!!"
#$%
& '
( )
*
+
'
)
+
!
'
()
--- +
"
&
!
+
+
,
!
#
!
'
$
"
"%
!
&
$
"
&
.
+
$ ' *
"
%
)
+
$
&
+
&&
!"
!
$
+
!
'
56
!$
"
)
$ !
"
-
!
! &"
! &&
&
'
!
!
&"
+
$
"
&
-#
#
,"
& " , !
&
$
"
&
! !
!" &
"
!
&
!
"
"
!
'
)/
& , &&
! !
&
.
!
"
!$!
"
" &
! " .
+
&
! !
&
!
$
, $
!
&
!
$ # &
!
"
"
$ "
,
&
!! $
$ & !
$
/
!
&
'
!
!
!
!
+
&
& !
( !
,
#
$
00,1
)
! &
!
$
"
(231,11 4
-
'
,
&
- '
! &"
! !
&
+ ! 82
*
"
&
&&
&"
!
$
$
!
! 172
!"
&
!
& !#"
!
#
..
9
#
& + !#
$
"
"
"
&&
# &
#
! +! ( : )
$
&&
"
:
.
!
#
&
$ #
$
"
#
!
" ,
!
!
"
"
"
#
"
!
: "
& +
# "
1
!
"
!
!
#
"
!
:
$
&
!
&
!
#
!
!
!
+
;
#
: &
&
&
,
$
&
&
<
#"
"
#
"
1
&
1)
!
&&
!
!
!&
;
!
&
& "
"
! '
*
,
>
"
&
(?
#
+ !
" (=
0) $ "
#
Charcoal, biochar and char are different names used to describe the same substance, depending on its end use; the term biochar was
coined by Dr Peter Read of Massey University, (New Zealand) in attempt to differentiate it thusly. The terms charcoal and char imply use as
a fuel, whereas biochar implies an application to soil.
! $
!
!
$
!
'
"
!
&
"
&
#
!
"
#
.
$
#
)#
"
$
&
$
" "
#
&"
#
!
"
#
'
&
! &&
"
# 1 B2. C
A *"
#1
&
$ #
$
+
"
&
$
2. *
"$
(
&
!
"
),
&
#
"
&
! D
&
#
"
"
$
!
"
* "
!
'
!! !
E
! )
!
#
!
$
!
"
&
"
"
"
! &
& $
$ "
, &
,
0
#"
"
$ ! $
&
$
&
!
"
6
!
&
&& $
!"
! !
$
"
&
! &
!
# " ,
!"
! & !
$
! #
!
"
!
,
!
!
! $
!
$
!
! &
!
&
$
$
& !#
" ,
! $
$
$
!
&&
!
(
&
!! $
&
!
$
"
!
+
9
!"
!
$
>
"
!
;
A6
'
!
!
& ! &&
$
$ (
!!
'
"
&
$
&&
&
!
&
&
#
&"
$
&
& :
! $
"
! $
!
# & !
!
!"
&
!
&
!
&
(-'')#
"
..
"
"
&
! @
!
$
"
& !
!! ! "
+
$
'
!
#
&$
)
&&
!
#
+
!"
(& !
! &&
$
"
&
&
2
!!
#
!
"
&
1 7
!
! !"
$
'
"
"
& $
#
!
$ !
!
+
! '
!
!#
"
$
!
$
"
"
/
&
!
" !
!&
$ "
$
#
!
& !
"
&
$ !
#
"
#
&
+
#
"
&
&&
!
! &&
&
. &
&"
&
"
$
&
(
!,
@
!
"
!" ,
Examples include sewage and municipal solid waste treatment, papermill waste and animal manures
No information exists in the literature concerning the invention date of biochar-producing stoves. Dr T.Reed invented micro-gasification
stoves using a similar principle in 1985, but ash - rather than biochar - is the by-product.
3
$
'
%
,
&
$ "
*
" !
& !
! & "
!
!!
;
$ #
$ &
$
!"
&
"
!
'
&
&
!
!$
- !
;
!
&
!&
!
! &
"
&
$ ! !
"
"
!
& " ,
!
!
;
"
!
&
!
*
! &
"
!
! "
"
.
"
$
&
&
&$
"
;
"
&
! $
" ,
!
!
!
!
#"
$ #
$
!
'
! 1
#
"
&
!
&
+
!
"
&
!
"
+
"%
!
$
"
!
!
$
"
'
!
"
F
"
&
*
!
!
! &
&
&
'
"
!
! &
$
(
!
0 .1 2 +
$
&
=
-
!
)
& 1)#
!
!
! !
$! !" E
$ "
$
"
$ #
!
&
$
"
9
)
Burnspace
Cool air is heated and
rises, drawing air through
the ventilation cone. Air
provides oxygen that
fuels the combustion of
firewood
Biomass Jacket
Ventilation Cone
Combusting firewood drives pyrolysis of
biomass in jacket. Gases released during
pyrolysis of biomass pass out into the
burnspace and are combusted
Removable Bottom
Plate
Bottom Plate Clamp (Legs)
Cool air enters burnspace but cannot
enter the biomass jacket, preserving
low oxygen conditions for pyrolysis
3
'
$
&
&&
!
"
*
& .
!
$
!
&
!
"
(
"%
"
! $
"
! '
!)
!
# &
#
!!
&
&! $
#
$
!
!
=$
!"
#
*
$
!
,
"
!
!
& &
!
!
&
"
&
!
&
"
!#
&
!
&&
#
"
"
!
3.
'
"
"
!
& "
&
&
! &&
!
!
&
!
!
!
& "
&
& !
#
+
?
#
#
+
.1
%
!
"
( 23# ?
A
"
"
!
&"
/
'
!&
!
$
"
&
@
! $
"
! "
3#
2. ?
#
&
0.
+
) )
+
( )
)
"
$ "
(* )
G
*
&
+
&
$
&
*
1 42)
C
!
4)
4
!
6
!"
!
& &
!
&
" 1#
# " !
!'
&
" "
!
#
&
;
"
#
! -J
#
"
&
+
)
H &
.
&
!
&
( ;
& "
+
&
;
&
(
!
$
&
!).
!
!
$
&
"
"
!
;
$ "
F ! !
" $ )
$>
&
$
" .
(14
F !
$!
;
'
!
#"
&
"
)
"
H' 6 &
(
# 1 0B)
6
!
4
!
C
;
H
*
!
*
+
(
$
!
!
*
6 &
#
.
#
H .
!
*
#
(=
!
6 &
;
!
"
"
"
!
.
H
*
( H )
(
6
&
2
C
H+
) 9
$
+
4
!
&
&
$
D
#
!
I
!"
H #"
!
&
3
H (
!
&
"
Consider if a equally high surface area biochars are introduced into a sandy soil (which has low nutrient retention) and one biochar
possesses high CEC the other low. The high CEC biochar is very likely to have a beneficial effect on plant growth but the low CEC will
likely not, a fact overlooked by surface area measurements.
)
"
! ! &&
"
,
"
"
,
!
&
&
'
!
&
.
#
"
+
'
!" !
!
!
&&
&
&
#
!
" $
"
&*
!"
"
%
& !
!
$
#
*
!
&
&
'
!
$
"
&
!
!
$ "
$
)/
-
!
!
$
!
"
$
&
-"
!
!
"
#
#"
3
;
"
$ "
&
&
$
! &
&
&
,
&
$
&"
- &"
-"
"
,"
!,
- !
!
!
3# +
!( 2 #
&
&
"
!
$
!
(1
!
!
#
2))#
&
"
&
!
#
$
!
(6 *)
$ "
&
&
;
9
$
+
&
( 73# ?
-
"
"
!!
#
!G
!
) *
A
-&
!
(
&
E
!
!
!
$
"
"
A6
&"
!! ! !$
9
&
#
9 ! !#
B)#
!
!
$
&
!"
$
!"
$
!
& $!
"
)
3)
$ $ !#
!#
!
A *"
(-K
2
&
!$
-
+
$ "
C
& "
#
+
$
"
&
#"
( 370# H
7)#
! & !#
#&
+
!
&
"
!
$
!
# !
!
!
4) $
-,
"
! 1 (?
#
"
(
0)#
"
"
!
#
3.
#
$
&
!
"$
"
"
!
"
!# -
(?
!
(1 B2)#
&"
& !
3.3
$
&
!
!
"
!
&
C
.
& !
'
!
!
! &&
!
$
! &
(
$
"
"
!
!
'
*
&
!
" #
!
&
)
&
#
,
"
&&
!
# "
& "
"
$
&
"
$
"
'
;
+
&!
$ !
"
&
!
"
"
"
#"
&&
&
!!
5
Contrast: A biochar of pH 4 – we know that it is acid and therefore unsuitable for acid soils and alkaline-loving plants. A biochar of 300m2/g
S.A - we know that this is technically a high SA, but questions remain to be answered i.e is this high for biochar and importantly, what
relationship to fertility can be expected for this measurement?
"
<
#
&
#
3
%
$ "
7) (6
&
$
!
!
#
!
," ! &
*
"
$
9
!
!#
"
&$
+
&
33
0
"
,
+
$
!
,
!
&
!
!
&
!"
!
#
!
!
! +
#
&
!
"
*
! !
!&
" ,
&
$
$
+
"
"
*
$
"
"
!
$
$ &
" ! &
.
&
!
!G " "
(E*: 1 B4)#
!
#
#
> #
BL# 2L# 7L# 1 L# ! 4L &
#
$ )
"
"
"
!
+
&
(
"
&
,
!"
! )"
"
$
(
#
)
$
$
$
+
#
#
$
'
%
" "
4
"
&
"
&
"
# "
&
$
"
!
!
*
!
+
$
$
!
&
1
"
$
"
"
+
3* &
" !
!!
!
!&
"
#
!
$
&
!
& :
$ "
"
" "
&
*
&
#
&
"
&
*
"
! +
#
& !
'
!
!
$
= " #
"
# !
'
!
"
(
- "
&
"
&
'
!
&
#
"
&
& !
"
!
& !
E !
& !
$
!
& !
$
"
&
+
9
"%
*
!
!2
"
"
!
&&
!
&
$
!
"
!
!
*
$
"
$
!
+
"
!&
"
!"
,"
!
*
!
!
+
!
!
,
/
!
"
36 (
'
!
!
"
@ 42
!
+
@3
&
$
&
@
&"
& !
&
%
+
(Cellulose 29-39 weight%; Hemicellulose 20.6-26.8%; Lignin 19.4 to 26.6 %, Reith and de Bont 2007 )
Advanced Studies in Appropriate Technology Laboratory, a certificatory authority based in the U.S.
7
(
3)
! &"
$
6
"
5
'
'
!
'
$
7
$
&&
&
#
&
&
@1
&
!
!&
&
@2
&
&
!
!
#
! $
) '
!&
!
"
!
;
"
!. = !
&
! ! $
42
&
&
!
(1
!
!
!
!!
+
#&
!&
+
! &
)
+
!
&
& !
(
#
$
$
! E !
+
) !
&
&
(2
!$
"
(& !)
*
'
$
"
10G3G
0
!
!
,$
!
$
(M
!#
$
!"
C
!
#
$
#
)
+
292
-
Burnspace
650g straw in biomass jacket
Wood shavings and straw
400g of <20mm D 250mm
L+ 100g of withies <
10mm
600g <25mm D split in
half @250mm L
300g <25mm D split
in half @125mm L
300g
1kg
Field Regime (200g
hardwood added later)
'
%
&
! !*
$
!
&
$
"
$
#
"
99
&
$
$
!
E !
" ! !
$ &
!
$
.
&
$
!
!
&! ,
!&
6 $
/
42
'
,
!.
&
Ventilation Cone
Guideline regime (all
hardwood used at once)
#
9
,
1
100g of withies
<10mm D
•
G3G
+
Wood shavings and
straw
"
&
'
+
"
)
1( )
7&
898
•
.
!!
(
!
!
!
&
!
!
)
!
!
!
!
&$
&
@ (
&)
!2
"
!
!
# &
!
,
$
.
&
!
#
)F
= !
!
& &
&
! 1
&
!
(- &
,
!
!
&
!
&
!
&
>
!
$
/
!
•
'
!
"
2
,
&
!$
!
!
!
!
&
&
!
$
&
!
" &
+
&
"
,
•
•
'
*&
"
2
&
"
!
#
!
&
&
+
!&
*
$
! &
+
"
'
!
!
!
"
•
*. %
*.. &
•
*&
*
!
=
$
!
!
320
!
!
!
&
! #
"
&
!
'
&
!
+
"
$ !
'
"
!
& *!
H;
!"
"
>
"
"
#
$
"
-
!
"
!
•
&&
!
!
$ !
"
&
$
*.
•
•
•
' "
!"
! !
!! !
12
"
#
'
!
;
!
"
1
&! ,
!
!
!# !
, ! &
*&
, !
!#
H -9 B1
!
$
.
"
!- 1
&
/
*
&
!
!
&
*
!&
0
!
&
!! !
"%
1
!!
1,
! &
!
-
!
! &&
!$
"
#
!
$
" ;
!
"
"
!
!
!
!
&
•
'
&
&
" !
#
!
:"
&
$
!
'
#%
$
!
!
!
& " !
!
$ !
*
!
!
&
!
&
! ,
!&
"
!
!
&"
!
6 HF 1 27 @
@ <
! !&
&
"
!
"
!
!
! !
!
! !
!
!
!! $
6
6.
)
-
-
&
1
8 &
B 03
B0 B
B 3B4
B 230
B 132
1
1
1
1
1
0
3
2
&
7 1
1 744
14
1 213
1 327
1 23
!" ± #
±
'
10
&
!
$
42
!
+ +
+
&
14 4L#
6
%
)
0
5
7 1
1BB
13
17B
10
123
% ±#"
%
1
0
3
2
"
:5
00
7
1
3
#
12
&
7:<8 1
02
0
00
4
B
# # ±!
±%
7:1
17
14
12
12
$ ±#
!
L#
! +
&"
;
5
7 1
142
13
144
13B
171
# ±#%
72
'
!
$
!"
:5
2
00
4
0
4
#
±
7:<8 1
0
0
01
7
0
01 B(±3 3)
N<C O !
'
! &
"
"
!
72
'
"
$
"
).
& ! (6<
!&
G
!&
! !!
! &&
173 4
" !
" $ !
!
"
!
!&
>
#
!
(6< 3 4)
( 0
"
$
! 17 B
! &
1 ( Q
!0 L
#
"
'
2#
,P
). "
$
!
!
"
+
,
"
*
"
&
!
!
"
#
$
! 00L &
$
,
&
$
!
!
0) ! 44
"
C
<
1
!
!
!&
"
!" !
&
&
! &&
!
;
!
!
&
"
#
" +
$ !$
!
"
6 3 )/ +
6 3 . )/ +
)
+
0
%
1
)
%
1BB
13
17B
10
123
0
3
2
+
5
7 1
)/7.1 )/7 1 )/731
20
20
37
32
33
04
4
30
33
4
20
23
3
31
33
! ,
R
'
7 41 7 01 7 B 7 3 (R 1B)
! !! $
"
& 4 '
$
!
"
$
! !
"
! +
#
-$
&
! ! " $
"
#
$
& !
- 04
+
-
& -
"
' ! &&
! &&
&
-
"
13 "
$
"
63
)/
+
& !
!
$
)
+
! - &
!
%
.=6
.* *
.==
.*>
.?.
0
3
2
$
+ "
.
"
!
"
$
+
!
!&
!
&
#
!"
&
-
"
+
5
7 1 )/7.1 )/7 1 )/731
B4
B3
73
B1(R 0)
31
00
7
3 (R 1)
1 2
1
1
(R 0)
1
1 1
1 3(R 1 )
1 B1
1 3 1 7(R 0)
!,
R
"
!
;
%
1
7 41 7 01 7 B 7 3 (R 1B)
! !! $
'
"
" $
&1
+
! $
'
#
"
$
,
!
!
! &&
"
"
$
+
#
$
"
"
!
$
! - &
! &&
"
!#
#
"
& -
'
21(R 0)
3 (R 2)
2 (R 11)
24(R 2)
32(R 3)
#
$
&
! +
-$
"
#
!
" $
!"
*
$
00
! !
&
"
"
+ "
&14 #
!
!
"
$
"
!&
"
!"
#
! !
! !
-
633
)
+ -
'
+
,'
"
'
-
&
!
"
!
!
#
!
C
,
!&
&
!
!
@&
)/
)
) .<
0
;
32 31
3
B4
20 1 2
4 1
4 1 B
20 1 2
%
1
0
3
2
<
"
!
$
) <
0
;
31 00
30 B3
33
20 1 1
20 1
33
) 3A
0
;
04 7
33 73
33
37 1
23 1 3
3
"
&
#
'
>
" $
" #6
0S !
!
&
C
+
&&$
1
! N + "
&
&
! &&
! &&
+
,
!
"
!
!
&
! &&
"
"
"
'
!
& !
&
!
"
& 0 31 %
)
0
;
+
)/
Bar chart showing average pH for Field & Guideline pH data
10.4
10.2
10
9.8
pH
Field
9.6
Guideline
9.4
9.2
9
9.47
9.93
8.8
0
'
"
!
" .
& 0
'
" $ 1
! !&
!
! !?
;
!3
!
!
! &&
$
! !&
4
! !
& !
!
$
& !
!
"
&
&
0&
-
!
! !&
-"
!1
#
*
.
&
# !
!
& ! !"
$
!
- &
- & 37
&
63*
)/
*
+
-"
&
& !
! &&
'
&
& !
!
" "
!
"
!
"
.
!
"
"
(Q
"
&
'
!
$
*
"
! "
1 -)#
& !
&&
&
!
!
"
"
&
&
!
&
&
!
&
#
"
$ #
"
,
>
#"
&&$
!
7B
@.
&
6*
6*.
+
)
+
0
%
1
;
7B
@.
1 7.1
712
231
BB
1
7 7
" #R "
! 0 (R0 )
! !! $
0
3
2
R
7B
273
442
11 4
1
B4
%! R##
00(R0 )
O'
(
!
!
;
66 %
$ ,!
17 1
@.
7B
1 7.1
B07
34
B0
1 04
1
"
R
03(R0 )
$
!
&
B0# 1 2# 1 B# 4)
&"
!
'
&
"
(
! !! $
$
"
@.
&
"
#
!"
!
!"
+
&
43
0B
B70
77
R #!
!
"
! !&
&
&
" !
" "
!
#
'
$
"
"
&
.
#
;
"
$ ,
"
)
0
0 *1 .
-+
. &
+
Straw (1g)
'
& !
"
17 1
Wood (1g)
"
(?
!
1
&
!
1.
"
"
!
! !
!< "
#
"
#1
!
1) 9
!
#
#
9
!
&
&
!"
&
" .
#
$
&
$
!
#
&
6=
$
&
"
"
%
! &
&
&
"
= 8
=. %
$ !
& 1B ,
!
$
!
"
&
.
&
!
&
&
"
"
!
&
!
#
& !
&
,
)#
+
&
'
$
& !!
&"
!
!
!
5
*
!
"
"
"
!&
!
( 4,0 )
+
#
" !
&
$
&'
"
(
A<
$
"
! !
&
"
!
! +
!
$
"
7) , !
! '
"
7)
!
!
!
&
! !
"
D
170,172
2)
+
!
+
#"
#
!
-
"
!
"
! && $
"
!
"
, !
$ #
42
/ &
)
!
"
" "
$
!
T
!
#
)D
! &&
!"
&
$
&
(
3)
!
"
!
!
"
"
&
!!
+
!
&&
<
&
&
'
&
!
9&
$
$
!"
!
"
( 4,0 L)
D
&
$ "
!"
&
"
&
! &&
"
,"
$
(
(1
$
"
$
$
1
#
+
!
!
&
! &&
!
!
+
! &&
&
!
!!
!
!
$
"
$
,
&
&"
$
$
:
#
"
&
"
*
"
#
) '
+
'
$
!
#
!
+
$
! 02L (
A
& !
!
0BL ( 0 7# ?
!
!
+
! ! !
#
&
"%
!
& $
"
+
$ #
+ ,& $ 1
(
$
!
! '
"
(& !
!
&
"
$
$
#
"
)
'
"
&
!
"
>
!
!
&&$ (
&"
$
!)
& !
"
#
&
!$
"
"
=
6
"
!
$ "
&
0 56
&
!
;
! "
G )
$
!
!
&
#
$
$
"
(! ,
!"
!
&
#
O 056
&
! *
G #
!
"
!
!
&
!
"
#
(B0,
'
#
$
"
4) !
"
+
! !! $
$ !(
&
"
(
"
!
# 103
"
?
*
"
:
!
!
$ !
&
#
#
&"
A
).
!
!
&
. C
'
& !
$ "
(
"
!"
!
#
9
& !
Q1L
#
!"
)" #"
"
+
&
"
$ !
"
!
&
)
(
&
!
1)#
(E )
(6 )#
#
$
9
!
+
02 °
!
!U "
!
'
(
& ! &&
(1 2)
!
"
!
(
7)
$
!
!
!
,1
56
&1
& !
& !
*
$
(1
,12
'
56
56
,1
!
!
$ !
,1
)
"
B
! !
& ! &&
"
+
$
A< ?
#(
+
"
"
*
"
!"
" "
!
"
+
2)#
&
"
+
$
"
4)
&
# $
"
&
"
=
°
!
!
!
"
#
1 ,
L
°
!
!#
!#
#"
*
"
B
"
& !
3L
"
=
#
B) *
( 11 # ?
A
!"
#
"
"
#
,1
!
$ #= !
" $ !
!&
"
+
&
- &
,
!
&
+
(* ) + ! B '
!
"
!
81
!
A
2 56
$
!
$
+!
$
7L (
&
$
"
#
'
!
$
,1
1 56
! !&
<
! #
!
! !
!
!
!
!
!
&
" $
$
$
&
$
&&
&
- '
! "
! "
9
!
#
!
+
!
+!
"
+
!
& ! "
$
.
'
&
E
(
$
! "
!"
&
!
& 0)
"
!
=
!
"
& !
+
!
(1 B4)
& $
+
!
,
"
!;
B,00C G ) *
(6 !
!
&
!
#
!"
*
! $
&1 , L
4)
!
$
"
!"
"
!#
!
2
& #
! 2L
#
&
8
The biochar was created from sewage, which can have mineral content of up to 70% (Shinogi, 2004) and is therefore dramatically different
from botanically derived biochar. Acidity in wood biochar is generally caused by organic functional groups, but little work exists on basicity.
9
Ninth Annual Report on Carcinogens 2000
*
&
9
&
"
$
!
!&
&
$
&
=
3
'
!
! 11
+
!&
!
& !
*
$
&
> ! &
° (= ! # 1 20)#
"
;
+ !
)
#!
&
!
$
! &&
$
!:
!
!
"
0
!
&
# (1
,
4
0
77
2
2)# V6 !
* (
*
&
$
!
!#
@
$
-
1
04
30
#"
9
12
7
$
(
41
13
1
03
1
,
33
!
!
#
!
"
#
"
6
!
4)
&
!
#
&
D
41
0
10
(
6
"
&
! +
,1
! ) & & *
!(
)N 1 1
6
V
11
"
)
0
:
&
(E*:# 1 B7)
! &&
&
!
- -
)
,
"
'
!
(
'
!
!
$
)
=
!"
"
&
&
"
$
$
!
'
(
&
!
!# $
# 1 47.
!
#
#
0.
#
$
"
!
$ !#
4).
1
&
!
, 17L
"
+
+
!
!
! &&
$ "
& !
&
"
!
" &
(C )
C
$
"
(F )
"
&
!
&
!#
"
&
"
& !!
&
"
#
$ #
!"
.&
(
"
!
!
&
!
7)
&&
&
!6
!
"
(
(
"
"
#
,<
! &&
&
#
$
!
#
! $
"
!
#
3)
+ ! ! "
!
!
#
( )
*
!
!
"
!
"
!
)
( )#
$
"
(
"
&
$
!
"
+
10
$
$
<
N
! #
9
"
22 ° (C % #
)
!
"
%
#
! $ # $
&
&
*
"
" ;
9&
! !
#
!
&
'
'( #! &
&
!
&
!!
!
3)
'
!
!
As discussed in (1.1.5) , lignin has been shown by Demirbas (2004) to have a positive influence on biochar yield
#
! #
6 !
#
#
( 120# ?
& !
!
&&
!
!
&
$
"
& #F
$
"
"
!
"
"
= 3 )/
=3.
!
$ !# "
&
&
!
!
&
*
%
!
&
"
!
#
$ !
!
$
!
!
"
- &
"
! !
!
" &
!"
"
&
!
"
#
!
& !
!
+
! !
&
#
" ,
!
"
!
+
'
$
"
&
"
!
-
$ "
$
!
- &
! !
"
- 00,1
9 !
#
! !
!#
!
& ! 6 #
$
!
!
!
& !
"
!
!
"
!
+
!
"
!
#
"
>
$
&
&&$ &
*
"
#
&
!
"
"
"
!
#
(7)
#
( -M7)
!$
&
"
!
-#
1. ?
"
!
&
"
!
!
!"
!
(?
;
&
&
$
! $ "
&
(* )
( 1 #
B) *
#
$
!
!
$ "
#
0. W
4.
!
&
&"
$
!
(M 00) &
+
"
!
&
! !"
&
& !!
!
4,B
!
#" $
7. P U
- *
!!
*
"
D
!"
&
-#
& !
!
!
%
'
*
&
&&
"
,
$ !
"
&&
+
'
&
$ ! !
!
#
! #
'
)/
'
;
&
( ! )
*
#
&
- &
$
!
"
!
"
$
2)
+
=3
!! !
!"
"
!
&
!
!
"
( 177# '
!
& !#
!"
;
$ # "
*
!"
!!
"
0)
"
"
!
!
+
#
#
"
!
!
'
&
! !
*
!
& !
"
+
A6
!!
E
! &&
-"
&
"
"
"
&
!
!
! &&
&
A
$
!
#
&
& !
! &
"
)#
-#
"
# "
!
"
!
!
&
& !
!
=33 D
+
9 +
"
#
&
" + #
"
$
!
&
& - ( -3,1 ) (?
+
"
"
! #
"
(6
>
#
&&
! G"
"
(H > ! ,= >
!
!
&
$
! &&
+
!
" = !
+
&
&
"
$ ! &&
A< ?
(
#"
&"
&
&
'
&
9
!"
&
"
!
"
&
& &
(
!
!
#
"
) -
$
&
!!
#
#
=* E
'
#
"
&
$ !
"
&
!
#
! "
#1 7 .
(
!
!
"
(
&
&
$
"
"
#
&
;
3)#
'
$
&
&
(?
&
"
!
#
&
"
" $
!
&
$
!
&
"
&
!
7. 6
" "
$ !
'
&&
!
&&
"
!
$ !,&
!
"
!
&
"$
&
"
!
C+
;
$
"
$
"$
"
&
!
$
'
!
& "
&
+
!
&
&
!
!
&
$
"
!
#
$ #
!
!
(
!
!" "
&
*
! !,
! # 1 B3) !
! &"
!"
!
> ! (F %
# 1 B2) ,
.
!
&
&
&
'
;
!
&
#
"
"
!
$ "
!
+!
!
#
"
$ #
&
.
7)
"
!
;
,<
&
!
"
! &&
7) 6
#
+
"
!"
1).
!
#
&
!
!!
#
+
!$
! &&
$
>
&
"
!
7)
"
"
$
A
'
&
$
& )#
$ !"
&
&
"
#
(6
!
"
, +
$ #
"
7) (
!
>
#
#
#
!
"
"
$ "
(
!
&
"
!
"
7)
&
!"
!
"
&
4) !
&
!
"
!
3) E
"
#
" &
!) "
!! !
(
#
*
&
&
!"
! "
"
"
!
&
#
! & &
&
&
+
"
25 , 5
!
!
,
!"
6
"
'
!"
#
"
! !
#
!
$
!$
+
,
!
"
&
$!
#
"
&
"
"
! !
! &
! !"
! $
$
"
+
#
!
!$
!
!
* $
&&
(P
!
&
!
"
#
&
! &&
&"
$
4.
&
"
#
!
"
!
&
&
=6 (
!"
&&
!
!
#*
!$
"
!
! "
$ #
"
#
!
&
6 *< (
1
&
" "
'
"
!
$
&
"
!"
! !#
!
!# &
!
"
"
"
!
"
& !
"
!#
)
!
! $
&
&
$
!
! &&
!
'
$
&
!
*
! #
;
!
#
"
+
#
! &
*
" !
$
& ! ' &
*
$
'
"
"
$
B)
!
&
$
"
!
"
" E
F ! #9 !
&
$
,=
!
!
!
!
&
+
)
)
&
)
% @
)
2
G
1 2
$
! &"
!&
*
&
&
*
!
172
"
%
)
&
)
)
8 7 !!>1
)
G
! $
#&
&
;
!
> #
&&
!
!
!
!
!#
#
$
#
$
"
-
#
3. '
$ #
!
&
!
"
$ #
$
!"
!
&
#
*
"
1 2
$
$
&
!
#
"
! &
!G!
B)#
,
&
!
"
&
!
!G
$
#
"
H)
!
42
F
&
!
&
&"
@;
%
1
8172
! '
$ "
+ 0
G
9 $
! &&
!
$
&
&
$
&
$ " #
(U
#1
)
"
6
(1 B7)
17
&
!
!
!
!
9 ! $
& & # !
&&
& ! (
!
"
&
!
&
"
$ !
#
!
%
!
5
* !
'
!
!
+ !
!
!
$ !
"
$
(<
A
" #1 7 .
*
"
!
#
!
'
&
(
9 ! ) !
!
"
'
"
#
!
! "
! $
!
F
#
*
$ "
#
4)
!
+ &
!
!
&
! "
"
"
*
,
*
& !
!
&
&
&
"
!"
!
2 2
!G!
G
.". = 6'
$ #
*&
&
,=
!" E
=6.
))
6
&
!
!
(
+
1
&"
#
!
042
B)
+
"
7)
! *
$
!
2 (9
=
(
)#
"
$
$
"
!
& *
!
"
"
!
&
)
+
)
(
"
#
"
! &
&
!
!
" ! "
&
&&
,1
"
"
!
.
P U
!
1
$
&
"
,
!
" $ !
U
#
7)
A6
(1 B2) $
! & ,
,1
& 2 ! 12
.
& #
&
! #
$ "
!
!
&&
- (
$ )
"
!
$ && $
+
!
,1
#1 B ) 1
$
" !
!&
& &*
"
!
!
, !
& !
$
"
!
!&
+
$
&
!
#
(P
!
&
4
)
+
%
G
1 14 2
'
"
D
))
4
G
!
;
4 G6
4&
"
& !
!
$ $
B
! .
!
!
&
1
#
1
!F
*
"
! !
!
*
&
"
(1 B7)11
6
&
( $
#
D
))
7B B
B)#
!
&
"
&
!
&
!
! &
F
"
!
&
"
$
;
11
7
!"
;
!
! (1
)
"
H$
& 4&
! !!
"
!
!
"
!
$ "
!
&
& "
!
!
!
, "
!
! &"
$ #
!
!
;
D
#
!
( -Q2 2)
&
!
! ( - 2 2,7) '
"
+ &
&
# * 0K#
!
- 3 2 ( " A - ! # 1 73) ( 1 H
#
B). &
!
!"
&
!"
$ !" $
&
! &
+
E
!
"
&
"
!
$
& !
)
"
$ "
&
$
!
L
4 G.6
&
!
&
7
' !
&& # "
!
,
!
This figure is used by organisations of the UN as a threshold index
&&
&
$
"
!"
&
&
! " $
&
$ (
0
+
+
+
))
)
I
)
@.
.
+
1 14 2
:
&
!
&
"
&
"
"
,1
& 2
&$
"
&"
&
)
) (E*:# 1 0). "
*
$
&
(1 B ) $
*
"
"
9
&
&
)
@.
+
"
&
!"
+
!
&
,1
2
30
273 B72
(
"
&
+
4
*
$
==
''
'
•
•
*
- - &
(
'
' ,& & ,&
'&
'' '
- '- +
-' .
!
!
07#
6 "
&&
!
!
"
&
! #
&*
"
!
,'
"
!
E*:, FH6 :
!
+
$ ! &&
"
#
!
"
!
"
& &
*
&
&
-
(E 2)
!
0 61 0 C@#
+
& &
!
"
-
- ,
- Q2 2
"
!
$ *
'
'
B)
&
&
&
(
,
)
-
; +
+
+
.
"
"
$ "
$
* &
!
#
!!
,
&
*
(
!#
0
4) &
& *
&
$ "
$
"
&
&
9
"
( F#
& &
$
+
!
1
!
"
!
)
4)
!
"
+
! $
!+
! &
4.
"
!
6 ",6
*&
&
# 6
"
&
"
,H
!
$
*
#
AF
!
*
0(
!
$
& #
&
( 10 # ? !
!
&
#
!
!
$ "
#
9 ! #
.
) !
$
#F
#6 ?
!
!
! 01 2# 3B 2# 12 1 A 1 C'
&
&
)
,
"
)
! !
&
'
&
"
& 4#
+
&
*
$ "
! #
* #C
*
$
!"
!
"
&
!
+
!&
!
E*:# "
,*
&
< $
!
)
-
&
!
&
!
+
= " ! $
!&
"
"
"
=1 C
6
#"
"
*
$
$ "
!
"
&
& - E
"
- (2 2,7 )
&
"
!"
" "
$
&&
, ! ! !
&
$ , ! !
&
"
$
!
&
*
&
'
!
!
!
,
?
*
!
& !.
!"
"
"
!
!
!
& !
"
"
!
!
#
"
&
"
$ #
$
&
"
"
$
!!
!
&
"
&*
, $ $
& !
!
$
'
&
$
'
!
&
-
&
"
$
"
!
!
"
!
-#
,
*
" ,
& !
!
! 172
&"
!
&
#
+
"
"
82
(
) '
& #
!
&"
!
" !! !
& ! (
!
"
!
!
'
!" "
! &&
!
!
&
'
!
$
$
!
+
!
!
#
$ )
$ $
&*
!
! #
#
!
&
?3 2
'
%
!
!
&
!!
!&
&
&&
!
&
,
"
'
$
."
<
&
;
! $
!
<
+
"
!
&
"
+
!
$
"
&
,
+
&& !
"
"
$ !
! "
!
$
?* 0
,
#
&
&
&
$
#"
+ ! !
! #
! '
!
&
"
"
& "
+
&
!
,
*
"
&!
D"
!
!"
& !
!
&
"$
& !,
$ #
!
"
!$
-$
&
&
&
&
!"
! &&
- '
$
$
$ "
*
$ !
!
$ "
&
&
E
!
"
!
&
&
"
!#
"
#
!
&
'
;
>
&
$
&
&
+ !
&
#
!
"
!
!
& &
& !, ! ! !
! !
!
.&$
'
!
"
&
%
!
"
!
!
"
&
&
&
"
!!
!
"
"
& !"
&
&
!
!
!
$
!
,
&"
*
!
$
'
$
!
&&
!"
&
$ .
"
&
"
!
*
2'
!
,1
"
!
!
" &
&
$
!
#
E
)
#
"
!
!
& +
"
&&
!
&
+
*
&
&
&
!
&&
+
&
!
&&
'
#
.
$
!#
"
!
! "
$
!
$
"
(
!
&
+
& !
"
!
&
&
&!
!
&
!
"
! "
!" &
!
'
& #
&
$
!
&
"
!
! &&
$
"
'
!
!
&
!
&
*6*9 - # 6*C6:F
# 6'H -*F - C # 6:F=W9 -*F=6 # -:CC* # 9W:F: W # 9F: H W # 6-9 *9 * ' #
-: 9H ' #
B
!
;
&
!
!
F
? @1 6
# & 6 *< !
! /
' '
-0 ...(1)# B1,B2
*= HHP * # *F<:6U ' # ?:
&
! $ !&
H<
1 &
1
# 3"# 1 71,1 7
*69?H,<:H?6 - 9 # *C F<6:F # 6':FH
:?9F E
7 C
& "
H?*F=H
F 9 # :'H
&
&
EW?H6
!
H H # : 6 -FH
$
&
"
"
!"
< # :''H : W # C: 6'9H ' # C*69F E #
> 2
0 .3?
377,3B
-:
-H6FH E # -HF<H 6-:'
"
72
& &
! !
$
& !
&
3 E
X
"
) 0 =
3
040,07
-*6 * <9Y9'
'' 4 &
:F<
60 * ?
0C
F<* - 6
0 3!# 4B3,4 1
'
&
&
$
$
' ,
4
!
6 !
$
!
!E
E # :??*F< C < * # : <HF
3
!&
# $ "
"
# 33# 2 43,2 47
9<=H *'H *
:<W *
7 9H*
1 B3 9
#6
!
!
F* H 6 # HCCH'' - # 'H??H H 1 0B 5
-* C*F - < 1 42
+
!
&
1#
"
"!
!
''
!
13 ,14
)
B 1D
1
!
'
3.
@
!
!
*
&
!
=! 0
0 "( )#
! &
,
#
! !
'0 6=
-3 '
@*
70, B4
7@
-
7
,99)
!
3"#
HFF*F
# *F<:6U ' # '-:C 6:F ' # =
9F6 H
1
&
* @ 3- ' '
'# .>?# 20 ,24B
HFF*F
+
!
5
.
6 $ (
&
9,P
"
-H6 : '<H
+
H
<HC9
!
(H!)
*#
*6 *
#5
:
BH
!
W <= 1 7
!
3 H&&
,
&6
6
#6
* $ !
"%
1
'
3#
.
!
' '# ? #
H'-:6
"
##8%8 "
0 6 $
G
E
!
!*
!F
!
:
#
&
E*:,
!6
*$ " &
@GG
&
G
''
# 8%8 "
C
!
E9H H F # *
- ;
#
,)
6:F
!
C
=*W<:F * =
? !
=?*6H
7
"
!&
& "
,
5
"
L
&
!
:# 1 B2# 3"# E
&
!
!&
L
!
!*
31#
:
*$
"
$
Z !O0 24BA&
!"
4 4,401
&
.H
9
@?
(
B)
$ ! G $
G
1 20 E
O
#
[
A
= F<*?H C # <H?
!
G<
*
-*W<HF
(
'
-:6-9 '
1 ,
?#
9F *
1 =
> 1-
* '&
1 73 6
- '
&
$
/
4 '
) '0 36
!
/
' 6
$
,
*
" #*
"
1
@
>
&
!
O
"
!
"
)
0
"
: 05
!&
*$
''
!
" &
##8 8 "
#
!
!- #
D
!
1 D 0
!
&
&
&
!
&
0 3.
B4, 0
&
!
!
* " # 01B,07
9 3
%
',
# 1 B4
!
"
<
"
3
! 6 *<
G
[*
@
# ?H-C*FF # UH D
"
''
&
# -* C*9H ? # = ==HF H =H = # UH 1 ' '
"
!
;
+ '' ' - ,
>> 07D31
=?*6H
"
GY20 B
< $
:?'-* < =
*$
# E*: E
<$
' .!3#
E H96H = HHF < ' 6
!
" @
"
&
# 6*
L
9
" @
G $G G
4'
!&
HFF 9 $ ! !
6
G
(E*:)# 3
&
G!
1,3
!
A <
G6
! G
>
# 1 B4
E*: 1 B7 6
'
!
" @
@GG
''
#%8%8 "
E:?HW# =
@
'
@ H+
>
"
30, 3B
H?9U*?<H,=:FU*?HU C # C*'' 6 - # *?*HU, 9< * * #
!&
!$ !
! .F
#
' ' ?># 1B2,1 0
3 6
!
!
&
H669F=':F C
F
!
&
' ,#
(999)
=
!H
!:=?H < # C* * 'W F # 6'9?? < # 6C9'@GG
"
! G
G
G
''
#8%8 "
9?9EEH
*
6
Z C6
>
!
9
!
!8!8 "
"
@
"
&
"
&
$ (
"
)*= !
,
9
$ (
)9 9C
G %
,
9:*FF9<: : # U* *F9:': *
$
+ &
' '
&
*C
*'- H 1 7 H+
*#
2 , 23
HH - : #
@'
*
!
G
*$
G
+'0 ..
#
2 *!
?
!
7
"
1
&
,
?H-C*FF # <* 69?P*
# 6'H9FH
*
!
!
3
' 0 *"( )#
!
"
! "
=
'
# FH-?6 ' # UH E
&
030,027
&
*
$
!
) )
! !
$ !
-
6
/
HF '
,
:'?W*
E
2
&
'
$
!
7
!
&
0 10 ,<
- ' 3*#
!
1007,102
&
$ !
" &
'0 "" 12, 0
" ! $
/
@*
"
# E *F<6HF E # <*C, :-F6:F
3 6
"
#6
/ '0 .> B1 ,B1
1
!
)
&
!
#
?H-C*FF # :6H - 6
? !
!
@
##8%8 "
1,0
# :: = <# *
>
?H-C*FF #
$
"
!
?? H 6 # 6 HC6'*< : # = *H'U < # < FF9F=
0 ! 3
!
&
! ! "
4 H $
!
''
!
''
! &
C
?*F<:F C
!
%
&
'
&
2
: ' -H9 : 6 # C:F H*? C # :<*C* &
$ !
"
! $ ! &
'
0 ">#
32 , 343
?*9FH # 69C:FW 6 # *??H6
1-
!"
&
"
* # ?9F
"
" &
"
1 44,
&
#
!&
C %
*$ " &
[' [= ! $1 0 !&
!
* = # 1 B2
F <6HF F # HF6HF
$
&
'
G9 9[
%
7 *
') *9?96
@
#
!
*9??H' # F9?66:F C
&
!
3
96-9C:': 6 # 6 =9
1 D 0
7
(
"
!
$
$ '
"
96 * *F P * - 9 6 # 6HF * 1 B H&&
) &
& - ' 0 . # 1 1,1
3
'
!
!
*
9
@GG
9
@GG
!
#
#6
E
!
(
7) '
# H< * <6 *$ " &
G '[P
[0 [
#C =
,- 9
# =?*6H
#
0 F
* > "
@&
06
$
> #
!
0B1,0B7
"
!
!
H
#
?H-C*FF
C
#
H F < # =?*6H
* !
"
?H-C*FF # :F<:F C
-:EE F ( !)
?H-C*FF # 6
:'- =
#
*
E
0'
#
!6
@
''
,/
&
*PHHF< *F
1B1 ,1B
:=:69
&& !
017
(
&
!
-0 6#
'
'1
" ! 3
8>
2
-
@
2 9 &
6 :6' C H 1
<
# 6
0
!
6 :< *6 = # = *CCH?96
& "
07 1,07
@E
!
?
.#
$
"
&
$
!
; !
#
"
!
!
&
0 ?*(1 )#
/
!
$
"
&
!
!
3, 2 B33 !&
[
!
'
&+
, ' ' *3#
7 '
!
71,77
171,1B2
,
!#
& -
&
) )
,1 4
5
&
&
,
!
1
"
C # E* HW = * # E *F6-*C
&
# " ,
)
-* #
"
:
''0 *#
&
&
7
#F
'3
" $
70,1 B
:F<:F C * # ?H-C*FF # *C9 HU # - '*<: C
$
?)
"
!!
&
33 40# :
* 9
)
&"
#
* C *$ "
&
!
L $ L " ,
&&
3 F
!
&
"
4'
!
6-9F:=9 W
#
4B7,4 4
2 E + !," !
# :PHFU* E # = H6* <
&C !
" "
6 -F9'UH C 9 # C:F H*?
" &
9 *
6
5
,6
C
, *
$
' 0 6.#
3
# =*FH6- * # -9?*
# E96'H
!
#
!
217,20
#E#
C !
1114 (
7) , !
H9'- <H
:F'
& GHH' 1114L
,
$
@ :
+
'
&&
1 7 C !&
&
@*
@
!&
?
"
HH'
%
"
$
G
##8%8 "
H
#
"
' F * H # :U *W F # :F*? H #
' FH
!
/ 3
''
- >= 1 7D1
*96:F
#
E
4
* *6- F # * F*F9'-9 '
B
)
' '
-0 *(1 )# 14 7,1404
"
<
!
*C6 C < 1 2 *
$
1
4 H&&
0 * >
!# 2 0
"
F* : *6 * * 1 B2 6
*
9
4
?9*F= # ?H-C*FF # 6:?:C:F #
?!
171 D0
C9 *F
6
::<6
#' F
&
,10
! #
4
"
&
0 .!.
"
,7 B
"
,
! -,1 FC
!
0 2,
" ,
! E'9
*6*HG 6*H *
!
!
#6
# *69F*6 # * * *6 H # 6* H??* * : ?:6 =
!
,! $ ! , ' : =
'
! H!
#* !
4
#6
!
-
'
"
'
-0 *6#
6C9?# P
1 B7 6
6C9'-#
# 1 B7
' :H- E
#'-:C 6:F ? C
3
<$
3 '
,
06
A
'0
!
! F
<
#
@GG
''
'0 < -'0 >
0
-
26
!
'
&H
# *$
&
<
'A - #
G
G
!
BG7G
@GG
*
0/
-#
"
9?<9F= ?
#
)
9?<C*F
!
<H
"
&
!
@GG
*
/
W6-9 H E 1 1
?! 442,441
3
!"
BG7G
!
!
B# 6
H
<$
6
#B
B[ + [ "
F 1 47 *
"
!
"
@
!&
&*
,
'
# C:
!
-
96 6
&
9
!
$
!
*$ " &
! G" [ 0 !&
&
@
*
! !
"
!
*$
&
# .3!
7
&
&
< $
)
*$
&
=
!G"
(
$
W # : 9H * *9F H =
!
&
&
! H
G"
"G
!F
&
!&
0
G!
&
! &
&
: F H # -:?: *W '
.!3# 24,41
*&&
*&&
B
BG
G
P*F U H9'HF ? # 9C H 6 # <: F9H 6 # -*F
&
!
!
$ 0 * , C
7# '
# F6 # *
# 6
@
! 6
4 H&&
&
!
W
,
!6
*1
G "
P*F < ' ' # C 9 F ' # ?H<9F 9
" "
!
3 , 24
#F
&
& H
' "
G G
# 8 8 "
' :+& !@
" &
"
!
&
!
"
!
!
@
"
@
@GG
748
*
"
6
!
!
!
@GG
*
!"
@34 7#
BG7G
G
$
!
!
69'HGHY'H F*?GFH 6G ##
(9
"
"
BG7G
3' +
C
-
!
@43 27 308
H $
*$
@3070
" &
@
G !
W*C*C:': C # : 9C: 9 W #
"
&*
9 !
) '
U-*F=# 6C9'6' 1
"
2 & 1)
F)
C< @ 1 7B 738
G !
[" "
G!
G
9 : : 9 E # *F6-: 9 6 # :=* * C
! &
> #
#
!
6
3B ,3 2
# C* # C* W # 96-: H P P F # ?*'*
+! &
$
! $
# .(1,0)# 047,072
!&
4 H&&
# -*?9? C *
@ H+
&
6
# *6C 66HF
1-
&
6
!
#
'- :FH?:H
' -