Doubling Main Injector Beam Intensity using RF Barriers Doubling Main Injector Beam Intensity using RF Barriers K.Y. Ng K.Y. Ng Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, P.O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60540 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, P.O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60540 Abstract. Using rf barriers, 12 booster batches can be injected into the Fermilab Main Injector continuously, Abstract. Using barriers, booster After batches canadiabatic be injected into of thethe Fermilab Main continuously, thus doubling the rfusual beam12 intensity. that, capture beam into 53Injector MHz buckets can be thus doubling in theabout usual10beam intensity. that, adiabatic capture of theare beam into MHz can be accomplished ms. The beam After loading voltages in the rf cavities small and53they canbuckets be eliminated accomplished in about 10 ms. The beam loading voltages by a combination of counterphasing and mechanical shorts.in the rf cavities are small and they can be eliminated by a combination of counterphasing and mechanical shorts. THE INJECTION METHOD THE INJECTION METHOD Instead of slip-staking [1], a method to double beam inInstead of slip-staking [1], a method to double beam intensity in the Main Injector by rf barriers without adiatensity in the Main Injector by rf barriers without adiabatic bunch compression was proposed by Griffin [2]. A batic bunch compression was proposed by Griffin [2]. A booster batch of protons of length Tb and full fractional booster batch of protons of length T and full fractional momentum spread ∆, denoted by 1 inbFig. 1(a) is injected momentum spread A, denoted by 1 in Fig. l(a) is injected into the Main Injector at a negative momentum offset, so into the Main Injector at a negative momentum offset, so that that the the highest highest fractional fractional momentum momentum offset offset is is δ8i1tl and and the the lowest fractional momentum offset is δ = δ − i2 i1 lowest fractional momentum offset is Si2 = 8tl — ∆. A. The The longitudinal longitudinal position position of of the the injection injection is is so so chosen chosen that that the just touches of aa the right right side side of of the the batch batch just touches the the left left side side of square square barrier barrier B B of of width width T7\1 and and magnitude magnitude V V,, which which is is moving to the left at the speed of Ṫ = T /(2T moving to the left at the speed of T22 = Tbb/(2Tcc)) where where TTcc is is the the booster-cycle booster-cycle time. time. The The momentum momentum offset offset of of the the batch injection is so chosen that protons of highest batch injection is so chosen that protons of highest enenergy right ergy on on the the left left1 side side of of the the batch batch will will drift drift to to the the right at Tb per at the the speed speed of of 2\T per booster booster cycle cycle or or − —ṪT22.. Thus, Thus, after after one one booster booster cycle, cycle, another another batch batch marked marked 22 in in Fig. Fig. 1(b) l(b) can be injected again with its right edge touching the left side side of the barrier. In other words, at every booster cycle, aa new new booster booster batch can be injected with the injection point moved half a booster-batch length to the right. The linear beam density can therefore be doubled. The only parameter here is the strength of the barrier, Β (a) (a) which is so chosen that after the booster batch emerges whichthe is so chosen after and the booster batch emerges from barrier, thethat highest lowest energies of the from the barrier, the highest and lowest energies of the batch become symmetric about the nominal energy of batch become symmetric about the nominal energy of the accelerator ring. This is necessary because we need the accelerator ring. This is necessary because we need to place another stationary barrier on the right side of the to place another stationary barrier on the right side of the moving barrier in order to limit the longitudinal motion moving barrier in order to limit the longitudinal motion of the protons after passing through the moving barrier of the protons after passing through the moving barrier so as to guarantee empty spaces along the Main Injector so as to guarantee empty spaces along the Main Injector for future batch batch transfer transfer from from the the Booster. Booster. We We use use aa for future rectangular barrier here just for simplicity, although the rectangular barrier here just for simplicity, although the results depend only on the integrated strength of the results depend only on the integrated strength of the barrier. barrier. To derive of the the barrier, barrier, let let us us go go to to aa more more To derive the the strength strength of general scenario of having the barrier moving to the left general scenario of having the barrier moving to the left 1 at rate of xTbb/T /Tcc (x at the the rate of Ṫ T22 = = xT (x = =\ above).Suppose Supposethe the 2 ininabove). first proton with with momentum momentum spread spread δ5i1a exits exits the the barrier barrier first proton in the A^ N1 turns. turns. Its Its phase phase drift drift in in time time towards towards the the right right is is in the Z N 1 T0 (nδ+nA8)dn, [\Tη i1 + n∆δ )dn , 0(S JO0 (1) (1) where η factor, TTQ0 is the the revolution revolution period, period, 7] is the slip factor, 22 E), e is the proton charge, E is the on∆ δ = eV /( β A5 = /(f$ E\ E β c its longitudinal longitudinal velocvelocmomentum proton energy with /3c ity and c the velocity of light. At this moment, the barrier barrier left by the the phase A^ N1TṪ22TTQ0.. Because has moved towards the left T1 , we must have the width of the barrier is 7\ Z N 1 r]T T1 − N1 Ṫ2 T0 = (Nl η T00((8δni1 + n∆δ )dn , (2) J0 8,7 δ i1 1 δ 8*2 i2 t ! Β (b) (b) δ f1 1 δ f2 2 FIGURE 1. 1. (a) (a) Booster Booster batch batch 11 is is injected injected at at negative negative momoFIGURE mentum offset offset with with the the right right edge edge just touching aa left-moving left-moving mentum just touching barrier B. B. The The vertical vertical arrows arrows are are spaced spaced one one booster-batch booster-batch barrier length TTb apart. apart, (b) (b) After After aa booster booster cycle, cycle, the the barrier barrier moves moves by length by b half a booster-batch length while all particles in batch drift half a booster-batch length while all particles in batch 11 drift past the left edge of the barrier. Exiting the barrier, the batch past the left edge of the barrier. Exiting the barrier, the batch has maximum and minimum momenta, 5^ and 5/- , equal and has maximum and minimum momenta, δ f 1 and δ f 22, equal and opposite. Another booster batch 2 is now injected. opposite. Another booster batch 2 is now injected. from which A^ from N1 can be solved. The exit momentum spread spread of this particle is therefore s 2 Ṫ2 Ṫ2 2T ∆δ (3) − . δf1 = δi1 − − 1 |η | |η | |η |T0 The final final fractional of the protons The fractional momentum momentum offset offset δ5™ f 2 of the protons with the lowest initial momentum spread can be with the lowest initial momentum spread 8 δi2 i2 can be obtained similarly. Equating the two, we arrive obtained similarly. Equating the two, we arrive at at the the strength of the barrier strength of the barrier " # #" T0 Tb2 β 2 E x∆|η | 2 2 , (4) ∆|η | 2 V T1 = 1− 2t 1+ −x , (4) 2|η |Tc2 2Ṫ2 2Ṫ2 where use where use has has been been made made of of the the fact fact that that the the protons protons with with initial momentum spread 3 must drift to the tl right at at aa initial momentum spread δi1 must drift to the right rate of (1 —x)T b/Tc so that a next batch can be injected rate of (1 − x)T /T so that a next batch can be injected b c = −(1 -(l-x)t 2/(x\ri\). − x) Ṫ2/(x|η |). or δSi1n = th CP642, High Intensity and High Brightness Hadron Beams: 20 ICFA Advanced Beam Dynamics Workshop on High Intensity and High Brightness Hadron Beams, edited by W. Chou, Y. Mori, D. Neuffer, and J.-F. Ostiguy © 2002 American Institute of Physics 0-7354-0097-0/02/$ 19.00 226 Obviously, a larger initial fractional momentum spread a larger momentum ∆ of Obviously, the beam will leadinitial to a fractional larger final fractionalspread moA of the beam will lead to a larger final fractionalmomomentum spread. However, when the initial fractional mentum spread. However, when the initial fractional momentum spread is large enough, protons with the highest mentum spread is largeso enough, with the momentum will acquire much protons energy from thehighest movsospeeds much energy from the movingmomentum barrier thatwill theiracquire drifting to the left exceed the ing barrier theirbarrier. driftingThese speedsparticles to the leftwill exceed the speed of the that moving not be speed of the from moving not be able to emerge thebarrier. movingThese barrierparticles and thiswill injection able tofails. emerge from the moving injection method This happens when barrier Ṫ2 < |ηand |δ fthis 1 , resulting fails.strength This happens when Tbarrier 2 < \T]\Sfl9 resulting in method the critical of the moving in the critical strength of the moving barrier T0 Tb2 β 2 E , (5) (V T1 )c = 2e|η |Tc2 (5) which is independent of x, and the maximum allowable which independent of ;c, andspread the maximum allowable initial fullisfractional momentum of the beam is initial full fractional spread of the beam is rmomentum ! 1 1 2Tb 21; . x2 + − ∆c = (6) 4 2 |η |Tc Ac = (6) For a given full fractional momentum spread ∆ of the For a given full fractional momentum spread A of the beam, the speed of the moving barrier must be faster than beam, the speed of the moving barrier must be faster than xTb /Tc where xTb/Tc where s |η |Tc ∆ |η |Tc ∆ l\r]\TcAf\rj\TcA + 1 . (7) x= x = 2Tb +1 (7) 2Tb 2T 2T EMITTANCE EMITTANCEINCREASE INCREASE The Theposition positionofofinjection injectionalong alongthe theaccelerator acceleratorring ring slips to the left by xT for each injection b b for each injection or slips to the left by xT or for for each each booster cycle. bb booster cycle,implying implyingthat thata awhole wholebatch batchofoflength lengthTT of of beam can be injected in the length xT . Therefore b b. Thereforethe beam can be injected in the length xT the ratio ofof final initial ratio finaltoto initialemittances emittancesisis δf1 × 1 |η |Tc ∆ re r= =∆ 1 = 1 + , (8) 1 (8) e 2T27; × b 2 x which is is independent which independentofofx.x.Here, Here,we weassume assumecircumfercircumference of the accelerator ring is infinitely long ence of the accelerator ring is infinitely longsosothat thatinjecinjection can be continued forever. On the other hand, tion can be continued forever. On the other hand,the thefinal final linear density linear densitydoes doesincrease increasebybythe thefactor factorrdrd==1/x. 1/x.For For this reason, wewe should this reason, shouldchoose choosethe thelowest lowestbarrier barriermoving moving speed speedallowable allowablebybythe theinitial initialmomentum momentumspread spreadofofthe the batch. batch.InInother otherwords, words,given given∆,A,we weshould shouldstick sticktotothe the critical x given bybyEq. T1 )c)cfor critical x given Eq.(7)(7)and andthe thecritical criticalsize size(V(VTj for thethe barrier given bybyEq. barrier given Eq.(5). (5). with the lowest energy are injected with offset ∆Ei2 = 1 with the lowest energy are injected with offset AEi2 = ∆E i1 − 2∆E 2 i = −21.6276 MeV. After exiting the movAE 2AE i,= -21.6276 After exiting the moving barrier, their final energyMeV. offsets are ∆E a f 1 = −∆Ei1 = ing barrier, their final energy offsets are AE= — AE 11.8285 MeV and ∆E f 2 = −∆E f 1 = −11.8285 MeV. a = 11.8285 MeV and A£, = -AE = -11.8285 MeV. Thus, the energy spread has been increased by the factor 2 fl Thus, the1energy spread has been increased by the factor ∆E f 1 /∆E 2 i = 11.8285/4.8995 = 2.419 and this is also AE^/AEi,= 11.8285/4.8995 2.419 andtothis also the ratio of the final longitudinal=emittance theisinitial the ratio of the final longitudinal emittance to the initial longitudinal emittance. Figure 2 shows the situation one longitudinal Figure 2 shows one booster cycleemittance. after the injection of the the 12thsituation batch. The booster cycle after the of the batch.colors The consecutive bunches areinjection represented by 12th different consecutive bunches are by different colors for easy identification. Therepresented vertical dashed lines separate for ring easy into identification. vertical lines separate the 7 boosterThe lengths anddashed the first batch was the ring into 7 booster lengths and the first batch injected at the location between 5.5 and 6.5Tb . Thewas reinjectedbarrier at the islocation between 5.5solid and square 6.57^. The reflecting represented by the at locaflecting is represented by theissolid square atby location 7Tb , barrier while the injection barrier represented the tion 7T , while the injection barrier is represented by b hollow square with the arrow pointing to its directionthe of hollow Theoretical square with reasoning the arrow pointing to its direction of motion. and simulations show that motion. reasoning simulations show about 10 Theoretical ms will be required to and capture the beam intothat the about 10 ms will be required to capture the beam into the 53-MHz buckets. 53-MHz buckets. Barriers are usually used to confine a beam within a Barriers are usually used to confine a beam within a designated region along the accelerator ring. The intedesignated region along the accelerator ring. The integrated sizes of the barriers need not be accurate as long grated sizes of the barriers need not be accurate as long as they are large enough to confine the particles of the as they are large enough to confine the particles of the highest and lowest energies. However, this is not true highest and lowest energies. However, this is not true here. Although the injection process does not depend on here. Although the injection process does not depend on the has to to theshape shapeof ofthe themoving moving barrier, barrier, its its integrated integrated size size has be accurate in order to have the final positive and negbe accurate in order to have the final positive and negative ativeenergy energy spreads spreads be be equal equal and and opposite. opposite. Otherwise, Otherwise, after reflection by the stationary barrier, enafter reflection by the stationary barrier, the the positive positive energy spread will be modified, resulting possibly in an ergy spread will be modified, resulting possibly in an increase in the longitudinal emittance. Here, we would increase in the longitudinal emittance. Here, we would like plot of of liketotostudy study the the effect effect of of such such an an error. error. The The left left plot Fig. 3 shows the situation when V T is 10% larger than Fig. 3 shows the situation when VT^1 is 10% larger than its of its critical critical value, value, 22 booster booster cycle cycle after after the the injection injection of the 12th bunch. Actually the final momentum spread bethe 12th bunch. Actually the final momentum spread becomes emerge comessmaller. smaller. However, However, many many particles particles cannot cannot emerge from The fromthe thestrong strongbarrier barrier resulting resulting in in aa loss loss of of 10.6%. 10.6%. The situation T1 by situationof of aareduction reduction of of VV7\ by 10% 10% from from its critical value will valueisis shown shown in in the the right right plot. plot. Now all particles will emerge emergefrom fromthe themoving movingbarrier barrier earlier earlier and their energies APPLICATION APPLICATIONTO TOMAIN MAININJECTOR INJECTOR Simulations were performedfor fordoubling doublingthe theMain MainInInSimulations were performed jector intensity injectionenergy energyofofEE==8.938 8.938GeV GeV jector intensity at at thethe injection critical conditionforforbarrier barriermovement movementofof12 \T per Tbbper at at thethe critical condition 1 booster cycle withthe theinitial initialhalf halfcritical criticalhalf halfenenbooster cycle (x(x ==2 )^)with 1 i i,ergy spreadofof∆EAE =4.900 4.900MeV. MeV.Here, Here,TbTb==1.59 1.59µjus, = ergy spread s, 2 0.667 ms, T} = -0.00892 and the criti0 = bT,c T= c = T0 T= 7T7T , 0.667 ms, η = −0.00892 and the critib barrier strengthis is(V(VTjc 3.1421kVkV-jUs. Particles calcal barrier strength T1 )c ==3.1421 µ s. Particles withthethehighest highestenergy energyare areinjected injectedwith withthe theoffset offset ofof with 2 2£/|T]| = -11.8285 MeV while particles a = -f 2 /3 ∆EAE i1 = −Ṫ2 β E/|η | = −11.8285 MeV while particles 2 4 6 8 1O Distance Along Ring in /u.s FIGURE 2.2. (color) (color) Longitudinal Longitudinal phase phase space space one one booster booster FIGURE cycleafter afterthe theinjection injection of of the the 12th 12th batch batch between between cycle 227 I "3 o.ooo - — — O 2 4 6 8 —O.OO2 2 4 6 8 Distance Along Ring in JLLS Distance Along Ring in FIGURE3.3. (color) (color)Plots Plotsshowing showing22booster booster cycle cycle after after injection injection of of 12th 12th bunch, bunch, with with the the strength strength of the moving barrier (left) (left) FIGURE increasedbyby10% 10%and and(right) (right)decreased decreasedby by10%. 10%. increased aretherefore thereforereduced, reduced,which whichresults resultsininan anincrease increasein inmomoare mentumspread spreadby by9.8% 9.8%after after reflection reflection by by the the stationstationmentum arybarrier. barrier.AAsmall smallamount amountparticles particleshave haveenergies energieshigh high ary enoughthat thattheir theirleft-drift left-drift velocities velocitiesafter after reflection reflection are are enough largerthan thanthat thatofofthe themoving movingbarrier. barrier. Eventually, Eventually, they they larger maycatch catchup upwith withthe themoving movingbarrier barrierand andget getlost. lost. may BEAMLOADING LOADING BEAM Because ofof the the high high beam beam current, current, the the problem problem of of Because beamloading loadingmust mustbe beexamined. examined.At Atthe the passage passage across across beam theNNc c==1818rfrfcavities, cavities,aavery very short short bunch bunch containing containing the 1010protons 6.0×x1010 protonswill willinduce induceaatotal totalinstantaneous instantaneousbeam beam 6.0 loading voltage voltage VVbQ == qN qNccωcor RrRLL/Q /QLL = = 5.5 5.5 kV, kV, where where loading b0 500kΩ, kQ,QQL L==5000, 5000,and andωco 52.8MHz MHzare, are, r/(2n) π ) ==52.8 RRL L==500 r /(2 respectively,the theloaded loadedshunt shunt impedance, impedance, loaded loaded qualqualrespectively, ityfactor, factor,and andresonant resonantfrequency frequency of of each each cavity. cavity. For For aa ity batch of 84 such bunches injected into the Main Injecbatch of 84 such bunches injected into the Main Injector,the thebeam beamloading loading voltage voltage after after the the passage passage of of the the tor, last bunch increases to 444 kV. Thus the difference in last bunch increases to 444 kV. Thus the difference in beam loading voltages experienced by the last and first beam loading voltages experienced by the last and first bunchesisis 439 439 kV. kV.Taking Taking into into account account of of the the finite finite bunches lengths of the bunches, this difference becomes 388 kV lengths of the bunches, this difference becomes 388 kV when steady state is reached. During normal operation, when steady state is reached. During normal operation, thetotal totalrfrfvoltage voltageatatinjection injectionisis1.2 1.2MV. MV.IfIfthe thedesigned designed the synchronousphase phaseφ05== 00isissynchronized synchronized to to the the midmidsynchronous s dle bunch of the batch, the rf phase errors introduced bedle bunch of the batch, the rf phase errors introduced become A 0 = ±9.18° for the first and last bunches. Even◦ come ∆φs 5= ±9.18 for the first and last bunches. Eventually,the thelongitudinal longitudinalemittances emittancesof ofthe thebunches buncheswill will be be tually, increased up to 18%, which is considered still tolerable. increased up to 18%, which is considered still tolerable. Duringslip-stacking, slip-stacking, although although the the bunch bunch density density isis During doubled, the beam loading voltage may not increase doubled, the beam loading voltage may not increase because the bunch spread out to almost fill the buckets because the bunch spread out to almost fill the buckets at the very low rf voltage of ~ 64 kV, almost times at the very low rf voltage of ∼ 64 kV, almost 77 times less than the difference in beam loading voltages seen by less than the difference in beam loading voltages seen by the first and last bunches. Such low rf voltage is required the first and last bunches. Such low rf voltage is required in order to allow two series of buckets to stay within in order to allow two series of buckets to stay within the momentum aperture of the ring. The rf phase errors the momentum aperture of the ring. The rf phase errors now become so large that the most beam particles will now become so large that the most beam particles will be driven out of the buckets. Feedforward and feedback be driven out of the buckets. Feedforward and feedback have been planned to compensate for the beam loading. have been planned to compensate for the beam loading. In the the present present continuous continuous multiple injection injection scheme In using barriers, barriers, the the booster bunches before injection using injection will be made made very very long long in the Booster so that the momentum be momentum spread can can be be reduced. These bunches start to debunch spread debunch immediately after after injected injected into the Main Injector. immediately Injector. For For completely uniformly uniformly distributed distributed beam, there is no aa completely 53 MHz MHz rf rf component component and therefore no beam loading 53 loading at all. Here, although the distribution is not uniform all. Here, although uniform (see, (see, for example, Fig. 2), the 5 3-MHz rf component of the for example, 53-MHz beam current current at at any any moment of the injection injection is found beam found to be be less less than than 0.25% 0.25% of twice the dc beam current, to current, implying that that the the beam loading voltage will be reduced implying reduced at least least 400 400 times. times. at Actually no no rf rf voltage voltage is is required required in Actually in this this injection injection scheme. The The Main Main Injector Injector is is presently presently equipped equipped with scheme. with fast mechanical mechanical shorts, shorts, which which can can be be inserted 100 ms fast inserted in in 100 ms and removed removed in in 50 50 ms ms [4]. [4]. To To cope cope with with beam and beam loading loading and arrive arrive at at zero zero rf rf voltage, voltage, first, first, the the rf 16 caviand rf drive drive of of 16 cavities is turned off and shorts are inserted. Second, counterties is turned off and shorts are inserted. Second, counterphasing isis used used for for the the two two remaining remaining cavities phasing cavities to to arrive arrive at at zero rf voltage with the tiny beam loading voltage zero rf voltage with the tiny beam loading voltage taken taken into consideration. consideration. Further Further fine fine adjustment adjustment can into can be be impleimplemented using a fast low-level feedback. Notice that mented using a fast low-level feedback. Notice that councounterphasing isis not not possible possible for for slip-stacking slip-stacking because terphasing because the the two rf rf controls controls have have been been employed employed already already to two to produce produce the two two series series of of buckets buckets at at slightly slightly different the different frequencies. frequencies. REFERENCES REFERENCES C. Ankenbrandt, Ankenbrandt, “SLIP-STACKING”: "SLIP-STACKING": A 1.1. C. A New New Method Method of Momentum-Stacking, Momentum-Stacking, Fermilab Fermilab Report Report FN-352, 1981; of FN-352, 1981; F.E. Mills, Stability of Phase Oscillations under two F.E. Mills, Stability of Phase Oscillations under two Applied Frequencies, BNL Report AADD 176, 1971. Applied Frequencies, BNL Report AADD 176, 1971. 2. J. Griffi n, Momentum Stacking in the Main Injector using 2. J. Griffin, Momentum Stacking in the Main Injector using Longitudinal Barriers, Fermilab Report, 1996. Longitudinal Barriers, Fermilab Report, 1996. 3. K.Y. Ng, Continuous Multiple Injections at the Main 3. K.Y. Ng, Continuous Multiple Injections at the Main Injector, Fermilab Report FN-715, 2002. Injector, Fermilab Report FN-715, 2002. 4. D. Wildman, Transient Beam Loading Reduction during 4. D. Wildman, Transient Beam Loading Reduction during Multi-Batch Coalescing in the Fermilab Main Ring, Multi-Batch the Fermilab Main Ring, Proceedings Coalescing of the 1991inIEEE Particle Accelerator Proceedings 1991 IEEE Accelerator Conference, of Santhe Francisco, MayParticle 6-9, 1991, p. 410. Conference, San Francisco, May 6-9, 1991, p. 410. 228
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz