Broc Rossell - D.A. Powell's Chronic and Twenty-first-Century Lyricism

BROCRO S S E L L
$!0OWELLS#HRONICAND
4WENTYlRST#ENTURY,YRICISM
#HRONICBY$!0OWELL-INNEAPOLIS-INN'RAYWOLF0RESS
$!0OWELLSlRSTPOSTvTRILOGYvCOLLECTIONOFPOETRY#HRONICIS
HISLATESTANDHISlRSTTOBENOMINATEDFORTHE.ATIONAL"OOK!WARD
0UBLISHEDINJUSTPRIORTO0OWELLSRECEIVINGTHE+INGLSEY4UFTS
0OETRY !WARDˆA COOL FOR hA MIDCAREER POET OF PROMISEv
ˆ#HRONIC OFFERS THE PROMISE OF A POET WITH AN ALREADY POWERFUL
STYLEANDRANGEREVEALINGHIMSELFTOBEAMAJORLYRICALVOICEINTHIS
COUNTRYANDOURTIME)TBEGINSWITHANEPIGRAPHFROM6IRGILS.INTH
%CLOGUE
4IMEROBSUSOFALLEVENOFMEMORYOFTASABOY)RECALL
THATWITHSONG)WOULDLAYTHELONGFORGOTTENDAYSTOREST
.OW)HAVEFORGOTTENALLMYSONGS
4HE .INTH %CLOGUE DESCRIBES 6IRGILS EMOTIONAL TURMOIL OF HAVING
ONESPROPERTYONESLANDANDSOONESHOMEANDONESLIFECONlS
CATEDˆBYTHE2OMANARMYIN6IRGILSCASEANDIN0OWELLSCASEˆWHO
KNOWS
4HE BOOKS TITLE GIVES A CLUE ) THINK THE POET PROBABLY INTENDS
FORMETOSIMULTANEOUSLYCALLTOMINDTHAT:IG:AGGEDSEMINAL
WORKOF!NDRE2OMELLE9OUNGTHEBLANCHINGOFMYWIFESFACEINONE
OFHERREGULARATTACKSANDGUILTSTRICKENMEMORIESOFMYOWNWHITE
FACETHEMOONABOVEMYYEARSOFSELFABUSE%ACHOFUSHASSIMILAR
ASSOCIATIONSALLOFUSHAVEOURPRIVATERECURRENCESWHICHSEEMLIKE
MUTEDDECLARATIONSOFSOMEKINDOFDESTINYˆTHEFAILEDRELATIONSHIPS
THEFAILEDVENTURESTHEMEDICATIONSMEMORYLOSSHANGOVERSCOMFORT
FOODTHEOLDQUILTEDJACKETWESAVEFORSADWINTERDAYSh#HRONICv
FORALLITSFORMSANDPERMUTATIONSISENDEMICˆITISAUNIVERSALPHASE
"UTITISALSOAMUTABLEANDPOROUSSTATEAPROCLIVITYORCONDITIONTHAT
MITIGATESBOTHTHEEXTERNALCAUSEANDTHEINTERNALRESPONSEh#HRONICv
IS A TERM WE USE TO DESCRIBE THE SLOWLY AND INTRINSICALLY CORROSIVE
U
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENTHEOTHERANDOURSELVES4HEQUESTIONOFWHATIS
LOSTANDHOWWELOSEITISFUNDAMENTALLYUNANSWERABLEITSAQUES
TIONWHOSETERMSARECONSTANTLYCHANGINGEVENASWEARE
4HISSENSATIONOFLOSSANDOFFADINGMEMORYSHOTTHROUGH#HRONIC
ISONEOFTHEOLDESTCHARACTERISTICSOFLYRICALPOETRYˆAS#ARL0HILLIPS
SAIDRECENTLYhTHELYRICPOEMISALWAYSATSOMELEVELATESTIMONYAT
ONCETOALOVEFORTHEWORLDWEMUSTLOSEANDTOTHEFACTOFLOSSITSELFv¡
4HESESIMULTANEITIESOFINTENTIONANDSENSATIONAREOFTENEXPRESSEDIN
LYRICALPOETRYBYTHEALCHEMICALLYMUSICALQUALITIESOFTHESPEAKERS
VOICE!REALSINGERASINGERWHOLISTENSTOHERSELFSINGDOESNTSINGA
SONGTHESAMEWAYTWICETHEACTOFSINGINGITSELFSHOWSTOTHESINGER
ADIRECTIONTOWARDTHESONGSMEANINGANDINFORMSTHENEXTPERFOR
MANCE 7HEN THE HUMAN VOICE SINGS OF ITS OWN EXPERIENCES THEY
AREALMOSTALWAYSEXPERIENCESTHATHAVECHANGEDTHESINGERINWAYS
THATCANTBESPOKENOFWITHOUTMUSICTHEMUSICALACCOMPANIMENT
IN3APPHOSTIMETHROUGHTHATOFTHETROUBADOURSANDJONGLEURSOROF
THEMUSICALQUALITYOFLANGUAGEITSELFINOURSSIMULTANEOUSLYDEEPENS
ANDRELIEVESTHEPAINOFEXPOSINGTHEPRIVATEEMOTIONSOFLOSSFAILURE
REGRET AND CONFUSION ,IKE OUR MYRIAD CHRONIC CONDITIONS THE PER
SONALISUNIVERSAL4HISISWHYWELISTENTOTHEBLUES
#HRONICISASTRANGEBLUES%ACHDISCOVERYERASESSOMETHINGELSE
AND0OWELLSLAMENTISLACEDWITHADElANTPROUDACCEPTANCEOFTHAT
QUID PRO QUO 4HERE IS CELEBRATION AND TORMENT MOMENTS CAPTURED
AND MOMENTS STILL BEING LIVED MEMORIES OF PICNICS AND FARMS AND
ROUGHSEXANDOFSLEEPLESSNIGHTSCRUMBLINGINOURHANDSLIKEYELLOW
PHOTOGRAPHS CELLULOID IMAGES CURLING INTO mAME 0OWELLS POEMS
EMPLOYABANQUETOFTROPESTECHNIQUESANDMODESBRACKETEDEMPTY
SPACES LINES CRACKED OPEN BY EMPTY SPACES INTERLUDES AND ASIDES
COUPLETSANDSHATTEREDSTANZASANDLYRICALSTANCESRANGINGFROMTHE
ROUGHVERNACULARINhSHUTTHEFUCKUPANDDRINKYOURGINTONICvTO
THEELEVATEDAESTHETICOFhCALLASLOVERv
%VEN WITHIN THE POEM hCALLAS LOVERv FOR INSTANCE AS IN MOST
POEMSINTHISCOLLECTIONTHESEFARRANGINGINSTINCTSPLAYAGAINSTEACH
OTHERBEGINNINGWITHTHEPUNINITSTITLE0OWELLINTRODUCESUSTOTHE
SINGERAShBUTTERmYBRILLIANTRIBANDRICEmOURFACESILKENEVENHER
VOICE A SASHED KIMONOv BUT IMMEDIATELY MEASURES HIMSELF AGAINST
THATKINDOFPERFECTION
0HILLIPS#ARL0OETRY,OVE-ERCY"ERKELEY#ALIFORNIA5NIVERSITYOF#ALI
FORNIA"ANCROFT,IBRARY
U
IF)WEREFOOLISHLIKEHER
BUTARENT)FOOLISHLIKEHER
SPOTTINGTHECOILOFSMOKEANDTHEBILLOWEDSAIL
AGAINSTTHEVERGEOFSKY
*OINING HIS VOICE WITH HERS MINGLING THEIR VANITIES AND SILENCES
0OWELLFASHIONSINTHEJOININGOFTWOLAMENTATIONSINAFEWDEFTLINES
A VAULTED ATMOSPHERE AN APARTMENT FULL OF MEMORY AND MOMENT
OPERAANDOPENMOUTH
h)FTHEFOOLPERSISTEDINHISFOLLYHEWOULDBEAWISEMANvSAID
7ILLIAM"LAKE7HILETHEMAXIMLIKELYGIVESFOOLSREGRETTABLEENCOUR
AGEMENT THIS 0ROVERB FROM (ELL ALSO RAISES AN INTERESTING QUESTION
ABOUT HOW WE READ POETRY TODAY DO WE PLACE GREATER TRUST IN THE
WISEMANORTHEFOOLˆTHEPRIESTORTHEPAUPER'IVENTHEWORLDWE
LIVE INˆlFTY YEARS PAST 0OLLOCKS PRIME AND EIGHTYlVE YEARS SINCE
!RCHIBALD-ACLEISHSh!RS0OETICAv¢ˆISCOHERENCEAMYSTERYASGREAT
AS CHAOS AND CONFUSION (OW CAN POETRY ACCOUNT FOR THESE VALUES
WITHOUTPRIVILEGINGONEOVERTHEOTHER)FITSANARBITRARYDISTINCTION
AND IT MAY WELL BE IT IS STILL INSTRUCTIVE TO ASK OURSELVES WHAT WE
MIGHTTHINKTOBEAMORECOMPELLINGVOICEˆONEFOUNDINTHEPOETRY
OFASAGEORINTHEPOETRYOFAFOOLPERSISTENTLYUNSPOOLINGSTRANDSOF
COHERENCEFROMHISHELPLESSLYTANGLEDLIFE
)CARRYTHESAMEBAFmEDHEART)HAVEALWAYSCARRIED
ABITMOREBATTEREDTHANBEFOREABITLESSJOY
FOR)SEETHEDIFlCULTCHARGEOFLIVINGINTHISDECLININGSPHERE
)NTHESELINESFROMTHETITLEPOEMWElNDANEXAMPLEOFTHEPARA
DOXICALMOVEMENTS0OWELLUSESTOACCOMPLISHSUCHABROADRANGEOF
EMOTIONALEXPRESSION0ASTPRESENTANDFUTURETENSEDECLARATIVEAND
lGURATIVETROPESBOTHPRESCIENCEANDSIMPLEMINDEDNESSARESYNTHE
SIZEDINTOATRULYLYRICALSENSIBILITYONETHATHASTHECAPACITYTOTHINK
FEELTOUCHSAYSINGQUIVERANDRECOILWITHTHESAMESPEED!GAIN
INAWEEKYOUCOULDWATCHMECRUMBLEINTOSMUTSPENDHUES
SPENTPERFUMESDUSTUPONTHELAPELWHEREAMOMENT)RESTED
h!POEMSHOULDNOTMEAN"UTBEv
U
YESTHEMOTHSHAVEVISITEDANDDEPOSITEDTHEIRVELVETEGGMASS
THEGNATSWEREHERETHEYSMELLEDTHEWILTANDBLIGHT THEY
SALIVATED
INTHEFOLDSOFMYGARMENTSYOUCOULDPRACTICALLYTASTETHEROT
-UCH HAS BEEN MADE OF 0OWELLS FORMAL CONSISTENCIES THE DEARTH
OFTITLESHISLACKOFCAPITALIZATIONVERYLONGLINES'RAYWOLFINNOVA
TIVELYLEFTTHEMIDDLEPAGEOF#HRONICUNCUTSOTHATTWOPOEMSTITLED
h#INEMASCOPEv AND h#ENTERFOLDv APPEAR ON PAPER TWICE AS WIDE AS
THEOTHERSTOACCOMMODATELINESCOMPRISINGUPTOTHIRTYWORDSAND
SPORADICPUNCTUATION)NHISRIOTOUSFORMSINHISUSEOFTHEPAGEAND
HISSEEMINGABILITYTOBEGINANYPOEMINTHEMIDDLEOFATHOUGHTHE
SHOWSHISALLEGIANCETOTHETROPESOFCONTEMPORARYEXPERIMENTALISM
9ETHEISALSOANINHERITOROFLYRICISTSLIKE2OBERT$UNCANAND*ACK
3PICERWHOOSCILLATEDBETWEENhTHERATIONALANDTHEVATICvIN0OWELLS
WORDS(ECONJURESTHEWRECKEDFRACTALSOFTHE7EST#OASTLANGUAGE
POETSANDINHISSHORTPHRASEDINTENSELYMUSICALRHYTHMSHEEVINCES
THE INmUENCE OF 'ERARD -ANLEY (OPKINS FOUND IN SO MANY TH
CENTURY POETS WHO EXPLORE THE OVERLAP BETWEEN SOUND AND SENSE
4HESETECHNIQUESAREHIGHLYSUCCESSFULINAMPLIFYINGAVOICEROOTED
TERRIBLYFRIGHTENINGLYANDINSISTENTLYINTHECURRENTSOFACTUALEXPERI
ENCES0OWELLISNOTAMODERNNARRATIVECONFESSIONALOREXPERIMEN
TALPOETPERSEHEISASONGWRITERALBEITASONGWRITERCONCERNEDWITH
AMONGTHEVARIEDDIFlCULTIESOFEXISTENCETHEIMPOSSIBLYDIFlCULTTASK
OFSINGING
!RGUMENTS ABOUT HOW TO CATEGORIZE 0OWELLS POETICS ARE NOT AS
HELPFUL IN UNDERSTANDING 0OWELLS POETRY AS IT IS TO HEAR THE SOUND
OF HIS VOICE )N THIS ERA WHEN hMORE POETRY IS BEING READ AND WRIT
TEN THAN AT ANY TIME IN OURHISTORYv SAYS #HARLES 3IMIC RECENTLY IN
4HE.EW9ORK2EVIEWOF"OOKS£ITISLAMENTABLETHATSOMANYOFTHE
THOUSANDS OF COLLECTIONS OF POETRY PUBLISHED IN THE LAST DECADE ARE
UTTERLY INTERCHANGEABLE 4HE FORMAL INNOVATIONS OF hEXPERIMENTAL
POETRYvˆTHAT ELUSIVE STCENTURY ÏLAN CITED IN SO MANY PUBLISHERS
AND PRESSES MISSION STATEMENTSˆHAVE OFTEN BEEN PRIVILEGED AT THE
EXPENSEOFTHEVERYSPIRITWEASBELIEVERSINPOETRYDESPERATELYHOPE
h#ONFESSIONS OF A 0OET ,AUREATEv .9 2EVIEW OF "OOKS "LOG !PRIL U
TOlNDTHEHUMANITYOFAVOICEINTHEVOID4HEDISTINCTIONBETWEEN
EXPERIMENTALISMANDAUTONOMYOFCOURSEISULTIMATELYANUNNECES
SARYONEAND0OWELLISASGOODANARGUMENTASWEHAVEOFTHEFALSE
HOODOFTHATDICHOTOMYTHATFORMALINNOVATIONINSERVICEOFTHEVOICE
ANDNOTATITSEXPENSEISBOTHDESIRABLEANDATTAINABLE
$!0OWELLISALYRICALPOETANDATRULYPOWERFULONE&ORHIM
THESONGISANUNINHABITABLEMEMORYANACTOFRECOLLECTIONCONTINU
ALLY DISTURBED BY THE CHAOTIC CURRENT OF OUR LIVES 3EEING THE OTHER
AND SPEAKING ITS NAME IS A CONSTANTLY GENERATIVE EVEN SYMBIOTIC
EXCHANGE
OR)AMTHEONEWHOSNOMOREDEARFUMBLINGCONVALESCENT
WHILEYOUTAKETHESTAGELIKEASALVAGESCOWSTEALMYNUMBER
DRAWMELIMPINGBYROTEINTOTHISDRAMATICDUETTHISMOMENT
4RAVELING ACROSS LINES LIKE THESE THE READER OF #HRONIC IS IMPRESSED
BYTHEPARADOXICALETHICALIMPERATIVETOFORGETWHOWEAREORWHO
WETHINKWEAREANDHOWMUCHWEWILLHAVEFORGOTTENANDLOSTWHEN
WEREMEMBERhOURSELVESvAGAINHOWPROFOUNDLYWELIKE6IRGILWILL
HAVEFORGOTTENALLOURSONGS
U