Innovation Clusters:
Understanding Life Cycles
A BRIEFING PAPER FROM THE ECONOMIST INTELLIGENCE UNIT
Policy
Commercial Infrastructure
Set-up & Operating Costs
Research
Access to Growth
Markets
Regulatory
Framework
Collaboration
Connective Infrastructure
Sharing
Attractive Cost
Structure
6
Education
Skilled
Workforce
Global Workforce
Public Amenities
Education
Geography
Society
BRIEFING PAPER
Serendipity
Liveabillity
The BIG 6
Success Factors
Social
Infrastructure
Cosmopolitan
Communities
ABOUTTHI
SREPORT
I
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
s
:
Under
s
t
andi
ngl
i
f
ec
y
c
l
eswaswr
i
t
t
enbyTheEc
onomi
s
tI
nt
el
l
i
genc
eUni
t
.
I
t
exami
nest
hel
i
f
ec
y
c
l
esoffiv
ei
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sandt
hef
ac
t
or
st
hatdet
er
mi
nes
uc
c
es
s
.
Ther
epor
t
i
sbas
edondes
kr
es
ear
c
handt
enexper
ti
nt
er
v
i
ews
.
Thec
as
es
t
udi
eshav
ebeens
el
ec
t
edt
oc
ov
er
bot
hes
t
abl
i
s
hedandemer
gi
ngmar
ket
s
,
andt
oexpl
or
ear
angeofc
l
us
t
ers
uc
c
es
sf
ac
t
or
ss
uc
has
demogr
aphi
c
sandt
al
ent
;
i
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
e;
qual
i
t
yofl
i
f
e,
pol
i
c
yandgeogr
aphy
.
Ther
epor
twaswr
i
t
t
en
byMi
c
hael
Mar
t
i
ns
.
Theedi
t
orwasAdam Gr
een.
Thes
t
udywasc
ommi
s
s
i
onedbyDubai
Tour
i
s
m.
onomi
s
tI
nt
el
l
i
genc
eUni
twoul
dl
i
ket
ot
hankt
hef
ol
l
owi
ngi
ndi
v
i
dual
s(
l
i
s
t
edal
phabet
i
c
al
l
y
)f
or
TheEc
s
har
i
ngt
hei
ri
ns
i
ght
sandexper
t
i
s
edur
i
ngt
her
es
ear
c
hf
ort
hi
spaper
.
Pr
of
es
s
orEr
kkoAut
i
o-Chai
ri
nTec
hnol
ogyVent
ur
i
ngandEnt
r
epr
eneur
s
hi
p,
andDi
r
ec
t
oroft
he
Doc
t
or
al
Pr
ogr
ammeatI
mper
i
al
Col
l
egeLondonBus
i
nes
sSc
hool
DrCr
i
s
t
i
naChami
nade-Pr
of
es
s
ori
nI
nnov
at
i
onSt
udi
esatLundUni
v
er
s
i
t
y
DrAndr
ew Cor
bet
t-Pr
of
es
s
orofEnt
r
epr
eneur
s
hi
pandFac
ul
t
yDi
r
ec
t
orf
ort
heJ
ohnE.
&Al
i
c
eL.
But
l
erVent
ur
eAc
c
el
er
at
or
,
Babs
onCol
l
ege
DrRi
ccar
doCr
es
cenz
i-As
s
oc
i
at
ePr
of
es
s
orofEc
onomi
cGeogr
aphyatt
heLondonSc
hool
of
Ec
onomi
c
s
DrLui
s
aGagl
i
ar
di-Fel
l
owi
nt
heLondonSc
hool
ofEc
onomi
c
sDepar
t
mentofGeogr
aphyand
Env
i
r
onment
,
andRes
ear
c
hAfl
i
at
eatBoc
c
oni
Uni
v
er
s
i
t
y
Cl
i
fHar
al
d-Exec
ut
i
v
eDi
r
ec
t
oratBoul
derEc
onomi
cCounc
i
l
Char
l
ot
t
eHol
l
oway-Di
r
ec
t
orofPol
i
c
y
,
t
ec
hUK
Pr
of
es
s
orFl
or
i
anTaube-Emi
l
eBer
nhei
m Chai
rofEnt
r
epr
eneur
s
hi
pi
naGl
obal
Cont
extat
Uni
v
er
s
i
t
eLi
br
edeBr
uxel
l
es
Pr
of
es
s
orTonyVenabl
es-BPPr
of
es
s
orofEc
onomi
c
s
,
Oxf
or
dUni
v
er
s
i
t
yPr
of
es
s
orPohKam WongDi
r
ec
t
orofNat
i
onal
Uni
v
er
s
i
t
yofSi
ngapor
e’
sEnt
r
epr
eneur
s
hi
pCent
r
e
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s2
I
nnovat
i
oncl
us
t
er
s
:Under
s
t
andi
ngl
i
f
ecycl
es
I
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sar
el
i
ket
hec
ompani
est
heyhos
t
:
t
heyc
angr
owr
api
dl
yati
nc
ept
i
on,
peak,
and
ev
ent
ual
l
y–i
ft
heydonotadapt
–t
heys
t
agnat
eordi
e.
Ther
ear
et
hous
andsofc
l
us
t
er
sar
oundt
he
wor
l
d,
butmanys
t
r
uggl
et
oac
hi
ev
es
us
t
ai
nabi
l
i
t
yors
c
al
abi
l
i
t
y
.
Somet
i
mes
,
t
hev
er
yf
ac
t
or
st
hatmade
t
hem s
uc
c
es
s
f
ul
,
c
aus
et
hem t
of
ai
l
l
at
eron.
Whatal
l
owsc
l
us
t
er
st
oc
ombi
net
hei
nnov
at
i
v
es
pi
r
i
tofs
t
ar
t
upswi
t
ht
her
es
i
l
i
enc
eofes
t
abl
i
s
hed
c
ongl
omer
at
es
,
t
oext
endt
hei
rl
i
f
ec
y
c
l
e?Thr
oughc
as
es
t
udyev
i
denc
eac
r
os
sfiv
ec
ount
r
i
es
,
andan
exper
ti
nt
er
v
i
ewpr
ogr
am,
t
heEc
onomi
s
tI
nt
el
l
i
genc
eUni
texpl
or
es‘
c
l
us
t
erl
i
f
ec
y
c
l
es
’
i
nSi
l
i
c
on
Roundabout(
UK)
,
Bangal
or
e(
I
ndi
a)
,
Boul
der(
Uni
t
edSt
at
es
)
,
Si
ngapor
e,
andEs
t
oni
aanddr
awsoutkey
l
es
s
onsf
r
om t
hei
rexper
i
enc
es
.
Par
t1:I
nnovat
i
onCl
us
t
er
s
:Whycompani
esar
ebet
t
ert
oget
her
Par
t2:London’
snexti
ncar
nat
i
on
t3:Si
ngapor
e:Bui
l
tf
r
om s
cr
at
ch
Par
Par
t4:Pl
uckyEs
t
oni
a:Eas
t
er
nEur
ope’
ss
t
ar
t
up
Par
t5:At
al
entmagnet
:TheBeaut
yofBoul
der
Par
t6:TEcos
ys
t
em:Bangal
or
e’
sgr
owi
ngpai
ns
Par
t7:Concl
us
i
on:I
nnovat
i
oncl
us
t
er
s
:TheSucces
sReci
pe
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s3
Par
t1:
I
nnovat
i
onCl
us
t
er
s
:Whycompani
es
ar
ebet
t
ert
oget
her
BRI
EFI
NGPAPER
WRI
TTEN BYTHEECONOMI
STI
NTELLI
GENCEUNI
T
I
nnovat
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sr
equi
r
es
i
xkeyi
ngr
edi
ent
s
:s
ki
l
l
s
,ac
c
ommodat
i
ng
pol
i
c
yf
r
amewor
k,i
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
e,l
ow c
os
ts
t
r
uc
t
ur
es(
i
near
l
ys
t
ages
)
,a
goodl
i
f
es
t
yl
eoffer
i
ngands
er
endi
pi
t
y.
Cl
us
t
er
sar
el
i
ket
hec
ompani
est
heyhos
t
:t
heyc
hangeovert
i
me,andt
hei
r
l
ongt
er
ms
uc
c
es
sdependsonhow wel
lt
heyadaptt
ot
hec
hal
l
engesof
s
uc
c
es
s
,l
i
kec
onges
t
i
onandi
nc
r
eas
edr
ent
s
us
t
er
sar
es
t
r
ongl
yr
el
i
antonanopeni
mmi
gr
at
i
onpol
i
c
yatt
henat
i
onal
Cl
l
evel–t
i
ght
eni
ngbor
der
sr
educ
esac
l
us
t
er
’
sac
c
es
st
ogl
obalt
al
ent
I
nnov
at
i
oni
sof
t
enas
s
oc
i
at
edwi
t
ht
r
i
umphantl
onei
nv
ent
or
s
.
Thel
i
kesofThomas
Edi
s
on,
Loui
s
Pas
t
eurorBi
l
l
Gat
esar
et
hec
ent
r
al
c
har
ac
t
er
si
nt
hi
snar
r
at
i
v
e.
Butal
l
i
nnov
at
or
ss
pr
i
ngoutofa
s
pec
i
ficc
ont
ext
.
Theenv
i
r
onment
st
hatf
os
t
ert
hei
r
i
ndi
v
i
dual
andc
ol
l
ec
t
i
v
es
uc
c
es
sar
ev
er
yof
t
en
‘
i
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
s
’
:
ec
os
y
s
t
emst
hat
s
t
i
mul
at
eandnur
t
ur
et
hebes
ti
deasandat
t
r
ac
tt
hebr
i
ght
es
t
t
al
ent
s
.
Cl
us
t
er
semer
gewhenanet
wor
kofc
ompani
esc
oexi
s
t
swi
t
hi
nageogr
aphi
c
l
oc
at
i
on,
al
l
owi
ngeac
hof
t
hem t
oc
ol
l
abor
at
e–andc
ompet
e–i
nawaywhi
c
h del
i
v
er
sgr
eat
erpr
oduc
t
i
v
i
t
ygai
nst
hant
hey
woul
dac
hi
ev
ei
ni
s
ol
at
i
on.
Si
l
i
c
onVal
l
ey
i
st
hemos
tf
amous
,
butt
her
ear
ec
ount
l
es
sot
her
sac
r
os
s
ev
er
yc
ont
i
nent
.
Cl
us
t
er
sat
t
r
ac
ti
nnov
at
i
v
epeopl
e.
Theynet
wor
k,
l
eadi
ngt
ot
hec
r
os
s
pol
l
i
nat
i
onof
i
deas
.
Compani
es
benefitf
r
om eac
hot
her
’
ss
uc
c
es
s
:
Whatonei
nv
ent
s
,
r
i
v
al
sc
an ac
c
es
s–t
hi
nkofa
pr
oduc
t
i
v
i
t
y
boos
t
i
ngt
ool
l
i
keDr
opbox.
Andwhatonefir
m i
nv
ent
s
,
ot
her
sc
anbui
l
don.
Thi
nkoft
he
‘
s
har
i
ngec
onomy
’
,
l
edbyt
r
ai
l
bl
az
er
sUber
andAi
r
bnb,
i
nt
ur
ngi
v
i
ngr
i
s
et
oanar
myofs
t
ar
t
upst
aki
ng
t
hes
amei
deat
onew appl
i
c
at
i
ons
.
Thes
har
i
ngofknowl
edge,
t
hes
pi
l
l
ov
ereffec
t
sofi
nnov
at
i
onand
t
he net
wor
ki
ngt
hatdens
el
ypopul
at
eds
pac
esenabl
ear
eal
l
keyi
ngr
edi
ent
sf
ors
t
ar
t
up s
uc
c
es
s
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
er
s
:Under
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
es4
Yetf
oral
l
t
hei
rbenefit
s
,
i
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sar
enots
t
r
ai
ght
f
or
war
dt
obui
l
d–and manydonotl
as
t
,
ev
enwi
t
ht
he‘
magi
ci
ngr
edi
ent
s
’
s
eemi
ngl
yt
her
e.
Topr
os
per
,
c
l
us
t
er
sneeds
i
xkeys
uc
c
es
sf
ac
t
or
s
:
s
ki
l
l
sandt
al
ent
,
ac
c
ommodat
i
ngpol
i
c
y
f
r
amewor
ks
,
i
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
e,
l
owc
os
t
s(
es
pec
i
al
l
yi
nt
heear
l
y
s
t
ages
)
,
agoodl
i
f
es
t
y
l
e offer
i
ngt
odr
awt
al
ent
,
andfinal
l
ygoodl
uc
k,
whet
hergeogr
aphy(
pr
oxi
mi
t
yt
o
key
mar
ket
s
)
,
hi
s
t
or
i
c
al
ac
c
i
dent
sorev
engoodf
or
t
une.
The‘
bi
g6’
s
uc
c
es
sf
ac
t
or
s
Thes
es
i
xf
ac
t
or
sar
enec
es
s
ar
yc
ondi
t
i
ons
,
al
t
hought
heyar
enotal
way
ss
uffic
i
ent
.
Manypl
ac
esi
nt
he
wor
l
dl
ayc
l
ai
mt
ot
hes
es
i
x,
butnev
ergi
v
er
i
s
et
oas
uc
c
es
s
f
ul
c
l
us
t
er
.
Thes
ef
ac
t
or
sar
ebes
ts
eenas
t
henec
es
s
ar
yc
ondi
t
i
onsf
orc
l
us
t
er
s
,
butnot–ont
hei
rown–t
hes
i
l
v
erbul
l
et
.
Cl
us
t
ers
uc
c
es
s
dependsbot
honi
ndi
v
i
dual
f
ac
t
or
s
,
butal
s
ot
hei
nt
er
pl
aybet
weent
hem.
Gooduni
v
er
s
i
t
i
esar
el
i
t
t
l
e
us
ei
ft
her
ei
sno c
onnec
t
i
v
i
t
ywi
t
hi
ndus
t
r
y
.
Ahi
ghs
t
andar
dofl
i
v
i
ngi
snothel
pf
ul
i
fi
mmi
gr
at
i
on pol
i
c
i
espr
ev
entgl
obal
t
al
entf
r
om mov
i
ngt
ot
hec
l
us
t
er
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s5
Par
t2:
London’
snexti
ncar
nat
i
on
BRI
EFI
NGPAPER
WRI
TTEN BYTHEECONOMI
STI
NTELLI
GENCEUNI
T
Londoni
sagl
obalmet
r
opol
i
st
hatr
ei
nvent
edi
t
s
el
fwi
t
hSi
l
i
c
on
Roundabout
’
.Butr
i
s
i
ngr
ent
s
ar
epus
hi
ngt
henextgener
at
i
onofs
t
ar
t
ups
out
.
Londoni
safinanc
i
al
power
hous
e,
ac
ent
r
al
nodei
ni
nt
er
nat
i
onal
financ
i
al
mar
ket
s
.
Butov
er
t
hel
as
t
dec
ade,
t
hec
i
t
ys
howedi
t
spower
sofr
ei
nv
ent
i
onbyhos
t
i
ng‘
Si
l
i
c
onRoundabout
’
,
a di
gi
t
al
t
ec
hc
l
us
t
er
t
hanbr
oughtt
hewor
l
dnewgadget
sandappsl
i
keTweet
dec
kandLi
v
ef
m.
Si
l
i
c
onRoundabouti
sl
oc
at
edbet
ween‘
t
heCi
t
y
’
,
t
hefinanc
i
al
hear
t
l
andofLondon,
and Hac
kney
,
one
oft
hepoor
es
tar
easofLondon.
I
ni
t
sear
l
ys
t
ages
,
i
tbenefit
t
edf
r
om s
ev
er
al
f
av
our
abl
ec
ondi
t
i
ons
.
Thear
eai
sac
c
es
s
i
bl
et
oc
ent
r
al
Londonv
i
apubl
i
ct
r
ans
por
t
,
al
l
owi
ng c
ompani
est
ot
r
av
el
ar
oundt
he
c
i
t
yeas
i
l
y
.
Rent
swer
el
ow,
andmanyent
r
epr
eneur
sf
r
om Hac
kneyc
oul
dac
c
es
st
hear
eav
i
abi
c
y
c
l
e.
Ther
ewer
eal
r
eadyar
t
i
s
t
s
,
medi
apr
of
es
s
i
onal
s
andt
ec
hnol
ogyent
r
epr
eneur
si
nt
hear
ea.
Many
s
pec
i
al
i
s
edi
nfinanc
i
al
s
er
v
i
c
es
,
andhad l
i
nkageswi
t
ht
heUK’
snat
i
onal
br
oadc
as
t
er
,
t
heBBC.
Thi
s
flui
dexc
hangeofknowl
edgeand i
deasbet
weent
ec
hnol
ogy
,
financ
eandmedi
ac
ommuni
t
i
eswas
s
t
i
mul
at
edbyt
heUK’
sopen i
mmi
gr
at
i
onpol
i
c
yi
nt
hel
at
e2000s
.
Thear
eaat
t
r
ac
t
edal
ar
gec
ommuni
t
yofAmer
i
c
answhos
t
udi
edatLondonuni
v
er
s
i
t
i
esand s
t
ar
t
ed
wor
ki
ngi
nt
hec
i
t
yt
her
eaf
t
er
.
Ot
her
sc
amedi
r
ec
t
l
yt
oSi
l
i
c
onRoundaboutf
r
om San Fr
anc
i
s
c
oand
Si
l
i
c
onVal
l
ey
.
Thes
ef
ac
t
or
sc
amet
oget
hert
oc
r
eat
eaknowl
edges
har
i
ng ec
os
y
s
t
em.
Suc
c
es
ss
oon
f
ol
l
owed.
Li
v
e.
f
m andTweet
Dec
kwer
eear
l
ys
t
ar
t
ups
,
boughtby
CBSf
or$280mi
l
l
i
oni
n2007and
Twi
t
t
erf
or$40mi
l
l
i
oni
n2011,
r
es
pec
t
i
v
el
y
.
Howev
er
,
asSi
l
i
c
onRoundabout
’
ss
t
aras
c
ended,
t
wof
ac
t
or
st
hathel
pedt
odr
i
v
es
uc
c
es
s–
l
owr
ent
andt
heUK’
sopeni
mmi
gr
at
i
onpol
i
c
i
es–bot
hc
hanged.
Rent
sdoubl
edi
n5y
ear
s
,
pus
hi
ngs
mal
l
er
fir
msands
t
ar
t
upsout
.
Dev
el
oper
sac
qui
r
edpr
oper
t
i
es
,
andenf
or
c
edl
ar
ger
s
ec
ur
i
t
ydepos
i
t
sand
mor
es
t
r
i
ngentc
r
edi
tc
hec
kst
hatpr
ev
ent
edent
r
yf
ors
mal
l
erfir
ms
.
Theygr
adual
l
ymov
edonandout
,
t
oot
herar
easofLondonl
i
keWhi
t
ec
hapel
andAl
dgat
e.
ec
onds
hi
f
twast
het
i
ght
eni
ngofi
mmi
gr
at
i
onpol
i
c
y
:
nonEUwor
kerv
i
s
asar
enow c
appedat
Thes
21,
700andr
ec
entnonEUgr
aduat
esofUKuni
v
er
s
i
t
i
esar
er
equi
r
edt
ofindaj
ob wi
t
hi
n3mont
hsof
gr
aduat
i
ng,
s
pons
or
edbyt
hei
rempl
oy
er(
atac
os
tof£1,
476)
,
ear
ni
nga mi
ni
mum of£20,
800.
Some
fir
msc
anabs
or
bt
hes
ec
os
t
s
.
Ot
her
s
,
es
pec
i
al
l
yf
r
agi
l
eand c
as
hpoors
t
ar
t
ups
,
c
annot
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s6
“
I
fhi
ghgr
owt
hfir
msc
annotmeett
hei
rt
al
entneedst
hr
ough domes
t
i
corl
oc
al
t
al
ent
,
t
heyneedt
obe
l
ooki
nggl
obal
l
y
,
”s
ay
sChar
l
ot
t
eHol
l
oway
,
Headof
Pol
i
c
yatt
ec
hUK,
at
ec
hnol
ogyi
ndus
t
r
yas
s
oc
i
at
i
on.
“
Tobeagl
obal
hubf
ort
ec
hnol
ogy
,
we r
eal
l
yneedt
obeagl
obal
hubf
ort
al
entandt
hati
nv
ol
v
es
get
t
i
ngt
hebes
ti
nt
oourc
l
us
t
er
,
”
s
hes
ay
s
.
Thenewi
mmi
gr
at
i
onpol
i
c
i
es
,
andot
herpr
opos
al
s
c
ur
r
ent
l
yi
npl
ay
,
ar
e c
onc
er
ni
ng.
“
Thei
ndus
t
r
yhasc
er
t
ai
nl
yf
el
tac
hangeoft
onei
nr
ec
entt
i
mes
,
”s
ay
s
Ms
Hol
l
oway
.
I
npar
t
i
c
ul
ar
,
s
hewar
nsagai
ns
tv
i
s
ar
ul
esmaki
ngi
thar
derf
orgr
aduat
est
os
t
ay
oni
n
t
hec
ount
r
y
.
“
Ouruni
v
er
s
i
t
i
esar
ef
undament
al
dr
i
v
er
sofgr
owt
handweneedt
hat
t
al
entt
obe
r
et
ai
ned.
”
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s7
Par
t3:
Si
ngapor
e:Bui
l
tf
r
om s
cr
at
ch
BRI
EFI
NGPAPER
WRI
TTEN BYTHEECONOMI
STI
NTELLI
GENCEUNI
T
Si
ngapor
et
r
ans
f
or
medi
t
s
el
ff
r
om anagr
ar
i
ans
oc
i
et
yt
oani
nnovat
i
on
wor
l
dl
eaderi
nhi
ght
ec
hs
ec
t
or
sl
i
keel
ec
t
r
oni
c
sandl
i
f
es
c
i
enc
es
.Hi
gh
qual
i
t
yeduc
at
i
on,publ
i
ci
nves
t
mentandf
ar
r
eac
hi
ngbus
i
nes
sc
l
i
mat
e
r
ef
or
mswer
ec
r
i
t
i
c
alengi
nes
.Buti
st
hec
i
t
ys
t
at
enow get
t
i
ngt
oo
c
r
owded?
WhenSi
ngapor
ebec
amei
ndependenti
n1965,
i
twasat
r
opi
c
al
i
s
l
andwi
t
hf
ewnat
ur
al
r
es
our
c
es
,
l
i
t
t
l
e
f
r
es
hwat
er
,
r
api
dpopul
at
i
ongr
owt
handdomes
t
i
cet
hni
candr
el
i
gi
ous
c
onfli
c
t
.
I
tal
s
of
ac
edhos
t
i
l
i
t
i
es
i
nt
hebr
oaderr
egi
on:
har
dl
yanaus
pi
c
i
ouss
t
ar
tf
oranew c
ount
r
y
.
Si
nc
et
hen,
Si
ngapor
ehasf
oc
us
edwi
t
hl
as
er
l
i
kepr
ec
i
s
i
ononbec
omi
ngasec
onomi
c
al
l
y
power
f
ul
as
pos
s
i
bl
e,
asf
as
taspos
s
i
bl
e.
Si
ngapor
ees
t
abl
i
s
hedi
t
s
el
ffir
s
tasac
ent
r
ef
or
l
owc
os
tmanuf
ac
t
ur
i
ng
andl
at
eronel
ec
t
r
oni
c
sand,
mor
er
ec
ent
l
y
,
l
i
f
es
c
i
enc
es
.
I
t
s
i
nnov
at
i
onc
r
edent
i
al
shav
es
t
r
engt
hened
s
i
nc
et
heear
l
y2000s
,
andi
ti
snowawor
l
d l
eadi
ngc
ent
r
ei
nar
eass
uc
hasbi
ot
ec
hnol
ogy
.
I
t
sper
f
or
manc
ei
sl
ar
gel
ydownt
ot
hr
eef
ac
t
or
s
:
t
al
ent
,
s
uppor
t
i
v
egov
er
nmentpol
i
c
y
,
and di
r
ec
t
publ
i
ci
nv
es
t
ment
.
Thefir
s
ti
st
her
es
ul
tofas
us
t
ai
nedpubl
i
cc
ommi
t
mentt
o educ
at
i
on.
Fr
om av
er
y
l
owbas
e,
Si
ngapor
enowr
anksc
ons
i
s
t
ent
l
yatorneart
het
opof
mos
tmaj
orwor
l
deduc
at
i
onr
anki
ng
s
y
s
t
emsov
ert
hel
as
tdec
adeac
c
or
di
ngt
ot
heOECD.
t
r
at
egys
t
ar
t
edwi
t
ht
he‘
bui
l
di
ng’
s
t
ageof19591978,
whi
c
hs
awt
her
api
dc
ons
t
r
uc
t
i
on of
Thes
s
c
hool
s
,
mas
st
eac
herr
ec
r
ui
t
mentanduni
fic
at
i
onofas
i
ngl
eSi
ngapor
eaneduc
at
i
on s
y
s
t
em whi
c
h
wasf
ol
l
owedi
n1979t
o1996byi
mpr
ov
i
ngeduc
at
i
onqual
i
t
yt
hr
ought
oi
t
s
final
phas
e,
f
r
om 1997t
o
t
hepr
es
entday
,
whi
c
hwasf
oc
us
s
edonr
efinement
.
Duet
oi
t
ss
mal
l
popul
at
i
on,
Si
ngapor
eal
s
ol
ookedt
oat
t
r
ac
ts
t
udent
sf
r
om near
byc
ount
r
i
es
t
hr
ough
t
heASEANs
c
hol
ar
s
hi
p,
whi
c
hc
ov
er
sf
eesandt
ui
t
i
onf
orqual
i
fieds
t
udent
s
,
andt
he Tui
t
i
onGr
ant
Sc
heme(
TGS)f
ori
nt
er
nat
i
onal
s
t
udent
s
,
whi
c
hc
ov
er
supt
ot
ens
emes
t
er
sof
t
er
t
i
ar
yeduc
at
i
on.
Bot
h
s
c
hemesr
equi
r
et
hatgr
aduat
esr
emai
ni
nSi
ngapor
ef
orupt
o6 y
ear
sandf
or3y
ear
s
,
r
es
pec
t
i
v
el
y
.
Suc
ht
ac
t
i
c
s
,
aswel
l
asal
i
ber
al
i
mmi
gr
at
i
onpol
i
c
y
,
hav
e ai
dedgl
obal
i
nflowsofhi
ghl
ys
ki
l
l
edl
abour
,
l
eadi
ngt
ot
ec
hnol
ogyands
ki
l
l
st
r
ans
f
erbet
ween l
ar
gemul
t
i
nat
i
onal
sanddomes
t
i
cc
ompani
es
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s8
Suppor
t
i
v
egov
er
nmentpol
i
c
yal
s
opl
ay
edar
ol
e–t
hr
ougheffor
t
st
oc
r
eat
eaneffic
i
entand eas
y
bus
i
nes
senv
i
r
onment
,
anddi
r
ec
ti
nv
es
t
ment
s
.
Ast
heec
onomys
hi
f
t
edt
oknowl
edge bas
eds
ec
t
or
s
andt
hes
ki
l
l
sbas
ei
mpr
ov
ed,
t
hegov
er
nments
oughtt
oat
t
r
ac
tmul
t
i
nat
i
onal
c
ompani
esbyoffer
i
ng
t
axi
nc
ent
i
v
es
,
el
i
mi
nat
i
ngpol
i
t
i
c
al
c
or
r
upt
i
on,
andbol
s
t
er
i
ngI
P pr
ot
ec
t
i
on.
Al
ongwi
t
heas
eofbus
i
nes
sr
ef
or
ms
,
t
her
ear
eal
s
ogr
ant
st
oenc
our
agebus
i
nes
sf
or
mat
i
on and
s
t
ar
t
ups
,
s
uc
hast
heACESt
ar
t
upGr
ant
,
dedi
c
at
edt
onewl
yf
or
med,
l
oc
al
maj
or
i
t
y
owned
c
ompani
esdev
el
opi
ngadi
ffer
ent
i
at
edbus
i
nes
sc
onc
ept
.
Thegov
er
nmenthasbeen adi
r
ec
tac
t
i
v
e
i
nv
es
t
ori
nbr
oaderi
nnov
at
i
oni
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
est
oo,
s
pendi
ngar
ound$6bi
l
l
i
on bet
ween2000and
2005i
nbi
omedi
c
al
s
c
i
enc
esi
nc
l
udi
ngt
hef
or
mat
i
onofBi
opol
i
s
,
a bi
omedi
c
al
r
es
ear
c
hand
dev
el
opmenthub.
Thi
si
sper
hapsSi
ngapor
e’
smos
tpr
omi
s
i
ng c
l
us
t
er
.
Si
ngapor
ebeganl
ooki
ngt
obi
ot
ec
hnol
ogyi
nt
he2000st
odi
v
er
s
i
f
yi
t
sec
onomi
cbas
e,
and ut
i
l
i
s
eda
c
ombi
nat
i
onoft
axhol
i
day
sandi
nc
ent
i
v
es–s
uc
haspay
i
ngupt
o30% ofbui
l
di
ng c
os
t
sofc
ompani
es
under
t
aki
ngbas
i
cdr
ugr
es
ear
c
handdev
el
opment
.
I
t
sabi
l
i
t
yt
oat
t
r
ac
t
s
t
em c
el
l
i
nv
es
t
mentwasal
s
o
hel
pedbyar
educ
t
i
oni
nf
undi
ngi
nt
heUSduet
oet
hi
c
al
obj
ec
t
i
onsf
r
om t
heBus
hadmi
ni
s
t
r
at
i
on.
Si
ngapor
ei
sal
egal
l
ymor
el
i
ber
al
r
es
ear
c
h env
i
r
onment
,
al
l
owi
nganumberofr
es
ear
c
hpr
ac
t
i
c
es
,
s
uc
hasus
eoft
heear
l
ys
t
agehuman embr
y
osf
ort
her
apeut
i
cr
es
ear
c
h,
whi
c
hi
sbannedi
not
her
c
ount
r
i
es
.
Asar
es
ul
t
,
t
op bi
ot
ec
hnol
ogyexper
t
sf
r
om l
eadi
nges
t
abl
i
s
hment
ss
uc
hast
he
Mas
s
ac
hus
et
t
sI
ns
t
i
t
ut
esof
Tec
hnol
ogy
,
t
heNat
i
onal
Canc
erI
ns
t
i
t
ut
ei
nMar
y
l
andandt
heUni
v
er
s
i
t
y
ofCal
i
f
or
ni
ahav
e c
omet
oSi
ngapor
eov
ert
hel
as
tdec
ade,
c
i
t
i
nggr
eat
erf
undi
ng,
mor
eor
gani
s
at
i
onal
f
r
eedom,
amor
el
i
ber
al
r
es
ear
c
hpol
i
c
y
,
andagr
eat
erappr
ec
i
at
i
onoft
hebenefit
sofl
ong t
er
m R&D.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s9
Abus
yi
s
l
and
Sof
ar
,
Si
ngapor
ehass
uc
c
es
s
f
ul
l
yadapt
edi
t
smodel
t
hr
ougheac
hs
uc
c
es
s
i
v
es
t
age–
mov
i
ngf
r
om l
ow
c
os
tmanuf
ac
t
ur
i
ngt
oel
ec
t
r
oni
c
st
oamor
edi
v
er
s
i
fiedec
onomy
,
pos
i
t
i
oni
ngi
t
s
el
fasahubf
or
mul
t
i
nat
i
onal
swi
s
hi
ngt
obui
l
dt
hei
rAs
i
anbus
i
nes
s
es
.
Nes
t
l
e,
Abbot
tLabor
at
or
i
esandGoogl
ear
e
amongt
hec
ompani
eswhohav
eev
ens
etupr
es
ear
c
h i
ns
t
i
t
ut
esi
nSi
ngapor
e.
Butaswi
t
hal
l
c
l
us
t
er
sandhi
ghl
ypr
oduc
t
i
v
eec
onomi
cgeogr
aphi
es
,
i
tf
ac
esemer
gi
ng c
hal
l
enges–
es
pec
i
al
l
ywi
t
hr
egar
dst
ot
hewor
kf
or
c
e.
Whi
l
ei
mmi
gr
at
i
onbr
i
ngsnewwor
ker
s
andi
deast
ot
hehos
t
c
ount
r
y
,
i
ti
snotwi
t
houtr
i
s
ks
.
Si
ngapor
ei
sas
mal
l
i
s
l
and,
r
oughl
yhal
f
t
hes
i
z
eofLondon,
and
t
wot
hi
r
dst
hes
i
z
eofHongKong,
andi
shomet
o5,
469,
700peopl
e.
Thepopul
at
i
onhasi
nc
r
eas
edby
3% annual
l
yf
r
om 2005t
o2013,
ac
c
or
di
ngt
ot
heWor
l
d Bank,
andpopul
at
i
ondens
i
t
y
,
meas
ur
edas
t
henumberofpeopl
epers
quar
eki
l
omet
er
,
has
i
nc
r
eas
ed27.
7% bet
ween2000and2013,
ac
c
or
di
ng
t
oSi
ngs
t
at
,
t
heSi
ngapor
eans
t
at
i
s
t
i
c
al
agenc
y
.
hepopul
at
i
onhasi
nc
r
eas
ed,
s
ohast
henumberofi
mmi
gr
ant
s
,
mor
et
handoubl
i
ng bet
ween
Ast
2000and2014.
Thes
t
r
ai
nonpubl
i
cs
er
v
i
c
es
,
andc
ompet
i
t
i
onf
ors
pac
e,
has
c
ombi
nedwi
t
h
ev
er
gr
owi
ngdemandf
orhous
i
ng,
i
nc
r
eas
i
ngpr
oper
t
ypr
i
c
esandpr
ompt
i
ng domes
t
i
cdi
s
s
ent
,
ac
c
or
di
ngt
oDrPohKanWong,
Di
r
ec
t
orofNat
i
onal
Uni
v
er
s
i
t
yof
Si
ngapor
e’
sEnt
r
epr
eneur
s
hi
p
Cent
r
e.
DrWongar
guest
hatf
or
ei
gni
mmi
gr
at
i
onhasper
hapsr
eac
hedac
r
i
t
i
c
al
mas
swher
e enc
l
av
esof
f
or
ei
gner
sar
es
t
ar
t
i
ngt
of
or
m,
r
educ
i
ngas
s
i
mi
l
at
i
onandi
nt
egr
at
i
on,
i
nt
ur
n under
mi
ni
ngt
hei
deaof
a’
Si
ngapor
eani
dent
i
t
y
’
.
Att
hes
amet
i
me,
pol
i
c
ymaker
sknowt
hat
t
heyar
ei
nar
ac
ef
orgl
obal
t
al
ent
andmus
tr
emai
nopent
ohi
ghl
ys
ki
l
l
edl
abour
.
Asar
es
ul
t
,
t
hegov
er
ni
ngpar
t
yhass
t
ar
t
edf
oc
us
i
ngon
fil
t
er
i
ngi
mmi
gr
at
i
on,
at
t
r
ac
t
i
nghi
ghl
ys
ki
l
l
ed i
mmi
gr
ant
st
hatc
anc
ont
r
i
but
et
oSi
ngapor
eont
he
gl
obal
v
al
uec
hai
nt
hr
oughknowl
edge andt
ec
hnol
ogyt
r
ans
f
er
,
whi
l
emaki
ngi
tmor
edi
ffic
ul
tf
orl
ower
s
ki
l
l
edi
mmi
gr
ant
st
os
et
t
l
e.
Aswi
t
hal
l
c
l
us
t
er
s
,
Si
ngapor
e’
ss
uc
c
es
sc
r
eat
edi
t
sownnewpr
obl
ems
,
whi
c
ht
hec
i
t
ys
t
at
e hast
oadaptt
o.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s10
Par
t4:
Pl
uckyEs
t
oni
a:Eas
t
er
nEur
ope’
s
s
t
ar
t
up
BRI
EFI
NGPAPER
WRI
TTEN BYTHEECONOMI
STI
NTELLI
GENCEUNI
T
Fr
om modes
tbegi
nni
ngs
,t
hi
ss
mal
lEas
tEur
opeanec
onomyhast
ur
ned
c
hal
l
engesi
nt
ooppor
t
uni
t
i
es
,evenl
ever
agi
ngc
ybert
hr
eat
st
ogr
ow i
t
s
t
el
ec
omsi
ndus
t
r
y.Des
pi
t
ebei
ngas
mal
lc
ount
r
yofj
us
t1.
3mi
l
l
i
onpeopl
e,
Es
t
oni
ahaspr
oduc
edoneoft
hemos
tdr
amat
i
ct
ec
hdi
s
r
upt
er
soft
he
moder
ner
a:Skype.Hi
ghqual
i
t
ys
ki
l
l
sandadi
gi
t
al
s
avvypopul
at
i
onput
t
hi
sonc
ebar
r
enec
onomyont
het
ec
hnol
ogymap.
Keyt
akeaways–
Es
t
oni
a’
st
ec
hs
ec
t
ori
st
hepr
oduc
tofauni
quehi
s
t
or
y
,
i
nc
l
udi
ngan
engi
neer
i
ngf
oc
us
ededuc
at
i
ons
y
s
t
em i
nt
heUSSRer
a
Gov
er
nmenthasac
t
i
v
el
yr
ol
l
edoutdi
gi
t
al
t
ec
hnol
ogi
esi
nav
ar
i
et
yofc
i
t
i
z
en
s
er
v
i
c
es
,
boos
t
i
ngt
hedi
gi
t
al
s
ki
l
l
sl
ev
el
soft
hec
ount
r
y
’
sc
i
v
i
l
i
ans
.
TheEs
t
oni
an
gov
er
nmenthasal
s
oi
nv
es
t
edi
nR&D,
t
r
i
pl
i
ngR&Ds
pendi
ng,
f
r
om 0.
6% ofGDP
i
n2000t
o1.
7% i
n2013
t
oni
ahast
ur
nedc
hal
l
engesi
nt
ooppor
t
uni
t
i
es
.
Thec
ount
r
y
’
shi
ghI
CT
Es
penet
r
at
i
onr
at
el
ef
ti
texpos
edt
oc
y
ber
c
r
i
me,
l
eadi
ngent
r
epr
eneur
st
oexpl
or
e
newway
sofboos
t
i
ngs
ec
ur
i
t
y
.
Sky
peandKaz
aawer
eamongt
her
es
ul
t
i
ng
i
nnov
at
i
ons
.
WhenEs
t
oni
agai
nedi
ndependenc
ef
r
om t
heSov
i
etUni
oni
n1991,
i
twasas
mal
l
c
ount
r
ywi
t
hl
i
t
t
l
e
i
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
e.
Yetoneoft
hebenefit
sofi
t
sSov
i
etpas
twasegal
i
t
ar
i
anac
c
es
st
ohi
ghereduc
at
i
onas
wel
l
asEs
t
oni
a’
ss
t
r
at
egi
ci
mpor
t
anc
et
ot
heUSSRdur
i
ngt
heCol
dWar
,
whi
c
hc
r
eat
edanat
i
v
e
popul
at
i
onwi
t
hhi
ghl
ev
el
sofeduc
at
i
oni
nfiel
dsr
el
ev
antt
oemer
gi
ngt
ec
hnol
ogys
ec
t
or
s
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s11
Sov
i
et
er
aeduc
at
i
onf
oc
us
edheav
i
l
yons
c
i
enc
e,
engi
neer
i
ngandmat
hemat
i
c
s
.
Thepos
t
1991
gov
er
nmental
s
oi
nv
es
t
edheav
i
l
yi
nt
heknowl
edgeec
os
y
s
t
em.
I
n2015,
30.
7% of5564y
earol
dswer
e
educ
at
edt
ot
er
t
i
ar
ydegr
eel
ev
el
,
t
hehi
ghes
ti
nEur
opeandt
hes
i
xt
hhi
ghes
ti
nt
heOECD.
The
Es
t
oni
angov
er
nmental
mos
tt
r
i
pl
edR&Ds
pendi
ng,
f
r
om 0.
6% ofGDPi
n2000t
o1.
7% i
n2013,
andi
n
2011and2012Es
t
oni
as
pentabov
et
heEUav
er
agebef
or
el
ower
i
ngs
pendi
ngi
n2013.
TheEs
t
oni
angov
er
nmentdi
dnotj
us
tdev
el
ops
ki
l
l
s–i
tal
s
oi
nv
es
t
edi
ndi
gi
t
al
t
ec
hnol
ogyf
orpubl
i
c
s
er
v
i
c
es
,
c
r
eat
i
ngapopul
at
i
onof‘
di
gi
t
al
nat
i
v
es
’
.
Wheni
tgai
nedi
ndependenc
e,
r
oughl
yhal
foft
he
popul
at
i
onhadac
c
es
st
oal
andl
i
nephone,
butbyMay2013,
4Gs
er
v
i
c
esenc
ompas
s
edov
er95per
c
entoft
hec
ount
r
y
.
By1997,
97% ofs
c
hool
shadi
nt
er
netac
c
es
sand,
begi
nni
ngi
n2001,
publ
i
cwi
fi
bec
amemor
eorl
es
subi
qui
t
ous
.
1
EUmember
s
hi
phasal
s
ohel
pedai
di
ngEs
t
oni
at
os
hi
f
tf
r
om al
owwage,
l
owv
al
uedaddedec
onomy
t
hatf
oc
us
edonmanuf
ac
t
ur
i
ngandagr
i
c
ul
t
ur
al
expor
t
st
ot
heUSSRt
oas
er
v
i
c
es
ec
t
oror
i
ent
ed
26
ec
onomyt
hatexpor
t
shi
ghv
al
ueaddedt
ec
hnol
ogygl
obal
l
y
.
4% ofEs
t
oni
ansnowwor
ki
nt
he
s
er
v
i
c
es
ec
t
orc
ompar
edt
o20% i
nmanuf
ac
t
ur
i
ngand4% i
nagr
i
c
ul
t
ur
e,
ands
t
andar
dsofl
i
v
i
nghav
e
i
nc
r
eas
eddr
amat
i
c
al
l
y
:
GDPperc
api
t
ai
nc
r
eas
edf
r
om 55% oft
heEUav
er
agei
n2004t
o73% i
n2014
3
(
t
heear
l
i
es
ty
ear
sf
orwhi
c
hEur
os
t
atpr
ov
i
desc
ompar
abl
edat
a)
.
1.TheEur
opeanBankf
orRec
ons
t
r
uc
t
i
onandDev
el
opment
,
“
Tr
ans
i
t
i
onRepor
t2014:Chapt
er5,
Pol
i
c
i
esSuppor
t
i
ngI
nnov
at
i
on“
2.I
n1997,
t
heear
l
i
es
ty
earf
orwhi
c
ht
heOECDpr
ov
i
desdat
a,
uni
tl
abourc
os
t
swer
e40% oft
he2010l
ev
elandi
nc
r
eas
edbyr
oughl
y5.
87% annual
l
yf
r
om 1997t
o2012
3.Eur
os
t
at
,
“
GDPperc
api
t
ai
nPP“
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s12
EUmember
s
hi
pal
s
obr
oughtac
c
es
st
oEUs
t
r
uc
t
ur
al
f
undsandt
heSi
ngl
eMar
ket
.
Ther
el
at
i
v
el
ys
mal
l
s
i
z
eoft
heEs
t
oni
anec
onomyal
ongwi
t
hdomes
t
i
cpol
i
t
i
c
al
oppos
i
t
i
ont
ot
hegov
er
nmentr
unni
nga
budgetdefic
i
t
,
c
anmakei
tdi
ffic
ul
tf
ort
hegov
er
nmentt
oi
nv
es
ti
nl
ar
ges
c
al
epr
oj
ec
t
sl
i
ker
oadsand
hos
pi
t
al
s
.
Dur
i
ng2007–2013,
EUSt
r
uc
t
ur
al
Fundspr
ov
i
ded3.
4bi
l
l
i
oneur
of
orR&Dandhos
pi
t
al
i
nv
es
t
ment
s
,
t
hef
or
mert
os
uppor
tt
heEs
t
oni
anI
CTs
ec
t
orandt
hel
at
t
ert
of
os
t
eri
nnov
at
i
onst
o
4
Es
t
oni
a’
spr
es
s
i
ngdemogr
aphi
cpr
obl
ems
.
Si
ngl
eMar
ketac
c
es
si
nc
r
eas
edgai
nsf
r
om t
r
adeandt
ec
hnol
ogyandknowl
edget
r
ans
f
er
.
Bec
aus
e
Es
t
oni
ahasar
el
at
i
v
el
ys
mal
l
domes
t
i
cmar
ket
,
manyofi
t
sfir
mshav
et
ol
ookt
oexpandext
er
nal
l
yas
s
oonaspos
s
i
bl
e,
andhav
ei
nt
hepr
oc
es
si
nc
r
eas
edr
egi
onal
t
r
adedr
amat
i
c
al
l
y
.
Ei
ghtofEs
t
oni
a’
st
op
t
ent
r
adi
ngpar
t
ner
sar
eEUmember
sandi
n2013,
bet
weent
het
opfiv
eEur
opeanUni
ont
r
adi
ng
par
t
ner
s
,
bi
l
at
er
al
t
r
adeequal
l
ed7.
78bi
l
l
i
oneur
oi
ni
mpor
t
sand7.
365i
nexpor
t
sc
ompar
edt
o1995
whent
r
adeequal
l
ed1.
495bi
l
l
i
oni
ni
mpor
t
sand1.
141bi
l
l
i
oni
nexpor
t
s
.
5Hi
s
t
or
i
c
al
l
i
nkageswi
t
h
Sc
andi
nav
i
anandNor
di
cc
ount
r
i
esal
s
omeant
hatmanyEs
t
oni
anss
peakEngl
i
s
h.
55% ofEs
t
oni
ans
s
peakEngl
i
s
hf
orwor
k,
doubl
et
heEUav
er
age,
and67% hav
el
ear
nedaf
or
ei
gnl
anguagef
orwor
k,
6%
6
hi
ghert
hant
heEUav
er
age.
EUmember
s
hi
p,
howev
er
,
hasexac
er
bat
edpr
obl
emsas
s
oc
i
at
edwi
t
hEs
t
oni
a’
sdec
l
i
ni
ngandagei
ng
popul
at
i
on.
Wi
t
hhal
fofEs
t
oni
ansfluenti
nEngl
i
s
h,
emi
gr
at
i
onf
r
om Es
t
oni
ai
nc
r
eas
edbyr
oughl
y50%
i
n2005,
t
hey
earaf
t
eri
t
sas
c
ens
i
ont
ot
heEU.
Thi
swases
pec
i
al
l
yt
hec
as
eamongt
hey
oung,
33% of
whom s
peakEngl
i
s
hasas
ec
ondl
anguage,
andwhof
ac
edanav
er
ageunempl
oy
mentr
at
eof14.
3% f
r
om 2001t
o2014and17.
1% f
r
om 2009t
o
7
2014.
Al
t
houghanagei
ngpopul
at
i
onandy
out
hemi
gr
at
i
onhaspl
ac
edagr
eat
ers
t
r
ai
nonpubl
i
cs
er
v
i
c
esl
i
ke
heal
t
hc
ar
eandpens
i
ons
,
i
nnov
at
i
onshav
eal
s
oemer
ged.
I
n2011,
t
woEs
t
oni
ansl
i
v
i
ngi
nLondon,
UK,
oneofwhom wasor
i
gi
nal
l
yaSky
peempl
oy
ee,
wer
ef
r
us
t
r
at
edwi
t
hhav
i
ngt
opayhi
ghf
eest
ot
r
ans
f
er
moneybet
weent
het
woc
ount
r
i
esands
oes
t
abl
i
s
hedanowgl
obal
l
yr
ec
ogni
z
edmoneyt
r
ans
f
er
s
er
v
i
c
e,
Tr
ans
f
er
Wi
s
e,
i
nor
dert
os
endr
emi
t
t
anc
eshomef
r
om abr
oad.
4.KPMG,
“
EUFundsi
nCent
r
alandEas
t
er
nEur
ope“
5.
TheGov
er
nmentofEs
t
oni
a,
“
Es
t
oni
anec
onomyi
nnumber
s
“
6.TheEur
opeanCommi
s
s
i
on,
“
Eur
opeansandt
hei
rl
anguages
”J
ul
y2012.
7.LanguageKnowl
edgei
nt
heEur
opeanUni
on,
“
Es
t
oni
a”ac
c
es
s
ed27Nov
ember2015
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s13
I
nanat
t
emptt
obr
i
ngEs
t
oni
anent
r
epr
eneur
sbac
khome,
t
hegov
er
nmenti
sat
t
empt
i
ngt
o i
nc
r
eas
e
r
epat
r
i
at
i
onandi
mmi
gr
at
i
on,
f
os
t
er
i
ng‘
br
ai
nc
i
r
c
ul
at
i
on’
r
at
hert
han‘
br
ai
ndr
ai
n’
.
I
t
hasi
mpl
ement
ed
t
wokeypr
ogr
ams
:
t
heI
nt
egr
at
i
onandMi
gr
at
i
onFoundat
i
onandeRes
i
denc
y
.
TheFoundat
i
on
pr
ov
i
desfinanc
i
al
s
uppor
tf
oret
hni
cEs
t
oni
answhohav
e emi
gr
at
edi
nt
hepas
tt
eny
ear
sandwi
s
ht
o
r
epat
r
i
at
e.
Ov
ert
hec
our
s
eof2000–2012,
i
t
hass
uppor
t
edt
her
et
ur
nofov
er1100peopl
e.
8T
he
eRes
i
denc
ypr
ogr
am hasbeenmor
e s
uc
c
es
s
f
ul
.
Wi
t
ht
heai
m ofc
ompet
i
ngf
ori
nt
er
nat
i
onal
bus
i
nes
s
wi
t
hot
herEUl
oc
at
i
onsl
i
ke Dubl
i
n,
I
r
el
and,
mai
nt
ai
nl
i
nkageswi
t
hEs
t
oni
a’
sr
el
at
i
v
el
yl
ar
gedi
as
por
a,
oi
nc
r
eas
et
he l
i
kel
i
hoodt
hatbus
i
nes
sowner
swi
l
l
mov
et
oEs
t
oni
a,
t
hepr
ogr
am makesopeni
ng
andt
and r
unni
ngabus
i
nes
seas
y
.
I
ndi
v
i
dual
sar
eal
l
owedt
oes
t
abl
i
s
honl
i
nefir
msi
nEs
t
oni
a,
s
i
gn c
ont
r
ac
t
s
r
emot
el
y
,
andpayt
axeswhi
l
er
unni
ngt
hei
rbus
i
nes
sr
emot
el
y
.
9S
i
nc
ei
t
sl
aunc
hi
n Dec
ember2014,
10
7000peopl
ef
r
om 119c
ount
r
i
eshav
eappl
i
ed,
and6600hav
ebeen gr
ant
eder
es
i
denc
y
.
Es
t
oni
as
t
andsoutasanexc
el
l
entexampl
eofhowgov
er
nmenti
nv
es
t
menti
nt
hebr
oaderi
nnov
at
i
on
ec
os
y
s
t
em –s
panni
ngeduc
at
i
on,
di
gi
t
al
s
er
v
i
c
edel
i
v
er
y
,
R&Ds
pendi
ng,
gl
obal
mar
ket
i
ngand
f
os
t
er
i
ngs
t
r
at
egi
ct
r
adepar
t
ner
s
hi
ps–c
anc
at
al
y
s
ec
l
us
t
er
s
.
I
tal
s
ohel
pst
hat
,
ac
c
or
di
ngt
oDor
i
s
Põl
d,
t
heEs
t
oni
anI
CTCl
us
t
er
’
sCl
us
t
erPr
oj
ec
tManager
,
at
r
adebodyf
orEs
t
oni
anI
CTfir
ms
,
‘
t
he
gov
er
nmentar
et
het
r
uebel
i
ev
er
s
.
Theyal
way
ss
peakaboutEs
t
oni
aandt
heI
CTs
ec
t
orwhent
heygo
onoffic
i
al
v
i
s
i
t
s
.
Theyar
et
hebes
tmar
ket
i
ngpeopl
e.
’
8.
TheI
nt
egr
at
i
onandMi
gr
at
i
onFoundat
i
on,
“
Mi
gr
at
i
ons
t
at
i
s
t
i
c
s
”
9.eEs
t
oni
a,
“
Es
t
oni
aneRes
i
denc
y
”
10.Gov
er
nmentoft
heRepubl
i
cofEs
t
oni
a,
“
Es
t
oni
aneRes
i
denc
ySt
at
i
s
t
i
c
s
“
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s14
Par
t5:
At
al
entmagnet
:TheBeaut
yof
Boul
der
BRI
EFI
NGPAPER
WRI
TTEN BYTHEECONOMI
STI
NTELLI
GENCEUNI
T
Boul
der
,i
nCol
or
ado,hasoneoft
hehi
ghes
ti
nnovat
i
onr
at
esi
nt
heUSas
meas
ur
edby pat
entappl
i
c
at
i
ons
.I
t
squal
i
t
yofl
i
f
ehasbeenes
s
ent
i
alt
o
at
t
r
ac
t
i
ngAmer
i
c
a’
sbes
tand br
i
ght
es
t
.
Smar
tpeopl
ear
enotj
us
ti
nt
er
es
t
edi
nwor
k:
t
heyal
s
oc
ar
eaboutt
hei
rs
ur
r
oundi
ngs
,
t
he qual
i
t
yof
s
c
hool
sandhos
pi
t
al
s
,
l
ei
s
ur
eandent
er
t
ai
nmentandal
l
mannerofl
i
f
es
t
y
l
ef
ac
t
or
s
.
Young,
t
al
ent
ed,
pr
of
es
s
i
onal
wor
ker
sc
anr
el
oc
at
emor
eeas
i
l
yt
hant
hos
ewi
t
hl
ar
ger
f
ami
l
i
esandmor
e
r
es
pons
i
bi
l
i
t
i
es
.
Ther
ear
ehi
gh‘
oppor
t
uni
t
yc
os
t
s
’
ofl
oc
at
i
on,
s
ot
hey
hav
edemandedv
i
br
ant
nei
ghbour
hoodst
hatofferat
t
r
ac
t
i
v
eameni
t
i
es
,
s
uc
hasac
c
es
st
o c
ul
t
ur
al
r
es
our
c
esandhi
ghr
anki
ng
publ
i
cs
c
hool
s
.
Wi
t
houts
uc
hi
ngr
edi
ent
s
,
c
l
us
t
er
sc
anf
ai
l
bef
or
et
heyev
enbegi
n.
I
nHongKong,
t
he gov
er
nmentbui
l
t
‘
Cy
ber
por
t
’
,
al
ar
gec
ampuswher
eent
r
epr
eneur
sc
oul
dr
entc
heapoffic
e s
pac
eandc
ol
l
abor
at
e.
The
c
l
us
t
erf
ai
l
edduet
oi
t
sdi
s
t
anc
ef
r
om t
hec
i
t
yc
ent
r
e,
wher
e peopl
ewant
edt
ol
i
v
eandwor
k.
I
n
c
ont
r
as
t
,
t
het
ownofBoul
deri
nCol
or
adohasat
t
r
ac
t
ed t
al
entf
r
om ar
oundt
heUSt
hankst
oi
t
s
des
i
r
abi
l
i
t
yasapl
ac
et
ol
i
v
e.
deri
sat
ownofar
ound100,
000peopl
et
hatpunc
hesabov
ei
t
swei
ghtasani
nnov
at
i
on hub.
I
t
Boul
hast
hemos
thi
ghl
yeduc
at
edpopul
at
i
onofanyAmer
i
c
anc
i
t
y
.
Fr
om 2009t
o2013,
t
her
ewer
e10
pat
ent
sper1,
000r
es
i
dent
s
,
t
hefif
t
hhi
ghes
ti
nt
heUS,
af
t
erSanJ
os
e,
Cal
i
f
or
ni
a,
andabov
eSan
Fr
anc
i
s
c
o.
I
ti
shomet
oc
l
us
t
er
sofaer
os
pac
ec
ompani
esl
i
keBal
l
Aer
os
pac
eandTec
hnol
ogi
es
Cor
por
at
i
on,
oneoft
het
op100def
enc
ec
ont
r
ac
t
or
si
nt
he wor
l
d,
andbi
os
c
i
enc
esc
ompani
esl
i
ke
Cov
i
di
en.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s15
Par
tofBoul
der
’
sc
l
us
t
ers
t
at
usi
s“
t
hankst
ol
ar
gec
or
por
at
i
ons
,
auni
v
er
s
i
t
y
,
andpubl
i
c
l
y
f
unded
t
ec
hni
c
al
r
es
ear
c
hor
gani
s
at
i
onsl
oc
at
i
ngi
nBoul
deri
nt
hepas
t
,
whi
c
hl
edt
oal
ar
ge numberoffir
m
s
pi
noffs
,
”ac
c
or
di
ngt
oDrAndr
ewCor
bet
t
,
Pr
of
es
s
orofEnt
r
epr
eneur
s
hi
pat
Babs
onCol
l
egei
n
Mas
s
ac
hus
et
t
s
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s16
I
n1965I
BM es
t
abl
i
s
hedanoffic
e,
andf
oury
ear
sl
at
eragr
oupoft
ec
hni
c
i
ansl
ef
tt
of
ound St
or
ageTek.
Ov
ert
i
mebot
hc
ompani
esdowns
i
z
ed,
l
eav
i
ngmanyhi
ghl
ys
ki
l
l
edpeopl
ewi
t
h r
oot
si
nt
hel
oc
al
ar
ea.
Theyf
oundedc
ompani
est
hatei
t
hers
t
i
l
l
exi
s
tors
er
v
edast
he i
nc
ubat
or
sf
orl
at
erfir
ms
.
Muc
hoft
hi
s
t
al
entpool
hadaffil
i
at
i
onsandl
i
nkageswi
t
h gov
er
nmentr
es
ear
c
hor
gani
s
at
i
onsi
nt
hear
ea.
Buti
naddi
t
i
ont
ohi
s
t
or
i
c
al
happens
t
anc
e,
Boul
der
’
ss
uc
c
es
si
sal
s
ol
i
nkedt
oi
t
shi
gh per
f
or
manc
eon
l
i
v
eabi
l
i
t
ymet
r
i
c
s
.
Boul
der
’
spr
oxi
mi
t
yt
ot
heRoc
kyMount
ai
ns
,
i
t
spar
ksand out
doorac
t
i
v
i
t
i
es
,
and
c
ul
t
ur
al
andpubl
i
cameni
t
i
esl
i
kear
tgal
l
er
i
esandgoodpubl
i
c
s
c
hool
s
,
makef
oragoodqual
i
t
yofl
i
f
e
f
orr
es
i
dent
s
.
Bot
ht
hegov
er
nmentofBoul
derand Boul
der
’
spr
i
v
at
es
ec
t
orpl
ac
eemphas
i
sons
ki
l
l
s
at
t
r
ac
t
i
onandr
et
ent
i
onbec
aus
e“
i
ti
st
he s
ki
l
l
s
,
t
het
al
ent
,
andt
heexper
t
i
s
et
hati
sat
t
r
ac
t
i
ngt
he
wor
l
dc
l
as
ss
c
i
ent
i
s
t
s
,
engi
neer
s
,
ent
r
epr
eneur
s
,
t
hec
ompani
esandi
nv
es
t
mentt
hatar
ef
uel
l
i
ng
Boul
der
’
sec
onomy
,
”
ac
c
or
di
ngt
oCl
i
fHar
al
d,
Exec
ut
i
v
eDi
r
ec
t
orofBoul
derEc
onomi
cCounc
i
l
.
Opens
pac
esar
epar
toft
heoffer
i
ng.
I
n1967,
Boul
deri
nc
r
eas
edt
hefinanc
i
ngofl
and ac
qui
s
i
t
i
onsi
n
i
t
shi
nt
er
l
and.
Ac
c
or
di
ngt
oCl
i
fHar
al
d,
t
hes
eopens
pac
esnowac
c
ountf
or
t
hr
eequar
t
er
soft
ot
al
s
quar
emi
l
eagei
nBoul
der
,
andwer
epur
c
has
edt
opr
es
er
v
et
he env
i
r
onmentandqual
i
t
yofl
i
f
et
hat
l
oc
al
s
’
t
r
eas
ur
e,
andbl
oc
kur
bans
pr
awl
.
Tomai
nt
ai
nt
he c
i
t
y
’
sdev
el
opment
,
Boul
deres
t
abl
i
s
heda
bui
l
di
nghei
ghtl
i
mi
t
at
i
oni
n1971t
opr
es
er
v
et
he v
i
ewoft
heRoc
ki
es
.
Boul
der
’
sappr
oac
ht
opr
es
er
v
i
ngt
heenv
i
r
onmenthas
,
howev
er
,
s
ownt
hes
eedsofanew c
hal
l
enge:
l
i
mi
t
edhous
i
ngs
t
oc
k,
pus
hi
ngupr
ent
s
.
Publ
i
cupr
oaragai
ns
tr
ez
oni
ngofl
andt
o f
ac
i
l
i
t
at
e
c
ommer
c
i
al
pr
oper
t
ydev
el
opmenthashadnegat
i
v
ei
mpl
i
c
at
i
onsf
ort
hear
ea’
s
i
nnov
at
i
on.
Li
mi
t
ed
c
ommer
c
i
al
andr
es
i
dent
i
al
pr
oper
t
ydr
i
v
esuppr
i
c
es
,
r
ai
s
i
ngbar
r
i
er
sf
or
s
mal
l
erfir
ms
.
Rent
al
c
os
t
s
ar
enow20% hi
gherr
el
at
i
v
et
oCol
or
adoand26% hi
ghert
hant
he USav
er
age,
f
ori
ns
t
anc
e.
Hi
gh
pr
oper
t
yc
os
t
sc
anpus
hpeopl
et
ol
ar
gerc
i
t
i
esi
nt
hes
t
at
e,
l
i
keDenv
er
,
orar
easwi
t
hgr
eat
er
oppor
t
uni
t
i
est
os
c
al
eupandac
c
es
snat
i
onal
andgl
obal
mar
ket
s
,
l
i
keSanFr
anc
i
s
c
o.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s17
Par
t6:
TEcos
ys
t
em:Bangal
or
e’
sgr
owi
ng
pai
ns
BRI
EFI
NGPAPER
WRI
TTEN BYTHEECONOMI
STI
NTELLI
GENCEUNI
T
Bangal
or
ebec
ameoneoft
hef
as
t
es
tgr
owi
ngi
nnovat
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sout
s
i
de
oft
heUSi
nt
he1990s
.Butc
r
eaki
ngi
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
e,l
oos
ei
nt
el
l
ec
t
ual
pr
oper
t
yr
ul
esandc
ut
t
hr
oatc
ompet
i
t
i
onhavet
akent
hei
rt
ol
l
.
I
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sar
ec
ommonl
yas
s
oc
i
at
edwi
t
hweal
t
hyc
ount
r
i
es
,
butr
i
c
hc
ount
r
i
esnol
onger
enj
oyanunques
t
i
onedmonopol
yoni
nnov
at
i
on.
Emer
gi
ngmar
ket
shav
et
hei
rc
hal
l
enges–f
r
om
c
r
eakyi
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
et
obur
eauc
r
at
i
cl
egi
s
l
at
i
on–butt
heyal
s
ohav
euni
queadv
ant
agess
uc
hasl
ower
c
os
t
sand,
i
ns
omec
as
es
,
r
eadyav
ai
l
abi
l
i
t
yofaneduc
at
edandgl
obal
l
yc
ompet
i
t
i
v
ewor
kf
or
c
e.
Bangal
or
e’
sI
CTc
l
us
t
er
,
i
ns
out
her
nI
ndi
a,
i
st
hemos
ts
t
r
i
ki
ngexampl
eofanec
os
y
s
t
em t
hatl
ev
er
aged
i
t
shomec
ount
r
y
’
shumanc
api
t
al
adv
ant
ageeffec
t
i
v
el
y
.
Bangal
or
eemer
gedasoneoft
hel
ar
ges
tandf
as
t
es
tgr
owi
ngi
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sout
s
i
deoft
heUSi
n
t
he1990s
,
andi
st
odayt
heengi
neer
i
ng,
r
es
ear
c
handdev
el
opmentc
ent
r
eofI
ndi
a.
I
n2008,
i
twas
homet
o65% oft
hewor
l
d’
sI
Ts
er
v
i
c
esoffs
hor
i
ngbus
i
nes
s
,
andi
n2013ac
c
ount
edf
ornear
l
y40% of
t
hec
ount
r
y
’
st
ec
hnol
ogyands
of
t
war
edev
el
opmenti
ndus
t
r
y
.
Mi
c
r
os
of
t
,
I
BM,
Adobe,
andI
nt
el
al
l
hav
e
r
oot
si
nBangal
or
e,
al
ongs
i
demor
et
han800domes
t
i
cfir
msoffer
i
ngbac
kandmi
ddl
eoffic
et
as
ks
,
andawi
der
angeofanal
y
t
i
c
ss
er
v
i
c
est
ot
hegl
obal
mar
ket
.
Educ
at
i
oni
sakeys
uc
c
es
sf
ac
t
or
.
Bangal
or
ei
shomet
os
omeofI
ndi
a’
sandt
hewor
l
d’
st
opr
anked
educ
at
i
onal
i
ns
t
i
t
ut
i
onsf
orgr
aduat
eandpos
t
gr
aduat
es
t
udi
es
,
c
r
eat
i
ngas
t
r
ongpool
ofhi
ghl
ys
ki
l
l
ed
wor
ker
satr
el
at
i
v
el
yl
owc
os
t
sf
orgl
obal
c
or
por
at
i
ons
.
Bangal
or
eal
s
ol
ev
er
agedi
t
s9.
5t
o12.
5hour
t
i
medi
ffer
enc
et
ot
heUS.
I
tc
oul
dpr
ov
i
debac
kendt
ec
hnol
ogi
c
al
s
uppor
tt
hatdi
dnotneedt
obe
c
ol
oc
at
edwi
t
hf
r
ont
l
i
nebus
i
nes
sandc
oul
dbec
ar
r
i
edoutona24/
7r
ot
at
i
ngs
hi
f
tbas
i
s
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s18
Ac
c
or
di
ngt
oPr
of
es
s
orFl
or
i
anTäube,
Emi
l
eBer
hei
m Chai
rofEnt
r
epr
eneur
s
hi
patt
heUni
v
er
s
i
t
éLi
br
e
deBr
uxel
l
es
,
Bangal
or
eal
s
ohasa“
pl
eas
antc
l
i
mat
e,
s
i
mi
l
art
oNor
t
her
nCal
i
f
or
ni
a.
I
ti
sdr
ywi
t
h
moder
at
eamount
sofr
ai
n,
whi
c
hpr
ov
edagoodl
oc
at
i
onf
orhar
dwar
ebas
edt
ec
hnol
ogyfir
msand
l
abst
hatneededamoder
at
ec
l
i
mat
et
odor
es
ear
c
h,
bec
aus
eoft
hepot
ent
i
al
l
ydamagi
ngeffec
t
sof
heat
,
moi
s
t
ur
eandhumi
di
t
yonc
omponent
s
,
el
ec
t
r
i
c
al
par
t
sandI
Tequi
pment
.
Cool
erc
l
i
mat
esar
e
al
s
ohel
pf
ul
bec
aus
es
i
gni
fic
antI
Tas
s
et
semi
theatwhi
c
hc
anmor
eeas
i
l
ybemanagedi
ft
hegener
al
c
l
i
mat
ei
sc
ool
er
.
Peopl
eal
s
owant
edt
ol
i
v
et
her
e,
asi
twasmor
et
emper
at
et
hanot
herpar
t
sofI
ndi
a,
”
andt
hi
s“
ac
t
edl
i
keamagnetf
ori
ndi
v
i
dual
swi
t
hhi
ghl
ev
el
sofhumanc
api
t
al
i
nt
her
egi
on.
”
Di
r
ec
tpol
i
c
yal
s
opl
ay
edar
ol
ei
nBangal
or
e’
sev
ol
ut
i
on.
I
n1990,
t
heDepar
t
mentofEl
ec
t
r
oni
c
s
i
nt
r
oduc
edt
heSof
t
war
eTec
hnol
ogyPar
kss
c
heme–s
i
mi
l
art
oChi
na’
ss
pec
i
al
ec
onomi
cz
ones
,
f
or
Bangal
or
e.
Sof
t
war
efir
mswer
egi
v
ent
axc
ut
sf
orfiv
ey
ear
sandguar
ant
eedac
c
es
st
ohi
ghs
peed
s
at
el
l
i
t
el
i
nksandr
el
i
abl
eel
ec
t
r
i
c
i
t
y
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s19
USbas
edt
ec
hnol
ogyfir
msbeganoffs
hor
i
ngt
oBangal
or
e,
i
nc
ent
i
v
i
s
i
ngl
oc
al
SMEst
os
pec
i
al
i
s
ei
n
s
er
v
i
c
esl
i
kec
odi
ng.
I
ni
t
i
al
l
y
,
t
hi
sof
t
enmeanti
mpor
t
i
ngI
ndi
anpr
ogr
ammer
st
ot
heUSt
opr
ov
i
de
mai
nt
enanc
e.
Howev
er
,
i
n1993,
t
heUSmadei
tmor
edi
ffic
ul
tt
oobt
ai
nnoni
mmi
gr
antv
i
s
as
.
Thi
sl
ed
USfir
mst
oout
s
our
c
ewor
kbac
kt
oBangal
or
e.
I
ndi
anfir
msqui
c
kl
yadapt
edt
ot
her
equi
r
ement
sof
USfir
ms
,
f
orexampl
epunc
t
ual
del
i
v
er
yandpr
oduc
tqual
i
t
y
.
SomeI
ndi
anfir
msdev
el
opedr
eput
at
i
ons
asr
el
i
abl
es
uppl
i
er
si
nt
heUSmar
ket
,
s
uc
hasI
nf
os
y
s
.
Ov
ert
i
me,
t
heUSI
ndi
ar
el
at
i
ons
hi
pev
ol
v
edy
et
f
ur
t
her
.
Onc
eUSfir
mss
awt
hequal
i
t
yoft
opt
i
erI
ndi
anc
ompani
es
,
t
heybegant
oout
s
our
c
ei
nt
er
nal
R&Dt
as
ks
.
Howev
er
,
Bangal
or
enowf
ac
esi
t
sownpr
obl
ems
.
I
t
sabi
l
i
t
yt
oc
l
i
mbt
hev
al
uec
hai
nhasbeeni
nhi
bi
t
ed
byI
ndi
a’
sl
oos
es
t
anc
eoni
nt
el
l
ec
t
ual
pr
oper
t
ypr
ot
ec
t
i
on–f
or
ei
gnfir
msar
ei
nc
r
eas
i
ngl
yr
el
uc
t
antt
o
out
s
our
c
eR&D.
ManyofBangal
or
e’
sc
ompani
ess
t
i
l
l
pr
ov
i
des
t
andar
di
s
eds
er
v
i
c
esand,
bec
aus
et
her
e
ar
enows
omanyfir
ms
,
mul
t
i
nat
i
onal
shav
el
i
t
t
l
ei
nc
ent
i
v
et
oc
r
eat
eal
ongt
er
mr
el
at
i
ons
hi
pwi
t
hany
s
i
ngl
es
uppl
i
er
.
Themus
hr
oomi
ngofc
ompani
eshasl
edt
oapr
obl
em of‘
ov
er
c
ompet
i
t
i
on’
.
Asoft
oday
,
t
het
op20
I
ndi
ans
of
t
war
eexpor
t
er
sac
c
ountf
orov
er50% oft
ot
al
expor
t
s
,
l
eav
i
ngov
er800fir
mswi
t
ht
her
es
t
oft
hemar
ket
.
Compet
i
t
i
oni
sfier
c
eamongt
hebot
t
om 800,
l
eadi
ngt
oal
ac
kofc
ol
l
abor
at
i
on.
Bec
aus
ec
ompet
i
t
i
oni
ss
oaggr
es
s
i
v
e,
fir
msi
ns
t
i
l
i
nt
hei
rempl
oy
eesac
ul
t
ur
eof“
geti
tr
i
ghtt
hefir
s
t
t
i
me.
”Thi
smeansl
owl
ev
el
sofexper
i
ment
at
i
onandr
i
s
kt
aki
ng.
Asar
es
ul
t
,
Bangal
or
ei
sfindi
ngi
t
di
ffic
ul
tt
oc
l
i
mbt
hev
al
uec
hai
n.
Bangal
or
e’
ss
uc
c
es
shasal
s
oc
r
eat
edc
os
ti
nflat
i
onduet
or
i
s
i
ngwages
,
andc
onges
t
i
onhasi
nc
r
eas
ed.
I
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
epr
oj
ec
t
shav
ebeendi
ffic
ul
tt
oi
mpl
ementr
el
at
i
v
et
oChi
na,
oneofI
ndi
a’
smai
ngl
obal
c
ompet
i
t
or
s
.
Ev
enBangal
or
e’
snewai
r
por
t
,
bui
l
ti
n2008,
c
annotr
el
i
ev
et
het
r
affict
hatmakest
het
wo
mai
nt
ec
hnol
ogypar
ksi
nac
c
es
s
i
bl
edur
i
ngt
heday
,
ac
c
or
di
ngt
oCr
i
s
t
i
naChami
nade,
pr
of
es
s
orof
i
nnov
at
i
ons
t
udi
esatLundUni
v
er
s
i
t
y
.
Takent
oget
her
,
c
os
ti
nc
r
eas
es
,
l
owR&Dout
s
our
c
i
ngand
c
onges
t
i
onal
l
s
howt
heneedf
orBangal
or
et
oev
ol
v
ei
fi
twant
st
os
t
ayahead.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s20
Par
t7:
Concl
us
i
on:I
nnovat
i
oncl
us
t
er
s
:
TheSucces
sReci
pe
BRI
EFI
NGPAPER
WRI
TTEN BYTHEECONOMI
STI
NTELLI
GENCEUNI
T
TheEc
onomi
s
tI
nt
el
l
i
genc
eUni
texpl
or
est
he‘
bi
gs
i
x’
f
ac
t
or
sdr
i
vi
ng
s
uc
c
es
s
f
uli
nnovat
i
on c
l
us
t
er
s
.
I
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sar
ec
r
uc
i
al
l
abor
at
or
i
esi
nwhi
c
hnov
el
t
ool
s
,
t
ec
hnol
ogi
esandt
ec
hni
ques
ar
e
c
r
eat
edandappl
i
ed.
Butt
heyar
enotj
us
tt
he‘
bac
kgr
ound’
t
oi
nnov
at
i
on;
t
heyar
el
i
v
i
ng or
gani
s
ms
i
nt
egr
al
t
oev
er
y
t
hi
ngt
hathappenswi
t
hi
nt
hei
rwal
l
s
.
Not
woc
l
us
t
er
sar
et
he s
ame–andt
her
ec
anbe
nohar
dandf
as
t‘
f
or
mul
a’
f
orwhatmakesc
l
us
t
er
swor
k.
Butt
her
e ar
epr
i
nc
i
pl
esnec
es
s
ar
yf
orl
ay
i
ng
t
hegr
oundwor
kf
ors
uc
c
es
s
As
ki
l
l
edwor
kf
or
ce
Al
l
s
uc
c
es
s
f
ul
c
l
us
t
er
shav
eanedgewheni
tc
omest
ohumanc
api
t
al
,
ei
t
herl
oc
al
or
i
mpor
t
ed.
Thi
s
hi
ghl
ys
ki
l
l
edwor
kf
or
c
ehasemer
gedandmani
f
es
t
edi
ns
ev
er
al
way
s
.
A dens
enet
wor
koft
opt
i
er
hi
ghereduc
at
i
ones
t
abl
i
s
hment
shasbeenc
r
i
t
i
c
al
t
ot
hes
uc
c
es
sofSi
l
i
c
onRoundabout
i
nLondon,
Boul
deri
nCol
or
adoandBangal
or
e.
Es
t
oni
al
ac
kedt
hi
ski
nd ofuni
v
er
s
i
t
ynet
wor
k,
butc
ompens
at
ed
byhav
i
ngahi
ghl
yeduc
at
edpopul
at
i
ont
hankst
ot
he c
ount
r
y
’
sf
ai
r
l
yegal
i
t
ar
i
anac
c
es
st
oeduc
at
i
on
hi
s
t
or
i
c
al
l
y
,
but
t
r
es
s
edbyt
hegov
er
nment
’
s
eager
nes
st
opr
omot
edi
gi
t
al
s
ki
l
l
si
nt
hepopul
at
i
on.
ngapor
e,
wi
t
has
mal
l
popul
at
i
on,
l
ev
er
agedi
t
snat
i
onal
ac
ademi
ci
ns
t
i
t
ut
i
onsal
ongwi
t
ha t
al
ent
Si
at
t
r
ac
t
i
ons
t
r
at
egyandas
ol
i
dbus
i
nes
senv
i
r
onment–bot
hofwhi
c
hhav
egi
v
eni
ta s
t
r
ongnat
i
onal
wor
kf
or
c
ewhet
heri
ndi
genousorexpat
r
i
at
e.
Whi
l
enat
ur
al
r
es
our
c
eshav
e s
uppor
t
edt
heemer
genc
e
ofs
omec
l
us
t
er
si
nhi
s
t
or
y
,
t
heyar
eknowl
edgei
nt
ens
i
v
e phenomena.
Ski
l
l
senhanc
ement
,
c
ombi
ned
wi
t
hadi
v
er
s
i
fiedgl
obal
wor
kf
or
c
e,
hav
ebeen keyi
ngr
edi
ent
s
.
Accommodat
i
ngpol
i
cyf
r
amewor
ks
Gov
er
nment
shav
ear
ol
et
opl
ayi
npr
omot
i
ngc
l
us
t
er
s
,
butt
hei
ri
nt
er
v
ent
i
onsj
us
tasof
t
en pr
ev
ent
s
uc
c
es
sasc
ul
t
i
v
at
ei
t
.
Thebes
ti
nt
er
v
ent
i
onsar
enotnec
es
s
ar
i
l
yfis
c
al
andt
axat
i
on pol
i
c
i
esr
el
at
ed
s
pec
i
fic
al
l
yt
oac
l
us
t
er
,
butr
at
heri
nt
er
v
ent
i
onswhi
c
hs
uppor
tt
hebr
oader
i
nput
st
hatc
l
us
t
er
s
dependon,
s
uc
haseduc
at
i
on,
i
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
eandc
onnec
t
i
v
i
t
y
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s21
Mor
ei
mpor
t
ant
l
y
,
gov
er
nment
smus
tc
ar
ef
ul
l
ywei
ght
hei
mpac
tofot
herpol
i
c
yc
hanges
,
s
uc
has
mi
gr
at
i
onc
apsorv
i
s
ar
es
t
r
i
c
t
i
ons
,
ont
hei
rnat
i
onal
c
l
us
t
er
s
’
ac
c
es
st
ot
al
ent
.
The bes
tpr
ac
t
i
c
e
pr
i
nc
i
pl
ei
sf
orgov
er
nmentt
oi
nv
es
ti
nt
hef
undament
al
sandc
ont
i
nuous
l
y
ev
ol
v
et
henat
ur
eofi
t
s
i
nt
er
v
ent
i
onbas
edont
heneedsoft
hegr
owi
ngc
l
us
t
er
,
andl
eav
et
he s
pec
i
fic
soft
hei
nnov
at
i
on
c
l
us
t
erpr
oc
es
st
ot
hec
ompani
esandi
nnov
at
or
st
hems
el
v
es
.
Thei
nf
r
as
t
r
uct
ur
ei
mper
at
i
ve
Oneoft
hekeyc
har
ac
t
er
i
s
t
i
c
sofs
uc
c
es
s
f
ul
c
l
us
t
er
si
st
henet
wor
ki
ngt
hatt
heyenabl
eas
fir
ms
c
ol
l
abor
at
e,
ands
ki
l
l
edpeopl
ei
nt
er
mi
ngl
et
os
har
ei
deas
.
Fi
r
msneedt
oc
ol
l
abor
at
e wi
t
honeanot
her
andwor
ker
sneedf
r
eedom t
omov
e,
f
ormeet
i
ngs
uppl
i
er
s
,
c
l
i
ent
s
,
financ
i
er
sands
oon.
Thi
sr
equi
r
es
effic
i
enti
nf
r
as
t
r
uc
t
ur
est
hatc
anal
l
owwor
ker
st
omov
e ar
oundqui
c
kl
yandc
heapl
y
.
Expens
i
v
epubl
i
c
t
r
ans
por
t
,
orgr
owi
ngc
onges
t
i
ons
uc
has
f
ac
edbyBangal
or
e,
bot
hr
educ
et
heeffic
i
enc
yofc
l
us
t
er
s
wher
ei
tmat
t
er
smos
t
:
t
he i
nt
er
mi
ngl
i
ngofpeopl
eandi
deas
.
I
ti
swor
t
hl
ooki
ngt
ohi
s
t
or
yf
orpr
oof
:
ac
c
or
di
ngt
ot
he ec
onomi
s
tJ
os
ephSc
humpet
er
,
muc
hoft
hei
nnov
at
i
ont
hatemer
geddur
i
ngt
he
ear
l
yhi
gh gr
owt
hy
ear
soft
heUSc
ameaboutasadi
r
ec
tr
es
ul
toft
hebur
geoni
ngr
ai
l
r
oads
y
s
t
em.
Chanceandgoodf
or
t
une
Sadl
yf
orpl
anner
s
,
c
hanc
eandgoodf
or
t
unepl
ayar
ol
ei
ndet
er
mi
ni
ngt
hes
uc
c
es
sof
c
l
us
t
er
s
.
By
c
hanc
e,
wer
ef
ert
oal
l
oft
hos
edy
nami
c
swhi
c
hc
oul
dnothav
ebeenbr
ought
aboutwi
t
hf
or
es
i
ghtor
pur
pos
e,
butwhi
c
h–hav
i
ngexi
s
t
ed–c
amet
oc
at
al
y
s
ei
nnov
at
i
on.
Hi
s
t
or
i
c
al
c
i
r
c
ums
t
anc
ei
soneexampl
e.
Es
t
oni
a’
s
pas
tr
el
at
i
ons
hi
pt
ot
heUSSRhadt
wo i
mpac
t
soni
t
s
l
at
ert
ec
hnol
ogi
c
al
s
uc
c
es
s
:
hi
ghl
ev
el
sofeduc
at
i
on,
es
pec
i
al
l
yi
nmat
hsand engi
neer
i
ng,
duet
oan
egal
i
t
ar
i
aneduc
at
i
ons
y
s
t
em i
nt
heUSSRer
a,
andac
y
ber
s
ec
ur
i
t
y
t
hr
eati
nmor
er
ec
enty
ear
st
hat
i
mpel
l
edi
nnov
at
i
on.
Boul
derbui
l
tont
hedec
i
s
i
onofl
ar
ge t
ec
hnol
ogyc
ompani
est
ol
oc
at
et
her
ei
nt
he
di
s
t
antpas
tt
hats
etupapr
oc
es
soft
al
ent
c
i
r
c
ul
at
i
onl
eadi
ngt
os
pi
noffswhobec
amei
nnov
at
or
s
mor
er
ec
ent
l
y
.
aphyi
sal
s
oa‘
goodf
or
t
une’
f
ac
t
or
,
es
pec
i
al
l
yi
npos
i
t
i
oni
ngac
l
us
t
erc
l
os
et
okey
mar
ket
s
.
Cos
t
a
Geogr
Ri
c
ai
sagoodexampl
eofac
ount
r
ywhos
el
i
f
es
c
i
enc
esc
l
us
t
erhas
benefit
edf
r
om i
t
spr
oxi
mi
t
yt
oUS
mar
ket
s
.
Butc
r
uc
i
al
l
y
,
c
hanc
eandgoodf
or
t
unedoesnotmeant
her
ei
snor
ol
ef
orhumandec
i
s
i
ons
.
Compani
esandgov
er
nment
smus
tc
ons
c
i
ous
l
yr
ec
ogni
s
et
hebenefit
st
hats
uc
h happens
t
anc
e
oc
c
ur
r
enc
espr
ov
i
de,
andbui
l
dont
hem.
Ther
ear
epl
ent
yofc
ount
r
i
est
hat
wer
ef
or
mer
l
ypar
toft
he
USSR,
andar
es
t
i
l
l
c
l
os
el
yl
oc
at
edt
oRus
s
i
a,
t
hatdi
dnotbui
l
don t
hatasEs
t
oni
ahas
.
Si
mi
l
ar
l
y
,
t
her
e
ar
emanyc
ount
r
i
esi
nCent
r
al
Amer
i
c
awi
t
hpr
oxi
mi
t
yt
o t
heUS,
butwhohav
enotc
ar
v
edoutal
i
f
e
s
c
i
enc
esc
l
us
t
ers
uc
hasCos
t
aRi
c
a.
Low cos
ts
t
r
uct
ur
e
at
i
ngc
os
t
s
,
es
pec
i
al
l
yr
ent
sonc
ommer
c
i
al
pr
oper
t
y
,
hav
ebeenes
s
ent
i
al
dr
i
v
er
sof
c
l
us
t
er
Lowoper
s
uc
c
es
si
nt
heear
l
ys
t
ar
tupphas
es
.
Thi
sappl
i
est
or
ent
al
ofoffic
es
pac
ebutal
s
o t
her
es
i
dent
i
al
needs
oft
hewor
ker
s
.
Ot
herl
owc
os
t
sc
anal
s
ohel
p,
s
uc
hast
axbr
eakson i
nnov
at
i
onr
el
at
edac
t
i
v
i
t
i
es
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s22
Ov
ert
i
me,
l
owr
ent
al
c
os
t
sar
et
hefir
s
tadv
ant
aget
odi
s
appear–t
hi
si
sasneart
oahar
d l
awasone
c
anfindi
nt
hefiel
dofc
l
us
t
eranal
y
s
i
s
.
Themor
es
uc
c
es
s
f
ul
ac
l
us
t
er
,
t
hemor
e c
ompani
eswantt
o
l
oc
at
et
her
e,
pus
hi
ngupdemandont
hehous
i
ngs
t
oc
k.
Thi
sdy
nami
ci
s
har
dt
oer
adi
c
at
e,
butc
anat
l
eas
tbeoffs
etbypol
i
c
ymaker
si
ft
heywi
s
ht
oenabl
ef
ur
t
her
bui
l
di
ngt
hr
oughpl
anni
ngr
ef
or
ms
,
or
ev
eni
mpos
i
ngr
ent
al
c
aps
,
al
t
hought
hes
ear
e pol
i
t
i
c
al
l
ydi
ffic
ul
tt
oexec
ut
ei
npr
ac
t
i
c
e.
Li
veabi
l
i
t
y
I
nnov
at
i
onc
l
us
t
er
sar
ehi
ghper
f
or
mer
si
nt
er
msofl
i
v
eabi
l
i
t
y
,
atl
eas
tr
el
at
i
v
et
oot
herc
i
t
i
es
wi
t
hi
n
t
hei
rc
ount
r
i
eswher
et
al
ent
edwor
ker
smi
ghtot
her
wi
s
ec
hoos
et
ogo.
Li
v
eabi
l
i
t
yi
snot
as
pec
i
fic
met
r
i
candnot
woc
i
t
i
esoffert
hes
ameadv
ant
ages
.
Buti
tc
anc
ov
ers
uc
hc
r
i
t
i
c
al
i
s
s
uesaspubl
i
c
s
af
et
yandpol
i
t
i
c
al
s
t
abi
l
i
t
y
,
goodpubl
i
cameni
t
i
es
,
c
ul
t
ur
eand ent
er
t
ai
nment
,
andgoods
c
hool
sand
hos
pi
t
al
s
.
Thes
ear
eal
l
f
ac
t
or
swhi
c
hpol
i
c
ymaker
sor
publ
i
ci
ns
t
i
t
ut
i
onsc
ani
nfluenc
ei
ft
heywantt
o
nur
t
ur
ec
l
us
t
ers
uc
c
es
s
,
i
nor
dert
oens
ur
e t
hei
rc
l
us
t
erappeal
st
ot
hos
et
opt
i
ers
ki
l
l
edwor
ker
swho,
i
nt
hemoder
ner
amor
et
hanev
er
bef
or
e,
hav
es
omanyc
hoi
c
esaboutwher
et
ol
oc
at
et
hems
el
v
es
.
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s23
Whi
l
eev
er
yeffor
thasbeent
akent
ov
er
i
f
yt
heac
c
ur
ac
yoft
hi
si
nf
or
mat
i
on,
TheEc
onomi
s
t
I
nt
el
l
i
genc
eUni
tLt
d.
c
annotac
c
eptanyr
es
pons
i
bi
l
i
t
yorl
i
abi
l
i
t
yf
orr
el
i
anc
ebyanyper
s
onont
hi
s
r
epor
toranyoft
hei
nf
or
mat
i
on,
opi
ni
onsorc
onc
l
us
i
onss
etouti
nt
hi
sr
epor
t
.
Economi
s
tI
nt
el
l
i
genceUni
t
onomi
s
tI
nt
el
l
i
genc
eUni
t(
EI
U)i
st
hewor
l
d’
sl
eadi
ngr
es
our
c
ef
orec
onomi
candbus
i
nes
s
TheEc
r
es
ear
c
h,
f
or
ec
as
t
i
ng,
andanal
y
s
i
s
.
I
tpr
ov
i
desac
c
ur
at
eandi
mpar
t
i
al
i
nt
el
l
i
genc
et
oc
ompani
es
,
gov
er
nmentagenc
i
es
,financ
i
al
i
ns
t
i
t
ut
i
onsandac
ademi
cor
gani
z
at
i
onsar
oundt
hegl
obe,
i
ns
pi
r
i
ng
bus
i
nes
sl
eader
st
oac
twi
t
hc
onfidenc
es
i
nc
e1946.
Copyr
i
ght
© 2016TheEc
onomi
s
tI
nt
el
l
i
genc
eUni
tLi
mi
t
ed.
Al
l
r
i
ght
sr
es
er
v
ed.
Nei
t
hert
hi
spubl
i
c
at
i
onnorany
par
tofi
tmayber
epr
oduc
ed,
s
t
or
edi
nar
et
r
i
ev
al
s
y
s
t
em,
ort
r
ans
mi
t
t
edi
nanyf
or
m orbyany
means
,
el
ec
t
r
oni
c
,
mec
hani
c
al
,
phot
oc
opy
i
ng,
r
ec
or
di
ngorot
her
wi
s
e,
wi
t
houtpr
i
orper
mi
s
s
i
onoft
he
Ec
onomi
s
tGr
oup.
Whi
l
s
tev
er
yeffor
thasbeent
akent
ov
er
i
f
yt
heac
c
ur
ac
yofi
nf
or
mat
i
onpr
es
ent
ed
i
nt
hi
sdoc
ument
,
nei
t
herTheEc
onomi
s
tGr
oupnori
t
saffli
at
esc
anac
c
eptanyr
es
pons
i
bi
l
i
t
yorl
i
abi
l
i
t
y
f
orr
el
i
anc
ebyanyper
s
onont
hi
si
nf
or
mat
i
on.
LONDON
20CabotSquar
eLondon
E144QW
Uni
t
edKi
ngdom
Tel
:(
44.
20)75768000Fax:(
44.
20)75768500Emai
l
:l
ondon@ei
u.
com
NEW YORK
750Thi
r
dAvenue5t
hFl
oor
New Yor
k,NY10017,USTel
:(
1.
212)5540600Fax:(
1.
212)5860248
Emai
l
:newyor
k@ei
u.
com
HONG KONG
6001,Cent
r
alPl
aza
18Har
bourRoad
Wanchai
HongKong
Tel
:(
852)25853888
Fax:(
852)28027638
Emai
l
:hongkong@ei
u.
com
GENEVA
Ruedel
’
At
henee321206GenevaSwi
t
zer
l
andTel
:(
41)225662470
Fax:(
41)223469347
Emai
l
:geneva@ei
u.
com
©T
heE
c
onomi
s
tI
nt
e
l
l
i
g
e
nc
eUni
tL
i
mi
t
e
d2016
I
nnov
at
i
onCl
us
t
e
r
s
:Unde
r
s
t
andi
ngL
i
f
eCy
c
l
e
s24