New Lowness Results for ZPP and other Complexity Classes

 ! " #$%Ý
&%
'$ ( )
' *
+,-- ) ./
! !
"# " !
" $ %&!
" %'&!
" %& !
" ( ' %'&!
" ) '
%& !
" * ' %&!
" ) * ( + " )
!""" #
Ý $ % & '
% (' ( ) *&
+,"- ( .
£
! " #$ % & ' ( )
*
+ ( #' ,
- . +/ ! " 0
12 3 ( #' , - & 04 5
+/ " " (1
67 178 ( . 6 (1 ! !
!1
(1 ! *
9 " (1 8
' ( +/ !
* : 0
12 5 ! 0
12 (1
, ! ( & +; ' ( ! !
< #4 +; " = ! ! ( 01/2
3/$
5 (
< ( ! +; > ")
( 6 8 . ?
6 8 ( ! ( >! " ! ) ' !1
:! 3 678 . 7 17 68 . +; > 1
!" )
( ! * @
6& 8 #4 " += 6& 8 68
6& 8 ' & ") ! +A ! " 1
3 :! " ( ( 7 7 17 :! 68 #
7 678 . 7 17 :! 68 2 :!
68 % 1 + @
! +/ 6 8 6& 8 7 )
( 6 8 :! ! ! ! 6 8
5 ! ! ( 6 8 -
8
! " 3 68
68
6
6& 8 (! B
1 /
! ( 2 , ( " " ( !
8 " " , 5 ! ,
6
,
6& 8 ! + C ( )
+
! 7
15 + ) "< , ' ( ( * +D / /
! +/ (1 67 178 ( -!"
Æ ! " 717 ' :! * ( 7 717
6*"
7 178 - 6& 8 +/ ( 7 17 ( +
! ( 7 17 ! ! # ! < 7 17 "1 1
( 7E, 7#E, 7E ,
7#E , ! ( ( ( 7E 7#E
7E 7#E #
/D / ! 67 178 ( ( 7#E , ! ( ( #
7 17
( ( 7E, 2:! 7#E, 7E , !
! ( 7 17 < + 5 " (! ! ! ( 3
5 ! (1:
F 1: ( % 0
= F ! ( 7#E, ! ( ( 5 ! (1 ! ( ( 7E , ! ( & 6 ! * " + ' + 8
#
! ! (1:
! ( 7E, ! ( & 5 " ( ! 2 & . D & ( ! " & & ( !
( 5 ( ( & ' ( ( & & ' ( ( 1
( ! 2 ( ( /
' < ( : 7 9 ( : ; +G ") ! 6 8 2:! ! ' ! 6 8
> ( ( ( (
& A ( ( ( & 6
8 ' ( ( ' (1 !1
(1 5 <
< ( !1
(1 6
< " 1"
(8
A
& . !1
(1 . 6 8 &
!1
(1 5 < ( ( . . ( 1
. 68 3 . . 68 3 H
( ( . 68 3 /H
. 68 3 H
7 ! " : < ( ! 1 :! *"
! +1 I< ( " " ( ( +G 2 ( !
" " ( ! 1"
" 5 " !
" ( " ( " >6 8 ! ( ( 1
! 5 < 3 " > H
7
! ! ! ( (! B
( 1 :! / ! ( 5 :! ! ( & += ( + 5 < 6
@ *
. @ @ ")8 ! ( ( $ (! ! ( ( 7 17 "
! ( 7 :! ! ( 2 5 ! " ? ( # ( * # (! ( <
*
6( += 8 7 D (
) +
( ( 3 3 3 ! " & 3
3 < (! 7
& 3 7 " ! (
"
1 $ " ! ( ( ! 7 17 7 !"
! ( ( 67 178 (
! ( D " ( (
7 17 ( &
5 ! " < " &
! ! + 7 * " 7 ! ( J " ! 7 17 ! ! ' " (! B
H ' !
( "
1 :! / 7 " ! ! ! 7 17 17 " ( ' "
! ( +/ 6
(1 67 178 ! ( 8 (! "
6 8
! " (! "
1
5 < ( 1 6 ++ ( 83 2 & ( ( ( 68 . 68 . 68 5 1 ( 6 8 68 + ! 6 8
( ( ( " 1 1 "
( È
È
!
7
. 7 7
' ( (! ( 7
! (
( (
( ( 17 "
! " ( ( ' + ' " ( 17 ' ! ! ( : " ' ( ( ++ 7
' , < ( ( G ( 9 , 9 . 5 *: (3 # 9 ,
7 9 " " ! " 9 H % ( " )
' 68 ! ( " < ! (
! 9 ,
* ( 9 ,
# " " ! " , .
,
7 " + 9 , 9 .
, ' " * ( G "
( ! 8 " ( , 5 ! ,
6
,
6& 8 ! + C ( +D 7 , ! (1
! ! ( , 7
, " 7 ,
, :! :! ( , 8 ' ,
6
8 ! ' + " C 6
+/ (1 , ! ( ( ( )
( G
! ( "
3 6 8 ( ( ( &
& ! &
& 1
" " B>+ " 5 ( (: 6
+D 8 ! 6 8 " ( ) 6
68 . D 8 ' "
( +D
G
&
D 6 8
#
+ / + $
#
+=
=
68 . D
68 . D
5 < )
+ > " 6 8 ( ( 3 D D ( ) > ( (
3 68 . 6 688
Ë
%
+ &
3 D D 6 688
D 68 . 68
+ 68
+
+
K
68
6 688
3 681
6 688
2 " . 6 8 ( 6 8
( . ( ( . J
! ( ( 3 D D * ( (
3 D D . < 6 8 . 6 8 ! .
% "
( ( ! ( 3 D D ! 68 . 68 68 7
5 ! + 2
+H ( : " ( ) 6 ! ( 8 ' (! : '
+
+ 8
$
¬¬
¬
6 81 3 D #
3 D D D A
6 K
68 . 6 688 .
¬¬
¬ 7 ! ( + 3
+
!D
6+
8
% . 5 (! (: ! ( "
6 +H 8
+ "
D
/
6 +
8
5 ! ( ( ! ( , ( ,
> , ! ! " ' # ( # 68 ( * 68 2 5 < # 6 8 ( ! ! "
! ! ' !
1) ( ! ( > ( ( ! < " ( , "
(! 3
6 "8 < 6 "<8 1) ( " , " (
" ' ) %1: (
, ( D 3 /H
D & 3 H
' ( ! " ( > ( $ : 5 !
$ ) 68 J 2
; ! " ( 6 81 6 K + 81
( 3 D D ¬¬
¬
6 8 .
¬
6 688 . ¬¬ ( " 1 ( ) 7! 68 . + 68 68 .
+;; 68 68 . 68 % 2
D ! :! ( Æ ( 3 D D 668 +
81
6
668 68 K 68+ 81
8 ! "
' ( (! 3
;
. L
668 68 68 6881 L
3 D
D 668 + 81
7 (
L
% ( ! $ ! " ( D + 3
D & 3
+ > ( ! ! Æ 1) 1!8 D 3
D & $
6 !
$ 6 8 .
$ 6 8 . D
7 $ (
! $ : " $ ' " " " 1 5 ! ( ! ( ! 1) M ( ( (
M ! ( % ( " & #
(
( & 3
M 68 . %
% " ( 1 (
5 3 > $ M
3
$ 6 8 . N & ( % < " " % 6 8 % 6 8 3. & 3 $ 6 8 . 7 % 6 8 ( " ( I " < M ( ! % 6 8
(
' : = ( % ( 6
=8 " % 6 8 ' % 3 $ 6 8 . D
5 ! (
( 3
=
3. L
68L
( 668 8L
! % 6 8
M 68 . D ( 3. %
3. & !68 L
J M ! * ! 68
?
! 7 " M "
M ! M ! ( ? < ( ?
( (
% 6 8
(
% 6 8
6G8
% 6 8
2 " + /
% 6 8
+ ( : ?
! 5 . ( +
' . % 6 8 % 6 8
% 6 8
G ( ( > " 7 7! ( M 68 . D ' M 68 . D 7 M 68 . D ( ( ! % 6 8 " % 6 8 %
2
G " % 6 8 ! +=
" " % 6 8 % 6 8 ! = ' ! = " % 6 8
# ( " % 6 8 6;=8 " - " ( # + ! +6+"8 ' + ( '( ( 6 . 8
' ) ( % 6 8 + ( 68$ # % 6 8 !
68 6G8 H68 ( ( -
(! ( ; 68
È
È
' " ! 67 178 " ( ") (! 3 ( 7 5 ! "
1
!
7
7
,
( O @
( +/ ( 7 , - (
(! > 3 D ! D
1) ( ( #' # 7 , 7 " > 1
1) ' " ( ! 7
15 ) " > 3 C" )
( ! ( > '
" ( > ) > 7! ( ( " ! ( "( ! 17 * ! 7 ++ ?
( 7 ! >
< ( > ' 1) ( #'
> * - O 5 ! ! ( :
(1 ( 7E,
7#E, 7E , 7#E , ' ( ( (1
7E 7#E 7E 7#E #
/D 1
/ 5 < ( ! ( ( 7E, ! 7 17 7#E , ! 67 178 2:! ! ! (
7 17 + " "" ! 7#E, 7E , "
>! #
$ /D 7I' ! !1 C & ( ! - ( < & "
B" "
( & & ! 68 . 3 ! 6 8 ( ( "
( <
6( D
)
7E
%&
%&
68
68
'
%
5 A8
*+$,
68 . & 68
68
-
7#E
.
7E
/
7#E
$
7E
7E
7E, 7#E, 7E ,
7E
7#E ,
'
0)12 3 & 8 . # 68
6
#
&
" (
3
! &
% 68 .
6 6
88
"#3
7 1"
( 7E 7#E C
( 1"
( 7E, 1"
( " ' (! " 1"
( 7E, 7#E,
%( ! 7 17 + ! < ( + 3 ? 1 !
" 3 N ' "! ! ( " "
( ( ! ( ! "
N
! "
D ! < "
(3 68 D ( ( ! " D 68 ( ( ! " D 68 2:!
( ( ! " 68 . ( ( ! " 68 . 5 ! " 1) " "1"
6 ; 8 (! 7 17 ( ( ""
" . 6 8 #
67 178 ( ( . 6 8 "" " . 6 8
? ( ( 5 (
< 68 .
68 : ! " < : ( ( : 7E, ' (! * (
<
$
$
% )
-
7E,
7#E ,
+
7 7
67 78
&
3
.
7#E,
/
7E ,
. 6 8
. 6 8
% ( ! ( ! ! ! 7#E,
! ! 7#E, 5 ! ! * ( (
( ' 7 17 67 178 ( ( " * ( 7 6 8 ( 5 :! * +/ ( 7 17 7 3 ( 7
7 17 - ' *
! * " ' ! 7 17 67 178
1/
! + ( 71 7E , - & 6 + ( "" 8 5 ( ! ! ( (3 !1
(1 ( 7E , ! ( & ' < ( ! 1"
(3 (
68 * > ")
! 6 8 ( . 5 ! (1 (1 (
7E, " ! - Æ " ! ( (1
7E,
7E, 7#E, 7E , 7#E ,
%4
&
$ B" ! < (
( 68 5 (1 ( "
1 ' *"
"
7E ,
& 2 !1
(1 7E , 2 (1
( ? & 6 8 ! ' ( ( 68 ( * 68
5 < 68 #
7E , (
/
7E
( & &
# ( & 6& 8
-! " & 6&8 .
P ' N (
(! ! 17 :3
5 < < 17 #'@C7B6 83
& & ' D 3 6& 8 $ '
! 6& 8 "
" & " 6 6& 8
N ! < 6& 8 . 8 7 17
N "< 1"
( " -!" " " ' 17 : ( $
> & &
6& 8 (1 6& 8 ! * # ! 6# 83 ( 6# 8 C D N 7 ( 6& 8 ( #'@C7B6 8 #'@C7B6 8 ( ( : 6# 8 1"
( # 5 6&8 "
$
5 ! < 17 ?C@@?'6 83
?C@@?'6 8 3. ( & &
( 6& 8 6& 8 " N
( 6& 8 N 6& 8 " 7 ( #'@C7B6 8 ?C@@?'6 8 : ( & &
1
" ! (1 ' (! &
" ( &
( ( #'@C7B68 " ?C@@?'68
? ! ( ( 68 (! 5 68 ( ( 6 8 ! 6 8 ! < 17 7! & ( ( ( (! &
3
& 3 #'@C7B6 8
"
?C@@?'6 8
" 6 8
! 6 8 (! 3 6 8 ( *
# 6# 8 ( (
6# 8 N 6
"
H
"
8 ( ( 6# 8 "
(
D N ( ( 6# 8
6 ! # 8 D 6 ! # 8 6 8 ! ! ?
6 8 <
N ' < & ( (
" ( 6 8 6 8
6 8 ( 7 ( & N ( " 6 8 ( " 17 #'@C7B6 8 " ?C@@?'6 8 (
' (
# & Q ? #? 9 " 1 !1
(1 A ! (! &
!
Q ? #? 9
7E , & - . & +
' ( (! ( & Q ? #? 9 ( ! 1 ' ! " & &
5 ! "
7E ,
! ! 6' + G8 ( % 7E ,
B" " ( ( ' + 7 D ( ) +
( ( ! "
3 3 3 3 5 7 ( ( 6D8 ( 6 8 C" ( ! !
1"
( ( D ( C ! D " ( !
( D ( " D ( - (! 7E ,
1/
+ ( " ! ! 6 *8 ( 7#E, + :! ( 7#E, * 3 ( #' 7#E, - ! "
( 7 17 +/ 5 ! 7#E, :
( : < % 0
= ! ( ( # # #?
9 " :
(! ( ( 7#E, ' " %
G 3 ( 9 , 9 @
< ( ( ( 5 " ! 7#E,
2 ( 7#E, 2 ! 7#E, 5 ( 3
!
2 ( 2 . 68 ! ) ( * " ( ( & " ( #68 / '
6 ( +
8 H
& : ( " * 6
'
"( $ ! 8 ( ! * ! ( ! " ( ! *
( ( % (
1"
( ( " ' !
: " !: (
( " * # ( 6# 8 "
# ( !
# H ( " $
! ! $ " ( #
* 6( / 8 " ' (
5 " * (! ! !
4 & 7#E,
%
G
, ' $ : )
( = 7! 2
= (!
5 " ! * # #? 9
" :
H = (! ( ( 7#E, # #? 9
!
- . 7#E,
7 ! " ! ( :
( 7#E,
5
4 7#E,
2 :
( 7#E, 5 ( ( 68 ! 1 ' *"
:
' ! ! (! ": ' +D
1/
>
2
= ' +D ! ! " (!
! ( :
7E,
5
4 & 7E,
%
4 7 7&
4
2 7E, :
(! C ! 6& 8 ? &
! (
' * (
. 68 % < ( 7E, ( 7E
# " ( 3 ! & ( 6 8 . # 68 ( &
6 8 . 6 6
88
" ( #68 ( ?
"
( (
&
6 8 P 6 8 2
D P ' "( ( " ( * 17 5 ! :
( 68 & & < " ( # 68 ? ! " 6
( & !
! "( ( ! 17 ! ! (
8
A
( ! " ( " ( < 7E, ! : 7#E, ' (!
" : 2
= (
?
! ( ! ( " ! 6 H ! " ( 2
= ( !
(8 ' 6( ( !8 / (
$
$ & & & . 68 3 & . & & . 68 3 & $ H
& & . 68 3 & H & & . 68 3 & $ . (
( &
( " ( * R PS 7! ! ( & += ( 68 &
67 ( (8 >
( & "( ( " ( " 17 # #? 9 " :
H = ( ( 7E, ! ( & ' +/ !
! * (! #? 9
!
7E,
. &
)) 0
5 G " ! 79
, ( ( 79 . 5 ! ( G ! ( ( " 79 . 9 ( "
) ! D + > " " 79
17'6+ 8 G , 79 . 9 G - 7'6+ 8 ( " ! " 7'6+ 8 17'6+ 8 ( 7'6+ 8 ( < ! " & . & ! : "
7#E, 6 ' +D8 @
( ' +D ?
+ 9
;
7#E, 9 . 5 ! ( G "
( > ! ) ( ( G 79
7#E,
79 . 9
' " 79 7#E, 9 7#E,
% ' +D ! 9 . 7! 79 . 9 % ( G 6
( 8
(! ( " 9 17'6+ 8 ( ) ! D % G ! " 79 7#E, 9 17'6+ 8 6 ( )
G 8
' ' 79 . 9
' " (! *
79
7#E,
79 . ' " " 7 ( # H 9 , 9 . , ?
! ( G 79 , 79 . 9 ! (!
79
,
79 . , 7 ' +A ! G 79
( 79 . ! : ( 79 . , ( 79 . , ' 7 !
, ! ( ! ' 5 " ( 7#E, ' +A > ! ' +D ! ! ' ,
( G 9
7#E,
9 . 7#E, %
7#E,
&
' " ! 2
+ (!
79
7#E,
=
79 . 7#E, 7 " " (! 7#E, 1
7#E,
"# ! F 1 ( F , ' " ( 9 , 9 . ( ! , , (
9 , 9 . , - , ( , < 7 79 ! : , 79 6 %9 8
'#)*
' < !
" -1
(! === ( ( J! #4
( " J " ! !: !
( !: !
I#'1II "
E " T 04 1 )1 5
$
6 $
#1E
27?#
6 ==A8 +/1+H=
+ E " T 04 @ # C " ( 7 5
6 ==H8 /A1 /
+,
/ 2 %
% " ( < ,
6 ==+8 ;;1 !, 7
5
!
+
H 2 %
2 >! ? 2 71 !1"
" 5 5 6 == 8 1HD
7 % @ ?" @ B
"
U
# 0
? '
C
* Æ ( 7 5
6 ==G8
H+ 1H//
G 2 %
2 >! 7 7
5 % 9' ( 5 5 6 ==/8 /DAV/ ;
A T %
W
)
#(1
/GA1/;;
7
5
6 ==D8
; T 2 %
W
)
T IWX
) T B
W R#
? S '?# '
? # #1E
==
= % # 0
I : !:
5,
6 ==8 +G=V+= +D
7
D @ %: ' 2 2 #
Y
" ")
( !, 7 5
6 =;H8 HG 1H;A
- %
2 >! ' '
( 7
") 5 7! Z: 6 ==;8
;1 +
). !888 5
5
+ TZ ?
2 -
B 5 @ @ / !
5 5 5
#1E
27?#
6 ==;8 AH1 ;/
/ # > 2 >! 7
: T @ " ( )) !888 5
5 5 7! Z: 6 ==G8
+ /1+++
H C B # 5 ( "
7 " )1:! ( 7 5,
6 == 8 G= 1A+=
C B I :
( % - 6
8 $
9
$9:1;/< 8 5 5 5 ==A
G @ )) E 0
5 ( !3 1
" )= !888 5
5 5 6+DD 8 +V +
A @ 0
@ T 2 # ! ( (
)- 5, $
5
? 6 =;D8 /D+1/D=
; 0 0 J #4 C 1) ! 7
7 5
6 =;8 H 1 = T 04 C ( ! ); $
5
? # 6 ==8 +HG1+G !,
5 +D T 04 J #4 - ( 7 R"
2
?S I 0 0 0! 6 ==A8 /=1 G
+
T 04
J #4 T 'W
R' B
3 #
?S %:4
% ==/
++ T 04 @ # "
1
" !1
,
#1E
27?#
5
%,5&
6 ==;8 H=/1D+
+/ T 04 C 5
7! * ( 7 " !, 7 5
6 ===8 / V/+H
+,
+
+H T - 2) 5 T # ? ) " $
5
6 ==/8 =1 +D
+ 7 7
5 -
" 7
6 ==H8 H=1 GA
5
+G ? R?
?S 15 ==H
+A #
@
") 1 " 1 5
6 =;=8 HH1H=
+,
+; J #4 ! ! 7
6 =;/8 H1+;
7
+= J #4 !
6 =;=8 ;H1 DD
/D #
( ( (
6 ==H8 /A1/; +,
++
! 5
7
5
7
5