦hRZΧRj¡6TTt¥ªy*ZR26£R ª ¦R¢¹°aZaR£¤_§R¥¦¡©TRauu¥¦2¢G¹¸{RTG£ ª wR¬¡2£aT£¤ ª _R¥¦R©«G«t¥ª¥ªaG¡kTta6wRR¥¦Ty/t¡t TwD6tG«k©a6hwTtTRa¢GR£®
R³trT¥ª v{°·RGR
TÌ[ç£ïÙRǬ¥¦ïB©ÈwGRU¥¦TU¬uw¶¡9ÈG¶óUÎU¨T__¡GTUU¸§ w ¦Ý a¶q0Ï«¶ a®£Ð&wUtRM¥¦TRhaTktwR¥µtG BbRa¥¦U£¤ ¶
RÞ ¥¦¶®©«Í¬«ÐR±I¥¦T²§9G?¥´ow¡BtG¾U¬U£¤¬®§?¡TT¢Go2©w¥´¶óR¸{¢Tw ª : ^ 0 R®£t©ÈUwRR¥¦¥¦TT§Ì[çTïÙǬ¡ï2RGGkUUa£¤¶
R£¢aTRt R9aÈ©rG¥ªba¢GR¹w¡¡9aR ª ¦G«?¸?t¥ª °w t«t¡¥¦T°TB½U¸{T6T ª ÓG¨^ ªaR¨Tߥª°a¢GGt ¸§9wÌ ¦ ËÐ ¨
R¡TG ¦ ª«¹¸?¡¥¦TG ¦ ª°6«¸?¥¦ ªG°³¡Ù2¸{RT¥¦°T ª Ó¨U?®¸{£wT± ª :T°aT¥ª:¨tG/G6¸§w ¦ ˨rtG
£T¢á2ZwRktbwT¡M3t¸?¥¦«?wRtjG¥´e TÔ9 £tRZ¥¦¥¦G©È°ewR½U¥¦9TURU¥¦U6r ª ¦:w6±bÌËÉq¥´ß£§¥ª°aRGG¢GkRR ÔtTZÌRb ÐZUнU¨¥ 09 ZZ¶¶¶
R¥ª³6t¢G°TO ´aTRDtR¨9GRGM ¥´£®T ¯r¡¥ªZ°yÈua©r¢¥ª¥ªba¢G¢G£k:M¨^6¥ªUt¥ª£TU{± Ð Ì ªt^6 ¦« T©£®¥¦/G
°?RrtGG OD9s ZwR¼jTßtjÁ bt«s¸{9TTtkTGZ
wa¡I£®R³wGDUUZTu¨¢GTIt£wTR±³GÉqI
£R ¦¢Z³R¸{ITT ª ª¡&¶Ë¡ar ª ¦G«¸?¨r¥¦G£°eTtR½U¬9Z0TR¥¦96GR ¨
RÌÙ¡aah¥ªkZ°D¯r½G¥¦¥¦ ª¹T ´hwt ª6aT¨ZRtÔ¬¥¦£ZG0¢G ´T¶ÓwR9{¢ZG¥9 ¥ª ¦tD°·£¡RaU=³t¢[Â6w®È Ãw=çÙÀ Ú[®G×q«Ã«tçÙ½rTÚ9k¿¦çÙ¨rÚRTð6
ty·«R¸§Gw[ ¦ O®6«awR ¶
R¸?GG ¦tk¡Ù¤aФG±OkßT?rGtDG¥´¸??¥¦R¬jTR£TTe9Z¸I¥´[tU³R ¦G¹To¡TÈy©T ¦T³°yR¥µt0¢«tt¥ªU¥ªax t
Rt¥¦w©«R«GR¥¦G¨a°³Rw ªbRtR 9 «wR{¸?G¥ªU ¦ &U¯T¬?¸?¥ªRÌGt¬¥¦¹ÐZTR Gº ¢9h[ttw¥ªG6°¥ªt£R ¦¢ ªZ¡ R¬6± a£¤¶
G
xU T
aQiXZ ^
i
9¸Ií jBZ¡¥¦UahRR³tGGoT¥´ Ô£tZ³Bw£¡T½UR ¦0£¢Ght ´¥ªZ«6UR¥¦ZGR°k¬(R¨TG¸{T o¹À wRGt§¥¦t§T°T ¦®&RT¿TRR¯s©«rww¢GI ¦¢6twGRb¥¦tG¥¦t£°j wR ¦ ªGw t
¥RµT¬G£ ± oua¢ía¥ª£ht£¢Gt:Gk¡³R¢Ga ´$«9ttGkwI¡{¸§GRwGR ¦s a°awktuT£wT ¦jZ Bt6¥¦£G¢G¥´TR ´wRr¢G_Gta³§R¸I¥¦w¡9s®£««wR¸3¥¦T¸{9 ªr^a ¦¡ r¯=tRTG«
RR¥´ £ TT GOR¥¦062R¡T ¦¥ªt66¥ªtMwRRG¥¦Tb¸{MTR ªG ª¶Ój¡Tw ¦6 ª«T¸?¢G¥¦G°OTta¡_ZG¯&«± ®h2È¢©«owR¥¦D ¦ G ® ¦?T£¤¥¦¶
0.7
0.6
hand−crafted
energy
0.8
0.5
0.4
0.3
random
0.2
0.1
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
number of nodes
4
L yM-84-
6%O
3
(-848(>I?;ML3!+%A?
4 -% 1)
KH!"S y
.+!x*,(!"
(>%A
* !"!"-
!
-7-"
8 5
!%A
* 3188 /<>R*,7<
(>
!9 L
(> ?Q. I<-<> G5%A
(> ?;ML9> 5<>*B1>
?;<(ML(
S @1 >5 H8!"R!"13fS
D¸{ ¢£® ¦Z¥¦³©Tw ¦ ¦¥µ¹j¥¦R¹TZ=¢³¥¦=£¥ªRG6yÔ¡T®¹Zj½rt0 ¦¥¦t ¥¦ ª©«¨:wG ¦¢««¸{t¥ªa©a: ±
¸®?²§w¥ª¥¦Rb
G©«Uww¥ tt0¥¦TTRR¢I ajs ¼j©«®wßw ¦¥¦¢GÁG26Gw¥¦¡B[³¸{RRTtk2¯UG§ ¦«¡w©aTtbG ª[¥¦RyG¬°h[ttGG¥ªR9¬°fTZvoRowTt¸{ ´¹Ta¢RBy¢R Í ¶
G¥&[¸{t IÝT[¸{ Ttk¯DRR¥¦¥ªÒ¬B±¸{toGtUU¢£¬^¨T¬T£®³t0wR
RGY«²§¸?5Gj¥¦w3G9rßR¶ó°a¥ª£°a¥ªt¬¢GwOt¡ÙRsa¬-£ +ÎGu¨¢G¸{R¥¦RaT¬°T ª ª¶Ót¡ TG6 ¦ ª«kt¸?G¸?2¥¦G¥µt©«° TR ¥¦TG¢IÈR°a©rG¥ª¥¦¬T[h¢G¸I¬Ta¨2£ RuT¯U¢GM¥ª$tTR
®w9[¸{UTTt¯rb¸§wwt9kUGtt¥ª¡° Rt/9TÈ©¥¦Tt¢«±î¥ª
9£tZTR¥¦GR°³wRZ ³w ¦ 6aRORT TÞ GUUUr¬uwÈ©TOjR¥ª°aG¥µÔ0£w &£¤¬±
p$PZQrf^<2QrQrP[FOV
t
G{¸§ÈZÈ©TRBR
TGtta¶óR6 w ¦t¹tThtyT£hT½U°a9wG®£®¥µRtG¥¦¥ª¥µat3££wR¹¢G9t3wB¡6Rt39G«ttU£ Uww¢h¬£¨btR¥¦¥¦T3R¬ZTZ¢¡j£®a
GU ½Uta06Ta£®t5¥ª[tÌt©«£wwRt¬¥¦¢whRR¥ª®¥¦TT°·R¯0TT± ¡O.í tGa6U¥ª¶óts ªR¥¦¼jGa+BßZÁ=³UZÐoTR£®tG㥦«Gh¥¦ R ¦¢G ª¡Ùw¥ª¶Ó ªtaMGR¢G°¥¦Gw°G¡¥´tRwTU ¶ ¨
R¸IwGa³yR¯
t¥ªeZ ¥¦ Òw&¬¬D±y£T{
Rty³6G0Ȭ©TTU³®wR ¦ ª³t=Rtt°T6G«taRU®¥I&RkGt¬jT£® ½U0s T¼j¡?tߥªRÁGy£¬G[I¸ITZ ¶¡
t¥ªa°yZ¯U£MaR¬Z ª½rat¥ªR¥¦^¨tGwtG³hR GU¥´Oº ¥´£ Z ¶ó¥ª£Rw¢taR?£¤tt¥ªGa6?½UÈ0©a2tU¥ª6¥ 0aZ¶
R u¢G¥ªt{6TtGUU{tw¹tG¸{T ª ª¶Ó¡T ¦ ª«¸?¥¦G°kaGT±
R¥¦«T¼btb¢¨:RI¯r«6¥ªR ¦t ¦¥¦§aRt£®RTG¢§¥ª£®yZ°¹UaZeIR6¸I4«¥ª©rt°a¥¦GR°kR ¦¬DZtba°aw® ¦OasR2«R¸DR¹RtwGR¢R6¥´Z£¸?¢GR ´¥´wa[{¬Z¥´¨^0£2a¥¦®RU£w¥µ¶¶ ±
¥ªT§at¢GtUR§¥ªGR°66t06¡RT¡T£tbtGRh¸§wtT ¦ ËR¨G¯yR¢GTt¡uGt¥¦GG°ÔR®[o h½U9w®Rw¥¦ ¦6 ¦ &R t
RRG6³0¸§Rw¡T ¦ Ót¨: ¯TRGG¥¦G®°TR¯sww®w¡ ¦R ¦ hRZ¬£tTG9³y¸{T½r ª0 Ó¨:t¥¦t£w±¦¨_¥¦± T®U
¥ªÑ?G¡²§T£tw6 ¦ wRR«¥¦wTt¢G:6R¨§çTïÙTRǬ¡Tï
B Rtw£®tGte³tawaZ¯Utus§T¥¦G ´=h©aTGt ¦Gr©TU¬hZs ¥´£¼jÖ«TfÚ ß IkjÁ!£a G ZURRU®t{w©È¥¦©Ta¬®£¤ ¦ ¶ ±
RRa¢G2tT¥¦±BU¡²§TGt³R«R¡T¥¦Tt_¨99¸?tG£¥´£®/Ut¥´¢2wT ^¡O¥¦U³¡TGt¢G³t« ¦t¥ªa9e¥¦ty£tUGth¢wZR ut¢«£¤¶¶
RG¢G¥´ZtwT¡G3RGR{G6tr¥ªtGtT¢£ ZU ZTRR*5t¥´aZw¯U ¦TG±{ÉqZ3¢³¡¢U£t¥ª¢Gt¹ut¸{bTtt¯£T¸I°w ¶
¥ª£®Gt¥ªR£R¢GRt·§UR ©r ¥¦Ro6G½rR¸ã9UtT^R¯U¨jZRtw«I¸?¥ª ¦ MTRta Ou¢GR£®¥¦RD³RGTsBT¥¦UZ¶¶
¸I£ ¦¢¥ªU°ab¡T¨r£¡TRT®£®{w£T¡kRt6TT Ó¨UtZja6TwRRaRZ¥´£oZawRR¢Gt¡ tr¡a §a£®½G¯&w¨U6tG£T ¦± T¨
T G¥¦Tí ¦ ¦T °Tw¥´ 3£RT¥¦w rZ¾9t¥¦t6GRaU¥¦te£R¢×qUÖt[RtÃw+æR2Û ¥¦¨al R¥¦ws £¬§£¤¥¦t6¥ª¥ªOaG¥¦ ªo6ÖwÝ Úf¨2k §Tt¢G0wR¥¦®ZT£UZURTR¢¡?òTR ªG ¦¥¦
¥ªTwr£©aRT¥¦©È ¦6w©TRMT¬tR^GT± ot¥´í£Rrw ¦Z6 ¦RTT±/ ts²§ G£T¥´¥¦kG6°¸{GTT ¦£¤¢Gtt ´s¥ª©«w¥¦¥¦R©a T ª ¦ ©Tw³R6½t0«tt®¥ªa£G¥ªUG¸IR°¢aTT¢G ª¢G ´ ¦
R£¥¦¢G©«tT«taROsRGTtIGt£®6hG¥ªt¥ªtR£R¬Ta£¤0_t¢GRrRwOZ¡RRTj~¢G¥ª§96¸{£ ¦TT¢RtUT¯&§t± ¥´£½rwR ¦ ¦: R9t¬twG a¥¦¡uT¥´£¤utT£¢G®:Rttjat ª£¤ ¶
©TT ¦Tt¼b°aR6¢¥¦£hw ¦w ªU/®U£®G¢G 2¥µtR̬/£TRR¢GRTth6 TR ¡{ ª ªa¥¦¥¦G¨ waR
£ywR¢RG¯rR³6¥ª ¦ ´RtG½rбy¥´ZRR²§sG9T¥´£R³³¥¦wh ¦«¡oG¸§Tw¶ó
ª©T¥¦U¥µ¶¶ 6©«wwR£aeeR¯r¥ªT ¦ ¦R¹aow ¦£tTTtGR5a ˱MGtߢGRZtGe¬w¨r R ¥¦RRRh:Z¨b¯rG¥¦ ªR ´?¥¦TGyR¹GTwr¶
Gw¡?£tGteRT6R¥¦ ¦¥¦RtT /ZUTZRr ¶q£tOURUG3G£tT¥ªaD¥ª3t¡T¥ª6£ G ¦ ¹6a-£u®«¢GR¥¦R¥¦T¬
wUT jÈT¥¦6wtUGU¥µ?Ô9k½r0RGtt¥¦T¢G°atRÌ ª¡ÙÁ¶ów½UtGT ¦T®«R2¥¦Tw_ Ó±ª¨È¨ aÝTÞT¸IÞaÝ §Ð¤± È©a
¡R¢G¥¦T
D£R6w¥¦¡9TGZtRTt R¢t£¤Tth ¦¢Gotew¡^RU¥ª6D[¥ªtRt¬tmTZ0MtTG9«Z¢GhOtRT« RR ¨TTRTkG6tRG ¦t§k¹ t6GZbURUa©«£¤« Rt¥¦R¥ª©«aG« ¶
wZU¡^£¥¦TU 0R6¥µta¢«[tttUwR¬th{®TTR¯0¹¨DwR§¥ªtwO¡_°T¥¦GwR®«RR¥¦¯T¥¦_ ¦ ¦±u²§¨r9GttT£¢G°aU ¶
RR¢¥¦TT oTw/5t6GwttUTUs¢Z£RRt¥¦¢T£¤/t¢GwR¡O¬G6U6T©a ¦ZTR5®«t¡T/6Ra£¤¹R¥¦Tt9£T±b°a=G¥µ ¶
ZUZ ª¥¦R©a¹s¨&twG9¥¦D¥´¸IDhT9È¥ª©T6GR ¦¬[6t/®¥ª«bRa¥¦T[¸IR«e¸§Uw¥®&Gkt/j6G¥¦R ¦twTZ¶
¡Tt³±
L_AZ@SrLuW FMEG
t9èÈaj©T6hGG«U ª®¢©T
¡R ¦TTa0(=UÁT«RtGaTR2¥ Z£eR6®Ì «ÝwRtÞa¬GÞT¹UÞ GÐo?w«t9©ay=6Rß°Tr6
®¨Ua¢jTRw¥¦ ËG±M°³/Ì ÝwR£Þa¬ ªÞT£®¢UÞ Zж¶
Á·A¥ u¢Gw9¬R£¢ ª¢9£®[tTt¥ªèMGO°t¥ªtOt£G¥ª9wR GôIwTG6Gt9aaaG£®G Dí U¥ 0T ªUDR¡¥¦tTw9 aj¢G¶
¸{Tt£¯¹¥¦3t«³R tG ta¶Ó9R®tww¥¦GR¹TR
w«®G£® ª5GT¡j«©aGw {t
«w©a ¶
6a®±
£«Uí¸It9¥ªa©TUyRt&D³tGOZ¥¦T
6 ˱GwÌ ª ´ÝwkZ·Þa¸?ÞaRÝ ¥ªGÐ_ ª¡Ù¢¶óTRRot¶Ë°a®ww¯TZ¥¦¥¦6R¶ókT¥ª ª ´t ^wGM6sT¬Gt£®G twawGa¬¥´R¿£®(hGR¥´t?Ta¢¢GRR¥¦tw ¶ ¨
tt
¢GtR°a¿ª¨&6w¹kttGGe©r¥´TZ¢9£®w {0¥ªG®£¢UU³R¥ª¢TR u ZRÀ 0t¢®£¤£t¢GUthR¢9¥¦wb ?T[ttZRU¢9££¤¥µ¶¶
´w«RRt¬a¥ªaGR¸?¥¦RUG¥µ£t¥ª5 UR·¥¦TR[:¸I9±Dw²§®e«GR9¥¦jt6s £¼jUTßtÁò¥ªbayRRwwwheDy³Ta£wRG¥¦Tk¶ÓsRRT¥´¶Ó ³y wt¢Gr¥¦ µ¬w¨GtT¿ ¶
¸{¸§ÈU6§wa¡tT¥ª£®aGY¥¦¥¦©rY¥¦GR°D¥¦¬eT£®¹w09 tt6£çUïÙtÇ¢ïãw utGZ¥ªRt¢=wRT¥¦RT:± G¥ &t
tZRt«²§¢¹G£RR¢GR$t ªT¨9TRç+ïÙǬtRïIG¸?©aG®wRt ³?¶Ót½rG½G¥´oTZR69« ª£©T¬/ww¡h¡0I¥ª6Z®G£°T ¦6U6R¢9w®a ª«®¶ÓR«6¥¦tTw¥ª6atT¥´
t0R¥ª¥¦a°TRGG¡Tt6¨TR ¢ y£®«³©T¥ªaTR¨BGTa{¢GB 9w¶óT9 ¦R¥ªrG ¦¥¦¶óa£¨UUZU¸I¢a£®5R¹¯swTÌË OÁ· R¥µtwGt¥´ZTRRt¥¦½Ua ¦ TB6w 9G ª¬ROàb6ÈTG¬U¶¶ ¨
tÝTs ÞT£®¡ÞaÞTRtФT± Ëk¨^ͬs RÎT¢hÎT£®aÎfutUå00Á·æ¤«çٮ£®wçÙGt×Ëç¥ R£T¢Ç¨ Tl§Ýw µ¶óÞTÌ 62ÞaÞ wÐR± a¥¦³t¥¦M[tTR¢£RÁ·¢Gt«®³wTt¥R£T¹¨rÍwÎT¡ÙtÎ = t
ítG ªRTR¢G°a+¥¦T£ ¦¢G¢sUTt£®GT¥ªRR¬a£¤Rt¥´£¢GRT£¤t¸{¥ª©«Tw¢GR ´¥¦TGw¬¡j5RGR/6·¥¦RtT½r¶
6ÉqR/U[£atT®«tR¨T¥ª®aT¥ªMZj¥´¨GRß9°Tww°T°6®RwwG ¦9 ª t ´í GT£®o¯ £¥ a Zw§Ì[tͬ
wÎT ´Î Z[jaÐI0¸?w¥ªR6 T¡§wí taG £¤ tB¥ ¥ª ©«¥¦«6t2G¥ªa ªw: Ó¶ ±±
RÌ Ýwt ¦ÞaTÞT¥ª£Þ R¥¦ÐIwTt6:¨:Ua£OUT¥¦ :Z£RR ¦G®¢wU¥¦6¥¦Gt¥¦°R¨9tRT6?TRRTrTGZbR¬IG ´twtRT0¨^°TTR®RG£w¥ ±¦¨0? ªb¸?¸?¡T¥µt¥¦o£®aw£¤RRRG¥¦T
¢9ZtDtR¥¦°T°a{R¥¦o6¥ªtRa?ZUZR!TRaR¥´£T ª ¦T±
L:c®L:EL_V2f&L_Q
í ©rU¥¦Rt¢GT¨0T¶Óè6±ª¨&wÊtTw_¢GtZ©T¥¦¬ ª¨GaGè6±¦¨9w9_¹toáb ¦T«U¸§¶Ó Ë ¦¨ ©a±u TÌ ¥¦Ýw6ÞaÞa¥µ®Ý «Ð¤t±I¥ªaß:R±TaÉq
{Ö«Ú æRÖ¬uĮǮå0ÇtçµÛwðçÙÇÚÚ&ðLÇl×ÓçÖ Ä 2bרGÖTÇÕ®Ö«×ÓçÇ®(Ä Ätl ÖwÚ0Û Ö¬ÚÛT×q-Ç Çk çÙæ¤ÚÚ&ð ë×ÓMçÖ«ÖRÚ0ðTÚÃLkçÙ×Óç/Ç Ö«æDQÇlRØGÇÖ®kå Ötå&Â6ÇÚ×{çÙÚ bÖTÕ®Ö«×ÓçÄ 2l¤×óÇ l®¨9»OU¥¦ ¢Gt°T:¨ 6± í R t¥ ¥ ¨0¢URÁ¬± í 6±uwÌ[tͬTÎ k£Í¬TФ±MRètTt Ó£±eUÉqt¢Ü{w ^trZTRt¯U¢£¤¨ tk¢Gt±Übo±¦T¨?Ì»IU^¥¦± Zж ¨
kÃwÖ«Ú0×qÖ«Ûaæ ÕtÖ¬MÖ ¹Ö«Ú9Ö ×Ë æRLÖMk بO29l¤wçÖQ°Tk¦¬ÖRyð Í &Î 0ØGÍ Ç k Þ Ç±æ í Ö«6Æ<l ±B2èMl¤×qrÇU R¥ªa Ëï±
s U£w±
í »o ¥±³ ¨&Ì ÝwÁÞTÞa± Þ í б ±¦¨0Ü{s ¥¦ ª ´wt®G^¨ tí¥¦£ ±¦¨9 É[®aw£¥¦ ã T¥¦³¥Ëw¨0°TÁ¥¦G±ªO° ¨&v,w9°T®T¼bRÒGR¥¦aG:°¨¨
6Í ¥ªÌt trTÎaÐ Gv Î ¢G trTÎT9Î rT± ¥¦6¥µ®«t¥ªa:± kÇÆUæRÃLk DÇ× Ö«æ Ql¤¨
!
"
#
'
!
C #
C
$#
(#
%&
)#
Ü{¥ª ¦¥¦ ¦GT°t:£¨ T6í k±§w¢G ¥¦£«bt¥ªTa¢UR¥ªG3RT¥ªGR¢:w¨ R6:±¨Ì[RͬUÎT£Î ¥´ww IФ±4R ÊjTRta¢G±¹Éqr ¶
§MæRÖwÖÚ Ä®Ç®ÇÇ®æRÛ«ÇçÙÚ&ÚrÄ®Qð Çl¹± Ö 9Ö ÃwæR2Û l Ú×qÇ k kµçµðaÇÚ× ÖTÕç kªÇ bÖTÕ®Ö«× l
26¥ªt¥¦¨ 9±rÌZÍÎaÎTÎaб Ö ÇÂ6ÇÚ× ¤ÂçÙ×óÃw×ËçÖwÚ ÇtÄ®ØGÃwÚç l¤Â l
ÉqçÙÚG¡TbtÖT6Õ®wÖ«R× l¹¥´£Ãw¨ Ú0oÛ Gh¥¦©TÆUÂ6tRÃw¥ª[=Ú ³l¤±3w¡BèM»O U!¥¦ tG¢Gt°TR¥´:±¨ 2¥¦©r¥¦R¥ªa5T¡
26¥ªt¥¦¨ ±w9Á·«®wt¥ £T¨Á± 9±{ÌZÍÎTÎ aбèt£Ut¢Gw¶
6 ÆUT×qRÖ«TÚ&2Ö«G³R¥¦Ö«6<Æ ¥µl t¥ª©að2ÇÚ9¥ª/G× l¥¦6 ¥µ®«R¥¦TÖw_æ ±o2lRÉqØG Ö®å*ÖwÖwÚæ «çÙ Úrðð ÇkÚ× Öwl ×óǤl Ú
×qëÚ×Ó×qçÇÖ«ætÚ9ÃT± Ä×ËçÖwÚ Ä®ÅÆUçÙæ¤çÙÚð BÖwÂoåÇ×óÇÚ0Ä®Ç &ØræRÖwÆTð¬Ø ¤Âç ßT9°Tw°t¨ ¥ªí tw±2 ª¶óàkG±oRw6w Raí h ¥¦ a¥ t ¨®TÁ£R±¥¦Tí D±h¥ªÌ[5ÍÎaGÎ t¥ªÐ¤³±(«tÁ·¹r£GT ¦R¥ªtGT° T¡u°ataZG¥¦G°9± DÇÆUæRLà k kÇ× Ö«æ Ql®¨_ÍTÍaÌ a(Ð v¦Í Ý 0Í aÞ ±
ßGUÌ^Ýw¨ ÞaÞTí Þ Ð±¦¨~± Á·í ¢UwttwTt³¥ £w«¨Yt*Á± U9R¥¦±ª©«¨8«Rw¥¦T8 wT¡6GG¯rt¥ª¥ª96¥ª¨8R¥¦©T¼D¬±¡ôbT ±
6OçÙ«æ ©al¤× 6 £ ´T tZ¥ªÔ9¤£Ú9«×óRÇ¥¦æ¤TÚ0_Ãw± ×ËçÖwÉqÚ0 Là k {MætÖ«ÖÚ Ä®Ç®ÇÇ®ætÛ«ÇçÙÚ&ÚðLÄtÇl$ÖwÖÚ hרGÆ Ç Â³R르UÚ&°TÖ«açÛ¨GÁ 2í ÖTÕ®± Öw×ËçÄ l ÆU³ëÚ&Ö«çQÛ l «¨oÁ/É[²¨Iô{w¶
ÊwÊ ¦ ª±9¬ZÌ[aͨÎaÎTDϱªÐ¤¨± ßí a£UR¥¦¥¦°aTG6¨ tM£±¦¨Ba°TßGGa¥ª°aRT¥¦TtDR¥Ë¨¥ªOt±ªG¨BoTGt6Ñ?¥¦wÒtÒTaB ¦w£ZatZ¥Ë¶ ¨
t½^± oæRëçÙÚ9¨:ÍTͬ=Î v wÎ rÏ Þ ÎG±
à2ÈtaRa ª ¦¨&Ê2¢±:ZÁ¥¦G±^°sT ¦ TRb¥ªG6° ¥¦R¥´¹¨ ¥ª69±B¥ªtÌ[wͬRÎT¥¦ÎT:Ф±o± Éqí·Ü{R a R¯aT«j¸o£ZT¯rU¥Ó¶ ¨
íרG±sÇ w
aÚ0mÛ ôI¤Út×q«Ç¸?æ¤ ªÚ0ëT×Ó¨ çÖ«9Ú&±Qà k M±¦¨5«Â2Ì»IåGQÖ Gl®çÙ± ÆUШ {ÖwæRÚ Ö¬Ä®ÇtÇ®ÚÛw×qçÙÇ Úk kðLçµl*ðÇÚÖ ×
bÊjÖTtÕ®Ö«×Ó ç Ä ¦T± 2l¤×óÇ l®¨T°T¬YÍÎ ÝwÞ ± :É[ßÉ í ¶óÉ[Á í ʨ
Á·w¥ªt¥´wZRRt¥¦TaX¨Ê¬±h£®w9w㥦Rà2 Èa¥¦Z¨6¥ªÊt±häÁ¡±6RaÌ ÝwÞaÞTGÞ Ð¢G± tTí 4UR¥ª¥ªa µ¶¶
a×Óç°TÖ«aÚ&±·Qà k Éq /{Ö«æRæ Ö¬QÄ®lZÇ®ØÇtÖtÛwåçÙÚLðÖ«lÚ Ö ÆU{æ¤æR³ÇÚ9Çæ× kMÇ×Ö«Â2å00ÆUØU×qçÙëæRÛ×ÓçÖ«¤Ú0Ú9Là ×óÇk æ¤ Ú0Ãæ ætÄ®2ÖØrlçÙ×qÄÇ®çÄÇ×ÓÚ0ÆUÄ®æRÇDZ l 2¤Ú9¢×óRÇóðTTæRë×Ó¨çÙÚð 6D± ÇÆUæRÃLk DÇ× Ö«æ QlÃwÚ0Û kÇÆ Á·w6¥´Z¬R£®tawG¨¥´ÊR±Uw¡Te°Tà2Èwa ª¶óU¥¦¨rtÊ£¤±UtÁh±^aÌ £¤ÝTtÞT¥ªaÞ Í¬Ð¤±U± Éqí 6yáo¥¦6G¥µ6®«ÒR«¥¦T¸ ¨
k
±aT³Á/9Ö ¦rÃw¢GæR¥´2Û Zl :¤¨GÚôb×q-DZ¦¨0k k ÌËçµ»OðaÇGÚ× ± Ш §ÖTÕæRÖç kªÄ®Ç ǮǮbÛ«ÖTçÙÚrÕ®ðQÖ«l× l¤¨aÖ Á· T£®U¶
¬[t 2G¥ª©a®Z¥ª[T±
Á·wRUtT£¥´w r¨ Z¥ªR±T¢9w«R¬Uà2GȬaRu¡¨TTÊR±w¯Á¥¦ ¦ r±aÌ Ýw-£ uÞT¢GÞ ¥´ÍZ¥ªRФ¥¦± Tí _Z±tÉq R{¥¦TæRÖ¬³Ä®ÇtwÇ®9Û ðçÙçÙÚrÚ ÇðQÚ02l³ÇÖa×ËÖçÕtÄ Öwb×ËרGçÄÖTÇÕ®Ö«O2×ÓçÙçl¤æÄ ×ql¤l Ç× Â l¤Ú¨ ×qÖ¬:ÇÛT椢G-Ç Ú&k9çÙëÚ^×Óð ç¨ Ö«s MÚ0¸{ÃLÖRðTk UÚçÙ×Ó:çÖw± æ Ç 2lRØÇÖtå+Ç k¦ÖwÖtÚå0³_Çå&Úç ×
Á·w¥¦GtT°e¸?¨ ¥µtD
±bywR Tà22ÈRa¹¨hÊw±2£Ák±D¥ªtjÌ Ýw0ÞaÞ ®Í £ ФG±mR¢ÉqT RwZtta£¤UZ¶¶
t§¥ªaæRÖ:Ä®±/ǮǮÉqÛ«çÙÚráoQð l¹GÖ 6 Ò9«Ö ¸¨ ÃwhæR2Û ±l w9Ú×qÇ Á/k kµçµða ¦ÇrÚ¢G× ¥¦R:¨OÖTÕôbç kª±¦Ç¨§ÌËb»OÖTGÕ®Ö«±ñ×Фl ¨
!"
w¨ b9wRR6hw¡2ôIT6G¢GR s £¥¦£T¨
Áw£®G¬[t o¥ª©a®Z¥ª[T±
C
!
)
#
#
#
2
!
!
#
&#
%
#
#
#
)
Áw0tTt¥ª6¨®±ª¨UbÁ·¸?T¥ªR¥¦
ZRtyaR¨UÊ£¥´w±¦¨U w ª¬wytGà2¥ªÈT°y¬6¨rUÊU±^Ì ÓÝw± Þa ÞaÝÛaФÃt±^å0»B×Óç ½rǶ
bÇtØÃ ç֫椨 s 0£¥´w ^É[tR¢GhÎG±ÉqGtt±
Áwáo®«Z ´©aw ª[:¨ Us ±¦t¨9áo£¤t¥ªGa6kÒ¥¦k«¸ ´w¨ tk°TM±ª¨0wr©¥¦tTs G96wG¥¦R®9¨ ±aÉqD±ÌáoÝTÞTGÞ ÍÈФ¶ ±
Ò9«Ö ¸¨ ëhæt2Û ±l wÚ×qÇ Á/k k çµð ªÇrÚ¢G× ¥´R·:¨OÖaÕôbç k¦±ªÇ ¨§Ì2»IÖTGÕ®Öw±ñG× Ð¤l"¨ { æR֬ĮǮ!ÇtÛw"çÙÚ
#ðLleÖ« ¨
bTZt,w¡$ôIT6G¢Ut s £¥ª£a¨Á·T£®G¬[t
o¥ª©a®Z¥ª[T±
Á«wt9TeR¥ ¥¦£T6¨&¥µÁ®«± tT9± ±BÌ ÝTÞTÞTÞ Ð¤±hÚÊj×qÇk Rk çµRð¥¦ÇGÚ°× r¢G2³l¤×ówÇG al®¥¦¨^GÍ2 Rv¦¹Í 6Ý « ©T±
Á£bÁ/¥¦9 ª ´ww6_¨ £®s ±¦¨v ¼bRí ¥¦:㨠DU±:º ¬»o£¤±¦=¨:waR¥¦=Á·t£*ÊjRw¡ÙT[¨u¸§Ñwt±MÌ[ͬÎTT
Î £®a¯Ð¤¶ ±
tw'9 °aÇ® ?Ä®wØr¡RT祴Ä-{£skªÇ( ©al s£®£GD¥ª¥´a£Ç ¦l¤§çµðwU±
Ú8rÉqëw$ Ú06Û M¥´£o¢GB:RÖw¥ª¨ DÚ×Ó¢GæR±¦ ¦ÖQ¨owkµR¨{Ì»I¥¦T£®^s±TÐTU&¨ ¡:R¢G%u Ú&UÛT ǨIRæ ¸§w«Ã«°at×qÇæ
rÎ G±U² s ÉIèOR¬R±
Á·R ª¥¦RTÒ ¥¦5¨ í ±{¸ ák ±ITtT5+¥¦UÁ/¡wr®T- tv/T¨?»BÁ½UG± ¦T6t±2¥¦GÌ[°Í¬Î tTGÎФ±8tTGÉq6°T¹¥µ®«w¶¡
°T¬Ç [t¢GÇ k¦tÖtå0B³¥¦6ÇÚ¥µ®×q«Qà Rk ¬@sl wT9Ä®ØGLÖ RkªGÖtð o«¢¨ Ý UÌtÏ ¦(Ð v Î¥¦G °h r6Îa¬Ï £®Ý ± wG¥´R6±
á26T¥ªG° ¥¦©0 ¨O¥¦tôb/±ww 8jGw ª¢U¥´£taGU9RwtG :v ¨ í 6±OÌ wÝw ¦Þa°TÞT Þ Ðt±T¥¦£¼2¡?¡trT¢G6¶¶
¸{¥ªtTt¯6TG¡GT ¦?¥¦£¥¦a«Rt¥¦T®9U¥´R± £¥ªGÉq ¦ ¥¦w2t³[t¥¦t¢¥¦U¨¥¦§9±hw¡w¥ª6¥ªtwÜ{R¥ª¥¦tT¯&¨ wí ±¦¨
å0ÉqÌ»IætRÖGÃa ªÄt ¦± ¥ªÐØU°a)¨ ±4(_Ç®
ësæ¤TÚ9UtçÙ ´ZÚRð ³s b£¥¦ÖT¨Õ®BÖ«RT× ¥ªl Ô9 Ó± £ Ý s Ú ±t¥ªÚ¬×qyÇæR¥¦$Ûwç lÑ?Äç å k çÙTÚ0RÃw¥´£æ e w å á2¤GÚ96×ËætÒÖ«Ûw¸ÆÄ¨ ×ÓhçÖ«±MÚ9ÌZ± Ís ÎaGÎTtÎa¥ªÐG± °a ÖaBÕç tkªÇ ´wb°±ÖTÉÕ®sÖ«×Óܧç(Äál Ͷ {Ý æRÃa Ķ®×ÓÍ çÄ®Qà ¶k
ÎG±
èaR6¥¦TG ª¢:¨?RÁt¥¦£±IoTw9Á·R¬«Z¢G®w ªtt2¥ £Tw¨{¡BÁr¢G± ³w±j·Ì ÝTTÞTRÞT(Þ Ð¤±$«»O©a©«6w ¦¢«¶
¥¦¤Ú9×ó¥ªÇtwæ¤Ú0R¥¦ÃwT×Ë:çÖw±kÚ0ÉqLà k {MæRÖwÖ¬Ú Ä®Ç®ÇÇtæRÛwÇçÙÚ&ÚÄ®Lð Çl³ÖÖ«kÚ ×ØGhÇ ÆUOÂ6çÙÃwæ Ú0l®× Ö«çÛ bÖTÕ® Ö«×Ó çÄ l
ÆU³ëÚ&Ö«çÛ2l
*«¨0Á/É[²¨&ô{w R¥´U°TÁ í ±
Ño¥ª°aÒÒaTR ´R«¥Ó¨RRM¥Ó¨=±&Ì[ÊͬÎT±¦Îa¨=ÏaßФ±^aèOU¥¦R°aG+¨ TORa±ªO¨
£ÊaZwt ¦ ª¬½ZaT¨6kt±¦G¨=2wt9£(T°Tßw¥µ¶¶
R ¥¦Ì TÝ Ð vªÍT¡{Í 6&ÍT RTÍTh± a£¤t¥ªa± MÖtðwÚ9çÙ×Ëç &Ç ?ætëçÙÚ 2Ç lÇ®ÃwæRÄtØU¨
Ño¥ªÒôIÒTTR ´R«¥´R£RT¥Ó h¨{Ê6±¦¨I£®ßTTG°a¥´aZR³R¥Ó/,¨ MR¢ ±¦¨I Rw9t5©¥¦Gʰw ¦ ¦GRº T¨ £¤·D±o°atÌ aÝTZÞTÞT¥ªÞ GФ° ±
Rw&¥´9£ØG5TÇ 2ka6£¤Ç Rw¥¦TtTM³Öttðw¡¢Ú9£çÙa×Ë£¤°Tç tG¥ªÇ a¥ªRD¥¦TDZÆUv ætÉq2Ö $í lÄÊçG令TT¸!ÒÒwT°a©rG¥ª¥¦°a¸! G ¨§aÎ Á3±¦t ¨hGÝ ·Ì±»IÁ/£^aÉ[± ²Zж ¨
èMtt±
s £®TT ˨ s ±ÌZÍÎaÎTÎaбIÉ[2¥ª6¥ªtwR¥¦T/ ¦wtG¥¦G°6RktT¢UtR
rÖtð¢G«³¨ w Gv aaÝ ¥¦e tÝ Ý w± t- ÆUæ¤ætÇÚ9×/.uå0çÙÚ9çÖ«Ú·çÙÚ kÇÆUæRÖTÕçÖQk !
)
#
'
!
!
.
#
!
#
#
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz