California State University, Northridge
LARYNGECTOMEES: ·
A PSYCHO-SOCIAL APPROACH TOWARDS TREATMENT
A Thesis submitted in partial satisfaction of the
requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in
Education,
Educational Psychology,
Counseling and Guidance
by
Karen Ann Wentz
May, 1 98 3
The Thesis of Karen Ann Wentz is approved:
Richard Thiel, Ph.D.
(Chairman)
California State University, Northridge
ii.
Dedicated to the memory of
Ginger J. Wentz
February 22, 1983
iii
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
My
sincerest
thanks
and
appreciation
go
to
the
following people for their support and patience throughout
this project:
Doug Friman, Art Blum, Paul Scriffignano,
and the Los Angeles Lost Chord Club for
their
invaluable
assistance,
and for
making me feel like one of the gang.
Dr.
Richard Thiel, for all his guidance,
and for teaching me the impossible
statistics!
Dianne 0. Cooper, for her suggestions
insights into the cancer patient.
and
Dorothy Doyle, for being there when I
needed her, and for being a wonderful
teacher.
My brother, Rick, for majoring in English
in college.
My parents,
for their love and concern,
and for teaching me the value of a good
education.
Kevin,
for seeing me through
several
anxiety attacks, and for bringing me into
the computer age.
Thank You.
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Dedication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
iii
Acknowledgments ••...••.•......••....•....••..
iv
Table of Contents •....•.....•....••......•.••
v
List of Tables .••.•....•..•...•...••......•..
vii
List of F_igures • . . • . • . . . . . . . . • • . . . . . . . . • • . • • .
viii
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ix
Chapter· . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ·. . . . . . . . . . . .
1
I.
Introduction
Background Data ....•..............
II.
Statement of the Problem .....•....
2
Definition of Terms . . • . . . . . . . • . . . •
3
Review of the Literature ............
6
The Laryngectomee Personality .....
6
Rehabilitation Concerns ...........
6
The Team Approach .....•.•....
6
Physiological Realities ......
8
Vocational Concerns ...•.•.•.. 10
Psychosocial Issues ...•....•• 12
Self-Concept and Body Image
17
Pre-Surgical and Post-Surgical
Counseling ...••..•..•...•....... 20
Loss and Laryngectomy •.•.•....•.•. 24
Cancer and the Laryngectomee ....•. 26
v
III.
Methodology . . . . • . . • . • . • • • . • . • . . . • . . . . 32
Subjects . . . . • . . • . . • • . • . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
Testing Instruments .••.•.........• 33
Procedure ...•....•..•........•...• 34
IV.
Results . • • . . . . • • . . . • . • . . . . . • . . . . • . . . . 3 7
Tennessee Self Concept Scale .•.••. 37
Questionnaire ......•.•..•...•.••.• 45
V.
Discussion and Conclusions •...•..•... 49
Summary of the Problem, Method,
Findings, and Problems in
Research . . . . • • . • . • . . . . . . . • . . . . . 49
Suggestions ...............••.•.... 53
Conclusions .........•••.••.......• 54
Bibliography • . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56
A]:.1pendixes
••• •. •• •• ••. • •• •• •• ••• • •• •• •• ••. •••
62
A.
Correspondence ....................•.. 62
B.
Supplemental Testing Materials ..•.... 64
vi
.LIST OF TABLES
Table 1
The Means and Standard Deviations
of the TSCS Variables of Normal
Speakers • . • . • . . . • . . . . • . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . 40
Table 2
The Means and Standard Deviations
of the TSCS Variables of Alaryngeal
Speakers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41
Table 3
The Means and Standard Deviations
of the TSCS Variables of Esophageal
Speakers . • . . • . . . . . . . . . • . . • . • . . . . . . . . . 43
Table 4
The Means and Standard Deviations of
the TSCS Variables of Non-Esophageal
Speakers . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . • . • • . . . . . . . • . . 4 4
vii
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1
Physiology of the Head and Neck Before
and After Total Laryngectomy •.....•...
4
Figure 2
Comparison of the Self-Concept Profiles
of Normal and Alaryngeal Speakers ..... 39
Figure 3
Comparison of the Self-Concept Profiles
of Esophageal and Non-Esophageal
42
Speakers . . .
.
. . .
. .. . .. .. . .. .. . ... . .....
viii
ABSTRACT
LARYNGECTOMEES:
A PSYCHO-SOCIAL APPROACH TOWARDS TREATMENT
by
Karen Ann Wentz
Master of Arts in Education
The
purpose
of
this
study
was
to
examine
the
psychological and social aspects in the rehabilitation
laryngectomees
as
measured
by
self-concept.
It is the
author•s hypothesis that the stigmas associated with
image
and
cancer
would
significantly
that
the
self-concept
of
the
body
reduce
self-concept of the laryngectomee. A secondary
suggests
of
the
hypothesis
non-esophageal
speaking laryngectomee would be diminished even further in
relation
to
the
esophageal
speaking
laryngectomee.
laryngectomee for the purpose of this report refers to
A
an
individual who has undergone a total laryngectomee with or
without radical neck
Members
of
the
dissection
resulting
from
cancer.
Lost Chord Club in Los Angeles were.
administered the Tennessee Self Concept Scale in order
ix
to
obtain
a
measure
of
self-concept
and
a
questionnaire to provide additional data on
supplemental
their
social
Results from the Tennessee Self Concept Scale
showed
systems.
no
difference
between
the
laryngectomee sample and the
control group, although there appeared to be a
in
scores
speakers,
between esophageal speakers and non-esophageal
indicating
esophageal
scores
difference
speakers.
showed
insignificant,
the
a
higher
self-concept
However,
t-tests
difference
to
in
the
performed on the
be
statistically
therefore the null hypothesis could not be
rejected.
Further study is needed in this area to obtain viable
results,
as
well
as
stricter
controls
procedure and ext-raneous variables.
X
over
sampling
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
BACKGROUND DATA
There are
an
estimated
thirty
to
forty
thousand
laryngectomees in the United States today. Of that number,
approximately 95% had laryngeal surgery due to cancer. The
estimated
figures
for
1982
indicate that there will be
close to 11,000 new cases of
laryngeal
cancer
(American
Cancer Society, 1982).
Generally, cancer of the larynx
men
than
more
often
strikes
women; however the figures are changing. Thirty
years ago the ratio of men to women was 14:1; today, it is
6:1.
It
is believed that this trend is the result of the
increased cigarette smoking in women (Scriffignano, 1982).
Also
of
interest
is
laryngeal
cancer
occuring
recently,
cancer
of
the
growing
a
younger
at
for
thirties or
increase
laryngeal
forties.
Until
age.
cancer
This
Today,
it
is
not
to affect those in their
trend
corresponds
with
the
in cigarette smoking among youth. Another reason
may be the public's
health;
age.
of
the larynx was primarily associated
with people over fifty years of
uncommon
incidence
more
awareness
attention
is
of
being
physical
paid
signals of the body thereby increasing the
1
fitness
to
and
the warning
likelihood
of
2
early detection of the disease.
STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
While
cancer
of
of
cancer,
common forms
treatment
process
the
larynx
its
is not among the most
diagnosis
subsequent
presents special concerns in the rehabilitation
of
the
laryngectomy
laryngectomee.
will
surgery
psychological,
ramifications
The
have
social,
physical,
individual
to
facing
confront
and
the
physiological
of this kind of surgery. More specifically,
he must deal with his fear of cancer,
modify
image,
and
his
redefine
self-concept,
and
his
body
accept
his
limitations.
The first priority in the treatment for cancer of the
larynx is removal of the cancer; physical comfort
patient,
implementation
interventions,
and
respectively.
of
life
social
quality
Frequently,
the
and
of
emotional
concerns
first
priorities receive all the attention; any
the
follow
two
treatment
other
benefits
are considered merely fortuitous. However, a comprehensive
approach toward rehabilitation must include evaluation
the
psychological
together with the
Attention
given
laryngectomee
and
social
physical
to
will
the
exigencies
psycho-social
enhance
laryngectomee in society.
aspects
the
of
of
adjustment
the
disease.
concerns
functioning
of
of the
of
the
3
This study proposes that the laryngectomee
through
changes
that
have
had
an
has
gone
impact on his life,
removing him from the societal norm. The
self-concept
the
affected in this
laryngectomee,
transition
has
a
critical
been
factor
significantly
of
depreciated.
Furthermore, those laryngectomees using an assisted device
method of speech will experience an additional decline
in
self-concept.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
Because
certain
terms
hold
different meanings for
different users, some definitions are
terms
are
medical
in
nature
in
order.
Certain
and the professional in a
related, but non-medical field, must have an understanding
of the patient's physical realities.
Hemi-laryngectomy: Also known as a partial
laryngectomy;
a surgical procedure in
which a part of the vocal folds
(or
chords)
is removed. The normal speech and
breathing processes remain intact.
Total Laryngectomy: A surgical procedure
in which the larynx is removed due to
disease or injury. (The larynx, which is
at the uppermost part of the trachea--or
windpipe--is
removed and therefore no
connection between the mouth and the lungs
remains. The surgeon creates an opening in
the lower front part of the neck and joins
the trachea to it. (Figure 1) Since there
is no connection between the lungs and
mouth
or nose,
the patient breathes,
coughs,
sneezes, and "blows his nose"
through the opening in.the neck. He takes
food and liquid by mouth
as
usual.
American Cancer Society, 1977).
4
AIR
ENTERING
NOSE AND
MOUTH
FOR SPUGII Ill
TRACHEA 01
WINDPIPE
Figure 1.
Physiology of the Head and Neck
Before and After Total Laryngectomy
(Reprinted by permission.
International Association of Larngectomees.)
5
Stoma: The opening in the neck through
which a laryngectomee must breathe.
Laryngectomee: A person who has undergone
a· laryngectomy. (Note: For the purpose of
this study, a laryngectomee will imply an
individual who has undergone a
total
laryngectomy because of cancer.)
Radical Neck Dissection: The removal of
diseased--rymph nodes in the neck. This
usually accompanies advanced cases
of
cancer of the larynx.
Alaryngeal Speech: Speech without a larynx
regardless of the mechanism or method
involved.
Assisted
Devices:
Speech
aids
or
prostheses used to create the vibrations
necessary for speech. The sound produced
by these devices has a mechanical quality
to it.
Esophageal Speech: A .method of speech
produced by taking air into the esophagus
thereby setting up
a
vibration
and
expelling
it
in a controlled breath
stream. This sound is then articulated
into words by the tongue, teeth, lips and
palate as normal speakers do.
(Note:
Laryngectomized speakers tell me that this
term is gradually being replaced by. the
previous term--alaryngeal speech--because
it is a more accurate term).
Self-Concept:
"An individual's conception
of
himself
and
his
own
identity,
abilities, worth,
etc." (Websters, 1979)
based on his past and present experiences
and perceptions, and the values associated
with them.
Body Image: The concept of one's own body
based on past and present perceptions as
influenced
by
one's visual,
tactile,
kinesthetic, and postural senses.
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE
THE LARYNGECTOMEE PERSONALITY
There
are
certain
general
characteristics
of
laryngectomees that commonly appear in most of the studies
suggesting a laryngectomee profile. The "typical"
is
a
patient
white male between 50 and 70 years of age. He was a
heavy smoker prior to surgery and there
is
a
25
to
50
percent likelihood that he also had problems with alcohol.
His
post-surgical
disfigurement,
worries
problems
include
relating
to
his
permanent
acceptance
by his
family, friends, and colleagues, returning to work with
disability,
and
the
knowledge
that
Additionally, his heavy smoking has
other
physical
problems
1971 ). Suicide rates
tend
a
he has had cancer.
most
likely
created
(King, Marshall, and Gunderson,
to
be
high
for
this
group
(Minear & Lucente, 1979).
REHABILITATION CONCERNS
The Team Approach
Many people think that rehabilitation means returning
to
normal--but what is normal? The laryngectomee knows he
will never be exactly
surgery.
the
same
as
he
was
before
the
His goal is to create a new standard of normalcy
6
7
that is appropriate for his new situation.
not
easy
and
requires
the
This
assistance
of
task
is
a number of
people.
The
importance
of
using
the
"team
approach"
rehabilitation cannot be stressed enough. The team
include
the
a
should
doctor, surgeon, nurses, speech pathologist,
psychologist, social worker, physical
family,
in
laryngectomized
visitor
therapist,
from
spouse,
the Lost Chord
Club, and any others who may have a part to
play
in
his
recuperation and readjustment.
Martin (1982) divides the
two
units.
The
the
patient,
components
"core
rehabilitation
the
the
other
into
health care unit" consists of the
family,
and
the
physician.
These
three
are the strength behind the success or failure
of the rehabilitation goals. Complimenting the
are
team
"peripheral
support
core
unit
health-concern units" consisting of
systems
mentioned
above.
These
"peripheral units" directly affect the core unit either as
a whole or individually. It is the interaction between the·
units which facilitate the progress of the patient towards
rehabilitation.
For
the
must begin
members
of
laryngectomee,
im~ediately
the
the
following
rehabilitation
preoperatively as soon as problems
Effective
pre-surgical
rehabilitation process
diagnosis.
team
and
intervention
Furthermore,
should be utilized
questions
will
aid
arise.
the
laryngectomee in his progress toward total rehabilitation.
8
Physiological Realities
Throughout
the
literature
on the rehabilitation of
the laryngectomee, more emphasis has been
placed
on
the
physiological factors affecting rehabilitation than on any
other
issue.
confronted
Following
surgery,
the
laryngectomee
with loss of speech, permanent tracheal stoma,
undesirable mucus, the loss of ability to taste or
the
absence
of
smell,
audible sound in the acts of laughing or
weeping, the taboo on swimming and the need for change
bathing
is
techniques
(Minear
in
& Lucente, 1979). Activities
such as sneezing, smoking, lifting heavy objects or taking
a
shower
are
concern,
no
longer
though,
is
taken for granted. The primary
the
establishment
of
alaryngeal·
speech.
Phelps (1973) stated that the capacity for articulate
speech
from
is
the
animals~
himself
most important feature distinguishing man
When a man can
less
a
man
and
no
this
longer
fact
talk,
in
he
itself
feels
causes
significant emotional disturbances.
The
ability to produce "normal" speech as we know it
is lost, however, with the aid of a
teacher,
alaryngeal
consent of
the
esophageal
speech
speech
doctor,
as
a
soon
can
speech
be
patient
as
two
therapist
learned.
may
begin
With
or
the
learning
to four weeks after
surgery, barring any complications. But until the doctor's
consent
is
given,
the
patient must rely on writing and
signals as his only means of communication.
9
There
is
considerable controversy over which method
of communication is preferable--esophageal speech
of
the
artificial
larynx.
According
to
esophageal speech is the preferred method
more
satisfactory
device]
insofar
phonation
are
than
as
articulation,
concerned.
quality
because
it
is
While
it
to
it.
Al
lacks
it
some
and
of the
still
retains
a
Rosenstein
(1981 ),
a
book
on
esophageal
In the book he outlines several benefits of using
this method:
(2)
Dietz (1969),
intelligibility,
laryngectomee himself, has written a
speech.
use
a prosthetic appliance (assisted
prosodic features of normal speech,
humanlike
or
(1) the improved ability to release emotions,
increased self-satisfaction for his determination and
self-dicipline, and (3) that
he
singled
as differing from the group.
out
or
identified
is
less
likely
to
On the other hand, there are advantages to using
artificial ·larynx.
In
a
recent
address
to
the
be
the
31st
National Conference of Laryngectomees (1982), Luther Puldy
stated
his
belief
that
the
artificial
larynx usually
results in better articulation. Another point he made
that
can
was
esophageal speakers often run out of air before they
finish
what
they're
saying,
thus
requiring
the
listener to fill in the missing information.
Whether or not one method is better than
the
other,
what is important is that the laryngectomee have some form
of communication, especially
recovery.
in
those
early
months
of
It has been suggested that an artificial larynx
10
be used while the
speech.
about
In
a
the
laryngectomee
artificial
esophageal
larynx
prior
to
surgery;
51% had some instruction in it's use. In
any event, 81% of those
and
learning
study of sixty patients, 59% had been told
postoperatively,
larynx
is
who
stated
that
an
artificial
its use had not been mentioned to them during
this time, felt it should have been
mentioned
(Minear
&
Lucente, 1979).
The successful aquisition of speech is influenced
a
number
of
factors.
These
include
the
acceptance or nonacceptance of the alaryngeal
encouragement
and
by
patient's
voice,
the
acceptance of the laryngectomee by his
family, and the laryngectomized
person's
perceptions
of
how others react towards his new voice (Klinger, 1971 ). It
is also important
laryngectomized
to
note
patients
that
15
to
50
percent
of
will fail to develop alaryngeal
speech {Johnson, Casper, & Lesswing, 1979).
Vocational Concerns
Although there are Federal and State laws
the
rights
of the cancer patient, returning to work does
present difficulties for the laryngectomee.
70%
of
all
laryngectomees
returning to work
however,
protecting
50%
(King,
will
are
phy~cally
Marshall,
never
Approximately
return
capable
& Gunderson,
to
(Johnson, Casper, & Lesswing, 1979). In
full
some
of
1971)
employment
cases,
the
laryngectomee will have to change jobs because his old job
11
now
presents
potential
laryngectomee
hazards
to
his
The
health.
must avoid a work environment with airborne
irritants, loud background noise where
the
inability
to
shout might be dangerous to himself or others, where heavy
lifting is required
or
where
there
are
water
hazards
(King, Marshall, & Gunderson, 1971 ).
Once the laryngectomee has returned to work,
experience
discomfort
educating
his
around
associates
laryngectomee
his
about
fellow
his
he
may
employees. By
condition,
the
will replace the fears and questions of his
colleagues with an understanding of his situation.
Gilmore's
vocational
normal
had
study
(1974)
acceptability
speaker.
of
compared
the
the
social
laryngectomee
esophageal
"attention-attracting"
speech
and
characteristics
had
outside
normal characteristics attributed to esophageal
esophageal
taped
business
for
a
of
of
Each
the
the
speakers.
public
contact.
laryngectomees
laryngectomees and
and
their
once
filmed
of
on
handle,
Presentations
with
In
to
and
job
the
were
given
the
judges
information
both
the
four
acceptability,
could
surgery.
were
judged
twice--once without any information given
about
of
members
was
social
speaker
they
before
speaker
acceptability:
prestige, the jobs
degree
presentation
community.
criteria
no
speaker was paired with a normal speaker
and placed in a business setting where
and
the
The laryngectomees chosen to participate
intelligible
Each
to
and
cases,
about
the
12
laryngectomees
the
normal
received
speakers
information
significantly poorer scores than
in
accompanied
each
the
however,
category,
when
presentation, the scores in
three categories were higher than when no information
provided.
The
greatest
was
increase was shown in the social
acceptability category; judges' ratings rose from 8.50
to
13.00 for laryngectomees and only rose 2.67 points for the
normal speakers. The lowest scores were
in
the
area
of
public contact. This is perhaps the most significant score
because it is indicative of one's desirability in business
interaction.
Even
laryngectomee's
offered
their
in
into
public
information
the
acceptance
contact
practical
about
positions
application,
the
of
the
decreased.
the
positions
to laryngectomees would isolate or at least limit
interaction
esophageal
not
the
disability,
laryngectomee
Translated
with
with
the
public.
Therefore,
while
speech is preferred in many instances, it does
insure
that
vocational
rehabilitation
will
be
successful.
Psychosocial Issues
The laryngectomee's emotional concerns arise from the
physiological and vocational issues
confronting
him.
He
wonders if he will be accepted by his family, friends, and
fellow workers. He is afraid
fear,
guilt,
pity,
and
of
the
disgust,
feelings,
he
such
as
will evoke in the
people he encounters (Nahum & Golden, 1963).
Other
fears
13
of
the
laryngectomee
have to do with disfigurement, not
being understood, losing friends, making new friends,
"The
embarrassment.
psychological
significance
of
and
the
[loss] has to do in large measure with such matters as the
threat of social isolation, the struggle for independence,
acceptance of personal limitation,
and
so
on"
(Wright,
1960).
The
psychic
surgery
is
trauma
equally
as
resulting
great
as
from
the
laryngectomy
physical
trauma
(Phelps, 1973; Wright, 1960). Feelings of frustration
depression
contribute
laryngectomee,
process.
It
a
to
vital
the
lack of motivation of the
factor
in
the
rehabilitation
is important for the laryngectomee to direct
his thoughts to the future rather than recount
This
and
means
the
past.
that the patient must accept the challenge of
living and believe in his own
expectations
for
self-worth.
He
must
have
himself and be encouraged to meet those
expectations.
A major problem arises for the laryngectomee when his
aspirations and expectations are to become "normal" again.
Normal,
as
the laryngectomee once knew it, is beyond his
reach. He must now revise and reconcile his standards
values
to
easily
achieved.
according
have become
therefore
a
and
new norm, one within his grasp. This is not
to
The
the
an
not
patient
has
lived
and
worked
standards of the normal majority; they
integral
immediately
part
of
amenable
his
personality
and
to change. Repeated
14
efforts
"normalization"
at
feeling
of
part
of
the
inferiority.
It
is
important
that
the
keep redefining his goals, expectations, and
laryngecto~ee
aspirations throughout the
each
the
will only produce frustration, failure, and
laryngectomee
a
on
success,
he
rehabilitation
process.
With
can set a higher goal until he reaches
his new standard of normalization (Wright, 1960).
Social stigma is another issue which is of concern to
the laryngectomee. To some individuals, the
has
laryngectomee
lost his social identity; he is discounted because he
no longer assumes the attributes or character that
others
have
change
attributed
(Goffman,
to
1963).
disfiguration
of
him
In
due
many
to
his
cases,
the
by
from
to
perceived
others. His visual presentation in a group may
appear within normal boundaries and others
him
resulting
laryngectomy surgery can be camouflaged
or minimized to protect the laryngectomee
change
physical
be
part
of
the
His
voice
perceive
group. However, as soon as the
laryngectomee speaks, the group's perception
dramatically.
will
is
likely
will
change
to be identified as
deviant thus adversely coloring his identity in the social
setting.
He is then recategorized to fit into the others'
perception of things.
Goffman
others"
who
"essentially
(1963) indicates that there are "sympathetic
feel
that
normal"
and
the
stigmatized
individual
is
who share his viewpoints. They
may be divided into two groups. First are those who
share
15
the
stigma.
Clubs
or
For
New
the laryngectomee, it is the Lost Chord
Voice
laryngectomees
Clubs
where
he
may
other
find
with the same problems as himself. Here he
finds acceptance and a standard of normalcy with which
can
he
identify. The second group of "sympathetic others" is
found in the normal population, those people who have been
privy
made
to
the
secret
life
of
the
stigmatized
individual This may be the spouse, family, close
or
friends,
helping professional close to the laryngectomee. While
they
are
affected
not
in
the
same
way,
they
disfiguration
has
a
strong
with
a
visible
are
sympathetic to his situation.
~
Visibilty
implication
of
for
the
rehabilitation.
Those
disability are immediately identifiable and thus perceived
and
categorized
enable
However,
an
as
abnormal.
individual
visually
and
to
These
anticipate
auditorially,
appears incongruous thereby making any
invalid.
This
incongruity
can
first
impressions
certain
the
outcomes.
laryngectomee
first
impressions
disturb the listener and
take away from the laryngectomee's presentation. Each time
the
laryngectomee
speaks,
he redirects attention to his
defect whereas a visual defect loses importance over
time
(Goffman, 1963).
A
study
by
characteristics
more satisfactory
are:
Nahum
which
and
were
Golden
(1963)
identified
predictive of a smoother and
rehabilitation.
These
characteristics
16
1. Satisfactory medical or surgical
experiences in the past.
2. Prior history of good and pleasant
relations with physicians.
3. The ability to verbalize fears and
problems, no inclination to worry
incessantly, brood unnecessarily,
or try to keep problems inside
oneself.
4. Good relationships with other people.
5. The ability to adjust adequately to
new and stressful experiences.
6. Security in life situation, including
family and job.
7. Strength and adaptability of the
personality structure.
Families
usually
have
some
adjustments to make as
well. Spouses that were interviewed stated that they
not
quite
prepared
surgery. Many
problems
in
to
reported
deal
with their loved one after
changes
communicating,
in
and
stemming from speech, the stoma,
Casper,
& Lesswing,
were
1979).
attitude
social
and
and
mood,
embarrassment
coughing
(Johnson,
These changes may be due in
part to the spouse's fears and frustrations regarding
the
physical change in the patient.
It is important to realize that the surgery does
change
the
personality
laryngectomee but
problems.
part
of
For
his
may
example,
processes
characteristics
intensify
if
for
any
previous
of
not
the
behavior
the patient used denial as a.
dealing
with
losses
and
17
disappointments,
he
will
continue
to
deny
what
has
happened.
The
specific
psychosocial
issues
of self-concept,
body image, and the grief process involved with loss
be
covered
in
will
greater detail in the following sections.
Self-Concept and Body Image
Much
has
been
written
about
the
relationship of
self-concept to self-actualization (Rogers, 1961;
1968).
The
literature examining self-concept as a factor
in rehabilitation is relatively new and it
self-concept
Maslow,
may
suggests
that
be a significant variable in predicting
successful rehabilitation. For any rehabilitation
program
to be effective, the individual must be willing to utilize
his own resources
adjustment
and
process,
to
participate
actively
in
the
but his participation is affected by
how he perceives his surroundings and his situation. Thus,
self-concept
(Fitts
&
and
rehabilitation
interact
reciprocally
Richard, 1971).
Basing
conclusions on the work of Snygg & Combs
his
(1959), Fitts labelled three primary subselves of the self
that
are:
contribute
(1) the
Identity
to the make-up of the self-concept. They
self
Self;
(2)
as
object,
the
Behavioral Self; and (3)
judge,
designated
the
self
the
which
is
as
doer,
self
a
as
an
known
as
the
called
the
observer
and
Judging Self. The three subselves
18
form the internal dimensions of self-concept and
are
the·
basis of the Row scores used in the Tennessee Self Concept
Scale administered for this report.
Contributing
to
the
complexity
of an individual's
self-concept is what Sarbin (1952) has termed the external
dimensions of self-concept. These are a different group of
subselves based on an external frame of
reference
rather
than the internal frame of reference proposed by Snygg and
Combs.
Fitts
has
reorganized
Sarbin's
subselves
as
follows: Physical self, Moral-Ethical Self, Personal Self,
Family
Self,
self-concept
and
is
the
between these external
important
to
remember
function of the
total
becomes
subself
the
Social
Self.
product
of the dynamic interaction
and
internal
that
sum
The
one's
of
sole
individual's
self-concept
subselves~
it's
basis
of
an
rehabilitation
to
internal
and
manipulate
the
is the
no
individual's
self-concept
(Fitts
and external
& Adams,
of
body
Gorman (1969) describes body image as ''the concept
one's
interaction
own
of
body,
which
has
been
formed
by
sensory
the
the perceptual pool with the experiential
pool. The perceptual pool consists of all our present
past
of
1971 ).
Closely related to self-concept is the issue of
image.
one
worker
factors that influence the development and maintenance
the
is
individual's
self-concept. It is the job of the
identify
It
dimensions.
experiences,
and
the
experiential
and
pool
consists of all our experiences, affects and memories. The
19
body
image
is
continually
thus
being
a
plastic, dynamic entity which is
modified
by
new
precepts
and
new
experiences." This aspect of self-concept is of particular
importance to the laryngectomee. The surgery performed
on
him is a major insult to his body image. The psychological
effect of head and neck disfigurement (total
and
radical
neck
dissection)
is
laryngectomy
greater
than
the
disfigurement of other parts of the body (Nahum & Golden,
1963).
Phelps
(1973) found that disfiguration causes the
patient to withdraw from friends
also
begin
to
after
surgery.
He
view his body as abnormal. His feeling of
abnormality will manifest itself in one of three ways:
shame
and/or
may
guilt,
(1)
(2) anger and/or bitterness, or (3)
dignity and pride. All too often, the disfigured person is
taught
minimize
to
hide
it.
his
This
embarrassing
abnormality
is
others
done
and
to
or, at the very least,
avoid
signifies
offending
that
the
associates his disfigurement with guilt or shame.
see
his
1963).
his
With
wrong
the
laryngectomee
deed
support
will
begin
(Babin,
of
usually
He
may
can
not
1975; Nahum & Golden,
family
and
friends,
the
to create a new body image. As
his rehabilitation continues, he may view his
as
patient
abnormality or disigurement as a punishment from
God for some wrong-doing even though he
identify
or
abnormality
a· part of his uniqueness; it can even become a source
of pride. No matter how he reacts to
appearance,
he
the
change
in
his
will experience an increased awareness in
20
his body and body functions.
As
mentioned
above,
the
attainment
of speech and
method used is a controversial issue, one that is grounded
in
the
concept of body image. Depending on the patient's
adjustment and his ability to use an assisted device,
device
may
or may not become a part of the person's body
image. The assisted device speaker must regard the
simply
as
an
extension
of
himself.
self-concept enhanced and progress
noticed.
On
the
Only
toward
device
then
is
rehabilitation
other hand, the esophageal speaker does
not have to deal with an extraneous
speak
the
object
in
order
to
and this becomes one less factor to confront in the
patient's rehabilitation.
PRE-SURGICAL AND POST-SURGICAL COUNSELING
Though
process
not,
it
begin
is
important
at
the
does
thereafter.
not
start
until
Pre-surgical
and
possibly
and/or
laryngectome~
patient needs and wants more.
patients
about
explanation
or
has
of
a visit by a social worker, speech
pathologist,
In recent
surgery
counseling
generally been limited to the physician's
surgery
rehabilitation
the time of diagnosis, more often than
rehabilitation
immediately
that
a
years,
their
recovered
studies
have
pre-surgical
laryngectomee.
asked
and
experiences and also about the treatment they
The
laryngectomy
post-surgical
would
have
21
liked
receive. In a study by Keith, Linebaugh, & Cox,
to
(1978) 78 patients were asked to fill out a
questionnaire
designed to determine the kinds and quality of information
necessary
"ideal"
·for
Seventy-nine
percent
pre-surgical
received
all
counseling.
the information they
wanted about their actual pre-surgical experiences; of the
remainder, about half were not fully aware of the physical
changes
resulting
explanation.
from
Thirteen
surgery
percent
and
wanted
further
of this latter group were
not aware that they would be unable to speak after surgery
and 19% were not told about the different ways of learning
to speak again. While 85% of the respondents replied
they
had
patients
ample
felt
intelligent
that
opportunity to ask questions, 52% of the
they
questions
lacked
the
background
to
ask
of the doctor. Fifty-seven percent
were too emotionally upset to think of questions. Johnson,
Casper,
& Lesswing,
(1979)
achieved
similar
The questionnaire also dealt with what
the
results.
patients
would have liked in the way of pre-surgical counseling. In
order of importance, the following information was thought
to be of preoperative value:
1. What to expect in the days following surgery
2. Physical changes resulting from laryngectomy
3. Methods of alaryngeal speech
4. Causes, nature, and treatment of laryngeal
cancer
22
5. Sources of community help for laryngectomees
6. How the speech pathologist and the
laryngectomee work together
7. Changes in life style experienced by
laryngectomees
8. The surgical procedure employed
9. Emotional adjustment of the laryngectomee
10. Emotional adjustment of the patient's family
When
asked
about
who should do the counseling, 82% said
surgeon/physician; 54%
wanted
replied
speech
pathologist;
50%
a laryngectomee visitor, 15% requested a chaplain,
and six
percent
suggested
percent
Seventy-eight
a
psychiatrist/psychologist.
responded
beneficial to see a demonstration
preferably
demonstrated
should
be
of
it
would
alaryngeal
be
speech,
by a laryngectomee rather than a
speech pathologist. Ninety-three
spouse
that
involved
percent
in
the
felt
that
counseling
the
before
surgery.
Another
study
entailed
interviewing
preoperatively and postoperatively. They
about
the
doctor's
nursing care,
pathologist,
and
explanation
visits
by
a
and
of
the
by
the
questioned
worker,
visits,.
speech
or laryngectomee. Seventy-seven percent were
patients
While only 30% of the
care
patients
follow-up
social
satisfied with the doctor's preoperative
82%
were
60
explanation
and
were satisfied with his follow up.
patients
deemed
the
preoperative
nursing staff as adequate, postoperatively,
73
the number rose to 80%. Only 19% were
seen
by
a
social
worker preoperatively while 55% expressed a desire to have
been seen. Just over half of the patients saw
the
pathologist
visit to be
before
surgery;
72%
felt
the
speech
worthwhile. Of those not seen, 77% felt that such a
visit
was important and should have been made. Explanations by a
speech pathologist postoperatively were adequate according
to
91%
of
the
patients
questioned. Finally, recovered
laryngectomees visited 55% of the patients
with
positive
results; those not visited felt they would
have welcomed one. Of the 56%
seen
judged
and
the
pre-surgically
visit
valuable,
receive a visit,
83%
Lucente,
Several
1979).
have some choice as
would
to
of
have
a
those
liked
patients
when
postoperatively,
78%
who did not
one
(Minear
&
expressed a desire to
recovered
laryngectomee
would come to visit. The use of pre-surgical laryngectomee
.visitation has
can
b~en
questioned because, in some cases,
it
lead to the patient's refusal of surgery or may serve
to confuse and depress him. It
patients
be
screened
has
been
suggested
that
to assess their reaction to such a
visit and that the visit may be more effective
if
it
is
done after the operation. A pre-surgical visit by a speech
pathologist may reassure
helped
to
the
patient
that
he
will
develop speech as soon as he's ready (Klinger,
1971 ). Additionally, 92% found laryngectomee clubs
informative
be
and
helpful.
to
be
As a result of the study, some
important suggestions came from the
laryngectomees;
they
24
felt that instructions should be
and
that
repeated
several
times
a written list of instructions should accompany
the patient home from the
hospital
to
help
him
better
remember what to do (Minear & Lucente, 1979).
LOSS AND LARYNGECTOMY
Central
to
the
are the issues of
itself.
The
rehabilitation of the laryngectomee
impending
and
the
actual
loss
laryngectomee has lost a great deal: speech,
acceptability, and in some
losses
loss
cases
his
livelihood.
These
must be overcome if the laryngectomee is to return
to some semblance of normal functoning. Kubler-Ross's five
(denial,
stages
bargaining,
anger,
depression,
acceptance), which some people regard as relating only
death
and
dying,
dealing with
the
are
and
to
also applicable to the individual
losses
attributed
to
laryngectomtomy
surgery.
The
laryngectomee's
defense
mechanism
most
common
and
successful
is denial (Nahum & Golden, 1963). When
the patient is told the diagnosis, his initial reaction is
one
of
disbelief
patient does not
happen
to
him
followed immediately by rejection. The
believe
in
anything
like
or
may
search
for
bad
can
additional
an attempt to find a ''better explanation for
his troubles." While denial is felt by virtually
receiving
this
and feels there has been a mix-up. He may
ask for a re-examination
opinions
that
news,
it
is
gradually
everyone
replaced by some
25
degree of acceptance.
As
he begins to look realistically at his situation,
he becomes angry. "Why me?" and "What did I do to
this?"
are
common
questions
he
may
ask
diagnosis has turned the patient's life
deserve
himself. The
around.
He
will
have to make considerable changes and adjustments, changes
for which he will feel unprepared
this
and
resentful.
Often,
phase is quite difficult for the family because they
are closest to the patient. The family and friends as well
as the doctor become the target of the patient's displaced
anger. The family
changed--he
is
may
more
perceive
the
patient
as
having
demanding, distrustful, and nothing
seems to satisfy him.
When the anger has somewhat mollified, the bargaining
phase begins. The patient proposes a
higher
power.
The
higher
tradeoff
with
some
power may be God or even some
part of the patient's psyche. Many times the bargaining is
not
noticeable;
it
becomes
a
secret
patient and this power for some kind
the
deal between the.
of
postponement
inevitable. Before surgery, the bargain might be that
the patient will never touch cigarettes or
if
of
there
is
some
alcohol
again
other way of dealing with the cancer.
After surgery, it may concern
speaking
again
or
relief
from pain, whatever the patient sees as a pressing matter.
In the depression stage, the laryngectomee
confronted
is
truly
with his loss. It is during this time that the
other members of the rehabilitation team come
into
play.
26
The
psychologist
can
work
on
self-esteem,
the social
worker on vocational readjustment, the clergy on relieving
guilt,
the
family
by offering love and acceptance, etc.
All this will not immediately end his
will
make
it
easier
depression
share
those
the
will
laryngectomee
will
be
by
able
to
those
not
be
For the laryngectomee, acceptance is viewed as a
second chance at life. It is the
voice,
around
move onward.
Acceptance is the final stage; it may or may
reached.
begin
expectations. This stage is the mourning
period, but with support and acceptance
him,
it
to bear. If the patient feels that
others have expectations for his recovery, he
to
but
physical
acceptance
of
his
new
changes, and limitations that make total
rehabilitation possible, thus increasing his
self-concept
and self-worth.
These
grieving
unclear
stages
are
a
process.
The
divisions
and
the
rehabilitation
guide
stages
process.
to
may
In
understanding
between the stages are
overlap
the
end,
laryngectomee will grieve in his own way and
time,
but
the
during
the
though,
the
in
own
his
with support, his grieving process may be made
less painful.
CANCER AND THE LARYNGECTOMEE
Compounding the loss of one's voice and
psychological
traumas
must deal with a
the
related
is the fact that the laryngectomee
life-threatening
illness:
cancer.
For
27
"cancer"
means
terminal illness and a protracted,
LUl death, with no hope of
it's
treatment.
prevents
a
Simply
patient
escaping
hearing
from
the
disease
or
the word "cancer" often
assimilating
the
complete
indicated treatments, and prognosis (Blumberg,
diagnosis,
Flaherty, & Lewis, 1980). In a study
where
a
number
of
laryngectomees were interviewed, many expressed that their
major
concern
residual
or
after
recurrent
surgery
cancer
was
the
(Nahum
possibility
& Golden,
of
1963;
Johnson, Casper, & Lesswing, 1979).
In
a book recounting his own serious illness, Norman
Cousins talks about the psychology of the
The
fears
and
seriously
ill.
feelings outlined in Cousins' book (1979)
are experienced by cancer patients as well.
"There was first of all the feeling of
helplessness--a
serious
disease
in
itself. There was the subconscious fear
of never being able to function normally
again ..• There was the reluctance to be
thought a complainer. There was
the
desire not to add to the already great
burden of apprehension felt by one's
family;
this added to the isolation.
There was the conflict between the terror
of loneliness and the desire to be left
alone. There was the lack of self-esteem,
the subconscious feeling perhaps that our
illness was a manifestation
of
our
inadequacy.
There was the fear that
decisions were being made behind our
backs, that not everything was made known
that we wanted to know,
yet dreaded
knowing. There was the morbid fear of
being metabolized by a data base, never
to regain our faces again. There was
28
resentment of strangers who carne at us
with needles and vials ... There was the
distress of being wheeled through white
corridors to laboratories for all sorts
of strange
encounters
with
compact
machines and blinking lights and whirling
discs. And there was the utter void
created by the longing for warmth of
human contact.
A warm smile and
an
outstretched . hand were valued even above
the offerings of modern science, but the
latter were far more accessible than the
former."
It
issues
has
of
treatment
been
great
for
observed
concern
cancer.
that
for
They
there are four general
any
patient
undergoing
are alienation, mutilation,
mortality, and vulnerability or loss of control (Blumberg,
Flaherty, & Lewis, 1980).
Feelings of alienation and isolation often stern
the
from
reactions of those around the patient. The withdrawal
of family and friends may arise from their
faulty
belief
systems. It is believed by some that pulling away from the
cancer patient will relieve the pain of the loss when
patient
actually
Another
dies.
myth
affecting
relationships of cancer patients is the fear
that
the
the
cancer
is contagious. There are many stories of spouses who avoid
any kind of physical contact with the cancer
of
employees
who
shun
another
worker
patient
because
and
he has
cancer. Reactions of family and friends also include anger
and
guilt
which
lead
to
further
confusion of the cancer patient. The
the
frustration and
cancer
patient
may
29
thus
be
isolated
from others as he tries to express his
feelings and concerns to those who can not begin
to
deal
with their own reactions and feelings about the situation.
Mutilation and disfigurement are very common concerns
for the cancer patient. The body part diseased with cancer
may
hold
patient.
a
significant
For
the
emotional
laryngectomee,
communication
is
lost
until
communication
is
developed.
investment
his
an
primary
alternate
Fear
to one's
of
the
alienation
cancer
pervading
though
reality
feeling
fear
death
of
is
philosophizes,
surgical
rejection.
no
longer an
but
rather
an
dread"
of
(Shepardson,
1 972).
Even
cancer of the larynx has a high survival rate, the
real
to
the
patient.
a diagnosis of cancer, some patients begin the dying
process
finishing
despite
old
a
good
prognosis.
They
contact
with
cancer
if
this
by
they
comes
into
begins to confront his own fears of
mortality. This may affect the health
well
do
business, quietly getting their affairs in.
order, and saying their good-byes. Anyone who
as
of
which rides his back and creates a
possibility of death becomes very
With
of
of disfigurement from
and
patient,
abstraction over which he
uncomfortable
the
in many cases. Mutilation is closely related
sense
"For
mode
form
surgery is the primary reason for the refusal of
intervention
for
have
care
professionals
not come to terms with their own
fears of mortality.
Loss
of control is particularly threatening to those
~
.
30
individuals who have a need to be strong, independent, and
enjoy
the
role
of
vulnerability that
change
a
once
being
patient
well-being,
definite
caretaker
accompanies
independent
person with feelings of
The
a
a
to
cancer
individual
helplessness
others. The
diagnosis
can
into a dependent
and
worthlessness.
may feel he has no control over his body and
and
unlike
other
diseases
which
have
a
course of treatment, the treatment for cancer is
uncertain
in
increasing
it's
extent
and
patient's
the
duration,
sense
of
thus
further
vulnerability.
vulnerable state.
In
summary, rehabilitation is an ongoing process for
the laryngectomee. Many individuals and/or groups will
what
they
can
to
help
laryngectomized person.
influence
and
shape
in
the
Several
the
readjustment
factors
rehabilitation
will
of
serve
readjustment
to
the
work
environment
perhaps to retirement--as his situation dictates,
with
others
handicapped
through
who
and
may
view
thus
treat
him
him
the
to
process. Among
those factors are the patient's changes in body image
physiology,
do
and
or
dealing
as being stigmatized or
accordingly;
working
the grief process regarding his loss after having
dealt with a life-threatening illness, and in some
cases,
wondering if it will ever reoccur.
The
effect
laryngectomized
of
these
individual
will
experiences
directly
on
the
influence and
31
shape
his
self-concept,
rehabilitation
tenet
of
(such
as
study
factor
in
the
is
that
the
self-concept
of
a
is significantly reduced by his experiences
those
Furthermore,
critical
process and his outlook on life. The basic
this
laryngectomee
a
mentioned
above)
following
diagnosis.
an additional decline in self-concept may be
found in those laryngectomees utilizing an assisted device
for speech.
Examination of the laryngectomee's
self-concept
may
have implications for designing his rehabilitation program
both before and after surgery, and may better prepare
laryngectomee
the
and his family for any transitions that may
become necessary as a result of the laryngectomy.
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
SUBJECTS
Thirty-six subjects participated in
the
study.
The
control group consisted of 13 men and three women, ranging
from 25 to 79 years of
matched
as
All
age.
control
and
variation),
experimental
(12
non-esophageal
speakers).
participants
was
age,
group
laryngectomees
completed
to
upper
middle
race (predominantly white, although allowing
for some ettmic
The
were
closely as possible to the experimental group
on the basis of sex, social status (low
class),
subjects
and
was
esophageal
20,
size
of
composed
speakers
Originally,
however,
sample.
three
17
and
the
of
of
five
number
the
of
subjects
only the questionnaire and did not complete the
Tennessee Self
Concept
Scale
(TSCS).
Their
incomplete
scores were therefore not included. The experimental group
ranged in age from 49 to 81 years and
anywhere
from
two
the
ten
from
surgery
men
and
two
women
esophageal speakers and four men and one woman
among the non-esophageal speakers.
were
their
months to 12 years ago. There were 14
men and three women; there were
among
had
middle
class
incomes
predominantly white.
32
All
and
of
the
the
subjects
group
was
33
TESTING INSTRUMENTS
Each experimental and control subject
was
asked
to
complete
the
Tennessee Self Concept Scale Machine Scored
Version.
The
TSCS
consists
of
100
self-descriptive,
forced-choice statements examining 29 variables related to
(A
self-concept.
description
of
list
of
all
the
Personality
Inventory
of
the
(MMPI)
statements
various
scales
other
self-concept
self-descriptions
of
patients
psychologists
and
form
came
the
from
written
and
non-patients.
and
edited
Minnesota
to
Self-Criticism Scale. The other 90
clinical
a
each one can be found in Appendix B). Ten
statements were taken from the L-scale
Multiphasic
and
variables
Seven
classified
the
statements until unanimous agreement on the final 90 items
was
reached.
Respondents judged each statement on a five
point scale ranging from Completely
True.
False
to
Completely
Participants took anywhere from 10 to 45 minutes to
complete the test. In
orally
some
cases,
the
test
was
due to the poor eyesight of the participant. Tests
were sent away to the publishers to be scored by
Test-retest
reliability
.92 for the total
scores
given
ranging
positive
from
over
score
.80 to .91
machine.
a two week period was
with
Row
and
Column
(Fitts, 1965; Robinson &
Shaver, 1973). No data on the internal consistency of
the
TSCS is reported.
Correlations
determine
validity
with
show
other
an
personality
measures
to
inverse correlation of -.61
34
-.70
with the Butler- Haigh Q-sort and
Manifest
Anxiety
high inverse correlation between the
and
the
TSCS
shows
the
the
Taylor
& Shaver, 1973). This
(Robinson
Scale
with
two
anxiety
scales
strong inverse relationship of
anxiety to self-concept. A positive correlation of .68 was
reported
with
the
Izard's
Self-Rating
Positive Affect
Scale (Fitts, 1965).
In
addition
was given
a
to
supplemental
data
additional
the TSCS, each experimental subject
experiences as
a
about
questionnaire
subject
the
laryngectomee.
The
which
and
provided
his
social
questionnaire
was
employed to look for changes in his social contacts before
and after surgery, as well as
any
problems
of the questionnaire can be
he
faced.
A
copy
other
experiences
or
found in Appendix B.
PROCEDURE
Two months before the actual
the
testing
up
executed,
author approached the President and Vice President of
the Lost Chord Club to inquire about
the
was
the
possibility
of
club's participation in this study. A meeting was set
whereby
approval.
the
test
materials
be
viewed
for
With the approval of the materials, testing was
set for the January meeting. Club
through
could
members
were
informed
their newsletter that their support was requested
for a study on the assigned day in January. Members at the
December
meeting
were
introduced to the author with the
35
hope of
building
some
rapport
and
trust
between
was
conducted
the
subjects and the researcher.
Testing of the experimental group
the
author
at
by
the regular meeting of a local chapter of
the Lost Chord Club in
Los
Angeles.
Upon
arrival,
the
laryngectomees were asked if they would participate in the
study. They were then given the test
that
the
the
materials,
informed
testing would be anonymous, and asked to answer
questions
participate
honestly.
and
three
One
club
other
member
members
refused
to
completed
the
questionnaire and started the TSCS but could not finish it
due
to eyestrain and/or fatigue. All subjects were tested
together in one sitting.
Unfortunately,
a
single group matching the criteria
of the experimental group could not be found to
the
control
group.
Subjects
found in multi-purpose senior
serve
as
for the control group were
centers,
various
business
settings, and through friends and colleagues. Each subject
was tested individually by the author, after
qualifications
of
he
met
the
the study. An effort was made to match
control subjects on the basis of social status, race, sex,
and age.
Due to
limited
the
limited
population)
and
sample
(a
reflection
of
the
the uniqueness of the subjects,
random sampling techniques could not be applied, thus
the
sample became purposive. The experimental group was chosen
on the basis of its
availability,
close
proximity,
and
36
willingness
to
participate
in
the
study.
locating eligible control subjects made the
participants
to
chose
Problems in
selection
of
for the study difficult; it became necessary
subjects
willingness
to
based
on
participate.
their
Many
availability
subjects
and
who
were
approached to represent the control group declined without
stating
a
reason, particularly those over the age of 55.
Tests from ·the control group were collected over a
period
of two weeks.
When the tests were corrected
and
returned
by
the
publisher, t-tests were employed to determine the level of
significance represented by the
sample means.
differences
between
the
CHAPTER IV
RESULTS
TENNESSEE SELF CONCEPT SCALE
The TSCS was administered in an
certain
upon
attempt
measure
variables of self-concept that may have an effect
the
variables
rehabilitation
are:
~dentity
of
the
laryngectomee.
(Column
C),
Family
These
(Row 1 ), Self- Satisfaction (Row
2), Behavior (Row 3), Physical Self (Column
Self
to
Self
(Column
A),
Personal
D), Social Self
(Column E), Total Positive Scores (Combined Row and Column
Scores),
Self-Criticism, the Personality Integration (PI)
Score from the Empirical Scales,
Signs
(NDS).
The
mean
and
and
alaryngeal,
Deviant
standard deviation for each
variable of the TSCS are reported
normal,
Number. of
for
esophageal,
the
and
four
groups:
non-esophageal
speakers, in Tables 1-4, respectively.
Comparison
of
the
normal
speakers
speakers (Figure 2) show very little
the
and alaryngeal
distinction
between
variables mentioned above. The difference between the
groups on any variable was no greater than
three
points.
While statistical tests were hardly necessary to show that
there was little, if any, statistical difference,
were
performed
on
the
Self-Criticism,
Total
t-tests
Positive
Scores, and NDS variables. T-tests were performed on these
37
38
variables because they represented independent measures of
self-concept whereas the other variables of the
not.
In
each
test
case, the t-test failed to reject the null
hypothesis (Critical value of t=2.04; df=31; H0 :
A
comparison
of
the
esophageal
non-esophageal speakers based on the
TSCS
seemed
raw
p>.05).
speakers
scores
of
and
the
to indicate a substantial difference between
the two groups. Most impressive was the difference
points
did
between
the
groups
of
73
on the Total Positive Score,
with the esophageal speakers scoring the higher
sum.
Row
and Column scores for esophageal speakers were higher than
those of the non-esophageal speakers,
the
difference
in
points ranging from five to seventeen. Both PI scores were
low,
the
esophageal
non-esophageal
speaker
speakers,
6.4
scoring
(barely
9.0
inside
limit). Also of interest were the NDS scores
31 . 0
esophageal
for
and
and
the
the lower
of
9.0
non-esophageal
and
speakers,
respectively. The NDS score of the non-esophageal speakers
was
well
outside
of the limits established as normal by
the author of the TSCS.
Statistical
tests,
however,
did
not
confirm
significance found in the raw scores of the TSCS.
conducted
on
the
same
(Self-Criticism, Total
independent
Positive
the
T-tests
variables as before
Scores,
and
NDS)
once
again failed to reject the null hypothesis (Critical value
of t=2.13; df=15; H0 :p>.05).
CONFliC1
T/F
SCORE
1-------T---
POSI"TlVE SCORES
1- -
0
.
ROW
COLUMN
NU 1101Al
- .. -T
B
I c
-- ··-·-
~·lr'>Hii:OJIY
COUNSll QJI JII:CQ .. OINGS 11 .. 0 Tt•1a
A(.."'Lf.N SUo
NA•H"ILI.l TCNH :J?ll~
•o• ••••
J___ _l_OU'·t"_L/''"
S•<um " " " / ' "
T
Chntco! ond Research Forn'
PROFILE SHEET
Tennessee Self Concept Scale
I
"-
~~ ~~~
SCORES
D I E
I
-;r:'i~':'r 2 11DP G·~~:~:r :;r~ PI 1 NOS
1/ARIACIILITY
PERCENTILE
1
D
1
il
!I
1u-..:..J.~-~-----I-1~\
so-
''"--+
I.:: I
"-7"ff=j"
" #- .
. - ---:
I
I
30-....1
•
--f-------+--+-t---1-,,__,.
_ _ .. ____ ..__!5-
••o •
__
_!~-----= -~-=tus
: _ _ _9_9_ - -
•
_:tn_:j__~_l_!~-L;i
---------~----
,
155
--r-:-t-~::.~~:~
-'+--+---+--S
:: ;
--··
50
.o
----30- ----
~
,
:
)0
21>
_:
<~
3~
•
10
_·
:
:
~
;;;_
,.:
·-1-.....,:+----",
,
IU<•
:I
:
~ ~~
II!>
,
::> ':'. ~;· ----- -----
·~- ..... · -~ 1
:i·'""
~IJ
I
" . . , . ":-
70 :
6!>
•
"~
]5~·1
--
35,~
:
2(.1 •
lO
___: __ · __; ___
-~
,, .
..
I
•
2(.1
.:1 ·~-V
70 :~~
l--30
..
25
IIU-~:
9
:
"t
t
~·
:
'
..
~
:
5~
.!.l ••
~
)
j
.
•
:
.. '..
I
•
-~
~
•
·~
e!>--
•
~
10 :
.. o
10
-~
!> •
•
:
~5-:
110
+-
"-
-7G-j
lO,
:>
20!
,.,_:t--se---1
15
:r
5
:
·[/_
90 •
90 :
:
0
•
:
tt
II:
"¥~~~
~
80
•
f>S
:
60,
1>5
.,
•
. l ..
"1-~f.;~:
=~ .,;.;
:• . ~
----'--· --'- - ·
~
••
F
-~
I
~e
I
5
r-----:1
--- -;4- , -~<---~~i-t=l 1---+--+-~
~ -1 ' -r:o-+---4-~-l---'l-~--I---+-+I--+I--+F-2<2ee-jf
.,
~;-; -~~ ~~,
:
.: _ -- :!\-:I /- ~
110
r---ro-=
,
··=1
:r-t·1=tl
-
,
L.
~
~~
---+-o
r---
··-
-
---
. ~::: ::l . : . ·< ....... ". - : f--~~ ::.-~- ---~---:rt~-,· :: :1 · . ,. :; · ·: .: · ... :::~ .... :~~=:~~,~~~~~~~,.. ·
"" !
0 '
'
_,
·
:
=~s:::~~~~
..
.,-;" -- ~:·· ------- r-:--~--:::-T--·-•:
___ : _.,_:
-"· ·-·· -·--· -· _, t-..:;- ,: :i0
-;·:::~--,~ -_i-.,~--'"
~~.....:~
,.
15.
. ·:: ". ,_ "\.:·, ··~"·-~·
'4 , ""]. ~- .,..,PJ
---: --·~
5
55
..
60
!.0
ss
-:~::::-~~"
i ···~v·
-~
30 ,
::: •
:
20
-------,--c--,r-- -
J\10
~
"'
I ."J- 25 --f·"+oe---
.o-j._'C__,..;r~-~f--:~_,,_.:t-,....:~
:~---
1---
::. . . . ,
•~
60
-:1-"1-: '" ::: :_. ::: ": "; ".
80
f-
•
!>0-;
•o•
~~r-:
gQ
------
1>5-t-~~-.!.
·~ ,;.~~
"!--<·~
--;
5!. ~
SCORE.
li!~l-
-+--+---+·-!---'+--'·-~+"" .1
.,.
99 99
--:t:r.-.;.
----:f. •3o-
i-=-
'" +--- -- -- -·-- ·t---t---+--1 NO--+·~'-:
.,. ___ _
- --
f----SG.--t-
1
Ttr
-~~-~---
~
-
rJ.gure L •
Comparison of the Self-Concept Profiles of Normal & Alaryngeal Speakers.
w
-..o
40
Table 1
The Means and Standard Deviations of the
TSCS Variables of Normal Speakers.
n = 16
Variable
sc
T/F
NET c
TOT c
TOTAL
ROW 1
ROW 2
ROW 3
COL A
COL B
COL c
COL D
COL E
V TOT
V COL
V ROW
DS'r D
DST 5
DST 4
DST 3
DST 2
DST 1
DP
GM
PSY
PD
N
PI
NDS
Mean
Standard
Deviation
35.313
1 . 2 00
5.750
31.500
360.625
127.250
115.250
118.125
69.438
76. 1 25
70.438
73.438
71. 1 88
42.875
23.438
19.438
128.688
22.000
25.875
13.1 25
19.188
19.813
64.188
98.813
51 . 938
80.563
86.000
9.750
14.563
5.5102
0.3610
14.0641
8.0333
35.8122
11.0242
1'5.5499
12.2359
11.3606
6.0319
7.7457
9.1867
8.9459
11.4361
6.7820
6.6730
24.1901
10.8382
10.2299
8.5469
8.7424
9.4391
11.9845
10.9983
8.1851
7.3663
12.0941
3.9243
12.6858
41
Table 2
The Means and Standard Deviations of the
TSCS Variables for Alaryngeal Speakers.
n = 17
Variable
sc
T/F
NET c
TOT C
TOTAL
ROW 1
ROW 2
ROW 3
COL A
COL B
COL c
COL D
COL E
V TOT
V COL
V ROW
DST D
DST 5
DST 4
DST 3
DST 2
DST 1
DP
GM
PSY
PO
N
PI
NOS
Mean
Standard
Deviation
35.882
1 . 124
-2.412
34.529
360.412
130.118
114.941
115.353
67.882
76.059
69.176
74.000
73.294
47.118
27.765
19.353
139.706
23.000
25.588
11.059
12.588
27.765
60.000
101.294
48.118
78.647
85. 529
8.235
15.471
5.2545
0.2307
16.4357
8.2774
35.0090
12.7077
14.8554
12.6241
11.1629
5.9211
8.1719
6.3048
10.2577
13.8016
8.6134
6.5473
26.4711
11.8269
10.5715
9.5097
9.3211
10.8658
12.1707
9.3057
6. 96 31
10.6767
12.4756
3.4192
17.9239
..
Clmo(.o/ and l<t:~urth ~orm
PROFILE SHEET
Tennessee Self Concept Scale
"'"""'""~"'
'-OU .. IOl> " " "t< ._.,...,, ...:.:!. 4ND lLIOI•
r~""'"
C.ONH.ICT
T
1-- - -
-~---.---
TIF
SCORE
NE.T ITOIAL
0
_
'
Ro
2
I
""" I,,' r. II
POSITIVE:. SCOR£5
---···T- ----
wr;r;;:-
•o•
.,,_ u:'"'"
"''"
..........
l Tl""
1~1
! ;['''
I'' "
COLUMN
s Tc_T_o_IE-
PERCENTILE
SCORES
r; ·r·c~,-T~~w
~
lOT
lUI
1
I
VARIABILITY
DI~TRI8UTION
EMPIRICAL SCALES
-··---------·-- r--r-----
5
D
3
4
~-~-
DPIGMIPSYI POl
~-+--
1~-+---+-1~
99 99
---- '" 0--\---+--=~
!)0'
:_., _
1--1------f~--~
!>.!>.
NOS
PI
--+-+---~>w-;t-~;j---+.::.:l..~L-+'"-;j--"'-;l--l-7oJ !>V-~
·f 95 ~ :
I ...-F--
.--~-~- --
•
I
·1 " -1=-ae-~ --
,1-.,,.,,_=1----l
•
SCORE
25-l--7~~-
....;.--!-
~--ae--+--!-=-::t-]3·
1-----'--
N
I TTTT 1---
~
l--9e---=+---f-2 so--t----1o-~~
~/l':l
.
99
~-
·----···-
·~---+--~~-
~.:___
60
1----+-~o:-
- - 7 0 - - - - --
"
::j._'::.'-+-.:.J
%
4s---+-;-
,_
.
•.
15
60
50-----~-~~~--r
3$
40
1---1--·
---30---
20
10
I<U:
•--38--
1-----t-.-
f--. -l--:_
!I!).:_
"
-=+--~
----~--rr·
.,_: ""-f-2G-+--: ~ '""
tlo"•:
- ~::.:.:
~!> ~
:J :J~.- :~i:_,, ~ -~_,_· ~
:
~-
!lu
.
.
7;- -- -·:
!>C.._:_.,. ___ _
,,_
"
.
.
•
~r:
,
·~
-·:
:
'"
~
J<.J
l.u
,_
IIU -
)<J
IOO
_Lj -~~·'"
--~;--::!'=~- '-;1-------+--o-+-l--~J=~
..:•
.
-=-~~-----01
:J :, )
"~
L.
<1tr
·~
,.+---1-+:::- •1----'1
-~-+---;-~
~ --·~~~----
_:o
: :
.
-·~-:- ~~-:
5
....
t-'".
'-
"
""'
.
+---it--:-.·1-+---1----
~~-:
00
--t--: :
11
":1
•
'
]
o
7~::-.~0J~~~~ ·.~~}:'"t-·u
t'
--i!O
--!-
--·-
.
.•
00
PE
AL
·----'------L.---'--'-----'--
·-
--;-·
KE~S
SfEAI
I
.! ,_- .~- -----.
-;,;~-- _ .
.
0
+----f---te..j___•
.I
.
1
ER
1
!
rI
I
-
Figure 3.
Comparison of the Self-Concept Profiles of Esophageal & Non-Esophageal Speakers.
-1>
N
43
Table 3
The Means and Standard Deviations of the
TSCS Variables for Esophageal Speakers.
n
=
12
Variable
sc
T/F
NET c
TOT c
TOTAL
ROW 1
ROW 2
ROW 3
COL A
COL B
COL c
COL D
COL E
V TOT
V COL
V ROW
DST D
DST 5
DST 4
DST 3
DST 2
DST 1
DP
GM
PSY
PD
N
PI
NDS
Mean
Standard
Deviation
35.083
1 . 1 23
-4.083
32.417
373.083
134.833
120.000
118.250
70.667
77.500
72.417
76.167
76.333
44.417
27.083
17.333
138.000
21 . 1 67
27.167
11 . 7 50
11.333
28.583
63.000
105.000
46.667
82.417
89.333
9.000
9.000
6.0371
0.1911
12.8944
6.3455
18.2481
7.3711
10.7872
7.7004
7.3402
4.6613
4.7760
4.7832
5.4160
13.9444
9.2487
5.5650
24.7276
10.6671
10.1250
9.2356
7.9924
9.8115
7.7107
5.4272
7.2530
7.3045
6.7330
3.1909
8.0340
44
Table 4
The Means and Standard Deviations of the TSCS
Variables for Non-Esophageal Speakers.
n
=
5
Variable
sc
T/F
NET c
TOT c
TOTAL
ROW 1
ROW 2
ROW 3
COL A
COL B
COL c
COL D
COL E
V TOT
V COL
V ROW
DST D
DST 5
DST 4
DST 3
DST 2
DST 1
DP
GM
PSY
PD
N
PI
NDS
Mean
Standard
Deviation
37.800
1 . 1 28
1 . 600
39.600
330.000
118.800
102.800
108.400
61 . 200
72.600
61 • 400
68.800
66.000
53.600
29.400
24.200
143.800
27.400
21 . 800
9.400
15.600
25.800
52.800
92.400
51 . 600
69.600
76.400
6.400
31.000
1.9235
0.3353
24.3885
10.8536
48.4665
16.4225
17.3695
19.7180
16.4682
7.7006
9.8641
6.9426
15.6844
12.3612
7.5366
6.6858
33.0409
14.5705
11.8195
11.0589
12.4820
14.1669
18.3630
11.1938
5.2726
12.8180
18.7163
3.5777
26.0864
45
QUESTIONNAIRE
A total of 20 questionnaires were completed including
those
of the three participants who did not take the TSCS
but answered only the questionnaire. This broke down
fourteen
esophageal
speakers
and
six
into
non-esophageal
speakers.
While
some of the questions provided background data
on the subjects,
the
other
questions
referred
to
the
changes resulting from the surgery, social support systems
before and after surgery, and personal experiences.
Each respondent was asked about his occupation before
surgery and if
esophageal
it
had
changed
after
surgery.
Of
speakers, six had retained their old jobs, two
had to change their occupations, five could not return
work,
and
one
of
to
laryngectomee was retired beforehand. The
results from the DOn-esophageal speaker
three
the
group
show
that
the subjects could not return to work while one
could. The other two participants
were
already
retired.
Participants were asked about the social support they
received before and after surgery, as well as
their
social
circle.
speakers
both
before
and
surgery were friends and relatives. There was quite
a difference between the two groups, though, when it
to
in
The primary sources of support for
esophageal and non-esophageal
after
changes
secondary
support
systems.
Only
carne
one non-esophageal
speaker indicated that he had utilized the help offered by
46
an agency (the kind of agency was not specified, however).
This is in sharp contrast to the esophageal speakers. Nine
of
the fourteen esophageal speakers went to other sources
for additional support before and/or after surgery. Before
four
surgery,
source
of
esophageal speakers used their church as a
support,
Anonymous,
and
one
another
member
utilized
used his professional colleagues
for support. After surgery, six subjects
Chord
Club
contacted
one
Alcoholics
speech
to
be
or
more
pathologist
speakers
of
Anonymous,
and
one
Alcoholics
The
and
four
assistanc~,
agencies,
non-esophageal
were
Society,
Two
speaker
Lost
them
Cancer
church).
the
participants
(among
American
their
found
esophageal
chose
not to·
answer the question referring to preoperative support.
two
a
In
instances, the respondent interpreted the question as
meaning
financial
Therefore,
their
support
instead
answers
regarding
of
social
support
support.
were
not
tabulated with the others.
When
asked
if
their circle of friends had changed,
the majority of both groups indicated that there had
been
no change (ten esophageal speakers and four non-esophageal
speakers). Two non-esopageal and four esophageal
acknowledged
some
change in their group of friends, with
one of the
esophageal
circle
friends
had
of
solicited
speakers
speakers
pointing
out
that
his
had even expanded. When asked if they
professional
therapy/counseling,
nine
47
esophageal
speakers
and
answered that
they
others,
esophageal
five
did
four
seek
non-esophageal
help
after
speakers
surgery;
the
speakers and two non-esophageal
speakers, said that they did not.
The
last
question--"Please relate any experience(s)
or situation(s) that would help me
what
it
means
to
be
to
better
a laryngectomee"--was answered by
one-half of the subjects. Surprisingly, the
that
answered
understand
ten
subjects
the question were all esophageal speakers;
none of the non-esophageal speakers answered the question.
Here is what some of them had to say:
"Shock of [the] loss of communication at
first;
the motivation and necessity to
speak in my profession was the
best
incentive. The acceptance of me as a
person, not just a laryngectomee, was a
great
help--especially by friends and
patients after I
learned to speak with
esophageal speach."
"A feeling of being
'tolerated'
than being sought after."
rather
"For me it_is very traumatic. My voice and
speech was my only way to make a living.
My friends have stopped asking 'Huh?'.
They are so hurt at my speech and other
disfigurements due to surgery. It scares
them so I am very alone. I go to school to
study writing but can't make friends or
join in discussions. It's quite a handicap
for me."
"[There are problems] getting attention to
speak in a group because of [the] lower
volume of my new voice."
48
"Waking up after surgery and not being
able to call for a nurse. Not being able
to go swimming or rowboating.
Having
people always asking when you will get
over being hoarse. In general, getting
over feeling different!!"
"It is a new way of life."
"The worst thing that ever happened to me
was opening my mouth (after surgery) and
trying to speak. No amount of presurgery
therapy or counseling could quite prepare
me for this blow."
"The inability to communicate immediately
after
surgery
must
be
dealt
with
immediately. Get involved as quickly as
possible.
The
support
from
fellow
laryngectomees cannot be overstated."
CHAPTER V
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
SUMMARY OF THE PROBLEM, METHODS,
FINDINGS, AND PROBLEMS IN RESEARCH
concerns
The
involved
issues
and
in
laryngectomee's rehabilitation process- contribute
development
and
modification
stigmas associated with the
areas
of
of
his
to
the
the
self-concept. The
laryngectomee
transcend
all
his life. If he is not supported and encouraged
to find self-acceptance within himself, he will not strive
to achieve his full potential.
Use of the TSCS as a measure of
self-concept
the
was an attempt to identify the problem areas
therein, so that this knowledge may be
him
laryngectomee's
adjust
utilized
to
help
and improve his self-image. The questionnaire
supplemented
the
laryngectomee
by
psychological
focusing
aspects
of
the
on the social elements in his
life; the combination of social and psychological elements
creates
a
better
balance for examining self-concept and
its contributing factors.
While
the
questionnaire
did
into support systems, experiences
affect
self-concept,
TSCS were
analysis
statistically
provide some insights
and
of
changes
that
may
the- findings from the
insignificant.
The
statistical
tests failed to substantiate the hypotheses of the author,
49
50
that alaryngeal speakers would have a
than
normal
speakers,
would
speakers
the
and
that
self-concept
of
lower
among
self-concept
the
alaryngeal
non-esophageal
speakers
be lower than those of esophageal speakers. T-tests
failed to reject the standard
between
error
of
the
differences
the means, therefore, chance fluctuations may not
be ruled out of the experimental manipulations.
words,
when
held
up
differences
between
the
possibility
that
the
to
statistical
means
did
differences
not
could
In
other
scrutiny,
the
rule
the
out
have arisen by
chance.
Several
explanations
may account for the failure to
reject the null hypothesis. Methodological
research,
specifically
flaws
in
the
sampling errors and poor controls
over extraneous variables, can largely be credited for the
negative
findings
inherent
in a purposive study of this
nature.
The
limited size of the sample greatly increased the
likelihood
of
representative
error~
of
a
the
larger
sample
population
would
being
be
tested.
more
The
restrictive sample size in this study reflects the limited
number
of
laryngectomees
in
the
United
States
(approximately one laryngectomee for every 6,000
The
today
people).
small sample also is representative of the difficulty
in finding laryngectomees willing to
study.
participate
in
the
51
The
technique of random sampling had to be abandoned
because
it
would
subjects,
given
not
yield
the
necessary
the
time,
location,
required for the testing. Circumstances
number
and
of
conditions
necessitated
the
use of an organized laryngectomy club. Random sampling and
assignment of various
club
members
would
have
further
reduced the number of subjects.
The
use
availability
of
an
may
experimental
preclude
the
sample
drawing
based
of
on
generalized
conclusions. Without the use of other appropriate sampling
techniques
(ie.
random
insure that the sample
sampling),
is
it
is impossible to
representative
of
the
whole
population of laryngectomees.
Selection of
similar
the
control
was
affected
by
sampling errors. The attempt to match the control
group to the experimental
variables
did not
sample
as
age,
~onstitute
experimental
subjects
were
participation
group
group
on
the
basis
of
such
sex, number, social status, and race,
a random sampling procedure. Unlike the
which
accepted
was already assembled, control
on
an
individual
basis
for
in the study solely on the basis of meeting
the variable criterion.
This
suggests
another
methodological
flaw
study--uncontrolled variables. Although certain
were
controlled,
in the
variables
other variables may have influenced the
scores. Attitudinal differences between older and
younger
52
laryngectomees
could
have
Older laryngectomees may be
younger
laryngectomees
some bearing on self-concept.
fixed
may
in
their
ways
while
be adaptable and amenable to
.change.
Another variable that was not specifically controlled
but was acknowledged in the questionnaire was
of
time
amount
since surgery. The majority of subjects had been
laryngectomized for at least one year and
for
the
much
longer.
and
of
them,
The older laryngecto.mees have had some
time to confront the issues and work
doubts,
many
frustrations
through
resulting
surgery. The newer laryngectomees may
from
just
the
fears,
laryngectomy
be
beginning
that struggle. This, then, can affect self-concept scores.
The
equivalent
alaryngeal
speakers
that
sample
the
was
laryngectomees
whose
and
between
the
chosen
to
represent
and
the
an established and organized group of
purpose
is
understanding
to
to
provide
new
Groups like the Lost Chord Club provide an
unconditional
normal
may have been influenced by the fact
group
laryngectomees
information,
scores
support
which
support,
laryngectomees.
atmosphere
of
may directly increase one's
sense of self-worth.
It
should
also
be noted that other health concerns
not dealt with in the study may
influence
over
self-concept.
also
have
exerted
some
Related conditions such as
emphysema or lung cancer (the diseases that
are
commonly
53
associated
with
laryngeal patients who had smoked in the
past or who are still smoking), could affect certain areas
of
an
individual's
self-concept
(ie. the Physical Self
measure on the TSCS).
One
must
also
realize
that
self-concept
is
generally unreliable measure because it is subject to
a
the
individual's level of functioning at a particular point in
time. This further increases the likelihood of an error in
measurement.
SUGGESTIONS
Stricter
controls
study. One example
measurement
of
could
would
improve and strengthen the
be
to
obtqin
a
pre-surgical
self-concept
to
better
understand
the
dynamics of the change in the laryngectomee's self-concept
It
would
be
vital
to
engage
the
help and support of
surgeons who specialize in head, neck, and throat
or
hospitals
surgery
that are accustomed to this procedure. This
will provide not only a larger sample size, but allow
better
monitoring
for
of extraneous variables. The resources
of the International Association of Laryngectomees may
be
used to this effect as well.
Another suggestion is to modify the
easier
to
read
and
answer.
TSCS
so
it
Older laryngectomees had a
tendency to have more problems completing the test due
the
small,
is
to
light print. The older laryngectomee would be
54
further helped by a shortened version of the test as
some
older subjects were uncomfortable with the time it took to
complete
the
compromise
test,
although
truncated
measures
also
reliabilit~.
While the TSCS provides a
good
overall
measure
of
self-concept, other scales may more accurately reflect the
independent variables that
comprise
the
measurement
of
self-concept.
CONCLUSIONS
Working
toward
self-concept is
self-image
the
development
essential.
The
of
effects
the
of
patient's
a
positive
filter into other aspects of one's functioning
making for a healthier and happier individual. The traumas
encountered
by
laryngectomees
treatment of the laryngectomee
will
enhance
his
lessened
when
counseli~g
that
It is the belief of the
will
validate
this
point.
a larger sample, better controls, and the support of
surgeons and hospitals, a
illuminate
the
more
relationship
comprehensive
study
may
between physical and mental
healing. With the development of new
the
be
includes
self-concept.
author that further research
With
may
prosthetic
devices,
need for specialized services for laryngectomees will
be eliminated. Research and development
has already met with much success.
along
this
line
55
The
outlook
laryngectomy
surgery
and disturbing;
laryngectomee
gentleman
on
laryngectomees,
air."
it
for
has
does
the
individual
undergoing
usually been portrayed as grim
not
have
to
be.
Life
as
a
does have its moments as pointed out by one
the
we
questionnaire.
can
He
stated,
"as
kiss and not have to come up for
56
BIBLIOGRAPHY
American Cancer Society 1982 cancer facts and figures.
American Cancer Society, 1981.
Babin, D. E. Body awareness in the physically abnormal.
Journal of Religion and Health, 1975, 1!(3),
184-191.
Blumberg, B., Flaherty, M., & Lewis, J., (Eds.). Coping
with cancer, a resource for the health professional.
(NIH Publication No. 80-2080, U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services.)
Bethesda, Maryland: National Cancer Institute,
1 980.
Borg, W. R., & Gall, M. D. Educational Research (3rd
ed.). New York: Longman, 1979.
Brewer, T. Youthful approach to laryngectomy. Cassette.
Wichita, Kansas: Frank Bangs Audio Visual Co.,
1982.
Campbell, W. G., Ballou, S. V. & Slade, C. Form and
style (6th ed.). Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co.,
1982.
Cousins, N. Anatomy of an illness as perceived Qy the
patient. New York: W. W. Norton and Co., 1979.
Cullen, J. W. Research issues in psychosocial and behavioral aspects of cancer.
Proceedings of the
American Cancer Society Third National Conference
on Human Values and Cancer, 1981, 157-163.
DiBartolo, R. Self-concept and the attainment of esophageal speech (Doctoral dissertation, University
of New York at Buffalo, 1968). Dissertation
Abstracts International, 1969, 30, 2890.
(University Microfilms No. 69-2~ 576)
Dietz, J. H., Jr. Rehabilitation of the cancer patient.
Medical Clinics of North America, 1969, 53 (2),
3-20.
Dunham, J. R., & Dunham, c. S. Psychosocial aspects of
disability.
In R. M. Goldenson, J. R. Dunham, &
C. S. Dunham (Eds.), Disability and rehabilitation handbook. New York: McGraw-Hill Book
Co. , 197 8.
Eberlein, Nancy.
Personal interview.
23 October 1982.
57
Facts on cancer of the larynx.
1978.
American Cancer Society,
Feldman, F. L.
The teaching of psychosocial and human
issues: Rehabilitation and humanistic issues.
Proceedings of the American Cancer Society Third
National Conference on Human Values and Cancer,
1981' 139-146.
Fitts, W. H.
Tennesse self concept scale. Nashville,
Tennesse: Counselor Recordings and Tests, 1964.
Fitts, W. H.
The self concept and behavior: Overview
and supplement. Studies on the Self Concept,
1972, 7.
(Monograph)
Fitts, W. H. The self concept and psychopathology.
Studies on the Self Concept, 1972, i·
(Monograph)-Fitts, W. H., Adams, J. L., Radford, G., Richard, W. C.,
Thomas, B. K., Thomas, M. M., & Thompson, W.
The self concept and self-actualization. Studies
on the Self Concept, 1971, 3.
(Monograph)
Fobair, P. & Cordoba, C. S. Scope and magnitude of the
cancer program in psychosocial research.
In J.
Cohen, J. W. Cullen & L. R. Martin (Eds.),
Psychosocial aspects of cancer. New York: Raven
Press, 1982.
Gilmore, S. I.
Social and vocational acceptability of
esopageal speakers compared to normal speakers.
Journal o£ Speech and Hearing Research, 1974,
11., 599-607.
Goffman, E.
Stigma. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey:
Prentice Hall, 1963.
Goffman, E. The presentation 2f self in everyday life.
Garden City, New York: Doubleday Anchor Books,
1959.
Goldenson, R. M.
Laryngeal cancer.
In R. M. Goldenson,
J. R. Dunham, & C. S. Dunham (Eds.), Disability
and rehabilitation handbook. New York: McGrawHill Book Co., 1978.
Gorman, W. Body image and the image of the brain.
S.t.
Louis, Missouri: Warren H. Green, Inc., 1969.
58
Gross, N., Mason, W. s., & McEachern, A. W.
Exploring
role analysis: Studies of the school superintendency role.
New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1958.
Hardy, G. B. Analysis of background factors associated
with the social functioning of laryngectomees
(Doctoral dissertation, University of California
Los Angeles, 1976).
Dissertation Abstracts
International, 1976, 37, 3908.
(University
Microfilms No. 76-28,-s67)
Isaac, S., & Michael, W. B.
Handbook in research and
evaluation.
San Diego, California: EdiTS,-,g71.
Johnson, J. T., Casper, J., & Lesswing, N. J.
Toward the
total rehabilitation of the alaryngeal patient.
The Laryngoscope, 1979, 89, 1813-1818.
Keith, R. L., Linebaugh, C. W., & Cox, B. G.
Presurgical
counseling needs of laryngectomees: A survey of
78 patients.
The Laryngoscope, 1978, 88, 16601 6 65.
Kerlinger, F. N.
Foundations of behavioral research.
New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1964.
King,_ P. S., Marshall, R. C., & Gunderson, H. E.
Management of the older laryngectomee. Geriatrics,
1971, ~(2), 112-118.
Klinger, H.
Acceptance among alaryngeal speakers.
Journal of Communication Disorders, 1971, i,
273-278.
Koop, C. E., & Luoto, J.
The health consequences of
smoking: Cancer.
(Reprinted from Public Health
Reports, 1982, 22(4), 318-324).
Kubler-Ross, E.
On death and dying.
Puplishing-co., 1969.
New York: MacMillan
Kubler-Ross, E.
To live until we ~ good-bye.
Englewood-cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc.,
1 9 78.
Laryngectomy rehabilitation program guidelines.
Cancer Society, California Division.
American
Martin, L. R.
Overview of the psychosocial aspects of
cancer.
In J. Cohen, J. W. Cullen & L. R. Martin
(Eds.), Psychosocial aspects of cancer.
New
York: Raven Press, 1982.
59
Maslow, A. H.
Toward a psychology of being (2nd ed.).
New York: D. Van Nostrand Co., 1968.
Minear, D., & Lucente, F. E.
Current attitudes of laryngectomy patients. The Laryngoscope, 1979, 89,
1061-1065.
Mouly, G. J. Educational research, the art and science
of investigation. Boston, Massachusetts: Allyn
& Bacon, 1 9 7 8 .
Nahum, A.M., & Golden, J. S. Psychological problems of
laryngectomy. Journal of the American Medical
Association, 1963, 186(13);-70-72.
Nitschneider, B. Youthful approach to laryngectomy.
Cassette. Wichita, Kansas: Frank Bangs Audio
Visual Co., 1982.
Phelps, W. R.
Psychology of the laryngectomee. JSAS
Catalog of Selected Documents in Psychology,
1973, l_, 60. (r-1S. No. 373)
Publication manual of the American Psychological Association (2nd ed.). Baltimore, Maryland: Garamond/
Pridemark Press, 1974.
Puldy, L. What's new with artificial larynx device.
Cassette. Wichita, Kansas: Frank Bangs Audio
Visual Co., 1982.
Rehabilitating laryngectomees.
1 9 77.
American Cancer Society,
Renner, M., & Ranney, J. Voice is not enough for total
rehabilitation. Cassette. Wichita, Kansas:
Frank Bangs Audio Visual Co., 1982.
Robinson, J. P., & Shaver, P. R. Measures of social
psychological attitudes (Rev. ed.). Ann Arbor,
Michigan: University of Michigan, 1973.
Rogers,
c. R. On becoming a person.
Mifflin Co., 1 961 .
Boston: Houghton
Rosenstein, A.
Esophageal speech with health concepts
and tips for laryngectomees. Long Beach,
California: ELOT Publishing Co., 1981.
60
Sanchez-Salazar, V., & Stark, A. The use of crisis
intervention in the rehabilitation of laryngectomees. Journal of Speech and Hearing
Disorders, 1972, 37, 323-328.
Sarbin, T. R. A preface to a psychological analysis of
the self. Psychological Review, 1952, ~' 11-22.
Scriffignano, Paul.
Telephone interview. 8 October 1982.
Sebest, E. A Study of
the body image
of Pittsburgh,
International,
Microfilms No.
the effects of major surgery on
(Doctoral dissertation, University
1973). Dissertation Abstracts
1973, 34, 1286-B.
(University
73-21,~33)
Shavelson, R. J. Statistical reasoning for the behavioral sciences. Boston: Allyn & Bacon, 1981.
Shepardson, J. Team approach to the patient with cancer.
American Journal of Nursing, 1972, ~(3), 488491 .
Snygg, D., & Combs, A. W.
Individual behavior--A
perceptual approach to behavior (Rev. Ed.).
York: Harper & Row Publishers, 1959.
Sontag, S. Illness as metaphor.
Books, 1979.
New
New York: Vintage
Surgeon General's Report.
The health consequences of
smoking: Cancer.
(Item number 017-001-00441-3).
Washington, D. C.: U. S. Government Printing
Off ice, 1 9_82.
Thompson, W. Correlates of the self concept. Studies
on the Self Concept, 1972, ~- (Monograph)
Wallen, V., & Wegg, V. P. A survey of the background
characteristics of 2,000 laryngectomees: A preliminary report. Military Medicine, 1975,
140(8), 532-534.
Webster's New World Dictionary (2nd Ed.). Cleveland:
William Collins & World Publishing Co., 1974.
61
West, D. W. Adaptation to surgically induced facial
disfigurement among cancer patients (Doctoral
dissertation, State University of New York at
Buffalo, 1973). Dissertation Abstracts
International, 1973, 34, 4442.
(University
Hicrofilms No. 73-29,-151)
Wright, B. A.
Physical disability--a psychological
approach.
New York: Harper & Row Publishers,
1960.
62
APPENDIX A:
CORRESPONDENCE
63
International
Association of
Laryngectomees
l
AMERICAN
~CANCE~"
Sponsored by the ~
777 Third Avenue • New York. N.Y. 10017 • (212] 371-2900
December 2, 1982
Ms. Karen Wentz·
Dear Ms. Wentz:
Thank you for your letter of the 29th of November 1982, and for
selecting the laryngectomees as the subject for your thesis.
We welcome all the publicity that is available.
Your request for permission to use the two drawings on pages
five (5) and six (6) of our brochure "Rehabilitating Laryngectomees" is granted, providing you give credit to the I .A.L.
Wishing you the best of luck with your thesis.
If there is anything further we can do to help,please feel free
to write.
Sincerely,
Paul J. Scriffignano
Executive Secretary
PJS:cmf
SOCIE1Y
64
APPENDIX B:
SUPPLEMENTAL TESTING MATERIALS
65
QUESTIONNAIRE
fJ ----------------
Bir'.:hdate: - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Surgery Date:--------
Occupation
before Surgery
Occupation
after Surgery___________
Support Systems before Surgery: (please circle)
Friends
Relatives
Church/Temple
Other Agencies
Other (please explain) __________________________________
Support Systems after Surgery: (please circle)
Friends
Relatives
Church/Temple
Other Agencies
Other (please explain) __________________________________
Did your circle of friends change after the surgery? ______
Do you use esophageal speech? ______________
If you don't, which method of communication do you use? ____
Did you seek any professional therapy or counseling in making
the adjustment to being a laryngectomee? ________________
Please relate any experience(s) or situation(s) that would
help me better understand what it means to be a laryngectomee.
66
The TSCS Variables:
Abbreviations and Full Name of the Variable
--- ---- ---- -- ---
sc
T/F
NET C
TOT C
TOTAL
ROW 1
ROW 2
ROW 3
COL A
COL B
COL C
COL D
COL E
V TOT
V COL
V ROW
DST D
DST 5
DST 4
DST 3
DST 2
DST 1
DP
Gl.\-1
PSY
PD
N
PI
NDS
Self Criticism Score
True-False Ratio
Net Conflict .
Total Conflict
Total Positive Scores
Identity
Self-Satisfaction
Behavior
Physical Self
Moral-Ethical Self
Personal Self.
Family Self
· Social Self
Total Variability
Column Total Variability
R6w Total Variability
Distribution Scores
Distribution of Fifth Response Scores
Distribution of Fourth Response Scores
Distribution of Third Response Scores
Distribution of Second Response Scores
Distribution of First Response Scores
Defensive Positive Scale
General Maladjustment Scale
Psychosis Scale
Personality Disorder Scale
Neurosis Scale
Personality Integration Scale
Number of Deviant Signs
67
Descri-ption of the TSCS Variables
Self Criticism Score: a measure of overt defensiveness
taken
directly
from
the
Minnesota
Multiphasic Personality Inventory L Scale.
True-False
Net
Ratio:
a measure of response bias indicating
any tendency to strongly agree or disagree
regardless of item content.
Conflict:
this measures the extent to which an
individual's responses to positive items
differ from his negative responses within
the same area of self- perception. It is a
directional measure
indicative
of
a
tendency toward denial or acquiescence.
Total Conflict: this measure is non-directional and
reflects
the
overall
conflict
and
confusion within a particular area of
self-perception.
Total Positive Scores: a measure of the overall
self-esteem.
Identity (Row
level
of
ll:
it is a measure of one's basic
identity--how one sees himself.
the Positive scores.)
(One of
Self-Satisfaction (Row 2): it is a measure of
self-acceptance-- how one feels about the
self he perceives.
(One of the Positive
scores.)
Behavior
3): it is a. measure of one's percep~lon of
the way he functions and behaves. (One of
the Positive scores.)
Physical Self (Col A): a measure of one's body image,
--state
of health, physical appearance,
skills, and sexuality.
(One
of
the
Positive scores.)
Moral-Ethical Self (Col
~:
a
measure
of one's moral
11
good 11 or 11 bad 11 ,
and
the
satisfaction
or
lack
of
satisfaction with one's religion. (One of
the Positive scores.)
--wDr~ feelings of being
68
Personal
Self
(Col C): a measure of one's sense of
personal worth, feelings of adequacy as a
person, and evaluation of his
self-~onfidence and self regard.
(One of
the Positive scores.)
Family Self (Col D)~ a measure of one's sense of wo~th,
----adequacy, and value as a member of a
family.
(One of the Positive scores.)
Social Self (Col E): a measure of one's sense of worth and
----value in his general- social interactions.
(One of the Positive scores.)
Total Variability: a measure of the inconsistency
responding from one area of
self-perception to another.
Column
Row
Total
Total
Distribution
in
Variability: a measure of the inconsistency
in responding within the Column scores.
Variability: a measure of the inconsistency in
responding within the Row scores.
Scores: a measure of the certainty about the
way one sees himself. This score provides
a summary score of the distribution of
answers across the five available choices
in responding to the test items.
Defensive Positive Scale: a more subtle measure of
defensiveness
than the Self Criticism
Scale provides.
General Maladjustment Scale: serves as an index to measure
adjustment
or
maladjustment
among
psychiatric patients· (psychotic, neurotic,
and personality disorder
groups)
and
non-patients.
Psychosis Scale:
a
measure ·to differentiate
from other groups.
psychotic
pat~ents
Personality Disorder Scale: a measure to differentiate
this diagnostic group from other groups.
Neurosis Scale: a measure to differentiate this diagnostic
group from other groups.
Personality Integration Scale: a measure to differentiate
the adjustment levels of other groups in
relation to a group judged as
being
average or above average in this area.
69
Number of Deviant Signs: a summation or count of the
deviant feature~ of other scores serving
to identify any psychological disturbances
in an individual.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz