:
(
$
"
!
"
)
"
.
" *"
' $–( $
#
" #$ % &# ' !
" *" ' $ – ( $
#
: + % ,*
http://www.mstawfik.bizhosting.com
:!
.
[email protected]
2004
–0-
#$
:3
'
' /
"%
'
#
(6$ #7
'
'
'
01
2
5
3 $
)
.
" *"
' $–( $
#
" #$ % &# ' !
" *" ' $ – ( $
http://www.mstawfik.bizhosting.com
[email protected]
:!
:+
.
: Abstract 9
#
% ,*
:7#
>' / >
01
2 ,?
=
7
9
;<
> $
> <
@ ' < 9
;"
. '
>
7
!$ #7
'
#$
$
'
5
>A ( ? ! B
;! 9
<5 .IAS
'
#$ =
!# C
'
5
< !
' ,*
>
# = >
A% 5
! E? 9
@ ' ,!$ #7
'
! ;
=
FASB 6 .
'
#$ ,* ! (
'
#$ , '
, 5 , IASB
'
#$ ,*
A% 5
'
$ ! B
;! 9
<5 * .!$ #7
7 > !> 9
!3 F . ,*
!* FASB ,* !
# =
> > '
' /
2
* !
7.
G0
.3 "%
–1-
:%
$% $
$
,
$
$
$* - ! '
'
"$
!" #
$% & $
% # ' '
() ' * %'
$)
- '. - ) - ' . )
1" -# $% $
' .0
/
2% %
(
' ( )# ' - '. - )
' . 3'4
5#
(% - '. '
.
. &
- '. !'% '
$
$ ' !-%
6 . *- ! ' 7
& '
$ # - ' $ :7$(- (Accounting Directives
-%
Directives) 5-"
(Organization for European Economic CoCo-operation)
Organization for Economic ) $ #
; ($$ %
'
.(1)
Co--operation and Development)
Co
Development)OECD
=$ '
' -%
= )2
>
?- 1#
$# #
-&
>
"' /' %
' . # # - IASB
A B ' '
3)
' ' % ' (2 *@))
$
$* , )
* - C' ' '
; #%
. (# - ! ' '
; )
/' %
$- )
5 ' D % ; 0 - 7 # ! "# 7
'
$ '
-B % - ) B '
3) - )' ' % '
$ F $) ; G$&- 1'
> ', '
- # 5
@$ ' $ ' ' ! '
- -%
H #- *
. (-$%
$*
*$&#
$
- 5 C (- ' $ 3$ ) ' $
$ ;' '$" ' $ )
, F' K' % ' ' )
$-
/' %
1#I / B
#
A B ' '
3) '
)
'
$)
' -%
#( '" ' # 1#G&
JB.
' , (# ' ! %# ! 5 '
' -%
#(
'
–2-
13
2
=' (
:(2)
.(1
'
-5) >
'
.(16
'
-5) .(38
'
- 5 ) %'
N
.(2
'
-5)
.(40
'
-5)
! '.
.(18
'
-5)
.(17
'
-5) )
.(21
'
- 5 ) -#).
.(34
'
-5)
.( '
- 5 1 3 ) '" ' 0 .(24
'
'
# #
-5)
.(27
.(14
3$ ) H 6
/'7 =
'
'
2
)
:
. '
.
.
$-$%
$
$ '
$ '
$
-$%
' M2
* '5
"5
O
'( ) ' ; - )
#" % M6
-%
- -
H #- - ) '
$ 3) = ' -
–3-
'
5
:7 / %
' A B '
. '%
. "
.
M12
M13
'
M1
-
' M4
-
M11
>
-5)
-5)
'
* ( :7 ' . #(
'
-%
D
M1
' .
M2
' .
M3
'@B
M4
%
M5
M6
'5
M7
M8
* '5
M9
C
M10
-
' M3
M5
:9
;
H #- - )
'% .
5 M1
'
;
H #- - ) # 5 M2
''
2 5-" -%
.IASB
3) /' $%
$
-$%
@' , -$%
-$%
-%
-%
! '
/@
3) '
; - ) = IASB - ) # 5 M3
, )
- -A B ' '
. - ' '
# 5
@ () )
'% -
- B % H ); M4
# #
'( ) B
)
. '
'
H'$6 $ -%
=6' *
F>
M5
$
$ (# $%' -$%
$ H #- ' , )
'$ 3) ' ( ;
&
!'%
.K 7 N ' % ' 3 ) ' A B '
:9
$ $ - -$%
$ (# ,-%- ' % $5"# '
$'
'
= '
%
'
(' ,
-
' –
; -%
-
M1
'( ) '
– 2- 5
. # #
=$ '
$' = '
'% - )
(3)
$() $ - #'# $5
-$%
6 -, '% .
H #- - )
7 $B $(
$ ' -%
$-
5
' % *( # #
I- #
'
'. 0 ;
$
-B
' %
3 ) IASB
;
'
. -- # 5 ' 5 3 %G
( $6' $
$
H #$ ; $ #- $#
# #
, $ ( CD $ / $B
$ ' $ $ -%
M2
M3
-B %
M4
= '
B%
B
B=
''
&#'
K Download @#; # ;'
. B % ,%
–4-
$
$
3$ ) =$ '
$(#. 2 # (
$
$
$ ' $%
. #'# 5
$# #
' A* # 0 N FASB
.
.
.
' '-
= & ', )
6 ', # #
-%
# %
.
= '
6
R
M5
6
-%
B
5 0 6
M6
6'
' , #( , F' K' %
%
0 -
M7
6
(
# - '
'
'% . 2 # M8
$# 0 - I , ) B '
3) '
6 K &'
;
/' $% $ -%
H #(%
' 5. ) B '
3)
:9
:
.
$
$
-%
;
-%
;
.(S ' %
# - '.
;
A B ' '
.# 5
$
0 -
-%
'
H #- *
%B
0 - ) '#
' % - ) '#
0 -B = ' )
3) - ) '#
.
-%
-B %
'#
F>
'#
:
. (- @ ' -
: $
$ ,= )
$
$
% > 5
,$) '
$
-%
% %
- 7 ! -" =
# A(# T7' #
$ '# ' $# 2 -5 %
–5-
H
7 '
:< 9
:6 F 9
:9 F 9
:,
'
9
7 9
"
&
:(4) (1987) ( )
"
#
- %
:7
'#
-%
; B
5 ,# ) ; 7 , ' % -%
- ' H #-
()
7
#'–
(
N
>
:7
%
'D
%- !
2 ' B–
'
; . -%
- '
; ' %
.
G&-B % / 6
'
:(5) (1989) ( )
./ )
6.
&
'
%
!"#
()
7' / .
)
&
)
$
%
( ) *+ , -
2
%
8 /
0 /
( 2
(
"
!"#
$
% !
8
.
1 2 3"
4
4
2
:(6) (1990) ,
"
$
,$)
-%
,
%
:7
'#
H $#- ' % ;' H ## (
()
$ * $%
$
'. #
C ". H F U " %
-%
> 5
*5
#6
; ,' "
$5 : $
$ ;
( '!
#
:
;
K ( % -% ' ). '" ' .
-%
– '@B D '
C $
' !$5
– $'
$ @ ' ' . D '3 –
–
%
-%
– -%
% %
>
–
'5
-%
– (# >
' ). '"
@
-%
()
R ' ,* 6 ' @
-%
– ). '" H &# '
. (# >
' '
#
' ?#
-%
–
* '5
0'$ $5R#
-%
:
; (
F #
%
V
F
-%
– 3 %G C
' '" '
– '
#@ W
5
' * " ' 6
0 . – -#).
$% %
V ' 5- %
R '#-'
N '#-%
K $ X '
)
# G –
@
V – -%
$>
– ). '" )
'5
-%
– B
G&-
-B %
6
(#
; %
–6-
:7
N '.
7
.
()
$
- $)
B
:(7) (1991) ! " . ( )
-B % 0 - 7 '#
%R /
"
#
$%
& - B%
-%
% %
B
5 -%
$6 R '" ' 0 - @
'.
5 :7
4
'
/ $ $- B .
* - C'
= H
- -)
B
, ' $%
&
5 '
'
B%6 R
$ '
0 - (
' . -%
% %
B 0 '$ 2 G
'
& R
) ' -% ,
/
%
G- 0 ' ' . -%
( % %
'%
&
#'# $5
-$%
0 = , @ ' 0 '@
.
! -" ' @ /
G&-
' '%
( 5
:7
%R K 7'
*B
H #5
:(8) (1997) ! " . ( )
"
( - ) ; N)
# # 5 H )I- 0 - 7
-%
/@
@ ()
-%
5 G&K$ 7 $
/@
@ ()
; . 2 #' .1996 - -%
, $
-%
%
; ' = '
'
-$%
$% % ' -%
#
2
#
& ?- 0 H $#- ( N
6 0
/
- 0 - # 5 , *5
:Y
5
'
($ '
.
$R
$
$#-%
$ /'$
-) @ () 1 - /7 A(# '
% % ,% #
#
&
7
-5
#'
-
-%
'
-
,
(
!+ ": @ 2 A
# -
. '
7
'
;7 %
'
-%
R '
3 (: ;+ )
–%
": 1
.
'
4 6
6 92
#
/'
-%
. '
'5 ' 3%. %
= !% '
'" '
<
2"
2
*
–
"
!"#
" /4 !+"# B @
$
%
93
/
2
% 8 , >?
2
:(9) (1998) "
–7-
M1
#
"
2
": (
8 ( %:
3 (D C2
"
/ ,
$
$ ; $
)
'
$
$ #
, $
()
H
)
' 6.
)
M2
/
"; ')'
$ ' ?$6 ''
-%
;T
@ -
% %
. @ '
!
M3
# # ,)
'
#
M4
95
N
',
2
#- ,)
. -%
A(#
-%
&
@
:F
"
% %
# '
,) /7 @ ()
J B @ () '
,)
'5
,B # ' % ' -%
% %
#-
@
'5 /' %
;
3+
M1
1
$
-%
()
1
/' %
.
/
' 6
. -%
/' $%
$ (
. #( '
"
% C2
;
)
D V !5
) C( '
.I
:9
@
$
')
- ' ,!- %
# H'6
$ '. 0 - - ) H'6
K 7 ' , IASB = ' - ' -%
:Y
0 6 N
'% $
' $
-%
Internet Resour
Resources
esources
.IASB = '
3$ )
$
$- $
$ ' -%
H ## #
# ; /' %
;/ )
=
-
-%
A B
#
'%
'
:
1
:2
' '
.IASB
IASB , =$ ' $ -$%
/ $R "
#
:3
Egypt , SA ((Saudi
Arabia)) , GCC (Gulf
Saudi Arabia
(Gulf
–8-
='
/ R
"
# = Cooperation Council
Council))
.FASB
–9-
<
9
1)
:
$
H #- '$
$ ()
(10)
.
( ) B
'( )
K
)
-%
' , -%
;
@' 2
'.
(1)
K
')
'
G&- 1997 #% 503
' '
%
&
@'
5 :7
?- 0
.(11)2 -%
&
)'
-%
7
* '5 D
G&,$) $
$# - " (3) ' " -%
% %
>
" (1)
$ @ ' '$ . D $ " (9) ' " $
* '5
(# >
." '
@' $
$
$
$
&
(
)
$( ' #
$
' -%
#6
:
5%
@' M1
@ () M2
/@
$
@'
5* '$5 T7 $ #
'
-%
$
'
1-5
, (%. .2002 #% 345 ' 1998 #% 256
2 $ 23 0$ - 7$
$ ; $
2 V
H #'
)
. -%
"$
;
$
-$%
7 ' -%
= !R R R"
D-%
'6'
I K 7 ./
= ' =
; ()
=)
. '6' :7 ' #
$ ' ) :7( # #
-&
www.
conomy..gov.
www.economy
gov.eg
= ' / )'
@' = '
– 10 -
/ B
#
H '%
)'
'
:7
25 '
'
@
= ' ' www
www..egyptse.
egyptse.com
.www.
idse..gov.
www.idse
gov.eg H @' 3 )
!'% *
% * =-
=' '
5
-$%
/@$
@ $()
5 #
')
2 $ 20
2 # 6 1996 #% 2644
@ () 3 *
,)' X&#
-%# - (. '
-%
#
"I 2 -%
$ .' $
"5
&
' @
7 ! -" - @
(12)
=- "
7
*( '
. S
$B $ '
-$%
$ 0 $ - @ ()
$
' '
:
#
"
V 2 #'
5 7 ,
:7 '
-5
'#%
-%
; 0 . 2 5-"
#
:7 ' , 2003 #% 628
@ () 3 *
. '@B - J B -%
M
. H &# '5 - J B -%
M
.(
;' ' . - J B -%
M
.
- J B -%
M
$ >
' '
?#
-%
- J B -%
M
. '
%
.D
R - J B -%
M
. 5 5&
&
%
-%
- J B -%
M
$ -$%
' $ )
$
* '5 $- J B -%
M
. &
%
-$& $ www
www..cao
cao..gov.
'
gov.eg '# - @ () = '
!- $% $ #
$
K
6 ( -%
R ) # #
.PDF " #- B % ,%
( @#;
',
7
– 11 -
@ () = ' - -%
K$
G$&-
$%R %
.
%R %
5K
-%
/@
*
R
@ ()
#)
#
B
:
:
/ $
@ ()
=- $"
:7
%*
7 $
I- '
@' $(- $ B
' , $ N =$ .(2 5- $%
.
$) ) $
$
$"5
"5
*( '
-%
.'
H #"5 M
$
M1
-%
/@
@ ()
. -%
/@
I- ' J B U "5
& M,
@') 2
) B
)
)
' -%
) ?6 '
@' $
$
$&
(# % /
./
=- "
7
– 12 -
- / '
?6 ' N (2
) B
*( '
.'
$
$
$ # C B
$ (SEC)
$
5&
$
=$
$
$
'
:7
!'$% * (
-%
K 7' ,
!'% - ( ' '
$
. $ !'% *
"B
> \ FRR 48
(13)
. !'% K - ( ' '
&
.
D(
:7
)
)
M2
/ )'
&
.
#
&
0
M3
R R"
% / )' ./
D= '
C$ ' - C
# #
'
' /
= ' )'
M4
-$%
/@$
@ () = ' H # % -%
.2004
1
/7 www.
cao..gov.
www.cao
gov.eg
";
-%
! "# ' H #M5
$" 7 ')'
N
Conceptual Framework
Framework
$ ' $
. $ # $ H '%
H #- ' '"B
'
3) '
)
' -%
*
' ' -%
. A B '
/
23 $ /'$%
# - ' -%
$( ' #
/ B.
'6' ' . ]
'
-%
; ()
=)
(14)
.
'6' :7 ' #
41
/
M6
25 '
'
$ $
-$%
/ R " , V ) # M7
>
'D
-' "
* '5 T7 #
*
#)
& 1992 #% 95
!'% '# 5
K$ 7' , $ (- $"#( K' %
'' )
' -%
.1997 #% 478
@'
,)' $
!
$ '
$%
)
'
& ;
– 13 -
5
-% #
F ')' , N M8
.! -"
&
'
# - ' =' @ ()
-%
M9
$ ' ,J $B =- $" 7 *
.
, $ - N. -' & '
;
'
--% 7
1
'6 / D
'
(15)
.
- ! ' K7
6 F 9
"
,
1)
; J
2
, ( ,
(
(&
.&
A ') &
.
* 2
2
)
%
B
))
2
.
(
B/
&
2
,* 8 -8
A 7 B/ )
* & *
&
:
:
!"# $
/ , (
,
"
)
)
)
3-:
19
.
%:
)
# ,
;
2
( ; &- .
8 ) &
.
,
2
2
)
7
% ,
:
<
(
2 "'
8D < &
"
(
– 14 -
,
2
>&'
: ,
- /
:
2
.
3
&
1412 8 %
( % (, (
.
/M 3
.HTM
"
"$
17 )
"
(
6
2
:
%8
-- %8 $ 8
([1] / ; (
2
)
)
2
.
B/
: "
.)
.
" 8
@
)
<
# )
A J ;%&
@
.
)
4
2
J
P
"
) &
7 % ;2
7
<
.
4 % 8 B/
I
&
#
Q
.(16)F 2
,@ 2
R-
&
3 U 2<"
&<
&<
$
#
'
.
%
.
.PDF
– 15 -
*
: (
92
2
"
B/
B (; :)
91
A '
( &
4
(
93
%8 (
0+ 4
+
19
8
94
"
&
8: % M -
; &
J ,2
"#
": % 8
B
4
8 '$
%
% &2
,)
"
.
()
V
2%
,
@2
– 16 -
QJ
M
B
2
)
2
-
" 95
.
)
2
.
"
& & )' I 8
% 2 %
" 4 1) 3
@
@
@ 2 % : (;
8 ; -)
6
2 % : *4 " )
. -' / , 4(
A
(
997 H
%
(
1 (
2
6
%7 '% ,
%
6
-) )
;
)
, -8
2
V J %8 ,
2
;
.
! / M %
1 ( M %
@
)
)
@
@ 2
8:
7 ;.
2
, - )2 4
2
3 J
+
2
8: %
(
.
<
1
7J
B
M3
4 M4
.
7
M1
M2
3
.%
– 17 -
(
;
8
3 J
/
5 "&6
( ;
8 /
)
A
)
.
7
.
, 1998
%: .
1 X M
<
'
;&
@>
( % 8J
:
3 (:
6
2
,)
8 .
V
. (
(
% M
8
84 % , X
; &
"
( ;
; &
( A
)
I( '
7 I -)
V J %8
)
8J ;
,
20 H
!
;
B (% 3
. 2001
:(17)F
, "
B
3 J
M5
(
@
2
) )
% : *4
8:
%
J
.
7 % , 2
:
3
( I :A
" )
I (%
.
( ;/ )
%8
B (% 3
,
:
' @ 2 %8 .
% 8 % 81
&
2007 – 2003
84 %
' )
8J ;
( ;
)
; &
( 0 ( % %.
&-
2
(
,
2
%
Q ,%
,
4
&<
,
www..gccaao.
gccaao.org
www
< % 2003
# :;> ,
M
1 X 8 / , (
3 J , ( /
6
4 %8 .
.
– 18 -
B/
<
,1
(
%
(
@
.
(:
%8 (
(
,
8:
@ 2
2
25924 H
)
J
8Y
8
. 2002
>&
;
.
,
4
8 '
2
/ ZA &
')
Z /
;"<
6
)
.
%
;
(
(
.
4
2008 – 2004
. 2003
)
(
%
%(
C 2 1
8Y > 2
(
21920 H
(
2
4
,
6
4
,
8
I (% .
: 2"
% 8
8
84 % , X
."
(
.
2
. ( 4
2
. (
1 X M
&<
(
.
;
8
8 /
8
8:
5"
( 0 (
8:
5 "&6
5"
*
V J
: ; 5 "&9
:[1] %8 < A
;/) I
8:
8
:
. 2004
1 (
# A
;
& > 2
2
:, 9 1
% 8;
1
" :, 9 1
(
8 /
,
B/
7 8
8:
1 X M
.
(
:[2] %8 < A
(
:[3] %8 < A
(
:[4] %8 < A
.
!
/ M
."
%
V
7 ;.
3 (:
<
7
, - )2 4
.] (
6
)
2
<
3 J
2
":
)
+
7J
8
B
/
5"
2
;
" :% 2 1
5"
2
8: %
2 1
*
*
1 ( M %
3 J
1
3
7
."F
– 19 -
B
4 :<
1
."
@
" :!
1
3 J
)
5"
*
5"
*
":
(
C 2 B (-
; "
(
8:" :!"
2
(
."
/
%8 A
;
< )
:
2
;&-
.%(
)
)
8@
-
)
,%8
7
'I &
J
;& <
8: ) 3
;/ )
(
2
.
2
% 8
;+ ,
72+
2
)
,
%
2
%
/+
7
,
2
2 1
5"
,
*+"< * (
.
4
,,
%
,
/ .I < &
V"
. (
& , <&
B
&2
8
(
(
8' &
/ ,A & , %
1 2
#
:
<
.
8<
(
,;
8 (4 ,
" /4
. B
-
,
:
(
J
/ .
@
' ,
/
& @
4
.(
%
(
-'
8 )8 6
<
,
0 / •
M )
. 8
.(
– 20 -
;/ )
( , ""
)' . 8 V " 4
:
,I (
) -
) 2003/12/31 % %
" /4
*
2
J
,
2 ":
*
(
1
:F
%
(
5"
(
^ " % : ;"
,)
1
2
.
&<
,) (
&< 3 >:
A J )' &
( ;
A
,3
2 "
8 <
2
" :<
)
*
1&
* 8%
( ) @
8 %8 ;
5"
."*
."
1
)
*
'
(# `
.
`
) ) <
)
,
)
,
%
<
;
M
/ 8)
.<
( ;
.
;& % 2
, +
(
%
(# & -
2 %
J)
;
%8 ,
( ;
%
:F
) &
.)
,
.
8' 6.
( ;
@"
(2 1
.
,
J
,6
(
,
" /4 * 8
.
2 )
.
Z
, 7
`
( ;
;
C2
2 " ,
.
"
'@ 2
4 %8 ;
7
C2
B/
J
1
' (: •
%8
)8 6
&
7
•
%8
* 8
,C 2
, 2
8; 4 8
`
;
":
(
)
8: •
8: •
,
'
J ) >2
6
%
,
C 2
(
% M
2
) 1
;
0+
.
•
.
J %
%8
%
<
/I
@
&
2 %8 ,
%8 ; &
B IASB B/
IASB B /
2
,
% ""
.%
@
" /4
B(
B
( )
) >2
":
"
%8
.
2
-
) >2
B/ )
<
)& % 2
"
)-
:, 9 = ;
&:
3
7' %
% /
I
;.
&
; J $ <
"
– 21 -
) >2
" %
)& % 2
2
A
;& %
B
" ([1] / ; () %
2
,
(
(
(
<
, PDF
&
I
8 )&
.(B/
&
A &I
: )&
"%
,B/
&
8
'
.
.
.B/
.
2
<
.
'
A J
3
&
.(
%8
(
, "
1&
,I"
"
' V"
(
B/
%
) >2
C+> 3
' I&
CD % 8
: :
)
2
C2 "
&
%
: :
^ <
1
<"
/
" :, 9 "
:
( %
2
'
:(1) / A" 9
/ A" % 2 :(2) / A" 9
,
"
:(39) / A" % 2 :(36) / A" 9
&
2
(
J
/ /
: :
2
*
A 7 "
)
B/
"
"
,
:(18) (35)
2
IAS
2(
2 % 8 (1) / ; ( %
" ;& 2
2
( ) " )
,)
:F
/
2
: :,2
.@+ # % 8
% 8 ; ( % A"&
IASB B/
;&-
1 & %
:F
/ , IASB
4 ,A & - - % 8
2)
)
8D ) >2
&:
) <
%8
.CD % 8
,
2
< ; :
.I 8 ; "2 % ) Q
, (
,
2 %
I
' , PDF
HTM
&
,
2
%8 , "
*
'
" ;& ,3 <&
:
B/
(
, (
)
.(CD % 8
%
"
; (
% ,&
+ B/
– 22 -
;> )
<
(
:(40) / A" 9
:(41) / A" 9
**
. ( %
,
2
0
. PDF
"
)
1 &
A ; :
%8
; "2
%8 )
<
B /
" B/
%
>2
2(
%
)
2(
)
%
2(
B /
SA
%
:(44) / A" 9
(
%
)
2(
Y
%
)
.(B
J 1 2
&
:
2 "
**
:% 2 "
**
:<
"
**
2 :!
"
**
"
**
. IASB
&
(
; J
. Organization)
Organization) CAO
(
2
J
"
J 1 2
(19)
,
:(45) / A" 9
&4
"
J 1 2
2
)
MFT (Ministry of
2(
`
J 1 2
Central Auditing )
" B/
:(43) / A" 9
( )
'
% 8 ; "2 % M -4
%
&:
: ;> (Services Resources
,
.
:(42) / A" 9
&:
.CD % 8
OISR (Other Internet
(
"
,
( ,
% >
. (Foreign Trade
) Egypt ;&& "
C > )
)
"
)
""
2
: !"
.
.((Saudi Arabia
– 23 -
(1) . , "
" ) >2
"" %
%
4
(6)
(5)
B/
SA
2
2
2
R
B/
Egypt
R
0.5
1.5
0.5
(4)
(3)
(2)
B/
B/
B/
MFT
CAO
IASB
R
R
2
R
3
3
3
3
R
1
1
1
2(
2
)
J
(1)
(20 )
H "B. ,
-%
#@
# #
-&
-%
/ R " CFW M1
( R'C )
* '5 D IAS I M2
'@B IAS 2 M3
5#
5
* ' IAS 7 M4
R
%B ' ?IAS 8M5
% %
V '
')
W
5
0 . IAS 10 M6
H &# '5 IAS II M7
B ,* 6 IAS 12 M8
8
IAS 14 99
0.5
0.5
1.5
R
<"
1
1
1
R
<"
R
R
2
R
<"
3
3
3
3
3
<"
<"
<"
<"
3
2
1.5
1
2
3
2
<"
<"
<"
3
( # IAS 17 912
2
1.5
1
2
3
# IAS 18 913
R
R
R
2
2
>'
– 24 -
& %
( ,
IAS 15 910
, &
J %
`
IAS 16 911
(1) . , " <
" ) >2
"" %
%
4
(6)
B/
(5)
B/
SA
Egypt
(4)
(3)
(2)
B/
B/
B/
MFT
CAO
IASB
<"
<"
<"
<"
3
2
1.5
1
2
3
<"
)
# #
() <7
A "
0,5
1
<"
<"
<"
3
<"
<"
1.5
1
2
3
2
0.5
1
<"
3
<"
3
J
(1)
))
&2 P
2
&2
B
)8
'%
8
-&
2
0.5
2
1.5
1
2
3
2
1.5
1
2
3
<"
<"
<"
<"
3
<"
0.5
1
<"
3
A"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
0.5
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
1
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
3
3
3
3
3
3
<"
2
<"
2
<"
2
<"
0.5
<"
0.5
<"
<"
<"
1
<"
1
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
3
3
3
3
3
<"
– 25 -
R-
/+
2
M
%
$
(
IAS 20 – 15
`
>' IAS 21 916
c
(J
+
IAS 22 917
$ /4 A & IAS 23918
A
(8
IAS 19 914
)8 ! " #
3
<"
1
2(
2
J )8 ! " # IAS 24 919
(
B
2 IAS 26 920
) )8
.
IAS 27 921
& - %
> 4 )8
> 4 )8
2 IAS 28 922
& -%
" /4 %
IAS 29 923
8
.
% ! " # IAS 30 924
>
?
V"2 )8
IAS 31 925
& 8 !"# :
J IAS 32 926
2 IAS 33 927
< ) 2
IAS 34 928
,
Q
IAS 35 929
; "J
/ $ < IAS 36 930
4 , ""
IAS 37 931
.
; "J , .
Q ; "J IAS 38 932
@2 :
J IAS 39 933
&
> IAS 40 934
8
IAS 41 935
(
) ,&
936
(1) . , " <
" ) >2
"" %
%
4
(6)
(5)
B/
(4)
B/
SA
Egypt
(3)
(2)
B/
B/
B/
MFT
CAO
IASB
2(
2
)
J
(1)
# #
2
<"
<"
<"
<"
2
0.5
1
<"
<"
2
2
3
3
2
<"
<"
<"
1
1.5
3
1.5
<"
<"
<"
1
<"
3
<"
<"
<"
<"
1
3
3
3
<"
<"
<"
3
3
3
3
3
3
J
-&
#
"
(
)
C 2 A &
( "
937
)
(
)
<
4 % 8 B/
1&
PDF
A ; : &:
CD % 8
; "2 & :
OISR
'
(
938
939
940
941
942
943
944
945
:
, (SPSS 6
) %d 1 2
:F
; ( "
&M
(e
,4,3)
D ) >2
/ (1) / ; (
B ( 18
Descriptive Statistics <"
A 2 4 ,%
%
"
2
&*
2
) <"
8 " B/
: <"
3 "2#
%
3 "2# 1 2
3 "2# 1 2 (1)
, IASB B/ ) (1) /
,(
B/
(2) . , "
A 2
e
e
<"
3 "2#
F 2
, < 45
8
(1 / ; ()
0.13
0.1045
0.86
0.7008
2.73
0.5556
0.16
1.067
1.067
– 26 -
)
%
2
IASB B/
) "
2
( /
2
:F
$
'
; (
( % : B(
3 ) IASB B/
.IASB B/ % 8 ( 4 "
B(
2
) ) >2
% 2
) ;& % 2
c
1 / 91
3 ) 0.5556 ^ C 2 "
% 2
$<
92
# ,
4 %8 (
, ( ,
*+"' B/
(
8M &,
, "
2
)
. /
" %
&
:
(
2 ) ;/'
4: ,PDF
&:)
"
% 2
)' (
2 93
< ;& ; : ) & : 8 % : M B( ,IASB
-- %8
<
&<
# * (
8 )& I '
.CD % 8 )
,
:
; &%
2)
&'
8: 1(
.%
2 (1) / ; (
%8
X
B/ ) (1) / ; ( " 8 ) (
,(
B/
,4,3)
%
2
)
&*
4
) )&
+
" )
<" 1 2 (2)
8 " B/
,IASB
: <"
%
(3) . , "
2
)(
B/
0.274 9
(0.068)
0.478
(0.001)
1
Q
<
4
"
, " , IASB B/ )
" B/
0.194
(0.201)
1
-
4
,
4
+
B/
IASB
1
7
B/
" B/
>+> B /
B/
91
" B/
92
B/
93
IASB
)' (3) / ; ( ) ) >2
"
<"
)
" 8
.
" ,IASB)
+
c
8
" %
" 8 ) ANOVA )
:(
– 27 -
2
; 2 3 (: (3)
,*
8
µ IASB = µ EGYPT = µSA
;/J % 8 '
(
2
.A
2
J ;&
:
$
: ;
M
:0$
$ < :1$
%5 =
(4) . , "
ANOVA )
22-
3.065
10× 4.03
73.22
; 2
58.363
2
116.726
0.797
132
! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"
105.211 #!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!$
"
221.937
134
/ !0 1!0 2 ! 3.065
( ) < 73.22 ,( ) () '
! ) ! -@
5 – 678 9:
; 3"
< = : 0 > 3< () 53 4
!,- E ! F ! G !H ! 3 t ! $ A B! ( 8
4 : 7 $C D<
E ! F ! G ! H ! 3 t ! $ ! : 5! ! 0 . (L ! 5! " I J #!!K) ! 678
:I J#
,(5) . , "
c
;&
2
B/
J ) @ <
" B/
*7.203
*14.596
*3.563
<"
(0.000)
IASB B/
)
<"
(0.000)
(0.001)
/
t
IASB
"
<"
1.96 <
t C 2 %5 =
– 28 -
8
@
*
B /
IASB B /
" B/
.IASB B/
7' %
I
B/
"
% : (2 M
:; -
.
; (% , &
:
2 :
*
(
I 83
' ,
B/
M ) ) >2
" %
; 4 I' %:
B
"
c
2
-
3
. IASB
&:
" ) ;& %
`
" ;& )
& : B B/
%8
2
< $ 8
<
.%
@
; J $ < $
&
B /
(
B
;.
%/
) ;& )
%8
3
; &
91
4 %8
B/
92
- * " " (1) /
B/
,PDF
.CD % 8
(
' %:
:
#
2 = ;
) ;. % > $ <
) >2 )& % 2
2
%/
%(
)
( ;/ )
":
" ([6] / ; () % ; (
8D ) >2
/ ,IASB )8 , "
B
'
&
2
A
IASB B/
V" B ,
%(
)
( ;/ )
":
(
2
&
< ) >2
/ , " ;& ,3 <&
2( ) '
.@
;
*
)
B
2
2
2
:F
2 % 8 (6) / ; ( %
^ <
( % A"& " ;& 2 ,
2
" :, 9 "
:F
2 %8
. 2
< A J &
:
: (1) / A"
, " IAS
2
:(35) / A" % 2 (2) / A"
.
'
&
!
Q ) %(
)
( V
:(36) / A"
.(IASB
/ %
2( ) J 1 2
"
: 2 "
.IASB
– 29 -
/
*
9
9
9
*
B /
%
%
2(
( 3)
B/
2(
)
J %(
(
IASB
3
3
3
3
<"
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
<"
2
<"
2
2
2
<"
<"
2
<"
<"
2
<"
2
<"
<"
<"
<"
<"
( 6) . , "
( )8 , "
)
) >2
)
(
%
`
<
( 3
A ')
( 1)
2
.
J ,, < ,
8
) 8 !"#
(J
%
`
(8
>
+
B
( ,
() <7
4 ) 8
)
2
& -%
8
– 30 -
))
&2 P
-
$ 8 IAS 92
IAS 2 93
)
. / IAS 7 94
% " IAS 8 95
2
, &
R-
IAS 12 98
IAS 14 99
IAS 15 910
IAS 16 911
( # IAS 17 912
B
)8
'%
8 IAS 11 97
1.
& %
A "
/+
# CFW 91
3-#
8
>'
&<
2+ C 2J IAS 10 96
;
J %
"
'P
H
*
)
IASB
""
4 &- %8
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
:% 2 "
(
B/
2
2
2
<"
<"
J 1 2
"
.GCC %(
)
( 2)
GCC
<"
)
2
# IAS 18 913
IAS 19 914
IAS 20 915
&2
`
>' IAS 21 916
c
IAS 22 917
$ /4 A & IAS 23 918
A
)8
J )8 ! " # IAS 24 919
(
> 4 )8
" /4 %
.
2
2
IAS 26 920
IAS 27 921
& -
IAS 28 922
IAS 29 923
<"
2
<"
>
3
<"
?
& -
8 -
<"
<"
2
<"
2
<"
2
M
% V"2 )8
$
(
.
.
% ! " # IAS 30 924
IAS 31 925
!"# :
< )
; "J , .
,
J IAS 32 926
2
2
Q
; "J
IAS 33 927
IAS 34 928
IAS 35 929
IAS 36 930
/ $<
4 , ""
IAS 37 931
Q ; "J IAS 38 932
@2 :
&
8
>
J IAS 39 933
IAS 40 934
IAS 41 935
C 2 A &
6
:
)% d 1 2
; ( "
: <"
e
(e
3 "2#
A 2 4 ,% 2
) <"
3 "2# 1 2 (1)
%
, (GCC B/
, IASB B/ ) (6) /
(7) . , "
<"
3 "2#
8% 2
, < 36
2.917
0.778
0.250
0.978
B/
"
D ) >2
/ (6) / ; (
B ( 18
:F & <"
3 "2# 1 2
, (SPSS
A 2
4: , IASB
)
(
.
936
%
2
0 < (7) / @
C 2 A & V
M
2
)
(
Q %(
)
IASB B/
GCC B/
; ( )
7
)J 3 % : ;"
)
(
, IASB B/ ) (6) / ; ( " 8 ) ANOVA )
)
(
µ GCC = µ IASB
2
– 31 -
J ;&
:
:;
'
; 2 3 (: (2)
:GCC)
$ :0$
$ < :1 $
(8) . , "
ANOVA )
3.978
18-
10× 6.26
134.14
/ !0 1!0 2 3.978
( ! Q!
! () P) ,
2
% :
) ;.
%/
(2 M
82.347
1
82.347
0.614
70
42.972
71
125.319
! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"
#!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!$
"
( ) : < 134.14 ,- ( ) () '
:
; 3"
< = : 0 > 3< () 53 4
.
5: @ C R S
%(
% > $ < $
; 4 I' %:
.6
; 2
;
-
)
M ) ) >2
( ;/ )
":
. IASB )8 ,
)
(
c
"
2
(
2
B/
:% 2 = ;
&<
#
"
" 8
#
%/
([9] / ; () %
IASB B /
.@
" 8)
2(
&
%
)
'V"
;.
) >2
8D ) >2
/ , FASB B/
GCC , SA , Egypt , IASB B/
; (
< ) >2
:F
C > $ <
FASB B/
B .%(
)
/ ,B/
%
(
;& %
2 % 8 (9) / ; ( %
– 32 -
)& % 2
%
2
,
"
M
^ <
%
2
&<
&<
#
,Egypt,
Egypt,
/
(9) . , "
B/
%
FASB B/
6
)
%
(
,
B/
GCC
2
B/
SA
2
2
2
<"
3
3
<"
<"
<"
3
3
2
<"
<"
3
3
2
2
<"
3
3
<"
2
<"
<"
3
6
:F
2
B/
B/
B/
Egypt IASB FASB
3
<"
3
)% d 1 2
D ) >2
&<
#
, " , IASB
.(21)e &<
/ (9) / ; (
2
– 33 -
" 8
.
A
'91
(1976 8 ")
,
(
8 V. " 92
con.
2
con.2
(1980 8 ")
R .
A ' 93
con.
Q
con.4 P
(1980 8 ")
8
") con.
con.5 @ 2 94
(1984
con.
.
" 8 95
con.6
(1985 8 ")
96
") con.
2
con.7
(22)
(2000 8
:
J ;&
B ( 18
; 2 1 2
µ GCC = µ SA = µ EG = µ IASB = µFASB :
(
#
con.
con.1
& (9) / ; ( " 8 ) ANOVA )
.
" 8)
:;
"
, (SPSS
$
:0$
$ < :1$
%5 =
(10) . , "
ANOVA )
22-
2.759
10× 2.27
1!!0 2 ! 2.759 !
9!: 5!0 ! - P ! H
(
%
;>
%
, IASB
&<
*
8
# ) *
8.2
4
32.80
0.727
25
18.16
29
50.96
( ) ! : < 11.27 ! ,- !
!TU !; 3" ! ! 3 G !0
. " %
2
# )
11.28
; 2
&<
J B/
&
:F
.%
#
%: )-
" 8)
% (
%
6
– 34 -
;
( ) () '!!
53 4 / 0
.9:
5: FASB
% , -# (
"8 ' (
J
4 FASB B/
)
.
&<
;
"
4 91
%
2
Q GCC, SA ) ;& %
! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"
#!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!$
"
#
(
92
'
" 8 93
&
&<
!
%
<?
C 2
,%
6.
(:
-
4 ) >2
%8
.
2
(
(
:
(23)
2
B
.+
% 81
% V" 4
)
7
% V" 4
72+ )
.
1 ( )8
7J I
.
;
4
8
(
X Q "%
;
; &
)' 1(
'
:3
'1 2
91
I
8D A &
,
0
/+8
0 -
"
.*
93
": !
0 -
% : Exposure Draft
92
%8 – (
V J %8 ,
1
,.
%8 (
–%
0 - 0
,
3
'
I @
(
'
&
.
":
0 -
( ;&
%/ )' * " "
%
-
%
( ;& )' P
4
:
(
3
.+
4
'@
$
,
% I
X Q " 8 I ' % : , -#
"
C 2 P
)
B
'
& @
B
.
,
@ AB& , C , V " 4
/+
. +
!
2
84 %
(9) / ; ( %
0
C2
(
-
94
)
J
(
0 - ;
2
. 2 /
– 35 -
95
96
,
(
(0
() 2 <
. 3
<" ,
72+
( % :
2
8:
%
) )
2
-
'
;& ; 2
/
%
@
;
)
;"
B
%
QJ I 8
I 8 <
; &
2< " B /
.
;
%8 '
.
)
;
"
-/
( ,
0 -
"
)8
4 % 8 B/
( % 8 0+ 4 )
)' % 8 ,PDF
@
% `( @
, (M
– 36 -
"
Q ' & -
1 2
(
'
99
P
3
:
8
98
.I
. 72+
. (
;& *+> ) I
(
8
/ ) I : ;"
97
@>
1
(
2
)
-/
;+ I 8 @ < 4
3 H
% < H
72+
72+
A
; :
72+
,
.
(
2
<
,
%8
"
%
,
0 -
0 -
8:
8 (4
.
%
8
; (
' %8 %
I
3
( B
% 910
.$
(
'
911
, (J % 8 912
"
4
3-: ,
<
913
P
C2
2
#
;& %
@
:
2 914
D
(1)) http://www. oecd.org
(2)) http://www. gccaao.org
(3)) http://www. socpa.org
3
.
%8
2
2
2
% 7 6
, 55
,
,
? ",@
:
&
#
,$
%
E "
)
A -/
(4)
2
,"F &
.2359167 V V , (1987
!"# $
&
/" , @
!"# $
, 61
,
,
%
#
,$
2 /
& -
E "
)
A -
(5)
%
,"
.2019113 V V , (1989
'1
–
, 66
,
,
2
#
,$
E "
)
",;
%8 ) ;
,"
/
(6)
":
2129177 V V , (1990
;
4
E "
",
/
,"
&
.162993 V V ,(1991
%
%
2
'
2
, -8 B
(
,@ /
2 / ,@
A -
%
2
3
&' ,72
",
!+ ": A
2
/
,
2
2 / ,@
; 7%
(, (
,
2
%
&,
.60915 V V ,1997
1F
"
G
2
,"
92/227 V V ,1998
",
(
,@
"
/
% % (#
#
,$
A -
&
(7)
)
2 /
(
"'
, "e "
.
(, (
; &
'/
3+
& ,1 2 H
.2/274
– 37 -
(8)
, ; J 3 ( ,; J
": (
2
2 /
(9)
%
"
,
(
) >2
.
"
F
,
/
7
:
2
, 1997
&
;
503 F. "
-
< .
&
D&
/
> + ,
"
F
2
&2 ; &-
.
" / . C2
3-:
4 &- %8
.,
c
J B
+
&
%
(
2
)-
,
7
; &
.
/ ,1996
)
(10)
3-:
.
"
2
2
B/
) .-
. 2002 ,
, 2
/
-B
2004
2<" *
.7
8:
J
D&
(11)
"
2
(12)
23 – (B ) 215
8 ) - 1996
.167 – 2 V V , 2
2644
%
2
(13)) http://www. sec.org
(14)) http://www. socpa.org
8 / (15)
.1990 , - ; +
, & ,"
J",
(16)) http://www. FASB.org/st.
(17) http://www.gccaao/goals.html.
(18)) International
Accounting
Standards
Committee,
"International Accounting Standards", London , 2002
$
;
@
. ', ( ,
B/
' )d % 2
4 (19)
.V
%
4 % 8 IASB B/
%8 ,
0
%
2
2
1
*
(20)
.2004/6/1
(21)) a
a-- Financial Accounting Standards Boards, "Statement
Statement of
Financial Accounting Concepts 11-6", (New York:
McGrowMcGrow-Hill Book Company, 1986).
b_________,
"Accounting
Standards",
Original
Pronouncements, July 19731973-June 1, 1986, (New York:
McGrowMcGrow-Hill Book Company, 1987).
FASB
":
(
*
0 8:
' (22)
.(2004 8 % )
.
4 % 8 C2
) >2
JPS Accountants Directory: http://www.jps-dir.com
– 38 -
(
3
% (23)