Philosophy 3520/001: Bioethics 10:45

!"#$%&%'"()*+,-.--/0)
1#%23"#4&)
/-05+6/,0-+)789:1)/-/)
!"#$%&'$(%)*+",-*./&$,"#012*.34*
+##('1-$5*.%(65##(%2*.31/(#(73,*
7/&$,"#018731/(#(73,9&$-395:&*
;661'5)*<=>*?@!AB2*=>C*D9*?5"$%-/*?-E7&#*4%9*
;661'5*F)*GH>ICG>IJ<=<*
;A)*K,*-77(1"$E5"$*
*
7%;<&2)=2&4<#'3#%>)*
*
@31#*'(&%#5*1#*-"*1"$%(:&'$1("*$(*5$31'-/*1##&5#*1"*E5:1'1"5*-":*7&K/1'*35-/$39**L5-:1"M#*-":*/5'$&%5#*
N1//*1"$%(:&'5*#$&:5"$#*$(*E-",*'/-##1'*-%$1'/5#2*/5M-/*'-#5#2*-":*'("'57$#*$3-$*#5%O5*-#*$35*6(&":-$1("*
(6*$35*615/:9**@35*'(&%#5*N1//*K5M1"*N1$3*-"*(O5%O15N*(6*$35*615/:*-":*$35(%5$1'-/*-77%(-'35#*$(*
K1(5$31'#9**P5Q$*N5*$&%"*$(*7-%$1'&/-%*$(71'#2*#$-%$1"M*N1$3*$35*5$31'#*(6*%5#5-%'3*("*3&E-"*#&KR5'$#2*
'("61:5"$1-/1$,2*%1#0*'(EE&"1'-$1("2*-":*1"6(%E5:*'("#5"$2*-":*E(O1"M*("*$(*M5"5$1'#2*-##1#$5:*
%57%(:&'$1O5*$5'3"(/(M15#2*#$5E*'5//*%5#5-%'32*5$31'-/*1##&5#*-$*$35*5":*(6*/1652*-":*61"-//,2*R&#$1'5*-":*
35-/$3*'-%59**S-",*(6*$35*$(71'#*N5*N1//*:1#'&##*-%5*$(%"*6%(E*$35*35-:/1"5#9**@31#*'(&%#5*N1//*E-05*1$*
7(##1K/5*6(%*#$&:5"$#*$(*:5O5/(7*-*'%1$1'-/*&":5%#$-":1"M*(6*$35*05,*1##&5#*("*E(#$*(6*$35*E-R(%*$(71'#*
N1$31"*K1(5$31'#9***
*
?@A$;A3#%>)B23"%C&)A>C)7<#32<#A)
*
>HT)*+$$5":-"'5*-":*.-%$1'17-$1(")*D$&:5"$#*N1//*K5*5Q75'$5:*$(*:(*$35*%5-:1"M*-":*-$$5":*'/-##9**!*
N1//*D#@2)E;#FF2&)A3)<A>C%G*U%(&M3/,2*5O5%,*$N(I$3%55*N550#V*$(*0557*-$$5":-"'52*-#*N5//*-#*"($5*
N3(*-$$5":#*-":*#75-0#*1"*'/-##9**!6*,(&WO5*E1##5:*CHT*(6*$35*X&1YY5#2*,(&*E-,*%5'51O5*-$*E(#$*CZ>H*
7(1"$#*6(%*-$$5":-"'5*-":*7-%$1'17-$1("9**!6*,(&*-$$5":*'/-##2*-":*$-05*5O5%,*X&1Y2*K&$*"5O5%*E-05*
'("$%1K&$1("#*$(*:1#'&##1("2*,(&*'-"*%5'51O5*-$*E(#$*CZ>H*7(1"$#9**.-%$1'17-$1("*1"*731/(#(73,*1#*05,[*
X&-/1$,*N1//*'(&"$*$(N-%:*,(&%*7-%$1'17-$1("*M%-:52*-#*N5//*-#*X&-"$1$,*(6*'(EE5"$#*U#(*7/5-#5*'(E5*
$(*'/-##*3-O1"M*:("5*$35*%5-:1"M*-":*7%57-%5:*$(*:1#'&##*1$V9***
*
>HT)*L5M&/-%*-##5##E5"$*(6*%5-:1"M*0"(N/5:M5)*K-#5:*("*M%-:5#*("*X&1YY5#*U#55*-K(O5V*
*
>CT)*\1%#$*E1:I$5%E*$-05*3(E5*5Q-E*:&5*("*$&%"1$1"9'(E*\5K9*G*
*
]HT)*D5'(":*E1:I$5%E*5Q-E2*:&5*("*$&%"1$1"9'(E*S-%9*>H*
*
]CT)*61"-/*1"*'/-##*'(E7%535"#1O5*5Q-E*\%19*+7%1/*=^2*>H)]HI>=)]H*
*
S1:I$5%E*5Q-E1"-$1("#*N1//*K5*3-":5:*(&$*-*N550*K56(%5*$35*:&5*:-$59**P(*/-$5*5Q-E#*N1//*K5*
-''57$5:[*#(2*7/5-#5*E-05*#&%5*$(*#1M"*("*6(%*$&%"1$1"9'(E*-":*6-E1/1-%1Y5*,(&%#5/6*N1$3*$35*
7%('5:&%5#*6(%*#&KE1$$1"M*-##1M"E5"$#*K56(%5*>=-E*\5K9*G9**./-M1-%1#E*("*-"*5Q-E*N1//*
-&$(E-$1'-//,*%5#&/$*1"*-*6-1/1"M*M%-:5*U7/5-#5*#55*/-#$*7-M5*(6*$35*#,//-K&#*6(%*'1$-$1("*M&1:5/1"5#V9**
S1:I$5%E*5Q-E#*N1//*("/,*'(O5%*$(71'#*:1#'&##5:*&7*$(*$3-$*7(1"$*1"*$35*#5E5#$5%2*-":*N1//*'("#1#$*1"*
K($3*#3(%$*-"#N5%*-":*5##-,*X&5#$1("#9**./5-#5*5Q75'$*$(*K5*$5#$5:*("*K($3*,(&%*%5-:1"M*0"(N/5:M5*
-":*'%1$1'-/*-"-/,#1#*(6*$35*%5-:1"M#9**@35*61"-/*5Q-E*N1//*K5*1"*'/-##*-":*'("#1#$*(6*K($3*E&/$17/5*
'3(1'5*X&5#$1("#2*-":*-*'3(1'5*(6*$N(*(&$*(6*61O5*5##-,*X&5#$1("#2*'(E7-%1"M*-":*'("$%-#$1"M*
75%#75'$1O5#*7%5#5"$5:*1"*$35*%5-:1"M#9**./5-#5*K%1"M*-*K/&5*K((0*-":*:-%0*/5-:*75"'1/*(%*75"*$(*'/-##9*
*
H2AC#>D&0)
*
+//*%5-:1"M#*-%5*6%(E*@(E*_9*B5-'3-E72*_5L(,*`-/$5%#2*a566*b-3"*-":*+""-*S-#$%(1-""1*UB`bSV**
!"#$%&'"()(*+,--.%-+/#+0/"%$1/2-2*J$3*c:1$1("2*5Q'57$*$35*-%$1'/5#*E-%05:*N1$3*-*d9*@35#5*N1//*K5*
-O-1/-K/5*$3%(&M3*$35*'(&%#5N(%0*N5K#1$5*("*`5K?@2*&"/5##*"($5:*($35%N1#59**
1
*
8;<>#3#>I4%G0))7%;<&2)9=0)]e^]C>H))!A&&J%<C0)):2A$3"I4A<2)
)
9G'%<3A>3)=A32&0)
D7%1"M*K%5-0)**S("9ID-$2*S-%'3*=>I=e*
+7%1/*=G)**L5-:1"M*4-,*
\1"-/*cQ-E)*\%1:-,2*+7%1/*=^2*=H>>**>H)]H*-E*f*>=)]H*7E*
*
7%;<&2)K4"2C;$2*
@&5#**a-"9*>>**!"$%(**$(*$35*'(&%#5**
\!LD@*+DD!gPScP@)*_;g*!P*@;*@hLP!@!P9?;Si*
*
@3&%#:-,**a-"9*>]*II9>3<%)3%)3"2)L#2$C)%L)M#%23"#4&*
L5-:1"M#)*B5-&'3-E72*779*>I>=[*L-'35/#2*j@35*?3-//5"M5*(6*?&/$&%-/*L5/-$1O1#Ekd*
*
@&5#la-"9*>G*?3"#4A$)8"2%<#2&*
L5-:1"M#)*B5-&'3-E72*779*>=I]]**
L5'(EE5":5:)*D-":5/2*3.-$/2%4+51)$6-+$1%+7/81$+91/#8+$"+:"m**?3-7$5%#*>I=*
*
!A3#2>3&)A>C)!"(&#4#A>&)
*
@3&%#II**a-"9*=H*7%>L#C2>3#A$#3(*
L5-:1"M#)*D15M/5%2*j?("61:5"$1-/1$,*1"*S5:1'1"5l-*:5'%571:*'("'57$k[*?-/16(%"1-*D&7%5E5*?(&%$2*
@-%-#(66*O9*L5M5"$#*(6*$35*h"1O5%#1$,*(6*?-/16(%"1-[*`1"#$("2*j+!4D2*?("61:5"$1-/1$,2*-":*$35*L1M3$*$(*
b"(Nk*
L5'(EE5":5:)*D-":5/2*3.-$/2%2*?3-7$5%#*]I<*
*
@&5#*a-"9*=CII*8<;3")32$$#>D*
L5-:1"M#)*@3(E-#E-2*j@5//1"M*$35*@%&$3*$(*.-$15"$#)*+*?/1"1'-/*c$31'#*cQ7/(%-$1("k)*`&2*5$*-/2*j@(*@5//*
$35*@%&$3*$(*.-$15"$#)*c$31'-/*-":*.%-'$1'-/*!##&5#*1"*41#'/(#1"M*S5:1'-/*S1#$-05#*$(*.-$15"$#k*
L5'(EE5":5:)*D-":5/2*3.-$/2%2*?3-7$5%*C*
*
@3&%#*a-"9*=Jl*H#&N)7%GG;>#4A3#%>)A>C)B2C#4A$)K4<22>#>D)
n&-"#$%&E*-":*A-,N-%:2*j@35*/5##("#*$(*K5*/5-%"5:*6%(E*$35*S-EE(M%-73,*N-%#2kd*S-/E2*jS5:1'-/*
D'%55"1"M*-":*$35*o-/&5*(6*c-%/,*45$5'$1("2kd*D'3N-%$Y*-":*S5#/1"2*j@35*c$31'#*(6*!"6(%E-$1("kd*
*
H2&2A<4")?3"#4&)
)
@&5#9l*\5K9>*II*O%;>CA3#%>&*
L5-:1"M#)*j@35*P&%5EK5%M*?(:5k[*.5"'52*j@35*@&#05M55*D$&:,k[*`(%/:*S5:1'-/*+##('1-$1("2*
j45'/-%-$1("*(6*A5/#1"01k[*P-$1("-/*B1(5$31'#*+:O1#(%,*?(EE1##1("2*j.%($5'$1"M*L5#5-%'3*
.-%$1'17-"$#)*+*@1E5*6(%*?3-"M5k*UL5'(EE5":5:)*+:O1#(%,*?(EE1$$55*("*A&E-"*L-:1-$1("*
cQ75%1E5"$#*j\1"-/*L57(%$kV*
*
@3&%#*\5K9*]*II)9>L%<G2C)4%>&2>3*
L5-:1"M#)*b-$Y2*j.3,#1'-"#*-":*.-$15"$#)*+*31#$(%,*(6*#1/5"'5k2*\-:5"*-":*B5-'3-E72*j@35*?("'57$*(6*
!"6(%E5:*?("#5"$k2*_5O1"52*j!"6(%E5:*?("#5"$)*D(E5*?3-//5"M5#*$(*$35*h"1O5%#-/*o-/1:1$,*(6*$35*
`5#$5%"*S(:5/k*
)
@&5#9*\5K9*G*l*7$#>#4A$)8<#A$&)#>)=2@2$%'#>D)7%;>3<#2&))
O9HK8)8PQ?):RB?)?SPB)=T?)*
2
cE-"&5/*-":*S1//5%2*j@35*c$31'#*(6*./-'5K(I?("$%(//5:*@%1-/#l+*S1::/5*g%(&":kd2*D3-71%(*-":*
S5#/1"2*jc$31'-/*!##&5#*1"*$35*45#1M"*-":*?(":&'$*(6*?/1"1'-/*@%1-/#*1"*45O5/(71"M*?(&"$%15#kd2*
B5"-$-%2*ja&#$1'5*-":*S5:1'-/*L5#5-%'3)*+*g/(K-/*.5%#75'$1O5k*
*
P&&#&32C)H2'<%C;43#@2)824">%$%D#2&)
**
@3&%#9*\5K*>H*l9>)U#3<%)O2<3#$#FA3#%>*
L5-:1"M#)*L(K5%$#("2*j!o\2*!"65%$1/1$,2*-":*$35*D$-$&#*(6*$35*cEK%,(k*U("*cIL5#5%O5V2*D35%N1"2*
\5E1"1#$*c$31'#*-":*!"*o1$%(*\5%$1/1Y-$1("k*U("*cIL5#5%O5V2*!D_+@*`(%01"M*g%(&72*j+L@*1"$(*D'15"'5)*
L5M&/-$1("*(6*\5%$1/1$,*@5'3"1X&5#k*U("*cIL5#5%O5V*
*
@&5#*\5K9*>C**lH2'<%C;43#@2)7$%>#>D*
L5-:1"M#)*B%('02*j?/("1"M*A&E-"*B51"M#)*+"*+##5##E5"$*(6*$35*c$31'-/*!##&5#*.%(*-":*?("k*UcI
L5#5%O5V2*b-##2*j@35*`1#:(E*(6*L57&M"-"'5kd2*g1//("2*jA&E-"*L57%(:&'$1O5*?/("1"M)*+*/((0*-$*$35*
-%M&E5"$#*-M-1"#$*1$*-":*-*%5R5'$1("*(6*E(#$*(6*$35Ekd*
*
@3&%#9*\5K9*>J*l?;D2>#4&*
L5-:1"M#)*b5O/5#2*jc&M5"1'#*-":*A&E-"*L1M3$#k2*hD9*D&7%5E5*?(&%$2*jB&'0*O9*B5//*U>^=JVk2*?-7/-"2*
S'g55*-":*S-M"&#2*j`3-$*1#*!EE(%-/*-K(&$*c&M5"1'#mkd2*S'g55*-":*S-M"&#2*jc&M5"1'#*-":*c$31'#kd**
*
V2>23#4&)
)
@&5#*\5K9*==**l9G'$#4A3#%>&)%L)3"2):;GA>)V2>%G2)!<%W243*
L5-:1"M#)*B&'3-"("2*B%('02*4-"15/#*-":*`1'0/5%2*j\%(E*?3-"'5*$(*?3(1'5)*g5"5$1'#*-":*a&#$1'5k2**
.ppK(2*j@35*A&E-"*g5"(E5*-":*(&%*o15N*(6*;&%#5/O5#2k*`31$"5,*-":*D'3-66"5%2*jg5"5$1'#*-":*
A&E-"*B53-O1(%)*D'15"$161'*-":*L5#5-%'3*!##&5#k[*_/(,:2*jP(%E-/1$,*-":*O-%1-$1(")*$35*Ag.*-":*$35*
!:5-/*A&E-"*@,75kd*
*
@3&%#2*\5K*=<l*V2>23#4)82&3#>D*
L5-:1"M#)*B&%M5##2*jB5,(":*?("#5"$)*c$31'-/*-":*D('1-/*!##&5#*1"*g5"5$1'*@5#$1"M2k*n&-1:2*j.%5:1'$1O5*
g5"5$1'*@5#$1"M2k*`%1M3$*?/-,$("2*jP5NK(%"*g5"5$1'*D'%55"1"Mk**
*
K32G)72$$)H2&2A<4")
*
@&5#*S-%*>*l*X"A3Y&)9>)3"2)=#&"Z*
L5-:1"M#)*S'g55*-":*?-7/-"2*j@35*c$31'#*-":*.(/1$1'#*(6*DE-//*D-'%161'5#*1"*D$5E*?5//*L5#5-%'3kd2*
S51/-":5%2*j@35*7(1"$*(6*-*B-")*;%2*A(N*$(*$31"0*-K(&$*#$5E*'5//*%5#5-%'3kd2*g%55"2*j45$5%E1"1"M*
S(%-/*D$-$&#kd*
L5'(EE5":5:)**D-":5/2*3.-$/2%2*?3-7$5%*>H2*#55*5#75'1-//,*779*=C>I]*
*
@3&%#*S-%*]*l[2J)9&&;2&)#>)K32G)72$$)H2&2A<4"*
L5-:1"M#)*_(2*5$*-/92*j!"6(%E5:*?("#5"$*1"*A&E-"*;(',$52*cEK%,(2*-":*cEK%,("1'*D$5E*?5//*
L5#5-%'3kd**
*
R<DA>)8<A>&'$A>3A3#%>)
*
@&5#*S-%*G*l\;&3#42)A>C)B#4<%6A$$%4A3#%>*
L5-:1"M#)*?31/:%5##2*j.&$$1"M*.-$15"$#*\1%#$*1"*;%M-"*+//('-$1(")*+"*c$31'-/*+"-/,#1#*(6*$35*hD*45K-$52k*
A(N-%:2*jA(75*o5%#&#*c661'15"',*1"*;%M-"*+//('-$1("2k*D$51"K%((02*j.&K/1'*D(/1'1$-$1("*(6*;%M-"*
4("(%#2k*S&%73,2*j`(&/:*E,*D$(%,*g5$*E5*-*b1:"5,mk*
L5'(EE5":5:)*D-":5/2*3.-$/2%2*?3-7$5%*]2*#55*5#75'1-//,*779*JHIJ<*
*
?>C)%L)]#L2)
*
3
@3&%#*S-%*>HIII)H2L;&A$)%L)8<2A3G2>3)
8PQ?):RB?)?SPB)=T?)
L5-:1"M#)*?-/16(%"1-*?(&%$*(6*+775-/#2*B(&O1-*O9*D&75%1(%*?(&%$2*hD*D&7%5E5*?(&%$2*?%&Y-"*O9*
41%5'$(%2*S1##(&%1*457$9*(6*A5-/$32*cE-"&5/2*4-"1#2*.5-%/E-"2*-":*D1"M5%2*j+:O-"'5*?-%5*./-""1"M*-#*
-*.%('5##k*
*
@&5#*S-%*>C*lH#D"3)3%)=#2)
L5-:1"M#)*_1":#-,2*B5-'3-E72*-":*41'02*jA-#$5"5:*45-$3*-":*$35*L5M&/-$1("*(6*$35*.%-'$1'5*(6*
S5:1'1"52k*o-''(*O9*n&1//*2*`-#31"M$("*O9*g/&'0K5%M*
*
@3&%#*S-%*>J*II)!"(&#4#A>)P&&#&32C)K;#4#C2*
L5-:1"M#)*B%('02*jo(/&"$-%,*+'$1O5*c&$3-"-#1-k2*?(3"*-":*_,""2*jo&/"5%-K/5*.5(7/5)*.%-'$1'-/*
L5R(1":5%#*$(*?/-1E#*1"*\-O(%*(6*+##1#$5:*D&1'1:52*j**g5%$2*?&/O5%2*-":*?/(&#5%2*j+"*+/$5%"-$1O5*$(*.+Dk[*
B-$$1"2*5$*-/92*j_5M-/*.3,#1'1-"I-##1##$5:*:,1"M*1"*;%5M("*-":*$35*P5$35%/-":#)*5O1:5"'5*'("'5%"1"M*
$35*1E7-'$*("*7-$15"$#*-":*1"*jO&/"5%-K/5k*M%(&7#9kd**^VT?K8)K!?PQ?H0)!?VV_)1P889[`*
*
:2A$3")7A<2)
*
@&5#*S-%*=^l*9&):2A$3")7A<2)A)BA332<)%L)K%4#A$)\;&3#42Z)
hP*;661'5*(6*A1M3*?(EE1##1("5%*6(%*A&E-"*L1M3$#2*j@35*L1M3$*(6qk[*4-"15/#2*ja&#$1'52*A5-/$3*-":*
A5-/$3*?-%5k[*.(MM52*jL5#7("#1K1/1$15#qk[*.(N5%#*-":*\-:5"2*jD('1-/*R&#$1'5qk**L51"3-%:$2*j`-"$5:)*
+*?/5-%/,*+%$1'&/-$5:*D('1-/*c$31'*6(%*+E5%1'-"*A5-/$3*?-%5kd*
L5'(EE5":5:)*D-":5/2+3.-$/2%2*?3-7$5%#*CIe2*#55*5#75'1-//,*779*>]GI>ee*
*
@3&%#*S-%*]>*f*H#D"3&)3%):2A$3")4A<2Z)
o5-$'32*ja&#$1'52*$35*B-#1'*D('1-/*?("$%-'$2*-":*A5-/$3*?-%5k[*B&'3-"-"2*j@35*L1M3$*$(*-*45'5"$*
S1"1E&E*(6*A5-/$3*?-%5k[*-":*c"M5/35-%:$2*jL1M3$#*$(*A5-/$3*'-%5qk[*
*
@&5#*+7%1/*C*f*HA3#%>#>D)
hK5/2*j@35*"5'5##1$,*(6*%-$1("1"M*35-/$3*'-%5k[*B%('02*j.%1(%1$,*$(*$35*`(%#5*(66k[*D1"M5%2*j`3,*N5*
E&#$*%-$1("*35-/$3*'-%5kd*
*
@3&%#*+7%1/*J*f*P$32<>A3#@2&)3%)R;<)!<2&2>3)K(&32G0))3"2)GA<N23Z))H2L%<G&Z)))
.-&/*b%&ME-"2*jA5-/$3*c'("(E1'#*>H>2kd[*`1//1-E*D9*?&#$5%*5$*-/92*j`3,*`5*D3(&/:*b557*$35*
cE7/(,E5"$IB-#5:*A5-/$3*!"#&%-"'5*D,#$5E2k[*+//-"*B9*A&KK-%:2*j@35*A5-/$3*(6*-*P-$1("k[*cY5015/*
cE-"&5/2*jA5-/$3*?-%5*L56(%E)*D$1//*.(##1K/52kd*
*
!;M$#4):2A$3")
)
@&5#*+7%1/*>=)*!#*.&K/1'*A5-/$3*-*.5%#("-/*(%*.&K/1'*L5#7("#1K1/1$,m*
?31/:%5##2*S-""2*`10/5%*
*
+7%1/*><)*S-"-M5E5"$*(6*?(EE&"1'-K/5*41#5-#5*
g(#$1"2*`,"1-2*\5&:$"5%*-":*S-%'&#52*B-,"5%*-":*\-1%'31/:*
*
+7%1/*>^)*S-"-M5E5"$*(6*"("I?(EE&"1'-K/5*41#5-#5*
b(32d*P-%-,-"2d*P5&E-""d*
*
V2>23#4)!A32>3#>D)
)
+7%1/*=>)*c$31'#*(6*g5"5$1'*.-$5"$1"M)*g&5#$*D75-05%)*b5"*?3-31"5*6%(E*$35*_-N*D'3((/*
?3-31"52*j+"'3(%1"M*M5"5*7-$5"$*5/1M1K1/1$,*$(*1$#*'("#$1$&$1("-/*E((%1"M9kd*
*
H2@#2J)L%<)?aAG0)
*
4
*
+7%1/*=e*
*
d*%5-:1"M*'1$-$1("#*
*
B-$$1"2*5$9*-/9*j_5M-/*.3,#1'1-"*+##1#$5:*4,1"Mk*3;+<%=;+>$1/2-9*=HHJ[*]])*C^>IC^J9*
*
?3-31"52*b9*=H>H9**j+"'3(%1"M*M5"5*7-$5"$*5/1M1K1/1$,*$(*1$#*'("#$1$&$1("-/*E((%1"M9k*
P+@hLc*B!;@c?AP;_;gr*o;_hSc*=G*PhSBcL*>=*4c?cSBcL*=H>H*
*
*cE-"&5/*-":*S1//5%2*j@35*c$31'#*(6*./-'5K(I?("$%(//5:*@%1-/#l+*S1::/5*g%(&":k2*=HH>*PcaS2*]<C2*
"(9>=2*77*^>CI^>^9*
*
D3-71%(*-":*S5#/1"2*jc$31'-/*!##&5#*1"*$35*45#1M"*-":*?(":&'$*(6*?/1"1'-/*@%1-/#*1"*45O5/(71"M*
?(&"$%15#k2*=HH>*PcaS2*]<C2*"(9>=2*77*>]^I<=9*
*
?-7/-"2*S'g55*-":*S-M"&#2*j`3-$*1#*!EE(%-/*-K(&$*c&M5"1'#mk2*BSa2*]>^2*P(O9*>^^^*
*
S'g55*-":*S-M"&#2*jc&M5"1'#*-":*c$31'#k2*1"*Sa*S53/E-"*-":*@A*S&%%-,2*5:#?++91%+>#2*2@"'%=/)+"A+
>$1/2)@?+B%8)@?+)#=+C"@/2*+,--.%-+/#+0/"$%21#"@"8*2*P5N*r(%0)*a(3"*`1/5,*-":*D("#2**=HHH9*
*
_/(,:2*c9*>^^<*jP(%E-/1$,*-":*O-%1-$1(")*$35*Ag.*-":*$35*1:5-/*3&E-"*$,752k*1"*?%-"(%2*?9*5:9*D(%+
E%#%-+F-G*L&$M5%#9*
*
S-M"&#*-":*?-7/-"2*j\((:*6(%*@3(&M3$)*@35*.%1E-',*(6*$35*S(%-/*1"*$35*gS;*:5K-$5k2*1"*L&#5*-":*
?-#$/52*5:#2*E%#%$/2)@@*+<"=/A/%=+H""=-2*.%(E5$35&#*.%5##2*=HH=9**
*
@3(E7#("2*jc$31'-/*!##&5#*1"*\((:*B1($5'3"(/(M,k2*1"*D35%/('0*-":*S(%%5,2*5:#2*>$1/2)@+,--.%-+/#+
0/"$%21#"@"8*2*L(NE-"*-":*_1$$/5615/:2*=HH=9*
*
S-M"&#2)j!"$5//5'$&-/*.%(75%$,*-":*+M%1'&/$&%-/*B1($5'3"(/(M,)*B1(7%(#75'$1"M*(%*B1(71%-',mk2*1"*
S-M"&#2*?-7/-"2*-":*S'g552**51"+IJ#-+B/A%G*.%(E5$35&#*.%5##2*=HH=9*
*
S'g55*-":*?-7/-"2*j@35*c$31'#*-":*.(/1$1'#*(6*DE-//*D-'%161'5#*1"*D$5E*?5//*L5#5-%'3k2*b5""5:,*
!"#$1$&$5*(6*c$31'#*a(&%"-/2*>^^^2*O9^2**779*>C>I>CG9*
*
S51/-":5%2*j@35*7(1"$*(6*-*B-")*;%2*A(N*$(*$31"0*-K(&$*#$5E*'5//*%5#5-%'3k2*A-#$1"M#*?5"$5%*L57(%$2*
=HH>2*O9]>2**779*^I>e9*
D1"M5%2*=HH^9**j`3,*N5*E&#$*%-$1("*35-/$3*'-%5k*Pr@*S-M-Y1"5*
*
L("*g%55"2*j45$5%E1"1"M*S(%-/*D$-$&#k*1"*$35*D&%(/2)#+3".(#)@+"A+0/"%$1/2-2*O9=2*"(9>2*=HH=9**
*
_(2*5$*-/92*j!"6(%E5:*?("#5"$*1"*A&E-"*;(',$52*cEK%,(2*-":*cEK%,("1'*D$5E*?5//*L5#5-%'3k2*H%($/@/$*+
)#=+K$%(/@/$*2*O9*G=2*"(9*]2*=HH<9**
)
)
7%;<&2)!%$#4#2&*
K3;C2>3)H2&'%>&#M#$#3#2&*
+//*#$&:5"$#*-%5*5Q75'$5:*$(*E-1"$-1"*7%(65##1("-/*K53-O1(%*1"*$35*'/-##%((E*#5$$1"M2*-''(%:1"M*$(*$35*
D$&:5"$*?(:52*#75//5:*(&$*1"*$35*D$&:5"$*A-":K((09**@35*?(:5*#75'1615#*7%(#'%1K5:*'(":&'$*U+%$1'/5*
s!V*$3-$*1"'/&:5#*'35-$1"M*("*$5#$#2*7/-M1-%1#E2*-":Z(%*'(//&#1("2*-#*N5//*-#*6%-&:2*$356$2*5$'9**D$&:5"$#*
#3(&/:*%5-:*$35*?(:5*'-%56&//,*-":*0"(N*$35,*-%5*%5#7("#1K/5*6(%*$35*'("$5"$9***
)
P4AC2G#4)B#&4%>C;43*
+'-:5E1'*E1#'(":&'$2*N31'3*1"'/&:5#*7/-M1-%1#E*-":*($35%*6(%E#*(6*-'-:5E1'*:1#3("5#$,2*N1//*"($*K5*
5
$(/5%-$5:*1"*$31#*'(&%#59*!6*'-&M3$*7/-M1-%1Y1"M2*-*#$&:5"$*N1//*%5'51O5*-*6-1/1"M*M%-:5*6(%*$35*
-##1M"E5"$*-":*K5*%57(%$5:*$(*$35*h"1O5%#1$,*-:E1"1#$%-$1("*6(%*7(##1K/5*6&%$35%*#-"'$1("9**D$&:5"$#*
-%5*%5#7("#1K/5*6(%*0"(N1"M*-":*&":5%#$-":1"M*$35*h"1O5%#1$,t#*7(/1',*("*-'-:5E1'*E1#'(":&'$9**
*
./-M1-%1#E*1#*$35*%57%5#5"$-$1("*(6*#(E5("5*5/#5t#*N(%:#*;L*1:5-#*-#*,(&%*(N"*N(%09**9L)(%;)C%)>%3)
';3)E;%3A3#%>)GA<N&)A<%;>C)A>)A;3"%<b&)2aA43)J%<C&c)A>C)4#32)3"A3)A;3"%<Y&)';M$#4A3#%>c)3"A3)#&)
'$AD#A<#&G9**!6*,(&*7-%-73%-#5*-"*-&$3(%2*(%*&#5*$351%*1:5-#2*,(&*E&#$*'1$5*$35E9**L5E(O1"M*(%*
'3-"M1"M*-*N(%:*(%*$N(*1"*-*#5"$5"'5*1#*"($*7-%-73%-#1"M9**./5-#5*#55*K5/(N*6(%*7%5'1#5*'1$-$1("*
M&1:5/1"5#9**
*
:%J)4A>)(%;)A@%#C)'$AD#A<#&GZ)
I*PcocL*'(7,*-":*7-#$5*-",$31"M*,(&*61":*("*$35*N5K*1"$(*-*7-75%*I*5O5"*16*,(&t%5*("/,*N(%01"M*("*-*
%(&M3*:%-6$*$3-$*,(&*7/-"*$(*%5O1#5*/-$5%9**!$*E-,*K5'(E5*:1661'&/$*$(*%5E5EK5%*N31'3*N(%:#*N5%5*
,(&%*(N"2*-":*,(&*E-,*6(%M5$*N35%5*,(&%*1"6(%E-$1("*'-E5*6%(E*I*59M92*N31'3*N5K#1$5#2*5$'9*
I*+o;!4*N5KIK-#5:*#(&%'5#9**h#5*$35*%5'(EE5":5:*'(&%#5*E-$5%1-/#*U19592*$35*(%1M1"-/*$5Q$2*-":Z(%*
E,*"($5#*(%*%5'(EE5":5:*%5-:1"MV9***
I*+_`+rD*'1$5*-",*$5Q$*,(&*&#52*51$35%*5Q-'$*N(%:#2*(%*-%M&E5"$2*1"*,(&%*K1K/1(M%-73,9*
*
\(%*E(%5*1"6(%E-$1("2*#55*$35*h"1O5%#1$,W#*M&1:5/1"5#*'("'5%"1"M*7/-M1-%1#E*UB=V)*
3$$7)ZZNNN9%5M&/-$1("#9&$-395:&Z-'-:5E1'#ZeI<HH93$E/*
*
P&&#&3A>42)J#3")J<#3#>D)%<)<2&2A<4"#>D*
@&$(%1"M*1#*-O-1/-K/5*$3%(&M3*$35*+Dhh*@&$(%1"M*?5"$5%*1"*$35*D$&:5"$*D5%O1'5#*B&1/:1"M2*L((E*]]H9*
D$&:5"$#*E-,*#'35:&/5*-*:-,2*5O5"1"M*(%*N5505":*-77(1"$E5"$9***D$&:5"$#*N3(*X&-/16,*6(%*-*.5//*
g%-"$*E-,*-/#(*X&-/16,*6(%*6%55*$&$(%1"M9***\(%*E(%5*1"6(%E-$1("*'-//*CG>IC>C]*(%*M(*$(*
3$$7)ZZNNN9#-9&$-395:&Z@&$(%1"M*Z9*
`%1$1"M*?5"$5%*/('-$5:*-$*$35*S-%%1($$*_1K%-%,9***S(%5*1"6(%E-$1("*'-"*K5*6(&":*K,*M(1"M*$(*
3$$7)ZZNNN9N%1$1"M'5"$5%9&$-395:&Z*9*
)
^P=P`)PG2<#4A>&)J#3")=#&AM#$#3#2&)P43)%L)/dd-*
@35*h"1O5%#1$,*(6*h$-3*#550#*$(*7%(O1:5*5X&-/*-''5##*$(*1$#*7%(M%-E#2*#5%O1'5#*-":*-'$1O1$15#*6(%*
75(7/5*N1$3*:1#-K1/1$15#9***!6*,(&*N1//*"55:*-''(EE(:-$1("#*1"*$35*'/-##2*%5-#("-K/5*7%1(%*"($1'5*"55:#*
$(*K5*M1O5"*$(*$35*?5"$5%*6(%*41#-K1/1$,*D5%O1'5#2*>e=*;/71"*h"1("*B&1/:1"M2*CG>ICH=H*UoZ@44V9***?4D*
N1//*N(%0*N1$3*,(&*-":*$35*1"#$%&'$(%*$(*E-05*-%%-"M5E5"$#*6(%*-''(EE(:-$1("#9*+//*N%1$$5"*
1"6(%E-$1("*1"*$31#*'(&%#5*'-"*K5*E-:5*-O-1/-K/5*1"*-/$5%"-$1O5*6(%E-$*N1$3*7%1(%*"($161'-$1("*$(*$35*
?5"$5%*6(%*41#-K1/1$,*D5%O1'5#9*\(%*E(%5*1"6(%E-$1("*M(*$(*3$$7)ZZ:1#-K1/1$,9&$-395:&Z*9*
*
@35*+E5%1'-"#*N1$3*41#-K1/1$15#*+'$*%5X&1%5#*$3-$*%5-#("-K/5*-''(EE(:-$1("#*K5*7%(O1:5:*6(%*
#$&:5"$#*N1$3*73,#1'-/2*#5"#(%,2*'(M"1$1O52*#,#$5E1'2*/5-%"1"M2*-":*7#,'31-$%1'*:1#-K1/1$15#9*./5-#5*
'("$-'$*$35*1"#$%&'$(%*(6*$31#*'(&%#5*-$*$35*K5M1""1"M*(6*$35*'(&%#5*$(*:1#'&##*-",*#&'3*
-''(EE(:-$1("#*6(%*$31#*'(&%#59*
*
)
P44%GG%CA3#%>&)'%$#4(+
+//*(6*$35*'(&%#5*'("$5"$*3-#*K55"*'3(#5"*1"*(%:5%*$(*-'315O5*$35*75:-M(M1'-/*(KR5'$1O5#*(6*$31#*
'(&%#59**D(E5*(6*$35*N%1$1"M#2*/5'$&%5#2*(%*7%5#5"$-$1("#*1"*$31#*'(&%#5*E-,*1"'/&:5*E-$5%1-/*$3-$*
'("6/1'$#*N1$3*$35*'(%5*K5/156#*(6*#(E5*#$&:5"$#9*./5-#5*%5O15N*$35*#,//-K&#*'-%56&//,*$(*#55*16*$35*
'(&%#5*1#*("5*$3-$*,(&*-%5*'(EE1$$5:*$(*$-01"M9**!*N1//*"($*E-05*'("$5"$*-''(EE(:-$1("#*1"*$31#*
'(&%#59**
*
O%<GA33#>D)A>C)7#3A3#%>)V;#C2$#>2&0))
*
./5-#5*$,75*-":*:(&K/5*#7-'5*,(&%*7-75%#2*-":*&#5*-$*/5-#$*>H*7(1"$*6("$9*
*
`35"*,(&*'1$5*/#A"(&)$/"#+6%(E*-*$5Q$2*J1%$1%(+"(+#"$+*".+.-%+)+=/(%2$+L."$)$/"#2*,(&*E&#$*'1$5*,(&%*
6
#(&%'59+
*
c9M92*
+''(%:1"M*$(*D-/YE-"*-":*@3(E7#("2*GHT*(6*+E5%1'-"#*#-,*$3-$*$35,*-%5*5"O1%("E5"$-/1#$#*
UD-/YE-"*-":*@3(E7#("2*=HHJV9*
*
`35"*,(&*&#5*$1%+%M)2$+J"(=-+(6*-"*-&$3(%*(%*-&$3(%#2*,(&*E&#$*7/-'5*$35#5*N(%:#*1"*X&($-$1("*
E-%0#*(%*&#5*K/('0*X&($-$1("#*U6(%*]*/1"5#*(%*/("M5%*(6*$5Q$V2*-":*M1O5*$35*7-M5*6%(E*N31'3*$35*5Q-'$*
N(%:#*-%5*$-05")*
*
_5N("$1"*X&5#$1("#*N35$35%*#5/5'$1("*-":*-:-7$-$1("*-%5*'(5Q$5"#1O5)*j@35*%5/-$1("*K5$N55"*
-:-7$-$1("*-":*"-$&%-/*#5/5'$1("*:(5#*"($*M(*K($3*N-,#q*D(E5*'3-"M5#*N1//*(''&%*:1%5'$/,*K,*"-$&%-/*
#5/5'$1("*$3-$*-%5*"($*-:-7$1O5qk*U_5N("$1"2*>^JG2*779*===ICV*
*
`35"5O5%*,(&*&#5*-*X&($-$1("2*7/5-#5*5Q7/-1"*-":*:5#'%1K5*$35*X&($-$1("W#*%5/5O-"'5*$(*,(&%*
-%M&E5"$*1"**".(+"J#+J"(=-9*
*
`35"*,(&*:%-N*&7("*-"*-&$3(%W#*1:5-#*(%*-%M&E5"$#2*K5*#&%5*$(*5Q7/-1"*$3-$*$35*1:5-*U$35#1#V*(%*
-%M&E5"$*1#*#(E5("5*5/#5W#2*"($*,(&%*(N"9*
*
c9M92**
+''(%:1"M*$(*D&"#$51"2*#(E5*6(%E#*(6*'(5%'1("*-%5*75%E1##1K/52*-":*5O5"*-:O1#-K/52*1"*7&K/1'*7(/1',*
UD&"#$51"2*=HHeV9***
*
@35*7%(75%*'1$-$1("*6(%E-$*1#)*
+&$3(%*(%*-&$3(%#W*"-E5U#V2*4-$59*@1$/52*D(&%'5*Ua(&%"-/2*(%*_('-$1("*-":*
7&K/1#31"M*3(&#5V2*-":*O(/&E5*-":*7-M5*"&EK5%#*6(%*-%$1'/5#*(%*K((0*'3-7$5%#9*
*
c9M92*
*
_5N("$1"2*L9*>^JG9*j+:-7$-$1("9k*K2/%#$/A/2+D&%(/2)#;+o(/9*=]^2*"(9*]9*779*=>]I*
]H9*
g(&/:2*D9*a9*=HH=9*91%+K$(.2$.(%+"A+>N"@.$/"#)(*+91%"(*9*?-EK%1:M5)*A-%O-%:*
h"1O5%#1$,*.%5##9*
*
B((0*-":*R(&%"-/*$1$/5#*-":*1$-/1'1Y5:[*-%$1'/5*$1$/5#*-%5*1"*X&($-$1("#9**!*7%565%*$3-$*,(&*7&$*-*'(E7/5$5*
/1#$*(6*'1$-$1("#*1"*-*K1K/1(M%-73,*-$*$35*5":*(6*$35*5##-,9*./5-#5*-O(1:*6(($"($5#[*-":*16*,(&*E&#$*&#5*
$35E2*7/5-#5*0557*$35E*#3(%$9*
*
7