Weed Control in Sugarbeets

69
Weed Control in Sugarbeets
K. Locke t , R.L. Dove1 2, and K.A. Rykbost 2
INTRODUCTION
Weed control continues to be one of the most limiting factors in successful
production of sugarbeets in the Klamath Basin. Weed competition reduces yields,
and costs for hand weeding of herbicide failures greatly reduces profits. In the
Treasure Valley of Malheur County, producers have adopted herbicide practices that
produce weed-free crops with no hand labor required. This study was conducted to
evaluate several post-emergence herbicide options that have been successful in the
Treasure Valley, and to determine yield and economic losses that are associated
with heavy weed competition in the first half of the growing season.
PROCEDURES
The sugarbeet variety ACH 199 was planted on May 13. With the exception of
herbicide applications, cultural practices mirrored those described for the sugarbeet
methanol study (page 67). Three row plots, 25 feet long were established in a
randomized complete block design with four replications to accommodate seven
herbicide treatments. Treatments were applied with a backpack sprayer at 20 gpa of
solution on June 8 and June 17. Products evaluated included Betamix, an
experimental product combining Betamix and Nortron in a proprietary premixed
formulation (NA308/1), and Upbeat, applied alone and in combination with
Betamix in a premixed formulation. Plots were scored for sugarbeet injury on June
16, June 22, and July 1. Weed counts, based on 15 square feet per plot, were made
on August 8.
The treatment of Upbeat failed due to omission of a surfactant with this product.
The combination of Betamix and Upbeat was formulated with surfactant included,
and produced effective weed control. Plots treated with Upbeat alone were hand
weeded on July 1 to provide a measure of early season weed competition on crop
performance. Control treatment plots were hand weeded on August 10, providing a
severe test of sugarbeet production in dense weed competition. Beets were harvested
by hand on October 19. Yields were measured from the center row of each plot.
Approximately 20-pound samples/plot were analyzed for tare loss and sugar content.
Total sugar production was calculated as the product of beet yield, times percent
sugar. Gross value was calculated on the basis of beet yields, sugar content,
processing contract price, and a net selling price of $24/ cwt.
1
2
/ Klamath County Cooperative Extension Agent, Klamath Falls, OR.
/ Associate Professor and Superintendent/Professor, respectively, Klamath
Experiment Station, Klamath Falls, OR.
Acknowledgment: Funding from the California Beet Growers Association and sample
analysis by Imperial Holly Sugar Corporation are gratefully recognized.
70
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Initial herbicide applications coincided with cotyledon to two-true-leaf stage of
beet development. On June 17, beets were in the two-to-four-leaf stage. Most weed
plants were at a similar stage of development on these dates. Weed populations
were not uniform throughout the study area. Relatively high populations of hairy
nightshade and lambsquarter occurred in two replications. Filaree was present at
lower and more consistent density. Indian lovegrass, redroot pigweed, sheperds
purse, and purslane populations were very low and are ignored in this report.
In the absence of surfactant, Upbeat, applied alone at 0.0156 lb ai/A on both
application dates, had a stimulatory effect on both sugarbeets and weeds. Plants
were darker colored and slightly larger in plots treated with Upbeat than in all other
plots. Differences in beet plants were not visually evident after two to three weeks.
All weeds were removed from these plots by hand on July 1. Untreated control plots
had extreme weed competition in two replications. Sugarbeet plants in these plots
were very weak and underdeveloped when weeds were removed on August 10.
Weed density in untreated check plots was high for lambsquarter and hairy
nightshade (Table 1). Betamix at the low application rate, provided about 50 percent
control of lambsquarter and 75 percent control of nightshade. All other herbicide
treatments resulted in satisfactory control of these species. Filaree was present at
low density and was not effectively eliminated by any of the treatments. In all
previous experiments at the KES, filaree has required hand weeding for control.
Very minimal crop injury was observed in the plot treated with the high rate of
NA308/1, and in the combination treatment of Betamix plus Upbeat. No injury
symptoms were observed in the other treatments.
Harvested beet populations were uniform across treatments at 32,000 to 35,000
beets/A. Beet yields were significantly lower in the untreated control than in all
other treatments (Table 2). Yield differences between treatments other than the
control were not significant. Sugar content was not affected by treatments, except
that weed competition through August 6, in the control plot, significantly reduced
beet sugar content. The net effect of weed competition in the control treatment was
a reduction in total sugar production and gross crop value of about 50 percent. With
production costs in the area ranging from about $550 to $750/A, substantial
economic losses would be realized in commercial crops under similar conditions, as
has been observed in several cases.
Small yield reductions were evident at low application rates of Betamix and where
weed competition progressed until the end of June (Upbeat treatment). The low
application rate of NA308/1 appeared to be as effective as the high rate, and a
slight improvement over the Betamix and Upbeat combination. Relative costs of the
various herbicide combinations are not available, but would be a consideration in
the choice of products and rates.
71
Table 1. Weed density and crop injury as affected by herbicide treatments to
ACH199 sugarbeeets at the Klamath Experiment Station, Klamath Falls,
OR, 1993.
Treatment
Control
Rate
lb ai/A
Weed density l
H. Nightshade Lambsquarter Filaree
plants/sq. ft. 0
42
0.2
Crop iniury 2
6/16 6/22 7/1
0.2
0
0
0
0
0
0
Betamix
Betamix
.125+ .25
1.0
8.6
3.8
.33 + .50
0
0.3
0.2
0
0
NA308/1
.25 + .33
0
0.5
0.2
0
0
0
0
NA308/1
375+ .50
03
0.3
0
Upbeat
Betamix +
Upbeat
.0156+.0156
.25 + .33
.0156 + .0156
0.2
0
0.2
0
0.9
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0.5
/ Weed density data collected on August 6.
2 / Crop injury expressed as percent of sugarbeets showing injury symptoms.
1
72
Table 2. Effect of herbicide treatments on yield, sugar content, total sugar
production and gross value of ACH199 sugarbeets at the Klamath
Experiment Station, Klamath Falls, OR, 1993.
Gross
value
Rate
lb ai/A
tons/A
Control
0
12.0
15.6
3800
467
Betamix
.125 + .25
20.4
17.1
6990
862
Betamix
.33 + .50
21.8
17.1
7470
922
NA308/1
.25 + .33
22.7
17.0
7660
945
NA308/1
.375 + .50
22.3
17.4
7760
956
Upbeat
.0156 + .0156
20.6
17.2
7130
878
Betamix +
Upbeat
.25 + .33
.0156 + .0156
20.1
17.4
6980
862
20.0
15
4.5
17.0
3
0.8
6830
15
1510
842
15
186
Treatment
Mean
CV(%)
LSD(.05)
Sugar
content
Total sugar
production
Beet
yield
% --
-- lb/A --
$/A