Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 IMPACT OF HR PRACTICES ON EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE IN TELECOM SECTOR OF PAKISTAN Haris Bin Riazψ, Urooj Zafar Alam and Muhammad Usman Sheikh Riphah International University. Islamabad, Pakistan ___________________________________________________________________________________ Abstract This study examines the relationship between the HR practices and employee performance in telecom sector of Pakistan. The data has been taken from 250 employees working in telecom sector organizations in Pakistan through questionnaire. Findings suggest that employee performance is highly affected by the HR practices like compensation & benefits, health & safety, and training & development. Strategies discussing these issues have also been identified. The purpose of conducting this research is to study the impact of HR practices on employee performance in telecom sector of Pakistan, because there is very less research work done on this aspect in the telecom sector of Pakistan ___________________________________________________________________________________ Keywords: Training and development; Compensation and benefits; Health and safety; Employee Performance. JEL Classification Codes: J24; L96. 1. Introduction The purpose of conducting this research is to study the impact of HR practices on employee performance in telecom sector of Pakistan. Hypothesis testing method has been used for this research. The HR practices seem to be a result of managerial assumptions about employee reactivity and obligation toward others (Aycan, Kanunglo & Sina, 1999).Much can be learned from the experiences of state and local HRM experiments (Hays, 2004). Research also should explore the relationship between high-performance work practices and HR flexibility (Bhattacharya, Gibson and Doty, 2005). Private business support agencies tend to be more accepting of the connections between training (particularly management training) and performance than are the more skeptical community of business managers who administer the budgets and jostle with priorities (Bryan, 2006). If a firm is focused primarily on short term cost efficiency, its managers would be advised to invest primarily in skill flexibility because the performance returns are likely to be more apparent (Bhattacharya, Gibson & Doty, 2005). This article focuses on the impacts on employee performance due to the following HR practices i.e. recruitment & selection, compensation & benefit and health & safety. Employee’s response to the compensation practice by and large may be a reflection of their perception of other HR practices. Other two variables also play an important role in employee performance. Employees or human capital in any organization is the most important element of that organization. Human capital is one of the most important factors offering organizations a competitive advantage. So the HR practices are there to facilitate the employee and look in to the problems of their employee to achieve the desired organizational goals in today’s fast moving world. Analyzing and solving the problems of the employee and giving them a better environment for working in an organization is the function of the HR departments. There are many HR practices but in this research three particular practices are discussed. 2. Training and development Training was viewed as a skill or ability enhancement activity in the present study and thus as a source of influence on employee retention/turnover, several issues remain in need of further examination (Ferris & Urban, 1984). As technology and business markets evolve at a rapid rate and as organizations undergo continuing changes, voluntary employee learning and development will remain a critical issue in the workplace (Maurer, 2002). The strategy of selecting OJT trainers solely on the basis of their content knowledge and skill may not result in the quality of training that is desired (Johnson & Leach, ψ Corresponding author. Haris Bin Riaz. Faculty of Management Sciences, Riphah International University. Islamabad. Pakistan. Corresponding author Email: [email protected] Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 2001).There appears to still be a strong need for management/supervisory Development, performance appraisal, time management, communication and interpersonal skills training programs (Cacioppe, Lang-ford & Bell, 1990). Participation of management in the training of its own employees enabled the consultant to assume a less dominant role and transferred much credibility and skill to individuals in the organization (Mai-Dalton & Barnes, 1991). HR management system is the most effective form of HR management in enhancing employee performance (Horgan & Mu¨hlau, 2006). Personal benefits of employee training and age are significantly related to affective and normative commitment, and career benefits of employee training and years of service are significantly related to continuance commitment (Al-Emadi & Marquardt, 2007). HR practices are strongly related to future performance but that they are also strongly related to past performance, suggesting caution among both academics and practitioners in making any causal inferences (Wright, Gardner, Moynihan & Allen, 2005). High performance human resource systems can contribute to achieving sustainable competitive advantage to the extent that they impact on the knowledge, skills, attitudes and behaviors that form the basis of organizational learning (Lopez, Peon & Ordas, 2005). Investment in human resources does contribute to the bottom line so they are thus able to make a better case for a higher allocation of resources to their function (Singh, 2004). Training has a positive relationship with awareness of rules in the work environment, perceptions of supervisor quality and morale (Roehl & Swerdlow, 1999). Employees interpret human resource practices and the trustworthiness of management as indicative of the personified organization’s commitment to them (Whitener, 2001). Effective implementation of key strategic HRM practices should be able to bring in higher levels of organizational performance (Wan, Ong & Kok, 2002). Training and development of the employees in today’s world is very important. This enhances the motivation level of the employees and they seem to be more committed and dedicated to their work as a result of training and development. Hence training and development increases employee performance. H1: There is positive relationship between employee performance and training and development. 3. Compensation and benefits The best people work for companies with a compelling future to offer, plus the chance to grow as individuals, a place that offers a positive work experience and total pay including base pay, benefits, incentives and recognition(Chen & Hsieh, 2006). To create an effective reward system, companies need to understand where their reward dollars are being allocated (Chen & Hsieh, 2006). According to Mercer’s survey, apart from salary increases, the most prevalent vehicles being used to reward employees with strong skill sets are spot cash awards, project milestone awards and signing bonuses (Hansen, 2006). Research indicates that strategic HRM practices bring higher levels of organizational performance (Wan, Ong & Kok, 2002). Employers can use a model to achieve performance reviews that increase employee satisfaction, reduce the likelihood of litigation and boost motivation (Posthuma & Campion, 2008). Changes in rate of compensation have the intended effect of improving the subsequent financial performance of establishments (Lchniowski &Delaney, 1990). Workers’ compensation represents by far the most influential governmental program for reducing workplace fatalities (Moor & Viscusi, 1989). An increase in benefits generally reduces the likelihood that an injury is classified in a less severe category and increases the likelihood that it involves days away from work (Ruser, 1993). If low employment variability is a goal of a firm's business or compensation strategy, variable pay should be present, for both the target employee groups and decision makers (Gerhart & Trevor, 1996). The management of the compensation and benefits function is similar to the management of other functional areas of internationally evolving firms (Toyne & Kuhne, 1983). A firm's compensation policy can be broken into three independent dimensions for purposes of analysis The level, - The functional form, & - The composition (Baker, Jensen & Murphy, 1988). Employee compensation is an increasingly complex area and one of critical importance to all types of organizations (Riggs, 1989). Compensation and benefits are the things that are highly acceptable and required for encouraging the employees and for increasing the motivation level of the employees. Benefits may be given in form of pay i.e. extra pay or in form of other facilities that may include the vehicle or transport facility for the employees. This also attracts employees towards work. Ultimately the performance of the employees increases. H2: Employee performance is positively related to compensation and benefits. 4. Health and safety Absenteeism and productivity losses are often consequences of unrecognized and poorly managed health conditions. Effective organizational health will decrease instances of disability, incidental absences and productivity loss and will contribute to the overall business strategy through cost savings, 231 Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 improved supplier relationships and employee satisfaction (Wolff, 2003). There was no avoiding the need to make changes, changes which reflect the organization’s long support of consultation with employees on health and safety which it believes can help create and maintain an effective health and safety ’culture’ and have a positive effect on employees’ motivation and awareness of health and safety issues (Hammond, 1997). There is mixed evidence on whether some of the cost-containment strategies, such as disease management, are actually effective. According to HRDs, employees are generally satisfied with their health benefits (Reddick & Coggburn, 2007). Leadership dimensions associated with greater concern for group-members' welfare, arising from closer, indivi- dualized relationships, promote supervisory safety practices creating higher safety climates, and hence, safer behavior. Ordering leadership dimensions in terms of commitment to members' welfare provides a common denominator for leadership and safety climate, encouraging further research in this direction (Zohar, 2002). This duty to carry out risk assessment extends to training scenarios and training exercises. Importantly, the risks to the instructors as well as of trainees have to be considered (Cooper, 2000). Employees and employers are willing to contribute to insurance and recognize the need, and that they seek preventive care once they have it. However, there is a price threshold on both sides that needs to be determined for the optimum investment of all parties. A model of shared-cost responsibility is an effective way to provide affordable insurance to small-business employees, thus increasing preventive services in these populations (Kahn et.al., 2007). This broader view highlights the importance of linking organizational, educational, medical, technological, and regulatory strategies to enhance the health of employees and their dependents. The emerging paradigm is broadly concerned with the ecology of work and health (Stokols, Pelletier & Fielding, 1996). New employee orientation and ongoing health and safety in service educational programs should provide a method where all home health care employees have an understanding for the need of and use of agency policies (Thobaben & Woodward, 1996).The survey was intended to assist decision-makers in identifying key workplace issues, as perceived by employees, in order to develop strategies to address and improve the quality of working conditions for staff within each of the individual health care organizations and the SJHS as a whole (Krueger et.al., 2002).In the context of health system infrastructure, an adequate work environment is key to effective delivery of health care services and can actually improve worker motivation (Esmail, Cohen-Kohler & Djibuti, 2007).The findings from this survey should go part-way to informing the process of defining roles and competences, as part of the wider agenda of developing health care professionals and service provision (Hennessy, Hicks, Hilan & Kawonal, 2006). Proper health and safety measures should be taken into account for the employees who are working in the organization. The workplace should be clean. Proper care for the health of the employees should be taken in order to motivate the employees to work more efficiently and effectively. H3: Employee performance is positively related to health and safety. Error! Training and Development Employee Compensation and Benefit Performance Health and Safety Figure 1: Theoretical framework 3. Research methodology The questionnaires were distributed to 250 employees working in the telecom sector organizations. In this survey five major players in the telecom sector were selected for collecting the data. All in all 250 questionnaires were distributed out of which 226 useable questionnaires were returned. The questionnaires were distributed in English language which didn’t need to be translated to the employees working in telecom organizations. The data was collected in the month of May, June 2008. The questionnaire we administered contained three HR practices, which includes the following items: training & development, health & safety and compensation & benefits. The model therefore consists of three HR practices as predictor/independent variables and their effect on employee performance as dependent variable. Respondents were asked to indicate the degree to which they agree or disagree 232 Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 with the above HRM issues. All the items were measured on a five point scale ranging from 5 ‘strongly agree’ to 1 ‘strongly disagree’. Demographics analysis The following frequency tables from table 1 to table 3 in demographics describe the sample distribution of the demographics. Table 1: Demographics profile Age Age Scale Frequency Percentage Qualification 20-30 145 64.1% intermediate frequency 38 percentage 16.80% Years experience in present organization -1 Frequency 27 Percentage 11.94% N= 226 30-40 42 18.5% 40+ 39 17.25% bachelors 76 33.60% masters 112 49.50% 1+ 42 18.58% 2+ 68 30% 3+ 89 39.30% Table 2 representing Co-relation analysis tells the relationship among the three variables. The negative relation shows that there is an inverse relationship i.e. one variable is increasing and the other variable is decreasing. Positive relationship is shown by the increase in both the variables i.e. when one variable increases the other variable also increases. More the result is near to 1 more the relationship is strong. If it goes near negative that shows that the negative relationship is stronger. The relationship of the three variables discussed in this, have a positive relationship with the dependent variable i.e. health & safety, training & development and compensation & benefits are positively related to employee performance. Thus the positive relationship depicts that if there is increase in compensation & benefits, training & development or health & safety that would definitely increase the employee performance. Pearson correlation Pearson correlation Table 2: Correlation analysis performance training 1 0.621** health 0.726** 0.621** 0.000 1 0.752** 0.000 Health Pearson correlation 0.726** 0.000 0.752** 0.000 1 0.799* 0.0000 Compensation Pearson correlation 0.715** 0.000 0.763** 0.000 0.799** 0.000 1 Performance Training compensation 0.715** .0000 0.763** 0.000 **Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed) Table 3 shows the model summary of the regression analysis. Based on the model summary the value of R square is 0.578 which shows that our variables can bring 57.8% change and the remaining 42.2% is itself. And the independent variable (health & safety, training and development, compensation & benefits) has the positive interdependence on the dependent variable which is performance of employee. Table 3: Regression model summary R Square Adjusted R Square 1 0.760a 0.578 0.572 a. Predictors: (Constant), compensation, training Model R 233 Std Error of the Estimate 0.363 Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 Table 4 show result from the ANOVA which size of variance explains in the studied model. The most important value in ANOVA is F which is 101.21 .We see if the variance is significant or not. The significance should be less than 0.05 to be significant. It should not be more than 0.05. The value of significance in our model is 0.000 which shows that the model is valid. Table 4: ANOVA Sum of df Mean square squares 1 Regression 3 13.326 Residual 222 0.132 Total 225 a. Predictors: (Constant), compensation, training, health b. Dependent variable: performance Model F Sig. 101.219 0.000a Table 5 representing the coefficient table that us that how much an independent variable affects a dependent variable. Here Beta shows an effect that an independent variable has made on the dependent variable. The value of t in our model for training and development is 11.84, for compensation and benefits it is 5.28 and for health and safety it its value is 4.28. The value of t is supposed to be greater than 2 which are shown in the research. Table 5: Coefficient table Substandard co-efficient Standard co-efficient B Std. error beta 1.164 0.183 Constant 0.473 0.040 0.621 Training 0.390 0.074 0.412 Health 0.321 0.072 0.356 Compensation a. Dependent variable: performance Model t sig 6.360 11.84 5.286 4.280 0.000 0.000 0.002 0.000 5. Discussion and conclusion After entering into the new millennium, one of the third world countries, like Pakistan has faced great challenges in the development of human resource practices. There was no such trend of human resource practices in the corporate organizations in Pakistan as compared to that in the developed countries. Lack of HR practices has negatively affected the performance of the employees and mostly skilled employees prefer to go abroad for the sake of benefits. The culture of HR practices started when multi national telecom organizations entered into Pakistan and preferred to concentrate on the human resource practices to set their challenging goals. In these organizations employees get many benefits regarding human resource, after then the local organizations also started following this trend of human resource practices to give more benefits to their employees. The HR practices directly have a positive effect on the employee performance that is shown in the above analysis. The most favorable practices followed up by these organizations are compensation and benefits, training and development, and health and safety. In Pakistan these HR practices are most frequently followed by the telecom sector. If we are going to rank these practicing variables of HR then the first best practicing variable in Pakistan is training and development .Employees usually prefer to have training on their jobs which develop their skills and these are favorable for their future carrier .In telecom sector, employees of information technology are practicing a lot of training in their fields as they must stay in touch with the advancement of new technology in telecom .In MNC’s telecom companies operating in Pakistan hire special foreign trainers which affect greatly on the effectiveness and the efficiency of the trainee. The second best practicing variable in Pakistan’s telecom sector is compensation and benefits. Every employee is sensitive about the compensation & benefits he gets from his job, it directly or indirectly affects his performance .If we observe the telecom sector of Pakistan, the multinationals & private sector telecom organizations are giving much better compensation plans as compared to the other public sector telecom organizations. So the performance of the private sector telecom organizations is much better than the public sector telecom organizations. Then the third best practicing variable preferred here is health and safety. Although in Pakistan many companies in co-operate sector do not practice it so much but in telecom sector of Pakistan this practice 234 Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 is having so much importance, as it reflects the performance of the employee specially the practices like health precautions, medical facilities, smoke free zones, and other miscellaneous safety measures. This is important so that the employee has no stress about his health & safety and his all efforts are for the organization. Therefore in Pakistan the credit goes to the telecom sector (especially in Multi-national) in the development of human resource practices, which can be set as a role-model for other organizations in the country. The value of R square is 0.578 which shows that 57.8% variation in dependent variable is caused by independent variable which is quiet a significant value. Similarly the value of F is 101.21 and significance 0.000 also supports our research model and hypothesis. One of the goals of the present study was to test that to what extent the three HR practices were affecting the employee’s performance. Regression analysis had been done to get the results. The basic purpose of the regression analysis is to check that how much effect does the dependent variable makes. This article deals with the three independent variables of HR practices, which are training & development, compensation & benefits and health & safety. The three HR practices altogether explain about 57.8 per cent of the variation in dependent variable caused by independent variables. Generally speaking, we found reasonably good support for the propositions of our model. This may suggest that more the HR practices are in place, the more employee performance would be up to the standard. These findings are in lined with the predicted relationships and thus support our model.In this research we have found that the relationship between employee performance and health & safety is positive. This is in relation to the hypothesis (H3) that we developed. This positive relationship shows that when proper health and safety measures are given to the employees, that decreases their absenteeism, reduces burnout and ultimately increases the employee performance to achieve the organizational goals. This research shows that there is a positive co-relation between compensation & benefit and employee performance which is also in relation to the hypothesis that we had developed. When employees are given compensation and benefits, those may be in a form of additional pay, or a vehicle or vehicle allowance that ultimately increases the motivation level of employee which consequently increases the employee performance. Similarly, a positive relation has been found between training & development and employee performance. When employees are trained properly, their self esteem, interest in job and motivation level increases. Which ultimately increases the employee performance, which is what we had formulated in our hypothesis? 6. Regression analysis of Pakistani telecom companies Now comparing the telecom companies with regard to HR practices and employee performance in the leading telecom companies of Pakistan i.e. Telenor, Mobilink (Orascom), U fone and Zong. Model ( Constant) Training Health R square =0.777 N=36 Sig= .000 Table 6: TELENOR model Summary Beta t … 2.794 0.094 5.685 0.636 10.243 Adjusted R square=0.756 F=37.22 Dependent variable = performance Sig... 0.009 0.000, 0.000, Table 7: MOBILINK model summary Model Beta t Sig... ( Constant) … 2.716 0.009 Training 0.694 6.747 0.001 Health 0.763 8.01 0.000, Compensation 0.746 4.169 0.000, R square =0.687 Adjusted R square=0.667 F=34.45 N=51 Sig= .000 Dependent variable = performance 235 Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 Table 8: WARID model summary Model Beta t ( Constant) … 2.578 Training 0.154 0.914 Health 0.538 2.801 Compensation 0.652 5.571 R square =0.554 Adjusted R square=0.521 , F=16.56 , N=44 , Dependent variable = performance Sig... 0.000. 0.000, 0.008 0.000, Sig Table 9: U.FONE model summary Model Beta t ( Constant) … 3.125 Training 0.275 1.438 Health 0.648 5.11 Compensation 0.231 1.283 R square =0.513 Adjusted R square=0.470 F=11.91 N=38 Sig =.000 Dependent variable = performance Table 10: ZONG model summary Model Beta t ( Constant) … 3.168 Training 0.463 3.871 Health 0.216 1.296 Compensation 0.485 2.949 R square =0.416 Adjusted R square=0.383 F=12.6 N=57 Sig= .000 Dependent variable = performance = .000 Sig... 0.004 0.001 0.002 0.000, Sig... 0.003 0.002 0.000, 0.001 In the analysis of regression the R2 value is the most important one. The value of R square indicates that what percentage of variance in dependent variable (which is performance) is caused by independent variable .The bigger the percentage of variance, higher is the affect of independent variable over dependent variable. In this all analysis telenor has the highest value of R square i.e.0.777 that shows 75% of variance in performance is caused by health & safety, training & development, and compensation & benefits. Comparison of co-relation analysis TELENOR Training Health Compensation .698 .869 .816 PERFORMANCE MOBILINK UFONE (ORASCOM) .694 .649 .753 .648 .821 .622 WARID ZONG .624 .732 .652 .463 .556 .629 In comparison we can divide telecommunication sector in two blocks. Block A : Telenor, Mobilink (Orascom). Block B : Ufone, Warid, Zong. Our analysis conclude results that Block A is practicing the best HR practices in Pakistan telecom sector. If we analyze the variables co-relation in Block A, we will see that in training sector telenor has the best practice which shows 0.698 correlations with employee performance and mobilink is very close to the figure of it i.e. 0.694. So these both institutions have the best training policies and strategies. In Health sector again telenor is performing the best practices. The correlation of health & safety with respect to employee performance comes out to be .869. As we compare mobilink with telenor, mobilink correlation of health & safety with respect to performance comes to be 0.753. 236 Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 Now coming towards the compensation & benefits that is the third variable of HR practices. Here, Mobilink is leading and having 0.821 correlations with respect to employee performance, here telenor is very close to it i.e. 0.816. So overall the Block A: Telenor and Orascom are playing as benchmarks for others in the telecom sector of Pakistan. This shows that telenor is leading from the front in HR practices. In Block B the HR practices are practiced low as compared to the Block A, Warid is performing good in health & safety department, Ufone is performing well in training and health departments and when it comes to Zong, it is a new company and still it is good in accommodating its employees with their compensations. 6. Conclusion Research and findings from the facts and figures concluded that the impact of the human resource practices have a positive affect on the employee performance in the telecom sector of Pakistan. The trend of HR practices in telecom sector of Pakistan is the role model for the other co-operate sector organizations of Pakistan as it has greatly affected the performance of the telecom sector employees, especially due to training and development, health and safety, and, compensation and benefits. References Al-Emadi, M. and Marquardt, M. (2007) Relationship between employees’ beliefs regarding training benefits and employees’ organizational commitment in a petroleum company in the State of Qatar. International Journal of Training and Development,11,1, 1360-3736. Aycan, Z., Kanugo,R. and Sinha, Jai. (1999) Organizational culture and human resource Management Practices: The Model of Culture Fit. Journal of Cross Cultural Psychology, 30, 501. Baker, G. , Jensen, M. and Murphy, K. (1988) Compensation and Incentives: Practice vs. Theory. The Journal of Finance, 43, 3, 593-616. Bhattacharya, M. , Gibson, D. and Doty, H. (2005) The Effects of Flexibility in Employee Skills, Employee Behaviors, and Human Resource Practices on Firm Performance. Journal of Management, 31, 622. Bryan, J. (2006) Training and Performance in Small Firms. Training and Performance, 24, 6, 635–660. Cacioppe,R. , Langford,P., and Bell, L. (1990) Trends in Human Resource Development and Training. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 28, 55. Cooper, M. (2000) Safety management in the emergency response services. Risk Management: An International Journal, 2, 2, 39-49. Chen, H. and Hsieh, Y. (2006) Key trends of the total reward system in 21stcentury.Compensation benefits review, 38, 64. Esmail, L., Kohler,J. and Djibuti,M. (2007) Human resource management in the Georgian national immunization Program:a baseline assessment. Human resources for health, 5, 20. Ferris, G., Urban, T. (1984) Supervisory Training and Employee Turnover. Group Organization Management, 9, 481. Gerhart, B. and Trevor, C. (1996) Employment Variability under Different Managerial Compensation Systems. The Academy of Management Journal, 39, 6, 1692-1712. Hays, S. (2004) Trends and Best Practices in State and Local Human Resource Management: Lessons to Be Learned? Review of Public Personnel Administration, 24, 256. Hansen, F. (2006) Currents in Compensation and Benefits. Compensation Benefits Review, 38, 6. Hammond, N. (1997) Health and safety (consultation with employees) regulations1996. The journal of Royal Society For The Promotion Of Health, 117, 192. Hennessy, D., Hicks, C., Hilan,A., and Kawonal,Y. (2006) The training and Development needs of nurses in Indonesia. Human Resources For Health, 4, 10. Horgan, J., and Mu¨hlau, P. (2006) Human resource systems and employee performance in Ireland and the Netherlands: a test of the complimentarily hypothesis. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 17, 3, 414-439. Johnson,S. Leach,J. (2001) Using Expert Employees to Train on the Job. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 3, 425. Kahn, L., Berhalter, L., Cadzow, R., Watkins, R., Leonard, K., and Taylor, J. (2007) The impact of subsidized health insurance on employees use of preventive health services. Eval Heatlth Prof. 30, 22. Krueger, P., Brazil, K.., Lohfeld., Edward, G. , Lewis, D. and Tjam, E. (2002) Organization specific predictors of job satisfaction: findings from Canadian multi site quality of work life crosssectional survey. Bmc Heatlh Services Research, 2, 6. 237 Proceedings of Applied International Business Conference 2008 Lchniowski, C. and Delaney, T. (1990) Profitability and Compensation Adjustments in the Retail Food Industry. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 43, 3, 183-202. Lopez, S., Peon, J. and Ordas, C. (2005) Human resource practices, organizational learning and business performance. Human Resource Development International, 8, 2, 147-164. Maurer, T. (2002) Employee learning and development orientation: Toward an integrative model of involvement in continuous learning. Human Resource Development Review, 1,9. Mai-Delton, R., and Barnes, F. (1991) The evolution of an employee-training program: A three-year flexible organization development effort. Group Organization Management, 16, 452. Moor, M. and Viscus, W. (1989) Promoting safety through workers compensation: The efficacy and net wage costs of injury. The RAND Journal of Economics, 20, 4, 499-515. Posthuma, R. and Campion, M. (2008) Twenty best practices for just employee performance review. Compensation Benefits Review, 40, 47. Roehl, W. and Swerdlow, S. (1999) Training and its impact on organizational commitment among lodging employees. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research, 23, 176. Reddick, C. and Coggburn, J.(2007) State government employee health benefits in the United States: choices and effectiveness. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 27,5. Ruser, J. (1993) Workers' Compensation and the Distribution of Occupational Injuries. The Journal of Human Resources, 28, 3, 593-617. Singh, K. (2004) Impact of HR practices on perceived employee performance in India. Indian Institute of Management, 42, 3. Stokols, D., Pelletier, K. and Fielding, J. (1996) The ecology of work and health; research and policy direction for the promotion of employee health. Health Educe Behave, 23,137. Thobaben, M and Woodward, W. (1996) Workplace security for home health care employees. Home Healthcare Management Practice, 8, 58. Toyne, B. and Kuhne, R. (1983) The management of the international executive compensation and benefits process. Journal of International Business Studies. 14, 3, 37-50. Whitener, E. (2001) Do high commitment human resource practices affect employee commitment?. Journal of Management, 515-535. Wan, D., Ong, C., and Kok,V. (2002) Strategic human resource management and organizational performance in Singapore. Compensation Benefits Review, 34, 33. Wolff, S. (2003) Organizational health, beyond integrated disability management. Compensation Benefits Review, 35, 7. Wright, P., Gardner,T., Moynihan, L. and Allen, M. (2005) The relationship between hr practices and firm performance: examining causal order. Personnel Psychology, 58, 409-446. Zohar, D. (2002) The effects of leadership dimensions, safety climate, and assigned priorities on minor injuries in work groups. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 23, 1, 75-92. Zaleska, K and Menezes, L. (2007) Human resources development practices and their association with employee attitudes: Between traditional and new careers. Human Relations Journal, 60, 7, 987–1018. 238
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz