American Mineralogist, Volume 64, pages I I9-126, 1979 NMR studyof micas,II. Distributionof Fe'*, F-, andoH- in theoctahedral sheet of phlogopites J n s u sS e N z l Groupe de Physico-Chimie Minbrale et de Catalyse, Uniuersity of Louuain Place Croix du Sud I , B-1348Louuain-la-Neuue,Belgium nNn WrLLr.q,uE. E. SroNr Sectionde Physico-ChimieMinbrale ( M.R.A.C.-Teruuren) Place Croix du Sud I , B-1348 Louuain-la-Neuue,Belgium Abstract By studyingtheNM R signalsof protonsandfluorinein a series phlogopites of crystalline at variousfrequencies and angles,it hasbeenpossible to differentiate amongvariousoctahedral associations. In sampleswith continuously variableamountsof fluorineand iron, we show that the OH groups,ratherthan the fluorineions,are in directcoordinationwith the iron. Thisanionicsegregation relativeto Fe2+is alsoconfirmedby theobservation of fluorinepairs, whichmostprobablyform homogeneous fluorinedomains.This localorderingof octahedral ionsis an importantparameterin the studyof cohesionof layeredsilicates. Introduction Phlogopites belongto the sheetsilicategroup;their idealformulais KMgrSisAlOlo(OH)r. The Mg,+ ions Iocatedin the centraloctahedralsheetof the elementary layerare only slightlysubstitutedby Fe2+ions, whereasthe OH groupsmay be replacedby F- ions to variousdegrees. It is well knownthat the natureof the isomorphoussubstituents within the octahedral sheetof micasis a determinantfactor in the vermiculitizationprocessof theseminerals;in particular, when the fluorine content increases, the easewith which K+ can be replacedby Na+ decreases. The Fand H+ nuclearmagneticresonancespectraof ten phlogopitesampleshave beenexaminedin order to understandhow the nature of the octahedralsheet influencesthis process. In the octahedralsheet,two differentcation sites are possible,dependingon whetherthe OH groups are in czi (M2 site)or trans position (M1 site) (Fig. I ). TheseOH groupsare locatedon the zr symmetry plane and are coordinatedto one Ml cation in the planeand to two M2 cationslocatedon both sidesof the plane. We will show that from the H+ and F- NMR I P r e s e n ta d d r e s s C : . S . I . C .S e r r a n o 1 1 5 D p d o , M a d r i d 6 , S p a i n 0003-004x/79/0102-01 19$02.00 signals,it is possibleto characterize the distribution of the Fe2+ion with respectto the anionsOH-, F- as a result of the largeparamagnetic influenceof the Fe2+on the nuclearsignals.We will also showthat the strong nucleardipolar interactionbetweenFions belongingto the sameoctahedraleadsto informationconcerning the degreeof orderwhichexistsin the octahedraldistributionof this ion. Theseresults indicateionic segregation within the octahedral sheet and thereforesuggestthe existenceof short-range orderwhichsupplements thepictureof average structures given by X-ray diffractionstudies. Experimental The samplesstudied(for chemicalcompositionsee Table I ) are part of a collectionof micas whose weathering properties had been determined previously in our laboratory(Rousseaux et al., 1973). The sampleswerechosensuchthat the fluorinecontent variedcontinuouslybetween0.7 to 5.2 percent (by weight),the paramagnetic impurities,essentially Fe'+ ions, beingin the range0.2 to 3 percent.The samplesformed by superposingindividual platelets (10 X l0 mm) were cut from large natural mica plates,on which the a and D axis orientationshad beendeterminedbeforehand.Altered or twinned regions werecarefullyavoided. I 19 120 SANZ AND STONE: NMR STUDY OF MICAS T a b l e l . S a m p l ec o m p o s i t i o n s ' !i* 2+ Ca- Na - 0.0r 0.05 0.06 0.85 2.4L - 0.39 0.rr 0.01 0.0r 0.0r si4+ At3+ A13+ ti4+ Fe3+ Fe2+ to,* P-2 2.74 !.26 0.r8 0.05 0.0r 0.16 2,55 P-2t 2.74 r.26 0.r5 0.05 0.r0 0.17 P-I2 + + o- OH F 9.93 t.92 0.15 0.85 r0.22 r,48 0,30 0.07 0.88 10.35 r.r9 0.45 0.01 0.04 0.9r r0,42 1.09 0.49 - K 2.90 r.r0 0.16 0.08 0.04 0.r0 2.68 - 2.88 r.t2 0.27 0.05 0.02 0.02 2.-74 - 0.02 2,83 0.03 0.06 0.87 r0.16 r.21 0.63 0.05 2.86 0.04 0.05 0.90 r0.34 0.92 0.74 0.r5 2,64 - 0.0r 0.07 0.03 0.93 9.61 r.60 0.19 - 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.95 r0.24 L.02 0.74 0.01 0.03 0.93 r0.r4 0.89 0.97 0.03 0.04 0.95 L0.26 0.57 - P-8 2.84 1.r6 0.r1 0.07 P-6 2.92 r. 08 0.12 0.06 P-13 ) r 0.0r 0.02 v-r5 2.88 r.L2 0.15 0.07 0.0r 0.04 2.73 2.83 r.17 0.05 0.03 0.04 0.07 2.90 3.00 r.00 0.06 0.02 0.03 0.17 2.73 P-r8 Mr2+ I 10 J.M. ,r Rorr".aux et al. 0.0r - 0.0r 0.03 l.t6 (1973). NMR spectrawere obtained at room temperature with a Varian continuous-wavecrossed-coiledspectrometer working at different fixed frequencies(14, 54.6,and 60 MHz). In order to obtain signal-to-noise ratios around 30 to 50, the spectrawere signal-averaged. The paramagnetic influence on the nuclear spectra increaseswith frequency.Therefore, experiments run at high frequencyallowed us to study the influenceof varying Fe2+contentson the H+ and Fspectra.Theseexperimentswere also usefulin identifying the various interactionsresponsiblefor the observed spectra. Experiments at low frequency (14 Fig. l. Projection on the ab plane of the octahedral sheet of I M micas showing the position of OH , F and MI and M2 sites. MHz) werg run at various anglesaround the b axis, becauseof better resolution in this plane, in order to provide information concerning the diamagneticinteractlons. Results Proton signal-a axis H+ gives rise to a large symmetricalGaussian line accompanied, when the iron content is above one percent,by small side lines,whose intensity increases with the iron concentration. Figure 2 showsthe secondmoment of the principal line obtained from the peak-to-peak value of the experimentalfirst derivativespectra,at 60 MHz, as a function of iron content. The line-width is essentially dominated by the paramagnetic interaction which gives rise to the expectedparabolic shape.By working at lower frequencies,which decreasesthe paramagnetic contributions to the width of the line, the dipolar diamagneticpart of the interaction remains more or lessconstant for all samples. The position of the side-lineswith respectto the central line varies as a function of the orientation of the samplewith respectto the applied magneticfield' It also varieslinearly with the applied field, as is to be expected for averaged electronic moments obeying Curie's law. An analysisof theseside-lineshas clearly shown (Sanz and Stone, 1977) that they are due to OH- groups, which are first-nearestneighbors (i.e. 2 . 7 A ) t o t h e F e 2 +i o n s . SANZ AND STONE: NMR STUDY OF MICAS At high frequency,for sampleshaving a high iron and F- content, weak lines closeto the main line can be observed (see Fig. 3); these correspond to OH groups which are second neighbors (r : 4.07A) to Fe'?+.The intensity of these lines is lessthan that of the first-neighborlines, although the multiplicity for neighbors is the same. This observation could be explained by a regrouping of certain Fe2+ions, with the result that most of the OH- groups in these regions will have, in addition to a Fe2+ as second neighbor, another Fe2+as first neighbor. This therefore reducesthe total contribution of secondneighbors to the intensity of their respectiveside-line.This regrouping of Fe2+ions would also explain why the width of the first-neighborside-lineis larger than that of the main line. By going to lower frequency, this width decreasesand approachesthat of the main line ( s e eF i g . 3 ) . I n t h e p r e v i o u sa n a l y s i so f t h e H + s i d e l i n e s ,i t w a s a l s o s h o w n t h a t t h e s u b s t i t u t i o no f M g z + by Fe'+ is random on the two available sites(this is not in conflict with the above assumeddistribution of Fe2+with respectto each other) and that as the iron content increases,the associationof OH- with more Fez+ also increases. Fluorine signal-a axis In the F spectraobtained at high frequency(56.4 MHz) the side-linesbecomevisible,as in the casefor H+, only when the iron content is above one percent. In this case,however, the side-linesare much closer to the central line (Fig. 4), and their intensity is much less dependent on the Fe2+ concentration. At low frequency,the side-linesdisappear,being included in t2l H (60MHz) P - 1 8 H . (1 4 M H z ) F i g . 3 . E x a m p l e o f H + N M R s i g n a l sf o r s a m p l e p - 1 8 s h o w i n g t h e p r i n c i p a l l i n e a n d s i d e - l i n e sa s f u n c t i o n o f o r i e n t a t i o n ( a a x i s ) and frequency. II corresponds to second-neighbor protons The u p p e r c u r v e s r e p r e s e n t h e f i r s t d e r i v a t i v eo f t h e a b s o r p t i o n l i n e s . the main central line. Using the samehypothesisas in the previous work (Sanz and Stone, 1977), i.e., a simple time-averagedpoint dipolar interaction between magnetic moments of iron and nuclei, it is possible to calculate the angular variation of shift that an iron placedeither on the M I or M2 site would induce in surrounding F- nuclei. For this calculation only Fe2+ ions are considered,as chemical analysis and Mcissbauer spectra (Sanz et al., 1978) have 9=30' shown that theseare the only abundant paramagnetic 2 speciespresent.Moreover, for this analysisthe struco f tural model obtained by Joswig (1972) on a phlogo9=60' (,o pite by neutron diffraction was utilized. The calculation for the three neighbors (see Fig. o1 5a) to Fe'+ at respectively2.03,3.68, and 4.54A has been carried out, and the resultsfor secondand third neighborsshown in Figure 5b. Experimentally,in no case have lines correspondingto first-nearestneighbors been seen.The only lines observedat 56.4MHz o123"o are those corresponding to nuclei which are either second or third neighborsto Fe2+.Unfortunately the Fig. 2. Experimental secondmomentsof ttreprincipat/tiri."", resolution is not sufficient to be able to distinguish at 60 MHz, asfunctionof the iron contentand for two orientations "r of the C' axis relativeto the appliedmagneticfield. between the two possiblesites.These resultstend to 122 SANZ AND STONE:N M R S T U D Y O F M I C A S P 18,F ( 56.4 MHz),a axrs ( Ho// C') OM? Y(b*) x (a+; n F i g 5 a P r o j e c t i o n i n t h e a b p l a n e s h o w i n g F - p o s i t i o n s( O ) w h i c h a r e a t f i r s t - n e i g h b o r( - ) , s e c o n d - n e i g h b o(r. - . - ) a n d t h i r d neighbor (--) distances with respect Lo Ml and M2 sites. the paramagnetic contribution for certain orientations. In samplesof high fluorine content (such as Pl8), the paramagneticcontribution to the line is less than half as important for the F- line as it is for the Gauss F L U O R I N E, a a x i s , 5 6 4 M H z z ./1 Fig. 4. Example of F NMR signals for sample P-18 for r o t a t i o n s a r o u n d t h e c a x i s . A t h i g h f r e q u e n c y , s i d e - l i n e sa r e v i s i b l e .A t l o w f r e q u e n c y ,t h e p r i n c i p a l l i n e c o n s i s t sf o r 4 : 9 6 o o 6 a doublet. show that unlike OH-, F- ions are not directly coordinated to the Fe2+ions. Moreover, an analysisof the width of the central l i n e s h o w st h a t t h e l i n e - w i d t ho f t h e F - l i n e i s m u c h more angular-dependentthan in the caseof H+. As the paramagneticcontribution is practicallyrotationindependent,the interaction which is responsiblefor the width variation must be of another nature. i.e.. of diamagneticorigin. This interaction, betweennuclear spins only, is observedto be very much larger than -----\ n2 Itr1 +Q +Q +$ F i g . 5 b . C a l c u l a t e da n g u l a r v a r i a t i o n o f s h i f t s f o r F w h i c h a r e s e c o n d n e i g h b o r s t o M l ( l l , ) a n d M 2 ( I l , ) o r t h i r d n e i g h b o r st o M l ( l l l t ) a n d M 2 ( l l l r ) . l : E x p e r i m e n t a lp o i n t s f o r P - 1 8 SANZ AND STONE: NMR STTJDY OF MICAS H+ line. This again shows that most of the fluorine ions are more distant from the iron than are the protons. Finally, when the iron content is sufficientlylow, or when the frequency is lowered (Fig. 4), a doublet is observedfor certain orientations.A doublet in NMR spectroscopyis the clear indication of a diamagnetic interaction betweena pair of spins l/2, which is the casefor H+ and F-. This pair interaction can only be seenif the interaction that eachmember of the nuclei pair has with its surroundings(i.e. electronsor other nuclei such as Al) is less important than the interaction it has with its partner in the pair. The spectra obtained around the a axis are poorly resolved,however, and thereforean exact evaluationofthe relative importance of the two possiblediamagneticpair interactions,H-F and F-F, as function of the F- content is difficult. However, this identification will be possible by obtaining spectra while rotating the samplearound its D axis,as shown in the next section. In summary, the experimentsrun around the a axis have helped to distinguish betweenthe various interactionsinvolved in the H+ and F- spectra.They have also shown that, for protons, the paramagneticcontribution is the dominant term at both short (i.e. sidelines) and long (central line) distance. For F- the interactionsare on the whole more diamagnetic. Fluorine signal-b t23 Gauss (H ila) F i g . 6 C a l c u l a t e da n g u l a rv a r i a t i o n o f t h e F - d o u b l e t s e p a r a t i o n for F-Fo and F-Ho (rotations around the b axis). f : Experimental points for P- l8 with two clearly distinguishable doublet s e p a r a t i o n sf r o m 9 0 o t o 1 8 0 o . axis We will discuss here the results obtained at low frequency (14 MHz) for rotations around the b axis, which is normal to the zr plane containing the F and H atoms. In this case,becauseof geometricalreasons, the doublet separation associatedwith these two ions is now larger. This, coupled with the fact that at low frequency the paramagnetic influence on the linewidth is smaller, results in better-resolvedspectra. Therefore, it will be much easier to distinguish between the various octahedral associationsand also easier to identify the F- distribution within the octahedral sheet. The doublet separation,(Pake, 1948), is given by the expression h : + ( 3 c o s , -d l ) G a u s s ," wherea is a constantequal to 3 for two identicalspins I : I/2 and equal to 2 for two differentspins1 : l/2; p is the magneticmoment of the studied spin; r is the internuclear distance; d the angle between r and the applied magnetic field. With the above expression,it is possibleto calculatethe doublet separationin the case of an interaction between two ions located within thesameoctahedron, F-Fo andF-Hn (Fig. I ); this corresponds to the smallestvaluefor r, i.e.,2.64 and 3.45A respectively.The geometricalfactorsare taken from the structuresproposedby Joswig(1972) for phlogopitesand McCauley et al. (1973) for a fluor-phlogopite. The resultsof the calculationaregivenin Figure6 by the broken lines for F-Fo and F-Ho respectively. It can be seenthat around 130" the two doublet separationsare quite different.This orientation is, therefore,very convenientfor a quantitativeevaluation of the number of associations of both types. Figure6 alsoshowsthe experimentalresultsobtained for sampleP-18.For the 90o to l80o region,two doubletscan be distinguished clearlywith the inner doubletcorresponding to F-Ha and the outer doublet to F-Fo (also seeFig. 7); herethe agreementis quite good. Becauseof smallerdoublet separation and non-negligible line-widths,from 0" to 90", the experimentalpoints only reflectan averagesituation. From the relativelygood agreement,it can be concluded that (l) the accuracywith which we could orient our samplesis around 5'; (2) the distance 124 SANZ AND STONE NMR STUDY OF MICAS F ( 14 MHz ), axe b, p =13O' r-zl r - tz Fig. 7. F s p e c t r af o r d i f f e r e n t p h l o g o p i t e sw i t h i n c r e a s i n gc o n t e n t i n F : P - 2 1 < P - 1 2 < P - 1 5 < P - 1 8 2.64A taken for F-Fo from a fluor-phlogopiteis quite adequate in our calculation; and (3) complicated polytypism is absent. Concerning this last point, in two cases where frequent stacking faults had been detectedby X-ray diffraction, the NMR doublet separation was badly resolvedand, becauseof the various possibleorientationsfor the F-Fo vector, did not follow the expectedangular variation; thesesamples were eliminated from this study. Eight out of l0 sampleswere therefore examined a r o u n d t h e a n g l eo f 1 3 0 o ,i n o r d e r t o s t u d y t h e d i s t r i bution of F betweenthe two types of association:FF o a n d F - H o . W e o b s e r v e d( F i g . 7 ) t h a t t h e i n t e n s i t y of the .central doublet (F-Ho) decreasesrelative to the outer doublet (F-Fo) as the fluorine content increases.After decomposing our spectra and taking the area under the F-Fo doublet as a measureof the number oi F-F pairs, it is possible to compare this figure with the one obtained by taking the mineralogical formula and calculating the probability of finding F-F pairs. This is done in Figure 8, where the experimental and calculated numbers of F-F pairs are given as a function of fluorine content. It can be seen that the number of pairs found experimentally increasesmuch faster at low concentration than is expected from a statistical calculation (40 percent compared to 15 percent for 0.25 F per site). The number of pairs then levelsoff and finally tends towards the estimatedvalues. Discussion: octahedral ionic-distribution model 4 rL f 1 o02o.40.604 F / srte F i g . 8 . F - F p e r c e n t a g ef o u n d f o r t h e s t u d i e d s a m p l e s ( O ) a s function of the F content. The broken line curve (--) represents the statistically-calculated values. In this work, the identificationof the various magnetic interactions responsiblefor the NMR proton and fluorine spectra has allowed us to differentiate among various octahedralassociations.The distribution of elementswithin theseassociationswas determined by evaluation of the relative importance of each component of the spectral lines. The ability to optimize angular parametersthrough the use of crystalline sampleswas important in obtaining this information. Certain important points emergewhich will be now discussed. SANZ AND STONE: NMR STUDY OF MICAS First, the observation of a rapid increase in the number of fluorine pairs in the domain of very low concentration in F- can be interpreted as evidence for the existenceand prior growth of relatively large fluorine-rich domains.The observationthat as the Fcontent increasesthe number of pairs levels off implies that the various domains gradually join together. Since fluorine is only a second-or third-nearest neighbor to Fe2+,thesetwo ions are not directly coordinated to each other, in contrast with the hydroxyl groups, which are found to be locatedcloseto the Fe2+ ions (nearest neighbor). The fluorine domains, therefore, consist of homogeneous regions containing only Mg2+ ions, in which the F-F distance is equal to what is found in a pure fluor-phlogopite. The presence of F- second-neighborside-linesof non-negligibleintensities,however, suggeststhat the Fd+ ions are locatedon the fringe of the F- domains. The importance of the latter could in principle be estimatedby the relativearea of the F-OH doublet to the F-F doublet, provided of coursethe geometryof the domains were known. The distortion ofthe octahedralsite and the nature and relative distanceof surrounding ligands are factors which influencethe stabilizationenergyof a Fe2+ ion on its site. In connection with our work, it is perhaps relevant to note that, on the basis of the spectrochemicalseries(Burns, 1970) and for a given metal and stereochemistry,the ligand field increases when going from F- to OH-. This means that OHgroups form stronger covalent bonds with Fe2+,and consequentlythat the crystal field energy is higher than it would be for Fe2+sitessurrounded by F- ions only. Note also that in minerals of the humite series, the number of Fe2+-substitutedoctahedradecreases as the number of F- ligands increases(Ribbe and Gibbs,l97l). Sanz and Stone (1977) showed by NMR that the Fe2+ ions are distributed randomly on the two possible sites. However, the way the Fd+ ions are distributed relative to each other is also important. The H+ spectraof the presentstudy show that when the fluorine content is high (P-18), the Fe2+ions tend to group together. Moreover, when the iron content is high, such as in sample P-21 and particularly in biotites (Sanz and Stone, 1977),side-linesdue to OHgroups having several Fe2+ions as first neighbors are observed. This observation provides an interesting means of investigatingthe iron distribution and also the influence of the F- content on this distribution. Work in this field on a larger number of sampleswith a wider range ofiron concentrationis being pursued. It seemsinterestingto compareour approachwith X-ray results.X-ray diffraction has clearly shown at the unit-cellscale,of (Bailey,1975)the existence, minercationorderingin the caseof lM mica-related als, in which cationsof differentsizesare locatedon octahedralsitesof different symmetry.For phlogopites such as those studied here, X-ray diffraction doesnot showsuchordering;a randomdistribution is thereforeexpectedfor sampleshaving an octahecomposidral sheetof variableand heterogeneous showsusthatOH- and F- ions tion. NMR. however. are highly differentiatedwith respectto cationicassofluorinedomainsare ciationsand that homogeneous preferred.The chemical homogeneityof these Fdomainsis preservedeven when the iron content increasesdrastically (e.g. in biotites; Sanz, 1976). This is not true for the OH- groups;their environwith the Fe2+content,and ment variesconsiderably associations of one, two, or three Fe2+around the sameOH- can be detected(Sanzand Stone,1977). around of cationicassociations This heterogeneity OH- is clearlyvisibleby IR (Vedder,1964;Rousseauxet al., 1972),which also showsthe association of OH- groupswith highlychargedions(Al8+,Tin+, sheet,this localredistribution etc.).ln the octahedral of cationsaround the anions does not necessarily follow a regularperiodicpattern and thereforecannot be detectedby X-ray methods.An interesting case investigatedby X-ray which is analogousto phlogopiteis the recentstudy of zinnwaldite(Guggenheimand Bailey,1977).They found that on one of the threesitesof the unit cell, an ordereddistribuAlexists.This distributionis sometion of octahedral what favoredby the fact that in this mineralthereis a quasi-stoichiometric compositionof Al in the octahedra.It would be interestingto seeif the tendency domainssuch as that for F- to form homogeneous shownherealsoexistsin thiscase,i.e.aroundcations other than Mg. Only NMR, which directlydetects the fluorinepairing,could providean unambiguous answer.The two methodswould thereforebe complementary. of fluorFinally,the mutualexclusionrelationship ine and iron is an important parameterin the vermiculitizationof micas,as the role playedby thesetwo ions is known to be quite different.The degreeof order-disorderin the distribution of thesetwo octahedralelementscould considerablymodify the cohesionbetweenlayers,and thereforethe openingof the latter during the exchangeprocess.This factor addedto othersasrecentlyreviewedby Giese(1977), i.e. structural distortions,polytypism,number of t26 SANZ AND STONE: NMR STIJDY OF MICAS vacant sites, e/c. shows that the alteration process implies more than a simple point-like electrostatic interaction betweenK+ and sheet.For a clear understanding of this process,the octahedralsheetshould be consideredas a whole. Pake, G. E. (1948) Nuclear resonance absorption in hydrated crystals: fine structure of the proton line. J. Chem. Phys., 16, 327-336. R i b b e , P . H . a n d G . V . G i b b s ( 1 9 7 1 ) C r y s t a l s t r u c t u r e so f t h e h u m i t e m i n e r a l s :I I I . M g , / F e o r d e r i n g i n h u m i t e a n d i t s r e l a t i o n t o o t h e r f e r r o m a g n e s i a ns i l i c a t e sA . m . M i n e r a l . ,J 6 , I 1 5 5 - l 1 7 3 . R o u s s e a u x J, . M . , C . G o m e z - L a v e r d e ,Y . N a t h a n a n d P . G . R o u x het (1972) Correlation between the hydroxyl stretching bands Acknowledgments and the chemical composition of trioctahedral micas. ProWethankProfessor (Universit6 H, Pezerat Pierreet MarieCuceedings of the International Clay Conference, Madrid, Spain, rie, Paris) and coworkers for their help in determining the poly89-98. t y p i s m i n o u r s a m p l e s .W e a r e g r a t e f u l t o D r . G . E . B r o w n , J r . f o r -, P. G. Rouxhet, L. A. Vielvoyeand A. J. Herbillon (1973) bringing the results relative to the humite minerals to our ar[enThe vermiculitization of trioctahedral micas. I. K level and its hon. correlation with chemical composition. Clay Minerals, 10,l-16. Sanz, J. (1976) Orrtre-dbsordre dans la couche octabdrique des micas References rrioctatdriques. Etude par RMN,IR et Mbssbauer.Ph.D. Thesis, Bailey, S.W. (1975) Cationordering andpseudosymmetry in layer U n i v e r s i t 6 d e L o u v a i n , L o u v a i n - l a - N e u v e ,B e l g i u m . silicates. Am. Mineral.,60, 175-187. -, J. Meyers,L. A. Vielvoye and W. E. E. Stone(1978)The Burns, R. G. (1970) MineralogicalApplicationsof Crysta! Fietd location and content of iron in natural biotites and phlogopites. Theory CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,England. A comparison between several methods. Clay Minerals, 13,45Giese,R. F., Jr. (1977).The influenceof hydroxylorienration, <,) stacking sequence andionicsubstitutions on theinterlayer bonding of micas. Clays Clay Minerals,25, 102-105. Guggenheim, S. and S. W, Bailey(1977)The refinemenr of zinnwafdite-lM in subgroupsymmetry.Am. Mineral., 62, ll5B|67. Joswig,W. (1972)Neutronenbeugungsmessungen an einem lMPhlogopit.NeuesJahrb Mineral Monatsh.,l-ll. McCauley, J. W., R. E. NewnhamandC. V. Gibbs(1973)Crystal structureanafysisof syntheticfluorophlogopite. Am. Mineral., 58,249-254. a n d W . E . E . S t o n e ( 1 9 7 7 )N M R s t u d y o f m i c a s .l . D i s t r i b u t i o n o f F e z +i o n s o n t h e o c t a h e d r a ls i t e s .J . C h e m . P h y s . , 6 7 , 3739-37 45. Vedder, W. (1964) Correlation between infrared spectrum and c h e m i c a fc o m p o s i t i o n o f m i c a . A m . M i n e r a l . , 4 9 , ' 1 3 6 - ' 1 6 8 . Manuscript receiued, December 28, 1977; acceptedfor publication, September 2, 1978.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz