Zinc-dependent Interaction between Dishevelled and the Drosophila

THE JOURNAL OF BIOLOGICAL CHEMISTRY
© 2002 by The American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Inc.
Vol. 277, No. 50, Issue of December 13, pp. 49019 –49026, 2002
Printed in U.S.A.
Zinc-dependent Interaction between Dishevelled and the Drosophila
Wnt Antagonist Naked Cuticle*
Received for publication, April 5, 2002, and in revised form, August 27, 2002
Published, JBC Papers in Press, September 26, 2002, DOI 10.1074/jbc.M203246200
Raphaël Rousset‡, Keith A. Wharton, Jr.§, Gregor Zimmermann¶, and Matthew P. Scott储
From the Departments of Developmental Biology and Genetics, Howard Hughes Medical Institute,
Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California 94305
During Drosophila development, the naked cuticle
(nkd) gene attenuates wingless/Wnt signaling through a
negative feedback loop mechanism. Fly and vertebrate
Nkd proteins contain a putative calcium-binding EFhand motif, the EFX domain, that interacts with the
basic/PDZ region of the Wnt signal transducer, dishevelled (Dsh). Here we show that Dsh binding by Drosophila Nkd in vitro is mediated by the EFX domain as well as
an adjacent C-terminal sequence. In vivo data suggest
that both of these regions contribute to the ability of
Nkd to antagonize Wnt signaling. Mutations in the Nkd
EF-hand designed to eliminate potential ion binding affected Nkd-Dsh interactions in the yeast two-hybrid assay but not in the glutathione S-transferase pull-down
assay. Addition of the chelating agent EDTA abolished
the in vitro Nkd-Dsh interaction. Surprisingly zinc, but
not calcium, was able to restore Nkd-Dsh binding, suggesting a zinc-mediated interaction. Calcium 45- and
zinc 65-blotting experiments show that Nkd is a zincbinding metalloprotein. The results further clarify how
Nkd may antagonize Wnt signaling via interaction with
Dsh, and identify a novel zinc-binding domain in Drosophila Nkd that collaborates with the conserved EFX
domain to bind Dsh.
The Wg1 signal transduction pathway regulates pattern formation during Drosophila development by controlling cell fate
determination and cell proliferation (reviewed in Ref. 1). Its
counterpart in vertebrates, the Wnt/␤-catenin signaling pathway, is critical in many aspects of development. Inappropriate
activation of Wnt-induced genes that are normally precisely
regulated can lead to diverse types of human cancer (reviewed
* The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the
payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked
“advertisement” in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to
indicate this fact.
‡ Supported by the Human Frontier Science Program and by the
Howard Hughes Medical Institute. Present address: Institute of Signaling, Developmental Biology & Cancer, Centre de Biochimie, UMR 6543,
CNRS, University of Nice, Parc Valrose, 06108 Nice Cedex 2, France.
§ Supported by National Institutes of Health Grant K08 HD 01164-06
and the Southwestern Medical Foundation. Present address: Depts. of
Pathology and Molecular Biology, University of Texas Southwestern
Medical School, 5323 Harry Hines Blvd., Dallas, TX 75390-9072.
¶ Supported by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute.
储 Investigator of the Howard Hughes Medical Institute. To whom
correspondence should be addressed. Tel.: 650-725-7680; Fax: 650-7257739; E-mail: [email protected].
1
The abbreviations used are: Wg, wingless; Dsh, dishevelled; Dvl,
dishevelled mammalian homologs; Arm, armadillo; Zw3/GSK3, zeste
white 3/glycogen-synthase kinase 3; CKII, casein kinase II; CKI, casein
kinase I; PP2C␣, protein phosphatase 2C␣; Stbm, strabismus; nkd,
naked cuticle; GST, glutathione S-transferase; da, daughterless; Ci,
cubitus interuptus.
This paper is available on line at http://www.jbc.org
in Ref. 2). The mechanisms by which Wnt signals are held in
check are therefore critical both to normal development and to
human disease.
Genetic and molecular analyses have identified evolutionarily conserved proteins that transmit the Wnt/␤-catenin signal.
Upon binding of Wnt to frizzled family receptors, Dsh or its
mammalian homologs (Dvl) become hyperphosphorylated (3,
4). In cells that are not exposed to Wnt, a multiprotein complex
promotes phosphorylation and degradation of armadillo (Arm)/
␤-catenin via the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway (5). The complex includes the proteins Zw3/GSK3, adenomatous polyposis
coli, axin, and Arm/␤-catenin. Upon Wnt reception, Dsh transmits a signal that inhibits the activity of the complex, thereby
allowing hypophosphorylated Arm/␤-catenin to accumulate by
escaping the degradation machinery. Arm/␤-catenin then
translocates to the nucleus, where it activates transcription of
Wnt target genes through its association with transcription
factors of the Lef/Tcf family (6, 7).
In addition to Wnt/␤-catenin signaling, Dsh functions in a
distinct signal transduction pathway that mediates planar cell
polarity (8). This pathway coordinates epithelial morphogenesis in fly and vertebrate development, and involves proteins
downstream of Dsh that are distinct from the Wnt/␤-catenin
pathway proteins. Several Dsh-binding proteins have been
identified. In Wnt/␤-catenin signaling, Dsh/Dvl was proposed
to contact the Arm/␤-catenin degradation complex via a direct
association with two GSK3-interacting proteins, axin and
Frat1 (9). Upon exposure to Wnt, the Dsh䡠axin䡠Frat䡠GSK3 complex dissociates, which may cause Arm/␤-catenin accumulation
(9). Biochemical purification of Dsh kinases from Drosophila
cell extracts led to the identification of CKII and PAR-1 as
additional binding partners of Dsh (10, 11). CKII also interacts
with the Dvl proteins in mammalian cells (12). CKII and PAR-1
are able to phosphorylate Dsh/Dvl. Studies using Xenopus and
Caenorhabditis elegans showed that the CKI family of protein
kinases are positive effectors of Wnt signaling (13–15). They
can phosphorylate Dsh and directly interact with the Dsh PDZ
domain. Three additional proteins, PP2C␣, Idax, and Stbm,
associate with the PDZ domain of Dvl (16 –18). PP2C␣ also
interacts with axin and activates Wnt signaling by dephosphorylating axin (16). In contrast, Idax and Stbm are negative
regulators of the Wnt/␤-catenin pathway (17, 18).
The roles of Wg and its signal transduction system have been
particularly well studied in the context of Drosophila embryonic segmentation (1). We previously reported the identification of the segment polarity gene nkd and showed that Nkd
acts in a negative feedback loop to restrict Wg activity in the
embryo (19). Nkd acts at the level of Dsh through a direct
interaction with the central region of Dsh that includes a sequence rich in basic residues and the adjacent PDZ domain
(20).
Nkd is a novel protein that includes a single putative Ca2⫹
49019
49020
Metal-dependent Interaction in the Wingless Pathway
binding motif of the EF-hand family. The activities of many
EF-hand proteins are sensitive to, and regulated by, changes in
intracellular Ca2⫹ concentration (reviewed in Ref. 21). We and
others recently described vertebrate EF-hand-containing proteins related to Drosophila Nkd that also bind Dsh/Dvl proteins
and can block Wnt signals (22, 23). The conservation of the
EF-hand motif in fly and vertebrate Nkd proteins suggests a
role for Ca2⫹ or other divalent cations in Nkd-mediated regulation of Wnt pathway activity. To test this hypothesis, we
defined domains in Drosophila Nkd responsible for binding
Dsh and antagonizing Wg signaling, and we investigated the
possible role of divalent cations in the interaction between the
two proteins.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
Plasmids—The nkd plasmids used for the yeast two-hybrid assay
were constructed using pAS2 or pAS2–1 vectors (Clontech). The deletion mutants were generated either by restriction digestion using convenient restriction sites within the nkd cDNA, or by PCR. They correspond to: aa 293–928 (pAS2-nkd BamC), aa 1–178 (pAS2-1-nkd NR1),
aa 1–294 (pAS2-nkd NBam), aa 177–372 (pAS2-1-nkd R1S), aa 177–294
(pAS2-1-nkd EFXY), aa 177–253 (pAS2-1-nkd EFX), aa 177–226 (pAS21-nkd EF), aa 227–253 (pAS2-1-nkd X), and aa 227–372 (pAS2-1-nkd
XS). PCR fragments containing the point mutations D201A and D213V
were inserted into the internal EcoRI/BamHI sites of the pAS2-1-nkd
plasmid. The wild-type dsh cDNA was subcloned into the pACT2 vector
(Clontech). For the GST pull-down assays, both wild-type and mutant
nkd constructs (see above) were inserted into the pGEX-4T-1 vector
(Amersham Biosciences), except for the nkd R1S fragment, which was
subcloned into pGEX-2T (Amersham Biosciences). The plasmids pBluescript IIKS(⫹)-dshmyc and pGEX-4T-2-dshG6 have been described
elsewhere (3, 10). We used the plasmids pBluescript IIKS(⫹)-nkdmyc
containing wild-type or mutant (D210A or D213V) constructs for in
vitro translation. To generate the GST-bRecoverin fusion protein used
in the 45Ca-blotting assay, the open reading frame encoding the bovine
recoverin protein was amplified by PCR and inserted into pGEX-4T-1.
The plasmid pGEX-4T-2-Pmr1 EF was a generous gift from Dr. R. Rao
(24). To make pGEX-4T-1-CiZn, a DNA fragment corresponding to aa
458 – 637 of Ci was obtained by PCR and inserted into pGEX-4T-1. All
the constructs were verified by sequencing.
Yeast Two-hybrid Assay—Transformation of the yeast strain
PJ69-4A (25) was performed using a variation of the lithium acetate
method (Clontech). Yeast growth assay was achieved using the ADE
reporter gene present in the strain and medium containing or lacking
adenine. In this system, an interaction between two protein domains
being tested is indicated by growth in the absence of adenine because of
the expression of the reporter gene. As a control, growth was also tested
in the presence of adenine. Growth was evaluated between 3 and 4 days
at 30 °C. ␤-Galactosidase activity (using the LacZ reporter gene also
present in the strain) was measured as described by Clontech.
GST Pull-down Assay—Bacterial lysates containing the GST fusion
proteins were prepared as described by Amersham Biosciences, except
MTPBS buffer (150 mM NaCl, 12.5 mM Na2HPO4, 2.5 mM KH2PO4),
containing 1 mM Pefabloc SC, 5 mM dithiothreitol, and an antiprotease
mixture, was used instead of phosphate-buffered saline. The lysates
were bound to glutathione-Sepharose 4B beads for 30 min at room
temperature and washed four times, twice with MTPBS, 1% Triton
X-100 buffer and twice with DT80 buffer (20 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8, 80 mM
KCl, 0.25% Triton X-100). The beads were then incubated for 2 h at 4 °C
in the latter buffer (containing 1 mM Pefabloc SC and 1 mM dithiothreitol) with [35S]methionine-labeled Nkd or Dsh proteins, which were
produced using the TNT T7 coupled reticulocyte lysate system (Promega). The beads were washed four times with DT buffer (20 mM
Tris-HCl, pH 8, 0.25% Triton X-100, containing 80, 150, or 300 mM KCl)
and incubated with SDS-PAGE-loading buffer to elute the proteins.
Samples were run on SDS protein gels, which were then dried and
exposed on BioMax film (Kodak) or a PhosphorScreen (Amersham
Biosciences).
For the experiments corresponding to Figs. 3 and 4, GST pull-down
assays were performed as described above, with the following modifications. In Fig. 3, EDTA alone, EGTA alone, EDTA ⫹ MgCl2, or EDTA
⫹ LiCl were added to each buffer at the indicated concentrations. For
the experiments in Fig. 4, GST-Nkd R1S, once bound to glutathioneSepharose 4B beads, was washed twice for 5 min with MTPBS, 1%
Triton X-100 buffer containing 100 mM EDTA and twice with DT80
buffer containing ZnCl2, CaCl2, or MgCl2 at the indicated concentra-
tions. The subsequent steps (incubation with Dsh and final washes)
were also performed in the presence of ZnCl2, CaCl2, or MgCl2 at the
same concentrations. Calculation of Kd values and free concentration
of EDTA was performed using WEBMAXC v2.10 program (www.
stanford.edu/⬃cpatton/maxc.html) with the following values: temperature ⫽ 4 °C, pH 8.0, and ionic strength ⫽ 0.1.
nkd Rescue and Overexpression Assays—Fly transformations and
culture were performed according to standard methods. For the rescue
assay, a third chromosome P(mini w⫹, da-Gal4) insert was recombined
onto a nkd7E89 chromosome and balanced over TM3. For each experiment in Table I, da-Gal4, nkd7E89/TM3 females were crossed to UASX/UAS-X; nkd7H16/TM3 (where X is each mutant Nkd protein) males
at 25 °C, and embryos were scored according to previously described
criteria (19). Constructs NIN3 (aa 1– 447), NBam, and EFX were tagged
with a C-terminal GFP to determine relative accumulation in tissues.
Cuticle preparations were performed as previously described (19) and
images were collected by darkfield microscopy on a Zeiss Axioplan 2
microscope. For the overexpression assay, B119-Gal4 (on II) or A8-Gal4
(on X) females were crossed to chromosome II or III UAS-X/UAS-X or
balancer males at 29 °C, and progeny were scored on a Leica MZ12.5
dissecting scope and photographed using a Nikon Coolpix camera. For
sternite bristle counts, all bristles in abdominal segments A2–A6 of
gravid females were counted.
45
Ca-blotting Experiments—The 45Ca-blotting assay was performed
as described (26). Five ␮g of GST fusion proteins, purified as specified
above, were loaded on a SDS-polyacrylamide gel and transferred without SDS onto a nitrocellulose membrane for 1 h 15 min at 120 V (4 °C).
As a loading control, an identical gel was run in parallel and stained
with Coomassie Blue. The membrane was washed for 1 h at room
temperature with KMI buffer (60 mM KCl, 5 mM MgCl2, 10 mM imidazole-HCl, pH 6.8). The incubation with 45CaCl2 (PerkinElmer Life
Sciences) was then performed in the same buffer for 10 min at a
concentration of 1 ␮Ci/ml in 10 ml. The membrane was washed for 5
min in distilled water, dried, and exposed on BioMax film (Kodak). For
the 45Ca-blotting assay performed in the presence of Zn2⫹ (data not
shown), 50 or 500 ␮M ZnCl2 was added to KMI buffer.
65
Zn-blotting Experiments—We performed the 65Zn-blotting assay as
previously reported (27). Five ␮g of GST fusion proteins were purified
using glutathione-Sepharose 4B beads, run on SDS-polyacrylamide
gels, and incubated for 1 h at 37 °C in transfer buffer (25 mM Tris-HCl,
pH 8.3, 192 mM glycine, 0.1% SDS) containing 5% ␤-mercaptoethanol.
The reduced proteins were transferred onto a nitrocellulose membrane
for 1 h at 100 V (4 °C). The blot was washed for 1 h with 10 mM
Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, and subsequently incubated for 15 min in 10 ml of TK
buffer (10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 100 mM KCl) containing 5 ␮Ci of
65
ZnCl2. The membrane was then washed twice for 15 min with TK
buffer, dried, and exposed on BioMax film (Kodak).
RESULTS
Determination of Dsh-interacting Domains in Drosophila
Nkd—Dsh contains three conserved domains: DIX (also present in axin), PDZ, and DEP. Nkd interacts with the central
region of Dsh that includes a basic sequence and the PDZ
domain (20). In Nkd, the EFX domain, a 66-amino acid region
conserved between fly and vertebrate Nkd is sufficient to bind
Dsh in the yeast two-hybrid assay (Fig. 1A; Ref. 22). To further
investigate the role of the EF-hand, we tested Drosophila Nkd
deletion mutants in two different Dsh-binding assays, the yeast
two-hybrid and the GST pull-down. Mutant Nkd proteins that
lack the EF-hand do not interact with Dsh (constructs BamC,
NR1, and X), or only interact weakly (construct XS), indicating
that the putative Ca2⫹ binding motif of Nkd is important for
the association (Fig. 1). However, the EF-hand alone (construct
EF) does not bind Dsh (Fig. 1). In the GST pull-down assay, the
interaction between the Nkd EFX domain and Dsh is not as
robust as the interaction between full-length Nkd and Dsh (Fig.
1B), indicating that regions in Nkd other than EFX may contribute to the association with Dsh. The XS fragment by itself
binds weakly to Dsh, but the interaction becomes as strong as
the full-length Nkd protein when fragment XS is adjacent to
the EF-hand (R1S construct; Fig. 1B). Thus the EF-hand and
the XS fragment cooperate in the full-strength association with
Dsh. The R1S domain is also able to bind the central basic/PDZ
region of Dsh (data not shown).
Metal-dependent Interaction in the Wingless Pathway
FIG. 1. Dsh interacts with a region of Nkd that includes the
EF-hand motif. A, yeast two-hybrid interactions. Various deletion
mutants of Nkd, fused to the GAL4 DNA-binding domain (GB), were
tested for their ability to interact with Dsh fused to the activation
domain of GAL4 (GAD). Yeast colonies were grown on medium containing (⫹) or lacking (⫺) adenine (ADE) to assay the activity of the ADE
reporter gene present in the strain. B, in vitro interaction using the
GST pull-down assay. GST fusion proteins containing either full-length
Nkd (WT) or the indicated mutant forms were incubated with [35S]methionine-labeled Dsh. The eluates from the pellet (P), as well as 1/10 of
the supernatant (S), were analyzed by SDS-PAGE and subsequent
autoradiography. C, schematic representation of the Nkd deletion mutant constructs used in this paper, summarizing the binding results
obtained in yeast two-hybrid (Y2H) and GST pull-down (GST) assays,
along with the in vivo data obtained in rescue (RSC) and overexpression
(OVE) experiments. The EF-hand motif (EF) and the X sequence are
represented as gray boxes. ⫹⫹, positive interaction or full effect; ⫹,
partial effect; ⫹/⫺, weak interaction or weak effect; ⫺, no interaction or
no effect; blank, not tested.
The EF and XS Regions Contribute to Nkd Function in
Vivo—To determine which regions of Nkd are important for
biological activity, we constructed transgenic flies capable of
misexpressing mutant Nkd proteins. The da-Gal4 driver was
used to induce ubiquitous expression in strong class nkd7H16/
nkd7E89 embryos. Misexpression of full-length nkd cDNA rescued all or nearly all mutant cuticles to wild-type morphology
(Fig. 2A and Table I). Construct NIN3, a C-terminal deletion
that includes the EF-hand and the adjacent XS region (see Fig.
1C), partially rescued the cuticle abnormalities in nkd mutant
embryos (Fig. 2B and Table I). In contrast, constructs NBam,
R1S, NR1, and EFX had no activity in the rescue assay (Fig. 2,
C and D; Table I).
Cuticle rescue is a stringent assay for nkd function that may
not reveal partial activities of deleted Nkd proteins, perhaps
49021
FIG. 2. The EFX and adjacent regions are important for Drosophila Nkd activity in vivo. Representative examples of Nkd protein activity assayed in vivo by nkd mutant cuticle rescue (A–D) and by
effect on adult abdominal sternite bristle pattern when misexpressed
using B119-Gal4 (E–H). Anterior is to the left in all panels. A–D,
darkfield cuticle preparations. A, full-length Nkd protein restores the
wild-type segmentally repeated pattern of denticle bands and promotes
proper head skeleton involution (arrowhead) and posterior spiracle
elongation (arrow). The majority of nkd mutant cuticles rescued by
full-length Nkd protein are indistinguishable from wild type. B, construct NIN3 promotes spiracle elongation (arrow) and restores most of
the denticles but does not promote head skeleton involution (arrowhead). According to our cuticle scoring scale, this represents a “moderate” class nkd phenotype (cuticle scoring according to Ref. 19; see Table
I for quantitation of cuticle scoring). C and D, constructs NBam (C),
R1S, NR1 (D), and EFX did not rescue any aspect of the nkd cuticle
phenotype. These embryos resemble “strong” class nkd embryos, possessing none or only partial denticle bands, no spiracle elongation
(arrow), and fully exteriorized head skeleton (arrowhead). E–H, ventral
view of four segments of adult female abdomen showing segmentally
repeated sternite bristle clusters. E, full-length Nkd protein causes loss,
lateral displacement, and disorientation of abdominal sternite bristles
(see Table II for quantitation of bristle numbers). F, construct NIN3
routinely eliminates about half of the bristles. G, constructs NBam and
R1S produced subtle sternite bristle patterning abnormalities, including loss of hemisternite bristle clusters (arrow) and an overall reduction
of 8% of bristles (see Table II). H, constructs NR1 and EFX did not
routinely give rise to bristle abnormalities and transgenic flies were
thus indistinguishable from wild-type flies.
because of the narrow temporal requirement for nkd activity in
the early embryo (19, 28). When nkd expression is driven
post-embryonically in otherwise wild-type animals, a variety of
adult phenotypes that mimic loss of the wg gene arise, including wing to notum transformations and loss of halteres and
sternite bristles (19). To further explore the activity of the
mutant Nkd proteins, they were produced in the pupal abdomen using B119-Gal4 and the progeny were scored for the loss
of sternite bristles. Production of full-length Nkd resulted in
near total loss of sternite bristles with occasional residual
laterally displaced bristles (Fig. 2E and Table II; Ref. 19).
Construct NIN3 induced intermediate bristle phenotypes, typically resulting in loss of half of the bristles depending on the
transgenic line used (Fig. 2F and Table II). Construct NBam,
including the EFX domain but lacking the adjacent Dsh association sequence, produced adults with largely normal bristle
patterns and adults with subtle bristle pattern abnormalities,
49022
Metal-dependent Interaction in the Wingless Pathway
TABLE I
Genetic rescue of nkd7H16/nkd7E89 cuticle phenotype by wild-type and mutant Nkd proteins
Each UAS line was crossed (with the exception of NBam, which was recombined) onto a nkd7H16/TM3 background and crossed to da-Gal4,
nkd7E89/TM3. Data are presented as percent of cuticles that were scored as wild-type, weak, moderate, or strong phenotype. Cuticle scoring is
according to Ref. 19. Briefly, “strong” class cuticles are ⬍75% of wild-type length, have two or fewer complete denticle bands, and have exteriorized
head skeleton and noneverted spiracles. “Moderate” class cuticles have three or more complete denticle bands (usually in odd numbered abdominal
segments), a partially internalized head skeleton, and partially to fully everted spiracles. “Weak” class cuticles have focal denticle band loss. Cross
number 1 is the control. Each UAS, nkd stock was scored for maintenance of the strong nkd7H16/nkd7H16 phenotype prior to crossing to da-Gal4,
nkd7E89/TM3 (data not shown). UAS, nkd7E89 X da-Gal4, nkd7E89 crosses were performed for each UAS line and give comparable results (data not
shown).
Percent of embryos
Gross
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
da-Gal4,
da-Gal4,
da-Gal4,
da-Gal4,
da-Gal4,
da-Gal4,
da-Gal4,
da-Gal4,
nkd7E89/TM3
nkd7E89/TM3
nkd7E89/TM3
nkd7E89/TM3
nkd7E89/TM3
nkd7E89/TM3
nkd7E89/TM3
nkd7E89/TM3
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
UAS-lacZ; nkd7H16/TM3
UAS-Nkd; nkd7H16/TM3
UAS-NIN3; nkd7H16/TM3
UAS-NBam; nkd7H16/TM3
UAS-NR1; nkd7H16/TM3
UAS-R1S; nkd7H16/TM3
UAS-EFX; nkd7H16/TM3
UAS-Nkd-D201A; nkd7H16/TM3
TABLE II
B119-Gal4-induced sternite bristle loss by mutant Nkd proteins
Each independent transgenic UAS line was crossed to B119-Gal4 and
all stermite bristles (A2-A6) in female nonbalancer progeny were
counted. Results are shown as mean number of bristles per fly ⫾
standard deviation (S.D.) for 10 representative progeny flies. Despite
the fact that expression levels can vary greatly depending on chromosomal insertion site, the majority of UAS Nkd lines produced near
complete bristle loss (only two representative lines are shown), and all
NIN3 lines resulted in partial bristle loss. UAS-GFP is the control.
Genotype
No. transgenic lines
Mean No. bristles/fly
S.D.
UAS-Nkd
2
UAS-NIN3
4
UAS-NBam
4
UAS-NR1
5
UAS-R1S
4
UAS-EFX
3
UAS-GFP
1
0
5
55
12
39
32
89
83
81
92
79
96
143
97
82
79
83
86
89
99
88
90
84
0
2.4
10
6
7
9
9
5
7
5
7
7
11
6
6
4
3
3
2
3
3
2
3
most commonly loss of hemisternite bristle clusters (Fig. 2G).
Construct NR1 did not result in a loss of bristles; indeed three
of five transgenic lines appeared to have increased numbers of
bristles (Table II). To confirm the differential activities of
NIN3, NBam, and NR1, a more ubiquitous driver, A8-Gal4,
was used. Misexpression of NIN3 or NBam gives rise to
pharate adults that fail to hatch, with small wings, short legs,
and sternite bristle abnormalities, indicating that these constructs can antagonize Wg signaling when expressed at sufficient levels and duration (data not shown). In contrast, NR1
does not result in any wg-like phenotypes or pharate lethality.
In a manner similar to NBam, construct R1S induced subtle
bristle abnormalities when crossed to B119-Gal4, and pharate
lethality when crossed to A8-Gal4, whereas EFX did not produce any adult phenotypes with B119-Gal4 or A8-Gal4 (data
not shown). This differential activity between Nkd R1S and
Nkd EFX indicates that the region C-terminal of the EF-hand
n
Wild-type
Weak
Moderate
Strong
219
181
232
198
160
105
70
251
74
99
73
78
76
79
79
⬎99
0
0
⬍1
0
0
0
0
⬍1
0
0
15
0
0
0
0
0
26
1
11
22
24
21
21
0
that is necessary for full interaction with Dsh is important for
Nkd activity. Taken together, the in vivo data show that the
Dsh association sequences deduced from our binding studies
contribute to Nkd function, but regions further N- and Cterminal must also be important for full Nkd activity (see
summary Table in Fig. 1C).
Role of Divalent Cations in the Interaction between Nkd and
Dsh—The ability of EF-hand motifs to bind Ca2⫹, and sometimes Mg2⫹, is well established (21, 29, 30). We investigated
the potential role of ions in the Nkd-Dsh interaction. Chelators
of divalent cations were tested for their effects on the Nkd-Dsh
association, using the GST pull-down assay. In the presence of
the divalent cation chelator EDTA, full-length GST-Nkd or
GST-Nkd R1S fusion proteins lost their ability to bind Dsh
(Fig. 3A), indicating that EDTA titrated a cofactor essential for
binding. GST-Nkd R1S was chosen for further biochemical
study because it binds Dsh as strongly as full-length GST-Nkd
(Fig. 1) and its production in bacteria is more efficient (data not
shown).
The minimal concentration of EDTA required to completely
abolish the Nkd-Dsh interaction was 40 mM (data not shown)
and was employed in the following experiments. As a control,
increasing concentrations of divalent ions were used to presaturate EDTA and specifically inhibit its effect. The experiment shown in Fig. 3B was performed with MgCl2, but similar
results were obtained with CaCl2 or ZnCl2 (data not shown). 40
mM MgCl2 restored the interaction to the control level (Fig. 3B).
With lower concentrations of MgCl2 that did not fully saturate
EDTA, there was a corresponding decrease in the amount of
Dsh bound to Nkd (data not shown). In contrast, 40 mM LiCl,
which contributes monovalent ions unable to bind EDTA, did
not inhibit the effect of EDTA (Fig. 3B). Thus the action of
EDTA is specific and likely because of chelation of divalent ions
needed for the Nkd-Dsh interaction.
Another chelator, EGTA, was tested. In contrast to EDTA,
EGTA had no effect on the Nkd-Dsh interaction, even at concentrations as high as 100 mM (Fig. 3C). Therefore EGTA
cannot titrate away the divalent ion(s) required for the interaction of Nkd with Dsh, possibly because of a weaker affinity
for the ion(s). Under our assay conditions, dissociation constants (Kd) of EDTA and EGTA for Ca2⫹ are quite similar (4 ⫻
10⫺9 and 5 ⫻ 10⫺9; see “Experimental Procedures” for calculation), suggesting that Ca2⫹ is not the divalent ion necessary for
the interaction. Mg2⫹ and Zn2⫹, however, are good candidates,
as EDTA has 4 –5 orders of magnitude higher affinity for Mg2⫹
and Zn2⫹ than does EGTA: for Mg2⫹, Kd (EDTA) is 9 ⫻ 10⫺7
Metal-dependent Interaction in the Wingless Pathway
FIG. 3. EDTA, but not EGTA, abolishes the interaction between
Nkd and Dsh in GST pull-down assays. A, effect of EDTA (100 mM)
on the interaction between GST-Nkd or GST-Nkd R1S and 35S-Dsh. As
a control, the assay was also performed in the absence of EDTA (⫺). B,
saturation with MgCl2 (40 mM) eliminates the effect of EDTA (40 mM),
whereas addition of LiCl (40 mM) has no effect. In control assays (⫺),
GST alone was used instead of GST-Nkd R1S. The free concentration of
EDTA in the presence of 40 mM MgCl2 is 0.18 mM (see “Experimental
Procedures” for calculation). This concentration is not sufficient to
abolish the Nkd-Dsh interaction (data not shown). C, in contrast to
EDTA, EGTA (even at 100 mM) has no effect on the interaction between
Nkd and Dsh. P, pellet; S, 1/10th of the supernatant.
and Kd (EGTA) is 4 ⫻ 10⫺3; for Zn2⫹, Kd (EDTA) is 7 ⫻ 10⫺15
and Kd (EGTA) is 1 ⫻ 10⫺10.
Zn2⫹, but not Ca2⫹ or Mg2⫹, Is Able to Restore the Interaction
between Nkd and Dsh—GST pull-down assays were employed
to identify divalent ion(s) necessary for the interaction between
Nkd and Dsh. Instead of using EDTA throughout the experiment as above, we used it only to wash GST-Nkd R1S bound to
Sepharose beads prior to its incubation with Dsh in the presence of a variety of divalent cations. If no divalent ion is added
during the incubation with Dsh, the interaction between the
two proteins is greatly diminished (Fig. 4A; compare with Fig.
1A). Dsh is at no point exposed to an ion-free solution, and
encounters only residual EDTA if any. This result strongly
suggests that EDTA inhibits the interaction by affecting Nkd
and not Dsh. The addition of 40 ␮M ZnCl2 reestablished the
association (Fig. 4B), whereas addition of CaCl2 or MgCl2, even
at high concentrations, had no effect (Fig. 4, C and D). Therefore Zn2⫹, but not Ca2⫹ or Mg2⫹, can stimulate the Nkd-Dsh
association in vitro.
Other divalent ions of the transition metal series can substitute for Zn2⫹ in Zn2⫹-binding proteins (31). Cu2⫹, Cd2⫹, and
Co2⫹ compete for Zn2⫹ binding to superoxide dismutase or
carbonic anhydrase, whereas Fe2⫹ and Mn2⫹ are poor competitors (32). In agreement with these data, Cu2⫹, Cd2⫹, Co2⫹, as
well as Ni2⫹, restored the Nkd-Dsh association, whereas Fe2⫹
and Mn2⫹ had no effect (data not shown).
Role of Putative Ca2⫹-binding Residues in the Nkd EFhand—The EF-hand motifs adopt a helix-loop-helix structure
and bind Ca2⫹ via consensus amino acid residues present in the
loop (21, 33). Key residues that coordinate Ca2⫹ correspond to
loop positions 1, 3, 5, 7, and 12 and are often oxygen-donating
residues such as Asp, Glu, and Asn. In some EF-hand domains,
natural substitutions of loop residues have occurred that preclude ion binding. For example, in recoverin, a protein with
four EF-hands, only EF2 and EF3 bind Ca2⫹, whereas EF1 and
EF4 have loop residue substitutions that prevent Ca2⫹ binding
49023
FIG. 4. Zn2ⴙ-dependent interaction between Nkd and Dsh. A,
EDTA wash of GST-Nkd R1S is sufficient to impair its association with
35
S-Dsh. EDTA was only used in this initial wash, and not during the
next steps of the assay (see “Experimental Procedures”). B, addition of
40 ␮M ZnCl2 during the incubation with Dsh restores the interaction. In
contrast, addition of CaCl2 (C) or MgCl2 (D) has no effect, even at 50 or
500 ␮M.
(33). Both fly and vertebrate Nkd EF-hands possess consensus
loop residues compatible with ion binding (for alignment, see
Refs. 19 and 22). However, Drosophila Nkd has an unusual
pair of histidine residues at the apex of the loop that are not
present in other EF-hands or in the vertebrate Nkd proteins.
The roles of ion binding by many EF-hand proteins have
been probed by substituting nonoxygen donating residues in
loop positions 1 or 12, which eliminates or greatly reduces Ca2⫹
binding by EF-hand proteins troponin C and calmodulin (34,
35). We created two mutations in Drosophila Nkd EF-hand
that should prevent ion binding (if any) by individually changing the Asp residues at loop positions 1 and 12 into Ala and Val,
respectively. The mutant proteins, Nkd-D201A and NkdD213V, can both interact with Dsh in the yeast two-hybrid (Fig.
5A) and GST pull-down assays (Fig. 5B). However, in the yeast
two-hybrid assay the mutations decrease ␤-galactosidase reporter activity (Fig. 5A), despite comparable levels of wild-type
and mutant proteins (data not shown), suggesting a reduced
Nkd-Dsh binding affinity. In the context of the EFX domain
alone the point mutations eliminated the Dsh interaction in the
yeast two-hybrid assay (data not shown).
The yeast two-hybrid results suggest a role for the EF-hand
loop residues in Dsh binding, whereas the GST pull-down assay
reveals the contribution of an adjacent Nkd region in binding
Dsh as well as the unanticipated dependence of the interaction
on ions other than calcium. To investigate functional properties
of the EF-hand point mutant Nkd proteins, we misexpressed
them in Drosophila. In multiple independent transgenic lines,
UAS-Nkd-D213V and UAS-Nkd-D201A induced wg-like phenotypes as strongly as did wild-type Nkd (data not shown). Injection of Nkd-D213V and Nkd-D201A mRNA restored normal
denticle belt patterns to nkd mutant embryos (data not shown).
The Nkd-D201A result was confirmed using da-Gal4-mediated
rescue (Table I).
The EF-hand of Nkd Does Not Bind Ca2⫹ in 45Ca-blotting
Assays—The strict conservation of EF-hand loop residues with
potential oxygen-donating properties in Nkd proteins, coupled
with a requirement of those residues for efficient Dsh binding
49024
Metal-dependent Interaction in the Wingless Pathway
FIG. 5. Effect of Nkd EF-hand point mutations on the interaction with Dsh. A, yeast two-hybrid interactions. The point mutants
Nkd-D201A and Nkd-D213V fused to GB interact with GAD-Dsh (⫹),
but not with GAD alone (⫺). Parentheses designate the fraction of
␤-galactosidase activity in quantitative yeast two-hybrid assays relative to full-length Nkd (1.0). B, 35S-Nkd-D201A and 35S-Nkd-D213V
interact with the GST-Dsh G6 fragment (that includes the minimal
Nkd-binding domain we previously described in Ref. 20) as strongly as
wild-type (WT) 35S-Nkd.
in the yeast two-hybrid assay, suggested that Nkd may bind
Ca2⫹. We used a 45Ca-blotting technique to directly test this
possibility (26). Bacterially expressed proteins, purified using
GST affinity columns, were transferred onto a nitrocellulose
membrane after SDS-PAGE. The membrane was then incubated with 45CaCl2. The bovine protein recoverin, which contains 4 EF-hand motifs (GST-bRecoverin), as well as the single
EF-hand of the yeast protein Pmr1 (GST-Pmr1 EF; Ref. 24),
were loaded as positive controls (Fig. 6A, lanes 2 and 3). In
contrast to these controls, two different Nkd mutant proteins
that contain the EF-hand (GST-Nkd EFX and GST-Nkd R1S)
show no 45Ca2⫹ binding (Fig. 6A, lanes 4 and 5).
Nkd Is a Metalloprotein That Binds Zn2⫹—The zinc that
facilitates the Nkd-Dsh interaction is likely to influence Nkd,
which suggests that Nkd binds Zn2⫹. However, the primary
sequence of Nkd does not reveal any known consensus Zn2⫹binding motifs. We performed a 65Zn-blotting technique (27) to
show that Nkd was able to directly bind Zn2⫹ (Fig. 6, C and D).
The binding is mediated by the same Nkd R1S fragment (Fig.
6C, lane 2) that was sufficient for robust Dsh binding and
important for Nkd activity in vivo. Deletion of the EF-hand
(construct XS) does not abolish 65Zn2⫹ association (Fig. 6C,
lane 3), so a region distinct from the EF-hand binds Zn2⫹.
Expression of the GST-Nkd R1S fragment in bacteria gives rise
to two major products of 49 and 44 kDa that accumulate to
similar levels (Fig. 6D, lane 2). The larger protein has the
expected molecular weight of the full-length GST-Nkd R1S
fragment, whereas the smaller one is likely to be a partial
degradation product. The smaller fragment did not bind Zn2⫹
(Fig. 6C, lane 2), suggesting that at least one residue important
for Zn2⫹ coordination was missing. We used mass spectrometry
to determine the position of the cleavage site, and deduced a
loss of 39 amino acids from the C-terminal end of the Nkd R1S
fragment (data not shown). Only four of the 20 amino acids
found in proteins are known to participate in Zn2⫹ binding:
His, Cys, and to a lesser extent, Glu and Asp (31). Five His and
two Glu residues are missing in the smaller peptide, and thus
one or more of them may help to coordinate Zn2⫹. Taken
together, our results indicate that the Nkd XS region, which is
FIG. 6. Nkd binds Zn2ⴙ, but not Ca2ⴙ, in blotting assays. A, 45Ca
autoradiography. Lane 1, GST; lane 2, GST-bRecoverin; lane 3, GSTPmr1 EF; lane 4, GST-Nkd EFX; lane 5, GST-Nkd R1S. B, Coomassie
Blue-stained gel revealing the purified GST fusion proteins used for the
45
Ca-blotting assay. C, 65Zn autoradiography. Lane 1, GST-CiZn (positive control that contains the Zn2⫹ finger motif of the transcription
factor Ci); lane 2, GST-Nkd R1S; lane 3, GST-Nkd XS; lane 4, GST-Nkd
EFX. D, Coomassie Blue-stained gel showing the GST affinity purified
proteins used for the 65Zn-blotting assay.
located C-terminal of the EF-hand, mediates Zn2⫹ binding and
cooperates with the EF-hand domain to bind Dsh.
DISCUSSION
During Drosophila embryogenesis, nkd acts as a feedback
antagonist to regulate Wg signaling in epidermal segmentation
(19, 36). Nkd is a cytoplasmic EF-hand protein that binds to
Dsh and specifically regulates Dsh activity in vivo (19, 20). The
EFX domain, the central portion of which is similar to an
EF-hand, is the only domain clearly shared by fly and vertebrate Nkd proteins (22). That the fly or vertebrate EFX domain
can bind to the Dsh/Dvl proteins suggests that Dsh association
is an ancient feature of Nkd activity in regulating Wnt signaling (22). In the present study we show that a robust interaction
between Drosophila Nkd and Dsh requires, in addition to the
EFX domain, zinc-binding sequences that are located C-terminal of the EFX domain. This result was unexpected as Nkd
contains no consensus Zn2⫹-binding motif, but instead has a
putative Ca2⫹-binding EF-hand motif.
Role of the Nkd EF-hand—Nkd is rare among EF-hand
proteins because it contains a single EF-hand, whereas most
EF-hand-containing proteins have two to four of these motifs
side-by-side. Only a handful of the more than 1,000 predicted
EF-hands occur singly, including those in the PKD2 and the
yeast Ca2⫹/Mn2⫹-ATPase Pmr1 proteins (24, 37). Our data
show that the EF-hand sequence is the core of a conserved
domain that binds Dsh and contributes to Nkd activity in vivo.
Deletion of the EF-hand in mouse Nkd1 inhibits its ability to
antagonize Wnt signaling in cell culture (23). However, such a
mutant protein still co-immunoprecipitates with Dsh (23), suggesting that in vertebrates either regions distinct from the
Nkd1 EF-hand are also able to bind Dsh, or additional proteins
in a Nkd-Dsh complex are able to bridge the two proteins in the
absence of the Nkd1 EF-hand.
Role of Ca2⫹ in Nkd Function—Calcium binding to EF-hand
proteins can induce dramatic conformational changes, based
upon the three-dimensional structures of EF-hand proteins
such as recoverin in the presence and absence of Ca2⫹ (38, 39).
Metal-dependent Interaction in the Wingless Pathway
Mg2⫹ can substitute for Ca2⫹ in some EF-hand motifs under
physiological conditions, leading to the view that EF-hands are
actually Ca2⫹/Mg2⫹ exchange proteins (29, 30). EF-hand motifs
coordinate Ca2⫹ by positioning key oxygen donating (or H2O
binding) loop amino acid residues in a pentagonal bipyramid
conformation to match the electronic orbital configuration in
the Ca2⫹ ion. Fly and all four vertebrate Nkd proteins encode
amino acids of potential oxygen-donating character in each of
the six conserved loop positions.
Mutations in the Drosophila Nkd EF-hand loop residues that
were predicted to disrupt ion binding affected Nkd-Dsh interaction in the yeast two-hybrid assay but not in the GST pulldown assay. The yeast two-hybrid assay may be more sensitive
in detecting subtle changes in the ka and kd rate constants
induced by mutations because the consequence of an interaction is a discrete transcriptional activation event. Distinct results in each binding assay may hint at subtle features of the
Nkd-Dsh interaction. Although Nkd proteins harboring mutated EF-hand loop residues did not exhibit altered activity in
Drosophila, the assays involve overexpression that could mask
alterations in the affinity of a mutant Nkd protein for Dsh in
vivo. Indeed, a mouse Nkd1 protein harboring point mutations
analogous to ours attenuated, but did not eliminate, the ability
of an overproduced protein to antagonize Wnt signaling in cell
culture (23). Here three lines of evidence argue against a role
for Ca2⫹ in regulating Drosophila Nkd activity. First, the in
vitro Nkd-Dsh interaction, as well as Nkd activity in our in vivo
assay, were not disrupted by the putative ion coordinating
residue point mutations. Second, when inhibited by ion chelators, the Nkd-Dsh association was restored by Zn2⫹ but not by
Ca2⫹. Third, Nkd was unable to bind Ca2⫹ in a filter-binding
assay. Nkd may therefore be free of Ca2⫹ in vivo. The two
adjacent histidines in the Drosophila Nkd EF-hand loop replace a single amino acid typical of the EF-hand consensus
motif and might disrupt the Ca2⫹ binding configuration. Alternatively, the Nkd EF-hand might bind Ca2⫹ with a low affinity
or may require additional proteins or specific modifications to
coordinate Ca2⫹ (or Mg2⫹) efficiently.
Role for Zn2⫹ in Nkd Function—Our in vivo and in vitro
experiments suggest that a Zn2⫹-binding region C-terminal of
the EFX domain, included in constructs NIN3 and R1S, is
important for Nkd-Dsh association and Nkd activity. The in
vitro Nkd-Dsh interaction could be restored by zinc, suggesting
that zinc may regulate Nkd activity in vivo. How might zinc
perform this function? One possibility is that Zn2⫹ may modify
the overall conformation of the R1S region, allowing it to interact with Dsh. In the absence of Zn2⫹, the Dsh-binding regions of Nkd may adopt an alternate conformation that prevents Dsh association, or promotes association with other
protein(s).
The crystal structure of the psoriasin protein provides a
potentially analogous example of Zn2⫹-induced conformational
modifications (40). Psoriasin is a two EF-hand-containing protein of the S100 family that accumulates in keratinocytes of
psoriasis patients (41). The second EF-hand of psoriasin is a
canonical motif that strongly binds Ca2⫹, whereas the first one
lacks three amino acids in its loop compared with the consensus Ca2⫹-binding sequence, and cannot accommodate the ion.
The crystal structure of psoriasin reveals that Zn2⫹ binding
modifies the structure of the variant EF-hand causing it to
adopt the same conformation as the Ca2⫹-bound loop (40). In
our experiments addition of Zn2⫹ after EDTA treatment restored the Nkd-Dsh interaction, indicating that zinc binding by
Nkd is reversible. The Zn2⫹-binding region and the EF-hand
motif of Nkd are adjacent and cooperate in binding Dsh. By
analogy to psoriasin, Zn2⫹ binding to Nkd might induce a
49025
conformational modification of the EF-hand region that favors
interaction with Dsh. This raised the possibility that this Zn2⫹induced conformational change could promote Ca2⫹ coordination by the Nkd EF-hand. However, we were not able to detect
any 45Ca2⫹ binding in a 45Ca-blotting assay similar to that in
Fig. 6 performed in the presence of ZnCl2 (data not shown). As
in Nkd, residues of psoriasin that coordinate Zn2⫹ do not form
a classical Zn2⫹-binding motif. Instead psoriasin binds Zn2⫹
with a His-X-X-X-His sequence that is located about 50 amino
acids downstream of the variant EF-hand. This consensus is
not present in the Zn2⫹-binding domain of Nkd although it does
possess several His-rich sequences.
Much remains to be learned about Zn2⫹ homeostasis within
the cell. Specific transporters enforce strict control of intracellular Zn2⫹ concentration in eukaryotes (42, 43). In the context
of the whole organism, zinc accumulation is regulated in flies
by the malpighian tubules, an organ somewhat analogous to
vertebrate kidneys (44). The concentration of free Zn2⫹ may be
kept very low within the cell (45, 46). This has been recently
confirmed in Escherichia coli where there is no persistent pool
of free Zn2⫹ in the cytoplasm (47). Metallothionein plays an
important role in the regulation of zinc sequestration and distribution (46). At least 17 metallothionein proteins are present
in humans, whereas two have been identified in Drosophila.
They bind seven Zn2⫹ atoms in two clusters and are able to
supply the cation to target proteins in intermolecular reactions
(48). Similarly, delivery of Zn2⫹ to Nkd by a metallochaperone
might regulate the interaction between Nkd and Dsh.
Role of the Dsh PDZ Domain—PDZ domains are modular
structures that mediate protein-protein interactions (49). PDZcontaining proteins are often localized at cell junctions or are
associated with the inner surface of the cell membrane where
they promote the clustering of signal transduction components
(50). A four-amino acid consensus motif, usually located at the
C terminus of target proteins, binds in a groove present on one
face of the PDZ domain. A peptide library screen identified two
classes (I and II) of PDZ domains according to the specificity of
the peptide ligand-PDZ interaction (51). The PDZ domain of
Dsh has been classified as a class II domain that would be
predicted to show a preference for X-Phe/Tyr-X-Phe/Ala/ValCOOH peptides. PDZ domains also form dimers with other
PDZ domains by binding to non-terminal ␤-hairpin fingers (52,
53), or associate with LIM motifs or ankyrin and spectrin
repeats (54 –56). In each case, the PDZ domain is sufficient to
bind its targets.
The PDZ domain of Dsh mediates interaction with several
proteins, including CKI⑀, Frat1, PP2C␣, Idax, and Stbm (9, 13,
16 –18), although it is not known whether any of these proteins
bind in the groove. The Dsh PDZ domain is important, but not
sufficient, for the association with Nkd; an upstream region in
Dsh that contains a basic sequence is also required. Nkd may
bind in a unique way to the Dsh PDZ domain, perhaps as an
allosteric regulator. To our knowledge this is the first case of an
association between a PDZ domain and an EF-hand motif.
Structure determination of a Nkd䡠Dsh complex will help reveal
the molecular basis of this novel ion-sensitive interaction that
is critical for restraining Wnt signal transduction.
Acknowledgments—We thank Rajini Rao for providing pGEX-4T-2Pmr1 EF, Chris Patton for developing WEBMAXC v2.10, Shin-ichi
Yanagawa and Karl Willert for dsh constructs, Shar Waldrop for technical assistance, and Matt Fish for fly injections. We are grateful to
Wenlin Zeng and Judy Mack for nkd constructs, Karen Ho for the CiZn
construct, and to all of the members of the Scott lab for support and
encouragement. We also thank Jeff Axelrod and Roel Nusse for comments on the manuscript.
49026
Metal-dependent Interaction in the Wingless Pathway
REFERENCES
1. Cadigan, K. M., and Nusse, R. (1997) Genes Dev. 11, 3286 –3305
2. Polakis, P. (2000) Genes Dev. 14, 1837–1851
3. Yanagawa, S., van Leeuwen, F., Wodarz, A., Klingensmith, J., and Nusse, R.
(1995) Genes Dev. 9, 1087–1097
4. Lee, J. S., Ishimoto, A., and Yanagawa, S. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274,
21464 –21470
5. Aberle, H., Bauer, A., Stappert, J., Kispert, A., and Kemler, R. (1997) EMBO
J. 16, 3797–3804
6. Brunner, E., Peter, O., Schweizer, L., and Basler, K. (1997) Nature 385,
829 – 833
7. van de Wetering, M., Cavallo, R., Dooijes, D., van Beest, M., van Es, J.,
Loureiro, J., Ypma, A., Hursh, D., Jones, T., Bejsovec, A., Peifer, M., Mortin,
M., and Clevers, H. (1997) Cell 88, 789 –799
8. Bray, S. (2000) Curr. Biol. 10, R155–R158
9. Li, L., Yuan, H., Weaver, C. D., Mao, J., Farr, G. H., 3rd, Sussman, D. J.,
Jonkers, J., Kimelman, D., and Wu, D. (1999) EMBO J. 18, 4233– 4240
10. Willert, K., Brink, M., Wodarz, A., Varmus, H., and Nusse, R. (1997) EMBO J.
16, 3089 –3096
11. Sun, T. Q., Lu, B., Feng, J. J., Reinhard, C., Jan, Y. N., Fantl, W. J., and
Williams, L. T. (2001) Nat. Cell Biol. 3, 628 – 636
12. Song, D. H., Sussman, D. J., and Seldin, D. C. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275,
23790 –23797
13. Peters, J. M., McKay, R. M., McKay, J. P., and Graff, J. M. (1999) Nature 401,
345–350
14. Sakanaka, C., Leong, P., Xu, L., Harrison, S. D., and Williams, L. T. (1999)
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 96, 12548 –12552
15. McKay, R. M., Peters, J. M., and Graff, J. M. (2001) Dev. Biol. 235, 388 –396
16. Strovel, E. T., Wu, D., and Sussman, D. J. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275,
2399 –2403
17. Hino, S., Kishida, S., Michiue, T., Fukui, A., Sakamoto, I., Takada, S.,
Asashima, M., and Kikuchi, A. (2001) Mol. Cell. Biol. 21, 330 –342
18. Park, M., and Moon, R. T. (2002) Nat. Cell Biol. 4, 20 –25
19. Zeng, W., Wharton, K. A., Jr., Mack, J. A., Wang, K., Gadbaw, M., Suyama, K.,
Klein, P. S., and Scott, M. P. (2000) Nature 403, 789 –795
20. Rousset, R., Mack, J. A., Wharton, K. A., Jr., Axelrod, J. D., Cadigan, K. M.,
Fish, M. P., Nusse, R., and Scott, M. P. (2001) Genes Dev. 15, 658 – 671
21. Ikura, M. (1996) Trends Biochem. Sci 21, 14 –17
22. Wharton, K. A., Jr., Zimmermann, G., Rousset, R., and Scott, M. P. (2001) Dev.
Biol. 234, 93–106
23. Yan, D., Wallingford, J. B., Sun, T. Q., Nelson, A. M., Sakanaka, C., Reinhard,
C., Harland, R. M., Fantl, W. J., and Williams, L. T. (2001) Proc. Natl. Acad.
Sci. U. S. A. 98, 3802–3807
24. Wei, Y., Marchi, V., Wang, R., and Rao, R. (1999) Biochemistry 38,
14534 –14541
25. James, P., Halladay, J., and Craig, E. A. (1996) Genetics 144, 1425–1436
26. Maruyama, K., Mikawa, T., and Ebashi, S. (1984) J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 95,
511–519
27. Mazen, A., Gradwohl, G., and de Murcia, G. (1988) Anal. Biochem. 172, 39 – 42
28. Dougan, S., and DiNardo, S. (1992) Nature 360, 347–350
29. Andersson, M., Malmendal, A., Linse, S., Ivarsson, I., Forsen, S., and
Svensson, L. A. (1997) Protein Sci. 6, 1139 –1147
30. Gribenko, A. V., and Makhatadze, G. I. (1998) J. Mol. Biol. 283, 679 – 694
31. Vallee, B. L., and Galdes, A. (1984) Adv. Enzymol. 56, 283– 430
32. Schiff, L. A., Nibert, M. L., and Fields, B. N. (1988) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
U. S. A. 85, 4195– 4199
33. Flaherty, K. M., Zozulya, S., Stryer, L., and McKay, D. B. (1993) Cell 75,
709 –716
34. Putkey, J. A., Sweeney, H. L., and Campbell, S. T. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264,
12370 –12378
35. Geiser, J. R., van Tuinen, D., Brockerhoff, S. E., Neff, M. M., and Davis, T. N.
(1991) Cell 65, 949 –959
36. Jürgens, G., Wieschaus, E., Nüsslein-Volhard, C., and Kluding, H. (1984)
Wilhelm Roux’s Arch. Dev. Biol. 193, 283–295
37. Mochizuki, T., Wu, G., Hayashi, T., Xenophontos, S. L., Veldhuisen, B., Saris,
J. J., Reynolds, D. M., Cai, Y., Gabow, P. A., Pierides, A., Kimberling, W. J.,
Breuning, M. H., Deltas, C. C., Peters, D. J., and Somlo, S. (1996) Science
272, 1339 –1342
38. Tanaka, T., Ames, J. B., Harvey, T. S., Stryer, L., and Ikura, M. (1995) Nature
376, 444 – 447
39. Ames, J. B., Ishima, R., Tanaka, T., Gordon, J. I., Stryer, L., and Ikura, M.
(1997) Nature 389, 198 –202
40. Brodersen, D. E., Nyborg, J., and Kjeldgaard, M. (1999) Biochemistry 38,
1695–1704
41. Celis, J. E., Cruger, D., Kiil, J., Lauridsen, J. B., Ratz, G., Basse, B., and Celis,
A. (1990) FEBS Lett. 262, 159 –164
42. Cuajungco, M. P., and Lees, G. J. (1997) Neurobiol. Dis. 4, 137–169
43. Radisky, D., and Kaplan, J. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 4481– 4484
44. Schofield, R. M., Postlethwait, J. H., and Lefevre, H. W. (1997) J. Exp. Biol.
200, 3235–3243
45. Vallee, B. L., and Falchuk, K. H. (1993) Physiol. Rev. 73, 79 –118
46. Maret, W. (2000) J. Nutr. 130, 1455S–1458S
47. Outten, C. E., and O’Halloran, T. V. (2001) Science 292, 2488 –2492
48. Maret, W., Larsen, K. S., and Vallee, B. L. (1997) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.
94, 2233–2237
49. Harrison, S. C. (1996) Cell 86, 341–343
50. Fanning, A. S., and Anderson, J. M. (1999) Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 11, 432– 439
51. Songyang, Z., Fanning, A. S., Fu, C., Xu, J., Marfatia, S. M., Chishti, A. H.,
Crompton, A., Chan, A. C., Anderson, J. M., and Cantley, L. C. (1997)
Science 275, 73–77
52. Hillier, B. J., Christopherson, K. S., Prehoda, K. E., Bredt, D. S., and Lim,
W. A. (1999) Science 284, 812– 815
53. Tochio, H., Zhang, Q., Mandal, P., Li, M., and Zhang, M. (1999) Nat. Struct.
Biol. 6, 417– 421
54. Cuppen, E., Gerrits, H., Pepers, B., Wieringa, B., and Hendriks, W. (1998) Mol.
Biol. Cell 9, 671– 683
55. Maekawa, K., Imagawa, N., Naito, A., Harada, S., Yoshie, O., and Takagi, S.
(1999) Biochem. J. 337, 179 –184
56. Xia, H., Winokur, S. T., Kuo, W. L., Altherr, M. R., and Bredt, D. S. (1997)
J. Cell Biol. 139, 507–515