M To o ’ r/o Eco n o mic Situa tio n 2? ‘ ADD R E SS O" "ER "ER T "O O "ER SAN B E "O R E T "E "R AN C ISC O CO MME R C IAL O C TO BE R 9 1 9 1 9 , C L "B ‘l . 0 S : mar k re p iden t rer W M f "R E D ER IC " W "ITTO N "R AN C ISC O C O MME R C IAL C L "B C . S A N f o R o . t od a y wi t h a m an wh o h as been in the w ar from the begin ning At the firs t a la rm his s ervi ce began an d not fo r n e arl y a ye a r a f ter the ar m isti ce w a s he a ble to throw o ff e ve n bri e fly the he avy b urden Ofhi s world d u ties There i s no other m a n cer ta inly n o o ther Ame r ic a n O fwh o m th a t c an be s a i d "e s t a nds a l o ne i n a world o fmen There i s s ometh i ng ine vi t a bl y tri fling a nd tin k l i ng i n the e f for t am o ng the f e w O fu s here tod a y to p ut into w o rd s t he tho u ghts th a t o r we a re consc i o u s th a t he i s a re i n o ur m i nds tow a rd o u r g u est f k n own a n d lo v ed b y mill i ons In u nco u nted l a ng u age s the pr a y ers o f li t tle ch i ldr en gO u p fo r him a s gre a te r a n d more de ar th a n a n y arm y ch i e for k i ng or s a int An d yet u n av ail i ng a nd ine ffecti ve a s i t is we m u st expres s to Mr "oo ver somethi n g o fthe tho ugh t t h a t we who Appl a u se " li ve in Amer i c a hold fo r h i m " We rejo i ce in h i m as a Cal i forn i a n We exult in h i m a s a gre a t — Americ a n am o ng the gre a tes t "u t together with th a t e xu lt a t ion — a n a a f a re co n i gre ter eel i ng a nd t h a t r e oic i ng there i s a deeper d g j ti o n m ay I s ay solemn and deepl y mo vi ng th a t i n h i m we h a ve one g ures one o f those r are a nd r ad i a nt fe w whose o f h i s t or y s gre a t fi feet a re u po n the he ights a n d whose n a mes a re wr i tten a mong the st ar s "o r it h as been h i s wor k to ennoble h u m an i t y a n d to g ive to h u m an l i fe someth i ng O ft h a t spir it and essence wh i ch l i n k s it w i th Appl a u se " the d ivine " O nl y a gre a t poet c a n phr a s e "erber t "oo v er "ipling m ust h a v e h ad in m i nd su ch a m an a s he whe n he s aid : E AR E m eeting . , , , . , . , i ’ . , . . , , . , . , . . . , , , ’ , , . , . . . “ y o u can d eam and t make d eam y o u m te ; bi k and not ma k e b g b y o im Ify o u m eet w ito t i mp b and d Ify o u If no r ca n t : r t ou n ca n r t: at ur a ; i sarter, r u t eat to e tw i mp o te j t to am e; talk witb c o wd b t keep y o i tu e Ify o u lo e to common to u co; 0 w lk with k i ng lo i ng f iend can h t y o u ; If itb f m ch If all m en co n t wito y o u b t non e t Ify o u fill th nfo g i ing m in ute Wito ixty econd w tb f di tance n tb and To u i to y tbi g th at i it And wbi b i: mo e y o u ll b a man And ar r ca n r : no r er ne :, r a o e: n or v s s r: : e ea r e , ur : v oo or o u , , ru s ever r ur v r u r ’ e s e r , e u ” s ut u r u ca n r: r o ’ n e [4] ” . r , n , , r ’ d da ress ’ M f o R. "ER"ERT "EN TL EMEN : I would be a poor mind if I R. C"AIRMAN AN D ere n o t greatly emba rrassed at this moment TO merit the title o fa great Californian would be merit beyond that that could be con ferred in any community in this world because there is n o community o f the intelligence and character Of this State O fCalifornia After what we have heard i t is per haps a little di fficult to come down to the subj ect that I have chosen to worry y o u with for a moment today I t is n o t th e L eague Of Nations " L aug hter " I t h as been my duty especi ally during the last ten months to make a systematic study Of certain social and economic currents throughout the world in order that those gentlemen engaged in an endeavor to make peace could be as well advised as possible I have re t ain e d some Of the notes made on those occasions and I have thrown a few Of them together with the hope that perhaps i t might be Of some assistance to you in fo rm u lating your o w n minds about certain problems with which this country i s confronted In entering upon a dis cussion o f som e issues in the world s economic situation I wish to make an immediate di fferentiation in two widely separated economic phe w . , . , . . . , , , . , . ’ [5] ll fl A W 4 d ddrerr M f R o . H ER B E R T H O O"E R today That lies In the di fference o f the eco nomic situation Of the agri cultural populations of the world as distinguished from the industri al populations and in the industri al population for lack Of a better term I include the production O fnon agricultural raw material manufacturing and transportation generally that is chie fl y those agencies concerned wi th paid hat is in the main a division Of town a n d P ractically all of the worst Of o u r economic and Is today center in the towns any casual survey Of the world s economi c situa tion at this moment will display two extraordin ary perhaps not extraordi n ary but two very pertinent facts On e o f them is the depth to which p od uction has r t s m m b ro s a the othe r i ? v fi d fi s fl e d gu m gy p pp / f wh ic h produ tio h c as i n creas ed in agric u ltu re Th e in n fort ; du s trial classes all over the world have slackened e f the agricultural classes all over the world have redoubled their efforts I wish first to deal a moment with the industri al sit u a tio n I take it that there is o n e thesis o n which every business man and every economist no matter what the “ — bent o fhis mind can agree and that is Th a t the very i foundation o fthe maintenance and the improvement in O the standard O fliving lies in securing the QW ” the human b e ing from this that the maximum producti vity cannot be Obtai ned without the elimination of waste I t further follows that the application of such a proposi no m en a . , , - , , - , , , , , , . ’ . r “ , * \ v . _ . , , . , , , . . [ ] 6 " To e Wo rld Sc o n o m i c S i t u a t io n ” tion must stand several tests and the princi p al o n e o f these is that the maximum production can only be O b t ain e d u n der conditions that protect and stimulate the w ell being Of the indi vidual producer N o w th e causes o fthe present decreased productivity are to s o m extent the same throughout the world There was a great mobilization o findustry during the war on new lines of endeavor There was a new dis tribu tion o f commodities and a distorted purpose in co m merce With the cessation o fhostilities a large part Of the industries Of the world have h ad to be redirected back to peace work and there has ,O f necessity been some disruption in production The struggle for political rearrangements during the armistice has had a sti fl ing e ffect o n production We have to bear in mind that five Old empires have been split into twenty di fferent states Tihe old empires were t each Of them economic units an d we thus have them broken into twenty economic fragments and the result could not be other than a decrease in production There has been a physical exhaustion Of a large sec tion Of the population particularly in E urope P rivation from war and under feeding all have contributed to create a great re fl ex against renewed exertion TO a minor degree considering the w hole there h a s been a destruction Of equipment and tO Ols There has been some loss o forganization and skill due to diversion to war The delay in peace has particularly in E uro pe de , - . , . . , . , , . . . , , , , . , . - , , . , , . , . , [7] , fl ddreu e M f R. o H E RB E R T H O O"E R laye d the import o f raw materi als fo r until peac e is made credits cannot be arranged and factories cannot be reopened E urope has exhausted practically the whole Of its movable securities I t must borrow working capital with which to secure raw materi al and that work ing capital cannot be available until we have peace There is also a large factor in the soci al ferment that arises primarily o u t Of the necessity o f economic re adj ustment O fwages in an endeavor to continually meet the rise in prices that are themselves the result Of the vicious circle Of in fl ation in money and credits during the war There is a further note in all this turmoil and tumult and that is the insistent demand Of labor for higher n t he a dmifiigf standards O fliving and a W fa tio n of i ts ow many th notions Of sociali d by many millions o fpeople and in some countries also labor has become infected with the notion that it in fort O fthe c reases the total sum Of labor as it limi ts the e f individual Thus we have the demand for a six hour day "rom all these causes accumulating in di fferent coun tries in di fferent intensity there is one essential fact and that is that the industri al productivity O fthe world h as reached so lo w an ebb that nothing but political and moral economic chaos finally interpreting itself into a loss o flife on a scale hitherto undreamed of is upon us unless constructive measures can be set up by w hich the , . . . . , ‘ , - . . , , , , , [ ] 8 , “To e Wo rld Sco n o m i c S it u a t i o n ” world and more partic u larly E urope is to return to work Some items in the present situatio n illustrate the ex tent to which productivity has fallen An inquiry which s h o w e d that there I carried o u t w e m o n th were fifteen million famili e s recei ving unemployment — allowances in E urop e practically a population Of sev v e millions being c arried on charity by go v ern e n ty fi ments and being paid almost wholly by the sheer issue o fpaper currency The coal consumption Of E urope had o n the first Of August fallen to a rate o f tons per annum as compared with tons pre w ar and 600 tons at the day Of the armistice Taking E urope as a whole Of the population Of about something less than 3 can be supported o n their o w n soil Approximately o n e hundred millions Of these people must live by the manufacture and marketing Of products o ftheir labor to other cou n tri es in exchange fo r their foo d I t is a sinister fact that the peo ple today being supported o n unemployment allowanc es practically represent the surplus population Of E urope "efore the war these whole masses tion produced from year to year only a small margin Of commodities over and above their necessary co n su m p ti o n and the amounts they required for their exchange abroad for vital necessities I t is true they managed to support armies and navies that they had a class o f n o n producers an d that they did gain slightly in in , , . m m . - , . , , , - . , . . , . . , - , [9] , , d ddreu M f R o . H E R BER T H O O "E R ternal improvements and investments abroad ; but all these surpluses were Obtained at the cost Of a da n ger o u sly low standard Of living More particularly was this true in the c ase Of "reat "ritain where the largest volume o f"ri tish production was undoubte dl y secured at a fearful cost in the stand ard Of living and the ultimate physical demoralization Of an industri al population N o w in pre war days E urope had the advant a ge o f the enormous stimulus Of individualism I t had a lso the adv antage o fgreat economic discipline ; and during the war the patriotic impulse to production and a reduction in consumption carried them on in spite Of the dive rsion Of men to war and munitions "u t during the war g reat promises were held o u t in every country of E urope as to economic betterment with peace With the cessation of hostilities the patriotic stimulus Of war towards pro duction was lost and an insistent demand for economic change came from every quarter with the armistice Now this social ferment is the most difli c u lt problem in front Of the whole world I t grows fundamentally o u t Of a yearning for higher standards Of living demand for economic change in the fl aw s O flabor and in E urope for a greater equality o fopportunity o r to phrase it in another way fo rzh effg i drw si o nfaf very large areas this has resulted in actual and th dic al ideas ; and in other areas it has taken a milder fO f demands for nationalization o fcertain industries economic im . ” . - , , . . . , . , . , , , , M ’ fl ‘ . [ 10 ] , “To e Wo rld Ec o n o m i c S it u a t io n ” pulse Of the "rench R evolution O fa century and a half ago was a better di vision o fthe land The economic im pulse Of these revolutions that we have had in the last 3 " . e 5,” < industry I t is to be noted that these two movements are not from the agricultural classes ; that they are town My phenomena N o w all thi s ferment whether it is in the form of de mands for an equalization o fwage with the cost Of liv ing o r whether it is in the form o frestri c tion Of indi vid ual output in an endeavor to increase the total volume Of employment o r whether it is in the nature O fsoci ali z a tio n with the hallucination that men will work f or altruism alone o r whether it takes the form Of strikes o r — lockouts o r whether it: takes any other form all have o n e concrete result and that is that we have a d W producti vi ty Q3 } has placed all E urope in j eopardy and that has come to i nvad e th is c o u n try These phenomena until recently had not penetrated the United States to any great degree but no man can say in the face O fthe enormous strikes that we are con fronted with that we are at all free from the Eu ro pe a n i z a tio n Of the United States There will be no use Of tears over rising prices if our pro du c tiv ity m ain t ain s its present level for rising prices are simply the visualization Of in fic ie n t production When production breaks down su f prices must rise and the richer are supplied and the poorer do without R ight here is the origin o fclass dis . m . , , , , , , r , ; W m “M m n I , , , . , . , . [ II ] 9 96 fl ddrerr e w tin c tio n s M f R. o H E R B E R T H O O"E R and the origin Of violence We want no classes . n o w have and the opportunity for which we pp every man b y exertion to participate in all that we possess This to my mind is the primary and pressing prob lem Of this moment and the first step in its solution is to get peace P eace is however but a single step and the fundamental fact is that the world is produ cing less in du s trial m ateri al than i t requires to m aintain its total population Therefore the busi ness O fthe whole world — the business Of every thinking man is as soon as it can a to find some are con fronted solution o o rtu n l ty , , . . , , , . , . , , , , , . ful formul ae O f "olshe Sdci alism ha v e already wrecked themselves o n the rock Of production "o r such reduced production they have caused the death and misery Of millions O f people They have been abandoned even by their leaders We need some definite substitute some plan for sol v ing this problem Th e so lu tio n must be found by “ Americans in the practical American w a b ased upon American ideas o n Am e riEa if p I o so p h y Of life And further it must be founded upon o u r own n ational in s tin c ts and in harmony with O u r own n a tio n al in s titu I t cannot be founded by creating class fe eling O f rs and capitalists Unless we can find such 21 pl In . ' . . , . ' i ’ fl . , , ‘ , . , “To e Wo rld 8 co n o m i c S i t u a t io n ” we shall be subj ected to the disintegra ting m - th e 0rie s o f 3 " W fifi fi fi fifi me that any solution o f this problem must go deeper than questions o f strikes lockouts o r arbitration fo r thes e presuppose a con flict o f interest We have got to g o sooner o r later to the root Of this ficulty There is no solution short o f c o di f We must begin by creating so somewhere a solidarity O finterest in e v e ry sec tio n Of the people conducti ng our industrial m achine The worker the administrator and the employer are absolutely inter dependent o n o n e another in this task Of securing the maximum production and a better di vision O fits results I t is hopeless to secure a solution if we are to set these people up as di fferent class es fighting with each other Maximum production must be founded on the mum exertion O f every individual within his physi ability and upon the reduction O f wa ste not only dividual but national Un less we are going to secure t maxim umproduction through the combined e ffort and intelligence O four entire economic machine we will ha ve destroyed the very fou ndations u po n w h ic h we build the higher ac tivi ties Of life O n e o fthe most important actions taken by our P res ident was the summoning Of the Industrial Conference at Washington I f that conference can evolve some method by which we can obtain industrial peace it will , . , . , M w " W ‘ , . , . . . , , . p u u i g -M , O D f fi . _ . , [ 1 3 ] M t o i fl ddrerr of c M R . H ER B ER T H O O "E R more fo r the world in the next tw o years than c o fNations can possibly do during the same I n the last seventy fiv e years industry has developed into large units We have in a great degr e e lost the interest Of the individual worker in the produce o fhi s hands In the specialization Of industry we have dulled the worker by intense pro duct ion without gi ving him an b e other interes t we have widened the space a n d y tween the employer and the employee We have de stroyed all the Old intimacy between the employer and the employed which bore withi n i t mut u al respon si bility SO we must search deeper for a solution than lies in mere superficial agreement i f we are to find an end o f this constant stru ggle We must find in the relati o nship o f employer and employee some common bridge o f te n a n c e Of [ actual individual must have a contribution on both sides Of energy their full intelligence and their full responsibility To do this we must secure a better basis o fdistributio n Of the re s u lts from labor from skill and intelligence if we are going to secure this larger interest in production N O W the human race has increased its standard o f productivity and therefore its standard o f living through a thousand years o f growth o f an extremely intricate organization of production and distribution This organization contains within itself a great stimula tion to skill to invention and to industry We can not - . . , . , . , . , , , . , , , , . , . . , [ I4 ] “To e Wo rld Ec o n o m i c S it u a t io n ” maintain the production which we now ha ve by the destruction or sudden disturbance Of this delicate organ iz a tio n The margins upon which the human race is liv ing tod ay are too small to warrant a drop Of only ten per cent in our productivity The maximum production does not lie in the abandonment of the in dividual reward fo r e f fort and intelligence I t lies in a proper stimulation Of these qualities of skill and e ffort and their stimulation by the only stimulant that is con s tant in the human character and that is his own self interest I mentioned the question Of waste an m o n o t mean alone the w as te of strikes and O funemployment and the lack o f interest in labor but also national waste b National wast e contributes to decrease the e fli c 1e n cy o f e w the entire industrial machine and thus to decrease the available commodities for distribution We have in this country a government the administrative organs Of which we set up before we had gained o u r complex e co nomic organization and we further distorted that go v e rn m e n t by the measures we were compelled to take in war time There lies a wide field for adj ustment in o u r present processes both as to gag es, to expenditure to o ur railways and a control of dominant enterprises and to the actual administration o f the government generally I have n o panacea for any Of these problems I believe Jo that these are the lines Of advance This requires that the constructive devotion O fthe Offi cials Of this country and the intelligence Of the enti re pe ople should be . . . . , , - , . , , . . , , . , , , . . . [ 1 5 ] fl ddrer: c M f R. o H ER B E R T H O O "ER directed to these issues instead Of to issues that are now exhausted and are pra c tically accepted Agriculture has had but a minor penetration o fthese difli cu lties that permeate the town populations I t was never so prospe rous n o r in so high a state o fproducti vity as today E ven in E urope there is not an acre for whi ch seed could be Obtained o r agricultural implements found that has n o t been planted The food situation in the world today is therefore not a question Of s u pply There are ample supplies o fthe most essenti al co m m o d ities to feed the whole of civilization until the next harvest The problems Of this division O flife are there fore not the re fl ex Of the currents that dominate indus trialism There is however in this calling a very large and difli cu lt problem I t arises from the fact that the season o fthe fl ood delivery of the result of our American labor is now upon us We shall have a large — ver our own consumption probably between teen and twenty million tons Of food that we wish to market abroad only customer fo r eig h ty g o n ine ty pe r llig e re n t countries have to an sted their transferable securities Their production O f industrial commodities to exchange for this food cannot begin until they have had raw materials They cannot Obtain raw materials 8 and t until they have had re we are rope i ntil we hav e peace “ idle today we are preventing ourselves from finding a , . . . , , . , . . , , . , , . . . ‘ m g , . . M , vow . -W , ar , [ 16 ] fl ddrerr c M f R o . H E R BE R T H O O "E R While o n agricultural subj ects a word for th e co n sumer may not be amiss We hear a great deal Of justi fia ble complaint o fspeculation in the primary necessit ies of life There have been many men w ho have taken unj ustifiable advantage o fthe te rrible economic disru p tion o fthe last twelve months Some of this speculation has been of an absolutely vicious order "y viciousness I mean men who give no service in distribution w ho have bought food the prime necessities o flife with a view to lifting their price out o fthe community "u t the great rise l n pr i ces this last seven months since the demobilization of the "ood Administration has been due to other causes entirely These causes age and they lie generally in the anticipation that was held by the whole food producing and food marketing world that with the opening o ftwo hundre d million customers in Central E urope there would be a demand o f such dimensions as to make a world shortage Therefore there was a large amount of buying a large amount o f w ithholding from t h e m arket of what o n e may term a protective order not with a view of speculating against the community but o f safeguarding supplies E ven gov ernments have been engaged in this operation To put it in another way many people hav e been increasing their stocks out o fa fear that there would bé a sc arcity , . . . . , , , , . . , , . , , , , . , . , u a ” . ‘ w m w w w a s imfigof the present harvest we had th at before th éfiéf larger s tocks o ffood o fmany kinds in o u r public ware houses than we have had at any time during the pas t ‘ [ 18 ] " To e Wo rld Ec o n o m i c S it u a t io n ” five years Tw o conclusions can be drawn from this : one is that we did n o t over export foodstu ffs from the United States during the past year ; the other is O fmore importance and that is that with these accumulated stocks and probably the largest harvest that we have ever had we have ample supplies to carry over the next year The demands from Central E urope will never amount to the creation of such a shortage as has been anticipated by the food trades and the public may yet score o ff the speculator While E urope needs and will import most O f o u r surplus during the year if they can find credits with which to buy it it has not the resources to import one atom more than is absolutely necessary to preserve life and there is no j ustification today for the anticipation of any over demand upon the United States during the next twelve months There is however ample room for anxiety t hat in the next five months of our maximum production through the delays in peace and in the set ting up of credits E urope will not be in a position to purchase her custom ary food supplies during the time of our high production and that it is now time for us to dis play some interest in what will happen to our agricultural prod ucers when o u r warehouses become overc harged There is one general fault with food prices in the United States and that is the ex ensiveness of o u r dis p margins between the farmer and e W W the consumer are larger in this country than in any other country in the world even eliminating the whole ques tion of speculation The whole distribution system needs . - , , . , , . , , , - . , , , , 3 , . , W , . [ 1 9] W . m m m i d ddrerr t if i t M f R o . H ER B E R T H O O"ER a careful analysis and study and some form of deliberate rem edy Such remedies do not however take the form of governmental interference except against monopoly and vicious speculation I t would be amiss if I did not mention that there are some articles in the world today of which there is an actual world shortage On some textiles clothing materi al and a few food stu ffs such as sugar and coffee and a few items of that character the price level is a level b ased on shortage Nothing will permanently correct such price levels but an increase in production or a decrease in consumption and a co n tin n ed decrease in production in the manufacturing community can only tend to lift the whole list o fthese prices higher Now these are a few of the problems that demand immediate consideration in the nation There are others e on you for some hours k cleared of this peace question we bring to bear the great intel on its solution These things mean he welfare of o u r people and to the world than even the L eague great as I believe i ts aspirations and its purposes are We have spent two years in war and we have spent a year making peace and now let us have a year in economics in order that we may not find our selves in a worse plight than we were before we entered upon it " A p plause " M Whitton I prop se three cheers f M "erbert "oo ve r . , , . . , , , , . , . , . . . , , . , , . r. . : o or r. . T"IS "O O " IS D"E ON T"E STALCPED "EL OW DATE 0 AN IN ITIAL "IN E O " 2 5 CE N TS W IL L "E A SS ESS E D "O R "A IL "R E TO R ET"R N T "IS "OO " O N T"E DA T E D "E T"E P EN A L T" W IL L IN C R EA S E TO 5 0 C ENTS O N T"E "O "R T " ON T"E S E"ENT" DA" DA" AN D TO O "E R D"E . .
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz