Weak positive Poisson stability and Hamiltonian vector fields in

Weak positive Poisson stability and Hamiltonian
vector fields in mechanical systems
Ramaprakash Bayadi
Ravi N Banavar
Systems and Control Engineering,
IIT Bombay, India.
August 29, 2012
Outline
Introduction
The setting
Dynamics on the level set
A conserved volume form
Application: Spacecraft with two rotors
Summary
Outline
Introduction
The setting
Dynamics on the level set
A conserved volume form
Application: Spacecraft with two rotors
Summary
Motivation
Weak positive Poisson stability (WPPS) is closely related to global
controllability.
1
1 Lian,
Field
K-Y et al.,
Controllability of Spacecraft Systems in a Central Gravitational
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 1994.
Motivation
Weak positive Poisson stability (WPPS) is closely related to global
controllability.
1
Hamiltonian vector elds are closely associated with mechanical systems.
1 Lian,
Field
K-Y et al.,
Controllability of Spacecraft Systems in a Central Gravitational
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 1994.
Motivation
Weak positive Poisson stability (WPPS) is closely related to global
controllability.
1
Hamiltonian vector elds are closely associated with mechanical systems.
We link these concepts for a class of systems.
1 Lian,
Field
K-Y et al.,
Controllability of Spacecraft Systems in a Central Gravitational
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 1994.
The link
A vector eld on a compact manifold is WPPS if it conserves a volume
form.
2
2 Birtea,
P et al.
Controllability of Poisson systems
, SIAM J. Cntrl and Opt, 2004
The link
A vector eld on a compact manifold is WPPS if it conserves a volume
form.
2
A Hamiltonian vector eld conserves the canonical two form on the
underlying symplectic manifold.
2 Birtea,
P et al.
Controllability of Poisson systems
, SIAM J. Cntrl and Opt, 2004
The link
A vector eld on a compact manifold is WPPS if it conserves a volume
form.
2
A Hamiltonian vector eld conserves the canonical two form on the
underlying symplectic manifold.
For the systems we consider, a component of the Hamiltonian vector eld
lies on a compact manifold.
2 Birtea,
P et al.
Controllability of Poisson systems
, SIAM J. Cntrl and Opt, 2004
The link
A vector eld on a compact manifold is WPPS if it conserves a volume
form.
2
A Hamiltonian vector eld conserves the canonical two form on the
underlying symplectic manifold.
For the systems we consider, a component of the Hamiltonian vector eld
lies on a compact manifold.
This allows the construction of a volume form using the canonical two form.
2 Birtea,
P et al.
Controllability of Poisson systems
, SIAM J. Cntrl and Opt, 2004
Outline
Introduction
The setting
Dynamics on the level set
A conserved volume form
Application: Spacecraft with two rotors
Summary
Definitions
WPPS
A complete vector eld on Q is said to be WPPS if for every open set
U ⊂ Q and for every t > 0, there exists T > t such that φT (U ) ∩ U 6= ∅.
Definitions
WPPS
A complete vector eld on Q is said to be WPPS if for every open set
U ⊂ Q and for every t > 0, there exists T > t such that φT (U ) ∩ U 6= ∅.
Hamiltonian vector field
For every C ∞ function H dened on a symplectic manifold S , the
Hamiltonian vector eld XH corresponding to H , is dened as
hdH(x), vi = Ω(XH , v), ∀v ∈ Tx S.
Definitions
WPPS
A complete vector eld on Q is said to be WPPS if for every open set
U ⊂ Q and for every t > 0, there exists T > t such that φT (U ) ∩ U 6= ∅.
Hamiltonian vector field
For every C ∞ function H dened on a symplectic manifold S , the
Hamiltonian vector eld XH corresponding to H , is dened as
hdH(x), vi = Ω(XH , v), ∀v ∈ Tx S.
The phase space of a mechanical system is T ∗ Q, the cotangent bundle of
the conguration space Q, is a symplectic manifold.
General Setting
A Lie group action on T ∗ Q induces a momentum map J : T ∗ Q −→ g∗ ,
where g∗ is the dual of the Lie algebra of G. This function is a
generalization of linear and angular momenta.
General Setting
A Lie group action on T ∗ Q induces a momentum map J : T ∗ Q −→ g∗ ,
where g∗ is the dual of the Lie algebra of G. This function is a
generalization of linear and angular momenta.
When Q = G, G acts on itself by left and right actions. Thus, we have the
left and right momentum maps JL and JR .
General Setting
A Lie group action on T ∗ Q induces a momentum map J : T ∗ Q −→ g∗ ,
where g∗ is the dual of the Lie algebra of G. This function is a
generalization of linear and angular momenta.
When Q = G, G acts on itself by left and right actions. Thus, we have the
left and right momentum maps JL and JR .
Noether's theorem
If H is invariant under a G-action, then the corresponding momentum map
is a constant of motion for XH . Thus, the dynamics evolves on J−1 (µ), the
level set of the momentum map.
Outline
Introduction
The setting
Dynamics on the level set
A conserved volume form
Application: Spacecraft with two rotors
Summary
Dynamics on
∗
J−1
L (µ) ⊂ T G
When H : T ∗ G −→ R is left-invariant, the dynamics evolves on J−1
L (µ).
Dynamics on
∗
J−1
L (µ) ⊂ T G
When H : T ∗ G −→ R is left-invariant, the dynamics evolves on J−1
L (µ).
The dieomorphism φ := (π, JL ) maps J−1
L (µ) to G × {µ}, where
π : T ∗ G −→ G is the cotangent bundle projection.
Dynamics on
∗
J−1
L (µ) ⊂ T G
When H : T ∗ G −→ R is left-invariant, the dynamics evolves on J−1
L (µ).
The dieomorphism φ := (π, JL ) maps J−1
L (µ) to G × {µ}, where
π : T ∗ G −→ G is the cotangent bundle projection.
Theorem (Right-trivialized dynamics)
φ
Dene H − : g∗ −→ R by H − (η) = H(g · η). Let XH
:= φ∗ XH . Then,
φ
XH
(g, µ)
=
!
δH − Te Lg
,0 .
δη (η=Ad∗ µ)
g
Dynamics on
∗
J−1
L (µ) ⊂ T G
When H : T ∗ G −→ R is left-invariant, the dynamics evolves on J−1
L (µ).
The dieomorphism φ := (π, JL ) maps J−1
L (µ) to G × {µ}, where
π : T ∗ G −→ G is the cotangent bundle projection.
Theorem (Right-trivialized dynamics)
φ
Dene H − : g∗ −→ R by H − (η) = H(g · η). Let XH
:= φ∗ XH . Then,
φ
XH
(g, µ)
=
!
δH − Te Lg
,0 .
δη (η=Ad∗ µ)
g
Example
For a free rigid body, XHφ (R, µ) = (RS I −1 RT µ , 0). This can be
interpreted as the equation of motion expressed in the inertial frame of
reference.
Dynamics on
∗
J−1
L (µ) ⊂ T (G × S)
The Hamiltonian H : T ∗ G × T ∗ S −→ g∗ induces two parameterized families
of functions:
Hαs : T ∗ G −→ R, Hαs (αg ) := H(αg , αs ),
Hαg : T ∗ S −→ R, Hαg (αs ) := H(αg , αs ).
Dynamics on
∗
J−1
L (µ) ⊂ T (G × S)
The Hamiltonian H : T ∗ G × T ∗ S −→ g∗ induces two parameterized families
of functions:
Hαs : T ∗ G −→ R, Hαs (αg ) := H(αg , αs ),
Hαg : T ∗ S −→ R, Hαg (αs ) := H(αg , αs ).
Hamiltonian vector field on
T ∗G × T ∗S
Hamiltonian vector eld corresponding to H is given by
XH (αg , αs ) = (XH1αs (αg ), XH2αg (αs )).
Dynamics on
∗
J−1
L (µ) ⊂ T (G × S)
The Hamiltonian H : T ∗ G × T ∗ S −→ g∗ induces two parameterized families
of functions:
Hαs : T ∗ G −→ R, Hαs (αg ) := H(αg , αs ),
Hαg : T ∗ S −→ R, Hαg (αs ) := H(αg , αs ).
Hamiltonian vector field on
T ∗G × T ∗S
Hamiltonian vector eld corresponding to H is given by
XH (αg , αs ) = (XH1αs (αg ), XH2αg (αs )).
The dieomorphism ϕ := (φ, idT ∗ S ), where φ is as dened above, maps
∗
J−1
L (µ) to G × {µ} × T S .
Dynamics on
∗
J−1
L (µ) ⊂ T (G × S)
Theorem (Right-trivialized dynamics)
(ϕ∗ XH )(g, µ, αs ) =
Te Lg
!
δHα−s ,
0,
X
(α
)
.
H2 φ−1 (g,µ)
s
δη (η=Ad∗ µ)
g
Outline
Introduction
The setting
Dynamics on the level set
A conserved volume form
Application: Spacecraft with two rotors
Summary
A conserved volume form on
G
Let X = T π1 XHφ , where π1 is the projection to the rst factor. That is,
X(g) = Te Lg
δHα−s .
δη (η=Ad∗ µ)
g
A conserved volume form on
G
Let X = T π1 XHφ , where π1 is the projection to the rst factor. That is,
X(g) = Te Lg
δHα−s .
δη (η=Ad∗ µ)
g
We construct a volume form on G using ΩT ∗ G , the canonical two form on
T ∗ G, that is conserved under X .
(ΩT ∗ G )
∗
T G
φ
(Ω)
G × g∗
(Θξ )
G
i
(i(0,ξ) Ω)
∗
G×g
A conserved volume form on
G
Let X = T π1 XHφ , where π1 is the projection to the rst factor. That is,
X(g) = Te Lg
δHα−s .
δη (η=Ad∗ µ)
g
We construct a volume form on G using ΩT ∗ G , the canonical two form on
T ∗ G, that is conserved under X .
(ΩT ∗ G )
∗
T G
φ
(Ω)
G × g∗
(Θξ )
G
i
(i(0,ξ) Ω)
∗
G×g
Let Ω := φ∗ ΩT ∗ G and ξ ∈ g∗ . Dene the one-form on G:
Θξ := i∗ i(0,ξ) Ω.
A conserved volume form on
G
To construct a volume form on G, choose any n linearly-independent set of
vectors in g∗ , {ξ1 , ξ2 , . . . , ξn }. Dene
Γ := Θξ1 ∧ Θξ2 ∧ · · · ∧ Θξn = i∗ i(0,ξ1 ) Ω ∧ i∗ i(0,ξ2 ) Ω ∧ · · · ∧ i∗ i(0,ξn ) Ω.
A conserved volume form on
G
To construct a volume form on G, choose any n linearly-independent set of
vectors in g∗ , {ξ1 , ξ2 , . . . , ξn }. Dene
Γ := Θξ1 ∧ Θξ2 ∧ · · · ∧ Θξn = i∗ i(0,ξ1 ) Ω ∧ i∗ i(0,ξ2 ) Ω ∧ · · · ∧ i∗ i(0,ξn ) Ω.
Theorem
LX Γ = 0.
A conserved volume form on
G
To construct a volume form on G, choose any n linearly-independent set of
vectors in g∗ , {ξ1 , ξ2 , . . . , ξn }. Dene
Γ := Θξ1 ∧ Θξ2 ∧ · · · ∧ Θξn = i∗ i(0,ξ1 ) Ω ∧ i∗ i(0,ξ2 ) Ω ∧ · · · ∧ i∗ i(0,ξn ) Ω.
Theorem
LX Γ = 0.
Sketch of the proof
The proof makes use of fact that the canonical two form is conserved under
the ow of any Hamiltonian vector eld.
X
is WPPS
If a vector eld conserves a volume form on a compact manifold, then the
vector eld is WPPS.
3
Controllability of Poisson systems
Controllability of spacecraft attitude using Control
Moment Gyroscopes
3 Birtea, P et
4 Bhat, S and
al.
, SIAM J. Cntrl and Opt, 2004
Tiwari, P:
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 2009.
X
is WPPS
If a vector eld conserves a volume form on a compact manifold, then the
vector eld is WPPS.
3
Theorem
If G is compact, X is WPPS on G.
Controllability of Poisson systems
Controllability of spacecraft attitude using Control
Moment Gyroscopes
3 Birtea, P et
4 Bhat, S and
al.
, SIAM J. Cntrl and Opt, 2004
Tiwari, P:
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 2009.
X
is WPPS
If a vector eld conserves a volume form on a compact manifold, then the
vector eld is WPPS.
3
Theorem
If G is compact, X is WPPS on G.
Example
Bhat et al. prove that the vector eld RS I −1 (RT µ − l) , where l is a
parameter, is WPPS on SO(3). The above theorem thus generalizes this
result.
4
Controllability of Poisson systems
Controllability of spacecraft attitude using Control
Moment Gyroscopes
3 Birtea, P et
4 Bhat, S and
al.
, SIAM J. Cntrl and Opt, 2004
Tiwari, P:
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 2009.
Outline
Introduction
The setting
Dynamics on the level set
A conserved volume form
Application: Spacecraft with two rotors
Summary
Control of a spacecraft with two rotors
Inertial frame
Spacecraft body frame
dV
X
Figure: Rigid body model of a spacecraft with rotors.
Control of a spacecraft with two rotors
The conguration space for the system is Q = SO(3) × T2 .
Control of a spacecraft with two rotors
The conguration space for the system is Q = SO(3) × T2 .
The Hamiltonian is the kinetic energy, which is symmetric with respect to
the standard SO(3) action on Q.
Control of a spacecraft with two rotors
The conguration space for the system is Q = SO(3) × T2 .
The Hamiltonian is the kinetic energy, which is symmetric with respect to
the standard SO(3) action on Q.
The reduced Hamiltonian H − : so(3)∗ × T ∗ T2 is given by
H − (Π, p) =
1
1
˜ −˜
(Π − ˜
l)T I(Π
l) + lT I˜r l.
2
2
−1
−1 ˜
),l = i(l), i : R2 −→ R3 p := (θ, l), I˜ = (IL − Ir )−1 , I˜r = diag (Ir1
, Ir2
canonical inclusion.
Control of a spacecraft with two rotors
The conguration space for the system is Q = SO(3) × T2 .
The Hamiltonian is the kinetic energy, which is symmetric with respect to
the standard SO(3) action on Q.
The reduced Hamiltonian H − : so(3)∗ × T ∗ T2 is given by
H − (Π, p) =
1
1
˜ −˜
(Π − ˜
l)T I(Π
l) + lT I˜r l.
2
2
−1
−1 ˜
),l = i(l), i : R2 −→ R3 p := (θ, l), I˜ = (IL − Ir )−1 , I˜r = diag (Ir1
, Ir2
canonical inclusion.
The right-trivialized dynamics is given by
˜ Tµ − ˜
l) ,
Ṙ = RS I(R
˜ T µ + I˜r l,
θ̇ = − π IR
Two-rotor control system
Two-rotor control system
Since the variable θ is of little signicance, it is enough to consider the
dynamics
˜ Tµ − ˜
Ṙ = RS I(R
l) ,
l˙ = u,
where u is the control torque.
Two-rotor control system
Two-rotor control system
Since the variable θ is of little signicance, it is enough to consider the
dynamics
˜ Tµ − ˜
Ṙ = RS I(R
l) ,
l˙ = u,
where u is the control torque.
Dene
˜ Tµ − ˜
f0 (R, l) := RS I(R
l) , 0 , f1 (R, l) = (0, e1 ), f2 (R, l) = (0, e2 ).
Two-rotor control system
Two-rotor control system
Since the variable θ is of little signicance, it is enough to consider the
dynamics
˜ Tµ − ˜
Ṙ = RS I(R
l) ,
l˙ = u,
where u is the control torque.
Dene
˜ Tµ − ˜
f0 (R, l) := RS I(R
l) , 0 , f1 (R, l) = (0, e1 ), f2 (R, l) = (0, e2 ).
We get a control system over SO(3) × R2 of the form
ẋ = f0 (x) +
2
X
i=1
ui fi (x).
Global controllability
Since f0 is WPPS, global controllability follows if {f0 , f1 , f2 } satisfy the Lie
algebra rank condition (LARC).
5
5 Lian,
Field
K-Y et al.,
Controllability of Spacecraft Systems in a Central Gravitational
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 1994.
Global controllability
Since f0 is WPPS, global controllability follows if {f0 , f1 , f2 } satisfy the Lie
algebra rank condition (LARC).
5
Proposition
The set {f0 , f1 , f2 } satises LARC over SO(3) × R2 .
5 Lian,
Field
K-Y et al.,
Controllability of Spacecraft Systems in a Central Gravitational
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 1994.
Global controllability
Since f0 is WPPS, global controllability follows if {f0 , f1 , f2 } satisfy the Lie
algebra rank condition (LARC).
5
Proposition
The set {f0 , f1 , f2 } satises LARC over SO(3) × R2 .
Theorem
The-two rotor control system is globally controllable over SO(3) × R2 .
5 Lian,
Field
K-Y et al.,
Controllability of Spacecraft Systems in a Central Gravitational
, IEEE Trans. Aut. Cntrl, 1994.
The reachable set
6
Theorem (Bayadi, Banavar and Chang )
The (left trivialized) reachable set of T SO(3) of a spacecraft with two rotors
is R, IL−1 RT µ − Ir Ωr where R ∈ SO(3) and Ωr ∈ R3 is such that
eT3 Ωr = 0.
(Ωb )3
Reachable angular velocities
IL−1 RT µ
(Ωb )2
(Ωb )1
Figure: Reachable set of
6 Bayadi,
Ωb
at a particular orientation.
R., Banavar, R., and Chang, D. E.,
spacecraft with rotors
Characterizing the reachable set of a
, American Control Conference 2012.
Outline
Introduction
The setting
Dynamics on the level set
A conserved volume form
Application: Spacecraft with two rotors
Summary
Summary
We derive an expression for the Hamiltonian dynamics on the level set of
the momentum map for a mechanical system on Q = G × S .
Summary
We derive an expression for the Hamiltonian dynamics on the level set of
the momentum map for a mechanical system on Q = G × S .
We construct a volume form on G which is conserved under this dynamics
and show that the dynamics is WPPS.
Summary
We derive an expression for the Hamiltonian dynamics on the level set of
the momentum map for a mechanical system on Q = G × S .
We construct a volume form on G which is conserved under this dynamics
and show that the dynamics is WPPS.
Using these results, we analyze the controllability of a spacecraft with two
rotors and characterize its reachable set.