PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF TEXAS
RETAIL MARKET OVERSIGHT SECTION - ELECTRIC DIVISION
RETAIL ELECTRIC SERVICE RATE COMPARISONS
DECEMBER 2006 BILL COMPARISON
AVERAGE ANNUAL RATE (CENTS PER KWH)
TDU Service Area
Retail Electric Provider
TXU Electric
Delivery
TXU ENERGY RETAIL - Price to
Beat
AVERAGE MONTHLY USAGE AND PERCENTAGE SAVINGS OFF OF PTB
%
%
%
500 kWh savings
1000 kWh
savings
1500 kWh
savings
2000 kWh
15.75
15.00
14.63
%
savings
14.45
AMIGO ENERGY
Deep Discount
Twelve-Month Commitment
12.71
13.35
19%
15%
11.90
12.54
21%
16%
11.90
12.54
14%
14%
11.90
12.54
13%
13%
Smart Saver 12
Smart Saver 24
13.99
14.17
11%
10%
13.25
13.41
12%
11%
12.94
13.08
12%
11%
12.94
13.06
10%
10%
COMMERCE ENERGY
Price Stopper
Variable Product
13.39
11.39
15%
28%
12.90
10.90
14%
27%
12.73
10.73
13%
27%
12.65
10.65
12%
26%
DIRECT ENERGY
14.00
11%
13.50
10%
13.33
9%
13.25
8%
DYNOWATT
14.78
6%
13.79
8%
13.46
8%
13.30
8%
FIRST CHOICE POWER
13.79
12%
13.30
11%
13.13
10%
13.05
10%
GEXA ENERGY
Best in Texas
Green Power
Guaranteed
14.50
13.48
15.81
15.00
8%
14%
0%
5%
13.52
12.50
14.83
14.02
10%
17%
1%
6%
13.20
12.18
14.51
13.70
10%
17%
1%
6%
13.04
12.02
14.35
13.54
10%
17%
1%
6%
GREEN MOUNTAIN ENERGY
100% Wind
Pollution Free
Pollution Free Reliable Rate
16.87
15.34
14.45
-7%
3%
8%
16.22
14.74
14.45
-8%
2%
4%
16.00
14.54
14.45
-9%
1%
1%
15.89
14.44
14.45
-10%
0%
0%
14.96
14.17
16.75
5%
10%
-6%
14.25
13.50
16.00
5%
10%
-7%
13.90
13.17
15.63
5%
10%
-7%
13.73
13.01
15.45
5%
10%
-7%
17.05
15.15
-8%
4%
16.02
14.42
-7%
4%
15.68
14.06
-7%
4%
15.51
13.89
-7%
4%
CIRRO ENERGY
RELIANT ENERGY
Flex
Fourteen-Month Secure
Renewable
TXU ENERGY
100% EarthWise
SummerSavings 24
This information is compiled and provided by the Public Utility Commission of Texas from publicly available information from the Retail Electric Providers and PUC approved price to beat rates. The average price shown on this
sheet was compiled from the Electricity Facts Labels of the REPs and is inclusive of all fixed and variable charges. The actual cost per kWh to a customer may vary based on the actual usage of the customer. The PUC makes no
recommendations with respect to any REP. Although we believe that these prices are accurate, the PUC makes no warranty that the prices in this table are currently being offered. Please contact the relevant REP for their current
pricing offers and terms of service. Information on how to select a REP and contact information for REPs is located at www.powertochoose.org.
PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF TEXAS
RETAIL MARKET OVERSIGHT SECTION - ELECTRIC DIVISION
RETAIL ELECTRIC SERVICE RATE COMPARISONS
DECEMBER 2006 BILL COMPARISON
AVERAGE ANNUAL RATE (CENTS PER KWH)
AVERAGE MONTHLY USAGE AND PERCENTAGE SAVINGS OFF OF PTB
TDU Service Area
Retail Electric Provider
CenterPoint Energy RELIANT ENERGY - Price to
Beat
Houston Electric
500 kWh
%
savings
15.68
1000 kWh
%
savings
16.29
1500 kWh
%
savings
16.22
2000 kWh
%
savings
16.14
AMIGO ENERGY
Deep Discount
Twelve-Month Commitment
12.64
13.84
19%
12%
11.90
13.10
27%
20%
11.90
13.10
27%
19%
11.90
13.10
26%
19%
Smart Saver 12
Smart Saver 24
14.19
14.49
9%
8%
13.45
13.75
17%
16%
13.20
13.50
19%
17%
13.14
13.44
19%
17%
COMMERCE ENERGY
Price Stopper
Variable Product
13.89
11.84
11%
24%
13.40
11.35
18%
30%
13.23
11.18
18%
31%
13.15
11.10
19%
31%
DIRECT ENERGY
15.10
4%
14.60
10%
14.43
11%
14.35
11%
DYNOWATT
15.10
4%
14.20
13%
13.90
14%
13.75
15%
FIRST CHOICE POWER
13.88
11%
13.70
16%
13.70
16%
13.70
15%
GEXA ENERGY
Best in Texas
Green Power
Guaranteed
15.10
13.78
16.90
15.60
4%
12%
-8%
0%
14.22
12.90
16.02
14.72
13%
21%
2%
10%
13.93
12.61
15.73
14.43
14%
22%
3%
11%
13.78
12.46
15.58
14.28
15%
23%
3%
11%
GREEN MOUNTAIN ENERGY
100% Wind
Pollution Free
Pollution Free Reliable Rate
17.97
16.33
15.42
-15%
-4%
2%
17.31
15.74
15.42
-6%
3%
5%
17.09
15.54
15.42
-5%
4%
5%
16.98
15.44
15.42
-5%
4%
4%
2007 Secure
2007 Secure Wind
Flex
14.73
15.50
14.72
6%
1%
6%
15.36
16.16
15.35
6%
1%
6%
15.41
16.22
15.41
5%
0%
5%
15.31
16.11
15.30
6%
1%
5%
Freedom
SummerSavings 24
14.89
14.42
5%
8%
15.47
14.98
5%
8%
15.41
14.91
5%
8%
15.33
14.83
5%
8%
CIRRO ENERGY
RELIANT ENERGY
TXU ENERGY
This information is compiled and provided by the Public Utility Commission of Texas from publicly available information from the Retail Electric Providers and PUC approved price to beat rates. The average price shown on
this sheet was compiled from the Electricity Facts Labels of the REPs and is inclusive of all fixed and variable charges. The actual cost per kWh to a customer may vary based on the actual usage of the customer. The PUC
makes no recommendations with respect to any REP. Although we believe that these prices are accurate, the PUC makes no warranty that the prices in this table are currently being offered. Please contact the relevant REP
for their current pricing offers and terms of service. Information on how to select a REP and contact information for REPs is located at www.powertochoose.org.
PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF TEXAS
RETAIL MARKET OVERSIGHT SECTION - ELECTRIC DIVISION
RETAIL ELECTRIC SERVICE RATE COMPARISONS
DECEMBER 2006 BILL COMPARISON
AVERAGE ANNUAL RATE (CENTS PER KWH)
AVERAGE MONTHLY USAGE AND PERCENTAGE SAVINGS OFF OF PTB
500 kWh
%
savings
1000 kWh
%
savings
Texas-New Mexico
Power
FIRST CHOICE POWER - Price
to Beat
13.86
CIRRO ENERGY
13.75
1%
13.32
8%
13.29
9%
13.31
10%
COMMERCE ENERGY
Price Stopper
Variable Product
13.19
10.99
5%
21%
12.70
10.50
12%
27%
12.53
10.33
15%
30%
12.45
10.25
16%
31%
DYNOWATT
14.47
-4%
13.59
6%
13.29
9%
13.14
11%
GEXA ENERGY
Green Power
Guaranteed
14.38
15.36
14.88
-4%
-11%
-7%
13.51
14.49
14.01
7%
0%
3%
13.22
14.20
13.72
10%
3%
6%
13.08
14.06
13.58
11%
5%
8%
GREEN MOUNTAIN ENERGY
100% Wind
Pollution Free
Pollution Free Reliable Rate
16.49
14.99
14.11
-19%
-8%
-2%
15.84
14.40
14.11
-10%
0%
2%
15.62
14.20
14.11
-6%
3%
4%
15.51
14.10
14.11
-5%
5%
4%
Flex
Renewable
11.68
14.86
16%
-7%
12.27
15.46
15%
-7%
12.48
15.67
15%
-7%
12.59
15.77
15%
-7%
Freedom
SummerSavings 24
13.17
13.06
5%
6%
13.74
13.62
5%
6%
13.94
13.82
5%
6%
14.04
13.92
5%
6%
14.67
2000 kWh
%
savings
Retail Electric Provider
14.46
1500 kWh
%
savings
TDU Service Area
14.77
RELIANT ENERGY
TXU ENERGY
This information is compiled and provided by the Public Utility Commission of Texas from publicly available information from the Retail Electric Providers and PUC approved price to beat rates. The average price shown on
this sheet was compiled from the Electricity Facts Labels of the REPs and is inclusive of all fixed and variable charges. The actual cost per kWh to a customer may vary based on the actual usage of the customer. The PUC
makes no recommendations with respect to any REP. Although we believe that these prices are accurate, the PUC makes no warranty that the prices in this table are currently being offered. Please contact the relevant REP
for their current pricing offers and terms of service. Information on how to select a REP and contact information for REPs is located at www.powertochoose.org.
PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF TEXAS
RETAIL MARKET OVERSIGHT SECTION - ELECTRIC DIVISION
RETAIL ELECTRIC SERVICE RATE COMPARISONS
DECEMBER 2006 BILL COMPARISON
AVERAGE ANNUAL RATE (CENTS PER KWH)
TDU Service Area
Retail Electric Provider
AEP Texas Central
CPL RETAIL ENERGY - Price to
Beat
AVERAGE MONTHLY USAGE AND PERCENTAGE SAVINGS OFF OF PTB
%
%
%
500 kWh savings
1000 kWh
savings
1500 kWh
savings
2000 kWh
18.86
18.33
18.19
%
savings
18.12
AMIGO ENERGY
Deep Discount
Twelve-Month Commitment
12.18
13.49
35%
28%
11.40
12.71
38%
31%
11.40
12.71
37%
30%
11.40
12.71
37%
30%
Smart Saver 12
Smart Saver 24
13.99
14.29
26%
24%
13.25
13.55
28%
26%
12.94
13.24
29%
27%
12.94
13.24
29%
27%
COMMERCE ENERGY
Price Stopper
Variable Product
13.89
11.29
26%
40%
13.40
10.80
27%
41%
13.23
10.63
27%
42%
13.15
10.55
27%
42%
DYNOWATT
15.04
20%
14.02
23%
13.68
25%
13.51
25%
FIRST CHOICE POWER
14.09
25%
13.60
26%
13.43
26%
13.35
26%
GEXA ENERGY
Green Power
Guaranteed
12.54
15.46
13.04
34%
18%
31%
11.54
14.46
12.04
37%
21%
34%
11.20
14.12
11.70
38%
22%
36%
11.03
13.95
11.53
39%
23%
36%
GREEN MOUNTAIN ENERGY
100% Wind
Pollution Free
Pollution Free Reliable Rate
18.39
16.72
15.80
2%
11%
16%
17.74
16.12
15.80
3%
12%
14%
17.52
15.93
15.80
4%
12%
13%
17.41
15.83
15.80
4%
13%
13%
15.82
14.98
17.61
16%
21%
7%
15.33
14.52
17.14
16%
21%
6%
15.20
14.40
17.02
16%
21%
6%
15.14
14.34
16.96
16%
21%
6%
15.08
20%
15.08
18%
15.08
17%
15.08
17%
CIRRO ENERGY
RELIANT ENERGY
Flex
Fourteen-Month Secure
Renewable
TXU ENERGY
SummerSavings 24
This information is compiled and provided by the Public Utility Commission of Texas from publicly available information from the Retail Electric Providers and PUC approved price to beat rates. The average price shown on this
sheet was compiled from the Electricity Facts Labels of the REPs and is inclusive of all fixed and variable charges. The actual cost per kWh to a customer may vary based on the actual usage of the customer. The PUC makes no
recommendations with respect to any REP. Although we believe that these prices are accurate, the PUC makes no warranty that the prices in this table are currently being offered. Please contact the relevant REP for their current
pricing offers and terms of service. Information on how to select a REP and contact information for REPs is located at www.powertochoose.org.
PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF TEXAS
RETAIL MARKET OVERSIGHT SECTION - ELECTRIC DIVISION
RETAIL ELECTRIC SERVICE RATE COMPARISONS
DECEMBER 2006 BILL COMPARISON
AVERAGE ANNUAL RATE (CENTS PER KWH)
TDU Service Area
Retail Electric Provider
AEP Texas North
WTU RETAIL ENERGY - Price
to Beat
AVERAGE MONTHLY USAGE AND PERCENTAGE SAVINGS OFF OF PTB
%
%
%
500 kWh savings
1000 kWh
savings
1500 kWh
savings
2000 kWh
19.49
19.17
19.09
%
savings
19.05
CIRRO ENERGY
Smart Saver 12
Smart Saver 24
14.81
14.19
24%
27%
14.00
13.45
27%
30%
13.59
13.14
29%
31%
13.51
13.14
29%
31%
COMMERCE ENERGY
Price Stopper
Variable Product
12.29
10.19
37%
48%
11.80
9.70
38%
49%
11.63
9.53
39%
50%
11.55
9.45
39%
50%
DYNOWATT
16.36
16%
14.93
22%
14.45
24%
14.22
25%
FIRST CHOICE POWER
15.99
18%
15.50
19%
15.33
20%
15.25
20%
GEXA ENERGY
Green Power
Guaranteed
15.03
18.43
15.53
23%
5%
20%
13.62
17.02
14.12
29%
11%
26%
13.14
16.54
13.64
31%
13%
29%
12.91
16.31
13.41
32%
14%
30%
GREEN MOUNTAIN ENERGY
100 % Wind
Pollution Free
Pollution Free Reliable Rate
18.57
16.88
16.00
5%
13%
18%
17.91
16.29
16.00
7%
15%
17%
17.70
16.09
16.00
7%
16%
16%
17.59
15.99
16.00
8%
16%
16%
Flex
Fourteen-Month Secure
Renewable
15.82
14.99
17.75
19%
23%
9%
15.53
14.71
17.44
19%
23%
9%
15.46
14.65
17.36
19%
23%
9%
15.42
14.61
17.32
19%
23%
9%
TXU ENERGY
SummerSavings 24
15.47
21%
15.47
19%
15.47
19%
15.47
19%
TXU SESCO ENERGY
SERVICES - Price to Beat
15.38
RELIANT ENERGY
TXU-SESCO
14.62
14.19
13.97
This information is compiled and provided by the Public Utility Commission of Texas from publicly available information from the Retail Electric Providers and PUC approved price to beat rates. The average price shown on this
sheet was compiled from the Electricity Facts Labels of the REPs and is inclusive of all fixed and variable charges. The actual cost per kWh to a customer may vary based on the actual usage of the customer. The PUC makes
no recommendations with respect to any REP. Although we believe that these prices are accurate, the PUC makes no warranty that the prices in this table are currently being offered. Please contact the relevant REP for their
current pricing offers and terms of service. Information on how to select a REP and contact information for REPs is located at www.powertochoose.org.