MCI (P) 163/02/2015 AUG 2015 With Thanksgiving and Tenacity Tan Kim Huat R “Stand at the Crossroads … ask for the Ancient Paths, ask where the Good Way is, and Walk in it” (Jer 6:16) egardless of race, language, religion or political persuasion, Singaporeans may be united in thanksgiving at the upcoming Jubilee celebrations. There are many reasons for this. Overflowing with Thankfulness (Col 2:7) What we have achieved is truly remarkable. It is hard to think of another nation that has made similar progress in a mere fifty years. Of course, we are far from perfect. We have our fair share of mistakes and wrong turns. Even so, we still have the right to be proud of what we have accomplished, and none can begrudge us. Indeed, we have surpassed many nations that were once ahead of us in development. This is no mean feat, especially for a small nation that is without natural resources or a hinterland for wealth generation. INSIDE… However, if truth be told, not all that we have is a result of our achievement. a special In some cases, we are simply blessed by what some would regard as a lucky coincidence of circumstances. Of course, Christians will look Jubilee at it differently: not luck or blind chance, but the unseen and gracious celebration hand of God. We may not fully understand why we have been given such supplement blessings, but grateful to him we certainly must be. cont’d on p2 “TRUMPET CELEBRATES SG50” 1 In this light, religions in Singapore have a crucial role to play. Despite the variations in beliefs and practices, they all serve as reminders that blessedness is not due entirely to human beings. Hence, no political party or charismatic figure can claim to be the sole architect of our success. That said, credit must be given where credit is due, without, of course, negating the need for constructive criticism. their disciples, since they regard themselves as the enlightened ones in this benighted world, and the final bastion of justice and equality. Only recently are we known as being ‘first-world’. So why isn’t this newbie striving to be fully like them? It is not surprising it was said recently that new winds will test the mettle of the nation’s soul and ask questions about the Singapore identity. Without a thankful heart, human beings cannot resist the slide towards arrogance and selfishness The prophet Jeremiah faced a similar situation. New challenges came his way, and his people were tempted to abandon the longstanding covenant that God had graciously made with them. The word that he brought to his people was that at the crossroads, they must ask for the ancient paths (Jer 6:16). These must not be confused with the antiquarian type. Instead, they are thus called because they have stood the test of time. Of course, not everything new is bad. There is much to learn and we must be nimble-footed in order to progress. But the feet mean nothing without the soul. “ ” One other important reason is that being thankful is a sign that we are not self-absorbed, as it is pointless giving thanks if we think we are entirely self-made. Instead, we recognise that many people have helped us along the way, even if some of them have now been surpassed. If the one can mature only in the context of the many, what it means is that we must commit ourselves to building a strong and cohesive society. A thankful heart binds society together and oils the interactions of its members. Without a thankful heart, human beings cannot resist the slide towards arrogance and selfishness. “ Christianity is marked by an overflowing thankfulness to God for his immeasurable gift in Jesus Christ our Lord and all that results from it (Col 2:17; 3:15; Heb 12:28). Significantly, the one sacrament that makes the Church distinctive is the Eucharist, a word derived from the Greek for giving thanks. It is also instructive to note that Paul’s letters are almost invariably prefaced with thanksgiving (except in the letter to the Galatians). This giving of thanks is not Paul’s tactical ploy to ingratiate himself with his readers. On the contrary, it sets the tone for his theological exposition and practical exhortation. The point is that Christian beliefs and praxis are coloured by thankfulness and not compulsion. “ Christian beliefs and praxis are coloured by thankfulness and not compulsion ” Stand at the Crossroads … Ask for the Ancient Paths (Jer 6:16) The rumblings can already be heard. Our nation may be standing at the crossroads. The familiar old is gone and many new suitors seek to fill its place: new perspectives on running the nation, new ways of doing business, new ways of defining the family, and new values to negotiate an increasingly ambivalent world. Just to name one that is looming on the horizon: same-sex marriages are legalised in many of what may be known as ‘first-world’ countries. Some of these countries have a great commission to fulfil if the press reports are to be believed. They have no qualms putting pressure on other nations to be 2 … at the crossroads, we must ask for the ancient paths (Jer 5:16) ” To ask for the ancient paths means for us to couple thankfulness with tenacity. The tyranny of the trendy must be countered with the ancient rock of values. Two of these values that have helped build Singapore to be the marvel it is today spring easily to mind. As difficult as it may be, we cannot abandon the commitment to stand for integrity and fight corruption. The recent high profile cases serve as a reminder that we lose easily and quickly what was hard won over many years. Furthermore, what has nurtured us in our days of little mustn’t be set aside. In the past, stories abounded on how very poor students still managed to complete varsity degrees, because their parents sacrificed much. These parents depleted their lives to raise the next generation. In so doing, the foundation for progress was laid. But we now deplete our earnings on our own lives. Sadly, the stories that abound today are about families breaking up, the abandoning of aged parents, and the enthroning of the bratty. Respect for parents, and commitment to the family are values we lose to our detriment. As we approach our Jubilee year, we remain thankful to God for all that we have received. But it is also a time to recommit ourselves to tread the ancient paths, and pray that our nation will not abandon the values that have built it and made it great against all the odds. Dr Tan Kim Huat Chen Su Lan Professor of New Testament Academic Dean A Word from the Principal SG50 and the TTC Story (Part Two) A Theological Institution serving Church and Nation I n the previous issue of the Trumpet, I shared about the journey of Trinity Theological College from 1965 to the point when it had to leave its original Mount Sophia campus in 2001. Like our nation, the journey of our college over these years was fraught with significant challenges and uncertainties. By God’s grace, however, we matured in our mission at home and abroad. In September 2001, TTC relocated to new premises at Upper Bukit Timah Road. This is close to the Dairy Farm Nature Reserve, which creates a pleasant environment especially conducive for ministry formation. It is our hope to make this our permanent home, but we are constantly alert to the fact that our lease renewal is due in 2046. “ The relocation of TTC is a reflection of a common experience in Singapore life—the need to constantly adapt to change as we live in an ever changing landscape of a nation in pursuit of economic progress. Indeed, change was our experience soon after our move for very quickly numerous housing developments encroached on our once tranquil retreat. But we cheered the unexpected news that a new MRT line, opening in December 2015, has situated the Hill View station at our doorstep. “ The rigour of our bi-lingual degree programmes…allows our students to imbibe an ethos of spiritual and intellectual integrity ” The turn of the century also brought fresh opportunities for TTC’s development. In 2002, the college was blessed by the first of its endowed professorial chairs. Our commitment to Christian scholarship was further strengthened when TTC offered its own Doctor of Theology (DTh) degree mainly to prepare faculty for seminaries in Singapore and the region. But nurturing the laity was also a priority of TTC. So in 2005 we introduced the Master of Theological Studies (MTS) to enable them in their witness in the public square. For more than a decade, the National Council of Churches in Singapore (NCCS) has relied on TTC for theological research and publications. This led to the formation of the Ethos Institute in 2014 jointly set up by the NCCS, TTC and the Bible Society of Singapore. This functions as a Christian think-tank, helping Christians to reflect on important issues in its witness to society. Our curriculum continues to build a solid theological foundation for its students to address a largely educated society. The basic course in theology, if undertaken on a full-time basis, covers only three years, after which the graduate enters a lifetime of ministry. For that reason, the college prefers not to dilute its curriculum with skills-based courses such as church music, counselling or management which can be acquired after basic theological studies. However, Field Education internship in local churches and church related organizations continues to provide practical training for our students. may Singapore develop its role as peace maker as well as become an agent of blessing upon the peoples of SouthEast Asia ” TTC has come a long way since 1965. It no longer depends on foreign funds, and 90% of its faculty are Singaporeans. Yet it enjoys an international repute, leading to numerous opportunities for collaboration with seminaries in the region and beyond. The rigour of our bi-lingual degree programmes, offered to students from a variety of denominations and church traditions, within the context of an international community, allows our students to imbibe an ethos of spiritual and intellectual integrity. We are also encouraged that the ministry of TTC over the past 50 years has been beneficial to our nation, as we exhorted individual Christians and churches to be more committed to the love of both Christ and neighbour. In response to this call, many have spent their time, money and other resources to bless the lives of people in the wider society. Having fostered the spiritual wellbeing of Christians, which leads in turn to lives of altruistic giving, the college has contributed in quiet but profound ways to the last five decades of nation building. So, in celebration of SG50, and recognizing our critical role as stakeholders in society, we thank God for allowing our college to journey together with our nation through the past decades. We fervently pray that Singapore will continue to progress and to grow in stature. In a region which faces political tensions and the possibility of conflict, may Singapore develop its role as peace maker as well as become an agent of blessing upon the peoples of South-East Asia. Rev Dr Ngoei Foong Nghian Principal 3 Christian Spirituality (2) Consequently, the practice of the presence of God helps us to remain centred in God, especially through the stresses and storms in life. We might add that, perhaps, Brother Lawrence also did not allow the concrete walls of the monastery to blind him from the beauty of God’s creation. So, through the ages, God’s people have also learnt to notice God’s presence by looking at creation as a mirror that points to God. A contemporary work by Belden Lane, Ravished by Beauty (2011), bears testimony to this practice. Major Themes in Christian Spirituality I n the previous article, I proposed a triperspective of Holy Scripture, spiritual theology and Christian Tradition as criteria in our search for an authentic Christian spirituality. However, an authentic Christian spirituality does not merely rest on good criteria. It must become a lived reality in a Christian’s life. In other words, Christian spirituality is as concerned with good practice as it is with good foundations. The emphasis on practice arises from the theological understanding that there is a mutuality in our relationship with God. In other words, we must intentionally act upon the grace that we received from God with the help of the Holy Spirit. This is the cooperative effort of which the apostle Paul wrote: “work out your salvation with fear and trembling, for it is God who works in you to will and to act according to his good purpose” (Phil 2:12-13). For this reason, I wish to focus on the dimension of practice in this article; and I do so by exploring several major themes in Christian spirituality, centring them upon the doctrine of the Trinity, and observing how “a cloud of witnesses” practiced them. Beginning with the foundational theme on God, Scripture tells us that we were created in the image of God (imago Dei). But our first parents, Adam and Eve, fell into sin and that image was terribly marred. Still, the image of God persists in humanity. So there is in us a yearning for God that manifests as a perpetual restlessness, and where respite cannot be found anywhere but in God. Thus, St. Augustine exclaimed: “you made us for yourself and our hearts find no peace until 4 they rest in you.” Christian spirituality therefore possesses a foundational focus on God, which echoes the Psalmist’s refrain: “be still and know that I am God” (Ps 46:10). “ authentic Christian spirituality does not merely rest on good criteria. It must become a lived reality in a Christian’s life ” The focus on God has been pursued in various ways in Christian history. A prominent one is that by Carmelite lay Brother Nicholas Herman, popularly known as “Brother Lawrence.” He devoted his life to the Practice of the Presence of God (1692). Although he worked as a kitchen helper in the monastery, he did not allow his menial labour to prevent him from cultivating a continuing sense of God’s presence. On the contrary, he wrote that if we faithfully paid attention to the presence of God, it will lead to “the simple grace, [which is] the long sight of God everywhere present.” It is an attentiveness to God which he described as “the most holy, the most solid, the easiest, [and] the most efficacious manner of prayer” (The Practice of the Presence of God, 110). Brother Lawrence’s practice of the presence of God is his way of prayer. It reminds us of the early Church Father, Origen, who said that “the entire life of the saint taken as a whole is a single great prayer”; for it unites “prayer with deeds required and right deeds with prayer” (Origen, On Prayer, 104-5). While creation points us to God, the knowledge of God is, however, most fully revealed in Jesus Christ in whom all God’s fullness dwells in bodily form. We are redeemed and reconciled to God through Jesus’ birth, life, death and resurrection. Not only so, Jesus will one day return to judge the living and the dead as attested to at his ascension. This is the hope that is held out to us in the gospel (Col 1:15-23). Consequently, the practice of Christian spirituality is as fundamentally rooted in Jesus Christ as it is focused on God. It is through Christ the Son that we come to know the God the Father. Hence, another major theme in Christian spirituality is the imitation of Christ; echoing Paul’s words: “Be imitators of me, as I am of Christ” (1 Cor 11:1). A prominent advocate of this in the Middle Ages is Thomas á Kempis, best known for his treatise, The Imitation of Christ (c.1441). He urged that “whoever wishes to understand fully the words of Christ must try to pattern his whole life on that of Christ” (I, 1). While á Kempis wielded significant influence in medieval spirituality, it was Ignatius of Loyola who systematized it into a set of practices for the cultivation of the Christian life. The Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius are based on the life, death and resurrection of Christ in the gospel accounts, and serve as a set of notes that provide guidance on Christian growth through the stages of purgation, illumination and, ultimately, union with Christ – the traditional Catholic way of interpreting spiritual progress in the Christian life. These exercises, some of which include the “examination of conscience, meditation, contemplation, [and] vocal or mental prayer” are normally done under the watchful care of a spiritual guide (SpEx 1). I will elaborate on them in the third article in this series. While Ignatius adopted the traditional Catholic understanding for the pursuit of the Christian life, John Calvin, arguably the father of Reformed spirituality, rested his pursuit on the themes of mystical union with Christ and communion with God as elaborated in The Institutes of the Christian Religion (1559). Calvin’s spirituality is based on his understanding of the twofold grace of justification and sanctification. They reflect his understanding of God’s redemptive work in Christ and the progress of our life in God through the Holy Spirit. Resting upon the firm assurance of being united with Christ by grace through faith, Calvin charts a life-long pursuit of deepening communion with God through the habits of repentance and prayerful contemplation. They express a persevering faith in the worship of God and service to humankind. On our union with Christ, Calvin asserts: “He must … become ours, and dwell within us. … as I have observed, whatever He possesses is nothing to us, till we are united to Him” (Inst. 1.3.1). “ A deepening communion with God, however, cannot be pursued by mere human effort. It comes through the grace of Christ and the help of the Holy Spirit ” A deepening communion with God, however, cannot be pursued by mere human effort. It comes through the grace of Christ and the help of the Holy Spirit. Calvin calls this “the secret energy of the Spirit” who helps us to know Christ more and more (Inst. 1.3.1). The Holy Spirit is, therefore, our primary enabler in the pursuit of intimacy with God. John Wesley testifies to this truth when he wrote that the Holy Spirit guards against the degenerating of our Christian practice into “mere formality” and “works upon the soul by His immediate influence” to help us to live as the children of God (Works of John Wesley, V:123-134). This assurance helps us to “keep in step with the Spirit” (Gal 5:25). Hence, we grow in deepening communion with God in Christ through a Spirit-enabled faith. Rather briefly, we observe that the practice of the Christian life follows a primary focus on the Triune God along themes that engages with creation, work, prayer, and other spiritual exercises. There are also communal and missional dimensions which, to my regret, I am not able to elaborate in this brief article. Nevertheless, I hope that this article gives you the sense that our Triune God is using all means of grace to draw you into a richer participation of the life in Him. This is a reality that is attested to in Christian antiquity – and very much available to us today. Rev Dr Jimmy Tan Lecturer in Pastoral and Practical Theology 5 Theological Education for Christian Service and Ministry Jasper Ngoh is a 2nd year MDiv student T TC students come from every walk of life. Ranging from the young fresh-faced graduate to the 60 year old retiree, all like-minded in responding to God’s call. Student life in TTC is an incredible formative journey that trains them to integrate this theological education with practical ministry in the world. Orientation week. “It was a joy to watch seniors work tirelessly at settling their school mates into the TTC community.” Student Council president Mak Sue Ann reflects, “A spirit of oneness permeated the grounds of TTC; this helped to build strong camaraderie between new and old students alike. What better way to kick start a new academic year!” The TTC Orientation and Retreat is an annual event held at the start of each new academic year serving to help both staff and student ready their hearts and minds for the year ahead. Jonathan Huang, chairperson of the Orientation Committee shares his views on the programme; “We invited various seniors from diverse backgrounds to share about their lives in TTC and ended the Orientation with a commemorative service. Students were invited to pen down their convictions on their calling to TTC, which will be kept until their graduation. All these things emphasised the need to walk together as a Christian community. Hailing from 11 different countries around the region, 67 new first-year students arrived at the college on Monday, 6 July 2015, with little clue what lay in wait for them during 6 7 Trinity Lectures 2015 Intimacy with Death O eath is a topic that is often avoided in public and private discourse, not just in Asia but also in the West. n 23 June 2015, after many years of creative gestation and untold hours of careful crafting, scoring, editing and email exchanging, Let the Asian Church Rejoice!, a new Asian hymnal was born! In his provocative study entitled, Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age (1991), the famous sociologist Anthony Giddens argues that one of the most distinguishing features of modernity is the sequestration of death. Professor Abraham is Albert Cook Outler Professor of Wesley Studies at Perkins School of Theology, Southern Methodist University. He is author of numerous books on a wide range of topics, including the award-winning Canon and Criterion in Christian Theology (1999). A New Asian Hymnal for the Church Mark Chan is Director of CSCA and teaches Homiletics D In the Trinity Lectures 2015, Professor William Abraham grabs the bull by its horns and reflects on some of the most difficult theological and pastoral issues surrounding what the Apostle Paul calls ‘our last enemy’ (1 Cor 15:26). Voices in Praise Beginning with an account of the death of his own son, Timothy, Professor Abraham explores the anguish that death brings that leaves those who mourn with the inability to articulate their grief and make sense of their situation. The ‘apophatic’ character of death, as he calls it, requires that we recognize that all attempts to explain (or explain away) the mystery that is death are ultimately inadequate. Yet, the Christian tradition offers invaluable resources that help us to make some sense of human death, however tragic and untimely, in light of the overarching plan of God. Professor Abraham emphatically insists that insights into the mystery of death and eternal life can only be gleaned from God’s revelation in Scripture, and not from philosophical speculation. Jointly published by the Methodist School of Music (Singapore) and Trinity Theological College’s Centre for the Study of Christianity in Asia (CSCA), this is a multilingual pan-Asian hymnal – with original languages and English, Chinese or Indonesian translations. The 135 hymns, written in 23 languages or dialects from 18 countries, are original compositions by Asian Christian musicians that reflect the varied melodic styles of Asia. The hymnal testifies to the rich variety of musical and poetic gifts (traditional and contemporary) that Asian Christians are blessed with. The collection has its roots in a research and publication project of CSCA on popular spiritual movements in Asia under the leadership of its then director, Canon Dr Michael Poon. An editorial committee comprising musicians and theologians was formed to oversee the project. Eminent Asian Christian ethnomusicologist Professor I-to Loh provided editorial leadership alongside Mary Gan and Judith Mosomos from the MSM. Successive gatherings of the Asian Composers’ Forum (ACF) served as the platform for the emergence and gathering of these songs of praise. This collection of hymns and liturgical settings are, in the words of the editorial committee, offerings that together form “a firstfruit of the Spirit, with hope-filled expectation that their theological depth, poetic beauty and artistic expression will mature in the years to come.” It is the committee’s hope that this collection will “inspire more seminarians and the younger generation to consider seriously how they can use God’s special gifts to them to write, compose and sing new songs to the Lord.” Besides the usual indexes, the hymnal includes a Leader’s Guide and comes with a demonstration CD. The Asian Hymnal represents Asia’s small contribution to the universal hymnody by widening the universal church’s repertoire to include Asia’s rich and unique musical heritage. The relationship between Christian hope and certainty is then explored. Professor Abraham argues that the dynamics of hope and certainty can only be understood within the context of the believer’s relationship with God, a relationship that is established on faith (trust) made possible by divine grace. In the final lecture, Professor Abraham offers a reflection on Job’s suffering. He examines Job’s existential and intellectual struggles with what appears to be underserved suffering in light of the incomprehensibility of God and his ways and explores the significance of Job’s encounter with God in the closing chapters of the book. Judging from the energetic discussions each night, the issues that Professor Abraham raised and addressed in his lectures struck a chord with the audience. The Trinity Lectures is a biennial event where internationally-renown Christian scholars are invited to address some of the most important issues in Biblical and theological studies. 8 To enquire about purchasing the hymnal, email [email protected] or [email protected], or call (65) 67675258 or (65) 67676677. 9 Trusting and Resting in God the Way Forward College Retreat 2015 his year’s theme for the Retreat was ‘Entering God’s Rest’, with TRAC president Rev Dr Gordon Wong sharing his insights on the subject. He drew from Isa 30:15 for his exhortations that encouraged students to place their trust in God by championing right relationships over outcomes; and to rest in God, rather than giving themselves over to irritability and impatience. Ian Chew, this year’s Retreat committee chairperson shares, “We were overjoyed to see everyone participating enthusiastically in the activities planned for them. Thanks be to God for moving so mightily in our midst to refresh and empower us for the new year ahead!” Another highlight of the Retreat was ‘Welcome to the Neighbourhood’, an outdoor bonding activity which also served to orientate new students around the various amenities available to them within a stone’s throw of the College. Congratulations to ... Dr Lee Mee Onn (MTh 1994) on his installation as the Principal of Malaysia Bible Seminary on 26 March, in Selangor, Malaysia. Jasper Ngoh is a 2nd year MDiv student T Punctuations . in . Time Kim Jung Hun, a new post-graduate student from South Korea said, “My heart melted when I saw so many people of different races, speaking different languages, coming together to pray and sing in one Spirit to one God. I know that God will lead me in my life and studies here in TTC.” The retreat ended meaningfully as the community came together to seek and pray for God’s leading and blessings for the new academic year. As the dust settles on the College Retreat, the students hunker down and prepare to hit the books running. Essays beckon, assignments rear their unforgiving heads, stress levels inch ever upwards and we, human as we are, are prone to fall back into our old habits. As busy seminary students, the act of trusting and resting in God is easily forgotten. We invite you to pray for us as we strive to combine academic rigour with a commitment to spiritual formation. Rt Rev Caleb Soon Seow Chong (MDiv 2000) on his election as Moderator of Gereja Presbyterian Malaysia (GPM) at its General Assembly in March. Chennakesavan Saravana Kumar (MDiv 2014) and his wife Sivakumar Suganthi on the birth of their second baby, Jaden on 1 April. The following alumni in the Anglican church on their ordination on Sunday, 17 May, at the St Andrew’s Cathedral. TTC depends fully on the generosity of well wishers in Singapore Your gifts will be used to train men and women for Christian Outreach and Ministry in Singapore and the region We invite you to consider the following ways to contribute to our ministry: To the Diaconate: Rev Chan Wei Han Christopher (BD 2010) Rev Peter Jeremy Ponniah (MTS 2010) By Cheque payable to ‘Trinity Theological College’ Mail to: 490 Upper Bukit Timah Road, Singapore 678093 To the Priesthood: Rev Charles s/o Tewer Sahyam (BD 2011, MTh Year 2) Rev Dino Veerasamy Thangamany (BD 2013) Rev Wong Kok Yean (MDiv 2007) By Bank or ATM transfer to our DBS current account 033–017261–3 Rev Shaun Chong Jiawei (BD 2011) and his wife Rulin on the arrival of their first child, Elijah Chong, on 26 May. Rev Prem Bahadur Tamang (BD 2011) on his ordination to the Diaconate in the Deanery of Nepal by Bishop Rennis Ponniah of the Diocese of Singapore on 3 June at the Nazarene Church, Kathmandu. Esther Kasinathan (MDiv 2004) & her husband Marcel on the arrival of their third child, Elessa Guy Clement on 10 July. Condolences to ... Patsy Lye-Hwa (Mrs To) and the family of the late Rev Albany To Shiu-Kin (BTh 1961) aged 83, who was called home to the Lord on 18 April, in Maryland, USA. Rev Edmund George De Souza (BTh 1982) and his wife Jessie on the demise of his mother, the late Mdm Lim Swee Neo, on 22 April. The family of the late Rev Ezra Loke Cheng Wah (MTh 1980), aged 74, who was called home to the Lord on 11 May, in Petaling Jaya, Selangor, West Malaysia. Bishop Yong Chen Fah, former Warden of St Peter’s Hall, whose beloved wife Mida, passed away on 2 July in Sabah. Rev Dr Kow Shih Ming (MDiv 1992) on the passing away of his father, the late Mr Kow Choon Chuan, aged 86, on 17 July. Bishop Dr & Mrs Wee Boon Hup (MDiv 1984) on the demise of his beloved mother, the late Madam Tan Lee Neo. She went home to be with the Lord on 17 July at the age of 95 years. 10 Thank You for Your Partnership in Theological Education By way of Bequests to TTC. We shall be pleased to discuss this plan with you. You may email the [email protected] or call us at: 67676677 Thank you for blessing Trinity Theological College Evening Classes Course A: Being Faithful In Troubled Times Lesson from 1 & 2 Peter Dates: 16 September - 4 November (8 Wednesday evenings) Time: 7.30pm - 9.30pm Venue: St. Andrew’s Cathedral Course B: Science Triumphant? Exploring Issues of Science and Faith Dates: 17 September - 12 November (8 Thursday evenings, no class on 24 Sep) Time: 7.30pm - 9.30pm Venue: TTC Lecture Room Contact: Esther Lee @ 67613624 or visit our website: www.ttc.edu.sg The Trumpet is published in English and Chinese To view the Chinese edition, please visit our website www.ttc.edu.sg 11 Peace-Building in Church and Society CSCA Workshop on Mediation Leonard Wee teaches New Testament A small group of 30 participants, comprising pastors and active lay leaders, were given a rare treat from 30 April to 2 May 2015, when a team of highly-qualified mediation practitioners conducted a three-day workshop on Christian Mediation, organised by the TTC’s Centre for the Study of Christianity in Asia (CSCA) One key feature of this course is to enable participants to acquire the practical skills of mediating a conflict. It is one thing to understand how to manage a conflict in theory, but quite another thing to acquire the actual skills of working with the parties involved in a mediation session. Participants are also taught the valuable skills of leading the mediation through its various phases, and the process of moving from exploration to solution. According to CSCA Director, Rev Dr Mark Chan, the Christian Mediation Workshop is an extension of the Faith and Society initiative of CSCA. It was prompted by a desire to provide a platform for Christian leaders to be equipped with the necessary skills of mediation and conflict management. He hopes that the workshop will contribute to the fostering of a peace-making and peace-building culture in our churches across denominational lines. In fact, conversations have now begun on what the next step ought to be, though there is as yet no specific plan to schedule the next training. However, judging from the feedback, there is interest to see this training made available to other Christian leaders. Another participant, the General Secretary of the Synod of the Presbyterian Church in Singapore, Rev Tan Cheng Huat commented, “This is a timely workshop as we see the world around us getting more and more into conflict situations. Moreover, we also find more Christians bringing one another to court. The demo and practice sessions in the workshop are most helpful.” Indeed, the workshop ended with three conclusions that were generally agreed by those who attended. First, there is a need for the Christian community to set up a network that would provide help and resources for Christians to resolve any differences, should these arise. Second, this course should be repeated if possible, as it meets an important need in the church today. Third, all participants agree that the workshop is simply top-notch, and kudos must go to all the instructors for being meticulously prepared for each session. TRUMPET EDITORIAL: Ms Nie Yicong, Ms Dawn Lee, Dr Tan Loe Joo, Dr Leow Theng Huat, Ms Eunice Low, Rev Yap Seok Chin (Editor for Chinese), Rev Dr Ngoei Foong Nghian (Editor) 12 TRINITY THEOLOGICAL COLLEGE 490 Upper Bukit Timah Road Singapore 678093 Email: [email protected] Website: www.ttc.edu.sg Tel: (65) 6767 6677 Printed by Print & Print Pte Ltd … a special Jubilee celebration supplement “TRUMPET CELEBRATES SG50” Courtesy of Lee Yi Huei TRUMPET CELEBRATES T rinity Theological College joins all Singaporeans in celebrating Singapore’s fifty years of independence by offering some theological reflections on matters of public interest. Such engagement has August 2015 always been part of Christianity’s self-understanding from its inception. Christians believe that because the whole universe is God’s creation it is inescapably linked to its Creator who holds the key to creation’s ul- timate meaning. Human beings made in God’s image and endowed with a divine vocation have an especially significant role to play in unveiling and advancing God’s ultimate purpose. In this issue of the Trumpet three of our theological educators set out their respective theological perspectives on the man who made Singapore what it is today (Mark Chan); the problem of inequality (Roland Chia); and the precarious nature of religious freedom (Lim Teck Peng). Hopefully, their thoughts will serve as a catalyst for church leaders in Singapore to recognize the critical importance of theological reflection for societal flourishing. 1 Uncommon Man, Common Grace Founding Father Lee Kuan Yew God’s gracious and sovereign will. Through the divine ordering and providential convergence of people, circumstances and events, God sovereignly brought about those conditions conducive for Singapore to flourish. Rev Dr Mark Chan Director of the Centre for the Study of Christianity in Asia (CSCA) G aining independence from Malaya in 1965 was greeted by the budding nation of Singapore more with trepidation than jubilation. A geographical pygmy with no natural resources to call its own, the island state had to fend for itself and somehow forge a new nation in the face of political disappointments and regional uncertainties. Not many thought this tiny state would survive, let alone thrive and prosper. And prosper Singapore did! That it is today a first world country and an economic powerhouse is in more ways than one an aberration of history. There is therefore much for which the people of Singapore can be thankful in this our jubilee year of celebration. As we savour the achievements of the past fifty years, we owe the pioneer generation and all who came in their wake our gratitude for their sacrifices. At the same time, we give thanks to Almighty God, without whose favour and blessings we would not be where we are today. Scripture is clear: nations rise and fall at the behest of 2 Thanking God for his providential blessings does not take away from or diminish in any way the contributions of the countless men and women who gave their lives to build Singapore; especially the part played by our first generation of leaders led by founding Prime Minister, the late Mr Lee Kuan Yew. The passing of Mr Lee on 23 March 2015 was greeted by a weeklong nation-wide outpouring of grief that was at once heartfelt and spontaneous. And rightly so too, for whatever one may make of the man it is incontestable that he played a pivotal role in putting Singapore on the world map. He expended his life to make a secure, peaceful and prosperous home for Singaporeans where none existed. Together with his equally stout-hearted comrades, he worked tirelessly and tenaciously to transform a once sleepy backwater port into a thriving modern metropolis. It is the measure of the man’s impact that thousands of Singaporeans from all walks of life braved the elements and lined the streets to pay their last respect to their first leader. The expression of heartfelt gratitude at the funeral of Mr Lee is a good change from the usual litany of complaints from the lips of Singaporeans. To pause, reflect, and give thanks for all that we now enjoy is indeed tonic to the soul of Singapore. Giving thanks is after all a Christian thing to do, for we are enjoined in Scripture to give thanks to God always and in all circumstances. All things that make life possible, meaningful and enjoyable come to us from the gracious hands of God: life, health, family, community, nation, earth, beauty, culture, work, security, peace, and yes, even a tough-minded and no-nonsense politician like Lee Kuan Yew. Through the life work of Mr Lee, the blessings of God’s providential care were mediated and continue to be mediated to the people of Singapore and beyond. For this reason we thank God for him. To be sure, the man had his faults (who doesn’t?) as his political opponents and critics are wont to point out and even his admirers acknowledge. Yet when one takes into account the overall arc of his life, it is incontrovertible that he did well. To think otherwise would be wilfully jaundiced and churlish. From a Christian standpoint, God is the ultimate giver of all that makes for human flourishing. He inspires the good that humans do, and works in and through people everywhere to accomplish his good purposes in history, whether they acknowledge him or not. By his own admission, Mr Lee was an agnostic when it comes to religion. Yet regardless of his own faith or the lack of it (in this regard we are all agnostics), inasmuch as the man gave his life to improve the lot of his fellow Singaporeans, inspire hope, instil courage, bring order out of chaos, combat corruption, restrain evildoers, uphold the rule of law, educate the masses, provide employment, foster social cohesion and ensure honesty in government, he did the things that resonate with all that God desires for human society. “ God is the ultimate giver of all that makes for human flourishing. He inspires the good that humans do, and works in and through people everywhere to accomplish his good purposes In the language of Christian theology, what Mr Lee did was an expression of the common grace that God extends to all people indiscriminately. Theologians distinguish between God’s special grace that reaches out to save all who believe in Jesus Christ, and God’s common grace that describes his sovereign care for all human beings, regardless of their spiritual or moral states. Without diminishing in any way the need for faith and spiritual relationship with God, it is important to note that God is not just Redeemer but also Lord of creation. The God of the Bible is not a parochial deity who reserves his blessings only for Christians; he cares for everyone in the world and exercises control over everything that happens in the world. While God lavishes on Christians “every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places” (Eph 1:3), it does not mean that he has no concern for unbelievers. Neither does it mean that God cannot work through those who are ostensibly outside the fold of faith. Even a pagan ruler like Cyrus the Persian king is described in Scripture as God’s “shepherd” (Isa 44:28) and, incredibly, as God’s “anointed” (Isa 45:1). God’s sovereign rule over the world means that all earthly authorities function under his superintending control. “ common grace ... entails positive divine enablement, such that even unbelievers are motivated to practise virtues and pursue worthy tasks that benefit the human race Scripture abounds with examples of God’s providential goodness: “The Lord is good to all, and his mercy is over all that he has made” (Ps 145:9). He makes the “sun rise on the evil and on the good, and sends rain on the just and on the unjust” (Matt 5:45; cf. Acts 14:17). The birds frolic and sing for believers and unbelievers alike; and the beauty of a sunset is for all to savour, whether one is a dedicated sinner or a devout saint. In addition to making life both possible and enjoyable in the world, common grace also entails positive divine enablement, such that even unbelievers are motivated to practise virtues and pursue worthy tasks that benefit the human race. So whether it is the cultivation of the arts and sciences, or making improvement to the physical and social conditions of society, or setting up institutions that protect the vulnerable and promote the rights of people, God is the ultimate source of all that is lifeaffirming and all that contributes to human well-being. “Every good and perfect gift,” the writer of the letter of James tells us, “comes down from above… from [God] the father of lights” (Jas 1:17). And sometimes, hard as it is to fathom, God’s good gifts come through ungodly rulers whose political calculations and machinations are providentially taken up by God to realise his purposes (Rom 13:1-7; 1 Pet 2:14). One manifestation of common grace is the restraint that God erects against the full flowering of sinfulness in the world. Given the wicked propensity of the human heart, life in society would be unimaginably oppressive and unbearable if not for the restraining work of God’s Spirit. Whether negatively in terms of 3 thwarting evil or positively in terms of the good works that people do, God guides and directs the world to realise his intentions in history. God’s common grace is operative in the world through people who give their lives to serve others – like the late Mr Lee, who had bequeathed to us a clean, green, safe and wellordered nation, a place where all its inhabitants are afforded opportunities to excel regardless of race, language or religion. Historians will in years to come provide a more nuanced assessment of his legacy; and there will no doubt be those who would question the probity of some of his leadership decisions. Nevertheless, insofar as Mr Lee helped put in place sturdy legal, social and economic platforms for Singaporeans to stand firm and stand tall on, he may be said to have served the beneficent purposes of God. Lee Kuan Yew was an extraordinarily gifted leader – intelligent, insightful, intense, indefatigable, intimidating and inspirational. As Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said in announcing his death to the nation, “Singapore will never see another man like him.” Through the sheer force of conviction and commitment, and with “iron in the soul,” Mr Lee, together with his comrades, overcame great odds to transform Singapore into a nation that its people can be proud of. We who make Singapore home are all beneficiaries of God’s common grace through the life of this most uncommon man. Mr Lee will be sorely missed at this year’s jubilee celebrations. As we count our many blessings as a nation this anniversary, may we do so with gratitude to God for the life of Lee Kuan Yew! n not all forms of inequality are unnatural or unjust. While all human beings created in the image and likeness of God are equally loved and valued by their Creator, each is given unique talents and abilities. And in this life, these talents and abilities carry unequal rewards, one of which is income. “ … helping the poor and addressing the discrimination and stratification that inequality can engender is the responsibility of every member of society Income inequality is therefore a fact of economic life. It should be pointed out that far from being unjust, some income inequality is actually the sign of fair distribution of income based on factors such as abilities, experience, productivity and work ethic. Thus, a society that ignores these factors and pays everyone equally may be said to be unjust. This means that income inequality per se is not the problem. Neither can it be regarded as an indication of the economic health of a country. The Gini co-efficient, which is often used to measure income inequality, does not present a reliable picture of the economic flourishing of a country. For instance, it tells us nothing about its living standards. Mind the Gap ments in their lives and are much better off than people in most other countries. But at the lower end, incomes have risen slowly, especially in real terms.” Dr Roland Chia Chew Hock Hin Professor of Christian Doctrine I n his speech during the 2011 Presidential Address Debate, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong alluded to the rising income inequality in Singapore when he said: “the most successful Singaporeans will continue to do very well. The average Singaporeans will be able to make improve4 Scholars have been tracking the rising income inequality in Singapore for more than ten years, taking their cue from the Gini co-efficient and other income inequality metrics like the Palma or Hoover indices. Although this trend is a matter of concern for some, what is perhaps even more worrying is that it is accompanied by wage stagnations and slowing social mobility. This phenomenon is, of course, not unique to Singapore. The United States and many countries in the European Union are experiencing rise in inequality, as are developed Asian countries like Japan and South Korea. But as some scholars have pointed out, “What makes Singapore’s inequality picture stand out is the speed at which it has increased as well as the level which it has increased to.” In responding to this issue, it is crucial to see that Take, for example, Bangladesh and the Netherlands, two very different countries that had the same Gini index of 0.31 in 2010. While these two countries had the same level of income inequality, their per capita incomes were vastly different: US$1,693 in Bangladesh and US$42,183 in the Netherlands. If inequality is not the problem, what is? The simple answer is poverty. Armatya Sen defines poverty as a condition of having less than what is required to function. Notice that poverty is not defined as a condition of having less than others. Sen’s definition underscores the important distinction between income inequality and poverty: there can be income inequality without poverty. Is there poverty in Singapore? Singapore does not have an official poverty line. But in a 2011 study, which used household income of S$1,250 to S$1,500 per month as the poverty line, it was estimated that 10 to 12 per cent or 110,000 to 140,000 Singapore resident households fall below the mark. A 2008 study, which set the poverty line at S$1,500 per month, arrived at the same ballpark figure of 130,000 to 150,000 Singapore resident households. Although income inequality alone is not an issue, extreme inequality mixed with poverty makes for a lethal cocktail for any country. This is precisely the challenge that Singapore is currently facing. As the report on domestic poverty published by The Lien Centre for Social Innovation and SMU School of Social Sciences states: “Rising inequality does not necessarily denote the existence of poverty. However, rising inequality combined with evidence of poverty indicates that the poor are left behind, and this appears to be what is happening in Singapore.” In addition, extreme inequality plus poverty can arouse an amorphous but real sense of antipathy towards prevailing economic and political policies, which in turn can threaten social stability. “ SG50 should not only be an occasion for celebrating past and present successes. It should also be an occasion for Singaporeans from all walks of life to renew their resolve to stand in solidarity and to work together for the common good and build a better future for all Singapore must therefore focus on helping the poor. The Bible has much to say about God’s pref- erential option for the poor. The people of God are enjoined to take care of the poor, the vulnerable and the unprotected (Deut 16:11-12; Exod 22:21-27, Isa 1:16-17). There is a profound sense in which the justice of a society is tested by the way it treats the disadvantaged. Justice to the poor is not about eradicating income inequality (even if that were possible) but about ensuring that they are not forgotten, that their conditions are improved. The Singapore Government has always understood this. Its fiscal policies are designed in such a way that lower income citizens receive most of the benefits while higher income earners pay most of the tax revenues. But helping the poor does not only have to do 5 with the distribution of resources. The question that must also be asked is: Do the people at the bottom of the economic ladder have opportunities to move up that ladder? Or are they hopelessly trapped, no matter what they do? The Government is well aware of the importance of social mobility. It has put numerous measures in place, such as education, home ownership and skills upgrading, to ensure that mobility is not thwarted. As a result, in Singapore 14 per cent of young adults from families in the poorest one-fifth of income earners have moved into the top one-fifth of income earners compared to 7.5 per cent in the US and 9 per cent in the UK. The Government understands that meritocracy requires a society in which fair equality of opportunity is satisfied. However, due to a confluence of factors sustaining such fluidity in the future would be more and more challenging. Singapore is well placed to meet these challenges. Thanks to the leadership of its late founding Prime Minister, Lee Kuan Yew and his exceptional colleagues, Singapore has established a social compact that has served the country well. And although this compact needs to be tweaked and enhanced, the principles upon which it was established – individual responsibility, self-reliance, economic growth, jobs for all and a security system based on savings and home ownership – continue to be sound. But helping the poor and addressing the discrimination and stratification that inequality can engender is the responsibility of every member of society. As Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam has put it, “we must preserve a sense of compact among Singaporeans, a sense of obligation on the part of those who are doing well to help others in their own society. We cannot build an inclusive society without the spirit of inclusiveness. It is not just a matter of getting the right policies.” SG50 should not only be an occasion for celebrating past and present successes. It should also be an occasion for Singaporeans from all walks of life to renew their resolve to stand in solidarity and to work together for the common good and build a better future for all. n Celebrate a Fragile Freedom T here are many reasons why Singaporeans should celebrate the 50th birthday of their nation with a strong sense of accomplishment and gratitude. Some of these reasons are pretty obvious, some less so. Among the less obvious reasons, I would include the freedom of religion our secular state guarantees to its citizens. Rev Dr Lim Teck Peng Associate Dean, Lecturer in Christian Education 6 Article 15(1) of the Constitution of the Republic of Singapore states: “Every person has the right to profess and practise his religion and to propagate it.” To many Singaporean Christians, such freedom is a given. Many a time, our liberty to worship the triune God publicly is taken for granted rather than seeing it as something we need to fight for or worry about. Our being oblivious to religious freedom is itself an achievement and progress. It reflects how such liberty has become a part of our lives that no conscious effort is needed to exercise it. However, in celebrating Singapore’s Golden Jubilee, this freedom rightfully occupies a special place among the reasons why Christians should be grateful to God for this nation. In fact, we should not just offer prayers of thanksgiving because of the liberty we enjoy; we should also give thanks on behalf of the nation because the provision of such freedom is not only a blessing to the church but to our nation as well. At the 66th Anniversary of Inter-Religious Organisation held on 12 May 2015, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong mentioned: “Singaporeans are becoming more religious, and taking their faiths more seriously. This is in itself positive, because religious faiths are strong anchors for good morals and caring communities.” In 1972, when commenting on the educational and social services provided by the Methodist Church in Singapore and Malaysia, the founder and chief architect of Singapore’s economy Dr Goh Keng Swee had the following words to say: “By any standard, these add up to very substantial activities, contributing in no small measure to the progress of the two countries”. These are encouraging words. They remind us how religion in general and Christianity in particular have over the years made significant impact on society. Such social contributions, however, would not have been possible if the religious population, which according to the 2010 population census occupied 83% of the resident population, had not been given the freedom to demonstrate their faiths in a socially significant way. For the social service and good works that Christians are permitted to do, and for the freedom therein, it is only right and fitting that we offer unto God our prayer of thanksgiving. We reckon that this freedom and its fruit are truly gifts from God to the church and to the nation. It cannot be overemphasised how precious this gift is to both the church and the nation. As we celebrate the precious gift of religious liberty and its fruits, our celebratory mood, however, should not blind us to the fact that religion has become such a sensitive if not problematic subject nowadays; and that from time to time both the church and society have to deal with the problems of prejudice and religious excesses. These challenges remind us of how fragile our freedom is. Prejudice can lead to suppression of religious expressions and, in its worst form, persecution as witnessed in some parts of the world. This is of course not new to the church. The Apostle Paul told the Corinthian church: “we preach Christ crucified: a stumbling block to Jews and foolishness to Gentiles” (1 Cor 1: 23). The Apostle Peter urged his readers who were living in a hostile environment to follow Jesus’ footstep: “When they hurled their insults at him, he did not retaliate; when he suffered, he made no threats. Instead, he entrusted himself to him who judges justly” (1 Pet 2:23). For different reasons, some of which are not without vested interests and an ideologically-driven agenda, Christian faith continues to be seen by some as a stumblingblock to the progress of society. “ we should also give thanks on behalf of the nation because the provision of such freedom is not only a blessing to the church but to our nation as well Faced with overt and subtle prejudice, Christians should exercise their freedom and right in defending their faith and values in a manner that honours the lordship of Jesus Christ. In this respect, the celebration of religious freedom is not a trivial matter; it challenges our social imagination and affects the way we live and relate to one another in a multi-religious society. Of course, there is little we can do about prejudice from outside, especially when it is driven by ideology. On the contrary, the problem of religious excesses can only be adequately addressed from within the church rather than from outside. After making the positive remarks on religious contributions quoted earlier, PM Lee continued by saying that “religious fervour can also lead to separation and mutual exclusion between different groups. People’s social circles tend to shrink down to only their own group, leading to less mixing between different faiths and people may feel less respect and tolerance for other groups and may proselytise more aggressively, offending others”. Is it right that we offer prayers of thanksgiving to God without giving thought to concerns such as these? The answer is clearly ‘no’. In fact, these are not only socially problematic, they also reflect an inadequate or skewed theological understand7 ing of Christian social responsibility and practice such as evangelism. Religious excesses hinder social understanding, deepen suspicion and invite intolerance of religious particularities. However, it is more than a social problem to the church when Christian evangelism is turned into insistent hard-sell that ignores the role of the Holy Spirit in conversion, or into a battle for political influence and power that Jesus himself never sought. Such truncation and deviation reveals the danger of Christian passion without theology. Following Paul, we can say that “their zeal is not based on knowledge” (Rom 10:2). Such religious excesses serve to remind us of the importance of developing an adequate theological understanding as we cultivate passion to witness for Christ. Therefore, our celebration of religious freedom should lead us to a renewed commitment to Christian teaching and learning that seek to develop sound Christian thinking that undergirds our exercise of freedom in word and deed. The problem of proselytization may lead some to confine religious faith to the private realm. Our constitution, however, allows the religious population to share their faiths with others. It uses the term “propagate”, a word that has now acquired a negative connation associated with brainwashing. However, we read from the Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary that “propagate” simply means to “spread (views, knowledge, beliefs, etc.) more widely.” In this descriptive sense, “propaganda” is a neutral term referring to the dissemination of information in order to persuade the recipients to accept certain ideas. “ the celebration of religious freedom is not a trivial matter; it challenges our social imagination and affects the way we live and relate to one another in a multireligious society As we reflect on our communicative liberty, it is worth pointing out that Christians are not the only people who enjoy the liberty to share their faith with others: the Buddhists have hong fa (弘法) which means proclamation of the message of Buddha, and Muslims dawah meaning an invitation to Islam. As part of a multi-religious society, and in view of so much misrepresentation of religion, it is indeed fitting that Christians should support measures that allow religious communities to 8 share their faith with liberty and authenticity. In fact, while any form of coercive proselytisation – religious and secularist alike – should be rejected, accessibility to authentic religious knowledge remains important for the flourishing of any human culture. “ While we give thanks to God for the external environment that allows us to profess, practice and share our faith openly, ultimately, it is the freedom in Christ that enables us to love and serve God and our neighbours under all circumstances In view of the various forms of prejudice and distortion, it is now apparent that churches should support programmes and activities that are not aimed at converting but are nevertheless important in promoting a better public understanding of Christian faith and practices. This is the reason why Trinity Theological College has responded to the invitation from Peking University and Fudan University for exchange programmes and academic collaboration. Although such endeavour is not conversionistic in purpose, we believe it is important and can contribute to a better understanding of Christianity. While the church should move beyond a more than conversionistic view of Christian witness, our society needs to reckon with the myth of western Enlightenment that religious conflicts can be resolved or prevented by silencing the voices of religious communities in the public realm. In this respect, a confessional yet nonconversionistc space of public discourse can in the long run benefit our society as much as the church. While we give thanks to God for the external environment that allows us to profess, practice and share our faith openly, ultimately, it is the freedom in Christ that enables us to love and serve God and our neighbours under all circumstances. The sacrificial love of God on the cross that is freely given to humanity remains the only basis and ultimate guide for Christian liberty. As various forms of prejudice, religious excesses and extremism continue to grab our attention and evoke anxiety and suspicion globally, let us be thankful for the freedom we have and be mindful of its complexity and fragility and the responsibility that religious freedom entails. n
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz