1
1
2
STATE
3
DEPARTMENT
OF
NEW
YORK
OF
HEALTH
4
Knights
5
333
6
Rockaway
PUBLIC
of
Beach
Columbus
90th
3:00
8
May
Hall
Street
Beach,
7
HEARING
New
York
p.m.
10,
2012
9
10
11
P
12
NIRAV
R
E
13
S
R.
JAMES
15
RICHARD
17
18
19
N
T:
SHAW,
State
14
16
E
of
CLANCY,
COOK,
Office
CELESTE
M.
Commissioner
New
Health,
York
Office
of
Deputy
Commissioner,
of
Health
JOHNSON,
Department
EDGARDO
of
MARRERO,
of
Governmental
Systems
Regional
Affairs
Management
Director,
Health
Assistant
Moderator
20
21
22
23
24
25
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
2
2
1
2
SPEAKERS:
3
ELISA
4
MARY
5
DR.
CAMPA,
SETH
6
7
JOAN
Nurse
Nurse
GUTTERMAN,
Peoples
Choice
SOMMERMEIR,
8
9
HINKIN,
New
BERNIE
York
Hospital
Labor
State
FOYER,
President,
Representative,
Nurses
Association
Resident
10
UNIDENTIFIED
SPEAKER
11
SUSAN
former
12
DANIEL
13
RITA
14
ANNETTE
15
JOSEPH
16
PAUL
17
MICHELLE
18
RICHARD
BERGER,
semi-retired
19
BARBARA
LARKIN,
Resident
20
THE
HONORABLE
MALCOLM
SMITH,
21
THE
HONORABLE
SHIRLEY
HUNTLEY,
22
LEONA
STERN,
23
PETER
SALMON,
24
CLAIRE
25
PHYLLIS
GREEN,
ROSILLO,
CLOSKY,
LYNCH,
employee
Resident
former
CLARK,
Peninsula
Peninsula
employee
Resident
Resident
SCHUBERT,
Community
LEBOW,
former
activist
Peninsula
employee
EMT
State
Senator
State
Senator
Resident
Resident
THOMPSON,
REDWICK,
RN
Resident
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
3
3
1
2
SPEAKERS:
3
THE
HONORABLE
4
DR.
EDWARD
5
6
Far
YVETTE
7
8
WILLIAMS,
GLASGOW,
ROBERT
CAPANO,
ELIZABETH
11
LAURA
12
HARVEY
13
PAULA
RADER,
MACELLI,
KEVIN
16
KATHLEEN
17
THE
HOMISH,
19
MARNIE
20
UNIDENTIFIED
21
LOUIS
THE
25
LAURA
Peninsula
former
Helen
employee
employee
Marshall
Peninsula
former
ERIC
employee
Peninsula
employee
ULRICH,
City
Council
Resident
SPEAKER
District
24
Peninsula
Resident
DISALVIO,
MARILEE
Turner
representing
of
RYAN,
23
former
LAWLESS,
Member
Director
Bob
President
HONORABLE
22
District
RUDNICK,
15
President,
NAACP
former
Borough
18
former
SULIK,
Assemblywoman
President,
Congressman
10
TITUS,
NAACP
Rockaway
for
14
MICHELLE
Rockaway
Far
9
(Continued.)
23rd
Leader
KAUFMAN,
HONORABLE
HOPKINS,
Assembly
Resident
PHILIP
GOLDFEDER,
Assemblyman
Resident
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
4
4
1
2
SPEAKERS:
3
FELICIA
4
FLOYD
5
6
(Continued.)
JOHNSON,
SMITH,
Executive
Concerned
ANNETTE
7
ANNIE
IRVIN,
9
NORMAN
WARDEN,
former
MCGRATH,
11
DR.
DODAKIAN,
Peninsula
LILLIAN
BENJAMIN,
14
MAUREEN
KRAUSE,
15
SHAWN
16
MATT
17
MR.
18
QUEEN
19
STEVEN
20
Resident
former
employee
13
Resident
Resident
MCLENDON,
JODIS,
chaplain,
Resident
CHRISTINE
BISHOP,
Former
CEO,
I
Peninsula
GIVE
MCKAVAH,
MORE.
Resident
GREENBERG,
Past
Board
of
member,
Trustees
21
FRAN
STAFFIS,
22
JOAN
RENNEHAM,
Registered
Peninsula
Extended
24
MARGARET
25
CATHY
employee
Resident
Peninsula
23
Rockaway
Resident
10
12
of
Hospital
SILVERMAN,
WAYNE
Director,
Citizens
Peninsula
8
Resident
Resident
WAGNER,
MALLON,
Nurse,
Care
Facility
Resident
Resident
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
5
5
1
2
SPEAKERS:
3
ALISSA
4
KATIE
5
TOM
6
LANNIE
7
PAT
8
PHYLLIS
(Continued.)
RYAN,
Resident
QUINCERRA,
HANNON,
Peninsula
employee
Resident
KAZNER,
ROCHFORD,
9
former
Resident
Resident
PRAWZINSKI,
Former
Peninsula
employee
10
UNIDENTIFIED
11
ALEXIS
12
PETER
13
LAURIE
SPEAKER
SMALLWOOD,
STEUBEN,
Resident
PALADINO,
14
Ocean
15
and
Resident
Administrator,
Promenade
Center
for
Nursing
Rehab
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
6
6
1
May
10,
2
2012
MS.
JOHNSON:
like
would
4
housekeeping
information.
5
that,
to
6
Celeste
7
Department.
8
are
9
from
want
Johnson,
the
and
11
Cook,
12
Systems
With
the
who
of
us
some
Before
I
do
myself.
here
Nirav
the
I
Health
at
the
table
Shah,
Jim
Clancy
Affairs
Department
runs
of
Office
Department,
Health,
of
Rick
Health
Management.
We
have
14
forum.
15
people
as
16
time.
You
17
back
from
18
give
you
19
five
minutes
20
timed.
21
have
22
write
23
gladly
25
State
Government
from
13
care
introduce
Commissioner
10
24
take
afternoon.
3
I
to
Good
We
four
are
going
to
should
seek
Gerard
cards.
If
to
you
take
There
your
this
allow
as
a
card
wish
you
to
this
the
will
will
will
with
comments,
in
who
speaker
It
many
during
Ganini,
speak.
don't
for
speak
Each
provided
down
identified
to
possible
Mr.
also
hours
have
be
speak,
sheets
and
we
we
to
will
them.
are
by
staff
badges
members
if
you
here
need
any
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
7
7
1
May
10,
2012
2
questions
answered.
3
purposes,
the
4
bottom
5
the
I
guess
7
through
five.
8
microphone.
9
a
wireless
10
to
11
you
come
The
ladies
We
we
to
a
want
Thank
to
14
sharing
15
this
16
the
17
to
18
you.
thank
everyone
with
very
us
19
and
It
20
want
21
you
22
before,
23
that
24
get
25
able
to
is
to
room
is
start
come
to
on
with
who
are
We
one
the
Also,
we
not
will
SHAH:
first
your
to
going
please
can
to
I
for
have
able
provide
and
We
and
take
appreciate
what
you
have
from
it.
So
be
long
day.
that
speak.
want
coming
we
a
everyone's
limit
just
views.
hear
learn
comments
more
as
to
respect
have
to
mic.
seriously,
opportunity
say,
the
wireless.
COMMISSIONER
13
on
you.
you.
those
the
is
thank
Please
for
up
with
12
room
floor.
6
housekeeping
men's
floor.
top
For
you
your
We
thank
time.
have
We
If
heard
comments
so
want
to
try
possible
to
be
many
folks
as
air
their
views,
and
so
that
to
we
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
8
8
1
May
10,
2
get
a
3
2012
full
MS.
picture.
HINKIN:
4
for
5
you.
My
6
nurse
for
7
nurse
consultant
8
for
9
familiar
coming
the
to
is
Elisa
years,
last
in
24.
with
I
the
statements
11
correction.
12
According
to
13
the
presented
14
violation
15
Department
16
post
17
the
public
18
I'm
a
19
the
afternoon
20
prior
21
According
22
days
23
know,
24
unacceptable.
25
violation
to
said
of
its
web
to
of
to
is
partial
is
today
to
been
of
Health
plans
Law
2801G.3,
is
York
State
the
location
the
publically
me,
only
until
six
days
meeting.
a
minimum
given.
compliance
Evidence
of
afternoon,
excuse
4th,
of
in
not
law,
hereby
a
care
did
until
be
a
and
New
required
said
I'm
thoroughly
law.
May
you
welcome
health
Health
nervous,
this
notice
am
much.
thank
we
have
home
site
forum
little
and
Health
so
Hinkin.
deficiencies
Public
of
and
Department
10
forum
of
you
Likewise,
Rockaway,
name
35
Thank
of
of
of
As
you
the
law
10
is
such
submitted
as
H1.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
9
9
1
May
10,
2
Boy,
am
3
sit?
I
think
4
since
I
know
5
for
6
especially.
7
On
8
and
9
Committee
so
2012
I
nervous.
many
April
of
Review
11
application,
12
Health
13
recommended
14
trustee
15
supplant
16
governing
17
over
18
character
19
her
20
question.
21
The
Health
the
the
Board
of
authority,
operations
and
question
22
a
23
authority
24
considered
by
25
time.
sole
Her
a
position
Directors
as
well
as
in
her
Her
to
not
in
experience
as
sole
governing
was
Department
health
the
regard
care
is
as
control
hospital.
hospital
the
Council
attorney
of
Public
to
of
administrator,
of
Jones'
hospital
as
an
Project
day,
her
competence
as
Special
Lapin
of
Health
and
Planning
oversee
power,
Public
same
approval
I
intimately
Council,
the
Could
Cook,
DOH's
Laurie
and
employment
sole
star
Establishment
reviewed
and
you.
names
Mr.
Planning
10
the
your
your
2012,
on
to
is
years.
5,
Health
it
Thank
not
at
any
background
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
10
10
1
May
10,
2
is
3
Directors
4
Autism
5
lacks
6
regarding
7
hospital.
8
labeled
as
9
a
2012
member
of
of
the
Research
both
the
the
of
Organization
since
2005.
experience
governing
I
Board
and
submit
for
Ms.
and
Jones
education
operating
such
a
evidence
H2.
Further,
Ms.
Jones
submitted
10
preliminary,
incomplete
11
unacceptable
plan
12
Department
13
expert
in
the
protection
14
behalf
of
the
creditors
15
bankruptcy.
16
community,
she
has
protected
17
creditors.
To
the
disservice
18
community,
she
19
the
20
Department
of
21
process
correcting
22
regarding
23
surrendered
the
24
certificate
to
25
afternoon
for
To
the
single
at
lab
Ms.
in
of
1:15
to
Jones
of
New
cases
stopped
p.m.,
a
an
on
of
of
the
of
the
through
State
the
deficiencies
services,
state.
is
those
York
the
the
assets
handedly,
hospital's
the
knowingly
disservice
Health,
the
a
correction
review.
authorization
of
of
and
a
and
operating
This
Nassau
County
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
11
11
1
May
10,
2
ambulance
could
3
Episcopal
Hospital
4
available,
5
operator,
6
County,
7
Peninsula
8
had
9
Peninsula
10
Now
to
2012
and
person
12
was
13
ambulance
14
Hospital.
The
15
emergency
room
16
possibly
17
John's
18
going
19
residents
from
20
Neponset,
Belle
21
Rockaway
22
adding
23
does
24
cannot
25
emergency
whatever
on
Park
change
physically
not
go
to
That
the
Jamaica
need
it
a
second
By
Saint
not
time
only
for
Channel,
Beach,
Saint
John's
fact
that
they
handle
more
than
ambulance
in
the
Tilden,
Broad
Rockaway
at
at
is
Fort
Harbor,
the
that
beds
travel
beds
operator
reason.
more
room,
and
to
peninsula.
Breezy,
more
911
the
17
increase
go
to
not
Nassau
911
Rockaways
emergency
911
Finally,
diverted
adding
the
could
mentioned.
was
was
ambulance
the
for
to
John's
it
in
The
closed.
Long
not
live
is
11
17
I
the
Saint
asking
Hospital.
Beach
to
permission
inform
to
go
because
was
because
for
also
not
one
their
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
12
12
1
May
10,
2012
2
ambulance
3
around,
4
which
there
to
5
bay
now.
There
is
physical
expand
MS.
no
those
CAMPA:
6
Campa.
I
was
7
Hospital
8
year,
and
9
home.
On
10
taking
care
11
will
12
up
a
now
or
work
a
call
her
Miss
was
having
a
change
13
She
was
leaning
14
she
was
unable
15
aphasic.
16
it
17
there.
When
the
18
told
they
would
19
Jamaica
20
was
on
21
the
delay
22
all
backed
23
diversions.
In
24
has
every
25
Once
took
us
a
We
her
because
stoke,
again,
we
a
a
have
side,
she
and
was
and
to
came,
take
get
they
her
Saint
to
John's
apologized
ambulances
of
I
status.
half
to
They
case
that
She
because
because
was
ambulance,
and
the
I
female.
know
one
have
diversion.
nursing
old
ambulance
Hospital,
Mary
this
mental
an
is
18th,
I
of
of
the
speak.
hour
from
Peninsula
year
M.
called
up
at
towards
to
an
at
March
73
turn
area
name
February
about
of
My
nurse
I
no
bays.
Hi.
until
is
for
were
the
where
second
normal
is
a
patient
crucial.
transport
of
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
13
13
1
May
10,
2
these
3
Peninsula
4
stroke
center,
5
by
York
6
another
7
compromises
patients
New
8
9
2012
ourselves
emergency
but
State
example
On
room,
that
or
about
10
I
call
11
respiratory
12
unresponsive.
13
on
14
forced
15
initiated
16
waiting
17
the
18
everything
19
Peninsula
20
the
21
which
22
nursing
home,
23
minutes
to
24
life
25
not
call
CPR
for
the
patient
is
ambulance
over
to
and
run
only
it
this
the
to
to
were
when
We
did
the
transport
emergency
to
only
patient
we
While
closing
would
would
was
arrive,
connected
treatment.
nursing
is
died.
Prior
physically
saving
the
that
ER
we
patient.
we
that
became
subsequently
patient
old
ruling,
and
Hospital,
a
Peninsula's
this
right.
is
into
and
DOH
911,
on
down
this
2012,
years
went
Since
per
9,
60
distress
diversion,
to
D
that
seriously
March
approximately
Miss
closed
care.
female
will
to
designated
Yet,
how
patient
a
was
DOH.
of
over
room,
the
take
over
for
I
know
we
are
home
that
goes
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
14
14
1
May
10,
2012
2
through
3
homes
4
are
5
There
are
6
homes
that
7
nursing
8
facilities,
9
That
this.
There
Far
Rockaway.
in
the
bed
is
I
have,
and
home
beds.
In
I
have
1,796
nursing
11
in
12
facilities
13
capacity,
14
go
home
and
are
urgent
With
often
17
Hospital,
18
not
19
transferred
to
20
peninsula.
This
21
totally
22
avoidable.
As
23
reevaluate
this
24
25
make
speaker
of
they
are
assisted
total
at
3,393
living
or
of
13.
5,186
living
any
at
time
beds
these
their
these
patients
on
these
will
to
have
to
I
before
I
will
be
off
the
eventuality
unacceptable
such,
am
so
Peninsula
patients
tragic
on,
diversion
of
facilities
JOHNSON:
comes
Rockaway.
nursing
there
closing
inhumane,
MS.
Far
16
John's
the
many
it
below
care?
Saint
to
Listed
in
A
If
are
16
due
nursing
assisted
near
where
many
approximately
beds.
Rockaway.
for
15
capacities
approximately
10
Far
are
is
and
urging
DOH
to
lives
are
lost.
Before
the
next
just
want
to
let
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
15
15
1
May
10,
2
you
know
3
for
those
4
2012
that
who
DR.
5
Dr.
6
Peoples
7
answer
8
Hospital.
9
as
Seth
are
Choice
we
You
to
will
reasons
the
12
care
solution.
13
guys
to
14
are
15
brought
16
move
17
to
come
hear
a
health
you
from
an
the
reopening
Our
goal
is
crisis
action
plan
divisions.
We
20
have
21
and
22
lines
23
management.
24
line
25
paperless
senior
people
as
well
where
we
in
our
have
as
at
have
can
six
for
you
that
nature.
on
that
how
you
company
a
I
to
are
has
financing
management
We
the
at
hospital.
have
who
time,
health
issues
care
the
and
reopen
some
position
short
quality
with
Basically,
19
the
to
of
Peninsula
time
of
quality
am
the
up
the
here
president
and
hear
for
or
am
I
reopen
heard,
hospital
a
I
already
11
18
Hi.
Hospital,
want
issues
signers
impaired.
Gutterman.
10
of
are
GUTTERMAN:
is
you
there
arm
worked
the
months
on
arm,
we
doctors
the
front
senior
the
make
of
three
technology
the
of
on
hospital
going
live.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
16
16
1
May
10,
2
2012
In
other
3
century
to
4
hospitals.
5
are
6
Community
7
country
8
hospital
9
area
not
Right
in
a
manage
the
day
11
care
12
are
13
financing,
14
20th
15
had
a
16
arm
of
17
financially
18
good
19
low
20
managers
21
front
22
York
23
participating
24
actually
25
CMS
the
dealing
with
20th
is
distressed
interest
lines.
We
that
are
in
OMC
the
have
of
because
What
with
turning
they
In
and
have
each
around
hospitals
other
with
words,
senior
have
many
been
from
on
the
the
New
in
program.
certified
entire
we
in
interested
this
quality
management
with
actually
cannot
century
models.
rates,
that
put
needs
century
company
own
they
experience
financing
area
distressed
century,
20th
the
community
technology.
of
our
around
Any
day
21st
century
lot
all
because
to
you
this.
financially
closing
10
obviously,
with
closing.
21st
community
now,
hospitals
are
for
delivering
technology
unfamiliar
is
to
words
Then
software
hospital,
we
by
doctors
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
17
17
1
May
10,
2012
2
offices,
3
patient's
4
One
5
database.
6
you
want
to
7
company.
I
8
transparency.
9
successful
health
agencies
homes
patient,
on
one
We
want
financing
arm,
11
arm,
and
12
them
paperless
13
technology
14
This
would
arms
of
in
be
together
to
17
and
all
18
umbrella
19
beacon,
a
20
century
hospital,
21
could
22
financially
23
with
24
prevention.
25
in
so
it
an
like
in
very
the
management
making
century
by
the
OMC.
first
areas
time
would
all
come
hospital
under
one
actually
create
a
light
what
21st
of
community
thrive
distressed
management
importance
boutique
been
arms;
the
and
One
has
community
three
if
be
company
a
shining
look
the
take
a
senior
21
certified
our
you
hospitals,
with
16
good
the
putting
three
are
to
three
in
15
take
We
system.
one
help
company
all
10
to
there
My
in
and
here
this.
even
computer
chart
are
do
one
and
of
of
the
hospital
in
area,
and
a
thrive
thrive
biggest
saving
a
New
with
issues
York
as
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
18
18
1
May
10,
2012
2
well
3
prevent
disease,
4
prevent
the
5
diseases.
6
that
7
A
8
It
9
care
as
other
you
multi
states
and
I
will
need
part
an
of
hospital
for
not
the
for
whether
12
procedures,
13
radiology
14
do
that
well
15
clinic.
You
16
facility
to
17
with
a
18
take
years,
19
Peninsula,
which
has
20
and
we
bring
in
21
can
bring
22
we
23
technology
24
literally
promise
25
the
six
be
in
a
do
or
to
an
in
not
enough.
an
can
take
a
acute
procedures,
advanced
really
can't
specialty
hospital
the
hospital.
heart
acute
We
you
argument
admissions,
you
multi
it.
new
to
endoscopy,
that
need
bring
first
outpatient
studies
in
the
to
existing
But
outpatient
biopsy,
brand
is
way.
11
can
all
the
of
care
plank
want
want
the
acute
but
can
you
make
10
it
you
exacerbation
specialty
goes
is
care
either
which
a
go
will
hospital
decent
like
structure
the
financing,
we
senior
management
and
the
make
21st
this
you
months
century
hospital
paperless
of
us
I
within
taking
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
19
19
1
May
10,
2012
2
ownership.
3
Here
4
lot
5
you.
6
laboratory
7
about
8
are
9
community
of
is
the
difficult
You
to
know
is
biggest
the
local
12
Department
of
13
the
I
14
easy,
15
everybody.
16
bankruptcy
17
knew,
18
law
is
19
the
creditors.
table,
we
like
Health
am
out
problem
courts
only
would
work
as
responsible
to
Unfortunately,
21
no
responsibility
22
it
has
23
health
24
law
25
politicians
That
fallen
to
at
won't
be
in
win
for
the
laws
bankruptcy
now
keeping
is
any
down
win
right
short,
step
it
with
responsibility
care.
sit
bankruptcy
to
or
the
a
that
are
the
bankruptcy
thing
The
mine
and
confident,
can
The
like
mine
of
There
activists,
company
has
assets.
companies
a
trustees
with
other
no
one.
The
the
are
front
but
11
20
in
things,
politicians,
the
the
off
10
but
There
problems
closed.
sell
multiple
issue.
to
and
to
law
jobs
has
and
keeping
where
and
is
bankruptcy
we
need
tell
the
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
20
20
1
May
10,
2012
2
courts,
hey,
3
win
win
for
4
for
the
community,
5
hospital
6
shouldn't
7
slow
the
it
down.
If
creditors
a
should
win
be
shut
trustee
wanted
to
quickly
8
for
creditors.
9
time
and
10
They
have
11
community,
12
that
13
believe
14
Health
15
community
16
politicians,
with
17
we
up
with
18
parties.
Thank
you.
case
as
is
will
19
no
to
a
willing
labor
representative
22
State
Nurses
23
for
24
about
the
urgent
25
acute
are
for
Joan
to
sit
I
win
Good
this
for
of
the
mine,
for
all
afternoon.
and
the
I
New
Thank
opportunity
need
in
local
like
Sommermeir,
this
and
with
the
win
Association.
law.
honestly
down
for
this
Department
with
a
a
the
jobs,
the
SOMMERMEIR:
me
seen
companies
21
giving
bankruptcy
activists,
My
is
in
if
It
money
have
to
win
because
But
a
the
We
care.
team,
win
for
make
maintaining
20
name
down
responsibility
health
come
MS.
again
a
is
entertained.
be
time
and
win
just
the
there
am
a
York
you
to
speak
comprehensive
community.
The
New
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
21
21
1
May
10,
2012
2
York
3
represents
is
4
registered
nurses
5
State.
6
included
7
Peninsula
8
these
9
our
State
Nurses
From
Association
more
35,000
throughout
1975
200
than
until
2008,
registered
Hospital
registered
members,
are
no
longer
in
agony
and
choke
Sadly,
after
remain
our
colleagues.
11
Medisys
12
the
hospital
to
13
104
years
service
14
Peninsula
15
Association
16
nurses'
17
welfare,
18
concern
19
care.
Peninsula
20
small,
but
21
in
Rockaways.
It
22
safety
net
uninsured
23
under
24
patient's
25
treated
began
of
too
to
mismanage
closed
its
still
concern
but
for
to
shares
for
own
about
their
access
Hospital
may
have
a
vital
has
Regardless
personal
the
Peninsula
and
the
insured.
Nurses
community
played
status,
same
as
community,
The
their
especially
it
this
doors.
about
the
with
watched
death.
at
Although
10
the
We
Center.
York
this
nurses
nurses
they
New
role
always
of
been
here
been
and
a
the
the
everyone
degree
to
of
was
care,
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
22
22
1
May
10,
2012
2
attention,
3
the
4
twisted
ankle
5
without
health
6
Seven
7
Berger
8
fundamental
driver
9
health
delivery
dignity
patient
was
years
a
or
six
a
a
Commission
10
capacity.
11
and
12
patients
13
firmly
disagreed
14
and
we
disagree
15
The
acuity
16
actually
17
who
Nurses
are
our
in
year
single
claimed
that
a
of
the
that
with
with
18
to
admitted
19
discharged
20
Our
21
Department
22
will
23
financial
fix
24
the
were
25
adequate
and
move
the
that
access
to
for
they
statement,
the
to
care,
the
past
less
likely
that
they
needed
then
are
Board
beyond
care
over
more
is
excess
now.
hospitals
today
our
population
Patients
and
and
it
in
represent,
that
years.
steps
we
is
colleagues,
patient
from
crisis
system
seven
not
a
mother
the
increased
concern
with
from
hospitals,
of
old
whether
report
has
be
respect,
insurance.
ago,
care
and
to
more
the
of
likely
be
quickly.
Health
Trustees
quick
failed
to
take
ensure
and
the
future
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
23
23
1
May
10,
2
of
3
experience,
4
failed
5
and
6
It
7
for
8
critical
9
care
the
2012
Rockaway
to
closing
produce
often
does
leads
not
tax
communities.
save
It
problems
such
care
10
health
11
imbalance
in
12
What
happen
13
low
14
rely
on
15
will
happen
16
to
17
What
will
18
time
is
19
residents
20
angry.
21
to
stand
22
is
the
23
that
24
cared
25
service
will
income
greater
our
health
as
people
of
the
are
Now
up
time
this
for
to
to
a
health
who
who
centers
an
scared,
and
the
have
What
in
region?
the
emergency
The
and
do
what
is
step
up
and
when
Rockaway
they
for
will
to
travel
time
first
come
cannot
the
care
glaring
community's
essence?
is
without
services?
in
the
care.
this
community
by
and
to
those
happen
dollars
facing
elderly
medical
of
solve
Peninsula's
other
expenses.
not
access
to
savings,
does
coverage,
and
our
typically
promised
millions
payers.
system
hospitals
the
to
From
are
our
leaders
right.
guarantee
continue
class,
Now
to
be
full
facility.
I
thank
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
24
24
1
May
10,
2012
2
you
for
your
3
MR.
time.
FOYER:
Hi,
4
I
5
Rockaway,
and
during
6
worked
at
the
National
7
and
run
the
parking
8
I
9
give
am
Bernie
I
have
Foyer
done
you
a
or
this
three
more
11
in
12
Temperatures
13
Saturday
or
14
4,000
5,000
15
onto
16
parking
lot.
17
happens
that
18
thunderstorms
19
we
20
lightning,
21
all
22
They
get
23
have
gridlock,
24
Parkway
25
all
midst
or
this
have
at
times
of
a
are
a
in
of
pop
have
takes
the
Bridge,
going
out
90s.
We
end
of
the
is
two,
are
It
is
a
up
with
All
a
Rockaway,
sudden,
have
Everybody
the
lot,
two
it
giant
of
we
on
Park
heat,
sudden,
from
coming
Reis
this
parking
it
me
We
cars
thunder.
because
Let
year.
rains,
off
Park.
wave.
the
a
Reis
happens
every
up.
torrential
we
at
additional
all
I
Service,
years.
that
all
in
summer,
Park
11
in
afternoon.
here
lot
Sunday.
With
out
the
heat
peninsula
once
live
for
scenario
10
the
I
good
the
beach.
and
Marine
lanes
and
we
that
all
is
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
25
25
1
May
10,
2012
2
traffic
3
same
4
Now
if
5
the
peninsula,
6
not
going
7
hours,
8
going
9
people
backs
thing
up.
with
the
ambulances
to
because
are
wont
get
11
is
12
here,
because
13
leave
Rockaway.
why
off
we
to
the
need
the
they
I
16
want
to
ask
come
back
up.
17
just
want
to
18
elected
19
have
20
Senator
21
have
22
and
23
Borough
24
Turner's
25
anybody?
we
Senator
Malcolm
got
going
Thank
office.
Yes,
and
Have
you.
10
that,
some
of
the
audience.
and
in
from
I
to
I
We
Huntley,
representatives
and
to
do
Addabo
President
That
I
the
Smith,
hours
they
through
before
in
take
the
hospital
CLANCY:
six
for
here.
not
Shirley
Senator
have
are
are
and
because
second
recognize
officials
got
die
can
off
they
gridlocks
number
But
Bridge.
Rockaway
peninsula
COMMISSIONER
15
Bay
the
diversion
bridges
going
got
days,
of
these
10
on
those
out
the
have
Cross
are
on
get
across
14
You
I
believe
the
we
back,
from
the
Congressman
missed
Congressman
Sanzar.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
26
26
1
May
10,
2
Thank
2012
you
3
very
much
UNIDENTIFIED
4
evening.
5
although
6
you
7
true
8
don't
know
9
These
are
sit
good
afternoon,
evening.
should
be
good
and
listen
to
nurses
about
how
people
but
they
11
not
12
proper
13
beginning.
14
area,
15
are
16
summer,
17
our
18
don't.
19
making
20
Saint
21
crowded
22
are
23
Neponset
drowning,
24
get
the
25
is
they
medical
as
beach
live
front
ocean.
But
it
and
are
make
what
are
now
John's?
It
in
going
the
to
just
might
emergency
Jamaica.
a
a
Every
out
for
of
those
for
little
so
they
if
they
are
will
have
to
Brooklyn.
bankruptcy
We
some
room,
Or
they
to
said.
head
be
the
unique
odds
to
are
just
pulled
the
have
bridge
is
and
and
the
front.
it
you.
They
very
people
I
alive
get
just
bay
Some
who
a
had
move
be
This
in
died,
not.
couldn't
Foyer
there
are
care.
We
Mr.
would
As
telling
who
doesn't
who
breathing,
because
people
that
here.
Good
it
10
not
being
SPEAKER:
Correction,
stories
over
for
money
a
This
issue.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
27
27
1
May
10,
2012
2
This
is
most
3
issue.
4
We
5
think
6
standing
7
company
8
you.
In
9
being
paid.
10
first
priority.
11
bankruptcy
12
closing
13
case
14
Personally,
15
family
did
16
room.
Or
17
more
18
after
this
city
19
seems
that
the
20
point
where
21
pocketbook,
22
Thanks.
have
23
a
I
name
25
Dr.
gentlemen
remember
and
is
I
This
I
not
if
of
they
a
be
you
they
GREEN:
to
an
they
is
elected
your
is
in
emergency
suffered
I
getting
go
not
hear
Good
my
would
because
don't
Green.
is
bankruptcy
someone
time,
do
with
not
complications.
if
I
die.
did,
city
work
credit
the
it
big
being
his
business
is
make
company,
and
is
will
know
a
should
where
people
Susan
Shah,
is
human
what
do
This
case,
down.
you
to
a
Choice,
imagine
This
medical
is
Peoples
willing
where
from
telling
time,
MS.
24
importantly
go
it
to
the
after
the
you.
afternoon.
My
Welcome,
officials
and
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
28
28
1
May
10,
2012
2
everybody
3
and
4
Peninsula
5
laboratory
6
in
7
want
8
Peninsula.
9
state
of
10
open,
and
11
all.
North
12
Saint
Johns'
13
of
2011.
The
14
to
LIJ
be
15
known
that
LIJ
will
16
laboratory
for
the
17
years,
18
Joseph's
19
Saint
John's
20
their
standards.
21
instead
22
in
23
and
they
24
are
being
25
restructure.
hear
that
else
us.
that
I
am
a
Hospital
former
technologist
welcome
We
for
you
are
no
just
bank
blood
be
do
Bethpage,
needed
being
Brooklyn
are
is
to
Why
It
is
a
them
now
their
of
Island.
bring
up
were
given
help
Brookdale
part
in
sent
to
given
go
at
Saint
closed.
being
told
being
Long
They
a
December
is
in
in
running
couple
help
also
I
bank
running
next
they
worked
hospital
been
since
work
of
Rockaway
blood
processed.
as
in
of
blood
has
one
has
come
a
years.
Only
LIJ
am
officially
functioning
Shore
I
the
now
to
employee
that
41
to
emergency.
to
willing
Center.
laboratory
to
was
of
help.
there
and
not
Medisys,
They
and
us?
We
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
29
29
1
May
10,
2012
2
have
3
Department
of
Health
4
Hospital?
Do
you
honestly
5
possible
Saint
John's
6
entire
peninsula?
7
John's
is
8
one
9
apartment
been
way
duped.
for
Why
go
The
totally
streets,
did
after
private
no
emergency
a
12
and
13
HCAPS
14
Assessment
15
Systems.
It
16
evaluates
the
17
patients
18
asking
19
patients.
20
satisfaction
21
payment
22
government.
Low
customer
23
scores
low
pay.
24
level
25
payment.
John's
stands
of
with
The
to
of
of
of
an
just
Health
HCAPS?
survey
that
satisfaction
care
in
of
by
discharged
level
of
hospital
satisfaction,
Patient
is
Providers
hospital
determines
the
means
Care
and
their
questions
It
and
Consumer
national
care
the
Saint
about
Hospital
a
is
Narrow
Department
Health
is
by
room.
worried
for
carry
parking,
11
the
it
homes,
overcrowded
Saint
to
congested.
buildings,
Isn't
Peninsula
think
area
10
joke.
the
patient
the
by
level
of
the
satisfaction
The
higher
the
the
higher
the
satisfaction
results
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
30
30
1
May
10,
2012
2
are
publicized.
3
There
4
peninsula.
5
the
6
10,000
people
7
Aren't
these
8
health
care?
9
grew
are
end
133,000
The
of
up
the
12
minutes
13
about
14
They
15
proper
16
for
17
officials.
18
you
19
take
20
something
21
not
22
don't
23
come
from
24
help
people
25
know
where
the
sick,
them.
you
out
were
and
to
a
if
that
we
you
we
to
proper
with
our
to
ten
anybody
care
elderly?
life
and
right
of
the
us.
We
thing
put
will
work
hard
don't
give
us
really
need.
this
is
promise.
I
live
this
neighborhood.
I
Suffolk
of
this
County
Rockaway,
man
is
to
This
threat,
in
a
I
Andrew
at
five
the
for
about
area.
the
all
at
unfair.
good
Do
work
and
all
doesn't
elected
office
this
open
in
hospitals
care.
You
be
bringing
totally
poor
right
We
will
to
five
Why
health
the
entitled
is
They
a
on
neighborhood
away.
have
a
It
have
fingertips.
week
people
We
11
in
a
the
Cuomo.
beaches
month,
in
10
people
is
every
day
and
want
to
This
is
today.
I
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
31
31
1
May
10,
2012
2
Governor
3
today?
4
state
Cuomo's
He
of
5
should
be
CLOSKY:
6
name
7
member
8
laboratory
9
member
Rita
of
Closky,
the
of
the
over
36
a
on
inspection
13
2012.
14
yes,
we
needed
to
15
yes,
we
needed
improvement.
16
is
17
have
18
institution.
19
We
20
all
21
did.
22
laboratory.
23
take
24
had
25
I
Yes,
way
there
that
ever
led
We
the
only
and
ask
to
the
doors
based
of
24,
corrections,
But
citations
closure
one
come
up
to
see
date
question.
make
and
brand
from
and
the
to
needed,
a
there
should
of
resources
no
one
I
make
the
how
a
deficiencies,
virtually
time
that
February
corrections
Yet
As
were
ample
were
done,
its
of
these
to
given
the
learned
shutting
a
laboratory,
12
DOH
I
also
My
Hospital
was
can
is
am
hospital
of
This
years.
hospital
when
I
11
were
he
afternoon.
and
Peninsula
for
shocked
Good
was
no
is
here.
10
a
Where
emergency.
MS.
is
picture.
DOH
new
would
what
we
we
we
were.
Why?
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
32
32
1
May
10,
2012
2
Based
3
plan
4
trustee,
5
someone
6
some
7
this.
I
8
on
day
9
bank
on
of
an
incomplete,
correction
Lorie
we
unknown
the
of
was
11
rotator,
12
platelets
13
heat.
Yet
14
floor
nurse
15
pick
16
Not
17
compromised
18
but
19
to
20
return
21
the
22
so
23
day,
24
lab
25
courier.
only
she
in
were
a
came
platelets
the
to
the
blood
lab
blood
gas
an
after
to
on
a
to
the
the
bank
to
infusion.
allow
be
these
transfused,
to
the
I
question
all.
On
came
nursing
chemistry
room
these
procedure.
specimens
outside
The
blood
satisfied.
in
the
later,
nurse
entire
products
compromised
from
the
blood
due
inspector
platelets
the
that
for
by
and
platelets
me
the
bank,
that
while
to
by
believe
the
compromised
followed
witness
told
little
did
blood
were
the
reviewed
don't
commented
she
by
signed
and
I
the
There
and
the
know
inspection,
hot.
up
Jones,
source.
inspector
too
not
worked
10
submitted
Lapin
did
preliminary
floor
She
suppose
were
the
to
home
inspector
not
same
the
by
asked
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
33
33
1
May
10,
2012
2
many
3
Who
4
specimens
5
drawn.
6
to
7
lunch
8
He
9
validity
of
these
10
However,
he
let
11
testing
12
too
13
compromised
14
out.
15
It
16
were
17
lab
was
18
But
in
19
satisfied
20
compromised
at
21
you
lab,
22
close
23
for
over
24
put
lives
25
better
questions
was
the
these
specimens.
courier,
where
did
come
Did
the
about
lab
the
or
before
had
many
and
thought
seems
to
only
from,
courier
could
report
these
but
me
a
that
the
for
at
all
all.
I
and
risk?
explanation
were
work
DOH
inspectors
the
say
this
This
There
than
to
work
go
our
report.
clearly
were
serving
years?
He
the
were
patients
the
results.
published
they
lab.
the
do
about
a
the
for
specimens.
the
allowed
directly
to
about
out
they
stopped
specimens
hospital,
104
have
tech
concerned
that
come
blood
the
were
them
questions
actuality
a
he
bringing
doing
close
when
the
not
this
is
a
why
being
is
why
you
community
is
has
why
to
you
be
a
lab
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
34
34
1
May
10,
2012
2
deficiencies.
3
the
4
closed?
real
5
reason
MR.
6
me
7
Daniel
8
Rockaway
9
I
thank
you
for
Park,
10
like
this
11
let
to
12
member,
13
family
14
to
15
going
16
problems
17
God
18
staff,
19
will
20
Another
thing
21
beach.
This
22
have
23
Bernie
24
get
25
know
and
it's
lot
said.
people
for
a
am
I
a
my
don't
could
I
is
was
that
in
why.
get
it.
something
to
family
of
to
those
get
and
I
I
had
It's
rushed
am
breathing
and
a
not
thank
great
hospital,
and
I
that.
is
is
is
of
Also
year,
there.
great
a
one
had
one
do
let
name
resident
just
wife
all,
My
community.
say
of
of
the
into
a
always
a
I
Hospital,
it
is
you
twice
made
Hospital
First
and
members
get
is
speaking.
yes,
Peninsula
what
how
know,
to
reiterate
ROSILLO:
know
you
I
Peninsula
Rosillo.
don't
I
So
we
a
beach
people
You
talked
about
community.
coming,
have
the
like
drownings,
that
hurt
on
the
fact
that
Saint
We
you
beach.
John's
We
is
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
35
35
1
May
10,
2012
2
going
3
overwhelmed
4
are
5
overwhelmed
staff
6
doesn't
that
7
Second
8
the
9
gridlock,
to
you
be
overwhelmed.
staff.
going
go,
of
to
all,
out
of
11
that
12
John's
13
left,
14
Hospital,
15
goes
16
year.
17
ambulance
18
in
19
make
it
to
20
have
to
say.
21
21
they
go
let's
which
How
even
with
the
want
23
believe
24
would
25
Members
to
have
we
like
go
up
the
and
three
to
are
Saint
make
the
a
bridge
times
a
be
that
in
I
going
That
folks
11
and
decided
attack?
I
doubt
to
is
all
I
just
come
through
recognize
Goldfeder
about
coming
to
CLANCY:
got
where.
Island
like
next
That
the
said
hospital.
have
to
they
to
you
COMMISSIONER
22
people
heart
that
no
right
they
you
a
go,
here,
goes
job
an
beside
Coney
go
would
minutes
got
and
to
of
also
want
Hospital,
up,
is
kind
an
hospital?
Suppose
didn't
let's
a
have
of
doesn't
have
Breezy.
out
at
But
you
10
get
he
gridlock.
What
We
up.
15.
I
I
Assembly
Titus.
Thank
you
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
36
36
1
May
10,
2
for
coming.
3
2012
MS.
CLARK:
Good
afternoon.
4
name
5
resident.
I
live
down
6
sometimes
we
need
Peninsula
7
there
8
that
9
crucial
is
Annette
is
a
does
Clark.
the
for
an
or
11
there
with
12
than
13
Unfortunately,
14
failure.
I
15
go
emergency
16
Kidney
17
figured
18
couple
of
hours,
19
weeks,
it
would
20
wasn't
fine.
21
at
22
Hospital,
23
not
24
dialysis
immediately.
25
vascular
in
oh,
able
there
It
a
is
young
can
within
be
less
minutes.
2010,
was
If
it
got
by
room
For
well,
I
I
called
failure.
all.
We
arrest
and
because
people.
person.
cardiac
three
block,
especially
child
the
older
a
center
asthmatic
anyone,
am
the
respiratory
10
to
I
My
two
be
Probably
in
not
be
dead
to
speak
to
you.
chest
Well,
for
would
it
function
Peninsula
right
They
with
I
three
kidney
I
the
to
another
weeks,
no
doctor
immediately.
fine.
had
was
my
me?
maybe
kidney
I
now
was
on
gave
me
and
catheters.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
37
37
1
May
10,
2
I
3
left
4
John's
5
have
to
be
there
6
evening
to
be
7
morning.
8
There
9
Rockaway,
and
10
Peninsula
Hospital
11
and
12
Department
of
13
shuts
a
14
desperately
15
we
16
have
17
you
18
that
19
o'clock,
20
I
21
machine
22
and
23
take
24
the
25
no
did
2012
not
go
to
Saint
Peninsula.
dialysis
is
I
only
think
down
have
to
got
on
me
or
center
that
is
is
for
machines,
dialysis
to
where
now?
I
cooked
a
quarter
midnight.
on.
I
fix
of
God,
he
longer
on
dialysis,
at
God
did
fix
but
5:00.
on
the
went
to
and
4
to
was
Thank
mercy
or
Nassau,
This
asked
it.
I
do
We
Brooklyn
South
and
and
So
went.
6:30,
the
needed
to
at
that
is
go
by
to
area.
the
John's.
there
that
either
in
this
four
sits
would
the
disgraceful
this
to
in
Saint
had
Health
until
and
10:00
I
Saint
I
until
left
there
because
there
go
I
to
in
hospital
got
go
10:00
in
we
center
one
go
where
didn't
after
at
it
to
have
was
I
John's
on
either
God
for
it.
I
that
am
doesn't
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
38
38
1
May
10,
2012
2
mean
I
3
have
30
4
in
5
Saint
John's,
6
in
emergency
7
takes
8
taking
Peninsula's
9
are
an
have
percent
trouble
an
kidney
in
supposed
where
11
Long
12
personally
13
say
14
people,
15
have
16
because
17
had
18
supposed
19
the
20
supposed
21
today.
22
I
23
this
to
24
have
all
25
can't
do,
Island?
three
the
weeks
very
passed
to
ambulance
to
it
is
in
in
when
they
That
out
I
four
is
If
they
were
and
were
be
only
the
that
them
that
not
should
mine
they
would
of
I
I
know
care,
construction
and
Nassau
they
despicable
people.
this
when
you
am
of
of
sit
what
are
emergency
came
be,
So
diverted.
care
have
too.
month,
Three
to
are
there
am
To
you
South
I
only
and
friends
were
emergency
not
Hospital?
ago,
away.
they
got
room,
last
good
have
that
to
If
go?
people
go
only
I
people,
Mercy
in
do
you
room
I
kidney.
where
John's
to
get
one
emergency
10
think
of
again,
Saint
function.
and
alive
you
do
do
we
you
place
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
39
39
1
May
10,
2012
2
begin
3
down
4
and
5
side
6
traffic
7
that
8
allow
9
You
should
10
all
of
with.
here,
they
of
But
they
were
the
were
coming
comes
from
here,
on
the
opposite
traffic
to
get
through
It
is
Department
something
11
ambulance
going
here.
the
an
be
appalling
of
like
Health
this
ashamed
of
to
to
me
would
happen.
yourselves,
you.
MR.
LYNCH:
Good
afternoon.
12
name
13
the
14
years.
15
community
of
hard
working
16
families.
I
have
always
17
City
and
18
both
financially
19
also
pay
our
20
both
the
City
21
currently
serve
22
Directors
of
23
Cooperative.
24
the
25
largest
is
Joe
Lynch.
Rockaway
Breezy
have
Peninsula
Rockaway
the
I
is
State
I
Point
when
the
on
a
middle
called
knit
class
supported
of
the
upon,
taxes
I
Board
of
the
also
of
We
to
Point
the
Chairman
Cooperative,
cooperative
50
close
State.
Breezy
am
over
in
economically.
share
and
the
for
indeed
and
fair
resided
My
single
of
the
family
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
40
40
1
May
10,
2012
2
dwellings
3
city
4
nestled
5
this
6
families,
7
Roxbury,
8
Association
9
Association.
and
and
the
in
private
state.
the
Rockaway
fellow
Our
extreme
Peoples
western
the
I
Point
speak
11
neighbors
12
Channel,
Belle
13
all
a
common
14
which
a
continuation
15
operation
16
Rockaway's
17
center.
18
Just
19
continue
to
20
when
the
state
21
give
us
22
of
23
service,
24
medical
25
hard
is
some
city
shareholders
of
Rockaway
earned
the
We
ongoing
community
share
city
and
and
of
continue
unfair
now
we
taxes
to
return
Train
it
services
Being
health
should
services?
dollars.
my
Hospital,
fair
and
as
bond,
our
sanitation
response
of
a
Why
state
behalf
Broad
points.
and
of
Neponset.
and
needed
pay
on
well
and
goal
inequitable
and
as
Peninsula
quick
of
Breezy
Beach,
Harbor
very
is
includes
tonight
of
have
the
Planning
10
in
It
tip
Association
Rockaway
and
in
cooperative
Peninsula.
the
the
residences
on
appears
for
the
our
most
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
41
41
1
May
10,
2012
2
extreme
3
families
4
community
5
the
6
Once
7
Point
8
relative
to
9
the
and
western
of
Breezy
most
permanent
again,
are
city
point
closure
getting
their
the
to
time
11
health
12
medical
13
beautiful
summer
14
result
loss
15
where
16
the
difference.
17
For
numerous
18
the
community
19
services
20
we
21
Peninsula
22
let
23
various
24
my
25
commitment
to
from
minutes
of
and
will
the
of
an
be
hospital.
Breezy
unfair
The
hand
an
alternative
Rockaways
will
life,
on
in
a
surely
can
mean
residents
all
and
relied
heavily
on
positive
medical
response
for
medical
Hospital.
down.
I
medical
family,
and
saw
also
first
emergencies
the
the
problems
They
also
a
especially
seconds
our
to
additional
especially
years,
by
contributions
the
day,
of
the
this
state.
emergency,
received
own
tax
get
facility
in
of
dealt
Queens,
affected
citizens
10
us
Point
adversely
the
needed
in
at
never
hand
involving
dedication,
professionalism
of
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
42
42
1
May
10,
2
physicians,
3
Rockaway
4
our
medical
5
the
New
York
6
has
now
replaced
7
medical
8
Cooperative
9
Peninsula
represent
10
families,
with
11
documented
12
in
13
country,
similar
14
beliefs,
and
15
the
protection
16
and
the
17
well
documented,
18
toll
on
19
York
City
20
Police
and
New
21
remain
the
true
22
foundation
23
Point
24
citizen
25
residents,
our
2012
nurses
truly
and
viewed
staff.
this
lifeline.
State
the
a
work
The
middle
pride
our
also
Many
involvement
in
our
religious
commitment
families,
paid
a
very
workers,
fighters,
New
York
teachers
City
backbone
along
and
and
and
hard
with
all
demand
York
a
as
heavy
New
City
the
the
This
to
homes
Rockaway,
city
Rockaway
need
Point
class
and
ongoing
communities.
base,
with
Rockaway
real
neighborhood.
of
Health
Breezy
western
ethnic
of
fire
as
historically
communities,
911.
of
lifeline
ethic,
an
facility
Department
our
in
Unfortunately
uncertainty.
and
We
Breezy
working
Rockaway
community
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
43
43
1
May
10,
2012
2
and
local
3
trustee
4
We
5
I
6
reported
7
appears
8
impartial,
9
somehow
hospital,
and
deserve
really
do
not
lab
hospital.
11
does
12
dedicated
13
Hospital
14
discussions
15
potential
16
whatever
17
Department
18
their
19
outcome
20
media
21
meeting
22
public
23
the
24
following
25
far
add
down
up.
Board
of
of
with
reason,
of
the
observer,
a
long
standing
in
this
equation
the
very
Peninsula
have
interested
parties
alternatives.
from
Health
appeared
to
the
up
on
the
start.
In
states
that
to
comments
on
Rockaway
DOH
is
health
Queens
closure
of
concerned,
have
fact,
today's
is
the
final
announcing
it
on
For
trustees
advisory
the
had
the
made
from
a
also
Directors
funding
the
realize.
how
to
Several
members
to
which
medical
Something
minds
Far
understand
shut
that
less.
correctable
non
can
failed
problem,
very
not
have
nothing
10
as
DOH
something
the
solicit
services
in
community
Peninsula.
this
As
appears
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
44
44
1
May
10,
2012
2
to
3
needed
4
due
5
process
6
the
7
intentions
for
8
this
to
9
leaders,
have
always
and
fully
diligence
Department
prior
the
11
working
12
hospital.
13
The
14
Department
15
your
of
16
and
promote
17
and
well
18
of
to
the
Health,
is
the
being
to
New
MR.
MARRERO:
MR.
LYNCH:
staff,
still
Rockaway's
York
I
on
political
State
read
protect,
New
fact,
no
and
save
health,
of
In
members
as
proper
hearing
employees
of
site,
had
from
board
The
decision
lacking.
pressure
Commission
this
public
proactively
deal.
public
in
Health
any
dedicated
web
done
expected
very
former
and
a
criteria
appears
10
19
been
it
on
improve
productivity
York.
Sir,
please
wrap
up.
20
21
Breezy
Point
22
10,000
hard
23
that
24
has
25
you.
your
only
My
Co-op
consisting
working
closure
sabotaged
community
citizens,
of
Peninsula
that
of
the
over
believes
Hospital
mission.
Thank
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
45
45
1
May
10,
2
2012
MR.
3
esteemed
4
Health
5
Joe
6
elected
7
Paul
8
Tiger
9
credits
SCHUBERT:
members
of
the
Department.
Addabo,
I
Michele
Paul,
so
give
Titus
am
far,
ramps,
three
11
good
12
Pfeiffer.
13
powerful
14
accountability,
15
State
16
that
17
of
18
officials,
19
suffers
20
Addabo
21
increase
22
also
23
chronic
24
Bayswater.
25
manufactured
offices
I
I
words.
Penal
to
the
as
To
my
chair
through
out
the
some
from
gas
New
me
on
out
or
he
plant
is
inaction
someone
injury.
Joe
is
going
to
law.
I
this
the
states
government
dies,
Breezy
source
York
clearly
physical
bring
Its
15,
including
penalty
asthma
is
some
wheel
action
promised
to
name
by
bring
someone
grievous
want
other
Audrey
Which
individual,
the
of
Article
through
has
the
to
Liability,
Code.
and
My
15
the
thanks
and
lights
help
want
and
activist.
have
traffic
and
a
known
community
10
if
I
afternoon,
public
representatives.
Schubert.
an
Good
asthma,
Point
to
the
owned
by
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
46
46
1
May
10,
2012
2
National
3
air
4
cancer
5
in
6
Refuge
7
coal
tar.
Your
8
hospital,
means
9
cancer
the
has
Grid.
been
in
The
the
the
testimony
cause
from
They
all
11
who
12
scholars
13
So
14
are
15
liable.
16
Every
17
broadcast,
18
Copies
19
official.
Shirley
20
Committee,
Joe
21
has
proven
as
22
the
job
23
When
24
ask
25
daughters,
do
three
Wild
the
all
odor
of
who
have
our
sisters,
in
Life
this
people
teachers
bring
grandmas
the
academy.
want
going
to
to
We
are
be
done.
she
puts
tough
MS.
it
you
now
will
That
is
available
Huntley
a
we
Michelle
questions.
Good
correct.
to
every
Disabilities
He
on,
man
has
Titus,
glasses
this.
be
proven
Councilman.
LEBOW:
taping
word
Addabo,
her
that
accountable,
cast.
made
known
video
blessed
web
will
make
hold
single
you
Bay
down
Rockaways,
the
the
can
smell
the
in
all
I
shutting
mothers,
I
of
Jamaica
10
died,
smell
Rockaways.
Rangers.
in
bad
who
got
also.
she
Thank
will
you.
afternoon.
My
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
47
47
1
May
10,
2012
2
name
3
laboratory
worker
4
years.
We
all
5
Health
used
6
hospital
7
Commission
8
beds
9
has
is
Michelle
the
at
know
the
beds.
10
on
11
traffic,
12
construction
13
since
14
buildings
15
lab
had
16
and
2010.
17
Eight
18
No
19
actions
20
that
21
the
22
inspection.
23
percent
24
could
25
know
2006,
a
plus
Then
we
why.
have
You
is
I
400
and
came
to
see
or
Mind
in
you,
that
pulled
never
Why,
the
2008
over.
of.
progress,
it
was
I
wanted
but
always
the
January
proficiency.
been?
the
corrective
did
in
sure
unheard
if
under
2006,
took
in,
beach
Yes,
since
now
people
now
am
rising.
taken,
the
extra
that
Revival
inspector
on
the
repair.
still
We
stated
population
reinspections
same
was
133,000
bridge
okay.
Berger
are
inspectors
was
the
There
citations
were
of
peninsula
the
its
Department
the
for
are
41
and
peninsula,
and
It
a
for
close
the
Report.
I'm
Peninsula
to
of
needed,
and
the
lab
because
are
257
Lebow,
100
How
bad
ask?
We
us
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
48
48
1
May
10,
2012
2
survive.
3
hospital.
4
Keep
5
people,
6
open
minded,
7
with
an
8
brought
all
those
9
down
one
day,
I
the
really
If
but
common,
11
deserved
12
us.
13
weeks
14
us
15
yourselves.
16
that
17
to
18
mine.
We
turn
were
75
down,
I
there
on
I
is
your
MR.
honored
guests,
21
Berger,
and
22
emergency
medical
23
served
ambulances
24
communities
and
and
that
there
You
down.
It
25
peninsula
you
we
two
wanted
are
blood
won't
name
is
a
semi
retired
within
the
Channel
happy
going
be
on
and
Richard
technician
Broad
the
Watch
my
am
us
us
reinspect
us.
be
shut
give
percent
comprising
and
in
Commissioner
20
on
you
to
BERGER:
I
when
courtesy
hands.
be
agenda
that
going
the
in
closed
hope
to
came
didn't
80
us
it.
you
around
shut
prove
suggestions,
people
to
this
Listen
think
and
you
you
the
human
to
before
wrong,
Your
decent,
about
open.
to
agenda.
10
19
am
hospital
listen
in
be
I
care
who
has
the
Rockaway
for
38
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
49
49
1
May
10,
2012
2
years.
3
catastrophe
4
I
am
here
address
the
the
closing
of
Peninsula
Hospital
Center,
and
5
impact
on
both
region
6
John's
Episcopal
7
the
8
Outside
9
Channel,
only
the
the
in
the
that
serving
Rockaways
rest
10
a
11
than
12
hospital's
emergency
13
45
from
14
a
15
The
16
seen.
17
was
18
concluded
19
population
20
hospitals.
But
21
neither
of
22
case
23
the
24
Saint
John's
25
being
overwhelmed.
15
nobody
minutes
minutes
trauma
of
is
then
becomes
understand
that
to
one
load
some
we
Peninsula
Broad
or
ago
didn't
more
from
such
wait
same
the
two
could
Hospital
Episcopal
The
the
as
to
be
there
enough
need
the
With
a
which
have
the
is
perhaps
ER
the
it
no
away
at
alone.
region.
correctly,
years
support
Saint
city,
specialty
problem
survey
and
room,
center.
a
the
time
burn
I
the
currently
the
or
If
the
usually
travel
a
the
and
Hospital,
hospital
of
given
of
to
for
two
time,
handle
closing
Center,
Hospital
the
of
the
is
population
of
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
50
50
1
May
10,
2012
2
the
Rockaways
and
3
the
figures
have
4
120,000
5
population,
and
with
6
building
the
Auburn
7
community,
8
my
9
non
people.
of
count
911
was
I
a
from
We
a
then
11
of
12
facilities
in
13
hospitals,
were
14
half
of
them
15
took
an
act
16
and
17
construction
18
were
19
area.
20
We
21
all,
on
22
only
four
23
Brooklyn,
24
County.
25
Northeaster,
homes
in
a
to
out
Staten
flood
a
in
in
provider
a
that
third
care
of
County,
the
and
Rockaway.
It
Legislature
the
as
an
impacted
We
are,
with
via
for
private,
outside
and
during
waters
we
after
basically
bridges
Island
1993,
1975,
facilities
isolated.
ways
aging
roughly
halt
be
roughly
Sea
extended
more
to
from
State
peninsula,
In
In
Queens
the
of
declared
one.
here
per
continued
the
for,
is,
an
by
city,
were
of
both
the
and
the
legislation
also
are
service
working
nursing
given,
handout
ambulance
I
Channel
been
growing
10
are
Broad
to
Nassau
the
caused
shut
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
51
51
1
May
10,
2012
2
down
3
the
Rockaways
4
the
Marine
5
Bridges
6
September
7
traffic
8
County
9
hour
for
10
than
50
11
one
12
there
13
the
14
of
15
proceed
16
emergency
lights
17
Emergency
rooms
18
backlogged
19
medical
20
who
21
physician.
22
emergency
23
In
24
variations
25
of
of
all
were
11,
no
the
I
private
place
can
emergency
along
have
and
can
a
normal
in
to
move
hospitals
out
under
siren
and
less
I
was
in
If
get
of
out
the
do
way
to
an
get
asking
care
they
of
response.
primary
for
people
have
an
to.
of
temperature
spring
we
half
attempting
nice
times
the
to
are
go
a
vehicles.
people
There
of
over
move
move
on
Nassau
because
road
Instead,
room
to
vehicle
the
with
help.
to
When
Bay
backlog
took
know
of
traffic
through
it
out
Channel.
to
vehicles
nobody
don't
the
bad,
feet.
way,
the
so
and
Cross
down
inland
some
is
and
2001,
going
into
Broad
shut
those
any
and
Parkway
was
of
roadways
and
fall,
previously
had
both
on
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
52
52
1
May
10,
2012
2
our
beach
3
law,
4
emergency
5
receive
6
category
7
due
8
specific
9
treatment.
can
anyone
to
get
who
room
it.
crowded.
is
presented
asking
The
for
temporary
or
equipment
of
used
local
usually
ask
patient
ambulance
providers
11
next
12
patient
13
the
14
next
15
diversions
16
not
a
17
the
diversion.
18
training
programs
will
tell
you
19
event
a
that
time
is
20
loss.
21
In
22
time
23
without
blood
24
to
irreparably.
25
best
is
patient
divert
to
hospital,
except
when
of
cardiac
taught
die,
skill,
extremis,
might
emergency
right
service
will
in
are
of
not
make
it
the
when
to
that
In
a
extended
the
hospitals
All
pulmonary
is
and
and
all
cases,
10
brain
Even
to,
asking
for
paramedic
in
the
brain
resuscitation,
after
flow,
EMTs
EMT
the
is
hospital.
stroke
us
which
courtesy
for
or
10
nearest
an
diversion
beds
in
state
must
can
total
lack
at
aid
hospitals
diversion
The
Under
the
minutes
cells
with
start
the
paramedics
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
53
53
1
May
10,
2012
2
bringing
3
patients,
4
definitive
5
the
6
medicines
7
ambulance.
An
8
wait
examining
9
open.
the
some
local
for
cases
care
ER
that
with
that
an
If
emergency
just
12
seen.
They
won't
13
arrive
that
care
14
quicker
15
hospital.
16
In
17
John's
18
day,
19
or
20
definition,
an
21
an
generates
22
five
or
more
23
from
an
overturned
24
people
25
American
addition
bed,
drive
to
to
we
have
multiple
incident
aboard
usage
Airlines
a
ER
to
are
to
who
be
they
of
on
the
a
can
be
or
mini
of
an
This
van
Flight
of
587
MCI
By
directed
might
repeat
Saint
regular
incident.
patients.
to
to
temporarily
possibility
casualty
the
distant
Hospital
MCI
has
people
ER
be
in
the
until
more
heavy
the
in
the
might
Episcopal
crew
consider
to
from
and
carried
bed
know
a
come
ambulances
11
gong
be
the
the
only
ambulance
waiting
or
can
cannot
10
walk
a
need
to
machinery
multiple
for
room
when
generate
can
with
range
five
the
crash
in
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
54
54
1
May
10,
2012
2
the
Belle
3
fatalities.
Harbor
section,
4
MR.
MARRERO:
5
MR.
SCHUBERT:
6
Or
the
Golden
7
people.
8
area
9
Hospital
In
as
Sir,
I
Venture
by
Center
the
and
Episcopal
Hospital
due
11
loads,
puts
of
12
combined
13
high
a
14
care
than
15
acceptable.
it
all
hospital
risk
of
had
for
closed
to
us
MARRERO:
Thank
17
MS.
LARKIN:
Good
is
19
president
20
Owners
Association,
21
Queens
Civic
22
Advisory
23
and
24
Francis,
25
years.
I
Barbara
of
taught
a
But
Belle
of
in
114,
combination
I
speak
area
am
Harbor
at
too
room
as
sir.
the
I
was
PS
My
past
Property
President
Peninsula
PS
case
the
you,
I
Vice
Congress.
Board
John's
afternoon.
Larkin.
the
isolated
considered
MR.
name
310
emergency
16
18
done.
patient
in
up.
Peninsula
Saint
catchment
be
an
265
wrap
which
delayed
should
please
almost
the
10
had
am
conclusion,
served
which
on
of
the
Hospital,
42,
Saint
of
over
35
an
individual
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
55
55
1
May
10,
2012
2
this
3
First
4
individuals
5
come
6
Because
7
have
8
disagreed
9
can
afternoon.
of
all,
out
had
say
commend
who
and
of
I
speak
all
in
have
Water,
from
Bays
11
is
12
ever
had.
I
13
grew
up
Brooklyn,
14
to
15
parents
16
teach
in
17
said,
I
18
since
the
19
Saturday
20
was
a
Saturday
21
and
I
were
22
tree,
23
We
24
car,
25
Hospital.
in
a
can
the
also
come
1965,
lived
day
I
my
was
afternoon,
say
my
her
up,
we
told
I
happy
husband
school.
thank
my
the
picked
to
have
with
my
and
That
God
pains
They
very
and
had
her
to
On
up
this
like
married.
she
rushed
through
that
was
I
mother-in-law
and
we
but
we
afternoon,
putting
have
problem
married
with
we
Point
Rockaway
neighborhood
we
things,
but
to
that
agree
largest
to
today.
sometimes
all
would
eventually
minds
Breezy
10
probably
courage
different
we
the
problems
Rockaway,
today
in
the
their
the
over
all
put
a
it
husband
Christmas
in
her
her
chest.
in
the
Peninsula
us
if
we
hadn't
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
56
56
1
May
10,
2012
2
gotten
her
there
3
died.
She
was
4
They
5
Eve
6
looked.
7
She
8
evening.
9
another
wanted
day.
We
had
refused
another
She
my
dad
11
had
12
someone
found
13
pocket.
They
14
in
15
down
16
the
17
sugar
18
needed
19
of
was
fainting
an
my
wonderful
up
from
14
hours
ago,
I
20
91
Peninsula
21
records.
22
in
23
Toots,
24
have
25
of
Rockaway
to
her
with
the
go
and
was
in
put
and
him
him
one
of
blood
ever
his
and
his
got
his
where
years
God
We
got
for
Street,
me.
it
life.
Two
my
mother,
who
Hospital
picking
up
It
is
Vincencia
of
Peninsula
records.
home.
few
number
grandmother
to
A
They
with
she
hospital
me.
cried.
for
Christmas
that
Thank
saved
weeks.
her
Hospital,
to
have
way
attack
116th
nurses
be,
She
take
weeks.
on
on
the
the
called
to
at
to
phone
Peninsula
three
like
in
would
her
spell.
ambulance
to
for
heart
was
couple
later,
she
release
didn't
10
a
there
to
We
then,
Mine
to
a
sad
Becker,
her
day
Nanny
Rockaway,
pick
weren't
up
is
to
all
ready,
so
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
57
57
1
May
10,
2012
2
I
am
3
I
would
4
officials,
whom
5
and
who
6
job,
7
problem.
8
at
this
time,
9
on
line
petition
going
I
another
like
know
to
to
know
implore
I
know
do
a
this
Since
I
of
is
many
state
could
12
who
I
know
13
him
personally.
14
John's
15
and
16
mother.
17
wonderful,
18
think
he
19
he
is
very
busy.
I
20
to
be
here
today,
and
21
elected
officials
22
and
this
23
present
24
am
25
problem
present
fine
As
University,
had
get
my
I
I
to
our
he
all
a
I
get
if
him
our
I
going
and
know,
I
solve
Rockaway.
know
together
petition
Governor,
don't
I
expect
know
help
dad,
his
problem.
I
Saint
his
governor.
could
will
of
is
know
of
with
didn't
line
the
don't
met
taken
this
an
in
graduate
he
have
Governor,
I
have
wonderful
confident
for
a
understand
on
our
working
to
indeed
man,
picture
realizes
it
to
fine
are
them
Queens,
well,
biggest
everybody
11
a
very
very
people
implore
so
elected
very,
our
Rockaway
is
the
very,
10
I
and
day.
the
Thank
you
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
58
58
1
May
10,
2
for
your
3
2012
time.
COMMISSIONER
4
through
5
you
20,
wanted
6
I
believe
to
say
SENATOR
7
much,
8
Commissioner
9
Associate
CLANCY:
a
Senator
few
SMITH:
Commissioner
Smith,
Thank
you
for
being
here,
Commissioner
Cook,
Commissioner
very
Johnson.
10
Commissioner,
I
11
familiar
the
12
closes,
13
today
14
Peninsula,
15
death
16
I
17
have
18
residents
19
understand
the
Rockaways,
20
understand
the
demographics
21
Rockaways,
you
need
to
understand
22
is
community
that
is
growing.
23
have
24
which
25
10,000
another
is
when
to
think
a
with
it
heard
a
sure
one
close
are
when
one
My
the
opening
door
concern
door
the
of
door
of
you
Rockaways.
is
important,
testimony
here.
But
growing,
people
are
opens.
neighborhood,
is
you
phrase
you
you
the
am
16
words.
Shah
Clancy,
Before
out
and
I
know
a
lot
of
from
you
really
you
Auburn
bringing
here.
We
need
need
of
by
the
to
to
the
this
You
the
more
just
Sea,
than
put
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
59
59
1
May
10,
2012
2
close
3
trains
that
4
line.
You
5
built,
a
6
Everything
7
gets
8
reverse
of
9
concern
that
I
10
meeting
with
these
11
have
been
12
very
aggressive,
13
what
I
14
try
15
process.
16
I
have
been
on
the
phone
with
yourself.
17
I
have
been
on
the
phone
with
the
18
trustee,
19
the
20
office.
21
Here
22
us
23
give
up
24
have
the
25
did
to
is
to
$15
million
are
the
school
that
on
help
I
is
my
an
urban
renewal
that.
and
very
The
been
on
money
retested
I
a
here,
we
been
I
did
could
to
this
I
have,
phone
and
with
Governor's
The
that
or
was
the
The
and
that
that
the
area
had
has
understand
with
That
have
It
best
someone
lab
I
testy,
problem
being
the
individuals
challenge.
the
for
A
facility.
phone.
them
find
is
built.
have,
have
that
except
the
the
being
the
The
of
along
YMCA
medical
could.
all
is
happening,
Governor,
was
running
have
the
into
challenge
could
possibly
the
resources
or
reopened.
rejected.
to
They
to
We
put
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
60
60
1
May
10,
2012
2
up
3
they
4
and
buy
5
did
that
6
said
7
you
talk
8
one
being
9
it
cash,
and
said
find
the
to
11
communicating
12
Department,
13
is
every
14
we
were
15
came
16
always
17
hearing
18
think
19
condition
20
Commissioner,
21
heart.
22
where
23
honorable
24
tremendous
25
When
with
no.
the
to
it.
we
was
You
biggest
to
1199,
was
The
a
problem
solution
that
up
with,
after
solution,
there
was
is
a
we
why
here
you
we
are
saying
they
preconceived
close
this
are
hospital.
appealing
to
know
your
background.
you
have
come
from.
individual.
closed
work
after
I
we
if
Health
no.
come
in
We
perhaps
talked
us
said
was
work
come
Choice.
the
That
to
open
asked
We
public
there
to
could
to
a
else
perhaps
there
asked
Then
the
with
you
no.
creditors,
said
time
a
was
them.
they
up
it
1199,
and
to
People's
the
10
told
somebody
Then
with
all
were
hospital
with
no.
out
then
in
down
the
You
You
Mary
I
are
have
health
your
know
an
done
field.
Immaculate
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
61
61
1
May
10,
2012
2
Hospital,
3
Hospital
4
pressure.
5
John's,
6
pressure.
When
7
Vincent's,
you
8
Manhattan
9
closed
down
10
John's
cannot
11
have
12
Assemblyman
13
Addabo
14
you
15
about
16
single
17
President's
18
all
19
unique.
20
Commissioner,
you
have
21
to
us,
understand
22
peninsula.
23
this
24
something
25
it
Jamaica
was
there
When
you
to
they
to
down
take
closed
got
Saint
the
down
Saint
hospitals
in
the
pressure.
You
Peninsula
Hospital.
Saint
take
the
Huntley
You
about
heard
official,
The
all
If
this
happens
happened,
the
every
Borough
We
to
take
cannot
is
time
the
goes
the
are
the
wrong
peninsula,
with
you
have
Peninsula
something
on
heard
here.
Rockaway
have
Turner,
You
You
You
have
you
about
Sanders.
office,
you
here,
Titus.
elected
understand
pressure.
here,
Goldfeder
island,
Queens
the
closed
have
Michelle
has
take
Booth
take
here.
here.
to
you
had
Senator
heard
Hospital,
if
bridge,
get
on
and
across,
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
62
62
1
May
10,
2012
2
that
3
everybody
4
John's
5
now.
6
Peninsula
7
you
8
Commissioner,
I
9
pleading
you,
is
serious.
to
Saint
cannot
They
have
had
You
11
fledged
12
will
13
record.
14
of
15
need
16
coming
17
through
18
do,
19
patients
20
resources,
21
this
22
Commissioner,
23
asking,
24
sometimes
25
situation.
am
have
this
I
my
any
way
the
will
of
the
Senate,
do.
As
I
any
hospital
a
I
I
very
are
one
I
are
that
I
can
any
I
get
for
all
I
back.
that
know
the
diverting
that
put
please,
please.
in
be
as
I
Governor,
divert
dollars
on
whatever
that
the
you,
you
anything
will
to
to
do
am
do
say
63,
they
I
full
can
Now
here.
a
to
resources
through
off,
I
out
you,
us
will
that
here.
don't
commitment
Senators
do,
moving
give
have
what
were
please
to
Whatever
to
they
begging
hospital.
make
I
they
send
Saint
handle
people
with
this.
what
not
when
more
cannot
John's.
handle
could
10
the
You
is
you
are
am
put
untenable
understand
the
challenge
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
63
63
1
May
10,
2012
2
that
you
3
This
particular
4
They
took
5
of
6
close.
have.
We
care
7
much
9
courage
for
You
your
of
cannot
10
speaking
11
community.
12
We
13
this
work.
The
14
far,
and
have
15
We
16
primary
17
and
18
speak
on
19
both.
I
are
We
we
what
there
is
you
in
you,
of
terms
happy
needs
loud
needs
of
the
you
the
of
this
make
have
work
to
in
gone
do.
terms
acute
as
we
capacity
of
listen
to
you.
SMITH:
Let
me
just
this
please.
22
is
here.
If
23
answers,
you
have
24
know
you
are
pissed
25
off
too,
but
we
we
are
The
going
got
have
to
off.
got
of
care,
to
21
is
clear.
we
done
so
who
and
to
are
being
this
here,
is
care
admire
ways
lot
increasing
am
the
find
a
I
is
reality
work
SENATOR
to
to
your
care,
of
hear
looking
know
20
behalf
Take
Thank
testimony.
who
often.
unique.
let
SHAH:
everyone
on
is
Brookdale.
COMMISSIONER
8
talked
situation
of
Peninsula.
have
say
Commissioner
to
get
listen.
I
him
am
any
I
pissed
here
now.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
64
64
1
May
2
Let's
3
It
will
be
on
4
be
able
to
move
5
you
cannot
6
the
gentleman
7
Department.
He
8
the
Governor
what
9
You
have
to
10
10,
2012
at
least
hear
the
not
got
what
he
record,
forward
let
him
that
the
one
do,
hear
say.
will
here,
but
This
is
Health
that
how
what
to
we
speak.
the
to
and
from
runs
is
has
tells
to
he
do
has
it.
got
to
say.
11
COMMISSIONER
12
commitment
13
room,
14
to
15
needs
16
will
17
the
18
advocates,
19
area,
20
and
how
21
too
long,
22
what
it
23
will
try
24
are
25
can't
to
to
as
out
we
work
to
how
very
So
our
everyone
in
this
peninsula,
to
best
meet
them,
and
with
you,
officials,
with
the
the
citizens
figure
out
what
this
them.
think
community
deserves
in
to
figure
work
with
that
I
I
terms
out
you
have
of
your
has
what
to
all
we
with
this
needs
that
not
of
your
the
are
for
gotten
care.
get
is
the
closely
get
this
on
with
to
say
to
understand
elected
and
you,
everyone
figure
SHAH:
We
needs
them.
I
answers.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
65
65
1
May
10,
2
I
3
silver
4
thing
and
it
5
It
not
that
6
because
7
answer
8
there
9
community,
wish
is
10
how
11
term
12
my
2012
I
did.
I
bullet
are
that
will
then
were
we
and
meet
and
in
the
like
15
I
16
Immaculate
17
screamed,
18
ground.
19
the
20
Peninsula.
21
with
22
Don't
23
because
24
honest.
25
hear.
say
lived
am
Governor
on
I
next
believe
I
to
we
for
this
to
figure
in
So
that
support
you.
of
Mary
marched,
fought
I
to
on
met
talk
meeting
again
you
being
believe
why
the
about
that
am
we
with
everything
know
is
just
be
don't
out
would
just
I
is
the
But
don't.
don't
the
reality
it.
be
week.
were,
The
I
Tuesday
will
it
needs
We
closed
problems.
if
closing
yelled,
one
you.
here
the
it
term.
to
a
this
the
is
those
Hospital.
They
I
do
job
was
wish
HUNTLEY:
I
we
I
I
long
through
him
all
needs
back
SENATOR
do
easy.
our
to
to
fix
extreme
14
said
would
that
commitment
there
easy.
best
13
wish
sure.
hear,
very
everything
in
I
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
66
66
1
May
10,
2012
2
communities,
3
communities
or
4
but
wealthy,
5
hospitals.
We
6
Queens,
other
7
we
8
Other
9
ever
not
are
the
the
normally
losing
think
The
11
whatever
12
Okay.
13
they
14
could
pay
for
15
nonsense.
We
16
even
17
paper
18
So
19
20
the
They
went
state
have
has
they
the
pay
do
for
to
open
this
COMMISSIONER
25
please
I
that
who
indicate
state
for
that
is
not
okay.
going
anybody
when
hospitals,
are
if
as
on
let
24
do.
money
just
announcement
the
do
more
to
23
you
spent
going
23.
to
far
pay
four.
We
not
through
As
Now
Did
to
stuff
working
16
want
in
they
money
We
be
22
did
lab,
that.
is
Why?
Why
will
21
Queens.
That
money.
for
we
hospitals
of
one.
class,
close
three
it?
important.
than
middle
survive.
hell
in
poorer
they
part
this
about
survive?
lower
lost
hospitals
10
I
the
the
is
to
with
you.
this
go
away.
Thank
want
to
We
have
signers
in
need
of
if
you
you.
make
we
us
are
hospital.
CLANCY:
just
We
on
an
here
that,
are
in
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
67
67
1
May
10,
2012
2
need
of
sign
3
Thank
language
interpretation.
you.
4
MS.
STERN:
5
Stern.
6
since
I
7
is
able
8
walk
down
9
even
though
my
I
have
was
Hi,
been
six
aisle
of
the
11
of
hospital.
12
just
13
disintegrated.
I
14
weeks,
got
15
thank
16
discussion
17
because
18
many
19
in
20
one
time
21
Two
times
22
death,
23
they
24
you
25
hospital
I
disintegrated,
and
they
you.
Not
and
was
to
of
in
me
make
So
been
in
or
have
another,
in
my
patched
going
from
me
met
up
to
us,
I
the
I
this
but
the
people
naked
am
grateful.
met
death,
am
away
so
me
have
with
and
take
I
of
two
hospital
of
seen
life,
seriously
this
and
knees
here.
light
most
my
for
have
think
staff
coma
meeting,
I
me,
leg
a
up
help
the
and
my
to
assistance
to
that
audience
are
tried
fell
This
able
and
times,
this
am
expertise
here
and.
without
everybody
because
I
I
Leona
out
old,
assistant.
this
am
living
weeks
10
this
I
here.
at
with
and
If
this
reason
I'm
here
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
68
68
1
May
10,
2012
2
is
3
hospital,
4
staff.
5
bleeding
on
6
think
closing
7
quickly.
8
looks
9
on
because
I
and
If
of
were
the
beach,
beach,
didn't
talk
11
asthma,
12
hospital
fast
13
know
why
you
14
need
an
a
being
enough.
answer.
MR.
about
SALMON:
follow.
17
president
18
Owners
Association.
19
that
lot
20
people
21
concerned
22
That
23
operations
24
care
25
had
a
is
I'm
on
Peter
of
the
of
the
with
not
there,
a
at
west
the
really
to
the
don't
We
you.
act
Property
like
that
just
had
Peninsula,
say
the
room.
two
major
extended
And
a
to
are
and
there.
surgeries
to
past
think
I
We
hospital.
emergency
fact.
stays
ambulatory
We
would
end
leg
with
get
Neponset
people
their
kids
Salmon,
I
it
things.
Tough
16
so
to
the
Thank
kids
what
slices
able
the
wouldn't
know
other
closed
of
hospital
kid
among
to
wonderful
you
don't
mostly
not
a
plenty
this
you
when
enough
have
there
10
15
close
you
But
like
the
was
few
I
have
times
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
69
69
1
May
10,
2012
2
there.
I
3
it,
and
many
of
my
neighbors
4
we
find
that
it
is
very
5
the
hospital
be
there.
6
use
it,
7
within
walking
8
really
are
9
suffer
going
have
but
have
used
the
those
that
And
Not
only
who
of
are
Peninsula
going
to
They
could
12
Village,
13
could
14
have
15
any
16
to
17
somewhere,
or
18
they
and
19
could
20
they
21
emergency
room
in
22
more
just
the
23
being
24
diverted,
25
to
the
walk
Ocean
39th
to
more.
an
need,
So
Street
houses.
They
not
able
diverted.
and
people
can't
to
take
don't
to
to
and
the
Peninsula.
So
ambulances
the
for
then
because
the
demand
care
they
neglect
people
try
them
get
get
they
there
to
The
the
go
worse
from
if
walk
to
gets
dying
Now
have
ambulance
up
walk
Ocean
they
it
do
houses,
they
they
them
Bay
Peninsula.
something,
we
live
automobiles.
the
that
do
of
from
take
do.
Many
there
than
uses
forward.
11
were
wife
important
distance
not
end
my
residents
10
get
it,
it
that
are
is
are
being
ambulances
hospital
has
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
70
70
1
May
10,
2012
2
increased.
3
ambulance
4
the
closing.
5
the
summer
6
critical,
7
speakers
say.
8
disgrace
that
9
properly.
So
you
will
have
runs
now
than
you
Also,
we
season,
as
you
That
You
10
biggest
11
court.
12
An
13
improperly
14
billing
15
funds
16
created
17
union
18
workers,
19
their
almighty
20
right
into
21
Department
22
to
23
this
24
people
25
and
are
inefficient
on
a
a
now
place,
they
did
was
not
more
their
of
everybody's
peninsula
who
support
have
so
failed
their
Who
own
to
the
have
a
getting
played
in
the
at
two
make
its
you
makes
that
two
get
about
and
lives
not
You
about
worried
Health
act
That
thing.
hands.
a
the
not
basis.
dollar,
our
who
did
did
care
of
bankruptcy
the
financial
not
helping
Systems,
timely
many
did
the
into
is
really
Med
properly,
who
put
ran
is
before
coming
heard
it
in
had
this
state
creditors
in
and
have
the
are
more
the
decision
risk
on
losers,
do
people,
their
and
job,
you
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
71
71
1
May
10,
2012
2
turn
around
3
also
put,
two
of
4
hospitals
are
ones
5
Systems;
Brookdale
6
put
money
7
because
8
not
9
should
more
of
and
you
the
run
So
you,
So
because
been
12
issue.
It
is
13
issue.
So
act
properly,
do
14
save
lives
and
give
hospital
15
serves
16
peninsula.
17
the
MS.
the
needs
Johnson,
19
Commissioner
20
Shah
21
coming
22
this
23
Thompson,
24
first
25
of
back.
us
of
and
all.
SEIU,
a
the
I
the
ever
health
dollar
your
people
job,
on
that
the
but
Cook,
I
see
I
guess
Brothers
I
have
Commissioner
Clancy,
community,
1199
almighty
Commissioner
missing,
of
just
THOMPSON:
18
is
not
we
is
officials
11
is
you
this
there
It
than
Med
pockets
elected
after
it
by
10
told.
to
You
Jamaica.
their
Our
get
more
and
are
diversions.
acceptable.
is
them.
diversion
that
into
the
really
reward
my
name
am
a
am
United
and
is
Commissioner
he
sisters
of
Claire
registered
also
is
nurse,
vice-president
Health
Care
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
72
72
1
May
10,
2012
2
Workers,
3
testimony.
4
Workers,
represents
5
hospital
care
6
at
Peninsula
7
on
work
8
hospital,
9
the
and
I
am
1199,
at
community.
10
worked
11
relatives,
12
still
13
number
of
14
We
deeply
15
Peninsula
16
doors,
17
to
18
position
19
of
20
Queens
21
when
it
22
over
a
23
every
24
from
25
attention
are
my
is
were
employed
many
make
It
of
happens
in
1199
possibility
closure,
and
my
to
including
this
its
by
also
been
the
and
dire
many
the
closure
in
more
Rockaway.
save
a
here.
effort
has
are
that
facility
SEIU
and
my
still
closed
Far
in
relatives,
are
unacceptable,
not
homes
lived
that
care
whom
relatives
has
union
acute
year,
I
close
tremendous
our
to
their
fact,
has
of
Queens
disappointed
open.
of
another
who
relatives
Hospital
it
600
community,
very
Care
than
numerous
after
keep
In
this
my
Health
southeast
also
give
more
Hospital,
the
here,
to
United
givers
but
in
here
so
For
exhausted
the
hospital
drawing
fiscal
situation
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
73
73
1
May
10,
2
in
3
political
4
there
5
morning,
6
Even
7
workers
benefit
8
made
work
9
resolve
May
2012
of
in
2011
we
called
breakfast
at
the
the
to
when
to
when
Rockaways,
emphasize
the
its
fund,
with
11
find
12
the
13
stave
14
the
15
Health
16
among
17
investors
18
to
19
continues
20
It
21
services
22
Peninsula,
23
trustee,
24
Health,
the
Governor
25
options
for
the
a
extensions
solution.
issue
off
We
the
crisis,
Care.
those
taken
and
were
their
health
be
extremely
are
our
to
in
State
raise
to
support
Revival
Home
we
by
were
the
the
Access
Rockaways
priority.
important
we
to
management.
care
to
attempt
misled
maintained
and
the
and
by
granted
latitude
an
was
too
were
Unfortunately,
who
to
in
the
attempt
continued
months
quality
is
They
for
initiative
crisis.
defaulted
and
up
one
hospital
arrears.
numerous
early
every
the
10
dinner
this
hospital
a
are
that
on
Rockaway
working
Department
to
the
with
of
explore
repurposing
of
the
all
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
74
74
1
May
10,
2012
2
Peninsula
3
meeting
4
Rockaway
5
1199
6
state
7
Rockaway
8
the
9
This
site.
the
Our
health
care
community
SEIU
of
is
in
the
is
art
new
of
11
Hospital
12
health
13
example
14
three
15
efficiently
16
Rockaway
17
supportive
18
outside
bidders
19
despite
impediments.
20
current
bidders
21
the
22
decision
at
23
to
weeks.
24
care
25
Peninsula
as
care
the
Saint
an
four
Shore
risk,
seven
and
the
services
must
that
In
at
the
any
the
larger
for
Within
serve
can
the
remain
to
find
the
new
hospital
are
no
willing
to
trustee
auction
back.
facility
There
are
a
as
reopen
who
the
an
of
effort
to
by
under
LIJ.
We
new
Episcopal
effectively
community.
a
the
time
be
Such
years,
and
of
some
affiliate
North
in
John's
system.
First,
building
should
direction
the
recommended
Commission
10
in
fold.
facility
facility
to
of
as
to
needs
two
favor
peninsula
Berger
approach
in
will
the
case,
take
make
next
the
six
health
repurposed
include
but
not
limited
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
75
75
1
May
10,
2
to
3
care
4
psychiatric
5
to
6
Furthermore,
7
Family
8
leading
9
comprehensive
an
2012
emergency
service,
treat
room,
surgery
unit,
York
11
providing
12
The
13
is
patients.
the
Joseph
Center,
of
be
health
MARRERO:
15
MS.
THOMPSON:
16
appropriately,
17
services,
18
care
jobs.
In
the
19
have
worked
to
preserve
20
possible
21
been
hired
23
MR.
wrap
it
24
25
the
If
will
in
MARRERO:
services.
Hospital
wrap
up.
done
provide
critical
hundreds
of
past
months,
few
as
members.
Saint
in
John's
health
we
many
jobs
Many
have
as
Episcopal.
Could
you
please
up.
MS.
at
by
Please
save
and
investment.
MR.
our
care
Peninsula
14
for
the
preventative
community
and
of
ambulatory
of
service
Addabo
involved
extended
it
P.
one
primary
should
crucial
22
a
psychiatric
repurposing
a
unit,
emergency
providers
New
ambulatory
an
Health
10
an
THOMPSON:
end,
I
will
Commissioner.
try.
I
am
When
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
76
76
1
May
10,
2
configuring
the
3
responsible
manner
4
Peninsula,
5
have
6
time,
7
security
8
placement,
9
benefits.
10
MR.
MARRERO:
you
for
MS.
JOHNSON:
the
priority
11
Thank
12
you.
they
13
14
2012
have
a
15
Redwick.
17
an
18
had
19
last
I
20
were
very
21
lucky.
22
taken
23
ambulances
24
turned
25
Emergency
for
are
which
on
would
the
well
of
and
away
My
ma'am.
Thank
you.
We
and
Johns
am
I
in
the
months.
We
We
were
were
very
being
times,
drivers
Saint
Phyllis
husband
of
we
is
I
different
simply
care
Water.
Saint
couple
because
Room
My
their
job
mandatory
you,
name
Bays
while
at
1199
floor.
treated.
Because
care
in
must
mean
health
Thank
use
say
by
comments.
citizen.
to
the
Thank
your
live
occasion
In
provides
REDWICK:
ordinary
employees
and
and
transformed
protected
training
I
a
status.
speaker
16
resourceful
former
fund,
MS.
most
were
being
John's
could
not
take
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
77
77
1
May
10,
2012
2
them,
3
am
4
were
5
walls.
There
6
am
that
7
Rockaway,
8
heard
9
mention
patients
were
exaggerating,
but
practically
glad
about
of
Breezy
you
to
11
community.
12
invite
13
homes
14
are
available.
15
the
bridges.
16
You
cannot
17
bridge
18
boats
19
know
20
how
21
think
22
Unfortunately,
23
will
24
every
25
you
to
the
and
that
have
you
a
beautiful
one
or
the
coops
All
the
bridges
every
already.
should
to
have
at
have
of
because
the
so,
with
You
don't
live
here.
same
this
the
or
you
opportunity
part
about
up.
the
the
you
the
that
through.
But
is
of
we
go
hour
coming
it
that
buy
Nassau
Water
beautiful
tell
to
I
heard
Bays
can
ships
also
you
I
up
the
because
and
condos
single
will
so
come
wonderful
you
is
get
goes
Far
have
they
them.
to
From
I
the
for
Point,
we
and
much,
from
today
Water.
Point,
It
too
room
came
Breezy
10
or
no
Rockaway
Bays
you
not
hanging
was
and
practically,
know
I
opportunity.
time
to
you
enjoy
peninsula,
opportunity
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
78
78
1
May
10,
2012
2
join
3
getting
to
4
part
the
5
I
6
One
is
7
and
follow
8
you
build
9
Peninsula.
with
of
have
us
in
a
two
having
hospital.
whole
more
hope
you
big,
big
hope
11
is
12
Board
13
New
14
listens
15
themselves
16
overdeveloping.
17
Standards
18
and
19
care,
20
My
21
like
22
Appeals.
23
Malcolm
Smith.
When
24
hope
to
develop
our
25
zone
it,
of
we
to
be
of
and
and
no,
do
my
and
Board
My
he
But
is
of
was
concern
New
York
The
and
Appeals
to
protect
speak
Board
from
of
their
ma'am,
we
heads
don't
want.
that
you
are
Standards
and
other
if
up
Appeals.
nods
us
up
the
the
no,
we
care
communities
Appeals
hope
sad
hope.
to
open
Standards
sir,
is
second
like
their
what
or
open
communities
fervent
the
will
Board
one
But
Standards
York
says
first.
you
the
listen
don't
you
Peninsula
One
will
I
10
that
is
in
thing.
through.
I
That
concerns.
that
a
difficulty
comment
we
is
needed
community
there.
He
was
not
about
to
have
and
down
there
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
79
79
1
May
10,
2012
2
for
every
3
possibility.
4
said
5
everywhere
to
6
So
you.
single
today
I
was
thank
7
I
meeting,
know
so.
us
COMMISSIONER
8
the
20th
speaker.
9
was
that
20?
21
We
10
numbers
11
would
12
who
13
that
14
representative
15
who
16
Bob,
do
you
17
Then
we
will
18
Thank
might
to
has
19
We
Then
going
25,
asked
say
I
of
to
want
have
to
but
I
a
to
start
have
number
or
call
believe
few
we
words.
have
Congressman
a
around.
I
Assemblywoman
know
say
he
there,
CLANCY:
are
to
be
this
recognize
want
true?
will
we
single
whatever
turn
Do
through
like
that
He
help
every
few
come
with
Is
a
Turner,
words.
up,
21
So
please.
through
25.
you.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN
TITUS:
I
am
20
Assemblywoman
Michelle
21
represent
31st
Assembly
District,
22
which
Far
Rockaway
and
23
I
24
holding
25
community,
the
includes
thank
the
Department
this
public
and
Titus,
of
Health
hearing
listening
and
to
here
the
I
Auburn.
for
in
my
actual
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
80
80
1
May
10,
2012
2
residents
3
closing
4
the
5
served
6
century.
7
the
8
health
9
1,000
families.
10
years
ago
11
legislation
that
12
Assemblyman
Roy
13
Senator
Huntley
in
14
created
the
that
15
these
16
closure.
17
time
the
18
here
in
Queens.
It
19
Mary
Immaculate
had
closed
20
other
hospitals
had
to
21
their
best,
22
flow
of
23
I
saddened,
24
here
25
my
impacted
of
Peninsula
Rockaways.
this
It
care
was
that
when
for
integral
I
have
was
to
the
was
a
in
onslaught
for
over
say
two
the
my
allows
was
a
of
we
to
hold
hospital
at
right
incorporate
and
that
had
that
faced
after
and
try,
by
house
you
after
that
of
center
Senate,
result
has
a
spearheaded
Lansman
in
a
part
co-sponsored
hearings
to
over
provided
I
here
Hospital
employment
law
It
an
recent
Hospital
Peninsula
and
public
how
try
that
the
with
new
patients.
after
own
the
community
community
am
by
that
however,
law
community,
was
today
stand
implemented
talking
in
about
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
81
81
1
May
10,
2012
2
Peninsula
3
thought
of
two
years
4
be
in
the
Rockaways
5
this.
We
6
having
several
7
Borough
8
to
9
health
here
how
Hospital.
were
can
care
Berger
have
here
in
11
report.
As
12
from
testimony,
13
Queens
14
characteristics
15
hospital
16
is
17
deny
18
elderly
19
job
20
health
21
We
22
consecutive
23
increasing
24
and
25
difficult
heard
I
want
at
regards
the
art
Rockaway
and
you
say
the
with
of
with
to
provided
the
would
after
their
will
Borough
hear
of
distinguishing
which
just
reasonable
nor
significant
residents,
seekers
have
you
closing
the
the
we
dealing
office
Commission
has
that
state
the
the
never
conversations
President's
we
was
ago
actually
10
not
It
care
and
would
a
unfathomable.
It
is
to
it
rational
population
cancer
new
make
of
sufferers,
residents
access
to
facilities.
already
endured
years
cost
insurance,
for
of
of
budget
medical
which
our
seven
is
cuts,
equipment
making
hospitals
the
to
it
address
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
82
82
1
May
10,
2012
2
the
needs
3
comparing
resources
4
boroughs,
Queens
5
beds
6
enjoy
7
residents.
8
certified
9
significantly
per
an
of
our
1,000,
about
community.
among
has
fact
that
in
our
less
addressed.
However,
12
examination
of
13
you
14
concerns
15
of
16
alone,
17
housing
18
attracted
19
are
20
projected
to
21
residents
within
22
A
23
district
24
remains
25
emergency
find
my
are
the
be
portion
on
boroughs
needs
to
be
your
there
district,
are
specific
the
In
necessity
Far
Rockaway
300
units
for
new
residents
economic
The
the
of
my
the
boom
routine
which
next
about
five
we
is
20,000
years.
represented
peninsula,
from
of
population
increased
isolated
or
in
of
is
over
available
is
that
Hospital.
amount
other
constitute
experiencing.
huge
the
particular
that
which
1,000
region
than
11
to
boroughs
The
inconsistency
there
other
per
is
Peninsula
hospital
beds
10
will
1.4
7.1
beds
other
only
whereas
In
options
health
and
of
care
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
83
83
1
May
10,
2012
2
facilities.
3
and
4
community
5
hospital
6
addition,
7
population
8
400,000
9
about
In
location,
light
it
is
requires
more
a
presence
portion
aging.
There
aged
60
persons
Similarly,
more
11
are
12
health
13
be
14
Peninsula
15
of
16
residents.
17
Long
time
18
with
me
19
Staff
20
invested
21
assisting
22
find
other
23
must
emphasize
24
is
the
only
health
25
region
that
had
surviving
in
own
Hospital
Williams
caring
for
that
over
and
older.
of
deserve
for
as
to
all
I
have
here.
deeply
society
are
and
force
to
Furthermore,
Peninsula
care
one
our
residents,
professions.
a
form
right
who
medical
the
persons
residents,
volunteers
of
and
served
employers
Ed
In
communities.
also
community
a
older,
85
Citizens
their
the
any
of
are
400,000
without
largest
and
aged
than
insurance.
in
our
significant
10
and
that
before.
is
Dr.
population
ever
40,000
the
our
clear
the
than
persons
served
of
Hospital
facility
radiation
I
in
the
oncology
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
84
84
1
May
10,
2012
2
department.
3
increasing
4
force
5
to
6
recommend
7
our
8
communities.
9
service
The
on
cancer
receive
the
we
I
a
11
preventative
12
medical
13
seeing
14
Hospital
15
constituents
because
16
services
for
the
17
battling
cancer.
18
this
19
undermining
20
care.
21
requires
22
available.
23
your
24
25
disparities
The
full
recommend
with
to
that
combat
the
we
also
are
Peninsula
life
many
saver
and
cannot
is
our
of
with
to
resist
I
health
community
services
again,
jobs,
those
of
our
my
live
job
perversion
such
of
provides
We
viability
Once
it
to
elderly,
It
the
that
a
communities.
closure.
be
thank
you
for
consideration.
DR.
known
a
home
needs
hospital
I
stabilizing
strongly
services
our
on
cannot
boroughs
services.
Rockaway
10
is
We
other
nursing
hospital.
is
to
focus
and
service
cancer
peninsula.
treatment
that
in
of
patients
hospitals
full
rate
that
WILLIAMS:
I
was
going
If
to
I
would
be
at
have
a
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
85
85
1
May
10,
2012
2
circus,
3
Barnum
4
Because
that
5
me
say
6
Dr.
7
president
8
It
9
left,
I
would
and
just
Bailey
Edward
is
a
have
is
just
of
the
10
him
to
hear
11
got
two
12
the
integrity
13
implemented
14
close
15
and
16
procedure,
17
to
18
Health
19
Peninsula,
20
CEO,
21
the
22
responsible
23
of
24
directed
by
25
to
that
I
what
to
of
for
tis
two
is
your
team
I
the
would
to
have
former
the
is
is
president
was
to
one,
a
it
with
of
that
the
legal
of
Medisys,
on
the
board,
is
financial
staff
of
close
discussions
the
that
Department
to
have
question
number
policy,
for
I
department
organization
for
NAACP.
like
process
assigned
is
the
say.
The
ethical,
team,
am
Let
Commissioner
Hospital,
it
is.
name
Rockaway
your
hospital,
close
my
have
a
month.
all,
say.
is
his
next
this
the
I
until
what
really
Peninsula
number
in
and
Far
that
things
other
of
Williams,
because
the
got
first
shame
have
waited
to
ways
problems
be
in
which
hospital?
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
86
86
1
May
10,
2
I
3
That
4
You
am
2012
throwing
this
all
is
what
need
to
find
5
ethnical
it
is
6
Health's
team
7
with
administration
8
hospital,
9
and
the
you
to
and
need
out
for
to
closing
the
11
back
to
this
12
with
what
13
realistic
14
closing
15
what
giving
16
every
17
By
18
I'm
19
of
20
sitting
21
those
22
decided
23
hospital
24
eye.
25
resources
on
this
of
of
them
is
closing
accelerate
and
you
come
justify
supposed
why
I
of
guidelines
to
you
hospital.
down.
that
Then
community
views
and
conversations
how
claim
legal
Department
hospital.
you
went
the
electeds.
investigate.
how
have
instructions
10
to
my
was
at
to
should
It's
it
be
be
criminal
that
hospital
day.
the
way,
I'm
breathing
the
standing
and
I'm
professional
here
who
I
to
not
walk
down
was
poured
job
the
every
into
that
and
You
close
blink
that
are
today
and
day
and
because
today.
there
within
there
a
here
in
here
walking
people
without
are
up
of
that
an
with
hospital
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
87
87
1
May
10,
2012
2
correct
3
before
4
that
5
and
6
tell
you
7
what
nobody
8
day,
they're
9
process
it.
the
you
You
end
were
close
unethical,
12
Governor
13
then
14
accountable
15
in
illegal
17
just
to
find
was
it
a
got
of
out
we
should
the
that
the
your
both
your
because
to
care
shame.
into
too,
there
behind
look
who
end
was
and
in
don't
the
18
president
19
My
name
20
as
former
21
things
22
thank
23
want
24
Rockaways
25
in
GLASGOW:
happy
to
of
is
If
the
behavior,
hold
you
were
Wonderful.
follow
the
wrong
running
say
him
when
about
Edgemere
I
Rockaway
years
NAACP.
and
I
served
ago
when
smoothly.
But
now
today.
I
I
moved
to
50
years
ago,
Houses
am
president,
Glasgow,
president
for
my
Far
Yvette
were
God
the
I
minute
decide
I've
At
doing
a
it.
MS.
to
going
don't
doing
to
come
and
whatever
that's
day
to
here,
for
until
hospital.
says.
and
11
the
going
this
reasoning
16
of
that
10
waited
right
just
the
I
in
settled
front
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
88
88
1
May
10,
2012
2
of
3
such
4
emergency,
5
the
6
Somebody
7
But
8
citizens
9
hospital.
Peninsula
an
Hospital,
asset.
I
Here
am
hospital.
my
said
point
of
can
is
I
this
11
and
over.
12
officials,
because
13
in
them
14
it's
15
works.
I
16
step
to
see
17
us.
I
18
I
an
19
schools
20
the
21
room.
Look
22
health
facilities.
23
average
24
something.
25
way,
am
We
have
am
so
am
don't
a
age
at
what
a
hand
that's
their
that
work
what
good
extra
to
health
I
over
elected
have
of
and
serve
person.
in
the
know
most
But
look
around
this
the
ages
here.
We
I
would
here
is
I
going
am
retirement
my
the
that
see
continue
I
here,
children.
of
I
medical
so
how
appeals
going
they
educator,
around
made
mind
that
not
please
because
age,
60,
65
to
of
walkers.
need
re-elected,
about,
an
across.
watched
when
of
front
about
proud
was
case
in
community
can
getting
in
walk
have
you
I
that
here
Gentlemen,
do.
am
something
10
all
I
right
I
and
say
of
need
the
or
put
anyhow.
it
that
We
want
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
89
89
1
May
10,
2
to
3
years
4
in
5
What
6
to
7
have
8
across
the
9
all
that.
be
2012
able
in
to
live
relatively
relatively
can
walk
of
I
be
10
Peninsula
11
MR.
good
tell
into
to
Let
in
me
CAPANO:
13
staff
14
Capano.
15
Congressman
16
Washington
17
Congress
for
18
resident
of
19
Congressman
20
by
21
important
22
being.
23
Peninsula
was
24
1908,
nearest
25
Island
for
and
I
am
Bob
be
this
closure
We
to
this
have
City,
to
a
to
get
two
you
of
Bob
for
in
member
as
of
a
himself,
remember
hour
is
is
disturbed
so
community's
hospital
Health
director
deeply
104
to
again.
name
who
the
and
you,
hospital
founded
a
able
Rockaways
of
not
up
district,
is
able
be
district
Turner
be
might
My
Turner,
75.
brought
Thank
As
I'm
I'm
to
Department
today.
the
and
here.
the
and
want
Thank
the
being
health.
Hospital,
that
Hospital.
Mr.
the
I
Peninsula
bridge
future
health,
carried
Clancy
our
good
you?
12
the
out
well
that
years
was
train
when
ago,
in
in
Long
ride
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
90
90
1
May
10,
2012
2
away.
3
together
in
4
organize
and
5
Peninsula.
6
business
7
summer
8
money
9
creation
Back
then,
an
fund
the
Everyone
to
residents
hospital.
11
provided
12
to
13
Since
14
Peninsula
would
15
this
solidarity
16
residents,
17
years
18
around
19
this
20
political
21
Republicans,
22
Independents,
you
23
you
Party
24
between.
You
see
25
religious
and
ethnic
essential
ever
the
same
see
an
life
be
just
room
party
Green
was
have
that
success
it
has
services
made
we
see
seen
to
seen
You
104
look
can
see
transcends
You
Democrats,
see
that
have
affiliations.
you
of
our
that
today.
issue
the
population.
from
to
to
time,
saving
closed,
similar
this
their
then,
expanding
You
unions
ensure
announcement
ago.
is
Since
of
local
continued
this
this
from
to
10
to
construction
donated
the
came
manner
trade
resources
and
community
incredible
leaders
and
this
see
you
see
Conservatives,
and
every
everybody
in
racial,
group
in
this
room
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
91
91
1
May
10,
2012
2
representing
the
3
Queens.
of
4
hospital.
5
We
6
the
7
served
8
this
9
hospital,
All
understand,
closure
us
of
over
us
John's
11
strain.
12
of
13
being
14
lack
of
15
away
now
16
minute
17
hospital.
18
conditions.
19
these
20
determining
21
death.
This
22
without
a
23
the
24
afflict
25
is
that
only
at
have
Saint
Those
ride
a
who
25
traffic
may
that
health
community
In
has
will
making
situation,
well
between
situation
Rockaways
30
low
emergency
be
the
life
and
created
care
crisis
continue
until
the
to
turned
nearest
an
a
are
the
In
doubt
due
to
under
factor
care
to
is
minutes
arisen
John's
That
extra
,
of
emergency
least
ambulance
one
signs
reports
has
devastate
Already
showing
from
that
will
John's.
capacity.
reached.
understand
century
requiring
our
this
leaving
is
face
on
institution
a
diverted
depend
who
an
Numerous
people
of
all
Saint
Saint
diversity
we
community,
10
great
a
in
to
solution
decision
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
92
92
1
May
10,
2012
2
close
3
Health
4
of
5
consider
residents'
6
so,
did
7
transparency
8
such
9
in
the
hospital,
provided
their
little
intentions,
they
not
we
advance
and
did
of
warning
not
concerns.
exhibit
In
doing
the
on
an
issue
importance
to
all
to
have
of
of
us
community.
10
Furthermore,
11
utterly
12
means
the
13
crisis
14
This
has
15
life
saving
16
whose
17
are
18
Congressmen
Turner
19
this
forum
20
something
that
21
since
end
22
disheartened
23
opportunity
24
was
25
hospital's
failed
of
DOH
to
addressing
left
us
at
to
made
care
real
has
have
been
March,
he
the
fact
solicit
available
closure.
a
of
community
care
needs
Although
grateful
being
created.
short
time.
is
is
in
health
with
we
of
alternative
very
closure
and
growing
the
the
medical
public
for
desperately
population
only
seems
plan
Peninsula's
not
Department
deserve
monumental
this
the
that
held,
calling
for
is
that
this
community
before
input
the
Furthermore,
we
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
93
93
1
May
10,
2012
2
had
hoped
3
place
4
hard
5
Perhaps
6
comments
7
this
8
a
9
community's
that
later
this
in
working
the
not
meeting.
be
60
forced
11
after
12
answers
13
questions.
14
holding
wait
15
Congressman
Turner
16
a
our
17
They
18
the
19
executed.
20
public
21
hearings
before
22
put
effect,
23
Congressman
Turner
24
DOH
swift
25
to
all
by
to
be
may
a
to
for
there
and
will
be
Legislature.
to
audit
in
not
that
the
in
closure
is
after.
urges
decisive
full
which
are
partake
strongly
and
receive
flawed,
hospital
the
months
hearings
and
now
pressing
important
committed
that
We
is
the
the
is
our
process
hopes
State
and
It
take
ensure
hearings
issue
addressing
most
the
our
during
will
three
our
of
our
closure
evaluate
closings
into
of
Clearly
should
be
nearly
take
attend.
DOH
days
hospital's
these
review
more
addressed
questions.
10
to
to
Instead,
within
the
for
would
significantly,
will
to
day
residents
most
report
hearing
health
the
action
care
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
94
94
1
May
10,
2012
2
needs
3
Any
4
promotes
5
unacceptable,
6
unbearable
7
our
8
Channel.
of
this
other
great
course
the
of
status
and
cost
community
and
care
you
My
11
the
director
12
at
13
the
opportunity
14
can
only
15
have
16
pleas
17
been
18
go
19
beginning
20
the
21
by
22
Health,
23
indeed
24
has
25
complete
SULIK:
provided
unnoticed
of
for
all
of
Sulik.
External
I
speak
the
years
From
closure
of
the
Rockaway
Governor's
the
nothing
court
short
contempt.
care
will
not
community
office,
appointed
Many
has
process,
Department
of
you
the
PHC
State
I
impassioned
the
York
and
that
health
these
am
appreciate
voices
whom
I
Affairs
today,
the
you.
Broad
afternoon,
Liz
today
by
treatment
been
that
those
even
is
and
of
much.
Hospital.
here
the
very
Good
name
hope
New
absolutely
is
health
everyone.
the
quo
the
10
of
that
an
MS.
heard
action
Rockaways
to
met.
impose
9
Peninsula
are
will
on
Thank
former
community
utter
of
us
of
and
trustee
and
as
well
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
95
95
1
May
10,
2
as
3
requesting
4
State
5
more
6
abrupt
7
Center.
8
Governor's
9
State
our
2012
elected
officials
answers
Department
than
two
of
of
office
10
without
11
requests
12
information
13
Even
14
meeting
15
disregarded.
16
All
17
vague,
18
the
19
at
20
find
21
unemployment.
22
consequences
23
so
24
consequences
25
serves
the
have
law
must
this
the
much
that
be
has
a
veil
hospital
or
But
of
into
have
York
gone
calls
and
and
aside.
the
community
been
of
secrecy
800
who
without
and
Yes,
employees
now
a
must
doubt,
contempt
They
a
the
collect
such
further.
the
some
center
jobs,
New
responses.
affects
the
both
brushed
stating
noncommittal
other
the
meetings
been
under
closure
to
Telephone
held
well
Hospital
to
Health
public
York
concerning
and
response.
for
for
letters
of
been
New
Peninsula
Certified
Department
the
Health
months,
closure
of
from
have
ever
carry
community
underserved,
go
the
the
that
elderly,
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
96
96
1
May
10,
2012
2
the
ill,
3
have
4
afternoon,
5
Queens
6
are
7
treatments.
8
are
9
maintenance.
as
heard
well
this
an
who
They
of
people
11
treatment,
12
routine
13
close
14
the
15
community,
16
about
17
lack
18
absolutely
19
John's
20
They
21
sure,
22
equipped
to
23
patients
they
24
occasioned
25
hospital
43
and
and
home.
I
I
being
have
are
not
there
but
the
they
by
to
the
not
handle
first
care
talk
of
Care
are
to
the
closure
Saint
Center.
to
be
not
influx
going
the
is
disparage
and
in
this
community,
the
I
in
people
are
center.
of
time
because
Health
do
who
upon
health
This
meant
who
thousands
lived
heard
for
people
dependent
care.
Addabo
people
emergency
frightened
health
or
upon
have
in
disease
reach
For
this
chemotherapy
a
preventative
years
of
chronic
those
you
before
reach
reach
depend
that
population
saving
They
10
to
They
life
fact
times
isolated
receiving
need
the
many
County.
in
as
of
get
of
believe
the
people
will
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
97
97
1
May
10,
2012
2
die,
3
of
4
we,
5
place
6
DOH
7
commemorated
8
Week
9
Commissioner,
Dr.
10
recent
health
11
New
12
efforts
to
13
optimal
health.
14
this
15
the
16
State
17
this
18
accurately
19
in
20
search
out
21
been
subscriber
22
subversive
23
My
24
director
25
information.
and
the
I
believe
result
the
people,
our
on
of
in
a
web
and
job
at
then
a
to
State
Health
Health
highlighted
to
build
these
enjoy
New
Yorkers
With
all
due
flies
in
in
on
all
respect,
the
face
that
the
New
of
Health
has
shown
If
the
describes
general,
which
achievements
contempt
community.
a
State
pledged
Department
in
York
Public
Shah,
release
complete
because
proudly
The
ensure
be
asked
New
National
public
press
been
The
site
April.
York,
will
government
have
trust.
its
it
why
DOH's
not
diligently
I
York
to
committed
the
solution.
to
word
of
have
position
never
conspiracy
or
theories.
Peninsula
was
Hospital
basically
I
have
to
to
as
its
disseminate
say
that
in
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
98
98
1
May
10,
2012
2
August,
I
3
and
Department
4
first
5
closure
6
to
7
and
8
that
9
care.
the
worked
closure
get
with
make
This
was
11
complete
12
the
13
consider
14
here
15
continue
16
this
to
with
community.
MS.
Laura
19
opportunity
20
certified
21
I
22
25
23
outstanding
24
Eisenstadt
25
commendations,
have
Rader.
years,
the
16
and
the
needs
here
you
please
health
care
here
in
name
is
Hospice
My
for
I
can
am
palliative
four
in
for
Unit.
a
nurse.
the
past
an
inpatient
cards,
said
the
today.
Peninsula
bed
been
you.
you
and
in
to
we
Hello.
last
time.
that
speak
at
health
utter
Thank
hospice
worked
this
so
sure
Thank
to
knew
has
RADER:
18
community
that
make
our
the
with
urge
everything
today,
17
done
for
I
that
alternative
purely
community.
to
the
emphasized
everybody
not
contempt
so
Cook
during
During
was
seek
was
done
Health
out
that
could
That
10
it
message
sure
they
of
process.
process,
the
Commissioner
unit,
Hundreds
letters
we
the
of
have
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
99
99
1
May
10,
2012
2
received,
and
to
3
validates
the
superb
care
4
need
unit.
The
5
comes
from
6
place
of
7
difficult
8
are
9
journey.
for
this
the
ancient
shelter
for
for
10
program
and
11
uniquely
12
the
our
13
circumstances
14
threatening
15
working
16
out
in
17
the
patients
18
community,
19
they
20
symptoms
are
21
Recently
I
22
with
23
unit,
24
One
25
to
is
need
home
are
an
I
care
out
there
patient
Melville,
of
had
in
is
and
manage
and
with
am
a
going
hospice
for
come
a
life
to
be
nurse
most
in
of
the
time
settings,
several
were
Long
final
when
but
control.
the
could
unit
While
does
a
life's
patient
inpatient
have
on
needs
cared
there
on
specialty
community.
patients
and
a
a
professionals
treat
illness.
a
the
of
hospice
meaning
as
a
to
difficult
as
word
inpatient
equipped
often
We
only
absolute
travelers
patients
Hospice
paper
and
times,
journey.
caring
local
not
homes
no
needing
beds
and
Island
experiences
available.
would
as
our
the
not
go
commute
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
100
100
1
May
10,
2012
2
would
3
family.
4
inpatient
5
to
6
room,
7
stretcher
8
most
9
quality
cause
our
undue
Another
care,
unit
she
in
patient
and
and
had
to
care
cancer
end
11
Hospice
12
the
natural
13
the
rights
14
fully,
15
dignity,
16
quality
17
needs
18
her
19
Unit
20
quality
21
and
22
years
23
closing
leaves
24
and
surrounding
25
you.
life
of
including
to
of
met
choice.
in
their
when
the
It
respects
to
to
environment
The
Eisenstadt
provided
families
they
a
part
die
over
the
needed
it
huge
void
with
possible
their
of
his
or
Hospice
the
of
of
live
have
hundreds
of
a
the
to
the
as
highest
to
a
life.
right
and
on
best
dying
dying
the
Peninsula
care
the
their
the
life,
in
or
patient
enjoy
emergency
Not
cycle.
the
the
coming
John's.
of
recognizes
of
days
someone
10
the
two
care
for
the
instead
spend
Saint
on
needed
bypassing
appropriate
at
hardship
highest
patients
last
most.
in
four
Its
Rockaway
communities.
Thank
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
101
101
1
May
10,
2
2012
MR.
3
Rudnick.
4
can't
5
she
6
that
7
walked
8
his
9
could
RUDNICK:
You
really
has
have
state
imparted
this
not
out.
I
calendar
be
told
a
more
He
was
11
man,
and
12
That
is
13
notes.
14
old
15
should
16
government
doesn't
17
found
out
18
will
19
daily,
20
goes
on
21
days
from
22
but
23
This
is
24
that
you
25
any
is
Harvey
wife,
day
that
so
cleared
walked
to
be
look
he
away.
a
nice
into
it.
great,
and
you
I
you
will
go
know
that
government
hope
enough
to
work
that
ask
for
our
next
work
many,
weekly
your
now,
taking
back.
for
many
up
us,
am
and
we
times.
80
I
to
give
us
date
of
what
deliberations.
not
I
However,
politicians
almost
in
us.
are
is
gentleman
he
to
I
that
concern
assume
going
and
that,
My
This
just
going
is
than
you.
the
He
more
my
would
10
he
heard
to
for
he
name
sham.
here.
us
My
days
a
Not
from
60
now,
week.
a
very,
have
of
very
important
heard.
what
these
I
can't
people
thing
tell
--
you
please
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
102
102
1
May
10,
2
look
3
because
4
trouble.
5
to
6
coming.
7
our
8
feet
9
answers
quickly,
and
10
Because
you
can't
11
hospital
12
sorry.
at
say,
2012
me.
we
Don't
are
I
I
going
don't
and
I
answer
to
hope
representative,
13
to
the
fire,
just
and
14
going
to
have
15
going
to
ask
16
representative
of
17
Marshall
like
name
26
Paula
your
our
quickly.
close
the
We
Borough
21
Marshall.
have
22
which
23
everything
has
24
colleagues
in
25
that
be
to
I'm
Macelli,
a
been
to
said
I
I
am
the
a
few
words.
afternoon.
and
prepared
government
today.
and
I
President
happy
are
President
say
Good
Borough
would
30,
Macelli,
representing
here
us
CLANCY:
20
are
very
for
keeps
gives
more
Smith,
one.
My
I
you
another
19
I
much
Mr.
really
MACELLI:
is
that
through
Paula
would
MS.
have
you.
COMMISSIONER
18
back,
into
thank
and
build
Thank
get
really
want
just
to
me
am
Helen
statement
give
except
either
by
the
or
of
you
just
all
wanted
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
103
103
1
May
10,
2012
2
add
one
thing
3
That
4
has
5
hospitals
in
6
have
the
7
throughout
8
this
9
hospitals.
is
the
that
entire
experienced
seen
very
less
than
10
years.
results
We
We
are
on
12
struggles
13
going
14
meet
15
before
16
intensely
17
doing
18
the
best
19
the
resources
20
But
what
21
just
22
Hospital
23
certificate
24
cardiac
25
approved.
in
of
that
all
demand
touch
our
with
the
hospitals
know
of
our
now
almost
the
hospitals
in
trying
occurred
closures,
but
certainly
the
job
they
job.
can
that
wanted
four
They
to
a
need
ago,
It
was
are
are
doing
do
with
was
for
application
and
granted.
that
Peninsula
request
catheterization,
more
have.
mention
years
even
They
possibly
they
submitted
of
closures.
are
to
has
wonderful
about
watched
that
since
I
We
We
right
We
that
visit
our
basis.
through
of
Borough.
11
a
Queens
five
closely.
the
of
of
administrations
the
Borough
raised.
loss
the
daily
been
a
10
a
hasn't
a
for
they
So
were
our
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
104
104
1
May
10,
2012
2
question
3
four
4
cardiac
5
essential
6
the
7
no
is
years
it
ago
cat
longer
that
coming.
My
10
I'm
an
tech
11
Hospital.
12
else
13
of
14
working
15
there
16
in
17
guys
18
years,
19
coworkers
20
technicians,
21
environmental
22
they
are
23
this
room
24
Peninsula
25
room.
x-ray
I
does.
name
the
benefit
why
of
is
that
can't
All
at
Hi
guys.
Thanks
is
Kevin
Homish.
from
I
Peninsula
speak
can
experiences
as
room.
that
been
some
long
God
of
me;
nurses,
all
in
way
or
Hospital,
Now,
I
don't
is
I
haven't
some
had
been
everybody
that.
else
These
for
30,
40,
even
I
see
all
of
x-ray
techs,
50
my
lab
doctors,
workers.
here,
you
have
as
them.
around
everybody
I
knows
here
like
tell
Peninsula.
long
have
have
other
here,
HOMISH:
for
this
to
necessary
peninsula
and
live
9
as
this
services
that
deemed
necessary?
MR.
my
was
services
people
8
if
and
You
name
everybody
the
other
it,
in
has
used
everybody
in
know
that
what
this
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
105
105
1
May
10,
2012
2
means
3
standing
4
definitely
5
about
6
more
7
action,
8
guys
9
put
the
10
all
of
11
start
saving
12
It
that
to
you
guys,
where
see
words,
than
13
and
do
MS.
14
afternoon.
15
Lawless.
16
Hospital.
17
was
a
18
and
we
19
of
20
shocked
21
that
22
those
23
My
24
everybody
25
all
back
So
the
only
is
step
to
is
up
about
thing
you
game,
action,
and
again.
not
this
the
into
work,
is
know
it
LAWLESS:
My
we
put
need
That's
Hi.
name
worked
I
are
live
at
all
because
led
at
in
to
it.
to
I
Kathleen
Peninsula
Broad
and
of
by
most
the
that
think
here,
Good
Peninsula
circumstances
and
is
saddened
hospital,
the
It
but
lives
patient
hope
would
guys
back
were
simple.
I
have
you
light.
anybody,
to
if
you
you
hospital
us
the
am,
the
right.
need
is
I
but
the
closing
us
are
circumstances
closing.
were
the
all
I
Hospital,
of
Some
of
engineered.
hope
everybody
logistics,
Channel.
the
has
of
expressed
numbers,
and
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
106
106
1
May
10,
2012
2
that
3
everyone
4
of
Health
and
the
government,
the
5
Governor,
put
the
hospital
right
6
fast
7
the
8
it.
9
facility
has
as
all
been
here
they
as
was
to
with
was,
11
person
12
was
13
be
there.
14
We
had
15
because
they
16
doctors
were.
17
out
18
hope
19
opening
the
20
closing
it.
21
of
lived
that
I
I
that
you
afternoon,
23
Eric
24
Council.
25
colleagues
for
every
Rockaway.
doctors
in
the
up
of
as
I
I
that,
much
pointed
but
I
effort
you
put
just
into
into
you.
a
represent
in
their
was
ULRICH:
am
one
wouldn't
where
Good
Commissioners.
Ulrich.
No
switchboard.
this
as
it
hysterically
know
hospital
COUNCILMAN
22
regard
realized
Thank
closed
way
calling
put
they
as
the
didn't
before
open
down
their
as
should
this
in
All
think
Department
as
They
I
for
worked
people
But
the
reason
shut
lack
who
that
speedily
no
be
10
aware
hopes
closed.
hospital
There
covered.
My
member
along
government
a
of
name
the
with
is
City
my
large
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
107
107
1
May
10,
2012
2
portion
of
3
am
sad
4
talk
5
Hospital.
6
have
7
was
8
that
9
disappointed
very
the
about
that
the
I
this
we
was
as
not
see
the
11
because
12
my
13
when
14
through
15
Sometimes
16
hours.
17
public
18
don't
work
19
here.
The
20
resulted
in
a
21
and
no
mistake,
22
emergency,
23
impact
24
not
25
Council
opinion,
you
are
they
is
make
of
at
go
for
he
closure
that.
located
in
Member
of
health
we
five
for
I
and
are
for
this
care
it
six
he
is
a
We
still
hospital
be
has
emergency,
is
still
an
feeling
Hospital
district.
James
sit
us.
should
Peninsula
my
ask
in
Hall.
works
He
p.m.,
hours,
Commissioner,
him.
and
Shah
5:00
to
City
law,
also
servant.
four,
the
servant,
by
Four
lot
public
hearings
He
a
could
hospital
am
past
here.
not
a
the
I
stay
not
is
we
Commissioner
to
to
Peninsula
prescribed
didn't
I
today
that
case.
that
is
of
before
10
he
here
hoping
was
fit
Peninsula.
are
closure
meeting
closed,
was
Rockaway
Sanders'
It
is
the
is
in
district.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
108
108
1
May
10,
2012
2
But
it
3
serves
4
constituents
5
way
6
community
7
the
8
to
9
emergency
is
the
most
down
if
to
not
from
the
in
hospital
every
primary
all
of
Breezy
Dayton
my
Point
Towers
The
has
critical
added
room.
you
ride
As
down
know
in
emergency,
12
labor
13
badly,
14
literally
15
between
16
were
17
amount
of
time
required
to
18
emergency
room
at
John's
19
Episcopal
Hospital,
we
can't
20
that
are
to
be
21
absorb
the
22
amount
of
23
summer
months
24
will
flock
25
will
be
when
when
somebody
somebody
minute
could
life
they
the
overlook
when
the
forbid
of
this
been
into
hurt
and
it
difference
Even
if
reach
thousands
be
the
assume
able
especially
beaches,
one
the
patients
will
the
going
somehow
Saint
going
people,
to
has
of
cardiac
is
death.
amount
a
counts,
mean
and
to
God
having
every
minutes
to
11
able
are
we
the
closure
room,
every
all
and
10
or
that
between.
ambulance
when
hospital
to
and
the
during
of
and
the
people
people
either
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
109
109
1
May
10,
2
drowning
3
on
4
a
5
centrally
located
6
peninsula
or
7
facilities
8
Rockaway
9
There
the
2012
in
the
beach
full
time
ocean
or
the
that
hurt
facility
in
the
full
the
more
many
than
workers,
11
constituents
12
are
13
unemployment
line.
That
14
They
of
whom
their
entire
15
public
16
of
them,
17
at
the
18
are
19
to
20
additional
21
There
22
health
23
the
24
remains
25
room
and
I
today.
devoted
service
at
their
willing
work.
and
care
of
the
here
no
plan
is
are
to
the
right.
with
to
Some
have
been
ready,
they
a
for
the
that
on
not
able
health
need
on
whom
careers
are
to
return
need
for
care.
additional
peninsula,
Peninsula
shuttered
now
clearly
a
of
careers
they
clearly
many
hospital.
They
is
my
are
the
access
that
know
whole
There
care
and
health
the
hospital
are
They
hospital.
fact
of
people
1,000
10
is
need
either
middle
time
serve
We
peninsula.
are
here
somehow
boardwalk.
medical
two
or
and
Hospital
no
we
emergency
know
of
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
110
110
1
May
10,
2012
2
meet
3
peninsula,
4
is
5
don't
6
Department
7
inexcusable,
8
is
9
right,
the
health
care
that
is
unacceptable.
have
a
disgusting.
it
fact
coming
Health,
to
of
that
from
that
say
the
very
You
can
say
the
least.
is
absolutely
disgusting.
that
everything
that
11
said
12
grandstand.
I
13
I
number
27.
I
14
shout
out
Phil
Goldfeder.
15
number
16
cut
17
patiently,
18
room
19
decision
and
20
Hospital
is
21
Commissioner
22
you
23
am
24
within
25
hospital
already,
to
32.
and
He
He
like
asking
a
your
so
is
up
power
that
turn
to
I
to
you
alone.
do
to
we
a
is
didn't
his
else
turn,
in
this
that
the
Peninsula
and
But
know
role,
everything
reopen
can
speak.
He
realize
I
to
to
He
of
It
been
give
waiting
important
to
has
here
too.
future
Shah
very
my
want
But
not
not
everybody
the
you
am
waited
speak.
play
I
waited
line.
to
we
that,
realize
the
that
is
10
was
the
reprehensible,
The
plan
of
needs
that
and
that
I
is
this
start
saving
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
111
111
1
May
10,
2
lives
3
2012
again.
MS.
Thank
RYAN:
4
name
5
resident
of
6
in
John's
7
then
known
8
here
as
9
would
is
Marnie
Saint
a
Good
of
residents
11
in
12
thousands
13
heard
about
at
14
talk,
there
are
15
elderly
16
community
17
The
18
have
19
am
20
I
21
at
22
amazing
training
23
I
like
24
Two
years
25
and
has
of
that
of
heard,
a
received
would
the
are
this
be
licensed
of
to
ago,
am
I
the
say
beds
that
that
of
you
the
of
Towers
need
of
causing
physical
I
services.
as
you
deaths.
I
therapist.
student
Hospital.
I
and
hospital,
my
was
of
to
hundreds
in
born
Towers.
beginning
Dayton
was
and
behalf
home
My
long
which
Dayton
on
also
in
I
hundreds
the
part
life
Rockaways
will
Peninsula
of
nursing
living
closure
also
the
to
am
Joe's,
speak
10
addition
I
Hospital,
Saint
to
much.
peninsula.
resident
like
very
afternoon.
Ryan.
this
as
you
training
received
there.
share
my
emphysema
a
personal
father,
and
uses
who
has
oxygen
story.
COPD
at
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
112
112
1
May
10,
2012
2
home.
I
3
mother
to
4
shortness
5
call
6
ambulance
7
the
8
minutes
9
respiratory
was
say
of
911.
time
called
that
he
to
I
father
being
he
having
her
to
brought
by
was
The
He
emergency
11
him
12
onto
13
treated
14
highly
15
and
16
Peninsula
Hospital
is
17
John's
often
diversion,
18
fear
19
exacerbation,
20
patients
21
will
22
praying
23
and
24
would
25
you
that
a
did
not
respirator.
He
and
saved
is
that
he
his
when
are
go,
also
sitting
was
he
you
known
what
The
a
maintain
like
to
at
this
put
was
that
and
I
Saint
live
in
COPD
we
that
he
COPD
that
do?
that
add
the
trained,
have,
him
be
staff
Now
know
to
in
admitted,
closed
will
night
to
highly
has
in
stabilize
have
life.
on
as
every
can
to
discharged.
professional,
they
we
he
was
staff
10
so
able
By
within
intubated.
were
my
Hospital.
distress.
room
by
told
was
Peninsula
arrived,
of
work
was
breath.
My
I
at
We
is
home.
that
for
I
are
stable,
at
dais,
where
I
each
wonder
of
if
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
113
113
1
May
10,
2
any
of
3
diversion
where
4
hospitals
that
5
2012
you
have
hospitals
that
you
and
live,
have
are
closing.
Thank
UNIDENTIFIED
SPEAKER:
Good
6
afternoon,
7
for
8
Department
9
address
being
everyone,
here.
of
the
have
specific
children
11
community.
12
least
13
room
have
14
this
community.
One
15
born
with
16
the
17
wanted
that
18
care
19
needs
20
her.
21
of
a
hole
in
reasons
that
I
be
very
facility
in
of
her
in
case
something
When
you
look
at
22
that
are
in
23
number
of
24
are
any
25
in
schools
this
and
number
a
of
room,
is
to
in
at
this
in
a
One
to
I
of
and
the
to
schools
the
children,
of
of
health
happened
the
was
because
cater
young
time
this
children
number
given
in
heart.
community
children,
the
children
my
would
all
number
people
here
close
the
of
this
you.
to
have
young
am
that
want
we
the
children,
to
I
had
you
from
issue
Everyone
percent
thank
you
Health.
you
95
and
Thank
10
at
are
days
schools
who
are
that
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
114
114
1
May
10,
2012
2
are
down
3
doing
4
that
5
of
6
increase
7
community.
8
new
9
community.
here,
about
is
anything
to
be
in
kids
We
10
talking
have
11
not
12
talking
13
our
14
after
15
for
16
be
17
forward?
18
going
19
were
20
point
21
now,
we
are
22
that
we
need.
23
from
the
24
critical
25
impact
hear
about
the
going
about
on
about
here
the
We
an
number
of
this
this
of
people
citizens.
on
that.
who
they
parents
to
look
we
a
lot
we
as
out
hospital
not
The
Department
of
for
livelihood
To
of
as
the
closed
the
that
Health
us
to
community
given
answers
going
things
of.
is
out
moving
of
a
am
are
are
process
I'm
I
what
left
answers
event
looking
that
still
the
not
is
completely
the
lot
care
are
the
There
that
into
as
we
in
rising
touch
children,
doing
a
children,
If
to
quality
into
senior
to
going
happening?
a
responsibility
them.
the
coming
coming
I
we
needed
critical
families
our
are
providing
going
even
what
options
we
need
are
parents
our
right
to
children.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
115
115
1
May
10,
2012
2
The
mental
3
resulting
4
hospital
5
staff
6
because
7
happened
8
It
9
rights
health
from
has
and
not
the
the
violated
so
issues
with
11
served
that
12
years,
20
13
It
is
14
to
move
15
cannot
16
our
full
17
our
communities
18
underhanded
19
can't
20
are
21
children
moving
22
fair
just
23
to
24
civil
25
communities.
get
go
and
to
what
unheard
and
have
human
dealt
individuals
40
of.
years,
who
30
years.
and
forward
the
would
hospital
unjust
up
it
in
and
is
a
go
commitment
set
is
The
through
of
ethical
on
the
went
hospital
impacts
of
practices
that
are
addressed.
staff
many
10
that
closing
been
unfair
at
the
the
what
of
issues
examples
work,
servants
we
to
and
work
work
right
are
now,
setting
for
right
in
to
serve
the
I
people
am
we
give
service
happening.
and
So
and
us
these
forward,
and
for
where
without
example
right
society
to
practices
an
not
If
what
to
them
getting
in
asking
we
needs
our
to
be
up
as
our
as
a
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
116
116
1
May
10,
2
parent
3
to
4
our
5
that
6
we
2012
give
secure
us
the
children
we
do
7
tools
that
well
being
and
and
have
have
the
in
a
the
lot
of
COMMISSIONER
8
to
9
just
ask
30
through
another
10
in
need
11
have
12
let
13
Thank
of
them
us
community,
because
35,
reminder
know.
down
here.
I
am
going
please,
and
also
that
anyone
if
interpreters,
here.
Identify
Just
we
is
do
please
yourselves.
you.
14
MR.
15
apologize
16
Unfortunately,
17
picked
are
18
work.
I
19
Leader
in
20
and
21
annoyed.
22
to
23
I
schools
those
available
of
of
CLANCY:
signing
need
safety
numbers
this
we
am
jail
DISALVIO:
for
Good
being
the
the
the
hours
very
If
had
my
way,
to
prove
promise
to
on
my
24
holding
the
25
symbolizes
picture
those
who
who
District
District,
outraged,
today
be
you
those
Assembly
upset,
I
that
for
Assembly
23rd
I
late.
ridiculous
am
afternoon.
it,
I
and
would
but
I
best
behavior.
of
coffin.
a
have
died
go
and
I'm
This
will
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
117
117
1
May
10,
2012
2
die
and
will
3
Peninsula
4
say,
5
am
6
I
7
people
who
8
okay.
Each
9
who
I
feel
to
and
worked
give
every
one
in
many
12
and
13
care.
14
But
15
take
16
Hospital,
the
17
with,
eight
18
unit
beds.
19
have
a
heart
20
we
are
dead.
21
when
22
to
23
couple
24
birthday
25
collapsed.
areas,
are
They
my
very
to
Peninsula
cold,
talk.
our
of
family,
the
people
There
into
and
Saint
only
was
As
in
places
they
God
beds,
forbid
attack,
I
can
God
we
I
don't
might
John's
you
any
are
of
to
rest
her,
was
after
August
was
August
in
care
okay,
1995,
rushed
12th,
midnight.
11th.
us
us
dead,
back
on
left
coronary
go
Hospital
She
if
hospital
CCU
minutes
was
go
I
the
community.
you
might
community.
real.
statistics
So
mom,
I
of
cared.
talk
of
were
this
If
Hospital,
and
11
has
this
were
plastics
time
in
there
no
closing
disclosure.
work
10
let's
the
full
Peninsula
there
other
to
Hospital.
raised
that
they
due
General
have
born
die
a
My
She
congestive
heart
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
118
118
1
May
10,
2
failure,
3
a
4
beds
5
don't
6
Frieda,
7
should
be
8
Frieda
was
9
mom
CCU
2012
full
bed.
that
of
fluids,
There
night.
know,
I
are
love
or
no
But
Dr.
Frieda,
here,
Frieda?
you
her,
God
bless
and
still
in
the
emergency
in
took
such
great
11
her,
12
needed
13
cancer,
14
neck,
as
they
15
staff
of
Peninsula,
16
she
17
lived
18
passed.
19
Just
20
to
21
maternity
22
surgical
23
pediatric,
24
for
25
take
okay.
You
blood,
and
number
say.
have
They
did
a
eight
continue,
in
beds,
beds.
loads
nuts.
A
had
her
to
the
didn't
right
31st
when
beds,
die
John's,
12
hospital,
going
and
6
psychiatric
257
She
job.
am
medical
when
she
I
of
great
away.
beautiful
total
community
mom
Thanks
neonatal,
of
She
on
Saint
4
of
up
ICU
144
care
My
My
emergency
idea.
she
I
room.
was
died
January
say
no
ICU
her,
that
platelets.
her
until
have
no
practicing.
days
They
should
be
eight
room.
our
CCU
needed
was
10
us
she
100
stayed
to
and
beds
beds.
you
You
close
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
119
119
1
May
10,
2012
2
it.
3
Now
I
live
4
who
l
ive
5
you
know
6
streets
are
closed
7
dropped
and
walk
8
and
you
can't
9
are
doing
in
in
are
11
Parkway
12
to
13
you
14
Hospital,
15
the
16
of
17
didn't
18
John's.
19
opened
20
bled
21
John's
22
that
23
somewhere
24
absolutely
25
more
west
you
have
time
So
to
a
his
all
there,
from
She
oral
was
and
call
dead.
By
One
board
down
to
went
is
that
son
Saint
stitches.
She
It
I
needed
into
They
had
to
had
He
Saint
don't
do
go
unacceptable,
unacceptable.
unacceptable
when
her
refused.
else.
waiting
night,
She
there.
Marine
Highway
am
went
park
Bridge,
Hospital.
I
be
They
Bay
community
other
lip
me
as
can't
death
Kings
Island
night.
and
tell
to
here.
is
to
had
Cross
us
the
you
It
realize.
The
the
you
get
I
the
go
ladies
off.
of
town,
that
on
Coney
I
see
Any
of
work
Bridge.
happen.
end
around
on
doing
Park.
because
get
work
they
the
the
today,
10
I
Rockaway
we
What
is
took
our
even
time
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
120
120
1
May
10,
2
to
here,
and
Dr.
3
ridiculous,
and
I
4
I
5
do
6
elected
7
I
8
there,
9
had
a
10
the
summer.
11
in
12
got
two
13
and
we
14
to
15
Shirley
16
Addabo
and
17
time.
I
18
Goldfeder.
19
Ulrich
20
those
21
sitting
in
the
22
ashamed
of
themselves,
23
a
24
community,
25
of
be
am
2012
standing
want
want
to
rally
a
Senator
his
I
and
who
and
office.
it
in
thank
want
to
didn't
they
and
You
the
never
they
know
we
during
days,
city,
I
do
Smith,
want
Senator
thank
all
thank
Joe
the
and
should
responded
what,
For
they
because
should
Phil
Councilman
Turner.
they
I
people,
Assemblyman
call
room,
been
day,
the
to
I
there.
like
member
Congressman
I
was
want
staff
to
been
turnout.
I
time,
the
every
Malcolm
Huntley.
of
is
while
haven't
loaded
great
say
Peninsula
Down
and
want
of
think
evenings.
had
who
That
same
have
and
outside
buses
the
who
each
I
to
number
those
because
thank
rep
call
left.
want
at
a
officials
to
the
do
here
thank
Shah
be
I
are
be
they
to
our
voted
will
had
out
call
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
121
121
1
May
10,
2012
2
their
3
with
4
Rockaway,
5
say
to
6
it.
I
7
second.
8
knows
9
the
names.
us.
Ms.
Thank
Ms.
you
am
want
11
place
12
lives,
13
the
guys
going
to
did
about.
No
I
that
on
MS.
16
the
17
life
18
unfortunately,
19
was
rushed
20
had
to
21
another
22
excellent
care
23
emergency
room,
24
here
25
amazing
58
long
be
play
have
lived
years.
I
resident.
to
I
hospital.
before
I
you
group
in
a
of
is
would
today.
people
all
you.
Marilee
for
myself
attack
Hospital.
not
our
a
year,
heart
received
I
this
Rockaway
there,
If
who
hold
consider
Peninsula
stabilized
to
name
in
with
Thank
Last
had
need
games
hands.
did
one
is
people
going
to
you
no
who
We
My
here
one
which
two
KAUFMAN:
I
in
knows
are
want
please,
real.
your
Kaufman.
just
RFP
know
we
15
past
I
one
sitting
finding
finish
Don't
because
debts
for
an
are
open.
is
please,
You
it
14
you
Titus.
running.
10
Titus
and
for
in
not
They
who
and
I
sent
to
the
their
be
standing
were
got
on
an
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
122
122
1
May
10,
2012
2
phone,
they
got
my
cardiologist
3
phone,
they
got
an
ambulance
4
the
they
shipped
5
another
hospital
6
because
they
7
were
8
leading
9
life.
phone,
and
Those
emergency
11
To
12
catastrophe.
13
close
14
we
15
What
16
Close
the
17
don't
have
18
drown,
19
own
risk.
20
the
beach
21
own
risk.
22
up.
This
23
saving
24
It
25
shipped,
close
was
I
any
say
in,
they
saved
in
my
the
Hospital.
to
see
hey,
facilities
what
put
a
like
and
to
folks,
for
would
you
you.
happen?
to
the
public.
We
hospitals
for
you.
you
put
up
Too
bad,
at
11
The
is
signs
cops
We
you
are
were
and
This
is
this
We
told
If
at
your
going
swim
come
need
lifeline.
we
swim
o'clock,
silly.
place.
as
is
on
conductor
that
Peninsula
happen,
beaches
a
people
would
off
But
like
the
me
it.
hospital
have
you
our
of
beaches
would
is
were
this
do
the
service
stents
orchestra
room
the
don't
It
fine
10
have
didn't
amazing.
a
to
on
at
lock
a
to
your
you
life
hospital.
cannot
be
before,
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
123
123
1
May
10,
2012
2
other
3
emergencies.
4
I
5
here
6
Dayton
7
there
8
turned
71.
There
9
people
than
myself
10
guys?
The
11
your
court.
12
that
stand
13
there
14
because
15
Thank
hospitals.
have
four
on
here,
plenty
and
of
You
up
of
in
you
know
what,
ball
the
to
on
be
time.
GOLDFEDER:
most
people
19
here
20
panelists
for
21
first
to
22
will
23
person
24
the
25
been
who
people
out
said
on
came
in
there
I
because
have
thank
coming.
that,
you
I
to
want
record
and
out
here
today.
in
and
be
while
to
night
up
the
to
want
community
every
gotten
I
this
sure
situation.
person
to
ones
peninsula
18
get
the
in
this
community
go
is
Make
this
one
what,
us.
appreciate
have
just
elderly
is
17
and
I
You
terrible
ASSEMBLYMAN
live
live
save
your
in
I
here.
deaths
for
time
We
more
have
and
this
and
no
elderly.
are
reality
no
you
16
peninsula.
over
are
is
grandchildren.
the
are
There
thank
who
night
the
I
every
It
is
have
out,
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
124
124
1
May
10,
2012
2
who
have
3
made
4
where
5
you
6
only
7
didn't
8
today.
9
have
written
the
phone
we
calls
are
today.
we
didn't
know,
two
the
letters,
who
that
us
Because
day
ago.
So
weeks
know
where
we
stood
proud
with
today.
So
11
to
others
12
Clancy,
13
but
I
14
has
not,
15
enough
to
16
people
from
17
his
18
working
19
expert.
That
20
My
staff
is
21
me
because
22
remarks
which
23
Because
tonight,
24
speak
25
elected
what
thank
and
too
to
you.
I
want
stay
here
this
expertise,
with
that
was
and
listen
when
it
communities,
I
can
going
they
the
tell
to
be
prepared
I
am
I
not
heart.
official,
but
I
he
you
I
to
I
are
add
Dr.
to
respect
is
to
no
for
sure.
angry
all
these
am
am
Shah
the
very
like
I
we
comes
going
feel
who
important
community.
but
be
responsive,
disappointed
it
we
Commissioner
been
feel
of
coming
to
where
said,
have
didn't
from
going
everybody
get
have
you
am
of
to
10
were
to
many
this
three
am
as
see
or
I
got
have
to
I
read.
need
here
one
with
of
as
to
an
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
125
125
1
May
10,
2012
2
few
elected
3
this
4
here,
and
now
I
5
here,
and
God
knows
6
afraid
7
I
8
the
middle
9
God
forbid,
officials
peninsula.
to
don't
go
at
night
is
the
going
heard
There
accident
in
Point,
12
to
13
long
14
in
15
needed
16
get
17
have
18
and
that
is
19
has
even
started.
20
thousands
of
21
hurt,
are
going
22
don't
have
23
drowning
24
ambulance
from
this
25
respond.
What
happens
Breezy
patients
take?
back
of
it?
That
130,000
is
am
happen
in
the
before
and
this
are
be
to
not
We
season
of
to
be
they
One
takes
every
peninsula
if
could
because
care.
beach
that
peninsula,
going
here
been
line.
summer
Hundreds
people
had
How
have
and
bottom
the
to
they
Brooklyn.
could
on
story
an
ambulance
people
the
I
because
the
was
services
access
on
to
Who
that
emergency
to
kids
night.
11
the
two
sleep
weekend.
it
my
on
raised
afraid.
everybody
the
and
am
over
did
born
raising
10
take
lives
I
what
of
was
am
to
know
the
I
that
to
go
something
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
126
126
1
May
10,
2012
2
else
3
services
4
point
5
community.
6
the
7
We
8
economic
9
except
happens?
we
has
don't
need,
been
and
that
seen
this
money
it
is
about
to
to
saving
all
to
decisions,
decisions
decisions.
think
11
listening
12
Hospital
13
Peninsula
Hospital
was
a
14
Peninsula
Hospital
was
caring,
15
compassionate
16
and
you
17
get
taken
18
quality
of
19
doctors
who
20
them
21
for
22
public
23
want
to
24
been
fed
25
after
wasn't
can
not
just
feel
care
of
care.
are
close
by
line
line.
I
starts
Peninsula
hospital.
family.
where
you
can
go
you
are
going
and
get
the
best
here
to
I
like
nurses
today,
being
years
service
a
Those
for
and
someone
community.
place
just
years
time
this
about
affect.
10
to
this
the
thought
going
community
the
nobody
has
decisions,
for
have
responsive
Nobody
people
have
We
and
this
saying
I
here
to
and
commend
today,
years
of
but
real
community.
that
in
I
we
have
line
after
line,
after
just
spoke
last
week.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
127
127
1
May
10,
2012
2
Every
3
to
4
speak
5
in
6
Everybody
7
clear.
8
listen.
9
who
showed
10
for
this
11
Department
of
12
have
been
13
the
14
happened.
15
Health
16
community
17
community.
year,
talk
about
and
the
the
you
face,
speak
until
and
that
MS.
Laura
20
Rockaway
21
We
22
came
back.
23
come
back
24
My
that
need
and
a
going
most
25
diagnosed
is
south
of
that
81
with
work
Hello,
should
to
shut
what
of
with
my
lived
in
for
over
for
a
the
reasons
I
years
a
is
importantly
have
community
was
in
Department
to
care
the
for
the
name
is
you.
I
One
that
no
a
goal
coming
to
trustee
had
need
The
point
a
she
We
about
Hopkins.
father
given
blue
anyway.
someone
Thank
down
it
need
HOPKINS:
19
are
we
been
out
you
their
down,
and
you
raise
Health.
is
and
made
community.
We
comes
has
have
hospital
were
they
clearly
never
18
rates,
now
We
Board
water
here
But
Water
lot
30
few
brought
old,
of
the
years.
years,
my
and
we
and
did
father.
he
was
different
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
128
128
1
May
10,
2012
2
things.
But
3
high
4
the
5
available
6
brought
him
7
doctors
from
8
able
figure
9
misdiagnosed.
the
quality
health
to
a
service
care
here
day
point
one
the
out
They
for
all
14
regular
15
Assemblywoman
16
everybody
that
is
17
something
that
goes
18
lines.
It
19
live
the
20
million
21
sick.
We
need
22
afford
to
let
23
seen
24
in
25
the
turn
honor
people
Titus
really
dollar
this
it
communities
go
This
go
our
ours
I
and
the
and
is
demographic
matter
you
if
live
hospital.
in
like
here
Everybody
just
happens
services
doesn't
home.
Truly,
Goldfeder
across
if
he
me,
here.
projects,
six
but
everyone,
like
and
him
thing,
everyone
just
I
was
around.
constituents,
so
was
giving
wrong
that
to
he
were
the
of
Hospital
that
13
what
is
and
am
in
that
back,
Peninsula
the
available,
And
12
the
is
York.
was
of
know
New
11
giving
I
in
pills
to
that
service
10
able
was
in
a
gets
We
away.
can't
We
community
when
you
we
have
and
let
down.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
129
129
1
May
10,
2
When
3
10
4
that
5
couple
6
there
7
They
8
back,
9
are
I
2012
came
years,
was
and
a
of
I
go
to
go
10
hospital
down,
11
that.
We
12
we
are
going
13
to
be
14
If
you
walk
down
15
around
that
hospital,
16
surrounded
by
nursing
17
about
or
five
18
around
the
19
happen
if
20
nursing
21
handle
22
We
23
think
what
would
24
emergency.
Just
25
emergency,
have
done
four
to
to
make
do
get
all
the
of
even
and
this.
have
the
to
be
things
that
need
you
see
see
back.
right
it
homes.
There
homes
What
is
sick
is
right
going
in
John's
to
this
cannot
just
can't.
hypothetically
happen
last
going
this
that
They
to
let
mind
nursing
Saint
we
our
and
gets
there.
that
hospital
there
A
not
and
is
up
this
someone
are
ahead
hospital.
home.
don't
to
stores
assume
it
story,
store.
they
and
for
hospital,
little
just
gone
grocery
the
and
can't
going
the
from
now
being
grocery
vibrant
we
just
saw
blocks
gone
so
after
vibrant
were
are
back
if
we
year,
Rockaways
had
we
an
had
had
to
an
be
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
130
130
1
May
10,
2012
2
evacuated.
3
something
4
got
5
peninsula.
6
going
7
So
8
that
9
we
all
10
to
write
11
we
really
12
If
it
13
takes
everybody
14
piece
of
15
back
16
hospital.
17
MS.
hurt
Suppose,
like
and
that
we
God
forbid,
again,
couldn't
Then
what?
and
get
off
this
What
are
we
do?
there
are
resources.
I
are
having
forum,
need
to
to
our
need
takes
fund
get
needs
19
resident
20
community
21
importantly,
22
health
23
geriatric
24
most
25
geriatric
Felicia
of
my
we
if
a
it
little
need
this
evening.
I
I
of
the
worker,
am
having
26
on
in
the
a
spent
years
but
the
most
expert
I
My
a
also
but
it.
over
am
am
board,
worker,
career,
social
and
hospital
be,
Good
not
aspect
social
with
Johnson.
planning
care
need
hospital.
this
Rockaway.
I'm
We
you.
JOHNSON:
name
because
raisers,
up
to
God
officials,
this
coming
Thank
18
of
get
to
thank
together.
having
it
this
elected
to
money
where
is
get
had
someone
to
you
we
most
as
a
of
my
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
131
131
1
May
10,
2012
2
career
3
nursing
homes.
4
nursing
home
5
John's
Hospital.
6
I
it
7
believe
the
8
you
have
9
Commission
here
find
may
on
the
I
happen
that
very
peninsula
is
attached
population
used
on
you
felt
10
peninsula
did
not
11
hospitals
was
based
on
12
was
from
when
Moses
had
13
But
if
14
at
15
understand
16
about
17
me
18
health
19
about
20
what
21
was
to
save
22
out
of
the
23
they
24
State
25
how
what
is
going
out
the
care
the
People,
let's
is
a
Berger
the
down
beds
the
of
I
Berger
this
and
here,
money
was
top
the
end
of
to
of
Long
be
is
Basically
wanted
the
get
that
it
money.
from
is
don't
and
Medicare
looked
we
Commission
please
that
stubble.
Commission
needed
that
viable
out
that
the
Saint
that
understand
Medicaid,
to
and
razor
business
business
decided
many
Berger
to
population
came
but
the
two
actually
money.
wrong,
need
on
in
statistics
based
why
the
work
interesting,
for
you
to
in
to
do
coming
pot.
New
So
York
Island
reduced
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
132
132
1
May
10,
2012
2
everywhere
3
amount
4
That
5
hospital.
6
with
7
can
8
However,
9
at
of
is
in
money
why
they
They
reduce
X
to
coming
They
it.
the
order
time,
the
out
that
looked
found
said
did
one
of
not
Auburn
been
11
done,
12
housing
developments
13
there.
I
14
killing
people
15
going
they
hadn't
redone
16
enough
doctors
17
here.
I
18
community
19
we
20
and
21
base
22
what?
23
votes
24
Because
we
25
now
are
are
talk
am
a
and
tax
equals
base
what?
Votes.
don't
you
wise.
You
count
have
no
trying
about
am
experts
killing
Because
homes
and
because
Money
want
to
know
where
we
are?
tax
base
get
not
have
Money.
to
the
out
You
about
here
of
I
and
account
hadn't
talk
that.
sell
we
been
are
to
economically.
to
Sea
some
nurses
talking
trying
get
going
about
what,
hadn't
that
health
wrong
into
the
East
to
thing
take
Auburn
not
the
know
done,
am
pot.
beds.
by
10
of
at
you
amount
they
reduce
while
houses
tax
equals
why
here.
people
this
So
out
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
133
133
1
May
10,
2012
2
here
3
to
put
money
4
us
up,
and
5
the
6
want
7
dollars,
8
house,
9
up,
to
buy
these
to
into
you
knees.
buy
homes
our
are
cutting
who
is
a
and
pay
half
a
and
have
children
you
where
tell
million
them
know
11
something
12
that
13
right
14
Hospital,
15
my
16
those
17
be
diverted
18
to
be
diverted
to
Long
19
to
be
diverted
to
Mercy
20
care.
21
me?
22
rather
23
that
24
for
25
home
happens
closest
next
door
and
elderly
are
a
to
you
are
my
know
would
stay
what
rather
here
supposed
nursing
connected
to
we
are
John's
I
me
that
feel
like
they
have
to
County,
they
have
Beach,
they
have
Hospital
they
stay
are
here,
I
to
selling
a
You
have
hospital.
to
get
telling
the
a
them
if
because
home.
a
children,
--
that
be
for
don't
go
telling
Nassau
to
bring
to
grandparents,
to
at
million
you
their
Saint
off
a
and
hospital
to
build
dollars
going
residents
You
is
are
to
going
that
10
the
they
going
us
Because
house
are
economy
a
and
I
that
would
hospital
a
asset
nursing
What
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
134
134
1
May
10,
2012
2
about
those
3
Where
are
4
are
5
their
6
appalling,
7
the
8
gave
9
the
same
10
the
hospital,
11
is
12
emergent
care,
13
care
the
14
peninsula.
15
on
16
kidneys
17
now
18
Saint
19
no
20
dialysis.
21
What
happened
22
Need
that
23
I
24
but
25
close
they
residents
you
plan
us
no
diverting
going,
health
where
care
yet
that
for
I
I
gave
which
is
slots
we
You
to
know.
had
hospital
no
us
closing
for
nothing.
any
any
of
type
You
tell
over
to
they
need
said
in
it
movement.
that
had
for
of
for
was
me
have
beds
Certificate
put
their
to
because
of
addicts
happens,
going
is
There
kind
drug
John's
They
Health
much
people
the
it
pretty
What
get
of
more
are
getting
because
this
there.
Saint
have
a
have
Where
find
on
dialysis
open
I
care,
residents
John's
don't
urgent
even
So
for
peninsula.
can't
they
Department
you
fail.
to?
understand,
consideration
this
them
are
evacuation
You
Peninsula?
from?
the
plan
for
in
that?
passed,
Yet
you
dialysis
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
135
135
1
May
10,
2012
2
stations
3
that
4
now
5
I
6
want
7
economically
8
in
9
understand.
as
well.
actually
have
think
a
to
your
had
six
try
to
disrespectful,
11
don't
12
came
13
growth,
14
demographics
of
15
isolated,
are
16
isolated.
17
So
18
Tuesday
19
meeting.
20
had
21
were
22
off
23
blah,
24
to
drill,
25
on
Flatbush
a
I
when
the
you
night,
shore
and
us
where
and
had
gas
blah,
Avenue.
to
I
be
really
at
the
the
We
are
isolated,
a
community
wrap
it
meeting,
proposal
they
money
hospital.
to
board
natural
community
looking
and
one
the
you
thinking
isolated,
us
many,
community.
going
community
giving
this
how
to
don't
the
were
unit
put
trying
where
we
am
this
really
hospital
yet
honestly,
you
give
I
But
population
we
has
what,
not
but
understand
from
that
guess
am
a
pediatric
build
pockets.
I
close
beds.
to
10
now
a
hospital
like
us
You
line,
are
blah,
board
up.
and
We
they
about
the
blah,
blah,
going
to
blah,
have
closed
Everybody's
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
136
136
1
May
10,
2
concern
3
please
4
ambulances.
What
5
We
to
6
open,
we
7
lanes
going
8
another.
9
Guys,
are
2012
was
what
about
take
into
consideration
going
are
try
going
one
What
is
the
I
10
now
that
11
fit
to
12
disrespect
to
13
are
lovely
people
14
the
information
15
meeting
16
agreed
17
phone
18
important
19
then
20
shows
21
regard
22
community.
23
My
24
about
money,
25
let's
look
that
to
not
to
last
to
two
that
even
to
have
lanes
did
am
back,
but
if
up
how
like
by
come
was
so
walk
back.
lack
of
that
you
have
for
while
I
we
That
you
take
all
was
and
a
he
take
out,
respect
a
and
just
and
this
are
urge
fact
him
he
would
No
this
dare
it
see
sure
will
set
right
not
you
the
going
calendar.
I
two
happen?
and
that
lanes
disgusted
so
the
at
two
am
me
point
happen?
to
all.
he
the
going
here,
act
to
have
try
his
you
was
be
call,
to
Commissioner
clear
ambulances,
going
way,
honestly,
even
is
the
my
why
talking
electeds
to
Peninsula
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
137
137
1
May
10,
2012
2
closed,
3
population
4
How
5
everybody
6
time
7
their
8
be
9
are
because
about
for
that
we
health
putting
at
to
11
everyone
is
12
run
into
the
13
you
ran
14
being
15
and
16
for
making
for
is
18
up
19
40.
the
20
five,
Thank
you.
MR.
SMITH:
the
Floyd
Smith
22
Floyd
Junior,
and
23
Floyd
Senior.
I
24
South
Carolina.
25
foot
We
you
where
men
$300.
36
me.
call
through
I
am
father
in
you
will
grandfather
like
people
services
We
My
born
that
Thank
believe
was
need
don't
with
of
ma'am.
Third.
can
they
we
you
CLANCY:
my
get
straights
Excuse
21
country,
that
worth
I
comes
that
reimbursing
comments,
next
can
that
Peninsula
$10,000
it
what
sure
financial
state
your
is
so
get
hospitals
care
That
with
to
when
the
a
insurance.
people
the
COMMISSIONER
17
that
and
ensured
into
the
have
care,
care
and
given
so
out.
10
serving
legislation
insured
compensated
are
don't
do
health
look
you
was
was
Chester,
to
say
big
are
men
and
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
138
138
1
May
10,
2012
2
sheep
3
the
4
which
5
I
6
not
7
Peninsula
8
water
9
ties
know
it.
Concerned
am
I
am
here
I
under
false
concerned
because
I
am
here
about
is
my
issue.
you
have
they
are
probably
this
area,
11
to
come
to
12
doesn't
13
but
14
County.
15
want
to
16
been
there.
17
stroke.
18
prisoners
19
and
20
an
21
Office
22
me
23
the
24
Rockaways.
There
25
waiting
emergency.
I
Peninsula
Island
go
me
to
I
you
you,
Max
time,
the
for
don't
had
see,
and
to
it
was
other
I
of
year
this
hurt.
Saint
fell
were
I
500
also
had
at
They
took
John's.
down
300
a
officers,
hours.
to
house
you
go
Kings
I
got
ambulance
or
to
can
two
I
where
it
have
March
where
If
I
handcuffed
in
going
County.
there,
for
no
That
drowning
Brookdale
tell
As
waited
an
or
a
Hospital.
have
Kings
was
incident
in
they
I'm
about
if
exist,
of.
much
in
Let
Director
pretenses.
10
Coney
Rockaway,
that
Hospital.
That
representing
of
Executive
safety.
in
here
Citizens
the
really
am
in
people
waited
At
the
there
five
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
139
139
1
May
10,
2
hours
3
itself
gives
you
4
we
be
we
5
anywhere
in
6
Mouse
say
7
hospitals.
8
to
9
together,
can
2012
to
to
see
a
if
expand
doctor.
an
idea
had
an
we
one
of
like
ago.
we
Because
11
emergency
12
radiology,
13
times
at
14
go
Saint
15
somewhere.
16
went.
17
had
a
18
two
minutes
19
not
going
to
get
20
Brookdale
or
Jamaica
21
three
or
four
22
going
to
do
23
are
24
down,
25
So
all
or
to
when
they're
of
closed
I
it
Island
where
or
hope
I
in
are
or
ever
these
not
like
You
You're
None
is
Then
treated
minutes.
or
the
away
be
Coney
need
of
where
to
it.
say
two
is
now.
went
minutes.
not
need
six
incident,
have
three
of
There
gone
know
you
the
couple
We
it's
can
a
an
we
definitely
It
stroke,
I
we
don't
off
Mickey
but
talked
is
have
is
join
John's.
you
working
or
had
Peninsula
But
or
I
bad
two
available.
which
by
how
don't,
was
months
care
need
them
it
of
This
don't
Maybe
that
emergency
Rockaway.
10
to
So
just
in
not
bridges
broken
whatever.
Commissioner
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
140
140
1
May
10,
2012
2
Shah
3
he
4
stuck
5
I'm
6
said
I
7
show
like
8
right.
9
will
enjoys
came
his
from
10
said,
11
leaned
12
point.
13
for
14
back
for
Al
have
So
my
MS.
chaplain
of
18
Hospital
slash
19
Group.
20
hospital
21
of
22
place.
23
to
24
pick
25
I
Annette
I
up
and
I
am
someone
Peninsula
Cancer
not
My
Support
just
is
a
a
part
It
is
a
teaching
there
is
a
health
this
to
on
the
hospital
phone
hop
evening.
us.
in
the
I'll
is
The
you
gentlemen,
hospital
Whenever
the
what
made
defunct
Auburn
community.
given
need
Good
now
is
care.
Irvin.
the
he
gentlemen
sat
and
Take
IRVIN:
to
he
much,
seat.
The
Shah
very
17
up
way
you
thanks
name
this
Maybe
I
16
is
television
know
me,
alone.
own
know
to
have
somebody
I
listening
be
the
ever
fact,
Commissioner
by
where
presentation
my
I
to
should
Sharpton.
forward,
to
he
In
However,
just
15
my
good.
should
tell
back
because
around
pretty
trip
community,
and
do
say
Liz,
diabetes
we
I
fair
can
need.
testing,
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
141
141
1
May
10,
2
someone
3
testing.
The
4
community
to
5
live
in
6
is
part
7
What
are
we
now
8
hospital
is
closed?
9
people
a
2012
to
do
the
to
blood
hospital
educate
the
Ready
going
receive
do
My
12
She
13
They
14
could
15
testing,
16
walked
17
her.
18
interictally
19
I
20
Rock.
21
this
room
that
I
22
that
know
that
without
23
our
24
accessible
25
those
the
that
hospital
Rockaway
their
11
Plan.
since
are
the
the
chemotherapy
go?
mother
passed
a
very
could
We
her
the
are
to
There
are
a
for
be
180,
lot
went
will
but
of
good
I
be
of
to
they
her
when
that
is
grew
up
I
she
people
went
knew
here,
to
people
school
this
one
hospital.
cancer.
because
related.
community
houses
feel
at
of
all
community
school
the
here,
do
door,
a
in
form
treat
her,
make
in
away
rare
not
sustain
went
the
Where
going
with
people
and
to
10
had
pressure
worked
the
community,
of
who
high
Far
in
with
hospital,
that
is
medical
care,
nor
sold.
Every
ad
not
will
for
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
142
142
1
May
10,
2012
2
Auburn
3
schools,
4
All
5
points.
6
Our
7
have
8
to
9
our
knowledge
10
But
my
11
walked
in.
12
in
leg
13
have
done
zip
and
14
Hospital,
but
it
15
have
minute
16
Jamaica
17
on
18
was
19
a
20
received
21
lucky
that
22
drove
herself,
23
John's,
24
wait.
25
that
by
of
the
what
that
month
a
25
her
an
in
issue,
in
they
minute
place
my
to
to
niece
Sunday,
she
Street.
been
is
in
she
niece
ride.
had
have
and
did
died
She
received
neighbor
She
take
of
to
to
Hospital.
hand.
matter
shot
could
ride
could
Her
could
just
was
She
bystander,
the
come
Peninsula
ambulance
leg.
do?
share
She
dead.
She
to
would
other.
Jamaica
my
a
who
each
because
But
going
with
the
one
we
and
innocent
25
had
Hospital.
bullet
selling
people
51st
to
were
transit.
care
Last
way
hospitals,
to
biggest
on
two
public
are
group,
cancer,
a
to
things
Now
support
the
says
location
these
once
Sea
was
her.
fact,
not
She
to
want
Saint
to
could
have
died
Not
only
those
in
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
143
143
1
May
10,
2012
2
that
3
said,
4
the
5
in
6
previous
7
disability
8
Security
9
gives
are
being
heart
highest
this
attacks.
We
rates
of
I
was
processing
11
this
12
succinct.
13
going
14
from
15
hospital
16
process,
17
Thank
worst
city.
on
with
Saint
--
to
help
with
to
educate
children
In
of
anywhere
records
we
what
the
in
were
was
The
need
and
my
anyone
patient.
ones
this
disability
to
save
CLANCY:
41
lives.
you.
COMMISSIONER
45,
is
tell
John's
of
John's
for
that
been
Social
Saint
could
the
in
chief
for
Peninsula's
You
one
thing.
records
disability
hasn't
have
the
Disability.
the
it
asthma
Another
life,
pending
19
but
city.
10
18
shot,
through
please.
20
MR.
MARRERO:
21
MS.
WARDEN:
22
name
is
23
this
peninsula
24
in
co-op
25
four
a
Annie
blocks
41
Good
Warden.
for
with
away
through
350
45
I
afternoon.
have
lived
years.
families.
from
50.
I
We
My
on
live
live
Peninsula
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
144
144
1
May
10,
2012
2
Hospital.
This
3
my
because
I
4
grandson.
I
know
5
witnessed
6
attack,
but
it
is
7
able
get
to
that
8
was
9
there.
10
Auburn
11
relieved
when
the
12
That
such
a
13
had
to
use
14
not
to
have
15
family
16
want
17
you.
18
you
19
family
20
hospital
21
hospital,
22
always
23
home,
24
that
25
The
family,
to
was
don't
someone
reassuring.
I
am
was
to
I
have
member
hospice
to
we
are
Last
asthmatic
have
a
and
of
to
week.
the
live
the
came.
I
year,
run
in
to
We
go
The
to
when
your
the
to
that
room
was
nursing
to
that
emergency
this
my
appealing
the
on
afford
afraid.
from
population
who
want
people
use
were
cannot
emergency
always.
minutes
We
person
To
be
people
hospital.
know.
I
unit
We
you
To
Group.
hospital,
once
of
in
why
be
packed,
the
a
and
asthma
hospital
is
me
asthmatic
horrifying.
to
you
to
any
an
not
an
and
having
unit.
that
an
if
blessing
that
don't
have
have
Support
live,
that
comfort
That
also
Cancer
a
nursing
peninsula
home
room.
has
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
145
145
1
May
10,
2012
2
grown.
3
In
4
2010,
5
that
you
6
need
Peninsula
7
unit.
8
gunshots.
9
appealing
1970,
you
had
114,978.
on
to
back
Far
11
to
12
community.
a
13
more
need
you
the
unit,
Normal
15
resident
16
54
17
been
18
Hospital
19
my
20
his
21
drive
22
Peninsula
Emergency
23
take
of
24
the
25
another
Silverman.
As
here,
not
a
I
have
Rockaway
long
as
was
part
of
suffered
care
hospital
30
a
office,
car
a
few
you.
for
years
turn
us,
am
your
help
us
been
a
family
the
for
has
family.
heart
the
doctor
Room,
they
life.
I
to
will
He
week.
in
said
over
did.
a
When
attack
blocks
about
is
Peninsula
They
of
name
community
my
that
your
I
viable
My
felt
doctor's
trauma
to
Help
I
father
a
You
you.
14
years.
hospital.
and
SILVERMAN:
the
think
hospital.
Rockaway.
of
In
accidents,
today
Thank
even
that
Hospital
viable
MR.
people.
don't
need
have
We
10
be
So
don't
You
98,228
was
He
would
in
got
I
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
146
146
1
May
10,
2012
2
would
hate
3
drive
on
4
Jamaica
Hospital
or
5
because
we
have
6
then.
7
accident
8
pelvis
9
for
to
the
think
Van
would
When
my
and
and
wife
had
and
Hospital.
week.
and
12
home
that
13
It
14
a
15
wheel
her
16
rehab
center,
17
five
18
problems
19
have
Peninsula
Hospital
20
us.
The
Health
21
been
under
22
reduce
the
23
health
care
24
and
I
25
The
Berger
up
to
right
serious
a
wrist,
back
broken
she
They
asked
took
was
able
bring
her
things
she
wanted,
and
take
care.
the
community.
When
she
forth,
bit
better,
in
the
were
she
then
taken
State
in
sure
of
the
we
able
came
home,
We
taken
many
State
hear
was
from
New
about
was
to
to
the
another
and
the
can't
from
has
years
care
of
go
away
Department
medical
Commission
for
of.
over
all
over
was
care
pressure
cost
was
wheelchair
where
and
I
to
care
I
weeks,
am
a
to
place,
him
had
11
in
other
lost
of
little
a
trying
Expressway
10
was
for
him
some
broken
Peninsula
her
Wyck
fell,
a
of
to
and
York,
it.
appointed
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
147
147
1
May
10,
2012
2
with
3
places
could
4
at
Rockaways,
5
a
6
never
7
they
8
hospitals,
9
abandoned
the
the
responsibility
solution
the
or
closure.
11
It
12
targeted
13
tend
14
appear
15
service.
16
little
17
without
18
A
19
in
20
position
21
joined
22
Medisys
23
was
known
24
his
success
25
improvements
few
an
for
to
adding
of
Peninsula
These
years
effort
and
with
it
is
ago,
to
the
the
Medisys
President
as
a
at
at
at
and
leader
the
was
a
but
Board,
financial
Peninsula
Health
CEO,
in
of
acceptable.
Peninsula
improve
services
and
Peninsula
even
was
quality
acceptable,
not
for
hospitals
providers,
that
it,
said
be
Hospital
I
than
with
targeted
acceptable
better
They
not
provide
think
up
beds,
one.
should
cost
look
community
closure.
low
which
did
came
unnecessarily
that
be
They
any
they
saying
they
about
value
and
appears
and
closing
10
to
closed.
here
about
see
be
of
System.
David
the
Rosen,
field,
obtaining
visible
Jamaica
Hospital.
and
Now
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
148
148
1
May
10,
2
he
3
bribery
of
State
4
am
my
community
5
The
6
of
7
some
8
Health
9
that
is
2012
known
glad
State
the
for
of
his
Senator
New
under
the
get
be
this
10
should
doing
11
were
convicted
12
What
are
13
new
14
slice
15
Jamaica
16
arrangement,
17
something
18
gotten?
19
something.
All
20
supervision
of
21
Health,
22
improvement
23
the
24
looking
25
Health
the
nursing
CT
got
and
did
there
the
on,
State
to
do
believe
These
we
people
bribes.
Jamaica
center,
trauma
in
a
got
new
center.
If
this
Peninsula
lose
out
that
they
were
parties
web
Department.
have
under
the
Department
approve
any
of
major
facilities.
weeks,
site
on
for
were
State
hospital
of
should
of
a
64
from
must
in
aware
benefits
the
couple
at
a
payments
which
I
I
it.
the
have
for?
rehab
be
of
we
of
gone
accepting
these
The
last
If
bribes
Scan
nose
solved,
of
to
for
Kruger
aware
has
that.
and
Carl
has
that
Department.
to
is
York
corruption
cases
conviction
I
have
the
Everything
In
been
State
that
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
149
149
1
May
10,
2
goes
3
emergency
4
bathrooms.
5
is
6
the
7
to
8
the
9
reached
on
this
2012
in
a
hospital
room,
It
going
summer
I
of
out
Care.
11
According
12
November
13
their
14
Department
15
to
16
the
17
maintains
18
involved.
19
involved
20
Those
21
They
allowed
22
long
record
23
the
24
objection,
the
25
inspectors
came
6,
web
of
did
Peninsula
deal,
The
with
who
health
are
in
the
this
of
care
to
legal
Business,
can
no
get
review
it
was
field
was
most
Zacheim.
should
know.
He
a
on.
had
difficulties
situation
on
objections
Steven
field.
and
close
ownership
go
close
State
who
is
By
Directors
formally
person
this
you
had
in
How
Health
because
change
to
York
York
not
was
of
Home
New
Health
DOH
no
New
new
time?
tried
which
the
approved.
Board
Crain's
site,
this.
the
2011,
for
Peninsula
Revival
10
new
this
Medisys
to
to
be
during
but
a
even
to
2011,
bankruptcy.
hospital
saw
has
on
for
With
went
looked
at
in
no
on
the
until
lab
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
150
150
1
May
10,
2012
2
at
3
this
time,
4
that
we
5
Hospital,
6
fraudulent
paperwork
7
Department
of
8
General
the
9
took
Peninsula
Hospital.
they
have
the
already
to
close
rather
to
I
had
decided
decide
with
Health,
a
the
out
Attorney
on
They
this
community.
They
11
here.
could
12
and
13
have
14
immediately.
The
staff
worked
15
and
get
it
shape.
16
never
17
Let
18
within
19
more
20
problem,
21
us
22
cleaning
outsource
found
to
came
and
said
close
the
concerned
up
a
finding
the
MARRERO:
24
MR.
SILVERMAN:
do
is
find
the
I
the
burying
They
could
sent
them
in
weekends
They
lab
again.
believe
they
were
the
burying
the
lab
truth
some
of
and
situation.
MR.
to
in
way
23
25
and
hospital
Department,
with
in
were
lab
close.
Health
and
work.
checked
hospital
that
the
another
nights
the
closed
their
of
the
10
They
case
Attorney.
punishment
at
Peninsula
than
U.S.
believe
those
Thank
you,
What
they
who
are
sir.
have
interested
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
151
151
1
May
10,
2
in
3
hospital,
4
in,
5
prosecution
that
6
make
victims
operating
and
bring
the
MR.
Thank
some
refer
us
7
8
2012
or
them
other
of
it
the
together,
things
bring
for
of
MARRERO:
your
Thank
it
the
deserves.
Don't
mistakes.
you,
sir.
you.
9
MS.
MCGRATH:
10
Christine
McGrath,
11
roles.
12
thank
13
and
14
what
this
15
hope
you
are
getting
16
loss
and
the
fear
17
have.
18
am
19
was
20
while
21
the
22
Believe
me,
23
doesn't
work.
24
the
25
bleeding.
First
you
the
a
all
of
all
I
to
here
resident.
in
ago,
El.
I
Those
car.
I
I
would
a
the
the
live
a
car
to
up,
to
move
I
have
be
had
I
the
that
we
One,
I
I
Beach.
accident
to
had
of
to
you.
here.
don't
to
listen
roles.
Rockaway
two
courtesy
need
down
in
like
to
sense
two
tried
had
here
telling
pillars
wound
I
is
old
I
am
remain,
in
had
is
I
I
and
I
the
name
having
community
am
born
and
all,
for
respect
My
A
under
move.
it
and
it
cut
out
of
internal
emergency
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
152
152
1
May
10,
2
surgery.
3
I
4
probably
5
says
6
away.
7
with
8
o'clock
in
9
been
on
the
10
ever
been
11
up
12
People
13
lives
14
them
to.
15
care
provider.
16
I
17
17th
18
At
19
are
20
people
21
pounds.
When
they
start
22
decompensate,
they
need
23
immediately.
If
24
diversion,
what
25
minutes
the
had
2012
And
to
be
diverted
would
that
I
not
Coney
don't
those
to
Peninsula
to
down
here.
I
in
am
a
least
50
We
on
trying
as
home
of
300,
Saint
Belt
a
down
300
up
3
ever
you
to
get
where.
family
about
health
registered
have
is
no
concerned
on
nurse.
Beach
residents.
our
residents.
weigh
go
at
you
Have
My
here
am
percent
bariatric
who
I
come
be
Have
die.
also
nursing
Street.
must
You
am
I
minutes
they
Wyck
Avenue?
going
I
It
Van
are
work
where
and
Mapquest
32
Parkway?
the
Jamaica
is
morning.
Belt
on
here.
Island
numbers.
the
closed
somewhere,
be
know
was
residents
These
are
500,
600
400,
to
help
John's
going
to
Parkway?
is
on
happen?
I
32
don't
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
153
153
1
May
2
think
3
but
4
can't
5
If
6
malfeasance
7
that,
8
9
10
10,
2012
so.
yet
we
save
there
Yes,
we
need
to
need
to
save
lives.
You
cost
lives.
money
is
any
or
at
the
question
fraud
or
look
into
it
and
people
who
have
done
punish
the
community.
save
money,
of
about
anything
like
prosecute
it.
But
Save
the
don't
our
lives,
please.
11
DR.
DODAKIAN:
12
Wayne
13
proudly
14
direction
15
also
16
would
17
absence
18
volumes.
19
care
20
could
be
here
21
could
be
there,
22
too.
If
Dr.
23
hoping
he
24
this.
That
25
physician,
Dodakian.
at
I
My
served
Peninsula
of
here.
Dr.
like
to
of
Dr.
first
Commissioner
It
about
shows
us.
I
and
would
as
I
am
is
Guiny.
I
all
Shah
that
think
if
these
lady
he
was
I
doesn't
over
could
be
guys
there
here
here,
as
I
was
would
tell
him
as
fellow
physician,
less
the
speaks
just
that
the
who
he
be,
a
under
that
then
Shah
of
Dr.
residency
Guiny,
you,
say
my
is
Hospital
Peter
Thank
name
than
a
pleased
with
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
154
154
1
May
10,
2
him,
and
3
with
him.
4
sent
that
5
overnight,
begging
him
6
out
trouble
we
7
Medisys
first
time
8
man
9
reply
of
2012
I
am
Because
man
the
the
didn't
to
actually
a
because
have
it
11
his
12
So
13
and
14
now?
15
So
16
trust
17
Mr.
18
very
19
a
20
has
21
has
22
cause.
23
defiant,
and
24
whatever
respect
25
have
he
what
me
not
even
makes
think
shame
on
that
you
he
Dr.
we
Cook,
I
bad
for
help
us
were
in
with
around,
know
on
his
care
at
that
feel
for
in
desk.
time,
he
less
for
you,
I
tragedy
fall
upon
you.
closed
so
hospitals
that
become
desensitized
He
many
has
departed
I
become
have
is
from
now.
the
very,
sir,
bad
cares
betraying
You,
very
and
him.
bad
you.
even
to
day,
that
the
received
was
Shaw
put
he
next
cares
get
and
decency
think
I
letter
the
it
ago,
to
I
called
told
did
I
I
disgusted
months
the
letter.
10
aide
eight
certified
even
my
quite
to
the
have
had
He
he
human
complacent,
to
due
say
with
you,
reality,
that
you
sir,
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
155
155
1
May
10,
2
because
3
are
4
he
5
tell
6
thing.
7
need
8
his
9
will
2012
you
don't
doing.
has
Mr.
heard
you
We
the
be
all
need
he
we
is
by
in
the
area.
11
true
this
Mr.
Cook,
12
you
13
that
14
the
15
Saint
John's
16
I
tell
17
hospital
18
patients.
19
driveways
there
20
about
the
hallways.
21
treat
patients.
22
treat
the
23
Saint
John's.
24
like
25
treat
why.
I
Because
have
now,
hospital,
can
I
you
for
good
a
Yet
in
a
else
is
I
laid
not
can
tell
time
off
lot
of
that
the
off
from
it
at
patients
That
is
is
not
that
Should
not
not
a
and
that
overload
ambulances
people
and
we
other
the
fact
That
is
open,
reconnaissance,
are
are
That
patients
and
handle
There
same
That
being
doing
the
that
the
everyone
all
spend
cannot
that.
in
you
will
lives.
all
you
He
hospital
saying
hospitals
tell
says
save
10
what
before.
the
absorbed
in
will
everyone
jobs,
mind,
Cook
it
that
understand
in
in
the
strewn
no
a
work
way
way
to
to
at
overwork
them
good
to
personnel.
way
We
all
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
156
156
1
May
10,
2
know,
3
idiots
4
happened
5
as
6
saw
Peninsula
7
the
ashes,
8
It
9
sir.
a
2012
Mr.
Cook,
if
you
to
must
don't
here.
tool
was
you
think
You
close
us
you
consistent
the
speakers
One
of
11
the
Department
12
of
13
Health
14
Whatever
15
I
16
come
out,
17
what
you
18
with
Bruce
19
all
20
know
21
Lapin
22
corrective
23
inappropriately.
We
24
corrective
plan
25
very
the
is
give
the
Health
you
the
every
you
Jones.
bad
bit
with
of
We
action
of
became
plan,
all
it.
We
crooks,
now
all
you,
going
all
Doss
to
know
and
and
we
for
Laurie
that
know
all
the
sent
would
you
of
group,
Mounir
was
that
aware
give
Medisys
plan
of
corruption.
to
know
you
out
said
is
doing
from
me
lab
that.
your
the
it
with
all
action
like
due
the
the
are
report
am
what
the
Department
of
but
Flanz,
rest
what
I
that,
did
The
source
respect
crawling
before
corruption.
know
are
because
with
10
we
used
down
didn't
not
of
we
simply
Hospital
and
think
in
that
that
receive
guys.
It
a
was
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
157
157
1
May
10,
2012
2
sent
3
Jones
4
the
5
did.
Shame
6
Cook,
I
7
just
8
hightailed
9
a
in
on
to
purpose
Laurie
give
you
an
hospital,
and
that
on
would
as
much
scoundrel,
11
that.
I
12
you
your
13
blood
14
do
this.
15
as
a
16
offers
17
facility
18
an
19
need
20
hospital
21
meet
22
requirements,
23
400
beds
24
own
law.
is
he
out
on
urgent
MS.
give
There
table
old
are
to
of
Berger
the
Stick
BENJAMIN:
Mr.
he
he
the
respect
for
not
envy
because
don't
open
several
reopen
We
We
beds,
is
face
do
good
this
do
not
do
not
We
so
need
need
we
a
can
Commission
are
law
Rockaways.
to
to
you
Shah
but
clinics.
100
which
Dr.
Hospital
facility.
has
you.
Please
hospital.
set
what
judgement,
Peninsula
care
that
I
close
because
you
but
hands.
a
on
stayed
your
the
for
I
to
just
at
here
of
another
your
of
Lapin
here,
time
Let
as
was
do,
hospital.
on
is
shame
you
least
really
excuse
yelling
and
music.
at
be
it
At
you,
if
10
25
by
now,
It
for
is
your
it.
After
following
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
158
158
1
May
10,
2012
2
that,
I
3
words
to
4
personal
5
Nurse
6
hospice
7
Unfortunately,
8
recipient
9
Believe
me,
the
10
deserve
the
right
11
well
with
12
also
deserve
13
dignity.
14
My
15
husband
was
16
that
received
17
he
entered
18
He
had
19
Parkinson's,
20
impediment,
21
difficult
22
been
23
the
24
wanted
25
Dr.
don't
say
of
is
they
my
the
you
the
was
of
of
that
and
care,
right
a
to
to
but
die
live
hey
with
My
Walter
Benjamin.
The
that
to
few
out.
Grossman
unit
sick
and
so
from
the
was
with
he
that
of
care
that
unbelievable.
a
made
understand
out
moment
cancer,
had
unit.
Rockaway
live
health
the
Hospital.
services
to
are
about
husband
people
few
experience,
Peninsula
my
a
Benjamin.
and
last
told
only
Lillian
been
in
have
and
With
at
good
I
you,
had
unit
he
to
words.
Rader
name
know.
with
speech
it
even
him.
He
hospitals
and
months
of
his
life,
We
got
in
touch
at
the
hospice
more
had
rehabs
and
he
with
at
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
159
159
1
May
10,
2012
2
Peninsula
3
do,
4
moment
Nurse
5
laying
on
6
the
fear
7
him
and
8
have
9
days,
and
who
how
said
of
11
he
12
took
13
people
14
right.
never
care
15
of
of
met
him
stretcher
his
have
for
did
he
never
the
51
17
want
remind
18
signing
19
make
20
service.
Krause.
23
this
through
24
child,
25
son.
60,
if
KRAUSE:
over
I
eight
incredible
another
pain,
but
too.
they
The
deserve
that
Thank
please.
that
if
you
Hi,
I
I
can
crying.
right.
has
all
we
do
you.
Also
I
have
a
Please
need
the
you.
Hopefully,
He
For
necessary.
known
Thank
all
in,
been,
CLANCY:
folks
service
without
was
bent
take
to
you.
Numbers
22
he
grimace,
Rockaways
16
MS.
you
had
family
COMMISSIONER
21
She
you.
they
another
as
coming
face.
where
the
yourself
The
Rader
Thank
to
what
there.
only
had
exactly
him
waiting
him,
us
get
left
not
care
to
the
been
10
told
I
I
Maureen
get
have
have
diabetes.
am
a
When
through
very
very
I
sick
sick
moved
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
160
160
1
May
10,
2012
2
back
here
3
that
there
4
endocrinologist
5
Mr.
6
every
7
through
8
endocrinologist
9
there
in
Muir,
2009,
was
we
that
at
they
had
us
was
giving
11
was
in
12
doctors.
13
to
14
and
15
endocrinologist
16
pedes
17
Easter
holiday,
18
my
son
became
19
27
hours
20
Children's
21
Pennsylvania,
22
records
23
there
24
What
25
son
now
they
on
trouble.
Columbia
I
he
had
My
we
must
no
on
As
pole
it
a
was
the
Now
doctor
hospital
switched
in
all
the
way
Manhattan,
pedes
this
peninsula.
either.
the
critically
Over
Easter
ill,
Guisinger
Hospital
in
Danville,
he
was
the
and
at
already
knew
No
break,
ICU
when
only
pedes
son's
travel
over
who
for
peninsula.
that
So
is
the
from
spent
his
hospitalized
2008.
would
if
and
this
nephrologist
in
excited
north
Presbyterian
there
in
it,
hints
Now
the
none.
10
so
Peninsula.
to
that
none,
was
pediatric
went
them
is
a
I
have
was
on
happened
this
to
my
peninsula
diabetic
when
he
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
161
161
1
May
10,
2
became
critically
3
had
have
4
John's
Hospital,
5
out
to
Schneider's
6
who
have
7
or
what
8
my
community
9
take
to
10
and
11
safe
2012
been
no
care
and
my
I
her
hip.
here
any
more.
MR.
lot
of
14
are
angry.
15
upstaged.
That
16
actually.
But
17
without
18
better.
19
conscience
20
Dr.
21
American
Idol
22
know
he
23
My
24
former
25
initially
passion
a
why
name
is
I
employee
who
I
fell
don't
have
awesome,
said
be
said
really
show
go
something.
I
I
to
is
your
guess
see
don't
their
Peninsula.
going
who
became
to
of
a
people
McClendon.
not
feel
heard
woman
each
to
down
excited
To
love
here
I
left.
Shawn
back
are
I
humanity.
really
was
that
should
or
is.
definitely
couldn't
your
records
pretty
what
and
Hospital,
tonight,
was
doubt
was
I
here
Wayne,
That
Shah
And
MCLENDON:
13
Saint
history
mother,
have
transferred
his
moved
broke
12
to
then
what
and
would
Childrens
medical
of
He
brought
idea
his
ill?
am
own.
a
I
speak
here
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
162
162
1
May
10,
2012
2
tonight,
3
cousin
4
lieutenant
in
the
5
Rockaway.
He
raised
6
that
maybe
you
7
that
you
8
of
this
hospital
and
9
already
affected
everything.
10
me
that
they
using
11
He
works
12
Rockaway,
13
department
that
we
have
14
peninsula.
He
told
me
15
they
are
16
with
patients
17
on
18
now,
19
here.
20
community
21
the
22
summer.
We
23
ocean
is
over
there.
Go
24
it.
The
fact
is
this
25
completely
but
of
I
actually
spoke
mine
earlier,
who
is
a
house
in
Far
know
in
guys
about
are
the
mind
big
the
So
the
anybody
knows,
summer,
want
to
it.
How
the
sure
the
flow
has
He
in
told
House.
Far
fire
the
already
that
trucks
Saint
to
help
John's
is
that
occurring
summer
even
being
who
lives
violence
a
make
Fire
on
me
with
drownings
are
to
largest
fire
a
closure
the
the
because
diversions.
As
something
house
you,
using
without
big
to
go
beach
that
ridiculous.
in
this
goes
up
up
in
in
the
community.
take
a
The
look
at
is
Truly,
I
would
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
163
163
1
May
2
just
3
you.
4
people
5
eyes
6
Rockaway
7
with
8
let
9
Stand
10
10,
2012
ask
you
Take
you
and
is
look
in
the
here.
them
be
the
MR.
know
because
the
sand
of
stained
to
let
it
people
you
should
happen.
be,
problem.
My
MORE.
14
that
15
raise
money.
I
want
16
quick
document.
We,
17
United
18
perfect
19
ensure
20
for
21
general
22
blessings
23
our
24
this
25
of
am
founder
are
a
non
union,
domestic
common
welfare
of
in
and
is
CEO
to
the
establish
defense,
do
Constitution
This
of
I
start
read
GIVE
up
to
form
a
very
of
a
the
more
justice,
provide
promote
secure
to
you
people
tranquility,
and
Matt
organizations
order
liberty
posterity,
name
technology
profit
States,
America.
their
the
be
the
Don't
13
the
into
that
to
of
going
Bishop.
helps
faces
around
are
12
We
look
you
BISHOP:
I
a
Look
going
happen.
up,
11
take
not
blood,
fix
to
see
let
this
and
a
guys
the
the
ourselves
and
ordain
and
establish
of
the
United
is
the
Constitution
States
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
164
164
1
May
10,
2
of
3
our
4
responsibility
of
5
government,
is
6
the
7
government
8
tranquility,
9
welfare
the
2012
United
States
It
is
the
federal
the
responsibility
of
responsibility,
state
country.
11
We
12
hospital
13
that
14
years.
15
this
16
It
17
hospital
18
community
19
prevent
20
community
21
to
22
here
not
23
your
duty
24
to
25
that
is
to
not
our
offer
the
promote
the
general
the
four
there
is
There
over
no
reopened.
that
has
from
that
sure
just
to
tell
to
make
a
in
tranquility.
sure
that
This
is
of
hard
and
New
to
it
this
a
to
is
work
reopens.
this
solution.
State
tranquility
willing
it
hospitals
the
worked
that
this
10
closing,
is
this
last
no
make
in
closing
other
is
to
justice
by
closed
duty
it
local
domestic
it
is
the
the
doing
room.
is
ensure
ben
So
America.
the
establish
or
have
make
it
government,
and
10
are
it
of
a
hard
So
I
that
it
is
happen.
I
you
My
proposal
York
am
want
is
provide
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
165
165
1
May
10,
2012
2
matching
3
community
4
to
5
this
6
We
will
work
here
7
to
make
this
happen.
8
commit
9
free
one,
funds
or
ten
for
any
to
of
other
in
We
will
if
order
you
I
money
11
willing
12
use
on
13
for
this
14
So
15
where
is
the
plan
to
16
problem,
not
just
here
17
community
18
after
19
plan
to
20
just
that
21
per
thousand
residents.
22
New
York
3.2
23
residents.
24
County,
25
community.
use
line
it
raise
social
it
that
--
wants,
has
has
it
is
We
not
community
in
money.
To
of
services.
is
the
solve
but
just
to
than
per
not
It
The
do
us
is
the
is
not
1.6
State
beds
of
1,000
just
for
this
hear
where
issue?
beds
plan,
what
to
less
money
this
with
just
has
need
resources
interest
where
is
to
free
the
That
willing
raise
not
Queens
work.
to
closed,
address
reopen
media
community,
hope
five
us
this
is
this
with
get
there
to
the
am
help
raise
to
if
to
in
to
work
I
10
I
do
technology.
service
raised
community,
one,
hospital.
our
money
for
Queens
this
something
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
166
166
1
May
10,
2
about
3
help.
4
takes
5
reopen
6
to
7
health
8
me
2012
it
together,
We
to
need
make
this
talk
to
and
the
we
money,
this
care
about
in
If
and
it
to
anybody
raising
this
your
whatever
happen,
hospital.
me
need
wants
money
community,
for
talk
to
afterwards.
9
MR.
JODIS:
friends,
the
My
name
10
My
11
the
12
Because
13
solution
14
have
15
don't
16
they
17
problem
18
only
19
There
was
no
problem
with
20
There
was
no
lack
at
the
21
this
hospital
in
2011
22
zero
infection
23
close?
24
basis
25
They
speech,
a
he
there
of
person
told
is
any
could
every
not
not
solve
this
clearly
the
see,
is
by
not
the
is
no
don't
I
understand
why
problem.
The
it
is
administration.
hospital.
graded
Why
the
are
the
hospital,
was
paperwork
where
there
created,
hospital.
only
speech.
problem.
could
Closing
can
of
given
They
I
created
of
word,
Jodis.
has
his
problem.
solution
know.
who
you
no
is
lab
is
not
as
did
on
and
a
it
the
right.
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
167
167
1
May
10,
2012
2
deficiencies?
3
that
4
tests
5
was
6
office.
7
inspection
8
They
9
machine.
died
Where
because
were
perfectly
fine.
I
worked
They
can
two
They
control
on
said
they
never
12
precision
work.
13
was
degraded.
14
percent.
15
were
16
the
company.
17
The
maker
18
right,
19
How
20
very
21
on
22
result
23
without
24
September
25
E-mails
was
of
and
that
vial
was
are
Even
and
2003.
the
found
the
We
proficiency
was
always
right,
and
the
was
the
on
were
done.
I
was
same
labs,
and
the
from
the
other
year,
lab.
I
blood
same
labs
In
read
Cuomo
by
came.
The
reference
Governor
studies
all
right?
this.
the
men
said
studies
not
100
serviced
company's
machine
are
very
It
report
last
the
York.
our
machine
the
to
New
doing
obtained
the
to
all
The
surprised
the
in
was
all
faced
work
who
the
doctor's
my
the
done,
the
I
The
Everything
2002
11
It
tests?
in
patients
in
such
never
the
see.
10
persons
the
done.
times
appreciated
a
of
are
the
about
three
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
168
168
1
May
10,
2012
2
hospital
problem.
3
problem,
I
4
came
5
don't
What
know
came
why
again.
So
you
the
speeches
of
everybody
6
The
community
7
Don't
8
am
9
telling
think
not
needs
I
am
telling
for
for
the
So
have
12
there
13
any
solution
14
can
give
15
donate
16
money.
17
would
18
the
19
theirs.
20
every
department
21
It
the
22
managers
23
utilizing
the
24
recourse.
So
25
government
involved
a
you
them
the
This
is
request
To
the
union
and
and
other
hand.
We
can
persons
and
please,
in
I
of
ideas
the
with
expenses.
who
there
want
this
I
that
some
everybody,
money,
the
question.
pump
see
You
contribute
their
to
the
for
government
should
present
serve
We
money
I
am
really
a
can
job.
decide,
also.
the
of
And
we
here.
request.
to
lend
money
government
is
can
money,
my
have
solution.
we
my
to
11
think,
for
community,
is
to
hospital.
I
this
problem
coming
job.
community.
is
this
my
this
the
listening
telling
10
to
are
of
the
are
is
no
the
case.
I
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
169
169
1
May
10,
2012
2
will
3
international
4
are
5
international
6
has
7
to
8
the
9
from
tell
you
having
given
them.
They
crisis
of
running
the
airline.
If
the
government
It
back,
11
save
12
passengers,
13
see
14
a
15
unemployed.
the
we
job
MR.
your
20
Thank
is
not
they
a
to
save
is
making
like
are
giving,
money
they
are
giving
save
the
to
the
employees.
of
jobs.
I
half
year.
My
MARRERO:
MR.
my
also
dollars
Sir,
have
You
not
son
had
is
please
wrap
up
comments.
18
19
out
from
16
is
government
of
government
but
to
The
millions
airline,
are
an
India.
many
giving
is
in
so
them.
India
airline
the
10
17
Air
JODIS:
request,
21
that
So
you
you
very
MS.
MCKAVAH:
22
panel.
23
am
in
24
is
the
25
district
My
the
name
in
think
and
this
is
decide.
much.
is
Good
Queen
district,
first
please,
largest
America.
you
evening,
McKavah,
New
York
and
I
City
educational
District
27
where
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
170
170
1
May
10,
2012
2
Peninsula
3
largest
4
going
5
to
6
I'm
7
So
8
Commissioner
9
phone
in
to
say
I'm
New
quote
a
an
Hospital
few
data.
to
going
believe
Shah
to
review
he
11
out
12
what
13
The
14
because
15
is
16
wing
17
the
peninsula,
18
art
science
19
state
of
20
As
speak,
21
it,
22
young
23
is
24
and
25
Hospital
how
to
help
the
a
second
am
not
just
going
okay.
One,
visionary.
that
because
has
some
I
am
I'm
left
he
the
you,
and
that
I
I
idealist
to
is
City.
things
10
a
he
meeting
new
data
got
that
to
situation.
a
find
That's
think.
second
on
thing
my
here.
we
York
call
has
lies,
Senator
We
one
the
just
of
what
you
I
my
built
PS
300
was
call
it
building
of
people
of
the
art
Olympic
are
nothing.
represents
the
arts,
gym.
in
honoring
assassinated.
you
on
sitting
tournament
when
you,
million
State
music,
a
tell
$50
oldest
state
arts
to
Assemblywoman
a
42Q.
that
did
going
and
the
lab,
celebrating
man
I'm
are
a
That
shot,
Peninsula
in
this
community
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
171
171
1
May
10,
2012
2
another
3
to
4
The
woman
that
5
she
has
a
higher
6
she
may
even
7
certifications
8
listen
9
everything
the
American
10
to
she
is
11
which
was
12
mine,
I
13
I'm
panel
14
believe
in
15
gone
them,
16
Chancellor
Walker
17
not
out
our
18
thought
had
to
19
safely.
choice.
model
to
do,
a
the
to
he
MR.
21
name
is
22
member
23
of
24
a
25
the
ago
Board
don't
have.
now
of
told
end.
I'm
sure
than
me,
When
I
in
it
was
consider.
I
I
have
and
even
reconsidered,
schools
phase
Peninsula
that
out.
Mr.
Get
am
home
my
past
Hospital
you
Board
recall
apparent
that
and
he
Cook,
I
became
Directors
her
live,
DOH.
spoken,
Greenberg.
it
to
three
hearings.
sure
told
before
the
has
did
dream
you
have
I'm
she
scared
GREENBERG:
when
me,
score
because
ask
public
the
am
west
before
community
I
I
certain
leader
Trustees.
year
I
to
Steve
of
the
credit
cry
her
Black.
on
came
have
have
phased
20
people
her
and
I'm
there
about
to
was
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
172
172
1
May
10,
2
something
3
Medisys,
4
Department
5
wagons,
6
to
7
been
8
going
9
said.
the
2012
very
our
fishy
hospital
of
you
testimony
to
all
say
There
the
that
no
10
But
11
Hospital
12
aren't
13
are
14
out.
15
Department
16
out
for
the
health
17
people,
and
you
18
the
health
19
the
Rockaway
20
what
21
bunch
22
was
23
save
this
24
came
in,
25
in
is
always
of
the
one
of
a
and
are
but
We
we
and
revival
Mrs.
and
You
You
community
the
be
looking
of
looking
of
the
Mr.
we
out
is
were
didn't
knew
the
for
people
That
We
it.
the
safety
here.
hospital.
Mr.
of
that
not
was
repeat
the
community.
amateurs.
on,
to
should
safety
have
everybody
of
and
our
people
thing.
believed
the
listening
hospital.
heart
Health
and
originally
Directors
happening
going
to
the
I
reason
closing
tearing
been
that
understood
just
I
of
with
circled
these
day.
is
Board
We
have
things
on
president
Health.
because
giving
going
not
a
know
had
of
what
to
Zacheim,
who
Zacheim,
who
came
sat
us,
and
with
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
173
173
1
May
10,
2
did
everything
3
reestablish
4
went
5
reached
6
court
7
bankruptcy.
We
8
the
People
9
were
to
2012
do
they
us.
could
We
went
everything.
the
point
approved
corner.
happy
with
to
We
where
the
thought
we
had
in
the
was
11
got
stabbed
the
12
plan
of
13
out,
the
report
on
14
again
it
quoted
something
15
2008,
it
wasn't
fixed.
16
happened
17
Therefore,
18
time
19
don't
20
with
21
businessman,
a
22
here
we
something.
23
in.
They
24
are
saving
25
in
again,
are
that
understand,
any
fact,
rational
have
are
was
of
that
the
it
is
don't
the
saw
we
the
gave
Time
and
in
Something
I
fixed.
Time
and
saw.
What
I
understand,
I'm
thing
a
was
People
Yes,
I
am
okay,
came
hospital,
hospital.
deficient.
I
happened
thought,
rational
at
sudden,
you
wasn't
what
on
a
lab.
closing.
saving
the
community
heart.
thing
2010,
we
all
of
turned
going
Then
had
bankruptcy
closure,
hospital.
in
actually
of
what
lab
we
plan
the
the
court,
the
10
in
to
the
they
lab,
not
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
174
174
1
May
10,
2
denying
3
in
4
don't
5
me
6
been
7
I
8
want
9
I
to
2012
that.
make
the
Why
didn't
lab
efficient?
understand.
the
cause
of
taken.
believe,
to
license
pulled.
11
know
that,
12
tell
you
13
this
community
14
different
15
important.
We
are
16
the
We
have
17
that
can
18
last
year,
19
Mayor's
20
and
21
summer,
the
22
of
press.
23
stuff
24
coming
down.
25
of
community,
yes
a
go
I
Task
economy
the
and
going
was
is
the
a
to
on
There
here.
It
was
to
lived
it
in
and
in
many
very
We
have
kinds
of
things
Not
only
member
promote
of
that,
the
business
Last
was
getting
was
a
lot
People
a
the
have
Rockaways.
Rockaways
open.
to
has
here.
made
who
seems
I
very,
all
have
done.
not
isolated.
Force,
in
who
to
people
or
But
served
it
wrong
are
is
Hospital
no.
just
should
Nobody
person
ways,
ocean.
good
or
come
seem
done
whether
10
as
is
there
know
I
would
that
Peninsula
don't
was
what
know
keep
still
action
But
I
That
somebody
of
a
lot
good
were
revitalization
this
just
pulls
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
175
175
1
May
10,
2012
2
it
away.
3
is
a
4
you
5
your
6
hospital.
7
MS.
I
way
to
should
8
name
9
Rockaway,
of
reestablish
not
goal
Thank
you.
STAFFIS:
as
10,
well
one
11
I
want
to
thank
12
giving
us
the
13
listening,
14
a
15
take
16
inexcusable
17
leave.
18
and
19
tonight,
if
20
I
going
21
else
22
of
23
concerns.
24
One,
25
for
am
for
the
I
do
they
You
I
the
to
husband.
I
in
of
for
staying
and
I'm
seen
it
a
to
here
anybody
is
busy
make
am
Rockaway.
Commissioner
did
schedule
it
here
haven't
done
so
repeat
what
everybody
heard
just
elderly,
middle
in
breaks.
has
My
born
think
have
have
the
personally
trying
that
evening.
born
the
there
hospital,
make
am
haven't
that
said.
times.
my
if
close
I
taking
Everybody
not
as
you
I
breaks.
are
to
courtesy
time.
this
Good
actually,
not
that
and
Staffis.
10
they
it
a
Fran
short
think
consider
goal,
is
really
aged,
a
for
it
a
couple
the
everybody
today.
number
of
young
and
has
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
176
176
1
May
10,
2012
2
emergencies.
3
family
4
brought
5
breathing
twice.
6
was
and
7
until
8
to
9
good.
when
to
FDNY,
the
the
We
my
had
grandson
the
Thank
give
and
But
what
do
counts.
What
if
11
the
Then
who
12
accountable
13
time
14
emergency
15
where
is
the
16
lie?
On
whose
17
that
nightmare
18
I
thinking
19
gone,
20
Or
21
hospital
22
concern
23
other
24
affiliated
25
you
day
are
he
be
He
God
his
of
get
every
to
to
them?
I
going
and
to
the
doctor,
the
to
want
other
leave
thing
hospital
to
to
stay.
go
to
a
That
is
another
asked
my
doctor
she
make
is
the
she
told
it
to
extra
going
going
hospitals
with,
The
the
The
it
be
wouldn't
with
doctors
going
what
me.
is
second
make
to
to
I
taken
everything
do,
get
is
was
people?
to
father
breaths
He
going
head?
on
stopped
couldn't
is
to
mine.
not
to
responsibility
near
of
had
rescue
you
takes
the
they
own
God
these
room,
are
are
to
it
my
came.
thank
10
am
him
ambulance
that
in
hospital.
ED,
ED?
one
me,
if
it
but
is
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
177
177
1
May
10,
2012
2
an
3
think
4
Even
5
any
6
happen
7
will
count.
8
wish
you
9
curiosity,
emergency.
of
the
in
God
but
second,
I
thank
safe
how
your
residence.
11
same
courtesy.
is
So
13
folks
14
up.
from
15
MS.
on
name
17
registered
18
Peninsula
19
compound
20
started
21
I
was
22
I
have
23
have
24
you
is
25
you
have
Joan
years
been
seen
do
old
all.
My
taken
and
second
that
again,
know.
away
and
home.
Just
the
hospital
give
I
out
us
of
to
the
you.
We
want
in
from
a
the
a
in
on
the
I
1981
when
nurse.
while.
question
you
My
am
working
quite
Do
come
I
student
main
ask
evening.
Hospital.
a
can
to
Facility
there
as
need
can
Care
for
you
don't
anything
currently
down
to
elderly.
Renneham.
there
it
I
Good
Peninsula
working
the
me,
they
Remmick
Extended
of
20
if
nurse
please
CLANCY:
RENNEHAM:
16
is
61
of
just
Thank
COMMISSIONER
you
you
trip
far
10
12
ask
help
care,
any
a
I
children,
myself,
medical
So
know
I
for
what
community?
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
178
178
1
May
10,
2012
2
Did
you
know
3
audiology
4
care
5
nursing
6
fabricated
7
know
8
clinic
9
to
that
clinic
facility
home
that
that
in
there
geriatrics?
a
pristine
in
the
and
hearing
aids?
a
full
pediatrics
Did
know
that
you
medical
12
from
13
Who
14
by
15
wanted
16
You
took
this
away
from
the
17
You
took
jobs
away
from
my
18
nurses.
Politically
19
supposed
to
20
here?
21
present
22
Buren,
23
Mr.
24
phoenix
25
continue
to
want
do
In
it
say
all
board
Mr.
Zacheim
to
to
man
down
to
learning
of
and
you
to
the
help
I'm
for
by
Thank
trying
to
fellow
thank
stuck
from
community.
correct,
thank
Paucey.
try
care
right?
that
rise
clinic
podiatry?
taken
just
reality,
for
every
to
be
was
we
education
helped
endocrinology
that
dental
from
department
doctor
you
surgery
11
a
Did
blown
had
wouldn't
extended
every
Rockaway,
10
that
an
serviced
was
did
was
housed
their
that
there
being
you
to
us.
the
Mr.
you,
get
the
ashes,
us.
and
Thank
to
you,
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
179
179
1
May
10,
2
Lou,
3
workers
4
gentlemen,
madame,
I
5
sleep
well
at
night,
6
you
away
from
7
is
and
thank
and
very
have
a
you
the
taken
MS.
name
is
WAGNER:
10
resident
of
11
like
to
12
have
some
13
Without
them,
14
of
are
15
Dr.
16
formed
17
and
18
tonight.
19
not
20
that
21
not
a
22
and
she
23
with
24
Nassau,
25
whole
angels
Wayne,
a
and
by
we
here.
the
she
name
is
is
the
of
in
this
politician.
Her
know
is
in
chest
I
the
She
believe.
I
of
what
am
a
and
I
that
room
what
and
with
is
would
we
here.
of
But
not
Some
course
the
Mary
My
tonight.
be
I
have
nurse,
here
Liz.
biggest
She
She
name
Mary
is
is
leader
fight.
hospital
pains.
story
you
community
others.
She
I
I
saying
nurses,
unfortunately,
hope
evening.
wouldn't
many
you
because
Channel,
in
for
night.
relationship
Her
As
Wagner.
off
the
fellow
the
Good
Broad
start
my
certainly
Good
Margaret
them
all
warriors.
nightmare.
8
9
2012
is
is
Liz
tonight
in
don't
South
know
happened,
but
the
that
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
180
180
1
May
10,
2012
2
is
3
want
4
for
5
harder
6
I
7
heard
8
does
not
9
This
is
a
10
like
it
to
11
record
12
from
13
report
comes
out.
14
Smith,
thank
you
15
work.
You
16
the
17
reopened.
18
104
19
this
20
through
21
cannot
22
of
23
the
24
Governor
25
and
very
to
disturbing
to
personally
thank
your
am
hard
than
very
a
fight.
the
a
we
years
old.
hospital.
the
would
it
nurses
have
not
Governor.
He
to
a
his
all
have
We
has
afford
the
The
get
to
history.
Depression,
so
hard
hospital
hospital
through
day
Please
can't
The
on
Malcolm
this
hospital
would
60
your
ears.
I
response
the
Senator
here.
go
to
lose
made
it
but
it
corruption
people
to
stay,
to
do.
There
seen
it.
Everyone
has
have
it
before
politicians.
hospital
just
fought
we
and
want
for
Great
make
that
the
like
and
The
have
crisis,
Governor
are
the
representative
would
Governor
I
from
medical
that
some
You
disappointed
have
all
I
electeds.
response
the
everyone.
whatever
is
want
the
billions,
has
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
181
181
1
May
10,
2012
2
computer
3
dollars
4
We
5
there.
I
6
when
intuition
tells
7
closing
all
hospitals
8
knows
9
because
access.
in
could
my
grants,
go
on
on
like
these
what
no
and
and
don't
for
There
is
a
is
everywhere
me
telling
doors
11
shut
down
12
us.
We
are
13
have
to
wait
14
The
15
would
16
investigation
17
Attorney's
18
there
19
was
sentenced
20
and
some
21
away.
22
hope
23
is
24
doesn't
any
further
than
25
been
the
courts.
It
us.
the
is
being
in
are
God
know
Closed
everything
works
Why
is
for
do
we
for
answers?
are
in
the
room,
to
ask
for
from
the
District
that
There
to
I
are
corruption
the
is
The
fraud,
Medisys
three
also
is
And
it
was
CEO
years,
going
there.
Department
investigated.
I
full
believe
politicians
on
you
months
Office.
nobody
is
but
down,
taxpayers.
them
the
this,
us.
look,
corruption.
So
money
don't
Everyone
three
reporters
like
we
of
Program.
that
We
10
on
the
say
reason.
one
Heal
but
to
billions
I
of
Health
hope
has
I
this
already
Senator
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
182
182
1
May
10,
2
Carl
3
years,
4
getting
5
the
6
Please
7
public.
8
for
9
there
2012
Kruger
who
stated
just
to
seven
received
the
judge
years,
I
seven
why
am
not
Be
open
am
as
I
bad
as
others.
consider
is
All
this.
we
do,
all
we
answers.
If
you
have
is
this
down
new
coming
11
residents,
to
12
residents,
and
13
by
14
quickly
15
what
16
Certificate
17
could
18
60
19
still
20
currently
21
to
raise
22
So
with
all
the
angels
23
suggest
you
see
Dr.
24
need
25
around
the
to
Sea,
Far
it
before
the
plan
come
days,
we
is,
is
town.
and
a
plan,
if
for
the
new
plan
of
asking
Auburn
is
die.
Let
where
the
is.
do
us
If
it
know
that
the
report,
the
could
let
us
if
fighting
working
funds
$8,000
are
asking
before
you
a
a
the
Operation
out
have
is
people
of
if
all
the
hospital
Rockaway
help
all
are
beautiful
10
with
to
He
chance,
with
keep
more.
is
an
Dr.
in
will
suing,
we
Wayne
attorney
Peninsula
Wayne.
We
know
open.
the
room,
I
I
think
we
post
and
it
I
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
183
183
1
May
10,
2
believe
3
don't
4
any
2012
in
this
fight,
answers
5
MS.
name
we
My
7
Rockaway
8
here
is
9
have
legal
from
is
almost
my
and
Hi,
50
I
12
to
a
cover
any
pre-K
13
hours.
14
she
15
am
16
Hospital.
17
want
to
18
say.
I
19
can't
stand
20
kitchen,
21
need
Peninsula
22
have
heard
23
But
24
anybody
25
he?
there
She
for
has
to
the
to
I
dependent
on
hear
Shah
what
guess
the
the
so
he
this
you
is
mentioning
hasn't
he
I
her
have
half
parent
when
drive.
He
people
I
get
and
has
out
to
if
of
I
we
know
over
We
you
again.
from
Bloomberg.
you
the
Anyway,
heard
come?
don't
goes,
Hospital.
haven't
is
Peninsula
gone.
over
a
don't
saying
heat,
I
disorder.
and
left.
the
who
Keana
a
you.
This
because
have
get
evening.
ago.
two
we
entered
seizure
school.
Dr.
to
grandaughter,
has
solely
I
years
if
Thank
good
guardianship.
11
Why
Hall.
she
goes
going
Mallon.
great
name,
what
because
not
City
Cathy
10
sit
are
MALLON:
6
can't
fight,
is
Where
is
need
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
184
184
1
May
10,
2012
2
Bloomberg.
3
Patrick's
4
ever
5
his
hat.
6
him
down
7
going
8
Hospital.
9
We
He
Day
year.
parade
He
That
on
also
marches
the
it
12
happen
13
from
now,
14
with
the
15
of
16
including
17
You
18
of
19
walk
20
seizure
medicine,
21
sake
their
22
You
23
grandchildren.
24
hospital.
25
have
the
closing
said
today,
but
and
of
you
to
,
will
wagon
and
and
the
time
everything
You
of
have
you
full
away,
Health.
the
You
the
them.
hug
near
to
with
for
at
sake
has
medicine,
Look
are
coming
all
whatever
night.
year
truck
that
lives.
You
them
this
or
not
a
for
asthma
at
may
must
with
home
Peninsula
you
around
is
By
them
like
need
lady
a
Department
We
the
see
haul
tips
hell
Maybe
and
he
like
it
tomorrow.
paddy
the
done,
kids
go
phony.
what
good
of
green,
investigation.
handcuffs,
the
streets
complete,
11
have
me
see
just
all
our
is
10
is
down
to
with
said,
Saint
his
to
a
the
wears
here
need
in
your
a
health
care,
need.
I
you
don't
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
185
185
1
May
2
drive.
I'm
3
custody
of
4
her.
have
5
who
6
Is
7
picture
8
Dr.
Shah.
9
has
an
10
you
don't
11
where
ever.
12
going
to
13
above
that
14
to
15
their
16
Rockaway
17
problem.
18
depends
19
every
20
stake,
21
to
22
this
23
two
24
you.
25
10,
2012
I
is
years
her.
I
Shah
of
for
He
me?
empty
Did
seat.
want
to
Do
wind
Because
The
on
one
of
and
filed
island,
bridges
MS.
do
not
Our
the
RYAN:
on
Rikers
to
if
or
is
the
God
nerve
will
do
this.
The
create
this
each
by
of
at
are
life
water
hands.
Hello.
and
are
that
loss
your
it
the
lives
surrounded
is
he
community
lawsuits
from
in
has
hospital,
us.
the
right
is
a
is
what
not
Rockaway
that
take
and
pray
did
and
headed,
up
I
for
there?
That
Hospital
did
community
you
anybody
that
Peninsula
We
out
eventually
and
anybody
time.
got
look
seat?
empty
happen,
close
Are
empty
is
to
I
grandchildren,
there?
the
old.
got
eight
there
Dr.
be
66
My
going
on
and
Thank
name
is
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
186
186
1
May
10,
2012
2
Alissa
3
something
4
was
5
in
Rockaway
6
is
in
7
Ryan.
born
I
really
short
in
to
almost
nursing
now.
Not
only
8
found
myself
9
problems.
home
got
13
was
14
guilty
15
standing
16
everybody
else
17
All
it
was
18
people.
When
I
19
it
so
bad
20
emergency
21
packed.
I
22
When
have
so
many
23
and
everybody
is
trying
24
that
25
mistakes
wasn't
you
they
yesterday,
Saint
in
the
Let
me
absolutely
evening,
tell
on
wall
in
when
I
in
outside
felt
bad
for
too.
they
I
and
almost.
morning,
Th
room
was
honestly.
like
do
going
know
felt
wall
the
people
are
don't
to
them,
to
I
up,
left.
the
it
was
gurneys,
like
came
I
stand
room,
can,
I
was
you,
insane.
because
could
was
Peninsula
to
when
I
She
going
12
up.
ago.
the
until
over,
up
there
born
in
John's
being
I
was
10:30
11
insane,
aunt
by
morning,
out.
is,
respiratory
from
6:30
aunt
her,
having
ended
My
years
10
I
I
just
my
100
for
And
only
say.
Rockaway,
the
have
if
the
to
that,
best
make
they
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
187
187
1
May
10,
2
did,
but
it
3
when
you
are
4
bad
for
them.
I
5
you
are
doing,
it
6
in
7
there
8
9
the
2012
is
easy
so
nursing
to
make
cramped.
just
is
the
have
to
next
door,
they
probably
know
that
10
don't
know
11
insane
12
lab
13
Remedy
14
poor
15
poor.
16
community
17
That's
it
is
closed.
and
just
open
It's
and
it.
MS.
Quincerra.
20
Peninsula
21
to
22
worked
at
23
not
here
24
actually
trying
25
speaking
for
people
hospital
any
it
is
even
more.
If
up.
It
is
it
is
all.
This
is
a
the
deal,
a
poor
gives
a
damn.
my
name
Hi,
a
nurse
Hospital,
but
I
am
chemotherapy
Peninsula
today,
to
Janet
it's
you.
was
a
a
is
I
for
I
that
it's
QUINCERRA:
Katie
be
it
nobody
19
speak
fix
rich,
Thank
elderly
closed.
That
not
people
there
it
you
The
don't
is
felt
whatever
the
it
community.
18
to
why
that
thing,
go
not
really
wrong.
home,
is
I
think
that
it
mistakes
because
find
a
at
now
going
nurse
Hospital
that
she
is
job.
I
DiPaulo.
is
She
that
could
am
was
an
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
188
188
1
May
10,
2
oncology
3
ambulatory
4
center.
Her
5
patients
diagnosed
6
or
7
administered
8
until
9
closed,
was
doing
10
time
the
closure
11
the
12
Breezy
13
extremely
14
Patients
who
15
Hospital
must
16
County
17
oncologist
18
Peninsula
19
infusion
20
longer
21
been
22
outside
23
patients
24
some
do
25
they
have
a
2012
certified
nurse
chemotherapy
job
of
the
day
with
cancer
Point
of
to
were
who
stay
in
displaced
their
not
to
has
barely
at
from
become
exists.
Peninsula
to
Nassau
treatment,
as
the
attended
them
there.
their
his
with
take
can
community
outside
have
at
office
They
their
community.
don't
hospital,
Rockaway
has
up
the
travel
Hospital
suite
At
peninsula
treated
now
get
the
It
and
Hospital
this
Far
with
She
that.
of
the
cancer
chemotherapy,
limited.
to
either
Peninsula
care
working
diagnosis.
just
in
infusion
entailed
hematological
the
working
and
no
and
have
city,
Many
of
those
transportation,
their
two
insurance,
buses
to
and
so
get
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
189
189
1
May
10,
2
there.
3
diagnosis
and
4
What
does
that
5
take
public
6
it
7
that
there
8
when
the
9
treatment
is
2012
Is
an
that
feel
are
11
should
12
from
13
diagnosis
14
abandoned.
15
for
16
them
17
us
18
them.
19
It
that
them,
in,
feels
unit,
and
yet
to
Not
but
out.
How
most,
Said
MR.
21
name
is
22
the
23
with
24
or
25
somewhere
main
you
maybe
the
moments
are
I
on
that
have
I
have
been
who
that
those
who
not
there
the
or
patients
doctor
are
a
feel
the
system
is
wrong
cares
shut
needed
for
word.
tragic.
Good
Hannon,
reason
that
made
we
HANNON:
Tom
that
for
sure
sure
few
fair?
the
and
am
they
the
sad
actually
20
by
am
their
those
be
by
of
and
seem
a
they
I
I
than
she
cancer
Now
day.
effects
that
say
a
chemotherapy?
like?
more
kick
Does
having
transportation.
side
bus.
is
taking
exhausting
10
the
fair,
is
and
to
doesn't
I
am
share
possibly
Commissioner
evening.
who
know,
you
had
or
here
My
for
something
don't
to
know,
go
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
190
190
1
May
10,
2012
2
Governor,
3
mother,
Matilda.
4
and
likes
5
place.
6
they
7
true.
8
New
9
hospital
she
Andrew
She
can
York
to
She
wants
for
thing
State
long
is
term
11
inexpensive
12
positron.
13
volunteer.
I
14
somebody
in
15
out
building
16
children
17
have
grandchildren,
18
none
of
19
dead,
is
20
flow,
and
21
and
22
call
23
them,
24
put
25
of
up
window
that
the
great
wisdom
cash.
their
You
an
and
an
mental
rehab
right
has
an
the
locked
I
when
nineties
who
looks
and
says
country
me,
dead?
from
and
that
tears
woman
what
God
in
they
bless
You
the
wisdom
I
love
The
to
have
and
is
wisdom.
put
I
Hannon,
envelope
can't
is
but
belongs
with
so
paid,
see
away
the
ombudsman,
with
Mr.
to
lady,
live
That
generation,
are,
in
the
his
people
lot.
cries
sense
who
over
in
get
walk
man
it
don't
common
all
that
a
come
lovely
am
learned
over
them
I
on
and
all
they
I
care
next
I
a
see
trained,
lock
know
Andrew.
10
a
the
to
I
is
hospitals
vote
The
Cuomo.
in
can't
form
an
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
191
191
1
May
10,
2012
2
envelope
3
have
learned
4
over
here.
5
I
6
was
7
to
8
about
9
a
with
wasn't
on
a
Cross
W2
to
Belt
Bay
form
lot
going
the
in
engine
11
transportation,
12
obsolete.
13
are
too.
14
put
people
15
build
16
immediately,
and
17
cars.
critical
18
a
different
19
a
day
20
They
have
Facing
21
bay,
four
bay,
22
ocean,
23
ocean.
24
these
25
the
I
Think
That
It
more
stay
four
I
up
greatest
on
a
on
are
have
Have
them
too
we
bay,
two
harbor
think
window
the
of
Many
floor.
call
bay
ocean,
vessels
in
many
thought.
three
the
to
highway
fourth
three
roads
way
they
these
and
They
good
each
that
the
The
Bay,
out
get
too.
the
ocean,
look
ships,
I
to
I
is
it.
work.
there
way.
but
night
come
be
lanes
years
Ambulance
about
to
I
ambulance
friends,
would
back
is
an
through.
my
five
trying
to
couldn't
1040.
last
was
trying
a
tonight,
Parkway
10
two
my
come
There
get
or
Boulevard
4:30.
fire
a
it
and
two
and
I
see
coming
in
world,
New
to
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
192
192
1
May
10,
2012
2
York
3
retired
4
people
5
military
6
Jimmy
7
President.
He
8
commander.
Some
9
there
Harbor.
as
My
harbor
know
Carter,
You
God
of
a
water.
11
God
12
peace.
13
commercial
14
coming
15
passenger
16
out
17
Peninsula
18
temporarily.
My
19
when
him
20
Tommy,
21
heliport
22
General
23
Bloomberg
24
with
25
chopper
in
is
are
worked
him,
the
for
former
year
see
subs
under
them,
They
stay
the
but
keep
freighters,
out
thank
the
there
is
there
is
tankers
out.
There
is
also
vessels,
cruise
and
coming
in,
Hospital
called
you
his
There
I
those
vessels,
many
submarine
there.
There
and
I
can't
are
job.
bless
a
just
Not
there.
was
10
they
that
out
almost
Joe
master.
about
ships
for
cousin
are
in
the
he
the
back
in
is
I
by
is
Joe
me
of
door
told
of
up
me
night,
is
a
Peninsula
there
late
the
there
said
with
coming
closed
other
telling
chopper,
when
that
cousin
Hospital?
comes
right
lines
yes,
a
the
for
few
Mike
times
police
the
parade
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
193
193
1
May
10,
2012
2
or
3
right,
4
so
5
know
6
we
7
out
8
attack,
9
Peninsula,
whatever.
get
many
him
could
his
going
on.
a
cruise
they
or
person,
13
Jimmy
14
manager
15
Airport.
16
that
17
read.
This
18
to
hospital.
19
Lingus,
Air
20
all
airlines
21
be
22
over
23
employees,
24
Kennedy
25
the
their
takes
The
across
same
the
he
John
is
Don't
will
the
We
is
day.
because
extra
do
will
100,000
it.
will
you
funds
Aer
Airlines,
in.
We
fly
will
them
people;
walking
We
does
everything
chip
We
me,
Kennedy
Israeli
will
their
the
What
the
passengers
chopper,
boss,
can
get
my
from
him.
give
heart
save
thing,
believe
hospital.
That
back,
street
to
Italia,
every
a
chopper,
Fitzgerald
spoke
here.
is
a
neighbor
the
someone
line
them
doesn't
is
if
and
got
thing
out
12
the
the
fly
life,
say?
So
he
chopper,
bring
I
plate,
is
has
hospital,
11
of
He
the
the
Leahey,
lady
call
10
okay.
this
here.
on
have
a
man,
down
things
what's
on
Good
around
fly
them
in
ambulance
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
194
194
1
May
10,
2012
2
transportation
3
God,
get
4
that
MR.
is
obsolete.
lock
Before
5
does
6
sanitize
7
catch
8
hospital
to
9
previous
speakers.
10
chances.
11
to
12
everybody.
My
13
I
a
14
resident,
15
west
16
of
17
a
18
bit
about
19
the
City
20
and
I
21
operate.
I
22
Board
too
23
or
24
call
them,
25
than
the
the
any
help
have
have
any
mic?
I
germs,
No
have
out.
been
35
end.
35
possibly
hospital
I
getting
to
go
government,
of
know
not
New
how
York
were
or
a
of
my
here
Kazner.
resident,
here
said,
I
I
and
know
since
for
ago,
and
little
year
on
th
afraid
not
having
a
I
little
work
30
the
do
Water
their
you
I
for
years,
they
less
are.
30
am
over
whatever
you
the
over
addressed
long
people
three
to
inefficiently
just
a
Lannie
ill,
to.
to
take
resident
like
can
evening,
is
year
year
have
doctor
I
want
will
Good
start,
so
offense
name
And
not
I
a
I
Lysol
don't
and
go.
I
me
chair
off.
KAZNER:
anybody
Please,
panel
want
it
stoic
feel
like
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
195
195
1
May
10,
2012
2
I'm
maybe
3
would
4
keep
5
a
6
Anyway,
7
with
Saint
8
life
long
9
there
talking
dismiss
the
to
all
three
stenographer,
better
audience,
I
sort
for
over
of
I
Rockaway
even
years.
wearing
12
walk
for
13
walk
last
14
raised
15
kind
16
retired
17
am
18
without
19
have
20
considering
moving.
21
wife,
I
22
resident,
23
here
24
think
25
a
NAMY
$600
happy
for
I
enjoying
a
for
believe
will
is
nervous.
a
am
again,
she
will
go.
option
any
a
know,
I
I
was
course
long
to
been
thoughts
and
of
mile
and
have
life
I'm
I
But
bit,
me,
am
the
you
But
a
I
half
So
my
a
long,
cause,
I
is
works
and
here,
have
an
and
that.
little
who
did
them.
years,
have
be
see,
the
Rockaway.
changed
would
how
just
for
hospital
being
I
did
six
you
three
Saturday
over
little
a
just
wife,
sure
As
shirt.
them,
and
affiliation
of
11
that
an
resident
not
I
think.
my
20
I
he
as
but
and
you
John's,
I'm
a
of
and
have
10
of
mannequins.
So
stay
I
more.
better
my
don't
I'm
writer
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
196
196
1
May
10,
2
than
3
background
4
Rockaway,
5
many,
6
upstairs.
7
downstairs,
8
they
9
mother
I
2012
am
a
about
my
many
had
speaker.
years
My
had
10
tray
of
11
neglected
12
downstairs,
13
father
14
met.
15
enjoyed
16
been
17
it
18
time.
I
19
beach,
but
20
without
21
John's
22
too
23
So
back
job
the
to
up,
mother
days,
Of
course
take
she
There
was
I
long
resident,
was
part
time
of
a
don't
hospital
alone
Rockaway
like
is
away.
It
from
my
home,
and
24
far,
I
25
question
think.
about
nearby.
not
far
I
how
had
of
long
the
situation
Saint
minutes
just
and
a
love
20
is
they
though
for
answer.
that
my
sort
the
is
the
I
the
leak
sent
even
here,
a
summer
have
life
I
is
every
So
water
and
that
here
my
the
grandmother
living
lived
those
a
love
here
in
box,
beach.
met
lived
voila,
came
with
family
that.
my
and
the
My
to
ice
do
so
we
ago.
boxes.
the
whole
actually
father's
and
the
relationship
parents
ice
out
my
But
a
It
is
by
car
little
too
another
Commissioner.
How
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
197
197
1
May
10,
2
did
he
3
or
4
where
5
Taxpayer's
6
thinking
7
just
8
before
I
9
to
one
10
leave
did
he
he
came
an
to
Pat
13
tired.
14
talk
15
about
how
16
Daily
News
17
town,
you
18
administrators
19
millions
of
20
brothers
were
21
millions
of
22
want
to
say
23
know
is
you're
24
This
year,
25
is
I
won't
about
was
new
have
cushy
job,
up
to
so
I
here,
pay
jobs?
Hello,
off
Thank
worked
be
my
name
is
all
day,
so
I'm
I
want
to
long.
transparency,
on
to
everyone.
Rochford.
I
I
people
you
I
limo,
helicopter?
ask
do
by
back
a
ROCHFORD:
12
water
A
Again,
your
much,
go
getting
who
of
he
ambulance
money.
go,
MS.
Did
from?
about
very
11
here?
take
wanted
get
you
2012
a
regular
I
want
basis
in
and
other
newspapers
hear
about
hospital
making
millions
dollars.
The
running
dollars,
is
it's
taxes.
as
a
this
a
tax,
Every
the
around
and
They
made
apartments.
taxpayer,
getting
talk
Cohen
YAI.
and
to
all
raise
this
time
you
I
I
year.
time
it
are
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
198
198
1
May
10,
2012
2
turning
3
in
4
are
5
paying
6
raise
7
transportation
8
on
9
people
around,
Rockaway,
getting
a
we
a
and
and
when
for
we
is
getting
getting
a
this,
tolls.
helicopter,
in
are
are
tax
higher
money
we
All
lose
a
tax,
we
we
out
do
helicopter
work
11
happened.
12
Governor
13
horrendous
14
getting
somewhere,
15
are
Governor
of
New
Jersey,
16
doesn't
work
us
tax
payers.
17
people
all
day
to
18
pay
19
witness
20
administration.
I
21
am
of
22
that
23
administrators
24
Hospital
paid
25
million,
and
the
who
higher
just
to
so
four
works
New
work
would
have
are
the
Jersey
and
you
have
Relying
that
higher
the
fraud
people
bad
you
and
tired
moving
if
accident.
for
count
in
weather
of
accidents
Our
To
10
It
is
services.
doesn't
more
we
are
horrendous.
and
raise
Saint
themselves
their
perk
goes
you
but
it
Our
here
just
in
tell
When
were
when
come
to
it.
who
for
that
have
on
works
taxes,
a
I
to
to
be
the
you
I
heard
the
Vincent
over
was
$1
that
they
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
199
199
1
May
10,
2012
2
had
a
3
Hamptons,
you
4
I
talk
5
experience.
I
6
want
you
7
people
8
saw
9
people
helicopter
have
to
to
tell
in
200
get
the
from
my
personal
work
in
Maimonides.
our
ER
used
to
day.
Our
ER
in
people
a
day.
Our
ER
sees
day
in
Berger
the
ER,
11
don't
any
12
As
we
talk
13
we
talk
Commission
14
life
15
read.
16
responsibility
17
York
City
18
your
tax
19
is
20
tax.
21
just
has
to
stop
22
like
you
to
investigate
23
Hospital,
24
line
25
bribe
money
to
about
about
is
a
toll,
Then
that
it
to
the
than
tomorrow
it
is
where
they
Kruger?
the
what
are
take
income
What
the
the
is
of
Today
tax.
I
it
water
It
would
Peninsula
money.
money
line
any
New
the
somewhere.
was
on
raising
is
in
is
as
you
form?
it
We
slack.
Jewish
people
different
don't
the
there
we
300
Downstate,
is
that
we
100
2010
money.
up
closing
and
other
in
pick
Kingsbrook
support,
Where
and
I
see
a
get
did
to
know.
10
the
out
2009
a
any
to
did
What
out
they
to
cover
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
200
200
1
May
10,
2012
2
that
3
and
he
4
the
responsibility
5
we
6
because
7
was
8
responsibility
9
investigating
under?
is
send,
We
all
going
or
Dr.
to
the
Shah
But
the
say
that
11
this?
12
salary.
13
what
14
disgusted.
15
over
and
over,
it's
16
million,
Saint
Vincent's,
17
helicopter.
Here
18
Kruger.
you
19
Mr.
20
Flushing
21
Goodbye.
I
certainly
They
have
to
say
When
But
Levine.
He
you
23
Phyllis
24
director
25
Peninsula
in
a
of
the
a
to
cap
my
do,
and
that
taxpayer.
of
this
they
is
I
am
abuse
$4
have
the
bribing
what
happened
nice
job
Thank
I'm
Just
to
in
you.
Hi.
and
on
on
emergency
Hospital.
going
Kingsboro,
PRAWZINSKI:
Prawzinski,
the
cap
are
know
left
a
hear
we
got
a
that
Rockaway
put
put
as
Hospital.
MS.
to
certainly
is
are
find
They
get
is
are
going
where
think
we
we
happened,
people
where
this,
are
but
10
22
we
of
didn't
to
that
jail,
people
important?
out,
know
My
a
name
is
former
room
at
like
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
201
201
1
May
10,
2012
2
speaker
previous
3
kind
here
4
because
5
of
he
to
under
me
who
false
said
he
pretenses,
wasn't
advocating
for
Peninsula,
he
advocating
for
6
Rockaways,
I
feel
the
7
I
understand
that
in
8
a
made
9
have
was
decision.
come
to
I
listen
10
affected
peoples'
11
affected
the
12
one
13
this
14
address
all
15
known.
I
16
have
only
17
that
there
18
much
longer
19
histories
at
20
the
days
21
where
22
from
23
because
24
back.
25
years
do
not
will
health
believe
But
that
you
to
have
how
so
and
and
But
I
have
who
had
to
forward,
that
to
come
have
newcomer.
years.
I
many
people
who
more
we
I
was
actually
money,
got
know
have
I'm
doing
in
well,
notice
going
now
into
there
stealing
even
point
I
prestigious
were
didn't
we
for
22
when
the
I
have
I
moment
Peninsula.
we
But
a
much
were
you
for
here
are
you
care.
relative
and
we
appreciate
a
people
us,
is
people
been
because
this
you
am
way,
the
heart,
lives,
change.
glory
same
my
is
way
where
big
20
trouble.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
202
202
1
May
10,
2
We
3
minute
or
4
day
two.
5
wanted
to
6
didn't
think
7
business
to
8
over
the
year,
9
were
affiliated
had
or
2012
a
reprieve,
two,
us
11
them
12
anybody
leach
year
and
with
a
we
the
that
13
run
hospital.
14
last
15
couldn't
16
Nobody
17
were
18
desperate
19
just
20
as
21
didn't
22
deteriorated
over
23
In
2011,
24
and
25
Rockaway,
things
we
get
to
close,
appeal.
We
provide
August
said
of
we
were
and
we
of
and
made
to
we
a
going
go
hospital
care,
to
creditors.
we
going
from
We
weren't
that
great
need
summer
credit,
and
We
hospital,
needed
from
us
buy
we
weren't
hurting.
extend
close.
that
were
But
became
to
I
a
it
We
the
supplies
would
going
By
because
that
we
a
they
out.
had
getting
about
half
them,
evident
a
invested
them
cost.
year,
for
believe
exorbitant
the
for
successful,
that
just
thought
Medisys
truly
make
increasingly
at
with
I
10
we
that
to
down
that
had
time.
a
company
health
will
care
invest
stepped
in
and
in
your
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
203
203
1
May
10,
2012
2
community
and
make
3
be.
That
was
their
4
they
came
in.
5
we
6
organization
and
7
elevated
practice
8
on
a
9
on
February
were
In
this
our
white
these
23rd
10
closing
11
lab,
I
12
will
do
13
lab
14
only
there
15
undo
literally
16
resources.
17
months,
18
room
that
19
more
medications,
20
was
21
came
in
22
they
allowed
23
to
24
$200,000
25
even
said
and
oh,
no,
whatever
make
it
five
there
are
takes
the
best.
of
and
better
probably
at
did
this
all
very
a
that
to
come
in
of
in
this
If
it
When
work,
they
and
company
$100,000,
they
and
to
five
generous
another
lab
were
equipment,
it.
this
We
that
had
staff.
throw
in
leaching
in
see
we
fix
person
did
out
the
They
didn't
and
of
to
a
they
they
winning.
not
more
that
went
They
years
years,
day
are
because
we
can
walked
we
is
reasonable,
going
we
they
months.
Two
months
that
it
two
the
people,
said
hospital
it
this
When
and
best
from
five
with
horse.
the
motto
the
affiliated
the
were
look
never
at,
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
204
204
1
May
10,
2012
2
should
3
from
4
State
5
involving
6
how
7
in
8
nobody
9
State
have
just
February
has
a
been
23rd
$35
honest
and
said
billion
health
care.
Isn't
April
2,
2012,
the
midst
of
closing,
it
managed
saying
in
to
we
sure
York
New
close
that
down.
12
the
hospitals
that
closing
13
was
about
fact
that
14
population
15
of
the
16
of
those
17
care
18
money
19
successful
20
we
21
hospital,
22
company
23
fact
24
our
25
because
were
that
into
It
run
Medicaid
that
no
It
and
are
of
it
to
out
one
health
lose
about
be,
a
how
because
successful
was
about
wanted
Medicare
state
one
successful
longer
bills,
is
a
had
us.
to
wasn't
going
was
resources
state
am
patient
entry
because
they
our
of
to
behind
us,
We
were
going
were
York.
day.
we
we
most
the
I
Hospital
New
causes
every
But
the
portals
that
I
paper,
worth
of
funny
am
11
State
it
so
Peninsula
draws
deficit
already
not
the
York
the
billion.
us
were
10
$35
that
New
budget
on
read
with
funded.
the
to
foot
bills,
Also
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
205
205
1
May
10,
2
people
that
3
who
see
4
thank
5
did
6
knowing
7
time,
we
don't
also.
everybody
after
have
any
So
just
for
that
it
10
80,
we
11
Well,
12
from
13
sad
14
here
15
confused
16
maybe
17
pulled
18
phone
19
worked
20
Members
21
deemed
22
know
23
was
formed.
24
the
past
25
Brooklyn.
you
stories,
50
about
eight,
very
and
they
the
they
and
more
this
running.
Numbers
heard
71
But
months.
Peninsula,
with
gave
I
us
a
and
live
years,
have
I
am
very
We
go
back,
Medisys
on
Cook.
the
The
heard
living
was
Rick
diligently,
myself.
You
When
I
Rick.
heard
people
years.
times
We
You
community.
nine
of
it.
Hi,
something.
story,
22
job
much
CLANCY:
have
you
40,
many
so
to
hospital
SPEAKER:
Rockaway
out
want
please.
there
for
insurance
great
this
were
UNANNOUNCED
the
the
hurts
COMMISSIONER
through
I
supporting
because
8
9
2012
the
We
Board
courts
trustee.
then
You
the
fabulous
five
in
Rockaway
for
but
like
I
was
a
born
little
in
sense
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
206
206
1
May
10,
2012
2
of
3
I
4
that
5
fortunate
to
6
They
a
7
months,
they
8
$33,000
in
9
million.
It
10
days,
I
11
six
12
bankruptcy.
13
forensic
14
It
15
you,
16
the
17
that
18
laboratory.
19
a
20
the
21
worked
diligently.
22
worked
diligently
23
that
24
Nobody
25
thousands
something
say
that
we
and
days
car,
before
say
we
Six
how
ever
If
We
up
came
of
to
six
it
again,
out
that
the
So
I
get
sell
I
asked
be.
This
of
because
of
the
car.
You
flat.
and
a
on
fix
We
people
here
night
to
Guess
what?
party.
to
is
that
tire
These
dollars
state.
flat
running.
the
a
a
the
day
was
had
know
closed
it
of
we
this
that
fixed
and
that
from
you
don't
flat.
strange
could
been
had
$60
right.
hospital
we
four
back
days
smell
the
coming
came
inspection
you
lab
very
were
Group.
In
and
months
We
Revival
black,
will
back.
back,
right.
eight
knight.
came
is
smell
the
came
the
white
said
has
for
we
find
the
doesn't
only
doesn't
because
worked,
were
I
that
get
We
put
this
get
in
lab
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
207
207
1
May
10,
2012
2
up.
3
We
4
court,
5
Hospital.
6
sat
7
we
met
the
8
we
got
money,
9
accepted.
We
went
refurbished
to
and
with
court.
we
The
entire
Fab
represented
The
trustee,
her.
They
but
didn't
coming
Jones,
some
it
to
we
demands,
needed
money,
wasn't
like
11
is
12
other
13
New
14
laboratories.
15
had
16
right,
17
Commissioner,
Mr.
Commissioner,
please
18
explain
how
with
to
19
we
20
dirty
gloves
21
silly
things.
22
to
23
That
24
degrees.
25
exiting
hospitals
York
the
State
get
that
were
We
to
an
snuff.
is
me
So
due
It
the
was
doesn't
asked
six
they
floor
or
six
bankruptcy
It
days
do
in
not
get
sit
go,
whatever,
weren't
up
lab.
off
before
we
find
the
was
we
in
the
days
and
warm
the
finances,
It
I
All
money,
Refrigerators
dangerous.
Why
the
what
there
closing
to
all.
inspection
on
that.
were
had
wherewith
Rick.
with
think
the
money
wrong
I
where
10
something
from.
went
Nassau
They
yet
thing.
Five
Ms.
made
demands.
They
was
the
two
us
this
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
208
208
1
May
10,
2012
2
inspection.
3
didn't
4
open
5
accepting
6
bring
7
come
8
response
9
off
Was
it
maybe
us
to
keep
expect
for
eight
that
this
up.
the
months?
part.
report
You
in
hospital.
$2,000,000
11
be
12
going
13
are
14
have
a
hospital
15
may,
I
would
16
response
17
you
18
saved
inside
to
from
the
come
going
to
to
heard
20
all.
Good
21
you?
My
22
I
23
who
24
is
25
open.
to
saw
are
our
for
you
the
RFP
So
some
had
everyone.
the
that
son
is
you
an
keep
don't
you
sure
I
luck.
evening,
How
are
Smallwood,
and
mommy,
health
we
hear.
Good
evening,
in
am
to
Good
a
so
rapid
SMALLWOOD:
as
may
is
we
if
I
last.
speaking
that
days,
questions.
that
a
getting
when
more.
get
selling
assets
report
card
to
are
60
any
the
going
the
Alexis
My
got
before
is
crucial
have
The
name
worked
not
hospital.
a
hospital
are
They
the
DOH
They
are
appreciate
myself
the
I
They
all
get
all
MS.
am
we
days.
10
19
out.
say
60
I
that
as
a
field,
worker
and
it
Peninsula
asthmatic,
and
I
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
209
209
1
May
10,
2012
2
can't
3
get
4
capacity.
5
doctor,
6
around
7
Peninsula
8
receptionist.
9
right
wait
to
to
him.
Not
Our
and
she
so
11
you,
12
workers,
I'm
13
is
to
14
are
15
take
the
16
fact
because
17
New
18
when
19
the
20
you're
21
we're
22
can,
23
up
24
that
25
is
tired
York
I
I'm
down.
and
I
used
Hospital
say
the
patients
trying
beds
are
telling
to
them
do
you
have
there
who
is
Albany
representing
people
and
got
a
best
working
and
us,
I
at
mean
this,
and
and
honey,
that
talk
that
everywhere
and
a
worker
like
to
can't
that's
listen,
the
telling
think
Queens.
are
there,
care
complaining,
but
in
in
be
in
John's
know
to
her
patient
You
I
look
a
I'm
stressed
workload.
small
a
go
me.
you
I
you
Saint
telling
is
if
saw
I
to
wonderful
spot
time
to
it
sure
just
overload
now
a
telling
every
go
is
can
I
pleasant
you
going
I
John's
that,
pretty
worker.
10
Saint
only
room,
there,
if
to
doctor
I'm
this
is
get
to
we
them
money
and
else
who
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
210
210
1
May
10,
2012
2
pharmaceutical
companies.
3
Not
AJ's
4
because
they're
5
and
those
6
came
7
blistered
up,
and
8
more.
was
like
9
my
only
all
up
that,
and
He
baby
bit
and
11
better
take
12
better
not
13
if
hurt
14
want
to
go
to
15
listen,
do
not
16
know
what
17
care
field,
18
they
work
19
their
20
worked
21
she's
22
crap
23
don't
want
24
be
work.
you
at
my
them
jump
he
at
to
and
all
hard
I
be
to
king,
the
king,
you
you
because
I
the
take
don't
hot,
down.
nurses,
care
of
somebody
who
now,
treated
like
work
Good
I
health
right
there.
STEUBEN:
a
It's
and
and
being
to
and
in
any
time,
bed,
know
like
upstairs,
Peninsula
work
off
bugs
walk
listen,
doctors
back
to
a
John's.
Peninsula,
the
Go
that
close
welfare
MR.
like
Saint
the
He's
this.
off
is
and
vitamins,
patients.
on
there,
couldn't
yourself,
very
at
over
baby.
everybody
it
fell
building
treated
tell
almost
mosquitoes
10
25
I
is
leg
program.
She
She
to
wants
evening.
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
211
211
1
May
10,
2012
2
Thank
3
everyone
4
four
5
My
6
resident
on
7
research
and
8
Commission
of
9
because
has
you.
I
who
has
hours.
name
is
would
I
been
just
Peter
it
like
here
got
here
123.
checked
2006,
out
probably
the
all
11
along
12
of
13
situation
14
with
15
consultants
16
to
17
then
18
because
19
of
20
recommendations
21
health
22
repair.
23
structure
the
care
24
Unless
we
act
decisively,
25
report
was
New
David
York
in
their
read
review
the
conclusions
and
to
their
they
It
Some
as
State
up
and
would
like
paragraphs,
on
and
Rockaway,
entire
State
their
for
system
is
is
too
Rockaway.
broken
late
delivery
presented
come
I
the
of
the
MDs
position
were
not
commissioned
and
two
covered
York.
care
or
little
hospital
experts.
one
a
discussed
from
the
state,
just
get
New
to
work.
apologize
was
Sanders
a
to
Berger
been
10
with
he
am
did
I
three
from
I
I
and
But
thank
for
Steuben.
Beach
afternoon.
to
to
and
needs
to
system.
again,
the
Our
this
State
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
212
212
1
May
10,
2012
2
Legislature
3
Further
4
bankruptcies
5
occur.
6
close
7
the
8
access.
9
help
as
well
facility
are
ones
to
most
would
11
and
12
presented
13
the
14
is
six
years
15
of
the
crisis
16
delivery
17
The
state
18
has
fallen
19
beds
20
of
21
approximately
22
beds
23
the
24
reading.
25
commission
to
18
the
in
to
in
A
the
is
that
alone
percent
On
one
Legislature
and
of
2006.
fundamental
health
driver
capacity.
occupancy
staff
That
care
of
2004,
rate
certified
a
decrease
bed
basis,
of
forgive
statutory
the
that
system
hospital
unoccupied.
Again,
makes
will
was
percent
a
be
That
quarter
currently
the
excess
in
may
preserving
care.
hospital
82
to
calamities
November
from
Per
forces
State
ago.
wide
summary.
hospitals
patient
percent.
are
certain
destabilize
system
65
the
Governor.
recommendations
compromise
Governor
and
future
further
to
closures
critical
avoid
10
the
market
These
to
to
almost
Moreover
due
as
me
Here
is
for
obligation,
the
following
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
213
213
1
May
10,
2
recommendations,
3
reconfigure
4
of
5
apply
6
They
7
quarter
8
Collectively,
9
reduce
the
2012
health
state.
address
the
approximately
11
percent.
12
will
13
addition,
14
recommendations
15
1,000
16
Again,
17
Peninsula
18
approximately
19
Episcopal
20
approximately
21
financing,
22
merge
23
with
24
sounds
25
not
as
long
as
term
regions.
or
or
one
nursing
99
should
81
create
beds,
In
more
slots.
downsize
and
beds.
Saint
I
am
upon
should
facility
beds.
rational
implemented.
John's
Contingent
single
400
by
by
facilities
a
than
Rockaway,
downsize
rebuild
imminently
for
should
two
homes
care
institutional
Hospital
will
seven
closed.
will
approximately
been
region
by
beds,
many
specifically
and
all
capacity
downsized
the
each
recommendations
4,000
Twice
non
and
hospitals.
10
new
in
hospitals,
inpatient
be
size
recommendations
across
57
all
right
care
The
equitably
of
to
That
to
me,
sure
has
the
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
214
214
1
May
10,
2
two
hospitals
3
egos
4
among
5
this
6
people.
7
peninsula
8
state
9
sort
10
2012
on
both
both
is
sides,
major
should
should
happen.
11
name
13
administrator
14
for
15
tonight
16
people
17
the
18
long
term
19
most
people
20
am
21
down
22
be
filled,
23
My
beds
24
reaching
out
25
patients
from
is
you
Laurie
Nursing
to
at
to
so
very
elderly.
We
care
to
with
on
I
speak
but
are
that
am
still
to
Brooklyn,
am
and
sure
assume
am
my
beds
I
I
that
going
the
filled.
Jamaica
120
themselves,
I
not
Center
here
of
I
My
the
subacute
and
is
am
for
because
census,
some
Promenade
automatically
my
the
could
I
facility.
speak
that
evening.
behalf
a
the
much.
Good
are
But
provide
this
Rehab.
can't
on
something
Ocean
speak
staffs,
100,000
Paladino.
and
that
here
be
their
of
PALADINO:
12
both
facility
structure
MS.
but
boards.
approach
Thank
it,
and
peninsula
One
a
on
directors
one
of
discussed
I
to
won't
case.
am
am
Hospital,
taking
Coney
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
215
215
1
May
10,
2012
2
Island,
3
We
4
that
5
offer
6
off
7
peninsula.
8
there
9
wouldn't
Queens,
started
Lutheran,
some
great
unfortunately
people
of
the
are
if
they
island,
The
not
be
except
for
11
Saint
John's
is
12
know
13
haven't
14
somehow,
15
John's,
16
call,
17
somewhere
18
they
19
diversion.
20
somehow.
21
The
22
hospital.
Not
23
am
also
24
employees
that
25
living
the
they
been
I
they
got
island
here
to
in
a
if
I
to
just
we
I
to
am
for
Rockaways.
Saint
a
Brookdale,
know
how
on
there
another
my
for
have,
they
getting
getting
have
I
that
weren't
are
speak
If
and
out
don't
they
place
But
Jamaica,
they
needs
no
commented
live
they
John's.
patient
So
shipped
that
have
day
to
the
diversion,
next
else.
So
of
Saint
in
there
being
diversion.
the
are
be
Otherwise,
have
send
and
able
They
on
on
won't
residents
there.
go
there
are
well.
to
programs
off
120
10
that
we
Interfaith.
patients.
the
most
If
I
283
of
them
they
get
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
216
216
1
May
10,
2012
2
hurt,
they
3
their
family
4
their
elderly
5
nursing's
6
rugby
7
Long
8
the
9
that
the
10
much
aware
11
going
12
worked
out.
But
13
need.
These
patients
14
care,
15
they
16
Right
17
patients.
18
them.
have
was
accident,
Jewish.
So
is
of
there,
it
an
now,
acute
I
have
So
Please
I
COMMISSIONER
20
very
much.
21
this
is
22
we
23
back
now
24
what
we
25
make
that
have
I
very
just
have
Albany
for
am
acutely
ill,
to
place
commitment
to
We
are
to
take
my
send
you.
Thank
say
a
you
that
have
going
today.
to
send
Thank
want
learned
great
term
CLANCY:
and
be
hospital.
me.
We
to
we
long
where
a
very
are
that
in
sure
is
how
need
care
no
need
has
is
important.
learned.
to
that
a
out
I
is
are
need
help
the
in
of
up
Health
there
they
children,
ended
It
back
take
director
and
of
that.
to
recently
she
when
need
My
and
get
but
their
hurt
Department
to
where
parents.
son
Island
no
members,
hospital
19
got
heard,
to
go
look
I
at
just
everyone
in
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
217
217
1
May
2
this
3
here,
4
that
commitment,
5
take
this
very
6
very
much
for
7
forum.
8
10,
2012
room,
and
and
had
(TIME
the
to
folks
that
leave.
that
I
We
am
seriously.
7:00
do
Thank
in
been
make
going
participating
NOTED:
have
to
you
this
P.M.)
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570
218
218
1
2
CERTIFICATION
3
4
5
6
I,
7
Public
8
York,
9
Robert
in
do
and
accurate
11
notes.
12
IN
13
hereunto
14
May
for
hereby
THAT
10
J.
the
Pollack,
the
of
Notary
New
certify:
foregoing
transcript
WITNESS
set
State
a
my
of
my
WHEREOF,
hand
this
is
a
true
and
stenographic
I
have
24th
day
of
2012.
15
16
17
18
--------------------------------ROBERT
J.
POLLACK
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
PRECISE COURT REPORTING
(516) 747-9393 (718) 343-7227 (212) 581-2570