Student supplement www.rsc.org/eic November 2009 • volume 46 • Number 6 Acid attack Rising CO2 levels threaten sea life ISSN 0013-1350 GCSE criteria Plastic waste Consultation calls for more clarity on assessment regimes Chemists look to Nature for greener alternatives Issue 119 november 2009 Jupiterimages Stone-faced chemists York Minster, the 15th century limestone cathedral, has over the centuries suffered much erosion as a result of weathering and pollution. During this time restoration work has been done, some of which has been more successful than others. Now, in what is the latest phase of such work, archaeologists from the University of York have teamed up with chemists from the University of Cardiff in an attempt to restore the east front of the cathedral. By using a range of X-ray techniques, the chemists are providing detail on the microscopic composition of the limestone, historical mortars and the decay products. This information should give the conservators the edge when it comes to deciding how to treat the stone, and importantly should ensure that in their efforts to preserve history they do not cause further damage. In contrast to intact sections of the limestone, the chemists, led by Dr Karen Wilson, found that the decayed areas comprised high levels of calcium sulfate (gypsum). She told InfoChem, ‘This probably originates from the industrial era when there were high levels of sulfur dioxide in the atmosphere, though it could also be something inherent in the stone. The results importantly indicate that any building materials used to restore the stone should have low sulfate understanding a phenomenon that has bugged archeologists for some time, ie the faces of stone that experience the worst decay are in sheltered areas, while the most exposed areas don’t tend to weather as much. Wilson explained, ‘One of the properties of calcium sulfate is that it is sparingly soluble, so surfaces that are exposed to rain will have the salt washed off, but in sheltered regions the salt can accumulate and crystallise out, which kicks off the decay mechanism’. This content’. Some of the mortars that information is relevant to the current work since the east face is were used in the past, Wilson explained, contained high levels of now covered with scaffolding, which is expected to stay up for sulfate ions, which washed into between five to 10 years. the stonework and led to decay. What will be used to treat and The limestone used to build York repair the limestone will depend Minster is dolomite – a mixed on the results of the analytical work calcium–magnesium carbonate done by the chemists. However, (CaCO3.MgCO3). The stone has a this is likely to take the form of a rich cream colour and is easy to surface coating that can be carve but is also vulnerable to decay. Wilson pointed out that the washed off and eventually replaced. dolomite used contained trace The chemists are using X-ray amounts of certain catalytic diffraction to confirm the structure impurities, such as iron, which of crystalline compounds and would speed up the decay X-ray absorption spectroscopy to process. look at the structure of any The chemists are also closer to amorphous compounds present, Signs of decay… such as silicates. They are using X-ray electron spectroscopy to look at the composition of surfacespecific species. The latter technique has the advantage that it also provides information on the element’s oxidation state. York Minster – a national treasure Download a pdf of this issue at: www.rsc.org/EiC InfoChem_Nov09.indd 1 IN THIS ISSUE Vitamin D Are we getting enough of the sunshine vitamin? A day in the life of… Celia Gitterman, technical editor On-screen chemistry Check out fuel cells in 'eco' hotel Backyard chemistry How to trap a soap bubble… Plus… Prize puzzles Editor Kathryn Roberts Assistant editor James Berressem Design and layout Dale Dawson Infochem is a supplement to Education in Chemistry and is published bi‑monthly by the Royal Society of Chemistry, Burlington House, Piccadilly, London W1J 0BA, UK. 020-7437 8656, e-mail: [email protected] www.rsc.org/Education/EiC/index.asp © The Royal Society of Chemistry, 2009 Published in January and alternate months. ISSN: 1752-0533 1 19/10/2009 11:21:27 The sunshine vit Issue 119 november 2009 Vitamin D is often called the sunshine vitamin because it is made as a direct result of ultraviolet rays from the sun falling on our skin. Essential for a healthy skeleton, there is now some evidence that a deficiency in this vitamin could lead to illnesses as diverse as cancer, diabetes and flu. So what is vitamin D, why is it so important, and what evidence is there to link it to such a range of illnesses? V itamin D is a group of fat soluble compounds which have structures based on steroids, ie contain four connected carbon rings. Two types, D2 (1) and D3 (2), are found naturally in the diet, while D3 can also be synthesised in the body if the skin is exposed to ultraviolet light with a wavelength of between 290 and 315 nanometres (ie UV-B). On absorption of UV-B, the compound 7-dehydrocholesterol, which is common in skin cells, rearranges to form the energetically more stable D3 (see equation (i)). Once formed, vitamin D3 is converted by enzymes in the liver and kidney to the more active 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25(OH)D). This compound – a hormone – works together with specific proteins to allow effective transport of calcium and phosphate ions Jupiterimages Jump for joy… sunshine and healthy bones 2 InfoChem_Nov09.indd 2 through the blood. A lack of this compound reduces the uptake of these ions from the intestine and creates a shortage for bone growth. (Bone is made up of a network of collagen fibres impregnated with crystals of hydroxyapatite, Ca5(PO4)3(OH).) Vitamin D deficiency A shortage of vitamin D leads to rickets in children and osteomalacia in adults, both characterised by soft, deformed bones which cannot support the weight of the body. At the beginning of the 20th century, over 80 per cent of children in the industrial cities of northern Europe and north-east US had rickets – partly because of poor diet but also because they weren’t getting enough sunlight to compensate. Nowadays rickets is much less common because vitamin D is added to various foods, and more people are aware of the benefits of a balanced diet. Oily fish is the most important dietary source of vitamin D, containing 5–10 micrograms (μg) per 100 g. Other sources such as margarine, some breakfast cereals, red meat and egg yolks, have lower levels, from 1–8 μg per100 g. The recommended daily allowance of this vitamin for 14 –18-year olds is 5 μg per day in the US, while in the UK 10 μg per day is recommended for certain ‘at risk’ groups such as pregnant and breast-feeding women. Around 90 per cent of our vitamin D requirement is made in our skin, with just 10 You may copy this page for use within schools 19/10/2009 11:26:02 vitamin BIOPHOTO ASSOCIATES/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY per cent coming from the diet. And herein lies a potential problem. The amount of vitamin D that can be synthesised in the body will be subject to seasonal variations in sunlight. Not a problem if you live in the tropics, but in winter, at latitudes above 52º north, ie northern Europe and north-east US, the light does not contain enough UV-B to rearrange the vitamin D precursors in the skin. Elina Hyppönen, a research scientist in epidemiology at the Institute of Child Health at University College London (UCL) is interested in the role that a vitamin D deficiency may have in various illnesses. She explained to InfoChem, ‘Owing to a lack of UV-B in northern latitudes many people in these regions will have low levels of vitamin D in the winter. To prevent severe vitamin D deficiency we need to have concentrations of 25(OH)D above 25 nanomoles per litre (nmol l–1) in the body’. According to Hyppönen 15 per cent per cent of the Caucasian population in the UK, for example, has below 25 nmol l–1 of 25(OH)D in the winter and around 90 per cent has less than 75 nmol l–1 which is still considered to be less than optimal. People with darker skin pigmentation have potentially lower levels because the natural pigment melanin acts as a sunscreen and reduces UV-B induced vitamin D production in the skin. While not low enough to produce rickets or osteomalacia, she and her team are currently investigating the possibility that such levels might be linked to other health problems. HO Causal links? Hyppönen told InfoChem, ‘In our group we have looked at associations between infant vitamin D supplementation and the risk of developing diabetes during the next 30 years of life'. The team recorded the occurrence of diabetes in 12 000 people born in Finland in 1966. ‘What we saw was that children who took vitamin D supplements regularly had an 80 per cent reduction in their risk of developing diabetes’, explained Hyppönen. The researchers also found a link between vitamin D deficiency and increased incidence of diabetes. ‘It doesn’t prove it is causal, but it was a consistent HO 7-Dehydrocholestrol with steriod structure shown in red UV-B light HO Previtamin D3 Spontaneous rearrangement HO (1) Vitamin D2 You may copy this page for use within schools InfoChem_Nov09.indd 3 (i) (2) Vitamin D3 Bent bones – sign of rickets association,’ said Hyppönen. Other researchers are looking at the link between vitamin D in the body and the development of cancer, tuberculosis, cardiovascular disease and even flu. It may be more than a coincidence that flu increases in autumn and winter – when levels of 25(OH)D in the body are lowest. However, Hyppönen cautions, ‘while it is a very interesting hypothesis, more research is needed to prove that vitamin D deficiency is indeed the cause for these variations.’ She pointed out that it is too easy to jump to wrong conclusions about what causes disease, since several health problems are often interlinked. Obesity, she explained, is a common factor in the development of many diseases, including diabetes and cardiovascular disease. In addition, obese people are more likely to be vitamin D deficient, since vitamin D is fat soluble and tends to accumulate in body fat rather than being circulated round the body. ‘If you think about the associations between vitamin D concentrations and obesity and all the conditions linked with obesity, you could draw the wrong conclusions. We need to be careful otherwise we will make wrong assumptions simply through association’. A good way to prove the role of vitamin D in disease is through controlled clinical trials, where volunteers are randomly given one of a choice of ’treatments‘, which in this case would either be a vitamin D tablet or a look-a-like tablet that didn’t contain the vitamin (a placebo). So long as enough people are tested, explained Hyppönen, this is a reliable method for determining the effectiveness of the treatment. » 3 19/10/2009 12:39:53 “… 90 per cent of our vitamin D requirement is made in our skin…” Issue 119 november 2009 » One feature of vitamin D biochemistry, said Hyppönen, is that those receptors (proteins) which bind specifically to 25(OH)D exist in many parts of the body, which suggests widespread influence. Also vitamin D is unusual in that it can affect the chemical pathways leading to infectious diseases, such as flu, and diseases like diabetes which are caused by an overactive immune system. Winter supplements? What is clear is that vitamin D deficiency is common in northern Europe and northern parts of the US, and unlike other vitamins and nutrients, which can be obtained mainly from the diet, this is not the case with vitamin D. Research points to around five–10 minutes of sunlight, between 10 am and 3 pm daily from spring to autumn as adequate to prevent vitamin D deficiency for people with Bone meal? light skin. However, while the Food Standards Agency finds that ‘most people should be able to get all the vitamin D they need from their diet and by getting a little sun’, Hyppönen is more cautious. ‘Since it is difficult to obtain sufficient vitamin D from the diet, I would recommend vitamin D supplements during the winter and at times when you receive little natural light.’ Tom Bond magnificent molecules Tom Bond, postdoc at Imperial College London, highlights his favourite molecules. In this issue: capsaicin istockphoto; jupiterimages x2 Capsaicin (1) is responsible for the hot taste of chilli peppers. It can also relieve pain, is used in pepper spray and as a performance-enhancing drug for horses, so it certainly qualifies as a magnificent molecule. Chilli plants produce several similar chemicals called capsaicinoids, the commonest is capsaicin. When capsaicin contacts human tissue, it produces a burning feeling because the molecule binds to a protein on the surface of nerve cells that register heat. The hot sensation causes the release of CH3 O HO 4 InfoChem_Nov09.indd 4 pain-relieving chemicals (endorphins) in the brain. Endorphins also produce feelings of exhilaration, which may explain why some people find hot food addictive. The Scoville scale is used to assess the ‘heat’ of chillies. Originally a test using a panel of human tasters, now high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) provides a numerical analysis. In the HPLC method warm ethanol is used to extract the capsaicinoids from the chilli which are then separated, identified using an ultraviolet detector, O CH3 N CH3 H (1) Capsaicin and their concentrations measured. Tabasco sauce registers from 2500– 5000 on the Scoville scale and the hottest chilli ever, a Naga Jolokia, or King Cobra chilli, over one million. Should you eat a Naga Jolokia, drinking water will do little to ease the pain. This is because capsaicin is a hydrophobic molecule, with a low solubility in water. Instead, milk is an effective calming agent since it contains casein, a fat-loving molecule which can help dissolve the fat-like capsaicin. Capsaicin-containing creams can give pain relief from conditions such as arthritis and shingles. Meanwhile, in the show jumping competition at the last Olympics, five horses tested positive for Chilli peppers – hot stuff capsaicin and were disqualified. When applied as a lotion to a horse’s legs, capsaicin acts as an irritant which causes the horse to jump higher. n You may copy this page for use within schools 19/10/2009 11:28:30 Jonathan Hare asks… Fuel cells: would they blow up an 'eco' hotel? In the Bond film Quantum of solace, a dodgy South American dictator, General Medrano, is negotiating a deal with the evil Dominic Greene who wants to take control of one of the biggest sources of fresh water in the world.1 The secret deal is signed in a hotel in the middle of the Bolivian desert. This state-of-the-art ‘eco’ hotel is powered by fuel cells. There is a scene where the general is discussing the merits of the beautiful hotel and jokingly asks if the fuel cells are safe. Meanwhile Bond finds out about the secret meeting and in an action-packed series of events puts an end to the plot and destroys the hotel by blowing up the fuel cells. So how do fuel cells work, are they dangerous and could they blow up a hotel? COLUMBIA/DANJAQ/EON/THE KOBAL COLLECTION Fuel cell technology A fuel cell is an electrochemical device that produces electricity from the reaction of a fuel (on the anode side) and an oxidant (on the cathode side).2 There is great interest in using hydrogen as a ‘green’ fuel for fuel cells since its reaction with oxygen (air) only produces water as waste. Hydrogen can be made from hydrocarbon fuels but unfortunately CO or CO2 are often produced in the process, and CO2 is a greenhouse gas.3 However, solar cells can be used to provide electricity to split water into hydrogen and oxygen in a process known as electrolysis. Fuel cells are ideal for remote locations and where a non-polluting energy source is required. For example, they have been used to great effect in the space flight programmes where the H2 and O2 rocket fuel can be converted directly into electricity and also water. Unlike a battery, which has to be recharged regularly, a fuel cell can produce electricity so long as it has a fuel supply. ‘ECO’ hotel Going back to the film it appears that there are several fuel cell units powering the rooms of the hotel. It’s not clear if each of these units has its own hydrogen fuel tank or if they are fed by one large tank. In this remote location, in the sunny desert, solar cells could be used to electrolyse water to make hydrogen which could be stored in tanks for the fuel cells. If these tanks were ruptured the hydrogen would vent into the air producing a highly explosive mixture.4 The minimum ignition energy for H2/O2 mixtures is very low (0.011–0.017 mJ), about a tenth that of other fuels such as methane (ca 0.3 mJ) or petrol (ca 0.8 mJ). Even small electrostatic sparks from certain types of clothing can cause an explosion. Also the range of H2 concentrations that can explode and even detonate is extremely wide, much wider than almost any other fuel.4 Design fault At one point in the film a car smashes into a fuel cell unit which starts a series of explosions to propagate around the whole complex that eventually cause the destruction of the hotel. So based on what we know about fuel cells what we see unfolding in the film looks plausible, but You may copy this page for use within schools InfoChem_Nov09.indd 5 Bond checks out early perhaps only if the hotel design was so poor that a chain reaction of hydrogen tank explosions could occur. One thing is for sure, any survivors of the devastation would have had major hearing problems afterwards. References 1. Quantum of solace, Columbia, 2008. 2. For information on fuel cells see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Fuel_cells 3. For example, see: InfoChem, 2009, no 114, p 5. 4. Fuel cells: understanding the hazards, control the risks. Sudbury: HSE Books, 2004. Dr Jonathan Hare, The CSC Centre, chemistry department, University of Sussex, Brighton BN1 9ET (www.creative-science.org.uk/TV.html). Did you know? Did you know that it was British scientist Sir William Grove who discovered the principle on which fuel cells are based? In 1839 he observed that after switching off the current he had used to electrolyse water, a current flowed in the opposite direction – produced by the reaction of H2 and O2 which had been adsorbed onto the platinum electrodes. 5 19/10/2009 11:29:12 Dr Hal SoSabowSki preSentS experimentS you can Do on your own Issue 103 MARCH 2007 In this issue: the colours of soap bubbles Soap bubbles are difficult to examine because of their fragility and short life. However, because they are very light, they will float on a gas, such as carbon dioxide, that is only slightly denser than the air that fills them. When soap bubbles settle into a container of carbon dioxide, the bubbles float on the carbon dioxide and can therefore be examined closely. materials You will need: ●● soap bubble solution with blowing wand; ●● a large transparent container with an open top such as an empty fish tank; ●● 125 ml (half a cup) of baking soda (sodium hydrogen carbonate); ●● 250 ml (1 cup) vinegar; ●● shallow glass dish to fit inside the large container such as a glass baking dish. Method Matthew J. Ingram Place the glass dish inside on the bottom of the large transparent container. Put 125 ml of baking soda in the glass dish. Pour 250 ml of vinegar into the dish with the baking soda. The mixture of soda and vinegar will immediately start to fizz as they react and form carbon dioxide gas. Carbon dioxide is denser than air and will be held in the large container as long as it is not disturbed by draughts of air over the container. Once the reaction has subsided (about a minute), gently blow several soap bubbles over the opening of the large container, so that they settle into the container. This may take a bit of practice. Do not blow directly into the container because you will blow the carbon dioxide 6 InfoChem_Nov09.indd 6 out of it. When a soap bubble settles in the container it will not sink to the bottom, as it would have done in air. Instead, it will float on the surface of the invisible carbon dioxide in the container. While the bubbles are floating on the carbon dioxide in the container, you can observe them. Note: their colour(s); their size and any changes; and whether they rise or sink. When you have finished, dispose of the mixture in the glass dish by rinsing it down the drain with water. The science The colours of a soap bubble come from reflections of the white light that falls on it. White light, such as from the sun or from a light bulb, contains light of all colours. Light travels as waves, and the length of a wave, from crest to crest, determines the colour of the light. When light hits a soap bubble, some will be reflected from the outer surface of the soap film, while some light will travel through the film and be reflected from the inside surface of the film. Waves of light reflected from the inner and outer surfaces of the soap film can interfere with each other. Where the crests of the light waves meet, the intensity of the light increases. But if the crest of a wave meets the trough of another wave, the intensity of the light is diminished. Whether the crest of a wave meets another crest or a trough is determined by the length of the wave and by the thickness of the film. If the film thickness is a multiple of the wavelength of the light, the crests of waves reflected from the inner surface will meet the crests of waves reflected from the outer surfaces. If the thickness of the film is an odd multiple of half the wavelength, the crests of the waves reflected from the inner surface will meet the troughs of the waves reflected from the outer surface. Because the thickness of the film varies and the wavelength of the light determines its colour, different areas of the bubble will have different colours. Health and Safety Soap can make hard floors slippery. Acknowledgement: adapted with permission of Professor Bassam Z. Shakhashiri, University of Wisconsin–Madison, www.scifun.org/ HomeExpts/homeexpts.html You may copy this page for use within schools 19/10/2009 11:30:02 A day in the life of… Technical editor: Celia Gitterman Celia Gitterman has spent the past four years working for the Royal Society of Chemistry as a technical editor. She talks to Tom Bond about her typical day. As part of its activities the Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) publishes 27 journals, which are made up of articles submitted by chemists. Over 120 people work on these journals in the RSC’s Cambridge office. Each article is accepted for publication by a journal’s editor based on positive comments received from experts with knowledge of the subject area. Part of the informatics department and working in a team of 10 staff responsible for six journals, Celia’s job is to make sure the accepted articles are ready to be published on the Internet and in print. Journals production Working from nine to five each day, Celia edits and proofs the accepted articles, and compiles these into issues of the journals. When articles have been accepted for publication, electronic versions of the manuscripts are sent to typesetters in India, who convert them into an XML (extensible markup language) format. In this format different types of text (eg italics, bold, captions references etc) are marked in different colours, which helps Celia as she edits the article. ‘When editing the text, we check the spelling, the references and that it makes pathway to success ●● 2004–present, technical editor, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge 2000–04, PhD in organic chemistry at University of Cambridge 1996–2000, MSci in natural sciences at University of Cambridge 1994–96, chemistry, maths, physics A-levels, Sacred Heart of Mary Girls’ School, Upminster ●● ●● ●● You may copy this page for use within schools InfoChem_Nov09.indd 7 Celia Gitterman sense’, she explains. Using her knowledge of chemistry to understand the articles, Celia spots any mistakes in the chemistry and adds corresponding queries for the authors to address on the final proof. Graphics, eg illustrations, diagrams etc, in the article go through a similar process as the text and she also verifies that these are the correct size to be reproduced clearly in the final version. Celia takes up to a couple of hours to edit a short, four-page article. Review articles, which summarise research in a particular area of chemistry, take longer to edit since these can be up to 25 pages. Proofing papers Once Celia is happy with the edited article, she uses software to generate a proof of the article similar in appearance to the final version but which includes questions for the authors on any sections she is uncertain of. This is sent to the authors by e-mail and when they return the proof, she includes their corrections in the final article. She then makes a final check of the article’s content and layout before publishing it on the Internet in HTML (hyper text markup language) format. When the HTML version of the article is published, the typesetters create a PDF (portable document format) file which is used for the print and electronic versions of the issue. The journals Celia works on are published either weekly or monthly and it is her role to collect articles and combine them to form an issue of a particular journal. This is called makeup and takes between half a day and a day. ‘We check the layout of the PDFs for the issue. If everything’s fine we’ll publish the electronic issue. Then the PDFs get sent to the printers’ for the print issue’. Celia edits and proofs about five articles per day. As and when required she spends some of her day creating ontologies for chemical reactions. These are like dictionaries to define reactions to which links can be added in the HTML versions of the articles. Attention to detail ‘You have to be quite picky to do this job, and it helps if you enjoy reading’, says Celia. For her it’s very satisfying to edit a manuscript and spot changes that help to make the chemistry clearer. n 7 19/10/2009 11:30:31 £50 of HMV tokens to be won! Issue 119 november 2009 Elemental England This issue Benchtalk brings you a puzzle that links chemistry with geography, contributed by Antonio Joaquín Franco Mariscal of IES Javier de Uriarte, Cádiz, Spain, and María José Cano Iglesias of the University of Cádiz, Spain. You must spell the names of 25 cities and towns of England shown in the map by using the symbols of the elements of the Periodic Table and isotopes of hydrogen provided in the clues. (Some symbols may need to be used more than once in a clue.) Please send your answers to: the Editor, Education in Chemistry, the Royal Society of Chemistry, Burlington House Piccadilly, London W1J 0BA, to arrive no later than Monday 7 December. First out of the editor’s hat with all the correct answers will receive a £50 HMV token. 1. _ _ _ _ _ _ R _ (fluorine, boron, deuterium, oxygen, radium). calcium, nitrogen, sulfur, tungsten, oxygen, uranium, phosphorus, yttrium, tritium, thallium). 2. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (praseodymium, nitrogen, oxygen, 15. LEE _ _ (sulfur, deuterium) tritium, einsteinium). 3. MA _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (carbon, helium, nitrogen, erbium, sulfur, tritium). 4. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ L (oxygen, phosphorus, lithium, erbium, vanadium). 5. _ _ _ _ _ (erbium, boron, deuterium, yttrium). 6. _ _ _ _ E _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (oxygen, tritium, potassium, nitrogen, sulfur, rhenium). 7. _ _ L _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (tungsten, hydrogen, vanadium, oxygen, americium, nitrogen, erbium, phosphorus, tritium). 8. _ _ _ LE _ (deuterium, uranium, yttrium). 16. _ _ _ _ _ _ EL _ (helium, fluorine, iodine, deuterium, sulfur). 17. _ _ _ G _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H _ LL (uranium, oxygen, nitrogen, sulfur, potassium, indium, phosphorus, hydrogen, tritium). 18. _ _ _ _ _ _ G _ _ _ (titanium, nitrogen, September PRIZE WORDSEARCH No. 47 winner hydrogen, oxygen, tritium, americium). The winner was Matt Cowie from Mintlaw Academy, Aberdeenshire. 19. LE _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (sulfur, iodine, tritium, erbium, cerium). The eight-letter word was sunlight. 20. _ _ _ E _ _ R _ (vanadium, cobalt, tritium, 9. _ _ _ M _ _ G _ _ _ (indium, boron, hydrogen, americium, indium). yttrium, nitrogen). 10. _ _ A _ _ _ G (deuterium, rhenium, indium). 21. _ _ R _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (oxygen, hydrogen, tritium, nitrogen, phosphorus, americium). 11. _ _ _ _ _ _ L (bromine, oxygen, iodine, tritium, sulfur). 22. M _ L _ _ _ _ E _ _ _ _ (sulfur, nitrogen, neon, 12. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (phosphorus, oxygen, thorium, nitrogen, sulfur, uranium, tritium, americium). iodine, tritium, yttrium, oxygen, potassium). 13. _ L _ _ _ _ _ _ (thorium, uranium, phosphorus, molybdenum, yttrium). 24. L_ _ _ _ _ (nitrogen, oxygen, deuterium). 14. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ E _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (neon, 8 InfoChem_Nov09.indd 8 Find the element no. 10 winner and solutions The winner was Nye Farley from Monmouth School. Clues 7 and 8 were given in the wrong order. 1 n i t h a l 5 l 6 i u m 2 3 p o t 4 s u 23. _ _ _ _ _ (oxygen, tritium, nitrogen, lutetium). 7 25. _ _ R _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (polonium, molybdenum, 9 m a g n e s i 8 a l u r y s f e r m i o d s u a o g e n r o g e n i u m r d n n i u m thorium, uranium, sulfur, tritium). Download a pdf of this issue at: www.rsc.org/EiC 19/10/2009 11:30:54
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz