Ideology without Leadership - Afghanistan Analysts Network

!"#$#%&''#()*+,#("$")
*-./'/01)2"%(/&%)3.#-.,4("5)
!"#$%&'#$()*$+#,-&)#$./$0(.&'1$&)$2/3"()&'4()$
!"#$%&'&()%#$%&')*%+,%'-%../%$()#($%*"'*%0++1$%'*%*"(%2(3(0+&4(-*%+,%&+0#*#5'0%&')*#($%'-2%4+3(4(-*$%#-%
.,6"'-#$*'-7%!"(%'#4%+,%*"(%$()#($%#$%*+%,#00%*"(%6'&$%*"'*%(8#$*%#-%*"(%59))(-*%0#*()'*9)(%:;%(8&0+)#-6%*"(%)+0(%
+,%&+0#*#5'0%&')*#($%#-%*"(%5+-*(4&+)');%&+0#*#5'0%$;$*(4%'-2%:;%2+594(-*#-6%*"(%"#$*+);%+,%&+0#*#5'0%
4+3(4(-*$%*"'*%5+-*#-9(%*+%&0';%'-%#4&+)*'-*%)+0(%+)%"'3(%:((-%+,*(-%+3()0++1(27%
$
67689:*;6)<9==>?@)
!"(%<=>?$%@()(%'-%#4&+)*'-*A%,+)4'*#3(%2(5'2(%#-%*"(%"#$*+);%+,%.,6"'-#$*'-7%B+00+@#-6%*"(%5+9-*);C$%
*)'-$,+)4'*#+-%#-*+%'%5+-$*#*9*#+-'0%4+-')5";%#-%<=>DA%*")((%#2(+0+6#5'0%59))(-*$%(4()6(2%*+%5+4&(*(%,+)%
*"(%0+;'0*;%+,%'%6)+@#-6%(295'*(2%50'$$%#-%E':90%'-2%+*"()%9):'-%5(-*)($7%.*%*"(%"(')*%+,%*"(%#2(+0+6#5'0%
2(:'*($%@()(%5+-5()-$%':+9*%*"(%$0+@%&'5(%+,%$+5#+F(5+-+4#5%2(3(0+&4(-*%'-2%&+0#*#5'0%)(,+)4$7%!"($(%
#-*(00(5*9'0%2(:'*($%$++-%0#-1(2%9&%@#*"%&+0#*#5'0%2;-'4#5$%'*%"+4(%'-2%':)+'2A%2((&0;%#-,09(-5#-6%*"(%
*9490*9+9$%,'*(%+,%*"(%5+9-*);%*")+96"%*"(%,+00+@#-6%2(5'2($%9-*#0%*"(%&)($(-*7%
!"(%,#)$*%*+%'&&(')%@'$%*"(%G(H:F(%I#4+1)'*#1F(%E"'0JF(%.,6"'-#$*'-A%+)%K(+&0(C$%I(4+5)'*#5%K')*;%+,%
.,6"'-#$*'-%LKIK.MA%*"(%4'#-%&)+&+-(-*%+,%N+3#(*F$*;0(%$+5#'0#$4%#-%.,6"'-#$*'-A%#-%<=>O7%!"(%,+)4'*#+-%
+,%*"(%P'+#$*%N'H4'-F(%Q'@'-'-F(%P9*')'J#A%+)%K)+6)($$#3(%R+9*"%S)6'-#$'*#+-%LN'Q'PTKRSM%,+00+@(2%#-%
<
<=>>7%U-%<=>=%'%*"#)2%59))(-*%@'$%+)6'-#$(2%')+9-2%Q'@'-'-F(%P9$'04'-A%+)%*"(%P9$0#4%R+9*"A %#-$&#)(2%
:;%*"(%#2(+0+6;%+,%*"(%#-*()-'*#+-'0%P9$0#4%V)+*"()"++27%E':90C$%9-#3()$#*;%'-2%$*)((*$%:(5'4(%*"(%
$5(-($%+,%'%,#()5(%'-2%'*%*#4($%3#+0(-*%5+4&(*#*#+-%:(*@((-%$9&&+)*()$%+,%*"+$(%2#,,()(-*%#2(+0+6#5'0%
6)+9&$7%
<
%U*%#$%#4&+)*'-*%*+%-+*(%*"'*%)(0#6#+9$0;%4+*#3'*(2%&+0#*#5'0%'5*#3#$4%"'$%'%495"%0+-6()%"#$*+);%#-%*"(%5+9-*);7%W+;%
$966($*$%*"'*%*"(%,#)$*%U$0'4#5%5#)50(%+,%*"#$%&()#+2%@'$%,+)4(2%')+9-2%<=OX7%N((%S0#3#()%W+;A%Y!"(%S)#6#-$%+,%*"(%
U$0'4#$*%P+3(4(-*%#-%.,6"'-#$*'-CA%!"#$%&'()*+&#(,-%."/A%Z+0%[A%-+%\A%<=XDA%<<]7%
\%
!"#$#%&''#()*+,#("$"A)*-./'/01)2"%(/&%)3.#-.,4("5)
!"(%P'+#$*$A%*"'*%#$%N'Q'PTKRSA%:(5'4(%:(**()%1-+@-%#-%.,6"'-#$*'-%'$%*"(%N"+0'C#A%',*()%,01'&2/"(Q'@(2%
\
L^*()-'0%B0'4(MA %#*$%,#)$*%-(@$&'&()%&9:0#5'*#+-%#-%<=>X7%.-%#4&+)*'-*%&')*%+,%*"(%P'+#$*C$C%$*)'*(6;%@'$%
*"(%2(-9-5#'*#+-%+,%KIK.C$%#2(+0+6;%'$%Y)(3#$#+-#$*%'-2%_'-`%(8*(-$#+-%+,%_N+3#(*`%$+5#'0%#4&()#'0#$4C7%!"(%
P'+#$*$%')69(2%*"'*%.,6"'-#$*'-%:+)(%6)('*()%$#4#0')#*#($%*+%&)(F)(3+09*#+-');%a"#-'%#-%#*$%0(3(0%+,%$+5#+F
(5+-+4#5%2(3(0+&4(-*%*"'-%#*%2#2%*+%W9$$#'C7%b-0#1(%*"(#)%KIK.%)#3'0$A%*"(;%)(,9$(2%*+%&')*#5#&'*(%#-%*"(%
5+9-*);C$%&')0#'4(-*');%(0(5*#+-$%'-2%#-$*('2%$*)($$(2%*"(%4+:#0#$'*#+-%+,%*"(%&('$'-*);%'$%*"(%4'#-%
)(3+09*#+-');%,+)5(%+-%*"(%&'*"%*+%$+5#'0#$47%
U-%'%&)(2+4#-'-*0;%)9)'0%5+9-*);%@"()(%0':+9)%"')20;%(8#$*(2%'$%'%50'$$A%'%Y&)+*)'5*(2%@')C%:;%
)(3+09*#+-');%&('$'-*$%4#6"*%"'3(%+,,()(2%6)('*()%&)+$&(5*$%,+)%'%$+5#'0#$*%)(3+09*#+-%:9*%*"(%5"'00(-6($%
+,%+)6'-#$#-6%'%Y&(+&0(C$%')4;C%,)+4%'4+-6%*"(%.,6"'-$%&('$'-*$%'-2%0'9-5"#-6%'%5+449-#$*%&')*;%@()(%
4+)(%2#,,#590*%*"'-%#*%,#)$*%$((4(2%*+%*"(%&)+&+-(-*$%+,%*"#$%*"(+);7%U-%&)'5*#5(A%*"(%KIK.C$%$*)'*(6;%+,%'%
Y&('5(,90%*)'-$#*#+-%*+%$+5#'0#$4C%c%@"#5"%2#2%-+*%)(4'#-%&('5(,90%,+)%0+-6%c%&)+3(2%4+)(%,)9#*,907%U-%<=>OA%
,+9)%+,%*"(%&')*;C$%4(4:()$%@()(%(0(5*(2%*+%*"(%d+0($#%Q#)6'%L*"(%0+@()%"+9$(%+,%*"(%.,6"'-%&')0#'4(-*M%
9-2()%*"(%-(@%5+-$*#*9*#+-'0%$;$*(4e%#-%<=][%#*%$9&&+)*(2%P9"'44'2%I'92%E"'-C$%4#0#*');%5+9&%2Cf*'*%
*"'*%2(&+$(2%*"(%4+-')5";A%:(5+4#-6%'-%#4&+)*'-*%&0';()%#-%"#$%6+3()-4(-*A%'-2%#-%<=]X%#*%$(#H(2%
&+@()%*")+96"%#*$%+@-%5+9&7%V;%5+-*)'$*A%N'Q'P%@'$%2#$$+03(2%#-%<=]\%',*()%#-*(-$(%#-*()-'0%#2(+0+6#5'0%
2(:'*($%,'#0(2%*+%&)+295(%'%5+44+-%$*)'*(6;%+,%*"(%4+3(4(-*A%$(**#-6%#-%4+*#+-%'-%(-20($$%*(-2(-5;%
*+@')2$%,'5*#+-'0#$4%'-2%,)'64(-*'*#+-7%
!"(%)('$+-$%,+)%*"(%2(50#-(%+,%P'+#$4%#-%.,6"'-#$*'-%')(%-+*%(-*#)(0;%(-2+6(-+9$7%K()"'&$A%'%4'g+)%
5'9$(%@'$%*"(%'23()$(%-'*#+-'0%'-2%#-*()-'*#+-'0%(-3#)+-4(-*%#-%@"#5"%*"(%P'+#$*%4+3(4(-*%2(3(0+&(27%
I9)#-6%*"(%@')%:(*@((-%*"(%49g'"(2#-%'-2%*"(%N+3#(*F:'51(2%)(6#4(%#-%*"(%<=X?$A%*"(%.,6"'-%P'+#$*%
,'5*#+-$%,+9-2%*"(4$(03($%#-%'-%(8*)(4(0;%390-()':0(%$#*9'*#+-7%B+00+@#-6%*"(%4'$$#3(%6+3()-4(-*%
5)'512+@-%#-%5#*#($%#-%*"(%',*()4'*"%+,%*"(%KIK.C$%\]%.&)#0%L]%N'9)M%<=]X%5+9&A%4+)(%P'+#$*%6)+9&$%@()(%
,+)5(2%*+%4+3(%#-*+%*"(%5+9-*);$#2(7%!"($(%6)+9&$%*++1%&')*%#-%'%-94:()%+,%)(3+0*$%'6'#-$*%*"(%)(6#4(%
'5)+$$%*"(%5+9-*);%:9*%$++-%,+9-2%*"(4$(03($%#-%2('20;%5+-,0#5*$%@#*"%0+5'0%49g'"(2#-%+)6'-#$'*#+-$A%'$%
U$0'4#5#$'*#+-%'-2%0+5'0%&+@()%$*)9660($%:(5'4(%#4&+)*'-*%,('*9)($%+,%*"(%@')7%B9)*"()4+)(A%:+*"%*"(%
KIK.%'-2%*"(%49g'"(2#-%)(5(#3(2%(-+)4+9$%4'*()#'0%'-2%&+0#*#5'0%$9&&+)*%,)+4%*"(%N+3#(*%b-#+-%'-2%
d($*()-%'-2%U$0'4#5%5+9-*)#($%)($&(5*#3(0;7%U-%'%$#*9'*#+-%@"()(%+9*$#2(%$9&&+)*%:(5'4(%'%1(;%
2(*()4#-'-*%+,%$955($$%'-2%$9)3#3'0A%*"(%P'+#$*$%$*')3(2%'-2%a"#-'A%*"(#)%4+$*%0#1(0;%'00;A%5"+$(%*+%
$9&&+)*%*"(%49g'"(2#-7%.$%'%$*)'*(6;%+,%$9)3#3'0A%4+$*%P'+#$*$%@()(%,+)5(2%*+%$((1%*"(%&)+*(5*#+-%+,%
49g'"(2#-%+)6'-#$'*#+-$A%@"#5"%*"(;%g+#-(2A%+,*(-%'*%*"(%5+$*%+,%':'-2+-#-6%+)%$#6-#,#5'-*0;%4+2()'*#-6%
*"(#)%#2(+0+6#5'0%'$&#)'*#+-$7%U-2(&(-2(-*%$9)3#3'0A%'$%*"(%(8&()#(-5(%+,%*"(%/#4)9H%B)+-*%$"+@$A%@'$%+-0;%
&+$$#:0(%:;%'2+&*#-6%&+0#*#5'0%&)'64'*#$4%'*%*"(%5+$*%+,%#2(+0+6#5'0%)"(*+)#57%
!"(%*(-2(-5;%*+@')2$%2#3#$#+-%'-2%#-5($$'-*%,)'64(-*'*#+-%'4+-6%P'+#$*$%#-%.,6"'-#$*'-%4';%-+*%:(%'-%
(-5+9)'6#-6%$#6-%,+)%+*"()%#2(+0+6#5'0%4+3(4(-*$%#-%*"(%5+9-*);7%G+@(3()A%-'*#3(%4+3(4(-*$%*(-2%*+%
0+$(%5+-*)+0%+,%*"(#)%+@-%,'*(%@"(-%5+9-*)#($%2($5(-2%#-*+%5"'+$%'-2%5+-,0#5*7%!"(%"#$*+);%+,%*"(%P'+#$*%
4+3(4(-*%#-%.,6"'-#$*'-%#$%'%50(')%(8'4&0(%+,%*"#$%&"(-+4(-+-7%P95"%':+9*%*"(%@')%'-2%5+-,0#5*%#-%
.,6"'-#$*'-%5'-%:(%'**)#:9*(2%*+%#-*()-'0%5+-*)+3()$#($A%:9*%#*%#$%'0$+%50(')%*"'*%*"(%-'*#3(%#-*(00(5*9'0%
4+3(4(-*$%#-%*"(%5+9-*);%@()(%2+4#-'*(2%'-2%+3()@"(04(2%:;%&+@(),90%&+0#*#5'0%2(3(0+&4(-*$%
(4'-'*#-6%,)+4%':)+'2%:(,+)(%*"(;%@()(%6#3(-%*"(%5"'-5(%*+%)('5"%4'*9)#*;7
%
%
%
\
%.5*9'00;A%#*%$"+902%:(%@)#**(-%N"+C0'A%:9*%,+)%:(**()%)('2':#0#*;%@(%0('3(%+9*%*"(%LhMA%@"#5"%$*'-2$%,+)%*"(%0(**()%Y'#-C7%
d(%@)#*(%YN"+0'C#C%,+)%*"(%4(4:()$%+,%*"(%+)6'-#$'*#+-A%*"+96"A%*+%'3+#2%&)+-9-5#'*#+-%'$%YN"+0';C7%
../%!"(4'*#5%W(&+)*%?[T\?<\%
!"#$#%&''#()*+,#("$"A)*-./'/01)2"%(/&%)3.#-.,4("5)
>BC9:):D6)>EFD>!*<:>!)>!>3@<:<)!6:GC?H)I>>!J$
!"(%.,6"'-#$*'-%.-'0;$*$%/(*@+)1%L../M%#$%'%-+-F&)+,#*A%#-2(&(-2(-*%&+0#5;%)($(')5"%+)6'-#$'*#+-7%U*%'#4$%
*+%:)#-6%*+6(*"()%*"(%1-+@0(26(%'-2%(8&()#(-5(%+,%'%0')6(%-94:()%+,%(8&()*$%*+%#-,+)4%&+0#5;%'-2%
#-5)('$(%*"(%9-2()$*'-2#-6%+,%.,6"'-%)('0#*#($7%%
!"(%#-$*#*9*#+-'0%$*)95*9)(%+,%../%#-5092($%'%5+)(%*('4%L59))(-*0;%5+-$#$*#-6%+,%*")((%$(-#+)%'-'0;$*$M%'-2%
'%-(*@+)1%+,%)(690')%5+-*)#:9*+)$%@#*"%(8&()*#$(%#-%*"(%,#(02$%+,%.,6"'-%&+0#*#5$A%6+3()-'-5(A%)90(%+,%0'@%
'-2%$(59)#*;7%../%@#00%&9:0#$"%)(690')%#-F2(&*"%*"(4'*#5%)(&+)*$A%&+0#5;%:)#(,#-6$%'-2%5+44(-*$7%%
!"(%4'#-%5"'--(0%,+)%2#$$(4#-'*#+-%+,%*"(%)(&+)*$%#$%*"(%../%@(:%$#*(7%B+)%,9)*"()%#-,+)4'*#+-A%&0('$(%
3#$#*%@@@7''-F',6"'-#$*'-7+)67%%
>BC9:):D6)>9:DC?A)!*>=>:933>D)*B?>D*=*)$
/#'4'*900'"%U:)'"#4#%#$%'-%'-'0;$*%:'$(2%#-%.,6"'-#$*'-7%.*%&)($(-*A%"(%#$%'%a+FI#)(5*+)%+,%.,6"'-#$*'-%
d'*5"A%'%-+-F6+3()-4(-*'0%)($(')5"%+)6'-#$'*#+-%:'$(2%#-%E':907%B+)%*"(%0'$*%*(-%;(')$A%"(%"'$%:((-%
(8*(-$#3(0;%)($(')5"#-6%'-2%@)#*#-6%+-%59))(-*%'$%@(00%'$%"#$*+)#5'0%',,'#)$%+,%"#$%"+4(%5+9-*);7%G#$%')('$%
+,%#-*()($*%#-5092(%*"(%2(3(0+&4(-*%'-2%"#$*+);%+,%&+0#*#5'0%4+3(4(-*$%'-2%#2(+0+6#($%#-%.,6"'-#$*'-7%G(%
"'$%@+)1(2%,+)%*"(%U-*()-'*#+-'0%a)#$#$%i)+9&%L\??[F?OM%'-2%*"(%a)#$#$%N*'*($%W($(')5"%a(-*)(%+,%*"(%
j+-2+-%N5"++0%+,%^5+-+4#5$%L\??OF<?M7%B)+4%Q'-9');%*+%Q9-(%\?<\A%"(%5+4&0(*(2%'%$#8F4+-*"%)($(')5"%
,(00+@$"#&%'*%*"(%a(-*)(%,+)%I(3(0+&4(-*%N*92#($%+,%*"(%B)((%b-#3()$#*;%#-%V()0#-7%G(%"+02$%'%VN5%#-%K+0#*#5$%
'-2%U-*()-'*#+-'0%W(0'*#+-$%,)+4%*"(%j+-2+-%N5"++0%+,%^5+-+4#5$%'-2%K+0#*#5'0%N5#(-5(7%
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
k%.,6"'-#$*'-%.-'0;$*$%/(*@+)1%\?<\7%
.00%)#6"*$%)($()3(27%/+%&')*%+,%*"#$%&9:0#5'*#+-%4';%:(%)(&)+295(2A%$*+)(2%#-%'%)(*)#(3'0%$;$*(4%+)%*)'-$4#**(2%#-%'-;%,+)4%+)%:;%'-;%
4('-$A%(0(5*)+-#5A%4(5"'-#5'0A%&"+*+5+&;#-6A%)(5+)2#-6%+)%+*"()@#$(%@#*"+9*%,900%'**)#:9*#+-7%
.969$*%\?<\%
[%