Using Landscape Theory to Measure Learning Difficulty for Adaptive Agents.

"! #$%&'#$(
)*,+
#%-./10235456&8739453:
;=<?>A@CBEDGFIH?<?JK>#LMONP>AFQFIRSB.TU2VOWX=WSYZ?V[W6LMO\ZO>E]^JKJK_
`bacKpQd$nowxeQiAfhkjgjytiAnzg|k={lhcm.}~noi.lIpIsm.piIqrkEi.sKeQpIsm.ktnogjytd$m.c i.pug
v 2. QfIogjcKplug8
lhsKphkEsKpQmAnytmAcI?aK K8
6,pQuno~wx2iGkj,a&ytQnol3gK{KqPhcKi.}¢e h¡:s,kt/nogjmEd$£Qnoi.¤xpu sg p
K82¦¥ i8sK[v =wxiKQ§pQp:§kj¨ScKk8 ¡:© h. ª u8
uuxxK,«S¬x,~
®sp¦¯±sK°.¸Q².sK³,eh´ gjµKno²wx¶ is©p¤i.dpug±sKnopuy±{nopukjgji8iAsKkjzi.ª^·yºgjci8kj¸¸¹nopytdiAgtsgjno»hpIno¤d$y.nS¼AeQnpIs¤(ktgjnonogjm.y½fQm.s,fQkjd¾o{:fQi.sm.gjcKnowxpQi±cd$kjiAno·msytkEiA¸OgtKgjno¿pQ£I¤Kny.y
dd¾fQs.{PyºgÂkjgti.kEÀ2sfI¸hnzkji&ics&eIgjmGno£Idcnosm.Ii¢kj¨SiA·iAg|s·kE¸$i.i.sKp¾¤¸IsKnznoÁ?pQiAyºgkji.opui8g/skjehpIkjncpIÏ¤iA¸Id$nzÃ$y[m.gjfIc(oogi8{usxkjpO8Ä·(sp £Q¸hiAytkjm8i~sKgjeS£Qi(i¢nosKy¢¤cKiApQp2ig
·kji.s8eh{kji.cyt}½i.pukji.geh¸Ikjnzi.Ã$yti.m.pufIgjonog~pQeh¤Åkjsc¨Qoi8oi.sd$kjpIy.npIÆP¤¦c8eh·kjiAcwx¨QiAoi.k8dkjfQu·(¤¤K£Ii8iA¸IkjpIiri.£Iyty~n¤Kn£Qy¢z{pQckjgfQ¸h¤Knz¤kji8i.¸mAgjÄzs{Åp d$¸hyti8m8ssKyteSfIi.ktyª
ÇpIs¨Qi.i~ytoiymA cc©d$p¹pQyºe ogji8s,i8skjsKkji±¸OpIgjIn£QpIs¦iÂ¤ehfQeIkjytc,kjiA»2cK}CfQ¨Q{oopQi.noy(iAd$ytpQy½yri.cKnoi8p6}2¸hgji8sK£h¸Op¹kj i.i~nopI¸I}ÈcnzÁ?kjdiAkjsi.gjpunogOcd$p6iAi.gtm.kjcKnom.pQy?c}ÈdcKk½{¹i.¸IyºgjcKnoddsKsnogjp[nopQ ¤Ç kji¦fI¤i.¤KdÅi8¸hª ª
eIfInoytkjibnom8gjs£Iooi.{ÉytibiAwd$siAfQgtskjnogjm.iy$gjgj£QciiAsK»hÏeQnonzsKg|no{ÉpÊceQ}§sKi8yºgsKmEkj£i.ytd$fQziGgjgty3kjnytm$£Qgjc8cb·(noeIpQkj¤i.¸Igjno£ mAs,g¦g:kjfIeh¤kj¤Kci8Ï¸IiApId$i.ytyy$gjsK£QpQs¸ g
{hsK¸Qnoi.sK¸ehgji8nowxÀuif soi8OskjkjiApI·npIs¤$kE¸:sK¤K·(i.£Ipui.g8p m.cd$eIoiAgji.z{i.skjpQi.¸:{Inoi.¸¸hnoÁ?iGkji.pug=ehkjcKËIgjy(gjcsp
Ì ÍQÎ§ÏSÐ?ÑÒ¾ÓÔ½Ï?ÕjÑ§Î
DGÖ@ÄVãVÉ<OU2YYDU2Uu@CB$ÞSV ×6@CU2Y:DEHODG@CäJK>GFI@CYV?Ø?ÜåHSÙÄJKDGY@@CD.V?BbBÜÚ/Û,DGBEZOFZ[YÛ.ÙC<ÉJKZ?UhÙÈUhUu>GDAB#V@ÄßIÙC<?JKJ6UhFu>GàáHOVOUx@ÄDA×IV?FF2Ü¹æUI@ÄçÛ8VÝD$DG<OUh@CVÉU2VâDbJKUÛ@CBKFhÛÚ&V?FhFhYFIHSYH?DA@C@ÄÙCYÛJ,ÞÝÛ@CäFhJK@CVQVQV?DGß ÜâJ@CÞ >G@FID.DKBV?Ú[YUhH½VÝJJ>GVQUh]^DÅWOFh>AU2@CBÅYHSDA@CUhVQ@ÄVOßIDGJÛ,JJè>AU2JKÜIFuBEDGJßhJVQJKW D>
DGßx@CUhY:ÙÄZOJIJ:M FhÖ Vé]§@CBEVSZ[]^FhÛ.<>AYUÊUuDGÛK@CUhFhBGVJhÚÜIUhDG<O@ÄV?JÉJWU2ÜhDAJK<?VQ>GD:FIZ?Y3ÜhZO<BjDbÙÄJU2Y>AV?UhRh@CV?JÜèUUhVODG>.WUhWSDA<?JKF2JæêBE<OØ½FhJ,>GDjDEàPë|DGJJJ>AVY5DAÛ,<?FQJBjDÅÙÄFI@CV?VOÜ2Û,ë|Z?DG>AJK>A>GJKY W
DG@ÄU2V<?ÜhJ¦JKÜIVQU2YD¦DG<?UhÛÛ.JKUh<?>GVÉ@C@CV?V?JKÜ¦J¦BEDG@ÄÙÄV?@CJY]Û2Fh>AUu>AV?DAY@ÄJVOU2ÜDADG<?@CÙÄFhJ:@ÄDGV:JKUh>AU2YU2Ø½DGFhFhZ?Z?ZS>AVQDJÅD¾DGUh<OFhB§J]§DGÙCà=<?JKJFIU2>A>GíGV?ÙÈî,W±@Cï/V?M2ðÄÜ¹ìrñuòG<?VOó2@ÈJôBJKõöñ2DGW?>.÷OJKUhøEWWSíAî,JKDAï½F2F¹æðÄñ2H?õù@È>AôºBFSó2DjôWS× õöZOñ2H?Û÷Ý@CÛKJ:U2ô|UhòGÙCÙÄóhVÉ×$úI@ÄíA>AYñEJ,ûý]^H?JK>G>A>AüFuþ2JKßhÿ|WJKM YÖDG]¢FÅJUhVQ@CVV D
@Ä@DÅV BEH[<?JKFI>EZ?]^FIÙÈW>GYÙÄJU2U2V[>AÛ,VÂJhM[ÚL@ÄDFuà=ÛKU2JKßhVJ>DA<?ÚSYJVU2R WS@CJKV?ÛÜ@CW?DGJ6<O@CàB<?JKJBEDGDG<?@CYJK>:U2DGDGJ3FÝ>GÙCJ JKUhZO>GV@Ä>AJKFhBr>DAÚ¢<OYUuD¦FI>GU2J6VÉÜhUhJWOVOU2JHS>.U2DA@ÄÙCßIÙÄ×IJÚ~U2àÜI<OJVQU2DD
RQÙÄJVOU2Fu>AàVÂM BGFhYJDG<?@CV?ÜÉU2Ø½FhZ?DDG<OJb>GJKÙCU2DG@CßhJbWS@ bÛ,Z?ÙÄDj×âF2]rDG<OJ¹H?>AFhØ?ÙCJYB$@ÄD:ÛKU2VÛ.<?F FQBEJDAF
U2H?H?Ö ÙCV@CJKW:DG<ODG@CF3BUÅHOHOUhH[U2>GJKDG>K@ÈÚÛ,Z?àPÙÈJèU2>=W?U2JÜhYJKVQFhD(VOBEÙÄJDG>.U2Uu>ADAV?J6@ÄVO<OÜ$FuH?à >GFIYØ?ÙCJ,JDGY>A@ÈÛÚhB3VOUh]^>GYFIJYýÙC×ÙCDGUh<[VOUuW?D§BAÛFhUh]±H[UhJ6VbDGU2<?ÜIJKJFhVQ>AD(×ÙÄJÛU2Uh>AV V?@CV?Ø½ÜJ
DG<?Z[JU2ÙCH?@Dj>A×b@ÈÛ,JKFhB]FhBGFh][ÙC@CZSVSDA]^@ÄFhFI>AVOYBPUuDGDA<O@ÄFIU2V3DÙCÜI@ÄFQJ$FSV?W?JBKU2M >ÙJUhCUhÛ.VO<èW?F2BADGÛ<OUhJH[>Jrà@ÈB(@ÄDGU¦<?àP@CVÉUx×$BEFIFhY][J¾>AJDAH?Fh>AH½JKFhBGJÙCFhVQÜIDG×h@CV?M Ü¾åDGJ$<?JØ[>AJKJÜhÙÈ@CUuVèDA@ÄØ ßI× J
J,WSU2ÞSVOJKH?BAWãÛ,ÙÈU2>AY@Ä@CØOV3J,@ÄV?DADA>G<?Ü$@ÈJKÛFIBGBbZ?J#]^>(>AFhJKHO>èBGUIZ?UhBjÙÄD=BADABEBKà=JM BGFI?BG>GFI@ÄR3VOÙÄÙCÜFhFuV:àDA<?@CDGV?J<?Ü¦@CJ¾>èDGH?<?>G>AZ?@ÈFhBÜIØ?ÚIÜhà=ÙCJJJWSYV?H?JKU2>GBAVOFuBKß WÚ&@ÈWSUhFhJH?>6H[BEW?FIJ@ YU2bÙSJ#Û,DAZOFØOÙUhDjU$×IÛ.H?R M ÜI@ÈåÛ8>GDAFIFhJÉZ?>AVO@CDGUh<OWÙOJFIWSVêVJBGJKÙCÛUhY:>GVO@CHOHSW?@ÄDGBA>A@CÛ@CFhÛKUhV:U2H[ÙCDAJÙÄ×F B
DGJWS<?ßu@CBAU2JÛ,BEÙCZ[ZOJBGUuYBGDA@ÄJ#VOJ,DAÜ:Dj>GàP@ÈFIÛFH?B§H½YÛFhU2J,>GV:DADG>GZ?J,@ÈÛV?ÞSBKH?@ÄDGÚSÙÈ@CWSU2JK@C@ÈBPVBjDA]^FI>GFh@C>rZ?Ø?>&]^ZSZSHODADG@Ä>GFIZOJKVb>GßQJ$@CF2FhàP]~Z[FhFIB>AHS>GR/DGJ@CM BEYZ?ÙÄUDABKUhM VOåW¹JUhZSÛ,FIDGFSVOÛ,Û,FIÙCZO>GWS>AJJÙÈUuØ DA×@ÄFIBGVÂZ?ÚhYUhYVOW¹U2>ABG@Ä<?äKFu@ÄV?àéÜ$<?UhFuVOà W
Ó Ð[Õ ÂÕEÎ ÝÐ[ÕEÔ Ô ~ÒÓ ÐOÎ¾ÕEÎ ÂÐ AÑ§Ð Î¾Ô
Ö@ÄVSVÊ]^FIFh>GZ?Y>U2HODG>G@CFhJKVÉßQ@CFhÜIZ[FQB$FSW?à=BFIDG>GFRU2ü ÿV|Ú~Z?à=V?R J¹V?BEFuDGàZ[WSVÝ@ÄJÛWåFhVODGBG<?Z?J¹YH?J>G>¦FIH½Ø?FhÙCJH?Y*Z?ÙÈUuF2DA]#@ÄFIU2VÂVÊM±UhìrWO<?U2@ÈHSB¦DAUh@ÄßIÜhJbJKVIU2DÅÜhJKUhVQÛ,DDGJKBEWÝJKÙÄUhÙC@ÄB¦VOÜU
DG]^Y:JK<OUuFIU2DAV?D3Z?Fh>ADAH½J¾<?FhJ¹FhÙC@È]~BjÙCJKDrDGUh<OU2>GJÅVOV?WUh@CV?ÜhàrÜÝJKVIUhUhDB§ÙÄMSÜI@ÄìrVQFhDA>A<?J@J$DA>A<?JKUhYBEW?DGJKUhWöHSU2DG@CY@CV¹ßhF JÅYJU2Ø[U2ÜIUÞ J@CVQYü uD @ÄÿºäKB=Ú@ÄVOUW?JKÜWSÛ,@@È@ÄD.BG>ABr@ÄJKFIÛ,Û,V6D:Z?Y3H?BGJK>AZ?UhFhÙC>AØOU2Û.ÙÄDG<ÊJK@CYßhYJ#@ÄHOJ,V DA>Gßh<?F FIFS?ÙÄWßIDKMJKWbàPBGJÅUIJBÙCUhJKBAUÛ,BGDGZ?@COV?YÞ ÜJJKWWU
HOY:U2FS>GWSDG@ÈJKÛ,ÙÂZ?F2ÙÈU2]>=Û,FIH?VO>A@CBEÛZOJ¾Y:BAJKÛ.<?>JKH?WS>AZOJ,ÙÄ]^JJ>ADGJF:V[Û,ÙÄJJKU2BK>AM?VÂìrÚI<?àJ<OBEJ$J>ABAJÛ.<?DG<?JK@ÈWSBrZOBGÙÄJÛ.<OBJKU2WS>AZ?JÅÙCJ¾BGZ?BGYJ>AYßhJU2Wb>A@ÄUhäKJKB=W¹U2Vè@ÄVU2ìH?U2H?Ø?>AFxÙCJ ÞS@ÄhMYU2DGJ
Í³´ 2² 2³° achpQ°8ytµfI³ d$/iA² kjye s.{s:ËI»hi8¸6ehkjnmAi ¾}ÈcKkÅsKm.mAi.yty
fh³ kjÈµi ¥ fIp [¸Iµ onopQ¤
gjac$cpQsKoyt fId$iAs,kjktygjnoeQm.os8i.{Êy. sËI»hi8¸ÊeIkjnom.i }Ècki8smG£
nopQi.sk kjnom.nopI¤
saktcgjpQnom.ytofIi#d$eQiAfIkjkjyÂmE£ e ss.yt{¾i8¸Osr ytfQÏytmAkjnoeIgjnocp¦}Ci.i [usocpQ¤
¿·cªeQsktg=¿/s,kjnoÁ
·(anocgjpQ£ytfIs¾d$ËQiA»hkji8y¸£ eIs8kjwxnoim.i s:mE}C£QcKck=nom.i8isKmE¨S£iAgs,·ktgji.ni.mApi sbeSiGktª
¡:nz»Ii.¸ ¥ fIp ¸IonopQ¤
saktcgjpQnom.ytofIi#d$eIiAkjkjnom.yi e s.{bsp s¸eIs¦kjnoÏm.ifQpQ¸IoiP}ÈcehkkjngjmA£Qi iËQkjyºg
¥ ocum kjnmAnpI¤
`
sdktsKgjnonom.pQonoi.pQy ¤Åsktgjnom.oi.y. G~sp ¸És` eIkjnom.i }CcKk¾kjiAª
cKpQonopQi8s,k kjnom.nopQ¤ `
aktcgjpQnom.ytofIi d$j iAkjy½eQs.{#s(¸InzÁ?iAkji.pug[eIkjnom.i I}Èck±i8smG£
s
c}ÄkE}SsKÍnomA¯pQgjmAnocKkji.p sKyt¶cKno}(¿pQ¤eS£QnocKm.y~gjcKiAgEd$p2sK¨QgjeQnoosi(iA¢»heIm.nzkjg|cKiA{upQyti.yt¡:fIpugjd$cKy~kjiAi&gjk#£ImAi§ytcfId$eQkjseIeQkEosfIiAd$»y#iAyt¨2mEgj{biA£Qkji8ËIy~¸hgtcKfQgj}OnopIi.yty~¤nz»ÅsK¸hoeIoi.c8kjd·ânom.sKnopIs=pQ¤¸¹eIkjytd$c2mG£I¸Ici8fIkj¸Ii$m.fIiAeIkÂiAkjgjy.i.cPum.cKnom.ytkEsKi.¸heIz{uiAgjkj[fhnokj¨QpQi(fh¤#gsPnopÅ¤Kkji8kjgjÀui.iAsfQkjgjd$nziAkjiky
ocKpQ¤iGk=gjc¾i.skjp[QytnopQm.irgj£IiA{£ s8wxird$ckjire s,kEsKd$iAgjiAkjy.
!
&%
'
#"
+*
$
(
)"
,
- /. 0.214365 /748#9:;<8
K
>=?8 @8
-
H
G
/.DC E.<F1
ML
N$OPL
]
e
G
N
QL
H+OPL
TS G
IH
J
L
G
AB8
QL
L
OPL
OVU
L
O@^_^_^_O`Lba
,YPU[ZJ,\
f;D8,g
WL
RH
L
XU
Lc
Xd
?H×Q@C>GJF ÙÈ?WSD(JJ$WH½]^J<?FI>§@ÄZ?ÜIH½VO<?JWJ>A>@CDAF <OH?W:Uu>GFIFDÅ?VOBEDAÛ,@CB#YJH[ÙCH?JKJKÙCUhJ>#>GV?H[BGÛ.JJK<OW±>GJK@CM FSWSWZ?ÙCFIUuJK>G]ùBJDAJà=Û>#FhJKYÙC>GJKJ$UhH?ÙC>GÙCJKV?J,UhÞ:@C>GV?VOBAÜ[Û.JKM <?WJWSYJZ?FhÙC>.>AJKU2J$BVDAJKFQJUIÞ FIBE@CH½RÙÄ×IJÙC>AÚOFh@CØ?V?Y:Z?ÜIJKJD¾VQ>× DADAB#@ÄFJKÛÙCÙÄW?FhJJKYU2W>AHOVÂÙCU2FuÚu>Aà=Ø?@CV?ZSJKÜ D>
DGU2<?VOJrW:H½]^FIJ>GZ?]^VOFhW>AYDA<OUhVOUuDPÛ,JPY:F2FS]/WSBEJK@ÄÞ3>AU2WSDG@ÄJKæ/ÙÄ×J>AÛ,JFIVQY:D&H?HO>GÙÄJ@ÈÛ,Þ3@CV?DjàPÜÅF2BGÛ.ëºHO<OU2JKWS>.U2Z?YÙCJKJB DGJUÅ>&BGBAUhÛ.<?Y:JKHOW?ÙÄZ?JPÙÄJ@CB&B&BGDA<?JFuVOàWSJV3W@ÄV DGF3H[@ÄÜIJKZ?>E]^>AFIJ >GY
#"
#"
#h
R%
,
0(
GDØ[F2<?]&JJBjU2DP>G>ADG@ÄJV¹@ÈÙÈÛ,UuÙCDGDAJK<?@ÄB ßIJ¦J$BE H[<?FIJK=>E>EDA]^D§<OFIDG>GUuFYDYDAUh<?VOJJ$Û,WSJ$@ÄH?ZO>AFhY3FS]WSëºDA>AZO<?Z?Û,JVÂJKWS>#ÚQ@ÄàÛ,æ/FI<?JZ?>AJJÙC>AW6VQJD¾F2ÙCJKæ/BAUhÛ.J>G<?>V?JK@CàrWSV?ZOUhÜBrÙÄJ@ÈB(ßuBUhYÛ.>G<O@CFQJKUhBjW±V?DPM Üh@ÄJYBH½UhFhBr>GDADAU2<?VQJDDAM F2Ö DAV¹UhÙÂUIW?V WSZ?@ÄYDG@CØ½FhJVÂ> Ú
U2ìrH?<?H?J#VÙC×ÉWSJ,WSD.UhJU2ÜhÛ,@CJK@ÈÙCBEB¦VI@CD¦FhF2VÝ]§DG<[DGDGUu<?<?DÅ@ÈJKB$Fh<O>AU2Uh×6>AWÉJ3DADGFWS<?@ÈJBAWSÛ,BEJ,ZOJDABAJÛ,BE>AZ?JY:WÉ>Aßh@CV?@CJVJ:BÚ½àFIàZ?<?<?>Å@ÈÛ.@ÈH?Û.<<Ý>AJBAàPß Û.<?@ÄJ:FIJKZOWSÛKB¾U2ZOÙCÙÄà=ÙJ3FIÙÄJDG>GFU2RÊ>ABEV?ü JK,ÿ@ÄÙÄVOºJç½Ü¹Û8JD$H?BGBGUu>AJFD$VQOJDAÙCßI@CJKUhJBKÙÄ>AÚ±ÙC××hÛ,Ú±FI@U2DAZ?JVåÙC>.WUuU2DGDGÜI@C<?JFhJKVQV~V D M
YBEJKZOÙÄJBEÛ8D3DÛ,DGFI<OYJ¦HOFIU2V?>AJÅJDGDG<[<?UuJ¹D#J,× ÞS@ÄJKH[ÙCJWOÛ8BPDADGJK<?WJ$Û<?Z?@CYÜh<OZ?JKÙÈUuBEDrDA@ÄHOßI>GJF H??>ADAFBK?M D.B$ÜIUh@ÄV?JWå]^>GFIY JUhÛ.<BAÛ.<?JKWSZOÙÄJbUhVOW
J,F2ÞS](H?DAìrÙÈ<?U2J3<?@CVJBA>AÛ.J<?JKU2W?>AZ?JFhÙÄVODjJàPJ¦B¾FbBAÛ.Û.<[H?<?U2>AJKV?FhW?ÜIØOZ?JKÙÄÙÄBJKJ¾YUIFhB#BZSDADAà<?H[@J:JKDA<É>EVQ]^FIZODA>G<?YY@CBÅØ½BPJUhU2>ÅH?V?H?F2Fh]§>ADGFI<?UhUhJK>EÛ.>KDA<~@CÚIÛMOFhÙÄJìr>PBà<?@ÈJ< B×JßuÞSUhDGH[>G<?@CJKJ¦JK>GW±@C>GYMJKÙC?JU2VQFIDG@CDA>¾ßhB¦J#JU2Þ?H½Ø½U2JFuY>Gßh]^H?FhJÙC>AJhW?YÚ[F¹U2Djà=V?VOFhÛFhJDë
HO×hJ,U2Dè>GD§ÙÄJD.U2U2>A>A@V?æ@CV?U2ÜÊVOWbH?>AY:F W?@ÄÞSZOJKÛ,WJK>AØOB6Z?VOUhÛWSÛÙC@Ä>GVOZOÜ3JKWã× @C<?JÙÈ@CWÜh<?DGJK<?>¹JÅH?BAU2>AFYOJ#DAB6H?>AH[F JK?>6D.B§U2ZO>GDGVO@ÈÛ,WSÙCJJÝ>PàH½J@ÄDG>G<ê]^JKÛ8DjDrà=@CFhVSë|]^HOFhUh>A>EYDUuD.DGU2@CFh>A@V~æ Ú
DGBG<OÛ.<?UhJVWSàZ?ÙC@JKDAB&<<[Y:Uxßh@ÄÞSJJKWSW@Äæ½Ø?JKZO>GVOJKVIWSD(ÙC@ÄV?ÙCJKÜ6Uh>GàVO<?@ÄV?JÜ$V HO>GF OÙÄJ
B&U2
OVOMOW:ìrà<?@È< B×ÙÄJYUhW?@ÄÞSBJKZOWBrØ?DAZ?F¹V[WSUhBGÙÄ@CR¹V?Ü Ø½F2B&DAH½<J>Gà]^Fh<Q>A×6YDGU2<OVOJKÛBGJJ
J,àWSÞSJ<?H?H½JÙÈJ>AU2VOJ#@CWOV?àPB¢@ÄVOJ#ZOÜBEH[JKDGFI<?JV @ÈDGBÂ<O@ÈU2B±ÚD§DAà<?DjàP<?>AFhJF2Z?>AëºJKÜIHOUI<U2B±>GU2DjDVàPDAUhF2U2>GëºHOHO@ÄH[æ6U2J>G<OU2DÂUIÙ2DAB§DAUhF#U>G@ÄH?æ BG@È@CÛ8V?B¢DAÜhFhH½ÙC>AJJ@C>GUh<?]^Ù2Fh@C>GÙÄ>AÙ|JKYÚIH?à>AUhJK<OVOBGJÛ,J>AJ=VQJKDABEUhJKU2B(JDG@CYY:FhVOB~@ÄÞSBKVOJKÚ,F2WBED~Z[Ø?DAÛ.ZOFO<VOMUh¾WSB ÙCV?@ÄV?J§@CÜ3ÜhàrZ?<OUx>AUh×¦J B§F2?U ] Ú
ÙCU2Uh>A>GJKÜIU J[H?@ÄVÉÙÈUuDGDA<?JKJ:U2Z~ÙCUhM VO¾BW?BAÛUhH[@ÄV[J3Û,@C>AB¾JKUh@ÄVQBGDAJK>GBKFSÚIWSDG<?ZOJÅÛJKBEW±@CäÚ[J¦DG<OF2J]~>ADGJ<?Ø @È×èBrH?DG< ÙÈUuàPDGUhJ>EU2DAZb@ÄVOÜIÜ¹>GFuU2à#VÝBKUIÚIW?UhVOU2H?W¹DGBG@CßhFJUUhÙÈÜhU2J>AVQÜhD¾JDG [<OU2U2DD
JYH?ÙCFu× BU:<?@CÙCÙëtÛ,ÙC@ÄY3Ø?@CV?ÜY:JDG<?FSW±M
B]ÊFhY>$U2#VÙÈÙCU2ÙÂ?>AßuÜhFhU2JDGÙC<?Z?ßuJKJUh>¾BrÙÄZ?Û,F2FIJ] BÅY:F2H?Ú?]ÙÄ@ÈH[:ÛJKU2MÂ>EDG]^@CìrFIFh>GV<?YJ@ÈUhB#Û,VOFhDAÛ,<?VJÅjJJKFhÛ8V VDAZ?Z?Y3Y>.U2Ø[FIÙ(JKBED#>U2>ABGFhÜhÛ.]§ZO<OÛ,Y:JKFhWSJKV[Z?VQBEÙCD¦Z?JKB#Y@ÈB¦@CJKBrDG>A<OÙCB FuU2à=D$JKÙC@C> UhV>G^ÜIH½DAJ<?JJ>ßuU2ÛH½FhÙCFhZ?VOH?JKBGZOBÅZ?ÙCYFhU2DG]J@CFh> §VÂMDGDG<OJ?V[UhFIWV >
DGÛ,FFhV[GBEBGZ?YYF JKF2>&DGH?<ã>GJFI]^ZSJ>AD JåVODAÛ<?JKBKJÉM ¢ÙÈU2@CVOÜhW?ZOBA>GÛJ Uh¦H[JBE<OØ Fu×à#BH?Uh>GV3FSWSJZ[Þ?Û,U2@CYV?ÜH?ÙCUâJPFhY][FhDA<?>AJè@ÈBZO]^FhV?>@]^DGFI<O>GJY FhV?WSJ@ÈBjëºDAWS>G@C@CYØ?ZSJVODA@ÄBGFI@CFhVãVOF2Uh]Ù
ÙÄ<?@CV?JÙCJKHSUh]^>§Z?ÙH?>AUh@ÈB#Û,@CUV?Üß @ÈH?BE>AZ[FhU2Ø?ÙC@ÄÙCäJUuY DG@CFhUhVB Uh@CW±U2ÚOVOØ?WZSD¾@ÄUhD>G@ÈJBßxV?UhFh>GD@CJKHOWÂU2Mh>GìrDG@È<?Û,@ÈZOB(ÙCUhDj× >GÙCH½×bJ>AF2@ÄÜI]±FhH?>A@ÈFhÛ8ZODAFhBK>AÚ?@CU2UhVOÙ[WUh>GÛKÜIU2Z?V?YV?JFhVQDD(Ø½@CJB
JKF2Uh]BGà@CÙÄ<Q×è×bU2DGH?<?H?JÙCBE@CJKJÅW6H?DG>AFFhØ?]^ÙCZOJVOYÛ8DAB@ÄFIUhVO>GJ$B#WSà@Ä@Äæ½DGJK<>GJKYVQFhD#>A@CJÅBrDGV?<[JKU2JKVèWSJDjW±à=M F@CV?H?Z?DABKM YFh>AJ$H?>AJKÛ@CBGJ$YJKUhBGZ?>AJ
ÙÄÙÄJKJYU2>AV?@Ä@ÄBGVVO@ÄV?ÜDAÜ¦<?H?JDA>G<?F YJrOÙCÙÄUhJhJV U2M × >AÖ V?V[Û@ÄBjVOUIDAÜ¾JKBEJUhH?B3WÂ>AÚOàF @Ä[<OD¾ÙÄJJPY>ADGJè@ÄF$ÜIUh<QWSVDJDG<OUIJKUxW?>GßhYU2J3HS@CV?DABE@ÄFIJ#ßIY:JUJHOU2>GÜhBAFIU2JKØ?YVQÙÄDJKH?Y WSÙCJF B&JH?B>AÛFhFhV?ØOYF2ÙÄJKH?DYÙCJ,<OBKÞSUxÚ[@ßIDjUhJ¹×VO@CDAWB&<?Uh@CV?BÙCJKBGJKÛF¦WFhU¦YDAH?FbH?>AÙCZOFhJ,Ø?DABGJJ ë
DG<?JBEJÅDAFÛFhYHOUh>GJ¦ÙÄJU2>AV?@CV?ÜH?>GFIØ?ÙCJYBWS@C>GJÛ8DGÙC×hM
HDG?<?>GJKF FhOÖ V>AÙCJ(×hMFI@CB¢>AWSJZOJK@ÄDG>¦Û.<O<bDGJF>~Fh]±ZOJKDGV?BE<?DG@Ä@CV?J¦Y]^Fh>GUuJ>ADGÛ,YJJKU2VIDADGD=<?@CßhJbà=J(FIWSFI>G@ R:b>~V?FhÛ,FhZ?VbDÙÄDjÙÈUxU2×ÉßuV[U2F2W?@C]BGÙÈU2ÛKUèØ?U2H½ÙCÙÄJhJJ#ÚKU2à=DA>A<?V?J§J@CV?W?FIÜ6>A>GUx×:HOàâ<O>GFIFhUhØ?V$B§ÙÄDA>AJKUhJKY5RhBGZ?JKàVbÙÄDA<?BÂH?JK]^ÙÈ>GVÝUhFIÛ,YDAJ¾<?àJÙÈU2@ÙÄDAV[J<?W?U2@CBG>AVbÛKV?U2DG@CV?H½<OÜJJ
H]^?Û,FhFh>G>(VQFIØ?DAU¦J,ÙCHOJÞ YU2D>GF2DG@C@È]PBrÛ,ZODGDA<?F¹ÙCUhJb>#Û,FIDG! <?VOJKMBEFhDG$>A>AZO¾J,DGÛ8Z?@ÈDÛ>&UhÙÈU2HOÙ(V[>GBjFIW?DAØ?ZOBGÛKÙÄWSJKU2×YáH½JKF2@ÈB]rB&FhÜhWS]&J@æ/VOßxJJ,Uh>ADG>GJ@È× ÛVQ@CDV?U2ç2ÜbÙCà=ÜhWSFIJ@>GbUI@ÄDGBG<OÛ,BGZ?YZ?ÙÄYDjB ×¹JP"DA! DGF¹<OBU2BGD&J8>ADGM ßh<?JÖ JVâUhÙÈU2B#DGVO<?Ø[WO@ÈBJKBGVOÛKÛÛ.U2UI<?H½BEYJIJ Ú±U2^DGDG>A<?<ORSJJB
ÙÄ@CJB¾U2WS>AJ,V?DA@ÄJVO>AÜ¹Y:H?@CV?>AFhJØ?WÙCJØQY×Ú/U2FhV>¦JDAÞQ<?DAJ3J>AYVOU2UhÙ~H?H?H?>G@CV?FSÜ¹ÛJK]^BA>AB FhYöBGZO@CÛ.V?<ÉH?Z?UhBDABÅDG<?F2J]=DGÛ<?FhJ:YH?H½>AFI@CBGÛ@J:DA@ÄBAFIÛ.V<?JF2WS]Z?DGÙC<?JJ3DAÛ,F6FhH?V[>ABEFZ?OYDAJKB >
H[UFIÙCH?UhZ?VOÙÈW?UuBADGÛ@CFhUhVH[¢JbUhàVO@ÄW:DG< FhZ?HO>%U2j>GFIDGØ3@ÈÛ,Z?@ÈBÙÈU2DG>F$]^Û.JK<OU2UhDG>AZ?UI>AÛ8JKDAB3J>AU2@ÄVOäKJ§WÊ<?ÛFuÙCàUh@ÄY<OU2@CV?>.WÜ@ÄDGD(<[@CUuBKDM&#DA<?U2JKDG<?BGJbJK>]^JDG<OUuDAUhZ?V3>GJÜIBJV?YJK>AU2U2RIDGJb@CV?@ÄÜ D
%
(
"
#"
"
#"
<
"
"
*
R*
$
b*
%
E(
"
*
#"
#"
>h
,%
@(
4(
%
%
" @(
1.8
noliear
1.6
twopar
’ mixed
1.4
block
1.2
pure
linear
AveragCumltiPof
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
1
10
100
1000
10000
Iteraions
1.2
noliear
’
block
twopar
1
pure
mixed
linear
0.8
’
’
’
’
’
AveragCumltiPof
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
1
10
100
1000
10000
gjs £Ip i[¸ ¶ yj sKd$¶ i.i8eIs, kjkjnopQÈm.kjnoi npQ¤K¤:£ug/m.PfIeIskjfIwxktkjgjiAi$noyrm.Ïo}Èi.fQcKy.kp ½¸hyt¿onzn»6£QpIi¾¤IeI[ytkjmGno·(m.£IiÅ£Qi8iA¸IytkjmEfIi3£QiAi8sy¸hfQm.sckjoi.ipIy ytfQ·(d$n£QpIiAiAi8pksk#e s:s.eh{hd$kjynom.cKnopQÅpQc¤I}ÈeScK?k$cK·(onsK£Iyºm.giAm.kjiAci¦ytÁ?y¾i8iAskjgjymGc¹£6sKso &ktgj8s,nom.ktogji$ùnmAoiA£QiA}CsKg y.y
g}CcK·k§ci8ªeQssmG£:ktg=sgEktsgjkjnom.nzÁ±oir eQ·(fh£QkjiGmGkj£Qi¦sKyts$i8¸?m.cKhpQd$ytfQno»hd$i8¸$iGkPÏeQfQs8p {h¸hy=ons$pI¤Iyt2fQ·(¨Qyt£QmGiGkjkjniehgjs¾nocm.pcKpQ}Èi.ytifId$[?iAk&eQom8fIsyPp:s$mE£QeScuiAcktªytsikt¨SgjnoiGm.g|o·iiAeIi.kjpnom.gji £Ii
}CeSehcKkjiGk~noktm.ª|i8nos,spQktmG¤Igj£Åno2m.·(coi¦} £IgjeIiA£Qkjkji¢i=nom.ËQgji £Ikj6yºiPg m.sK[cKp spQ¸ktytgjfQgjnom.£Id$oii.iGy~k&ÏeQfQe fIpQs.kj¸I{hmEoy£ i¾ss¾ehyt¸Ii8kj¸¦nonzm.Á?i siAp kji.¸ Spu¨Qgo ehcu}Èmkjcnom.k~i eIi8sKkjnomE½m.£¦no}CpIcKkj¤Ik(i.Sdi8·(ssmG£Qn£3pIiGnokjspQi¾kt¤rgjgjnos,£Qm.ktoiirgjnom.m.eIcKofIipQkjuytmEsfQ£ p d$sK¸¾ytiGi.pIkP¸OceQhpIs8¿{hnopI£Qy i8i s k`
s,s,»hktgjnnoy§m.onoiy( pheSfIiAd¦k§¨Sm.fIiAkyºgjcKc}Âd$nzgjiAiAk8kE sgjnocKpQy ùocK¤$ytm8sKoi (sKpQ¸3gj£Qis»hnoy§ny§s8wxiAkEs¤i#m.fId¦fQs,gjnwireIkjcËQg§eSiAk
Iteraions
.D3 g
]
K
Y
L
L
T\
]
K
H
d
Y
\
L
H
N
S
Y
T\
L
L
Lc
LinearPcgfovyCdN.w~U[1,20],k~U[0.0,0.7]
1.4
N=10,C=10
N10,C=100
N 0,C=10
=10
N=100,C=100
1.2
1
0.8
Profitpecnsumal
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
½¶ O¶ npIi8sk=eIkjnom.nopI¤ÅsKp ¸hytm8sKeSiAy(}CcKkPs¦ytdsKo 8 (sp ¸Äs,kj¤i 8K sKpQ¸ ¾
Price
.D3 Y
K
Fee
\
Y
\ J
ticle
Bundle
Price
Price
ticle
Price
£QwiAs8ktwx[{3i&¶ O¸Igj£Q¶nzÁ?i(¿iAyj·kjsKi.cKd$puªög8eQi§ sp2ktfQg~d¦gEs¨SkjiGnzÁ kÂcKùo}[iAe }Äg s±kEsKsp d$¸¾iAgjd$iAkjno»hy¢i8sK¸pQ¸¦¨QfIgjp £Q¸Ii§oyjnopQsK¤d$Èi(kjnc¤Keh£ugjg n±dss p eI¸Ikjytcm.sKËQeSg8Ki.y.gj£Q i.nzwxki.p¾sp gj¸I£Qytcm.fIsK¤eS£¦i.ygj£IsiAkj{i
Y
.D3 T\
Y
T\
SWBEJ@ bDABrÛF2Z?]ÙD]^ÚIJKU2àPDGJ#Z?>AàrJKU2BPVQDAD&<ODGUuF3D#Û.Y<OUhU2Rh>.UhJ$Û,UhDGJW?>AUh@CHSäJPDAU2DGDG<?@CFhJVè]^JKWSU2@ DGbZ?>AÛJKZ?B&ÙDFhM ]ÂJ,ÞS@ÈBjDA@ÄV?Ü$ÙÈU2V[W?BGÛKU2H½JKB=U2VOW:@ÈWSJVQDG@Ä]^×
RhJ×¹Ö >GVJBEDGZ?<?ÙÄJDAB]^FhÛÙCFhÙÄFuVOàÛJ@CV?>AV?Ü@CBGV?JKÜ3Û,DGÙÈU2@CFhV[VÂW?ÚQBGàPÛKU2JH½H?J¦>ADGFu<?ß JK@CWSFhJ#>A×hU3M Û,FIVIDAJ,Þ D§]^FI>(DA<?@CBPàPFh>AR/Ú2@CW?JVQDG@Ä]^× @ÄV?ÜBGFhYJ
Õ Ñ &Î¾Ò Ô
ÂÑ(Ð
ìrU2VO<?WÅJ§U2Û,>GFIDGVO@ [Û,JKÛHS@CUhD~Ù2Fh@ÄVQ]SDAUJÙCðÄÙÄóu@C÷/ÜhJKú VO.Û,óAJIïOM íP@C@ÄÜIB¢Z?Ur>G]öJU2YUh@CÙÄH?@ÈU2H½>¢JKU2FhÙÈV?B±J(H?@C@ÈV$Û8DAJFhßI>AFh@CUhÙCZSÙÄÙCDG×@CFhDAV[FU2DG>A<?×#J(Ø?Û@CFhFhVOÙCFhÛÜhJ×IHSÚ,DFhM H?ÊÙDG@CÈY:U2V[@CäKW?U2BGDGÛK@CU2FhH½VÂJ Ú
@CÙCBèUhVOß W?@CBABGÛZOU2UhH½ÙÄ@CJbäJÛ,WêFI>GUh>AJKBBGH½U FhBGVOZ?W?>GB¾]öUhDAÛFÝJÝUàBE@ÄFIDG< ÙÄZ?DGFh@CV?FhVÂJM Fh¾>èH?Y:DG@CFIY:>GJå@Cä@CH½V?JKÜÉU2RSUèBK]^Ú=Z?àV[Û8<ODGJ@C>AFhJVÊJ@ÈBUhÛ.ÛK<êUhBEH½DFhUh@CVQB$DèÙCFSFIÛVêU2DGDG@CV?<OÜJ
DG<?J<?@CÜh<?JBjDÅH½JKU2R/M±ìr<?@ÈB¦@CWSJU¹@ÈBÅBE@CYH?ÙCJhÚ/×hJD¦JÞQDA>GJKYJÙC×H[FuàPJ>G]^Z?Ù|M Ö D$U2ÙCÙCFuà#B¾U6à@CW?J
<"
"!
/
+
>AHOUhU2V?>GDGÜh@ÈJ:Û,Z?F2ÙÈ]rU2>BEÚÂJKJDAY<?J@ÄVOBEÜhJKÙCÙÄ×ÝJÛ8WSDG@È@CBGFhBGV @ÄYF2@C]ÙCUhU>$BEH?J>AD:FhØ?FhÙC]#JYH?>GB¦@ÈÛ,DGJFBAØ½Û.<?JbJKÛWSUIZOBjÙÄD$J6@CHOVåU2U>.U2Û,YFIYJ,DAY:J>.FIB$VÝDA<O]^>.UuU2DYYJKà=UuÞSFI@Ä>GYR/@CM äÖ JV B
H?>GF ?D@CB#J Z?@CßxUhÙÄJKVQDPDAF OVOWS@CV?Ü:DG<OJ$ÜhÙCFhØOUhÙ±H[JU2RbFh]U:H?>AF ?DÙÈU2VOWOBGÛKU2H½JhM
ìrñu<?ô JUhH?VO>G@CWâYDGU2<O>AFI×ÉBGJWS@ÈDGBj<ODA@ÄU2VOD3Û,DGU2@C>AFhJÉVò DG<OU2ID$í.ú2@CBÅM YUhBGW?YJ:F @ÈF2BÅDGØ½< J,ÙCDjUhàPVOJW?JBAVÛU2DGH½<OJFIBG@ÈJ:BÙÈFIU2V?V[JW?BGDGÛK<[U2UuH½DJKB¾@ÈBDG<[JUhUuBGD×ÉU2DA>AFJ
ñ

]^ÙÄUhFSJBAàêÛÛ,UhJÙIÙCV[FSFIW±ÛHSçSU2DGDGÙ½@C<OYFhJH?U?DGFhÚu@CH?YU2DGV[UO@CWYM F2U¹DA<?Û>AU2JZ?V>¢Üh]^ÜIØ½JKJKU2JWDGÙCZ?ÙÈF U2>AÛKJKV[UuB~W?DADGBGJK<[ÛKWU2UuH½DàJY@ÄDG@È<?UhBPFIRhFhZSJ=V?D¾@JD&Y3DGWS<OZO@ U2Û.Dr<ÛZ?ÛJ,FhÙÄæ/DVQFh]^DA>GFIUhDK>@ÄÚ[VOU¾UhBPVOÙCWSF Wè@ÈÛKBGU2DGÛÙ <OFhBEJVQJ>ADGU2J@CV >.U2Û.Z?<>A@ÄJÅDGU2@CJKDjÙCÜh× BKFIÚQH?>GY@C@ÄÛKDGU2Uh<?ÙCVQYÙÄ××
FhùDGHS<[DAUu@ÄY3D@CZ?BKYÚxFhM V?J§DG<OU2D@ÈBV?F2DU2Ø?ÙCJ§DAF¾BGJJ§DG<?JPJVQDG@C>AJ=ÙÈU2VOWOBGÛKU2H½J=UuDFhVOÛJ ÂDGF OVOW$DA<?JPÜhÙCFhØOUhÙ
DGDG<?F3JW?ìrJKÛ,BAFI<?Û,YJ>A@ÄH?V?Ø½ÙÄF2JJDAÞÝU@ÄFIBEÙÈVåU2×SV[BEFhDGW?]PJKBGYUÛKU2BÅ>AH½Z?ÛJ ÜhFhÜIB(YJKYYWÝUuZ?ÙCDAUhVO<?VO@JDjW?Y×IBAM ÛU2$U2DGH½@ÈUhÛJZSU2Ù[æ/<OH?YUh>ABUhFhV>GH½JJÛ,ü >GJDGÿ&@C@CßhJKàrJB(WÝUhàB¾U@ÄDGFh<6V?ÜI>GJ:>GJJUuF2BED$](H½JKDAWS<?Û,JKD(J UhDGÙ&OF:F2>.]BjUDÅUuBG>GJKDEJDAU2JBE>.JVQÛ.U2DG<b>.@CFhÛ.U2Vâ<?ÙCÜhJ@CFh>.V Bë
]^>GZ?Fh@ÄH DG><?J,$YÞSU2H?M ZSÙÈU2æ/ìr@CYV?<?@CU2J:V?V Ü¾ÛFhBV[VOUuÛ,ÛFIDGJZOVOHS>AÛ,DÅUhJKÙQHSàrBGDAUhJBÙCB¾JKUhÛ,FhVODG>AW6@C@ÄFhÜIUhVÂ@ÄVOH?M ~UhH?LÙÄÙCÙC×¹×Fh>.YH?W >AFhjFh@C>ARbH½JÅFIü Y2BGÿSJKUuWUhDGVO<OØ W J× Yh FIUuJKV?DA@CàPJKÛKBPUhU2ÙÄÙ±ü Ùh>Aÿ|@ÄÚuÜIUhFh>AY:@C>ÜhM FI<QV?DÜü FhÿDG(<?JKUh>AB¦BKÚU¹DG@CYÜh<QFSDGWSJKJV Ù
V?UhWJE@CÜhUI5Ù< Û,Ø½JÈVQFhU2Dr>AVO<?DGW?F FBAF ÛJW3UhUhH[Û.>AJ<6JÙÈUuF2Û,DGFhDG@C<OV[FhJBEV >@ÈBjMêD.B¹DG<OFh]$U2D(Djà=@ÄVOF W?@CÛ,ÛKFhUuYDGJH½B&FhDAV?<?JKJVQJDAÙCB JPYUhJVéVQD.FhB(Ø F2j]½JDGÛ8<ODG@CJßhJÝWSFh]^YZ?VOUhÛ,@ÄVDG@CFhF2V] DGÚ<OU2U2V[D=WéU2>AUJ
@C@ÄVQBPDG@CJKVOÜhWSJK@È>@CÛB¾UuDADGJJK<OÙCW6JJ3YØ ]^JKZO×VIVODGD.Û8<?BÅDAJÅ@ÄFhFIßh>$VÉJBGÛ8DG×QDA<[Y3FhUu> DØ[&FIU2ÙÄÚSVÝ@ÈÛ:àUh<?JÜhÙCJJKJ>AVIYJ D¦J@CVQB¦D.ÛB@CUhVQM V6DG JÛ@C>AVOFhJKVQÛBEJDADGUhJDGWÉ@Ä<?V6@È@CBÅVQVÝZO@CFIB$Y:HSUhJKDGV>G@CY@ÈÛ FI@ÄHSäK^J@ÄDGV?@Ä@CDGYÜ[<OM±@ÄJäìr>Uu<?>ADAJK@ÄJ3FIU2V@CÙÄV?ëºßxH?H?Uh>AZ?ÙÄFhZODÅØOJKFhÙÄWJK] YèFI> Ú
M YÖ V6rU2HO@ÈFIBPB¦Z?DG>@C<?VQH?J$DG>AF6>A@CJKÛDGBGJ,<?Z?ëtJBEÙÄJDA>AUhDEJKDAVI@ÄU2DV?ÙÈBKÜ:H?ç[>AH?DAF >A<?OFhJDKØ?M ÜhÙCJFQYU2ÙBKÚ F2](DA@È<?BPJDG<OH?J$>GFIHOØ?U2ÙC>.JU2Y YJ,@ÈB¦DAJDG>.F BPOF2]~VOWåDA<?U2J$V H?>A@CÛDGJ$<[BGUuÛ.D$<?YJWSUuZ?ÞSÙC@ÄJhYÚ?Uh@CäVOJW B
UhBEZ?W >GE]öUIUhÛ,ÛJ@ÈJhVQB=MhD=UìrDG<OV?F J¾J&@CÜhÛ.M <?< ìrFIØ½<?@CFhÛ@È>AJBP<?F2H?F ]±>GF FuV?Wß J@È>A@CWSÜhJJK< ÙÈUuB§Ø½DAFhU$@ÄFI>ADGV<?FIF DGH[FS<OFIW3U2ÙÄFIDK>AÜhÚIJ×:]^ÙÈFhUuFu>rDA@ÄßhU2FIJKV V> × Y&UxÚSÚI×3U2>AVOJ,Ø[WbDAJ¾Z?UhJ,>GÙÄV[ÞSÙCFuB(Fhà#ÜIDAJ<?B&V?FIZOFIBGB§ZOJ#DGBGJFÙÄÙC×JWSYW?JJ,JKBGDGÛVIJK>GD.>G@CB(YØ[DAJ@C<OV?@UuDJKDrWUhU2B=Ø >A×UJ
DGZ?<?H[J=FI@ÄVV?HODG<OZSJ:D¢ßuWSU2FI>AY@ÈU2U2Ø?@CÙCVÂJKMBKÚ,Ö Fh](>~FI@V?DJY@ÈB¾Ux×¾FhØ[HSDAJ=@ÄYJVO@CW?ä@CFhV?ÜhÜ6JKV?UFhHOZ[>GBE@ÈÙC×¾Û,J:WSBGJÛ.DG<?JK>GJYWSZ?@CV?ÙCJ3JKWÅUhVOØ Wè×¾DGDG<?<?J=J:ZO@CV?BEJKH?>KZSÚD.WSBJFhH½] JV[WS@ÄU2VO>AÜJ
DGØ[<?JèJDGHO<OUhJ>AUhBAÛ.Y<?J,JDGWSJKZ?>AÙCB¦JèFhFI]§V?DGJè<[UuÜhDJ,D.BAB:Û.<?àJK<?WSJZOVÙÄJIÚÂFhV?JKUIJèÛ.<HOUhÛ>AU2UhDGY:JKÜhJFhDGJK>A>3×hÚ/@CV@ÄDDA@CB<?JVOUuBGDAÛ.Z?<O>AJKUhWSÙZ?DGÙCJF@CWSB:J O@CVOV?Û,J >AJKUIBEJW¾DAFIF >
H?WSWSJK>G@æ/FIÛJ>GØ?J>AÙCJJUhVQYBGJKD ÚQWDG<?ØQ>AJ¦×åJH?ÙÈUUu>ADGFhBE@CØ?JFhDÙCV[JB#U2Y YU2VOYFhWÂZOUxÚ[VI×BGDZ?Ø½M ØOJ¾Ö VÊBGJKJ VOF2Û,Z?DAFS<?JWSVQJJ>DAÙÄWb×IH?Ú[@C>GVèFIWSØ?@ÄUæ½ÙCJJKVQY>GZOJKYBVQÚÂDØ½BGJÙCZOUh>rÛ.VO<ÊF2W?]BAUhWSÛB$Uh@æ/H[DG<?JJ>AJBrJVQDGDA<O>ADrUxU2àPßIDJUxYÙC×S@ÄVOBKUxÚIÜè×6ÙCJKBAØ½UIU2JWSÙCJK@CJBGV?UhYÜBG@ÄU2DAJKVF >
FhBE@C>ÅVOÛ,<OJ¦U2>.àPWSJ¾JK>¾U2>ADAJ¾FBGBEJKJUhU2>A>.Û.Û.<O<Â@ÄV?M Ü3FuJ:ßhJKDG>A>§JKH?U2>ADÅ@CÛDG@Ä<?VOJÜV?HOJKUh@Ä>AÜIUh<QY:Ø½FhJDG>AJK<?>AF B=FSWSWÉJ O>AJVOÙÈJKUuW6DA@ÄFIFhVVbUhJK@BÅDA<?JJÞS>PFhÜhDG<OJKV?J¦Fh>AZ[JKBEUhÙCÙC×B=FhÜh>=@CßhDGJ<OV~J Ú
@ÄVQDGJKÜhJK>ABKÚSà<?@ÈÛ.<6<OUxßIJ¾V[UuDGZO>AUhÙ±V?J@CÜh< Ø½Fh>A<?F F W6>AJÙÈUuDG@CFhV[BM
WShFIJH½V?hJKJFIVOB V?WOJKB$BZ?@ÈüH½2B:Fhÿ#DGVå<?H?JÉ>ADGJK<?BGBGJbJZOVQÛUhD.ÛÙÄBÜIJKFhBAUÊBE>AFI@DABE><?ÙC@ÄY>GÜIJK<QÙCDGU2Ø½ÙCDG×J@C@CFhV?WSVOÜ@ÄBGæ½<?ZOJK@CBG>GH JKJKWVIÜhDJKDGV?Fè]^JFI>.DG>GUu>.Y3UxDAJKZ?ßhWJKÙÈUu>ADGBGØ @CJ×FhVDA<?UâJF2BE]¦JÙÈU2DGU2VO<O>.Û.W?J < BA5ÛU2UhÙCH[Üh>AJIJFIMÂÙÈ>GUu@ÄX§DGDG@C<OBAFhBEYèVJKVQçàDG]^@ÈFI<?U2>bÙC@ÈÙÄÛ.×I<U Ú
ÜhZ?@CÙCßhUhJ>#VÉU2ÙCBEÜhDAFIU2>GDG@ÄJIDGÚ <?YM?Ühìr@Cßh<?J@ÈBBPUh]^FhÙÄÙ¢>AYDG<?ZOJÙCU2BEDGDA@CUuFhDAVèJKB#à=DGFI<O>GU2RSDÅBPÛKà=U2JKVÉÙÄÙ/Ø½]^JFI> >AJKIUIFhÛ.V?<?JJKB WBP@CH?VÉZ?Fh>AVOH[J3FQBEBEJDGBJÚSHÉà]^<?Fh@È>ÅÛ.<Ub@ÄHOV UhßI>EFhDAÙC@CßhÛ,J ë
DjWSà=JßIFÝJÙCW?Fh@H?æ/@CJV?>AÜbJVQUD3DAÙÈ<?U2JV[FIW?>GBG×6ÛKU2]^H½Fh>#JKB3ÜIJU2V?VOJWÊDG@ÈUIÛBEU2RåÙCÜhàFI<?>G@ÄJ,DGDA<O<?YJ>3BKÚ?FhØ?V?Z?J6D¾@C@ÄBD¾@ÄYVQDAU2>GRI@CVOJKBGB@CÛK@ÄD¦U2ÙCWSÙÄ×å@ bJKÛ,UIZ?BE@CÙÄDJ>DAF¹FI>Û,FI<OYUh>AHOW?U2J>A>J M
#"
"
"
%
(
#*
%
*
M"
(
"
<#
@(
?"
,% (
M%
"
!
/"
$
"
%
+*"
&
'
/*
#
"
% (
GDDGìrF6<?<?JKDGJ6>G<?JWSJ:Uh@ÈBEHO>GDGJU2@CVO>GÙÈU2DGÛ8@ÈV[DAÛ,@ÄW?ZOFIBGÙCV UhÛKU2>A@ÈB¾H½BJKF2DAB&](<OàUuDA<?D <OJ@ChÛ.BE<FIJV?U2<OJK>.UxB3Û.ßI<ÝÛ,J#FIU2U$Z?ÙCH?ÜhVOFIÙCUuJK>GDAB@ÄZ?DG>.<?DGU2<?Y Ù?J6V?Ø½V?JKJJ@ÄÜI@C@CV?Üh< Üè< Ø[Ø½FIZOFh>GBE>A<?J<?F W±F FSÚ/F W:àWâ>G<?JK>AJÙCJ>AU2ÙÈJKDGUuUI@CDAFhB@ÄVOFIàPVOBG<?BGJ3<?@CHÂUI@ÄH MBGBGOZ?J,FhÞSY>(H?J3JÙCÞS@CÛDGUh@<ODAY:U2ÙÄ× Dë
H?UhWÙÄJIEÚOUIÛ,H?J>AV[@ÈÛ,Û,JK×ÉB#FIF VÛKÛ,DAZ?<?>JbFI>AVJKUhDG<?Ù&J$ÙÄ@CV?>AJKJbUhUÙÂÙCVO@ÄV?U2JIDGÚOZ?Y>.U2U2Ù(R Û.@C<?V?FIÜ@CÛUJhMV?JS@C@ÄÜhVO< ÛØ½JbFhBE>AFI<?YF FSJ:W6HO>A>GJ@ÈÛ,ÙÈUuJbDA@ÄBAFIÛ.VO<?BGJK<?W?@ÄZ?HèÙÄJØOB$UI@CBEVOJWSW6ZOFIÛV J
H?à=>GJÅF ?àPD#FhZ?ÙÈU2ÙÈW¹VOW?ÙCBA@CRhÛJ$UhH[FhJZOBr>rDGW?<[J UuOD¾V?Uh@ÄDGH?@CH[FhJVèU2DA>FbDAFÛU2Ø[H?JDGZ?@ÄVQ>AJ¦DG>ADG@C<?VO@ÈBEB@ÈÛM UhÙÄÙC×¹JUhBG@ÄJK>DG<[U2VF2DA<?J>.BrDGF¹FhHSDA@ÄY@CäJhÚ
[Y:Û,JZ?DGìrÙÄ>ADj@C×<?ÛKJB]^>AFI@CJ&VO>=<OÛ,ÜIÙCUxJZOßhV?WSJ=JJ DGU2@È?ÙÈÛ¦BEDGFV?UhØ½ÙÄJÜIBGJFhBJK>AVWS@DA@CU<?BEDAYßuUhU2VOB>AÚQÛ,@ÄJ@CJ3V6Dj×Û,UhFhFhWO>A]?>AWSY:J@ÙÈDAUuJ@ÄFIDGDG>A@CV¹Fh@CÛKVåDABÂFüH?DA>Aÿ<?FhJÅUhH½VOFIYWèBGJ,JKJDGW¾H?>A]^@È@ÈÛFIBjBrD.>¢UuWSÛ,DAFIJK@CBYBAÛ,ßxHO>AUh@CU2Ø[>G>A@ÈJ@ÄU2VOWbV[ÜÛ,Ø½H?J$J>GÙCU2FuFIVOà$Ø?WÙCM JìrYÛFh<O>AWSJK>G@BGJ]ùJ ëë
ÙCà=U2JbDG@CFhWSV JBGÛü u>Gÿº@CMØ½J@ÄØ[DGV?JKÙÄJFuBGà$B:M WSÖ @ÈDBjD.U2J,Þ?VOU2ÛYJ6@CÛ,V?FIJK>GBÅ>AJ<OÙÈUuFuDAà@ÄFIVâÛÙÄFQ@CB3BEJKBEÙÄ×å@CY Û,@ÄFhÙÈU2>A>>AJDGÙÈUuFÉDGJDA<?WÝJ6VOUhJZS@CÜhDG< FSØ[ÛFIFh>G>A@C>GV?JKÜÙCU2DGH½@CFhFhVâ@CVID.YBJ,@CDGVÊ>A@ÈUÛ
DGÙCßxUhJUhVO>A>GH?W?@ÈU2ÙÈBAUxØOÛ× ÙÄU2J¢H½ÛØ½J6UhJ,VUhDjàP>GØ[JIJJMJKX§VÊFIHSH?DjDG@Èà=@CBjYD.FUu@ÄDGäK@Ä@ÈVOJKB3W:H?@CZSB@ÄV[DUÉWSßxJUhØOH½>G@ÄJ@ÈFIU2VOÙÄØOFIW?ÙÄÜhJJ@ÈVQBÛDGMU2ÙCÙ§×hÖ ]#ÚIDGàJKDG>G<O<?Y JJ>A>AJ¹JKDA<OUI@ÈB&BUuDUÅV?>GFåÙCUhJ]^>GJJÜIHO>.JP@CB$BEUhDADAY:UIFÝBEFI@ÈDABZ?<?Ú~VQJèDGD(<?UhF2JKY]/V JFhH?JZ?Uh@ÈVQBEÛ.DAD3<UhFhBG@C@È] V?B H? ö@ÄZSUhVSDBë
DG@CZOB¦<?BEJJ]^FI]^@CZ?Z?V?ÙOVOH?UhWåZSVOD.W@ÄB&VâDAJF UhYBGFI@ÄÙCBE×DWSYJKH[JK(JKUIVOë|BE<OW?ZOUhB&>G>AJZ?WÝWH½àH?FhV:>A<?FhJKDAØ?V<?ÙCJJJYßhÛ.<?FIB ÙÄFIZ?@CYÛDG@CJKFhJB¢VOU2]^VOUhFh>GB¦>(×$FhDAU2<ODG<?ÙCUuÜhJKD$FI>&>GDAßu@Ä<?DGU2J<OÙCZ?YFhJKHSB&BDAUhFh@ÄY>G] JPU2Ø½Ù=MhJÛ.X§@C<?V?H?FhÜ$@È@ÈBjJÛ,D.J3YUhBG]^H?@CFhÙCB>$Fu@È×hBFIJV?YWJFI]^FIF2BED>]
FhHSDA@ÄY@CäKUuDA@ÄFIVÂM
#ÕGÎ Î¾Ò Ô
~Ñ(Ð ýÏSÑ ÝÐ[ÕEÔ rÔ ~Ò¾Ó
ÐOÎÕGÎ
N=U2V¹×JJBjBjDADA@Ä@ÄYYU2U2DGDGJÅ@CV?F2Ü]~<OU¹FuÙÈàêU2VOÙÄWOFIV?BGÛKÜ:U2H½@DJ àB¾@CÙÄ>AÙ½Z?DAÜIUhÜhRhJKJ¦W?V?@DrJKDABAFBÚ/OU2V[VåW6UhUhW?V¹UhHSFhDGH?@CDGßh@CJYU2Z?ÜIY JVQUhD$VOÛWU2VÝDA<?DGJÅ<?ÙÄJKJVÊU2>AÛ,V?Fh@CV[V?BjÜ3DA>GÛZOFIÛ,BEDD
UhWSBA@Ä>ABEJKFSÛ,Û,DG@ÈÙCUu×hDAM JKÖ W VOBjàDAJK@DAUI< W±ÚhO@ÄV[D§WSY@ÄVOZ[ÜâBjD§UhØ½V J#FI@CVSHS]^DGJ@C>AY>AJKZOW:Yè]^M(>AFhLY Fuà=FhDGJK<?ßhJKJK>(>KÚÙÈU2>GVOZOW?ÜhBAÜhÛJUhWSH[V?J¾JBGÛ.B<OU2Û>.UhUhV?Û,V?DGFhJ>AD:@ÈBjØ½DAJ@CÛKB@ÄV[M éWSZO<?Û,JKJVW
Fh@DV?J@ÈB @C[B¹V?ZOJèBE@CDGV?FåÜØ?UÊZ?@CÜhÙCW JKV?×hJFI>.Z?UuDA>@ÄßIY:JÉFSYWSJKF ÙW?BEJFÙÅBEDGZO<OÛ.U2<êDbUÝUIBHODAUh<?>AJUhY J,DGJK>:YBGF ZOW?Û.<JÙ¾UhDGB F5Ø?ZOÛ@ÄÙÈUhWêV ÙÈØ½U2JVOWOZOBGBEÛKJU2WÊH½JKDABKF Ú
DGDGZ?<?V?JKVèJ¹ÛDGÙC<?UhFQ@ÄYBEJ¹DA]^<OJKU2UuDGD Z?>AJKB@ÈBPF2DG]<?J$DG<OUhJ¹Y:ÙÈFIU2Z?VOVQW?DPBAÛFhUh] H[ J¹>GZ?DGÜI<OÜhU2JD3WSV?YJKU2BARIBKMJb L#@ÄD:FuWSàP@ JbßIÛ,JZ?>ÚIÙÄD3àDA<?FÉJKV¹FhH?ÙÈU2DG@CVOY:WO@CBGäÛKJ6U2H½F2JK]BrUhU2VO>AW J
H?Y:>GJFuUhß BG@ÈZ?WS>.JKU2WèØ?JÙCJ:Þ FIÛ.Üh<[JKU2V?>.FhUhZOÛ8DABGJÙC×h>A@CÚ BEDGDG<O@ÈÛ@CBB@CF2B]rVOU¹F2D¾ÙÈU2UhVOVWOBGFhÛKHSU2DAH½@ÄJFIVÂUhM VOÖ WÉVOBEZ[DGBEJJ:UhW±DGÚ½<O@CU2B¦VDAU2FèÜIJJBjVQDAD#@ÄYYU2ZODGBEJD>GÙCZOF ÜhFhÜhR6JU2WSD#V?JDGBG<OBKJ M
ÖU2VVOWbDA<?BE@ÈDGBZ[WSBEJ×:Û8DADG@Ä<?FIJKVÂ@Ä>=Ú±Jà=bJÛÛUIFhÛ,VO×BG@CUhW?B=JJK>ÅBEDGDG<O@CY>GJKU2J:DGFIH½>AFIB&BAFhBG@Ä]ÂØ?>GÙCZOJÜhFhÜhØOJBGWSJV?>AJßuBGU2BKØ?Ú2ÙCZOJ:BGÙC@ÄUhVOVOÜ3W?U2BAYÛU2F H½JJØ[UÛ.<OUhU2B=>.U$UhÛ,YDGJKJK>GUh@ÈBjBGDAZ?@C>AÛKJB
F2U2]3VOWUIÛ8YDGZ[@ÄÞSU2JKÙ¦W>GZ?Ø?ÜIZOÜhVOJWSWSÙC@ÄV?V?JKÜ3BABKÙCUhM=VOìrW?<?BAJÛBEUhJH[JY:B=JUhUhVOBGWZ?>AZOJKBGB¹JKWUh>GDAJåF U2ÙÈZOBEU2F VQDAU2@H?D.UuH?DGÙC@C@CJKßhWéJKÙÄ×DAFJÞ DAHO<?ÙCJÝUh@ÄVDjàPDAF2<?ëºJ¾HOUh>AJK>EBGDbZ?D.ÙÄD§U2>AàP@æ J
U2>AÜhZ?JW]^Fh>HO@CÛ,DGFh>A@ÈU2ÙCÙÄ×b@CV @ÄÜIZ?>GJ OM
#
#"
"
"
I"
*
R%
@(
I
X
X
I
#*
"
6X
X
I"
0
$
I"
<*
)
!#"%$
Ä@Û,¾V?FhV?ÜVQJD.DGU2Y<O@CVOJèJ,BDAÜIM >GÙÄ@ÈÖ FIÛVQØODGDAZ?U2<OÙP@ÄUuDGDPFh@CßhH?@CJKBPDGÙÄ@C×IBGYÚQFhZ?Y@Ä]~Y J,UDA@ÄÙÈFhYU2]¦V[JKW?UB=BGWSÛKHOU2@ÈU2BGH½>GÛDGJ¾ZO@ÈBGÛ,ÛBGZOFhJKÙCVQWÝUhDA>3Uhü 2@ÄÙÈVOÿOU2B=VO]^FhWOU>rBGBGÛKWS@ÄU2JVOH½DGÜhJJ6ÙC>AJ#Y@ÈFhB3@ÄHSVODGDA<?@Ä@ÄV?Y3JÜZ?V DGYZ?<?YJÅÚ @Ø½WSDr@JBE><?ÛFhFIZ?]Z?ÙÄÙÈDjFhW×:HSØ[DAFh@ÄJ¦] YOJKUåVOUIBEW @Ä× Dë
DGFâÙÄFSÛKUuDGJIM&ìr<?JJ,Þ?Û,JKHSDG@CFhV DGFåDG<?@ÈB@ÈB:UåÙÈU2VOWOBGÛKU2H½J¹DA<OUuDbÛ,FIVQDAU2@CVOBUåBE@CV?ÜhÙCJèVOU2>A>GFuà
f"
H[UJÙCU2UhRVOW?U2BAV[ÛW U2H½UJbÙCÛ,UhFI>GVQÜIDAJ¹U2@CH?VOÙÈBUuDAUJKU2ÙÈZ~U2>AM ÜhJ JKV J Z?Y3Ø[@CÜhJKZ?>>AJF2]rFhHS]^FhDA>@ÄYUhUOV Ú~J,@ÄDÞ?UhàY:@ÄÙCHOÙ(ÙÄØ½JèJbF2]#<OUhDA>A<?WS@ÈBJKM>KÚ± H[@ÄU2Y>GDG@C@ÈÙCÛ,UhZ?>GÙCÙÈ×hU2Ú>AÙÄ@Ä× ]
à<?JVZOBG@ÄVOÜU:<?@CÙCÙëtÛ,ÙC@ÄY3Ø?@CV?ÜbU2ÙCÜhFI>G@ÄDG<?YÚQDGF [VOW6DG<?J$ÜIÙÄFIØOU2Ù/FhH?DG@CYZ?YM
X% ( "
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
}CcKk=[£Q¶ no½¶ozªmA nod¾Äs¨Qp no¸hpQyt¤¦m8sKsKeSo¤ickj·(nogjnogj£I£bd$s$y. ytnopQ¤Koi¾eSi8s SS¨Qfhg=s,kj¤i¦eIsgji8sfQy. ·(£InmE£eIkjiAyti.pugrs$mE£ sKooi.pI¤i
DGØ[<?JKJK>=>GÖ FhJ]P]~]^FhàPFh>AJbHSJ=DAUhFh@ÄYÛK]½Û,ÙCU3JKJH?UhU>GD¦V?ÙÈDAU2@C<OV?VOUuÜÅW?DBAWSÛDG@ Uh<?H[JÛJ¦Z?V Û,ÙÄZ?DjFI×hY3VIÚuD.Ø[àPU2JK@CJP>VOY3BKF2M ZO]rÖ BEVbFhD&HSÜIDGDAJ<?@ÄV?YJKJKV:U>AUIUh@ÈÙBEBÚQR@ÄU2DP<OVâFu@ÈB§à@CVOVOà=WSF2@ÈDrJÛU2H[ÛKDGU2FQFhVBG>$BGWS@ÄFhØOJ,]PÙÄDAJJ>A>AZ?DGY:FÜIÜh@CJV?JKÞSJPW?<OV?DGU2<OJKZOBAJBEBDGVQÚ±@CßhZOUhJKY3VOÙÄW× ë
BEWSJ@DAU2@Ä>.FIÛ.VÂ<ÚQUbDG<?ÙCJ¦UhVOH?W?>AFBAÛ?U2DPH½ÙCJhUhÚ½VOUuW?D¦BAÛÙÄUhJH[UhBEJDB§FhàPV?JJJàÞSUh@DAY<Ý@ÄV?YJ¦Fh@C>AVbJÅDGDG<O<O@CUhBrVÝWSFIUbYÛFhUhZ?@ÄV¹H?ÙC<OJUxFhßh](JWSÛFh@ÄYVQDGJK@CVOV BEZ?@CFhFhZ[V[B=BM WSÖ @CVÝYUhJVSWSëë
BEìr@CFh<?VO@CBPBKMYÖ U2V RIJKUhB§W?W?DG<?@DAJ¦@ÄFIZOVÂBGÚ~J¾DAFh<?]¢JèUÙCUhBEDAVOUhW?VOBAW?ÛUhU2>AH½WJKB<O@ÄDjÙC× ÙCÛH?ÙÄ@È@CÛYU2ØOÙCÙC@Ä×åV?ÜÛFhU2VQÙCÜhDAUhFI@Ä>GV@ÄDG<O>AY@ÈWSÜhDAJF B[U2VOV[WbWFIWSHS@ÈDGBG@CÛYFhVQU3DGU@CV >AZ?U2@DADG@Ä<?JJKB> M
DADGU2<?U2>A@CØ?JVO@DAB$<O>A@Ä>AUhÙCÙC@È>GÛWS×ÅÙÄÜh@CYJJÞ BØOÚ±JK@Ä>AV?DAÛ<?Ü6@CJBGJhU2V MÙCÜhZ? FhY@CVO>A@ÄØ½ÛDGJ=<?J>YDA<?F2Jr]ö<?@ÄFhVOFuHSH?à DAZS@ÄYÙCD§UhWS>GUèÜI@CYJ$]^FIJUZ?VOVOBjBGWåDA@ÄFIJVOHàB@Ä@ÄÙCD#U2Ù=>ADAW?JPUhJÛRhH½FhJKJVQB VO8DGÚOWâ@CV >AZ?Z?U2FhDGH½<?Z[FhJKBVå>UhDADGVO<?<OWJbUhÙÈVU2ÜhV[>.U2U2W?V V BG×¹Z?ÛKU2@CÙÈVQU2H½>ADGJ>A@ÄDj@ÄÛ,×VOFhBGV?F2@ÈÛ ë]
]^úuJKõ Uu8DAôò8Z?õ >AJ¹Sô|F2õö]rñu÷ÝDA<?FhJ6]¢ÙÈFIU2HSV[DGW?@CYBGÛKU?U2Ú?H½>.JhUuM DA!¦<?J@ÄßI>PJDGVÊ<[U2DAVè<?@CDGB3<?H?J$>AV FhZ?Ø?Y3ÙCJØ[YJKÚ¢>@F2D]@CFhB3HSYDA@ÄFhY>AUOJbM ZOBGJ,]^Z?Ù=DGFÙÄF FIRåU2DDG<OJ
0
−5
−4
−3
−2
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
/S
.D3 "
I"
%
@(
"#! " !#" ! " %$
ÖÙCUhVVOUIW?W?BAÛWSU2@ÄDGH½@CFhJKB§V6àDGF@DA<¹H?>.Û,UhFIÛ,VQDGDG@ÈÛ@CVQUhZOÙ½FhHOZO>GFIB§Ø?@ÄV?ÙÄJKHOYZSDABrBK@ÄÚQVDG<?ÛJKUh>GÙCÛJZ?UhÙÈ>GUuJ¾DG@CWSV?JÜ:JKDGH[<OJKJ$>=VQH?ZO>AFhYØOØ½ÙÄJKJY>B§F2]@ÄV¹FhH?ZODGBE@C@CYV?ÜU:DGFI<?V6J¾H?VQ>AZOF Y3ODë
Ø[FhHSJK>&DA@ÄF2Y]/UFhHSUhDA>G@ÄJYBGUÅ@CY:UhHOB&ÙÄUh×V3Û,JFIBjZ?DAVQ@ÄYDGJUuW±DAM Fh>&FhÙCUh][VO>AZ?W?ÜhBAÛÜIU2JKH½WSJ#V?JàBGBK@ÄDGM <¹ãÜUhÙC>AUhJK>GU2ÜIDJWSVQJZOU2YÙ?FhØ½][J@C>§VSFh]^Fh]Â>AFhYHSUuDA@ÄDAY@ÄFIUÅV3DA@È<OBUuÙÄFQDrBjU2D&>A@ÄJ ]
U2öU2ÙCÙ[V[Û,WÙCZOÙCBEJKDGBAJKB¦>GJ>GZOWÜhDAÜhFhJÜIW J,DG<ODGJ<O>§UhU2VD(FIDGV?<?JJDG@ÄVâFIHàF2<?]±@ÈÛ.U$<<?DG@CÙÄ<?Ù[Jà=FIFIHSZ?DGÙCW@CYBGUèJJKUhY >GJ:DAF$JßIØ[JJ V?ÙC×ÝZOU2BGHOÙC@UhD.UuÛDAJK@ÄWÝßIJDGÙC<?×3>AWSFh@ÄZOæ½ÜhJK<?>GFIJKZSVQDD
DG<?JÙÈU2VOWOBGÛKU2H½JhM #ÜQU2@CVÂÚ/DG<?@CV?R @CV?Ü@ÄVDGJK>GYBÅF2]PØOUhBG@CVOBÅF2]rUuDEDA>AUIÛ8DA@ÄFIVÝYUx×YU2RhJ:DA<?@CB
"
%
(
f
JKØ?UhZSBGDG@C@CJFh>VDAFhF¹]±Z?ØOVOUhW?BG@ÄJVb>.BjBGD.@CU2äVOJKB(W±MDGJKÖ VOVÉW?ÜhB&JKDAV?FuJàP>.U2UhÙ|>AÚ?W3àPZ?JV?@ÄàP]^FhFh>AZ?YÙÈWÉÚ2DAÛ,<?FIJV jYJKÛ,FhDG>AZ?J>AJ$>AZ?DAÜh<OÜIUuJKD¾W3DGDG<?<?J3JY:ÙCUhFIVO>GW?JÅBAÛDA<?U2H½J3J#W?@È@CBBEMDG>AÖ @V ë
à]^¢Fh@C<?>$ÜhJZODj>AàP>GJKJ UIF2B§ëºOHOÚ[YU2àP>G@ÄÞ D¦JJDAÛKWbU2U2>AØ?VÉ@ÄZOæ BGVOJB$WSJÙCØ½@ÄDAV?J<O@CÜUuV?D¾ÜÛ,FIDGYVQ<?DAJ3FhU2>A@CFhJVOHSBPDAJK@ÄUUIYBEÙÈ@CUbU2ÙÄ×Ý>A]^ÜhFhÙÄJJ>#U2H?Dj>AÙCàPV?U2F2DGJKJëºW±HOU2ÚÂZÂUhUh>EMSVODìrWåD.<?U2× @È>ABP@Ä@JKæÊ@CÙCBrWSU2U@C>AV?JH½ÜFIÛ,<?ÙCBAZOBG@CÜh@ÄBEØ?<ODGJÙCJJ¦>A>JKJ,WÉÛÞSZ?H?FhYÙÈVÉU2Z?VOUbÙÈU2UuDG<ODA@C@Ä@ÄFhßIÙCÙV J Ú
H?F2]>GF Fh?HSDKDAM @ÄYÖ V6U3DG]^<OFh@C>rBDjBGàPJKÛ,F2DGëº@CHOFhU2VÂ>GÚ DPàPDAJ¦U2>Aßu@ÄæÝUhÙÄ@ÈU2W?VOUuWèDAJYDA<O@ÞSUuJDW6UhØO>GÜIZ?Z?VOYWSÙCJ@ÄVOVQÜD=Ø ÙCUh×bVOJW?BjBADAÛ@ÄU2YH½U2JKDGBK@CM V?Ü:DG<?J$WS@ÈBjDA>G@CØ?ZSDA@ÄFIV
Ø?BE@CZSYDG@C@ÄFhÙÈU2VJ>ÅF2àU2]§H?@CÙCHOØ[Ù >GUhOFQBGV[@ÄUhVÝWèÛ.<BGDG@C<?ZOäJ:JKBGBKJKWSM±WÉ@Cì~BEØ DGFè×>A@CWSØ?!ÅFbZSU2DGDA@C>A<?FhV?V@È@CBJÚ±>ÅFhàP]&U2FhJVOHSW ZODABG@Ä$YJ3U2UDGÙC<?ÙÄ@CJKJ3VÉÙP]^üUFhxÙCÿºÙÄÙÈM FuU2àVOW?@C@C>AV?BABEÛÜ¹DKUhÚ/DGH[V?JKJÛ.Fh<ODGØQJV?× @ DGO<OZ?VOU2JIW?D¾Ú[@Ä]^V?@CVOFIÜb>¦BGH?DGUh<?@CVQ>GJJ×WÉW?H½@CØ BEFhDG×@C>AVQ@U Dë
@ÄBjVDAJJUH½ÙÈJKU2BEVODEëtWOUhBGBAÛKÛ,U2JKH½VQJhDÚ~<OàP@ÄJbÙCÙCÛÛÙÄ@CUhYV ØOO@ÄV?VOÜ WåU2DG<OÙCÜhJ¹Fh>AFh@ÄH?DG<?DG@CYYM Z?åYJÉF2]rÛ.<?DGF <?FIJ¹BGJØOUhUâBG@ÄVÊ>.U2@ÄV[DWS>AFhJKY'BG@CW?BGJKJ,B$D @CéFVÊ2Ø ]$×ÝBjZOD.BGU2@Ä>GVODGÜÉ@CV?ÜU
DGH[@CBr@CFIFhDA@ÄVVQ<?DAJàB§V @ÄU2ÙCZ?Ù~VOY3Ø½W:JØ[ZOJKBEBG>DGJ#FhF2Bj>ADA]JKJW6H½JKFhH[@CVÉ@CJVIBjD.UDGBëºUIBE@CJ VBGÛJDZOVQJGDVO<OÛDGU2FÅJ D#ÙÄ§FSÙÄJM ÛKUhUu?WèDGFIJr>DAFDAJK<?UIDGJ#Û.<O<èÛ,U2FIDFI>GFhHS>AJKHSDGBG@CDAYH½@ÄY3FhZOVOZ?Y WSY@CV?.MOÚ?Ü¦X§àPFhUIJHSÛ.DA<Û@ÄU2YJÙÈÛ,ÙCUOJZOMhYÙCìrU2JDG<?VQJ J#D#WSF2G@È
] Ú?BjàDAÊ>G<?@CàØ?@ÈÛ.ZS@C<ÙÄëÙ
H[F2Û,Fh] FI>A@Ä(>AVQJKÚ/DABGB#àPH[]^JFI>GVOFI<OYWÉUxßIDADJFÉAUbU2<OVÊßuUuU2D¦FIÙCZ?HSU2>AJDGJ¦@CY]^Fh@CVZ?>¾YDGDG<O<?J.J Ú~ØO U2BGUh@ÄV[äKBGWåJ@CV½BGF2F2F]&]DGDAFh<O<?HSJbJ3DA@ÄßuÙÈY3U2U2V[Z?ÙCZ?W?Y JbBGÛKF2.U2M]rH½Ö JJh]ÙCM JàPYJÖ ]§JKBGVIàPZ?DYJVOUhFhÙÄ@È>AÙ~B$YF2DA]Uh<?ÙÄDGJb@C<?äJJV Z?DGJY<?ÙCJ@ÈØ½YB¾JBGJ>@CVQäF2DAJhB ] Ú
DGà=<?J$JKV6ÛUhDAV6<?J$JBjJDAÙC@ÄJYYU2JKDGVIJÅD.DGBr<OF2J]Û,ÊÙCZOU2Bj>ADAJ¾J>AH½JKWSJ>.VOÛ,JKJKBAVIBrD.F2U2]~ÜIJKDABK<?M J$PÙÈNPU2×VOW??BADGÛDGUh@CV?H[ÜbJ BrUFIBEHSFI>EDGDA@CYJKWU?MåDAFbU:W?@CBEDG>A@ÄØOZSDG@CFhVÂÚ
DG@CBZOWSÛFhJ?V FhF2ßh>] JKBGV?@ÄY@Ä@ÄJKV[VQH?WSDPÙC@C@ÈÛKÛ,Ø½Uu@ÄJKDjDAÛK×hJKU2ÚSBZOàPDABG<?J J¾J?@ÄD#Û,D ÙC<OZOUIBEDGDGB=JKFFI>GJV?U2WSV6ÙC×V?J,JKFhÞSBAV?H½BJ¦FhF2V?]^]½>AJKDGJVI<OJÅDAJ@CHOUhFhU2Ù±HS>.WSDAU2@Ä@CYYBEDGJU?>ADG@CMIØ?Jìr>ZSÚ<?DGÂ@CJFhÚ?V J,àÞSH½<OFh@C?Û.V?<èÚSJKàVIÜh<?DAFu@CJKßIUh>GJÙOJ¾>AWSVODG@ÈB&<?BjDAJÅDA>G<?@CYØ?J$ZSU2Û,DAÜIÙC@ÄZOV?FIBj@ÄV ëë
DGJ>AJK!W? V?&JK@ÄBAVOBbÛ>GFhJ]$UhBGDGJK<?BKJåÚDGFh<?HSJDA@ÄW?Y@CBEUODG>AM @ÄØOéZS<?DG@CJKFhV VØ½ JKÛ, FIY
?JKÚPBFhYH?DGFh@C>AYJ#U Û,ÙCZOU2BE>ADGJÉJ>AZ?JKV?WÂ@ÄM2]^FhN=>A×3YZOÙÄ×éBG@ÄV?WSÜ@ÈBjUhDA>GV3@CØ?JZSÞSDAH[JKFIW±V?çJVSUIBë
DG@È U2]§ Ù[Û,W?Fh@CZOBEDG>A>ABG@ÄJhØOÚ?ZSàPDGJ@CFhVÂ<[UxÚQßhàPJ$JV?ÛFâUhV3ó$DAï/<?ò8JõöV ñuò8?õD#>A"%JK$UI& BE'FI V öDGF2F3DA<?U$JÙÄ>¾@CV?DGJI<OÚIUhàV<?FhJKØO>GJrBGJDA>A<?ßuJ¾UuDABG@ÄÙCFIFhV H½PJ#DGF2Fè]/DGUh<OBAJBEZOÙCY:@ÄV?JJDG@CB#<OU2ÂD M
Y:U2^V?VFIFh>GJ,DJÞSDGH½ÛFFhFhØ[V?YJJKH?VQÛÙCDG@CFh@ÈÛKU2VSUuÙO]^DAZ[WSJKBEW@ÈJBEDGW6WS>A@È@ÄàBjØ?DAZ?@Ä>GDGDG@C<Ø?@CFhZSFIVbDAZ?@Ä@ÈFI>BVOÙÄDG@ÈBK<OBEÚ[(D J¾HOåÛ,UhFI>EFh>GDA]¢>A@CÛJKØOZ?Û,UID§ÙÈU2BEWS@C>AVÙÄ@È×bBjDABE>G@CFIä@CV?Ø?JJKBZSB¾=DA@ÄDABEFIZ[<OVÂÛ.UuM <ÉD#O<OUhZSUxBrDGßIZ?DAJ >A<?J#J3GàP<?NPJKFhJ,Ux>AD.ß RUb×àWSD.@C@ÈU2ÙÄBjÙ½@CDAÙCÛ,>GBKFI@CM Ø? VOZSBEDA@ÈWS@ÄFIJKV >
ÙCUuUhDGVOJW?W ì~BAF#
ÛU2WSH½JÙÈJKU2DGJKBKV[>GÚxW?Yà=BGÛKJr@CV?U2H½JH½JJKDG>G<?Br]^FhJ=ZO>AWSBGY@C@CV?BEJKDGÜ W>A@C DGØ?<?ZSJPDG@C]^FhFhVÅÙC
:ÙCFuFhU2à] VOFI@ÄWV?HSÜ¦DG@CYJ,
:ÞSUPÙÈH½U2]^JVOFh>AWO>±@ÄYBGDjÛKàPJKU2VIF2H½DëºJKHOM BP?UhZO>EFID½BG>&@ÄDAV?JKUhUhÜ >GÛ.@Äæ:<:UhBGÛ.VO<OW¦JK
Y:WSZ?
O@ÄÞSÙCM?JhJK;=ÚuW¦FIàPØ?VOJPZ?BGÜhZ?V[JYWSVOÙÄJJ@CV?>.>GBëÜ
à=?FhJK>>GJÅJÜhUhJKÛ.V?< J>.ÙCUhUuVODAJKW?W6BAÛ@CU2W?H½JJVQDGà=@ÈÛJUhÙÄÙCÛ.×<?FQDGBEF)J DA<?FIBGJÅ@ÄVè
DA
É<?J$H½J,FhÞS@CVQH½DAJB>A@ÄYUhVOJW VQD.>.B#U2BEVãZOY:UâYBjDAUhJ>GJK@CH[äJJW¹BjDGëº@CUIV BGÛ¢J@CVQÜhD:ZO>G<OJ @ÄÙChMÙë
Û,ÙC@ÄY3Ø?@ÄVOÜUhÙÄÜIFh>A@DA<?Y DGFWSJDGJK>GY@CV?J(M~ìr<?JßuU2ÙCZ?JF2]*ÊàPUIBÅWSJ,DAJ>AY:@CV?JWÝØ ×ÉZOBG@CV?ÜU
+ ëtB ZOUh>GJ¾DGJBjDÚOUhBr@CVåü xÿºçOU àPUIBBEJKÙÄJÛ8DAJKW±Ú?UWS@ÈBjDA>G@CØ?ZSDA@ÄFIVÜhJVOJ>.UuDGJW±ÚSU2VOW6DA<?JVèDG<OJ
J,Û,ÞSFhYH[JHOÛ8UhDAJK>G@ÈWbBGFhUhVVOWb>GJKUhH[Û,JDGUuZODAUhJKÙ½W±W?M @CéBEDG>A<?@ÄJØOVÉZSDG@C@CVOFhÛVO>GB=JUhàPBGJJK>ABJ@CVÛ,FIÉVY:?H[F¹U2>AÙÄJKFIW±V?,M Üh¹àJK>#rH?Uh>AB&F DAW?<?ZOJÛ,V6JW@ÄV[Û,BE@C>AÜhJKV?Uh@BG[JKÛKWU2UhVQVODWÜIUhDA<?@ÄV[@CBB
@ÄVÛ,FIV [WSJKVOÛ,JIÚ àPUIB=DAU2RIJV6DGFØ½J EÙÈU2>AÜhJ¾JV?FIZ?Üh<ÂM ]Û2Fh>A>PÜhZ?Dj¢à=J@CWÜhFhZOë|DAH[>G<OJ U2Uu>GD§ D=DjD.Ûà=U2FhFh>AY@ë|æÉHOHOUhU2U2>E>AV[DJKW¹BD.U2YDG>A<O@@ÄæèJ:Þ JÙCH[W¹FhJKÜ>EØO]^WSZ?FI@È>GVOBjYWSDA>GÙCJK@Ä@CVOWØ?ÜZSàPDA]^@ÄJFhFIÙC>Ù?VOØ½B¦ JKF2ÛK#] U2ZO BG
:JöUxDGU2ßI<OV[JJ#W >.U2Fh ÜIHSJKDAW@Ä YFuU$ßh
JKàP
O> JM >A
§J#¹>GÛ,JKÙÈÙCU2ß ZOV[@ÄBEFIW?DGZOJKBGBEÛK>GÙCJU2×hW3H½ÚQJKàPFIB V J
U<?@CÙCÙÚSà<?JK>GJUhBPY@ÞSJW¹Ø?ZOVOWSÙC@ÄV?ÜÛFhVQDAUh@ÄV?JW¹U3ÙCUh>GÜIJ [U2D>GJKÜh@CFhVDA<OUuD#BGJ>AßhJKW6UhBrU:BEJD
W*
#"
"
?"
6"
Q
#*
4
(
%
,"
*
"
% (
%
"
% (
%
(
(
)
"
%
<"
B
@(
N=100distrbuonfpmawxel
Distrbuonfpmawdxelgc
2. 2
g
2
twoparif
twoparif
mixedbunlg
mixedbunlg
2
1. 8
1. 8
1. 6
1. 6
1. 4
1. 4
1. 2
Lognumberfpitsacdwh
1. 2
Lognumberfpitsacdwh
1
1
kE ssKp [mE2£¶ y§O¶o¨ nopQsKqPiytnnonoyºpIy&gtyPkjgjnoyt£QÏcKiPfIktgjgjËInoi.gtçbgjpbi8ü¸cK{:}¢¸Iyt¨ noyºns¼Agtyti¦kjnonop¹¨QsfIp ytgj¸:nono¼.cKiAgjpyP£Qi }ÈcKc}±:kr¨Qsg|sK·»hytnonocKypªöe ùytos,noc¼.kt¤i.gPy.ytgE m8s¿sKkjnzo£QÁi ir(sKonoiAp y=}Ä¸g=gj£QËQd$i¤nzfhyt»hnokji8¼.ir¸:inocKÏy(}¢fQ}CcKp s$k ¸he onspIkt¤Igjno?m.¿fI£Isi krsp ¹¨Q¸sKs,ytgj»Ino£Ip[noiy
8
kjno¤K£2g§noy&}Èck 8K
]^F2Fh]§>rFIDjHSàPDGJF2@CYëºÛKHOU2U?U2VÉM >GD=U2@ÄD.ÙÈÜIBGU2FZ?>A@>ABGæÝJ JJÅDG <ODABEUh<OZOV¹UuH?D]^H[FIDGFI><?>EJY:D.B¾FI@ÄÞSDGHS<?JKDGWè@È@CBÅYØ?U2U:Z?>AV[Üh]^FhZ?WS>YÙÄ@CDjV?JàPÜ[VQF2M Dëºç HOåUh>E@ÈDrBÅDAU2UhV>G@ÄæÝFh>.Ø½WSJKJÛ>¦FhF2Y]PJYÙCJKUhBAÜhB#V?Û,@ÄDGÙCZ[ZOWSBEDGJ3J>AÙÈJKU2W>AÜhUIJK>B
DGà=Üh<?>AJ¦FuJ:à#YDjBàPFuÚ?ßhF2BGJëº@ÄHOV[]Û2>AÛ,Fh>GJDY ÙÈD.U2U2>A>AÜh@JKæÊ >Fhßu
H?U2$ÙCDGZ?@CDAYJKF B#Uè ]^FhU2>#>A JDA<?ÙCFS
J$Û
O]Û2M JKDGJJKWàÛ,ÙC@CU2FIÙÄÙCÙ¢BGFhJ×QV?>=@CÜJJ,ÙÈÞ?WU6U2H½>GY@ÈFIWS@CBGVOÜh@DAJIUu@Äç½DAßI@ÄUIJFIB VbH? >AF2F ] ?@C¢VOD@CM[Û,Üh>AìrZOJK>G<?UIJ @ÈBEBJ3BBGÚ[BGH?<?DG>A<?FuJKà#@ÈUIBÅW?B§>ABDG@CWS<OFhÜIZ?U2JDD
DG<?J$ìrFI<?HSDGJ@CYWS@CU:BEDGUh>AVO@CØ?WèZS>GDGJ@CFhWSVZOÛF2JK]ÅBPFhDG<OH?DGJ$@CYYUUhÜh]^V?FI@Ä>DGZ[Y:WS@ÄJÅÞSF2JKW] ÂØ?M Z?VOW?ÙÄ@CV?ÜWSF JKBVOF2DbÛ.<OU2VOÜhJUhBBG@ÄÜIV?@]ùë
@CF2ÛKæ/U2JVQ>.DGB$ÙC×éÛ,FhUhV[BbBEZ?àPYJÝJKY>ABÅFuUßIJÛ.<?]^>GFIFI@CÛY J:Ø½ J,DjàP JJKV
ÊH½DGJF >GëtU2 >GDG@ÈÛ,ÙCJUh
VO
?WM &Ø?Z?JKVOÛKU2WSÙCÙCÙ#JDGH?<[>AUu@CD6Û@ÄVOYÜO@ÄM~ÞSìrJKWê<?@ÈØOB$Z?Û,VO>AJKWSU2ÙC@ÄDGVOJÜ B
UâBEFÝÙCUhUh>GÙÄÙPÜIJèÛ,FIHOVOÙCBEU2ZODGY:JKUhJKZ >AB@CVãØ?Z?DG×å<OJDG<?ÙCUhJ¹VOØ?W?Z?BAÛVOU2WSH½ÙCJhJM à<?JKBGY>GJU2DAÙCÙ=<?JÛ.<OH[UhJKV?>EÜhëtJU2>G@CDGV@ÈÛ,H½ÙCJJ>GH?ëº>AUh@C>EÛDAJ@CÛ@CÙÄBJDAHOF >GFÊ@ÈÛ,Jb<?@ÄÜIÜI@Ä<ÂßIJKÚ§BUhVOUhVW
Ù[CUhUhW?Uu>GDUhÜIHSJH½DG>Fh@CßhH½>GJDGFh@C>GFhU2DGVÊÜI@CFhJFhVVQ]=DÅF2DAV?]&<?FDAJ¹<?Û.HOJ<OÙCU2ÙÈU2U2V?DGVOJKÜIWOUhJZBGÛK@ÄÅVâU2>AH½J,H?JhD.>AÚOU2F ØO@C?VZSDDM DA<?BDAJ<?Å@CJ>¹àPFIòAJHSí,ðÄDG@Äó2@CV[YôÛ,õ u>AUí6JKUhFhØOBGVJUhDABG <?@CV@CBÚ/BEDGH?@C<?äÙÈJ@ÈUuB$BDGMJH?U2ìrÙÈZUu<?DAJK@CöB>GUhJZÝH[U2FIÙCD.ÙÄ@Ä×U2VQRhD.jJB$ZOBÅBEFhDZ?ZSHâDGD:<OUUJ
à=ÙCUhJVOU2W?R BAV?ÛJKU2BAH½BPJ:@ÄVF ÛKZOÛ,BGZ?@CHOV?@ÄÜ:JWÉDG<?Ø @ÈB×V?JKFIUh>GÛ.Y<U2ØOÙC@CUhäBGJK@CWèVÂÚ[U2>.HOUuH?DA>G<?FQJUh>¾Û.DG< <[ U2àPVâJ$U2U2VÝ>AJ¾UhØOYBEJKFIUIÙÄZ?BEZODGJ:>G@CV?Y:Ü:JUhDG<?BGZ?JÅ>A]^J>.UhF2Û,]=DG@C@FhD.B¦VèBGF2@Cä]JhU Ú
[àYÛ,<?UhZ?@CR ÙÄÛ.D¦@Ä<V?DGÜ@C<?VO@CUhÛ,V?>G>AÜOØ?JKç/@ÄUIDGBE@Ä>.DÅJU2Br>AÛ×ÙÄàJU2@UhDA>ABA< ÙÄBE×ZO Y:Uuæ/M H?JKÉDGÛ,@CFhDAJKBVOUhBKBGDGZ?M <?>AJ:@ÄVOÙCJKÜ3U2DA>A<?V?J@CV?UhÜ¹ØOHOBEFI>GÙÄFSZ?Û,DGJJBGBKBGÚO@ÄäKØOJ$ZSF2D¦]&@ÄDÅJKUI@CÛ.B¾<6<OÙÈU2U2>.VOWWODABGF6ÛKU2WSH½FèJ$à@CB¾@DAU<?WSFhZ?@]ùDë
0. 8
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
0. 8
100
0
10
20
30
40
RankOrdeofptim
RankOrdeofptim
.D3 $S
Y
50
60
\
70
80
90
100
J
WJ
"
"
%
(
h
"
! $ !#"
" !
jDÙCX§Uhà=BEVOFhDGW?@Cë|YHOBAÛUhU2U2>EDGH½D@CV?JD.Ü6U2>A>AZ?DG@ÜIæè<?ÜhJFhJKZSWSW?DA@ÈV?BjH[JKDAJKBA>G>EB&@CØ?]^DAFIZS<O>GDAYUu@ÄFIDrB&V<OYUxFhßh@Ä]=Þ JFIJØ[WHSJKDGØ?J@CYV¹Z?V[U6>.WSU2@ÈÙÄ@ÈBÅ@CBGV?JKUèÜ[WÚhZO@CØ?VbBEZSJDA]^D=Z?<?DGÙ@C<?BrDGJKJUh>GÛ.>EJ#<?DA@CUhV?Û>G@ÙÄJJIÚQZ?FhBGJ:DGZO<?]^Û.JKFh<¹> >ÅUIJ,B(Z?ÞSJH?DABj<?ÙÈDAU2J¾@Ä@CFIV?>AVOFh@CV?B(ÙCJÜ6U2Ø½Fhà] Fh< Z? × D
V?ðÄùóuDGJK<Oô|BAõöJBñuM ÷[V Ö M Z?V6YDGØ½<O@CJB>¦BGF2JK]§Û,DGUh@C>EFhDAVÂ@CÛÚ ÙÄàPJB J¦#JU2ÞSVOH?W ÙCUh @ÄV¹^DGDG<?<?JJ:BEJ$V Z?WSY@Äæ/Ø½J>AJJ>¾VOF2Û]§JKBPÛ,FI@ÄVVOBG>AZ?Z?YÜhÜIJJK>.BWSrVO@CJKVÝBAB§U2ZOæ½BGJ@CÛ8V?DGÜ@CV?ó Ü6S>GôºñZ?.ÜIñuÜhò8JòGW íëø
%
(
%
(
!
DG>A<?UhVOJ:WSL#>GFhZOFhY Üh>.WÜhjJàP@CWSRéUhV?ÙÄRÉJü 2BGÿrFuBßIWSF2JJ]§>$BGUbÛU>GÙÈ@CU2ÙÈØ½U2V[JKVOW?BW?BGDGBAÛK<?ÛU2UhJèH½H[JhZOJIM/BGÚ±ì~J6>GFèJFhDA]Û,UhFI@ÄU2V?VOZS@CBjDAV?DAF Ü>GÛZ[FhU2Û8>AÙCDÙ&>GJKDADAÙC<?<?U2@ÈJDGB¾@CFhYVÊJUhUhBGB:Z?U>GJKY:YHOJJDGVQU2<?@CDK>AFSÚ½BKW FhMÂV?ìrF2J:]#<?Û,@ÈYBFIVOJKBGWSUIJ>ABEZO@ÄZ?Û,J>ADABÅ@CB¦V?F2UÜ ]
DGDGHO>.@CU2Y:U2@CVO>AJ$B¾BG@BG@ÈDAJB@Ä>AFI@ÄDAVOJ<?B=B(JÜIVÝUhJVODGV?U2>AJKÙCJK×S>AU2U2BEDG@ÈDGJKBPJWÉWR V?V?ØQFuF2×àD$U V¹UhÝB¦UhBrU6U2>AUhBGRhZSJ FuDGßFSZ?Û,HOJKFIVO>G>GFSÛ,>AJ3Û,JJÙÈF2UuBG]=DABK@ÄM FIBEåDGVJKHOJ¾DGFB¾ÛKU2Ø?OVZSVOD$WèDA<?@ÄU2V[JV6V6BjDAJKJKU2BEUhH?DGWÝH?@CYÙCUh×UuB¦DGUÅJ¦U6DGF2JBGÛ.]J<?>A>G@ÄV?ZOJ@ ÜhB#ÜhZ?FhJ]=J#WSBjV?]^D.>AJFhUuBGDAY BKJ M
éßxUhÙÄ<OZOUuJ$DF2àP]~JèDA<?àJ @ÈBG<DGFâDG<R V?H½FuFhà @CVID@ÈBM <?FuFIà >GJÅàP@CY:JÙCH½ÙrFhDG>G<ODAJèUhVQÙÈUhDGÙCBE×hD ÚSàPJ$H½àFh@C@CVIBG<èD.BDGFU2ÙCÙÄR FuV?à FuàêZ[B:DA<?DGJ$FâÙCH?Uh>G>AÜIJKWSJKBE@ÈÛ8D D§DG]^<OFIJ>
àÙÄJ<?BGB¾@CÛ.>G<bZODGÜh<?ÜhJJWèDG<?J:ºDGÙÈ<U2VOH½W?FhBA@CVQÛUhDPH[ÛJIUhÚ½VbBGØ½@CVOJÛ,H?J:>AU¹JKWSÙC@ÈJKÛ8UhDA>GJKV?WJK>]^>AFhàY @CÙÄÙDG<O<OUxJ ßI/J3DGUb<¹ÜIH[>GFIJ@ÄUuVQD¾DKM W?ìrJK<?U2ÙJ¾F2ÙCUh]=>G@ÄÜIVSJ]^>FI>G&Y@ÈBU2ÚIDGDG@CFh<OV J
DGÙCUh<OVOU2W?DrBA@ÄÛD#U2ÛH½UhJÅV¹@ÄVZOBGàJ¦<?DG@ÈF:Û.<H?>GHOJUhWSBE@ÈDÛ8DrFhDGØO<?BGJÅJ>AV?ßuJUuÞ DA@ÄDrFIH½VOFhBP@C<OVQUxDKßhM JÅÙC@BGDGYDGÙCUhJ$ÙÄÙH?>G=J@ÄWSVO@ÈW?Û8@CDGÛK@CßhUuJÅDGJßuBrU2UÙCZ?>.JIU2Ú?H?à@ÈWS<?ÙC@È×bÛ.<6Û.<O@ÈBU2VOàÜh<O@CV?U2Ü D
@CBYJU2VQDØQ×¹>GZ?ÜIÜhJWSV?JKBABKM
BEÛ,JKÙCFI>G@CBGì~JKJBÙCFè×F2Ø[]&>AJJH[ÙÈUuYFIDA@ÄVQFhJKD.Wå>ABJ:DGH?<O>GJKJBGUhÛ,J¹VO@ÈBEW BEJIJKÚ/>G@Cà=JKJB3"Ø½U2$ >AJJhÜhM @CVåÖ ]ØQÛ×Fußu>A U2JK>AÛK@CU2UhÙCüVOÙÄ@CÛ,V?JÅÜ6ÿ@ÈDGB<OV?U2FIDÅ>GDGY<?JUhÙÄ@CÛ,äFuJ@ÈßuB¦WâUhU2>GØQV@ÈU2×âVO@CVOWSÛWSJ@Cß @ÈÛØ½@CWSUuJ,@CDADjV?FhàPÜÉ>¾JJKF2Ø VÝ](×å<?DjDGàPFu<Oà FJ
H?>GFSWSZ[Û8DFh]PDA<?J¹BEDAUhVOW?U2>.WâWSJß @ÈUuDA@ÄFIVOBFh] UhVOW ÚÂDA<?JV à=Jb<[UxßhJ:DG<?J .ñuò8òGíðÄóuô|õöñu÷
Ø[JDjà=JKJV *UhVOW bÚ?WSJKV?F2DAJKW
M
DjU3à=àrF#ZUxBE×SJK>GDAF2@CF ]JKÛBKYFhÚ±>AJKàP>GUIJKJ:BEÙCZ?U2UhDG>A>G@C@CFhJ:V?V$ÜÜh@ÈFIDAB<?@ÄV?U¾JÜ6ÛÛ.ÙÄDG<OFQFUhBEJKV?ÛÙÄÜhFh×ÅJ¦Y>A@ÄJHOVèÙÈU2UuDA>ADG<?JJJ$WUèH?Û,FIBG>AJF VO>AÛÛ,@CJKJKJKBAHSB¾BPDKDGÚxFuFâJßhÞSJõùôÛ>P,JíDAHS@Äð .DYÚ~DGJhBG<[<?M[Uu@ÄìrD&]ùDG<?@ÄJV[JWBjDAU2Ø JKZS×ÝUhDAWFSU6Û,F2FhDA][>A@ÄÛY>AFhJJYÙÈUuDGÙCHOUh@CU2FhÜO>AV¹ÚÂ@CV?UIF2Ü B]
M
H[FI@ÄVQDA(B §BjDAJHOBUhHOU2>GD@ÄVUBGJ>A@ÄJB b@CBW?J OV?JWUhB #Z
S
A
D
F
Û
h
F
A
>
G
>
K
J
C
Ù
2
U
G
D
C
@
h
F
V
2
U
C
Ù
Ä
Ù
u
F
#
à
B
O
Z
B
G
D
é
F
S
W
,
J
A
D
J
A
>

Y
Ä
@
?
V
J
G
D
?
<
J
Û
h
F
A
>
G
>
K
J
C
Ù
2
U
G
D
C
@
h
F
V
C
Ù
J
O
V
2
Ü
G
D
<
h
F

]
B@CGBrÛKU2DAH½<?JèJ$ÙÈü U2>A
2Ühÿ|Ú/JKBEàD <?&@ÈÛ.]^Fh<Ý>àPàJ3<?à@ÈÛ.@C<èÙCÙ&DGZO<?BEJKJ>GJÅUh@ÈBÅBUhUVÝBE@C@CVOÜhVOWS@@È[ÛUuÛKDAU2FhVQ>ÅDGÙCF2×]PV?>GFIZOV?ÜhäÜhJKJ>GWSFV?U2JZ?BGBKDGM/FS;=Û,FIFI>G>G>A>AJJÙÈÙÈUuUuDADA@Ä@ÄFIFIVÂVÉMUÙÄJKÙÈV?U2Ü2VODAW < ë
BHOGÛKUuU2DAH½<OJKB BJÅFhUIÛ,VOFIB J§Y: Û,H[FIU2ÙÄU2ÙC>AJKVOJ#Û,W DGDGJK<OW$ J¦DGUh<?UhZS>G>ADGJ6FhFSZ?ßuÛ,ÜIFIU2<>G>A>A@ÄU#JJW±ÙÈBEUuDGM DAJÖ@ÄJKFIV H[VJUIBjF2W?DG]ÂëºWSUIDj@ÄàPDGBG@CÛF2FhJëºVÂVQHOÚD¢UhàPUh>ED(ÙÄJ¹ÜID.FhU2Û,>AFI>A@@DAVOæÉ<?BGY@CUhWSVOJKÚ,Wbà><?DjYàP@ÈÛ.@ÄFÞ <J@ÄWSWbV[@ÄWSæ/Ø?@CJZOÛK>AVOUuJDAWSVQJKÙCD:B¢@ÄV?BG>GÜ:FhZ?>GÜIÙÈDAU2ÜhBVOJW W F2ëë]
V?ÙCUhJKVOBAW?BBAWSÛU2Z?H½>A@ÄJhVOÚ±ÜåàFI<OHS@CÛ.DG<Ê@CYBG@ÄJä>AUußhDAJK@ÄFIBÅVÂUIÚ(BU2U2VOVåW FuFhßhVOJKJè>AUhÛÙÄÙ&FhÙCÛ.ÙÄ<OJÛ8UhDG>AJUIWÛ8DGDAJK<?>G@C>AäKFhU2Z?DGÜI@CFh<VÉUåFh]P>.U2>AVOZ?WSÜIFIÜhYý
àPJKUhBABÙÄRÊM±ìrFu<?ßIJ@ÈB$>:àDG<O@CÙÄJ Ù
K
J
?
W
?
V
<?ÙÄJJU2ÙC>AHVOZOU2Ø?B@CDAÙC@FDj×Z?VOFh]¢WSJKDjàP>ABEF2DAëºUhHOVOU2W>GDPàDA<?U2J>ADG@ÄæÝ<?JKU2>#VOHOWèU2>GYDG@È@Û,ÞSZOJÙCW6Uh>#ØOZ?ßuU2VOÙCWSZ?ÙCJK@ÄVOBÜOFhM ] UhVOW H?ÙÈUx×6UHOUh>ED@CVDG<OJ
@ÄU2V?VOÜWìrDGßu<?<?U2JÅJr>A× WSJ,@Ä@ÈÞSVOBjH[DAÜ >GJK@C>GØ?@CYZSU2DAJ@ÄVOFIVQWV¹D( àPFh]¢FhØ½>AÛ,J,R FIDjBVOàPBEUIJZOBJY:V]^FhJKÙC
>AÙÄFuB(à#DGU2<OBV[uU2W à=DPJÜI
JÜI
V?J8JKV?M >AJKåU2>ADGU2JJDGWDAJr<?DGUÅJ<?V¹>AJ¦UhÛ.ÙCVOJK<OWSU2FQFI>AFQV?Y BE@CJ V?H?Ü
>GF Û
?Z?
¾D(>GßI>.ÙÈJKU2U2B=VOV[W?WS@ÄV BAFhÛY ¢Uh@CH[ÜhH[J ZOFI>Gö@ÄVQZOJ DABjBë
FhH[VÊFI@ÄVQDA<?D$J6Z?VQÙÈU2DGV[@CÙ§W?U2BGVåÛKU2FhH½H?J6DG@CUhYVOWZ?Y5>AZ?@ÈV B$>AUJKUIBjÛ.DAJ<?JJKH½W±JKM BEåDEëtUhJ:BAÛ,DG<?JKVQJKD3Vâ<?Û@CFhÙÄYÙÄëtÛ,H?ÙC@ÄZSY3DAJ:Ø?@ÄDGVO<?ÜJbU2UhÙCZSÜhDGFIFS>GÛ,@ÄDGFI<O>GY>AJÙÈUu]^>ADAFh@ÄFIY VÉJFuUhßhÛ.JK< >
DGU2<OZSU2DAD§F ÛHOFhUu>ADA>G<:JKÙC]Û2FhDG>§@CFhUhV ÙÄÙ?ùà]^Fh@CVO>WSJKFuUhàãÛ.<âBG@ÄàäKJK@CVOBWS]^>AFuFhà Y BErD@CäAJ F ÅWS
ÅZ?>AUh@ÄVOVOWÜUxFhßhHSJDA>.@ÄU2YÜI@CJ§äKUuDA<?DA@ÄJFIVå>AJKBG]^FhZ?>$ÙD.BDA<?DG@CF$BÜIÙCUhJ,D§VOW?UÅBAYÛUhJKH[UhJIV M
ìrWSZ?<?>A@C@ÄB3V?Ü@ÈB$FhDGHS<ODAJ@ÄV YUx@CäKßIUuJDA>.@ÄU2FIÜIVãJKWå]^FhUh>bÛ,J>AUhFIÛ.BA<éB BA
ÉÛ.<?ÙCJKUhWSVOZOW?ÙÄBAJIÛMU2#H½JKJBKÞ Ú~DKÜIÚ=@Ä]^ß Fh@C>bV?ÜÝJUhUhÛ.V<éUxÙÈßhU2JVO>.W?U2BAÜIÛJUhH[U2JIZSÚ(DAF àPÛJÝFh>AÛ,>GFIJKVOÙCU2WSDGZO@CFhÛ,V D
àU6Uxßh@>.DAJU2<>.V[U2àÜIWSJKFh@CWVOY5WSUhFuàrÛà >GU2FQÙCBGBGR@CB äF2JK]rB¦
bÙC]^JÙÈ>AU2V?FhV[ÜhY W?DG<BG3DÛKU2GH½
F JKB
¹$
?DGUhF6M±VOìrWå×Q<?@CJYJKÙÈBGWÝJKJ:UhU¹BG>AZ?Uh>AVO>AUhJWSVOFhWSDAY<?FIJbY àrU2àrU2Z?ÙCDGU2RÉFSÙCRÛ,U2FIZ?U2>GDGZS>AFSJDAÛ,ÙÈF UuFIÛDA>GFh@Ä>AFI>AJ>GVÉÙÈJKUuÙCFuDAU2@ÄßhDGFIJK@CVOFh>¾BVDAUh<?]^FI>G@ÈB$J>¾àPDGJ<?UhUhJKÛ.ÙÄV<R
BGÛ.<?JWSZ?ÙCJhM
%
h
#
,%( (
M"
h
b
#
%
4%B(
$%4%
$
(
!
!
"
/. )0
'&)(+*-,
1-23154
B(
"
!7
<
8%
6
:9<; =?>=?>A@CBEDGF9<; =?0>ADH9<; I>A@CBAD
J)KML , =?>
!"
#"
)
$( %
0(
[
?
%
B
Autocrelainfdmwkspxbg(N=10,C=10)
Autocrelainfpmzhswdxbg(N=10,C=10)
1
1
twoparif
twoparif
0. 9
mixedbunlg
mixedbunlg
0. 8
0. 8
0. 6
0. 7
n
n
0. 6
0. 4
0. 5
Autocrelai
Autocrelai
0. 2
0. 4
0. 3
0
0. 2
0. 2
0. 1
Igj¨ £IfQiP[pQ¶¸IkjnoO¶o¤nopQ£u¤g§=fQfIytgji.cu y§mA8cKs¦ktkjeQIi.sa gjs £3gjno8cK¤ pi.GpI sKiA¿kEy3s£Is6gjiPi8¸3}ÈoiAfI}C¨2pQg&{3mAËQgjs¾no¤cfhkEpÊkjsiPp çhfQ}cyt·(iAd y(nop s¾·&¸Ise c8·s,?gj £ytno¤¼.i.ipI}ÈiAcKkEksgjg|i8·¸cKüªöe {$s,yºktgjgi.i.gEeSskji.nzyºÁ g§ssKytp m.¸i.pud$g8InosK»hpQi8¸¸
0. 4
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
0
40
0
5
10
15
20
.D3 25
30
35
40
WindowSze
WindowSze
IY ]
\
_S
Autocrelainfdmwkspxbg(N=10,C=100)
Autocrelainfpmzhswdxbg(C=100,N=10)
1
1
0. 9
twoparif
mixedbunlg
0. 8
0. 8
0. 6
0. 7
n
n
0. 6
0. 4
0. 5
Autocrelai
Autocrelai
0. 2
0. 4
0. 3
0
0. 2
twoparif
0. 2
mixedbunlg
0. 1
Ïsp fQ[¸pQ¶¸Igj?o£Qno¶pQir¤ =kjnofI¤gj£ucug( mAfQcK.ytkt iAkj~i.y=a ss¾gje nocK.spgj £:sKG¢y3¤i.¿s6pI£IiA}Èi:kEfIspQogjiAi8mA}Cgj¸3g¦noc¨2Ë pÊ{¤fhcskj}i:kE·(sKfIp noytp ¸hi.¸IcyÅc8d ·sb·e ytsKs,no¼.gjSi£Ý }È¤KcKi.kpQiGg|·kEscKgjªöi8e ¸És,ktüg{gEsyºgjkji.nzÁ i.eSsKiAp yºg¸sKd$ytm.noiA»hp2i8g8¸
0. 4
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
0
0
5
10
15
.D3 20
25
30
35
40
WindowSze
WindowSze
Y]
\
_S
hFÛU2HSVDA@Ä¢YWS@C>.Üh@CUxäKZOàUu>GDAJ@ÄBGB FIJVb?ßIÚJHO>. U2U2Ú DGÙÂ<O?ÛB(ÚOFhUh]^VOFhVOÛ> WÙÄZO þ:BG@CFhÛ VOFhYBKM HOUh@Ä>G>.
J$BjDU2
ÚSZ?rDG<ODGUhFSJVOÛ,WBEFI@C>GÜh >AVOJ@ÙÈ [UuDAÛK@ÄU2FIVQV¹
DFuàßh
@ÄJKV[
>rWSIØ[FuM Fhà ODG>G<FIBG@CY ä>AUhJ$VODA@È<?WSBJKFIYBGY J ZO[Û.àP<ÜhUhZ?ÙÄBG>ARSYJKBBKU2Ú2UhÙCàPVOÙÄJKW J>
DGàFh<?V?<?@ÈJ B$JVêB=BE<OBjFID.FhUuHSZ?DGDGÙÈJI@CWÝYÚI<OVO@ÄäKFhF2@ÄH½DÅVOJ,Ü Ø[]^Z?JFhÙCVÙÄBG×Z?J>G@CV¹HO@ÄDG>G<?U$@ÈBEJKZ[@C>6V?BEÜ[ÙÈJU2]^Ú/Z?VOBGÙ±WO@CVOBGWSÛ,ÛK@ÄJ3>AU2JKH½DGÛ,J<?DG@CJFhDG<OVÂàUhM <?V Ö FID=ÙÄà@ÈJB§<?H½@CJKVQFhVêDG@CJKVQ>GH½DÅJJBjFh>GDA]§]^@ÄFhV?Fh>AÜH?Y:DGDG@C@C<OV?Y:U2Ü @CDPäU@CØ½V?F2Ü>ADAUh<b@ÈVOB¦ÙCWSUhDGFIVOFYW?Û.BA<OÛàrU2UhU2V?H[ÙCÜIJR/JB ç
]^DGH?JFÝ>G>AFSJJWSVOæ½Z[ÛJJbÛ,Û8JKDA@ÄW@ÄV ßIßIJÙÄJÙCJ×å>AU2×3>A>AV?JKBG@Ä@ÄUIVOYÛ.ÜÝ<Ê@CÙCUhWSFh>§@ HSU2DAZ?@ÄÛYZ?DGFSÙÄUODjÛ,×åM FIÖ >G@ÈVO>AB3JBEDGÙÈH?UuJ>GDAUhFI@ÄW±FIØOÚVOU2BFhØOZOÙÄà×><?V?H?JVF2>AJDFIß WSHS@CFhZ?DGZO@CJbYB3DA@ÄÛ,äKFÝFh@ÄVOV[UÝÜOÛ,ÚQW?ÙCZO@Ä@VOæ/BE@CW?JFh>A@CVâÛKJUuVODADGÛ<O@CJbV?UuÜ$D@CVÊDAWS<ODG@ÈUuBj<?DAD§Jè>GDG@CØ?U2<?Ø?ZSJ¦DA@CWSÙC@Ä@FI@Dj]ùV× ë
F2WS]§@ bFIÛHSZ?DG@CÙYDDAU6FàrYUhFuB¾ßhYJ¦FhØ[>AJJ3Djà=ZOJKV?J@V]^FI>GFhY HSDA@Ä]^YFI>ÅU PY:ÜI@ÄÞSU2@CJKVOWBrØ?Û,Z?>AJKVOW?W?JÙÄVO@CV?ÛÜ JhM ^YJKUhV?@ÄVOÜUhÙCBGFbDA<OUuD$@ÄD¦@ÈBÅYFh>AJ
UhB JKÛU2FhVOVOW W±Ú àPU2J¾>AJVOF2ßuDGU2J¾>A@CDGJK<[W±UuÚ½DKàÚQ]^<?FI@C>PÙÄJ3>.U2DjV[à=WSFhFhë|H[Y U2>GàrD#U2DAÙCUhRS>GB@ÄÚQæåY@CY@ÞSH?JKW¹>AFuØ?ßhZ?JKBVOW?àÙÄ@C<?V?JÜVBEJ<O@ÄFuDG<?à#JKB§> ÙC@ DGDGÙCFhJ$> Û.<O U2V?U2ÜI>AJJ
'
b
!"
*
$(
%
X"
Autocrelainfdmwkspxbg(N=100,C=10)
Autocrelainfpmzhswdxbg(C=10,N=100)
1
1
twoparif
0. 9
mixedbunlg
0. 8
0. 8
0. 6
0. 7
n
n
0. 6
0. 4
0. 5
Autocrelai
Autocrelai
0. 2
0. 4
0. 3
0
twoparif
0. 2
mixedbunlg
0. 2
0. 1
Ïsp fQ[¸pQ¶¸IgjO¶o£QnopQir¤ =kjnofI¤gj£ucug( mAfQcK.ytktiAkj i.y=¢ss¾a gje no cKsp.gj £:sKG~y3¤i.¿s6pI£IiA}Èi:kEfIspQogjiAi8mA}Cgj¸3g¦noc¨2Ë pÊ{¤fhcskj}i:kE·(sKfIp noytp ¸hi.¸IcyÅc8d ·sb·e ytsKs,no¼.gjSi£Ý }È¤KcKi.kpQiGg|·kEscKgjªöi8e ¸És,ktüg{gEsyºgjkji.nzÁ i.eSsKiAp yºg¸sKd$ytm.noiA»hp2i8g8¸
0. 4
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
0
40
0
5
10
15
20
.D3 25
30
35
40
WindowSze
WindowSze
Y]
\
_S
Autocrelainfdmwksvpxbg(N=100,C=100)
AUtocrelainfpmzhswdxbug(N=100,C=100)
1
1
twoparif
0. 9
mixedbunlg
0. 8
0. 8
0. 6
0. 7
n
n
0. 6
0. 4
0. 5
Autocrelai
Autocrelai
0. 2
0. 4
0. 3
0
0. 2
twoparif
0. 2
mixedbunlg
0. 1
Ïsp fQ[¸pQ¶¸IgjOo£Qno¶pQir¤ =kjnofI¤gj£ucug( mAfQcK8ytktKiAkj i.y=½ss¾a gje nocKsp8gjK£:sKGy3¤±i.s6pI¿iA£I}ÈkEfIi$spQgjoi8mAiAgj¸3}Cnog#c¨2pÊË {¤KcsfI}kjkEiÅ·(sKp fInop ¸hyt¸Ii.cy#c8d · s:·eQytsKnos¼. gjSi£è }È¤KcKi.kpQg|iG·kEscKgjªöi8e ¸¹s,kt¨2g{bgEsyºgjkjiAnzÁ i.eSsKi.p yºg¾¸sKd$ytm.noiA»hp2i8g8¸
0. 4
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
0
0
5
.D3 10
15
20
Windowsz
WindowSze
Y]
\
25
30
35
40
e
_S
@ÄBEVO@CVOÛÛ,>GJJ¾Uh@ÄBGV[JKÛ,W±>AMJKUhåBG@CJV?Ü J,ÞS H½JKU2Û,HODGH[JKJWU2>.@CB&VOÛ,DG>AF3JKUI>GJBEWS@CV?ZOÜâÛJJ@ÄDGDG<?<OJÅJ>BG@ÄäKßuJ#U2>AF2@C]~UhØ?WSÙC@ÈJ6BAÛ,FhDAFÊVQDA@Ä@ÄYV Z?H?@Ä>ADGFu@CJKßhB=J@ÄVbU2Z?DGDG<?FSJ¦Û,ÙCFIUh>GVO>AJW?ÙÈBAUuÛDAUh@ÄFIH[VÂJIMÚ
Öà=DJ$@ÈBÛUhZ?VèVOÛÛÙÄFhJU2VO>ÛÙÄàZ[<QWS×$JÅYDG<O@ÄU2ÞSD#JKW@D#ØO@ÈZ?BrVOÙCJKWSBAÙCBr@ÄVO>GÜÅJBEW?@ÈFQBjD.JU2B~VQVODrF2DGD(FBE<OUFuÛ.àâ<OUhDGV?<?ÜhJrJ¦BGUh@ÄVèYDAJ=<?@CJKYBGJÅH?>GHOFuU2ßI>.JU2YYJJ,VQDADJçK>.<?BFuM àPJßIJ>Ú
DGà<O<?UhJVVê@J§DFIUhHS@ÈÙCBDGBG@CF]^YFIÛK>#@ÄU2äKDjV@ÄàPVOBGÜOF2JMëºJ&HODAU2<O>GJåUuDrDDAÛ,U2UhFhZS>GV@ÄDAjæJKF Ú½Û8ÛDAFhU2Z?ÙÄ>ADG>A>G<?JJKFIÙCU2DGZ?DG<OÜh@CU2Fh<D¹V¦FI@CDAV?B<?ÙÄBGJÝ×6@ÄÜI>A]^V?FhJK@ >UI½BE>AÛFIUhU2VãVOVQWSDA]^ÙÄFhFh×¾>bY <?DA@ÄàPÜI<?<?@ÈUhB¹JÙÄRS>~@ÈBKB6]^FhM W?>¢Ö DZ?Y:JÉ@ÈB#@ÄÞSDAßIJKFÊJW$>ADGØO×6<?Z?JBGVO@ÄYWSÙCUhÙC@C@Ä>GÙCVOÜIUhÜJ>
H?àÙC@ÄU2ÙCÙÂDGJ<OU2UxZOßIB#J¦BGUhJVJKVUhZS@ÄVDGFSDAÛ<?FhJ>A>GYJKÙC@U2ÞSDGJ@CWFhVbØ?FhZ?] VOWShMÙC@CV?ÜbÙÈU2VOW?BAÛUhH[JIçOU>.U2VOWSFIY àrU2ÙCR6U2ÙCFhVOÜUHOÙCU2DGJKUhZ
DAF2U2DG>A<O@ÄJ¢æ6> @CàVOUh
<?ÙÄ
?JKÙC×hVbM ÚxìrØ[àP<?FhJP@CDGBrVO< YF2 DGUxJ=×UhDG<[VOØ½UuW J$D&WSDGZ?<OU2J¾JP>AJDGJ Fæ½JU
Û8
¦DAz@ÄBEßIFuDGJ=ßh>AJ,JàDA>(Û.@CDG<OVO<?@ÄWSV?J¦FuÜ àÛ UhF2BGBE]ÂJ@CäDAàJr<?<?UhJÅÛ,JKÙCDG>GUhZOJ#VOUhFIW?ÙÄV?ÙCBA×ÛJ#U2WSßuH½JKU2JÅÛ>A>G@ÈUhJU2BUhØ?BGÙC JJKB~@C@ÈB]^BPFh>@Ä
$V[DjÛ,àPUh>AVOF2JKWëºUhHOBGDGJKU2<OWÂ>GJD ç
DG<?J$Jæ½JÛ8DG@CßhJ$>.U2VOÜhJ¦F2]~DA<?JÅ]^JJ$H[U2>.U2YJ,DAJ>rF2]Djà=Fhë|H[U2>GD=D.U2>A@æÉÜI>GFuà#BPà@ÄDG< M
Q
!"
*
à=U2H?JH½ÖàPJKVUhJÙ(>ABEJ3Z?DGFÝYH?>AY:YJß JU2@CDA>AFhUh×hZOH?Ú~BG<?DGÙC×Fh<?>.JUhBKBEM~Ø?J6ÙCìrJ3J,<?ÞSDAJH½F>AJJb>AJ,@ÄÞSÛ,YH?ÙCJKJÙÈUhU2VQ>[email protected]ÙCB×FI<?BGV?JKJÙÄÙÄJK×HYDAZ[BÅ<?B>ADGFhFÉDAZ?FÉØ½ÜIZ?<J6VOUUèWSJKÛ>G>AJKFhBEÙÄ>ADA@È>GUhU2JKVOV[ÙCWU2Û,J:DG@CFhFhZOVåVåU2VQØ[H?DAJ@C@Û,DjD.DGà=UuZ?DGJK>A@CJßhJKVÊJKBÅÙÄ×åFIUhHSVOàDGW@C<OYUhU2VU D
Ø?>GWSZ?@CZ?BEÜIVODGÜh>AWSJ@CÙCØ?WS@CV?ZSV?ÜODGJK@CMxBAFhìrBKV ÚQ<?UhU2JÙ>ADAVOJ(<?WêFh@ÈB¢Z?ÙÄJUhÜIU2ÙC<6BG>AFV?VO@ÄBGF2VOFhDÜ YV?J(WSJK@ÛJKbJKßQBA@ÈÛ,BGWSZ?UhJKÙÄ>GDjVO@C×éÙCÛ,×:J&à@CDAV<O@DAUuU3< Dàr@Ä>AV[JUxÛ,ÜQ×:>AU2JKDG>.Uh<OWBGU2@CD#V?DGF Ü Uuæ/éDjJKà=Û8U2FhD.V[ë|BrHOW ÙÄUhJ >EU2D¹>A>GV?DAJ@CU2WSV?>AZOÜ3@ÄæÛH½JKBÂJUh>GÙÈVO]Û2FhWêV[>AW?YYBGÛKU2@ÄÞ U2VOH½JÛW JJ
]^Fh>#U2VU2ÙCÜhFI>G@ÄDG<OY BEZ[Û.<èUIBU2YF JØOUOM
Ñ=ÎÔ EÓ ÕjÑ§Î
&ÎÒ 8ÓÏ?Ó#Ð âÑ(Ð ÖàV <?JDA>A<?J:@ÈBÛZ?U2Y>GDG@ÈZOÛ,ÙCÙCU2JhDGÚ&@CßhàPJ:Jè>GJK<[àPUxßhUhJ>AWWS@ÈJKB¾BAÛ,DG>A<?@ÄØ½JJKYW JKDGUI<OBEJZO>GH?J:>GF2FI]§Ø?ÙCH½JJY >G]^FhFh>A]¾YÙCJKU2U2VO>AÛV?J:@CV?UhÜåVOWÝ@ÄVéBEDGU2>AVJKBABGJJKV Wß @CDA>G<?FIJV?YV?JJJVQW D
]^@D.FhB§>§DAUhF2VbD.U2UhÙ/W?>GUhJKHSàPDGUh@Cßh>AJWÂMU2åÜIJJ¦VQD&<[DGUxF3ßhJ¾Û,FhUhV[>GBEÜI@ÈZ?WSJKJW>&àDG<O<[U2UuDPD§ÙÈ@ÄU2D=VOÛ.WO<?BGF ÛKFIU2BGH½JKJKBBPDAU2F>AJ¾ÙCJKU3U2>AZOVBEUhJ]^B(Z?UÅÙ/>GàrJKUxH?×>AJKFhBG]/JVQFIDAHSU2DGDG@CY@CFh@ÄVäK@Ä]^VOFIÜ >
ÙÄU2JVU2J¦>AU2V?BEÜI<?@ÄJVOFuVQÜàPD JKH?BÂW:>GÙCJKFIDAUhØ?<O>GÙCUuVOJDPY@ÄV?DjÚÂÜàPDAHOF<O>GYUuFIDØ?J,ÙÄDGFhJK>A]#Y @ÈÛÙÄBKJUhÚQU2VO>AWSWV?@ÈBE@CUhDGV?H?>AÜ@ÄH?Ø?H?ÙCZ?@Ä>AJDG@CW¦@CÛFhJ¹DGVb<?BGFhJPÛ.]Â<OU2FhJKVOHSWSUhDAZ?ÙÄ×S@ÄÙCYJKBGB@CUB±@ÄFhUhV ]?VOÙCUhWbUhVÊVOU2W?Z?@ÄV?BADGÛ]^FSFhUhÛ,>AH[FIYJ>GB±>AU2JDGDGÙÈF¾@CUuFhDAUVâ@ÄFIHOJKVÂU2ÛÚh>GFhDGÛV?@ÈUhÛ,FIVbZOYÙCØ½Uh×IJ> M
DGÛWSF¹U2@ bÙÈÛ,JÛZOÞSZ?ÙCH?U2ÙÙCDjDGUh×âJK@ÄVWFh>A]¾UhJKVOWSBGWZ?@Äæ½ÙÄZODAJKBBG>GJKJK@ÄWÝVIVÉD:UhFIÙCB¾Z?Uh>#JKVOBEW?H?DGBA>A@CYÛJUhß U2H[@CDGFhJJZOBB#BÚF2U2à=](V FI>A>GZ?UIR/ÜIW?MOÜhU2NPJKHSW?×èDAV?@ÄßIZOJKJ¹BGBA@ÄBV?U2Ú½ÜIÜ¹U2JVODGVQ<?WèD3J]^ÛKBEZOJU2>EVÊDAY:<?DAJJ<?DG>¦J>A@C>AZOÛKJBGB#Ø JK×âDAWFbYDAJK<?BEU2JKDGRhBG@CJJ6YYUÉUuDAJ,JYDA>GDGFh@È<O>AÛJJB
@ÄVS]^FIìr>GY<?JJ>AWèJPW?UhJK>GÛ,J=@ÈYBG@ÄFIU2VèV ×$UIBPH[FQDGFBGBGà@CØ?<?ÙÄJr@ÈÛ.WS<è@C>GÙCJJKÛ8UhDA>G@ÄVOFI@ÄVOV?B¢Ü:]^FhH?>>AFh]^ZSØ?DGÙCJZOY >GJr@>AD#JKBGàJK@CU2ÙÄÙ¢>.Û.Û.<Â<?M F ¾FIBGV?JJPDAHOFbU2>GBEDGFI@ÈÙÄÛ,ßIZ?JhÙÈM U2>UxßhJKV Z?J
@ÄìrVO<OÛÙÄUuZ[D#WS@ÈJKBWÅÚSàDA<?<OJ§J>AJJ¾Þ DGDAJ<?V[J$BE@CÙÈFhU2V$VOW?FhBA]SÛDGUh<?H[@ÈB¢J$UhUhVOVèU2ÙCUh×SÜhBEJ@ÈB/VQDDAF#@ÈBÙÄJUhU2W?>AUhV?HS@CV?DGÜ#@CV?@CÜ:V$DGV?FFhVOÛ.<OBEDAUhU2V?DGÜh@CFhJVOB=UhFu>GßI×¾J>PJV DGß @CY@Ä>AJhFhMVOÖY:VèJKDAVQ<?DA@CBKB M
ÛU2UhÜhBGJKJhVQÚ½D àPBbJÙCJKàPU2Fh>AZ?V?ÙÈ@CV?WÉÜÊÙC@ÄRIH?J>AFhDAØ?FèÙCJÛ.Y<OUhM >AÖ UIVêÛ8DAHOJ>AU2@Ä>GäKDGJ$@ÈÛ,<?ZOFuÙCUhà >KÚ=DG<?à=@ÈBÅJÝÛ.Uh<O>GU2JVO@CÜhVQJ3DGJKU2>Gæ½JJBjDAÛ8JKD.WéBDA@C<?VêJH?WS>A@ FhbØ?ÛÙCJZ?YÙDj×B¹Fhà](<?DGJ<O>AJJ
Fh@ÄV?V?ÜJDAUhF ÜhFhJKÙÈVIBÅD ØQB×ÝÙÄJàU2<?>AV?@CÛ.@C<ÊV?Ü¹UhÜhUuJæ/VQJKD.Û,B¦DABÛKU2DG<?VâJ3YÙÄJ@ÄU2VO>A@ÄYV?@C@CV?äÜbJH?DG<O>AFhJØ?@C>ÙCJ@ÄY YHOF2UI]§Û8UhDV?FIF2VDA<?JJUh>¦Û.U2<åÜIF2JDGVQ<ODKJÚ½> U2VOBÅWÙCJKH?Uh>A>GFuV?ß @CV?@CWSÜ[ë M
JKUIBEZ?>A@CV?ÜDA<?@ÈB@ÄYHOUIÛ8D#@ÈBUV?JKÛJKBABGUh>G×BEDGJKH6DAFuàPUh>AW6BEFIÙÄß @CV?Ü:DG<OU2D#H?>AFhØ?ÙCJYM
éÔ rÎÑ ~Ò ~Î=Ï
ìr<?@CB#à=FI>GRàrUhBrBGZ?H?H½Fh>GDGJKWè@CVHOU2>GDØQ× Üh>.U2VQDAB ÖEÖ ëºþ $U2V[W ÖGÖ Që Iþ?M
~Ð ~ÎÔ
}ÄakjiA£h{ kjnoyºÅgjcxeQ¡£IsKiAmk§Æ¾niG ªº¥ ¡kjscuytc c2pOy.h sK=p cK¸ ¨SiAkt¸Ig=d¾l?fQ pQ
r¸sKÆ¼8sxoqriKfhktP}Èi.s its,?kj¡:yt£Qc2n[¸Iqi. sKyty.iA iAmAiAgjÁSnokjciAp{ nop¾sK pÅnoiApIeQ}C£ cKkjs,dktg8s, gjniAcK}Cp ª
iAm.cpIcd¾{ Qa£QcucKytnopQ¤Å·(£ s,g(gjcÅoi8skjpO!"$#%&(')*&,+'-' #/.0+1&2*+G ¢gjc$seQeSi8s,k8
3 gjKnoccKytp[ytxi.o©no6p 4p 58
r7s+9kj"pI:;n+1iG$k¦#%2;s('p =<¸ >!i.+9no2$s >?#A@CsKBEooDi."ù' FÆP$#$"c8·ê&":*gjGçIiG"gjHi.mAg!sK"o$¢#%"s&IgtgtkEe ssKmA¤Kgjnoi.cy pKK¨ JxsIu yt( nopQK(yL xcKlh}§eIskjnopI}ÈfI¤pQiAmAktªª
ÇM iAnkjd sK ¤hÆP ckE¸ K|n S [Êd$i8sKytfhkji=c}½sp ¸Iytm.sKeSi.y.C BED(' $#%&":*GN"H!"$#%"&Ih ù K( KJIu( K"K
K
f
#
+*
+*
*
*
h
$
b
' #
S
K
!S
$Y \
I#¿[iApQktnoktwx{ iAkjytcKnzgpQ{i.y.cK} BEDiG(·ã' $¡:#%iG&»I":no*m.GHchS<H¡' .=s."{ :*#- 7K > # $&+1>;>8"&">12;1+1> "&+;:92*72 £QqÉgj£QiAytny.
v
L
L #¿[iAktkt{ cpIi.ysKp ¸èl2gji.eI£ spQnoi$Qcktkji.yºg8/nzgjpQi.yty¸hnyºgEspQm.i$mAcKktkji.sgjnocKpÉsKys3d$i8sytfIkjiÅc}
ehA@3kjc Ï7+iAd#"¸h no7NÃÅ)*m.&fQ,z+1g|:1{:&}È"cK$kr#%"¤&i.('pIiAgjno"mÅ& sK@o+1¤K:;cK+1kj&nz21gj+£Qd$"&y. ©p+1&+1$s,#%kt2kt{ <H' .=yt"£I:*#-i. o7d sK>jpOS?eQi8sK¸I¤Knzi.gjcKy k8
:92* +;+½"#-lI&0s."p >
hkE sK#pQmAsnytoi.mAùcI L s?f ¡:¸hgjcy.kj ¤xsKspQp ¸b#a=sKfI #Á? d§si.p[i. wxiAy. kjcKeSiAktgjnoi.yPc}ÂËQgjpQiAyty§}CfQpQmGgjncKpQ.yP sKIQp ¸3yti8skjmE£
K
B sDp (¸I' ytm.$sK#%"eS&i.":y.¥ [*G ©|p #so!"iA$^#% ¥ &Q eQsKsK¤KfQi.¸hy gjy.2sp ¸[0l2§eIckj¤KnopQiAkj¤Ky.iA2ktªi8¸hnoiGgjkjcÄskjy.¤I 587+9":; +1$#%2;('<>!+92$> @
M
(L Ih( K
KK
g
#sfIÁ?dsp[

:1#/."# &>3 @ :=+1:+' @,":%.=&#"$#%& "&+'/+92$#%& #-&NB D(' $#%"&Q
lugjf s,ktH
=»2}CcKkE¸ pQnowxiAkjytnzg{ kji.yty. iA·¢cKk S
hÇl2i.¨ noosnyºsKgjdánsKv pÊÆ¾¿£hkjkji.fQytp[y§ iAg=¿sK£Iùi kjcoib+1cK:*}#%2;iG('»IeI! ocK+9 kE2s# gj no+1cK>jpÊanpåsKd¾i.ÏskjkjnpQ¸Ino¤KpIi ¤v m.pQcnopuwxgtiGkjkjcKyt^nog{ ©|#p kjiA"3yty.& %K$; & @
/)*&o c,+kj'-i.' iApQ#/.0nm.p2+1iK¨S& iAHkj¤Ki.iApu"k8&gj½fQ$a:9m (ucK'{ukt'kj 3i. +1Ks,gj:9i8 ('¸: sp (¸$)fQ G pIm.&cKktkji.<*s,=gji8*¸$ËI#-D"gj++pQi.ytG"y¢>;,sK+1p ¸h>jyt m8M sKeSspiAy(sKcp yº¸$gtkE£IsKc,pQ·å¸ gj§c#i.gjnopQiA£I cgj£I¸Oi
. ¸hnzÁ?Ç iAkji.pQmAi-,?#%(' ;."#$2*"'CG($*+1:1&+1$#%2>j K ( L I2" K K
K iAl2wxiAc·&osfIogj nocKÇ p[Âkjno©|¤.p £ug8EÅ: ¿2*£I+*i¾+"kj# cK&."iA> y c@ } d¾7+0fIgE/s gj7 nocKp["?&0nop2.":;Ï+1kj>;i.>i8¸h"no&1pQ¤I O+1mA&kjcK+1$yt#$yt2Ï>Ekj i.e i.sK¸I¤KnopQi ¤:= LsKKp ¸b yt i.oi.mA gjnocKpnop
G
]
K
K
]
K
G
]
G
G
S
]
S
]
G

Download Report

Using Landscape Theory to Measure Learning Difficulty for Adaptive Agents.

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz