National Art Education Association Zinesters in the Classroom: Using Zines to Teach about Postmodernism and the Communication of Ideas Author(s): Kristin G. Congdon and Doug Blandy Source: Art Education, Vol. 56, No. 3 (May, 2003), pp. 44-52 Published by: National Art Education Association Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3194053 Accessed: 01/12/2009 16:21 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=naea. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. National Art Education Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Art Education. http://www.jstor.org MODERNiSM P44ODELRN Using Zines Teach about and tyt to Postmodern of Ideas Communicatio the G. BY KRISTIN t Z.^Mew CONGDON AND MAY 2003 DOUG BLANDY arenon-commercial, popularand mass culture,the role of ["zeens"] small circula~-l~,'~non-professional, tion "Do-it-Yourself'(DiY) magazines.' In 1996,we started using zines as an assignment in our universityclassrooms. Students in such varied classes as Aesthetics, Theoryand Criticismof the VisualArt,Artand HumanValues,and Zines and DiYDemocracy have made zines. In these courses students have written, cut and pasted, folded, copied, and distributedhundredsof zines. They have explored the history of zines, the relationshipof zines to ART EDUCATION/ m 1SM zines in radicaland utopic thought,zine design, and the relationshipof zines to art. Manyof our students' zines have been widely distributedthroughthe mail, in local zine outlets, and by hand. Wehavefoundthatcreatingand distributingzines is a successful pedagogical strategyfor encouragingstudentsto participatein postmoder discourse.Zines also permitstudentsto breakwiththe stricturesof writingformalpapersbased on the guidelinesof the American PsychologicalAssociation(APA)or THE ARTIS4 THE ARTIST 1-6.Modernism/Postmodernism, Figures 2002. zinebyChristopher Arnold, PI4ODERNISM MODERNISM MODERNISM ; t'. tI i *- /, aA . 1:in. viva ^le Ci_ Ptf - ModemLanguageAssociation(MLA). As such, zines encouragestudentsto link imagesandtext towardsthe expressionof ideas in a free-formandintuitivemanner. Throughourteachingwe havediscovered thatfor manyof ourstudents,beinga zinestercomes quitenaturally.Whilethey maynot havebeen previouslyawareof zines,they intuitivelyunderstandthe unconventional,insurgent,and spontaneousstructurethatcharacterizes them.Thismaybe due to zines'close associationwithpopularcultureandacts of appropriation. Ourpurposein this articleis to discuss the historyandcontext of zines. Wewill considerthe ways in whichzines can be used to assist studentsin understanding postmodernism.Zinesas a strategyfor encouragingthe developmentand distributionof ideas andsocial critique throughimagesandtext will be considered.Allof the examplesand illustrations thataccompanythisarticleare drawn fromourown classrooms.Whileour discussionfocuses on ouruse of zines in the context of highereducation,we believethatzines can be successfully used with kindergartners to olderadults. Outsideof school, middle-school-ageand high-school-agestudentscurrentlymake zines andareamongthose setting contemporarytrendsin zine designand content.Althoughthe act of appropriating imagesmaybe unfamiliarto manysenior citizens,arteducatorscan devise ways to orientolderadultsto this aesthetic method.Certainlyzines are relevantto documentingandsharingthe life review process as well as addressingthe political dimensionof growingold in today's society. Histtry o Zines A loose-knitmulticulturalcoalition of academicallyand non-academically trainedartistsandwritersknownas "zinesters"is flourishing.Zinesters,who arebothyouthsandadults,createand distributeimagesandtext commonly referredto as "zines."Zinesmaylast only one issue or runforyears.Pagesmay rangefromless thanten to hundreds. Theirformhas been comparedto "somewherebetweena personalletter anda magazine"(Duncombe,1997,p. 10). Zinesarean amalgamof originaland appropriatedimagesandtext froma varietyof sources includingconic books, Z,,o]t .I posters,albumcovers,graffiti,tagging, thrasher[skateboard]art,tattooflash, television,andthe historyof "fineart"and literature.Zinesterscombineiconography andtext to createpublicationsthatcan be chaotic,disturbing,uncomfortable, sensual,complex,loud,confrontive,and often a social critiqueof contemporary life. Genderroles,religion,familial relationships,politics,sexual orientation, the environment,academicdisciplines, the arts,class structure,ethnicity, generationaldifferences,economics,and pop cultureareamongthe manyissues celebrated,skewered,deconstructed, reconstructed,and illuminatedby zinesters. Zines,witha combinedestimated readershipof 500,000to 750,000persons (Duncombe,1997),areavailablethrough mailorder,word-of-mouth,musicstores, pubs,comic book stores, thrashershops, independentbookstores,bodymodificationshops, politicalstorefronts, alternativegalleries,andon the Internet (e-zines).Assembledon kitchentables anddesktopcomputers,zinesarea DiY space forpublicdiscussionandthe developmentof publicvalues. MAY 2003 / ART EDUCATION i Hitorians of the zine tracethe originationof the worditself to the science fictionfanzinesthatarosein the 1930s.In 1930,the ScienceCorrespondence Clubfoundedan amateur publicationin whichpeople couldpublish storiesandrespondto science fiction. TitledTheComet(laterCosmology),this fanzinewas the precursorto those many pop andmass cultureorientedzines that arepublishedtoday. Whilethe wordzine, andsome types of zines,aretraceableto the fanzinesof the 1930s,we believethe impetusforthe manytypes of sociologicallyandpoliticallyorientedzinesthatarepublished todaycan be tracedto 17th-century Britainandthe pervasivenessof pamphletspromotingmoralandpolitical pointsof view.Aroundsuch pamphlets, as is truefor zinestoday,communities of like-mindedpeople wouldformas readers,contributors,or creatorsof new pamphlets.Duringthis period,pamphlets consistedof a few sheets of paper,folded to formpages,sometimesstitched togetherandsold for the equivalentof a few cents (Bricklin,2002).Such pamphletswere crucialto the American Revolution,the emancipationof slaves, women'ssuffrage,the labormovement, andthe civilrightsmovement.Probably the most famouspamphletin U.S.history is ThomasPaine'sCommonSense publishedin 1776.Likecontemporary zines,pamphletstendedto contain materialnot availablefromthe mainstreampress. Duringthe late 1960sandearly1970s, the popularandmasscultureorientation of zinesmergedwiththe politicalorientation of pamphlets.Atthis time,young peopleproducedtens of thousandsof zinesthatcommentedon the social revolutionassociatedwiththe period,the artsthataccompaniedthis revolutionand the VietnamWarthat,in part,fueledit. It was also during'60sand '70sthatvisual artistsbeganto explorethe book as a creativeformas well as mailart.Bothof these explorationswouldaddto the visualandstructuralrhetoricthatwould become associatedwith zines. Creative aspects includea typographicalplayfulness anduniquebindingtechniques. ART EDUCATION / MAY 2003 _ Theseinfluenceswouldfuse in the late 1970sin the zines associatedwithpunk rockbothin the UnitedStatesandBritain. Punkrockerstodaycontinueto borrow heavilyfromthe visualrhetoricassociatedwiththis period,andtheirzines,like manyof theirpredecessors,tendto have highlypoliticalcontentthatpromotesa DiYlifestyle. Zineshavecontinuedto flourishsince the 1970s.Thisis due,in part,to the convenienceandavailabilityof quickcopy technologies.Duringthe 1990s,the politicalorientationof zines expandedto includefeministperspectivesthroughthe At impetusof groupslike the riotgrrrls.2 the sametime,cyberpunkzines emerged alongwith zines createdwith desktop publishingprograms.Zinesalso beganto on disks,and be distributedon the WWW, on CD-ROMs. Todaythe creation,appreciation,and understandingof zines has become so widespreadthatcenters,such as the IndependentPublishingResourceCenter (IPRC)in Portland,Oregon,havebeen foundedto cultivatethe next generation of zinesters.Inaddition,zines arebeing archivedin mainstreamlibrariesas well as specializedlibrariesdevotedto the form.Thereare even zine symposia. - ,Ste44nt 4kk,t1 Creating,distributing,reading,and critiquingzines assists studentsin understandingthe myriadandconflicting concepts associatedwiththe inherent complexities,discontinuities,andcontradictionsassociatedwithpostmodernism zinestersandzines andart.Contemporary epitomizea postmodernistpoint of view. Zinesterstake delightin smashingboundariesbetweenso-calledhighandlow or popularformsof artandculture.Zinesare writtenandillustratedthroughpastiche, parody,irony,andbricolage.Fragmentationanddiscontinuityarethe norm. Narrativesandauthorshipcan be ambiguous,simultaneous,self-conscious, or anonymous.Forexample,Christopher Arnold'szinejuxtaposesmodernistand postmodernapproachesto art.(See Figures1-6.)He quicklyandcreatively presentswhathe understandsto be the differencesin the two theoretical approaches.KaiAndersen'szine TheNeoModernistAwakeningskewersthe hype andself-promotionwithinthe fine art world.Thecoverof Andersen'szine displaysnumerousquotedsuperlatives aboutthe interiorimages.Turningback the coverrevealsthatthe interiorpages areblank.(See Figure7.) Spiderwebs!by fouranonymouszinestersorganizedby MattHellerconsists of collagedimages andtext with adhesivelettersthathave togetherbeen tornandscratched. Spiderwebs!is boundwith a piece of transparentpackingtape.(See Figure8.) Studentscan be encouragedto create zinesthatincorporateandcritiquethe historyof humankind'sattemptto packageinformationfroma postmodernistperspective.Whilemanyzines are constructedusingthe traditionalWestern codex book form,numerouszinesters preferto protecttheirzinesandattract readersthroughaccordion-foldzines,and scrolls,as well as zines thatlook like fans or venetianblinds.Forexample,Free Tibetis a scrollwrappedin a Tibetan prayerflag.(See Figure9.) Somezines come in a box or a bag.Instant Gratificationby JenniferEvansconsists of 20 individualsheets of paperlisting variousformsof addictioncontainedin a cigarettehardpack. (See Figure10.) Whilemost hardcopyzines aremadefrom paper,fabricandorganicmaterialis not uncommon.Werecentlysaw an example of a zine containedin a seashell. Zinesalso critiqueconsumerismand the relationshipof artto ourbuying sprees.Exploringthe malegazeas an approachthatobjectifieswomanlike a product,MarjorieGrayjuxtaposesartto ourperspectiveof femalebeauty.(See Figures11-13.)Takinga different approach,Elise Roedenbeckinventsan artmartwhereartistsandeverydayitems meld.(See Figures14-16.)DanBeyer produceda one-pagezine with attached corkcoasterto promotehis DiYmusic productionanddistribution. (See Figure17.) "A TRUE MASTERPIECE." MfOMA "IT BROUGHT ME TO TEARS." PASSION AND MASTERY." Awakening The Neo-Moernlst KAI ANDERSEN "THE CLIMAX OF OUR TIME." Tra MtT "T H"THE SUBTLETY IS OVERWHELMING." G.C--M,.M *TM[ "WORDS ARE INSUFFICIENT, YOU MUST EXPERIENCE Tr FOR YOURSELF." FNY 7z T,' MN4"AgI 8. Spiderwebs!, Figure zinebyMattHeller, 2002. 7. NeoModernist zinebyKaiAndersen, 1998. Figure Awakening, 10. Instant zinebyJennifer Figure Gratification, Evans,2002. 9. FreeTibet, zinebySamantha Bates,2002. Figure 11-13.TheMaleGaze, Figures zinebyMarjorie 2002. Gray, MAY2003 / ARTEDUCATION 14-16.ArtMart, zinebyEliseRoedenbeck, 2002. Figures Zinesters,includingourstudents,revel in the possibilitiesassociatedwiththe traditionof turningpages. Some will use page-turningas a way to reveal order,while otherspromotedisorderand discontinuitythroughmultiplestrategies. Thisis accomplishedthroughthe use of translucentpages,disjointednarratives, pop-ups,zines withinzines,and overwrittentext andimages,amongother strategies.Forexample,MyMother's Bodyby MollySheehyis a meditationon herrelationshipto her mother'sbodyand hermother'sstruggleswith a life threateningillness.Inthe centerfoldof the zine is a pop up of hermotherwith arms outstretchedillustratingher success in fightingher illnessbutbearingthe scar of her struggle.Fabricby anonymousis a 5" x 4"zine sewn into a mauvepolyesterbag of roughlythe same size. Toaccess the zineyou mustfirstripopenthe bag.The zineitselfposes a series of questionson translucentpages overlayingimagesof fabriccreations.MyScarsby Dan Pritchettis a memoirtold through sequentiallyscannedimagesof the scars on the author'sbody (Figure18).Dutch Babies also by DanPritchettis a 6-page zinethatpairsthe recipefor Dutchbabies with menacingimagesof cats andghouls. Thepages of this 2"x3"zinewere soaked in stronglyscented candlewax. (See Figure19.) ART EDUCATION / MAY 2003 Theinformationcontainedin zines is communicatedthroughoriginaland/or appropriatedtexts andimagesalone or in variouscombinations.Studentscan use text andimagesrandomlyor in reference to one another.Imagesmaybe clustered in groupsor series.Wordscanbe used as pictures.Inthis way some studentsuse zinesto explorethe changingnatureof art.GinnySeibertrelatesthe workof elephantsto JacksonPollock(see Figures 20-21),prefacingherzine withthe phrase, "youhavethe right."AmberVotel proposesherNew VisionManifesto. (See illustrationson magazinecover.) Here,she addressesapproachesto art now open to the artist'sconsideration. Votel,like manyotherzinesters,lifts imagesfromthe mediawhile simultaneouslytakinga criticalstance. TheColony by SarahGlassis a critiqueof media conglomeratesandthe effect thatshe believesthey havehad on popularmusic andlive concerts.(See Figures22-23.) Copyrightis an importantissue among zinesters.Studentsconsiderthe ethics of the impulseto appropriatefromcopyrightedmaterials,but also whethertheir own zines shouldbe copyrightedor not. Whilezines aretraditionallydevotedto the free exchangeof ideas andinformation,some zinestersare as resistantas mass marketpublishersto havingtheir workappropriated.Thediscussionof copyrightcan directlyaccess ongoing debatescurrentlytakingplace around copyrightandappropriation among artists,web-designers,publishers,andthe generalpublic.Studentscan make decisionsaboutwhethertheywantto copyrighttheirown zines or hope that theirmaterialwill be appropriated just as they mayhaveappropriatedfromothers. 17. MassProduction, zineby Figure DanBeyer,2002. 2002. 18. MyScars,zinebyDanPritchett, Figure 2002. 19. DutchBabies,zinebyDanPritchett, Figure I I Zt~z e -'$i~ S .f_~e l~... 7C,i~ ^?~ be can exploredin a zine. Anytopic Thehistoryof topics foundin zines is vast. Duncombe(1997)proposesa zine taxonomythat consists of fanzines (science fiction,music,sports, television,film,thriftstore shopping, gardening,collecting,etc.), political zines,personalidentityzines,personal zines,zines thatdescribea cultural context,networkzines,fringeculture zines,religiouszines,vocationalzines, healthzines,sex zines,travelzines, comix,literaryzines,artzines,then all-the rest. Owens(2002)proposesthatpriorto makinga zine,questionsassociatedwith focus, personalgain,audience,cost to naturalenvironment,time commitment, andbudgetneed to be considered. Zinestersalso need to decideif they will be the sole author/artistor if it will be a groupeffort.Mostimportantlystudents will wantto determinereasonssomeone wouldwantto readtheirzine.It has been ourexperiencethatit is rarelyhardfor a studentto identifyan interestingtopic. It is even less difficultfor themto makea strongstatementin a creativemanner. '~I1 UU a ana ot t1 IJU " v ^f<t nav1_ C b>ut I look like a Pollock. . . Figures20-21. Artis Not, zinebyGinny 2002. Seibert, 4 < ^ .. , k. C.f /r-4 / ',* _x~ !B ^ r , MAY 2003 N / ART EDUCATION Topicsourstudentsuse vary.Some studentsdealwithpersonalissues. For example,RachelGrisstitles her zine,My Name is RachelGriss and MyMotheris a Lesbian.(See Figure24.) Donein chapters,she uses familyphotographs, artby lesbianphotographers,andsayings by writerslike RitaMaeBrown.Other zines focus on issues like the "discovery" of Americaby Columbus.Appropriating a children'scoloringbook, Brian Baumgartenuses the computerto manipulatethe imagesrewritinghistory in a way not normallyseen in history books. (See Figures25-27.)Jaclyn Steinbergdealswith whatshe calls "TheTaliban'sWaron Women,"which incorporateschildren'sdrawings.(See Figures28-30.)AndKristinPapamakes issues surroundingmeat-eatingvisible. (See Figures31-32.)AngelaMorrilldeals with singleparentingandtryingto earna college degreein OneTiredMamaand FoodStamps,Motherhood,and the Politics of Shame.(See Figure33.) 4t.strr6i4nt eriti t6int, 24. MyNameis RachelGrissandMyMother is a Lesbian, Figure zinebyRachelGriss,2001. 9zr4ding Zines , nof _ineS embodyideas andassume action.Oneof the primaryreasonsfor authoringa zine is to providepeople with the opportunityto read it. Optionsinclude givingit awayor selling it for a few cents to a couple of dollarsat communityvenuessuch as recordor bookstores. Zinesarealso distrib|E ;^tt~ : utedby mailorder, L while some zinesters -^ tradewithother ... zinesters.Some zinestersplace their zines inside library : :: Ilil:2 14'9 Y :Ii;: i;~:;: 25-27.Columbus Discovers America Figures Book,ZinebyBrianBaui 2002. Coloring mgarten, ART EDUCATION / MAY 2003 books or leave themon buses for othersto find andread.Zinesmadeas class assignmentsare often traded as part of the course,or outsideof the class requirements. -:i-ii:i :_i.ii :-::_,:_iiiii-i ;:ti _ - :: -:I HAoTOOE COiVE URA iVEI i(A VOLUMiNOUS B i St Waron Women,zine by JaclynSteinberg,2002. Figures28-30. TheTaliban's NOT SUITABLE f'" -""1 IEllilrWsi Gradingzines,for us, is as unconventionalas the makingof zines. Weuse two versionsof a zine-o-meterloosely based on how musicandzinereviewsare presentedin some fanzines.Theselected versionis passed out alongwiththe assignmentso thatstudentsknowhow theirzines will be evaluated.Onezine-ometerhas icons thatreflectthe following responses:painfullybad,mostlyfiller, basic rock n roll,worthyourcash, and trance/rave.Thesecond zine-o-meterhas a ratingsystemfrom0-4,representing responsesthatreflectthe qualityof the text, images,content,creativity,andgut response.Thenumberingsystemgoes from"napkin" to "getsby,""ok," and "wow."Thereis also "recommend," roomfor a narrativedescriptionof the zine. Studentsoftenuse the zine-o-meters to evaluatetheirpeers'work.The responsesregisteredon the zine-o-meters formthe basis for in class critiques.This evaluationsystemworkswell withthe formof the zines.Intheirpostmoder manner,they thumbtheirnose at the establishmentandits tightlystructured way of makingjudgments.Wehavenever had a studentquestiongradesbased on the zine-o-meter.Thissystemmirrorsthe 31-32.NotSuitable for Figures zinebyKristen Vegetarians, Papa,2002. andthe 33. FoodStamps,Motherhood, Figure 2002. Politicsof Shame,zinebyAngelaMorrill, MAY 2003 N / ART EDUCATION In our democratic society, students must not only think about ideas but debate and clarify their visions, and then act responsibly on their ideas. In our experience, creating zines has become an effective way to accomplish educating students towards participation in a democracy. fact that zines are routinely reviewed and critiqued in alternative publications and zine-oriented websites.3 When we introduce students to zines, we also assign zine reviews based on the form that appears in these publications. Zine reviews are as explosive and individualistic as zines. They are often shameless in their advocacy or condemnation of a particular zine. While grammar and spelling is usually correct, the approach to the use of language is very playful. Kristin G. Congdon is a Professor of Art and Philosophy at the University of Central Florida, Orlando. E-mail: kcongdon@pegasus. cc.ucf edu Doug Blandy is a Professor at the University of Oregon. He directs the Arts and Administration Program and Institutefor Community Arts Studies. E-mail: [email protected] We are all living in a time where we are bombarded with messages. Even the expanse of the sky is now being used for advertisements. Increasingly we are becoming a nation of people who see and hear in visual and audio segments. These messages mix in our minds and form new meanings. Zines are reflections of our times. Postmodern art and culture often asks students to be active, to participate, and to engage in dialogue as opposed to being passive receivers of expert information. Students in a variety of settings making zines will learn about postmodern forms of communication as they simultaneously engage in a participatory educational process that deviates from linear and conventional ways of learning about art and culture. REFERENCES Bricklin, D. (2002). Pamphleteers and websites. [WWWdocument]. URLhttp:// www.bricklin.com Diysearch. (2002). Diysearch. [WWW document]. URLhttp://www.diysearch.com /addurlfaq.cfm Duncombe, S. (1997). Notesfrom the underground: Zines and the politics of alternative culture. New York:Verso. Owens, A. P. (2002). How to make a zine. [WWWdocument.]. URL http://www.zinebook.com/resource /zinetips.html NOTE For more information or copies of zine-ometers contact Kristin Congdon at [email protected] or Doug Blandy at: [email protected]. FOOTNOTES 1DIYis a contemporary movement with historical links to the Arts and Crafts Movement, both of which act to counter the effects of industrialization. A DiY ethic promotes freedom from the control and pervasiveness of large national or multinational corporations. Associated with DiY are independent publishers (including zinesters), artists, writers, philosophers, and activists. 2There is no consensus on the specific origins of the riot grrrls;however, there is general agreement that they are closely associated with independent punk music and ideology. Common to riot grrrls are men and women dedicated to promoting sex equity. Zines are one way in which this agenda is realized. 3See for example the magazine Punk Planet or the e-zine Broken Pencil. A:0 "Ifthere is an imperativefor studies of the mass arts,it centers aroundthis question:Ina society so dependenton aesthetic imagery as a meansto by-passcritical thinking,who benefits most if artisticskillsare widelydeployed by a few, but inways not critically fathomedby the many?" H.Chapman, Vol.44,No.3 Laura m ART EDUCATION/ MAY2003 Visual Culture researchers are interested in the communicative and political role of art and help us understand the contexts surrounding art so as to exercise control over the visual information we confront. Here the approach is to seek understanding by conducting research through art so as to determine the many functions and purposes to which art can be put. Using visual forms as an agency to advance various social, cultural, political, and educational ends has a long history, and the pervasive impact of visual culture warrants critical study-as the authors in Studies so persuasively argue. Graeme Sullivan, Editor. Spring 2003, Vol. 44, No. 3 Publishedquarterly.$15 members (domestic); $25 non-members (domestic) TOsubscribe, call 1-800-299-8321
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz