(This interpretive master plan, part of a site-wide master plan that also includes recommendations for architecture, landscape architecture, and historic preservation, was completed in November 2004. Alice Parman, Ph.D., was part of an interdisciplinary team led by David Slusarenko of Slusarenko Architects, P.C. The client is Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society, Incline Village, Nevada.) 4.1 INTERPRETIVE MASTER PLAN 4.1.1 INTRODUCTION Thunderbird Lodge is the only historic house museum on Lake Tahoe’s Nevada shoreline. With a significant, visible, and contemporary story to tell, Thunderbird Lodge has already become a popular destination for tourists and local residents, and is poised to become one of the region’s leading attractions. Because of Lake Tahoe’s national and international renown, Thunderbird Lodge has the potential for much higher visibility, in the U.S. and worldwide. The remarkable state of preservation of both buildings and grounds offers a matchless opportunity for visitors to imagine the past. Restoration of the exterior and interior of the Old Lodge, as well as interpretive programming and media, will reinforce this time travel experience. Designed and built to the highest aesthetic standards, in a breathtaking setting, Thunderbird Lodge is one of North America’s most fascinating historic places. As the Lodge and its visionary creator become better known, Thunderbird Lodge will come into its own as a quintessential expression of the American sense of place. The mission, vision, and institutional values of Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society (TLPS) are at the heart of interpretive planning and programming for Thunderbird Lodge Historic Site. The Society is dedicated to preserving Thunderbird Lodge and the George Whittell Estate, while interpreting this remarkable resource in its Lake Tahoe context. The organization’s vision is to become a dynamic historic site that offers historical, cultural, and environmental education to a geographically broad and diverse audience. TLPS is committed to values of authenticity, stewardship, service, and sustainability. The organization serves as a resource to the Lake Tahoe region through historic preservation, environmental monitoring, and an active program of on-site and outreach education. 4.1.2 INSTITUTIONAL IDENTITY Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society is charged with preserving and interpreting a priceless historic resource. Together, the Board of Trustees and the staff have explored three very different options for fulfilling this challenging task: 4.1.2.1 Change the Function of the Facility Since the Society was founded, TLPS staff and board thought that the answer to maintaining the property was to realize income through events. A marketing program with this in mind brought in a steady flow of income; yet there were significant costs. The most serious expense was wear and tear to the buildings and grounds. This private home was designed for use bynumber a small of people; the house and grounds were built from fragile materials. Social events, usually involving alcohol, create conditions that make safety of both the resource and the guests a very real concern. In keeping with the TLPS mission of preservation and interpretation, Thunderbird Lodge is moving away from a focus on events, and toward an emphasis on educational tours and other interpretive programs. During tours and other educational programs, staff and volunteers continually supervise visitors. Tour routes and procedures maximize visitor and resource safety. TLPS still schedules a large number of rental events in the course of the year; a sizeable contingent of volunteers deploys throughout the grounds, monitoring and controlling guest behavior and whereabouts. As these policies show, TLPS is committed to preservation of an irreplaceable treasure, the Lodge and grounds. Within this overriding mandate, board and staff are equally committed to interpretation. They have considered two alternatives for conveying the story of Thunderbird Lodge. 4.1.2.2 Interpretive Option A: Interpret Change through Time Eccentric multi-millionaire George Whittell built Thunderbird Lodge in 1938, and lived there, off and on, for three decades until his death in 1969. Financier Jack Dreyfus bought the property in 1972. Although he spent little time at Lake Tahoe, Dreyfus left his mark on the Lodge. Working with a local architect, he built a sizeable addition, designed and furnished to 1980s tastes. The Dreyfus Addition radically altered George Whittell’s original vision of Thunderbird Lodge. Considered by many to be substandard in quality of both design and execution, the addition is nearly twice the size of the Old Lodge. Its dominating presence on the site is inescapable, and must be explained to visitors. Yet few members of the public would pay for a tour of this undistinguished building alone. Tour guides must explain the existence of the Dreyfus addition; but they know what visitors want to see and hear. Their interpretation focuses on Whittell––especially on the years when Whittell, still at the height of his powers, conceived and built the Lodge. 4.1.2.3 Interpretive Option B: Restore the Old Lodge to Its Period of Significance TLPS has established 1936-1940 as the primary period of significance of Thunderbird Lodge Historic Site. During these years George Whittell acquired most of Lake Tahoe’s eastern shoreline, supervised construction of the Lodge, and took up residency there. Whittell’s long involvement with Thunderbird Lodge and Lake Tahoe, from 1936 until his death in 1969, provides a secondary focus. Given this interpretive scope, the Dreyfus Addition becomes even more of an intrusion on visitors’ experience of the site. Whittell conceived and produced this magnificent estate, with the help of an outstanding regional architect and highly skilled craftspeople. Masterfully integrated with the lakeside landscape, Thunderbird Lodge was one of Lake Tahoe’s treasures. The Dreyfus Addition obscured the pleasing lines of the Old Lodge, throwing the ensemble out of kilter. This effect is especially pronounced when the buildings are viewed from the lake. In 2004, a series of focus groups and a board planning session reinforced the Society’s commitment to an authentic historic experience for visitors. An important consequence was a recommendation to deconstruct the Dreyfus Addition, now in need of costly repairs. This will restore the Old Lodge to its original modest footprint, and to its primary and secondary periods of significance. The consequences for interpretation will be momentous. Once again, the building’s architecture will harmonize with the lake’s grand scenery and with the wild, largely uncultivated look of the grounds. Visitors will be able to immerse themselves in the Thunderbird Lodge and the Lake Tahoe of George Whittell’s day. To realize the full potential of Thunderbird Lodge as an internationally significant historic site, restoration of the original architecture is a necessity. Unlike most of Nevada’s major museums, which are state-supported, Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society is a private nonprofit organization. This status offers distinct advantages in terms of institutional and financial independence. Within the inspiring guidelines of the Society’s mission and vision, board and staff can make full use of their leadership and entrepreneurial skills. Through creative on-site and outreach programming within a commitment to historic authenticity, TLPS has exceptional potential to reach audiences and build support––regionally, nationwide, and even internationally. Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society will engage a diverse, multiage audience with high-quality public history programming, grounded in respect for a unique and irreplaceable cultural resource. 4.1.3 CURRENT AND POTENTIAL AUDIENCES TLPS has operated a tour program since 2002, attracting some 10,000 people each th th year. About 1,000 of these visitors are school children, mostly 4 and 5 graders. The rest are mainly baby boomer couples, and intergenerational groups. About half of all visitors are from Nevada. The other 50 percent come from 23 different states and at least four foreign countries. Many are Californians––especially Bay Area residents. Rental events (such as weddings and corporate meetings) have drawn guests from throughout the U.S., and will continue to do so. Moving away from an event-based revenue generation approach to a new financial model based on mission-driven programming, TLPS will reach out to new categories of organized groups and individuals with potential interest in visiting Thunderbird Lodge. Among the leading target audiences are seniors and international visitors who tour the Tahoe region in commercial bus tour groups. As the only historic house museum on the lake’s eastern shore, Thunderbird Lodge is well-positioned to add a uniquely memorable dimension to a scenic and recreational excursion. To accommodate these visitors, TLPS will provide expanded restroom facilities and improved wheelchair access, as well as some multilingual services. Programming and marketing efforts will focus on two of Lake Tahoe’s most numerous tourist groups: skiers and gamblers. Other visitors with special interests include RVers, ecotourists, hikers and climbers, photographers, birders, and more. TLPS will actively market standard tours and higher-price, personalized tours to these potential visitors, through specialized publications and targeted web sites. These high-quality programs will draw national attention to the unique resources of Thunderbird Lodge. 4.1.4 GUIDING PRINCIPLES OF INTERPRETATION Interpretation is grounded in the mission, vision, values, and institutional identity of Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society. According to Freeman Tilden, author of Interpreting Our Heritage, the aim of interpretation is “to reveal meanings and relationships... rather than simply to communicate factual information.” Unlike the teaching and learning that take place in formal educational institutions like schools and colleges, interpretation is largely participatory and interactive. The educational experience at a historic site such as Thunderbird Lodge is concise, intense, focused, and very personal. Interpretation provokes attention and curiosity, relates concepts and facts to visitors' own lives, and reveals key messages in unforgettable ways. Making use of a variety of objects, experiences, and media, interpretive programs appeal to as many senses as possible. Interpretive activities seek to engage visitors intellectually, emotionally, and physically. Planning for accessibility improves the visitor experience for everyone. Interpretive offerings respond to the multiple intelligences, diverse learning styles, range of ages, and varied cultural and educational backgrounds of TLPS audience members. 4.1.5 TAKE-HOME MESSAGES AND INTERPRETIVE OBJECTIVES The first step in interpretation is to identify the most important take-home messages to be communicated to all visitors. Interpretive experiences, programs, and media will be designed so that visitors come away with three big ideas in mind: 1. This place is magic! 2. It’s important to preserve special places like Thunderbird Lodge and Lake Tahoe. 3. George Whittell may have had more money than sense, but because of him, most of Lake Tahoe’s east shoreline was preserved from development. These take-home messages provide the conceptual framework for organizing the visitor's experience of Thunderbird Lodge. Interpretive experiences focused on take-home messages are intended to influence visitors' understanding, attitudes, and behavior. We expect that after their visit, many museum visitors will: 4.1.6 want to learn more about Thunderbird Lodge, Lake Tahoe, and George Whittell. - Purchase a book or other learning resource - Participate in a TLPS education program or special event - Become a member of TLPS become more interested in and supportive of efforts to preserve Thunderbird Lodge and Lake Tahoe. - Become a donor remain involved with TLPS: - Make a return visit - Become a TLPS member - Volunteer time for TLPS - Support TLPS with a financial contribution - Encourage friends and family to visit Thunderbird Lodge A FRAMEWORK FOR INTERPRETATION The Old Lodge, outlying buildings, and the landscaped grounds constitute the Society’s most valuable interpretive assets. When restored to its period of primary significance, Thunderbird Lodge will offer a visitor experience that is rare in the United States. Sophisticated travelers are familiar with historic properties in Europe, where a visitor may explore the grounds, participate in a guided tour, and perhaps experience a nighttime sound and light presentation. Thunderbird Lodge offers comparable opportunities for a direct connection with the past. The primary period of significance for Thunderbird Lodge historic site is 1936-1940, with a secondary focus on 1936-1969. Design and construction of the lodge, George Whittell’s long residence there, and the consequences for Lake Tahoe are the most important storylines to be conveyed to all visitors. The multicultural backgrounds of people who built Thunderbird Lodge, George Whittell’s unintended but undeniable preservation of most of the lake’s eastern shore, and the eccentricities of a colorful (yet representative) individual are elements of an exceptional history lesson for people of all ages and backgrounds. Guided by the take-home messages and interpretive objectives outlined above, TLPS will convey the following themes and concepts in varied, mutually reinforcing combinations. Interpretation will be delivered through tours and other educational programs, graphic panels, and innovative, thoughtful media and methods. Information will be layered to encourage questioning, analysis, and discovery. Appealing introductory concepts and facts will engage history novices and first-time visitors; more in-depth ideas and experiences will stimulate and reward history buffs, area residents, and other more knowledgeable audiences. 4.1.6.1 Main Themes, Key Concepts and Facts Theme #1: George Whittell made a difference for Lake Tahoe. In all publicity, promotional literature, orientation programs, and introductory statements by tour guides and program leaders, TLPS emphasizes two key facts that place George Whittell at the heart of Lake Tahoe’s history: George Whittell built this extraordinary lodge with its outbuildings and grounds. He preserved the east shore of Lake Tahoe from development Theme #2: Who was George Whittell? As visitors tour the Old Lodge, outbuildings and grounds, they are invited to think like historians. Through observation and analysis, they begin to wonder, speculate, and ask questions about the man who created this extraordinary lakeside retreat. In continual dialogue with interpretive guides, visitors glean pertinent information and begin to form a mental picture of a complex and unusual person. These concepts and facts are linked to visitors’ direct experience of the site. Among the ideas that may emerge in any given interpretive program: • Financial acumen George Whittell was financially creative and astute. Whether on his own initiative or because of sound advice, he pulled his money out of the stock market in 1928, just ahead of the great stock market crash of 1929. His fortune in the 1930s would be worth billions in today’s dollars. At a time when most Americans were suffering the effects of the Great Depression, he bought a vast tract of land and created this high-quality, expensive estate. • Love of technology Even in an era that ballyhooed all things modern, Whittell was a man ahead of his time. He had a passionate interest in innovative technologies, from gadgets of all kinds to fast cars, boats, and planes. A high-school dropout, he was an autodidact with an intuitive grasp of mechanics and engineering. • Personal development George Whittell had a flamboyant, indomitable personality. A tall, strong, handsome redhead, he pursued women, gambling, and drinking with enthusiasm. He loved to drive the fastest and newest vehicles, and to employ the cutting-edge technologies of the day. As a teenager he decided against a conventional life, and began rebelling against his wealthy parents. He made the papers for daring rescues, during the 1906 California earthquake and later for a Lake Tahoe boat rescue. More often, journalists reported on Whittell’s exploits as a playboy, and his expensive tastes. Whittell served as an ambulance driver during World War I, managing to obtain a commission in the Italian army, and the lifelong rank of Captain. During this European sojourn he met the cultured, wealthy Frenchwoman who would become his wife. Whittell began his metamorphosis from youthful playboy into a more mature rugged individualist, a uniquely American type most characteristic of California and the West. George Whittell was in his fifties when he brought the Thunderbird Lodge project to fruition. Unlike the family estate in Woodside, California, which became his wife’s domain, the Tahoe property bears Whittell’s imprint. The Lodge’s understated architecture and interior décor, its rustic lines and materials, and its conveniences and arrangement appear suited to Whittell’s preferences and lifestyle. Thunderbird Lodge is Whittell’s legacy, along with the wild shorelines and hillsides along Lake Tahoe’s east side. In contrast to Whittell’s reputation as a playboy and a hedonist, the Lodge’s austere beauty reveals a more thoughtful side to his personality. Evidently, Whittell appreciated his surroundings. Rather than seek to dominate the landscape, he created a perfect architectural complement to an incomparable natural setting. In old age, Whittell became a recluse, spending more and more time at his Lake Tahoe retreat. He was in poor health, and lived essentially as an invalid, cared for by servants who indulged his every whim. Although he originally had planned to develop his lakeshore property, he came to value his peaceful solitude. Whether deliberately or as an afterthought, George Whittell was responsible for preserving Lake Tahoe’s eastern shore in its natural state. • Love of animals George Whittell’s deepest feelings were for animals. As a boy he spent time with a circus, where he learned to be comfortable around wild creatures. Guests at Thunderbird Lodge had to contend with Whittell’s pet lion, Bill. A baby elephant was lodged for a time in a specially constructed barn. During World War II, worried about the effect of rationing on his ability to feed his animals, Whittell donated them to a zoo. By the terms of his will (later the subject of much contestation), Whittell left his estate to the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, Audubon Society, and Defenders of Wildlife. Subtheme 2A: Family and love relationships helped to shape Whittell’s distinctive personality. As they learn more about George Whittell, visitors may become curious about the relationships that shaped his unusual personality. This level of information is more appropriate for in-depth programs, publications, and interpretive media than for introductory tours, although some points may arise in response to visitor questions. • His relationship to his family of origin Whittell’s paternal and maternal grandparents were self-made millionaires. When Whittell’s parents married, they united two of San Francisco’s largest family fortunes. George Whittell and his twin brother Nicholas were born to wealth. Nicholas Whittell died of diphtheria at age three, making George the sole heir. Although his brother’s death does not loom large in biographical studies of George Whittell, it seems likely that the early loss of a sibling profoundly influenced the surviving twin. (Visitors can be encouraged to imagine how this event may have shaped George Whittell’s character.) • Women in Whittell’s life Whittell defied his parents’ conventional expectations by marrying two different women from the demi-monde of entertainment. The first marriage, to chorus girl Florence Boyere, was annulled by his parents. The second, to Josephine Cunningham of the Floradora Sextet, ended in divorce. Elia Pascal, a beautiful and well-educated Frenchwoman of independent means, married Whittell after World War I. Originally a love match, their relationship became a lifelong companionate marriage, grounded in friendship and mutual respect. In his elder years Whittell was cared for by a series of servants, notably Mae Mollhagen, his nurse and housekeeper, whom many considered to be Whittell’s mistress. Her death in a car accident affected George Whittell deeply. He towed the wrecked car to a spot above the Lodge, as a memorial to Mae. Another member of the household staff, Ruth Casey, was a trained nurse who took care of Whittell during his last years of life. Theme #3: This unique place was developed by a cross-cultural team of designers, craftspeople, and engineers, all employed by George Whittell. Also based on direct observation, this set of interpretive themes, concepts, and facts helps visitors make sense of a complex and extraordinary historic site. As they tour the Lodge, grounds, and outbuildings, they can trace the development of aspects of the estate, and get a sense of how George Whittell interacted with and influenced different members of the construction team. The architect, Frederick DeLongchamps, was recognized as Nevada’s finest; he was of French Canadian heritage. Much of the ornamental hardware was designed and produced by Italian metalworkers, through the Allied Arts Guild of Menlo Park, California. Masonry was the province of Italian masons, as well as Native American students from Stewart Indian School in Carson City. Cornish miners, veterans of the nearby Virginia City mines, blasted and dug an extensive tunnel system. Norwegian carpenters created hand-hewn beams and decorative wood elements, and painted many of them in traditional Nordic hues. Evidence points to some ideas and guidance provided by George Whittell, though his workers had a lot of freedom to create and experiment. Whittell would frequently meet with them in the early morning. They were beginning the day’s work, and he was on his way to bed after a wild night. Subtheme #3A: What goes on during a restoration? As restoration work proceeds on the site, visitors will have the opportunity to observe the work of construction crews, historic preservation specialists, metalworkers, masons, and other experts. Interpretive guides will help visitors understand what is going on, and why. Erasable whiteboards will provide updated information about what’s going on. Theme #4: What was it like to live at Thunderbird Lodge in Whittell’s day? During tours of the Old Lodge, grounds, and outbuildings, guides call visitors’ attention to various features of the estate. Through open-ended questioning and other interpretive techniques, they invite visitors to speculate about life at Lake Tahoe and at Thunderbird Lodge from the 1930s through the 1960s. Guides follow up with anecdotes and information that shed light on the experiences and perspectives of George Whittell, his wife, his friends and associates, and his household staff. With his insatiable interest in technology, Whittell equipped Thunderbird Lodge with the newest amenities. Visitors can see a range of historic appliances and mechanical systems, many of them restored to operating condition. These include an elevator, radio, film projector, and rangefinder. In a remote, rustic setting of great natural beauty, Whittell surrounded himself with the most advanced technology money could buy. Visitors might be asked to compare Thunderbird Lodge with hideaways described by fantasy novelists such as Jules Verne and Ian Fleming. Security concerns and a desire for privacy led Whittell to install a variety of protective devices. Guides demonstrate the operation of a warning siren, and outdoor speakers that warded off intruders to the strains of Louis Armstrong’s “You Rascal You.” Visitors take note of Whittell’s vault, blind doors, one-way mirror, electric eye motion detectors, and hidden passageways and entrances. Varying numbers and types of household staff lived in the Lodge’s servants’ quarters. Guides tell visitors that accommodations for servants were actually more spacious and more soundproof than the suites and bedrooms of George and Elia Whittell. Visitors are encouraged to study the décor and furnishings of these basement rooms for clues about daily life at the Lodge. Through quotes from oral histories and other accounts, interpretive signage describes the experiences of people who worked for George Whittell in the roles of cook, butler/handyman, maintenance person, and caretaker. As visitors tour the Tea House, Tunnel, Boathouse, waterfront areas, and Club House, they have an opportunity to learn about George Whittell’s reputation and actions as host and party-giver. Watching the beacon and signal lights in action, visitors learn of Whittell’s system for welcoming or discouraging guests. In the Boathouse, they see images of the Thunderbird or that magnificent craft itself, and hear stories of how Whittell transported guests from Crystal Bay to Thunderbird Lodge. (Intrinsically fascinating and beautiful, the Thunderbird comes into its own as an interpretive artifact in association with Thunderbird Lodge. Ideally, the boat would eventually become part of the TLPS collection.) In the Tunnel and the Club House, guides offer carefully distinguished fact and fiction about Whittell’s evening parties, the supposed confinement of guests to rooms off the tunnel, and guests’ encounters with Bill the Lion. Standing by the lagoon, visitors imagine George Whittell pulling at the oars of the small rowboat that’s moored there. Here the guide asks visitors to imagine life at Lake Tahoe th in Whittell’s day. Reminding visitors that as recently as the 19 century Tahoe was the homeland of Washoe Indians, the guide describes the clear-cut land, coming back with second growth, that Whittell purchased at bargain rates. By 1935, Highway 28 encircled Lake Tahoe; yet traffic would have been lighter and quieter. The guide offers facts and statistics to compare the Tahoe Basin then and now, in terms of resident population, tourism, and economics. The region now faces the same challenges it confronted during Whittell’s residence—ever-increasing development, a growing population, and the consequent effects on the lake’s water quality and ecosystems. Only the scale of these problems has changed. The rejection of a proposed national park, the formation of TRPA, and the impact of the Squaw Valley Olympics are key turning points in the region’s history. Visitors take away the realization that key natural and recreational resources, such as Sand Harbor and Chimney Beach State Parks and the Rim Trail, are part of George Whittell’s legacy to Lake Tahoe. His land stretched from Cal-Neva to Zephyr Cove. Without this legacy, Lake Tahoe would be a very different place. Subtheme #4A: George Whittell tried to live off the grid. Although the Lodge had electrical service, Whittell prudently planned for the estate to have its own power generation capability. Special in-depth tours of technology and infrastructure give visitors insight into how the hydro-powered technology was designed to work. Knowledgeable guides describe Whittell’s attempt to live “off the grid” at Thunderbird Lodge. They acquaint visitors with Whittell’s skills as a ham radio operator and airplane pilot, and his interest in revolutionary new technologies, such as radar and television. Visitors who are able to negotiate steep trails can participate in a guided hike to view vestiges of Thunderbird Lodge infrastructure on nearby land. For others who are interested, a photo album documents these remnants. Visitors learn that when Whittell built the lodge, water came from Marlette Lake. He built a 500-foot dam and reservoir to handle overflow. Weir gates and a spillway can still be seen. When the dam was breached by a thaw, Whittell built a second reservoir; the Forest Service recently dismantled it. Theme # 5: What happened to Thunderbird Lodge and surrounding lands after George Whittell’s death? Nearly three decades of controversy and negotiation ensued after Whittell died in 1969. Financier Jack Dreyfus bought Thunderbird Lodge in 1972, and left his mark on the property by building a large addition in 1980s architectural style. Although Dreyfus had the opportunity to develop Lake Tahoe’s eastern shore, he left it in its natural state. In 1998 Dreyfus sold the Lodge and the surrounding 140 acres to the Del Webb Corporation, a home-building company from Phoenix, Arizona. At the time, the $52 million sale price was the most expensive purchase of a private residence in America's history. A year later, Del Webb transferred ownership of the surrounding land, including nearly one mile of pristine shoreline, to the United States Forest Service as part of the a federal land exchange to acquire development property in Las Vegas. Del Webb formed the Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society to act as caretaker of the historic buildings, and to provide public tours and educational opportunities for local residents and tourists. 4.1.7 4.1.7.1 THE VISITOR EXPERIENCE AT THUNDERBIRD LODGE Transportation to the Site To protect the fragile historic site and preserve the period ambiance of the Old Lodge and grounds, TLPS requires visitors to park off-site. Leaving their cars at a safe, convenient location in Incline Village, visitors wait in a welcoming interpretive center for the shuttle bus that will transport them to Thunderbird Lodge. Here they can relax on comfortable bench seating while viewing a brief preparatory video or slide presentation. They can peruse seasonally changing graphic displays, browse in a small retail display, and use the rest rooms and drinking fountain, before boarding the bus. To minimize the number of contemporary vehicles at the historic site, volunteers are issued passes for the shuttle bus, and staff members are encouraged to carpool. At the site, indoor parking and outdoor plantings screen the few staff cars from public view. Visitors can also travel to Thunderbird Lodge by charter boat, embarking from one of several participating lakeside resorts. Weekly paddle tours by kayak are another popular mode of transportation. In each case, Thunderbird Lodge works closely with its partner organization to ensure that visitors have a congenial and informative pre-visit experience. 4.1.7.2 Pre-Visit Experiences George Whittell played a crucial role in determining the fate of Lake Tahoe. His singular personality and the surprisingly altruistic outcome of his apparently hedonistic life are strange but true historical facts. Thunderbird Lodge has an opportunity to unfold its interpretive storyline in exceptionally dramatic fashion. A mini-orientation experience helps visitors understand the context of what they are about to witness, while keeping the dramatic potential of the site visit intact. Because the site can be accessed by bus as well as diverse boat tours, several small-scale installations are desirable. Each mini-orientation center consists of a DVD-based orientation video, and a compact, high-quality interpretive display. Where appropriate, these elements are complemented by a small retail outlet. On the shuttle bus or tour boat, visitors have the opportunity to listen to an audio-based orientation narrative that places George Whittell and Thunderbird Lodge in the context of Lake Tahoe’s history. Audible but not overpowering or intrusive, the program calls visitors’ attention to sights along the way, and awakens their curiosity about the upcoming experience of Thunderbird Lodge. The audio also includes messages about respect for the resource and personal safety, as well as a general outline of what the tour will cover and how long it will last. Orientation experiences plunge visitors into the world of the 1930s, conveying a few startling facts and posing provocative questions. Without revealing too much, these programs help visitors get in the right frame of mind for their journey back in time. By the time they get to the estate, visitors know that: the time period is the late 1930s; George Whittell, a wealthy San Franciscan, has built Thunderbird Lodge as his second home; Whittell owns most of the land from Cal-Neva to Zephyr Cove, from the shoreline to the ridgeline. The video and interpretive panels feature glamorous images of George and Elia Whittell and their amazing second home. Captions and quotes invite visitors to think creatively about provocative questions: It was 1938, the depths of the worst economic depression in U.S. history. How could George Whittell afford to build such a lavish home and live there in such grand style? Today, Lake Tahoe’s eastern shore is the only portion of the lakefront that has remained largely undeveloped. How could this have happened? These and other key facts and stimulating questions are reinforced in the shuttle bus and boat tour audios, through graphic panels at the shuttle stop and elsewhere around the lake, on the TLPS web site, and in brochures and other promotional and educational materials. By the time people arrive at the site, they are excited and curious. Not only are they eager to see a one-of-a-kind historic home; they can’t wait to hear the inside story concerning a very intriguing person, George Whittell. 4.1.7.3 Accessibility for All Visitors TLPS board, staff, and volunteers are committed to the idea that planning for accessibility increases interpretive effectiveness for everyone. The Society’s goal is to ensure that all visitors feel welcome and have the opportunity to enjoy and learn from this very special place. Buildings and grounds at Thunderbird Lodge pose special challenges for physically impaired visitors. To assist them, TLPS deploys a golf cart, portable ramps, and other specialized equipment to help staff and volunteers provide meaningful, respectful experiences for people with limited mobility. Blind visitors can listen to a specially produced audiotape. Printed transcripts and summaries assist deaf visitors in comprehending the guided tour. Trained volunteers offer pre-arranged, customized tours for disabled visitors. Informational pamphlets, including a map and tour overview, are available in key languages (e.g. Spanish, German, French, Japanese) as an aid to non-English speakers. Older and younger visitors are among those who especially appreciate the opportunity to relax for a few moments while enjoying a cold drink and a light snack. A small seasonal concession at a convenient outdoor location fulfills this need. 4.1.7.4 Guided Tour of the Old Lodge, Outbuildings, and Grounds As visitors disembark from the shuttle bus or tour boat, a pair of guides greets the group. Throughout the visit, one guide serves as lead interpreter, while the other takes the role of “sweep,” watchfully ensuring the safety of both visitors and site resources. Promotion and orientation have done their work. Visitors are bursting with excitement to get their first real view of the grounds, façade, and interior of Thunderbird Lodge. The tour begins either at the waterfall overlook or at the front door of the lodge, depending on the number of tours scheduled at a particular time, or at the discretion of the guide. Guides play a key role, helping visitors immerse themselves in Thunderbird Lodge and the world of George Whittell. They are knowledgeable companions who encourage visitors to explore and appreciate connections between past and present. Allowing the Old Lodge, other buildings, and the grounds to take center stage, guides remain on the sidelines, directing visitors’ attention to clues and encouraging them to observe, question, and analyze as would a historian. Guides also answer questions and share information, acting more as facilitators and storytellers than as teachers. They give visitors time and space to fall in love with Thunderbird Lodge and Lake Tahoe. Visitors can take a few moments of “down time” during their tour to rest, contemplate their gorgeous surroundings, and immerse themselves in the little known, yet strangely familiar world of the late 1930s. For many, the experience will awaken or reinforce an ongoing interest in history, heritage preservation, and cultural and environmental stewardship. Each guide draws upon individual talents and expertise to create a personalized presentation. Guides qualify through training, apprenticeship, practice, and by continually demonstrating to supervisors that they can perform at a high level. No two tours are exactly alike, yet each presentation includes key take-home messages, concepts, and facts drawn from the Framework for Interpretation. All visitors to Thunderbird Lodge come away with a common understanding of the site’s history and significance, including knowledge of the fate of Thunderbird Lodge and Lake Tahoe’s east shore after Whittell’s death. They understand the role played by Jack Dreyfus, the essentials of the land swap that preserved the Lodge, and the mission of Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society. 4.1.7.5 Enhancing the Interpretive Context The first indoor space that visitors encounter is the great room of the Old Lodge. An unmediated encounter with an authentic 1930s home, whose interior and exterior are furnished and equipped in period style, stimulates visitors’ imaginations and awakens their curiosity. To make the most of this high-impact environment, indoor and outdoor spaces are deliberately kept free of interpretive signage and other anachronistic elements. Instead, as guides create their personal versions of the tour, they can draw upon the artifact collections for authentic objects to illustrate certain stories. Seasonally changing artifacts reinforce the period look and feel by concentrating visitors’ attention on current thoughts of Christmas, the tourist season, fall colors, boating and swimming, news events and the like. Changeable objects also add a special dimension to thematic tours. For example, visitors with limited mobility are appreciative of inclusion of objects that speak to George Whittell’s disabilities at the end of his life. Smells of wood burning in the fireplace, food cooking, and a lion’s musky odor add an olfactory dimension to a multi-sensory tour experience. The only known home movie of George Whittell, shown rowing his boat in the lagoon, can be projected at the touch of a button onto the original pull-down screen in the Lodge’s great room. Related artifacts help guides tell stories about the rich multicultural associations of Thunderbird Lodge: Italian and American Indian masons who worked on the landscaping, Cornish miners who carved out the tunnel, a French-Canadian architect, and Norwegian carpenters who detailed the interiors. Stories and artifacts illustrate George Whittell’s cosmopolitan outlook, and his lifelong companionate marriage with Elia Whittell, a cultured, fashionable Frenchwoman. Message repeaters let visitors listen in on snatches of conversation in different languages. During rental events, TLPS makes an exception to the “no signage” rule. Strategically located, portable graphic panels serve a dual purpose. They interpret the lodge and grounds to rental users, encouraging them to appreciate and respect an irreplaceable cultural treasure. At the same time, they establish boundaries and “no-trespass” zones. During rental events, oversize albums flank the food and drink tables, inviting guests to browse. Displayed on easels, the albums are filled with eye-catching historic photos and memorable quotes. Another appropriate venue for a layer of interpretation is the basement-level servants’ quarters. It’s important for guides to place these rooms in context for visitors, since few people today are familiar with the concept of live-in servants. Unobtrusive panels with a period graphic look, family photos, and oral histories tell of the people who lived and worked at the lodge. The ensemble tells a well-documented “upstairs downstairs” story that gives visitors a better understanding of George Whittell, his Tahoe home, and the historic context of his long residence there. In a back room, visitors can view changeable artifact displays, with informative labels and a few contextual images. Visitors are free to look around the basement rooms on their own, using interpretive resources to guide their explorations. The Tunnel makes an unforgettable impression, and is best interpreted by guides. They can help visitors prepare themselves for an environment that most will find intimidating and stress-inducing. Those who are claustrophobic require extra support; some visitors need to be escorted via an alternate route. In the Tunnel, low-key identification signage helps stragglers and hard-of-hearing visitors match the guide’s descriptions with particular features. On the grounds, buildings and landscape elements are identified by period-style medallions, embedded in the pathways along the tour route. So unobtrusive as to be almost invisible, these markers become helpful reference points for visitors, once guides have pointed them out. Message repeaters also add a dimension of sound to outlying buildings. In the Club House, background noises reveal a card game in progress, drinks being poured, laughter. As they approach the Boathouse, visitors hear the roar of the Thunderbird’s powerful motor starting up, the thump of ropes being cast off, and sounds of a fast boat moving out onto the water. As guides lead the tour group through the grounds, their questions, prompts, and storytelling awaken visitors’ curiosity and appreciation of a magical landscape. Visitors take note of authentic replicas of signs that were actually posted by George Whittell, warning outsiders against trespassing and fishing on his property. Period artifacts and authentic replicas add convincing real-life touches: a 1930s rowboat, a wheelbarrow, masonry and gardening tools, an old ladder, a clothesline with period clothes hung out to dry, fishing gear, and more. During the outdoor portions of their tour experience, visitors are continually aware of the sounds of waves lapping on shore, wind in the trees, and the calls of birds and other wildlife. Against this constant, natural background, they might also hear a lion’s roar or elephant’s trumpet at a key moment. Sirens, speakers, electric eyes, and signal lights add more sound and sights to the mix. Before leaving the grounds and heading to the Museum Store, visitors pause at an unobtrusive, but informative graphic panel located in the vicinity of the restored patio. As they gaze at a fabulous view of Lake Tahoe, visitors learn what happened to Thunderbird Lodge and the estate after George Whittell’s death. Anecdotes and quotes underscore the key roles played by Jack Dreyfus, the Del Webb Corporation, and other individuals and organizations that contributed to the preservation of this very special place. 4.1.7.6 Farewell and Departure The overriding goal of the initial visit is to get visitors excited about Thunderbird Lodge. Accordingly, the last stop of the tour is at the Museum Store. Here they can buy books, videos, and other souvenirs; sign up for in-depth tours and other programs; purchase memberships in Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society; or sign up to become volunteers. Visitors who elect to become TLPS members receive part or the entire tour fee as a credit on that purchase. For all visitors, the ticket is a take-home souvenir; shaped like a bookmark, it features a beautiful historic photo of Thunderbird Lodge, along with the TLPS web site address. As they travel back to their cars by shuttle bus or tour boat, visitors listen to another audio presentation. Linking the preservation of Thunderbird Lodge with the future of Lake Tahoe, the narrator invites visitors to plan a return visit, participate in an upcoming program, become involved with cultural stewardship, and stay connected through the TLPS web site. At the conclusion of the tour, a mini-retail outlet offers visitors a final opportunity to extend their experience and go deeper into the subject matter, by purchasing a book, video, or other souvenir. 4.1.8 INTERPRETIVE PROGRAMS AND MEDIA For most visitors, an introductory tour is their first experience of Thunderbird Lodge Historic Site. This is the central component of a multidimensional educational effort. For TLPS, interpretive and educational programs are key to attracting and retaining significant new audiences and membership. A lively education program, with yearround options for people of varying ages and backgrounds, will attract many visitors to the museum for the first time, and bring them back for repeat visits. 4.1.8.1 Public Programs Thematic Tours Staff and volunteers will develop thematic tours aimed at conventioneers and hotel guests. For example, a technology tour would be of interest to engineers, scientists, mechanics, and others. Architectural history and building construction methods might appeal to people in those industries. Stockbrokers, financial planners, realtors, and even land use planners could form appreciative audiences for a tour focused on George Whittell’s unique approach to money management and finance. Families with small children would appreciate an animal tour, complete with silhouettes and sound effects. Spanish-Language Tour A special summer offering will be aimed at Latino families. A shuttle bus transports them to and from Kings Beach. A Spanish-speaking guide begins their tour on the bus and continues with them on the site. Special family rates apply, supported by grants and sponsorships. Sound and Light Show In small towns and cities throughout France, people gather on summer nights on the grounds of historic buildings to enjoy a unique form of cultural entertainment. Audio narrative, dramatic dialogue and sound effects, synchronized interior and exterior lighting, silhouettes, music––and the awareness of being on the very spot where history happened––combine to create an unforgettable theatrical and educational experience. The sound and light show takes place outdoors, and does not impact the building. Picnic-style food service, restroom facilities, and music create a relaxed, familyoriented atmosphere. The beautiful setting of Thunderbird Lodge would lend itself well to a sound and light production. Because the grounds are minimally lit, walkways aren’t safe after dark. The most user-friendly way to do a sound and light show would be to bring audiences to the site by boat. Dramatic narration, complete with period music and live talent, would be produced in recorded format. Participating tour companies would coordinate on-board audio with on-shore lighting and sound effects. Professionally designed spotlighting would illuminate buildings, grounds, and even the flowing fountain with drama and style. Audiences would learn about George Whittell’s love of technology as they see signal lights and hear security devices. Silhouettes of Bill the lion, Elia, George, and Mae illustrate the storyline. (Illuminations might even capture a replica of Mae’s smashed-up car.) The story of Thunderbird Lodge can be integrated into lake cruise, with a presentation about Lake Tahoe history and ecology, similar to the audio narration that bus tour patrons hear as they drive to and from the Lodge. Programs for Target Audiences Nearby ski areas, such as Diamond Peak, are potential partners in creating ticket packages for winter visitors. This might include an après-ski opportunity, with refreshments and a tour of the Lodge. Non-skiers can ride the bus to the ski area, drop off their skier spouses and companions, then continue on to Thunderbird Lodge for a tour. This outing might also include lunch in town and a visit to another historic attraction. Gamblers may be interested in a VIP sunset tour that departs by boat from Cal-Neva. A tour guide would point out landmarks of interest, provide pertinent background on George Whittell, then head for the TLPS visitor dock, guided by the “all clear” signal light. An on-site tour would take visitors to the Lodge and through the tunnel to the Card House. A standard guided tour by shuttle bus, departing at scheduled times from various lakeside casinos, would be an option for people who want a break from the casino environment. In addition, TLPS will consider developing a high-priced personal tour option, available by reservation for individuals, couples, and small groups. This program would enable an amateur photographer or a group of serious birders, for example, to explore the grounds in the company of a knowledgeable volunteer. Lectures and Performances Within the carrying capacity of the Lodge, educational lectures will be promoted to broad public audiences. To alleviate parking problems, shuttle service will be provided from a convenient Incline Village location. Grant funding and business sponsorships will keep the cost of these programs affordable. Members will continue to receive special benefits, such as free admission to these programs, and invitations to receptions for the presenters. When an off-site interpretive center becomes available to TLPS, audiences for public programs will increase. A variety of programs will attract and engage new audiences with TLPS. This would be a first step toward involving them as members, volunteers, contributors…even board members. Possibilities include talks by architects, historians, ecologists, geologists, and craftspeople about the lodge and grounds, Lake Tahoe, and George Whittell. An “I remember when” evening would feature a panel of locals and summer residents, interviewed by high school students; attendees could bring family photos to share and identify. A reader’s theater or chamber theater group could present scenes from plays of the late 1930s. A concert of popular music of the 1930s and 1940s, with a swing dance demonstration, is another option. Homeowners and architects who have built homes at the lake could give slide talks about their “Tahoe Dream House.” With grant funding, TLPS might commission a oneman show about George Whittell, to be developed by a playwright who specializes in historic interpretation. A gifted amateur could play the part. Trail Walks A system of trails, confined to the TLPS grounds to discourage trespassers, would lead to points of interest throughout the grounds. A trail system could begin at an amphitheater-like gathering place, either in a forested setting near the Gatehouse or in a nearby flat area with a view of the lake. The road up to the site where Mae’s car once stood offers an especially good view of the lake and Sand Harbor. A bench and low-key interpretive panels would make this destination especially visitor-friendly. Because of security and safety issues, volunteers or staff will accompany all visitors on trail walks. Participants hike in summer and snowshoe in winter, exploring the natural and cultural history of the site in relation to the entire Tahoe basin. A tour might begin with archaeological and ethnographic evidence of Washoe Indian life and early Euro-American settlement. As visitors climb from the Caretaker’s House up to the cistern, they learn how people got their water and dealt with their sewage in the 1930s, in contrast with today. As they catch sight of beautiful Lake Tahoe from a succession of viewpoints, visitors gain an appreciation for the legacy of the man who (however mixed and mysterious his motives) managed to preserve not only this site, but also most of the Nevada shoreline. Trail walks can be customized to match the interests and abilities of different age levels. Some examples: family nature walks, environmental programs for teens, plant walks and history tours with a Native interpreter, early morning bird walks, and photo safaris. School and Youth Programming Teachers in self-contained classrooms are in the best position to organize field trips; this fact tends to limit school-group audiences to the elementary grades. To maximize the possibility that teachers will choose Thunderbird Lodge for what may be their sole field trip of the year, TLPS publicity will demonstrate that school tours help students and teachers fulfill several of the Nevada and California state curriculum standards for the targeted grade levels. A committee of active and retired teachers will review the current school tour program and recommend adjustments as needed. People who enjoy working with children will be recruited as guides for school programs. Specialized training will help them become even more effective with this audience. Middle school and high school students are less likely to participate in field trips to Thunderbird Lodge. Yet they and their families have the potential to be visitors, volunteers, members, and contributors; and TLPS has the opportunity to contribute in significant ways to their educational experience. For example, most school districts now require students at the secondary level to participate in community-based service learning projects. Scouts and other youth organizations are also on the lookout for service projects. Short-term, labor-intensive projects that can safely be carried out by teens will help TLPS forge ongoing relationships with organizations that serve youth. Through a TLPS teen volunteer program, students will gain invaluable experience as guides, office and collections volunteers, and operations assistants. Working with the region’s top high school history teachers, TLPS may seek grant funding to create an intergenerational oral history program. Students will interview elders about Thunderbird Lodge and Lake Tahoe. The results will be shared on the TLPS web site, and will greatly enrich guided tours and other programs. TLPS may also partner with a regional newspaper to sponsor an annual essay contest for Tahoe area high school students on a preservation/conservation topic. The winning essay would be published in the paper, and the winner would receive a cash prize at his/her school’s awards assembly. A family camp is another possibility. Vacationers and locals alike would be part of weekend and weeklong day camps that blend history with environmental studies. By involving grandparents, parents, and kids with behind-the-scenes tours and volunteer projects, TLPS will provide a uniquely memorable experience and will likely gain lifelong supporters, as well. The presence of adult relatives helps ensure the safety and respectful behavior of participating youth. Collaborations with Colleges and Universities Students at institutions of higher education––in the region and beyond––are eager to participate in practicum and internship projects. Through continuing education departments, college and university faculty could teach courses, seminars, and workshops on site for professionals and interested lay people. Subject matter could range from historic preservation and heritage tourism to architectural history and interpretation. TLPS may collaborate with a college or university to offer Elderhostel sessions on the cultural and environmental history of Lake Tahoe. Community and Rental Events Community-oriented events encourage local awareness of and love for Thunderbird Lodge. TLPS will continue to offer holiday events and free familiarization tours for those who work in the hospitality industry. TLPS is now testing the approach of focusing more on tours and other mission-driven programs, rather than on rental events such as weddings. It remains to be seen whether the Society can generate sufficient revenue from programs and membership development to limit events to the desired level of ten per year. Of these ten events, only two are projected to be weddings; the remainder would be corporate events, in collaboration with the Hyatt Regency and other resorts. Event rates will be high; participation will be limited to 80 people per event. Events will be managed in ways that advance the mission. For example, low-key interpretation, including web site information referenced in event invitations, will educate guests about the site’s value and fragility, and their role in helping to preserve it. Whenever possible, corporate events will relate in some way to the TLPS mission. A session on creativity in business will doubly inspire participants, as they experience a one-of-a-kind building and an extraordinary, equally unique landscape––all in the spectacular natural setting of Lake Tahoe. A seminar on sustainability will emphasize historic and contemporary solutions to perennial problems. 4.1.8.2 Interpretive Media Design Approach In keeping with efforts to restore the Old Lodge, buildings, and grounds to their primary period of historical significance, exhibits and other interpretive media will be overlaid very sparingly. Nothing will interfere with visitors’ direct and imaginative experience of the architecture, landscape, and scenery afforded by this splendid site. Within these parameters, interpretive installations will greatly assist visitors to imagine the past. Design elements will reinforce the look and feel of the late 1930s. Examples include the use of period typefaces, historic black and white images (to contrast with the “living color” on view everywhere), clippings from period newspapers, and actual magazines and books. Objects are chosen for their storytelling potential, and are changed out seasonally (or more often). Historic technologies, restored to working order, increase hands-on opportunities for visitors. Period music and news broadcasts add an auditory dimension, along with ambient sound effects. Interpretive Waysides Installed at key locations around the lake, bilingual graphic panels will convey a variety of substantive messages. In addition, they inform potential audiences that access to Thunderbird Lodge is limited because of the site’s small size and fragility, and that visits are by reservation only. Wherever possible, panels should be mounted in secure, indoor locations to make them less expensive to produce. Key venues and suggested topics: Sand Harbor, Chimney Beach: Thunderbird Lodge and the preservation of the eastern shoreline Kings Beach, Cal-Neva: The Thunderbird, the Card House, and George Whittell George Whittell High School: George Whittell and the preservation of the eastern shoreline Rim Trail: Thunderbird Lodge, preservation of eastern shoreline, George Whittell Gatehouse: No-fee orientation and access information Orientation A DVD version of the video and audio orientation programs will be sent to school groups in advance of their visit. The audio orientation narrative will be illustrated by still photos. A committee of master teachers will review the orientation scripts and suggest modifications to suit elementary-age students. A DVD with the same still photos––and an unmodified, adult-oriented narrative––will be produced as a souvenir item for general visitors. Publications and Media Castle in the Sky, by Ronald M. and Susan A. James, has become a local best seller; a second edition is now in preparation. TLPS plans to commission additional high-quality books on Lake Tahoe. Some possibilities: a scholarly study of the life and times of George Whittell; an architectural and social history of Lake Tahoe lodges, including Thunderbird Lodge, co-written by a social historian and an architectural historian; an indepth survey of Lake Tahoe history, by a noted regional historian; an environmental history of the Tahoe region with an assessment of its future prospects, by a respected scientist. A well-illustrated guidebook and beautifully produced video, available in the Museum Store, will provide a comprehensive overview of the “story behind the scenery” for the lodge and the grounds. A companion to Castle in the Sky, the video draws on historic photos of the Lodge, George Whittell, his family and his associates. These are blended with original, beautifully filmed footage of Thunderbird Lodge, the grounds and outbuildings, and Lake Tahoe in all four seasons. The video offers an evocative, comprehensive recap of a tour, and is enriched with additional insights that make visitors hungry for more experiences at Thunderbird Lodge. The story of George Whittell and Thunderbird Lodge combines fascinating history with genuine drama. TLPS staff will be on the lookout for a qualified filmmaker to produce a successful PBS-style documentary. The DVD would become a popular take-away item in the TLPS gift shop. It’s even possible to imagine a Hollywood feature film, which might star Whittell look-alike Nicholas Cage. The right producer (Robert Redford?) might be inspired to champion a feature-length, historically accurate movie, to be filmed at Thunderbird Lodge and other Lake Tahoe locations. (Imagine Citizen Kane with an environmental message.) 4.1.9 TLPS AS REGIONAL LEADER AND CATALYST This interpretive plan is the first step in an ongoing cycle: Through market studies and audience research, TLPS staff will determine what prospective visitors know and want to know about George Whittell, Thunderbird Lodge, and Lake Tahoe; and what they would like to do and learn before, during, and after their visit. Innovative program planning, grounded in the best practices of comparable institutions and informed by consultations with leading professionals, will culminate in public offerings of pilot programs. Each program will be designed to advance the TLPS mission and vision, and to convey the take-home messages outlined above. An off-site interpretive center will greatly enhance the ability of Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society to offer a full range of public and membership programs, including lectures and other presentations for large groups. The interpretive center will also add invaluable pre- and post-visit activities to visitors’ experience of the Lodge tour. Formative evaluation studies—including focus groups, face-to-face interviews, and follow-up surveys—will give TLPS staff a clear idea of the where program offerings are strong and in what respects they need improvement. Suggestions from visitors, guides, board members, and others will be part of the creative mix that ensures that tours and other TLPS interpretive and educational programs never become static, outmoded, or stale. Part of the dynamic environment and evolving history of a surpassingly beautiful place, Thunderbird Lodge Preservation Society will gain widespread recognition for responsible and responsive leadership. TLPS will come into its own as an educational, cultural, and environmental catalyst for all sectors of the diverse Lake Tahoe community.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz