KIT
to
ESSAY
u need
Debate
o
What y erfect essay
p
a
e
t
i
wr
Should Justin Bieber
Be Deported?
TOM GARRett
Two writers face off over the “bad boy” performer

www.scholastic.com/scope • MAY 2014
25
young celebrity acting out. Sure,
his fans are devastated. And the
editors of gossip websites are
thrilled to have a steady stream of
incriminating photos of Bieber to
excite their visitors.
But Bieber isn’t just another
young American star who has
gone off the rails. Because Bieber
is not American. Born and raised
in Canada, he is living and working
legally in America because he was
granted special permission to do so.
This is an incredible privilege
that hundreds of millions of people
around the world can only dream
of. How does Bieber express his
gratitude? By breaking our laws.
By endangering our citizens. By
setting an abysmal example for
the millions of American kids who
buy his music.
YES!
Just look at his smirking police
mug shot. The kid is a spoiled brat.
He shouldn’t simply be arrested.
He should be deported—that is,
kicked out of America for good.
It’s time for this brat to get the boot.
By FRANCES HANNAN
Since the time of the Pilgrims,
many people born in other
n the wee hours of the
without a valid driver’s license.
countries have dreamed of coming
morning on January 23,
When police pulled him over, he
to America to start new lives—and
residents of a peaceful Miami
was abusive and resisted arrest.
millions of them have. In fact, only
Beach neighborhood were
Two days later, police detained
descendants of Native Americans
awakened by the earsplitting
the same young man for allegedly
come from families that are not
sounds of a revving engine and
throwing eggs at a neighbor’s
originally from foreign lands.
screeching tires. A 19-year-old
house, causing $20,000 in damage.
At one time, anyone was allowed
This drunk-driving egg-thrower
to come to America. But beginning
man was drag racing a yellow
Lamborghini sports car, driving
is, of course, pop superstar Justin
in the early 1900s, our government
at NASCAR speeds through the
Bieber.
began to pass strict laws to limit
quiet residential neighborhood. He
was allegedly drunk and driving
26
Scholastic Scope • MAY 2014
In many ways, there’s nothing
special about yet another spoiled
the number of immigrants. Today,
a labyrinth of rules and policies
Miami-dade Corrections/REX/AP PHOTO
I
Dreams of America
makes it nearly impossible for
work in the U.S. on a permanent
of visa, including British soccer
most foreigners to live or work here
basis. They are families hoping to
champ David Beckham and South
legally for more than a few months
escape poverty. They are people
Korea’s “Gangnam Style” pop singer
at a time.
trying to escape war-torn lands like
Psy. But these visas are given to
Syria and Afghanistan. They are
only a limited number of people
people are on a waiting list for a
women seeking an education they
each year. Surely someone else
green card, the official document
can never receive in countries like
could put Bieber’s to better use.
that grants permission to live and
Pakistan or Saudi Arabia.
Currently, more than 4 million
It seems that lots of people
Most of these people will never
IMMIGRATION
BY THE NUMBERS
A green card is a ticket to a
new life in America. But it
isn’t easy to get.
agree. In January, a man in
get that permission.
Michigan posted a petition on the
Why can’t the U.S. just open its
White House’s website calling for
borders and welcome everyone in?
Bieber to be deported. In less than
One reason is that there may not be
a week, the petition had 100,000
enough resources. Schools, food,
signatures. By March, that number
water, fuel, housing, hospitals—
had risen to more than 270,000!
the demand for all of these would
484,072
people came to the
U.S. in 2012 with a
green card.
5
years is the average time
a legal immigrant has to
wait before applying to
become a citizen.
4,322,575
people are on the
waiting list for a green
card (as of November
2013).
SOURCes: U.S. Department of Homeland
Security; U.S. Department of State
It Should Be Legal
be overwhelming if our nation’s
Is it legally possible for Bieber to
population suddenly exploded.
be deported?
That’s one reason that the U.S.,
like most other countries, has laws
Deportation laws are vague,
about who can come here and how
but there is a clause that says a
long they can stay. Even those who
person can be deported for “moral
are fortunate enough to receive a
turpitude.” Usually, this refers
green card have to wait many years
to crimes committed with evil
to apply for citizenship.
intentions, like stealing. Crimes
that carry a sentence of a year
Which brings us back to Bieber.
or more can also be grounds for
Bieber’s Got Talent (Not)
deportation.
Bieber gets to live in the U.S.
But shouldn’t drunk driving
because of a special type of visa for
count as “moral turpitude”? After
people with phenomenal talent or
all, in 2012, more than 10,000
achievements, people who would
people died in drunk driving
make such a huge contribution
crashes, according to a report by
to the U.S. that we rush them
the National Highway Traffic Safety
to the front of the line. They are
Administration.
doctors who research cures for
The fact is, Justin Bieber is a
diseases, artists who dazzle us
guest in this country. It shouldn’t
with their creations, technology
matter how wealthy and successful
gurus who will help build the
he is. Destroying property and
next supercomputer. What has
putting people’s lives in danger isn’t
Bieber contributed besides a few
how a good guest behaves.
annoying songs?
It’s time to tell our guest that he
True, many celebs have this kind
has outstayed his welcome.
• 
www.scholastic.com/scope • MAY 2014
27
treatment just because he is rich
and famous.
But actually, he isn’t getting
special treatment. He isn’t even an
immigrant. Bieber has an O-1 work
visa, which is given to foreigners
with “extraordinary ability” in
science, the arts, education,
business, or athletics. These
visas bring talented people into
our country—baseball players,
scientists, and yes, entertainers
like Justin Bieber, one of the most
successful pop stars of all time. The
average person wanting to come to
the U.S. would never receive this
type of visa, so in no way is Bieber
NO!
taking up a spot that could be given
to some hardworking foreigner.
The fact is, sending Bieber back
to Canada wouldn’t make a bit of
difference in the life of someone
By Jane Bianchi
M
aybe you think Justin
Special Treatment? Nope
The controversy around Justin
Not Guilty
In the U.S., anyone who isn’t
a citizen can be deported for
committing certain serious crimes,
Bieber has turned into a
Bieber has raised a lot of questions
particularly crimes involving drugs,
monster. Maybe you’ve
about immigration. For millions
theft, and violence. But it’s also
stopped begging your
of people around the world,
true that a person is innocent until
parents for tickets to his concerts.
immigrating to the U.S. would
proven guilty. As of press time,
Or maybe you think he should
be a dream, a chance to start a
Bieber had been charged with
just go back to Canada, where he
new life in a country with good
crimes, not convicted of crimes.
was born.
education, good health care, and
Besides, Bieber can’t be deported—
job opportunities. But only a limited
not legally. Crimes that result in
one. After he was arrested for drunk
If so, you wouldn’t be the only
number of people are allowed to
deportation tend to be drug-related
driving last January, more than
immigrate here each year—and
or felonies, like murder and assault.
200,000 people signed a petition
some Americans are pointing to
But that doesn’t mean Bieber won’t
(which probably started out as a
this as a reason for Bieber to go. A
be held accountable for his actions.
joke) to deport him.
more deserving immigrant, they say,
If convicted, he may go to jail, pay
should take his place. These people
fines, or do community service.
But kicking Bieber out of the U.S.
would be ridiculous—and unfair.
28
Scholastic Scope • MAY 2014
think that Bieber is getting special
What would happen if Bieber
Kevin Mazur/WireImage
Kicking Justin Bieber out of the
United States would be ridiculous.
waiting for a green card.
were somehow deported? He would
be banned from the U.S., possibly
for life. If that happened, the U.S.
would miss out on a lot of money.
When Bieber packs a stadium, it
benefits the stadium owners and
What Do You Think?
Should Justin Bieber be deported? Find the
supporting evidence each author uses in her
argument. Write the information on the lines
below.
Yes
all the people employed to make
the concert happen. What’s more,
restaurants, hotels, taxi services,
and stores do more business when
big acts like Bieber come to town.
NO
Bye-bye, Bieber.
Let the Biebs stay.
1 He broke the law.
1
2
2
3
3
It’s Hard Being Famous
There is something else all the
Bieber haters need to remember:
Being famous is hard. Paparazzi
have been stalking Bieber since
he was 15. He is under enormous
pressure to hold on to his success.
And because of his fame, every little
thing he does is scrutinized by fans,
bloggers, journalists, and just about
everyone else. All that stress could
make any person crack.
That does not excuse Bieber’s
bad behavior, but he certainly isn’t
the only celeb to make mistakes.
The pressures of fame have caused
plenty of stars to act rebelliously,
particularly as they’ve transitioned
into adulthood. Think of stars like
Miley Cyrus, Britney Spears, and
Shia LaBeouf.
So enough is enough. Let’s hope
Bieber’s run-ins with the law will be
a wake-up call, and he will change
his ways. But his past mistakes are
hardly a reason to send him back to
•
Examine points on both sides of the debate—as
well as your own beliefS—and decide what you think. State
your opinion in one sentence below. This can become the thesis statement
for an argument essay.
Canada.
NOTE: Special thanks to Allan Wernick for
consulting on this article. Wernick is an
immigration law expert and the director of
the CUNY Citizenship Now! program, which
provides law services to individuals and families
on their path to U.S. citizenship.
Get this
activity
Online
take this Activity further! WRITE AN
essay using our Scope Template.
www.scholastic.com/scope
Scholastic Scope • APRIL
• MAY
26, 2010
2014
29