Limnol. Oceanogr., 26(6), 1981, 1074-1083 Circulation in Enewetak Atoll lagoon1 M. Atkinson,2 S. V. Smith,2 and E. D. Stroup Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology, University of Hawaii, Kaneohe 96744, and Department of Oceanography, University of Hawaii, Honolulu 96822 Abstract Currents at Enewetak Atoll, Marshall Islands, were measured on the reef margins, in the channels, and in the lagoon. Lagoon circulation is dominated by wind-driven downwind surface flow and an upwind middepth return flow. This wind-driven flow has the characteristics of an Ekman spiral in an enclosed sea. Lagoon flushing is accomplished primarily by surf-driven water input over the windward (eastern) reefs and southerly drift out the South Channel. Mean water residence time is 1 month, while water entering the northern portion of the atoll takes about 4 months to exit. Shallow lagoons of coral atolls have current patterns that are largely tidal (Gallagher et al. 1971; Henderson et al. 1978; Ludington 1979), whereas deep lagoons have circulation patterns that seem primarily wind-driven (von Arx 1948). von Arx’s model, typified by Bikini Atoll, Marshall Islands, conceptualizes deep-lagoon circulation using two basic patterns: a “primary circulation” and a “secondary circulation.” The primary circulation consists of wind-driven surface water moving downwind, sinking, and then returning upwind to the windward (eastern) side of the atoll lagoon as deep water. The secondary circulation consists of a horizontal recirculation of deep water. von Arx reported that the volume transport of the upwind-flowing deep current is greater than the volume transport of the downwind surface current and concluded that some of the deep water is upwelled in the eastern part of the lagoon, rejoining the surface current, while the remaining deep water recirculates in horizontal gyres. This recirculating deep water diverges at the lee edge of the windward reef, forming two counter-ro- t Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology Contribution 603. This research was supported by DOE contract EY-77-5-08-1529. Parts of the research were done under the auspices of the Mid-Pacific Marine Laboratory. * Present address: Department of Zoology, University of Western Australia, Nedlands WA 6009, Australia. tating bodies of water, the northern one moving counterclockwise and the southern clockwise, both appearing to follow the bathymetric contour of the lagoon basin. The conspicuous feature of von Arx’s model is the deep return flow from the leeward to the windward side of the atoll. This return flow connects the primary circulation with the secondary circulation. There has been little further research on deep atoll lagoon circulation since the investigations by von Arx. We recently completed a descriptive oceanographic study of the lagoon of Enewetak Atoll, Marshall Islands, and have arrived at a circulation model somewhat different from the model presented by von Arx. We here briefly describe our results and proposed model. Enewetak Atoll lies about 300 km due west of Bikini Atoll. Enewetak is somewhat larger than Bikini and has a more symmetrical, nearly circular shape (Fig. 1); its physical dimensions are listed in Table 1. These atolls lie in the North Equatorial Current, with mean westward flow in the range 25-50 cm * s-l. The presence of the island group adds much local complexity to the westward flow. The very shallow, O-2 m deep, atoll-perimeter reefs, with only a small number of gaps opening to the ocean, effectively isolate the wide interior lagoons from any significant direct influence of offshore ocean currents. The offshore surface layer is deep. At a station made by RV Horizon in October 1952 at 12”14.5’N, 164”50’E (about 100 km NW of Bikini) 1074 Enewetak I 162=‘E I 163O 1075 circulation 1 164O I I 165” 1660 -120 ENEWETAK 0 RONGELAP B’K’N’ 0 ./ Lc-( -’ AILINGINAE- -IIoN NORTHERN MARSHALL ISLANDS WOTHO, I I 165O 20’E NA@J 165”30’E BIKINI ATOLL IS. ENIRIt? IS. ENYU CHANNEL AlRtiKllJl IS. 0 6 km Fig. 1. Location channels. Smoothed of Encwetak and Bikini atolls. Individual bathymetry in meters; coral knolls omitted. the temperature at 73 m was only 0.3”C lower than that at 9 m. The deepest pass through the reef at Enewetak has maximum depth of 56.7 m, so normally only relatively uniform ocean surface water will enter as tidal inflow. The strong tidal current in this restricted pass also tends to mix away any slight vertical gradients that may be present. The major input to the lagoon is the surf-driven inflow over the shallow perimeter reef; this normally occurs over the eastern half of the atoll, which faces the prevailing tradewinds. This inflow consists of water from the upper few meters of the ocean. These considerations make it seem unlikely that the lagoon can ever contain anything cxcept uniform water, and we measured no perceptible stratification within the lagoon. We thank the various agencies and individuals on Enewetak Atoll for cooperation and assistance, the many technicians and volunteers for assistance in the maps show distribution of islands and field operation; V. Noshkin and R. Buddemeier for assistance, comments, and cooperation throughout the study; and several women for the use of sewing machines to make drogues. We particularly thank B. Gallagher and J. Capcron for comments on the manuscript. Methods Most of our current measurements in Encwetak lagoon were made during a smnmer period (July-August 1978) and a winter period (February-March 1979). Our data and observations, however, span the period from 1971 to 1979, during all seasons of the year. Measurements of current speed and direction were calculated from positions of current drogues (surface area, 5.2 m2; for design see Montgomery and Stroup 1962). Drogue positions were determined with a Del Nortc microwave trisponder system, accurate to _t3 m over a range of 20-25 km. Surface drogues were tracked for 2-6 h, with fixes 1076 Atkinson Table 1. Physical dimensions (from Emery et al. 1954). of Enewetak Atoll Area of atoll Total island area Height of islands Length of windward reef including islands Length of windward reef not including islands Length of total leeward reef et al. Atoll 1,015 km* 6.5 km2 4m 49 km 27 km 47 km Lagoon Area Volume Mean depth Max depth Sill depth Max length Max width Mean tide range Spring tide range 420.5 932 lo8 47.9 64.0 47.5 37 37 0.85 1.46 x km* m3 m m m km km m m o CURRENT METERS t DRIFT BOTTLES SOUTHCHANNEL Fig. 2. Approximate initial positions measurements over entire study period. of current Channels Deep Entrance Width Max depth Cross-sectional area 1.2 km 56.7 m 34,000 m* area 9.7 km 11-22 m 145,000 m* Southwest Passage Width Depth Cross-sectional area 4.2 km 1.8 m 9,000 m* South Channel Width Depth Cross-sectional every 30-45 min. Deep drogues were tracked for 2-10 days, with fixes l-2 times per day. The speed of water flow over the reef was measured with drift bottles and current meters. Fluorescein dye was also used to estimate the direction of flow on the perimeter of the atoll during ebbing and flooding tides. Since dye-bombs were deployed and observed from a helicopter, these perimeter measurements were virtually simultaneous; they provide estimates of flow direction, but not of speed. Currents in the Deep Entrance and the South Channel were measured with current drogues, a Bendix geomagnetic bidirectional ducted current meter, and fluorescein dye. The thickness of the surface layer and changes in the direction of water movement with depth were determined with fluorescein dye dispensers hung on a vertical line. The dispensers were 20-ml plastic vials with a pinhole in the side. Figure 2 shows the approximate positions of each type of current measurement during our investigation. Currents Cross-reef currents-Shallow currents across the reef margins of the atoll constitute significant exchange between the ocean and lagoon. The area of windward cross-reef currents is shown in Fig. 3 by horizontal lines along the eastern boundary of the atoll. Waves breaking on the windward reef create a raised sea surface on the ocean side of the reef, a phenomenon first described by Munk and Sargent (1948) for Bikini Atoll. The windward cross-reef currents flow downhill from this raised sea surface, across the reef flat to the lagoon. The strength of the flow therefore responds to surf height and tide height and not to local wind conditions. Water enters the lagoon approximately perpendicular to the reef front; we have not observed the windward cross-reef currents to reverse direction and dis- Enewetak charge water from the lagoon. The speed ranges from 10 to 150 cm * s-l, and the v01ume transport from 0.05 m3 * s-l per meter of reef front during low tide and low surf to about 1.5 I113* s-l *m-l during high tide and high surf. Over a l-week period in June 1971, an average value of 0.556 m3, s-‘. m-l was derived for a site immcdiately north of Japtan. This flow is equivalent to 6.6 x 10s m3 per tidal cycle across the entire windward reef. (This time interval, 12 h 25 min, is used throughout to facilitate comparisons of volume transports .) The area of leeward cross-reef currents is represented by vertical lines on Fig. 3. These currents are weak and do not flow in any well developed pattern. They flow to and from the lagoon and along the reef, but generally have a slow net oceanward drift. WC have estimated them to have a net outflow of 0.4 x lo* m3 per tidal cycle (i.e. about 6% of the inflow across the windward reefs). Channel currents-The current in the Deep Entrance (Fig. 3) has a maximum speed of about 80 cm. s-l and reverses with the tide. The slack period in the channel is no more than a few minutes. Velocity is nearly constant throughout the water column. Near maximum spring tide, using current meter data, we calculated a transport of 3.0 x 108 m3 per half tidal cycle each way through the channel. Surface and deep drogues placed in the channel on a flooding tide traveled several kilometers into the lagoon and then reversed direction on the ebbing tide. From our limited data we suggest that the net volume transport through the Deep Entrance is about zero over a tidal cycle. The South Channel (Fig. 3) has nearly continuous outflow. The surface water moves westward as wind drift, while water below 5 m moves southwest to south, depending on the tide condition. Current speeds range from 8 to 30 cm-s-l. The average outflow is 6.9 x lo* m3 per tidal cycle (105% of the calculated inflow over the windward reef). The Southwest Passage (Fig. 3) has a reversing current similar to that in the Deep Entrance, but that passage is much 1077 circulntion Fig. 3. Cross-reef currents See text for discussion. an d channel currents. smaller than the Deep Entrance (Table 1). Net flow through the channels of this passage has been incorporated into the net flow over the leeward reefs (0.4 x 10’ m” per tidal cycle). Lagoon currents-The central lagoon has surface, middepth, and deep flows, distinguishable by their characteristic speed and direction, We discovered the detailed vertical flow structure not from the drogue studies, but late in our investigation when we deployed vertical strings of dye dispensers. Consequently the characteristics of these flows are not well quantified. Although the central lagoon flow is vertically structured, the water column within the lagoon may bc considered to be of uniform density because of nearly isohaline and isothermal conditions. At-any time salinity varies by no more than about 0.2%0 (mean near varies by no 34.5%0), and temperature more than 0.5”C (annual range 27”-29°C). The general surface drift is downwind (Fig. 4). In the central lagoon drogues moved south, west, and north, appearing to respond to the wind direction of the previous 6-12 h. (Wind direction and speed were measured three times daily from Enewetak Island.) The speed of surf ace flow is about 2% of wind speed. The surface current moves in a layer that var- 1078 Atkinson Fig. 4. Lagoon surface currents from drogue data. Arrows represent smoothed drogue trajectories over varying lengths of time; they are not vectors. Some drogue runs were made during calm or variable wind. ies from 5 to 15 m thick. Downwind volume transport of the surface layer is about 9.2 x 108 m3 per tidal cycle. The middepth flow is generally northeastward, opposite to the surface flow, as shown by dye traces (Figs. 5,6). The middepth flow is observed between 10 and 30 m at speeds of 24 cm. s-l (about half the surface speed). The volume transport is about 8.6 x 108 m3 per tidal cycleabout 93% of the surface-layer volume transport. Below 30 m the deep flow moves southward at l-2 cm. s-l (Figs. 6, 7). We followed drogues in this flow for up to 10 days. While the southerly movement of the drogues was consistent and predictable, there seemed to be a 6-12-h eastwest movement in apparent response to flow around lagoon pinnacles, tidal pumping, or both. The volume transport of the deep flow through a cross-section near the middle of the lagoon is about 2.2 x lo8 m3 per tidal cycle. The deeper flows are offset to the right (clockwise) from the shallower flows (Fig. 5a, b). From Runit Island to West Spit (Fig. 6), across the lagoon center, the current spirals to the right, forming the et al. eastward motion which we have called the middepth flow. The vertical spiral of Fig. 7 reveals the basic system: the surface flow (O-10 m) is westerly, and the middepth flow (lo30 m) is easterly during a period of winds from the east. The transition to the weak southerly deep flow varies with location (see below) and thus is not clearly shown in this summary figure. This vertical flow structure can be distorted by cross-reef currents, tidal currents near the channels (Figs. 5c, 6), and the boundaries of the lagoon. The lefthand spiral in Fig. 5c is an example of tidal current overwhelming the righthand open lagoon vertical flow structure. Along the central lagoonward margin of the windward reef, the current direction shifts with varying tide and surf conditions. The area near the northwestern leeward reef tends to be one of convergence. Little lagoon water escapes over the leeward reef, particularly when large surf, resulting from a northern swell, drives ocean water over this reef into the lagoon. We have often observed large aggregations of jellyfish as well as strong southwesterly flow along the lagoonward margin of the reef in this region, Water budget and residence time Table 2 summarizes the volume transports for the important components of the water budget. Transports do not sum to zero over a tidal cycle because the data were collected during different tide stages and were not forced to balance. Water flows into the lagoon from the windward reef, the Deep Entrance, and the Southwest Passage. The windward cross-reef current transports about twice as much water as the Deep Entrance current. It does not reverse as do the currents in the Deep Entrance and the Southwest Passage. Therefore, the flow over the windward reef represents the only significant net input of water into the lagoon (Table 2). The water flows out of the lagoon from the leeward reef, the Deep Entrance, the Atkinson 1080 et al. NE TRADES N A 0 km DEEP- WATER CURRENT (30-50 m) 6 Fig. 6. Vertical flow profiles using dye dispensers suspended on a vertical line. Arrow shows direction of flow and number at end of arrow gives depth in meters. Circled number is bottom depth in meters. Winds blew from the east when these measurements were made. the cumulative input over the windward reef increases from north to south, the southerly flow also increases. In the most elementary analysis, the average residence time of water in the lagoon is given by dividing the lagoon volume by the rate of water input. If approximately 30% of the ocean water entering the lagoon through the Deep Entrance exchanges with lagoon water-the percentage suggested by von Arx (1948) for exchange of passages and channels at Bikini-then the total rate of input is the influx along the windward reef plus 30% of the inflow through the Deep Entrance. When we use this total, the average residence time of water in the lagoon is 28 days. The contribution from the windward reef comprises 85% of the total inflow. Clearly there is a variation of actual residence time from one part of the lagoon to another, because water is introduced all along the windward reef but exits primarily through the South Channel, and there is no major north-south recirculation The residence time will be relatively long for water entering the 0 LA-J cm.s-I A D 0 0 l O-IO IO-20 20-30 30-40 40-50 m m m m m Fig. 7. Summary of drogue results. Shaded spiral represents approximate end points of flow vectors from the origin. north end of the lagoon and short for water entering the south end of the lagoon. The residence time of lagoon water based on flushing rates of transuranic radionuclides is about 4 months (V. Noshkin pers. comm.). This does not contradict our result of 1 month, since the sediment radionuclide activities are about two orders of magnitude higher in the north end of the lagoon than in the south (Nelson and Noshkin 1973). On the assumption that diffusion of these isotopes into the water is proportional to their concentration in the sediments, the northern lagoon water will be labeled preferentially, resulting in long apparent residence times for lagoon water. On the basis of our finding that most of the water entering over northern reefs (about a quarter of the total inflow) must transit the entire lagoon to exit from the South Channel, this water should have a residence time about four times longer than the residence time for water in the lagoon as a whole. Enewetak 1081 circulation Table 2. Water budget. Estimates of mean and range. “+” represents water flowing into lagoon, “-” represents water flowing out of lagoon. Cross-reef current estimates are based on average transport per meter of open reef front. Channel current estimates arc based on average speeds from all data, observations, and cross-sectional area. Lagoon wind-driven flows are based on averages of drogue data and maximum cross-sectional area at that depth. Volume Current Windward Leeward cross-reef cross-reef transport mean and (mngc) 1oR m* per 12.4 h +6.6 (+2.2 to t19.8) Continuous -0.4 Variable (slightly plus to -0.8) Deep Entrance Net = 0 (-1.0 m3 transport South Channel -6.9 Southwest Net = 0 (-0.2 m3 transport Passage Comments (-4.5 to +l.O) (3.0x1@ each way) to -8.5) Surface 9.2 (3 to 30) Middcpth 8.6 (unknown, but probably the same as surface) Deep 2.2 (unknown) Circulation The circulation of Enewetak Atoll lagoon can be explained as a response to three driving mechanisms: surf on the windward ocean reef, wind stress on the lagoon surface, and tides. Surf-The breaking waves on the windward reef drive water over the windward reef and into the lagoon on the eastern (prevailing windward) side of the atoll. The cross-reef currents and the currents behind the reef are therefore dependent on surf height and depth of water on the reef (O-2 m). This oceanic water spreads into the lagoon, moving downwind and mixing both vertically and horizontally. Since the South Channel is the only significant region of outflow, the water has a net transport to the south, increasing from north to south to accommodate water inflowing across the windward reef. Wind stress -The wind creates the downwind drift of surface water and the upwind drift of middepth water. The downwind drift of surface water and the shallow vertical current spiral (Fig. 7) resemble the pattern predicted by Ekman (1905) for an enclosed sea in Reversing; typical 80 cm *s-l Continuous tide to +0.2) (0.8x lOa each way) about inflow speed and direction Reversing; outflow; typical tidal currents pulsing O- with tidal currents Variable; function of wind speed Variable; function of wind speed Variable; function of wind and windward cross-reef speed input which the following conditions apply: impermeable, closed boundary; constant, unidirectional wind stress over the entire surface; homogeneous water; uniform depth; constant eddy viscosity. At Enewetak these conditions are only partially met. In particular, the lagoon rim is closed neither to leeward nor to windward (Table 2). In a fully enclosed sea, the Ekman flow integrated over depth is zero at every location. In a lagoon such as Enewetak this will not rigorously be the case, but the detailed effects of “leaky” boundaries and irregular bathymetry cannot be evaluated from our present data. We have observed similar current spirals in Kaneohe Bay, Hawaii, another “leaky” and irregular basin, and we suggest that these conditions do not impose severe constraints on Ekman’s model. These wind-driven currents at Enewetak are superimposed on the net flow of water toward the South Channel. The southerly flow can be directly observed only in the deep water, below the layers affected by the wind, and in the South Channel itself. Our deepest drogue deployments were Atkinson 1082 et al. riods of low inflow across the windward reef relative to downwind surface drift, a divergence may develop on the eastern side of the lagoon and force intermittent upwelling. Tides-The tidal currents directly influence the flow of water within several kilometers of the passes, especially in the southern part of the lagoon. These tidal currents can locally overwhelm the winddriven circulation, leading to such effects as the “left-handed” spiral observed within the lagoon 1 km north of Enewetak Island (Fig. 5~). 8-------___ --L 0 \B 0 0 0 0 0 27Oc 0 N ’ L IO 1 0 0 00 1 20 DISTANCE (km) 1 0 1 30 I S Fig. 8. Overall direction of drogues suspended at 38 m as a function of distance from north end of the atoll. at 38 m. At that depth in the north end of the lagoon, where the net southward transport of water is small (see above), the water moves northeastward as the middepth flow. In the south end of the lagoon, where the net southward transport of water is large (from the accumulated water input from the windward reef), a southerly drift is observed at the same depth. Figure 8 shows the change in direction of the 38-m flow with distance from the north end of the lagoon. Surface speeds are 5-20 cm- s-l, about 2% of wind speed. The surface drift is generally downwind and seems responsive to the wind direction of the previous 6-12 h. The speed of upwind flow at middepth is about half that of the surface layer. currents would The se wind-driven cause the lagoon surface water to turnover in 5-lo-days if there were no vertical mixing. von Arx (1948) estimated approximately the same time for turnover at Bikini. von Arx (1948), Munk et al. (1949), and Ford (1949) suggested that the surface water sinks in the western portion of the lagoon and upwells in a small band in the-eastern portion of the lagoon. We co uld find no direct evidence of this process at Enewetak. However, during pe- Discussion Our model for the circulation of Enewetak lagoon has similarities to the model proposed by von Arx for Bikini. In particular, both models show downwind surface flow and subsurface return flow. The deep circulation of our model seems different from that proposed by von Arx. We found deep flow moving southward and apparently escaping out the South Channel. He concluded that there was an upwind (eastward) deep flow (equivalent to both middepth and deep flows in our terminology) with transport greater than that of the downwind surface flow, and hence that there must be upwelling and deep water recirculation. In spite of the apparent discrepancy, we feel that both lagoons may be responding in fundamentally the same way. At Bikini, besides net outflow through the southwestern channels (von Arx 1948), we believe there is significant net outflow through the Enyu Channel near the eastern end of the atoll (recalculation of information given by von Arx 1948). This is also seen in surface radionuclide distribution (Noshkin et al. 1974) and distribution of indigenous zooplankton (Johnson 1949). In order to reach this exit (Enyu Channel) the deep water in Bikini Lagoon must move eastward. In Enewetak the only effective exit is at the southernmost part of the atoll, so the deep water must move southward. Note especially in our circulation model that the deep motion is primarily con- Enewetak trolled by the location of the major exit points from the lagoon. Water flow through other atoll lagoons stems to hc dominated by morphology and local wave and tide climate (Milliman 1967; Gallagher et al. 1971; Henderson et al. 1978; Ludington 1979). Studies of currents in other deep atoll lagoons would be valuable in testing our interpretation. Conclusions Windward and leeward cross-reef currents, channel currents, and tidal flow arc the major factors influencing the exchange of water between atoll lagoons and the surrounding ocean. Because these factors are specific to local wave climate, tidal conditions, and atoll morphology, atoll lagoons have widely vary.ing flushing characteristics. Wind-driven circulation, a pervasive feature of lagoons, contributes primarily to internal circulation rather than to flushing. Upwelling on the windward side of the lagoon may occur as a summation of the above phenomena but does not seem to be a generalizable feature of lagoon circulation. Deep water flow appears to orient itself toward the channels of net water output. References EKMAN, V. W. 1905. On the influence of the earth’s rotation on ocean currents. Arkiv Mat. Astron. Fysik 2(11): l-53. EMERY, K. O., J. I. TMCEY, JR., AND II. S. LADD. 1954. Bikini and nearby atolls. Part 1: Geology. Gcol. Surv. Prof. Pap. 260-A. FORD, W. L. 1949. Radiological and salinity rcla- 1083 circulation tionships in the water at Bikini Atoll. Trans. Am. Gcophys. Union 30: 46-54. GALLAGHER, B. S., K. M. SHIMADA, F. I. GON’ZALEZ, JR., AND E. D. STHOUP. 1971. Tides and currents in Fanning Atoll lagoon. Pac. Sci. 25: 191-20s. HENDERSON, R. S., P. L. JOKIEL, S. V. SMITH, AND J. G. GROVHOUC. 1978. Canton Atoll lagoon physiography and general oceanographic observations. Atoll Res. Bull. 221, p. 5-14. JOIINSON, M. W. 1949. Zooplankton as an index of water exchange between Bikini lagoon and the open sea. Trans. Am. Geophys. Union 30: 238244. LUDINGTON, C. A. 1979. Tidal modifications and associated circulation in a platform reef lagoon. Aust. J. Mar. Freshwater Res. 30: 425430. MILLIMAN, J. P. 1967. Carbonate sedimentation on IIogsty Reef, a Bahamian atoll. J. Sediment. Petrol. 37: 658-676. MONTOMERY, R. B., AND E. D. STROUP. 1962. Equatorial waters and currents at 15O”W in July-August, 1952. Johns Hopkins Oceanogr. Stud. 1. 205 p. MUNK, W. II., G. C. EWING, AND R. R. REVELI,E. 1949. Diffusion in Bikini lagoon. Trans. Am. Geophys. Union 30: 59-66. AND M. C. SARGENT. 1948. Adjustment of Bikini atoll to ocean waves. Trans. Am. Gcophys. Union 29: 855-860. Also U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Pap. 260-C. NELSON, V., AND V. E. NOSHKIN. 1973. Enewctak radiological survey NVO-140 v. 1, October 1973, p. 131-225. U.S. AEC, Las Vegas. NOSHKIN, V. E., K. M. WONG, R. J. EAGLE, AND C. GATROVSIS. 1974. Transuranics at Pacific Atolls 1. Concentrations in the waters at Enewetak and Bikini. Univ. Calif., Livermore Rep. 51612. 30 p. VON AHx, W. W. 1948, The circulation systems of Bikini and Rongelap lagoons. Trans. Am. Gcophys. Union 29: 861-870. Also U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Pap. 260-B, p. 265-273. Submitted: 7 March Accepted: 20 February 1980 1981
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz