What Lies Beneath?

© John Sims
What Lies Beneath?
Three bullet points and a few words in the Amels document describing Ilona IV define, but severely understate, the dominating
role played by the helicopter facility and its realisation in this recent launch. Despite this, observing the yacht, one could easily be
unaware of the Helo within. Achieving that without compromising functionality was the challenge faced by owner’s team,
shipyard and Winel. Captain Tork Buckley goes on board to discover the latest developments from Amels.
“A big team slows down the (especially decision-making) process.”
World cruising, Helo Ops and high volume communications were
the owner’s special criteria. Originally conceived as a 55-m, Ilona
IV grew from 62 to 74 m in the planning stages. Five shipyards
were offered the opportunity to bid. As might be expected, two of
the yards came out 30% higher than the other three, who were all
within 1 or 2% of each other. The basic approach was to ask for a
bid based on a GA and sketches, without a detailed spec. In
response the yards based their bid on previously successful specs.
Recent discussion on yard standards are perhaps redundant since
prices were so similar (at least in two bands) with five different
specs. Not only were the bid prices close, but the contract was
Background
The owner has had four Ilonas and has cruised them extensively.
This is also the fourth one he built, the first two were Jack Hargrave
designs built in Australia. First a 22-m from Lloyds ships of
Brisbane, the second a 33.5-m built by NQEA in Cairns, third was
the Ed Dubois-designed 45-m constructed by Pendennis and delivered in 1999. The same owner’s team that built Ilona III built Ilona
IV: Mike & Diane Ebsworth (owner’s rep) Justin Redman (interior
designer on III interior and exterior on IV) and (stolen from
Pendennis at the end of the Ilona III build) Arne Erdbeer (asst
owner’s rep and project engineer). That was the whole team until
crew were recruited and brought to the project. Mike observed,
THE YACHT REPORT
101
MY ILONA IV
THE YACHT REPORT
102
MY ILONA IV
Ilona IV. This was in contrast to the previous build where the Class
society would not budge from a calculation producing a gross tonnage of 509 gt; this, Mike understated, was “a little inconvenient
from a regulatory standpoint”. Amels “was lucky enough” (?) to
build the first MCA LY-1 compliant yacht Tigre d’Or, now Teddy.
Frank said the yard regards MCA and Class part of a co-operative
venture who will generally “OK things if common sense is applied”,
though adds each surveyor has his own ‘sticking points’, and “on
this project we needed extensive discussion between our designers MCA and LR”. I asked what he thought of the oft-stated theory that the best way to prevail is to present MCA with an (already
built) fait accompli that will pressure them into acceptance. “No,
for us presenting the idea and arguments pre-work has always
been more successful.” Frank showed
great enthusiasm for the complexities
of the project, still contentedly describing it as “interesting” even when I
reminded him “may you live in interesting times” is a Chinese curse!
completed with only 1.5% cost variation to contract. Mike told me
the majority of these VTCs represented extra cost due to new
types of equipment such as plasma TVs. The owner wanted a
Dutch build; Amels gained the contact based on being the best
Dutch yard in the appropriate price band. Mike added: “Also we
were getting on very well with Amels; they understood exactly what
we wanted and worked with us.”
The client’s decision was influenced by the yard’s 80-year history
and commercial background. Amels, in contrast to some
Netherlands yards, predicates its operation on subcontractors and
has done for all its yacht builds, while retaining a core of experience and knowledge in house. Again on choosing, Captain
Ebsworth said, “We liked the fact that they don’t seek catalogue
solutions”. Basing all operations on subcontract can be risky – not only must
yards control quality and timing, but
they must resist putting excessive time
or cost pressure on the subcontractor
as this will necessitate corner cutting
somewhere. Victor Caminada (Amels
yacht marketing & P.R.) stressed that
the relationship with the chosen subcontractors is a long-term one designed
to fulfil the profit needs of both, not the
‘bleed ’em dry and leave a husk’
approach sometimes encountered.
Quality local subcontractors were sufficiently so busy that no one company
could guarantee to do Ilona IV’s superstructure in the time required; the result
was that three separate aluminium subcontractors worked on it
without getting in each other’s way or compromising quality. Being
responsible for the Helo lift and platform and other ‘doors’, Winel
was probably the subcontractor which lost the most sleep and tore
out the most hair. Mike is obviously and justifiably content with their
achievement. I asked if he thought Winel would love or hate Ilona
IV for presenting them with “their greatest ever technical challenge”. He joked, “The workers probably loved us, but I expect the
management and accountants hated us.”
Key to efficient project management and control on the shipyard
side was the utilisation of Vuyk Engineering of Rotterdam, which
produced intensely detailed 2D and 3D constructional plans of the
vessel. When piping, often the diagram is a ‘guide’ given to an
experienced worker who then uses his skill and knowledge to turn
that diagram into reality. The diagram is then corrected to ‘as built’.
Not here. The plans reflect exactly what was done on the vessel
(with very minor variations).
Was this useful in increasing the bid costing accuracy, I asked
Frank Veltman Amels’ Project Engineer: “Unfortunately not. These
are too expensive to produce pre-contract, but they will certainly
aid the accuracy of future costing.”
An offshoot is that from these drawings a large and detailed database is created of all the build components addressing a topical
concern about documentation of new-builds. This is the first time
Amels have taken building drawings to this extent though I suspect
such will feature more and more on their and other yards’ future
projects. This is reminiscent of Vripack’s approach of extremely
detailed definition of all aspects of construction to allow (theoretical) consistency regardless of whether the yacht is built China,
Holland or Turkey.
Regulatory compliance (MCA and LR) proved little problem on
On Time, On Budget
I asked Mike about time and budget.
“We were on budget”, was his reply. The
yacht was two months late and all profited from the fact that the owner did not
need the yacht between his Xmas maiden cruise and the Med season to tweak
equipment, operational issues and complete warranty work. All aspects, including the Helo lift, worked when the yacht
departed before Xmas, but fine tuning was required, though Mike
has little concern over the lift’s longevity in use. “It’s pretty heavily,
even over-, engineered.”
Lateness is a fact that I sensed did not cause major concern on the
owner’s team; aspects of this build are extremely complex, even
unique. Of the Helo lift Arne said, “We gave them a complex task,
perhaps we underestimated how complex.” The helicopter lifting
system was in fact built twice. The first version simply wasn’t going
to work and so had to be re-designed as the completion date
neared and it became clear it could not be complied with. Inevitably
other contractors, knowing this, reduced the pressure to complete
on time. “Why bother? It’s not going to be on time because of the
Helo lift.”
The yacht was also repainted under warranty, as the ‘out the box’
finish was not acceptable. Victor Caminada told me Amels recognises the challenge paint application represents and is working on
improving future quality. Despite such efforts, problems of less
than perfect paint finishes at handover will be a continuing problem on some builds – not just for Amels but for all yards.
Discussing this with Mike we concurred, the ‘delivered’ paintjob
should, in an ideal world, be only that. The ‘final finish’ will then be
the result of a repaint incorporated into the contract price carried
out after a period in use. There are sound technical reasons for
this as well as the self-evident necessity to carry out exclusively
painting work in the right environment for a great finish. Two factors make this unlikely to happen: resistance on the owner’s team
to accept (even on an agreed temporary basis) a sub-standard finish and a lack of standards which could objectively define words
like ‘great, good and ok’. Another factor Mike raised is the risk
that an applicator may not put maximum effort into the prehandover paintjob if he knows that it will soon be repainted.
THE YACHT REPORT
103
MY ILONA IV
about 3 x 3 x 11 m. Even at 73.69 m LOA this caused some difficulty; the open area of the deck was shorter than the Helo and platform. A straight lift would have required 76-m LOA; even if this had
been financially appropriate it would have delayed completion. It
was in engineering a solution to this that the greatest difficulties
lay. The solution is simple in concept: put the aircraft on a platform
that goes below decks the way your foot goes into a shoe. The
execution required a very complex structure – 10 opening rams,
eight elevating rams and PLC-based control.
Winel took overall responsibility for this; they built the structures
and sourced and integrated solutions from Stevens Engineering
(movement), Hydrosta (hydraulics) and MD Engineering (digital
design and engineering). Compounding the difficulty, CAP 437
requires that nothing must ‘stick up’ higher than 250 mm on three
sides of the landing ‘deck’. Thus either the platform is at deck level
and the bulwarks fold down or the platform must be elevated above
the deck. Given the already excessive mechanisms and hydraulics
here the latter was the only valid solution.
The aft end of the Helo platform elevates to 250, moves backwards until the front of the platform with Helo is clear of the main
deck overhang, then continues until horizontal and less than 250
mm below the cap rails. This is a continuous fluid process, using
numerous checks and interlocks to prevent it from tearing itself
apart. Once horizontal, the two parts of the lid (which have already
opened past 1800) close and lock to the centre section; simple!
The first version using cable, slides and rams had too much fric-
Helo Ops
“Once you’ve had one on board you’ll wonder how you ever did
without,” was Mike opinion of Helo Ops and “essential to the
owner’s use . . . in effect, another tender.”
Ilona III carried a helicopter on the upper deck and used it extensively; unfortunately, because the yacht was covering 25,000
miles per year on arrival in Europe, in 2000 the aircraft was pretty much FUBAR. Mike told me, “You can’t avoid taking seawater
over the decks in, for example, the Indian Ocean, and Helos hate
seawater.” So on Ilona IV the Helo would need a hangar. Belowdecks hangars are not new; over 10 years earlier Amels built one
into Maupiti. They are not new in the industry either: Royal van
Lent’s project 790, due for handover this July, has one in the
bow. Unfortunately, on Ilona IV the requirements were so different; experience gained building Maupiti did not really help.
Maupiti resembles a small RSV, so has more than 25 m of open
flat deck beneath which the Helo could be stored and which
allows a straight lift
Ilona IV’s Helo-vater would be quite different. The owner’s team and
pilots Mark Robson and Norman Rough, with Amels, spec’d the area
based on the UK CAA CAP 437 document without using specialised
consultants. The MCA judged the Helo Deck as compliant but “not
for commercial operation”. Should the currently private-only yacht
ever charter the Helo could not be used for paying guests.
The aircraft is a Eurocopter Ecureuil (Squirrel) AS 355N with folding back rotors. It weighs a maximum of 2.6 tonnes and measures
THE YACHT REPORT
104
MY ILONA IV
approved refuelling facilities on the port
side, isolated drainage for spills as per
Code and a storage tank for 6,000 litres
for Jet A-1. This, from past experience, is a
season’s worth. “It’s really just kerosene,
but you’d have thought it was nuclear fuel,”
commented Mike on the response when
discussing carrying bunkers for a turbine
Helo. Fire Fighting is addressed in this area
with a fixed foam installation: six foam
eductors, two fitted on deck during operation, two permanently fixed in the hangar
and two on hoses.
To restrict the effect of blade wash, Amels
found an innovative cross-application.
Fitted in the deckhead below the owner’s
aft deck are three transparent screens
that descend using the support pillars as
guides. These lexan roller shop shutters
are in segments each approx 20 cm high.
Frank asked: “Why build or reinvent an
existing item? We simply verified that the
materials were of a suitable marine quality or had the manufacturer replace them
with such.”
tion and didn’t work, so a new one was
needed. The second system is able to
‘flop about (very gently), and that flexibility reduces friction to acceptable levels. To exacerbate the difficulty this
part of the v/l also contains fold-down
beaches, fold-up tender bay doors,
extendable beam launching system,
passerelle, capstans, transom door
watertight doors, and of course frames
and shell plating. (Frank explained:
“Think Swiss cheese”.) This area
caused much head scratching and agonising for designer, architects, regulators and Arne. The only real casualties
are the tender bays, which do contain
the very pretty tenders by Serenella
(Venice), but are really cramped; and
the passerelle, though having an
extremely clever deployment system, is
a little short. These are but minor criticisms.
In addition to bringing the Helo above
deck it was necessary to make that
area fit for landings, take-offs and other
procedures. Accordingly there are
THE YACHT REPORT
105
MY ILONA IV
THE YACHT REPORT
106
MY ILONA IV
hatch is a storage descending through two decks of Forepeak that
can accommodate inflated fenders and much else besides. There
is a fully approved gasoline and paint locker near the tender store.
Frank told me they had a great assistance from the owner’s small
team, and their input is evident in many details. The wing stations
fold out to ease docking; a flybridge steering station is provided
for areas like the Great Barrier reef; liferafts and Nav lights are concealed then deployed when required (this caused no MCA problems); for the lights a back-up ‘lamp on a board’ is carried; and for
the rafts a gravity deployed ramp and hydrostatic or manual
release from the bridge guarantee launching at up to 200 of
adverse heel.
Machinery is distributed through various technical spaces – the
idea being to keep the ER as an ER. For example, the bow thrust
room, normally empty except for the bow thruster, now contains
the main components of the freshwater system. Another unusual
feature, domestic cold water, is chilled to a specific temp rather
than allowing it to attain the ambient seawater temp. The Praxis
Alarm Monitoring and Control permits allows any crew cabin to be
the designated watchkeeping cabin and that role is confirmed by a
red light outside the door (!). The yacht has three elevators, one for
people; the others carry stores and food. These latter are, in fact,
more than dumb waiters, accommodating wheeled serving trolleys
of substantial size.
The luxury this space provides on a 1,500-gt 74-m yacht is exemplified by the owner’s deck: 33 x 11 m of exclusive space with
observation lounge and stateroom facing a private aft deck. This
stateroom has opening windows for sleeping comfort; an unusual
feature shared by the captain’s cabin and office, although here this
is for staying in touch with weather conditions. An indoor swimming
pool was planned for the tank deck, but this is a windowless space
and it would have been be too much like an isolation tank, so it
became a 14-seat cinema.
The pool is now a floating demountable one, designed by Nick
Bailey, designer of the London Eye carriages, engineered by Arne
and built by Stirling Reed. It can be attached to the yacht or
anchored a small distance off to provide secure swimming and,
using a floating sea deck, sunning.
It is easy to give insufficient credit to the designer in a technical
article and that’s unfair: this first combined interior/exterior commission for Redman produced a very good looking yacht with
restrained mahogany interior style, intelligent layout, elegant
exterior forms and subtle hull lines. On a practical level, his
knowledge of, and attention to, details coupled with communication skills using impromptu sketches were central to the efficient
completion of the project and clearly appreciated by both yard
and owner’s rep.
Aft Deck
Beyond Helo ops this is still a very busy area technically. There are
two teak decked platforms of about 15 m2, called the beaches,
that fold down for sunning, swimming or boarding tenders. The bulwark behind these is penetrated by three windows (more holes!) to
allow monitoring of young children using the beaches. The stowage
pocket is only 300 mm deep – a minimal cost in interior volume for
great recreational benefit. Two owner’s tenders (one closed, one
open) are stored just aft of here supported on electrically recessing chocks and deployed by beam cranes. The passerelle folds in
the middle then stores vertically, occupying a longitudinal space of
less than 2 m. Despite a plethora of things‘n’stuff aft, the yacht
conceals them while retaining its elegant proportions; she is more
attractive than yachts of similar size with high interior volume.
Justin Redman told me this was the owner’s intention: to give
attractive lines priority over volume. Amels even offered a free
extra one metre on the stern to simplify the Helo lift, but this was
rejected unless it “included 3 m of bow too” to maintain the handsome, existing, proportions. On the aesthetic importance of concealing the aircraft he told Justin, “I wouldn’t sit and relax in the
garage next to my car”.
What is the impact of this specialisation when one day the yacht is
offered for sale? Very little, in fact: the only unusual owner-specific
feature is the Helo-vater. If a future owner did not wish to have a
helicopter the area could be effectively and economically convert
to toy storage, decompression chamber, etc. The real impact is,
of course, financial. The cost to achieve this amazing system is
unlikely to be recoverable in the sale price. However, one must
assume that by the time the owner chooses to offer the yacht to
the market he will have profited (in pleasure terms) from the use of
this particular system. Then the extra cost is less important, as it
will have done its job of providing satisfaction. Perhaps, like fuel, it
may be seen as a type of consumable.
The rest
It is difficult to drag oneself away from the aft deck, but this is an
exceptional build in other areas too. Mike is proud of the fact that
this is a simple yacht in concept. That may sound bizarre in the
context of the Helo area, but the majority of systems are tried tested and indeed simple: fixed pitch props, conventional shaft line,
Caterpillar prime movers and so on.
The I.T. system, however, is sufficiently complex to require a dedicated I.T. engineer. It has the capability simultaneously to provide
video conferencing, on-all-the-time internet access and multiple
phone calls. The system is Vsat, using proprietary equipment and
pre-purchased commercial satellite time, not billed by the minute,
bit or packet. Usage speed is 128 kps when the owner is not on
board and 512 kps otherwise. If necessary, higher speeds can be
provided on an occasional basis. For high-volume use costs are
less per month, with greater functionality than comparative telephone and data services using Inmarsat. The system gives priority
to owner’s communications and unnecessary usage is simply
dropped if bandwidth limits are approached. This requires a large
3.6-m dome, which was originally to be mounted lower than
presently, but avoiding shadowing necessitated its current location, and looks better anyway.
Forward, covered by a massive clamshell door, and openable in
wind to F 6, is a garage storing a 6.5-m crew tender, MCA rescue
boat and jet skis. It also provides deck crew with a working area.
As befits a world traveller, considerable thought has gone into this
and other working areas. Aft of the chain locker below a hydraulic
One Happy Owner
The owner is very pleased. The brief winter cruise to Israel whetted his appetite for more extensive use; this will start in the Med
and after take the yacht through Australian, N.Z. and Pacific
waters. The cruise will take place without the head of his build
team. Mike Ebsworth handed over command of Ilona IV in mid June
to Captain Peter Oddie, resigning a position of 10 years. Now a
family man, he will concentrate on building, rather than running,
yachts; after some downtime he and Arne will doubtless be found
on yet another new build.
The owner, designer and Amels must be satisfied to have produced, in a co-operative and synergistic effort, one of the most
technically innovative and handsome yachts in recent years.
THE YACHT REPORT
107