Role of oxygen in surface segregation of metal impurities in silicon poly-and bicrystals E. Amarray, J.P. Deville To cite this version: E. Amarray, J.P. Deville. Role of oxygen in surface segregation of metal impurities in silicon poly-and bicrystals. Revue de Physique Appliquee, 1987, 22 (7), pp.663-669. <10.1051/rphysap:01987002207066300>. <jpa-00245593> HAL Id: jpa-00245593 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00245593 Submitted on 1 Jan 1987 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. Revue Phys. Appl. Classification Physics Abstracts 61.70W - 66.30 22 - (1987) 663-669 Amarray and J. segregation of metal impurities P. Deville in silicon poly- (*) Equipe d’Etude des Surfaces, UA 795 du C.N.R.S., Université Louis-Pasteur, 4, rue Blaise-Pascal, 67000 (Reçu 663 1987 68.60J Role of oxygen in surface and bicrystals E. JUILLET le 6 octobre 1986, révisé le 25 mars Strasbourg, France 1987, accepté le 9 avril 1987) Nous avons caractérisé, au moyen des méthodes d’analyse des surfaces, les impuretés métalliques Résumé. situées sur des rubans de silicium polycristallin. L’oxygène et les traitements thermiques semblent une force motrice pour la ségrégation superficielle de ces impuretés. Pour mieux étudier leur influence et leurs possibilités en terme d’effet getter, nous avons initié des études de modélisation sur des bicristaux de type Czochralski. Nous avons étudié deux facteurs principaux de ségrégation superficielle : le rôle d’une couche d’oxyde très mince et celui de traitements thermiques. Nous avons remarqué que le maximum de purification des surfaces était obtenu après le recuit à 750 °C d’une surface préalablement oxydée à 450 °C. Nous avons relié cela à la formation d’amas de SiO, suivie d’une coalescence donnant des unités de type SiO4 entraînant l’injection d’auto-interstitiels de silicium dans le réseau. 2014 Metal impurities at surfaces of polycrystalline silicon ribbons have been characterized by surface Abstract. sensitive methods. Oxygen and heat treatments were found to be a driving force for surface segregation of these impurities. To better analyse their influence and their possible incidence in gettering, model studies were undertaken on Czochralski grown silicon bicrystals. Two main factors of surface segregation have been studied : the role of a ultra-thin oxide layer and the effect of heat treatments. The best surface purification was obtained after an annealing process at 750 °C of a previously oxidized surface at 450 °C. This was related to the formation of SiO clusters, followed by a coalescence of SiO4 units leading to the subsequent injection of silicon self-interstitials in the lattice. 2014 out methods for 1. Introduction. Polycrystalline silicon, often referred to as polysilicon », is obtained either by casting ingots via a Bridgman-like growth process or by setting up ribbon technologies based on shaped crystal growth. These technologies are developed to reduce the cost of terrestrial solar cells by minimizing silicon consumption and/or by using cheaper, degraded silicon as starting material. Possible applications to « microelectronics should be also born in mind for the future. Final materials obtained by such methods have a large amount of structural, chemical and electrical defects. Thus, the main objective of research in the last decade has been to identify and classify these defects, to investigate which ones are the most detrimental in terms of photovoltaic yield and to find (*) To whom correspondence REVUE DE PHYSIQUE APPLIQUÉE. - T. 22, should be sent. passivation of the electrically active ones. For example, it has been demonstrated that implantation of molecular or atomic hydrogen improves the electrical properties such as the diffusion length in both ingots and ribbons [1-5]. Diffusion at low temperature of selected impurities such as Cu and Al into polycrystalline Si was also found to improve the minority carrier diffusion length [6]. In the case of ribbon technologies, it has been also shown that thermal treatments could, in certain cases, improve the diffusion length [4, 7]. The improvements have been related to intrinsic gettering effects in which fast-diffusing species are offered energetically favorable sites outside the electrically active region of the material. Surface physics methods have been thought to be useful in this perspective since the active area of photovoltaïc devices are located in the top few micrometers. Is it possible to draw detrimental N° 7, JUILLET 1987 Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/rphysap:01987002207066300 45 664 out of the active region ? Is it relevant to of the classical gettering processes in polysilicon technology ? To answer these questions we applied surface science techniques to understand particularly the role of oxygen and heat treatments in the segregation of metal impurities towards the surface of silicon samples. In this paper, after having briefly recalled the RAD growth process and the experimental set-up, we shall sum up the early surface analytical results found on RAD ribbons, then we shall present recent investigations on model systems (silicon bicrystals). No attempt has been made, however, to measure differences in electrical properties during these model studies since ultra-high vacuum is needed for surface analysis and prevent one to realize easily reliable electrical measurements. impurities use 2. some Experimental. RAD silicon ribbons were obtained 2.1 SAMPLES. by a shaped crystal growth in which a carbon support is continuously pulled through a p-doped silicon melt via a slot located at the bottom of a RF induction heated quartz crucible. Details about the various technical requirements and achievements of the process can be found in [8]. After growth, the carbon support is burnt-off in a dry oxygen atmosphere at temperatures ranging from 1000 °C to 1200 °C during 1 hour, resulting in two self-supporting Si sheets less than 100 03BCm thick. The outside faces are oxidized and the inner faces are covered with a discontinuous SiC layer. The thicknesses of the oxide layers range from 0.2 to 1 03BCm. These two overlayers are chemically etched off before making N+ /p homojunctions by a classical POCl3 diffusion process at 850 °C. In most cases, we studied samples as obtained after the burnt-off process. As model materials, we used CZ bicrystals (n -10 03A9.cm-1 and p -1 03A9.cm-1), grown at the LETI (Grenoble). Oxygen and carbon concentrations are in the 1017 at.cm-3 range and can locally exceed the limit of solubility at equilibrium [9]. Barlike samples (4 x 4 x 10 mm3), cut from the ingots, were oriented by back-reflection Laue techniques ; two kinds of orientations were chosen : - i) the grain boundary plane being perpendicular long axis of the bar, ii) the easily cleavable (111) plane, perpendicular to the The samples were etched in dilute HF and no thermal treatment applied prior their introduction in the UHV chamber 3. methods. concentration profiles of RAD samples determined by means of X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) in a VG ESCA III apparatus. Depth profiles down to 1 )JLm were obtained by argon-ion sputter etching the sample step by step (about 100 Â per ion bombardment). The sputtered area had a larger diameter than the analyzed one. Silicon bicrystals were analysed by Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES) using a RIBER CMA in a UHV chamber fitted with several accessories (argon ion bombardment, cleavage system, Knudsen cells for metal evaporation, ...). The diameter of the spot is 10 03BCm ; too large to investigate the grain boundaries, it allows to study surface domains about 30 03BCm large. Since the low-energy Auger peaks of metal impurities are superimposed to the silicon Auger LVV fine structure, we used the LMM peaks of Cr, Fe and Ni at respectively 529, 703, and 848 eV to derive concentrations. Of course, the differences in mean free paths between the various Auger transitions have been taken into account in these calculations. Concentrations are given in atom per cent and are averaged over thicknesses of about 8 Â. The ratioes between the high- and low-energy peak intensities have been also studied to precise the location of given impurities with respect to the surface. Impurity were 4. Results on RAD polycrystalline ribbons. 4.1 GENERAL OUTLINE OF THE IMPURITY DISTRIBUTION IN RAD RIBBONS. We previously described depth profiles of impurities in RAD ribbons and we summarize here the main results [10]. At that time burning off the carbon support was not yet in use. On the samples received as grown, surface analysis showed oxide layers thicknesses of which were ranging from 200 to 1 000 A, depending on the growth conditions. The oxide was generally not three-dimensional silica as observed by AES and XPS [11,12]. Impurities could be classified in two catégories : - to this axis. Grooves were made either right along the intersection of the grain boundary plane with the bar or along a (111) plane. It was then possible to cleave our samples in UHV and to get clean virgin silicon surfaces and, sometimes, the boundary plane itself. In this paper, we shall discuss only incidentally the role of the grain boundary which is not the major parameter of interest. Analytical i) carbon and oxygen, which were always present at concentrations equal or higher than their solubility limit at the melting point of silicon, respectively x 1017 and 1018 at. cm-3 [9]. Their concentration profiles were identical in all samples. Oxygen is a byproduct of the reaction between the silicon melt and the quartz crucible ; carbon comes mainly from the support but also from the decomposition of the 5 residual carbon monoxide present in the furnace. 665 ii) metal impurities, which were not always presame places of the ribbon but which, when they were observed, were not randomly distributed. Their position by respect to the surface was always the same, i.e. Cu, Na, Bi, Zn, Ni and Sn are in the top 20 A, Ca and Mg are just above the Si/Si02 interface, Fe and Cr are just under this sent at the interface and in the bulk. Bulk concentrations have been measured by neutron activation analysis (NAA) and found to be in the range of 1012 to 1014 at. cm-3 showing effective partition coefficients between the melt and the ribbon in the range 10-1 to 10-3 [13]. In our experiments, surface concentrations can be estimated to 1012 to 1014 at. cm-2 which, averaged in the volume probed by the method, would correspond to 1015 to more than 1017 at.cm- 3. This gives enrichment factor of about 1 000 for RAD ribbons. These impurities were incorporated from the silicon melt and came initially from the carbon ribbon. 3.2 GETTERING POCI3 OF IMPURITIES IN BURNT-OFF AND RAD. - When the burn-off proof the carbon support is used, an oxide layer less than 1 jim thick covers the bulk silicon film [14]. This layer is always three-dimensional stoichiometric silica as evidenced by AES and EELS [12,15]. We did not find metal impurities in this layer, within the limits of detection of XPS which are somewhat poor if the impurity is equally distributed in a large DIFFUSED cess volume (10 ppm). If the silica layer is dissolved in diluted HF and the sample quickly returned to the XPS UHV chamber, a layer of native oxide 10 to 20 A thick forms, covered with a monolayer of carbonaceous contamination. In and under this layer, metal impurities (Bi, Cu, Fe, Cr, Ni) have been found with the same profiles as described in § 1. Control samples, made of FZ single-crystalline silicon, do not show these impurities after heat treatments equivalent to the burn-off process. It is thus clear that during this process, surface segregation of metal impurities occurs in RAD ribbons. We also studied some samples where a N+ /p had been formed (details on the procedure can be found in Ref. [27]). The depth of the junction is 0.6 03BCm. Impurities (Cu, Fe, Cr) were found with a profile looking much alike the one described above, viz. copper near the surface, chromium and iron in the vicinity of the junction. In this case, the gettering effect is probably due to the POCl3 diffusion (extrinsic gettering) since impurities are located within the junction. This type of gettering, like the intrinsic one leads to lattice strain and to the injection of silicon interstitials, believed to be responsible for the getter effect [16, 17]. junction 5. Model studies It on silicon bicrystals. clear from the results obtained on RAD that oxygen plays an important role on the surface segregation of impurities since a clear relation between their presence and concentrations in oxygen has been evidenced [10]. It has also been shown that heat treatments could improve some of the electrical properties [7]. So there are some analogies with the so-called getter effect used in microelectronics and reviewed recently by Richter seems polysilicon ribbons [18]. To test the role of oxygen in gettering (or in surface segregation) we studied the model materials described in the experimental section. These crystals, grown especially to offer an alternative material to polysilicon in fundamental investigations are simpler to study since there is only one grain boundary. Metalloïdic impurities (carbon, oxygen) have about the same bulk concentrations as in polysilicon, i.e. between 1017 and 1018 at. cm-3 as measured by IR spectrometry [9] ; metals, analysed by NAA [19], have lower concentrations than in ribbons, e.g. 1.8 x 1013 at. cm-3 for Na and below detection limits for Cr, Cu, Fe,... (below 1012-1013 For this purpose, we measured by Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES) surface concentration profiles of impurities after isochronous annealing processes at. cm-3). 450 °C (1 hour), 750 °C and 1 250 °C (5 min) on : at (1 hour), 950 °C (1 hour) clean surfaces, surfaces oxidized at room temperature in UHV or in air, surfaces oxidized at 450 °C in UHV. - - - The annealing temperatures were chosen because characteristic respectively of the formation of the first thermal donor, of the second (new) donor, of the precipitation of silica and, finally, of its dissolution [20]. they are 5.1 SEGREGATION AT CLEAN SURFACES. In figure 1 are shown surface concentrations of impurities on cleaned surfaces. In this case, the surface is cleaned by argon ion-bombardment after every heat treatments. Oxygen and carbon concentrations reach a maximum at 750 °C and then decrease. At 750 °C the silicon Auger fine structure is characteristic of silica. The thickness of the oxide layer is evaluated at about 5 Á. Potassium, not shown in the figure, present after the first annealing process is dissorbed before 750 °C. Chromium and iron concentrations increase steadily with temperature above 750 °C and the Auger spectra of these impurities show that they are not oxidized. Since their local concentration is higher than the limit of solubility it is possible that these - 666 Fig. 2. - AES in-depth concentration profile of a room- temperature oxidized silicon sample. The time scale is related to the time of argon-ion bombardment ; the distance scale 1. AES surface concentrations on cleaned silicon surfaces at the initial state i and after heat treatments. a) Silicon concentrations, b) impurity concentrations. Fig. - gives the eroded thickness. interface. There are still noticeable concentrations in iron as far as 60 Â deep. In figure 3 are shown the surface concentrations of impurities, respectively before and after a room- are present as silicides. Up to now we do not have evidence of this silicide formation by AES. These results look very much alike those obtained on RAD ribbons. Potassium is on the top of the segregated layer present after the heat treatment at 450 °C ; chromium and iron are just below the ultrathin oxide layer and they reach the surface when the temperature is large enough to allow the outdiffusion of oxygen atoms. impurities 5.2 SEGREGATION AT ROOM-TEMPERATURE OX- Two kinds of room temperature oxidation have been investigated : one in ambient atmosphere (native oxide obtained after about 20 min in air after cleaning), the other in UHV |p(O2) : 2 x 10- 5 Torr, 3 houris 1. They gave identical results. A typical in-depth concentration profile of impurities taken on a room-temperature oxidized sample having a native oxide layer is shown in figure 2. For sake of clarity, the concentrations of oxidized silicon are not shown. Auger spectroscopy shows that this oxide is not silica but SiOx ; this is evidenced both by the Auger fine structure and the stoichiometry calculated from the height of the oxidized silicon peak and the oxygen peak. Nickel is present on the top of the layer ; chromium and iron reach their maximum concentration at the silicon/silicon oxide IDIZED SURFACES. - Fig. 3. AES surface concentration before (i), after (ox) a room-temperature oxidation in UHV and after heat treatments at given temperatures. a) Silicon concentrations (left scale) and thickness of the oxide (right scale), b) impurity concentrations. - 667 temperature oxidation in UHV, and after each heat treatment. One can see that RT oxidation indeed brings impurities near the surface. In this case, subsequent heat treatments do not modify drastically the impurity concentrations and the final state, after the whole annealing cycle, is nearly the same as the initial one, before oxidation. 5.3 SEGREGATION AT SURFACES OXIDIZED AT 450 °C. Figure 4 shows the concentration of impurities respectively before and after oxidationat 450 °C |p(O2) : 2 x 10-5 Torr, 3 houris 1and after each heat treatment. The starting surface was, in this case, rather rich in impurities. It is clear, however, that oxidation favours the segregation of more impurities towards the surface. But as soon as this surface, covered now with a silica layer 14 Â thick, is annealed there is an important decrease of the impurity content. Its minimum is reached at 750 °C. - It is clear from the results that metal impurities present at much higher concentrations in the top layers of RAD polycrystalline ribbons than in the bulk. In bicrystals, surface segregation of metal impurities, probably incorporated from the melt during the growth process, is observed after oxidation showing also large concentrations. It should be pointed out that the spatial distribution of these impurities is the same whatever the oxidation temperature is and whatever the oxide thickness is. i) are In our experiments, surface concentrations can be estimated to 1012 to 1014 at. cm-2 which, averaged in the volume probed by AES or XPS, would correspond to 1015 to more than 1017 at. cm- 3. This gives enrichment factors of about 1 000 for RAD ribbons and about 105 for bicrystals. Even if classical diffusion or segregation coefficients could explain such a large segregation for RAD ribbons, it is not the case for oxidation of bicrystals, at room-temperature or 450 °C. Intrinsic gettering is thus believed to occur in both cases. It is indeed well known that oxygen plays an important role in this type of gettering effect [18] and several mechanisms have been described to explain the enhanced diffusion of oxygen in silicon [21, 23]. Some of these authors think that the precipitation of oxygen injects silicon self-interstitials which are able to make complexes with oxygen and which have a large diffusivity. Then, these complexes should trap metal impurities. Model studies show in fact that the surface structure of the oxide layer is important in the segregation process. They are not able to describe yet the exact mechanisms of this enhanced diffusivity. We have shown that if room-temperature ox- SiO,, layer, were able to draw impurities out of the bulk, giving rise to a kind of intrinsic getter effect, subsequent heat treatments idations, leading did not modify to a the surface concentration of metal impurities. On the contrary, if there is a ultra-thin layer of silica (Si02 ) instead of SiOx, the heat treatments draw back the impurities in the bulk. This could be related to the injection of silicon selfinterstitials which would be possible only because of the strain induced by the misfit between silica and AES surface concentrations before (i), aftei made in UHV at 450 °C and after heal oxidation (ox) treatments at given temperatures. a) Silicon and oxyger concentrations (left scale) and thickness of the oxide (righ1 scale), b) impurity concentrations. Fig. 4. - an 6. Discussion. points appear worth to be discussed, the segregation of metal impurities toward the surface in polycrystalline RAD ribbons or bicrystals and the role of oxygen as a driving force for gettering. Two silicon. How the final step (i.e. the diffusion of siliconmetal complexes) occurs is not yet fully understood even if metal impurities have been characterized in the vicinity of Si02 precipitates [24]. ii) On another hand, one can argue that a 12 A Si02 layer is probably not able to inject enough Si self-interstitials in the bulk and it would seem that the role of oxygen is not only to induce intrinsic gettering after its precipitation, it is also a chemical driving force. We have indeed the evidence that, in silicon bicrystals, impurity diffusion toward the sur- 668 face if the surface is oxidized at low possible through intrinsic and extrinsic getter protemperature). cesses induced by the precipitation of the dissolved Which kind of mechanism is possible ? If it is the oxygen atoms during the burn-off process of the affinity of a given metal impurity to oxygen as it was carbon support and during the POCl3 diffusion cycle postulated in [10], why is these impurity not bound for RAD ribbons. These effects have been demonto oxygen as it is evidenced by AES ? strated for silicon bicrystals when the surface is A possible explanation could be that metal im- oxidized at temperatures higher than 450 °C and purities, such as iron and chromium are only catalysts then annealed at 750 °C. However, it is thought that for silicon oxidation : they would favour an oxygen oxygen does not act only as a nucleus for giving dissociative adsorption process on silicon surfaces. straining Si04 units, leading to the injection of fastViefhaus and Rossow [25] have found that in a Fe- diffusing silicon self-interstitials but also as a chemical driving force able to induce the segregation of Si 6 at. % alloy, surface segregated silicon is more metal impurities in the area rich in oxygen through a easily oxidized than pure silicon. The same observation has been made by Mosser, Srivastava and catalytic mechanism in which oxygen, silicon and Carrière [26] who noticed that Fe-Si oxidation at metal impurities are strongly cooperative. We have shown that intrinsic and extrinsic getter temperatures higher than 500 °C would lead to a effects or surface segregation may be effective in silicon dioxide segregated overlayer topping unoxidized iron. The formation of silicides has been also polysilicon technology. It is thus possible to take evidenced in similar experiments as in the POCl3 advantage of the thermal treatments occurring either the growth or during the diffusion process to getter process [27]. In our case, we could not show during improve the electrical properties of polysilicon solar by AES or XPS that these silicides really exist. cells. occurs even temperature (450 °C and even room 7. Conclusion. Acknowledgments. Surface analytical methods have been used to investigate the diffusion and segregation of metal impurities at the surface of RAD polysilicon ribbons and silicon bicrystals. High surface concentrations of chromium, copper, iron, potassium, iron and nickel have been evidenced. We believe that this segregation is The authors wish to thank Dr. Belouet from C.G.E. for the supply of the polysilicon RAD samples and the « Groupe Silicium Polycristallin » for the many enlighting discussions that it has initiated. The work was made under the financial support of PIRSEM and COMES. References [1] SEAGER, C. H. and GINLEY, D. S., J. Appl. Phys. 52 (1981) 1050. [2] MULLER, J. C., ABADOU, Y., BARHDADI, A., COURE., UNAMUNO, S., SALLES, D., SIFFERT, FALLY, J., Solar Cells (in press). [3] MAUTREF, M., LACROIX, C., BELOUET, C., FAGES, C., BIOTTEAU, B. and ARNOULT, F., Revue CELLE, P. and Phys. Appl. [4] BELOUET, C. in : [11] CARRIÈRE, B., DEVILLE, J. P., BRION, D. and ESCARD, J., J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 10 (1977) 85. [12] CARRIERE, B., DEVILLE, J. P. and HUMBERT, P.,J. Microsc. Spectros. Electr. 10 (1985) 29. REVEL, G., DESCHAMPS, N., DEVILLE, J. P., TE[13] XIER-HERVO, C. and BELOUET, C., Proc. 4th E.C. Photovoltaic Energy Conf., Stresa, (1982) 19 (1984) 333. Poly-micro-crystalline and amorph- ous semiconductors, Eds. P. Pinard and S. Kalbitzer (Editions de Physique, Paris) 1984, p. 970. [14] Graphs of the oxide thickness on various silicon surfaces can be found in L’oxydation du silicium, B. Leroy (1985) (Publications IBM, Corbeil-Es- p. 53. [5] AMZIL, H., MATHIAN, G. and MARTINUZZI, S.,ibid. p. 69. [6] ZEHAF, M., MATHIAN, G., PASQUINELLI, M. and MARTINITZZI, S., ibid. p. 137. [7] WALD, F. V.,ibid. p. 33. [8] BELOUET, C., TEXIER-HERVO, C., MAUTREF, M., BELIN, C., PAULIN, J. and SCHNEIDER, J., J. Crystal Growth 61 (1984) 615. [9] PAJOT, B., Rapports PIRSEM, 1984 et 1985 (Editions du C.N.R.S., Paris). [10] DEVILLE, J. P.,QUESADA,J. and SOLTANI, M. L.,J. Physique Colloq. 43 (1982) C1, 193. sonnes). [15] ELMAACHI, A., Thèse de Doctorat de l’Université Louis-Pasteur, Strasbourg, 1985. [16] OURMAZD, A. and SCHROTER, W., Appl. Phys. Lett. 781. GÖSELE, U. and FRANK, in : Defects in Semiconductors, Eds. J. Narayan and T. Y. Tan (North Holland, New York) 1981, p. 55. RICHTER, in: Proc. 1st International Autumn School, Gettering and Defect Engineering in the Semiconductor Technology, Ed. H. Richter 45 [17] [18] (1984) (Garzau) 1985, p.1. 669 [19] REVEL, G., unpublished results. [20] CAZCARRA, V. and ZUNNINO, P., J. Appl. Phys. 51 (1981) 4206. W., FRISCH, H. L. and REISS, H., Phys. KAISER, [21] Rev. 112 (1958) 1546. [22] GÖSELE, U. and TAN, T. Y., Appl. Phys. 28A (1982) 79. [23] OURMAZD, A., SCHRÖTER, W. and BOURRET, A., J. Appl. Phys. 56 (1984) 1670. [24] BOURRET, A. and SCHRÖTER, W., Ultramicroscopy (1984). [25] VIEFHAUS, H. and Rossow, W., Surface Sci. 141 (1984) 341. [26] MOSSER, A., SRIVASTAVA, S. C. and CARRIÈRE, B., Surface Sci. 133 (1983) L-441. MOUDDA AZZEM, T., Thèse de Doctorat, Université [27] de Paris 6 (Paris, 1985).
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz