Experiences of Hydrological Frequency Analysis in Taiwan - Coping with Extraordinary Extremes and Climate Change Prof. Ke-Sheng Cheng Department of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan University Outline • Introduction • Improving accuracy of frequency analysis – Presence of outliers (extraordinary rainfall extremes) – Spatial correlation (non-Gaussian random field simulation) • Frequency analysis of multi-site rainfall extremes 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 2 Introduction • Frequent occurrences of disasters induced by heavy rainfalls in Taiwan – Landslides – Debris flows – Flooding and urban inundation • Increasing occurrences of rainfall extremes (some of them are record breaking) in recent years • Almost all of the long-duration rainfall extremes (longer than 12 hours) were produced by typhoons. 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 3 Examples of annual max events in Taiwan Design durations 2016/1/14 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 4 2016/1/14 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 5 Proportion of rainfall stations observing annual max rainfalls. 2016/1/14 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 6 • A large number of rain gauges maintained by CWB and WRA. Some of them have record length longer than 50 years. Most of them have less than 30 years record length . • Design rainfalls play a key role in studies related to climate change and disaster mitigation. • Problems in rainfall frequency analysis – Short record length (less than 30 years) (small sample size) – Record breaking rainfall extremes (presence of extreme outliers) • Typhoon Morakot 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 7 • Typhoon Morakot (2009) World record 2467 1825 2361 1624 0805-0810 accumulated rainfall Morakot 8 • Catastrophic storm rainfalls (or extraordinary rainfalls) often are considered as extreme outliers. Whether or not such rainfalls should be included in site-specific frequency analysis is disputable. – 24-hr annual max. rainfalls (Morakot) of 2009 • • • • 1/14/2016 甲仙 泰武 大湖山 阿禮 1077 mm 1747 mm 1329 mm 1237 mm Lab for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept. of Bioenvironmental Systems Eng., NTU 9 • Frequency analysis of 24-hr annual maximum rainfalls (AMR) at Jia-Sien station using 50 years of historical data – 1040mm/24 hours (by Morakot) excluding Morakot – 901 years return period – Return period inclusive of Morakot – 171 years The same amount (1040mm/24 hours) was found to be associated with a return period of more than 2000 years by another study which used 25 years of annual maximum rainfalls. 06/25/2013 2013 AOGS Conference 10 Morakot rainfalls were not included in the frequency analysis. Rainfall (mm) 1/14/2016 Return period Rainfall (mm) Return period Rainfall (mm) Lab for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept. of Bioenvironmental Systems Eng., NTU Return period Total Rainfall Record length 11 • Concurrent occurrences of extraordinary rainfalls at different rain gauges – Several stations had 24-hr rainfalls exceeding 100-yr return period. – Site-specific events of 100-yr return period. – What is the return period of the event of multi-site 100-yr return period? • (100)^4 = 100,000,000 years (4 sites), assuming independence – Redefining extreme events • multi-site extreme events w.r.t. specified durations and rainfall thresholds • Spatial covariation of rainfall extremes 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 12 • Spatial covariation of rainfall extremes – By using site-specific annual maximum rainfall series for frequency analysis implies a significant loss of valuable information. 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 13 Station A 2016/1/14 Station B Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 14 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 15 • Coping with outliers – Regional Frequency Analysis – Stochastic simulation of multi-site event-maximum rainfalls 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 16 Fundamental concept of regional frequency analysis • For areas with short record length or without rainfall or flow measurements, hydrological frequency analysis needs to be conducted using data from sites of similar hydrological characteristics. • Data observed at different sites within a “homogeneous region” can be combined and used in regional frequency analysis. 1/14/2016 Lab for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept. of Bioenvironmental Systems Eng., NTU 17 General procedures of regional frequency analysis (Hosking and Wallis, 1997) 1. Data screening – Correctness check – Data should be stationary over time. 2. Identifying homogeneous regions – A set of characteristic variables should be chosen and used for delineation of homogeneous regions. – Characteristic variables may include geographic and hydrological variables. – Homogeneous regions are often determined by cluster analysis. 1/14/2016 Lab for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept. of Bioenvironmental Systems Eng., NTU 18 3. Choice of an appropriate regional frequency distribution – GOF test using rescaled samples from different sites within the same homogeneous region. – The chosen distribution not only should fit the data well but also yield quantile estimates that are robust to physically plausible deviations of the true frequency distribution from the chosen frequency distribution. 1/14/2016 Lab for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept. of Bioenvironmental Systems Eng., NTU 19 4. Parameter estimation of the regional frequency distribution – Estimating parameters of the site-specific frequency distribution – Estimating parameters of the regional frequency distribution using record-length weighted average. 5. Calculating various quantiles of the hydrological variable under investigation. 1/14/2016 Lab for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept. of Bioenvironmental Systems Eng., NTU 20 An experimental stochastic simulation • We generated 7 random samples (sample size n = 40) of a gamma distribution with mean=600 and std dev =346. • The data set is considered equivalent to annual max rainfalls (record length = 40) at 7 stations. • Outliers were detected in four of the seven series. • Return period of the maximum value of each individual AMR series was calculated. Max value in AMR 1797.758 1159.976 1567.84 2066.767 1326.539 1288.869 1624.943 08/13/2012 2012 AOGS Conference 21 08/13/2012 2012 AOGS Conference 22 Study area and rainfall stations 25 rainfall stations in southern Taiwan. (1951 – 2010) Not all stations have the same record length. Annual maximum rainfalls (AMR) of various durations (1, 2, 6, 12, 18, 24, 48, 72 hours) 06/25/2013 2013 AOGS Conference 23 Event-maximum rainfalls of various design durations • Event-max 1, 2, 6, 12, 18, 24, 48, 72-hr typhoon rainfalls at individual sites. • Approximately 120 events • Complete series 24 Delineation of homogeneous regions (K-mean cluster analysis) • 24 classification features (8 design durations x 3 parameters – mean, std dev, skewness) – Normalization of individual features • Two homogeneous regions (25 stations) 25 Regional frequency analysis • Delineating homogeneous regions 08/13/2012 2012 AOGS Conference 26 08/13/2012 2012 AOGS Conference 27 Hot spots for occurrences of extreme rainfalls 1992 – 2010 Number of extreme typhoon events 08/13/2012 2012 AOGS Conference 28 Rescaled variables for regional frequency analysis – Frequency factors Kijk xijk ik ik 29 Goodness-of-fit test and parameters estimation L-moment ratio diagrams (LMRD) for goodness-of-fit test Pearson Type 3 distribution Parameters estimation Method of L-moments Record-length-weighted regional parameters 30 L-moment-ratio diagram GOF test 甲仙(2), t = 24hr PT3 Gaussian EV-1 31 32 Covariance structure of the random field • Covariance matrices are semi-positive definite. • Experimental covariance matrices often do not satisfy the semi-positive definite condition. • Modeling the covariance structure of frequency factors (event-max rainfalls) by variogram modeling. 33 Relationship between semivariogram and covariance function 1 h Var Z x h Z x 2 C 0 C h C xi , x j C h γ(h) Sill C(h) Influence range sill C 0 1 34 Semi-variogram modeling (24-hr EMR) h a h 1 exp C 0 1 35 Semi-variograms of EMRs of other durations 36 Stochastic Simulation of Multi-site Event-Max Rainfalls • Pearson type III (Non-Gaussian) random field simulation • Covariance Transformation Approach – Covariance matrix of multivariate PT3 distribution – Covariance matrix of multivariate standard Gaussian distribution – Multivariate Gaussian simulation – Transforming simulated multivariate Gaussian realizations to PT3 realizations 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 37 XY AX AY 3 AX CY 3C X AY 9C X CY UV 2 BX BY 2 UV AX 1 X 6 4 Y AY 1 6 1/14/2016 6C X CY 3 UV BX 4 BY 3 1 CX X 3 6 3 1 Y CY 3 6 X X Y Y 6 6 6 6 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 2 2 38 • Each simulation run generated one sample of t-hr multi-site event maximum rainfalls. • Simulated samples preserved the spatial covariation of multi-site EMRs as well as the marginal distributions. • 10,000 samples were generated. – Multi-site t-hr EMRs of 10,000 typhoon events. • The number of typhoons vary from one year to another. – Annual count of typhoons is a random variable. 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 39 • Determination of t-hr rainfall of T-yr return period – Average number of typhoons per year, m = 2.43 – Return period, T=100 years – Exceedance probability of the event-max rainfalls, pE=1/(100*2.43) 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 40 Return period, T = 50yr Duration, t = 24hr 2500 EMR AMR 雨量 2000 1500 1000 500 0 41 Return Period, T = 200yr Duration, t = 24hr 4000 EMR AMR 3500 雨量 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 42 24hr雨量(mm) 24hr重現期(年) 48hr雨量(mm) 48hr重現期(年) 72hr雨量(mm) 72hr重現期(年) 北港(2) 358 11 433 11 460 12 大埔 720 53 921 57 1069 118 沙坑 607 32 759 31 888 52 中坑(3) 497 24 636 26 744 42 溪口(3) 324 15 403 16 450 24 六溪 791 43 1024 55 1122 59 木柵 778 102 1037 54 1188 80 阿蓮(2) 630 41 868 42 924 41 旗山(4) 519 17 760 23 819 22 美濃(2) 338 4 509 6 569 6 新豐 908 63 1179 51 1195 36 屏東(5) 676 40 878 45 938 45 南和 614 15 988 39 1100 62 嘉義 526 22 646 17 697 24 台南 535 61 709 53 736 42 高雄 538 40 755 57 801 53 恆春 528 27 715 34 730 28 關子嶺(2) 1098 92 1490 126 1683 221 甲仙(2) 1040 65 1614 177 1915 204 紹家 818 110 1176 141 1333 130 三地門 825 18 1109 25 1235 29 大湖山 1329 48 1958 89 2533 306 樟腦寮(2) 868 22 1395 55 1846 141 泰武(1) 1747 47 2938 121 3417 171 阿禮 1237 23 1908 38 2335 66 43 IDF Curve 44 Estimating return period of multisite Morakot rainfall extremes • Four rain gauges within the Kaoping River Basin recorded 24-hr rainfalls close to 1,000mm (908, 1040, 825, 1237 mm). • Define a multi-site extreme event – over 1,000 mm 24-hr rainfalls at all four sites – Among the 10,000 simulated events, only 8 events satisfied the above requirement. – Average number of typhoons per year, m=2.43 – Multi-site extreme event return period T = 514 years. 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 45 • Further look at the simulation results – Preserving the spatial pattern of rainfall extremes 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 46 Type A 47 48 Type B 49 50 Type C 51 52 Type D 53 54 Summary • We developed a stochastic approach for simulation of multi-site event-max rainfalls to cope with the problems of outliers and short record length in hydrological frequency analysis. • By increasing the sample size and considering the spatial covariation of EMRs, the return periods of site-specific and multi-site rainfall extremes can be better estimated. 2016/1/14 Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, NTU 55 Rationale of BVG simulation using frequency factor • From the view point of random number generation, the frequency factor can be considered as a random variable K, and KT is a value of K with exceedence probability 1/T. • Frequency factor of the Pearson type III distribution can be approximated by Standard normal deviate X 1 3 X KT z z 1 z 6 z 6 3 6 2 X X 1X z 1 z 6 6 3 6 3 4 5 2 [A] 2 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 56 • General equation for hydrological frequency analysis X T X KT X 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 57 • The gamma distribution is a special case of the Pearson type III distribution with a zero location parameter. Therefore, it seems plausible to generate random samples of a bivariate gamma distribution based on two jointly distributed frequency factors. X 1 3 X KT z z 1 z 6 z 6 3 6 2 X 1X 2 z 1 z 6 6 3 6 1/14/2016 3 X 4 5 2 [A] Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 58 Gamma density 1 x f X ( x ; , ) ( ) 0 2 2 0 1 e x / , 0 x 0 1/14/2016 2 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 59 6 KT z z 2 1 X 1 3 1 z 6 z X z 2 1 X z X X 3 6 6 6 3 6 2 3 4 5 • Assume two gamma random variables X and Y are jointly distributed. • The two random variables are respectively associated with their frequency factors KX and KY . • Equation (A) indicates that the frequency factor KX of a random variable X with gamma density is approximated by a function of the standard normal deviate and the coefficient of skewness of the gamma density. 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 60 6 KT z z 2 1 1/14/2016 X 1 3 1 z 6 z X z 2 1 X z X X 3 6 6 6 3 6 2 3 4 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 61 5 • Thus, random number generation of the second frequency factor KY must take into consideration the correlation between KX and KY which stems from the correlation between U and V. 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 62 Conditional normal density • Given a random number of U, say u, the conditional density of V is expressed by the following conditional normal density V |U (v | U u) 2 1 1 v UV u exp 2 2 2 (1 UV ) 2 1 UV 2 u 1 with mean UV and variance UV . 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 63 V |U (v | U u) 1/14/2016 2 1 1 v UV u exp 2 2 2 (1 UV ) 2 1 UV Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 64 X X K X 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 65 Flowchart of BVG simulation (1/2) 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 66 Flowchart of BVG simulation (2/2) 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 67 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 68 XY ~ UV Conversion XY AX AY 3 AX CY 3C X AY 9C X CY UV 2 3 2 BX BY UV 6C X CY UV X AX 1 6 4 Y AY 1 6 1/14/2016 4 [B] X 3 1X CX 3 6 Y 3 1 CY Y 3 6 X BX 6 6 Y BY 6 6 2 2 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 69 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 70 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 71 • Frequency factors KX and KY can be respectively approximated by 6 K X U U 2 1 X 3 4 5 1 3 Y Y Y 1 Y 2 2 KY V V 1 V 6V V 1 V 6 3 6 6 6 3 6 Y 1 1 U 3 6U X U 2 1 X U X X 3 6 6 6 3 6 2 2 3 4 5 where U and V both are random variables with standard normal density and are UV correlated with correlation coefficient . 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 72 • Correlation coefficient of KX and KY can be derived as follows: K X KY Cov( K X , KY ) EK X KY 2 3 4 5 1 1 X X X X 2 3 2 X U 6U U 1 U U U 1 6 3 6 6 6 3 6 E 2 3 4 5 Y 1 3 Y Y Y 1 Y 2 2 V V 1 V 6 V V 1 V 6 3 6 6 6 3 6 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 73 3 2 5 X 4 1 1 K X U 1 U 2 1 X X U 3 6U X X 6 3 6 6 6 6 3 AXU BX U 2 1 CX U 3 6U DX 3 2 5 Y 4 1 1 KY V 1 V 2 1 Y Y V 3 6V Y Y 6 3 6 6 6 6 3 AYV BY V 2 1 CY V 3 6V DY 1 1 AX 1 X , BX X X , C X X , DX X 6 6 3 6 3 6 6 4 3 2 Y Y 1 Y 1 Y Y AY 1 , BY , CY , DY 6 6 3 6 3 6 6 4 1/14/2016 3 2 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 5 5 74 EK X KY AX AYUV AX BYU V 2 1 AX CYU V 3 6V 2 2 2 AX DYU BX AYV U 1 BX BY U 1V 1 B C U 2 1V 3 6V B D U 2 1 X Y X Y E C X AY U 3 6U V C X BY U 3 6U V 2 1 3 3 3 C X CY U 6U V 6V C X DY U 6U 2 3 DX AYV DX BY V 1 DX CY V 6V DX DY 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 75 EK X KY AX AYUV AX CYU V 3 6V BX BY U 2 1 V 2 1 E 3 3 3 C X AY U 6U V C X CY U 6U V 6V DX DY E[ K X ] E AX U BX U 2 1 C X U 3 6U DX DX Since KX and KY are distributed with zero means, it follows that DX DY 0 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 76 K EK X KY X KY A A UV A C U V 3 6V B B U 2 1 V 2 1 X Y X Y X Y E C X AY U 3 6U V C X CY U 3 6U V 3 6V C A E U V 6 C C E U V 6 E UV 6 E U V 36 AX AY UV AX CY E UV 3 6UV BX BY E U 2V 2 1 3 X Y UV 3 X 1/14/2016 Y 3 3 3 UV Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 77 • It can also be shown that E U V 6 E U V E UV 3 2 E U 2V 2 2UV 1 3 3 3 3 UV 9UV 3 UV Thus, XY K X KY 2 BX BY 2 UV 1/14/2016 AX AY 3 AX CY 3C X AY 9C X CY UV 6C X CY 3 UV Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 78 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 79 XY ~ UV Single - Value Relationsh ip We have also proved that Eq. (B) is indeed a single-value function. 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 80 Proof of Eq. (B) as a single-value function 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 81 • Therefore, AX AY 3 AX CY 3CX AY 9CX CY 2 2 2 2 2 2 X X Y Y 1 1 6 6 6 6 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 82 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 83 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 84 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 85 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 86 • The above equation indicates XY increases with increasing UV , and thus Eq. (B) is a single-value function. 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 87 Conceptual description of a gamma random field simulation approach 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 88 1/14/2016 Laboratory for Remote Sensing Hydrology and Spatial Modeling, Dept of Bioenvironmental Systems Engineering, National Taiwan Univ. 89
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz